Latest / Film And Whiskey / District 9 / Hardin's Creek Col. James B. Beam Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 2009, director Neil Blomkamp and star Charlotte Copley gave
- 0:05the world a strangely touching film about the dangers of.
- 0:09Human Pride. In 2024 we try one of the newer
- 0:13releases from the James B Beam Company.
- 0:17The film is District 9. The Whiskey is Hardin's Creek
- 0:20Colonel James B Beam. Or review them both.
- 0:24This is the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:47Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 0:49review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:52I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad Gee.
- 0:55And this week we are looking at the 2009 sci-fi classic District
- 1:009. Brad, I just want to set the
- 1:02stage today by talking about District 9 by offering a bit of
- 1:06an apology to our listeners who are big sci-fi fans because much
- 1:10like the Academy Awards who consistently ignore the realm of
- 1:14sci-fi, we've not done a lot of true sci-fi films on this
- 1:19podcast. I mean, fair like you've, we've
- 1:21done Star Wars, right? And maybe a couple others, but
- 1:24anything that's kind of science fiction related has been more
- 1:27horror than like pure sci-fi. Yeah, I was going to say I it's
- 1:32hard anymore to get pure sci-fi films right.
- 1:37Like anything set in space is either going to be like fantasy
- 1:42adventure or Marvel, neither of which fall into the realm of
- 1:46sci-fi. Now even Star Wars, I would say
- 1:50is like famously, it is a space opera.
- 1:54It's a fantasy. It's more about what it takes to
- 1:58be a heroic person than it is about the gadgets and technology
- 2:03and exploration of space and all that.
- 2:06So I can't think of many true sci-fi movies we've done.
- 2:10I I would call the original Alien like a an actual sci-fi
- 2:15movie. Yeah, I mean, it's a horror
- 2:17film, but it's also probably the closest thing we've gotten to a
- 2:20pure sci-fi film. And we've always said from the
- 2:23beginning that you are definitely more of a fan of
- 2:26sci-fi than I am. Not that I'm against it, it's
- 2:28just never really been my favorite genre and I'm kind of
- 2:32wondering now that we've parsed out all these different mini
- 2:34genres too, whether you're actually a fan of sci-fi or or
- 2:38if it's more like space operas, baby.
- 2:41I've always been a fan of fantasy over sci-fi.
- 2:45Like I, I've not read the original Dune books, but from
- 2:49what I know, they are highly technical and can be pretty
- 2:53dense to get through. And so I, I actually don't know
- 2:58if I would say I'm a huge sci-fi fan, but part of that's because
- 3:01I didn't grow up in the 60s and 70s when like sci-fi really was
- 3:06a hugely popular thing. Like as the world was trying to
- 3:10figure out technology and going to space and what is out there.
- 3:15Like there was this massive fascination in the general
- 3:18public about the the like technicalities of what it would
- 3:24take to go to space, and that's why the genre really exploded.
- 3:27Yeah. And I feel like that's where you
- 3:28kind of get this idea of a hard sci-fi and soft sci-fi being.
- 3:33Like, you know, you could call Jurassic Park a science fiction
- 3:36film because it's about a fictional use of human science.
- 3:40It's about this fantastical idea of where human intervention
- 3:45could go if we push our scientific knowledge to its
- 3:48limits. But I've never considered
- 3:50Jurassic Park a sci-fi film. And so when you look at a movie
- 3:53like District 9, I feel like it really toes that line because it
- 3:57is an Earthbound film, but it also features aliens and it has
- 4:01some pretty intense world building.
- 4:04So this is probably the most pure science fiction film we've
- 4:07done on the show since Alien. And I, I think that's one thing
- 4:10I really love about this film is the world building that occurs,
- 4:15the talent that blom comp blom comp blom camp.
- 4:20Yeah, just go with one pick. Let's pick one and we'll run
- 4:23with it today. OK.
- 4:24I'm going to go with Blom. Blom, I don't even know, man.
- 4:28Blomkamp, we're saying it. Blomkamp.
- 4:30All right, so Blomkamp does such an incredible job at giving you
- 4:35tiny little tidbits that lead off into like no man's land as
- 4:40far as world building goes, and then they just trail off and
- 4:43leave you nowhere. It's like, why the hell do these
- 4:46aliens love cat food? It's like nobody knows, but it's
- 4:51such a fascinating little piece of nothing that you need
- 4:56mountains of those little things built up to make a universe
- 5:00interesting. And I, I think he knocks that
- 5:03out of the park here. Well, we're going to explore
- 5:05every corner of that little universe, especially the cat
- 5:07food corner. But folks, let's let's welcome
- 5:10you in here a little bit. If this is your first time
- 5:12listening to film and whiskey, what do we do on this podcast?
- 5:15We review movies, we review whiskey.
- 5:17It's pretty straightforward. I know this season what we're
- 5:21doing is we're looking at films from the last 20 years and we
- 5:24are asking the question, does this movie deserve to be
- 5:28considered a modern masterpiece? Except for last week, when we
- 5:32forgot to answer that question for La La Land.
- 5:35This is the second time in our young season where we have
- 5:38forgotten to ask the core question of the season.
- 5:42So please forgive us folks, but I feel like our scores on La La
- 5:45Land are fairly indicative of what we think of the film.
- 5:49So I'm just going to very quickly say yes, I think it
- 5:51deserves to be considered a modern classic.
- 5:53Absolutely. Cool.
- 5:55All right, now we're going to ask that question about District
- 5:579 over the next 4550 minutes. So Brad, I think in order to get
- 6:01into the movie, we need to get to our first segment of the day,
- 6:04which we call, Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 6:07movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock, so let's go
- 6:11ahead and do your take with this little segment that we call,
- 6:14Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 6:17show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 6:20just seen, often for the first time.
- 6:23Brad, I'm pretty sure this was your first time with District 9,
- 6:25but perhaps the more important question, did you have any
- 6:29knowledge of this film? I have not seen this movie
- 6:33before and my the extent of my knowledge was that there's
- 6:39aliens that are like in a ghetto and that's it.
- 6:45So I, I knew very little about it, although one of the most
- 6:50important elements of world building that this movie does is
- 6:54to assume that humans aren't the only species who have tears of
- 6:59like intelligence and productivity and ability.
- 7:03I I love the way that Blomkamp shows how even in this alien
- 7:11society, it's like we don't really know why this ship landed
- 7:14here on Earth, but it seems to be alien ineptitude on some
- 7:19level. Yeah, I feel like that's that's
- 7:21kind of like what people think when they listen to our podcast,
- 7:23when they're like, I don't really understand why Brad is
- 7:26saying these things, but I'm just gonna assume it's it's
- 7:29probably alien ineptitude. Yeah, 100%.
- 7:34All right. So I'm glad that you were at
- 7:35least aware of the movie. And I think that's a testament
- 7:38to the fact that, you know, this movie was fairly low budget and
- 7:41upon release it ended up grossing over $200 million just
- 7:44in North America. So it was well seen at the time.
- 7:48I feel like I remember it also being a, a huge fixture on early
- 7:53streaming Netflix, like when everybody first got Netflix in,
- 7:57you know, 2013, 1415. It was on Netflix all like that
- 8:02entire stretch. And I think a lot of people
- 8:04caught it, you know, when it first came to streaming.
- 8:07So people are definitely aware of this film.
- 8:09I feel like it's the kind of movie that you couldn't release
- 8:11today and expect the same widespread viewership of like it
- 8:16has no movie stars. It's made by a guy from South
- 8:18Africa. It cost $30 million to make.
- 8:22This would be probably a direct to Netflix movie that people
- 8:26would watch over the course of like a Thanksgiving weekend and
- 8:29then no one would talk about it ever again.
- 8:31So I'm glad it came out when it did because it deserves a lot
- 8:34better than the fate it would receive today.
