Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Finding Missing Records: Looking Into The Case of An Unnamed Victim"- with Bellingcat's Peter Barth
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled Finding
- 0:07Missing Records, looking into the case of an
- 0:10unnamed victim with Bellingcat's Peter Barth.
- 0:13He broke down his recent investigation into a
- 0:1690s cold case murder, exploring how he filed
- 0:19record requests, which became central to finding
- 0:22answers. You can find links to all the resources
- 0:25mentioned in the talk in the podcast description.
- 0:28This talk was hosted by me, Charlotte Maher on
- 0:30Thursday the 17th of September 2026 in the Bellingcat
- 0:34Discord server. First and foremost, welcome all
- 0:52to today's stage talk. Before I get into the
- 0:55talk, I wanted to first announce, in case you
- 0:58haven't heard, that Bellingcat is finally launching
- 1:01an official merch line. I am so excited to get
- 1:05a Bellingcat t -shirt. And as part of this launch,
- 1:07we're asking you to submit design ideas for the
- 1:10merchandise. Those selected by public vote will
- 1:12feature in an exclusive community collection
- 1:15and the winning designers will receive merch
- 1:18for free. So if you're interested in submitting
- 1:21a design, details can be found on our website
- 1:24in the link in the chat that I posted earlier.
- 1:27but you do have less than three weeks to get
- 1:30your entries in. You don't actually have to submit
- 1:33an image. You can also submit a tagline, but
- 1:37please keep those suggestions PC and applicable
- 1:42to our brand. All right. Okay. Now on to today's
- 1:47speaker. We're exploring how to uncover records
- 1:51previously hidden today. What does it look like
- 1:54when your answers appear to not be online, but
- 1:57you know they exist, and how do you find them?
- 2:00My colleague Peter Barth is here to share what
- 2:03happened when he found himself in the same situation
- 2:06when looking into a 30 -year -old cold case of
- 2:09an unnamed victim. How do you get from a report
- 2:12of skeletal remains in an affluent suburb of
- 2:15Boston to a Chinese organised crime group? Following
- 2:19a paper trail with OSINT skills is not something
- 2:21we often speak about, but FOIAs, or FOIs if you're
- 2:25from Europe or Australia, have an important role
- 2:28to play in public data collection. And obtaining
- 2:31them and getting the vital information you need
- 2:33is an art in itself, as I'm sure Peter will go
- 2:36on to tell us. Bringing information into the
- 2:39public sphere is what we're all about here, and
- 2:41Peter spent a year in the shoot of a single name
- 2:45and an identity. So before we dive in, a short
- 2:48reminder that we will have plenty of time to
- 2:50answer your questions. You can place your questions
- 2:52in the chat accessible in the right -hand corner
- 2:54of your screen. But please remember that this
- 2:56is being audio recorded for the podcast. So if
- 2:59you don't want me to mention your username, please
- 3:02add that as a note in your question and I will
- 3:04avoid doing so. Okay. Peter, share with us your
- 3:09insights from this case. Yeah, thank you, Charlie.
- 3:13Good morning, good afternoon, good evening, everybody,
- 3:14depending on where you are. I'm Peter. I mostly
- 3:19research organized crime here at Bellingcat.
- 3:21And as Charlie said, for the past slightly over
- 3:25a year, actually, I was working on a cold case
- 3:29from 1996. So if you haven't read it yet, I'll
- 3:33go over at a very high level the case, kind of
- 3:36as we go through the talk today. And my goal
- 3:38today is I want to try to avoid repeating what
- 3:41I talked about last year. We did another stage
- 3:44talk on cold cases. So there's going to be a
- 3:46lot of topics we don't cover. This is also just
- 3:48a huge topic. And I want to make sure that I'm
- 3:51giving you guys something new this time around.
- 3:54So if you have any questions that I don't get
- 3:56to during the presentation, we can also chat
- 3:58afterwards. But I'll go ahead and just launch
- 4:01into it. So real quick, a couple housekeeping
- 4:04items to address. Today, we're going to talk
- 4:08about using open source research to look into
- 4:11historic unresolved murder cases and also missing
- 4:16and unidentified persons cases a bit. We're going
- 4:18to focus today though on using records requests.
- 4:22You're going to hear me say FOIA a lot or FOI.
- 4:26Apologies if I say FOIA, that's just my American
- 4:31like shorthand lingo coming out. apologies in
- 4:34advance, but what I mean, that means Freedom
- 4:36of Information Act here in the U .S. It means
- 4:38freedom of information in a lot of European countries,
- 4:42I think, FOI. So if I say FOIA, I'm usually,
- 4:45I just mean records requests in general. Yeah.
- 4:49So for our purposes, we're talking about researching
- 4:52these cases to publish information in some way
- 4:56to get it out there. This could be for a media
- 5:00article, like it could be for an article in Bellingcat.
- 5:03This could be for an academic paper on a cold
- 5:06case. This could be for a blog post, for a Reddit
- 5:09post, what have you. We are not talking about
- 5:12hunting down suspects. That is for the police,
- 5:15obviously. So that's not the goal with any of
- 5:18the research that we're talking about today.
- 5:20The goal is to try to collect, organize information
- 5:25about these older cases. and get it online so
- 5:29that we tell the story of these victims. So that's
- 5:32kind of the lens we're looking at all of this
- 5:34material through. And we're not going to be getting
- 5:36into more traditional journalism methods like
- 5:40conducting sensitive interviews with surviving
- 5:42family members or talking to retired law enforcement.
- 5:45That's part of what we do and work on these articles
- 5:50that I've written, but just for the sake of time
- 5:52and because there are a lot of other people Who
- 5:55are a lot more talented at those things who could
- 5:57you could tell you more about that? I'm gonna
- 5:58keep it focused on public records requests and
- 6:01Overall, we're kind of talking about this fly
- 6:04-on -the -wall approach. We're kind of Going
- 6:07out there and seeking information about these
- 6:09cases that may be online or it may exist on paper
- 6:12somewhere And we're trying to get it online.
- 6:14Basically, that's what we're doing. We're not
- 6:17meeting with a confidential source at 2 a .m.
- 6:18In the morning This is this is open source research.
- 6:22So just wanted to put that out there And with
- 6:25that, a quick recap, I talked a little bit about
- 6:27this last year, but why do we even use open source
- 6:31research to look into cold cases? Basically,
- 6:34that's because there's hundreds of thousands
- 6:36of them in the US alone. I'm sure there's an
- 6:39equivalent number over in Europe and in other
- 6:42regions. There are an enormous number of unsolved
- 6:46homicide cases. There are tens of thousands of
- 6:49unidentified persons in the US and tens of thousands
- 6:53of missing persons as well. So the research we're
- 6:57talking about is kind of focused on that today.
- 6:59And I would argue that a lot of these cases haven't
- 7:03really received much attention at all. So in
- 7:06a couple of the cases I'll talk about today that
- 7:08I've worked on, when I started looking into these,
- 7:11I quickly realized that there really was almost
- 7:13no information online about these. And so really
- 7:17quickly my research became, how can I get information
- 7:20held by the authorities that's on paper? that
- 7:23can now be considered public information. How
- 7:25do I access that and work with that with other
- 7:28more typical open source methods? Cold cases,
- 7:32I would argue, are a matter of public safety
- 7:35because for every unsolved case, there is theoretically
- 7:39a murderer or plural murderers out there who've
- 7:42gotten away with this. So these cases are often
- 7:46tied to other forms of misconduct as well. So
- 7:48it could be decades ago that maybe investigators
- 7:52dropped the ball somehow. They misplaced evidence
- 7:54and they couldn't get a conviction. It could
- 7:56be that the case is tied in with organized crime
- 7:59groups, like with the cases I've looked at. The
- 8:02victim might have been also a victim of human
- 8:04trafficking and moved to somewhere from another
- 8:07place, from another country. So there's all kinds
- 8:10of other forms of wrongdoing tied in with these
- 8:13murder cases usually. And then, unfortunately,
- 8:17there's this term out there called less dead.
