Latest / Surrounded / Are Conservatives the Snowflakes Now? | Isaiah Martin Surrounded Follow-Up
Transcript
- 0:00Aside from the content of the debates themselves,
- 0:02do you ever feel like you're,
- 0:04you're going too much for the jugular with people though?
- 0:07Facts are relentless,
- 0:09and that's just how they are.
- 0:10I think that in this country we've done too much playing around
- 0:13when people say
- 0:15objective
- 0:16mistruths.
- 0:17And so look,
- 0:18no,
- 0:18I don't.
- 0:19It's really clear that the Republicans
- 0:21are always spewing out misinformation,
- 0:23and I think the only way to beat that is very strong counters and rebuttals.
- 0:27So,
- 0:27uh,
- 0:28you know,
- 0:28sucks to suck,
- 0:29I guess.
- 0:30I'm here with Isaiah Martin.
- 0:32Uh,
- 0:33Isaiah,
- 0:33welcome to the follow-up and thanks for being in surrounded.
- 0:37Absolutely,
- 0:38it was such a great time.
- 0:39I really enjoyed it.
- 0:41Was it a great time?
- 0:42Uh,
- 0:42you know,
- 0:43I,
- 0:43I know it can be a little taxing.
- 0:46No,
- 0:46I mean,
- 0:47it was great.
- 0:47I mean,
- 0:48honestly,
- 0:48uh,
- 0:49you know,
- 0:49debating is what I like to do and,
- 0:51uh,
- 0:51these guys,
- 0:52they didn't really,
- 0:53uh,
- 0:54put too much fire in my view.
- 0:55So,
- 0:56you know,
- 0:56it was really just going out there,
- 0:57speaking the facts and,
- 0:59you know,
- 0:59getting out there.
- 1:00It was really fun.
- 1:01Yeah,
- 1:02well,
- 1:02we,
- 1:02on behalf of Jubilee,
- 1:03you know,
- 1:04thanks for jumping into the arena.
- 1:06And
- 1:07I actually wanna give you,
- 1:08you know,
- 1:08in your intro in the episode,
- 1:10You say you're a former uh congressional candidate,
- 1:14but I wanted you
- 1:15to have the opportunity to kind of just,
- 1:17you know,
- 1:18add a little bit more to that,
- 1:19like what has been your,
- 1:21what are your political aspirations and,
- 1:23and,
- 1:23you know,
- 1:24what's,
- 1:24what's sort of your background in running for Congress and
- 1:27are you planning on,
- 1:28on running again?
- 1:30Yeah,
- 1:31well,
- 1:31I know for me,
- 1:32uh,
- 1:32I got started in politics because I got frustrated with,
- 1:35uh,
- 1:36waiting in 4-hour long lines,
- 1:37uh,
- 1:38to go vote.
- 1:38Our governor
- 1:39had made things really difficult,
- 1:41so I got to work,
- 1:42turned our college football stadium into a polling site,
- 1:44and
- 1:45beat the heck out of the Republicans and got a 4-hour long wait time down to
- 1:49about 5 minutes on election day.
- 1:51And it's that kind of energy that,
- 1:53you know,
- 1:54propelled me to continue to keep going.
- 1:55I met a mentor,
- 1:56Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee,
- 1:58who was a really
- 1:59influential person in my life.
- 2:00She took me underneath her wing
- 2:02and uh really spent a lot of time with her learning how to do things,
- 2:05learning how
- 2:06uh the Congress works,
- 2:07learning how
- 2:08to really
- 2:09become productive in politics.
- 2:11So
- 2:11all that's kind of led me to this moment,
- 2:13you know,
- 2:13ran for Congress in this open seat that we had
- 2:16didn't go the way that I wanted,
- 2:17but now
- 2:18You know,
- 2:18I'm really just kind of focused on,
- 2:20you know,
- 2:20getting out and telling our message as Democrats
- 2:23as we're the party that can make life more affordable for people,
- 2:25the party with the best policies,
- 2:27um,
- 2:28and really kind of show a roadmap of where to go
- 2:31in 2026 for the midterms as well as 2028.
- 2:34So,
- 2:35uh,
- 2:35I'm excited about the future that's ahead of us.
- 2:38Mhm.
- 2:39I wanna hear more of your thoughts about
- 2:41the future of the Democratic Party,
- 2:43future of American politics,
- 2:44but,
- 2:45uh,
- 2:46first,
- 2:46I think we'll,
- 2:47we'll get there by reacting to,
- 2:48to your appearance and surrounded.
- 2:50I'm curious,
- 2:51um,
- 2:52what was the experience like,
- 2:54uh,
- 2:54filming the debate,
- 2:55um,
- 2:56and,
- 2:57and how did you feel going into it,
- 2:58and now how do you feel,
- 3:00you know,
- 3:00seeing it out in the world,
- 3:02um,
- 3:03as kind of like a finished product.
- 3:06Yeah,
- 3:06you know,
- 3:06I,
- 3:07I played sports growing up,
- 3:08so,
- 3:08you know,
- 3:08it kind of felt like going into a game,
- 3:10um,
- 3:11really kind of felt like going into an arena full of,
- 3:15uh,
- 3:15folks that
- 3:16don't want you to succeed and,
- 3:18uh,
- 3:19doing what's possible to,
- 3:21uh,
- 3:21to overcome that,
- 3:22you know,
- 3:22I really was kind of my
- 3:24mentality to prepare as much as I could before
- 3:26and to get in there and keep a very calm
- 3:29composure and just Hit back with facts.
- 3:32And I think that that's what people have been really seeing,
- 3:34you know,
- 3:34across the internet
- 3:35is,
- 3:36uh,
- 3:36I've really made sure to use the facts
- 3:38against these guys and you could see oftentimes
- 3:41the Republicans would start sweating cause they,
- 3:43uh,
- 3:43they don't really have very many facts.
- 3:45So
- 3:45I mean,
- 3:46look,
- 3:46it was a,
- 3:46it was a really good experience.
- 3:47I enjoyed it
- 3:48and,
- 3:49uh,
- 3:491010 times out of 10.
- 3:510 great.
- 3:52Well,
- 3:52don't feel pressured to,
- 3:54uh,
- 3:55To,
- 3:55uh,
- 3:56I'm serious.
- 3:57Thank you.
- 3:57I'm,
- 3:57I'm glad to hear it,
- 3:58and it's fun to watch,
- 4:00you know,
- 4:00I had,
- 4:01um,
- 4:01I actually hadn't heard of you prior to you appearing in the show.
- 4:05Um,
- 4:06I think,
- 4:06you know,
- 4:06when you were running,
- 4:07I think
- 4:08you crossed my newsfeed once or twice,
- 4:10but I hadn't kind of connected the dot dots of who you were and what,
- 4:13you know,
- 4:13your,
- 4:14your background was,
- 4:15and so it was cool to see you go to toe,
- 4:17toe to toe with them.
- 4:18And,
- 4:19you know,
- 4:19I think my,
- 4:20I know Jubilee's aspirations and my hope for the
- 4:22show is like it can really be a platform to
- 4:26find new voices or emerging voices in politics,
- 4:29stress test them,
- 4:31and launch them into the mainstream because if you can handle,
- 4:34you know,
- 4:3520 people coming at you like you're saying,
- 4:37in,
- 4:37in almost like a sports
- 4:39kind of intensity.
- 4:40They don't want you to win,
- 4:41they're bringing everything they've got
- 4:43to you.
- 4:44I think my hope is that that
- 4:46that strengthens
- 4:48uh and raises the bar of of public discourse.
- 4:51So
- 4:52speaking of,
- 4:52of facts,
- 4:53uh,
- 4:54you and Dennis right off the bat,
- 4:55and I don't know if this is how it happened when you guys recorded it,
- 4:58but like right off the bat in the episode,
- 5:01there's a
- 5:02stark disagreement
- 5:03around.
- 5:05Immigration,
- 5:06ICE,
- 5:07what kind of people are being deported right now?
- 5:09So I'm gonna replay you that and,
- 5:11and we'll kind of dig into.
- 5:12According to the DHS,
- 5:1370% of the people who have been deported so far
- 5:16have been criminals,
- 5:17either caught in the act,
- 5:18yes.
- 5:19I'm surprised you're surprised.
- 5:21You ran for Congress and you don't know this.
- 5:23That's what those numbers said.
- 5:24That is 70%.
- 5:25The other 30% are people who went through the entire immigration process
- 5:28and had some sort of deportation attainer.
- 5:31So that is a 700,
- 5:33700%,
- 5:33700,000 people
- 5:35were deported like that.
- 5:361.9 million people self-deported
- 5:39so far.
- 5:39That's all DHS data.
- 5:41It's publicly available,
- 5:41you can look it up.
