Latest / Ego and Other Things / What is My Story? (Part 3) | Worldview Series
Transcript
- William: Dear Heavenly Father, I thank you for just giving me the opportunity to be able to talk about this worldview I have. Lord, I know that I can't make this worldview series to good purpose without you. I can't do these recordings without you. I can't make my words make sense to others without you. I'm unable to help others without you. I'm unable to make sense of my own story without you. And so all these things, Lord, I surrender into your hands. I know that you live within me and that you are capable of making good and making meaning out of this where I am not. So I pray that you would do this. And Lord, I know that you will do this because you do good for all of those. Who believe in you. And so even if that good is not what I would expect it to be, I know that you will make good out of it. Even if the meaning is not what I expect it to be, I know that you will make meaning out of it. I know that I cannot do this without you, but I know that you who lives within me is capable of doing this. So I ask for that. I thank you and I praise you for the opportunity here to speak. And all this I pray, in Jesus' name, amen. All right, so I'm gonna try and continue off from where I left off last time, which was around the summer of my junior year in high school, where I had really encountered the concept of philosophy through the Canadian podcaster Stefan Molyneux. I had gone through a couple of different political phases and had landed around libertarian anarchism and anarcho-capitalism. I had start to awaken to the need to confront my own emotions and my own childhood experience for the first time, beginning to recognize the impact of my my childhood past on my thoughts and and on my growing political and philosophical awareness. I started to read about philosophy and get introduced. To like the basic concepts and the cast of characters from the history, kind of getting familiar with the basic concepts around philosophy. And I also began to be introduced to economic and and psychological ideas pretty much all through Stefan Molyneux, who led me eventually to a lot of resources. And My Stefan Molyneux influence on me would would pretty much stay that way until I was about 19 or so. I want to say until about 2016 was when he was really kind of having this this influence on me. And as I mentioned before, there was good parts of that in the sense that he introduced me to philosophy, he introduced me to psychology, he introduced me to the connection between my childhood experiences and my philosophical beliefs. he introduced me just to the wider intellectual tradition, which I've been a part, you know, I've been studying and and and working through pretty much ever since. And philosophically at least he introduced me to ethics, which has been my pretty much my central concern ever since. Malonu made this argument that If you wanted to change the world, you need you needed to tackle ethical ideas, ideas of value. and the reason why the case that he made was that people don't have he he was sort of critiquing libertarianism in general, or the kind of economic bent that libertarianism and anarcho-capitalism had taken, where a lot of the argumentation as For why we should have freedom and liberty came down to kind of practical economic considerations, that freedom would be sort of more economically efficient and this would benefit a lot of people. And Malinu's emphasis was that essentially, you know, the the economic arguments are interesting, they can add to the the value of a free society, but they don't really tackle the fundamental issue, which is the ethical issue, the issue of force, violence, and evil. And While people may not change their behaviors based on what's what another person argues to be practical, because practical is largely subjective, ethics is something that people at least pretend to take seriously. And if you can change their their ethical ideas, then you can really actually change their behaviors. If you could convince a person not that the state was inefficient, but actually immoral, then you could at you could much more effectively lead people to the sort of free society, libertarian anarchist kind of camp. And that's where he focused on in is in his ethics. And I think he developed his own foundational ethical system, which I still to this day don't really necessarily understand. But that's really besides the point, because it brought me to ethical thinking and to tying and to emphasizing ethical thought as the way as what I found to be most important, most intriguing in a philosophy in general. So I'm I really moved away, I started to move away piecemeal from politics and even from economics in general, towards ethics and everything that was involved in that, because of course the question of ethics brings in so many other kinds of questions, like questions about human nature, questions about the nature of knowledge, questions about the nature of reality, and how all of these combined with a notion of value and the notion of good and evil and how do we justify our moral standards. And this was compelling to me. This idea that you could rationally defend an ethical standard which could actually drive change in a person was something that was very compelling to me. Now, today, my focus is still pretty ethical. my my focus is on My philosophical emphasis has very been mu very much been in the ethical realm, though it's gradually transformed over time from what is the you know absolute ethical standard that we must live by to how do we live a good life, which are slightly different questions, and the latter is more individually focused, and I would say more focused on how we experience an imperfect world rather than trying to achieve an imper a perfect moral standard. But that's Perhaps a conversation for for another time. The point is to say that that through Molinu, I I inherited this emphasis on ethics, this emphasis on the good life, the emphasis on trying to figure out right and wrong and delving into all the different kinds of problems that ethical philosophers deal with, and really began to recognize for the first time that people's ethical premises, the i the ideas, the the the values that they held to were not often rationally analyzed. It it was very much my experience at that time that if I went up to somebody asked them something like, why is murder wrong, or why is theft wrong or why is violence wrong, that