- 8:36Brad, I'm rambling now. You have 60 seconds to break
- 8:39down the plot of this movie. Folks, if you have not seen
- 8:41District 9, I encourage you to stop this episode now, go watch
- 8:44it and then come back and join us.
- 8:46It's a nice breezy sub two hour movie.
- 8:49Brad, One minute and go. District 9 is a film about a
- 8:53fictional alien, not quite mothership, but a massive alien
- 8:58ship that settles in over South Africa.
- 9:01The inhabitants are released and ghettoized into a small area
- 9:08known as District 9. A large corporation comes in
- 9:12about 20 years later and is trying to move them out of this
- 9:15ghetto and into a nearby area. And in that process, the man in
- 9:20charge of the movement of the aliens is infected by an alien
- 9:25disease, slowly transformed into one of the aliens, and fights
- 9:30for his very survival and cure. Yeah, Brad, I think that's a
- 9:35good explanation of the plot of the movie.
- 9:37But I think where I'd like to start is talking about the, I
- 9:41don't want to say the genre, but the form of the movie, The way
- 9:44the movie is presented to the viewer because it has elements
- 9:47of obviously documentary. There's like legitimate fake
- 9:51documentary interviews with experts throughout the movie
- 9:54talking about the context of this alien invasion, setting the
- 9:58stage for the world building that we're going to do.
- 10:01You know, how did they come to live in a slum?
- 10:04Why are we trying to evacuate them?
- 10:06Who is this corporation? So it has documentary elements.
- 10:09It has found footage elements which we which would come to be
- 10:12really prominent over the following decade in horror film.
- 10:16And then it has like just straight action movie kind of
- 10:19shaky Cam, almost Cloverfield type cinematography throughout
- 10:23the movie. So it's this mash up of
- 10:25different genres that I think really helps create a unique
- 10:29movie experience. There's really nothing new here
- 10:32in terms of what the movie does, what the movie says, how it's
- 10:35put together, but I think like the unique combination of
- 10:39ingredients feels fresh. The way that they take this main
- 10:46character who we haven't named yet, his name is Vickis
- 10:50Vanderveer, which is a great name.
- 10:53Like of all the characters we've ever seen in the movie, I think
- 10:57it might be one of my favorite names.
- 11:00And the way that they take him on this journey of inept, like
- 11:06not quite politician, but like bureaucratic official and slowly
- 11:11turn him into a completely BA like action hero is, is
- 11:17absolutely incredible. And along the way you get so
- 11:21much world building that's like actually of interest.
- 11:24I, I, I think that's the thing that really clicked with me for
- 11:28this movie was that A, everything that they reveal to
- 11:32you about the alien culture and how the humans interact with
- 11:35them is so well done and fascinating and kept me like in
- 11:39my seat at the edge of my seat. And then B, the movie just has a
- 11:44way of keeping me guessing. I like I never found myself
- 11:48going. I know exactly what's going to
- 11:50happen next. The only element that was
- 11:53lackluster was the main bad guy, you.
- 11:57You just knew that he had plot armor until he didn't.
- 12:00That was like one of the very few in my opinion.
- 12:04Poorly part, poorly done parts of the film.
- 12:07All right, let's start talking about the movie itself.
- 12:09And I guess let's start at the top here with Charlotte.
- 12:12So Copley, who was unknown globally prior to this film,
- 12:16much like Neil Blomkamp and has been a steady working actor in
- 12:20Hollywood since this movie came out.
- 12:22It really helped establish an international career for him.
- 12:25I feel like unfortunately, he's has been cast as like really
- 12:29devious bad guys, mostly in movies from here on out, which
- 12:33don't tap into his strengths. Like, yes, he can play a slimy
- 12:36guy, but the great thing about his performance in this movie is
- 12:39is how much of A weakling he is. And that transformation that you
- 12:43were talking about Brad, you know, he he gives off huge early
- 12:47season Michael Scott vibes at the beginning of the film when
- 12:51they're showing the inner workings of the office.
- 12:53And he's not like he's not committing the social blunders
- 12:56and faux pas that Michael Scott does.
- 12:59But you can tell that like, none of these people respect him.
- 13:01None of these people think he's a good leader.
- 13:03And then slowly over the course of the movie, you watch his
- 13:06desperation, you watch his emotions, and then finally this
- 13:09resolve at the end of the film to do something about this
- 13:12predicament that he's in. And I just think it's an
- 13:14absolutely stellar performance, man.
- 13:17Yeah, he actually kind of reminds me of Jerry from Parks
- 13:21and Rec in that he, like, he's a complete bubbling fool but also
- 13:26has this wildly attractive wife. And you, like you don't really
- 13:31understand how it works or how it happened.
- 13:34And yet here he is. I will say for me, you know, you
- 13:37talked about the kind of like Maine mercenary guy that's
- 13:40chasing him throughout the film. I thought the weakest part of
- 13:43the film by a country mile was his wife because they have one
- 13:47scene together where she has to cry a little bit in his
- 13:51presence. And it is like, you know, bad
- 13:55Christian movie acting bad. Like it's, it's it's real bad,
- 13:59dude. You know you gotta.
- 14:02Throw Christian buses movies under the bus like that.
- 14:05At the end of the movie, or I guess throughout the movie,
- 14:07there's a couple phone calls they make to each other and
- 14:09she's crying on the phone and it's so much better than trying
- 14:11to watch her emote. She was real bad.
- 14:14Apart from that, I thought pretty much everybody in this
- 14:16movie was either incredible like like Charlotte O'copoly was, or
- 14:21at least serviceable in the roles they were given.
- 14:24Yeah, I mean, I I remember watching Pacific Rim and
- 14:28thinking like the main character in that is just generic white
- 14:32action guy #17 and I kind of feel that way about the big bad
- 14:38Boss for what is it multinational?
- 14:42Yeah, yeah, whatever the the main big bad corporation which
- 14:46MNUMNUI love that they just give it the most generic like.
- 14:52It's literally called Multinational United.
- 14:55Yeah, there you go. I absolutely love the naming,
- 14:59the nomenclature there. But, yeah, like, the CEO of
- 15:02that, who is his father-in-law, he's generic CEO bad guy #42 and
- 15:08the mercenary who is the head of their security branch, generic
- 15:12mercenary, white mercenary guy #14 like, and they do exactly
- 15:17what they need to do without drawing attention away from the
- 15:20main thing that's happening in the movie, which is this slow
- 15:24transformation from, you know, the human, all of the negative
- 15:31elements of humanity into something that is alien to
- 15:35humans, which is like, kindness and a desire for home and
- 15:39protection of your children and, and all of these, like,
- 15:42beautiful things. Let's talk a little bit about
- 15:45the aliens in this film and specifically the creature
- 15:47design. So I, I've said a couple times,
- 15:50this movie only cost $30 million, which is kind of
- 15:52staggering when you think about it.
- 15:54I mean, it is you can tell where they put every dollar of the
- 15:59movie because they're doing the documentary slash found footage
- 16:03thing. And so they're not having to do
- 16:05like these elaborate set pieces. It most of the film is contained
- 16:09to just like two or three locations.
- 16:11It's like Vickus's house and then you and then the the slum
- 16:16of District 9. That's pretty much the entire
- 16:18film. And so you know that the money
- 16:21is not really going to that. And so pretty much all the money
- 16:23is going to a couple explosions, some practical effects and then
- 16:28the CGI which is used to create these aliens.
- 16:30And I think I will say upfront, it's pretty obvious that this is
- 16:36$30 million of CGI and not $300 million of CGI.
- 16:41I'm not going to lie, I like the CGI.
- 16:44See, that's the thing I did too. Like there's, there's some
- 16:46things about it where like their eyes look kind of fake, but
- 16:50there's there's like an element of how the chintziness of it
- 16:53almost kind of works better because these creatures look so
- 16:57completely foreign to us that once you get used to the way
- 17:02they look, I think it works really well.