- 5:43So I'm just,
- 5:44how are you standing for criminals?
- 5:45Is that what you're doing right now of interior removals,
- 5:4770% of the people deported have literally have not been convicted criminals.
- 5:50What are you talking about?
- 5:51That's according to DHS.
- 5:52That's according to DHS.
- 5:54Where are you getting your data from?
- 5:55DHS?
- 5:56What day?
- 5:57Uh,
- 5:57this is like just recently,
- 5:59last from up to October or mid-October of this year.
- 6:01So we're gonna need a fact check on this because I literally checked yesterday.
- 6:05Not convicted criminals.
- 6:0570% of the people deported are not convicted criminals under interior.
- 6:09They were people,
- 6:10so
- 6:11they were people that had.
- 6:13Either been convicted criminals
- 6:15or they had.
- 6:17We're like at a stalemate because now you're claiming something.
- 6:19I'm claiming something from the same source.
- 6:20So 70%
- 6:22of the people that have been deported
- 6:23under interior removals are not convicted criminals,
- 6:26and that is a fact.
- 6:28That's not a fact.
- 6:30It goes on quite a bit,
- 6:32um,
- 6:33with Dennis.
- 6:34What's going on with Dennis,
- 6:35Isaiah?
- 6:37You know,
- 6:38I,
- 6:38I,
- 6:39it was really interesting to me because he came out with a lot of energy.
- 6:43And I really couldn't understand how somebody
- 6:46with that much confidence could be so wrong,
- 6:49you know,
- 6:49in his claim.
- 6:50And so it was very interesting,
- 6:52I think,
- 6:52to
- 6:53watch him go about that,
- 6:54you know,
- 6:54I think he came from the jump,
- 6:56trying to figure out if he could spark some type of confrontation.
- 6:59And as I
- 7:00later told him in the uh in the exchange,
- 7:03one of us is going to go viral here
- 7:05when this fact check.
- 7:05Comes out.
- 7:06And it's definitely not going to be me.
- 7:08And I think that uh the people now that the things have gone out have seen that,
- 7:11you know,
- 7:12Dennis was wrong on that one.
- 7:13But,
- 7:13you know,
- 7:14I think it's just,
- 7:14this is what he's been,
- 7:16you know,
- 7:16he did throughout the episode.
- 7:17I think people
- 7:18will get a good kick out of just watching,
- 7:20I think the discourse that went on.
- 7:22And uh like I said,
- 7:24facts don't really care about feelings.
- 7:26And uh
- 7:27it was proven
- 7:28by the fact check.
- 7:30Yeah,
- 7:30so,
- 7:31uh,
- 7:31and just to kinda let the listener know,
- 7:33you know,
- 7:34the fact check that appears in the episode um supports
- 7:38what you're saying.
- 7:39Um,
- 7:40I did my own digging and tried to see if there was,
- 7:43you know,
- 7:44maybe a misconstrued
- 7:46or,
- 7:46or a separate study that Dennis was referring to that he kind of got mixed up with.
- 7:50I couldn't find anything um
- 7:53to support the numbers that he was throwing out there.
- 7:56And so,
- 7:57Yeah,
- 7:58I mean,
- 7:58what do you think about
- 8:00just the information landscape that we're in right now,
- 8:03where
- 8:04two people come head to head in a debate as uh,
- 8:06you know,
- 8:06as visible as this,
- 8:08and it's just like a fundamental disagreement on what
- 8:12the data
- 8:13actually bears out as truth.
- 8:15Um,
- 8:17what do we do about that?
- 8:18Is it something you
- 8:20see recurring in,
- 8:21in your debates and discussions with people?
- 8:24Well,
- 8:24to be honest with you,
- 8:24I think that's why Jubilee is so important
- 8:27is because
- 8:29when people go viral for just having the wrong information like that,
- 8:33I think it really builds on all of us,
- 8:36uh,
- 8:36to remember,
- 8:37it's important to check your facts.
- 8:39Because the thing about Jubilee is very high stakes.
- 8:42And if you go out there and you start spewing stuff and you get fact checked,
- 8:44you know,
- 8:45there's millions of people that are going to see that and say,
- 8:47oh,
- 8:47wow,
- 8:47you know,
- 8:48that's not
- 8:48a good thing.
- 8:49So I think that,
- 8:50that
- 8:51having,
- 8:52you know,
- 8:52these types of discussions are important because people can see all
- 8:55kinds of disinformation that gets thrown out there into the stratosphere.
- 8:58And when it's pushed back against very vigorously,
- 9:01um,
- 9:01I think that kind of helps spread the
- 9:03correct information to as many people as possible.
- 9:06Mhm.
- 9:07Yeah,
- 9:07and you know,
- 9:08what's interesting about the comments on this video,
- 9:10you know,
- 9:10this interaction with Dennis,
- 9:12it's one of those unusual instances where like the very first debate,
- 9:15the very first encounter is kind of uh
- 9:17what everyone's talking about in the comments,
- 9:19and there was actually,
- 9:21you know,
- 9:21a popular comment that was like,
- 9:23we need real-time fact checks,
- 9:25um,
- 9:26and they want,
- 9:27you know,
- 9:27a moderator or,
- 9:28or some sort of engines
- 9:30stopping the conversation in the moment
- 9:32and being like,
- 9:33verifying a claim.
- 9:36Technologically speaking,
- 9:37that's something I've actually always,
- 9:38uh,
- 9:39envisioned or imagined being possible.
- 9:43You know,
- 9:43kind of like,
- 9:44uh,
- 9:44being there on set,
- 9:45it is kind of hard to think about how you would integrate that and how that
- 9:48could sort of derail things
- 9:51right away,
- 9:51but it's,
- 9:52it's an interesting kind of prospect.
- 9:54But what was,
- 9:55and I,
- 9:55I,
- 9:56I,
- 9:56I,
- 9:57you know,
- 9:57I,
- 9:57I kind of wanna hear Dennis's side of the story,
- 9:59but like,
- 10:00he chose to really like double down and just kind of deny.
- 10:04The validity of what you're saying altogether.
- 10:05Well,
- 10:06and we'll,
- 10:06we'll revisit,
- 10:07you know,
- 10:07you guys kind of,
- 10:08you went full circle,
- 10:09pulled them back into the center at the end,
- 10:11but
- 10:11what's going on there,
- 10:13uh,
- 10:13from your perspective?
- 10:15You know,
- 10:15I,
- 10:16it was one of those things I think that he was really,
- 10:18really set on that one specific point.
- 10:21And you know,
- 10:22he
- 10:23was going to try to go for it for the very end.
- 10:26And I think it was a very high stakes risk,
- 10:28right?
- 10:28Because look,
- 10:29if he would have turned out to be right,
- 10:30then I would have been the one that would have been mocked all over the
- 10:32lives of TikTok and
- 10:34all these different
- 10:35uh political accounts.
- 10:36So I think he was just Trying to make a gamble there.
- 10:39Um,
- 10:40it was a wrong gamble.
- 10:41And I knew in the back of my mind,
- 10:43because I had read over that data numerous times that I was correct.
- 10:46And so that's why I was willing to not let him change the subject,
- 10:50but to stay focused
- 10:51and to kind of let him hit a stalemate and say,
- 10:54look,
- 10:54OK,
- 10:54well,
- 10:55that's your position.
- 10:55Well,
- 10:56I guess the internet will,
- 10:57will pick a winner here.
- 10:58And I knew it wasn't going to be him,
- 11:01you know.
- 11:01Well,
- 11:02yeah,
- 11:02and he's,
- 11:03you know,
- 11:03he's running for Congress as well
- 11:05in California.
- 11:06I'm actually not sure at the time that was recording,
- 11:08I'm not sure where we are in that race.
- 11:10Um,
- 11:11so I have to kind of do some digging there,
- 11:13but
- 11:14From your perspective,
- 11:16I'm gonna kind of steel man the kernel of what
- 11:19I'm hearing coming from Dennis and,
- 11:21and what I,
- 11:22you know,
- 11:22the vibey argument I'm picking up is that Democrats are the party that
- 11:28supports criminals.
- 11:30Um,
- 11:30that's kind of like the,
- 11:31the subtextual claim there.
- 11:33And you know,
- 11:33I see that a lot on the internet and
- 11:36You know,
- 11:37you,
- 11:37even if you watch the Grammys last night,
- 11:39you know,
- 11:39you hear someone like Billie Eilish,
- 11:41kind of a pop culture figure
- 11:43on the left saying,
- 11:44you know,
- 11:44nobody
- 11:45is illegal on stolen land.
