Latest / The Morning Rundown / Smith Grilled, the Measles Data Fight, and City's Guilty Verdict
Transcript
- 0:00[Maya] Okay, so David texted me this morning and just said, "Buckle up."
- 0:17[David] Because it's one of those days.
- 0:19[Maya] It's one of those days.
- 0:20[Maya] We've got a Senate hearing that apparently got loud fast.
- 0:24[David] Real loud.
- 0:25[Maya] Then there's this whole fight brewing over measles numbers, and nobody can
- 0:28[Maya] agree who's even counting right.
- 0:30[David] CDC says one thing, Pennsylvania says another.
- 0:33[Maya] Three totally different stories, but somehow they all rhyme.
- 0:37[David] Yeah, it's basically a theme day whether we planned it or not.
- 0:40[Maya] And then just to lighten the mood a little-
- 0:43[David] Soccer's involved
- 0:45[Maya] Soccer's involved.
- 0:46[Maya] Manchester City just got hit with a guilty verdict.
- 0:49[David] Which honestly might be the least dramatic story of the three.
- 0:52[Maya] Might be, but it's still a big deal for the league.
- 0:55[David] Still, guilty is guilty, no matter how it dresses up.
- 0:58[Maya] Exactly.
- 0:58[Maya] It's not nothing just because it's the least chaotic headline of the
- 1:02[Maya] morning.
- 1:02[David] So basically, the whole hour is just who do you actually trust
- 1:06[David] when the people in charge can't agree?
- 1:08[Maya] That's the through line, yeah.
- 1:10[David] I like it.
- 1:11[Maya] I'm Maya.
- 1:12[David] I'm David, and this is the Morning Rundown.
- 1:14[Maya] Let's start on the Hill because that hearing did not go the
- 1:17[Maya] way anybody expected.
- 1:20[Maya] So CBS News had this hearing going about as long as you'd
- 1:23[Maya] expect, and Smith just sat there defending every call he made.
- 1:28[David] Every single one?
- 1:29[Maya] Every single one.
- 1:31[Maya] This is a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing from earlier this week, and
- 1:34[Maya] NBC News reported Smith telling senators his investigation found what he called
- 1:39[Maya] proof beyond a reasonable doubt of serious crimes.
- 1:42[David] Proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
- 1:44[David] That's a confident thing to say about a case that never actually
- 1:47[David] went to trial.
- 1:48[Maya] Right?
- 1:49[Maya] And Kennedy wasn't having it.
- 1:51[Maya] NBC News says he opened by just straight up asking Smith, quote,
- 1:54[Maya] "What does the word arrogant mean?"
- 1:57[David] Wait, that's how he opened?
- 1:59[Maya] That's the opener.
- 2:00[Maya] No warm-up, no throat clearing, straight to arrogant.
- 2:03[David] I mean, come on, that's a gutsy way to start a hearing.
- 2:06[Maya] And it didn't get gentler from there.
- 2:08[David] How much worse?
- 2:09[Maya] Newsweek covered the exchange, and Kennedy brought up the Tooth Fairy.
- 2:14[David] Wait, hold on.
- 2:14[David] That's not even a real government agency reference.
- 2:16[David] That's just pop culture at this point.
- 2:19[Maya] Right, which was probably the point.
- 2:20[Maya] Get everyone talking about the hearing instead of the substance.
- 2:24[David] The Tooth Fairy in a Senate hearing.
- 2:27[Maya] And Jimmy Hoffa.
- 2:29[David] Jimmy Hoffa too.
- 2:30[David] What's the connection there?
- 2:31[Maya] Basically needling Smith on things people believe without proof versus what Smith
- 2:35[Maya] says he actually had.
- 2:37[David] Ah, okay, that tracks.
- 2:39[David] So what's Smith's comeback to all that?
- 2:41[Maya] He kept saying his charging decisions were built on what Newsweek calls
- 2:44[Maya] him calling incredibly strong evidence.