- 17:04Brad. Yeah, there there is no doubt in
- 17:08my mind this is one of the best alien movies as far as like the
- 17:14visual composition of the aliens, like they're familiar.
- 17:18They do a good job of marking out which aliens you should care
- 17:23about. And also I you said that the
- 17:26eyes look a little chintzy. I think that the absolute 100%
- 17:31most important part of this movie is the fact that they made
- 17:34the aliens eyes look endearing. Like think about any like anime
- 17:44cute little dog character or something.
- 17:47It's got giant eyes right? And the the aliens eyes in this
- 17:52are big and they are round and they remind me of like a cute
- 17:55anime character. And without those eyes that show
- 18:00genuine pain and remorse and sadness like the aliens in this
- 18:06movie would be, you would not be able to empathize with them at
- 18:10all. But man, when you watch the main
- 18:13alien, who is named Christopher Johnson, interacting with his
- 18:18son, it's his eyes that draw you in and helps you understand the
- 18:22pain. And I, I think if you're ever
- 18:24going to make an alien movie that has relatable aliens, you
- 18:29have to get the eyes. Right, 100% and you can see fear
- 18:32in their eyes. You can see sadness and longing
- 18:35in their eyes. I, I just yeah, I'm with you.
- 18:37I like the the coloration of them and they don't look like
- 18:41they exist in the real world. But again, once you kind of get
- 18:44past that first filter in your brain and you start just
- 18:47watching the movie for what it is, I really thought that they
- 18:50did a great job with their limited resources and budget on
- 18:53that CGI. And I also think it's really
- 18:55funny. You know, the early goings of
- 18:57this movie are basically you are following a documentary team as
- 19:01they are raiding District 9, which is where the aliens all
- 19:04live to evict them and forcibly move them to a new sort of
- 19:08ghetto to another part of town. And Vickus is leading the charge
- 19:13because his father-in-law is the CEO.
- 19:15It's it's very bureaucratic and it's really funny.
- 19:18It's funny to watch Vickus like pretend like he knows what's
- 19:21going on. And he he does have some
- 19:23knowledge of the aliens, but he's bad at negotiating.
- 19:27He's bad at being an enforcer. He doesn't know how to properly
- 19:30handle alien weaponry. And then you get the what to me
- 19:34was I think the funniest reveal of the movie, which is like,
- 19:36he's talking to the 4th or 5th alien down on the list who
- 19:40becomes kind of our main protagonist alien.
- 19:43And they haven't named any of these aliens yet.
- 19:46And then he's like Christopher Johnson.
- 19:48That's you, right? And the reveal that they are
- 19:51naming these aliens and not just naming them, but giving them the
- 19:55most generic names. Again, this, you know, this
- 19:58entire movie is a reference to apartheid South Africa.
- 20:03You know, so I'm making light of the naming, but obviously, like
- 20:08the way that slaves in Africa and outside of Africa came to
- 20:12acquire the names they had today is because people gave them
- 20:14those names and they weren't names that they were were born
- 20:17with or brought here with. So I understand that I'm making
- 20:20light of something that is actually hitting on a very
- 20:22serious topic. But for the entirety of the
- 20:25movie to watch these people with a straight face refer to this
- 20:29alien creature as Christopher Johnson.
- 20:31It it did kind of just get me every time.
- 20:34Yeah, that was the surprising part for me about the film is
- 20:38the style of black comedy that it is like when he's going
- 20:42around trying to get these signatures from aliens that like
- 20:46there's just something visually so funny about the alien hitting
- 20:50the clipboard out of his hand. And he goes to his compatriot
- 20:53who he's like training and he's like, see, this is this is the
- 20:57scribble that I that I needed. He he hit it and therefore we're
- 21:00good to evict him in 24 hours. It really demonstrates how slimy
- 21:05the corporation is and it kind of sets the tone for the first
- 21:08half of the movie. I talked about how the movie
- 21:11structured or not even structured, but like put
- 21:14together out of three different kinds of filmmaking.
- 21:18But I think it also incorporates different genres really well.
- 21:21So at the beginning you've got kind of the comedy workplace
- 21:25environment elements and documentary style.
- 21:28And then there's this big government conspiratorial
- 21:31element with cover ups and becomes a parable or like a
- 21:35metaphor for apartheid. And it's really harrowing for a
- 21:38while. But then it shifts into like
- 21:40straight David Cronenberg style body horror.
- 21:45Like there's fingernails falling off and teeth falling out and
- 21:48limbs transforming into alien limbs and bodies exploding
- 21:53everywhere. And by the end, it's like a
- 21:55straight up action war film. And I really love how Blomkamp
- 21:59kind of weaves together these genres so effectively.
- 22:02Because to your point, Brad, I, I want to focus on that first
- 22:05part for a minute. It's really hard to watch at
- 22:08points because once you start empathizing with the aliens,
- 22:12seeing what happens to them gets continually worse.
- 22:15And I mean, I don't want to draw direct comparisons to a movie
- 22:19like Schindler's List, but it's like not out of the realm of
- 22:22comparison. You're watching this race of
- 22:25creatures get absolutely eviscerated and taken advantage
- 22:29of and exploited, and then you find out there's genetic testing
- 22:33and kidnappings and experiments and just firing weapons at them
- 22:38to see what happens. And it's a really tough watch in
- 22:41the early part of the movie. Yeah, and that's that's the
- 22:44entire impetus of the film is that we we humans, when we come
- 22:50upon something new, we often will show fascination and
- 22:54respect and dignity and all, all of these things where we are
- 22:57interested in the new thing. And then within a few years, if
- 23:03that the question no longer is, you know, wow, there's this
- 23:08beautiful new thing. What what is it all about?
- 23:11And it turns into the question of how is it useful for me?
- 23:15And like, that's the entire thrust of this movie is to say
- 23:19like, what is the cost of a human large corporation style
- 23:26entity that is only ever interested in its own profit and
- 23:31you like you end up with wild things.
- 23:34Like, I don't think it is a stretch to say that they were
- 23:37thinking about the Nazi experiments on humans when they
- 23:42were looking at what this corporation is doing to aliens.
- 23:44And you can 100% hear the justification of like, well,
- 23:47they're not human. They're just aliens.
- 23:50We can do whatever we want. This is for the betterment of
- 23:52humanity. It'll keep us safe if they ever
- 23:55invaded. Like you can hear all of the
- 23:57reasonings, but the movie is continually trying to show you,
- 24:00like, what is it costing humans to engage in such activities?
- 24:06What part of the movie did you find most effective?
- 24:09Was it the early documentary style or the middle body horror
- 24:13Manhunt? Or was it the third act where he
- 24:16starts fighting back? I think that the first two acts
- 24:20of the film are incredibly effective.
- 24:23I think that the third and final act kept me guessing based on
- 24:26the twists and how you think that they've lost.
- 24:29There's no way that they could win and they come back.
- 24:31Like it definitely is effective action storytelling and keeping
- 24:36you interested. But for me, the documentary
- 24:39style lasted just long enough for me to be like, OK, I wonder
- 24:43where this movie's going. And like, right as I was almost
- 24:47bored, his body starts changing and, and he starts trans, you
- 24:52know, transforming into this alien creature and you're like,
- 24:56OK, I'm back in. And then it's this mystery film
- 24:59of like almost like a fugitive type of movie where you're like,
- 25:03he's on the run, He's trying to find a solution.
- 25:06I and I think that was what was so effective about the three
- 25:10individual parts of the film is that it kept me interested the
- 25:13whole time rather than the entire movie being done through
- 25:171 lens. Well, and it's such a great
- 25:19action movie convention too, because in that middle part, he
- 25:22returns to the slum of District 9 to hide from multinational,
- 25:28whatever it's called. I almost said university.
- 25:32He's hiding out with the with Christopher Johnson, the guy
- 25:35that he was interrogating earlier in the film.
