Latest / Bloomberg Law / Weekend Law: Trump Appeals, Bayer Verdicts & George Carlin AI Suit
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: You're listening to Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:11Speaker 2: How do I apply round up, whaed and grass killer products?
- 0:14Speaker 3: Using roundup weed and grass killer products right is key
- 0:18Speaker 3: to maximizing their effectiveness and safety.
- 0:21Speaker 1: But plaintiffs say that Roundup is not safe, and Beyer
- 0:24Speaker 1: has gotten hammered by jury verdicts totally almost four billion
- 0:28Speaker 1: dollars in the last three months, and the company's latest
- 0:32Speaker 1: courtroom loss was its biggest since round up cases started
- 0:35Speaker 1: going to trial. About five years ago. A Pennsylvania jury
- 0:39Speaker 1: awarded two point twenty five billion dollars to a former
- 0:43Speaker 1: round Up user who blamed his cancer diagnosis on long
- 0:47Speaker 1: term use of the herbicide, and two billion dollars was
- 0:50Speaker 1: impunitive damages designed to punish Bayer. The long running litigation,
- 0:55Speaker 1: with more than fifty thousand round Up cases still outstanding,
- 1:00Speaker 1: has coused some investors to call for a change in
- 1:02Speaker 1: Beyer's litigation strategy, but its options seem limited. Joining me
- 1:07Speaker 1: is an expert in mass tort litigation, Elizabeth Birch, a
- 1:11Speaker 1: professor at the University of Georgia Law School. The long
- 1:14Speaker 1: running litigation, with more than fifty thousand round up cases
- 1:18Speaker 1: still outstanding. Has caused some investors to call for a
- 1:22Speaker 1: change in Beyer's litigation strategy, But the problem is its
- 1:26Speaker 1: options are very limited. Joining me is an expert in
- 1:29Speaker 1: mass tort litigation, Elizabeth Birch, a professor at the University
- 1:33Speaker 1: of Georgia Law School. So, Elizabeth, this latest Beyer verdict
- 1:37Speaker 1: was its biggest ever, more than two billion dollars. Aren't
- 1:41Speaker 1: companies supposed to learn as litigation goes on and be
- 1:45Speaker 1: able to refine and improve their strategy.
- 1:50Speaker 3: One would certainly hope. So although I think you know,
- 1:53Speaker 3: Bear would probably mention that they've won ten of the
- 1:56Speaker 3: last sixteen trials, I think their hope certainly is to
- 1:59Speaker 3: try to get a case like this reverse on appeal,
- 2:02Speaker 3: and there is some precedent.
- 2:03Speaker 2: For that in the past.
- 2:04Speaker 3: Back in twenty nineteen, a California jury awarded roughly two
- 2:08Speaker 3: point five billion dollars in damages that ended up getting
- 2:12Speaker 3: slashed to eighty seven million. So it's still a lot
- 2:14Speaker 3: of money, but certainly not money with a.
- 2:16Speaker 1: Bee By ors vowed to appeal, express confidence that will prevail,
- 2:21Speaker 1: and it says it's not giving up as far as
- 2:23Speaker 1: trying cases. But what is it strategy because it did
- 2:26Speaker 1: spend about ten billion on settling one hundred and fifty
- 2:29Speaker 1: thousand cases.
- 2:30Speaker 3: You're right, it absolutely did, and it also indicated I
- 2:34Speaker 3: think a year or two ago, that it was planning
- 2:36Speaker 3: to pull round Up off the market in the next
- 2:38Speaker 3: couple of years. I think the hope being that at
- 2:41Speaker 3: some point these cases will stop. But the difficulty that
- 2:44Speaker 3: Bear's facing is that there's a long gaps between exposured
- 2:48Speaker 3: around Up and then the potential for developing some sort
- 2:52Speaker 3: of a non Hodgkins and foma, a different type of
- 2:54Speaker 3: cancer and these types of cases. So it's really hard
- 2:57Speaker 3: to say, you know, even if we were to pull
- 2:59Speaker 3: round Up off the mark at tomorrow when the litigation
- 3:02Speaker 3: might end. You know, when they contemplated taking it off
- 3:05Speaker 3: the market and indicated that they were going to take
- 3:07Speaker 3: it off the market in the future, they were trying
- 3:10Speaker 3: to come up with something that was equally effective at
- 3:13Speaker 3: killing weeds, and that was going to take some time
- 3:15Speaker 3: to develop. With my understanding, so I think they're trying
- 3:18Speaker 3: to have some sort of replacement for it as soon
- 3:21Speaker 3: as they pull it from the shelf.
- 3:23Speaker 1: So Beyer is facing now. Ten trials are expected this
- 3:27Speaker 1: year in state courts. It says the companies committed to
- 3:31Speaker 1: trying round up cases based on the strength of the science,
- 3:34Speaker 1: favorable regulatory assessments worldwide, and approven record of success at trial.
- 3:41Speaker 1: It was successful until I think it was October when
- 3:45Speaker 1: plaintiffs started racking up victories in California, Missouri, and Pennsylvania
- 3:50Speaker 1: state courts. Did something happen where the cases started to
- 3:54Speaker 1: turn against Beyer.
- 3:55Speaker 3: Yeah, it's hard to pinpoint of particular sea change. They
- 3:58Speaker 3: were certainly successful in settling a bulk of those cases
- 4:02Speaker 3: through what's known as the multi district litigation process. That's
- 4:05Speaker 3: at the federal level, but where they're really facing pressure
- 4:08Speaker 3: now is at the state level, particularly in jurisdictions like Philadelphia.
- 4:13Speaker 3: You know, I think every case is probably unique in
- 4:15Speaker 3: the sense that you're really highlighting the facts of your
- 4:18Speaker 3: particular client. And I think what we see in this
- 4:21Speaker 3: latest case is not just the use of kind of
- 4:24Speaker 3: garden variety round up on a half acre plot of land,
- 4:27Speaker 3: but sustained use over a fairly large plot of lands
- 4:30Speaker 3: and multiple acres and many many gallons of round up
- 4:34Speaker 3: braid at a time. So you really do see a
- 4:37Speaker 3: high volume of exposure and it's possible that the cases
- 4:40Speaker 3: that have been lost are cases with more casual use,
- 4:44Speaker 3: and there.
