Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Mega Edition: Virginia Robert's Motion To Compel Documents From Improper Objections (Part 1-2) (7/3/26)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:04In this episode, we're diving right back into those core documents,
- 0:07and we're going to begin our look at the response
- 0:10to the motion to compel Attorney client communications and attorney
- 0:14work product materials. Case number fifteen DASH CV DASH zero
- 0:19seven four three three DASH RWs Virginia Roberts, Plaintiff Glenn Maxwell.
- 0:26The defendant, Plaintiff Virginia Roberts, by and through her undersigned Council,
- 0:33hereby files this response to Defendant's motion to compel all
- 0:37attorney client communications and attorney work product placed that issue
- 0:41by plaintiff and our attorneys D one sixty four. The
- 0:45motion should be denied. In its entirety introduction, the defendant argues,
- 0:50Miss Roberts and two of our attorneys, Cassell and Edwards,
- 0:53have somehow placed that issue her confidential attorney client communications
- 0:58and therefore have made a sweeting waiver of attorney client
- 1:01privilege in this case. Defendant, however, fails to cite the
- 1:05controlling law on this issue. Federal Rule of Evidence five
- 1:09oh two, enacted in two thousand and eight. Rule five
- 1:12oh two was designed to block exactly the kind of
- 1:15argument the defendant is making. Rule five oh two provides
- 1:19the litigants are entitled to the most protective laws on
- 1:22attorney client privilege, either state law where the disclosure was
- 1:26made or federal law. The alleged disclosures in this case
- 1:30were made in Florida, and under Florida law did not
- 1:33constitute any waiver of attorney client privilege. Indeed, defendant does
- 1:38not reveal to the court that the Florida judge who
- 1:40handled the case during which the alleged waivers occurred the
- 1:44Dershowitz case, has already considered and rejected their entirety, the
- 1:49very argument that defendant is advancing here. In addition, none
- 1:53of the alleged disclosures were made by Miss Roberts, who,
- 1:56as the holder of the privilege, is the only individual
- 1:59with the authority to waive it. Moreover, none of the
- 2:02alleged disclosures concerned the substance of confidential attorney client communication,
- 2:07and Finally, Miss Roberts will not be seeking to introduce
- 2:11or otherwise take advantage of any confidential attorney client communications
- 2:16in this case. Accordingly, for these and other reasons, the
- 2:19Court should deny the defendant's motion in its entirety. The
- 2:23factual background the CVRA case. The facts relevant to this
- 2:28issue begin in two thousand and eight, when Attorney Bradley J. Edwards,
- 2:32soon joined by co council Professor Paul Kassel, filed a
- 2:36pro bono action in the Southern District of Florida under
- 2:39the Crime Victim's Rights Act. Filed on behalf of Jane
- 2:42Do number one and later Jane Do number two. The
- 2:45CVRA action alleged to the federal government had failed to
- 2:48protect the rights of Jane Do one and other similarly
- 2:52situated victims of sex offenses committed by Epstein. See declaration
- 2:56of Sigared McAuley at Exhibit one. Can played filed in
- 3:00Jane Doe one versus United States Number zero eight CV
- 3:04eight zero seven three six, Southern District of Florida, July seventh,
- 3:08two thousand and eight. Janine Doses one and two achieved
- 3:12many victories in that case, including a ruling that the
- 3:15CVRAA rights of victims could apply before charges were filed.
