Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Community, Context, Confusion & The AI Credential Crisis
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning.
- 0:23It is Monday, September 14th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. That's Kyle Mounts here today.
- 0:30We're gonna recap all the things Kyle saw and heard at the NCM Friends and Family event last week. And whatever else we happen to come up with. It's gonna be- Whatever else we're talking about...
- 0:39we're moving and shaking, dude. It's fun. It's like- [laughs]... we haven't, we haven't talked about- Can we get back in our desks again, just you and me? I'm so excited, man. Can we do that one of these days?
- 0:47I'm so excited. It's happening. Tuesday's the day. It's Tuesday. Tuesday the day. Are you gonna be at your desk on Tuesday? I'm gonna be at my... Uh, no, I'm not gonna be at my desk on Tuesday.
- 0:54[laughs] And then I'm not gonna be at my desk 'cause I'm gonna be in T- Wednesday's the day. No, it's not. You will be. Oh, that's right, 'cause you're in DC. I'll be in DC for- Friday's the day... Wednesday.
- 1:01Friday's the day. Friday's the day. Friday's the grand reunion. Unbelievable. Oh, I'm super excited. We, we all are.
- 1:07Because tomorrow is the 15th, the day we're talking about what it is that we've been cooking up for the last several months. Big announcement coming up- Big things... on the 15th.
- 1:16So, uh, if you're not on the email list, you should be, 'cause that's probably gonna be the first place it drops. Absolutely. You can get that by going to daily.asotu.com.
- 1:25I don't know if we've moved it over to asotu.com yet. You can go to asotu.com too and get that. Either way, you can get the email. Yeah. We're getting our lives together over here. We're getting our lives together.
- 1:32[laughs] Trying. Can you believe- Thinking about it... can you believe it is almost Q4? Dude, I, I- Like, we're two weeks away...
- 1:38I actually was having a conversation, like, with someone last week about a tech product at AutoGenius. And I was like, "Yeah, yeah, yeah. That'll, that'll be done by, like, probably the end of Q3."
- 1:47And they were like, "You know that's three weeks, right?" [laughs] And I was like, "F-" "Probably gonna be beginning of Q4"... "We'll go Q4." [laughs] Just like that. Yeah.
- 1:55All right, today's show is brought to you by AutoHub. There are two ways to acquire used cars. The expensive way involves auctions, fees, transportation, and possibly even a breakfast sandwich you might regret.
- 2:07The other is AutoHub. The all-in-one platform helps you appraise, offer, and buy cars directly from your own customers in store, online, or right from the service drive in minutes.
- 2:17Visit autohub.io to help you buy the car that's already in your lane. So, um, we, we obviously, last week you were at the NCM Friends and Family. Yes. We have a few things going on- It was great...
- 2:27this week, so we're gonna have more.
- 2:28But, but tell me, whenever you get to spend time, like, checked out of the normal routine of life and in a closed time with dealers and practitioners who, and also industry partners, who are sharing.
- 2:39Like, a lot of sharing goes on in those rooms.
- 2:41'Cause we have an idea of what's happening in the world and what people are seeing, but the way tech is moving and the way even, like, industry forces are moving right now, best practices seem like they're changing on a monthly basis.
- 2:53So, um, what are some of the things and trends that you heard last week from the things that the dealers shared on what they're doing, what's working, what's not working? All right. So, so I've been thinking about this.
- 3:02I'm gonna be the, I'm gonna be a good Baptist preacher. I'm gonna give you the three Cs that I heard last week. [laughs] Uh, so it was community, confusion, and context.
- 3:10And I'm really, the, the second one is probably the one I'm gonna lean on the most. Um, you know, the, the NCM community and, and a lot of the communities that are within it are, are so rich and vibrant.
- 3:20And it really has to do with the centrality around 20 groups.
- 3:23A lot of the people that were, uh, there last week are in their marketing or AI 20 groups, but there are also plenty of general managers, dealer principals, owners, that are in their own 20 groups.
- 3:32And the value that, that is expressed that they get out of those tight 20-person relationships, where they can be in person three or four times a year and also leverage async communications, was very clearly expressed.
