Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #28: Political Efficacy: How Well We Know and Impact Politics (And Think We Do)
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Reeder.
- 0:05Today, we are gonna talk about political efficacy.
- 0:10Critical components to the health and efficiency of the American political system is
- 0:16not just how the system is structured, but how well informed voters are about the system and
- 0:22how much they can affect the system, and this is what we refer to as political efficacy.
- 0:28Starting it as not the most straightforward process in the world as there are whole bunch
- 0:32of other factors that can impact it, including educational level emphasis on civics in
- 0:40schooling, personality, age, economic status, even political competitive competitiveness, all
- 0:48sorts of things that can affect it.
- 0:51Nonetheless, however, there unfortunately seems to have been quite a dip in political efficacy
- 0:58in the American public in recent decades, though perhaps that's not a consensus opinion.
- 1:03Still low rates of political efficacy pose problems for elections, including potential
- 1:10decreases in government responsiveness, electoral competitiveness, and healthy election
- 1:16and policy discourse.
- 1:17So today, we're going to discuss political efficacy, how we define it, what threatens it,
- 1:24and some potential questions to ask about how we start to improve political efficacy in
- 1:32American politics.
- 1:33So let's get started.
- 1:36First of all, how do we exactly define political efficacy in general?
- 1:41Talked about it just a little bit in that intro, but at its most basic, there are two
- 1:45types of political efficacy.
- 1:47There's the internal, which refers to how much people know about politics.
- 1:51So do you know about current events going on?
- 1:55Who current elected officials are, like president or your congressperson?
- 2:00Well, appointed officials like the Supreme Court of the United States.
- 2:05Do you know basics of American civics and things like the three branches of government,
- 2:12executive, legislative, and judicial, which we just talked about in the last episode?
- 2:18How bills get passed, and so on.
- 2:22So internal is just about how much you or how much people, know and understand about politics
- 2:28and how it's structured and what's exactly going on.
- 2:31And then you have the external, which measures how much people can affect politics.
- 2:38So whether people vote, that's the most obvious one.
- 2:41But, also, how often they vote, how much they participate in campaigns, whether they're
- 2:49advocates for certain bills or policies.
- 2:52Do they go and try to teach people about politics?
- 2:55Do they try to hold town halls about politics?
- 2:58And so on.
- 2:59So internal because of how inside, how you understand politics, and then external, how you
- 3:06outside of you, how you actually impact politics.
- 3:10However, you can also break those two down arguably even further because there can be a
- 3:15noticeable discrepancy in people's perception of their own efficacy and what their efficacy
- 3:21actually is.
- 3:22So with the internal, there can be a difference between how much people think they know about
- 3:27politics versus how much they actually know.
- 3:30And when it comes to the external, it could be a difference between how much people think they
- 3:35can affect politics versus how much they actually can affect politics or how much they
- 3:40actually do affect politics.
- 3:44And one might argue certain things are a matter of both internal and external efficacy.
- 3:50For example, the many ways people can actually get involved in politics besides just voting,
- 3:55it's internal because or it it it concerns internal efficacy because it concerns, do
- 4:02people know the ways that they can get involved in politics?
- 4:05And then external is, of course, the actual effecting of politics in those ways.
- 4:10Do you know that you can participate in campaigns by doing things such as phone banking
- 4:17or going door to door?
- 4:19And you don't need necessarily need to be employed by the campaign.
- 4:21You can volunteer for it.
- 4:24And then different public opinion pollsters, political scientists, advocates, campaigners,
- 4:31and so on have different ways to measure efficacy.
- 4:34So there's no singular way to measure it.
- 4:36There's no clear cut, okay.
- 4:38This is how we say what people's internal political efficacy is and how much or what
- 4:44their external political efficacy is.
- 4:46There's no singular way to measure it.
- 4:48Not necessarily quantitative or qualitative.
- 4:51Could be both.
- 4:53It also depends on what your job is and what exactly you wanna know.
- 4:56So if we take campaigners versus civics educators, for example, campaigners are, of
- 5:02course, trying to win elections.
- 5:04Civics educators are simply trying to teach people about politics.
- 5:08So if a campaigner is trying to figure out a voter's political efficacy or internal
- 5:15political efficacy, they want people to know what is on the ballot.
- 5:19They don't really necessarily care all that much whether people know about whether there's
- 5:23three branches of government or there's two chambers of Congress, unless it actually
- 5:27impacts the campaign.
- 5:29They mostly just want people to know who and what is on the ballot.
- 5:33Whereas a civics educator is just gonna want people to know the basics of government and
- 5:39possibly who is running for office.
- 5:41So can be some overlap between the two groups, but, overall, though, they're both trying to
- 5:48measure different things.
- 5:49So efficacy is just not a really necessarily straightforward thing to measure, but it is
- 5:55important to measure.
- 5:57Speaking of which, let's get a little bit more into the weeds of well, first, we'll do
- 6:03internal efficacy.
- 6:05So, again, that is how much citizens know about politics.
- 6:10They and there might be a difference between what they think they know about politics versus
- 6:15what they actually know about politics.
- 6:18So it's not necessarily a straightforward thing to measure and then compare those two things.