- 8:21And if you haven't heard it before, it's the
- 8:24concept that certain victims might get less attention
- 8:28from not only from law enforcement, but less
- 8:30attention from the media, less attention from
- 8:32the public because, you know, they were a sex
- 8:36worker perhaps, or they were suspected of involvement
- 8:39in crime themselves, or maybe the person is an
- 8:43undocumented immigrant. And you know, came to
- 8:48the U .S. or came to another country from another
- 8:50part of the world and their entire family and
- 8:52everyone who would normally be there to advocate
- 8:54for them and to call the police and ask for updates
- 8:56just isn't there. That was the case with the
- 9:00story that I'll talk about today. So a lot of
- 9:03these cases just they don't have advocates that
- 9:05are out there pushing them forward as much and
- 9:07they unfortunately fall through the cracks a
- 9:09lot of the time. So many, many, many of these
- 9:11unsolved cases when you when you look into them,
- 9:16you're gonna notice that a lot of them, the victims,
- 9:20sort of fit some form of that concept. Also,
- 9:23just for the simple fact that a lot of these
- 9:25cases, especially like the older ones, the ones
- 9:27that are, you know, three, four, five, six decades
- 9:31old, there's a lot of information that could
- 9:34be out there in the case, but it just isn't online.
- 9:37It might be in older newspapers, and it might
- 9:39be just sitting on a shelf in a police department
- 9:41somewhere. And... What we're going to talk about
- 9:44mostly today is filing records requests so that
- 9:49the authorities make some of that information
- 9:51public and some tips and tricks to do that. And
- 9:55I'll talk through some examples that I've done
- 9:57where that's happened. Real quick note on generalizing
- 10:02murder cases. This might be obvious, but just
- 10:05want to put it out there. Each case is unique.
- 10:08There are different motives. There are different
- 10:10structural causes at play. There might be geographic
- 10:13factors associated with the case, like someone's
- 10:16murdered in a national park, for example, versus
- 10:19in an inner city somewhere. Because of this,
- 10:22there's not a one -size -fits -all approach to
- 10:25working on these and to researching them. You're
- 10:28going to use different sets of tools and different
- 10:31resources, and you're going to go about your
- 10:33research in a different way. every time, and
- 10:36just like with anything else we research in open
- 10:38source, you need to tailor that each time. That
- 10:41said, there are some common tools that generally
- 10:47seem to work for a lot of this type of research,
- 10:49so records requests are a big one for that. They
- 10:52don't always work, they won't always uncover
- 10:56new information, but they can be a really powerful
- 10:59tool in some of these cases. So just as an example,
- 11:02It's been really neat the last couple of years,
- 11:05especially, to see incredible advances in DNA
- 11:08technology that are being used to crack cases
- 11:12that are from the 1950s, the 1960s. I think here
- 11:15in Massachusetts, where I live, they just solved
- 11:17our oldest Jane Doe case. And the victim was
- 11:20from the 1950s with some of those DNA advances.
- 11:23So there's a lot of that happening. It's like
- 11:25every couple of days there's something like that,
- 11:27it seems like. But for many cases, like the cases
- 11:31that I've covered, there's no suspect DNA evidence.
- 11:34There's not thought to be at least some piece
- 11:39of physical evidence that the authorities think
- 11:43might produce a DNA sample and identify a suspect.
- 11:46A lot of the cases that I tend to look at are
- 11:48usually gang related or have ties to organized
- 11:51crime groups of different kinds. And the victim
- 11:53is shot from a distance. There's very little
- 11:55physical evidence. And so in cases like that,
- 11:58I find that open source, especially decades later,
- 12:02and sometimes help in collecting, organizing,
- 12:05and telling these stories a little bit better.
- 12:09I won't recap in detail my latest story. It's
- 12:13on our website, on the front page still at the
- 12:16moment, if you want to check it out later and
- 12:18see exactly what we found and how we did it.
- 12:22But just at a very high level, we basically used
- 12:25records requests. to publicly identify a John
- 12:29Doe in Massachusetts. This person, his name was
- 12:33Fuchun Wang. He was a Chinese immigrant from
- 12:37Fujian province. He came to the States in the
- 12:4090s and unfortunately got wrapped up in Chinese
- 12:43organized crime and it cost him his life, it
- 12:45seems. So we tried to tell as much of that story
- 12:48as we could gather. Most of that was done through
- 12:52records requests and also interviews with some
- 12:55retired investigators who worked on it. So the
- 12:57story is closely tied with the story of Chinese
- 13:02organized crime on the East Coast in New York
- 13:05and Boston, specifically in the 1990s. The victim,
- 13:11his associates and the suspect and his accomplices
- 13:14in this case. were all thought to belong to the
- 13:18same gang. Really, I use the term gang loosely
- 13:21here because they were a street gang, they controlled
- 13:24territory in New York, but they're really more
- 13:26like an organized crime group. They're fairly
- 13:28sophisticated and international. And so the story
- 13:31gets into that a little bit, what that looks
- 13:32like. And lastly, our investigation raises some
- 13:36questions about why he still officially remains
- 13:39John Doe and why the suspect and none of the
- 13:44accomplices I've never been prosecuted by authorities
- 13:48for the case. So check it out if you haven't.
- 13:51And then just at a sort of a basic level, just
- 13:55to give you some like behind the scenes, the
- 13:57way I heard about this was actually just through
- 13:58a conversation with my barber. So I was getting
- 14:01my haircut last summer. We were talking about
- 14:04my previous cold case story. And he told me a
- 14:08crazy story about how his childhood friend in
- 14:10his hometown in Sharon, Massachusetts, their
- 14:12dog had walked. home one day with a human femur
- 14:15in its mouth. And the owners immediately recognized
- 14:19that bone as, ooh, that looks like a little too
- 14:22big to be like a deer bone or a coyote or something.
- 14:26This looks like it might be human. So they called
- 14:28the police. And sure enough, this young guy's
- 14:32skeleton was found in the woods behind their
- 14:34house. He'd been dumped there after being murdered
- 14:36in Boston. So that's how the story started. And
- 14:39we were able I wasn't sure if we'd be able to
- 14:42do this. I thought I'd do this as an experiment.
- 14:45Like, can I use records requests to try to put
- 14:47a name to this guy? And then can I try to find
- 14:50out more of what happened? So yeah, that's basically
- 14:56what we did. This is his photo, and I'd encourage
- 14:58you to check out the story. So I get this question
- 15:02a lot, and I try to ask my peers with other media
- 15:07outlets this question whenever I can, whenever
- 15:09we're chatting. And it's a tough one, and the
- 15:12answers differ for everybody. But the question
- 15:14is, how do you pick which cases to research?
- 15:18There are literally hundreds of thousands of
- 15:20these cases out there, tens of thousands of John
- 15:23Doe's, tens of thousands of missing persons,
- 15:27and hundreds of thousands of unsolved murders.
- 15:30So how do you pick which one that you're going
- 15:31to devote time, energy, potentially money? How
- 15:37do you make that decision? And I think for me,
- 15:40there's a couple important questions that I start
- 15:42with. So for one, I think you need to ask yourself
- 15:46when you start looking into any given case, can
- 15:48you add to the public understanding about this
- 15:50case somehow? And how are you going to do that?
- 15:53And it's a little tricky because you don't usually
- 15:55know the answer until you've started to do a
- 15:57little bit of research. And it usually kind of
- 16:00becomes apparent quickly. But a lot of these
- 16:03cases have been worked extensively by you know,
- 16:07loads of podcasters, journalists, people, you
- 16:11know, on Reddit even. A lot of these cases have
- 16:14a lot of material out there already, and a lot
- 16:16of them have next to nothing. Personally, I tend
- 16:20to select cases to research that have a little
- 16:25bit out there on them, but I feel like I can
- 16:28collect more and get more out there. I want to
- 16:31tell more of the story if possible. So that's
- 16:33kind of what I'm looking for. And I can talk
- 16:35more about that later, but there's also this
- 16:38tricky issue of like, is there enough to start
- 16:40with? Because unfortunately, a lot of these cases
- 16:42also have next to nothing out there on them.
- 16:46It's just human remains. It might just be here
- 16:48in Massachusetts, for example, on the coast.
