Latest / Retail Fast Five / DoorDash Bags Instacart, Caper Carts Check Out & Starbucks Brews a Comeback | Fast Five
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, I am Chris Watman.
- 0:01Welcome to this week's Omnitalk Retail Fast 5, which is brought to you by the Omnitalk retail podcast network.
- 0:06Some weeks the news trickles in, but this week it came in by the truckload.
- 0:11Or should I say by the dasher.
- 0:14This week's guest host from the A and M consumer and retail group, Kelly Carey and I discussed everything from DoorDash's $17 billion Instacart grab to whether we've all been sleeping on Amazon's retail business.
- 0:25This is the Omnitalk Retail Fast 5.
- 0:29Grocery delivery is alive.
- 0:31And.
- 0:31For every type of purchase they get, that means there's a local grocer who isn't getting that purchase.
- 0:36What are they actually doing to get people back in the store?
- 0:40You gotta invest in making your store run smarter.
- 0:44First.
- 0:45Big statement here.
- 0:46I think this is the end of the smart cart.
- 0:48I think if you're a smart grocer, you're like, oh my God, I gotta get in front of this.
- 0:51I can't let a third party necessarily run my platform.
- 0:55I think QSRs in general are seeing slower traffic right now as people are being more price conscious.
- 1:00Trader Joe's, really?
- 1:02Why, Kelly Carey, always a pleasure.
- 1:07How are you keeping this morning?
- 1:09Hey, Chris.
- 1:10Doing well, how are you?
- 1:11I'm doing great, man.
- 1:12This is, this is the.
- 1:13We were talking before we got started this.
- 1:15We've been working with the A and M consumer and retail group, I think for five or six years, give or take.
- 1:20And this is the first time in history, in history of the Omni Talk Retail Fast Five, that we've had one guest host from the A M consumer and retail group.
- 1:29So.
- 1:30So, Kelly, I think first of all, that shows the esteem that your colleagues must have for you, does it not?
- 1:34I guess.
- 1:35I guess so, yeah.
- 1:37This is our first time having someone solo on a fast five.
- 1:41So we've done some five minute bits, but you know, they've sent me here 45 minutes with you.
- 1:47I hope I serve them well.
- 1:49Or, or, or they just want.
- 1:50Or they just secure the biggest glutton for punishment in the entire organization, willing to stand in here and go and go toe to toe as we debate the topics from the past week.
- 1:59But man, there's some good headlines this week.
- 2:01I'm really excited to get to them.
- 2:02Especially the door dash one.
- 2:03I mean, the door dash and instacart thing is big, big news.
- 2:06Which we'll get to right that.
- 2:07But, but Kelly, for those new to the show, maybe, because we do get a lot of first time listeners as well give give some background on what it is.
- 2:15What's the 411 on the A&M CRG.
- 2:19So Kelly Carey was senior director with Alvarez and Marcel's consumer and retail group.
- 2:23So our group's been around for about six, seven years now.
- 2:27And what we really do is aim to bring operator experience, expertise paired with kind of that consulting magic to consumer and retail clients.
- 2:39So, you know, this is really the perfect partnership with you, Chris, to talk about what's going on in the industry.
- 2:46But whether you are looking to address operational challenges, whether you're thinking about the next frontier of growth, we really kind of serve consumer and retailers end to end and whatever their unique problem sets are.
- 2:59So really love to talk to people who are interested in learning more about us.
- 3:04Can talk a little bit more about that at the end.
- 3:07Yeah.
- 3:07And tell us about yourself too, Kelly, before we get going.
- 3:10So I have been with the consumer Retail Group since its origin story original.
- 3:16Yes.
- 3:18So I've been working with the team for about seven years.
- 3:21I personally have worked across the the industry, spent a lot of my time in beauty, food and beverage and I do a lot of work on kind of the end to end planning, operating model and growth space.
- 3:34So excited about the headlines today.
- 3:38We're going to touch on some of those industries.
- 3:40Right?
- 3:40Right.
- 3:41Yeah, we're gonna get a wide swath of things today.
- 3:43You know, it's funny when just before we get started I was telling Ella producer Ella, who many of you listeners know before we got started that, you know, today we're going to do the solo A and M show.
- 3:53And she's like, who's it going to be?
- 3:54And I was like, kelly, Carrie?
- 3:56And she's like, oh, awesome.
- 3:57I love her.
- 3:57She's great.
- 3:58She's so fun.
- 3:59So we're gonna have a blast.
- 4:01So let's get right to it on this week's Fast 5, which is of course brought to you with the help and support of the A and M consumer and retail group Miracle Corso, Ocampo Capital Manhattan and Smart Scout
- 4:12in this week's Fast 5.
- 4:13Kelly, we've got news on Instacart pulling the plug on its caper smart cart business.
- 4:19Starbucks posting a 7.7% US comp as back to Starbucks keeps on brewing.
- 4:25Walmart plus heading south of the border with a big launch in Mexico and Andy Jassy telling Wall street it's sleeping on Amazon's retail business.
- 4:34But we begin today as I alluded to at the outset, with DoorDash agreeing to buy Instacart for $17 billion.
- 4:42Headline number one is of course brought to you with the help and support of our friends at the A and M Consumer and Retail Group.
- 4:47The A and M Consumer and Retail Group is a management consulting firm that tackles the most complex challenges and advances its clients, people and communities toward their maximum potential.
- 4:56CRG brings the experienced tools and operator like pragmatism to help retailers and consumer products companies be on the right side of disruption.
- 5:02All right, Kelly, here it is.
- 5:04Headline number one.
- 5:05It's a big one.
- 5:06DoorDash has agreed to acquire Instacart for $65 a share in equity value of roughly $17 billion, combining the country's biggest restaurant delivery app with its biggest grocery delivery platform.
