Latest / The Verse Effect: Lyrics that Changed the Game / Why Simon Says Hit Like a Sonic Command
Transcript
- 0:32Welcome to The Verse Effect, my name is Camille.
- 0:35Before we drop the needle on this, a quick disclaimer for everyone listening,
- 0:39this podcast is strictly for cultural, historical, and philosophical analysis.
- 0:45It is not a substitute for clinical therapy or professional mental health treatment.
- 0:50Now, Roderick, let us talk about 1999, because my goodness,
- 0:54that brass opening still makes my adrenaline spike.
- 0:57Oh, it is absolute, pure adrenaline, Camille.
- 1:00You hear those three heavy, descending brass notes--and your entire body just tenses
- 1:05up.
- 1:06That is Akira Ifukube's legendary composition from the 1992 film Godzilla vs.
- 1:12Mothra.
- 1:14It is not just heavy; it is the sonic representation of a multi-ton monster stepping
- 1:19on your neighborhood.
- 1:21And Pharoahe Monch, operating with that brilliant, chaotic A&R instinct,
- 1:25just loops it.
- 1:27He did not even slow it down.
- 1:29He just let that impending doom breathe right under his vocals.
- 1:33That 1992 Ifukube score is fascinating because it functions on a primal,
- 1:38acoustic level of threat.
- 1:40In music theory, those intervals are designed to induce a sense of inescapable
- 1:45dread.
- 1:46But when Monch pairs that terrifying cinematic monumentality with the schoolyard
- 1:50game rules of "Simon Says," something paradoxical happens.
- 1:55He screams, "Simon says get the fuck up," and suddenly, the dread is transformed
- 2:00into collective movement.
- 2:02Philosophically, he is establishing an absolute, sovereign command.
- 2:06Sovereign command is the perfect way to put it.
- 2:09Think about the average club environment in 1999.
- 2:12You have got people standing against the wall, holding their drinks,
- 2:16trying way too hard to look cool.
- 2:18It is all self-conscious posturing.
- 2:21Then Monch comes in with this absolute, dictatorial directive.
- 2:25He is not asking you to dance.
- 2:27He is not inviting you to the groove.
- 2:30He is literally ordering you to throw your hands in the air,
- 2:32but he uses the psychological loophole of "Simon says."
- 2:37If you do not do it, you--are out of the game.
- 2:40And that is where the clinical magic happens.
- 2:43From a therapeutic standpoint, self-consciousness is a form of hyper-vigilance--the
- 2:48ego constantly monitoring how the body is perceived by others.
- 2:53When Monch commands the room, he essentially short-circuits that cognitive override.
- 2:58By using a literal child's game as the vehicle, he introduces an element of
- 3:02absurdity that actually disarms the ego's defenses.
- 3:06It is somatic liberation through forced play.
- 3:09He tells you to "get the fuck up," but because it is under the banner of Simon,
- 3:14the shame of looking silly evaporates.
- 3:17You are just a participant in a mass psychological release.
- 3:21It is like a giant, sweaty therapy session where the therapist is a master lyricist
- 3:25holding a Shure SM58.
- 3:27He bypassed the brain and went straight for the central nervous system.
- 3:31I remember being in clubs in Oakland when this dropped, and the sheer physicality of
- 3:35the room shifting was terrifying.
- 3:37You had no choice.
- 3:38The song demanded your entire physical compliance.
- 3:42The compliance is driven by the sheer structural density of his performance.
- 3:47Let us look at the linguistics of the first verse: "New York City gritty committee,
- 3:52pity the fool that act shitty."
- 3:54The phonetics there are astonishing.
- 3:56You have the short "i" and "y" sounds repeating in rapid succession--gritty,
- 4:01committee, pity, shitty--creating a percussive, machine-gun rhythm that matches the
- 4:05stomping momentum of the Godzilla sample.
- 4:08That "gritty committee" line is a masterclass in internal rhyming and breath
- 4:12control.
- 4:13Monch is a trumpet player originally, you know.
- 4:15He literally views his voice as a brass instrument, pushing air through his vocal
- 4:20cords to mimic staccato horn stabs.
- 4:23And the content of that verse is a direct shot at the dominant culture of 1999.
- 4:28Remember, this is the height of the Shiny Suit Era.
- 4:31Puff Daddy, Ma$e Hype Williams directing multi-million dollar videos with wind
- 4:36tunnels and fish-eye lenses.
- 4:38It was all about wealth, platinum, and polished luxury.
- 4:42Then Monch drops: "Took my underground loot without the gold."
- 4:47"Underground loot without the gold" is such a sharp critique of the late-90s
- 4:52capitalist aesthetic.
- 4:53He is claiming value in the raw, unrefined material.
- 4:58In ethical philosophy, we talk about the distinction between intrinsic worth and
- 5:03instrumental value.
- 5:05The shiny suits valued hip-hop instrumentally--for what it could buy,
- 5:09the luxury it could secure.
- 5:12Monch is asserting the intrinsic worth of the underground culture itself.
- 5:16He is saying, "My wealth is in the dirt, in the grit, in the technique,
- 5:21not the commodified gold plating."
- 5:23And Rawkus Records was the absolute epicenter of that philosophy.