- 6:23And an internal efficacy measure could also vary for the same individual in different
- 6:29contexts.
- 6:30So they might know a lot about which candidates are running, but their understanding of the
- 6:34basics of government are kind of lacking.
- 6:38Or they may feel like they understand federal level politics, but not state level and local
- 6:43level.
- 6:43And that's the case for a lot of people because, typically speaking, when you get
- 6:48further down the ballots, when you get more and more local, there's a lot less information
- 6:53that's available about those local level offices, and we'll get a little bit more into
- 6:58that, shortly.
- 6:59But the founding fathers all believed in the importance of a well informed electorate.
- 7:05They did not all agree, though, on how exactly how much of the electorate could be trusted to
- 7:12know about politics.
- 7:13And in the really early days of US politics after becoming a or becoming an independent
- 7:21country, there was even being a white male wasn't necessarily enough to become a voter.
- 7:28Now, of course, back then, it's just prior to the nineteenth amendment, so women were not
- 7:33able to vote and then before the fifteenth amendment.
- 7:35So, black males could not vote.
- 7:38You know, racial minorities could not vote.
- 7:41But even back then, it was only propertied white males.
- 7:46So if you're a white male, but you didn't have property, you initially couldn't vote in
- 7:50elections either.
- 7:51So there was some, difference with the founding fathers as to how much of the, electorate could
- 8:00be trusted to know about politics.
- 8:01But in any case, they all generally believe that a well informed electorate was critical
- 8:08for the American experiment to succeed.
- 8:11Now how do we study this internal efficacy further?
- 8:16You're not necessarily directly measuring how people feel about their ability to understand
- 8:21politics, but couple of different ways that you can look at it is how well do people know their
- 8:28elected officials.
- 8:30Every so often, you'll see polls on whether people know who the president is.
- 8:34They're congressperson, justices on the Supreme Court, governor, and and these polls are nuts,
- 8:43very encouraging in that regard.
- 8:45There are, I forget the exact numbers, but when it comes to the Supreme court, very, very, very
- 8:53few people in those polls are able to name all nine supreme court justices.
- 8:59And not only that, most of them can't even name one, or they can maybe name one, but not two,
- 9:07and there's nine of them to know.
- 9:10Campaigners also sometimes use what we call name ID or name identification while engaging
- 9:17support for a candidate or whether whether it's their candidate that they're they're supporting
- 9:22that the campaign are supporting or it's the or it's an opponent.
- 9:26They might say, who do do you know who this person is, and, you know, what's your
- 9:31favorability on them?
- 9:33And sometimes if they have a low name identification, then they know, okay.
- 9:37We gotta get our camp, candidate's name out there.
- 9:42So that's another way that internal efficacy pops up.
- 9:48Another way you can do it is simply testing the electorate on the basics of government.
- 9:53What are the three branches of government?
- 9:55Executive, legislative, and judicial.
- 9:57How does a bill get passed?
- 9:59And, you know, if if if you don't know, there's a fantastic Schoolhouse Rock episode about
- 10:04that.
- 10:04I'm just a bill.
- 10:06Do people know that basic pathway for bills?
- 10:11Not a lot of people do.
- 10:13What are the two chambers of congress?
- 10:15There's a US house and a US senate, and the vast majority of state legislatures work the
- 10:20same way too, except Nebraska, which only has a state senate.
- 10:24So how much do people know those basics of government?
- 10:28Not just for the federal level.
- 10:30Do they know it for their state government?
- 10:31Do they know it for their local level?
- 10:34Another way to measure internal efficacy is whether states require civics education in
- 10:40schools because civics education is critical for not only just the overall for, yes, for the
- 10:47overall health of the American political system so that people know what is going on, but it's
- 10:54it's it's it's specifically is relevant for internal political efficacy because if people
- 11:01don't get a well rounded civics education, it's it's not necessarily that their internal
- 11:08efficacy will definitely go down, but it's a lot harder for that internal efficacy to be at
- 11:13a high level like it should be.
- 11:16But how how civics education in schools looks can vary from state to state because civics can
- 11:24encompass a wide range of relevant topics.
- 11:26So, for example, is there a stand alone middle school civics course?
- 11:30Is there a stand alone high school civics course?
- 11:34Is civics integrated into a normal social studies course?
- 11:37So it's not his own thing, but it's part of social studies.
- 11:40Is there a civics assessment?
- 11:42Is media literacy taught in grade school?
- 11:45And then you've also got to account for people who are out of school.
- 11:49So adults continuing education.
- 11:52Are there civics programs for them?
- 11:55So all sorts of, differences amongst the states in that regard.
- 12:02And there are unfortunately quite a few threats to internal political efficacy, and, it poses
- 12:10some significant, consequences for the American political system.
- 12:15So, for example, probably the biggest one is the ballot information problem.
- 12:21Basically refers to the fact that it's hard for people to find information about what's going
- 12:28on in politics.
- 12:30Yeah.
- 12:31For the really the highest level stuff there is, for, like, for president and congress,
- 12:36you'll find a lot more information.
- 12:38But then when you get to the state level, there tends to be a lot less.