- 11:47And so,
- 11:48there's this caricature which I think is sometimes valid
- 11:51of the left being
- 11:53the party that wants open borders,
- 11:55that doesn't want to enforce laws,
- 11:57that
- 11:58has almost a suicidal
- 12:01level of empathy
- 12:03for criminals
- 12:04to the point where
- 12:05it
- 12:06It creates kind of a degradation of law and order
- 12:09and,
- 12:10and order in society.
- 12:12Do you think there's validity there?
- 12:13Do you think Democrats,
- 12:14even if Dennis's facts were wrong,
- 12:17do you think there's validity in that claim that Dems
- 12:20have kind of missed the mark when it comes to
- 12:23communicating a clear message on
- 12:25law and order and,
- 12:26and what,
- 12:28what kind of laws we need to enforce versus not?
- 12:31Well,
- 12:31I think that
- 12:33that is often uh an attack that Republicans use,
- 12:35but it,
- 12:36it really doesn't have that much substance,
- 12:38largely because
- 12:39I know in Congress there's been work from Congresswoman Veronica
- 12:41Escobar to push the Dignity Act that she worked with
- 12:44Congresswoman Maria Alvera Salazar of Florida.
- 12:46There's been a lot of proposals and
- 12:48Republicans have blocked nearly every single one.
- 12:50So,
- 12:50I mean,
- 12:51I think that when it comes to,
- 12:52you know,
- 12:53border security,
- 12:53I'm a big supporter of border security.
- 12:56I think that those things
- 12:57are not mutually exclusive.
- 12:59You can have strong borders while also saying that we want a pathway to citizenship.
- 13:03And I talk a lot of times on TikTok Live that I say that for those
- 13:07people that are in this country that are undocumented.
- 13:10And
- 13:10they agree to pay every single tax,
- 13:12state,
- 13:12federal,
- 13:12and local,
- 13:13and
- 13:14they agree to pay an extra tax of 7% for 7 years.
- 13:18They haven't committed a crime inside the United States or elsewhere.
- 13:21At the end of that,
- 13:21they get American citizenship.
- 13:23It'll create billions of dollars for us that we can use to invest
- 13:26in.
- 13:27Trade programs for our kids and will also help
- 13:29millions of people that are undocumented come completely out of the shadows.
- 13:33And I think that that's something that's going to
- 13:34be able to benefit everybody in this country.
- 13:36Now you can push a policy like that
- 13:38while also saying we're going to enforce our laws
- 13:40and have a strong border similar to the way that Barack Obama did.
- 13:43So,
- 13:44um,
- 13:45I think that President Obama had a very strong,
- 13:47you know,
- 13:47track record on that issue,
- 13:49and I think that,
- 13:50you know,
- 13:50Bill Clinton had a strong track record on that issue.
- 13:53The belief that Democrats
- 13:54do not support a strong border,
- 13:55I think is a lie that's been made up by Republicans,
- 13:58and we need to look more forward on how we're going to actually fix it.
- 14:01Republicans have no solutions whatsoever
- 14:03on how to fix,
- 14:04um,
- 14:04the,
- 14:05the immigration system in this country,
- 14:07and I think that that was a reoccurring theme that we saw in Jubilee.
- 14:11Mhm.
- 14:12Yeah,
- 14:12you mentioned,
- 14:13you know,
- 14:13the way Obama uh enforced immigration and
- 14:16I remember at the time,
- 14:18hearing a lot of pushback,
- 14:19you know,
- 14:20he's the deporter in chief or something like that,
- 14:22um,
- 14:23because of the number of deportations that were happening.
- 14:25And I've seen a lot of clips of
- 14:27the way,
- 14:28um,
- 14:28Obama,
- 14:29when he was a candidate for president,
- 14:31talked about enforcing immigration and,
- 14:34and the status of illegal immigrants in the US.
- 14:36Those are kind of going viral now because it
- 14:38You know,
- 14:39a lot of people are saying this sounds really reasonable,
- 14:42uh,
- 14:42compared to what we're seeing
- 14:43in the world right now.
- 14:45Um,
- 14:46what do you think about how Biden and,
- 14:48and Harris,
- 14:49this came up in the episode and,
- 14:51and you said,
- 14:51you know,
- 14:51I'm not,
- 14:52I'm not defending everything Biden did.
- 14:54Do you think they fell really short,
- 14:56um,
- 14:57with how they enforce border security?
- 14:59Is that something that,
- 15:00uh,
- 15:00you think Dems need to own more publicly to kind of create more distance?
- 15:05I mean,
- 15:05I know that,
- 15:06that,
- 15:06you know,
- 15:06we were at a time in which we were recovering from a once-in a generation pandemic.
- 15:11Immigration started to increase at the end of Trump's term.
- 15:14We saw that,
- 15:14we could literally see a speech from Chip Roy,
- 15:17where he's literally talking about all the influx of
- 15:20undocumented immigrants that were coming across the
- 15:22border at the end of Trump's presidency.
- 15:24And that continued.
- 15:25You know,
- 15:25the Biden administration tried to get legislation across the finish line,
- 15:28um,
- 15:28but the Republicans ultimately filibustered it.
- 15:30That would have put,
- 15:31you know,
- 15:32a lot more resources towards that area.
- 15:34Um,
- 15:34and we saw immigration numbers come down towards the end of Biden's term.
- 15:37I think that ultimately
- 15:39what we need to be looking forward to
- 15:41is
- 15:42what the future looks like.
- 15:43And personally,
- 15:44I think that again,
- 15:45it's got to have to be something
- 15:47that's going to create something that's a real pathway for people.
- 15:49It's something that
- 15:50puts a lot of dollars towards enforcement.
- 15:53And I know that Democrats um can see that moving forward.
- 15:56Um.
- 15:57As well.
- 15:57So I mean,
- 15:58look,
- 15:58I,
- 15:58I don't agree with,
- 15:59with everything that
- 16:00was done by Biden personally.
- 16:02Um,
- 16:03you know,
- 16:04I'm a big believer in getting rid of the filibuster.
- 16:06I would have got rid of it to pass that,
- 16:08uh,
- 16:08immigration proposal so we could actually get a real,
- 16:11you know,
- 16:11solution down there.
- 16:12But,
- 16:12you know,
- 16:13it was a disagreement,
- 16:14and I think that as I kind of talked about on Jubilee,
- 16:16uh,
- 16:17that,
- 16:17you know,
- 16:18sometimes you have disagreements with politicians,
- 16:19and that's just kind of how it goes.
- 16:21Yeah.
- 16:22Yeah,
- 16:2311 more thing I kind of want to hit on with immigration.
- 16:26Are you familiar with like David Sachs and the All In podcast?
- 16:30I haven't heard it.
- 16:31No,
- 16:31no worries,
- 16:32no worries.
- 16:33David Sachs,
- 16:34I mean,
- 16:34he's in the,
- 16:35the current Trump administration,
- 16:36but he's got a very popular podcast.
- 16:38He's made the claim,
- 16:39and I've heard it circulate that,
- 16:40you know,
- 16:42Democrats will
- 16:43benefit from
- 16:45the presence of,
- 16:46um,
- 16:47undocumented people
- 16:49in blue cities because of
- 16:52it boosts census numbers and so he thinks that,
- 16:54you know,
- 16:55he,
- 16:55he makes the claim that,
- 16:56you know,
- 16:57Democrats want.
- 16:58A porous border
- 17:00and they want sanctuary
- 17:01cities because it,
- 17:02it boosts
- 17:04um their representation and,
- 17:06and,
- 17:06and sway in government.
- 17:07What,
- 17:07what do you think about claims like that?
- 17:09Is that why the Republicans were bussing undocumented people to blue states?
- 17:15Right,
- 17:15well,
- 17:15I think that was,
- 17:17I think that's a fair pushback.
- 17:19I think that was
- 17:20a different form of political theater that was meant to
- 17:24sort of be like,
- 17:25you deal with it,
- 17:26but you know,
- 17:28I mean,
- 17:28but if that's what they were worried about,
- 17:30then wouldn't they keep them in Texas and Arizona and all these other places?
- 17:33It's amazing how Republicans have such cognitive dissonance because,
- 17:37you know,
- 17:37I remember a time where they were trying to get them out.
- 17:39So now they're saying that blue states want them because.
- 17:42Uh,
- 17:43of political advantages.
- 17:45I mean,
- 17:45that's just pathetic.
- 17:46I mean,
- 17:46I think that,
- 17:47you know,
- 17:47Republicans
- 17:48always come up with these arguments that coincide with each other and,
- 17:52you know,
- 17:52it seems like that's what David Sachs is trying to do there.
- 17:56Mhm.
- 17:57Yeah,
- 17:57well,
- 17:57thank you for,
- 17:58for
- 17:58touching on that.
- 18:00I'm gonna pull up the next clip.