- 16:51Every couple of years, like a single human bone
- 16:53will wash up on one of the beaches. And you'll
- 16:55see it pop up on NamUs, on our national Missing
- 16:59and Unidentified Persons database. but it'll
- 17:01just be like a fragment of a bone and it might
- 17:03be from a shipwreck like in the 1800s. You have
- 17:07no further context than that, just bone discovered
- 17:10on the beach. So it's tricky. Some of these cases
- 17:12are more doable than others from a research point
- 17:14of view. A note on cases that are tied to organized
- 17:17crime and gangs. I also tend to select cases
- 17:22that are tied to organized crime because, well,
- 17:26for one, that's what I work on at Bellingcat.
- 17:29I spend most of my time um, with the financial
- 17:32investigations team looking into contemporary,
- 17:35you know, modern day organized crime groups and
- 17:37all of their various fun activities all over
- 17:39the world. So I can apply kind of some of the
- 17:42experience and skills that I have through that,
- 17:44uh, towards, towards looking into cold cases
- 17:47that are tied to them. But also there's just
- 17:49a lot of those out there. A lot of the unsolved
- 17:51murders out there in the U S and Europe, anywhere
- 17:54in the world, a lot of them, a good portion at
- 17:56least, um, tend to be tied to gang activity,
- 18:00to organized crime, to mafia groups, and there's
- 18:03a lot of reasons for that. Cultural reasons,
- 18:07a lot of the time it is fear of gang retaliation
- 18:10and a stigma about touching anything that is
- 18:14even perceived to have connections to that. I
- 18:16come across that all of the time when I'm trying
- 18:18to interview people here. A lot of people understandably
- 18:21do not want to talk about that, especially on
- 18:24the record. And a lot of the cases too, this
- 18:28is extremely common, victims and their family
- 18:31members themselves and their friends and members
- 18:33of their community don't trust law enforcement.
- 18:36There are huge historical, there's years of history
- 18:39at play there where people in certain communities
- 18:42just don't want to talk to the police and that's
- 18:44ingrained in them. So you navigate kind of all
- 18:49of these sort of factors combined and they mean
- 18:51that a good portion of the unsolved cases out
- 18:52there are tied to that type of activity. And
- 18:55then I also, I tend to look at these because
- 18:57they're usually tied to other forms of crime,
- 19:01other kinds of wrongdoing, and you can use that
- 19:03to your advantage when you're doing the research.
- 19:05You can get information sometimes about some
- 19:08of these murder cases by asking for records about
- 19:12the other crimes tied to them, for example, so.
- 19:16Okay, real quick plug. I think in conversations
- 19:19about unsolved murders, a related Topic and sort
- 19:25of a subtopic from this are unidentified persons.
- 19:29There are an enormous number of these cases out
- 19:31there They tend to get a lot less attention unfortunately
- 19:34than some of the more like high -profile murder
- 19:36cases that are covered on podcasts or on Dateline
- 19:39or You know a lot of the unidentified persons
- 19:42cases are basically just sitting on a shelf and
- 19:46they need bodies on them. Like they need people
- 19:50to be researching them and trying to figure out
- 19:53the story behind it. So I just think that it's
- 19:57a worthwhile cause. I think there's a lot of
- 20:00good to be done here. And if you're looking for
- 20:03sort of something to get involved with, I'd really
- 20:04encourage you to look at unidentified persons
- 20:08cases wherever you live, but also missing persons
- 20:11cases. There's a lot of really awesome groups.
- 20:14I can't put them all here. These are just some
- 20:15of the big ones. In the United States, our national
- 20:18database is called NamUs. And in it, you can
- 20:22see a pretty comprehensive, at least, data set
- 20:28on missing persons and on unidentified persons
- 20:31and on unclaimed persons. So sometimes they've
- 20:33identified a person, but there's been no family
- 20:35member to claim the remains and the person was
- 20:38just found deceased somewhere. And so there's
- 20:40a lot of really tragic stories in there and a
- 20:43lot of unresolved mysteries. Other groups would
- 20:46be DNA Doe Project, the Charlie Project, which
- 20:49was started by basically just a person who cared
- 20:54a lot about the subject and wanted to get involved.
- 20:55So there's really great groups. And if you're
- 20:59overseas, it varies country by country, but I
- 21:03found that a lot of European countries have really
- 21:06much easier to use websites and national databases
- 21:10on missing persons and unidentified persons.
- 21:13Here's a couple examples of that. This is from
- 21:17the UK up top here. This is missing and unidentified
- 21:21persons in the city of Manchester, for example.
- 21:25I've got examples from Ireland down here on the
- 21:28right, and then the Netherlands down here on
- 21:30the left. In my experience, their websites are
- 21:32a lot cleaner looking. They're a lot easier to
- 21:34use and navigate, and I wish NamUs was a little
- 21:36bit more like those. It's very clunky and it
- 21:39feels like it's out of the late 90s. If you've
- 21:41ever been on there, you might know what I'm talking
- 21:43about. Pretty much a lot of countries, the National
- 21:48Police Force will maintain a website on missing
- 21:51persons cases, unresolved murders and unidentified
- 21:54persons. Okay, I know I'm hitting a lot fast.
- 21:59I'm trying to like fit a lot in here and then
- 22:01we can talk afterwards. But for pre -internet
- 22:03cases, where do you even begin? So let's say
- 22:06you started to look into a case like I was doing.
- 22:09on my most recent story. And there's actually
- 22:11very little online. You might find a bare bones
- 22:13entry on NamUs that tells you there's a skeleton
- 22:19found in the woods. It's unidentified. That was
- 22:22basically the only note. It was five words, skeletal
- 22:25remains found in the woods. There might be, I
- 22:28found a Reddit post about it. Didn't have much
- 22:30more info. So it was very bare bones. And that's
- 22:33all I had to begin the research with. If that's
- 22:36the case with your story. then FOIA or FOI or
- 22:40records requests are your first and best stop,
- 22:43in my opinion. They can really be pretty key
- 22:46and they can unlock a lot of leads for you to
- 22:49start doing more research with online. But they
- 22:53can feel, if you don't work in journalism or
- 22:55you've never filed one before, they can feel
- 22:57a little intimidating or a little risky, like,
- 23:00you know, are the police going to be suspicious
- 23:02of me because I'm asking about this case? But
- 23:06just keep in mind that in a lot of countries,
- 23:09like in the US, for example, it's written into
- 23:12law that the public can request information.
- 23:17So in the case of the US and US states, there's
- 23:22no harm in asking the authorities for records
- 23:26on a case. The worst that can happen is they
- 23:28can say, we refuse to release them because of,
- 23:31and then they'll list. They'll list legal reasons
- 23:33why they're not going to release them to you.
- 23:34I'll show you what that looks like in a bit.
- 23:37But you do not have to be a journalist to file
- 23:39records requests in a lot of places. So a couple
- 23:43quick, big tips, just overarching ones. Try to
- 23:48file these as soon as possible. So if you're
- 23:50working on an investigation, and like me, you
- 23:53find very little online, out FOIA requests quickly,
- 23:57you can use tools out there like Muckrock. and
- 24:01similar guides and resources to help you craft
- 24:05those requests. Like, how do you word them? What
- 24:07kinds of records am I asking for? Who do I send
- 24:10it to even? There's a lot of really handy guides
- 24:13out there. And don't try to reinvent the wheel.
- 24:16More on that in a bit. So find similar requests
- 24:19to the ones that you want to file that have worked
- 24:22and use those as templates. Other communities
- 24:25are out there. There's a subreddit on FOIA. This
- 24:29is the National Freedom of Information Coalition,
- 24:31I think. I could be getting that wrong. There's
- 24:33all kinds of groups. University pages sometimes
- 24:36will have like a how -to guide on how to do these.
- 24:39And lastly, just collect as many records as you
- 24:43can from as many relevant government agencies.
- 24:47For the story that I just published, I filed
- 24:4927 records requests or FOIAs for one murder case,
- 24:54just because it was... It ended up being tied
- 24:57to crime sprees across other states and there
- 24:59were all kinds of different law enforcement agencies
- 25:01working on this or working on the related cases.
- 25:04So I file, I just did, I did a shotgun approach.