- 2:48[David] Incredibly strong, not just strong.
- 2:51[Maya] He really leaned on that word.
- 2:53[David] Incredibly strong evidence, and yet the committee didn't exactly seem convinced by
- 2:57[David] the phrase itself.
- 2:59[Maya] No, repeating a phrase isn't the same as backing it up with
- 3:01[Maya] a document they can actually see.
- 3:03[David] Okay, but here's my problem with that answer.
- 3:05[Maya] Go ahead.
- 3:06[David] If the evidence was that strong, why is a guy who ran
- 3:08[David] a federal investigation spending an afternoon getting compared to a mythical creature
- 3:13[David] and a guy who vanished in 1975?
- 3:15[Maya] That's fair.
- 3:16[David] I'm not saying Kennedy's questions were classy.
- 3:18[David] Some of it was clearly for the cameras.
- 3:20[Maya] Sure.
- 3:21[Maya] Some of these senators love a viral clip.
- 3:23[David] But you don't get grilled like that from multiple directions if your
- 3:26[David] case was airtight.
- 3:27[Maya] And to be fair to Kennedy, some of that questioning probably lands
- 3:31[Maya] with voters who already think Washington investigations run on vibes more than
- 3:35[Maya] proof.
- 3:36[David] Which is exactly the reputation Smith's trying to shake off by leaning
- 3:40[David] so hard on that incredibly strong language in the first place.
- 3:43[Maya] I'll give you that.
- 3:45[Maya] Smith kept his composure the whole time, from what CBS described, but
- 3:48[Maya] composure isn't the same as convincing.
- 3:51[David] Exactly.
- 3:52[David] Cool under pressure just means you rehearsed it.
- 3:56[Maya] Harsh.
- 3:57[David] I'm just saying, calling your own evidence incredibly strong is the kind
- 4:00[David] of thing you say when you know people are already doubting you.
- 4:03[Maya] Yeah, and the GOP senators clearly walked in doubting him.
- 4:07[Maya] This wasn't some ambush.
- 4:09[David] No, this was planned skepticism.
- 4:11[Maya] Which, fine, that's their job on that committee.
- 4:14[Maya] I don't think Smith's some villain here, but I also don't think
- 4:17[Maya] one guy insisting he was right settles it.
- 4:19[David] Especially when the guy insisting is the guy being investigated for how
- 4:23[David] he investigated.
- 4:24[Maya] It's a weird spot to be in, defending your own judgment about
- 4:27[Maya] your own investigation to the people funding the next one.
- 4:30[David] Yeah.
- 4:31[David] There's no independent referee in that room, just Smith's word against a
- 4:34[David] room full of senators who came in skeptical.
- 4:37[Maya] Right.
- 4:37[Maya] Right.
- 4:38[Maya] So nobody in that room actually resolved anything.
- 4:41[Maya] Smith says, "Trust the evidence," Kennedy says, "Answer the question," and everybody
- 4:45[Maya] left with their same opinion they walked in with.
- 4:47[David] Which is kind of the whole vibe lately.
- 4:49[Maya] Totally, and it's not just Washington.
- 4:52[Maya] There's a fight happening right now over public health numbers that's got
- 4:55[Maya] the same shape to it.
- 4:57[David] Wait, which one?
- 4:58[Maya] CDC versus Pennsylvania over measles data.
- 5:01[David] Oh, I saw something about that.
- 5:03[Maya] Yeah.
- 5:03[Maya] One side's counting deaths one way, the other side's counting them differently,
- 5:08[Maya] and depending who you ask, the numbers don't match.
- 5:11[David] So it's the same fight just with a death count instead of
- 5:13[David] a Senate transcript.
- 5:15[Maya] Kind of, yeah.
- 5:17[Maya] Someone's telling the truth about how to count it, someone else says
- 5:20[Maya] they're not, and nobody in charge agrees on the method.
- 5:23[David] All right, so what actually happened between the CDC and Pennsylvania?