- 18:02Well,
- 18:02you know,
- 18:02you talked about corporate taxes because that's what Kamala Harris ran on.
- 18:05She ran on raising the corporate taxes and raising the effective gains tax.
- 18:08Can you at least acknowledge that
- 18:10that is just
- 18:10economically suicidal for our country and would result in businesses
- 18:14slashing jobs and leaving our countries in droves?
- 18:16You know what the,
- 18:17the top corporate tax rate was in the 1990s when Bill Clinton
- 18:20had the largest peacetime expansion of the American economy on record,
- 18:2335%.
- 18:24Higher than what it was now.
- 18:25Do you know what they've affected corporate tax rate?
- 18:27Do you know what,
- 18:28do you know,
- 18:29do you know what the,
- 18:30do you know what the effective corporate tax rate was when
- 18:32Barack Obama had 74 straight months of job growth in America?
- 18:35Do you know when that was?
- 18:37Um,
- 18:37I know that we,
- 18:38it was,
- 18:38I know that we,
- 18:39when we slashed the corporate tax rates in 2017,
- 18:43that we had record job growth under Donald Trump going up you know what it was?
- 18:45What was it?
- 18:46It was 35%.
- 18:47So when these mass.
- 18:49Periods of time in which we've had so much job growth in this country,
- 18:52millions,
- 18:52tens of millions of jobs created in this country.
- 18:54We had a 35% corporate tax rate.
- 18:56And then when we cut it again,
- 18:58there was even more job growth under the first Trump term.
- 19:00And not what happened.
- 19:01The rate of job growth literally declined right after that.
- 19:04We just continued on a trend and then it literally smoothed a little bit.
- 19:06That's kind of what happened.
- 19:07Uh,
- 19:07no,
- 19:08we had,
- 19:08we had record job growth under President Trump from 2017 up until the start of COVID.
- 19:12That's just simply not true.
- 19:14I hear this claim a lot
- 19:16when
- 19:16the topic of the economy comes up
- 19:19and Democrats approach to it
- 19:21that
- 19:22You know,
- 19:24Democrats
- 19:24are bad for business.
- 19:26You know,
- 19:26they,
- 19:26they squash the economy.
- 19:28They,
- 19:29uh,
- 19:29they push,
- 19:30you know,
- 19:30and you,
- 19:30you heard this about,
- 19:31uh,
- 19:32Zoran Mamdani.
- 19:33I think we have to see
- 19:34how things play out,
- 19:35but
- 19:36businesses are gonna leave the cities.
- 19:38Um,
- 19:39wealth is gonna move
- 19:40out of the country.
- 19:41There's gonna be less jobs because companies,
- 19:44um,
- 19:44are gonna be more conservative about hiring because they have less money.
- 19:48Do you think,
- 19:49I don't think you think that's true,
- 19:50but how do Democrats message
- 19:52against that?
- 19:53And,
- 19:55and,
- 19:55and what is the right way for Democrats to message on
- 19:59how,
- 19:59how they can be strong with the economy?
- 20:02I think that the,
- 20:03the
- 20:04way to do it is just to ask people,
- 20:06do you think the economy was doing well in the 90s when Bill Clinton was president?
- 20:10Because if he did,
- 20:11we had a 35%
- 20:13top corporate tax rate.
- 20:14I mean we were hiring a lot of people.
- 20:16We had a lot of job growth that was happening.
- 20:18We had a lot of
- 20:19business growth that was happening.
- 20:20So many Fortune 500 companies were created during that time with a higher
- 20:24uh
- 20:24top corporate tax rate.
- 20:26You know,
- 20:26again,
- 20:2674 straight months of job growth under Barack Obama.
- 20:29The facts don't care about Republican tiers when it comes to this,
- 20:32and ultimately I think it's just a lie that
- 20:34the Republicans have pushed out for a very long time
- 20:37because,
- 20:38uh,
- 20:38the big companies that
- 20:40fund a lot of their campaigns really
- 20:42Don't want to see this,
- 20:43um,
- 20:44but what we do know is that
- 20:45after the tax cuts and Jobs Act,
- 20:47uh,
- 20:48was signed,
- 20:48we saw an increase in stock buybacks.
- 20:50We saw more private planes bought by these big corporations.
- 20:53We saw an increase in profits,
- 20:54stock market continued to increase,
- 20:56but we saw that
- 20:57the amount of money that they were investing in private
- 20:59sector manufacturing decrease under what it was under Barack Obama.
- 21:03That's not something that's very good.
- 21:05So
- 21:05ultimately,
- 21:06um,
- 21:07I think that we've got to be able to communicate
- 21:09the history of what we've been able to do,
- 21:11but then also talk about what,
- 21:12um,
- 21:13we will do in the future
- 21:14and,
- 21:14um,
- 21:15the benefits
- 21:16to
- 21:16make affordability better by raising the top
- 21:19corporate tax rate is definitely there.
- 21:22Um,
- 21:22that claim that Martin made at the end that there was record
- 21:25job growth,
- 21:26um,
- 21:26from 2017 to 2020,
- 21:27right before the pandemic.
- 21:29I did a little bit of digging and,
- 21:30you know,
- 21:32uh,
- 21:32it's obviously,
- 21:32it's a,
- 21:33it's a broad claim,
- 21:34but there was significant job,
- 21:36job growth in that period that he,
- 21:38um,
- 21:39Pointed out.
- 21:40And,
- 21:41you know,
- 21:41a,
- 21:41a big argument for Trump leading up to the last
- 21:45election was that Trump was great with the economy.
- 21:47He hadn't done the tariffs that we've seen this last year,
- 21:50but I mean,
- 21:51do you think
- 21:53Do you think Trump has done good things with the economy?
- 21:55Do you think his first term was,
- 21:57you know,
- 21:58before the pandemic,
- 22:00uh,
- 22:00you know,
- 22:01successful in,
- 22:01in generating growth?
- 22:02Because,
- 22:02you know,
- 22:03a lot of people try and kind of compare him to Reagan,
- 22:05this kind of deregulatory,
- 22:07um,
- 22:08president that,
- 22:09that,
- 22:10that opens up space
- 22:12for growth.
- 22:12Do you think that doesn't work?
- 22:13Do you think that's untrue?
- 22:16Well,
- 22:17I mean,
- 22:17but you got to look at what happened,
- 22:18what preceded Donald Trump,
- 22:20which was 74 straight months of job growth.
- 22:22I mean,
- 22:23when you have something that's going on a very strong trajectory,
- 22:26and then you see the rate of increase,
- 22:28decrease as a result of that,
- 22:30that's kind of what,
- 22:31you know,
- 22:31the point that I was
- 22:32making in that exchange.
- 22:33I think that ultimately,
- 22:34no,
- 22:35I don't think that
- 22:36an economy that was moving in a very strong direction.
- 22:39Um,
- 22:39that you effectively go give all these money
- 22:41to the richest people in America and you,
- 22:43you flew around on Trump Force One
- 22:45saying that you were going to bring all these big manufacturing jobs back,
- 22:48but those same companies,
- 22:49despite the fact that they were getting all this profit,
- 22:52were spending less on private sector manufacturing.
- 22:54I mean that's just how it is.
- 22:55So no,
- 22:56I don't think that Trump
- 22:57is some type of
- 22:59economic guru.
- 23:00I think he was somebody who benefited off of Barack Obama.
- 23:03Now traditionally what Republicans say is,
- 23:05well,
- 23:06in 2025,
- 23:08why is it that you don't make the same argument when it comes to Biden?
- 23:11Because the situations are vastly different.
- 23:13Trump inherited an economy where you had sub 2% inflation.
- 23:17He inherited an economy like I said with 74 straight
- 23:19months of job growth.
- 23:21When Biden got in office.
- 23:22He inherited
- 23:23$2.5 trillion printed into the economy as a result of the CARES Act.
- 23:27He inherited a once-in a-generation pandemic.
- 23:29It's a vastly different circumstances.
- 23:31Now this time that Trump is back in again.
- 23:33He inherited inflation that was going down,
- 23:35job growth that was going up,
- 23:37private sector manufacturing spend going up,
- 23:39and he ruined it all with a singular action,
- 23:42tariffs.
- 23:43He did a singular action that went and reversed all of these things.
- 23:46And so ultimately,
- 23:47I think that we've just got to be able to communicate,
- 23:49um,
- 23:50you know,
- 23:50the,
- 23:51the facts behind this.
- 23:52I don't believe that Trump has been some guru for the economy.
- 23:55I think his policies ultimately make us worse off.
- 23:57I think people are living with that today.
- 23:59Mhm.