- 12:41When you get to the local level, there tends to be a lot less.
- 12:45People often don't know where to find information.
- 12:49And even when they do know where to find this information, it can be very time consuming.
- 12:55You have to actually take the time to go and research all this stuff.
- 13:00And for people who are working and or have kids to take care of, it might be very hard for them
- 13:08to take the time to go figure out where this information is and then to actually go look up
- 13:14the information.
- 13:16It's it it the ballot information problem can even be an issue for those of us who work in
- 13:20politics for a living, especially when we wanna look up local level politics.
- 13:25And if that's the case, if even those of us who are involved in politics for a living, if we're
- 13:30having trouble finding this information sometimes, how can we expect other people who
- 13:34are not so ingrained in politics to be able to find things?
- 13:39And it becomes a bigger issue the more obscure a candidate or a ballot measure is.
- 13:43So generally speaking, again, the more local something is, the harder it is to find
- 13:49information on them.
- 13:50For candidates, this is particularly the case for independence and write ins.
- 13:56Sometimes write ins are also independence, but you generally have a lot less information
- 14:00available for independents because they don't have the same channels that Republicans and
- 14:05Democrats do.
- 14:06They have Republicans and Democrats have their own local and state parties that can also help
- 14:12boost them.
- 14:14People already have a general idea of what that candidate stands for with that republican or
- 14:20democratic label.
- 14:21Obviously, there's variation in what democrats believe amongst each other and what Republicans
- 14:27believe amongst each other, but there's a general idea that you have when you see that
- 14:33label next to somebody.
- 14:34When you have somebody who's an independent, you don't really get that same kind of thing.
- 14:40We call that a heuristic, basically, a mental shortcut.
- 14:44And it's also the case, especially the case for write ins as well because you don't see their
- 14:50name on the ballot.
- 14:51You have to actually write their name in.
- 14:55Ballot measures, especially when they're more local measures.
- 14:58They're like local bonds, for example, esoteric policy areas.
- 15:02So they're not the ones that necessarily get a whole bunch of fanfare.
- 15:08It can be very hard to research these things.
- 15:11And there's groups like Ballopedia who, full disclosure, is a former employer of mine, but
- 15:16Ballopedia has made phenomenal strides in helping to close this ballot information gap,
- 15:21but there's still a lot of progress to be made.
- 15:24And and Ballapedia will you know, that that's part of their whole mission is is is to close
- 15:29that ballot information gap, but there's there's still a lot of, issues with that.
- 15:39Another issue for internal political efficacy is the decline of civics education, the
- 15:48arguable decline of civics education.
- 15:51Recent decades have seen less of an emphasis on civics education schools, though the tide has
- 15:56somewhat been turning lately.
- 15:59But teaching civics is one thing.
- 16:02Having the programs there is one thing.
- 16:05What about its quality?
- 16:06That that can that can be a lot more subjective, but it's not just about having
- 16:13civics education.
- 16:14It's about having a quality civics education.
- 16:18And while civics education has made somewhat of a comeback at the state level, there's no
- 16:24robust continuing education curriculum for adults who are already done with school to
- 16:29learn about civics.
- 16:30So if they didn't have a robust civics program when they were in school, how do we provide it
- 16:38for them after they're done with schooling?
- 16:40Or they can actually just forget a lot of what they learned in school because that happens to
- 16:45all of us.
- 16:45There's some some things we learn in school that we forget as time goes on.
- 16:51So how do you remedy that?
- 16:54How do and whether they didn't get a robust civics education when they were in school or if
- 17:00they did get one, but they forgot a lot of what happened.
- 17:04How do we provide programs for those people?
- 17:07Because those are the ones who are actually at least of the age to be able to register to
- 17:14vote.
- 17:14So how do we get them a proper civics education as well?
- 17:21You gotta approach it a different way than implementing a civics curriculum in schools.
- 17:28Another problem for internal political efficacy is there's a lack of coverage from the media
- 17:34for certain government officials and electoral contests.
- 17:38There's many officials that a voter won't know about because the media doesn't cover them.
- 17:42And, again, that's typically more local level people like a city councilor or a mayor.
- 17:51And that's probably because there's generally not enough of a market to cover those people,
- 17:56especially in a much smaller population.
- 17:58When you got someplace like a New York City or Los Angeles or Chicago.
- 18:02Yeah.
- 18:02Those there's a lot of people in those cities that can vote on those local offices, so there
- 18:07will be more information available for them.
- 18:10But if you go to some random, rural town, that that's that's that somebody might consider in
- 18:21the middle of nowhere.
- 18:22There's usually not gonna be enough of a market to cover those people.
- 18:26So it'll be a lot not not that there won't be people to cover them, but the information will
- 18:30be a lot harder to come across, and it won't be as readily available.
- 18:34So if there's not enough voters to care about that office at or it's too costly to cover that
- 18:42office, it'll be that much harder to find information on those people.
- 18:46So people won't know who those officials are.
- 18:51They won't know who's running for those offices or who's been appointed to those local offices
- 18:58or state level offices, and so internal efficacy decreases.
- 19:03And this also, again, contributes to the ballot information problem.
