Latest / Randy Unscripted / The Death of Ownership

Transcript

The Death of Ownership · Randy Unscripted

0:34
Randy Black: This is the podcast where I kind of just talk about whatever happens to come
0:38
across my brain, whatever it just happens to come across it.
0:42
And today I want to start this episode with a really simple question.
0:47
How much of the stuff that you own, do you actually own?
0:52
Now I know that that might sound like an odd question. After all,
0:55
if you bought something, then of course you own it, right? Right.
0:59
For most of our lives, that's been a pretty safe assumption.
1:03
We bought books and we put them on our shelves. We bought music.
1:05
We added it to our collections.
1:07
We bought movies. We bought software. We bought games and countless other things
1:11
without ever giving a second thought to what ownership of those really meant.
1:17
But over the past couple of decades, something's changed. More and more of what
1:22
we buy has become digital.
1:24
Our music, our movies, our software, our games, our documents,
1:27
and even some of the features that are built into products that we already own
1:32
now exist behind accounts, subscriptions, licenses, and terms of service that
1:38
most of us never take the time to read.
1:41
And that raises a very interesting question. Have we quietly moved from a world
1:46
of ownership to a world of access?
1:49
Today, I wanna explore what ownership means in the digital age,
1:53
why so many companies seem to be moving away from it, and whether we've traded
1:57
something valuable for the convenience we've all come to enjoy. So let's talk about it.
2:03
So a recent announcement from Sony got me thinking a lot about this.
2:08
The company announced that hundreds of movies, like 550 plus,
2:13
would be removed from customer libraries because of changes to licensing agreements.
2:18
And these weren't movies people had rented. These weren't titles that were part
2:23
of some subscription service.
2:24
These were movies that customers had paid for and added to their digital collections.
2:30
And for a lot of people, the reaction to that was immediate.
2:34
Wait a minute. I bought those movies.
2:38
At least they thought they did.
2:40
The reality is that what many of us think of as a purchase today isn't always
2:45
ownership in that traditional sense.
2:48
In a lot of cases, what we're actually buying is a license to access content
2:53
under a specific set of terms and conditions.
2:56
As long as those agreements remain in place, everything works exactly as is expected.
3:02
You open your library, you click play, and you enjoy the movie.
3:07
But when those agreements change, things can get complicated.
3:12
Now, to be fair, this isn't really a story about Sony. Sony just happens to
3:17
be the latest example we have.
3:20
Similar situations have happened before.
3:24
We've seen it with digital books, television shows, video games,
3:28
software, and online services.
3:30
Content sometimes just disappears. Services sometimes just shut down.
3:35
Features get removed, and our access to those things changes.
3:40
What makes the Sony situation stand out is that it forced a lot of people to
3:45
confront a question they had probably never asked before.
3:49
If a company can remove something after you've paid for it, did you ever truly own it?
3:56
And that's where this conversation starts to get interesting.
4:00
Because at the same time that we're seeing stories like this,
4:03
we're also watching physical media slowly disappear.
4:07
More and more, entertainment is being delivered digitally.
4:11
Disk drives are becoming less common. I mean, can you buy a computer today with one? Not easily.
4:17
Streaming services, they dominate the market. it.
4:21
Entire libraries of content now exist only as entries in online accounts that users have.
4:29
We're moving toward a world where ownership is becoming harder to define.
4:34
And maybe that's because ownership itself is actually changing.
4:40
There was a time when ownership was a pretty straightforward concept.
4:46
You walked into a store, you picked something off the shelf,
4:49
you paid for it, and then you took it home. That was it.
4:53
Whether it was a record album, a cassette tape, a CD, a VHS tape,
4:56
a DVD, a book, or a piece of software on a disc, there wasn't much room for confusion.
5:02
Once you bought it, it belonged to you.
5:06
You could put it on a shelf and you could come back to it years later.
5:09
You could lend it out to a friend. You could sell it. You could donate it.
5:12
You could leave it to your children.
5:15
The company that made it didn't have any say in what happened after the sale was completed.
5:21
In fact, that's exactly what ownership meant. Control passed from the seller to the buyer.
5:28
Now, that doesn't mean everything was perfect.
5:30
Physical media took up space. Things got scratched. Books wore out.