they wouldn't really be able to give me too much of a coherent answer. And that with a little skill I could deconstruct a lot of what they were saying and left and leave them with like basically being unable able to answer me. And oftentimes this was a very frustrating experience for them. I wasn't necessarily tactful in it either. I was kind of mimicking Socrates in this way where I would pose difficult problems to people that they generally hadn't thought about and frustrate them when they couldn't find an answer. Which it was not great, but it did show me that you know A lot of people don't even really think too deeply about these problems that most people are functioning on this kind of well, they're they're acting on a a functional level of knowledge. Their ethics is are in terms of what works and allows them to sort of get along with their broader society and achieve whatever subjective goals that they have. And that their ethics tend to be molded to their personal concerns rather than being s their personal s concerns sort of being sacrificed to An ethical standard, which of course began to grow doubt in me about Molyneux's claims that ethics was the the actual thing which motivated people to change their behavior, because it seemed to me that even when you on the one hand, ethics wasn't actually people's major concern, but on the other hand, values were their concern, like what can I what can I actually achieve in my life? What can I What kind of values can I achieve in my life, not necessarily what the ethical standard is. But on the other hand, even if you had a person who had a very clear ethical standard, there was no guarantee that they would actually act according to that standard, meaning that hypocrisy was kind of a universal human experience. And this is something I found, you know, when it came to people like Stefan Molyneux or later people like Alice Miller. or Ayn Rand or Max Stirner or other kinds of philosophers, you know, practically any philosopher, whatever philosopher you're a fan of, has probably has in their biographies, if you read them, some great moral failing, even in violation of their own moral standards. So hypocrisy is this thing that we as humans wrestle with, where even if we have the right moral law, we don't always live up to it. Oftentimes we just don't, right? When especially when it interferes with our own personal interests and what we're trying to achieve in our life. But the ethical concern was something I started to pick up from Molly at that time. And that can that connection with childhood. there this sense that childhood in in many ways would go on to determine our ethical and political beliefs. That oftentimes the ethics and the politics that we espoused were varying forms of justifying, either on the one hand, justifying the kinds of experiences that we had as children, or else reacting very strongly against them. and that And you know, basically I'll say that that philosophical and political problems are, though not exclusively, they often involve deeper psychological problems that have their roots in childhood. And I could see this in my own life, where you know I was very anti-authoritarian, I was very focused on freedom and liberty, and I came from a background that was very violent, authoritarian, where I was not free to. To know myself, to be authentic, to act as I would value, or to live my life how I saw fit. And so, in many ways, my philosophy and my ethical philosophy was this reaction against an extreme childhood situation. Now, it's easy to psychologize in that sense. I mean, one of the things I also had to learn in this period is that just because some position has its roots in some kind of, you know, trauma or whatever or whatever, doesn't mean that in and of itself, that the position is wrong. And you kind of have to make this distinction where you You can you have to you have to analyze different kinds of positions, ethical positions on their own merits, but also at the same time you have to be aware of the deeper psychological, particularly the childhood roots of your beliefs, because without that kind of awareness, then you your, you might say to put this put it in a simple way, the unconscious will direct your awareness and direct your thoughts in a particular way. that help support whatever it is you're trying to work out on the unconscious level in in your past or your childhood. You want to to work through your childhood so that you can have in a more objective lens when it comes to philosophical and political roots. And so in one sense I was learning that one's childhood was an epistemological barrier to truth. to objective truth in the present. And so the the examination of childhood took on twofold importance. One, in order to process it in its real context so that it it it was no longer this epistemological barrier to objective philosophical truth, but also to just get the truth of my childhood and my experiences and confront that forthrightly. so Like I said, again, all those things were things that I picked up directly from Molonu over the course of these few years. Between I would say like seventeen and nineteen, these are kind of the ideas that I absorbed. I also absorbed very strong atheism by the end of that. and I would be an atheist all the way up until I was about twenty seven or so. And we'll get into that story later and why I fell away from atheism and embraced Christianity. But The point to say that that that was a point where like my intellectual my intellectual interests expanded much much more broadly and I began to take my own childhood seriously both as a barrier to truth as well as something that needed to be confronted and processed. And that was like the good things that I got out of Molina. The the downside the the major downside i would i i would point out with molyneux that wasn't merely having to do with his more extreme beliefs that he r really dove into after like 2015 or so was molyneux was confrontational was was deeply deeply influenced by ion rand and ion rand If I'm running as anything, she was very confrontational and very polemical in her in the way that she talks about ideas, right? She is very Willing to call out what she considers evil and really condemn people whom she disagrees with, even at an epistemological or metaphysical level, as kind of evil or corrupt, because she tied one's she called it like psychoepistemology, that your epistemological positions were revelatory of your values, revelatory of who