Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Salesforce‘s AI Bet: A Deep Dive into CRM's Maturing Business
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome, curious minds. Today, we're embarking on a deep
- 0:03dive into one of the well true Titans of cloud computing,
- 0:08Salesforce, that ubiquitous presence known by its ticker
- 0:11symbol CRM. We've meticulously gathered the
- 0:14latest financial research, peeled back layers of their
- 0:17business model and really analyze their operational DNA.
- 0:22Our mission today is clear to cut through the industry
- 0:25chatter, give you a genuine shortcut to being well informed
- 0:29and truly explore what makes this multibillion dollar company
- 0:32tick. Or perhaps what's changing about
- 0:36how it ticks? Absolutely.
- 0:37And what's particularly fascinating here, I think is
- 0:39that we're not just going to, you know, present a list of
- 0:42facts. We're going to apply a rigorous
- 0:44value oriented framework much like a seasoned investor would
- 0:47to understand Salesforce. Think of it as taking the
- 0:50company's pulse, you know, assessing its core health and
- 0:53truly understanding its, let's say, intrinsic market
- 0:56temperature. This deep dive will hopefully
- 0:58equip you with the tools to analyze Salesforce and indeed
- 1:02any company with a critical eye, helping you understand not just
- 1:06what is happening, but maybe more importantly, why it matters
- 1:10for long term value. Right, getting beyond the
- 1:12surface. Level, exactly.
- 1:13We're looking for those deep insights that separate, you
- 1:16know, surface level understanding from true market
- 1:18intelligence. OK, so let's unpack this then
- 1:21with a critical look at Salesforce's latest snapshot.
- 1:24The numbers are often the 1st place we go, right?
- 1:28But what do the recent earnings really tell us about their
- 1:31current trajectory and maybe more importantly, perhaps a new
- 1:34identity reforming for this cloud giant?
- 1:36That's a brilliant way to frame it actually, because Salesforce
- 1:39just reported a remarkably strong second quarter of fiscal
- 1:432026. That period ended July 31st,
- 1:472025 and they didn't just meet their own guidance, they quite
- 1:51impressively surpassed it on all the major metrics, which isn't
- 1:55just a good sign, it's a very positive signal to investors
- 1:58that management is executing well and perhaps more
- 2:02importantly, has a firm grip on the, you know, operational
- 2:06levers of the business. So if we pull back the curtain
- 2:09on those numbers, then what were the standout figures?
- 2:11What really captured this newfound strength you mentioned?
- 2:15Yeah, we'll start right at the top.
- 2:16Revenue. It came in at a robust $10.2
- 2:19billion. OK.
- 2:21That represents a healthy 10% year over year increase.
- 2:24Pretty solid for their size. Very solid.
- 2:27And if we adjust for constant currency fluctuations, which can
- 2:30muddy the waters a bit, that's still a solid 9% growth.
- 2:33Now this growth was overwhelmingly propelled by
- 2:36their core subscription and support revenue.
- 2:38That's the vast majority of their business.
- 2:39As we know that rose 11% year of year to $9.7 billion.
- 2:44So that recurring subscription model, it's clearly still the
- 2:47engine driving the top line and it's running strong.
- 2:51And on the flip side, profitability, that's crucial
- 2:53for value investors, isn't it? How did they perform on the
- 2:55bottom line? Profitability was equally
- 2:57strong, I'd say, and maybe even more indicative of this
- 3:01strategic shift we're talking about, they delivered gap
- 3:04earnings per share EPS of $2.91. That significantly beat the
- 3:09consensus estimates, which were around $2.78.
- 3:14But here's where it truly gets interesting.
- 3:16Their operating margin. It hit a company record of 22.8%
- 3:20on a GAAP basis. Wow, record gap margin.
- 3:23Record cap margin and it's soared even higher to 34.3% on a
- 3:27non GAAP basis. Now this isn't just a quarterly
- 3:30beat. This signals a strong,
- 3:32deliberate and I think sustained focus on efficiency and fiscal
- 3:35discipline, something we haven't consistently seen from
- 3:38Salesforce in its earlier, you know, more aggressive growth
- 3:41phases. Right, the growth at all costs
- 3:42era. Exactly.
- 3:43It really suggests a company that's, well, truly maturing.
- 3:46That record operating margin certainly tells a story of
- 3:49greater discipline, but for many, myself included, cash flow
- 3:52is kind of the ultimate measure of a company's health.
- 3:55What do we see there? Indeed, cash flow is king, as
- 3:58they say, and Salesforce is generating substantial cash.
- 4:02This is perhaps one of the most compelling aspects of their
- 4:04recent performance. OK.
- 4:06They're on track for potentially $15 billion in operating cash
- 4:10flow for the full fiscal year 2026.
- 4:13That's a huge number. 15 billion.
- 4:16Wow. And this powerful cash
- 4:18generation capability is allowing them to do something
- 4:20historically well uncharacteristic for them,
- 4:24return a significant amount of capital to shareholders.
- 4:27Right, that's the big change. It it really is.
- 4:29In this past quarter alone, they returned approximately $2.6
- 4:32billion that included $2.2 billion in share repurchases and
- 4:36about $399 million in dividends. And the truly monumental news,
- 4:40the real headline grabber, They expanded their share buyback
- 4:43authorization by an astonishing $20 billion. 20 billion more. 20
- 4:48billion more, bringing the total program to a staggering $50
- 4:52billion. $50 billion authorized for buybacks. 50 billion.
- 4:56This isn't just a commitment. It reflects, I think,
- 4:58management's profound confidence in the business's intrinsic
- 5:01value and its newfound dedication to shareholder
- 5:04returns. Yeah, you can't argue with that
- 5:06number. It's a game changer for how many
- 5:08investors probably perceive Salesforce now.
- 5:10Absolutely. It signals a major shift in
- 5:12philosophy. So a $50 billion buyback
- 5:15program, that's a statement, all right?
- 5:17It signifies A profound shift. And despite these changes
- 5:21focusing more on margins and returns, are they still feeling
- 5:24optimistic about the future? What's the guidance telling us?
- 5:27Oh, absolutely. The optimism remains, but it's
- 5:31maybe an optimism rooted in a more shall we say efficient
- 5:35approach. The company raised its full year
- 5:38fiscal 2026 revenue outlook slightly to 41.141 point 3
- 5:43billion and they also boosted their non GAAP operating margin
- 5:46guidance to 34.1%. So still expecting strong
- 5:50profitability and management specifically highlighted the
- 5:53early success of new AI products.
- 5:54They mentioned one called Agent Force, which apparently already
- 5:57boasts over 12,500 deals. 12,000 deals already.
- 6:00Yeah. And importantly, they said more
- 6:02than 6000 of those were actually paid subscriptions.
- 6:04OK. So not just trials, real
- 6:06revenue. Exactly this rapid uptake
- 6:09suggests that their strategic bet on AI, which is huge for
- 6:12them, is starting to gain real traction.
- 6:15And that's absolutely crucial for driving the next wave of
- 6:17growth and, you know, maintaining their competitive
- 6:19edge. So we've got this snapshot then
- 6:22strong financial performance, a clear pivot towards efficiency
- 6:26and shareholder returns. But for those who might only
- 6:29know Salesforce by its ticker CRM, what does this cloud giant
- 6:33actually do? How does it generate these
- 6:35billions? And what's the underlying
- 6:37business model that supports it all?