- 25:37And it does that brilliant thing where you've got two guys who
- 25:42both have to take down the same common enemy and they are bound
- 25:46together by circumstance. They don't like each other, but
- 25:49they have to work together. And then by the end of the film,
- 25:52they're buddies. You're bought into their
- 25:54relationship. And it's like, you know, it's
- 25:56been done 100 times, but it's been done 100 times for a
- 25:59reason. It's like it's a great
- 26:00convention to get two different parties to start working
- 26:04together. And like, you know, the second
- 26:06that they start revealing their plan to Vickus that they're
- 26:10trying to get this kind of like a small, I don't know what, what
- 26:14would you call that? Like a fighter jet almost to get
- 26:17back up to the ship so that they can go home and then hopefully
- 26:20come back and rescue their people.
- 26:22Once that plan is put in motion, it's like, OK, I can see where
- 26:25the movie is going to go now and I am 100% on board.
- 26:29And the reason I'm 100% on board with the relationship between
- 26:33Vicus and Christopher Johnson and the action and the escape
- 26:38and all the things is because they made a freaking adorable
- 26:42little alien boy who just wants to go home.
- 26:47Dude, that scene where he's asking his dad about how many
- 26:49moons there are around this planet?
- 26:52Come on. It's absolutely perfect at
- 26:56pulling on the heartstrings and helping you go.
- 26:59Yeah, no, these are just real people who are also aliens.
- 27:03And Oh my gosh dude, what an incredible use of emotional just
- 27:08like heart pulling on the heartstrings.
- 27:11I'm I'm talking myself into a higher score on this movie than
- 27:14I initially gave it. I dude, I, I, I came away from
- 27:18watching the movie. I was like, yeah, this is like a
- 27:207 1/2 like a like a really fun little action drama about, you
- 27:27know, the dangers of human predations.
- 27:29And I'm like, the more we talk about it more like, I don't
- 27:32know. This is a pretty good movie,
- 27:33Bob. That's a pretty good movie,
- 27:35Brad. I think this is a good place to
- 27:36hit pause. I have more to say, but I think
- 27:39it's time we drink some whiskey. Let's get to it.
- 27:47Today we are checking out Hardens Creek Colonel James B
- 27:51Beam Bourbon Whiskey. This comes from the Jim Beam
- 27:54Company as a new brand extension that launched I think in 2022.
- 27:59We haven't gotten around to trying it until now, Brad, and
- 28:01I'm really excited because it made a big splash upon release.
- 28:06Part of the excitement came because of Jim Beam's
- 28:09announcement that this would be a line of new annual releases.
- 28:13So there's multiple variants of Hardin's Creek, but today we're
- 28:16just focusing on the label called Colonel James B Beam.
- 28:20This particular whiskey is only two years old, but it's made at
- 28:23the new Fred B No distillery recently opened by Jim Beam.
- 28:27It's distilled by Master Distiller Freddie No, who we've
- 28:30talked to on the podcast before. They've said this expression
- 28:34honors Jim Beam with its low distillation proof and lower
- 28:37entry proof into the barrel. It's clocks in at 108 proof in
- 28:41the bottle. I'm going to be honest dude,
- 28:43that two year age statement is a little bit concerning for me.
- 28:48You and I have had wildly varied experiences with two year
- 28:52whiskey. Yeah, I read the same thing,
- 28:56that this is 2 years old and became a little suspicious that
- 29:01there's just, there's only so much you can do in two years,
- 29:05Bob, You know what I mean? Like I there's just a part of me
- 29:09that you drink enough whiskey. It feels like you have to
- 29:14recognize that 2 year old product is either a going to be
- 29:20for consumers that don't know much about whiskey, or it's for
- 29:28the other end of the spectrum of like people who are so familiar
- 29:32with the intricacies of whiskey production that they can taste a
- 29:362 year old product, recognize where it's going in the barrel,
- 29:40and like point it towards something greater.
- 29:43But that means that you're either a master distiller or you
- 29:47know somebody who is only interested in $20 bottles of
- 29:50whiskey. Now to your point, I think there
- 29:53are two ways to think about why they choose A2 year whiskey.
- 29:57You know, one approach is basically what Bardstown Bourbon
- 30:00Company has done, which is sourcing whiskey and then kind
- 30:03of gradually working their distillate into the blend until
- 30:06only their whiskey is left and kind of takes over entirely.
- 30:09Then the other approach is basically saying, hey, we think
- 30:13this stands up on its own at two years to release it.
- 30:16And so maybe they'll increase the age statement in coming
- 30:18years and kind of allow that whiskey to develop over time.
- 30:23But I think people have different reactions to that
- 30:25strategy. Like either it's hey, this
- 30:27company's trying to sell me a story about two year whiskey, or
- 30:32you can choose to do what I'm choosing to do, which is take
- 30:35the optimistic view. They really believe in this.
- 30:39And after talking with Freddie No about the product, I believe
- 30:41that they genuinely stand by it. Like they could have blended it
- 30:45really heavily and blended it in with a bunch of other stuffed
- 30:48and kind of masked its character.
- 30:49But they chose to showcase it for what it is.
- 30:53So whether they increase the age or not, I think that it's pretty
- 30:56clear that they believe in what they've made and I appreciate
- 30:58that. I I think that's a, that's a
- 31:02take that is a fair and honest. Take now, Brad, you've tried
- 31:09this already and I feel like, I feel like you're tipping your
- 31:11hand here a little bit. Yeah, So the nose on this bad
- 31:15boy, if I can get into it, there's peanut brittle, it's
- 31:19vanilla frosting like it's got some very sharply sweet notes.
- 31:25There's some black pepper. It gets a little bit spicy for
- 31:28me, though, the the more time I spent with it, there's a lot of
- 31:32young graininess on this nose that kept it from being a higher
- 31:37score. I'm going to give it a 7 out of
- 31:3910 on the nose. I I think it's interesting just
- 31:42a little. Bit young for me.
- 31:45I'd give it a 7.5. I think that there's a lot
- 31:48happening here. I get floral notes like rose
- 31:51petal on the nose along with some melon.
- 31:55There's definitely some graininess, but there's oak,
- 31:58there's black pepper, there's vanilla.
- 32:00What bums me out though is that even at 108 proof like the
- 32:04aromas feel very muted. It smells like a watered down
- 32:09whiskey even though it's not. So the flavors are good, but
- 32:12they don't stand out, which is why I'm landing at a 7 1/2.
- 32:15Yeah, and the the mutedness kind of continues on into the palate
- 32:20for me, man, I did not get very much sweetness at all on this.
- 32:26Like there's a little bit of caramel vanilla going on at the
- 32:29front of the pallet. After that, though, it is all
- 32:32black pepper oak. I don't know if I've ever given
- 32:36this note before, but it kind of jumped into like a paprika spice
- 32:40range for me. It's a really weird, interesting
- 32:46flavor profile that has that essence of youth about it that
- 32:54I'm going to give a six out of 10.
- 32:55Interestingly, this drinks like a very heavily oaked older
- 33:00bourbon. Like if somebody told me this
- 33:02was 10 year whiskey, I might believe it.
- 33:04On the palate, I got green apple upfront, which I really love.
- 33:09Caramel and the nuttiness that Beam is known for.
- 33:13That's all here. It definitely has more of a
- 33:15toasted oak thing though, like that that profile that can be
- 33:20hit or miss for me. So honestly, I don't know man,
- 33:24this is one of the best young bourbons I've had on the
- 33:27podcast. I'm going to give it a 7 1/2
- 33:30again here. I think the finish comes up a
- 33:33little bit from the palate. There's oak, there's coffee
- 33:37bean. It sticks with that black pepper
- 33:39like everything I kind of expect out of a finish.
- 33:42Once again though, it's got a little bit of that sour
- 33:45youngness that sticks around for a while.
