Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / CAMELS: The Top Has Never Looked Better - The Bottom Is Showing Stress
Transcript
- 0:00mark: Hey, everyone, this is Mark Trakel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Happy October.
- 0:04I'm recording this on Friday, October 2nd.
- 0:07This episode will go live Monday.
- 0:11I guess that would be October 5th.
- 0:14And the CAMEL data is out for quarter number two.
- 0:18Now, typically, NCUA would do a big reveal on CAMEL as part of the NCUSIF
- 0:24Insurance Fund briefing, which is typically done in September or October.
- 0:27Maybe they'll do it in October.
- 0:29But we found the financial data and the gross numbers on the
- 0:34CAMEL codes on NCUA's website.
- 0:37So without them having done a briefing, we have the data from their public sources,
- 0:41and we're gonna talk through that.
- 0:43Now Kyle Hauptman is gone.
- 0:46John Cruz is at NCUA.
- 0:48He's not yet had a board meeting.
- 0:49I'm sure he's drinking water from a fire hose at NCUA, getting caught up
- 0:53and trying to get ready to fill the requirement to have their budget briefing.
- 0:58And I'm looking forward to seeing his first meeting.
- 1:00Maybe it'll be in October.
- 1:02But here we have the CAMEL data, and I wanted to walk through what the
- 1:06data is showing and what it might mean for, what it might mean for
- 1:09me for my take, and what it might mean for you at your credit union.
- 1:13And then we'll have some data that was tied to that report.
- 1:17That is the financial data from June, and I'll have some thoughts on that, although
- 1:21we already did a separate podcast with that, with Todd and Steve and myself.
- 1:26And you can get more details on the financials than I'll give you here today.
- 1:31All right, so What's the headline of the report?
- 1:35It's an industry bifurcating, pulling apart at both ends.
- 1:39Currently, CAMEL code 1s are at 21.3%.
- 1:44That's the highest amount of CAMEL code 1 credit unions going back to 2016
- 1:49in the data that I've been tracking.
- 1:50So CAMEL 1s at an all-time high over the last 10 years.
- 1:54CAMEL 3s are down to 14.5%.
- 1:58That's the load-- the lowest amount of CAMEL code 3s in the 10 years.
- 2:03Why is this happening?
- 2:05'Cause NCUA doesn't have the resources.
- 2:08They're getting a little friendlier with coding.
- 2:10And this is all before the new CAMEL ratings come out, CAMEL
- 2:15guidance and requirements on how they rate you comes out.
- 2:18That's an FFIEC proposal.
- 2:19We've done separate podcasts on that here.
- 2:22And that's gonna make it, the CAMEL ratings even simpler.
- 2:26We also have a podcast recently on NCUA's entry letter, which goes into some of the
- 2:31things they're doing and not doing, which is also a positive for credit unions.
- 2:36What's gone in the wrong direction?
- 2:37100 CAMEL code 4s.
- 2:39That's up seven from the last quarter, while the industry is shrinking.
- 2:43So there's less, a few less credit unions, but there's more CAMEL code 4s.
- 2:47So that's the bifurcation.
- 2:49There's more 4s, but there's more 1s.
- 2:51So those 3s are either moving to 2s and 1s or down to 4s,
- 2:55and that's something to watch.
- 2:57That's something to watch if you are interested in buying credit unions
- 3:00from NCUA and/or merging credit unions.
- 3:03And there are seven credit unions with negative net worth.
- 3:06That's up from three at the end of 2025, and that is up
- 3:11from zero at the end of 2022.
- 3:14I will tell you, seven's a big number.
- 3:15That surprises me.
- 3:17Those are credit unions that NCUA has to either conserve or liquidate or merge.
- 3:22We recently saw a notification that Jackson Area via NCUA's notification,
- 3:28was purchased by Five Star.
- 3:30It also the headline kinda had one big reveal.
- 3:33It says they assumed the shares and the members.
- 3:35That meant all assets were kept by the insurance fund.
- 3:39Why would that be?
- 3:41Probably because there's fraud in the loans and fraud in the other assets.
- 3:45Otherwise, Five Star would have wanted to take them.
- 3:49But if you can't figure out a price because there's fraud present, you
- 3:52don't take them, and that may have been why the resolution of that
- 3:56dragged out longer than what NCUA had told the bidders that it would.