- 6:39Right, good question. At its core, Salesforce isn't
- 6:42just a software company, It's really the undisputed world's
- 6:45leading cloud based software provider specializing in
- 6:49customer relationship management or CRM.
- 6:51The leader, yeah. And they deliver their services
- 6:53through that ubiquitous model known as software as a service
- 6:56or sauce. OK, so imagine this.
- 6:59Instead of buying a software license and installing it on
- 7:02your own company computers, businesses simply subscribe to
- 7:05Salesforce's applications over the Internet.
- 7:07Right, like renting versus owning?
- 7:08Yeah, exactly. It's like renting a powerful,
- 7:10constantly updated suite of tools directly from the cloud,
- 7:14accessible pretty much anywhere, anytime.
- 7:16So it's all about that predictable, recurring revenue
- 7:20stream that, well, so many modern tech companies covet.
- 7:22Precisely. Their income primarily flows
- 7:25from these recurring subscription fees.
- 7:27That's for their vast array of enterprise cloud applications
- 7:31and the related support services they provide.
- 7:33OK. This subscription and support
- 7:35segment is absolutely dominant. It typically comprises roughly
- 7:3893% of their total revenue in recent years. 93%.
- 7:43Wow. Yeah, vast majority.
- 7:44The remaining 7% or so comes from what they call professional
- 7:47services. That's essentially consulting,
- 7:50implementation training, basically helping customers
- 7:53integrate Salesforce into their existing systems and, you know,
- 7:55maximize its utility. Kind of the setup and ongoing
- 7:58help. Exactly.
- 7:59Think of it as the white glove service that helps ensure
- 8:01seamless adoption and value. And within that massive
- 8:05subscription engine, what are the specific products, or clouds
- 8:08as they call them, that contribute the most to their
- 8:10revenue? Is it all just sales software?
- 8:13No, not at all. Their offerings are organized
- 8:16into several flagship application clouds, each
- 8:18targeting a specific business function.
- 8:21The Service Cloud, which empowers companies with customer
- 8:24service and Support Solutions, is currently the largest
- 8:27contributor that accounts for about 2324% of total revenue.
- 8:32Service cloud #1. Following closely behind is the
- 8:35venerable Sales Cloud that was their original offering focused
- 8:38on sales force automation that brings in roughly 22%.
- 8:42Still huge. Still huge?
- 8:44Absolutely. Then you have a category called
- 8:46Platform and other. This includes the foundational
- 8:49Salesforce platform itself, collaborative tools like Slack,
- 8:54which they acquired right, Slack and their app Exchange
- 8:56marketplace. That whole bundle contributes
- 8:58around 19%. Then there's integration and
- 9:01analytics. This encompasses powerful tools
- 9:03like Mulesoft for integration and Tableau for data
- 9:06visualization. That stands at about 15%.
- 9:08Mule Soft and Tableau, Yeah, big acquisition.
- 9:11Very big. And finally, the Marketing and
- 9:13Commerce Cloud contributes roughly 14%.
- 9:16So you see, it's a vast, interconnected portfolio
- 9:19designed to touch almost every aspect of how a business
- 9:22interacts with its customers. Yeah.
- 9:24So it's far beyond just managing sales leads.
- 9:26Like you said, it's a comprehensive platform for the
- 9:28entire customer journey. Who exactly are these customers
- 9:32then? Are they just massive
- 9:33corporations or is it a broader spectrum?
- 9:35Their customer base is incredibly vast and remarkably
- 9:39diverse. Salesforce serves over 150,000
- 9:42business customers worldwide. A. 150,000.
- 9:45Yeah, and this ranges from nascent small businesses, you
- 9:48know, just starting their digital journey, all the way up
- 9:51to over 90% of the Fortune 500, the true global behemoths.
- 9:54Wow, from small shops to giants. Exactly.
- 9:57This broad applicability really speaks volumes about the
- 10:00platform's scalability and its ability to adapt to different
- 10:03industry needs. And a cornerstone of their
- 10:05growth strategy, something they talk about a lot, is what they
- 10:08cleverly call land and expand. Land and expand, OK.
- 10:11This means they often get a foot in the door with a new client
- 10:14using maybe just one specific product, say Sales cloud, and
- 10:18then over time they strategically cross sell and
- 10:21upsell additional cloud solutions, new features or
- 10:25integrate more of their ecosystem like Tableau or Slack.
- 10:29Right. Get them hooked on one thing,
- 10:30then add more. Precisely this strategy
- 10:33dramatically increases the revenue generated from each
- 10:36customer over the client's lifetime.
- 10:39It makes their growth highly efficient once a client is
- 10:41onboarded and, you know, embedded in the Salesforce
- 10:44ecosystem. So a clear recurring revenue
- 10:47model build on a massive, ever expanding customer base that
- 10:51they can continuously monetize. It sounds on the surface like an
- 10:54impenetrable fortress. But even for giants, there are
- 10:57vulnerabilities, right? Which makes the transition to
- 11:00understanding their risks even more crucial.
- 11:03Here's where it gets really interesting.
- 11:04I think even with such strong performance and a seemingly
- 11:07robust business model, every company, even a Titan like
- 11:11Salesforce, faces challenges. So what are the headwinds?
- 11:14Salesforce is navigating both, maybe in the short term those
- 11:18temporary gusts, and structurally for the long run,
- 11:22those deeper currents that could reshape its destiny.
- 11:24Exactly. And understanding these risks
- 11:26isn't just about, you know, being pessimistic.
- 11:29It's crucial for any sound investment thesis and for
- 11:32understanding the strategic decisions a company makes,
- 11:35right. We can effectively break these
- 11:37down into two categories. I think the more temporary
- 11:39factors that might smooth out over time and then the more
- 11:42enduring structural challenges that demand continuous strategic
- 11:46adaptation. OK.
- 11:47Let's start with those short term, perhaps more fleeting
- 11:50headwinds. What immediate challenges are
- 11:53causing some friction for Salesforce right now or have
- 11:57recently? Well, the primary short term
- 11:59challenge that definitely cast a shadow, particularly back in
- 12:022023, was the broader macroeconomic slowdown.
- 12:06Yeah, when corporate spending tightens its belt, you see
- 12:09customers delay deals, scrutinize budgets more closely
- 12:13and sales cycles just get longer.
- 12:15And this naturally slowed sales forces growth from its, you
- 12:18know, prior blistering pace, high inflation, rising interest
- 12:22rates. These things make businesses
- 12:24more hesitant to invest heavily in big IT projects, even
- 12:27essential ones. Even CRM.
- 12:29Even CRM sales force, despite its market leadership, isn't
- 12:33fully immune to these broader economic forces that can
- 12:36temporarily dampen demand for its products.
- 12:39It's like a powerful ship encountering choppy waters.
- 12:42It can navigate, but it will slow down.
- 12:44Makes sense. What else in the short term?
- 12:46Another factor is currency fluctuations.
- 12:48Forex risk roughly 1/3. About 33% of Salesforce's
- 12:53revenue originates from outside the US.
- 12:55OK, significant chump. It is.
- 12:57So for instance, a strong U.S. dollar, which we've seen at
- 12:59times can temporarily reduce their reported revenue growth
- 13:03when those international sales are converted back into dollars.
- 13:06Right. Even if the business is doing
- 13:07fine locally. Exactly.