- 19:07Media is supposed to help bridge knowledge gaps on government officials for the general
- 19:12population.
- 19:13But if voters don't know enough about an elected official or a ballot measure, and they
- 19:18know they don't know about these things, they're usually going to decline to vote on it.
- 19:23Now some people will think they know about these things and they don't, and they still
- 19:29vote on it anyways.
- 19:30But in any case, it it still poses a big problem for internal political efficacy through
- 19:36this ballot information issue, this ballot information gap.
- 19:41And then, again, with independence on write ins, they tend to be disproportionately
- 19:45impacted by this because there's generally fewer avenues for them to reach people in the
- 19:51media.
- 19:52And then lastly, biased information.
- 19:54And and this is not a necessarily comprehensive list of threats to internal political efficacy
- 20:00efficacy, but there's it's just some of the big ones.
- 20:03You also have biased information.
- 20:05Obviously, bias is a problem, especially with how good AI is getting at faking and twisting
- 20:12things.
- 20:14And in addition to people willingly willingly sucking up like minded things because they
- 20:21agree with it, so it must be true.
- 20:23And staying in these information silos, Internet and social media algorithms are also
- 20:28incentivizing media outlets and reporters to give people information that fits their
- 20:36worldview.
- 20:37So there's a lot of pandering, quite frankly, to people to tell them what they want to hear.
- 20:46And that's gonna hinder internal political efficacy because they're not getting a well
- 20:51rounded, unbiased view of what's really going on or who's running for office.
- 20:59And people just aren't it's not just and that that's not to make it sound like, oh, it's
- 21:05only, you know, media's fault or it's only, the voters' fault.
- 21:10It's it's there's there's a lot of contributors to this.
- 21:14People also just aren't being taught well how to sift through this bias information.
- 21:19And, again, you have groups like Ballopedia who have done a tremendous job in cutting through
- 21:26all the these issues, but it's it's still a very it's a very tough issue to deal with.
- 21:32And it's bias is not something you can just completely eradicate, and it's very insidious.
- 21:37And if we don't realize how our biases wreak havoc on our internal political efficacy, it's
- 21:46it's just gonna keep on festering.
- 21:48It's it's just gonna keep on being a problem.
- 21:52But that's enough on internal political efficacy.
- 21:56Now let's move to the external political efficacy.
- 21:59Again, what that means, it's how much citizens can affect politics.
- 22:05There can be a difference between how much people think they can and do affect politics
- 22:10versus how much they actually can and do affect politics.
- 22:16And like with internal efficacy, it can vary for the same individual in different context.
- 22:22So maybe that voter thinks they can impact local level politics much more than federal
- 22:30level politics by getting involved in campaigns and town halls and so on.
- 22:36Knowing politics is all well and good, but how do you impact it personally?
- 22:42And usually, people just vote, and then they call it a day.
- 22:46For other people, they get a lot more involved by participating in campaigns or organizing
- 22:51town halls.
- 22:53So some of the ways it is studied, and it's not necessarily directly measuring how people feel
- 22:59about their ability to affect politics.
- 23:01But one way to look at it is through voter turnout rates.
- 23:05That's probably the most obvious way to do it, and that could be measured in several ways as I
- 23:10talked about in an early episode of the podcast.
- 23:14In short, it can be based on simply the number of registered voters.
- 23:18It can be the voting age population, so not everybody who's 18 years old is registered to
- 23:24vote.
- 23:25So you might base it on that because you're trying to get more people involved in in
- 23:30politics even by simply voting, so you might try to go get those people registered to vote.
- 23:35And then there's also voting eligible population.
- 23:38There are some people who, for one reason or another, typically, it's if they are a
- 23:42convicted felon or they're, or if they're an ex felon or they're in jail, depending on the
- 23:48state, their ability to vote is very much hindered.
- 23:54And then each state has, different stipulations for those people, whether they can vote or I
- 24:00mean, some some of them, they can't vote until the a certain amount of time.
- 24:05Some people, they immediately get the ability to vote back as soon as they get out of jail.
- 24:12Just several, different this depending on the states, there's different stipulations.
- 24:17But voter turnout rates are the most obvious way to measure external political efficacy
- 24:22because if you think you can affect politics, you're at least going to vote.
- 24:29Typically, if you don't think you can make any sort of impact whatsoever on politics, you're
- 24:36you're you're likely not going to vote.
- 24:39So it's not a it's not a foolproof measure by any means, but it is a pretty good indicator of
- 24:45to some extent of some people's external political efficacy.
- 24:51There's also, of course, measurements of how much voters are involved in politics beyond
- 24:56voting.
- 24:56Talked about a couple times already.
- 24:58Voting is the most obvious way to get involved, but you can also get involved by actually
- 25:03volunteering on campaigns, whether they are for federal, state, local levels.
- 25:10You can volunteer in elected and appointed officials' offices.
- 25:14Some of them have more public facing rules that you can get involved in where you hear
- 25:21constituents' concerns and complaints.
- 25:24You can organize discussions with people just simply saying, hey.
- 25:27Let's talk about what's going on in politics, or you can have a more formal thing like going
- 25:32to a town hall.