- 25:08I sent as many requests out as I could. And after
- 25:11a long time, they start trickling back in and
- 25:13you can start working with it. So backing up
- 25:18for a minute, why file records requests to begin
- 25:21with? And basically the answer is that law enforcement
- 25:26With unsolved murder cases or missing persons
- 25:28cases they they might decide to release more
- 25:32info than what's already out there online You
- 25:36never you never really know and in this case
- 25:39I heard about something from word of mouth. I
- 25:41heard about an unidentified person. I found very
- 25:44little online I submitted a records request and
- 25:47I'll show you within days. I got a phone call
- 25:50Basically saying hey, it looks like that. We
- 25:53pretty much wrapped up this case on our end We've
- 25:56pretty much identified this person. We're happy
- 26:00to send you the records." And they did. So you
- 26:04never know. I just stumbled upon that by sheer
- 26:07coincidence. In other cases though, what might
- 26:12happen is the law might compel them to release
- 26:16information. So I did a story last year on unsolved
- 26:21murder in Texas. and it ended up being connected
- 26:24to a second unsolved murder, again, in Texas.
- 26:28And when I filed my records request about that
- 26:31second murder, the related one, in Texas, there's
- 26:35this nifty little rule where if a law enforcement
- 26:38agency tells you that it's not gonna release
- 26:41records to you, they have to explain to the Texas
- 26:44attorney general, the illustrious Ken Paxton,
- 26:47No comment. But they have to explain to the attorney
- 26:51general why they're refusing to release records
- 26:53to you. So that happens automatically. Like I
- 26:56didn't have to write to the attorney general
- 26:58and appeal that decision myself. The sheriff's
- 27:01department that I requested records from had
- 27:04to send them a formal letter explaining, hey,
- 27:06this person requested records and we're denying
- 27:08them on these grounds. And what happened was,
- 27:11without me even being aware that this was happening
- 27:13and that there was a legal back and forth, the
- 27:16attorney general wrote back to them and said,
- 27:18actually, by law, you have to release more of
- 27:22the records than you think you do. So they wrote
- 27:26back and said, you actually have to release X,
- 27:28Y, and Z to him, because one of the explanations
- 27:32was that they hadn't established that the case
- 27:34was active and ongoing. This was a historical
- 27:36case from the 1970s, and that attorney general
- 27:40said, you know what, this case isn't active.
- 27:42You need to release more of the murder file.
- 27:45That can happen sometimes. And again, zero effort
- 27:48from my end. I filed the initial records request
- 27:51and this just happened. And a couple of months
- 27:52later, I had like most of the murder file in
- 27:55my hands. Be prepared to wait. I think this is
- 27:59the most difficult part for me, at least personally,
- 28:02because you will file these FOIAs or these records
- 28:04requests and they can take months and months
- 28:08and months. In the case of federal agencies in
- 28:10the US, they can take years sometimes. It can
- 28:14be really frustrating and that's why these investigations
- 28:17take so long. So this past one took me a year,
- 28:20but I was really working on it off and on in
- 28:23fits and starts. I was filing a records request
- 28:25and then a month might go by where nothing happens
- 28:28and I'm working on other stories for Bellingcat.
- 28:30So I kind of have them going on in the background
- 28:33at any given time. This is my research assistant.
- 28:37My cat right here, but basically this is to show
- 28:39you that when you do get their records It feels
- 28:41like Christmas morning. It feels like You filed
- 28:45them months ago. You've had a couple back and
- 28:48forth You know email exchanges with whoever's
- 28:52working on your records request and then you
- 28:53finally get your hands on them It's it can it's
- 28:56a really awesome feeling So, let me show you
- 28:59what my records request that started this latest
- 29:02story look like it was a simple email I had sent
- 29:05a couple of similar ones before, and I basically
- 29:07used those as a template. This is the chief of
- 29:10police in the town where the murder victim was
- 29:13found, and he happens to be the records access
- 29:16officer. I just went to their website, typed
- 29:18in sharing police department records requests,
- 29:20and the first page that came up was their how
- 29:23-to page, which included his email. So I sent
- 29:26him an email, I explained what I wanted, just
- 29:28very simply, and spelled out exactly what I was
- 29:32looking for. Please ignore my cat. He's right
- 29:34here. Um, and basically, um, within a couple
- 29:40of days, I got a phone call and he explained
- 29:43that the case, um, which is technically still
- 29:47unsolved and the victim is still publicly unidentified.
- 29:50He explains that internally they had identified
- 29:53this guy years ago and, um, basically determined
- 29:57that he had not been murdered in that town. So
- 30:00the murder case itself, um, You know, prosecuting
- 30:04the murder suspects for this case is probably
- 30:07something that's going to have to be handled
- 30:08by the Boston police. And within days of sending
- 30:12that email, this is what I got. So they sent
- 30:16me a summary of their investigation that included
- 30:20the victim's name immediately. This was nowhere
- 30:23else online. I knew immediately, okay, I've got
- 30:25a story here. This is a John Doe. The police
- 30:28actually have his name and they're confident
- 30:30about it. And they've released it to me crucially.
- 30:33So this is what I started with. And if you see
- 30:36here, what happened was, more on that in a second,
- 30:42in this summary of the investigation that they
- 30:44sent me, they noted a couple of things. They
- 30:48said that he was suspected of being tied to a
- 30:51crime spree in another state. And they mentioned
- 30:54an arrest in Boston where the victim had actually
- 30:57been arrested. They also mentioned that he'd
- 31:00been reported missing. So that gave me a lot
- 31:04of stuff to work with that basically gave me
- 31:05ammunition for more records requests immediately
- 31:08So in terms of what the what the research map
- 31:12actually looks like it's quite simple in this
- 31:14case It was literally a convo with my barber
- 31:18That let me find a couple results online a couple
- 31:21newspaper articles reddit posts and that sort
- 31:24of thing and then from there I found the NamUs
- 31:28entry. I found a few articles about the discovery
- 31:32of the remains. And I immediately, like within
- 31:35a couple of days, I'd sent that email to the
- 31:37police asking for more info, basically. And then
- 31:40what happened was, in the information that I
- 31:44got from the police, I then had more avenues
- 31:47to file more records requests. So I knew that
- 31:49he'd been arrested in Boston, and I immediately
- 31:51sent a records request to Boston, to the police
- 31:54department there. for that arrest because I knew
- 31:56the date and I knew the name of the guy who'd
- 32:01been arrested. And I could also file a records
- 32:04request for the missing persons report in the
- 32:07town where he was living in Quincy, which is
- 32:09just outside of Boston. Because it had mentioned
- 32:12this crime spree, I could then go to newspapers
- 32:14.com or whatever digitized newspaper archive
- 32:17you want to use. I happen to use newspapers .com.
- 32:20I'm not endorsed by them or anything, but I happen
- 32:23to use them And I started looking up newspaper
- 32:26articles about this spree of home invasions that
- 32:28was going on that the victim was allegedly associated
- 32:31with. And so the third stage of that was sort
- 32:35of, okay, I need to send out as many records
- 32:38requests as humanly possible to as many law enforcement
- 32:41agencies as possible, because some of them might
- 32:44decide to release records to me. And you'll see
- 32:47that the home invasions had happened in another
- 32:51state in New Hampshire. So I immediately sent
- 32:54records requests to all of the local police departments
- 32:56where there had been home invasions. And then
- 32:58I sent records requests to all of the Massachusetts
- 33:00towns where those had happened. And then sort
- 33:03of above that, I sent them to state agencies
- 33:06that were involved with the investigation, the
- 33:08Massachusetts State Police, the medical examiner,
- 33:11the New Hampshire State Police, and there was
- 33:14mention of the FBI as well. So I filed a FOIA
- 33:17with them. And check this out. What do you guys
- 33:22notice about this? You see a lot of rejections,
- 33:25right? A lot of my records requests for different
- 33:27reasons were rejected, denied, or they came back
- 33:31to me and said that they don't have any records
- 33:33anymore because it's been 30 years. And you'll
- 33:36notice that the ones that did reply to me that
- 33:39weren't rejected and where they wrote back to
- 33:41me and sent me, you know, sent me files, sent
- 33:43me PDFs or I went and I picked up paper copies,
- 33:45they were local law enforcement agencies. They
- 33:48were pretty much all Massachusetts and New Hampshire.
- 33:51local police departments. And I thought that
- 33:54was really interesting because in those records
- 33:58releases, they would have documents from like
- 34:00the FBI or from the state attorney general's
- 34:03office or from the local prosecutor. So I was
- 34:07able to kind of use records requests at the local
- 34:09level to unlock a little bit more than that.