- 5:27[Maya] So the CDC put out a number this week.
- 5:30[Maya] Second measles death in the country, officially.
- 5:33[David] Officially being the keyword.
- 5:35[Maya] Right, because that count leaves out Pennsylvania.
- 5:38[Maya] The Guardian reported that on September 29th.
- 5:41[Maya] The CDC's second death tally doesn't include any of Pennsylvania's measles deaths.
- 5:47[David] Wait, none of them?
- 5:48[Maya] None, and Pennsylvania's not exactly a small footnote here.
- 5:53[Maya] Same reporting says the state's up over 900 measles cases now.
- 5:57[David] 900.
- 5:58[David] That's a lot for one state.
- 6:00[Maya] It is, and four deaths tied to the outbreak according to that
- 6:03[Maya] same piece.
- 6:04[David] Four deaths the CDC isn't counting in its national number.
- 6:08[Maya] That's the fight.
- 6:09[Maya] Governor Shapiro's office and RFK Jr.'s health department are going back and
- 6:13[Maya] forth publicly over whose numbers are the real ones.
- 6:16[David] Nothing says functioning government like two agencies arguing about a body count
- 6:20[David] on Twitter.
- 6:21[Maya] Basically.
- 6:22[Maya] So there's a timeline out there, PBS NewsHour laid it out, and
- 6:25[Maya] it's kind of revealing.
- 6:27[Maya] The CDC starts off offering condolences to Pennsylvania.
- 6:31[David] Sounds normal so far.
- 6:32[Maya] Right.
- 6:33[Maya] But then it shifts.
- 6:34[Maya] The CDC ends up backing Kennedy's push to question how Pennsylvania is
- 6:39[Maya] even defining these deaths.
- 6:41[David] So they go from sorry for your loss to actually prove it.
- 6:44[Maya] Pretty much, and Pennsylvania's health department is not having it.
- 6:48[Maya] Per that PBS timeline, they call the CDC's characterization of their data
- 6:53[Maya] Inaccurate, flat out.
- 6:55[David] Inaccurate?
- 6:55[David] That's a strong word for a health department to use about the
- 6:58[David] federal government.
- 6:59[Maya] It is, and look, I get why people's ears perk up on
- 7:02[Maya] that.
- 7:03[Maya] When the number that makes the outbreak look worse just quietly disappears
- 7:07[Maya] from the federal count-
- 7:08[David] Yeah, that's the part that's gonna make people suspicious no matter which
- 7:11[David] side you're on
- 7:12[Maya] ...
- 7:12[Maya] and I think that instinct is fair, honestly.
- 7:15[Maya] You see a number shrink right as it gets politically inconvenient, and
- 7:19[Maya] your brain goes straight to cover up.
- 7:21[David] Same.
- 7:21[David] That's just how people are wired to read it.
- 7:23[Maya] Totally.
- 7:24[Maya] But here's where it's not as simple as they're hiding deaths.
- 7:28[David] Okay.
- 7:28[David] Make the case.
- 7:29[Maya] So Kennedy has actually got a public answer for this.
- 7:33[Maya] Townhall quoted him saying the CDC is, quote, "applying a consistent
- 7:37[Maya] national standard," his words, on how measles deaths get counted rather than
- 7:43[Maya] letting politicians set the number state by state.
- 7:46[David] A consistent national standard.
- 7:49[Maya] Yeah.
- 7:50[Maya] His argument is basically if every state gets to define measles death
- 7:54[Maya] its own way, you can't compare outbreaks or track anything nationally.
- 7:59[Maya] You need one rule book.
- 8:01[David] I mean, that's not a crazy position on its face.
- 8:04[David] If Texas counts differently than Florida, the national number's garbage either way.
- 8:08[Maya] Right, and that's actually a real methodology question.
- 8:12[Maya] What counts as measles associated versus measles caused?
- 8:16[Maya] Timing of death, underlying conditions.