- 4:45Speaker 1: Is pursuing another legal strategy with regard to those state cases.
- 4:49Speaker 1: It's trying to convince appeals courts that federal law preempts
- 4:53Speaker 1: state claims.
- 4:55Speaker 3: Well, the preemption question has been out there for a
- 4:59Speaker 3: long time. It's not something that they've been successful on
- 5:03Speaker 3: thus far, and so you know, I think that's still
- 5:07Speaker 3: a really open question that remains to be seen. But
- 5:09Speaker 3: they haven't gotten a lot of traction with it.
- 5:11Speaker 1: And there is contradictory scientific evidence introduced in these cases
- 5:16Speaker 1: and differing opinions from agencies about whether the chemical and
- 5:21Speaker 1: roundup is a carcinogen that's correct, and I.
- 5:24Speaker 3: Think that's part of what juries might be struggling with
- 5:28Speaker 3: and maybe the reason for the ten wins that they've
- 5:31Speaker 3: had at trial. So back in twenty fifteen, part of
- 5:35Speaker 3: the World Health organization called the International Agency for Research
- 5:39Speaker 3: on Cancer classified the chemical that's used in round up,
- 5:43Speaker 3: glycophosphate as part of a chemical that is probably carcinogenic
- 5:47Speaker 3: in humans. But the EPA back in twenty ten said
- 5:51Speaker 3: there were no risks to human help. So we really
- 5:54Speaker 3: have some conflicting findings between different organizations.
- 5:57Speaker 1: And yet despite those conflicting findings, the bulk of these
- 6:02Speaker 1: awards are punitive damages meant to punish Bayer.
- 6:06Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, you know, the juries are not happy
- 6:08Speaker 3: with the evidence that they hear. There is evidence that
- 6:11Speaker 3: they are wanting to punish the company. So this isn't
- 6:14Speaker 3: just sort of a slap on the risk, let's compensate
- 6:17Speaker 3: the victim type of damage awards. This is a you've
- 6:20Speaker 3: done something really wrong and we're angry about it kind
- 6:23Speaker 3: of award.
- 6:23Speaker 1: You know.
- 6:24Speaker 3: I think what we see oftentimes is in the headlines.
- 6:27Speaker 3: We get these astronomical verdicts because they are so newsworthy.
- 6:30Speaker 3: But it's important to remember that in about eighty percent
- 6:33Speaker 3: of the cases, judges and juries actually agree on what
- 6:36Speaker 3: the amount should be, and so when you see verdicts
- 6:39Speaker 3: like this, they aren't necessarily the run of the mill cases.
- 6:42Speaker 1: As you mentioned, Beyer has touted its previous success in
- 6:46Speaker 1: getting these awards knocked down. It points to three cases
- 6:50Speaker 1: before twenty twenty where verdicts totally more than one point
- 6:54Speaker 1: four billion dollars were knocked down to one hundred and
- 6:57Speaker 1: thirty two million. That's a reduction of near ninety five percent.
- 7:02Speaker 1: These appellate court reductions stem from Supreme Court guidance. Tell
- 7:06Speaker 1: us about that the.
- 7:08Speaker 3: Supreme Court back in the nineties decided several cases, a
- 7:13Speaker 3: trilogy of cases on punitive damages that capped essentially capped
- 7:17Speaker 3: the ratio between compensatory damages and punitive damages is no
- 7:21Speaker 3: greater than nine to one. Now, there can certainly be
- 7:24Speaker 3: some exceptions to that, but in general, the Supreme Court
- 7:27Speaker 3: has weighed in. So this is what we think would
- 7:30Speaker 3: be appropriate. But the Supreme Court really has not gotten
- 7:33Speaker 3: involved in these types of mass toward settlements. In fact,
- 7:36Speaker 3: the closest that we've really seen recently has been the
- 7:39Speaker 3: argument in front of the Supreme Court over the Purdue pharmacate,
- 7:43Speaker 3: where the Stackler family is trying to freeride on the
- 7:46Speaker 3: bankruptcy of Purdue to avoid civil liability for the opioid epidemic.
- 7:51Speaker 1: What about negotiating a global settlement? Is that a possibility
- 7:55Speaker 1: for Beayer.
- 7:56Speaker 3: I think it's going to be really difficult for them
- 7:58Speaker 3: at this point. They certainly try to negotiate a global settlement.
- 8:02Speaker 3: Several years ago, when they tried to certify these cases
- 8:05Speaker 3: as a class action in federal court. That was a
- 8:08Speaker 3: move that was denied by the judge in the federal
- 8:11Speaker 3: multi district litigation.
- 8:13Speaker 4: It would be.
- 8:13Speaker 3: Really difficult, I think, without plain of consent and plane
- 8:16Speaker 3: offs attorney's consent to get any sort of a global settlement,
- 8:20Speaker 3: given that we're now looking at individual state court litigations.
- 8:24Speaker 1: And as you mentioned, a settlement couldn't cover future cases
- 8:28Speaker 1: that are going to be filed because Roundup is still
- 8:31Speaker 1: on the market exactly.
- 8:33Speaker 3: So you can't sue just because you've been exposed to
- 8:36Speaker 3: a chemical. You can only sue once something has manifested,
- 8:39Speaker 3: some sort of injury has manifested, which means that if
- 8:43Speaker 3: it takes some ten to fourteen years between the exposure
- 8:47Speaker 3: to the product and the development of the disease, that
- 8:50Speaker 3: we're going to be looking at these types of lawsuits
- 8:52Speaker 3: for many years to come.
- 8:53Speaker 1: But plaintiffs who sue in the future, are they on
- 8:56Speaker 1: notice of the possible cancer causing a agents in roundup?