- 4:00So that's interesting to watch.
- 4:01There's also a lot of chatter on Jackson Area, by the way, who was probably
- 4:05one of the code 5s we're gonna get to here that the CEO pled guilty.
- 4:09I'm not gonna get into that here.
- 4:10Probably have a sec- a separate podcast to update on that.
- 4:14But the top of the distribution has never looked better.
- 4:17The bottom is showing stress that we haven't seen since 2017.
- 4:21Here's a chart.
- 4:22If you're watching on YouTube, you can see it.
- 4:24I'll talk through it if you're listening on the podcast.
- 4:26There's 4,211 federal credit unions.
- 4:29That's down from 4,450 at year-end 2024 and 5,844 10 years ago.
- 4:37So 10 years ago, there were 1,600 more credit unions, and the merger
- 4:41attrition is roughly 140 to 150 credit unions per year now that are
- 4:46are going away and being merged.
- 4:4983% of credit unions are either a code one or a code two.
- 4:53That's up slightly from last quarter at 82.7.
- 4:57And 2.5%
- 4:58of ⦠are either CAMELS four or fives, so a slight increase in
- 5:02combining fours or fives from 2.4
- 5:04to 2.5%.
- 5:06And, again, it's better at the top, but there's a heavier tail
- 5:10on the bottom An eight-quarter view code threes keep falling.
- 5:15From the third quarter of 2024, they were as high as 718.
- 5:20They came down in the fourth quarter '24, came down in first quarter,
- 5:23second quarter, third quarter, fourth quarter 2025, first quarter 2026.
- 5:29And again in the second quarter of 2026, there are 611, down from 718.
- 5:36So that's what?
- 5:37A high- a, a reduction of 100.
- 5:40100 compared to s- that's about 14, 15%, doing a rough
- 5:44justice math here in my head.
- 5:46CAMEL code four credit unions were as high as 138 in the third quarter 2024, and were
- 5:52on a, a downward trend until last quarter, first quarter of 2026 at 93, and then
- 5:58they peak back up into the 100s, right at 100 for the second quarter of 2026.
- 6:04And again economically, there are some credit unions that are being challenged.
- 6:08And it's interesting that NCUA is being nicer on the better credit unions
- 6:13and harsher on the bad credit unions.
- 6:15That may be an offshoot of, It may be an offshoot of the new marching orders
- 6:21that they have, is that they want them to deal with the real problems, but they
- 6:25don't want to do warning shot code threes.
- 6:28They don't wanna do CYA code threes which are not in writing
- 6:33anywhere, but it does happen.
- 6:35So There are six code fives.
- 6:37One of them was actually over a billion.
- 6:39I think I figured out which one that was, because they recently announced
- 6:42a merger, but I won't go in that here.
- 6:43If you wanna know who it was, shoot me a note.
- 6:46Under fi- 50 million four code fives.
- 6:49Between 50 and 100, there's one, and then there's the big one that
- 6:52was over, over a billion dollars.
- 6:56And if you look back through 2024, the code five count had been as low as two.
- 7:03It peaked last quarter at 10, is, and is now back down to six.
- 7:06Typically, when it goes down, it's because they were liquidated or
- 7:09merged, not that they got better.
- 7:12Code five means basically you got a year to survive until you die.
- 7:16At least that's what the old rule used to be.
- 7:19A str- a stronger average hides a thickening tail on capital.
- 7:23Pivoting to now off of the CAMEL codes into what the data showed.
- 7:28A- aggregate net worth ratio is 11.4%.
- 7:31There are 30 credit unions below 6%, seven which are negative, one between 0 and 2%,
- 7:37five between 2 and 4%, and 17 at 4 to 6%.
- 7:41So if you're interested in mergers, those are the ones, if you're on NCUA's merger
- 7:45registry, and if you're not, you should get on it, that they'd be contacting
- 7:49credit unions most likely and saying, "Hey, we're gonna be shopping this.
- 7:52Are you interested?"
- 7:53The other thing is you can get your data off Callahan's, you
- 7:55can get your data off NCUA.
- 7:57Look who those folks are and reach out to them to see if they might be interested
- 8:01in joining your credit union So it's the speed of decline that matters.