- 8:18[Maya] Public health people fight about that stuff all the time outside of
- 8:21[Maya] politics.
- 8:22[David] Sure, but the optics here are rough because the effect of applying
- 8:26[David] that standard right now is that the number goes down in an
- 8:30[David] election adjacent fight with a Democratic governor.
- 8:33[Maya] It's a genuinely hard needle to thread, separating a real standards debate
- 8:38[Maya] from a standard that happens to be convenient right now.
- 8:41[David] Especially when the guy setting the standard is the same guy who
- 8:44[David] spent years arguing public health agencies can't be trusted anyway.
- 8:48[Maya] That's fair.
- 8:49[Maya] Shapiro's team would say convenient timing doesn't make it wrong methodology, but
- 8:53[Maya] it also doesn't make Kennedy some neutral referee either.
- 8:57[David] Huh.
- 8:57[David] Nobody in this fight is a neutral referee.
- 8:59[Maya] No, and that's honestly where it sits right now.
- 9:02[Maya] Pennsylvania saying the characterization's wrong, the CDC saying it's just standardizing the
- 9:07[Maya] count, and nobody's produced the thing that settles it.
- 9:11[David] So depending which outlet you follow, you either get a headline about
- 9:14[David] a cover-up or a headline about standardizing data.
- 9:18[David] Same facts, two completely different stories.
- 9:20[Maya] Which is sort of the point.
- 9:22[Maya] Neither framing is technically dishonest.
- 9:25[Maya] They're just picking which detail to lead with.
- 9:28[David] So unlike the Smith hearing, there's no tape here, no hearing transcript
- 9:31[David] to point at.
- 9:32[Maya] Nope.
- 9:33[Maya] Just two agencies with two numbers and a state of parents trying
- 9:36[Maya] to figure out how bad this outbreak actually is.
- 9:39[David] Which four deaths either way is not nothing.
- 9:42[Maya] Not nothing at all, and I don't think this gets resolved this
- 9:45[Maya] week or maybe even this outbreak.
- 9:48[David] Yeah, we'll see if either side blinks.
- 9:50[David] Okay, I need a break from death counts and Senate hearings for
- 9:53[David] a second.
- 9:54[Maya] Please go ahead.
- 9:55[David] Because while it was happening in Washington, there's actually a verdict handed
- 9:59[David] down in the sports world this week, and it did not go
- 10:02[David] well for a certain Premier League club.
- 10:05[Maya] Oh, I know exactly where you're going with this.
- 10:07[David] Manchester City, guilty on every single count.
- 10:12[Maya] So David, remember that Manchester City financial case that's been dragging on
- 10:16[Maya] forever?
- 10:18[David] Oh, forever.
- 10:19[David] Feels like it started when I still had a flip phone.
- 10:21[Maya] Well, it's over.
- 10:22[Maya] The Premier League confirmed City is guilty of all charges tied to
- 10:26[Maya] serious breaches of the financial rules.
- 10:28[David] Wait, all of them?
- 10:30[Maya] Every charge.
- 10:31[David] Every charge?
- 10:32[Maya] Which, that's a lot of paperwork to lose on.
- 10:35[David] Right?
- 10:35[David] And it's not some quiet internal memo.
- 10:37[David] This is the league itself putting its name on the finding.
- 10:41[Maya] So what happens now?
- 10:42[Maya] They just take the trophies back?
- 10:44[David] Not yet.
- 10:45[David] Al Jazeera laid out where things actually stand, and no sanction's been
- 10:49[David] approved.
- 10:50[Maya] None at all?
- 10:51[David] Nope.
- 10:51[David] City is expected to appeal, obviously.
- 10:53[Maya] Of course they are.
- 10:54[Maya] Nobody just says, "Yep, fair enough.
- 10:56[Maya] Take our points away."
- 10:57[David] Can you imagine that press conference?
- 10:59[Maya] We accept full responsibility.
- 11:01[Maya] Please dock us 40 points.