you are. And I'm not going to get into all the details of that, and I'll talk more about. Ayn Rand's influence on me a little bit later, but Molyneux was very highly influenced by Ayn Rand. Ayn Rand was a very confrontational kind of thinker who, across broad ranges of philosophical concepts, would be willing to call out, condemn, and really express anger and indignation against what she saw as evil and corrupt. And Molnu, not to the same extreme, but to a similar extreme, you know, greatly emphasized free will, greatly emphasized the responsibility that people had to moral truth, the responsibility that people had to confront their own childhoods, the responsibility that parents had to their children, the responsibility that people in general had to figure out the moral truth and to apply it in their lives. And he was very, very, very, very strong on moral consistency. He absolutely hated hypocrisy and he was a great detector of hypocrisy. And when he would detect hypocrisy in either other thinkers or in the people that he would he would talk to on his call and show or in different ideas, he would flambast that hypocrisy, you know, he was really good at like showing the inconsistencies of thought and then jump really morally jumping down the throat of a person who acted inconsistently. because he had such a high responsibility, he placed us a high responsibility responsibility on people to know and apply the moral truth in a consistent way. And if they failed to do so, it was a moral failing. it wasn't simply an epistemological failing. It was a moral failing. He had a little bit of room for maybe ignorance, a little bit of room for like conversation over a couple of months or something like that. I think he described in terms of his personal relationships. But like if people acted in a way that he thought as immoral and didn't ultimately change to fit his standards of morality, he was very quick to confront that person, cut them off, and rail against them and call them evil. And that was something he really picked up from Ayn Rand. And That was I I was already primed, I wanna say, to be confrontational myself because confrontation had at certain points in my life, especially in my childhood, been really important in terms of helping me. It was my confrontation with my father making him feel really uncomfortable about a truth that I said that actually in in some ways saved my life. And when I heard Molyneux start talking, you know it wasn't necessarily something he talked always talked about explicitly, but you could see in in the way that he talked about moral failings, that he was all about the confrontation. He was all about maybe not the confrontation, but he was all about pointing out hypocrisy and and just like I wanna say cornering people with with their own moral hypocrisy or their own moral f their own failure to come to like the moral truth, because he was a believer in objective morality. And so he believed that, you know, any rational person should be able to arrive at like the moral truth, which he believed he had. And so that could that confrontation was kind of almost a moral obligation, that to to eschew confrontation in order to arrive at peace was a kind of a moral a moral compromise, moral hypocrisy, that one needed to be as forthright about what was good and confront others who were failing to do that. Now he didn't do much self-confrontation, unfortunately. There were some things he did, but ultimately, you know, we don't I'm not gonna get into all that, but he was in himself a moral hypocrite, but gave himself more slack than that. and often he could rationalize his own piz his own actions according to his own moral standard and sort of get away with not not being hypocritical, even though this was a rationalization and not the objective truth. So he was suddenly more slack when it came to His self-examination of you might say his moral righteousness. And this produced an attitude in myself, because I was encouraged even further into this of kind of self-righteousness, of I took every chance that I that I could to detect moral hypocrisy in other people, detect inconsistency with people, and kind of aggressively argue them to death. and this was the the combative attitude was something I took on I took took on very early. And it wasn't totally me taking that on wasn't I want to say totally Molly's fault because again, like I said, there are these there are these experiences from childhood which kind of prepared the way for that. I mean, I would argue with my dad where my other siblings were would not, I would out and out just argue with my dad, even as a kid about what I saw as as morally wrong. And even at the time, though I didn't I didn't really recognize this, in my philosophical search, I was looking for kind of the argument that I could give my dad, the confrontational argument I could give my dad that would like prove his abuse and prove that you know he had really hurt me and sort of pin him down in the intellectual corner. And and ultimately I would realize that that's pretty much all ridiculous because I didn't need to prove my abuse to my dad because he was there doing the abuse, right? if he wants evidence of his abuse, all he has to do is is remember. And trusting in my own mind and recognizing that yeah, trusting in my own mind means recognizing that I don't have to prove it I don't have to prove my abuse to the person who abused me because they were they were there, right? And I would learn that later on. But at the time, I want to say that again my own childhood and emotional and and the emotional things that I was trying to deal with was edging me on to be really morally confrontational with the people around me whom I thought were being morally hypocritical. And you know, I would cut people off pretty quickly if They didn't sort of agree with morally. and this was a time when like I didn't make a lot of friends because of this, and I became really even more isolated than than usual because of this. there was no room for for agreeing to the S degree. There was no form of tactful disagreement, and this like balance or this yeah, this balance or integration between like relationships. And trust with moral consistency combined together was like a lesson I had to learn again and again and again throughout I mean even up to now sometimes I I I struggle with it. because there is one part of me that takes morality and ethics really seriously and thinks, you know, should I should I associate