- 13:08Even if the underlying business performance in local currencies
- 13:11is perfectly solid, these foreign exchange impacts are
- 13:14often transient. But they can create unwelcome
- 13:17noise and volatility in quarterly results, making it,
- 13:21you know, a bit harder to assess the core performance sometimes.
- 13:24Got it. Anything else temporary?
- 13:27We also observed some significant post pandemic IT
- 13:31spending shifts. Think about it, after that huge
- 13:34acceleration of digital transformation during 20/20/21.
- 13:38Right, Everyone rushed to the cloud.
- 13:40Everyone did. Some of that.
- 13:41Demand naturally normalized afterward.
- 13:44Plus budget shifted towards other critical areas.
- 13:46Maybe cybersecurity became the top priority, or infrastructure
- 13:50upgrades, or even specific industry focused software.
- 13:53OK. This created some short term
- 13:55soft spots for Salesforce as IT spending priorities just
- 13:58temporarily realigned across the enterprise landscape.
- 14:01Interesting. What about internal factors?
- 14:02Yeah, that's important too. There was the impact of
- 14:04leadership transitions and reorganizations.
- 14:07Salesforce experienced pretty significant leadership turnover
- 14:09in late 2022 and through 2023. Right.
- 14:12I remember Brett Taylor leaving. Exactly.
- 14:14The departure of Co CEO Brett Taylor was a big one, along with
- 14:17several other key executives. Now, while Marc Benioff remains
- 14:21firmly at the helm, these transitions undoubtedly cause
- 14:24some internal uncertainty and frankly required management
- 14:27bandwidth to stabilize things. And then there was that major
- 14:30restructuring in early 2023, which included a 10% workforce
- 14:35layoffs that was explicitly aimed at improving margins,
- 14:38which it did. But understandably, it caused
- 14:40momentary disruption to internal operations and maybe sales
- 14:43productivity, even if it was ultimately a necessary strategic
- 14:47move for efficiency. Okay.
- 14:48And competition, is that more short term or long term?
- 14:51Well, there's a near term aspect to it, intensified competitive
- 14:54pressure on deals. This is particularly evident
- 14:56from rivals like Microsoft. Microsoft, yeah, they are
- 14:59aggressively bundling their Dynamics 365 CRM with other
- 15:04Enterprise Products, think Office 365, Azure, leveraging
- 15:08their vast ecosystem and frankly their pricing power.
- 15:11The bundle is powerful. It is this can create pricing
- 15:14pressure or maybe slower win rates for Salesforce, forcing
- 15:18them to fight harder for large enterprise contracts, at least
- 15:21until they can differentiate further with new features.
- 15:23Especially, you know, around AI. It's a constant battle for
- 15:26market share. OK.
- 15:27So these are challenges that a well managed resilient company
- 15:31like Salesforce can certainly weather and they seem to be
- 15:33adapting. But what about the more
- 15:35structural long term risks? These are the deeper currents
- 15:39that could fundamentally reshape its future, right?
- 15:42This is where the long term strategic game truly comes into
- 15:45play, I think, and where a company's ability to innovate
- 15:49and adapt is really tested. OK.
- 15:51The most critical long term risk hands down is intensifying
- 15:55competition, specially AI driven.
- 15:57AI Competition. Yes, mega cap rivals like
- 16:00Microsoft, Oracle, SAP, Adobe, they aren't standing still.
- 16:04They're all deepening their CRM and cloud offerings.
- 16:07They're embedding AI capabilities at a rapid pace.
- 16:09Right, everyone's talking to AICRM now.
- 16:11It's exactly Microsoft's Dynamics 365.
- 16:14For example, leveraging Azure AI and Open AI integrations poses a
- 16:18formidable threat. They can feel like a direct
- 16:20assault on sales forces core market.
- 16:23So if sales forces own AI innovation falters or maybe if
- 16:28it doesn't deliver meaningful tangible ROI for customers by
- 16:31say 2027, which is roughly management stated timeline for
- 16:35major AI financial impact, then market share could certainly be
- 16:39chipped away. That's a big if.
- 16:41It is. Plus you've got smaller
- 16:42specialized sauce firms continuing to emerge and expand,
- 16:46targeting specific niches that maybe Salesforce traditionally
- 16:48overlooked. The competitive landscape is
- 16:50just getting more complex. OK, intense competition.
- 16:52What else? Structurally.
- 16:54Another structural concern for any mature large company is
- 16:56market saturation and slowing growth.
- 16:59We talked about their growth moderating to high single
- 17:01digits, 810% for the FY20 26 outlook.
- 17:04Right, not the 2030% of the past.
- 17:06Exactly. The law of large numbers is an
- 17:10unavoidable reality for a company pulling in over $40
- 17:12billion in annual revenue. It's like a marathon runner who
- 17:16was once sprinting. It's just much harder to
- 17:18maintain those hyper growth rates when you're already
- 17:21covering such a vast market. Makes sense?
- 17:24This slowing growth is a core concern for investors
- 17:27historically accustomed to Salesforce's double digit rates.
- 17:31So to avoid long term stagnation, Salesforce needs new
- 17:35powerful growth. Factors may be expanding into
- 17:37new industry specific clouds or deeper international
- 17:40penetration, or again successful AI monetization.
- 17:44So finding new avenues for growth is key.
- 17:46What about execution? They've made some huge
- 17:47acquisitions. That's another big one.
- 17:49Significant execution risks related to integration and
- 17:52innovation. Salesforce has grown immensely
- 17:55through large, often multibillion dollar
- 17:57acquisitions. Mulesoft.
- 17:59Tableau Slack. Right, big names.
- 18:01Integrating these complex businesses into a truly cohesive
- 18:04platform, ensuring they work seamlessly together and actually
- 18:07extracting the promise synergies is a continuous, challenging
- 18:10task. It's not easy.
- 18:11A recent example is the announced, though possibly
- 18:15facing hurdles, $8 billion deal for Informatica, Adm management
- 18:19firm that's intended to significantly boost its AI
- 18:22capabilities. But integration missteps can
- 18:25distract management, they can dilute margins, and they can
- 18:28slow down critical innovation elsewhere.
- 18:31So the company must continually innovate, especially around AI
- 18:34features that genuinely enhance customer experience and
- 18:36productivity, just to remain relevant and justify its premium
- 18:39pricing. Integration is always tricky.
- 18:41What about external pressures like regulation?
- 18:44Definitely a factor we have to consider regulatory and data
- 18:47risks as a custodian of vast amounts of sensitive customer
- 18:51data across, you know, hundreds of thousands of businesses.
- 18:53Yeah, tons of data. Salesforce faces increasing
- 18:56regulatory scrutiny around data privacy laws like GDPR in
- 18:59Europe, CCPA in California. They're constantly evolving and
- 19:03compliance costs are only rising.
- 19:05And any major data breach or importantly now perceived misuse
- 19:09of AI capabilities could severely damage customer trust,
- 19:13which is arguably a company's most valuable asset.
- 19:16And while it seems distant now, antitrust scrutiny could also
- 19:20become a factor if they pursue another colossal acquisition.
- 19:23Given their already dominant market position, it's something
- 19:26to keep an eye on. OK.
- 19:27And technology itself changes. Always.