- 11:03[Maya] Thanks for having us.
- 11:04[David] Never happening, and it gets messier.
- 11:06[David] Other clubs are reportedly looking at going after compensation.
- 11:10[Maya] Compensation for what?
- 11:12[Maya] Missing out on trophies?
- 11:13[David] Basically.
- 11:14[David] If you finished second to a club that broke the rules, you've
- 11:17[David] got an argument you got cheated out of something real.
- 11:19[Maya] I mean, think about the fans too.
- 11:21[Maya] Season ticket holders who spent years watching this team, wondering now if
- 11:25[Maya] what they were cheering for was even a fair fight.
- 11:28[David] Right, and that's the part that doesn't have a compensation scheme.
- 11:31[David] You can't refund somebody's memory of a title race.
- 11:34[Maya] Okay, but here's my question.
- 11:36[Maya] Titles won since 2009, are we seriously talking about stripping those?
- 11:41[David] That's the debate people are having right now.
- 11:43[David] Nothing's decided.
- 11:44[Maya] So what, they just put an asterisk next to a decade of
- 11:47[Maya] trophies and call it a day?
- 11:49[David] I mean, banners don't come with a return policy.
- 11:52[Maya] Right.
- 11:52[Maya] You can't exactly unring that bell.
- 11:54[Maya] Season's over, everyone already celebrated.
- 11:57[David] There's also the question of every player who won a medal in
- 11:59[David] that stretch.
- 12:00[David] Do their records carry an asterisk too, even if they had nothing
- 12:03[David] to do with the finances?
- 12:05[Maya] That feels almost unfair to even bring up.
- 12:07[Maya] These are guys just doing their jobs on the pitch.
- 12:10[David] It's a genuinely weird problem.
- 12:12[David] How do you retroactively fix a competition years later?
- 12:15[Maya] Feels like trying to reshuffle a deck after everyone's already gone home.
- 12:20[David] And every other club in that era gets dragged back into the
- 12:22[David] conversation too, wondering if their own near misses suddenly look different.
- 12:26[Maya] Which nobody asked for, but here we are.
- 12:29[David] That's one way to put it.
- 12:31[Maya] So bottom line, Guilty verdict, but the punishment's still a total question
- 12:35[Maya] mark.
- 12:36[David] Exactly.
- 12:37[David] Verdict's in.
- 12:37[David] The fight over what it actually costs them is just getting started.
- 12:41[Maya] Either way, this one's going to drag on in courtrooms and appeal
- 12:44[Maya] panels a lot longer than the actual hearing did.
- 12:47[David] Probably years, if past cases like this are any guide.
- 12:50[Maya] Kind of fitting for this episode, honestly.
- 12:53[Maya] Smith's certain, the CDC and Pennsylvania can't agree, and now Soccer's got
- 12:57[Maya] its own mess to sort out.
- 12:59[David] Different arenas, same theme.
- 13:01[David] Somebody says it's settled, and somebody else says, "Not so fast."
- 13:05[Maya] Story of 2026, apparently.
- 13:08[David] Maya, take us out.
- 13:10[Maya] All right, that's it.
- 13:11[David] So that's the shape of today.
- 13:13[David] A prosecutor insisting he's right, an agency in a state stuck on
- 13:17[David] a body count, and a soccer club waiting to find out what
- 13:20[David] guilty actually costs.
- 13:22[Maya] Three different rooms, same headache.
- 13:24[David] And the honest takeaway isn't picking a winner in any of them.
- 13:28[David] It's just not taking the first confident voice as the last word.
- 13:32[Maya] Wait for the follow-up before you make up your mind.
- 13:35[David] That's the move.
- 13:36[Maya] All right, that's it for us this morning.
- 13:38[Maya] Thanks for hanging out with David and me.
- 13:40[David] Appreciate you listening.
- 13:41[Maya] Go grab your coffee, hug somebody.
- 13:43[Maya] We'll catch you next time on The Morning Rundown.