- 33:48It just doesn't have the age to give you a well-rounded
- 33:52experience. It's a 6 1/2 for me on the
- 33:55finish. The finish drops to just like a
- 33:59six for me, OK, Like it's, it's not the finish itself, but like
- 34:03the last gasp of the palette that graininess kind of presents
- 34:07like it's almost like when you drink like a bottled water that
- 34:12has minerals added like Dasani, like there's a minerality here.
- 34:16It gives you kind of that, like that chalky note, which I really
- 34:19don't like for 90% of the drinking experience.
- 34:22This is way better than those kind of young or cheap Jim Beam
- 34:26products that we tried at the end of last season.
- 34:29But that minerality at the end reminds me of even some of those
- 34:33like bottom tier Beam offerings. In terms of balance, I'll come
- 34:39back up to A7. Overall, this is really well
- 34:42balanced. The 108 proof was the right
- 34:44choice. At 80 or 90 proof, it probably
- 34:47would have been too watery. But that one off note at the
- 34:51end, like really keeps it from getting a higher score for me.
- 34:55So I'm going to give it just a solid seven overall.
- 34:58Yeah, Balance wise, this is a six out of 10.
- 35:01I, I, I don't think that there's enough going on here for me to
- 35:05be interested. And unfortunately, man, oh man,
- 35:09this just never goes anywhere sweet.
- 35:13And it, it's not that I need things to be sweet to be tasty.
- 35:16I, I love a good 95.5 rye, 100% rye, but it just doesn't have
- 35:24the balance to make the sour young grain worth it.
- 35:31And and getting into value Bob, this is an $80.00 bottle of
- 35:34whiskey for a two year product right?
- 35:40That is a lot of money for a average 2 year bourbon in my
- 35:49opinion. Dude this is a 3 1/2 for me on
- 35:52on value. Yeah, I mean, I think the
- 35:56whiskey is actually quite good. It is also a two year product.
- 36:00Like I just, there's only so much you can tell me in the
- 36:04marketing materials about how rare this liquid is to justify
- 36:09putting an $80.00 price tag on two year bourbon.
- 36:11Like I just, I don't get it. You know, we've tried the, I
- 36:14believe, 108 proof Jim Beam Single Barrel last season, which
- 36:18was fine, but that's like $35. And I think that that's a blend
- 36:22of, you know, four to seven-year bourbon.
- 36:25So like, what are we doing here at $80.00?
- 36:27I do think this is a poor value. I'm going to give it a four out
- 36:30of 10 on value, which takes me to a 32 out of 50 on average.
- 36:35Brad, where are you coming out on this one?
- 36:37I am at a 29 out of 50. Yeah, this is weird because I
- 36:41actually think that if we're just talking about the liquid in
- 36:44the glass, this is better to me than a 61 out of 100, which is
- 36:49what we're coming out to. But when you factor in the value
- 36:52category, you know, even if they were trying to sell this at 50
- 36:55bucks, I'd probably give them a little bit more of a pass on
- 36:58this one. I just, I don't know how you can
- 37:01justify an $80.00 price tag here.
- 37:04Yeah, it is massively overpriced.
- 37:06The only way I would come above like a 5 or 6 on my value score
- 37:12is if the price tag was 3999 or less.
- 37:15That like that is the only way I could justify this.
- 37:18As it is, this is my first sub 30W and quite some time I feel
- 37:24like. Do you feel like the the juice
- 37:27itself is sub 30 or is it just kind of dragged down by the
- 37:31value I? Mean my score was a 25.5 out of
- 37:3640, OK, for just the juice. So maybe, you know, extrapolate
- 37:42that out. Maybe it's like a 70 to 75 out
- 37:45of 100, you know, if I was just doing it on that basis, but man,
- 37:49I, I don't think I would buy this even at $40.
- 37:54Yeah, I agree. And, and I again, I don't think
- 37:56it's bad whiskey, but I just, there's nothing that would make
- 37:59me tempted to go out and spend $80.00 or honestly to get a
- 38:03pour, a pour of this is going to cost you probably 12 to $14.00.
- 38:07Like I, you know, I just think there's other things, especially
- 38:09from the Jim Beam company that I would try before this.
- 38:12So a. 100%. Brad, unfortunately we've hit
- 38:15kind of a snag here in our day with this product.
- 38:18But you know, this is what we're here to do.
- 38:19We're talking honestly about the whiskey in front of us.
- 38:23Yeah, the there's other places you can go to find good whiskey.
- 38:27Today is just an unfortunate detour.
- 38:31All right, man, let's get back to talking about District 9.
- 38:33What do you say? Let's get to it.
- 38:39All right, everybody. That was Hardens Creek Colonel
- 38:42James B Beam Bourbon. Is it a bourbon?
- 38:46It sure was. Yeah.
- 38:47A whiskey that I will not be returning to anytime soon.
- 38:52Paired with a place in the world, I probably wouldn't
- 38:54return to either. I do like that you had to double
- 38:58check if it was a bourbon. It would be really funny if you
- 39:00were like, oh, the whole time I thought it was single malt.
- 39:03This changes everything. All right.
- 39:07Well, Brad, I think it's time for us to get into our game for
- 39:09the day, which we call 2 facts and a falsehood.
- 39:12Brad is going to try to stump your ball. 2 are right and what
- 39:19is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 39:23and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me
- 39:26with three items as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 39:30which is a complete lie. Brad, as of right now, I am
- 39:33sitting at Let's count them up 123-4567 and two on the season.
- 39:39You're dominating, man. It's been pretty good so far.
- 39:41I I will say, beyond knowing that Neil Blomkamp made this
- 39:45movie, that it's set in South Africa, that it's about
- 39:48apartheid and that Peter Jackson helped produce it, I know very
- 39:51little about the background on this movie.
- 39:53So I said this last week with La La Land, and I just guessed.
- 39:57I pulled an answer right out of my butt and.
- 40:00Was happily lucky on that one. I might have to do the same
- 40:04thing today. I.
- 40:06Am excited to see you pull things out of your butt Bob.
- 40:09What a good time it. Doesn't help that we are video
- 40:12chatting as we do this so I I feel like you're being honest
- 40:16and I don't like that. Fact number one District 9 was
- 40:21largely inspired by director Neil Blomkamp's experience of
- 40:25apartheid and contains many references to that time period
- 40:28throughout the film. True such as?
- 40:30Such as anti apartheid graffiti and the use of the term prawns
- 40:35which is similar to the Isuzu word for oppressors which is
- 40:38pronounced Prawnzana. Fact #2 District 9 was
- 40:43originally supposed to be a spin off of the Halo Combat Evolved
- 40:47video game franchise. When the project fell through,
- 40:50producer Peter Jackson gave Neil Blomkamp the go ahead to make a
- 40:54movie about whatever he wanted. Fact #3 The design for the
- 40:59aliens went through quite a few iterations before the final
- 41:02insectoid prawn concept was finalized.
- 41:05Originally, the aliens were conceived as a quadrupedal
- 41:08hulking creatures with leathery skin and tentacled faces, and
- 41:12were intended intended to be performed by actors in creature
- 41:15suits. The prawn creatures were
- 41:18initially meant to be masters of the tentacle faced creatures,
- 41:21keeping with the idea that the aliens were slaves.
- 41:26OK, so I know that number 2 is true just from browsing the
- 41:30Wikipedia page before we jumped on here.
- 41:32Like I I knew that it was a a. Halo thing.
- 41:34I love when you. I love when you go.
- 41:36I know nothing about this film other than the director and the
- 41:39setting. And then you immediately go, you
- 41:42know, as I browsed the Wikipedia page.
- 41:45Well, forgive me for thinking that your research would go
- 41:48deeper than Wikipedia, my guy. I don't look at Wikipedia for
- 41:51this. Well, there you go.
- 41:52I did. I did today and I read the
- 41:55production thing which said Peter Jackson intended to make a
- 41:57Halo movie. And then that fell through
- 41:59'cause I was going to make note of it in the first part of the
- 42:01episode because they said that most of the props that are used
- 42:05in the movie were repurposed Halo props.