- 34:12I noticed that they had a bit more discretion
- 34:14in what they decided to release. So yeah, that's
- 34:16basically what I was doing here. I was asking
- 34:19all the local police for records on the home
- 34:21invasions and for the murder itself and explaining
- 34:24I'm a journalist. I work at Bellingcat. I'm looking
- 34:27into a home invasion that happened on, you know,
- 34:31June 20th, 1996. Can you please give me the offense
- 34:34report for that? So tracking records requests.
- 34:38There's a couple ways to do this. I keep it simple.
- 34:40I use Muckrock. They're really awesome. They
- 34:42have an automatic way to track those. And then
- 34:45I also just use a simple Google Sheets tracker
- 34:49for ones that I send outside of Muckrock, if
- 34:52that makes sense. So you can kind of do what
- 34:54you want and see what works for you. But that's
- 34:56what works for me, at least. What to include
- 34:59in your requests. And really easy way to do this
- 35:02is just go to Muckrock. I want to know about
- 35:05a murder case from the 1990s. You can go in there
- 35:07and you can search for folks who have submitted
- 35:09records requests that have been completed. And
- 35:12you can look at those records requests and see
- 35:13how they worded them and use them as a template,
- 35:16essentially. You're not reinventing the wheel
- 35:17here, but you can see what they asked for. And
- 35:21in this case, you can see that they worked. So
- 35:24if you wanted an example of a records request
- 35:27on a murder case that has worked where the person
- 35:29has gotten some files. successfully, you could
- 35:32go in there and use examples from someone like
- 35:34that. So a couple other little tricks. You can
- 35:38ask for the, quote, public information portions.
- 35:41So what's going to happen is the law enforcement
- 35:44agencies by law, in a lot of cases, are going
- 35:47to have to redact sensitive information. So that
- 35:50usually will be suspect names, birth dates, social
- 35:53security numbers, sensitive information like
- 35:55that. But they will internally have discussions
- 35:58about, hey, what can we release here? What do
- 35:59we need to release by law? What can we release?
- 36:02That sort of thing. The end product is that they
- 36:06might end up releasing some material that they
- 36:09consider should be public, but that's not already
- 36:11online. Borrow from requests that have worked.
- 36:15So here's an example from the guy in Muckrock
- 36:17that ended up working. He had a nifty little
- 36:20list here of the types of records he was requesting
- 36:23from the police. So if you're looking into a
- 36:25similar case, you could sort of base your request
- 36:29off of this. Of course, there's going to be limits
- 36:31to this. In a lot of cases, your requests are
- 36:34just going to be outright denied. They'll tell
- 36:37you, look, this is an active and ongoing investigation
- 36:39and we're not going to release anything. That
- 36:41happens fairly commonly by law, U .S. federal
- 36:44agencies, for example, because of privacy laws.
- 36:49If you're submitting a FOIA to the FBI, for example,
- 36:52on another living person, That's going to be
- 36:54denied based on privacy laws that we have here.
- 36:57If the subject is deceased though, and you can
- 37:00prove it with a death certificate or obituary
- 37:02from a major newspaper or something like that,
- 37:04they might release files to you if the case isn't
- 37:07considered active and ongoing. So there's limits
- 37:10to it. I've had a lot of requests that are just
- 37:13denied where they just, they don't want to release
- 37:14anything. Actually, for the most recent case,
- 37:17the district attorney would not release any of
- 37:20their file to me, but the local police department
- 37:22would. So that's a little interesting. There's
- 37:24differences between some of the agencies. So
- 37:27this is my process on the latest story. This
- 37:30might look different for others, but I kept it
- 37:33pretty simple. I just started with basic open
- 37:35source research, like you do on anything, search
- 37:36engines, newspapers .com and NamUs. And then
- 37:40I had multiple rounds of FOIAs. And the ones
- 37:42that worked the best for me were the FOIAs with
- 37:44the lead investigating agency, which was the
- 37:46local police department investigating the murder.
- 37:49So my first FOIA with them. unlocked a lot of
- 37:52leads to work with. And then I actually went
- 37:53back to them when I had worked the story from
- 37:57every other possible angle. I went back to them
- 37:59and I asked for more records and they released
- 38:02more records to me. So those were the most valuable
- 38:06FOIAs in this story. But I did get some extra
- 38:10sort of contextual info, some more info on the
- 38:13gang and the crime spree from other police departments
- 38:15in other states. And then lastly, our billing
- 38:18cat stories, the final step is I'm writing that
- 38:21up into a story form. I'm working with my editors
- 38:23to make the necessary edits. And then we're seeking
- 38:26comment from the authorities. Hey, we're about
- 38:28to report X, Y, and Z. Do you have an official
- 38:30comment you'd like to make? So keep it simple.
- 38:33Do one step at a time. Like with other OSINT
- 38:35investigations, be methodical. Keep track of
- 38:38your findings and leave a trail of breadcrumbs
- 38:40for yourself so you know how you found everything.
- 38:45And I think most importantly, be patient. There's
- 38:48a reason. these cases are unsolved and that they're
- 38:52decades old. They are usually very complicated
- 38:55or there's not a lot out there. Um, and it takes
- 38:58time for the person processing your records request
- 39:00to actually work on it. A couple of lessons I
- 39:03learned in this. Um, I filed that first records
- 39:06request with the local police department, and
- 39:08then I spent like months and months filing other
- 39:10records requests with like every other supporting
- 39:13law enforcement agency remotely mentioned in
- 39:15those documents. Before I went back to the lead
- 39:19investigating agency and asked for more. And
- 39:21they decided to release a lot more to me. And
- 39:25I remember they actually told me, they were like,
- 39:27you know, you probably would have saved some
- 39:28time if you had just come back and asked us again
- 39:30earlier. And I'm like, yeah, you're right. And
- 39:34then behind your records request, just remember
- 39:36that there are real people working on these.
- 39:39I have found working in this story that the people
- 39:42responsible for dealing with records requests,
- 39:45and a lot of cases with the local police departments
- 39:47here in New England, really, like, cared about
- 39:51trying to release what they could. And they would
- 39:54call me or email me with questions and try to
- 39:56kind of work with me a little bit to determine,
- 39:58like, hey, we're not having any luck finding
- 40:01these records. Is maybe the date wrong? Like,
- 40:03I had a couple really awesome interactions like
- 40:05that where they actually worked with me to try
- 40:07to release as much as they could under the law.
- 40:10So just remember that. I think that helps. It's
- 40:12not just like a robot answering it. It's usually
- 40:14a person on the other end. So retired law enforcement,
- 40:18when you work in the media, retired law enforcement
- 40:19are sometimes willing to be interviewed. In the
- 40:23case of this story, I ended up being able to
- 40:26interview a retired detective who was really
- 40:28like the main investigator for the homicide case.
- 40:31And I could talk to him and ask him questions
- 40:35that were sort of... gaps in the murder file
- 40:37where I wasn't sure about something I could check
- 40:39it with him and he would sort of confirm or point
- 40:41me in a better direction. So that helped a lot.
- 40:44And if possible, go local. I've generally had
- 40:48much better luck getting useful records back
- 40:52from local law enforcement agencies than I have
- 40:54from federal and state here in the United States.
- 40:57So if you're interested in getting involved,
- 41:00these are just, in my opinion, some ways to maybe
- 41:04start that. So join a community, even if you're
- 41:07just there to lurk. You know, obviously I'm biased
- 41:09because I'm a Bellingcat and we're kind of all
- 41:11about that, but we have a Discord channel, for
- 41:14example, on using OSINT to look into cold cases.
- 41:16That's a good place to start. There's plenty
- 41:18of communities out there. Read, watch, listen,
- 41:22consume well -reported investigations and try
- 41:27to sift through the more sensational and stuff
- 41:29out there because I'm sure all of you are aware
- 41:31that there is a lot of true crime. It's a huge...