- 3:20Those one and two versus United States eight seventeen f
- 3:23Dot supp two d. Thirteen thirty seven Southern District of Florida,
- 3:27twenty eleven, that they had standing to challenge the non
- 3:31prosecution agreement reached between the government Nepstein Jane Does one
- 3:35and two versus United States nine fifty f. Supp Dot
- 3:39two D. Twelve sixty two, Southern District of Florida, twenty thirteen,
- 3:44and that plea negotiations were not protected from disclosure by
- 3:48any federal rule of evidence those versus. United States seven
- 3:52forty nine f. Dot three d. Nineteen ninety nine eleven
- 3:55Circuit twenty fourteen. Congress also followed the developments in the
- 3:59case closely, recently amending the CVRA to ensure that the
- 4:03future crime victims received notice of any non prosecution agreement
- 4:08entered into by the government see Pubel one fourteen twenty two,
- 4:13Title one, Section one thirteen AC one, May twenty ninth,
- 4:17twenty fifteen one twenty nine, two forty two forty one,
- 4:21adding US Code eighteen Section three seven seven one A
- 4:25nine to give crime victims the right to be informed
- 4:28in a timely manner of any plea bargain or deferred
- 4:31prosecution agreement. On December thirtieth, twenty fourteen, Cassel and Edwards
- 4:36filed a motion pursuant to Rule twenty one for joinder
- 4:39in the action on behalf of two additional victims, Jane
- 4:42Doe three and Jane Do four. Jane Do three Virginia
- 4:46Roberts subsequently decided to reveal her name. The jointerer motion
- 4:50argued that Jane Does three and four should be allowed
- 4:53to join the two existing plaintiffs in the action because
- 4:57they had suffered the same violations of their rights under
- 5:00the CVRA McAuley declaration Exhibit two. Jane Does three and
- 5:04four joined her motion to establish that they were victims
- 5:08of Epstein's sex crimes with standing to join the suit.
- 5:11Jaine Does three and four alleged that they had suffered
- 5:14sexual abuse from Epstein. For example, Jane Do three alleged
- 5:18that she had been forced by Epstein to have sexual
- 5:21relations with various persons, including Alan Dershowitz, who had been
- 5:25one of Epstein's defense attorneys, negotiating the non prosecution deal
- 5:29and arranging to keep its secret from the victims McAuley
- 5:33Declaration Exhibit two at four. Jane Do three also alleged
- 5:36that defendant I. E. Glame Maxwell had participated in the
- 5:40sexual abuse of Jane Do number three. Alan Dershowitz also
- 5:44filed emotion to intervene to contest the allegations. Jane Doe
- 5:48three filed a response to Dershowitz intervention motion McAuley declaration
- 5:53Exhibit three response to Motion to intervene. The response explained
- 5:57that the allegations against Dershowitz were real, event to at
- 6:00least eight separate issues in the CVRA case id at
- 6:04eighteen twenty six. The response also explained some of the
- 6:08evidence supporting the allegations against Dershowitz, including sworn testimony from
- 6:13one of Epstein's household employees, Juana Lessi, that Dershowitz came
- 6:17pretty often to Epstein's Florida mansion and got massages while
- 6:21he was there, sworn testimony from another of Epstein's household employees,
- 6:26Alfredo Rodriguez, that Dershowitz was present alone at the home
- 6:30of Epstein, without his family, in the presence of young girls.
- 6:34Invocations of the Fifth Amendment rights to remain silent by
- 6:37three of Epstein's identified co conspirators, Sarah Kellen, Nadia Marsenkova,
- 6:42and Adriana musinsk when asked questions about whether Dershowitz had
- 6:47been involved with massages by the young girls. Refusals by
- 6:51Jeffrey Epstein to discuss Dershowitz's involvement, but instead to invoke
- 6:55his fifth Amendment right. Several months later, on April seventh,
- 6:59twenty fifteen, the Court marriage Ay denied Jane Do three
- 7:03and Jane Doe four as joined her motion mcaulay declaration
- 7:06Exhibit four order denying Jane Do three's motion to join.
- 7:10With regard to the eight separate issues as to which
- 7:12the allegations against Dershowitz were relevant, the Court addressed only
- 7:16the first, establishing victim status, and found that the factual
- 7:20details regarding with whom and where the Jane Does engaged
- 7:24in sexual activities are immaterial and impertinent to this central
- 7:28claim i e. There were known victims of mister Epstein
- 7:31and the government owed them CVRA duties, especially considering that
- 7:36these details involved non parties who are not related to
- 7:39the respondent government id At five. Accordingly, the Court struck
- 7:43the factual details from the victims, pleading as unnecessary at
- 7:46the time. The Court specifically recognized, however, that the details
- 7:51could be reasserted by the parties to the action i e.