- 42:08And I'm not a guy that plays Halo.
- 42:10So I was going to ask you, does it look like Halo stuff 'cause I
- 42:13have no idea. But do you play Halo?
- 42:16I have played Halo quite extensively, Halo and Halo 2
- 42:20specifically. Once it hit Halo 4, I was kind
- 42:25of out. Me too.
- 42:26Yeah, I know, right. I will say the weapons in the
- 42:30film, the alien weapons are very similar to a lot of Halo
- 42:35weapons. And actually the sniper that
- 42:37they use at the end of the movie that has like the giant like
- 42:41rectangular kind of muzzle at the end of the the barrel looks
- 42:47a lot like the sniper rifle from Halo 10.
- 42:50OK, cool. Well, so great.
- 42:52I'm going to say 2 is true. Number one I'm not entirely sure
- 42:58about because I remember reading that the prawns were based on
- 43:04like some kind of insect in South Africa, like it they call
- 43:08them prawn crickets or prawn. What are those things called?
- 43:12Not cicadas, but locusts. And so I don't, I don't know if
- 43:16like you would present number one as complete fact and then
- 43:20change the reference to what a prawn is.
- 43:23I don't know if you'd be that petty, which makes me think #3
- 43:27might be the falsehood because I just have no idea about the the
- 43:30creature design or what they put into it.
- 43:32So I'm going to say 3 is the falsehood, but I'm going to be
- 43:36really pissed off if you changed one tiny little detail about
- 43:40number one to make it false. Bob, you are now seven and three
- 43:47on the season. Damn it was it #1.
- 43:50It was #1. God.
- 43:51Bless it. The only part of number one that
- 43:54was true is the absolute first part that is inspired by Neil
- 43:59Blomkamp's experience of apartheid.
- 44:02Nothing about anti apartheid graffiti, nothing about the term
- 44:07prawn like like none of the rest of the fact was true.
- 44:10So did he not experience apartheid or what?
- 44:12He he did, yeah. He he grew up in the time of
- 44:16apartheid. But but the movie's not based on
- 44:20that. I'm confused.
- 44:21What did you make up here? So the second-half of the fact
- 44:24was that the movie contains many references to that time such as
- 44:27anti apartheid, graffiti and the use of the term prawns similar
- 44:32to the Isuzu word for oppressor which is pronounced Prasanna.
- 44:35That's all the part you made-up. The whole thing all.
- 44:38Right. I feel like you're stretching it
- 44:40here man. Like I by everything.
- 44:43Making up facts about the movie. Well, because like, there is
- 44:47graffiti that is similar, I would imagine, to what apartheid
- 44:51graffiti looked like. And the, I don't know.
- 44:54I just feel like sometimes you're like, yeah, I'm going to
- 44:56make this thing up. But then it's still actually
- 44:58there in the movie. And you're like, well, I wrote
- 45:02it, so it's not real. I I 100% can guarantee you that
- 45:08there's nothing. There is no Isuzu word
- 45:11pronounced pronzana. No, OK.
- 45:15Yeah, that that is 100% Brad G baby.
- 45:18I will take that at your word because you are a master of many
- 45:21languages so. I you know me man, I speak like
- 45:2414 languages. All right, all right.
- 45:26So I, I had preemptively filled in AW for myself on our little
- 45:30sheet here. I'm going.
- 45:31To change that to an L No wonder you lost Pride goeth before a
- 45:36fall, young Robert it. Certainly Goeth.
- 45:39All right, man, let's dive back into talking about the movie and
- 45:42I think let's kind of camp out here, Ha, camp on Neil, Neil
- 45:45Blomkamp, because Neil Blomkamp, this was his first feature
- 45:50length film. He had gotten the attention of
- 45:52Peter Jackson with some short films that he made, and he's
- 45:55made quite a few movies after this, but I feel like he kept
- 45:59trying to recapture the magic of District 9.
- 46:02He made a movie right after this, I don't know, maybe 3 or 4
- 46:05years later called Elysium with Matt Damon.
- 46:08And it had a very similar plot to District 9.
- 46:11Like Matt Damon ends up becoming fused with some sort of
- 46:15technology and he has to get up to the ship to try to get it off
- 46:18of him. And it's set in like the slums
- 46:20of South Africa. And so it's like.
- 46:23This is this is the same the same movie.
- 46:25The same movie then he made-up with Matt Damon, Then he made a
- 46:28movie called Chappie, which was about a robot that got stranded
- 46:32on Earth in what seems to be the slums of South Africa and
- 46:35they're trying to get him to escape.
- 46:38So again, the same movie. And after those two movies were
- 46:43not the financial successes that they wanted them to be.
- 46:46He's kind of since become a journeyman filmmaker.
- 46:49I watched a movie that he made last year, which was the big
- 46:51screen adaptation of the video game Gran Turismo.
- 46:56It was not great. And I'm, I'm really bummed that
- 46:59Neil Blomkamp has not panned out the way that I thought he would
- 47:01after this film because, you know, yes, he injected so much
- 47:05of his own personal experience into this movie.
- 47:08But it's a bummer when that doesn't translate to being able
- 47:12to direct other people's stories, too.
- 47:15And I think that's kind of what we ended up getting with Neil
- 47:17Blomkamp here. I, I feel like we're about to do
- 47:20a bonus episode on like top five one hit wonder directors and I
- 47:26feel like Blomkamp would fit into that cause District 9 is
- 47:29truly a one hit wonder there. There is all sorts of stuff here
- 47:33to love. I, I think to talk about him as
- 47:36a director. What was the element of District
- 47:419 that made you go OK, like this Neil Blomkamp guy?
- 47:45He knows what he's doing. I think that the the first part
- 47:49of the movie where they're doing the documentary found footage
- 47:51stuff, it felt a little artificial this time around to
- 47:55me where like in 2009 it was like, oh, this is a really
- 47:59clever way of covering up the fact that your budget's not
- 48:02huge. And I think we've seen that done
- 48:04so much since then. Maybe it's unfair for me to read
- 48:07that back on this movie because it was one of the first ones to
- 48:09do that. But it was like, oh, OK, I see
- 48:12what you're doing here. But where it really got me was
- 48:15in that third act, because they clearly spent the majority of
- 48:18the budget on the third act of this movie.
- 48:20There's, you know, much more multi camera setups and coverage
- 48:23from across, you know, the battlefield.
- 48:26And for me, it was this moment where Vickus gets in that big
- 48:29mechanical suit, which may or may not be a reference to the
- 48:33end of the movie Aliens, where Sigourney Weaver's, you know,
- 48:37give her back, you bitch. And and he's the one of the
- 48:40worst fight scenes in the history of cinema.
- 48:44Well, so he's like running away from Christopher Johnson.
- 48:47He's like, just, you can have the prawn, just let me go.
- 48:50And then he has his change of heart.
- 48:52And the, the shot that he chooses to frame it in is like,
- 48:56you see him in the metal suit, like slow down.
- 48:59And he kind of bows his head 'cause he's thinking about his
- 49:01choice. And you see the alien ship in
- 49:03the background and it's the only two things in the shot.
- 49:06And you see, like, here's the destination, here's my escape,
- 49:10here's my hope. And you watch him have an
- 49:12emotional transformation, the inside of a metal suit in the
- 49:16foreground, and I'm like, OK, this dude knows what he's doing.
- 49:19Like, Blomkamp composed that shot beautifully, and he's able
- 49:23to let these inanimate objects emote in a way that really gets
- 49:30the audience invested. I thought that he really proved
- 49:33himself in that final act of the film.
- 49:36Yeah, the, the claustrophobia of it, like every single time
- 49:40there's a shot inside of the suit and you're like shoved up
- 49:43in his face like it's Iron Man, like they like it.
- 49:46It creates this intense heated pressure of every decision that
- 49:52Vickus makes throughout the end of the film.