- 19:30That's the ever present threat of changing customer
- 19:32preferences. Technological paradigms are not
- 19:35static. They shift if new approaches
- 19:38like say, low code platforms become dominant, or hyper
- 19:41personalization takes off in unexpected ways, or maybe even
- 19:44open source CRM gains traction in the enterprise.
- 19:47Alesforce must be agile enough to adapt, right?
- 19:50The company is currently betting heavily on AI to augment its
- 19:53software, strategically repositioning itself as the
- 19:56Hashtag One AI CRM. Failing to anticipate and pivot
- 20:01to the next big technological wave, like what happened to the
- 20:04some legacy software firms during the cloud transition, is
- 20:07an existential long term risk for any tech giant.
- 20:10Yeah, you can't miss the next big shift.
- 20:12You can't. And finally, something we
- 20:13touched on earlier, the increasing pressure from
- 20:15shareholder activism and governance concerns.
- 20:18Right, the activists. In early 2023, those activist
- 20:21investors, Elliott Management Starboard Value Value Act,
- 20:25acquired significant stakes and pushed aggressively for higher
- 20:28margins and reduced spending. Now, while Salesforce responded
- 20:32decisively, these activist voices remained vigilant.
- 20:37And a clear signal of broader shareholder dissatisfaction was
- 20:40when that majority of investors voted against Salesforce's
- 20:43executive pay plan in 2024. Yeah, the pay vote.
- 20:46It emphasized the need for better alignment of management
- 20:49incentives with sustained, profitable shareholder value
- 20:52creation. That pressure is likely to
- 20:54remain. So it's a really dynamic and
- 20:56challenging landscape. Then you've got global
- 20:58macroeconomic forces converging, with intense competition, the
- 21:02absolute imperative for continuous smart innovation and
- 21:05increasing demands from shareholders.
- 21:07That sums it up well. Understanding these multifaceted
- 21:09risks truly underscores the importance of having a clear,
- 21:13adaptable strategy. OK, let's dive deeper now into
- 21:16how Salesforce actually operates.
- 21:19Let's explore their cost structure.
- 21:21Where does the money truly go after those massive subscription
- 21:24revenues come rolling in? And importantly, how is that
- 21:26changing in this new era of efficient growth you mentioned?
- 21:31Right. Salesforce operates with what
- 21:32we'd call a classic software business model.
- 21:35Fundamentally, it's characterized by very high gross
- 21:38margins, which is great, but also crucially significant
- 21:41operating expenses. Those are primarily concentrated
- 21:44in #1 sales and marketing and #2 research and development.
- 21:47It's a model really built on achieving scale.
- 21:50High gross margins, that's a phrase we hear a lot with sauce
- 21:52companies. Can you maybe just breakdown
- 21:54what that actually means for Salesforce?
- 21:56Certainly it means that the direct variable cost to deliver
- 22:00their cloud services, things like data center hosting, maybe
- 22:04some basic customer support for the core product, any third
- 22:07party license royalties they might pay.
- 22:09That cost is relatively low per additional user or customer.
- 22:12OK. Low incremental costs.
- 22:14Very low sales forces. Gross profit margins are
- 22:17typically around 7578%. 75 to 78%, that's huge.
- 22:22It's phenomenal. It means that for every dollar
- 22:25of subscription revenue they generate, only about 22 to $0.25
- 22:29are consumed by those direct costs.
- 22:32This is a true hallmark of the software as a service model.
- 22:36It provides powerful economies of scale because serving an
- 22:39additional customer or user on their multi tenant cloud
- 22:42infrastructure doesn't add a lot of direct incremental cost.
- 22:46Once the platform is built, each new subscriber is highly
- 22:49profitable, at least at the gross margin level.
- 22:51That's a very strong foundation then.
- 22:53So if those direct costs are relatively low, where do the
- 22:56larger expenses come into play? What eats into those impressive
- 22:59gross profits? Yeah.
- 23:00The big spenders for Salesforce are squarely in the operating
- 23:03expenses category or OpEx, and these often determine their
- 23:07ultimate profitability, OK. Sales and marketing S&M has
- 23:10historically been Salesforce's single largest operating expense
- 23:13category. Sales and marketing #1.
- 23:15By far. In fiscal year 2023, for
- 23:18instance, it was over $13 billion.
- 23:20That consumed roughly 36% of their total revenue. 36% on S&M.
- 23:24Yeah, and in prior years, during its hyper growth phase, it was
- 23:28often even higher, maybe 4550%. Wow.
- 23:31This budget is heavily weighted towards personnel.
- 23:34You know, that's the salaries and commissions for their
- 23:36massive global sales force and extensive marketing programs.
- 23:40Think about their huge, immersive Dreamforce conference.
- 23:44Right. Dreamforce is massive.
- 23:46It is. It's essentially the cost of
- 23:48acquiring new customers, expanding relationships with
- 23:50existing ones, and just maintaining their brand
- 23:52dominance in a highly competitive market.
- 23:54OK. So S&M is the biggest piece.
- 23:56What about investing in the future like research and
- 23:58development? That's got to be significant for
- 24:00a tech leader. Absolutely.
- 24:01Research and development R&D is the second largest expense
- 24:04category. In FY20 25 it stood at about
- 24:07$6.0 billion. That represented roughly 16% of
- 24:10revenue. 16% on R&D. Yeah, this covers the salaries
- 24:14of thousands of engineers, product developers, AI
- 24:17researchers, the people crucial for continuous innovation,
- 24:21developing new features and keeping the platform at the
- 24:23cutting edge, especially now in areas like generative AI.
- 24:26Right, got to fund the AI race. Exactly.
- 24:29Well, R&D is considered more of a fixed cost in the short term.
- 24:32It's a vital strategic investment to stay competitive,
- 24:35drive future growth and differentiate against those mega
- 24:38cap rivals we discussed. It's not directly tied to the
- 24:41number of customers served today, but rather to the
- 24:44company's commitment to advancing its technological
- 24:46prowess. Got it.
- 24:48What about the other costs? General and administrative GNA
- 24:51costs are smaller in comparison. They typically range from 810%
- 24:54of revenue. This covers corporate overhead
- 24:57like finance, legal, human resources, executive management,
- 25:01the cost of running the corporation itself and capital
- 25:04expenditures. CapEx are relatively modest
- 25:07compared to revenue, usually around 2% in FY20 25.
- 25:11This is primarily for data centers in IT infrastructure.
- 25:14Salesforce isn't an overly acid intensive business in the
- 25:17traditional sense, which is generally seen as a positive
- 25:20from a capital efficiency perspective.
- 25:22So when you break it down like that, it really boils down to
- 25:25people, doesn't it? The bulk of their cost is
- 25:28essentially human capital, the sales force, the marketers, the
- 25:31engineers. You've absolutely hit the nail
- 25:33on the head. The single most significant cost
- 25:35for sales force is indeed personnel salaries, commissions,
- 25:40stock based compensation, which is a big non cash expense for
- 25:43them. For it's approximately 76,000
- 25:45employees. That's the overwhelming expense
- 25:47category. Salesforce essentially spends
- 25:49heavily to acquire and retain top talent, to acquire customers
- 25:53through that Salesforce and to develop cutting edge products
- 25:56that maintain its market leadership.
- 25:58Their intellectual property and their human capital are their
- 26:00most valuable assets and therefore also their largest
- 26:03expenses. OK.