5:34
Tapes got tangled. CDs disappeared into the mysterious void that sometimes consume
5:39
socks, television remotes, and every pen that you actually like.
5:44
There were inconveniences. But despite those inconveniences,
5:49
there was only one thing physical ownership provided that we often take for granted today.
5:55
Permanence. If I bought a movie on a DVD 20 years ago, I can still watch it today.
6:02
Nobody can log into my house and remove it from the shelf.
6:06
Nobody can revoke my access because a contract expired.
6:11
Nobody can decide that the movie is no longer available in my region.
6:17
The movie is still there because I own it.
6:20
The same thing is true for books, for music, for software.
6:25
Once the transaction was completed, the item was mine.
6:30
And maybe that's why most of us never spent much time thinking about ownership.
6:35
It was so obvious that it hardly seemed worth discussing.
6:39
Ownership wasn't something that we questioned. It was simply the default.
6:45
But then something happened. Technology made access easier than ownership.
6:52
And little by a little, we started choosing convenience over control.
6:57
Not because anybody forced us to do it, because it was honestly a pretty good deal.
7:02
At least, it certainly seemed that way at the time it came around.
7:07
The thing is, none of this happened overnight. Nobody woke up one morning and
7:12
decided that ownership was no longer important.
7:16
Instead, we were offered something that was incredibly difficult to resist. Convenience.
7:23
Think about it for a moment. If you wanted to listen to music 25 years ago,
7:27
you needed a physical collection.
7:29
Maybe it was CDs. Maybe it was cassette tapes. Maybe if you're old enough, it was records.
7:35
Whatever the format was, if you wanted access to your music,
7:38
you had to own it and you had to keep track of it.
7:41
Then along came services like Apple Music and Spotify.
7:47
And suddenly, millions of songs were available instantly.
7:52
No shelves, no storage, no carrying case or binders that were full of CDs.
8:00
Just open an app and listen.
8:03
And the same thing happened with movies and with television.
8:05
Instead of building a DVD collection, we could subscribe to a streaming service
8:10
and gain access to thousands of titles with the click of a single button.
8:14
Software then followed the same path. Rather than buying a program at one time
8:21
and installing it from a disk,
8:24
we began subscribing to services that delivered updates and cloud synchronization,
8:30
and gave us access from multiple devices.
8:34
Heck, even our files moved into the cloud. No more worrying about external hard
8:39
drives or whether we remembered to back up our documents.
8:43
Everything was available from anywhere as long as we had an internet connection.
8:48
And honestly, that's pretty amazing. This isn't an episode about pretending
8:53
that those benefits don't exist, because they do.
8:56
Most of us enjoy them every single day.
9:00
The truth is that digital access solved a lot of problems. It reduced clutter.
9:05
It lowered our upfront costs. And it made content easier to discover.
9:10
Heck, it gave us access to more music, more movies, more books,
9:14
and more software than previous generations could have ever imagined.
9:18
In many ways, it made life better.
9:22
And that's why this shift happened. Not because consumers were tricked.
9:26
Not because ownership was stolen from us.
9:30
But because convenience was valuable enough that most of us were willing to make the trade.
9:36
The problem is that every trade has a cost.
9:40
And while we're focused on what we're gaining, many of us didn't spend time
9:44
thinking about what we were giving up.
9:47
Because the moment you stop owning something and start accessing it,
9:51
the relationship changes.
9:54
Ownership puts you in control. Access puts someone else in control.
9:59
And as long as everything works, the difference doesn't seem very important.
10:04
But when something changes, suddenly it becomes the only thing that matters.
10:09
For most of us, ownership and access really feel like the same thing.
10:15
I mean, after all, if I can watch the movie or listen to the music or read the
10:18
book or use the software, does it really matter whether I own it or I simply have access to it?
10:25
And most of the time, the answer seems to be no.
10:29
And that's exactly why this shift happened so quietly.
10:33
As long as the content is there when we want it, we don't spend much time thinking about who controls it.
10:39
But ownership and access are not the same thing.
10:44
Ownership means control. Access means permission. When you own something,
10:50
you decide what happens to it.
10:52
When you have access to something, someone else decides what happens to it and
10:57
allows you to use it under certain circumstances.
11:00
And most of the time, those conditions are buried inside terms of service agreements
11:04
that very few of us have ever taken the time to read.