- 9:02Speaker 3: So this is one of the questions that we'll have
- 9:04Speaker 3: to see in the future. You know that the cases
- 9:06Speaker 3: that we're seeing right now don't have notice about this
- 9:10Speaker 3: potential for cancer. But in tort law, there's something called
- 9:13Speaker 3: the assumption of the risk, and defense called comparative fault,
- 9:17Speaker 3: which means you know, for example, that if you're a
- 9:19Speaker 3: smoker and you've been smoking for a long time, but
- 9:22Speaker 3: you know that smoking can cause lung cancer, then you
- 9:25Speaker 3: bear some sort of fault in continuing to smoke. So
- 9:28Speaker 3: we may see defenses like that becoming more successful in
- 9:31Speaker 3: the future.
- 9:32Speaker 1: Also, Bay already increased its litigation fund from eleven point
- 9:37Speaker 1: six billion to sixteen billion in twenty twenty one, but
- 9:41Speaker 1: the lawsuits keep piling up. Does it even have enough
- 9:44Speaker 1: in its litigation coffers to cover the verdicts and settlements,
- 9:49Speaker 1: et cetera.
- 9:50Speaker 3: Well, I mean that certainly remains to be seen. No
- 9:53Speaker 3: money goes to the victims while cases are on appeal,
- 9:57Speaker 3: and as you know, appeals can last for a couple
- 9:59Speaker 3: of so certainly there's that question if Bear is going
- 10:03Speaker 3: to continue to face these types of billion dollar verdicts,
- 10:06Speaker 3: whether at some point it's going to become an issue.
- 10:09Speaker 3: But they haven't indicated that they are considering filing for bankruptcy.
- 10:13Speaker 3: To my knowledge, the shareholders are certainly watching this. So
- 10:17Speaker 3: this is a litigation that is the thorn in the
- 10:19Speaker 3: side of Bear.
- 10:20Speaker 1: Can the round Up litigation be compared to Johnson and
- 10:24Speaker 1: Johnson's TALC litigation.
- 10:26Speaker 3: It is similar Like round up. There is a latency
- 10:30Speaker 3: period in TALC, particularly between the exposure to TALC. Some
- 10:34Speaker 3: would say that's exposure to TUT laced with asbestos, between
- 10:38Speaker 3: the exposure and the development of the disease. So I
- 10:41Speaker 3: think both Johnson and Johnson and the TOUT cases and
- 10:44Speaker 3: Bear in the round up cases are struggling with how
- 10:47Speaker 3: do we get closure in a case like this where
- 10:50Speaker 3: there are likely to be in many more cases than
- 10:52Speaker 3: the pipeline for years to come.
- 10:54Speaker 1: If you were advising Behar, how would you advise them
- 10:58Speaker 1: to handle all these cases? I mean try to settle.
- 11:02Speaker 3: I mean it's a real problem. There's not a way
- 11:05Speaker 3: to get any kind of global resolution based on the
- 11:09Speaker 3: types of things that we know now. So the easiest
- 11:12Speaker 3: way to try to do something like that would be
- 11:14Speaker 3: the file bankruptcy. But bere has not indicated that I
- 11:18Speaker 3: know of that they have any sort of plans of
- 11:20Speaker 3: filing bankruptcy in the future. But in order to try
- 11:22Speaker 3: to get rid of state and federal cases in any
- 11:25Speaker 3: kind of holistic settlements, most defendants are looking at bankruptcy.
- 11:29Speaker 1: Thanks so much for those insights, Elizabeth. That's Professor Elizabeth
- 11:32Speaker 1: Burg of the University of Georgia Law School. Coming up
- 11:35Speaker 1: next on the Bloomberg Law Show, we'll look at some
- 11:38Speaker 1: possible grounds for Trump's appeal of the eighty three point
- 11:41Speaker 1: three million dollar defamation verdict. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 11:45Speaker 1: listening to Bloomberg. Before last Friday, Donald Trump used to
- 11:50Speaker 1: frequently rail against advice columnist e Gene Carroll, even after
- 11:54Speaker 1: he was found guilty of sexually abusing her.
- 11:57Speaker 5: And I'm going to explain, I don't know who the
- 12:00Speaker 5: hell she is. I have no idea. They called me
- 12:02Speaker 5: up years ago and they said, do you know about
- 12:05Speaker 5: this woman twenty five or thirty years ago? She doesn't
- 12:08Speaker 5: even know the date, the time, the month, the season.
- 12:13Speaker 5: She has no idea.
- 12:14Speaker 1: But Trump didn't get to explain that or much of
- 12:18Speaker 1: anything else at the defamation trial. And since a jury
- 12:21Speaker 1: delivered a stunning eighty three point three million dollar verdict,
- 12:26Speaker 1: there has been, perhaps justice stunning silence from the former
- 12:30Speaker 1: president on Egene Carroll. It took only three hours of
- 12:33Speaker 1: deliberations for a Manhattan federal jury to return the verdict
- 12:37Speaker 1: that Trump defamed Carol. Trump called the verdict absolutely ridiculous,
- 12:42Speaker 1: as did his attorney Alina Haba.
- 12:44Speaker 3: We will immediately appeal.
- 12:46Speaker 1: We will set aside that ridiculous jury. But it will
- 12:49Speaker 1: take more than filing papers to appeal the verdict. Trump
- 12:53Speaker 1: will need to put up a hefty amount of cash
- 12:55Speaker 1: if he doesn't secure a bond. Joining me is former
- 12:58Speaker 1: federal prosecutor Robert miss A partner McCarter in English, Bob
- 13:03Speaker 1: Trump's behavior in the courtroom was, by all accounts, off
- 13:06Speaker 1: the charts, muttering as Carol testified, sparring with the judge
- 13:11Speaker 1: who threatened to kick him out of the courtroom, and
- 13:13Speaker 1: this drama of storming out of the courtroom during the
- 13:16Speaker 1: closing arguments. Egene Carroll's attorney, ROBERTA. Caplan, has said in
- 13:21Speaker 1: an interview with Politico that it was Trump's own behavior
- 13:24Speaker 1: that convicted him.