- 49:55There there's when you pair that with the continual shaky Cam,
- 50:02all of the whipping around the battlefield, the coordinated
- 50:05movements of the MNU troops coming in, it just feels like
- 50:11this really cool mix of like a Sicario and Edge of Tomorrow
- 50:17experience that as a film goer, I, I was 100% there for.
- 50:22I think Edge of Tomorrow is such a good comparison point.
- 50:25You know, it, it's a little bit more fun, it's a little bit more
- 50:28slick and Hollywood, but I think it took a lot of the sort of
- 50:31griminess and the in the dirt fighting from this movie.
- 50:36I've never really seen it done in such a visceral way as I saw
- 50:41in this film the first time I saw it.
- 50:43And and I do think that it's a much more influential film than
- 50:46it maybe gets credit for today. You know, it's been what, 15
- 50:49years since the movie came out? It's a popular movie that I
- 50:52think many, many people have seen, surprisingly popular, but
- 50:57I don't know if it gets credit for for influencing the genre.
- 51:01And it may go back to what we were talking about at the
- 51:03beginning, that there's just not a lot of sci-fi movies made
- 51:06anymore. So even if it is influential, we
- 51:09might not notice it. Yeah, I I know that the tagline
- 51:12for this movie was something along along the lines of like
- 51:15humans not allowed or there's no way out.
- 51:18I feel like it should have been Aliens have feelings too.
- 51:26I like it. I think that would have made it
- 51:27do so much more business, Brad. Yeah, and I I feel like it
- 51:31directly led to a movie like Shape of Water becoming a thing.
- 51:35Well, it's on that note. What if they just made the
- 51:37poster that photoshopped image of Vickus, like having like
- 51:41rigorous sex with dude. That's that's probably the worst
- 51:48part of the whole movie in terms of like, oh, this poor guy.
- 51:51Like the second he goes rogue, they've got photoshopped images
- 51:54of him and he's like in that sandwich shop, Like, can I get a
- 51:57sandwich? And then they put that on TV and
- 52:00everyone's like. And then he goes to the Nigerian
- 52:06like gang in District 9 and they somehow have a print magazine
- 52:12that has made its way into the slums already of a Vickus just
- 52:18getting it on with some aliens. It's incredible.
- 52:21If they have like a subscription, you know, do they
- 52:23mail it to you in District 9? A nice little mailman shows up.
- 52:28Care of Nigerian warlord. Can I say one thing, though?
- 52:31The the one thing about this movie that surprised me a little
- 52:35bit. The whole film is about how
- 52:38humans are terrible and we treat essentially, once they realized
- 52:42that the aliens didn't have anything to offer them and that
- 52:45they were just poor people, that's when like humans started
- 52:49treating them like garbage. But then the way that they
- 52:52portray the Nigerian gang in this movie, racist very much.
- 53:00It's not good, Bob. Yeah, you're right.
- 53:02Like Neil Blomkamp is obviously making an apartheid metaphor
- 53:06where the aliens are a stand in for what he witnessed black
- 53:10people experience in South Africa.
- 53:13But then the only actual black people in the movie are like
- 53:17partakers of voodoo and eating. And you know, like there's a
- 53:22there's a shot where they're like, oh, and of course the
- 53:24Nigerians started interspecies prostitution.
- 53:27And it's like, OK, like was that?
- 53:29Necessary. Yeah.
- 53:32It felt like a really strange inclusion in a movie about the
- 53:37dangers of racism. I don't know it as the slightly
- 53:42more conservative person on this podcast, even I watch that and
- 53:45was like, I don't, I don't know if this is great.
- 53:49Yeah, I mean, I don't want to accuse Neil Blomkamp of having
- 53:52his own implicit biases, but it it definitely feels like you're
- 53:56undermining the point you want to make here, bro.
- 53:58Yeah, a little bit, little bit. But see, that's that's the
- 54:02paradox, because then what if he was aware of it and it's like,
- 54:05well, we can't we can't have the terrorists be Nigerian.
- 54:09So then he makes them Middle Eastern, you know, like it's
- 54:11still the same problem. You know what I'm?
- 54:13Saying sure, yeah. This is what happens when when
- 54:17we get along peacefully with the Russians, Brad.
- 54:19It used to just be the Russians. We would make the Russians the
- 54:22bad guy and everything. And it worked perfectly for 30
- 54:25years. You didn't want the Nigerian
- 54:28like ganglord to just look at Vickus and be like I will crush
- 54:32you. I wanted a scene like in
- 54:34Goldeneye where Vickus drives a tank, like through the Kremlin
- 54:37or whatever would have worked. Yeah, exactly.
- 54:39I would have loved that. All right, man.
- 54:42I think we're in a good spot to get to our final segment of the
- 54:44day, which we call Let's Make it a Double presented by Blackwood
- 54:48Distilling Company. We're near the end of the
- 54:50episode, so thanks listening to the film and Whiskey show.
- 54:54Let's have another film with this one, even if it's
- 54:56struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 54:58day. Now let's make it a double.
- 55:00Let's Make It a Double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 55:03movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 55:06feature. Earlier today, I'm finishing up
- 55:09the film and Brad texts me and says I have the best let's make
- 55:13it a double. And I got to say man, it it kind
- 55:16of distracted me from the end of the film because I was wondering
- 55:20and so I started taking guesses. Now my first guess at what
- 55:24Brad's Let's Make it a Double was came towards the end of the
- 55:27film when I said to myself, man, rough day at the office for
- 55:32Vickus. And I thought I was real clever.
- 55:35And then I thought, Oh my gosh, what if that was Brad's thought
- 55:38too? What if his Let's Make It a
- 55:39Double is Office Space? Because I feel like that would
- 55:42be a fantastic bad Day at the Office movie.
- 55:47Absolutely perfect double feature, Bob.
- 55:50Like 10 out of 10. No.
- 55:52No comments, no recommendations. And then he said, it's not, it's
- 55:56not Office space. So then I'm thinking, OK, maybe
- 55:58he paired it up with like Hugh Jackman's real steal because he
- 56:02gets in this thing at the end of the movie.
- 56:04Maybe Brad goes thematic with it and starts thinking, oh, this is
- 56:08about an emotionally stunted male helping an alien find its
- 56:12way home and becoming more brave and courageous.
- 56:15So maybe it's ETI think I'm just striking out here, Brad, but I
- 56:19really want to know what you're let's make it a double is.
- 56:22My Let's Make It A Double follows a middle-aged man who is
- 56:28just kind of skating through life and finally, throughout the
- 56:32film, grabs adventure, grabs life by the horns and really
- 56:37takes it for a ride. Come on.
- 56:39This is going to be paired with The Secret Life of Walter Mitty.
- 56:45I love it. Tell me that this isn't sci-fi.
- 56:49Action adventure, secret life. I mean, I guess, man, it's no
- 56:54Office space. OK, Brad, I, I told you at one
- 56:59point that I was going to just do a season where I paired every
- 57:02single movie with ET. And I feel like this might
- 57:05actually be the best chance I have to pair a movie with ET.
- 57:09I'm trying to think of of what would be a good, let's make it a
- 57:12double. I spent so much time trying to
- 57:14guess yours that I didn't actually come up with one.
- 57:18Recently. I saw a movie in the theater
- 57:20called Nickel Boys, which is positioned to be a big Oscar
- 57:23movie. And throughout that film,
- 57:27there's reference to a movie from the 1950s called The
- 57:29Defiant Ones. It has Sidney Poitier and Tony
- 57:32Curtis in it as two escaped prisoners from a chain gang who
- 57:38are chained together. And Tony Curtis's character is
- 57:41like, super racist. And they have to figure out how
- 57:43to a, like, get to where they're going while chained together.
- 57:46And you watch them kind of become friends all the way
- 57:49through the film as they're being hunted.