- 24:02I remember,
- 24:03you know,
- 24:03when the tariff,
- 24:04what,
- 24:05what was it called,
- 24:05Liberation Day,
- 24:07um,
- 24:08it's,
- 24:09it's almost,
- 24:09we've almost had about a year of tariffs,
- 24:11um,
- 24:13the economy,
- 24:14or
- 24:14not the economy,
- 24:15the stock market
- 24:17had a,
- 24:17a pretty sizable recoil
- 24:20right at that point.
- 24:21And since then I've seen a lot of people,
- 24:24you know,
- 24:24maybe soften their
- 24:26opinions on
- 24:28Trump's tariff strategy,
- 24:30you know,
- 24:30pointing out that
- 24:32We didn't,
- 24:33we haven't seen as much inflation as was projected.
- 24:36We haven't seen um as much economic
- 24:39uh recoil
- 24:41as was feared,
- 24:42and also that,
- 24:44you know,
- 24:44this revenue,
- 24:45which there's a valid
- 24:48argument that it's really revenue that Americans are paying,
- 24:51um,
- 24:51is
- 24:53helping,
- 24:54you know,
- 24:54it,
- 24:54it's a,
- 24:55um,
- 24:55it's a
- 24:56positive thing
- 24:57that the government is,
- 24:58is collecting this tariff revenue.
- 25:00Uh,
- 25:01do you think there were,
- 25:02we were,
- 25:02there was maybe too much fear mongering around that tariff impact,
- 25:06or do you think it's still going to bear out?
- 25:09No,
- 25:09because the tariff,
- 25:10um,
- 25:11the tariff impact is still very much there
- 25:14because when you look at things
- 25:16and you realize that a lot of these companies had backdated a lot of inventory,
- 25:20right?
- 25:20So that's what makes a lot of this inflation
- 25:23take place a lot later
- 25:24than what it is.
- 25:25And we're also seeing that the American taxpayer has to subsidize
- 25:28now our farmers in our country because they're getting screwed.
- 25:31There's more farm bankruptcies in the first quarter of this year,
- 25:34of last year than all of the previous year combined.
- 25:37That's pretty terrible.
- 25:38That is not a good thing to be in.
- 25:40So our food prices are effectively being subsidized even more
- 25:44as a result of Trump's tariffs having to be in place.
- 25:47And if you were to ask those farmers out in Iowa,
- 25:49if you were to ask those people out
- 25:51across middle America if they would rather have the subsidies
- 25:54or if they would rather have the tariffs gone away,
- 25:57they would 100% say get rid of the tariffs.
- 25:59And in addition to that,
- 26:00look,
- 26:01I think that ultimately.
- 26:03When it comes to
- 26:05the state of where we are,
- 26:07we didn't need that.
- 26:09These tariffs were not something that were
- 26:11effective for us,
- 26:12and I think that ultimately people kind of see
- 26:14that direction when it comes to the $600 billion
- 26:17right,
- 26:17that,
- 26:18that they're bragging about when it comes to tariff revenue.
- 26:21You,
- 26:21you,
- 26:21you said,
- 26:22you know,
- 26:22that that's money that comes from all of us.
- 26:24So what they did was they,
- 26:25they basically allow for the richest corporations on earth to pay.
- 26:29Less money in taxes.
- 26:30They're allowing for
- 26:32the deficit to increase because of all the international boondoggles and all
- 26:36the stuff that they're using for rich people to get richer,
- 26:39and they're extracting more revenue
- 26:41from people
- 26:42like you and myself.
- 26:44All that's happening is that the tax burden has
- 26:46been shifted while the deficit continues to go up.
- 26:49They're taxing us.
- 26:49They're bragging about $600 billion while they go ahead
- 26:51and cut taxes for the richest people in America.
- 26:54They're paying less,
- 26:55but we're paying more.
- 26:56That's all it is.
- 26:57It is a way to transfer the tax burden onto the American people,
- 27:01and what's happening right now is that the richest people in the world,
- 27:04the richest people in America are getting richer
- 27:06while everyday people feel themselves getting screwed,
- 27:08and I think that's reflective
- 27:09every single day.
- 27:11Mhm.
- 27:12Well,
- 27:12and I,
- 27:12I mean,
- 27:13I will say
- 27:14I think time
- 27:15will continue to tell.
- 27:18You know,
- 27:19how much,
- 27:21how much
- 27:22that is,
- 27:22you know,
- 27:23is
- 27:23these tariffs are being reflected in inflation,
- 27:25you know,
- 27:26the cost of goods and services,
- 27:27it's,
- 27:27it's,
- 27:28it's gone up.
- 27:29There has been inflation,
- 27:30but it,
- 27:30it hasn't skyrocketed and like you said,
- 27:32you know,
- 27:33some of this was being kind of budgeted in,
- 27:36and so there's kind of a slow absorption effect.
- 27:38But then there's also this argument that these tariffs are
- 27:43giving the United States a ton of leverage
- 27:45to get better trade deals with,
- 27:47with,
- 27:48um,
- 27:49You know,
- 27:50foreign
- 27:51with other countries,
- 27:52and to kind of renegotiate top to bottom,
- 27:55what our trade relationships are with them.
- 27:58And,
- 27:58and I'm actually gonna play you a clip because you and Martin kept going.
- 28:01And
- 28:02this is about Canada specifically,
- 28:04but he kind of makes the,
- 28:05the argument that,
- 28:06you know,
- 28:07this,
- 28:07this is a leverage thing,
- 28:08like,
- 28:09you know,
- 28:09we,
- 28:10we tear up everything because
- 28:12That's just,
- 28:12that's just how the art of the deal.
- 28:14So let's watch that and then,
- 28:16you know,
- 28:16we can kind of dig into it a little more.
- 28:18This is what happens when you have conservative government.
- 28:20They're so sensitive.
- 28:21They're over here raising your prices because they
- 28:23had a commercial that you don't like.
- 28:25I mean tariffs don't raise prices.
- 28:26There was just,
- 28:27there was just a study I believe U Chicago that came out that tariffs actually don't.
- 28:31Raise the prices.
- 28:32Why would you go put tariffs on a country we had free,
- 28:37free FREE
- 28:39trade with?
- 28:40I think that we have a strategic advantage of
- 28:42having our lumber industry here in the United States.
- 28:44I don't want to be reliant upon Canada for lumber to,
- 28:47to go and achieve that aim.
- 28:50Yeah,
- 28:50it makes it more expensive for imports to come to the United
- 28:52States so that Americans that businesses can relocate back to America.
- 28:56So now if your disagreement was
- 28:58tariffs
- 28:59on lumber,
- 29:01your answer now is for tariffs
- 29:03on everything.
- 29:04Again,
- 29:05yeah,
- 29:05you want to establish leverage for future trade agreements.
- 29:07That,
- 29:07that's how,
- 29:08that's how trade agreements work.
- 29:09That's how negotiations work.
- 29:10And the leverage is
- 29:12to go and charge for something you are getting largely for free.
- 29:17Again,
- 29:17because you want to have a strategic advantage of making it in the United States,
- 29:20obviously.
- 29:24That was probably the most animated I think you,
- 29:26you might have gotten.
- 29:28Um,
- 29:30yeah.
- 29:31What,
- 29:34what are you seeing happening there,
- 29:35Isaiah?
- 29:38Well,
- 29:38uh,
- 29:39you know,
- 29:39I,
- 29:42The conservatives always seem to trip themselves up
- 29:45with the tariffs when it comes to Canada
- 29:48because we had free trade.
- 29:50It was free.
- 29:52And so they are really celebrating us having to
- 29:55pay more for something we were getting for free.
- 29:58And so I think that for the vast majority of Americans when they listen to that,
- 30:02they say,
- 30:03well,
- 30:05how is it making America great to pay for something we weren't paying for?
- 30:09And I think that ultimately,
- 30:10you know,
- 30:11that's kind of
- 30:12what people are seeing,
- 30:13uh,
- 30:13you know,
- 30:13look,
- 30:13I think that he,
- 30:15he was trying his best,
- 30:16and,
- 30:17um,
- 30:18you know,
- 30:18it's what the conservatives use an argument all the time,
- 30:21but,
- 30:22um,
- 30:22I don't think it really landed there
- 30:23at all.
- 30:25There was something,
- 30:26there was,
- 30:26there was a direction.
- 30:28There's kind of an implied argument that
- 30:30he didn't build on,
- 30:31which was,
- 30:32and this is kind of tied to,
- 30:34you know,
- 30:34I've heard kind of arguments that like,
- 30:36you know,
- 30:37austerity is needed in the United States and we
- 30:39need to kind of like tighten our belts and,
- 30:40and
- 30:41And these tariffs are incentivizing American businesses to build.