- 13:26Speaker 2: Well, I think that it did, because what typically happens
- 13:29Speaker 2: is that jurors form a bond with the presiding judge.
- 13:33Speaker 2: The judge has time to talk to them during the trial.
- 13:37Speaker 2: He sometimes will make general small talk with him while
- 13:41Speaker 2: they're waiting for the trial to begin, and they form
- 13:43Speaker 2: a bond with the judge, and they look to the
- 13:45Speaker 2: judge as the arbiter of how this proceeding ought to
- 13:49Speaker 2: go forward. They see that the judge controls the courtroom.
- 13:52Speaker 2: The judge makes the decisions. And if jurors see a
- 13:55Speaker 2: defense lawyer or a defendant acting in a way that
- 13:59Speaker 2: seems to disrespect the judge and disrespect the process, often
- 14:03Speaker 2: juries will find that distasteful and that's not good for
- 14:07Speaker 2: the outcome of the defendant.
- 14:08Speaker 1: And his behavior also played into Caplan's closing arguments. She
- 14:13Speaker 1: argued that Trump acted as if the law didn't apply
- 14:16Speaker 1: to him, and this trial was to punish him and
- 14:19Speaker 1: to get him to stop once and for all. And
- 14:21Speaker 1: the jury listened, it came back with an award of
- 14:24Speaker 1: sixty five million dollars in punitive damages to punish Trump
- 14:28Speaker 1: and deter him from defaming her in the future.
- 14:31Speaker 2: No, that's exactly right. From the plaintiff side of the case,
- 14:34Speaker 2: This couldn't have played out any better because what the
- 14:37Speaker 2: lawyer was arguing is that mister Trump was asserting the
- 14:41Speaker 2: rules that apply to everybody else do not apply to him,
- 14:44Speaker 2: and rather than sit there stoically in the courtroom when
- 14:47Speaker 2: these accusations were being made against them, even though they
- 14:50Speaker 2: were extremely distasteful. His conduct suggested very much what the
- 14:55Speaker 2: planets were arguing here, which is that he does not
- 14:57Speaker 2: believe that the rules did apply to him. So in
- 15:00Speaker 2: many ways, you reinforce exactly the scene that the planet
- 15:04Speaker 2: floyers were trying to establish throughout the trial.
- 15:06Speaker 1: In the New York Attorney General civil fraud trial, you
- 15:09Speaker 1: had Judge Arthur and Goron, who seemed to be a
- 15:13Speaker 1: little more lass a fair in the courtroom. But in
- 15:15Speaker 1: this trial you had Judge Lewis Kaplan, who is known
- 15:18Speaker 1: for being very strict about keeping order in decorum in
- 15:22Speaker 1: the courtroom, and even he couldn't reign in Trump completely.
- 15:27Speaker 1: What does that say about Trump's future behavior at the
- 15:30Speaker 1: criminal trials he's facing, and those are trials where he'll
- 15:34Speaker 1: have to be in the courtroom every day. Do you
- 15:36Speaker 1: think it's even possible for him to sort of behave
- 15:39Speaker 1: like a normal defendant.
- 15:41Speaker 2: Well, that's a good question, and you make a good
- 15:43Speaker 2: point that this is a civil case, and so former
- 15:47Speaker 2: President Trump was not required to attend, but in a
- 15:49Speaker 2: criminal case he does have to be there for every
- 15:52Speaker 2: day and every moment of the preceding and that means
- 15:55Speaker 2: as a defense lawyer, you have to instruct your clients
- 15:58Speaker 2: to control themselves during the proceedings because you remember that
- 16:02Speaker 2: jurors are constantly looking at the defendant throughout the trial.
- 16:06Speaker 2: They're not only listening to the testimony coming from the
- 16:08Speaker 2: witness stand. They're not only listening to the arguments of
- 16:12Speaker 2: the lawyers during the trial, but they are looking at
- 16:15Speaker 2: both the plaintiffs and the defendant, or in a criminal case,
- 16:17Speaker 2: both the prosecution and the defendant to gauge their reactions
- 16:21Speaker 2: to the testimony. So a defendant is always on in
- 16:24Speaker 2: that respect, in that jurors are watching them, looking at
- 16:28Speaker 2: their reactions, and that ultimately factors into how they make
- 16:31Speaker 2: their decision.
- 16:32Speaker 1: Trump says, are going to appeal, and I'm wondering what
- 16:34Speaker 1: the appellate issues might be. The judge did severely limit
- 16:38Speaker 1: his defense and what he could say on the stand.
- 16:41Speaker 1: Is that a possible argument on appeal.
- 16:43Speaker 2: Well, I certainly think it will be one of the
- 16:45Speaker 2: issues raised on appeal because the key ruling in this
- 16:48Speaker 2: case that came before the trial started, when Judge Kaplan
- 16:52Speaker 2: ordered former President Trump's legal team not to attempt to
- 16:56Speaker 2: argue in court that he didn't sexually assault e Gene Carroll.