11:08
They're written in legal language. They're spread across dozens and dozens of
11:12
pages and are accepted with the single click of a mouse button.
11:17
And because everything works exactly the way we expect it to,
11:21
we rarely think about them again until something changes.
11:26
Maybe a movie disappears from a digital library.
11:30
Maybe a television show is removed from a streaming service.
11:33
Maybe a software company in support for a product that you've used for years.
11:39
Maybe an online service, suddenly shuts down completely.
11:44
Suddenly what felt like ownership starts looking a lot more like a rental agreement.
11:49
The difference is that traditional rentals are honest about what they are.
11:54
When you rent a car, you know that car is not yours.
11:58
When you rent a hotel room, you know that you're eventually going to have to leave.
12:03
Digital purchases, though, often feel very different. The language we use reinforces that feeling.
12:10
We don't say we're licensing a movie. We say we bought it.
12:14
We don't say we're obtaining limited access to a song. We say we purchased it.
12:20
The experience feels like ownership, even when the legal reality may be something
12:25
that's entirely different.
12:27
And that's where many people find themselves frustrated. Not because the rules
12:31
changed, but because they suddenly discovered what rules were there all along.
12:38
The Sony example that started this conversation wasn't really about a few hundred
12:43
movies. It was a reminder.
12:45
It was a reminder that many of the products we think we own today are actually
12:50
governed by agreements, licenses, and permissions that exist well beyond our control.
12:56
And as long as those agreements remain in place, everything works.
13:01
But the moment they change, we're reminded who's really in charge.
13:07
And once you start seeing that distinction, it's hard not to notice it everywhere.
13:12
Once you start noticing the difference between ownership and access,
13:16
you begin to see it everywhere.
13:19
We started with music, movies, and software, and it's grown into something that's much, much larger.
13:26
Today, we live in what a lot of people call the subscription economy.
13:30
For decades, the traditional business model was simple.
13:33
A company made a product.
13:36
A customer bought that product. The transaction was then completed.
13:41
Maybe the customer came back later and bought another product.
13:45
Maybe they didn't, but the original sale was finished.
13:49
Increasingly, that's no longer the goal. Today, many companies aren't looking for a one-time sale.
13:57
They're looking for an ongoing relationship.
14:00
Or maybe to put it more bluntly here, an ongoing payment.
14:06
Think about how many subscriptions the average person has today.
14:10
Video services, music services, cloud storage, productivity software,
14:15
gaming services, news subscriptions, fitness apps, home security monitoring, the list goes on and on.
14:24
And even industries that traditionally sold products outright have begun experimenting
14:29
with subscription models.
14:31
Automakers have explored subscription-based features. Subaru, Toyota, Remote Start.
14:38
Yeah, smart devices often rely on cloud services to even to function.
14:45
Products that once worked independently now require accounts,
14:50
they require online connections, and they require recurring payments to be able
14:54
to unlock their full functionality.
14:58
And from a business perspective, it's easy to understand why.
15:02
Recurring revenue is predictable. It creates long-term customers.
15:07
It reduces uncertainty.
15:09
For companies, subscriptions can be increasingly, incredibly attractive.
15:14
For consumers, the picture's a little more complicated.
15:19
On one hand, subscriptions often lower the barrier to entry.
15:23
Instead of paying hundreds of dollars up front, you pay a smaller fee monthly.
15:28
You receive updates. You get access to new features. You enjoy the convenience
15:33
of having everything connected and synchronized.
15:36
And don't get me wrong, those are legitimate benefits.
15:39
But there's another side to the equation. When the payment stops, access often stops too.
15:46
The software you've enjoyed for years may become limited. The content that you've
15:51
enjoyed may disappear. year.
15:54
That service that you've relied upon may no longer be available.
15:59
The relationship never truly ends because the transaction never truly ends.
16:06
You're not purchasing a finished product. You're maintaining access to an ongoing service.
16:12
And perhaps that's the biggest shift of all this.
16:15
For generations, ownership represented a destination.
16:20
You bought the thing, you paid it off, it was yours.
16:24
Today, many of the products and services we use are designed around the idea
16:28
that ownership isn't the goal at all. Continued access is.