- 5:19According to DoorDash's announcement on October 29, the $65 price per share price is a 26% premium to Instacart's October 22 close, the last trading day before deal reports surfaced.
- 5:32At least 75% of the consideration will be cash backed by up to a $13 billion J.P.
- 5:39morgan Bridge loan.
- 5:40And don't hold your breath on closing either.
- 5:43The deal isn't expected to close until the end of 2027 or even into the first half of 2028, pending antitrust review plus approvals in both Canada and Israel.
- 5:55Kelly, I can't wait to talk about this.
- 5:57What do you think of DoorDash acquiring Instacart?
- 6:00Number one.
- 6:00And number two, what are the different scenarios you envision playing out between now and the possible possible closing date?
- 6:07To start off with your first question, I think this is a great idea on DoorDash's part.
- 6:14You know, they on their own, independently have for many, you know, I think years now, been trying to get into the grocery space.
- 6:21I would say they're there.
- 6:23It's not something they're trying to do anymore.
- 6:26But to fully take advantage of that, get all the partnerships, all the retailers on board, that's a lot of effort.
- 6:33So to bring in Instacart, I think, can one help them with their own app grocery expansion, getting more partners on board and getting more kind of data in the way that instacart has really kind of created this data
- 6:47ecosystem with those partners.
- 6:49But also I do think, and I would imagine the DoorDash team thinks this as well, that there's a really different audience on these two apps.
- 7:00I.
- 7:00Think the person who's going to get groceries on DoorDash is very likely a different shopper than who's on Instacart.
- 7:06DoorDash has that, like, I need it now.
- 7:09Oh, I forgot something.
- 7:11Small cart.
- 7:12Whereas Instacart, you have more of this routine shopper who's doing their, their big batches, their weekly shopping.
- 7:18So I think it really opens not only the capability suite for them in grocery, but also is likely increasing the consumers that they're getting access to.
- 7:30So I think it's a great idea for those two reasons.
- 7:33Yeah, right.
- 7:34Okay, so you, you brought up some good points I hadn't thought about too.
- 7:36Like, you know, the, the one thing that's interesting in what you described too is, you know, DoorDash is essentially buying Instacart's media capabilities too, you know, where.
- 7:44Yeah,.
- 7:44I would say Instacart is probably better equipped at handling the retail media side of the business than DoorDash.
- 7:50So they're getting that as well, which is something I hadn't really fully thought of until you just articulated what you said and then.
- 7:56Yeah, I think you're right, Kelly.
- 7:57Like it, it essentially is two different use cases for the average consumer out there.
- 8:02Like, they're probably going to both.
- 8:05And so there probably is a nice synergy if you can round that into the DoorDash, the, into the DoorDash offering as well.
- 8:12How do you think.
- 8:12How do you think, if at all?
- 8:14Kelly, I'm curious before I give you my thoughts, because I'm going to get kind of Machiavellian on this one.
- 8:20How do you think, how do you think about the Instacart like side of the business that it does outside the consumer facing things like running the websites for grocers, running the pick and pick and pack for grocers, the
- 8:33delivery for grocers, all the white label services that they do for them.
- 8:36How do you think that factors into Door Dash's plans here and how do you think DoorDash is thinking about that?
- 8:40I would hope that they are thinking about it just in terms that that is a very different side of the business than they're used to today.
- 8:47So that's going to be challenging, I think, to take on and just start to operate in that ecosystem.
- 8:55But the benefits that it will have for them, I think are significant.
- 8:59They're going to get access to all of that kind of platform information and be able to deploy that into even more targeted work on their own platform, but then also on the Instacart app.
- 9:11But I think that will be like a big operating model challenge.
- 9:15And, you know, how do they actually want to.
- 9:16Run.
- 9:16This?
- 9:16They'll be curious to see what that looks like down the Road.
- 9:21But they have said in the article that they plan to continue operating the two banners at the moment.
- 9:28Not kind of combining it on your DoorDash, which, again, I think is smart.
- 9:31I think you have truly different consumers on the apps in terms of how they shop.
- 9:37But also, even, like, I personally didn't have Instacart until yesterday when I was thinking about this headline.
- 9:43So I think totally different populations, even on the apps so benefit there.
- 9:49I'd be curious, that side of the business specifically, does that fold under DoorDash, or do they also continue to operate that as Instacart?
- 9:58Right, right.
- 9:59And with the closing, with the length of closing, you know, there's a lot of time to learn that.
- 10:03And to your point, I think that's a really good point too.
- 10:05It gives.
- 10:05Gives DoorDash the chance to kind of learn the muscle memory required for that side of the business as well, which I imagine it has some experience with to a degree, although it's not publicly talked about nearly as much
- 10:16as Instacarts is.
- 10:17All right, so I want to get a little Machiavellian on this one, too.
- 10:20Kelly.
- 10:21Yeah,.
- 10:21I want to ask the question, like, how much do you think DoorDash really care if this deal goes through?
- 10:26So I start thinking.
- 10:27Like,.
- 10:28Like, what is the cost to DoorDash if it doesn't go through?
- 10:31Because the mere fact that the deal is happening, in my opinion, devalues Instacart in the long term.
- 10:39You know, grocers, grocers, you know what they're seeing.
- 10:41This deal, they're going to be like, okay, to, to the question, to the, to the.
- 10:44The conversation we're just having.
- 10:46I think if you're a smart grocer, you're like, oh, my God, I got to get in front of this.
- 10:49I can't let a third party necessarily run my platform like this because it's getting the first party data relationship of my customer.
- 10:56I've got to get a hold of that.
- 10:58So some, some grocers are going to start pulling out, if they haven't already, which is going to cause further devaluation for Instacart.
