Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 08/11/26 EPISODE 014: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN - RED TOP RYE by Old Commonwealth Distillery
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Mm-hmm. We are back for another episode of the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. Got my buddy John Carlo in the room. We're keeping it easy tonight. Just the two of us. Welcome back, buddy. Thank you. Happy to be here. And ⁓ I'm I've been kind of one one I wanted to do this with him alone because you heard on a future or a past episode, he's a big rye guy. I am. And you were one of the first people when you first came over, you were like, I like rice. And so we we tasted through some ryes. And I recently popped this bottle from Old Commonwealth Distillery. It's a brand new release. I think it just came out about a month ago. And well, by the time this episode comes out, it'll be a couple months ago. But I think it came out in May, April or May. yeah, end of May, I believe. End of May 2026. And we're gonna taste through and give our thoughts and give some history as well on. Old Commonwealth Distillery, but specifically this bottle, the Red Top Rye. ⁓ so the story behind this is long and fascinating. So ⁓ I know you're a rye guy, so feel free to dive in. Sounds good. Drink it, enjoy it while I I'm gonna give some history here. ⁓ on Old Commonwealth ⁓ distillery and red top rye, which is fascinating. ⁓ it's an interconnected tale, ⁓ forgotten by ⁓ Of a forgotten pre-prohibition giant. ⁓ the legendary Van Winkle family, the family legacy, and a modern day resurrection. Both names share a striking through line. They were once re rescued from obscurity by Julian Van Winkle the Third in the late 20th century, and both have recently been revived for a new generation of whiskey enthusiasts, which is awesome. So the history on Old Commonwealth, ⁓ Is it's deeply tied to us one specific plot of land in Glensboro, excuse me, on Glensboro Road in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, and the survival of the Van Winkle family business. ⁓ so the Hoffman roots from it began in 1889 and ran through 1979. So back in 1889, ⁓ there was a businessman named S.O. Hackley, and he broke ground on the distillery along the Hammonds Creek. It was soon bought by the Hoffman family. And became the Hoffman Distilling Company. Famous for high quality sour mash bourbons, the distillery survived the depression and was later run by the Rippe brothers, ⁓ famous whiskey barons, whose family also started what became wild turkey. By the late 1960s, it operated as the Ezra Brooks Distillery. But as the global demand for bourbon tanked back in the 1970s, the facility ultimately shuttered its doors in 1979. ⁓ fast forward a few years in 1983, ⁓ or excuse me, ⁓ in 1981, corporate owners took control of the famous Stitzel Weller distillery, ending the Van Winkle's family, the Van Winkle family's direct affiliation with the Stitzel Weller ⁓ distillery, which is obviously famous for the bourbon that it turned out, right? ⁓ in the 70s, 80s. But Julian Van Winkle, he needed a a new home base to bottle the old prized barrels of he was buying back from his grandfather Pappy Van Winkle's stock. In nineteen eighty three Julian purchased the dormant Hoffman Distillery property and rechristened it the Commonwealth Distillery. For nearly two decades the site was the literal epicenter of the Van Winkle Empire. In nineteen ninety seven Julian released a highly limited, legendary old Commonwealth tenure bourbon, bottled at 107 proof and believed to be sourced Stitzaweller weeded liquid. When Julian moved his operations to Buffalo Trace in two thousand and two, the Commonwealth distillery closed its doors once again. Just to pause, for those that happen to be watching this episode, we have a bottle of the not the the one from n two nineteen ninety seven, ⁓ but the but the re released old Commonwealth ten year old at a hundred and seven proof. We will pop that ⁓ on another podcast episode here in the very near future. I'm very excited to try that bottle. It's making me wait. Thank you. Have to wait a little bit. We'll try to get some of the other fellas in the room ⁓ to do that. So ⁓ so Julian leaves Old Commonwealth in 2002 to go work with ⁓ with Buffalo Trace. ⁓ they closed the doors ⁓ to the Commonwealth Distillery at that time. So fast forward ⁓ geez, what is this? All the way to 2024. ⁓ and the brand sat in ⁓ the the brand and the and the distillery sat in the dark till the fall of twenty twenty four. When new owners secured the rights to the name and property. ⁓ they revived the label with ⁓ a modern old Commonwealth ten year old Kentucky straight bourbon departing from the historically weeded mash bill. The new version utilized a sourced low rye Kentucky bourbon bottled at a blazing cask strength of a hundred and thirty-one point eight three proof. It instantly sold out. ⁓ so the history Of what we're drinking today, which is red top rye. And I heard you say, ⁓ fuck. ⁓ what are you getting on the nose? You started smelling it. What are you, what are you, what are you thinking about? The first one, I got tons of vanilla. Yeah. On the nose. ⁓ man. It is, it is a I'm gonna wait to taste it, but man, that thing does smell incredible. ⁓ so red top rye, the liquid that we're we're drinking today. So ⁓ it is one of the