- 8:06Capital is king, and what I wrote here is that capital is king,
- 8:09and it can keep NCUA at bay.
- 8:11As you move down the, in capital, your self-determination and
- 8:14your control greatly diminishes.
- 8:17And as a reminder, if you're over 7%, you're well capitalized.
- 8:20There are no mandatory PCA actions.
- 8:22If you fall between 6% and 7%, you're adequately capitalized,
- 8:26and there's an earnings retention required, 10 basis points per quarter.
- 8:30You have to write to NCUA every quarter.
- 8:33They get really ticked off if you don't file that request.
- 8:36Typically, 99.9%
- 8:39of the time they will say, "Yes, you can pay your dividends after
- 8:41you put your letter in," 'cause they don't wanna cause a run.
- 8:444% to 6%, undercapitalized, net worth restoration plan.
- 8:48This can be running the gauntlet.
- 8:50NCUA has you submit a net worth restoration plan that so shows
- 8:53what the definition says, you're going to restore your net worth.
- 8:57The nice thing about that is once you do that, you don't have to do those
- 9:00earning retentions every quarter, you just have to meet your plan.
- 9:03If you fall between 2% and 4%, you're significantly undercapitalized.
- 9:07It gives NCUAs more powers.
- 9:09And if it falls below 2%, that's when NCUA has a certain number of days per
- 9:13the act and the regulations to conserve the credit union Now, margins are at
- 9:19record levels over the last 10 years.
- 9:213.49%
- 9:22interest margin which had bottomed out in 2022 at 2.57%.
- 9:28Loan yields up also a record in the last 10 years at 6.1%.
- 9:32Cost of funds is down to 1.71%,
- 9:36which is below the peak of 1.93%
- 9:39at the end of 2024.
- 9:41ROA, or return on average assets, at 91 basis points.
- 9:44It's the best since the middle of 2019, and it's up from 63 basis points at the
- 9:50end of 2024, so it's up 50% since 2024.
- 9:55Provision expense, 55 basis points.
- 9:57It's off the peak of 63 basis points, but it's still above the 0.4
- 10:02to 0.48
- 10:04pre-pandemic range Delinquencies have plateaued, but it's at a higher level.
- 10:10Seventy basis points at the end of twenty nineteen.
- 10:13Twenty twenty-one, it fell to forty-six basis points.
- 10:16First quarter of twenty twenty-five, ninety-one basis points.
- 10:20End of twenty twenty-five, peaked at a hundred and three basis points,
- 10:24and now at ninety-six basis points.
- 10:26Charge-offs are at seventy-eight, eight basis points.
- 10:29The trailing four quarters in dollars is thirteen point four billion
- 10:33versus thirteen point two the year before, so it's up a little bit,
- 10:37and it's leveling off after the climb to thir- three point four.
- 10:42It's leveling off after the climb from three point four
- 10:45billion in twenty twenty-two.
- 10:48Participation loans are interesting to take a look at.
- 10:53Delinquency of participation loans is one point one one percent,
- 10:56which is highest in the data set.
- 10:58It's more than double the fifty-four basis points at the end of twenty twenty-two.
- 11:02Balances are up to eighty-eight billion from seventy-two billion
- 11:07at the end of twenty twenty-three.
- 11:09And buyers don't always have the originator's underwriting insight, so
- 11:12losses can be a bit of a more surprise when they do hit, and that does
- 11:16happen, and I've seen it happening.
- 11:18Indirect lending, eighty-eight basis points off of its peak of a hund-
- 11:22a hundred and two basis points.
- 11:23The peak was at the end of twenty twenty-four.
- 11:25On that, the worst may be behind us, but indirect still runs higher
- 11:29delinquency than direct lending, and of course, direct lending, because you
- 11:32know your members, is the sweet spot.
- 11:35Liquidity and balance sheet management, the squeeze is over.
- 11:39The deposit base has changed.
- 11:40The current share mix money markets are eighteen percent regular
- 11:45shares, twenty-eight percent, share certificates, twenty-nine percent,
- 11:49and all others fall into the twenty-five point four six category.
- 11:55Certificates are up from eighteen point four percent in twenty sixteen.
- 12:00The core is more sensitive, rate sensitive than five years ago.
- 12:03Earnings are at risk if rates are moving sharply, which they have
- 12:06been, and I'm sure the second quarter data will be interesting to see.