- 11:05And if the regulatory agencies also back it from happening, or, sorry, block it from happening.
- 11:11Not back it, block it from happening, Kelly.
- 11:13Like, DoorDash is stronger as a net result of that, too, over time.
- 11:19So basically, it's a call option somewhere between like 0 and $17 billion to kill your competition in a lot of ways.
- 11:26So, like, I think it's a shrewd move.
- 11:28Like, they know what they're mo at most gonna pay.
- 11:31And it could become a lot less than that over time.
- 11:34Of course, it depends on the stipulations contractually, if you know, who pulls out or what happens if it gets regulatory blocked or whatever.
- 11:40But, like, I'm getting kind of Machiavellian on this one.
- 11:43And I'm curious, Kelly, like, do you think.
- 11:45Do you think I'm at all sniffing in the right direction on it?
- 11:47I think you could be.
- 11:49That was just another reaction to me.
- 11:51Mine to the headline is this is a bit of a.
- 11:54An ultimate chess move.
- 11:56They're making the first move on the board, and it's a pretty big one because another player in the mix here is Uber.
- 12:04Yeah.
- 12:04Right.
- 12:04So back in 2024, Uber and Instacart entered a strategic partnership.
- 12:09When I did now open my new Instacart app yesterday, it literally pops up, you know, powered by Uber.
- 12:16So they are still kind of operating on that Uber ecosystem, is my understanding.
- 12:21So.
- 12:21So kind of knocks out some Instacart cart competition.
- 12:25It would be a huge hit to Uber as well.
- 12:29Who's kind of competing in this on the go food space.
- 12:33So, yeah, I mean, even if they're not getting all those benefits I talked about, which I think are real benefits, they're forcing some major shifts in this market and creating disruption that I think is going to net benefit
- 12:48them.
- 12:49Right?
- 12:49Yeah.
- 12:49And DoorDash, as we've talked about on this show many times with, with others, DoorDash is one of the shrewdest retail operators out there.
- 12:57You know, and I.
- 12:58The other thing too, about DoorDash, like, they are thinking like.
- 13:01Like a bona fide retailer right now.
- 13:03I mean, they're.
- 13:04They're going after Black Friday for the first time this week.
- 13:07Just yesterday, they announced Black Friday deals on DoorDash.
- 13:10Like, that's crazy to me.
- 13:12So, like, they are shrewd.
- 13:13So I don't know.
- 13:14There's going to be a lot more to this story, you know, in the coming months and even the coming years ahead.
- 13:19So.
- 13:19And to that point, like, there's a whole nother angle to this story, which I want to get to.
- 13:23So let's get to the next headline.
- 13:24The next headline is brought to you, of course, by Miracle, the catalyst of Commerce.
- 13:27Over 450 retailers are opening new revenue streams with marketplaces, dropship and retail media.
- 13:32And succeeding with Miracle, you can unlock more products, more partners, and more profits without the heavy lifting.
- 13:37So what's holding you back?
- 13:38Visit miracle.com to learn more.
- 13:40Headline number two.
- 13:42If you thought we were done with Instacart.
- 13:44No, I got news for you.
- 13:45Think again.
- 13:46In a move announced the same day the doordash deal talks went public, Instacart said it's winding down its capercart smart cart business five years after buying Caper AI for $350 million.
- 14:01Man, the guy that sold out, sold.
- 14:03That was so smart.
- 14:04According to Grocery Dive, Instacart said, quote, retailer adoption has not scaled quickly enough to justify our continued investment.
- 14:11End quote.
- 14:12The retreat reverses half a decade of work.
- 14:15Instacart's former CEO once called the carts the future of grocery shopping.
- 14:19And recent deployments included schnooks, a story we have covered many, many times.
- 14:23Weiss Markets and a UK debut with Morrisons.
- 14:27Kelly, here's my question for you on this one.
- 14:29Does the death of the caper cart signal the end of the smart cart in grocery, or just the end of Instacart's version of it?
- 14:37I actually am going to go, big statement here.
- 14:41I think this is the end of the smart cart.
- 14:43I don't think it's the end of the intent of the smart cart, but why invest a lot of money in a physical cart when.
- 14:52You could.
- 14:53Get the same benefits technology from your cell phone.
- 14:57It's free, your customers are already on it, they're using it before they get to the store to make their lists.
- 15:05Why spend on a physical cart when you could integrate it all into their app at zero physical cost to you?
- 15:12So I think there's still a huge opportunity.
- 15:14It's just, it's not going to be in a card format.
- 15:17Okay.
- 15:17Okay.
- 15:18So you think, you think this will.
- 15:19You will kill all investments on smart cards in the near term?
- 15:22For sure.
- 15:23I would kill all investments on smart carts in the near term.
- 15:26I would, too.
- 15:27And I've said that many, many times.
- 15:28What about in the longer term, like five to 10 years out?
- 15:31Do you think we're going to start to see this pop back up?
- 15:34I don't know.
- 15:35I think that my gut reaction is no.
- 15:38I think that just like technology is just becoming increasingly, there's so much more you can do on your phone every day with AI.
- 15:46Like what?
- 15:47The only added feature that I was seeing of these carts is, you know, navigation of the store tips.
- 15:53Why can't you do that mobile?
- 15:55There.
- 15:55Was the deeply expensive weighing of your products in the physical cart.
- 16:00I guess you lose that.
- 16:01But I feel like even the idea of accelerated checkout, which was so hot a few years ago, and they.
- 16:09Were.
- 16:09Thinking about how can we use this physical cart to also allow you to check out in the car.
- 16:14You don't even need to go to the line.
- 16:16That slowed down a bit.
- 16:17Like, that's not really something people are talking about as much this, like, demand to get out of the store as fast as possible.