- 30:47Um,
- 30:48and,
- 30:49and,
- 30:49you know,
- 30:49bring back some manufacturing and,
- 30:51and some kind of more fundamental economic activity
- 30:54to the United States because it's gonna,
- 30:56you know,
- 30:57there's gonna be a financial incentive to do that because if you're importing,
- 31:00it's gonna be more expensive.
- 31:02Uh,
- 31:02you push back,
- 31:03you're like,
- 31:04you know,
- 31:04is that
- 31:05really gonna happen?
- 31:07But I mean,
- 31:08this is something I've heard a lot.
- 31:09Do you,
- 31:09do you think the US needs more manufacturing onshore,
- 31:12Whether or not this is the right way to go about it?
- 31:16Well,
- 31:16uh,
- 31:17it,
- 31:17it depends on what sector,
- 31:18right?
- 31:19So for example,
- 31:20I support a lot of the high,
- 31:21high growth,
- 31:22uh,
- 31:22high wage,
- 31:23uh,
- 31:23manufacturing that we've been able to create.
- 31:25So like,
- 31:25for example,
- 31:26um,
- 31:27the semiconductor
- 31:29manu manufacturing that we've been able to push,
- 31:30it's done a really good job.
- 31:31I've been really proud of microchip.
- 31:33Oh,
- 31:34that is the semiconductor,
- 31:35but anyway,
- 31:36um,
- 31:36I'm proud of the,
- 31:37uh,
- 31:37clean energy that we've been able to develop as a result.
- 31:40You know,
- 31:40there's so many things that we've been able to solar panels,
- 31:42uh,
- 31:42that we've been pushing.
- 31:43Here
- 31:44in America.
- 31:44All of those things are really good for us,
- 31:46you know,
- 31:47and later on,
- 31:47we're gonna also need more energy,
- 31:49so that means more nuclear power.
- 31:50All of those things I think
- 31:51is going to be really good important jobs that we can
- 31:53bring right here to America that's going to pay our workers
- 31:56a lot of money.
- 31:57But what that does not mean
- 31:58is trying to go and bring every single good that we get from overseas back to America.
- 32:05You know,
- 32:05our economy does not really benefit when we're saying that,
- 32:08you know,
- 32:09we're going to go get
- 32:10every Mattel.
- 32:11Doll that's made to be manufactured right here in America,
- 32:14when we can say,
- 32:15look,
- 32:15we want those workers instead working on energy production.
- 32:18We want them instead working on semiconductors.
- 32:20And so
- 32:21the tariffs I don't believe are going to be effective
- 32:23for us because all it's going to do across the board
- 32:26is raise the costs
- 32:27that everyday Americans are going to have to pay.
- 32:30And I don't think that's good at all.
- 32:32I know that,
- 32:32you know,
- 32:33one of the early things that I learned
- 32:35uh in economics is that
- 32:37if you go tell people
- 32:39This particular good was made in this country and this one was made in another.
- 32:42Would you pay more for it if you found out that
- 32:45it was an American good?
- 32:46And the vast majority of Americans don't say that.
- 32:49They just want what's more affordable.
- 32:51So I think instead,
- 32:52we need to be more focused on high wage,
- 32:54high growth jobs that can pay American workers more money
- 32:58to grow the manufacturing sector.
- 32:59We did that when Joe Biden was In office with the
- 33:03uh inflation Reduction Act,
- 33:04with the Made in America executive order,
- 33:06that's the stuff that led to
- 33:08a massive increase in private sector manufacturing spend that hired,
- 33:11that's going to hire
- 33:12a lot more workers into the future.
- 33:14Um,
- 33:14so ultimately what I believe in is an
- 33:16America that does build on American manufacturing,
- 33:19but one that does it
- 33:20moving forward into the future with high growth sectors.
- 33:23Mhm.
- 33:25With the leverage component that Martin's talking about,
- 33:29you know,
- 33:30this is something you hear coming from Trump.
- 33:33We're,
- 33:33we,
- 33:34we had bad deals,
- 33:35we're being taken advantage of
- 33:37by our global partners.
- 33:39Um,
- 33:39globalization was kind of a bad deal for the US and,
- 33:42and
- 33:43we've let China take advantage of us and,
- 33:46and
- 33:47You know,
- 33:47become a superpower with very little benefit to our economy.
- 33:51Do you think
- 33:52there's some truth in,
- 33:54in the United States going
- 33:55back out and kind of like
- 33:57swinging a big stick a little bit and being like,
- 33:59hey,
- 34:00We,
- 34:00we wanna look out for
- 34:02Americans'
- 34:04interests
- 34:05and,
- 34:06you know,
- 34:06make sure we're getting the best
- 34:08deal for them.
- 34:10Well,
- 34:10Trump negotiated the last USMCA,
- 34:12right?
- 34:13So I mean he literally negotiated the trade deal with Canada and with Mexico,
- 34:17right?
- 34:17So
- 34:18I mean,
- 34:18look,
- 34:18I think we're a year into this.
- 34:20Let's look at the track record.
- 34:21Manufacturing activity is down in the United States.
- 34:23It does not have the effect that he believes that it will.
- 34:27I don't believe that.
- 34:27What he's saying is right.
- 34:28I don't think that making Americans pay more,
- 34:30um,
- 34:31is the way to incentivize growth and production.
- 34:34We had
- 34:35a massive increase under Joe Biden,
- 34:37because we were able to put targeted incentives in place.
- 34:40And I think that that's what's necessary here,
- 34:42not these ridiculous tariffs.
- 34:46All right,
- 34:46so I wanna move on to our last topic,
- 34:49um,
- 34:50which is your prompt,
- 34:51uh,
- 34:52or your,
- 34:52your claim around Doge,
- 34:54that Doge was a total
- 34:56I think it was total and utter failure or complete failure,
- 34:59and total failure,
- 35:00complete and total failure.
- 35:01Elon said
- 35:03that it was somewhat successful,
- 35:04and the only reason he wouldn't do it again
- 35:06is because everyone burnt down his Teslas and
- 35:08tried to destroy his business that he started.
- 35:11$100 to $200 billion in zombie payments is what he said.
- 35:15I have a question.
- 35:16Yes.
- 35:17Did you get your $2000 dose check?
- 35:20The,
- 35:20the,
- 35:20from the tariffs
- 35:22from,
- 35:22from Doge as a result of all the spending that was supposed to happen.
- 35:26There was supposed to be a $2000 Doge check.
- 35:28Did you get that?
- 35:29No,
- 35:29but they haven't said anything about that.
- 35:31Have they introduced something for that?
- 35:32What?
- 35:33Who said that they were supposed to do that?
- 35:34I know we're supposed to be getting that we'd be getting a check in the mail,
- 35:37but no,
- 35:37but you guys went into this not letting him start,
- 35:41do what he came there to do.
- 35:42So you.
- 35:43Why would anyone want fraud to be continued it's happened when I,
- 35:46we brought up California because it's.
- 35:49Happening in this government.
- 35:50Why is it happening over there?
- 35:52What do you mean?
- 35:53You control the House,
- 35:54the Senate,
- 35:56and the White House,
- 35:57OK,
- 35:57and you still couldn't get it done.
- 35:59How could anyone work like that,
- 36:01honestly?
- 36:02Having all did not let the guys having the House,
- 36:04the Senate,
- 36:05and the White House villainized him 2.
- 36:09Um,
- 36:10OK,
- 36:10first things first,
- 36:11do you,
- 36:11when you watch yourself
- 36:13debating,
- 36:13cause this came up a few times,
- 36:14you got under people's skin.
- 36:16This is aside from the content of the debates themselves.
- 36:20Do you watch yourself
- 36:21back in a,
- 36:22you know,
- 36:23in a,
- 36:23in a scenario like this,
- 36:24and,
- 36:25and do you ever feel like you're,
- 36:27you're going too much for the jugular with people or,
- 36:30or,
- 36:31you know,
- 36:31or,
- 36:31or do you stand by kind of like that,
- 36:33that degree of,
- 36:34um,
- 36:37Intensity that you,
- 36:38you were coming out April with.
- 36:42Facts are relentless,
- 36:44and that's just how they are.
- 36:45I think that in this country we've done too much playing around
- 36:49when people say
- 36:50objective
- 36:51mistruths.
- 36:52And so,
- 36:53look,
- 36:53no,
- 36:53I don't,
- 36:54um,
- 36:55you know,
- 36:56I think that
- 36:57it's really clear that the Republicans
- 36:59are always spewing out misinformation,
- 37:01and I think the only way to beat that is very strong counters and rebuttals.
- 37:05So,
- 37:05uh,
- 37:06you know,
- 37:07sucks to suck,
- 37:07I guess,
- 37:09yeah.
- 37:09So then,
- 37:10the Elon of it all,
- 37:12cause.
- 37:14I mean,
- 37:14there.
- 37:16There was a lot of promises made,
- 37:18trillions of dollars is what we were told.