- 25:34You can donate to campaigns and packs, all sorts of different ways to get involved with
- 25:39the political process.
- 25:41Or you can advocate for and against certain bills that are being heard in Congress or at
- 25:48the state level or at your local level.
- 25:50All sorts of different ways to actually get involved beyond just voting.
- 25:55And then there's also perceptions of government responsiveness.
- 25:58How much citizens believe government can actually listen to their problems?
- 26:02That inevitably impacts whether people think their opinions and actions on politics actually
- 26:08matter.
- 26:09If you don't think the government responds to your concerns, your thoughts, your feelings,
- 26:15you probably have a low level of external political efficacy.
- 26:19And this can also partly be influenced by partisan affiliation.
- 26:23That's to say, if you as a voter, your party matches the whether it's your congressperson or
- 26:32the president or governor or what have you, if a lot for a lot of people, the perception of
- 26:40response of government responsiveness and thus their level of external political efficacy
- 26:46depends in large part on the party of the person they're trying to reach.
- 26:50If you're a Republican voter and you're trying to get your Democratic congressperson to vote
- 26:55for or against a certain bill, a lot of times, you'll probably think your your external
- 27:01efficacy might go down because that congressperson has a different party than you.
- 27:05Same thing with a Democratic voter trying to reach out to a Republican congressperson.
- 27:09A lot of times, your partisan affiliation will have an impact on your external political
- 27:16efficacy, but then that could also translate to that same voter might have a different level of
- 27:22political efficacy when it comes to their congressperson versus their mayor or versus the
- 27:27governor or even the president.
- 27:30All sorts of different factors to consider.
- 27:33And then demographics such as age, income, and race can be factors too.
- 27:38When it comes to income, if you you definitely have a more you have more capability of
- 27:45influencing the political process.
- 27:47Now whether you think you know, whatever your opinions are about money in politics, you know,
- 27:52put that to the side for a second.
- 27:54It's just a matter of fact that if you have more money, you have more avenues through which
- 27:59you can influence politics, namely the fact that you can donate to campaigns and packs that
- 28:06support those campaigns.
- 28:08So it that's how income can affect that age.
- 28:12Typically, if you're an older voter, you'll probably think that your external political
- 28:18efficacy is higher than a younger person.
- 28:21Not necessarily the case, but for a lot of people, that is the case.
- 28:24And older people do vote at higher rates than younger people do.
- 28:29So in that sense, you could argue that older people's the elderly's external political
- 28:35efficacy is generally higher than younger people.
- 28:39Again, not always the case, but for some, it will be the case.
- 28:43And then when it comes to race, there is for some, voters, if there there's sometimes with,
- 28:53voters of a racial minority, they might feel that they're not heard as much by their
- 28:59congressperson if their congressperson's a white congressperson.
- 29:02There are studies that have shown that black voters often perceive a higher government
- 29:10responsiveness from their congressperson if their congressperson is also black.
- 29:13There's a similar case for other racial minorities too.
- 29:18So race can also play a factor in external advocacy depending on, which elected official
- 29:27or or government official in general is, in question.
- 29:33So all sorts of things there that affect your external political efficacy.
- 29:38Now as for threats to that external political efficacy, one of the really big ones is public
- 29:47trust in institutions.
- 29:49If citizens don't trust political institutions, they'll think their opinions and actions don't
- 29:54matter, and many will stop or have already stopped participating in politics.
- 30:00They will stop volunteering for campaigns.
- 30:03They'll stop advocating for things.
- 30:05They might even just not vote at all.
- 30:10US Supreme Court in particular has seen a noticeable drop in public confidence the last
- 30:16few years.
- 30:19Now that's not saying whether the the the ruling recent rulings that they've had, such as
- 30:27overturning Roe v Wade, are good or bad.
- 30:30But if you look at public confidence polls can't remember the exact numbers off the top of
- 30:35my head, but if you look at public confidence polling for US Supreme Court, it has gone down
- 30:42in recent years.
- 30:43So that poses a problem not just I mean, obviously, for the overall health of the
- 30:49American political system of government, but also for the legitimacy of these institutions,
- 30:55because a lot of that legitimacy comes from the fact that people perceive these institutions to
- 31:01be legitimate.
- 31:02It's a similar thing with congress.
- 31:04Everybody hates congress.
- 31:05Everybody's hated congress for a long time.
- 31:08Oftentimes, their approval rating is is in the single digits, So you might have, like, eight
- 31:14or 9% approval, and then over 90% of people disapprove of congress as a whole, though they
- 31:20love their congressperson, generally speaking.
- 31:25So the fact that they see abysmally low approval can be seen as a form of lower
- 31:31external political efficacy.
- 31:34To use more specific, a specific study, Pew Research Center used a report from the national
- 31:42election study, regarding this question of the percent of people who say they trust the
- 31:50government to do what is right just about always or most of the time, and that has been
- 31:56at or below an all time low.
- 31:59Or it's it's been at the all time low or around the all time low for about a decade and a half
- 32:07now.