- 16:24And we have these other options.
- 16:25So I'd say even in five to 10 years, like, I don't see this coming back.
- 16:30It's so expensive.
- 16:32I, I, I hope you're right.
- 16:34But sadly, the, the retail historian in me thinks, I don't think they're dead.
- 16:38I think Instacart's version is dead.
- 16:40But I think, I think we're gonna still see it.
- 16:42Because, you know, there are two use cases that I think became very palpable from the cart now.
- 16:48And I think to your point, there are many, many other ways to do them.
- 16:52One is the, the real time budgeting that you can see as you're shopping, that's valuable.
- 16:56But yeah, you could do that with your smartphone or you could do that in other ways, shapes or forms.
- 17:00And then of course, the one that always got people excited, which is what, you know, Instacart and others have been, you know, stumping for a while, is the retail media angle being able to serve up ads.
- 17:10But again, you can serve up people, you can serve up ads on the phone, you can serve up ads on digital screens, you can serve up ads on In Store via In store audio.
- 17:17There's lots of ways to do that.
- 17:19So I hope you're right.
- 17:20Kelly.
- 17:20The thing I would say too is like, and I've argued this for since the cows come home, since the dawn of time, is like, you don't put the smart cart before the store.
- 17:30Like, you've got it.
- 17:31You should, you gotta invest in making your store run smarter first before you actually make the carts run smarter.
- 17:39And that's why I hope, to your point, that in the short term particularly, and maybe hopefully even in the long term, that's where the investment goes, that's where the funnel goes.
- 17:48But what you get the last word here.
- 17:49What do you think?
- 17:50Yeah, I totally agree.
- 17:51And I think also just pause on the complexity of the physical cart and get the technology right of what do you want to be serving up to them?
- 18:02What information do you need from them?
- 18:04How are you getting them to integrate your app into their day to day?
- 18:09It's honestly a benefit if you're getting them on Instacart or your app rather than just the physical hardware and store, which they're going to then leave when they go Home.
- 18:18So how can they really think about making that mobile experience as well as the physical store experience top notch?
- 18:25Then we can play with an add on cart technology.
- 18:29The one thing I would love to see out of this is carts that have a holder for your cell phone.
- 18:36Because today I go to a normal car and I kind of just tilt the cell phone on the baby seat.
- 18:41So that's what I believe the future of smart card is.
- 18:45Just give me a little holder for my iPhone.
- 18:47And I can.
- 18:48You probably see, I can remember in business school, this is back in 2003, looking at IDO trying to reimagine the shopping cart.
- 18:55Not even the smart cart, the shopping cart.
- 18:56And that didn't even work.
- 18:57So like this stuff, they've been trying to redesign the shopping cart for years and years and years and it just, it just never takes the funny thing to, as I'm closing this out is, you know, I think I
- 19:08feel like Walmart has been giving us the roadmap on how to think about this conceptually.
- 19:11Like, you know, they've invested in the store, they've invested in understanding the data flows that are happening in the store at every level.
- 19:18They're using that to improve the lives of their, their, their associates.
- 19:22They're using that to improve the experiences of their customers both in store and online via their mobile interactions.
- 19:28Like you said Kelly.
- 19:30So the roadmaps, they're like, why are we, why are we dilly dallying around with things like smart cards at this point?
- 19:35So in a lot of ways I think this is a good announcement for the industry.
- 19:39All right, headline number three.
- 19:40Headline number three is brought to you by Corso.
- 19:42Your stores are full of data, but are your teams acting on it?
- 19:46Corso turns retail data into personalized daily to dos that drive sales, reduce waste and improve execution.
- 19:52No fluff, just action.
- 19:53Help your managers focus on what matters most.
- 19:56Visit corso.com to see Intelligent Management in Motion.
- 20:00Headline number three.
- 20:01God, we are just rolling here with these great headlines.
- 20:04Starbucks closed out fiscal 2026 with global comparable coffee house sales up 7.2% and US comps up 7.7% in Q4, according to Starbucks October 29 earnings release.
- 20:16US comps were driven by a 5.2% increase in average ticket and a 2.4% increase in transactions, topping the company's own guidance of 6.5% or better.
- 20:27For context, one year ago, US comps at Starbucks were flat.
- 20:32And last quarter traffic was doing more of the heavy lifting than ticket was this quarter.
- 20:38That mix, as I Just recanted has flipped Kelly.
- 20:43Starbucks CEO Brian Nichols back to Starbucks.
- 20:45Strategy appears to be working.
- 20:48But with ticket now driving more of the growth than traffic, is that a sign of strength or the first yellow flag in his turnaround plans?
- 20:56And what does Starbucks also need to do differently to keep the momentum going?
- 21:01I do think that this is a cautionary signal for Starbucks.
- 21:06There's.
- 21:06A.
- 21:06Lot of.
- 21:07I do, yes, I think a lot of great progress.
- 21:10The ticket improvement is really favorable.
- 21:13They've been taking so many calculated, smart actions around the menu to prioritize margin, you know, get interesting products in people's carts.
- 21:23So I think there's a lot of things moving in the right direction.
- 21:26But QSRs really need to pay attention to that traffic because ticket value is something that can easily turn around as consumers get more price conscious as they think about, you know, managing what they're buying.
- 21:44So really paying close attention to that traffic is going to be really important.
- 21:48It also feels a little counter even to the name of the turnaround back to Starbucks.
- 21:53People aren't going back as much.
- 21:55It's slowing down a little.
- 21:56So I think it'll be important for them to think about what are they actually doing to get people back in the store.
- 22:03And I think there has been a push around this about making it feel like a coffee house again, some of the kind of physical elements of the location.
- 22:10So I think the plan is there.