wildest, most successful pre prohibition marketing histories in the American spirits industry. ⁓ which it eventually crossed paths with Old Commonwealth. the Westingheimer phenomenon was what we're going to call it from the eighteen hundreds to nineteen twenty. ⁓ so in late nineteenth century a German immigrant named Ferdinand Westingheimer established a massive whiskey operation outside of St. Joseph, Missouri. His crown jewel was called Red Top Rye. Westenheimer was a marketing genius and he plastered red top rye Across Pullman train cars, passed out on f passed out free samples at the nineteen ⁓ four World's Fair and flooded the market with catchy taglines like the whiskey that leaves no regret. By nineteen hundred, it was one of the best selling rye whiskies in the entire country. He had good marketing. Yeah, fair enough. Marketing, labeling, branding goes a long way. However, when Westenheimer passed away just before Prohibition, his children chose not to keep the brand alive. Rat Bastard. it vanished into a trademark graveyard for decades. ⁓ so now now with the Van Winkle ⁓ intersection into the distillery. So while while running Commonwealth Distillery in the 1990s, Julian Van Winkle th ⁓ discovered the defunct red top rye trademark. He recognized its historical weight and he pulled it out of retirement for a hyper limited, highly celebrated one time run. As a 15-year-old single barrel rye. ⁓ and and it's believed to be that that was sourced from ⁓ a medley rye. after the single batch was gone, the brand fell asleep again. So he he he dropped it one time. One of. I don't even know how many bottles I'm I'm really curious as to how many bottles that was, that single release was. ⁓ so fast forward to now to the modern revival, 2026 or so. The newly revived old Commonwealth team officially bought ⁓ brought Red Top. Rye back to the market. ⁓ so mo a lot of the ryes on the market are 955 ryes. Yep. ⁓ and so ⁓ the but the arrival of this version and this version is w a 100% rye whiskey, a mash bill. Just rye in the mash bill. Yeah. I'm expecting it to be spicy. Spicy? Okay. But from the nose, it doesn't smell that spicy. No. ⁓ so this this particular release that just came out. ⁓ is aged for seven years. It's bottled at 105 proof. ⁓ and it trades the the the traditional grassy medicinal notes of a younger rye for a deeper profile of dark fruit, clove, fresh baked rye bread, and honey butter. ⁓ so I've got ⁓ some tasty notes. ⁓ we'll do our thoughts on it and then we'll like we'll see if we can see we'll see what the the press release says, right? No. Man, some like ⁓ fruit leathers in there. It's almost almost like a ⁓ yeah. Like a raspberry or a cherry fruit roll up type scent to it. Enough as James would say, enough with the nose and just drink cholera. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Some of us don't like nosing our bourbon. I definitely really like the nose. It's got this light, light, very light floral note on the on it as well. That I really like. Whoa. It c it tells you it's a rye mid to end mid palette. Through the finish. Through the finish. It tells you I'm a I'm a I'm a hundred percent rye. Yeah, but the front of it's sweet. Soft. Soft. Sweet and soft. Yeah. Nice mouthfeel and then they just built and then it hits you. Yeah. It's warming. It is warming. Maybe that it's for my first sip, but it's like I can feel it warming. Yeah. What but it's delicious. It's Hundred and five proof on it. We've had some pretty good rise lately, but I feel like Rise have really stepped their game up in the last, I don't know, a couple years. Last year there was some really good rise. 2026 there's been some really good rise. But actually a couple really good boo ries blends that have come out this year as well. Which is fun to try. I'm not a big fan. I'm gonna have to start writing everything I taste here because I'm starting to forget what so I have a notebook here. But I'm gonna start writing stuff down like you've had this and this is what you've gotten from it. But it's it's tasty. The the nose is continuing to develop for me. I get a little bit of like ⁓ fru the fruitiness from that fruit leather. There's also like a fresh pear in there as well on the nose. It's kind of in the middle of the nose. Like the first up I get that fruit leather, then it rolls into like a little bit of yeah florality. I get it. And then a fresh pear nose. I get the florality. It's almost like it's the blossoms from a fruit. Yeah. Cherry blossom or spring. ⁓ She's got legs too. Y ⁓ yeah. Very viscous on the on the pore. ⁓ It's only seven year. Only seven year. There's a lot of a lot of flavor in here for seven years. Yeah. I I think this ⁓ would stack up against some of the older, you know, eleven, twelve, thirteen year old rye that we've had, ⁓ you know, specifically out of MGP. ⁓ I don't believe this this is not an MGP product. It's it's a Kentucky distillate. ⁓ I'd have to do a little research on how many places are distilling one hundred percent rye. because that is a curious mash, but I don't feel like you come across that very often. Definitely getting the rye, of course. Yeah. Not so much the clove and other spices. H the honey butter, I think it said. It's Yeah, I think they said honey butter. ⁓ I get that because of the mouthfeel. Okay. Yeah, you you've you've called a note out that they call out and I and you're probably better at picking this one out is white pepper. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. ⁓ they they put that on the back side of the nose. Actually it's on the palate as well. I can definitely get it more on the palate. Definitely the white it's it's in the finish for me, the white pepper. Yeah, it's like a sweeter peppery note. The crazy thing is this smells great. I and for those of you that haven't had an opportunity to try any of the old Commonwealth products, they do they do move quickly. They sell out fast. ⁓ I have missed out on several offerings from them and I'm literally in the queue trying to hit buy and then all of a sudden it's sold out within thirty seconds of it going live. So if you're interested in old Commonwealth products, couple tips. Be when they say it releases at nine, be on it at nine a.m. or whatever time they say it's gonna release. have a Shopify account, because if you're trying to manually put in your credit card at that moment, you're gonna miss it. and and they do move quickly. This is not an expensive bottle. This is sixty five dollars. All day. Sixty five dollars on this bottle. I'll probably have a case of it. Yeah. They there was a limit three. There was a limit three. I bought two. ⁓ because I just I was like, I want to drink one and I love the packaging. I was like, if it's if it sucks, at least it's a pretty bottle. Yeah. Lo and behold, it doesn't suck. It's amazing. Yeah. So now I'm like, I should have bought three for 65 bucks. ⁓ we've got another bottle up here on the table that they they released just after this, maybe a month, called the Old Hoffman. ⁓ it's a six year old double oaked bourbon. ⁓ same thing, sixty-five bucks. Limit three. I did buy three. I'm gonna 'cause I was like I'm gonna have to start going on and the notes on that one are crazy. The website. It's like yeah, so sign up. If you want to know when it's getting released, follow old Hoffman Distillery or excuse me, old Commonwealth Distillery on Instagram. That's where I follow them. But you can also sign up for their their ⁓ their mailing list, right? They'll give you a heads up. I it's almost they usually give you like a two or three week notice that something's dropping. They don't tell you what day, they're just be aware. Just order it. And then I think about a week in advance, they tell you the exact date, the time, the price. Nice. ⁓ but they do a phenomenal job with the marketing. ⁓ there's a gentleman I I should have taken his note down, but if you go on YouTube or Instagram and just search Old Commonwealth Distillery, ⁓ it's ⁓ I don't know if he's like an author or storyteller, but he he does a really good job of painting this picture of what old Commonwealth Distillery is, and I feel bad that I didn't Look up his name to start the podcast. If it's you, please leave your comment or name in the comment section. Yeah, I'm excited about what they're doing. I know they're sourcing ⁓ all their all their whiskies, but the the fact that they're reviving the brands and the labels specifically, ⁓ you know, down to like the old Commonwealth bottle that they came out with. Julian Van Winkle used to bottle in a green glass. They're bottling it in a green glass in a in an ode to that old liquid. We know that it's not a weeded stutzel weller. It's a traditional rye bash bill bourbon now. But who knows? They may come out with a weeded in the future and let's hope they do. We love weeded around here. Exactly. So any what you're the rye guy. Final thoughts. Final thoughts on this is that sixty five dollars you should buy a case. Easy, easy enough. ⁓ it's a great it's a great pour. Tons of flavor for a seven-year-old rye. I would expect this out of a twelve, thirteen year old. Yeah. nose is great, flavor's great. I just wish you had more now, but Absolutely. And for the other two guys that weren't here today that couldn't unfortunately make it, ⁓ we have two bottles that are unopened and please hurry. We got some we got some future ones to try. I think the ⁓ what was I gonna say? ⁓ I had a funny quirp. And I it'll come to you. It'll come to me after we stop recording, which is which is great. ⁓ but yeah, no, Red Top Rye, if you can get it. ⁓ that's what I was gonna say. Hopefully they don't pull a Julian Van Winkle and only release it one time. ⁓ yeah. Let's hope it's not another ten, twenty years for the next release. I don't think it will be. ⁓ the old Commonwealth b ⁓ bottles, I know those are like a once a year release, I believe. ⁓ but these two, these two other bottles, Red Top Rye and Old Hoffman, they're brand new releases. I think they plan to continue to release them in the future. ⁓ so sign up. If you're interested in trying it, sign up on the website, get it on the mailing list. Please. Do whatever you can to get a bottle of that. If you like rise, I think you'll love this rye. If you don't like rise and you're just a bourbon person, enjoy this rye. I think this one is a great introductory rye. Yeah. It's soft on the On the front, you'll get that definitely get that rye at the end, mid to late palette, but it's very soft, very inviting. Uncommonly sweet for a rye. Very, yeah, yeah. Well, perfect. Appreciate you joining me for this. I'm glad you enjoyed enjoyed the whiskey. we'll see you very soon for another episode on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. See y'all soon. Cheers.