- 32:07So the trend has just been about the heights of, people who trusted the government in this
- 32:14regard was during Eisenhower, John f Kennedy, and beginning of Lyndon b Johnson's tenure as
- 32:24president.
- 32:25And you saw a sharp drop through the end of Lyndon Johnson's tenure as president through
- 32:32Nixon, Lyndon Johnson with issues such as the Vietnam War dragging on.
- 32:37With Richard Nixon.
- 32:39You saw it because of the Watergate scandal largely.
- 32:43Were a couple of points that it jumped back up over the ensuing decades.
- 32:48It jumped back.
- 32:49Percentage you trusted government to do what is right jumped up a bit during Reagan's tenure
- 32:55and then during Clinton's tenure and the start of George w Bush's tenure.
- 33:01But then it start it went back down again.
- 33:04And through Obama, Donald Trump's first term, and Biden's term in office, the percentage of
- 33:11people who say they trust the government to do what is right just about always or most of the
- 33:16time has never been above has not been above 26% in this past decade and a half.
- 33:22So that is also a huge concern.
- 33:25This pub this general public trust in political institutions is a it poses a lot of issues for
- 33:33external political efficacy and for government responsiveness.
- 33:38There's also a lack of political competition in a lot of places.
- 33:41If it's a given who is going to win an election, whether it's for congress or
- 33:46governor, the voters who are predisposed to vote differently are likely going to tune out.
- 33:52If if a Democrat regularly wins, like, 80% of the vote or a Republican generally wins with
- 34:00about, like, 80% of the vote, just as a example number.
- 34:04The other party is it's gonna be just be like, why am I even bothering?
- 34:08And then they won't show up.
- 34:09And then that can actually make elections even more lopsided.
- 34:14So if you feel like you can't change the outcome, it's a lot less likely that you're
- 34:19going to vote or participate in politics in other ways.
- 34:22So another way that your external political efficacy goes down.
- 34:28And, and, unfortunately, there are many contests at the federal, state, and local
- 34:32levels that are just not going to be competitive.
- 34:35And that's why you see election forecasters, they rate a bunch of different races as safe or
- 34:42solid for one major party or the other.
- 34:45It might be safe Republican, safe Democrat, solid Republican, solid Democrat.
- 34:50Each forecaster has their own, grading scale, but the or not necessarily that, oh, it's a
- 34:58done deal that that party's gonna win, but it's very, very likely they're gonna win, and
- 35:02they're probably gonna win by a lot.
- 35:05You're seeing a lot of elections that are like that.
- 35:08And less competition in elections has been shown by studies to have a negative impact on
- 35:14voter turnout, which, again, is a form of external political efficacy.
- 35:19So if we don't have, competitive elections, I mean, not only do we, in general, feel like we
- 35:26have little impact on government, but government is gonna have less incentive to
- 35:32respond to voices that are not the ones that they agree with.
- 35:38And then just like with internal political efficacy, another problem for external
- 35:43political efficacy is the decline of civics education.
- 35:46As we said earlier, there's been a decline in recent decades in civics education quality and
- 35:51availability.
- 35:52Some stat states have taken steps to alleviate this.
- 35:56But even if civics education in schools is available, you still have to account for
- 36:02adults.
- 36:03You have to account for continuing education.
- 36:06So not only, you know, teaching people go government so that they understand what's going
- 36:13on, Some people don't even know all the different ways that they can get involved in
- 36:18government, so it can be sort of both an internal and external, issue.
- 36:23But that that's so decline in civics education is another issue for external political
- 36:33efficacy.
- 36:34And then low internal political efficacy can also feed into this low external political
- 36:39efficacy.
- 36:39We touched on it a little bit already.
- 36:42If a voter does not understand politics and they know they don't understand politics, they
- 36:46may be disinclined to try to learn more, in which case then they're gonna be much less
- 36:53likely to try to participate in elections.
- 36:56Trying to understand politics takes time and effort that many would be voters are either
- 37:01unwilling or unable to put in.
- 37:08So why is political efficacy so important beyond what we just talked about already?
- 37:14It might be obvious, but we really should talk about why this is such a problem.
- 37:19Because both internal and external efficacy are linked together.
- 37:24We would expect either both are high or both are low, but it's possible that's not the case.
- 37:31Some people may feel like they understand the politics very well, but they don't feel like
- 37:34they can impact it.
- 37:36Or somebody may really want to impact politics a lot, and they feel like they can, but they
- 37:42don't necessarily feel like they understand it a lot.
- 37:45So it it it can be, one way or the when, one way for internal political efficacy and another
- 37:54way for external political efficacy.
- 37:57But if they are both low, I mean, it's already a problem if one of them is low.
- 38:02But if they are both low, both in terms of citizens' self assessment of their own efficacy
- 38:08and their true efficacy, that threatens the health of the American political way of life.
- 38:14Government becomes less responsive and accountable because citizens don't understand
- 38:19what's happening, and they can't make an impact, or they feel like they don't understand
- 38:25or that they can't make an impact.
- 38:28Government will feel much less like they have to respond to large segments of the population,
- 38:34especially the people that very much oppose those officeholders.
- 38:37Do you have a very strongly Republican officeholder?