- 7:54Jane Do one and Jane Do two if they could
- 7:57demonstrate a good faith basis for believing that such details
- 8:00are pertinent to a matter presented for the court's consideration
- 8:04id at six. Following the court's ruling, additional litigation has
- 8:08proceeded in the CVRAA case the Dershowitz case. While the
- 8:13cvr A case was moving forward in the Southern District
- 8:16of Florida on behalf of Jane Doe's one in two,
- 8:19separate litigation developed between the pro bono attorneys who had
- 8:22filed the lawsuit, Cassell and Edwards and Dershowitz. After the
- 8:26filing of the joinder motion in the CVRA case, Dershowitz
- 8:30took to the airwaves and attacked not only Jane do
- 8:33three but also Cassell and Edwards. Typical of these attacks
- 8:37one was leveled on CNN in which Dershowitz alleged if
- 8:41they Cassel and Edwards had just done an hour's worth
- 8:44of research and work, they would have seen she is
- 8:46lying through her teeth. They're prepared to lie, cheat and steal.
- 8:50These are unethical lawyers. They can't be allowed to have
- 8:53a bar card to victimize more innocent people. Halogarani, CNN Live,
- 8:57January fifth, twenty fifteen. Cassel and Edwards then filed the
- 9:02state defamation action against Dershowitz and Broward County, Florida see
- 9:06McCauley declaration Exhibit five complaint and Edwards and Cassel versus Dershowitz.
- 9:11The complaint alleged that Dershowitz had engaged in a massive
- 9:14public media assault on the reputation and character of Cassel
- 9:18and Edwards IDEA four. Miss Roberts was not a party
- 9:22to this defamation lawsuit. The Florida Court rejects a waiver
- 9:26of attorney client's privilege argument. As Cassell and Edwards Florida
- 9:30Defamation action move forward. Dershowitz sought to make an argument
- 9:34that they had somehow waived their client, Miss Roberts attorney
- 9:37client privilege. On September eighth, twenty fifteen, Dershowitz filed a
- 9:42motion to compel Cassel and Edwards to produce documents and
- 9:45additional responses to interrogatories McAuley Declaration Exhibits six, Motion to Compel.
- 9:51In his motion, Dershowitz argued that Cassell and Edwards have
- 9:55waived any privilege or protection that would otherwise attach to
- 9:59a responsive docum ments and information by bringing this defamation action,
- 10:03placing at issue the truthfulness of Jane do Number three's
- 10:07allegations against Dershowitz idea three and five. In his motion
- 10:11and reply pleading McAuley declaration Exhibit eight. Reply and support
- 10:15of Motion to compel Dershowitz argued that Cassell and Edwards
- 10:19actions throughout the case constituted a waiver of attorney client privilege.
- 10:24Casel and Edwards responded, arguing that Miss Roberts was not
- 10:27a party of the defamation action and that she was
- 10:30the only person who could waiver privilege. McAuley declaration Exhibit seven,
- 10:35at four and six response in opposition to the motion
- 10:38to compel. Cassell and Edwards also argue that there had
- 10:42been no waiver because confidential attorney client communications with Miss
- 10:46Roberts were not an issue in the defamation's case. Cassell
- 10:50and Edwards also later filed a sur reply further elaborating
- 10:54to on the argument that Miss Roberts had not waived
- 10:57any attorney client privilege by publicly discussing her sexual abuse
- 11:01by Epstein and the associates. McAuley declaration Exhibit nine, Sir
- 11:06Appliant Support of opposition to motion to compel. Cassell and
- 11:09Edwards also explained that communications with miss Roberts were protected
- 11:14not only beginning in March twenty fourteen, but even earlier
- 11:17than that date, when Miss Roberts understood that she was
- 11:20obtaining legal services from Cassel and Edwards. Following this extensive
- 11:25briefing on waiver issues, on December eighth, twenty fifteen, the
- 11:29Florida Court Lynch Jay ruled denying Dershowitz's argument that attorney
- 11:33client privilege had been waived McAuley declaration Exhibit ten, order
- 11:38denying motion to compel. Specifically, the court denied the motion
- 11:41to compel, explaining pre March twenty fourteen communications are protected
- 11:46by the work product privilege and the witness has not
- 11:49waived the communications that were protected by the attorney client privilege. Also,
- 11:54there was no waiver by Cassell and Edwards by filing
- 11:57the suit. All right, folks, were in a we'll part
- 12:00one there and in the next episode we'll pick up
- 12:03with part two. All of the information that goes with
- 12:06this episode can be found in the description box. What's
- 12:10up everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles. In
- 12:14this episode, we're picking right back up where we left
- 12:16off with the attempt by Glen Maxwell to get access
- 12:20to attorney client work privilege Miss Roberts deposition in the
- 12:26defamation case. As the defamation action move forward, Dershowitz subpoena
- 12:31Miss Roberts to a deposition McAuley declaration Exhibit eleven composite
- 12:36exhibit of excerpts from transcript of deposition of Miss Roberts.