- 37:21Even if you take the most generous estimates of savings that Doge did,
- 37:25um,
- 37:25uncover,
- 37:27it's nowhere near
- 37:28that target.
- 37:30Elon in the private sector is somebody who's achieved
- 37:33tremendous things.
- 37:34Uh,
- 37:36you know,
- 37:36some of the most amazing
- 37:38technological advancements we've witnessed in our life
- 37:42have happened with his companies.
- 37:44So,
- 37:45what's the delta?
- 37:46How come,
- 37:46how can someone like Elon who's achieved,
- 37:48you know,
- 37:49redeployable rockets
- 37:52in,
- 37:53in one part of his life,
- 37:56make such huge promises.
- 37:58And,
- 37:58and then fall so far short of them
- 38:01with Dosh.
- 38:03I think that this is a part of the poison of misinformation.
- 38:06Maybe Elon found out that the government is not as wasteful and
- 38:10uh
- 38:11ridiculous as he thought it was
- 38:13because ultimately I think that,
- 38:15that they all went in looking for something that just didn't exist.
- 38:18They were sold
- 38:19a pack of lies that Elon himself amplified and ultimately came out.
- 38:23That's why these Estimates just didn't
- 38:26even come close
- 38:27to what they were saying.
- 38:29And so this is what happens when people are sold misinformation as fact,
- 38:33and I think that Doge is a perfect example of that.
- 38:36Personally,
- 38:36I believe that Doge
- 38:37was created
- 38:39to effectively get people to not pay attention to the trillions of
- 38:42dollars' worth of tax cuts that they signed for the richest people.
- 38:45People in our country
- 38:46that they would feel that oh well we're saving all this money
- 38:49from Doge and that can justify the benefits of these tax cuts.
- 38:53That didn't happen and that was the main reason why I wanted to bring this up
- 38:56uh back into the forefront through this uh jubilee,
- 38:59um,
- 39:00was because it was a it was a distraction from the
- 39:02main event which was the richest people in America getting richer as
- 39:05from tax cuts.
- 39:06Yeah,
- 39:07and to be fair to Elon.
- 39:09You know,
- 39:09it's not exactly clear,
- 39:10but that did seem to be a point of
- 39:12fracture between him and the president.
- 39:14You know,
- 39:15there,
- 39:15he kind of went on a tweet spree,
- 39:18um,
- 39:18which sort of ended Doge or was the beginning of the end
- 39:21for Doge right around the time this bill was getting passed.
- 39:24Elon,
- 39:25you know,
- 39:25pointed out the adding to the deficit,
- 39:28um,
- 39:29and,
- 39:30and,
- 39:30you know,
- 39:30felt that it was like you're saying,
- 39:31kind of counterintuitive to the,
- 39:33the goals of Doge.
- 39:35Um,
- 39:35do you think Elon was kind of used?
- 39:38Uh,
- 39:38of course he was,
- 39:39but the thing is,
- 39:40is that,
- 39:41you know,
- 39:42it,
- 39:42it goes deeper than that as well because if you look at the way that Doge was,
- 39:46was activated,
- 39:48they also lied.
- 39:49They lied.
- 39:50They were caught numerous times by,
- 39:52by all these different organizations,
- 39:54independent fact checkers
- 39:55that showed that they were putting just
- 39:57completely misinformation in terms of the contracts that they were canceling,
- 40:00in terms of Of the top line number that they were reporting,
- 40:03they were lying.
- 40:04So
- 40:05Elon is not some kind of,
- 40:07you know,
- 40:07innocent,
- 40:08uh,
- 40:08pony here.
- 40:09He,
- 40:10he's somebody who,
- 40:11who
- 40:12oversaw an agency and amplified on his own personal accounts outright lies,
- 40:16did not clean up misinformation,
- 40:18and I think that that is a big problem
- 40:20and it shows kind of the really devious nature behind all of that.
- 40:24Mhm.
- 40:25Do you think
- 40:26Do you think just the power that Elon has changed his character?
- 40:29I mean,
- 40:29there was a,
- 40:30I think you described yourself as kind of an Obama Democrat,
- 40:33right?
- 40:34Um,
- 40:34in the episode,
- 40:35and
- 40:37Elon
- 40:38admired Obama.
- 40:39They had kind of a,
- 40:40a public,
- 40:41uh,
- 40:42relationship,
- 40:43you know,
- 40:45and then Elon changed his tune
- 40:48quite a bit.
- 40:49Um,
- 40:49so,
- 40:49you know,
- 40:50there might have been,
- 40:50once upon a time,
- 40:51you and Elon might have been kind of aligned.
- 40:52What,
- 40:53what do you think?
- 40:54Uh,
- 40:54factors in for that like drastic change.
- 40:58I don't know what happened to Elon's personal life,
- 41:00uh,
- 41:00between,
- 41:01you know,
- 41:02the
- 41:02moment that President Obama was in office to now.
- 41:05Um,
- 41:07I don't know,
- 41:07to be honest with you.
- 41:08I mean,
- 41:09I asked myself the same question when it comes to people like
- 41:11Nicki Minaj and all these other folks that are out there.
- 41:13Like,
- 41:13how do these people
- 41:14have these,
- 41:16have these wild swings,
- 41:18right?
- 41:18So
- 41:19I don't know what it is,
- 41:20but,
- 41:20you know,
- 41:20I do know that ultimately,
- 41:22um,
- 41:23what he
- 41:25Tried to set out to do did not happen.
- 41:28He then lied about that to millions of people around the world.
- 41:32Um,
- 41:33and that to me is pretty devious.
- 41:35So,
- 41:36um,
- 41:37I think if he was really just some good-natured guy
- 41:39that was just trying to really find ways in government,
- 41:42he could be a man and admit that,
- 41:44hey,
- 41:44you know what,
- 41:45we didn't find as much.
- 41:46And you know what,
- 41:47I was wrong.
- 41:48He could do that,
- 41:49but he didn't.
- 41:49He lied.
- 41:50He continued that.
- 41:51And that's something that proves to me that he was very devious in what he did.
- 41:55Mhm.
- 41:56To go back to April,
- 41:58who you were debating in the clip,
- 42:00something I hear from April,
- 42:02even if,
- 42:03um,
- 42:05Even if Doge didn't deliver.
- 42:08There's this clear concern
- 42:10and belief
- 42:11in her
- 42:12that fraud is abundant
- 42:14in the way the government operates.
- 42:16And
- 42:18this is
- 42:19clear in our culture,
- 42:20you know,
- 42:21what's happening in Minneapolis
- 42:23is not solely because of Nick Shirley's YouTube video,
- 42:28but I would say it's like
- 42:30pretty,
- 42:33that,
- 42:33that was a significant amplifying factor,
- 42:34you know,
- 42:34Nick Shirley puts out these
- 42:37Kinda
- 42:38amateur YouTube,
- 42:40investigative journalistic videos about fraud
- 42:42in daycares across
- 42:45Minnesota.
- 42:46And then the government goes so far as to,
- 42:48you know,
- 42:49threaten to,
- 42:50and I think they would have if,
- 42:51if the courts had let them
- 42:53stop funding
- 42:55going into the state
- 42:56until the fraud was sorted out.
- 42:59But there's also,
- 43:00you know,
- 43:00there's,
- 43:00there's plenty of smart people who are claiming,
- 43:02yes,
- 43:03fraud is abundant
- 43:04in programs like this.
- 43:05Minnesota is just,
- 43:06you know,
- 43:07kind of the tip of the iceberg.
- 43:09Do you think
- 43:10there's validity to that?
- 43:11Do you think,
- 43:12um,
- 43:13waste fraud,
- 43:14waste,
- 43:14fraud and abuse,
- 43:15regardless of whether Elon achieved,
- 43:18uh,
- 43:18reformation there,
- 43:20do you think that's a huge problem?
- 43:22Well,
- 43:22first off,
- 43:22Nick Shirley is a targeted plant.
- 43:24And the reason for that is because
- 43:26this was something that was uncovered
- 43:27and was investigated under the Biden administration.
- 43:30The ringleader for this organization is in prison today.
- 43:34Um we had multiple,
- 43:35multiple people got convicted from this.
- 43:36So Nick Shirley did not identify some type of fraud.
- 43:40This was something that
- 43:41we We saw,
- 43:42we knew about,
- 43:43and there were people that were being prosecuted
- 43:45and more people that were being indicted.
- 43:47I think that anybody that perpetuates fraud
- 43:49needs to be prosecuted,
- 43:51indicted,
- 43:51convicted,
- 43:52and put in prison.
- 43:53And if they are not supposed to be in this country and they're committing fraud,
- 43:57they need to be deported.