- 17:00Speaker 2: That was really one of the critical arguments that the
- 17:02Speaker 2: defense wanted to make in this case, and Judge Chaplin
- 17:05Speaker 2: said that would essentially be a do over of the
- 17:08Speaker 2: first trial, which he lost in May, when a jury
- 17:11Speaker 2: found him libel for sexually abusing Carol more than two
- 17:14Speaker 2: decades ago. And in that trial, there was five million
- 17:17Speaker 2: dollars that was awarded. So by taking that argument away,
- 17:21Speaker 2: it essentially prevented former President Trump from denying the allegations
- 17:26Speaker 2: that were at the heart of this case. Trial number two,
- 17:29Speaker 2: which is the trial that was just concluded, was simply
- 17:32Speaker 2: about the question of damages, and it was very difficult
- 17:36Speaker 2: for the defense to control their client because you have
- 17:39Speaker 2: there a defendant, former President Trump, who continues to deny
- 17:44Speaker 2: that he sexually assaulted Eging Carroll, or that he even
- 17:48Speaker 2: knew Eging Carroll, and that was the defense they wanted
- 17:51Speaker 2: to argue, but the court said they couldn't. They still
- 17:54Speaker 2: got that in. Former President Trump took the stand for
- 17:56Speaker 2: about three minutes and denied the underlying sexual assault, but
- 18:01Speaker 2: the jury was immediately instructed by the judge to disregard
- 18:05Speaker 2: that testimony. And whenever a judge instructs a jury to
- 18:09Speaker 2: disregard testimony from a defendant or a witness, or to
- 18:13Speaker 2: disregard arguments made by a lawyer that undermines the credibility
- 18:18Speaker 2: of that witness or that lawyer with the jury, And
- 18:21Speaker 2: that's never a good thing, Bob.
- 18:23Speaker 1: What are some other appellate issues Trump might raise?
- 18:26Speaker 2: Judge Kaplin made a number of significant pre trial rulings
- 18:30Speaker 2: that really hemmed in the defense here, which will likely
- 18:33Speaker 2: form the basis of an appeal. He barred Trump and
- 18:35Speaker 2: his lawyers from making arguments the trials concerning Carol's choice
- 18:39Speaker 2: of lawyer and the fact that her litigation was financed
- 18:42Speaker 2: by somebody with close ties to the Democratic Party. He
- 18:45Speaker 2: also barred the defense team from presenting arguments concerning Miss
- 18:49Speaker 2: Carroll's path romantic relationships, and really prevented the defense from
- 18:54Speaker 2: focusing on Egen Carroll and more focusing on the statements
- 18:58Speaker 2: that were made by former President and the Trump. Now,
- 19:00Speaker 2: the heart of the defense here at this trial was
- 19:03Speaker 2: ultimately that the statements made by former President Trump did
- 19:08Speaker 2: not actually damage her reputation but enhanced it. So the
- 19:12Speaker 2: defense argued that Egene Carroll was essentially down on her luck,
- 19:16Speaker 2: that the money she was making as an advice columnist
- 19:20Speaker 2: had essentially dried up, and that she made these claims
- 19:24Speaker 2: only to try to restart her career, and that ultimately,
- 19:29Speaker 2: by making this statement, she actually became more famous and
- 19:32Speaker 2: actually increased her reputation and her earning capacity. Ultimately, the
- 19:37Speaker 2: jury did not accept that they were able to hear
- 19:40Speaker 2: testimony about threats that were made against her, and obviously
- 19:44Speaker 2: the falsity of those statements was something that they took
- 19:47Speaker 2: into account in terms of reaching their verdict here. But
- 19:51Speaker 2: those will be issues that I expect will be raised
- 19:54Speaker 2: on appeal as well, and Trump.
- 19:56Speaker 1: Might also raise on appeal the damages calculation that Trump
- 20:00Speaker 1: wanted the judge to instruct the jury on, but he refused.
- 20:04Speaker 2: One of the other interesting arguments raised by the defense
- 20:07Speaker 2: on the question of damages was whether or not the
- 20:10Speaker 2: court should adopt a gross versus net view of the damages.
- 20:14Speaker 2: In other words, the defense was arguing that even if
- 20:18Speaker 2: the statements were defamatory, the court needed to look at
- 20:21Speaker 2: the total impact of those statements to determine damages. So,
- 20:26Speaker 2: in other words, it's possible. They argued that a defendant
- 20:29Speaker 2: could make a defamatory statement that injured someone's reputation in
- 20:33Speaker 2: one part of the community but actually enhanced it in another.
- 20:37Speaker 1: Bob, what about the disparity in the two Egene Carroll verdicts.
- 20:42Speaker 1: I'm wondering if that poses an issue on appeal, because
- 20:45Speaker 1: it was another jury, as you say, who made the
- 20:48Speaker 1: decision that Trump was liable for sexually abusing Carol. That
- 20:52Speaker 1: jury awarded five million dollars. The second jury who didn't
- 20:56Speaker 1: hear that evidence, but rather heard the judge who, as
- 20:59Speaker 1: you mentioned before, or a figure of authority that the
- 21:02Speaker 1: jury usually believes, and he said that Trump did sexually
- 21:06Speaker 1: assault Carrol. And he said that more than once in
- 21:08Speaker 1: different ways. And then this jury awards Carol eighty three
- 21:12Speaker 1: point three million dollars. That's more than sixteen times the
- 21:16Speaker 1: award of the first jury. Is there any problem with
- 21:19Speaker 1: the contrast in those two verdicts.
- 21:22Speaker 2: Well, the appeals court will probably look at these two cases.
- 21:26Speaker 2: The difference between case number one and case number two
- 21:29Speaker 2: is that case number one that went to trial in
- 21:32Speaker 2: twenty nineteen was about the statements that were made by
- 21:36Speaker 2: former President Trump after he left office. The reason there
- 21:39Speaker 2: were two trials here is because there were statements that
- 21:42Speaker 2: were made by former President Trump while he was president.
- 21:45Speaker 2: That was tied up in appeals as the former president's
- 21:48Speaker 2: legal team argued that he had immunity for those statements.
- 21:51Speaker 2: So it's possible that the appeals court could say that
- 21:54Speaker 2: defamatory statements that were made by somebody while they were
- 21:57Speaker 2: president carried even more weight than statements made when they
- 22:00Speaker 2: were a former president. But they will be looking at
- 22:03Speaker 2: the juxtaposition of those two verdicts and those two awards
- 22:08Speaker 2: to determine whether this eighty three million dollar verdict is excessive.
- 22:12Speaker 1: By the way, Trump says he's looking for new attorneys
- 22:15Speaker 1: to represent him in the appeal, and in order to appeal,
- 22:19Speaker 1: he has to put up cash to secure the verdict
- 22:22Speaker 1: or get a bond. Explain the process.