- 12:41During the deposition, held in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, Miss Roberts
- 12:45was represented by the undersigned legal counsel, who asserted objections
- 12:50to revealing attorney client information where the questions called for
- 12:54revealing confidential attorney client communications see e g. Id At
- 12:59two twenty two and twenty three, one thirty one and
- 13:01thirty two, one seventy three and seventy four, one eighty
- 13:05three and two o eight. During the deposition, Miss Roberts
- 13:08specifically stated that I decide not to waive my attorney
- 13:12client privilege at this time IDEA one seventy four. Miss
- 13:15Roberts also denied that Cassell and Edwards had ever pressured
- 13:19her into identifying someone as being involved intersexual abuse. The
- 13:24settlement of the defamation case. Ultimately, Cassell, Edwards, and Dershowitz
- 13:29agreed to settle their defamation case. That settlement included both
- 13:33public statement and confidential monetary payments. As part of the settlement,
- 13:37Cassell and Edwards withdrew their allegations against Dershowitz in the
- 13:41defamation case contained in the then pending some Rejudgment motion
- 13:45McAuley declaration Exhibit twelve, Notice of Withdrawal of some Rejudgment Motion.
- 13:51As explained in the Notice of Withdrawal of this motion,
- 13:54the withdrawal of the reference filings is not intended to
- 13:57be and should not be construed as being and acknowledgment
- 14:00by Edwards and Cassel that the allegation made by Roberts
- 14:04were mistaken. Edwards and Cassel do acknowledge that the public
- 14:08filing in the Crime's Victim Rights Act case of their
- 14:11client's allegation against defendant Dershowitz became a major distraction from
- 14:15the merits of the well founded Crime Victim's Rights Act
- 14:18by causing delay, and as consequence, turned out to be
- 14:22a tactical mistake. All these actions settling the Florida defamation
- 14:26case took place in Florida legal standards for waiver a
- 14:31federal rule of evidence five oh two controls on the
- 14:34issue of waiver. Defendant asks this court to find them
- 14:38as Roberts has somehow waived our attorney client privilege regarding
- 14:42various communications. In this case, this is a no small step.
- 14:46The attorney client privilege is one of the oldest recognized
- 14:49privileges for confidential communication Swidler versus Berlin versus United States,
- 14:55five twenty four US three ninety nine, four h three,
- 14:58nineteen ninety nine. The privileged purpose is to encourage full
- 15:02and frank communication between attorneys and their clients, and thereby
- 15:07promote broader public interest in the observance of law and
- 15:10the administration of justice five point twenty four US at.
- 15:14Four oh three. Internal quotations omitted in setting out the
- 15:18legal standards pertaining to waiving the attorney client privilege. Defendant
- 15:22fails to cite the controlling and protective law on the issue.