- 22:12I wouldn't say there's dramatically different things that they need to be doing, but it is something that they should watch cautiously.
- 22:20Okay, that's interesting.
- 22:21So I see things a little bit differently on this one.
- 22:24Yeah.
- 22:24So we'll have a little bit of a debate here.
- 22:26I actually think that the difference between traffic and ticket is actually a really good sign because the fact that traffic is still up year over year when your ticket is pushed up that high.
- 22:36And.
- 22:37And we know that, you know, you know, coming off the election yesterday, we know how pressed the average consumer is, too.
- 22:43So the fact that Starbucks is getting people in and they're actually paying more money for their coffee, that's a really good sign that things, I think, are potentially working out to a larger degree than.
- 22:54Than I think I would have anticipated.
- 22:57And so, like.
- 22:58And I say that too, if this is, of course, a sample size of 1.
- 23:02But my local Starbucks got the refresh, and it looks better, it feels better.
- 23:07It's got the digital menu board, which helps the customers understand where their order is in the queue.
- 23:11It helps the employees, you know, deal with all the angry customers, because Instead of them asking, where's my drink?
- 23:17They can see on the board that it hasn't even gotten through the first stage of production yet, which is valuable.
- 23:22But, but I think here's the caveat though is I think, like, I don't think Starbucks is out of the woods yet though, Kelly, because, you know, I go into Starbucks on a Saturday or Sunday, there's like 100 orders
- 23:32on the digital menu board.
- 23:33And I tried to meet somebody for a coffee in the store and it took us so long to get our coffee that it ended up killing our meeting.
- 23:42And so I think it's going to become a hassle for people to have meetings there if they can't operationalize the coffee production in a way that keeps up with the demand.
- 23:51So if the traffic's coming, that's great, but it's also going to cause another problem down the road.
- 23:56And so that's where I started wondering, like, and I told the guy I was with, I was like, go order your coffee in line.
- 24:02Don't order it via mobile because it's counterintuitive.
- 24:05You think I'd order it ahead, I'd be ready, be ready there when I get my, when I have my, Be ready for me when I have my meeting.
- 24:11It's not.
- 24:12You go and you go up to the counter, it actually gets ready for you faster because they got the four minute promise and all that kind of thing.
- 24:16At least that's what I think.
- 24:18So I'd actually, if I'm Starbucks, I would actually potentially lean into that from a marketing perspective to be like, hey, you know, come into our store, we're gonna, we're gonna give you your coffee as quickly as possible.
- 24:28You're gonna get priority.
- 24:30And because we want you to enjoy, I mean, that's something I'd at least be experimenting with.
- 24:34I don't know though, Kelly, call me crazy.
- 24:36No, I really like where you're going with that last idea.
- 24:38Just because as Starbucks started to get ahead of the mobile, ordering so many of the stores again, sample size of one that I walked into became a very stale experience from, as a consumer, you go in all the
- 24:54cups on the counter, they're just sitting there.
- 24:56Yours takes forever.
- 24:57It's exactly what you described.
- 24:58I've seen it in so many locations.
- 25:01So I do think they need to figure out how to incent people to go in and enjoy their time there.
- 25:07Again, fully agree, great that the ticket is up.
- 25:10That's progress for them and from a performance standpoint, but there's still work to be done.
- 25:16To actually get people to want to spend time in those stores.
- 25:19And I think the operational point is spot on.
- 25:23You can bring people in, get that traffic up, but if you're not going to also deliver from an ops standpoint, it's not going to hold.
- 25:31It will go back down.
- 25:33Yeah.
- 25:33The other point too, like you brought up, you brought up the mobile interactions on the last headline.
- 25:37I think, I think that's a valuable asset for Starbucks in this conversation too.
- 25:40Like, you know, I'm a frequent Starbucks shopper.
- 25:43Like I, I'm buying, I'm buying Starbucks three or four times a week.
- 25:46I know producer Ella is too.
- 25:48And they've got all that data on me from the mobile app.
- 25:51So why not incent me to purchase my, you know, when I go on the app, if they know the demand is high, why don't they incent me to go into the store and, and purchase it that way or
- 26:01you know, try to get me into the store more often with different incentives.
- 26:04Like I think there's things they can do from a loyalty perspective here that have never been tapped into before via the connection that they do have with the mobile app.
- 26:12What do you think about that, Kelly?
- 26:13Yeah, I think that could be interesting.
- 26:15And another avenue that I, I know they've played with before and I think could further explore is each individual store, what purpose does it serve?
- 26:25Like not all of their doors are going to be these coffeehouse experiences.
- 26:29So where can you use some of that data of where people are primarily doing pickup today versus not where's your kind of strong footprint area where you can really optimize the purpose of each store and then to your
- 26:45point, use the app, funnel them from there, especially your really loyal customers.
- 26:49Yeah, that's the other point, you know, and I think I've mentioned this on the past show too.
- 26:52I got in a very vociferous argument with the PR team when I, when I basically wrote an article in Forbes saying like that's what they still need to do because so many people don't care about the in store
- 27:01experience.
- 27:01I think it's obvious that, that a lot of customers don't care.
- 27:05Like they just don't because they will willingly wait in line for pickup and then take their coffee and leave.
- 27:11And so yeah, to your point, like then how do you create stores that are just that which they tried to do but went away from.
- 27:17But I think you have to bring that element back to some degree.
- 27:21But maybe, maybe, maybe Nichol's right, maybe you do that as like the next order condition.
- 27:25Like first you try to figure out how to segment your volume and give incentives to smooth out your demand.
- 27:31You go back to traditional operations planning in business school and you try to go there first before you have to start investing in new.
- 27:38Because it is expensive to do that.
- 27:40It's new infrastructure.
- 27:41You got to design it, you got to figure it out.