- 41:34huge space and there's a whole spectrum of people
- 41:38creating all kinds of content and doing all kinds
- 41:40of investigations of varying qualities and Ranging
- 41:44from people making accusations on tick -tock
- 41:46or something like that. So you need to be careful
- 41:48and I would look for People who do the types
- 41:52of investigations that that you're interested
- 41:54in and go from there. I Have only I've only worked
- 41:58on three Unsolved murder cases in two different
- 42:00stories. So I'm still learning a lot of this
- 42:03myself and I'm constantly Looking at my peers
- 42:06at other media outlets that focus on unsolved
- 42:09murders and I'm trying to like learn from them
- 42:10Like how are how are they filing foyers in a
- 42:13better way that I can learn from and I try to
- 42:15talk to them whenever possible and we kind of
- 42:17share share our experiences and stuff and that
- 42:20that helps and I've learned a lot that way and
- 42:22lastly, I would just say try to look for under
- 42:24reported cases that need attention because there
- 42:26are just tons of them out there. They are not
- 42:28hard to find. They're just sitting out there
- 42:31online in databases. And these research projects
- 42:35are marathons. They are not sprints. I am always
- 42:39working on other investigations for Bell and
- 42:41Cat while I'm doing these. So yeah, this is not
- 42:46comprehensive. These are a lot of the sources
- 42:49that I tend to rely on. So online newspaper articles
- 42:53are huge because a lot of the information on
- 42:56cases from like the 60s, 70s, 80s, even the 90s
- 43:00isn't really online outside of digitized newspapers.
- 43:04And a lot of reporters for those newspapers did
- 43:06really awesome, sometimes very in -depth articles
- 43:11early on about some of these cases. So pretty
- 43:14much everyone I've worked on, there's been an
- 43:16in -depth piece about sort of the initial murder
- 43:18or the initial discovery of the remains. and
- 43:20then you'll find that they sort of trail off
- 43:22and that's why they're cold, right? So those
- 43:24are very important newspapers. Genealogy Services,
- 43:27Ancestry .com, there's others out there, but
- 43:31you can find useful materials like a death certificate
- 43:34sometimes for the victim that might help you
- 43:37with your records requests. Social media, I look
- 43:41at cases that are pre -social media, so this
- 43:43is less relevant for the past couple that I've
- 43:45worked with at least, but they might be useful
- 43:47if you're looking at... had cases from, I don't
- 43:49know, the early 2000s or the 2010s or something
- 43:52like that. And last, but certainly not least,
- 43:56eFOYAs. Filing FOYAs electronically online are
- 43:59super important and there's so many good resources.
- 44:01Muckrock being like the key, in my opinion, at
- 44:04least for US research. More resources out there
- 44:08to find cases in your local area, but I would
- 44:10turn to your national databases first, wherever
- 44:12you live. There's these other ones. Charlie Project
- 44:15is really great. The DNA Do network. You can
- 44:18find cases all over the place. There's also some
- 44:21kind of crowdsourcing platforms that are newer.
- 44:24There's one called Solve the Case that I like
- 44:26in the U .S. where it doesn't have a lot of cases
- 44:29in it yet because it started in the past like
- 44:31two years. But there's a map where you can search
- 44:34for cases that have been put in there either
- 44:37by researchers or by law enforcement or by victims'
- 44:39families. And they'll have photos of the victim
- 44:42and kind of an account of the investigation and
- 44:44whatnot to get started. your library even, I
- 44:48ended up asking some reference librarians questions
- 44:50on how to do like some of the pre -internet research
- 44:53that I needed to do and that was really helpful
- 44:55and it was kind of fun to like go to a local
- 44:58library and like talk to a human person in person
- 45:00and learn some of that old school research. And
- 45:04lastly, if you guys have any questions, you have
- 45:07my Discord username here. You can send me a DM
- 45:11on here. I'm also on bluesguy there. And just
- 45:16keep in mind that there are so many of these
- 45:19cases that you could be the only person that's
- 45:21really interested in finding anything about it.
- 45:23It might be a case from the 60s where there's
- 45:25no living family left and this person's remains
- 45:28are sitting in a box somewhere unidentified.
- 45:30So I think it's a really cool area that can benefit
- 45:32from open source research. And I would encourage
- 45:35folks who are interested in it to learn about
- 45:38it. Yeah. Thank you, Peter. Thank you. That was,
- 45:41I think someone put in the comments earlier.
- 45:43What an amazing talk that was. So much information
- 45:47and so many helpful tips and tricks. I can absolutely
- 45:51second the need to call some of these offices
- 45:56and how charm can take you a long, long way in
- 46:00terms of getting a response. Peter has that in
- 46:04a lot of charms. Yeah, I didn't talk about that,
- 46:08I guess. I kind of skipped it over, but that
- 46:10ended up being... Very useful as if possible
- 46:14if you can talk to a human person looking at
- 46:16your requests on the phone And they can tell
- 46:20that you know, you're Like a researcher doing
- 46:24just trying to just trying to figure out information
- 46:26about this And again in this case, I'll just
- 46:29I can only speak to the experience that I've
- 46:31had so far in this case It was something that
- 46:34they all all of the current police that that
- 46:38I dealt with all remembered this case because
- 46:40they were working at the time that this skeleton
- 46:42was found, but none of them had remembered any
- 46:44kind of resolution with it. And they had had
- 46:47to move on to other murder cases and other crimes
- 46:49to investigate. And so they were willing to work
- 46:53with me to try to tell as much of this story
- 46:56as possible and to release as many of the records
- 46:59as they could under the law. So it was having
- 47:05the sort of exchanges with them, like over the
- 47:07phone. Was was useful and it was it I think it
- 47:11it can help out more than just like doing it
- 47:14over email But you have to decide that for yourself
- 47:17as well. I mean you have to decide how involved
- 47:19you want to be so Absolutely, and as we've only
- 47:22got like 10 minutes left, perhaps we can go five
- 47:25minutes over just because we have so many questions
- 47:27Just on that point. We had a question earlier
- 47:31from somebody in the audience who's asking when
- 47:34they ask for credentials, what are some ways
- 47:36we can respond? Obviously they should be replying
- 47:39to your freedom of information requests anyway,
- 47:42because it is a legal right that you have to
- 47:45ask these kinds of questions. But if you are
- 47:48doing those kinds of personal reach outs, for
- 47:52example, for interviews and you don't have Bellingcat
- 47:54backing you, what are ways to kind of... perhaps
- 47:58convince people that you aren't looking for a
- 48:01sensational murder podcast, for example, and
- 48:04you're actually trying to help further the case?
- 48:07That's a really, that's a really, really good
- 48:09question. And it's different for interviews than
- 48:11with records requests. Again, I can only speak
- 48:14to my experience. And in the US, when I'm filing
- 48:19the records requests themselves, I don't have
- 48:21to prove that I'm anybody. I usually say that
- 48:24I'm a researcher with Bellingcat. and they'll
- 48:29see my email signature or whatever. But I don't
- 48:32have to provide them like a press card or something
- 48:35like that to prove my credentials. So for the
- 48:38records requests themselves, that's different.
- 48:40For interviews, it's really tricky because I
- 48:43have an enormous amount of difficulty even working
- 48:46for Bellingcat, getting people to agree to speak
- 48:49with me. In fact, I'd say 90 percent of the time
- 48:51when you reach out to someone to speak with them,
- 48:54retired, law enforcement a lot of the time, just
- 48:57they're not interested in speaking to the media
- 48:59at all, let alone someone just a random Joe's
- 49:04Moe who wants to know about an old case that
- 49:06they worked on. So it's a good question. I don't
- 49:09really have an answer for the interview part.
- 49:12I try to interview anybody who will speak to
- 49:14me that I can identify. And I try to give them
- 49:18an opportunity to speak if they're going to be
- 49:21mentioned in the story, especially. But in most
- 49:24cases, people actually don't really, they have
- 49:27no interest in revisiting it. So it depends.