16:33
And while it may seem like a subtle difference, it fundamentally changes the
16:38
relationship between consumers and the things they spend their money on.
16:42
Because if access depends on continued agreement between you and the company
16:46
providing it, ownership starts to feel a lot less certain than it once did.
16:54
Up to this point, we've been talking about products and services.
16:57
You know, movies, music, software, subscriptions, things we buy,
17:01
things we use, things we consume.
17:03
But there's another side to this conversation that may be even more important
17:07
because some of the most valuable things in our lives aren't products at all. They're personal.
17:14
Think about where your memories live today. They're not in photo albums.
17:19
They're not in shoeboxes that are full of snapshots tucked away in a closet or under the bed.
17:24
For many of us, they're stored in cloud accounts. Thousands of photos.
17:31
Videos of our children growing up. Family vacations, birthday parties,
17:35
graduations. Moments we'll never get back. Hmm.
17:40
Now think about your documents, your emails, your notes, your calendars,
17:44
your contacts, the information that helps organize your life.
17:49
How much of it exists on a device that you control and how much of it exists
17:53
on servers that are owned by someone else?
17:57
For most of us, the answer is probably more than we'd like to admit.
18:01
And again, this isn't necessarily a bad thing.
18:04
Cloud services provide incredible benefits. Files can be synchronized easily across devices.
18:11
Photos can be backed up automatically.
18:14
Important information can be accessed from almost anywhere.
18:19
Those conveniences that exist are very, very real.
18:24
But they also come with a level of dependence that previous generations never had to consider.
18:29
A generation ago, if you wanted to see a family photograph, you opened a photo album.
18:34
Today, you may need a password. an account, an internet connection,
18:39
a functioning service, a company willing to continue providing you access.
18:45
And that's a very different relationship.
18:48
The same is true of social media. For many people, years of personal history
18:52
now exist on platforms that they don't own and they don't control.
18:56
Photos, conversations, memories, experiences, entire chapters of life that are
19:00
documented on services that could change, disappear, or lock an account at any moment.
19:07
Perhaps that's where this conversation becomes less about ownership and more about stewardship.
19:14
Because increasingly, the things that matter most to us aren't things we can
19:19
place on a shelf. They're digital.
19:21
They're intangible. They're stored somewhere out in the cloud.
19:27
We trust that they'll always be available because most of the time, they are.
19:33
But trust and ownership aren't the same thing.
19:38
The more our lives move into digital spaces, the more dependent we become on
19:43
systems that operate beyond our control.
19:46
And that raises a question that goes far beyond movies, music,
19:50
or subscription services.
19:52
If access to your digital life disappeared tomorrow how much of your life would
19:58
disappear with it it's not a comfortable question but it may be one that's worth asking,
20:06
so at this point we have to ask a question that may make some people uncomfortable,
20:11
what if digital ownership was never really ownership to begin with.
20:18
Think about it. When you buy a physical book, there's no confusion about who owns it.
20:22
It's sitting on your shelf. You can read it whenever you want.
20:26
You can lend it to a friend. You can sell it. You can donate it.
20:29
You can leave it to someone of your will. That book is yours.
20:33
But digital products have always been different. Unlike physical objects,
20:38
a digital file can be copied endlessly.
20:42
It can be distributed instantly around the world. It can exist in multiple places at the same time.
20:50
And because of that, companies and content creators have spent decades trying
20:54
to figure out how to sell digital products while maintaining some level of control over them.
21:01
That's where licenses came from. Instead of selling the product itself,
21:06
the companies often sell the right to use the product under very specific conditions.
21:11
For years, most consumers have never paid attention to that distinction.
21:15
And honestly, why would they? The experience felt the same.
21:20
You clicked that button that said buy. The item appeared in your library.
21:25
You used it whenever you wanted.
21:27
For all practical purposes, it felt like ownership. Until it didn't.
21:34
The sony situation reminded people of something that had been setting in the fine print all along,
21:41
many of these digital purposes purchases were governed by agreements that could change,
21:48
access could be restricted licenses can expire services can disappear and suddenly
21:57
what looked like ownership begins to reveal itself as something else.
22:02
But here's where things get interesting. Maybe the problem isn't that companies
22:06
change the definition of ownership.
22:09
Maybe the problem is that we applied an old definition to a new kind of product.