- 12:11Net long-term assets under NCUA's definition, just
- 12:15under thirty-five percent.
- 12:17Back to the ten-year average after being at forty percent range
- 12:22between twenty twenty-one and twenty twenty-two, so that's good to see.
- 12:26Share growth versus loan growth.
- 12:27Share growth's been five point two percent, loan growth
- 12:30at four point nine percent.
- 12:31With inflation and rates rising, I'm wondering if that share
- 12:35growth will be able to continue.
- 12:38Probably not, would be my guess.
- 12:40What examiners are seeing by s- by CAMEL code size.
- 12:44Let's see.
- 12:44The code fours and fives, 4.5%
- 12:47of credit unions under 50 million are code fours or fives.
- 12:51Between 500 million and a billion, that falls to 1.4%.
- 12:55Between a billion and 10, 10 billion, it falls to z- 40 basis points.
- 12:59And there are no code fours or fives over 10 billion.
- 13:03In the code threes, under 50 million, it's 22%.
- 13:07Between 500 million and a billion, it's 11%.
- 13:11Between one and 10 billion, it's 5%.
- 13:14And over fi- over 10 billion, it's 4%.
- 13:17So again, the smaller you are, the less resources you have to deal with your
- 13:22issues the worse your CAMEL codes are.
- 13:24But again these are the best CAMEL codes I've seen in a very long time.
- 13:28Quite frankly, I don't think they can get much better.
- 13:30The pendulum probably gonna swing, although with them redefining the
- 13:34CAMELs, and with them taking a softer touch, it's quite possible
- 13:38this trend could get a little bit better over the next year or two.
- 13:42But as some of these institutions have lost reviews by the inspector
- 13:46general, and then NCUA has to say, "How are you gonna deal with this?"
- 13:49And a potential administration change two years down the road one
- 13:53way or the other, there will be a new president, and that will lead
- 13:55to some different things changing.
- 13:57But the times are good to have a good CAMEL code right now because NCUA and
- 14:01other banking regulators are walking with a lighter touch So in conclusion, four
- 14:07things to take to your boar- boardroom.
- 14:09Your benchmark against your peers, not the aggregate.
- 14:12If your delinquency is twice the peer, they're not supposed to refer to peer.
- 14:17But they will ask you questions about your delinquency and what
- 14:20you're doing to control it.
- 14:21The problem pipeline is fullest as it is in years.
- 14:24That's bad if you're one of those problems.
- 14:26It's good if you're looking for potential merger partners.
- 14:29And participat- participations are becoming have been a- and will continue to
- 14:34be an exam focus, particularly when that delinquency in some situations is creating
- 14:41havoc for some individual credit unions.
- 14:43And that's what's driving those numbers up a few basis points, is that there's
- 14:46some, some bad situations out there in some particular credit unions.
- 14:51And you're always gonna have ALM conversations tied to your deposit mix.
- 14:55Generally speaking, I've seen NCUA getting a little bit nicer on this front, although
- 15:00I've had some very bizarre conversations with credit unions recently about a couple
- 15:05of overly aggressive risk RCMSs which have quite frankly shocked me recently.
- 15:11But I won't go into details here.
- 15:13But NCUA is supposed to be only enforcing regulations, only enforcing safety and
- 15:19soundness if it's extremely material.
- 15:22And I've seen some instances where, in general, NCUA is being a little
- 15:25bit more reasonable in that regard, and then I've seen others that have me
- 15:28scratching my heads when they're being tougher than they normally would be.
- 15:32So as always feel free to reach out if your exam if you have questions
- 15:36about your exam, you have questions about anything I've talked about here,
- 15:39or if you've got an exam and didn't like how it goes and you'd like my, my
- 15:42take you can find me on LinkedIn, you can find me at info@marktrakel.com.
- 15:47And I respond very quickly a- and we can set up a call to see what's going on.
- 15:53All right, that's a wrap.
- 15:54I hope you're enjoying the beginning of October.
- 15:56We got some other exciting episodes coming out here soon.
- 15:59And as always, if you're watching, thank you for doing so.
- 16:03If you're listening, the same.
- 16:05I hope you'll do the same again soon.
- 16:07This is Mark Trakel, signing off with flying colors.