- 27:43And maybe there are simpler ways and maybe that, maybe he smartly is trying to do that.
- 27:47I'll give him credit because he seems like he knows what he's doing.
- 27:49Maybe that, maybe that is the first, the first order condition of what you want to solve before you take that bite of the apple.
- 27:55Yeah, definitely.
- 27:56I mean, they've already invested a lot in stores as they're doing this back to Starbucks, but they've done the lower investment part relative to what else they could do, just in terms of really reformatting, revisiting location, how you're
- 28:13going to drive traffic.
- 28:14So, you know, like I said, I think the slowing of traffic is a little bit of a cautionary flag.
- 28:22I think QSRs in general are seeing slower traffic right now as people are being more price conscious.
- 28:27So it might just be a sign of the times.
- 28:29But as they're really thinking about winning the back to Starbucks, you know, what's the next step on traffic, I think will be really important.
- 28:37They've had great ticket progress.
- 28:39Like, let's focus on traffic now.
- 28:41Yeah.
- 28:41And then the one thing we forgot to mention is they could also just buy a burrito chain.
- 28:44You know, why not?
- 28:45You know, Right, Kelly.
- 28:47I will say their breakfast burrito, pound for pound, like, does a pretty good job against some of the others.
- 28:54Right?
- 28:54That was the funniest headline a few weeks ago when there was rumored to be, like, talking about a merger between Starbucks and Chipotle.
- 28:59I just had to bring.
- 28:59Oh, I haven't even seen that one.
- 29:01Yeah, and see that?
- 29:02Oh, my God.
- 29:02Yeah.
- 29:03No, that was a rumor that.
- 29:04Because he ran both things, there was a rumor that Starbucks was looking to acquire Chipotle.
- 29:08So I was like, yeah, let's just fuse those together.
- 29:10That'll solve all the problems.
- 29:11Headline number four is brought to you by Accapo Capital.
- 29:14OCAPO Capital is a venture capital firm founded by retail executives with the aim of helping early stage consumer businesses succeed through investment and operational support.
- 29:23Learn more@ocampo capital.com headline number four.
- 29:26Walmart plus has officially launched in Mexico, bundling free shipping and delivery with streaming mobile data and healthcare benefits into a single membership.
- 29:34According to Walmart, the membership costs 89 pesos per month or 890 pesos per year.
- 29:41And Walmart says the bundled benefits are worth more than than 260 pesos per month.
- 29:45Wow.
- 29:46Nearly three times the fee.
- 29:48Mexico follows Walmart Plus's Canada launch in June, part of what Walmart Plus's general manager Deepak Maney calls a quote build once skill globally strategy, end quote.
- 30:00In the U.S.
- 30:01walmart says members shop three times more often and spend four times as much as non members.
- 30:06No surprise there.
- 30:07Kelly, with Canada and now Mexico in the books, how far do you think Walmart can take the potential of Walmart plus globally?
- 30:13I think it's gonna be really interesting to see what adoption looks like in Mexico.
- 30:20So they have a really different cost structure here in Mexico than we have in the US it's when you annualize it, it's about half the price of the US model.
- 30:29So they seem to be testing something a little bit new in Mexico which is can we bank a little bit less on that membership fee and kind of the income that we're getting from having members and focus on
- 30:44really driving the habitual visiting a Walmart using Walmart as your go to because it's not free or cheap to run these membership programs.
- 30:56So if they're able to see that hey, this lower cost model in Mexico works and we're getting the benefit we need just from traffic expanded occasion of that consumer, I think they have a strong case to expand that
- 31:10more into Central America's other markets.
- 31:14But if that doesn't work it becomes an expensive approach to roll out in other countries.
- 31:21So I'll be really curious to see how it goes.
- 31:24Yeah, I think, I think that's, I think that's right.
- 31:26You know to me I was, I was actually doing, I did a, did a little research on this one too and I said like okay, you know, now that you know Walmart's in, Walmart's taking Walmart plus to Canada
- 31:35and now Mexico, like where else are the big opportunities?
- 31:37And like to me the logical next step is Chile, you know, for sure.
- 31:41Like I think if it, if it works in Mexico or even if it doesn't, I think we'll see it go down there too because you know, the one benefit of it, you know, is you are getting paid, your,
- 31:52your customers are paying you to shop with you which is hugely valuable.
- 31:56So any amount of money you can command to do that is super relevant.
- 32:01And then also you get the retail media side of it too because you get the people interacting with you more and all that.
- 32:05So it it, it fuels the flywheel which is what you know, Amazon discovered a while ago.
- 32:10So you know, but you know, I think when I go back to my question globally, I think, you know, beyond what we said in terms of Latin America, I don't think there's much more juice that Walmart can squeeze
- 32:21out of this.
- 32:21But there's still probably a lot of juice that it can squeeze in Canada, in Mexico and even here in the U.S.
- 32:26right.
- 32:26I think it's still, you know, when you look at it compared to prime, it's still relatively under penetrated to the population.
- 32:32At least that's my assumption.
- 32:34And so, and, and I, I've always said on this show too, my go to now for quick deliveries is Walmart.
- 32:39Like that's where I'm going.
- 32:40I don't even look at prime anymore.
- 32:42And I even questioned the value of prime at the end of the day because I have purchased things without prime and I don't feel like there's any really big difference.
- 32:49But hey, who am I to judge, right Kelly?
- 32:52Yeah, yeah, no, I, it would be really interesting.
- 32:54I, I agree with you.
- 32:55I do not know what their penetration is in the US But I think expanding further in the current markets will be a great opportunity where we know, especially in the US like grocery delivery is alive and well.
- 33:10It's just who's gonna win out on the order,.
- 33:12Right?
- 33:12Is the doordash instacart merger, is it fresh?