- 15:26In a federal case, issues of alleged waiver of attorney
- 15:29client privilege must be resolved under the new standards in
- 15:33Federal Rule of Evidence five oh two. In two thousand
- 15:36and eight, Congress enacted Federal Rule of Evidence five oh two,
- 15:39which is entitled Attorney Client Privilege and Work Product Limitations
- 15:44on waiver. New Rule five oh two places a number
- 15:47of protections in place to reduce litigation over claims that
- 15:51a party has somehow waived attorney client privilege see generally
- 15:55advance common note rule five oh two. Notably, defendant does
- 15:59not discover us to even cite rule five oh two
- 16:01inner motion. The issue currently before the court is specifically
- 16:05controlled by five oh two C, which covers situations where
- 16:09a disclosure in a state proceeding is alleged in a
- 16:12federal proceeding to establish waiver. Rule five oh two C
- 16:17provides the greater of protections found in federal or state
- 16:20law see disclosure made in a State proceeding. When the
- 16:24disclosure is made in a state proceeding and is not
- 16:27the subject of a state court order concerning waiver, the
- 16:30disclosure does not operate as a waiver in a federal
- 16:33proceeding if the disclosure one would be a waiver under
- 16:37this rule if it had been made in federal proceeding,
- 16:40or two it is not a waiver under the law
- 16:43of the state where the disclosure occurred. As is readily
- 16:47apparent from the text of the rule, there are two
- 16:49separate ways in which a party can prove that no
- 16:52waiver of attorney client privilege has occurred, one by demonstrating
- 16:57that no waiver exists under federal law, or two by
- 17:00demonstrating that no waiver exists under the state law where
- 17:04the disclosure occurred. Between these two possibilities, the drafters of
- 17:08the rule decided to apply the most protective law that
- 17:11governs waiver see fed R Evidence five oh two C
- 17:16Advanced Communication Notes. The Advisory Committee on the Federal Rules
- 17:20of Evidence determine that the proper solution for the Federal
- 17:23court is to apply the law that is most protective
- 17:26of privilege and work product B. Florida Law. Florida's protective
- 17:31law and attorney client privilege provides that neither an attorney
- 17:34nor a client may be compelled to divulge confidential communications
- 17:39between a lawyer and a client which were made during
- 17:42the rendition of legal services Florida's State Amendment ninety dash
- 17:47five zero two one in C. Communication denotes more than
- 17:51just giving legal advice. It also includes giving information to
- 17:55the lawyer to enable them to render sound and informed advices. Versus.
- 18:00Gator Land Kubata, LLC, Century Insurance forty five, South third
- 18:07seventy three, seventy six Florida First District Court twenty ten.
- 18:12Under Florida law, while the burden of establishing the attorney
- 18:15client privilege usually rests on the party claiming it First
- 18:18Union National Bank verse. Attorney eight twenty four Southern Second
- 18:23one seventy two, one eighty five, Florida First District Court,
- 18:26two thousand and two. When communications appear on their face
- 18:29to be privileged, the burden is on the party seeking
- 18:33disclosure to prove facts which would make an exception to
- 18:36the privilege applicable. Ford Motor Company versus Hall and Edwards,
- 18:40nineteen ninety seven SO two d eleven forty eight eleven
- 18:44fifty three, Florida Third District Court, two thousand and eight.
- 18:48Rousseau versus Hannon, one forty six Southern District sixty six seventy,
- 18:53Florida Third Court of Appeals, twenty fourteen. In this case,
- 18:57defendant does not appear to dispute that an attorney client
- 19:00privilege exists with regard to the communications between Miss Roberts
- 19:05and her attorneys. Rather, the defendant's argument is that this
- 19:08privilege has somehow been waived see motion to compel at
- 19:12one in two. Therefore, under Florida law, defendant must shoulder
- 19:16the burden of overcoming the privilege. Of course, because defendant
- 19:20failed to even cite much less discussed Florida law, she
- 19:23has not carried that burden. Defendant asserts that she can
- 19:27force disclosure of the privileged communications between Miss Roberts and
- 19:31her counsel under the ad issue doctrine. To establish this
- 19:36alleged waiver, Defendant's motion relies on a federal District court
- 19:39case Herne versus Ray sixty eight Frd five forty seven ED. Washington,
- 19:45nineteen seventy five, which was cited in Bank Brussels Lambert
- 19:49for his credit Lionaise Say two ten Frd five six
- 19:54five oh nine and five ten SDNY two thousand and
- 19:57two LSMJ see emotion to compel at eight, as discussed
- 20:02below as a matter of controlling federal authority. These cases
- 20:06have been repudiated by the Second Circuit and to the
- 20:09same effect. Florida law also rejects the expanse of Hearne
- 20:12approach to waiver. See Guarantee Insurance Company versus Hefferman Insurance
- 20:17Brokers Incorporated, three hundred fr D five ninety five ninety
- 20:22three through ninety five, Southern District of Florida, twenty fourteen,
- 20:26discussing Florida authorities. Florida law disfavors waiver of the attorney
- 20:31client privilege and will not readily find an ad issue waiver.