- 22:26Speaker 2: Sure, so former President Trump is appealing both verdicts, the
- 22:30Speaker 2: earlier verdict for five million dollars, now this one for
- 22:33Speaker 2: eighty three million dollars, and he has two options. Basically,
- 22:36Speaker 2: he can pay the money into the court system, which
- 22:38Speaker 2: is what he did for the five million dollar verdict.
- 22:41Speaker 2: He simply paid that into the court system and that
- 22:44Speaker 2: money is held by the court while the appeal is pending. Alternatively,
- 22:48Speaker 2: he can try to secure an appeal bond, which would
- 22:51Speaker 2: save him for having to pay the full amount into
- 22:53Speaker 2: the court. What that would do would be to essentially
- 22:56Speaker 2: assure Miss Carroll that mister Trump has the money to
- 22:59Speaker 2: pay if ultimately he's unsuccessful on appeal, but it prevents
- 23:03Speaker 2: them from collecting the money while the appeals are being heard.
- 23:06Speaker 2: The problem with getting the bond in this circumstance is
- 23:09Speaker 2: that former President Trump has to find a company willing
- 23:11Speaker 2: to write a bond when he's facing other significant legal jeopardy,
- 23:15Speaker 2: and the value of the bond is likely to be
- 23:17Speaker 2: about one hundred and ten percent of the verdict, which
- 23:21Speaker 2: would mean he would need a ninety two million dollar bond,
- 23:25Speaker 2: and he also would have to pay the bonding company
- 23:27Speaker 2: a substantial premium. And there's also a question of what
- 23:30Speaker 2: collateral he would have to put up. He might not
- 23:32Speaker 2: be able, for example, to post properties as collateral. The
- 23:35Speaker 2: bonding company might demand that he plays liquid assets, success
- 23:39Speaker 2: certificates of deposit or treasury bond. So although the bonding
- 23:43Speaker 2: option is certainly available and he may avail himself with that,
- 23:46Speaker 2: given the size of this verdict, it's not going to
- 23:48Speaker 2: be that easy to get a bond in this circumstance,
- 23:51Speaker 2: he does.
- 23:51Speaker 1: Seem to have the cash to put up. The Bloomberg
- 23:54Speaker 1: Billionaire's Index places his liquid assets at about six hundred
- 23:58Speaker 1: million dollars. I'm at a deposition. Last year, Trump described
- 24:02Speaker 1: his cash as substantially an excess of four hundred million dollars,
- 24:07Speaker 1: so he has enough to cover it if he wants to,
- 24:09Speaker 1: although there is also that verdict in New York's three
- 24:12Speaker 1: hundred and seventy million dollar a civil fraud trial against him,
- 24:16Speaker 1: and that's now expected by mid February, so we'll see
- 24:19Speaker 1: what he does. Thanks so much, Bob. That's Robert Mince
- 24:23Speaker 1: of maccarter and English. Coming up next, a suit over,
- 24:26Speaker 1: a supposedly AI generated comedy special featuring the late George Carlin.
- 24:32Speaker 1: I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg. Thank you,
- 24:39Speaker 1: thank you.
- 24:40Speaker 4: I like to start off with a heartfelt apology.
- 24:42Speaker 5: I'm sorry it took me so long to come out
- 24:44Speaker 5: with new.
- 24:44Speaker 3: Material, but I do have a pretty good excuse.
- 24:47Speaker 1: I was dead. It may sound like George Carlin, but
- 24:52Speaker 1: it's not. In fact. When podcasters Will Sasso and Chat
- 24:56Speaker 1: Colchin released the hour long comedy special called George Carlin,
- 25:01Speaker 1: I'm Glad, I'm Dead. They billed it as created from
- 25:04Speaker 1: generative AI technology trained on decades of the late comedian's material.
- 25:09Speaker 1: So Carlin's estate sued the duo for infringing his copyright
- 25:14Speaker 1: and illegally using his name and likeness. But then came
- 25:18Speaker 1: the twist. The podcasters are now claiming that the special
- 25:22Speaker 1: was actually written by a human one of the podcasters,
- 25:25Speaker 1: and that changes up what's at stake in the lawsuit.
- 25:29Speaker 1: If it sounds confusing, it is, but it's happened before
- 25:33Speaker 1: joining me is Zien Tang, a professor at UCLA Law School.
- 25:37Speaker 1: Let's start with the first iteration of this, which was
- 25:40Speaker 1: supposed to be AI generated. Tell us about that.
- 25:43Speaker 4: The claim that was at the center of the complaint
- 25:47Speaker 4: was that the comedians Will Sasso and Had Colston had
- 25:53Speaker 4: said thousands of hours of copyrighted material from George Carland
- 26:00Speaker 4: into an AI model, and then once that AI model
- 26:05Speaker 4: had been trained on all that Carlan material, it was
- 26:10Speaker 4: able to fit out or generate a entirely new comedy
- 26:16Speaker 4: routine based off of Carlin's jokes.
- 26:19Speaker 1: And in the lawsuit by Carlin's estate, they're making two
- 26:22Speaker 1: different claims. One based on copyright and the other on
- 26:27Speaker 1: the illegal use of Carlin's name and likeness.