- 33:17So I think that that's really still going to be the core focus.
- 33:20But again once we see how Mexico develops, South America, Central America I think become the next natural places for them to try it out.
- 33:30But we'll see.
- 33:31Yeah, it's like the domino theory of Walmart plus, where's it going to go next?
- 33:35All right, well, headline number five is brought to you by Manhattan Associates.
- 33:38Yes, you heard that right.
- 33:39We have a new sponsor this week on the Omnitalk Retail Fast 5.
- 33:43Manhattan Associates is the global leader in cloud native and AI empowered supply chain commerce solutions.
- 33:48Manhattan has spent more than three decades helping the world's leading brands manage their warehouses, transportation, inventory and fulfillment operations to efficiently and effectively deliver on their promise to their customers.
- 33:59For more details you can visit www.manh.com.
- 34:06Headline number five saved a good one for last, Kelly.
- 34:08Amazon CEO Andy Jassy used the company's Q3 earnings call to argue Wall street is underrating its retail business.
- 34:16According to Amazon's October 29 release, net sales rose 12% to $201.9 billion.
- 34:23Operating margin hit 13.9%, its highest ever, and AWS grew 39% to $46 billion.
- 34:31But on the retail side, per retail dive, online store sales grew just 2% to $68.5 billion, and physical stores grew 2% to $5.7 billion, with Prime Day's move from Q3 into Q2 making the comparison, albeit tougher.
- 34:47Jassy, however, said, quote, some folks are sleeping a bit, end quote, on Amazon's store's progress, noting fresh groceries and everyday essentials are growing three times faster than the rest of the store business.
- 34:59And that same day, perishable customers buy nearly seven times more essential units.
- 35:04Kelly, what do you make of Amazon CEO Andy Jassy out stumping for Amazon's retail business?
- 35:09Is he right or is this possibly the first sign of a crack in the foundation?
- 35:14This is the tough one for me.
- 35:16It.
- 35:16Is.
- 35:17This is so hard.
- 35:19I don't know if it's a sign of a crack in the foundation.
- 35:22You know, when you have that many good things going for you on the headline, it feels a little bit like, okay, are we, are we reaching?
- 35:30Do we need to cheer on every single person on the team?
- 35:36But you know, I do think that what he has stated are signs of progress for the retail business at least, seeing that they're, they're having this pickup in traffic on Fresh.
- 35:49It's really interesting, especially given all the other things we just talked about today.
- 35:54Instacart DoorDash.
- 35:55There's so many players in this online grocery delivery space, so I think it's important for them to be able to show they're still a relevant player in this market.
- 36:05Almost feels like a bit of a competitive move to kind of keep relevant on this very hot topic right now.
- 36:11100.
- 36:12Yeah, like, I don't think it's a crack in the foundation.
- 36:16I don't think they're doing poorly, but I would say we're, we're forcing some press and attention to this to make sure that they're staying relevant.
- 36:24Top of mind, as there are a lot of movers and shakers in the space right now.
- 36:29Are you buying the don't sleep on us argument or do you think that's just a sound bite?
- 36:34That feels like a bit of a sound bite to me.
- 36:36It feels like a sound bite.
- 36:37I 100 agree with you.
- 36:38Yeah, like, I'm not buying the don't sleep on it at all.
- 36:42I think it's, I think this, I think the, the sales performance is a little, and you know, there's only so much you can glean from an earnings announcement, but it seems a little bit like kissing your sister.
- 36:49You know, overall sales are up 2%, which it isn't that much.
- 36:53You know, it's just not, it's not, especially given the macroeconomic conditions.
- 36:57It tells me people are adding on perishables and essentials, which essentials is a whole nother conversation.
- 37:03Like how much of that is actually true grocery, which is another thing.
- 37:06But, but they might be adding on, but it's not moving the top line, you know, so like they're getting the unit movement potentially, but it's not moving the top line at all.
- 37:15Which means that Amazon, this is the kissing your sister argument, which to me means that Amazon is still at best, you know, the top up grocery option.
- 37:23Because they're blasting, you know, do you want a perishable with your order?
- 37:27With every order that I make on Amazon.
- 37:29Right.
- 37:29I mean that's just what they're doing.
- 37:30So of course they're going to grab some people with that.
- 37:32It's smart.
- 37:34But here's what, here's the thing.
- 37:35At the end of the day, Kelly, it still matters.
- 37:38It still matters.
- 37:39It's death by a thousand cuts like I've talked about because for every type of purchase that Amazon gets.
- 37:44He's right.
- 37:45The grocery industry particularly, not Wall street, but the grocery industry particularly shouldn't sleep on them because for every type of purchase they get, that means there's a local grocer who isn't getting that purchase and that purchase matters to
- 37:57their longevity.
- 37:58So yeah, it sounds like something a CEO, CEO says to get the sound bite out there.
- 38:03But you know, I, I, it still matters.
- 38:06That's what's crazy about it.
- 38:08It does.
- 38:08And it would be really interesting to your point actually to see how much of their fresh volume are those top up ads versus a full fresh cart that I'm, I'm going into the fresh tab.
- 38:21I'm putting the order together.
- 38:23That would be super interesting to see because that's where we'll really understand where is it habitual?
- 38:29And again even.
- 38:31Or where is it really like habitual.
- 38:33I'm going to do a grocery shopping trip.
- 38:35We're replacing the instacart, replacing the trip to the store versus the top offs which will damage the local market in terms of getting that quick trip.
- 38:46But I would love to see that information.
- 38:49Yeah.
- 38:50Although I think, I think it's rational to assume and somebody out there can disagree with me and if they know more than we do, please, please disagree with me on social media and point me in the right direction.
- 38:59But like I think if that were happening, the top line numbers would be bigger.