- 26:05Now, you mentioned earlier that Salesforce has been consciously
- 26:08moving towards efficient growth, especially after that activist
- 26:12investor pressure. How has that mindset shift
- 26:15specifically impacted this cost structure we just outlined?
- 26:18It sounds like it must have been a significant change.
- 26:21It was a very significant change, and it truly highlights
- 26:24management's agility, or perhaps responsiveness under pressure.
- 26:28Salesforce deliberately pivoted from that growth at all costs
- 26:32mentality to an efficient growth mindset, particularly after the
- 26:35activist pressure ramped up in 2023.
- 26:38And this wasn't just talk. It involved concrete actions,
- 26:41most notably that significant 10% workforce layoff, impacting
- 26:44about 7000 employees globally. Right.
- 26:47That was big news. It was, and they also
- 26:49implemented a freeze on major hiring.
- 26:51This was a very public and impactful adjustment to their
- 26:54fixed costs, primarily personnel costs.
- 26:56And the result. The result has been dramatic, A
- 26:58substantial expansion of their gap operating margin soaring
- 27:01from just 2% in FY20 23 to that robust 19% we saw in FY20 25.
- 27:07Wow, 2% to 19% gap margin in two years.
- 27:10Exactly. It proves management's ability
- 27:13to adjust these large labor centric fixed costs during
- 27:17slowdowns or when prompted. They can effectively leverage
- 27:20those high gross margins to translate more of that top line
- 27:24revenue into bottom line profit when they choose to or need to.
- 27:28So in high growth periods, they've shown they can invest
- 27:31aggressively, which compresses margins.
- 27:35But in tougher economic times or under investor pressure, they've
- 27:38now proven they can pull back, reduce or slow cost growth and
- 27:42boost profitability. That's a key sign of a maturing
- 27:45and arguably more disciplined company.
- 27:47That's a clear demonstration of financial discipline and
- 27:50responsiveness to shareholder demands.
- 27:52OK, shifting gears slightly, what about the people at the
- 27:55helm? How stable and aligned is
- 27:57Salesforce's leadership as they navigate these complex dynamics
- 28:00we've been discussing? Yeah, management and governance
- 28:02are undeniably key to steering such a large, complex ship
- 28:05through these waters. Marc Benioff, the Co founder,
- 28:08chair and CEO remains the iconic leader.
- 28:11He's been there since 1999. He's not just a CEO, he's really
- 28:15the visionary public face of the company, consistently driving
- 28:18strategy, especially around growth and new initiatives like
- 28:21AI. Right, he's synonymous with
- 28:23Salesforce. It really is.
- 28:25And importantly, he also retains a significant personal stake,
- 28:28approximately 2.3% of shares as of 2025.
- 28:33That strongly aligns his personal financial outcomes with
- 28:35those of other shareholders. OK, good alignment there.
- 28:39Who else is key? Other key figures include Robin
- 28:41Washington as president and KEO CFO, bringing a wealth of
- 28:46financial experience and Parker Harris, the other Co founder And
- 28:49CPO is still deeply involved in the technology direction.
- 28:53The board of directors also includes figures like Mason
- 28:56Morfit from the activist fund Value Act Capital.
- 28:58The activist on the board. Exactly.
- 29:00He joined as part of those earlier activist discussions,
- 29:03ensuring their shareholder perspectives are well
- 29:04represented right at the top. What's their track record been
- 29:07like in terms of performance and maybe transparency?
- 29:10Have they generally delivered on their promises?
- 29:12Management has a proven track record of well aggressive goal
- 29:16setting and generally meeting or in many cases recently exceeding
- 29:20guidance. For instance, after promising a
- 29:2325% plus non GAAP operating margin by FY20 26, they were
- 29:27already eating 34% by mid 2025, far surpassing that initial
- 29:31goal. Right, blew past that target.
- 29:33Yeah, suggests strong execution on cost control and strategic
- 29:36initiatives on transparency. They've been quite candid about
- 29:40broad challenges, like openly acknowledging some sales
- 29:43execution issues back in 2022. However, they sometimes been
- 29:47less specific on certain granular metrics.
- 29:50For example, they stopped reporting precise customer
- 29:52counts after 2016, and getting detailed acquisition integration
- 29:56costs can sometimes be tricky for external analysts trying to
- 29:59fully dissect underlying trends. OK, so mostly transparent, but
- 30:02some details are harder to get. Generally, yes.
- 30:05That said, crucially, there haven't been any serious
- 30:08allegations of financial misconduct, which is obviously
- 30:10paramount for investor trust. Absolutely.
- 30:12And what about that notable event you mentioned earlier, the
- 30:15shareholder vote on executive pay?
- 30:17What did that signal about how shareholders view their
- 30:20leadership? Yeah, that was a very notable
- 30:22event. The majority vote against
- 30:24Salesforce's executive pay plan in 2024. 54% against, you said.
- 30:2954% This wasn't just a minor descent.
- 30:31It signaled clear widespread shareholder concerns about
- 30:34executive compensation levels, particularly for Marc Benioff.
- 30:38And it highlighted A collective desire for better alignment of
- 30:41management incentives with sustained shareholder value
- 30:44creation right now. While the vote was technically
- 30:47advisory, meaning non binding, it carries substantial weight
- 30:51and public relations implications.
- 30:52It definitely demonstrates active shareholder engagement.
- 30:55Sends a message. It sends a message.
- 30:58However, as I mentioned, Benioff's substantial equity
- 31:01ownership does naturally align him with shareholder outcomes to
- 31:04a large degree. And the company is also known
- 31:06for its distinctive Ohana culture, that philosophy rooted
- 31:10in the Hawaiian concept of family and community, which they
- 31:13try to extend to employees, customers, partners, alongside
- 31:17its strong ethical initiatives. Right, The Ohana culture is well
- 31:19known. It is and.
- 31:21While there was higher executive turnover around 2022, the
- 31:24company seems to have stabilized the team since then, often
- 31:27promoting internally or bringing veterans back with Benny Austin
- 31:31during presence, providing that strong sense of continuity and
- 31:34strategic direction. It certainly sounds like a
- 31:36founder LED company that has demonstrated, perhaps partly
- 31:39prompted by activists, A willingness to be responsive to
- 31:42investor calls for greater discipline and financial
- 31:44transparency even on sensitive issues like executive
- 31:48compensation. OK, Now let's turn our attention
- 31:51specifically to the people who truly own Salesforce, the
- 31:54shareholders. Who are they, broadly speaking,
- 31:57and how have they been influenced in the company's
- 31:58strategic direction, especially concerning something as
- 32:01fundamental as capital returns? This feels like where the rubber
- 32:05truly meets the road for how value is created and distributed
- 32:10back to owners. This is a profoundly crucial
- 32:13area, you're right. As shareholder influence has
- 32:15visibly and dramatically reshaped Salesforce's recent
- 32:18actions, it's marked as significant, almost
- 32:21unprecedented pivot for the company.
- 32:23Understanding these dynamics is really key to seeing where the
- 32:26company might be headed. So who are the biggest players
- 32:28in terms of ownership? Are we talking about a diverse
- 32:30group or is it concentrated with just a few dominant
- 32:33institutions? Ownership is overwhelmingly
- 32:35dominated by large institutional investors.