- 5:27Rawkus was this independent powerhouse in New York, funded by some unlikely sources,
- 5:32but letting artists like Mos Def, Talib Kweli and Pharoahe Monch just create pure,
- 5:38unfiltered art.
- 5:40They were the counter-culture.
- 5:42But what makes "Simon Says" so brilliant is that it took that underground,
- 5:46anti-commercial aesthetic and made it a massive commercial hit anyway.
- 5:51He controlled the cultural landscape, which leads perfectly into that other
- 5:54brilliant late-90s line: "control the game like Tomb Raider."
- 5:59The Tomb Raider reference from 1999 is highly culturally specific.
- 6:04Lara Croft was not just a video game character; she was a global,
- 6:08digital phenomenon of control and navigation through hostile,
- 6:12complex ruins.
- 6:14By evoking Lara Croft, Monch is framing himself as the operator holding the
- 6:19controller, navigating the hazardous ruins of the music industry.
- 6:24He is asserting absolute agency in a space that constantly tries to reduce artists
- 6:28to mere avatars.
- 6:30And he really was holding the controller.
- 6:33The song was everywhere, from underground basement cyphers to high-end mainstream
- 6:37clubs.
- 6:39It bridged the gap between the purists and the casual listeners,
- 6:42which is one of the hardest tricks to pull off in hip-hop history.
- 6:46But even as he controlled the game, he was highly aware of the critiques.
- 6:51I want to look at that fascinating, self-aware rhetorical pivot: "Some might even
- 6:56say this song is sexist-es / 'Cause I asked the girls to rub on their breast-es."
- 7:01He does not ignore the potential discomfort of his own lyrics; he preempts it with
- 7:05this almost cartoonish, exaggerated rhyme scheme.
- 7:08"Sexist-es" and "breast-es" is such a clever, comedic deflection.
- 7:13He is playing with language to disarm the criticism before it can even solidify.
- 7:18It is almost like a defense attorney making a joke to the jury to make the
- 7:22prosecution's serious charges seem absurd.
- 7:25He is acknowledging the boundary-pushing nature of the song,
- 7:28but wrapping it in this theatrical, hyper-stylized persona so you cannot quite pin
- 7:33him down on it.
- 7:35It is pure performance art.
- 7:37Psychologically, it functions as a defense mechanism called intellectualization
- 7:42paired with humor.
- 7:43By naming the critique within the song itself, he robs the external critic of their
- 7:48power.
- 7:49He is essentially saying, "I know what this looks like, and by showing you I know,
- 7:54I am proving that I am in on the joke."
- 7:56But while he could deflect the cultural critics, he could not deflect the corporate
- 8:00lawyers.
- 8:01Man, the lawyers.
- 8:04This is where the story gets incredibly tragic from an industry perspective.
- 8:08As an A&R, this keeps me up at night.
- 8:12Rawkus Records released *Internal Affairs* in August 1999, and "Simon Says" was the
- 8:18lead single.
- 8:20But they never cleared that Godzilla vs.
- 8:21Mothra sample with Toho, the Japanese production company that owns the rights to
- 8:26Godzilla.
- 8:27Now, Toho is notoriously protective of their intellectual property.
- 8:31They do not play.
- 8:32When they caught wind of this massive hit using their iconic brass line,
- 8:37they filed a massive lawsuit.
- 8:39Toho's legal team did not just ask for a royalty split; they went for absolute,
- 8:44scorched-earth commercial suppression.
- 8:46Scorched earth is an understatement, Camille.
- 8:49They got an injunction that forced Rawkus to cease all promotion,
- 8:52pull *Internal Affairs* from store shelves, and halt all physical distribution.
- 8:57In 1999, physical distribution was everything.
- 9:01If your CDs are not in the racks at Tower Records or local indie shops,
- 9:06your album is effectively dead.
- 9:08It completely halted the momentum of what should have been a landmark,
- 9:11gold-certified album.
- 9:14The lawsuit financially devastated Rawkus and put Pharoahe Monch's solo career into
- 9:19a years-long legal purgatory where he could not release music or properly profit
- 9:24from his biggest masterpiece.
- 9:26It is a heartbreaking narrative of creative genius being crushed by rigid copyright
- 9:31frameworks.
- 9:32This song is the ultimate blueprint for the underground crossover because it proved
- 9:37that raw, unpolished, sample-heavy artistry could dominate the mainstream without
- 9:42compromising its soul.
- 9:45Yet, that very reliance on the raw, uncleared sample became its commercial undoing.
- 9:51It exists now as a ghost in the digital streaming era--difficult to find officially,
- 9:56yet absolutely immortal in our collective cultural memory.
- 10:00An immortal ghost is the perfect way to describe it.
- 10:03"Simon Says" still gets the crowd up, even if it has to live in the shadows of the
- 10:08internet.
- 10:09And on that note, we want to hear from you.
- 10:11Did you experience the absolute chaos of "Simon Says" in a club back in ninety-nine?
- 10:16Let us know in the comments, leave us a review, and make sure to subscribe to the
- 10:20channel so you don't miss our next deep dive into the crates.
- 10:24Take care of yourselves, pay attention to the commands you choose to follow,
- 10:28and we will see you next time.