with people who are doing something that is truly wrong? As far as I can understand it, but won't turn away from it, right? And how do I balance that with relationship with people? Where because you know people are not going to respond to your criticisms and rebukes and and whatnot if they don't trust you, if you haven't already established a relationship with you. if you yourself don't examine your own moral beliefs, this is something that would ultimately Find a solution in Christianity later on, but this was the beginning of that that kind of tension where I would heavily and negatively impact my relationship with the people around me for the sake of you know moral self-righteousness. And what was so hypocritical as well, and this this kind of hypocrisy would go on for for quite a number of years. Like I said, up until probably twenty twenty-six, twenty-seven-ish, was this the fact that I was so I would I would jump down people's throat for their own moral hypocrisy and not living up to moral standards while being generally extremely blind to my own evil, to my own hypocrisy, to the way that I was hurting the people around me. And not even just with talking with them about morality. But with like genuinely selfish and hurtful actings like like like stealing and cheating and lying and berating and using abusive language and all kinds of just selfish things that I that that I would do, like immoral things that I would do with other people, that I would condemn other people for. And then when I did them, I had an excuse, or I didn't even really think about it too much. I wasn't self, I wasn't at all self-reflective when it came to that. there was this sense that I had that only grew for a few years that I was a particularly good person. You know, and I was a particularly good person because I was studying philosophy and ethics, and I was growing in my knowledge, and I was a particularly good person because I was confronting the evil of the world. You know, everybody else was just a coward who wanted to keep everything peaceful and easy, but I was going to take the the hard road of confronting people with the moral truth, whether or not they they they liked it, right? And it was this kind of fantasy that that came in to fill in my own self-esteem, right? As the abuse of my childhood kind of destroyed, the one thing and a lot of other things in my life, you know, felt out of control. Like I I wasn't I wasn't popular in school. I wasn't popular with the girls. you know, I wasn't really skilled in all that much. I didn't do well at school because I didn't care about school. I didn't have like any other hobbies. Like i all of my whole identity and my whole self-esteem came down to knowledge and philosophy and reading and ethics and moral consistency, like all and the realm of ideas. Like that's where I derived all of my self-esteem. And that sort of moralism and self righteousness which came out of the which came out of like this toxic mix of like what I was getting from Stefan Molyneux as well as my childhood combining. And of course I had my own part to play. I mean, I don't mean to like blame all these other things. I had my own choices, and there are many times in which I just chose to do the wrong thing, so to speak, but it was definitely this this moral confrontation with the world while and it's about hypocrisy and evil while not looking at my own hypocrisy and my own evil. And this really hurt a lot of my relationships, including, you know, my most important relationships. I had a girlfriend, this is senior year now, and all the all these different things are happening, right? I had a girlfriend senior year who I I cheated on with her with her best friend. And and so not only did I did I hurt that that first girlfriend, but the the next girl that I was with after that, who I was with for a a number of years afterwards, I also was was very hurtful and selfish towards you know, I would say. Yeah, I would say, you know, really, really hurtful and selfish towards and over a number of years, like manipulative, again, selfish, verbally abusive at points, just angry, deceptive, lying. really always thinking about myself and my own my own self image and just thinking I was better and and and treating her at some points with disdain and all these different kinds of things which really just ruined what I mean was never fundamentally a great relationship, but was you know, probably the closest relationship that I had at the time was one that was was constantly attacked by my own hypocrisy and evil and and and and selfishness. And and But I was relatively blind to it, right? When things went wrong, I didn't I didn't look to what I was doing, right? I blamed her for it. I or I and that would be a pattern in a lot of my relationships where, you know, when friends walked away when I was when when yeah, when friends walked away when I had problems in my relationship, when I had problems with people at work, when I would, you know, confront people and get into arguments with them about morality, I didn't think I was the problem. I thought the world was the problem. I thought everybody was a a moral coward. He didn't want to face up to the things that they were doing wrong all the while being entirely blind or self-justifying my own hypocrisy and my own evil. And I would say the beginning of that pattern started around senior year and led up to about well, really it didn't really resolve itself until I was probably like twenty five, twenty-six at all. And Yeah. Twenty five or twenty six. But That was the major theme of like junior, I wanna say from like sixteen to nineteen, that was the major theme right there. And in the next part I can talk about I can go from about nineteen, let's say, let's see. I'll pick up there la I'll I'll pick up at nineteen next time and then talk about the different kind of changes that went on went on then because that's when I started to be much more influenced by By reading Ayn Rand. in particular, I I was kind of falling away from Stanfon Molyneux, and I started to pick up Ayn Rand, started to read her a lot more deliberately and and being influenced by her thought, which there are very similar themes between the two thinkers. So but that would be like the next part of the influence, especially her systemic thinking. Especially her systemic thinking. so we will pick up that next time 'cause we're we're a little past the half hour mark. So as always thank you guys for listening and I'll talk to you next time.