- 49:29I lucked out though, I was able to find a retired
- 49:33detective who decided like, you know what, I
- 49:35remember this case and it's ridiculous that it's
- 49:37still unsolved and he's still unidentified. That's
- 49:41the best I can answer. I think there's a lot
- 49:43of people out there who are a lot more skilled
- 49:45than me at getting people to talk on the record
- 49:47and get interviewed. Yeah. I would maybe suggest
- 49:50if you're thinking about interviewing individuals
- 49:53involved in cases, One, make sure that they are
- 49:56from the get -go. They're aware of what's going
- 49:58to happen to their voice in terms of where you're
- 50:00going to put it and what the outcome or the output
- 50:04is going to look like. And two, maybe listening
- 50:06and looking for resources on how to deal with
- 50:09sensitive sources would be a useful place to
- 50:13look for advice. We've had a previous talk on
- 50:16that. You can find it on our RSS feed or on any
- 50:19podcast platform under stage towards the villain
- 50:21cat. But there's also loads of resources online
- 50:24for journalists and researchers on how to talk
- 50:27to people who perhaps have gone through a traumatic
- 50:30event. Because again, all of the cases that we're
- 50:32talking about here are traumatic events, even
- 50:35if you're a detective. Some of these murder cases,
- 50:37for example, particularly unsolved ones, may
- 50:40still be in the back of your mind as something
- 50:42that's niggling away. Moving on very, very quickly,
- 50:45because of time, I was going to ask you about
- 50:48whether having A first response to an FOIA was
- 50:53useful to then file others, but in your case,
- 50:56it absolutely was. Do you think if you hadn't
- 51:00got that initial response with so much detail
- 51:03in it, that you would have been able to map out
- 51:06the bureaucratic maze of agencies and where you
- 51:11should have FOI'd in the first place? Or do you
- 51:13think it's quite difficult to find that out when
- 51:15you're starting afresh? For example, how do you
- 51:18know which local authority to message first?
- 51:23How do you go about that process? And then somebody
- 51:25else has asked that's linked to that. It sounds
- 51:28like local is more responsive than larger jurisdictions.
- 51:31Are there other attributes common to organizations
- 51:34that are more responsive to requests? Yeah, those
- 51:37are both very, very good questions. So for one,
- 51:41with the first records request, in short, I would
- 51:44not have been able to do the research that I
- 51:46did on this story had they not given me that
- 51:48initial summary that identified other jurisdictions
- 51:54where I could then ask for more records. And
- 51:58essentially my initial request got me a name
- 52:00and two more agencies to file records requests
- 52:04with and material to be searching for in historic
- 52:06newspapers. So it opened up the whole can of
- 52:08worms. That's not always going to happen. I lucked
- 52:11out here again. So that would be my answer to
- 52:15that is you're looking for opportunities to widen
- 52:19your research window. And sometimes FOIAs can
- 52:22do that for you, but that's not always the case.
- 52:25To the second question about, are there other
- 52:28attributes with agencies that are more willing
- 52:30to be responsive to records requests? It's tricky.
- 52:36In the US right now, at the federal level, we've
- 52:39had enormous changes to our freedom of information
- 52:42offices across federal agencies. And I've heard
- 52:46from colleagues at other places that they have
- 52:48a lot more trouble and they face more significant
- 52:51delays in getting records at the federal level
- 52:53now. And I know a lot of my peers are turning
- 52:59to more local government offices when they're
- 53:02able to. So I think the biggest difference for
- 53:06me at the local level was that usually it would
- 53:09be a person who is assigned to be like the records
- 53:12access officer as like a side duty to their main
- 53:14job. It might be a police officer. It could be
- 53:17like an admin assistant in the office. And usually
- 53:20when it was like a single person who was writing,
- 53:25who was responding to me or calling me, that
- 53:27was when it became a little bit more productive
- 53:31is because we could kind of work together to
- 53:34first find these records because they're so old
- 53:36that a lot of times they're kept in like a separate
- 53:38storage location. So sometimes the issue is just
- 53:42that these are old paper files that are misplaced
- 53:44or lost. And it's just a matter of like finding
- 53:46them. I wish I had a more comprehensive answer
- 53:48and like what else makes it easier, but I think
- 53:50being detailed and concise and using other records
- 53:54requests that have worked for others, I think
- 53:56using those as a template is a good place to
- 53:58start. Yes, I also put in the chat, sometimes
- 54:01it's also okay to just ring up and ask who is
- 54:04the right authority for this. I have done that
- 54:07on a few occasions and they've actually thanked
- 54:10me for doing it before filing because it saves
- 54:12you time and it saves them time. We had a question
- 54:15earlier from Delta who said, what do you suggest
- 54:18someone who is investigating cold cases do if
- 54:20their home country does not have FOIA capability?
- 54:26Which is the case in some countries. And also
- 54:29what is the general legality for digging into
- 54:31these cases? For example, if there isn't freedom
- 54:34of information requests at your disposal. Yeah,
- 54:37in short, I have personally never worked on trying
- 54:41to work on a case in a country without any FOI
- 54:44laws. So I'm very curious about that too. I wish
- 54:47I had some answers. I would like to learn them
- 54:49myself. I think in some of those countries that
- 54:53are like that, I would also assume there might
- 54:54be very significant risks in doing that, even
- 55:00more risks than in other places in doing that
- 55:03type of work. You know, I don't want to, that's
- 55:07a whole separate subject is like, like you're
- 55:09like conducting your risk assessment on how safe
- 55:11is it for me to do this type of investigation?
- 55:14That's like, we could give a whole other talk
- 55:15on, on that. And I think we've had talks on like
- 55:18personal safety and security when doing OSINT,
- 55:21but that's a great question. I've never tried
- 55:25it in a country that doesn't have FOI laws. I
- 55:27think you do have to be relying a lot more on
- 55:30previous, you know, previous media coverage,
- 55:33older newspapers. talking to other researchers
- 55:39who've worked on it or to retired investigators
- 55:42or to members of the community wherever you are.
- 55:46That's what I would do. My first stop would be
- 55:48members of other researchers who investigate
- 55:52this type of crime in that country and learning
- 55:54from them. Charlie, what was the second part
- 55:56of the question? Sorry. It was about the legality,
- 55:59but I think you've answered it. Yeah, thanks
- 56:03so much. Yeah. I mean, with all Bellingcat stories,
- 56:08like the legality part, we have the benefit of
- 56:11working for a newsroom with an editorial team.
- 56:14We go through legal review on our articles and
- 56:17stuff like that. So if you're an independent
- 56:18researcher, that looks a lot different. But I
- 56:23would say on a positive note with that, when
- 56:25you're asking authorities or government offices
- 56:28to release information to you, you're asking
- 56:30them to make certain information public so they
- 56:32have those discussions internally. And that happened
- 56:35in this case where the police had to go to a
- 56:38town attorney and determine, this happened actually
- 56:40multiple times, and the town attorneys would
- 56:43go through and redact sensitive information or
- 56:45tell them, hey, you can release this, you can't
- 56:48release that. So you're asking them to make those
- 56:51decisions for you in some cases. And we had a
- 56:54question earlier about complaints as well, like
- 56:56if you have to then take it Further, for example,
- 57:00if they reject it, but you feel like they shouldn't.
- 57:02And just as a quick note on that, most countries
- 57:06that have FOI systems also have a place for you
- 57:10to report if you feel like your request has not
- 57:14been met, your legal right has not been met.
- 57:18For example, in the UK, we have like the information
- 57:20commissioner. I think you have a similar system
- 57:23in the US and it's usually you have to wait a
- 57:26certain amount of time. And then you can kind
- 57:29of complain to the authority and see if they
- 57:33will rectify that. And then you can push it to
- 57:36the information commissioner or the similar legal
- 57:40authority that exists in your country. And that's
- 57:42quite a quick Google and you can find more information
- 57:44about that. We've had a few questions actually
- 57:49about your safety when working on organised crime,
- 57:53cold cases particularly. I know we just covered
- 57:55that slightly, but I wonder if you could just
- 57:58reassure people that you are safe working on
- 58:02cold cases of criminal organised networks. And
- 58:06it is due to the fact that you have some experience
- 58:10in this, right? Yeah, there's there's a that's
- 58:13a there's a lot to that question and and a lot
- 58:16to try to cover in a short amount of time So
- 58:19at a very high level and not gonna be able to
- 58:23answer this completely in a short window But
- 58:25at a very high level in a lot of ways doing this
- 58:28type of story You I'm taking the same precautions
- 58:32that I would with other organized crime stories
- 58:34that I'm doing a Bellingcat and a big part of
- 58:37that is the sort of like With it with the online
- 58:41portions of it. It's it's not leaving a trace
- 58:44I think a big part of cold case investigations
- 58:47though is the concept that the killer the killers
- 58:52the accomplices the suspects in it are Theoretically
- 58:56still out there if they're still alive, right?