- 38:42They're probably not gonna listen to those very strongly Democratic voters.
- 38:46If you have a very strongly Democratic officeholder, they're probably not gonna listen
- 38:50to those very strongly Republican, voters.
- 38:54Or they might just not listen to the other party at all even if they are not so even if
- 38:59that voter is not so strongly Democrat or not so strongly Republican, they might just not
- 39:05listen to them.
- 39:05That that office holder may might not listen to them anyways.
- 39:08But, also, government just won't necessarily know what voters' demands are because they've
- 39:15these voters have just become too disenchanted to engage with the political system.
- 39:19They don't even bother saying what their issues are because they just think it doesn't matter
- 39:24anyways.
- 39:24So not not just necessarily because the government official will be a jerk and doesn't
- 39:31want to hear differing opinions, but they may get a skewed vision of what the their
- 39:38constituents think because they're just not hearing from all of them.
- 39:42And if people are just not participating in politics at all, especially through voting,
- 39:48that means elections are gonna be decided by only a relative few voters who are the most
- 39:53ingrained in politics.
- 39:54And you see this a lot with local level offices.
- 39:58It's very common for races for mayor and city council to see turnout rates at, like, ten,
- 40:06fifteen, 20 percent as opposed to the presidency, which might see something like,
- 40:13again, partially depends on how you're measuring voter turnout, but that might be more
- 40:17like a 70%, and congress might be, like, 50%.
- 40:23Governor might be, like, 35, 40, 40 five, something around there.
- 40:27That just just general idea of differences in turnout rates.
- 40:31Obviously, it depends on on the states in question and what what election we're talking
- 40:37about.
- 40:37But you still see this relative few voters deciding things at state and then especially at
- 40:46local level races.
- 40:48So we need a government that is actually representative of people as well.
- 40:57Issues with the lack of internal efficacy specifically, people then become even more
- 41:04susceptible to deliberately biased information, and they have less understanding of what is
- 41:09really going on in politics.
- 41:12Lack of external efficacy specifically, that means fewer people are involved in campaigns,
- 41:18which means fewer volunteers, which are a critical component to campaigns.
- 41:23A lot of people notice just the the people who get paid to work on these campaigns, but
- 41:29especially for state and local campaigns, they rely heavily on volunteers.
- 41:35They can't pay everybody, so they need a lot of volunteers.
- 41:39And if they're getting fewer volunteers, then you're really just gonna see the most moneyed
- 41:44candidates win because they have to re they rely less on these volunteers.
- 41:49So you're having just less participation overall and not only with this with less
- 41:56participation by voters, you're having only the most powerful candidates being able to win
- 42:04these elections.
- 42:06And with and there's also a lack of pressure on government officials to try to act in service
- 42:12of all constituents or at least most constituents.
- 42:15In short, if we want government to work properly and at the best it can work, we need
- 42:22to seriously address the issues facing political efficacy.
- 42:26Now how do we exactly address political efficacy?
- 42:31How do we actually raise political efficacy, whether it's internal or external?
- 42:36Of course, you're not gonna solve the issue right away, but we need to take small steps to
- 42:41start.
- 42:42So important questions to ask first.
- 42:45How much of this issue is on citizens, and how much of it is that citizens are not being
- 42:52properly equipped to have a high efficacy.
- 42:57It's not meant to be a blame game on anybody.
- 43:00It's not, oh, citizens are our fault.
- 43:02Government's at fault.
- 43:03Educators are our fault.
- 43:04The culture at large is at fault.
- 43:07However, it is a good policy to think, how can we all contribute to a solution?
- 43:11How can we all do better in this regard?
- 43:13When you start just blaming people, they tend to tune out.
- 43:17It's much more about, oh, how do we all contribute to a problem, and how can we all
- 43:23contribute to a solution?
- 43:24Focus more on contributing versus blaming.
- 43:28Knowing how each segment of the population can contribute to a solution will help us figure
- 43:34out the best methods for tackling and improving efficacy.
- 43:39We also need to think about what's the gap between citizens' self assessment of their
- 43:45efficacy and what their actual efficacy is.
- 43:48We all, at some point, think we know more about things, not not just political things, but
- 43:54things in general.
- 43:55We all think we know more than we actually do at some point, and we don't all fully
- 44:01understand how impactful we are or can be when it comes to politics, or we overestimate how
- 44:08impactful we are.
- 44:10So how do we measure this gap?
- 44:12And the the issue with this gap is, for example, with internal political efficacy, if
- 44:18somebody thinks they understand politics a lot more than they actually do, they're probably
- 44:23gonna not be as amenable to information that they didn't already know previously.
- 44:30They are probably gonna be a little bit more susceptible to biased information because, oh,
- 44:34I have already got everything figured out.
- 44:36This thing that I I agree with that can I conveniently agree with, this must be correct?
- 44:41Might not actually be the case.
- 44:43And knowing how wide this gap is between citizens' self assessment of their efficacy and
- 44:49what their actual efficacy is also helps us in figuring out how to address citizens' self
- 44:56perception and what they can actually do.
- 45:01Another question to consider, what are the most important things to measure to best tackle the
- 45:08problems facing political efficacy?