- 32:38You can pretty much think of the big three index fund firms,
- 32:41Vanguard Group holding about 9.2%, BlackRock with
- 32:45approximately 8.4%, and State Street holding around 5.1% as
- 32:49collectively commanding over 20% of the stock.
- 32:52Wow, over a fifth just between those three, yeah.
- 32:55These are largely passive funds, meaning they don't actively pick
- 32:58stocks based on fundamentals, but their sheer size gives them
- 33:01immense voting power and therefore significant influence
- 33:04on governance matters like board elections and executive pay.
- 33:07Right. Of giants with active voices
- 33:10sometimes. Increasingly so.
- 33:12Beyond them, other large active managers like Fidelity and T
- 33:15Rowe Price also hold significant stakes, contributing to a
- 33:19diverse but definitely institutional heavy ownership
- 33:21base. And what about activist
- 33:23investors? We hear a lot about them shaking
- 33:25things up and forcing change. Were they a major factor here?
- 33:29You mentioned them earlier. Indeed, activist investors were
- 33:32a huge factor. They really acted as a catalyst
- 33:34for much of the change, particularly the efficiency, Dr.
- 33:37and capital return shift we've discussed.
- 33:39In early 2023, several prominent activist hedge funds, including
- 33:43Starboard Value, Value Act Capital and Elliott Management,
- 33:46acquired significant stakes. Big names and activism.
- 33:49Very big names, yeah. And they didn't just quietly buy
- 33:51shares, They actively engaged management, pushing relentlessly
- 33:55for changes, particularly around margin expansion, increase
- 33:58profitability and a more disciplined capital allocation
- 34:01strategy. Basically stop spending so much,
- 34:04return more cash. And as we noted, Value Add
- 34:07Capital even secured that board seat for its CEO, Mason Morphit,
- 34:11which provided a direct channel for influence right inside the
- 34:14company's highest decision making body.
- 34:16How did these shareholders, particularly the activists,
- 34:19managed to exert their power? Did it come down to a
- 34:21contentious proxy fight or was it more behind the scenes
- 34:25pressure? It was a very intense period,
- 34:27definitely, but it ultimately averted a full blown public
- 34:30proxy fight, which can get ugly. Instead, it seemed to be a
- 34:33sustained, concentrated campaign of pressure and dialogue.
- 34:37And that very strong signal was sent to the 2025 annual
- 34:41stockholder system meeting with that majority vote, 54% against
- 34:45Salesforce's 2024 executive pay plan.
- 34:48That pay vote again, Yeah. That was a clear rebuke, driven
- 34:52largely by proxy advisory firms like ISS and Glass Lewis
- 34:55recommending against it. And it showed that even those
- 34:58large, typically passive funds like Vanguard and BlackRock were
- 35:01willing to assert their governance concerns by voting
- 35:03against management on pay. Sends a strong signal even if
- 35:07it's non binding. Absolutely.
- 35:09While such votes are advisory, they carry substantial weight
- 35:12and public relations implications.
- 35:14However, it's also important to note that shareholders did
- 35:16reelect all board nominees, including Benioff, with broad
- 35:20support. This indicated general
- 35:22confidence in the board's overall direction, especially
- 35:25after the activist settlement led to those concrete changes in
- 35:28strategy. OK, so the activists didn't get
- 35:31everything they wanted, perhaps, but they certainly drove change.
- 35:34What were the tangible, real world outcomes of this activism
- 35:39and broader shareholder pressure?
- 35:41How did it reshape Salesforce's operations and financial
- 35:44strategy? Well, by late 2023, the activist
- 35:47funds were largely expressing satisfaction, at least publicly.
- 35:50They had seen Salesforce implement significant cost
- 35:53cutting layoffs, dramatically expand its buyback
- 35:56authorizations, initiate a dividend and add new independent
- 35:59directors to the board. This proactive response by
- 36:03management effectively averted those potential proxy fights and
- 36:06demonstrated a clear willingness to engage constructively with
- 36:10its most significant shareholders.
- 36:12But the most monumental, the truly transformative shift which
- 36:16really ushered in what many see as a new era for Salesforce, is
- 36:19in its capital return policy. OK, let's focus on that.
- 36:22This wasn't just a tweak, it was a fundamental reorientation of
- 36:25their financial philosophy. Tell us more about that because
- 36:27Salesforce was historically known for reinvesting virtually
- 36:30everything back into growth, often through acquisitions,
- 36:34right? That sounds like a complete
- 36:35reversal. Exactly.
- 36:36That's the perfect way to put it.
- 36:37For years, Salesforce epitomized that growth at all costs
- 36:41philosophy. They prioritized market share
- 36:43and top line expansion above almost everything else,
- 36:45including reported profits or returning cash.
- 36:48But that is fundamentally changed.
- 36:50Salesforce initiated its first ever share repurchase program
- 36:53only in 2022, starting with a $10 billion authorization.
- 36:57That alone was unprecedented for the company.
- 37:00Just starting in 2022. Yeah, very late compared to
- 37:03other large tech firms. Then in early 2024, it was
- 37:06expanded by another $10 billion. But the really big news, the
- 37:10truly eye popping figure that signaled this new phase came in
- 37:13September 2025, a further $20 billion increase, bringing the
- 37:19total authorized buyback program to that staggering $50 billion.
- 37:2350 billion. That's incredible.
- 37:25It's a massive authorization. It represents over 20% of the
- 37:28company's current market capitalization, and it's just a
- 37:31stark contrast to the prior decade where Salesforce
- 37:33virtually didn't repurchase stock.
- 37:35In fact, it's share count often rose significantly due to its
- 37:38aggressive acquisition strategy using stock.
- 37:41Right dilution was common. Very common now we are actually
- 37:44witnessing the share count begin to decline, indicating a genuine
- 37:47commitment to using buybacks to enhance shareholder value, not
- 37:52just offset dilution. And what about dividends?
- 37:54You mentioned those two. Is that also part of this new,
- 37:57more mature approach to capital allocation?
- 37:59Yes, absolutely. The company also initiated its
- 38:02first ever cash dividend in 2023.
- 38:05First dividend ever in 2023. That's right.
- 38:08It started modestly at dollars and $0.15 per share quarterly,
- 38:12but it has since been raised to billion dollars, $0.22 per share
- 38:14quarterly as of Q2 fiscal year 2026.
- 38:18OK. So growing the dividend too.
- 38:19Growing it, Yeah. Now, while it's still modest in
- 38:22terms of yield compared to, say, some mature industrial
- 38:24companies, this dividend symbolizes Salesforce's new
- 38:28phase as a truly cash generative company.
- 38:30It shows they're not willing to directly reward shareholders
- 38:33with consistent cash payouts. This is a notable departure from
- 38:36its history and signals a shift to a much more balanced approach
- 38:41between reinvestment for growth and direct returns to owners.
- 38:44Management has stated the buyback program is more
- 38:47opportunistic, used to offset dilution and return excess cash
- 38:50when the price is right, while the dividend signals a more
- 38:53mature, consistent return commitment to shareholders.
- 38:56It really solidifies this new identity.
- 38:58This is truly a significant pivot.
- 39:00As you said, it marks a clear transition from a growth at all
- 39:04costs philosophy to a more mature shareholder return
- 39:08focused approach. It fundamentally changes how one
- 39:11might view the company's long term value proposition and maybe
- 39:14even its valuation multiple over time.