- 3:46It was almost like, "Hey, look, I come here, and I'm gonna go back to my 20 group and talk to them about the conversations." So this peer-to-peer understanding.
- 3:54And I was just, as I was talking to a couple of those people, um, and I was talking to Brandon Beaver. Uh, he, he was out here from Beaver Toyota, good friends of ours.
- 4:03He said, he said what he's realizing engineering so much around AI, uh, and we'll get to that in a second, is that institutional knowledge is one of the, like, most important things right now. Hmm.
- 4:18Um, having that institutional knowledge and leveraging others that have similar institutional knowledge as opposed to leveraging AI to grav- to grab all of the knowledge that you need things to ha- things to happen, um, in, in your dealership or your business.
- 4:33So, so leveraging those 20 groups, the communities. Got to have dinner with, like, 17 people one night, and it was just clear that community is such a rich aspect to retail auto, that don't lose that.
- 4:46If you are starting to drift away from that or isolate yourself, do not do that. Um, Daniel Kim actually said, Daniel Kim, previously Orbee, um, now Barnes Crossing.
- 4:56He said, uh, to a few of us, he said, "You know, I've been to, like, a ton of other industries," uh, because he was in the software, uh, conferences, because he was in the software world. And he said,
- 5:07"There's nothing like a retail auto, uh, industry because people just love being in conversation and in community." So community's number one. No, that's, that's great. And so hold on, let me, let me feed back on that.
- 5:17So, you know, I was talking, I had a conversation with Ed Roberts, I think it was, not last week, the week before. Yeah. And he was saying, he's like, "Well, AI doesn't, doesn't actually solve your problems."
- 5:29He's like, "It just gives your inefficiency a dashboard and a monthly bill." [laughs] Right? He's say- gives you...
- 5:36And, but, but the reality is, like I've been thinking about what technology actually brings in, in a time when technology is shifting so quickly.
- 5:43What you just said is that institutional knowledge becomes probably the most primary, primary durable asset that you have. Yep. Absolutely. Anchor all of this as you move through.
- 5:53So investing in the time to cultivate that durable asset, knowing that there's gonna be a lot of layers on top of it, makes a lot of sense. Okay, community's number one. Okay.
- 6:01Number two- So I'm gonna switch, I'm gonna switch two and three because you just kind of l- you know, segued me into number two now, which is, or three, which is context.
- 6:10And- That especially with all of these AI tools, I was talking to Horizon, I was talking to, to Mia last week, um, and, and a lot of dealers that are developing their own stuff, is that the context of not just the digital data that's available, whether that be, uh, your vehicle data or your brand data, but the offline context of, like, how you make decisions, your standard operating proc- uh, procedures, um, the process that's required to sell a car, service a car, uh, you know, get a car th- get a deal through accounting.
- 6:40Any of those things, uh, why the leaders make decisions the way they do, are all a pa- a part of the data model and knowledge graph that it r- that is required- Mm-hmm... to leverage any level of AI technology.
- 6:52Otherwise, you are l- learn- you are leaning on others learning to create the process for your dealership.
- 7:00And that is a dangerous situation because as we say a lot, the single greatest, um, value proposition of retail auto is its people. Mm-hmm.
- 7:07And so if you strip that away, then the context that you bring to whatever conversation, the net new auto vendor- That makes you unique, right? Yes... any of that. Yeah. So- All right. That's good... context was two.
- 7:19What was confu- Was your second was confusion? Was that what you said? So confusion.
- 7:23So I had three conversations with different dealers this week, and they were all, they were all general managers or owners, um, uh, last week, that, that,
- 7:33you know, they said over the last, let's call it 15 years, the, especially the vendor community has been very aligned in, like, this is what to do next.
- 7:43Whether it be kind of like the prevailing conversation, whether it be digital retail or CDP or, "Hey, you need to get into, uh, you know, multi-channel marketing through digital spaces."
- 7:53Like, the vendor community would run after s- things in a similar vein, and everybody had their iterative way of doing it. Mm-hmm.
- 8:01But they said what they've experienced over the last six months since NADA is there's a lot of dissonance in the conversation.