- 45:10So for internal political efficacy, what are the most important aspects of government, for
- 45:17people to know?
- 45:19The branches of government, that there's two chambers of congress, what each branch does,
- 45:25and so on and so forth.
- 45:26How do we teach these things to people?
- 45:30We just we talked about earlier how it's one thing to have civics education in schools and
- 45:35even quality civics education in schools, but how do you address adults who need this
- 45:40information?
- 45:41How do you address continuing education programs?
- 45:46How do we tailor that to different states and localities and and just different geographical
- 45:51areas in general?
- 45:52Because you can't just have a one size fits all.
- 45:57It'll in a lot of cases.
- 45:59There might be different needs for each, state or locality, especially because they all when
- 46:07it comes comes to their local government or their state government, it's gonna function
- 46:11differently than a different state government or local government.
- 46:14So how do we teach those things?
- 46:18How do we teach again, how do we teach adults that are already done with schooling?
- 46:23And then how do we incentivize people to learn more about politics?
- 46:27We're all human beings.
- 46:28We all need incentives to or a lot of times, we need incentives to go do something.
- 46:34So how do we incentivize people to learn more about politics?
- 46:38We talked about earlier how a lot of people they have they have there's a lot of issues
- 46:44that face them in terms of do they know where to find information?
- 46:49And even if they do know where to find information, do they have the time and energy
- 46:54to spend to find that information?
- 46:57So how do we incentivize those people if they don't have or if they're much less able to go
- 47:04find that information?
- 47:06How do we address that issue, for external efficacy, what things should we measure there?
- 47:14How much do we pay attention to each nonvoting method of getting involved in politics?
- 47:19Most citizens are not gonna go beyond voting on an office, which isn't necessarily which isn't
- 47:25always a bad thing for some people.
- 47:27You know, not every single person needs to get involved in a campaign.
- 47:31But how much should how many people should be involved in politics beyond just voting?
- 47:38How do we more effectively teach citizens the ways that they can get involved with politics,
- 47:43like with phone banking going door to door, town halls, and so on and so forth?
- 47:48And once again, how do we incentivize people to get more involved with politics?
- 47:54What are the proper ways we should incentivize them?
- 47:56Because there can be when you try to get people more involved with politics, there can be some
- 48:02very shady ways that campaigners and and campaign professionals and candidates can try
- 48:09to get people involved trying to entice them to get involved with campaigns.
- 48:14So are are some of those necessarily a problem?
- 48:20And then, of course, what level of funding is needed for improving political efficacy?
- 48:27Everything costs money, especially when you get into politics.
- 48:32You need money for further academic studies of political efficacy, revamping civics programs
- 48:39in schools, implementing adult and continuing education programs.
- 48:43All these things need money, and money can come can come from various resources.
- 48:50It can be donors who really care about these things.
- 48:54Government, whether it's federal, state, or local level.
- 48:58Businesses, nonprofits.
- 49:01Out of our own pockets, depending on what the initiative is for trying to improve political
- 49:08efficacy, that money needs to come from somewhere.
- 49:11So what level of funding is needed to improve political efficacy, and what how far are you
- 49:21trying to improve political efficacy?
- 49:24That's also gonna change how much money you would need to put into these programs.
- 49:30So all sorts of little nooks and crannies to really think about.
- 49:35But in any case, fixing issues with political efficacy is going to take a lot of effort from
- 49:42a lot of us, but we can do it, and we do need to do it regardless of how poor of a state we
- 49:50think internal and external political efficacy are, because it's not again, it's not
- 49:55necessarily consensus that it's a serious problem.
- 49:59But I think there's quite a few indicators that we do have issues with internal and external
- 50:07political efficacy that we do need to address.
- 50:10And there's a lot of hard questions that we need to consider, but it is worth it to try to
- 50:19improve how much people understand politics and improve the ways that they can impact politics
- 50:28because these are very critical things, critical issues for the overall health of the
- 50:36American system of government.
- 50:40So that's gonna do it for today's podcast, and this is just this is something that can just
- 50:46you can just keep going on and on about this.
- 50:49And and maybe I'll do another episode about political efficacy at some point.
- 50:54But, we're gonna end it here because it's already another pretty long episode.
- 50:59But as always, thank you all so much for listening.
- 51:02Please like, comment, subscribe, share this episode with your networks, your friends, your
- 51:09family, random people you know even, or that you just met, even people you don't know.
- 51:17Please share with them anyways.
- 51:20But, obviously, I got the links in the show notes with my Facebook page, my LinkedIn
- 51:25profile, my book, why independents rarely win elections, and how they could become more
- 51:31competitive, my free five day, technically six day educational email course, about common
- 51:42mistakes made when trying to depolarize American politics and how we can take steps to
- 51:47mitigate those common mistakes and why we make those mistakes in the first place.
- 51:53And, Matchmaker FM profile if you wanna or or and and my email if you wanna contact me about
- 52:00being a guest on this podcast or if you want me to be a guest on your podcast.
- 52:06But that's gonna do it for today's episode.
- 52:07So once again, thank you so much for listening, and until next time.
- 52:11Take care.