- 39:17OK, this is where we really roll up our sleeves and apply it,
- 39:19let's say stringent framework. We're going to put Salesforce
- 39:23through a Buffett style checklist goblet.
- 39:26Exactly. This isn't just a casual glance.
- 39:28This framework is designed to help us gauge a company's
- 39:31fundamental strength, it's economic mode, as Buffett calls
- 39:34it, and it's overall value proposition with the same kind
- 39:37of discerning eye that Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger
- 39:39famously apply. Think of it as using a
- 39:41sophisticated diagnostic tool, maybe like that Buffett
- 39:44Indicator app people use for the whole market, but applying
- 39:47similar principles to measure the intrinsic health and sort of
- 39:50market temperature of this one particular stock.
- 39:53Indeed, the goal, as Buffett puts it, is to identify great
- 39:58companies at a great price. It's a high bar, especially for
- 40:02a company like Salesforce that has historically been viewed as
- 40:04a high growth tech stock, not a traditional value play.
- 40:08Right, Let's see how Salesforce measures up against Warren
- 40:11Buffett's renowned criteria. Drawing on roughly the past
- 40:14decade of data, we'll cover everything from valuation and
- 40:17cash generation to growth, balance sheet safety, and core
- 40:21profitability. OK, first up, valuation
- 40:23discipline. Buffett is famously patient
- 40:25about price, looking for undeniable bargains.
- 40:28How does Salesforce stack up against his preference for a
- 40:31price to earnings PE ratio of 15 or less compared to its own
- 40:34history? Right, the PE test on that
- 40:36critical front, it's historically been a clear fail.
- 40:39Salesforce's trailing PE ratio, even using its improved GAP
- 40:43earnings from FY20 25, is around 26 X.
- 40:46Stillwell above 15. Well above and historically for
- 40:50many years, it's PE was often in the hundreds or even not
- 40:53meaningful at all because reported earnings were so low or
- 40:56negative. Investors have consistently paid
- 40:59a significant premium for its growth and market leadership far
- 41:02exceeding Buffett's traditional valuation comfort zone.
- 41:05So by this stringent metric, Salesforce has almost always
- 41:09been perceived as expensive relative to its current
- 41:12earnings. OK.
- 41:13What about price to book PB value?
- 41:15Buffett sometimes looks at that, aiming for 1.5 or less.
- 41:19Another fail here. Salesforce's price to book ratio
- 41:22is about 2.7 X currently, even after a significant stock
- 41:26decline from its peak a few years ago.
- 41:28Still above 1.5. Yeah.
- 41:30And for most of the past decade, it ranged much higher from 5X to
- 41:3310X during its high growth years.
- 41:35Now, Salesforce does carry substantial intangible assets
- 41:38like goodwill from all those acquisitions, which inflates its
- 41:41book value. But this metric is quite
- 41:43stringent for software companies anyway, where the real value
- 41:46lies more in intellectual property and recurring revenue
- 41:50than physical assets. Salesforce simply doesn't meet
- 41:53Buffett's preferred 1.5 X standard.
- 41:55Got it. And the crucial margin of
- 41:57safety? Paying at least 25% below your
- 42:00estimate of intrinsic value, leaving plenty of room for
- 42:03error. This one is a bit subjective,
- 42:06obviously, because it depends on our intrinsic value estimate.
- 42:08But based on our later DCF analysis, which we'll get to OK,
- 42:11a conservative intrinsic value estimate might be around $205
- 42:15per share. At its current price of
- 42:16approximately $165, the stock is about 20% below that
- 42:20conservative estimate. So close to 25%, but not quite
- 42:23there. Not quite there, so probably a
- 42:26fail on the strict 25% rule. For vital context, the stock did
- 42:30briefly trade down in the 130, a $150.00 range, during the
- 42:34broader market downturn in late 2022 That would have offered a
- 42:37much better margin of safety based on that conservative
- 42:39value. Right timing matters.
- 42:41It certainly does, so at its current level, it's maybe
- 42:43borderline undervalued or on a conservative basis, but not a
- 42:46clear deep bargain hitting that strict 25% discount.
- 42:49OK. Let's move on to cash generation
- 42:50and allocation, a favorite topic for value investors.
- 42:53How has Salesforce performed in terms of consistent positive
- 42:57free cash flow FCF and a healthy FCF to revenue ratio say above
- 43:025%? OK, now this is an area where
- 43:04Fields Force truly shines and demonstrates its fundamental
- 43:07business strength. It's a resounding pass.
- 43:09Or a clear pass OK. Absolutely.
- 43:12Salesforce has consistently generated positive free cash
- 43:14flow year in and year out for over a decade.
- 43:17Even in years where it's gap net income was negative or very low,
- 43:21it's strong operating cash flow thanks to upfront subscription
- 43:25collections. High non cash expenses like
- 43:28stock based comp depreciation meant robust FCF.
- 43:32Cash flow is always there. Always there and FCF margins
- 43:35have ranged impressively from 15% to sometimes as high as 33%
- 43:40in recent years. That's well exceeding the simple
- 43:425% criterion Buffett looks for. So both consistency and the
- 43:46margin threshold are met with flying colors.
- 43:48It's a powerful cash generating machine.
- 43:50Good. To hear What about return on
- 43:51retained earnings? How effectively have they
- 43:54converted retained profits into more earnings or market value?
- 43:57Buffett looks for at least 12%. This one is complex for
- 44:01Salesforce, unfortunately, I don't have to mark it as
- 44:03inconclusive fail in the traditional Buffett sense.
- 44:06Why is that? Well, due to its history of
- 44:08often having negative retained earnings until very recently and
- 44:11those numerous large acquisitions funded
- 44:14significantly by stock issuance, it really muddy the waters of
- 44:18organic capital deployment. It's genuinely difficult to
- 44:22definitively assess how well retained operating profits, not
- 44:26new equity capital raised from shareholders, were reinvested to
- 44:30generate additional earnings or market value.
- 44:32OK. The acquisitions complicate it.
- 44:34They really do. While GAP BPS has grown
- 44:36significantly recently, especially with the margin
- 44:38expansion drive, it's not purely from reinvested operating
- 44:42profits in the simple compounding way Buffett
- 44:45typically measures. Plus, the long period of very
- 44:48low return on equity also makes it challenging to say it passes
- 44:51this specific measure in Buffett's traditional pure
- 44:54capital allocation sets. Understood.
- 44:56Next section. Growth and predictability.
- 44:58Buffett famously like steady, predictable, almost boring
- 45:01growth. Did Salesforce show positive and
- 45:04rising GAAP EPS every single year for the past 10 years?
- 45:06On GAAP EPS consistency, that's a clear fail.
- 45:09Fail OK. Salesforce's GAAP EPS was
- 45:13negative or negligible in many years prior to about 2018, and
- 45:17it even saw significant declines more recently, for example, in
- 45:20FY20 23, due to one time charges and that big restructuring,
- 45:23right. It simply does not exhibit the
- 45:25monotonic consistent year over year earnings growth that
- 45:28Buffett prefers, where each year is predictably better than the
- 45:32last. Its earnings chart has been much
- 45:34more jagged, reflecting its aggressive growth, investments
- 45:37and acquisition activity. Not smooth at all.
- 45:39OK. What about book value per share?
- 45:41Did that grow by at least 10% AGR over 10 years without any
- 45:45declines? Now, this one is interesting.