- 26:30Speaker 4: So it would be a copyright claim in the sense
- 26:33Speaker 4: that there was a lot of copyrighted content that was
- 26:37Speaker 4: fed into the Large Language Model the LMS, which resulted
- 26:42Speaker 4: in a copy of the material being made while the
- 26:45Speaker 4: LLM was being trained. So that's one claim, and then
- 26:49Speaker 4: the right of publicity claim is based off of the
- 26:53Speaker 4: replication of the comedian's voice, which you know, are both
- 26:58Speaker 4: claims that have been lodged against AI or Generative AI
- 27:03Speaker 4: companies for the past year, both on the training data,
- 27:09Speaker 4: which a number of similar lawsuits, many of them class actions,
- 27:14Speaker 4: have been making the same claims with regard to the
- 27:17Speaker 4: training of llms based on copyrighted books, for example, or
- 27:22Speaker 4: copyrighted comedy routines. There's, for example, one currently pending in
- 27:27Speaker 4: federal court filed by the comedian Sarah Silverman representing herself
- 27:31Speaker 4: in an entire class of plaintiffs the complaint alleges whose
- 27:35Speaker 4: material have all been copied into the LM, and then
- 27:39Speaker 4: on the right of publicity claim. There's been similar allegations
- 27:43Speaker 4: made against AIS, such as the Drake Weekend mashup that
- 27:48Speaker 4: went viral a few months ago in which the AI
- 27:51Speaker 4: basically is trained on a celebrity's voice and then is
- 27:55Speaker 4: able to generate an entirely new work or new songs
- 28:00Speaker 4: using that voice.
- 28:01Speaker 1: Now have any of these lawsuits progressed to the point
- 28:05Speaker 1: where there's been a legal opinion about whether this is
- 28:10Speaker 1: a violation of copyright.
- 28:12Speaker 2: So no, there have.
- 28:13Speaker 4: Been some courts that have issued opinions that have basically
- 28:18Speaker 4: denied or dismissed certain claims filed by the plaintiffs, but
- 28:23Speaker 4: certainly no opinion issued by a court that has definitively
- 28:28Speaker 4: answered the question of whether or not the use of
- 28:32Speaker 4: copyright and material as training data for the AIS constitutes
- 28:36Speaker 4: copyright infringement or and even if it is technically copyright
- 28:40Speaker 4: infringement in the sense that there is a copy being
- 28:43Speaker 4: made when the material is ingested, whether that copying is
- 28:48Speaker 4: protected by the defense of fair use.
- 28:52Speaker 1: You study this, you teach this, what's your opinion.
- 28:55Speaker 4: I think it's a deeply complicated issue. I certainly think
- 28:59Speaker 4: that there is a lot nine of cases that have
- 29:01Speaker 4: preceded this, based on, for example, whether or not it
- 29:05Speaker 4: is fair use or Google to scan massive amounts of
- 29:09Speaker 4: copyrighted books in order to create their Google Books function,
- 29:14Speaker 4: which I think a lot of US use, in which
- 29:16Speaker 4: you can search within books and it'll return snippets of
- 29:20Speaker 4: in many cases, copyrighted books, and it's helpful for researchers
- 29:23Speaker 4: to be able to search within books, many of which
- 29:25Speaker 4: are out of print. Now, those prior decisions have held
- 29:29Speaker 4: that such uses are fair even if they're technical copyright infringements.
- 29:33Speaker 4: They're still protected by fair use because they are transformative,
- 29:37Speaker 4: technologically transformative uses of copyrighted works, because they are using
- 29:43Speaker 4: the copyrighted works for a wholly different purpose. I think
- 29:46Speaker 4: in this case, similar arguments could certainly be made, and
- 29:50Speaker 4: I could see certain judges making that determination based on
- 29:54Speaker 4: the transformative nature of what AI does and the fact
- 29:58Speaker 4: that maybe what you would argue is true to the
- 30:01Speaker 4: name training data. The LM, the Large Language Model, is
- 30:05Speaker 4: simply learning from the copyrighted material, not to wholly reproduce
- 30:11Speaker 4: the copyrighted material on the output side, but instead to
- 30:15Speaker 4: create a wholly new, transformative work. I think that argument
- 30:19Speaker 4: is somewhat complicated by recent lawsuits, including one that has
- 30:23Speaker 4: been filed against The New York Times, which alleges that
- 30:27Speaker 4: even on the output side, apparently through some prompt engineering
- 30:31Speaker 4: that the lawyers for The Times did. What they were
- 30:35Speaker 4: able to get the AI to do was to generate
- 30:38Speaker 4: entire news articles that replicated, word for words New York
- 30:43Speaker 4: Times articles that have been published. And so if that's true,
- 30:48Speaker 4: then certainly you would say, well, the work that's generated
- 30:52Speaker 4: by the AI is a direct infringement, and moreover, maybe
- 30:57Speaker 4: even the ingestion of the copyrighted work into the language
- 31:02Speaker 4: model is also an infringement that is not protected by
- 31:06Speaker 4: fair use because it is ingested for the purpose of
- 31:11Speaker 4: directly competing with the plaintiffs the author's income streams and
- 31:16Speaker 4: is likely to harm the market for plaintiff's work.
- 31:20Speaker 1: Now there's a twist to the Carlin case because after
- 31:23Speaker 1: the lawsuit was filed, a spokeswoman for the podcasters said,
- 31:27Speaker 1: this was not actually created by AI. Quote, it's a
- 31:31Speaker 1: fictional podcast created by two human beings, Will Sasso and
- 31:36Speaker 1: Chad Culchin. The YouTube video I'm Glad I'm Dead was
- 31:40Speaker 1: completely written by Chad. So, surprise, surprise, they're saying it's
- 31:46Speaker 1: not AI.
- 31:47Speaker 4: So if that's true, then, of course, if the material
- 31:53Speaker 4: was entirely written by Chad, and if the voice is
- 31:58Speaker 4: just an imitation, so focusing first on the copyright claims,
- 32:03Speaker 4: so then the copyright claim is gone because you have
- 32:06Speaker 4: fully original material that's been written by the comedian himself,
- 32:10Speaker 4: and then on the right of publicity the voice imitation.
- 32:13Speaker 4: The thing that has always complicated this right of publicity
- 32:16Speaker 4: claim is that even if it were an AI that
- 32:20Speaker 4: was actually fitting out George Carlin's voice and not some
- 32:23Speaker 4: voice imitations, the right of publicity claim was always complicated
- 32:27Speaker 4: by the fact that this is a comedy special. This
- 32:30Speaker 4: is an expressive work, and right of publicity claims typically
- 32:34Speaker 4: have found that such expressive works are protected by the
- 32:37Speaker 4: First Amendment. Right publicity is slightly different from copyright, but
- 32:41Speaker 4: both share this idea right that there are certain uses
- 32:44Speaker 4: that are defensible, even if we might consider them technical
- 32:49Speaker 4: uses of a celebrity's image or technically copying of copyrighted content.