- 39:04They just would, especially given the push that they put towards grocery and putting that interstitial in the checkout every single time.
- 39:12Like the numbers would be bigger.
- 39:14They, they particularly would be, especially given the inflationary pressures that we're seeing, you know, in some of those categories as well.
- 39:21So, yeah, I, I don't, I'm just, I'm not, I'm not buying that it's as strong as he's making it out to be.
- 39:28But then again, the point that I make is it doesn't matter.
- 39:32That's what's crazy.
- 39:33Every, every order counts.
- 39:35All right, let's go to the Lightning round.
- 39:36Today's Lightning Round is brought to you with the help and support of Smart Scout.
- 39:40Smart Scout is Amazon and TikTok.
- 39:42Shop Intelligence.
- 39:43Most tools show you your own account.
- 39:46Smart Scout shows you the market, brand, revenue, category, share and who really owns it.
- 39:51Visit smartscout.com omnitalk to learn more today.
- 39:55All right, Kelly, first one.
- 39:57The Milwaukee brewers just won their first World Series in franchise history, beating the Rays in five games.
- 40:03I've got four questions for you today too, Kelly, since you're in a seat on your own.
- 40:07All right.
- 40:08Which retailer is the Milwaukee brewers of retail that is the longest suffering and finally due for its championship moment?
- 40:15I.
- 40:16Trader Joe's on this one.
- 40:18Trader Joe's?
- 40:19Really?
- 40:20Why, why are they in need of their championship moment?
- 40:24Yeah, I feel like in the, in the age of all of these conglomerates coming together, we have a lot of big headlines around retailers.
- 40:32Trader Joe's are just not in the headlines as much.
- 40:34And they are always there, always reliable, strong loyalty.
- 40:39I'd like to see them talked about more.
- 40:41They've been playing at a championship level, but they don't get the recognition they deserve.
- 40:44I could buy that.
- 40:45All right, next one.
- 40:46Clocks fell back this weekend.
- 40:47If you got one extra hour to spend inside any single store, which store are you picking.
- 40:53On?
- 40:54This one.
- 40:54I'm in a grocery mood today.
- 40:56After all our topics, I'd go Whole Foods.
- 40:59It takes me so.
- 41:00Long.
- 41:01Shop Whole Foods.
- 41:02There's a lot of discovery, fun things, sampling.
- 41:06I could wander a grocery aisle for hours.
- 41:09Wow.
- 41:09Maybe there is a little something in what Mr.
- 41:11Jassy's saying.
- 41:12Yeah.
- 41:12Given that Instacart just pulled the plug on caper carts.
- 41:15What's the.
- 41:16This is great.
- 41:16What's the next most overhyped piece of in store tech in the market today?
- 41:22I have to say next most overhype it's kind of a similar theme we talked about with the carts, but in general, in store screens.
- 41:31If we already have the screen on our phone, that's what we're looking at.
- 41:35Not looking around at the screens.
- 41:37That might be a little overhyped in space to optimize the phone screen more.
- 41:42Yeah, right.
- 41:42Yeah, I'm with you.
- 41:43I've been big on that one, too.
- 41:45Like, I feel like they're just billboards inside a store.
- 41:47They're not going to do what we're all thinking they're going to do.
- 41:49But I know people think I'm wrong about that one.
- 41:51So Halloween just wrapped you, Kelly.
- 41:53Last one.
- 41:53What's the one leftover candy you're hoarding and the one you're re gifting to the office?
- 41:58Oh, hoarding Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, no doubt.
- 42:02Handing out at the office.
- 42:04Tootsie Pops and Tootsie Rolls.
- 42:06Not.
- 42:07Not a.
- 42:07Not what?
- 42:07Tootsie Roll.
- 42:08A Tootsie Pop.
- 42:09That's a big difference, too.
- 42:10You don't like either one?
- 42:11Don't like either 1.
- 42:13No one.
- 42:13When I see the big Tootsie Bag, I'm like, oh.
- 42:16Oh, wow.
- 42:16Oh, I could get it.
- 42:17I could eat it.
- 42:18I used to eat Tootsie Pops every day in college.
- 42:20You can have my.
- 42:21Tootsie Bag then.
- 42:22Yeah, right.
- 42:22Yeah, yeah.
- 42:23Set it my way.
- 42:24All right, well, today's podcast was produced with the help and support of producer Ella Seward.
- 42:28Happy birthday Today to Matthew McConaughey, Bethany Frankel, and to the real villain of the Karate Kid, Ralph Macchio.
- 42:35And remember, if you can only read or listen to one retail blog in the business, make it Omnitalk.
- 42:39Our Fast five podcast is the quickest, fastest rundown of all the week's top news in our daily newsletter.
- 42:44The Retail Daily Minute tells you all you need to know each day to stay on top of your game as a retail executive and also regularly feature special content that is exclusive to us and we take a ton
- 42:53of perks pride in doing just for you.
- 42:54Thanks as always for listening in.
- 42:56Please remember to like and leave us a review wherever you happen to listen to your podcast or on YouTube.
- 43:00You can foster today by simply going to YouTube.com omnitalk retail or by searching omnitalk retail on TikTok.
- 43:08Kelly.
- 43:08If people want to get in touch with you, anyone at the A M Consumer and Retail group, what's the best way for them to do that?
- 43:14Yes, you can find us on LinkedIn, Alvarez and Marcel, Consumer Retail Group or visit us at our Website Alvarez and marcel-crg.com we'd love to hear from you.
- 43:26All right, well, Kelly, thanks for stepping in today, taking the guest hosting chair solo.
- 43:30Well, well done.
- 43:32And on behalf of all of us at Omnitalk Retail, to all our loyal listeners out there, as always, be careful out there.