- 20:35See Guarantee Insurance Company versus Hefferman Insurance Brokers Incorporated. Three
- 20:40hundred fr D. Five ninety five ninety three Southern District, Florida,
- 20:44twenty fourteen, citing Coats versus Ackerman, Center Fit and itisin
- 20:49Pa nine forty Southern District, five oh four, five oh
- 20:53eight at Florida Second District, two thousand and six, refusing
- 20:56to find waiver based on the at issue doctrine, in
- 21:00contrast to Herne Under Florida law, at issue waiver only
- 21:03occurs when a party raises a claim that will necessarily
- 21:08require a proof by way of a privileged communication Cotes
- 21:12nine forty Southern District, at five oh eight, quoting Jenny
- 21:16versus Air Data Wyman Incorporated. Eight forty six Southern Second
- 21:21District six sixty four, six sixty eight Florida Second District
- 21:25Court emphasis in original Indeed. In twenty fourteen, the Southern
- 21:29District of Florida rejected the hern at issue analysis and
- 21:33instead adopted the analysis of the Third Circuit, as outlined
- 21:37in Rome polank Roarer Incorporated versus Home Indemnity Company thirty
- 21:42two FT three d eight fifty one. Third Circuit nineteen
- 21:46ninety four Guaranteed Insurance three hundred fr d at five
- 21:50ninety five. The Third Court deem the Herne tests to
- 21:53be of dubious validity because, although it dresses up its
- 21:58analysis with a checklist of factors, it appears to rest
- 22:01on a conclusion that the information sought is relevant and
- 22:05should in fairness be disclosed id at eight sixty four.
- 22:08The Third Circuit specifically rejected Hearn because relevance is not
- 22:12the standard for determining whether or not evidence should be
- 22:16protected from disclosure as privileged Rohan thirty two f dot
- 22:21three d at eight sixty three. Florida law tracks at
- 22:24the Third Circuit C. Three hundred frd at five ninety
- 22:28three and ninety five. Also under Florida law, the client
- 22:32not her attorneys, holds the attorney client privilege see Florida
- 22:36State ninety dot five O two three. Also see Florida
- 22:40Statute ninety dot five zero two two. A client has
- 22:44a privilege to refuse to disclose and to prevent any
- 22:47other person from disclosing the contents of confidential communications when
- 22:52such other person learned of the communications because they were
- 22:55made in the rendition of legal services to the client.
- 22:59Some courts have even recognized serious due process issues could
- 23:03be created by a procedure through which a client lost
- 23:06their privilege without an opportunity to be heard in the proceedings. C. E. G.
- 23:12Rogers versus State seven forty two, Southern District eight twenty seven,
- 23:16eight twenty nine, Florida Second District Court, nineteen ninety nine.
- 23:20Under Florida law, so long as a client has a
- 23:23reasonable expectation of privacy in the communication under section ninety
- 23:28dash five oh seven, the privilege is protected. McWaters versus
- 23:33State thirty six, Southern District six thirteen, six thirty six, Florida,
- 23:37twenty ten. Also under Florida law, only the client not
- 23:42her attorney can waive attorney client privilege. CI Savino versus
- 23:46Luciano ninety two, Southern District eight seventeen, Florida, nineteen fifty seven.
- 23:51Coats versus Ackerman Center fit Nedicine, Pa. Nine forty Southern
- 23:56Second District five oh four, Florida Second District Court, twoud
- 23:59six and Genevies versus Provident Life and Accident Insurance Company
- 24:04seventy four Southern District ten sixty four, Florida, twenty eleven.
- 24:10All Right, folks, we're gonna wrap up this episode here
- 24:12and then the next episode talking about this topic, we're
- 24:15gonna pick up where we left off. All of the
- 24:18information that goes with this episode can be found in
- 24:22the description box.