- 58:59That's definitely a serious consideration with
- 59:02this case I'll speak to like this case for example
- 59:07It was a big reason, I mean, it was one of many
- 59:10reasons why the law enforcement records I got,
- 59:14the suspect names were redacted because they
- 59:18had internal discussions about what they considered
- 59:21safe to release to the media and what wasn't.
- 59:23And that was a big one. They redacted the suspect's
- 59:26names. Personal safety steps, I mean, a lot of
- 59:30standard stuff, you know, using VPNs. I think
- 59:33a big one for me is having a big network of people
- 59:35that I'm talking to at any given time. I'm talking
- 59:38to current and retired law enforcement. I'm talking
- 59:41to colleagues that do this type of work. We have
- 59:45our own safety and security officer at Bellingcat
- 59:48that I can go to with any sort of, you know,
- 59:51if there's any sort of threat or risk or I'm
- 59:54worried about anything in particular. But let
- 59:58me be very, very clear about something too. And
- 1:00:00I tried to say this at the beginning. Like, we're
- 1:00:02talking about open source investigations into
- 1:00:05these cases, right? I am asking the government
- 1:00:07for information that, under the law, that they're
- 1:00:11willing to release. And I'm looking at historic
- 1:00:16newspaper reporting. I am not meeting with the
- 1:00:19suspects or interacting with them in any way
- 1:00:22whatsoever. So it's a passive form of research,
- 1:00:27like a fly in the wall way. The most active thing
- 1:00:29I'm doing is is asking for records from law enforcement
- 1:00:33and trying to interview like retired law enforcement
- 1:00:37or a journalist that wrote a story on this or
- 1:00:41a victim of one of the home invasions. So that's
- 1:00:46a short answer and it's not comprehensive. There's
- 1:00:49other steps. It just depends on the investigation
- 1:00:52you're working on too. I wish I could be more
- 1:00:55detailed, guys, but I'm trying to save time for
- 1:00:57other questions. We've already had requests for
- 1:01:01a separate session focusing on exactly what you
- 1:01:04just spoke about. So perhaps we'll pursue that
- 1:01:07as well. Yeah, as you said, it is basically you
- 1:01:12are investigating the historical record of that
- 1:01:15case, not investigating the criminal case itself.
- 1:01:18And I think that's the distinct shot between
- 1:01:22the two. You're looking at what was previously
- 1:01:25collected and understanding kind of the missing
- 1:01:28information from the public sphere. Exactly.
- 1:01:31You're collecting and organizing information
- 1:01:33that's either already out there or that's sitting
- 1:01:35on a shelf that the authorities decide should
- 1:01:39be out there. So I think that's a really important
- 1:01:42distinction and we should be very clear about
- 1:01:44that. You're not out there as a vigilante trying
- 1:01:47to chase down suspects and stuff like that. Yes,
- 1:01:50absolutely. And you need to make sure that it's
- 1:01:52very clear that you're not law enforcement as
- 1:01:55well when you are working on these kinds of things.
- 1:01:58Quick last questions because we are way over
- 1:02:00time. Sky asked earlier, was there a relationship
- 1:02:03between the size of the police department and
- 1:02:05willingness to work with you? New Hampshire will
- 1:02:07tend to have smaller towns and departments. I
- 1:02:08thought it was interesting how willing they were
- 1:02:10to help you. My colleagues in Los Angeles really
- 1:02:13struggle with FOIA requests to LAPD. Yeah, that's
- 1:02:17not super surprising. I had the same experience
- 1:02:19here in Boston. I had a lot of trouble. getting
- 1:02:23anything from the Boston Police Department. And
- 1:02:26talking to peers here in New England, that's
- 1:02:28a common experience. The smaller New Hampshire
- 1:02:30departments are very responsive. They have an
- 1:02:33interesting caveat in their law, which is that
- 1:02:36in some cases, I had to drive up there and pick
- 1:02:39up the copies in person, which was fun because
- 1:02:41then I had to go scan them. But more often than
- 1:02:44not, those are the departments where I was working
- 1:02:46with an individual person who Told me what their
- 1:02:51name was and I had an email address or they called
- 1:02:53me and I was working with that person to try
- 1:02:54To like locate the records and then they would
- 1:02:57respond to me and be like, hey, we're working
- 1:02:58on redacting them We'll probably have them in
- 1:02:59like two or three weeks. That was my experience
- 1:03:02in New Hampshire. I've got to say it was actually
- 1:03:04pretty pretty great Massachusetts it really varied
- 1:03:07place to place but I had an enormous amount of
- 1:03:10Difficulty getting records from the Boston police
- 1:03:12I was able to get an arrest report from them
- 1:03:15or the victim because he'd been caught with some
- 1:03:17stolen credit cards That was that was the only
- 1:03:19That was the only information from the Boston
- 1:03:21Police Department I got. Okay, final, final,
- 1:03:25final thing. Guys, I wish I could get to all
- 1:03:27of these. There's some awesome comments and questions
- 1:03:29in here. So many. Feel free to DM me too. Okay,
- 1:03:34final, final thing, and then we will wrap. In
- 1:03:36regards to... when you're collecting information,
- 1:03:40is there any key information about a case that
- 1:03:42would be useful to keep when you are referencing
- 1:03:45it in FOI requests, for example, the arrest number,
- 1:03:49things like that. So anything that's super, super
- 1:03:51important details that people might want to know
- 1:03:54to keep a note of once they collect it from one
- 1:03:57agency to then request from another. Yes, great
- 1:04:01question. Name of either the victim, Yeah, name
- 1:04:07of like the victim. If you're looking into a
- 1:04:09missing persons case, a murder case or something
- 1:04:11like that, obviously the name, you want the date
- 1:04:13of the offense if it's available. If you don't
- 1:04:16have an exact date, you can give them a window,
- 1:04:18but the shorter that window is, the more likelihood
- 1:04:21they'll be willing to look for you. So yeah,
- 1:04:24date range, victim name. I've had trouble in
- 1:04:27a couple cases. Actually, Boston used this as
- 1:04:30a way to not get me something, in my opinion,
- 1:04:33which is I didn't have an address for where something
- 1:04:36had happened. And even though I feel like they
- 1:04:41should have been able to find what I was looking
- 1:04:42for without the street address, they said that
- 1:04:45without one, they couldn't. So address, state
- 1:04:48range, name. If you have, sometimes like with
- 1:04:52the district attorneys, they would ask for like
- 1:04:55a case number. So I think with the New Hampshire
- 1:04:57State Police actually, one of the local police
- 1:05:00departments wrote to me and said, hey, by the
- 1:05:02way, The state police have more records on this.
- 1:05:04Here's the case number. You should give that
- 1:05:05to them. So they helped me out a little bit with
- 1:05:08that. Amazing. And yeah, it brings us back to
- 1:05:12the whole, if you get to know the people behind
- 1:05:15the emails, it's always awesome. Oh, and Frogman
- 1:05:18said the main law enforcement officer involved
- 1:05:20is a good one, too. Yeah. If you have the names
- 1:05:23of any investigators, the main ones especially,
- 1:05:28that can definitely help. Yeah. Amazing. You
- 1:05:30must be very charming. I'm not. All right. We
- 1:05:36should wrap because we are seven minutes over.
- 1:05:39Thank you so much, Peter, for today. And for
- 1:05:42all of this information, this recording will
- 1:05:44be put on podcast platforms in the next few days
- 1:05:47and possibly some of the slides that you've seen
- 1:05:50today as well. Definitely all of the links mentioned.
- 1:05:54And we'll be back in two weeks time with another
- 1:05:57stage talk. But for now, go read Peter's stories.
- 1:06:01And yeah, thank you so much again. Thank you
- 1:06:04guys. Thanks for the comment. Thanks, guys. I
- 1:06:06really appreciate it. Thank you for listening
- 1:06:09to the stage talk. If you'd like to catch a stage
- 1:06:12talk live where you can ask the guest questions,
- 1:06:16join the Bellingcat Discord server by visiting
- 1:06:19www .discord .gg slash Bellingcat. The music
- 1:06:25you've heard is titled Dawn by Newer Self and
- 1:06:28is courtesy of Artlist.