22:15
Because the truth is that most of us don't expect digital products to behave like physical ones.
22:20
We know we can stream a song instantly from almost anywhere.
22:23
We know that our files can synchronize across multiple devices.
22:27
We know updates can improve software years after we first acquire it.
22:31
Those capabilities don't really exist in the physical world.
22:36
Digital products offer advantages that physical products just never could.
22:42
But those advantages often come with trade-offs.
22:47
The same connectivity that makes digital products convenient can also make them
22:52
dependent upon systems, platforms, accounts, and agreements.
22:58
Perhaps that's the tension at the heart of this entire conversation.
23:02
We want the freedom and the permanence of ownership.
23:06
We also want the convenience and the flexibility of digital access.
23:12
And sometimes those goals work together, but sometimes they don't.
23:17
And maybe that's why so many people reacted so strongly to the Sony story.
23:21
It wasn't really about losing access to a movie.
23:25
Was about discovering that ownership meant something different than they thought it did.
23:29
For years, we treated ownership and access as if they were just interchangeable.
23:35
Now we realize that they really aren't.
23:39
And that realization focuses us and it forces us to confront a much larger question.
23:47
In a world increasingly built upon services, subscriptions, cloud platforms,
23:53
and digital ecosystems, what does ownership even mean anymore?
24:00
When I started thinking about this topic, it was because of a story about movies.
24:05
A company changed a licensing agreement, and suddenly hundreds of films that
24:10
people thought they owned were scheduled to disappear from their media libraries.
24:15
And at first glance, it seemed like a story about digital media.
24:19
But as we've talked through it today, it's really much bigger than that.
24:24
It's about how our relationship with ownership has changed.
24:28
We moved from shelves full of books, CDs, DVDs, and software discs to libraries
24:35
that exist almost entirely in the cloud.
24:39
We traded physical collections for instant access. We traded permanents for convenience.
24:45
And in most cases, it was a trade that we were also happy to make.
24:50
After all, most of us enjoy the benefits every single day. I know I do.
24:54
The ability to carry thousands of songs in my pocket, to access my documents
24:58
from anywhere, and to stream movies on demand would have seemed almost unbelievable not that long ago.
25:04
The conveniences are real. The benefits are real.
25:09
But so are the trade-offs. Because ownership and access are not the same thing.
25:14
Ownership gives us control.
25:16
Access gives us permission. And perhaps the most important thing that we can
25:20
do as consumers is understand the difference.
25:24
This isn't an argument against technology. You guys know I love technology.
25:28
It's not an argument against streaming.
25:31
It's not even an argument against subscriptions. I have a ton of them.
25:34
It's simply a reminder to be aware of the agreements that we're making,
25:39
even when they're hidden behind convenience.
25:43
The truth is, ownership may not be disappearing.
25:47
It may be simply evolving into something different than what it used to be.
25:52
The question is whether or not we've noticed that. So the next time you click
25:57
a button that says buy, take a moment and ask yourself a very simple question.
26:02
Am I purchasing something that I own?
26:06
Or am I paying for access to something that someone else still controls?
26:11
Because in an increasingly digital world, that distinction may matter more than ever before.
26:19
Before I let you go, though, I do want to say thank you.
26:23
Whether you've been listening since the beginning or you've just discovered
26:26
Randy Unscripted recently, I genuinely appreciate that you're spending your
26:31
time with me for each episode.
26:35
There are more podcasts, videos, articles, and distractions that are competing
26:39
for your attention than ever before.
26:41
So the fact that you've chosen to listen to me means a lot.
26:46
If you enjoy these conversations and you'd like to help support the show,
26:49
you can do so by visiting randyunscripted.com support.
26:54
You can also support the podcast directly through many of the modern podcast
26:58
apps. Find them at podcastapps.com using features like boosts and the value
27:02
for value contributions and the listener support tools.
27:06
And if something from today's episode that resonated with you,
27:10
I'd love to hear from you.
27:11
Whether you agree, disagree, or have a story to share, or even have an idea
27:15
for a future episode, you can reach me through the contact page available at
27:19
randyunscripted.com slash contact.
27:23
So thank you again for listening, and thank you for being a part of this community.
27:28
I'm Randy Black, and this has been another episode of Randy Unscripted.