- 8:08And, you know, there's, there's kind of like, "No, no, you should do it this way," or, "You should do it this way." And it's the first time that they've really experienced that at scale. Hmm.
- 8:15And so they- That makes sense... were having so much, they've, they're having so much trouble finding what they would, they call it, they all three called it direction. Mm-hmm. "What do I do next?" Right? Mm-hmm.
- 8:26As opposed to, like, "I know what to do next, I just have to select the partner, or I just have to select the, the path." Right. This is, this is a very different world for dealers.
- 8:35So when, uh, I would say to, like, the vendor partners, you know, like, make sure that you understand the entire limit- landscape when you're talking to dealers so that you can clarify and talk to the other pathways, but also clarify what your pathway and what your desire is.
- 8:51And then for dealers, back to context. Make sure you're writing your processes. Make sure you're writing your mission and your vision so that you can have clarity no matter what the context of the technology is.
- 9:04Your clarity is on your mission, your vision, the values, the things that you require as a business to be solvent. Then it's, then it, it makes an, an easier decision-making process.
- 9:15I think the fact that there are so many resources and so many opinion... Like, there's, there's never been more ways to accomplish a goal than there are right now. Right. That's right.
- 9:26Because, uh, peop- people like Brandon Beaver, right?
- 9:29You have people who are very smart, who understand how pieces come together, and if a challenge comes up or when they approach a problem, they can approach it in a unique way to them.
- 9:39And they say, "Oh, well, maybe we solve this first and then this, this, this, and this." And that's not gonna be the same way that that problem would be solved in a different dealership or a different group.
- 9:48And now we used to, as an industry, just rely on industry partners to present solutions, so naturally there were fewer solutions and fewer directions to consider.
- 9:58But now, you know, you and I suffer from this all the time. It's like, "Oh, look what I just did." It's not what we should do. It's like, "I just explored this pathway" and then it answers the question.
- 10:07Got to the end of it. Yeah. But, but, but then it an- answers the question like, should we keep going down this pathway? Yeah. Because we opened it up and we can, right?
- 10:16And so I think that that adds to the confusion in this day and age, which means there's nowhere to hide for the people who aren't willing to go all in and answer.
- 10:25And the world is your oyster for everyone who is willing to be in the game and be hyper-focused. And I, I really think that the only way the winners are gonna win are by spending time together with one another.
- 10:37Like, I really do feel like those times- Back to community. Absolutely... and, and not in a way... Like, it can definitely help when you're in a clubhouse room.
- 10:43It could help when you're, you know, on an email list or something, sharing some of the same information.
- 10:48But I think the value of being in person with some other people is just going to become more and more and more important for the dealership- Yeah... that are gonna be in the front runners.
- 10:57What, isn't that funny how we go right back to that? Comes right back. So I got a bonus one. The very last conversation I had last- Is it a C? What? No. Uh. Okay. [laughs] Maybe concern. Uh, it's concern.
- 11:10Uh, the very last conversation I had with someone in the marketing and IT department at a slightly larger group, um, was, the, the question was, who should own the AI practice for a dealership?
- 11:23And I said, "Tell me why you ask that." And he said, "We had a platform manager over a few stores
- 11:29that had created this really cool dashboard and automated pricing for all of their used cars across the platform over three or four stores. And we went to them and said, 'Oh, wow, that's incredible.
- 11:39How did you do that?'" And the answer was, "Oh, it was really easy. I gave Claude my IMS credentials." And in that moment they were like, "Oh my goodness, this is a massive problem," because now credentials are leaked to
- 11:57a, a, a frontier model, uh, without IT governance. And so- Oh, my... if you aren't putting I- AI governance, AI best practices, AI training, and governance at the IT and marketing department levels- Wow...
- 12:14uh, that is, like, high importance this week. So my last one is concern. Wow. Go do that. [laughs] Oh my gosh. All right.
- 12:22Look, I don't know what else we can talk about but those three things, the three Cs, Kyle said them all. Well, four Cs 'cause we got concerning there. The bottom line is stay close to the people you trust.
- 12:32Learn from them, learn from one another, and we'll keep marching.
- 12:37[upbeat music]