- 43:58I believe that every
- 43:59good-natured American believes that.
- 44:02But the thing is,
- 44:03is that I'm not going to sit around and act like
- 44:06the fraud that Trump and Nick Shirley are trying to perpetuate
- 44:11is some blue state issue.
- 44:13When I can look at the states like Mississippi,
- 44:15where Brett Favre in Minnesota and and Mississippi Republicans were tied up in
- 44:20a scandal of TANF funding that was literally in that degree.
- 44:24I'm not going to sit around and say that when Rick Scott,
- 44:26the incumbent senator from Florida,
- 44:28literally presided over one of the biggest
- 44:31healthcare fraud schemes
- 44:32in the history of the United States of America.
- 44:35So,
- 44:35I mean,
- 44:35this is something
- 44:36that I think that
- 44:37we should just look forward to as Americans to say
- 44:40that fraud,
- 44:40no matter if it happens from a Democrat or a Republican,
- 44:43needs to be investigated.
- 44:44This from Donald Trump.
- 44:46is nothing more than an attempt to try to use,
- 44:49uh,
- 44:49a situation that was already uncovered,
- 44:52uh,
- 44:52to make it look out to be a political thing that was advantageous for him.
- 44:55Ultimately it's not going to work out
- 44:57because Amy Klobuchar is running for governor of Minnesota and
- 45:00she will slap the living daylights out of any Republican candidate
- 45:03that is in front of her.
- 45:05So,
- 45:05uh,
- 45:06I'm not really,
- 45:07uh prediction.
- 45:08Well,
- 45:08I,
- 45:08I'll take it to the bank and so,
- 45:10uh,
- 45:11you know,
- 45:11ultimately
- 45:12it's not gonna work out too well for them.
- 45:14I won't play you this clip,
- 45:15but you brought Dennis back.
- 45:17Dennis kind of had a rough video.
- 45:21Tough time
- 45:22And he does,
- 45:24it kind of,
- 45:25it repeats itself,
- 45:26you know,
- 45:27he makes the claim.
- 45:29AOC has made money off of uh her position.
- 45:32I can't remember what other,
- 45:33other Democratic
- 45:35politician he refers to,
- 45:36but
- 45:36basically,
- 45:38you know,
- 45:38if a Democratic politician is making money off of,
- 45:41off,
- 45:42off of their influence and off of their position in office,
- 45:46then
- 45:47they're doing it for selfish reasons.
- 45:48They're making money off the backs of Americans.
- 45:51It's not that hard to flip that around and
- 45:53point out that Donald Trump has made the most money
- 45:56of any politician.
- 45:57I,
- 45:58I mean,
- 45:58it,
- 45:58it probably of all time,
- 46:00um,
- 46:01from his position as president.
- 46:05What do you think it's gonna take?
- 46:07I mean,
- 46:07this is,
- 46:08this is just something I,
- 46:09I don't really think you can steal,
- 46:10man,
- 46:11at all.
- 46:11Like Trump is,
- 46:12is making tons of money
- 46:14off of
- 46:17the presidency,
- 46:18but people don't really seem to care.
- 46:22Why,
- 46:23how do you change that?
- 46:25Well,
- 46:25I do think that people do care and it's
- 46:27why Republicans are losing all across this country.
- 46:29It's why they lost the Virginia governorship,
- 46:31Virginia lieutenant governorship,
- 46:32Virginia
- 46:33attorney generalship,
- 46:3412 competitive seats in the Virginia House of Delegates,
- 46:36why they lost Miami mayor's race for the first time
- 46:39in 30 years,
- 46:40why they lost special elections in Kentucky.
- 46:42In Georgia,
- 46:43and why they've just lost a Trump + 17 state district
- 46:46in the state
- 46:47of Texas.
- 46:48These guys are losing everywhere across the country
- 46:50because people understand that this is a grift.
- 46:53They're losing people like Marjorie Taylor Greene,
- 46:55they're losing
- 46:56MMA fighters,
- 46:57boxers,
- 46:58Joe Rogan.
- 46:59I mean,
- 47:00the list goes on of Americans that
- 47:02are just seeing how pathetic this administration is.
- 47:05And so,
- 47:06look,
- 47:07um,
- 47:08I don't think,
- 47:08you know,
- 47:09there might be some folks in MAGA that's still running around with this
- 47:12or whatever,
- 47:13but,
- 47:13you know,
- 47:14people understand making $3 billion off the presidency is pretty outrageous
- 47:18and investing in a meme coin that has no transparency whatsoever
- 47:22at all
- 47:24and uh
- 47:25using taxpayer funds to meet with said donors
- 47:29and then it comes out that favors have been done for said donors.
- 47:32If that's not corruption,
- 47:34I don't know what is.
- 47:36Yeah.
- 47:37I mean,
- 47:38I,
- 47:38I'm really not gonna push back on that at all,
- 47:40um,
- 47:41cause I,
- 47:42I don't really know how you can,
- 47:44but.
- 47:46One thing I would say is if Democrats find themselves
- 47:49in a position ever in the near future where
- 47:52they have all three branches of government,
- 47:54let's say you were in the government,
- 47:56um,
- 47:56at that time,
- 47:57what would your top priorities be?
- 48:00Like,
- 48:00what are,
- 48:00what are the things they gotta be,
- 48:01that gotta get done
- 48:03on the Democrats' to do list?
- 48:05I believe in getting rid of the filibuster and pushing through our agenda.
- 48:09I think that means creating a universal healthcare
- 48:11system for Americans in this country so that,
- 48:14you know,
- 48:14people are not having to go and worry about cutting their pills in half or,
- 48:19or whether or not
- 48:21a broken leg is going to be,
- 48:23you know,
- 48:23a really expensive thing for them.
- 48:25I think we need
- 48:26uh universal childcare in this country
- 48:28so that people are not having to pay the cost of rent effectively for
- 48:32childcare in this country per kid.
- 48:33It doesn't make any sense to me.
- 48:35I think we need to wipe out medical debt in this country.
- 48:38I think that we need to do a lot of things,
- 48:40um,
- 48:40to be able to really get our country back on track and
- 48:42to make America a lot more affordable than what it is now.
- 48:45Um,
- 48:45and I think that people are sick and tired of the constant,
- 48:49uh,
- 48:49gridlock that we're seeing.
- 48:51I think we need to get money out of politics.
- 48:52Banning all outside money from politics is something that I firmly support,
- 48:57fundamentally reforming,
- 48:58uh,
- 48:59the Supreme Court
- 49:00to put,
- 49:01um,
- 49:02term limits in place.
- 49:03I think it's going to be a big thing.
- 49:05I think all of these things are going to be very important
- 49:06and to push it through,
- 49:07we're going to need
- 49:09to get rid of the filibuster to get that done.
- 49:11You know,
- 49:11I,
- 49:12I,
- 49:12I've seen a lot of different arguments from,
- 49:14you know,
- 49:14different folks that say,
- 49:15oh well,
- 49:16if you get rid of the filibuster,
- 49:17what happens if the other side gets in and they push through their agenda?
- 49:20Well,
- 49:20you know what,
- 49:20I look more to Canada
- 49:22because they do not have a filibuster in the Canadian Parliament.
- 49:25They do have national healthcare.
- 49:27It became so popular in Canada that no conservative can ever run on the idea
- 49:31of getting rid of it
- 49:32because they know that it's going to be an electoral loss for them.
- 49:35So,
- 49:35I believe in doing good policies,
- 49:37make them good,
- 49:38and then having Americans benefit as a result.
- 49:41What I'm hearing is,
- 49:42you know,
- 49:42a Congress that is more of a presence
- 49:45in the way
- 49:46government functions,
- 49:47um,
- 49:48as opposed to a,
- 49:48a,
- 49:49a really powerful executive,
- 49:50which is what we're seeing right now.
- 49:52Absolutely,
- 49:53100%.
- 49:54Well,
- 49:55Isaiah,
- 49:55thanks for being in surrounded,
- 49:57jumping into the arena.
- 49:58It was great to,
- 49:59uh,
- 50:00see you do your thing and thanks for coming back on for,
- 50:02for a follow-up chat.
- 50:03I appreciate it.
- 50:04For more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 50:06be sure to like,
- 50:07subscribe,
- 50:07leave us a positive review,
- 50:09follow us wherever you get your podcasts.
- 50:11If you're watching the video version,
- 50:13subscribe to Tubilee.
- 50:15Uh,
- 50:15if you want to see video episodes of Surrounded,
- 50:17subscribe to Jubilee's YouTube channel.
- 50:20Um,
- 50:20thanks for supporting us.
- 50:21Thanks for listening.
- 50:22Remember,
- 50:23you could be wrong,
- 50:24so could I.
- 50:25Keep your mind open until next time.