- 32:53Speaker 4: So in the right of publicity context, it's clear that
- 32:57Speaker 4: the use of a celebrity's image or the use of
- 32:59Speaker 4: a celebrity's voice in a commercial is a violation of
- 33:02Speaker 4: a celebrities right of publicity. But when we're talking about
- 33:05Speaker 4: something that's an expressive work, like a comedy of routine,
- 33:08Speaker 4: for example, then most courts have help. But that is
- 33:11Speaker 4: expression that is protected by the First Amendment, that comedians
- 33:15Speaker 4: should be able to, for example, make some commentary about
- 33:18Speaker 4: celebrities by imitating them, by maybe even exactly reproducing their voice,
- 33:24Speaker 4: by exactly reproducing their image on some type of parities
- 33:29Speaker 4: such as a newspaper paroity that uses a celebrity's image.
- 33:34Speaker 4: So expressive works get really broadly way under a rite
- 33:37Speaker 4: of publicity law, and that's why the right of publicity
- 33:40Speaker 4: claim is always going to be much harder to vindicate
- 33:42Speaker 4: than the copyright claim.
- 33:44Speaker 1: Would you explain sort of how close a comedian can
- 33:47Speaker 1: get to George Carlin's work in a new.
- 33:50Speaker 4: Work, so, of course, assuming that the comedian himself wrote
- 33:54Speaker 4: the skits, then even if it's in the style of
- 33:57Speaker 4: or the same manner of jokes, how long is the
- 34:00Speaker 4: expression is wholly different, so long as the comedic routine
- 34:05Speaker 4: is not an exact duplication word for word, or very
- 34:09Speaker 4: close paraphrasing even of a George Carlin routine, but instead
- 34:13Speaker 4: maybe takes the idea of a George Carlin joke and
- 34:16Speaker 4: expands upon it, takes the style of his comedic humor
- 34:19Speaker 4: and expands upon it. That is all fair game under
- 34:22Speaker 4: a copyright law, and you wouldn't even need to bring
- 34:24Speaker 4: in the fair use doctrine at all. You would just say,
- 34:27Speaker 4: I'm only taking the unprotectable ideas. I'm not copying the
- 34:31Speaker 4: protectable expression of George Carlin's comedy routines.
- 34:36Speaker 1: A lawyer for Carlin's estate says, the lawsuit is going
- 34:39Speaker 1: ahead despite this new claim by the defendants. Quote, we
- 34:44Speaker 1: don't know what they're saying to be true. What we
- 34:46Speaker 1: will know is that they'll be deposed, they'll produce documents,
- 34:49Speaker 1: and there'll be evidence that shows, one way or another
- 34:52Speaker 1: how the show was created. So we'll speed ahead.
- 34:56Speaker 4: Yeah, I mean, and you know, of course lawyers say
- 34:59Speaker 4: these say this stunt generated a lot of publicity. It's
- 35:03Speaker 4: unclear how much money was actually generated from this. And
- 35:07Speaker 4: even if some amount of evidence is willingly produced that
- 35:10Speaker 4: shows that there was actually no copyrighted works that were
- 35:13Speaker 4: ingusted into any kind of LM, then the potential damages
- 35:19Speaker 4: that the plaintiff can receive just basically evaporate. So in
- 35:24Speaker 4: that case, the parties will probably settle or the plaintiff
- 35:28Speaker 4: will voluntarily dismiss the lawsuit to bring a lawsuit like this,
- 35:32Speaker 4: all the way to the trial or fact finding stage,
- 35:36Speaker 4: where there are depositions and there's discovery, is an incredibly
- 35:40Speaker 4: costly endeavor, and if what the comedians are saying is true,
- 35:45Speaker 4: it would behoove them to, or would do them well
- 35:48Speaker 4: to immediately try to ward off that expensive factfinding by
- 35:53Speaker 4: producing some amount of evidence to show that in fact,
- 35:56Speaker 4: there was no AI training involved. Certainly, I think that's
- 36:00Speaker 4: been the complaint against a lot of this training data
- 36:03Speaker 4: that's been fed into the LMS is the very opacity
- 36:07Speaker 4: of the system, and that it's never clear. Then the
- 36:10Speaker 4: plaintiff has no visibility into what the defendant is doing,
- 36:14Speaker 4: what their process was, what materials were actually fed into
- 36:18Speaker 4: the LM. This is true not just of the comedians,
- 36:21Speaker 4: but of course of large companies like open Ai. How
- 36:25Speaker 4: are you to figure out what open Ai was training
- 36:28Speaker 4: their LLMS on. It's all proprietary. That's been always one
- 36:32Speaker 4: of the big complaints from the plaintiffs, and so in
- 36:34Speaker 4: those cases you want discovery to force the company to
- 36:38Speaker 4: produce evidence. But in this case, these are two individual comedians,
- 36:42Speaker 4: you know, I think the amount of money at stake
- 36:44Speaker 4: is vanishingly small. If they are able to produce some
- 36:48Speaker 4: evidence that this material was wholly original written content.
- 36:53Speaker 1: Now that the initial feure is over and the AI
- 36:56Speaker 1: claims have been taken back, we'll see if the lawsuit
- 36:59Speaker 1: gets tossed. Thanks for joining me on the show. That's
- 37:02Speaker 1: Professor Zen Tang of UCLA Law School, and that's it
- 37:06Speaker 1: for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you
- 37:09Speaker 1: can always get the latest legal news by subscribing and
- 37:11Speaker 1: listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at
- 37:15Speaker 1: Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, slash Law. I'm June Grosso
- 37:20Speaker 1: and this is Bloomberg