- 57:52And I think that, like, after I talked all about the action
- 57:55movie tropes of this film, I'm going to pair this up with the
- 57:58Defiant Ones. It's a movie that I don't know
- 58:00if we'll ever get to on the podcast, so I'm glad to be able
- 58:03to talk about it here. Yeah, I that sounds like a
- 58:05fascinating film, Bob. I have not heard of it before,
- 58:08and I've only ever seen Tony Curtis make out with Marilyn
- 58:12Monroe. So.
- 58:14Well, now you can watch him be in close quarters with Sidney
- 58:17Poitier. So they're they're excited.
- 58:19Brad picks Secret Life of Walter Mitty.
- 58:22I picked the Defiant ones and that is today's Let's Make It a
- 58:26Double brought to you by Blackwood Distilling Company.
- 58:29No matter what film you choose to pair this with, you can
- 58:32always make it a double with Blackwood.
- 58:34And folks, if you go to bourbonoutfitter.com/film
- 58:38Whiskey, that's Bourbon outfitter.com/film Whiskey.
- 58:42Buy a bottle of Blackwood and use our code film WHISKEY at
- 58:46checkout. You'll get 5% off your bottle of
- 58:48Blackwood. Have you ever seen the clip of
- 58:53how I think it was like in Brazil or somewhere they would
- 58:56like insert products into? Movies.
- 59:01I sent you these. It was.
- 59:03Yeah, the the Star Wars. Cervesa.
- 59:05What was it called? I don't remember but but it
- 59:08would have the guy singing really loud too.
- 59:11Yes. Oh my gosh.
- 59:12I, I kind of want to do that with District 9, but just put
- 59:15like bottles of Blackwood whiskey all throughout the film.
- 59:19Like they crawl down into the little cargo ship they're going
- 59:21to use to escape and there's just like Blackwood Whiskey just
- 59:25hanging out behind like a crate or something.
- 59:29Oh man. Oh, it's Chris Cervesa Cristal.
- 59:32Yes. If it wasn't a copyright
- 59:35infringement, I'd play the clip right now, Brad.
- 59:38Yeah, totally. All right, dude, let's give this
- 59:40movie some final scores. I think that, like, if we're
- 59:43talking about this film as an influential movie, as a good
- 59:47alien movie, as a good action movie, and in terms of like what
- 59:51it accomplishes by what sci-fi I think does best, which is
- 59:54getting at real human issues, I think this movie's like a nine
- 59:58out of 10, dude. I'm I've been waffling back and
- 1:00:02forth between an 8 1/2 and a nine.
- 1:00:04I kind of want you to go ahead and go first because you said
- 1:00:06you were at a 7 1/2 and it's coming up.
- 1:00:08So where are you coming up to? I, I think I'm going to sit at
- 1:00:12an 8 out of 10 Bob. Like, I think this movie is
- 1:00:15really effective. It does what it wants to do
- 1:00:18well. I don't know if it quite
- 1:00:21transcends that 8 out of 10 mark where you start getting into
- 1:00:25some absolute classics of the genre at like 8 1/2 to 9 out of
- 1:00:3010. I I think I would need to see
- 1:00:32this once or twice more to really gauge my reaction on if
- 1:00:37it's worth that high of a score. I think that's fair.
- 1:00:40I'm going to give it an 8.5 out of 10.
- 1:00:42And perhaps the harder question is, does this deserve to be
- 1:00:45considered a modern classic? I think if we're just talking
- 1:00:48about like, here's the stack of movies, should this be included?
- 1:00:53I think there's definitely better films than this, but as a
- 1:00:57representative of sci-fi, there are not very many things that
- 1:01:01can go into the Canon from the 21st century.
- 1:01:05I don't know what are you thinking.
- 1:01:07I mean, another movie we could have gone with for Let's Make It
- 1:01:11a Double would have been something like Children of Men.
- 1:01:14And I think that if you had cinematography like that in this
- 1:01:19movie, like I think I could call it a modern classic.
- 1:01:23But overall, there's just too much generic use of camera and
- 1:01:29it's not bad. Like it's well done.
- 1:01:31The found footage, the security Cam footage is great.
- 1:01:34All of it is well done. None of it like advances the
- 1:01:38medium of film in a way that makes this movie feel heavy and
- 1:01:44impactful. Right?
- 1:01:45Doesn't have the the gravitas that something like a children
- 1:01:49of man would have. So I I think I'm going to hold
- 1:01:52off on saying that this is a modern class.
- 1:01:54I think I will, too. This is one of those
- 1:01:57beneficiaries. This was the first year that the
- 1:01:59Best picture field expanded back to 10 after The Dark Knight
- 1:02:03missed the cut in 2008. And so it gets nominated for
- 1:02:07best picture. But it's definitely one of those
- 1:02:08movies that's like, Oh yeah, everybody can agree this is one
- 1:02:12of the 10 best films of 2009. But it's when we're talking
- 1:02:17modern classics, I'm with you. Children of Men is one of my
- 1:02:20favorite movies of all time. Like that gets in and then this
- 1:02:22is one of those that branch off where you say, hey, if you like
- 1:02:25Children of Men, check out District 9 next or check out
- 1:02:29Edge of Tomorrow next. Because those have those
- 1:02:31dystopian themes, but they don't have the artistry and I think
- 1:02:35the lasting impact that a movie like Children of Men had.
- 1:02:39Yeah. I mean, Bob, this is a year kind
- 1:02:42of stacked for best picture. Like Hurt Locker wins it all.
- 1:02:46You've got Avatar up in the air, Blind Side, Inglourious
- 1:02:51Basterds, like up is in this, like this is a stacked year in
- 1:02:57the history of film. So I'll be I'll be frank with
- 1:03:01you, man. I don't think this makes the top
- 1:03:04five. I think this is like a 8-9 or
- 1:03:06ten in that list of 10 films. Can I give you my hot take
- 1:03:11though? Oh, I'm ready.
- 1:03:13This. Is a better movie than The Hurt
- 1:03:14Locker? Oh, it's not.
- 1:03:19It's like on par with Up in the Air, and it's probably not as
- 1:03:23good as Inglourious Basterds or even Sharp, but I think it's
- 1:03:28better than The Hurt Locker. I think you might be right, like
- 1:03:32Hurt Locker has certain elements about it that are better, but
- 1:03:38overall as a film I think this is way more entertaining than
- 1:03:42The Hurt Locker. I don't know if the purpose of
- 1:03:44the Hurt Locker was like, let's send them out dancing, you know,
- 1:03:48But all right, so it is an 8 1/2 for me.
- 1:03:52It's an 8 from Brad for an average of an 8.25.
- 1:03:56But we want to know what you think of District 9.
- 1:03:58First of all, is it a modern classic and is it better than
- 1:04:01the Hurt Locker? You can find us on all of our
- 1:04:03social media platforms, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram,
- 1:04:07Tiktok, and YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:04:10Or if you want to join the conversation, we are on our
- 1:04:13Discord server every single day talking to you guys, fans of the
- 1:04:17film and Whiskey podcast. So if you would like to join the
- 1:04:20conversation, there's there's a link to our server at the end of
- 1:04:22every single one of our show notes.
- 1:04:24Next week we are kicking off the Christmas time season with one
- 1:04:28of my favorite films from last year, 2023.
- 1:04:31It's The Holdovers. Brad, I cannot freaking wait to
- 1:04:35dive into the Holdovers with you, man.
- 1:04:37Dude, what a great movie. Oh, have you seen it already?
- 1:04:40Oh hell yeah. Let's do it, man.
- 1:04:42I. I am so excited to go over the
- 1:04:44holdovers with you that like if there was ever a movie built for
- 1:04:51this podcast, like for a for this podcast, but B for Paul
- 1:04:55Giamatti, like it was the holdovers.
- 1:04:58All right, next week we'll see you for the holdovers, but until
- 1:05:00then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:05:03And we'll see you next time.