- 45:47It's technically a pass, but with a very important caveat.
- 45:50Pass with a caveat. Tell me more.
- 45:52Salesforce's book value per share grew impressively from
- 45:54approximately $6.02 back in 2015 to around $66.25 in 2025.
- 46:01Huge growth. Yeah.
- 46:02That's a compound annual growth rate of roughly 27%, far above
- 46:05the 10% threshold. And importantly, it never
- 46:08declined year over year during that period.
- 46:09So why the caveat? The caveat is how it grew.
- 46:13This robust growth was largely fueled by issuing shares for
- 46:16those large acquisitions. We keep mentioning Mule Soft,
- 46:19Tableau, Slack, potentially Informatica.
- 46:22It wasn't purely organic, retained earnings from
- 46:24operations building up the book. Belt acquisitions funded by
- 46:27stock. Exactly.
- 46:29Buffett's original intent for this metric probably leans more
- 46:31towards organic intrinsic value growth driven by internal
- 46:34reinvestment, but strictly looking at the numbers, the book
- 46:38value per share has indeed grown impressively and consistently.
- 46:42OK. And owner's earnings essentially
- 46:44a more representative measure of free cash flow, were they
- 46:48positive every year? And did the owner's earnings to
- 46:50market cap ratio, the yield hit at least 10%?
- 46:54It's a partial pass here. Partial pass?
- 46:56How so? Salesforce's owner's earnings,
- 46:58which we can approximate closely with its free cash flow, have
- 47:01been consistently positive every single year for at least the
- 47:04past decade. Even when Gap net income was
- 47:07negative, the cash flowed. So it passes the consistency
- 47:10part with flying colors. OK.
- 47:11Consistent cash flow. But the owner's earnings yield
- 47:15the OE market cap ratio. Currently it stands at about
- 47:187.9% using their strong FY20 25 FCF.
- 47:23That's below Buffett's strict 10% hurdle.
- 47:25Below. 10%. Yeah.
- 47:27And in earlier years, when the stock price was higher relative
- 47:29to cash flow, this ratio is often much lower.
- 47:33This indicates Salesforce was consistently priced richly
- 47:35relative to its actual cash generation, meaning you weren't
- 47:38getting that 10% initial return in terms of cash flow yield at
- 47:42the purchase price Buffett often looks for.
- 47:44Got it. OK, let's turn to balance sheet
- 47:46safety. Buffett loves a rock solid
- 47:48conservative balance sheet. Is debt to equity below his
- 47:51preferred .5 threshold indicating minimal leverage?
- 47:54Yes, that's a clear pass. Sales Force's debt to equity
- 47:57ratio is very low, currently at .19 as of FY20 25.
- 48:01Very low, very low. Even at its peak right after the
- 48:04big Slack acquisition, it only went up to around .24.
- 48:07This signifies a very comfortable balance sheet with
- 48:09minimal financial leverage. Sales Force often opts to issue
- 48:11equity for its major acquisitions rather than relying
- 48:13solely on debt, which helps maintain this conservative
- 48:16capital structure. OK.
- 48:17How well does its operating income cover its interest
- 48:20payments? Buffett looks for interest
- 48:22coverage interests of at least three times.
- 48:25Another strong pass. Mostly.
- 48:27Salesforce's operating income vastly exceeds its interest
- 48:29expense. In FY20 25, the coverage ratio
- 48:32was around 33 X, hugely above the 3X threshold. 33 times,
- 48:37yeah, that's safe. Very safe.
- 48:39Well, it did tip lower to about 3.6 X in that lean FY20 23 due
- 48:44to temporary factors depressing operating profit.
- 48:46It has generally been extremely robust and far more than
- 48:49sufficient. So yes, it easily passes this
- 48:51test, demonstrating excellent debt servicing capacity.
- 48:53Good. And related to that is interest
- 48:56expense, a small fraction of operating income, ideally 15% or
- 48:59less. There's also a pass, mostly.
- 49:01Interest expense is typically a very small fraction of operating
- 49:04income, often under 4% in strong years like FY20 24 and FY20 25.
- 49:08Tiny percentage. Very small.
- 49:10The only real exception was that anomalous FY20 23 where it
- 49:14temporarily hit 28% because operating profit dip so much
- 49:19relative to a fairly fixed interest cost.
- 49:22Aside from that single outlier year, sales force's interest
- 49:25burden is minimal, indicating a very strong financial position
- 49:28and minimal drag on its operating performance from debt
- 49:31costs. OK.
- 49:32Finally, for the balance sheet, a current ratio greater than
- 49:341.5. This shows ample short term
- 49:37liquidity to cover immediate liabilities.
- 49:40On this specific metric, it's actually a fail.
- 49:42Fail. Why is that if the balance sheet
- 49:44is strong? Sales force's current ratio,
- 49:47Current assets divided by current liabilities, has
- 49:49typically been around 1.0 to 1.2.
- 49:52Now this is actually quite common for subscription software
- 49:55companies and it's due to with Pacific Accounting Treatment,
- 49:58they carry large amounts of deferred revenue that's cash
- 50:00collected upfront from customers for services they'll deliver in
- 50:03the future. Accountants classify this
- 50:05deferred revenue as a current liability.
- 50:08So it's cash received but not yet earned.
- 50:10Exactly. So while Salesforce has
- 50:12substantial cash on hand, often billions, for exceeding that
- 50:15deferred revenue, numerically this accounting treatment of
- 50:19deferred revenue is a current liability causes its current
- 50:22ratio to fall short of Buffett's conservative 1.5 standard.
- 50:25So it's not necessarily a sign of liquidity to stress in their
- 50:28case, but it doesn't meet the strict miracle criterion.
- 50:31Understood. OK.
- 50:32Last section of the checklist, Profitability and efficiency.
- 50:36How effectively does the business convert its revenue
- 50:38into actual profits? Gross margin greater than 40%.
- 50:42And easy pass and then some. Salesforce's gross margins, as
- 50:46we discussed, are consistently high at 7378%, well above 40%.
- 50:50This is a strong indicator of its powerful sauce business
- 50:53model and its ability to scale efficiently.
- 50:56OK. Net profit margin of at least
- 50:5820%. This is currently a fail, while
- 51:00it's improving significantly in recent years with the efficiency
- 51:02push. Salesforce's GAP Net margin was
- 51:05approximately 16.4% in FY20 25. Close, but not quite 20%.
- 51:10Not quite 20% on a gap basis yet and historically it was often in
- 51:15the single digits or even near 0 as the company aggressively
- 51:18prioritize growth over reported accounting profit.
- 51:22So on a GAAP basis, it has not consistently met that 20%
- 51:25threshold, although it's certainly trending strongly in
- 51:27that direction now. OK.
- 51:29Return on equity Roe averaging 15% or more over the past 10
- 51:32years. Another clear fail.
- 51:34Return on equity was very low for much of the past decade,
- 51:37often ranging from 0% to 3%. It only recently reached
- 51:41approximately 10.1% in FY20 25. 10% recently, but low
- 51:46historically. Exactly.
- 51:47The 10 year average is well below 50%.
- 51:49This is partly due to that large equity base created by its
- 51:52acquisition strategy using stock, but it also reflects
- 51:55those years of low reported net income that depress the return
- 51:58generated on that growing equity base.
- 52:01Makes sense. How about return on invested
- 52:03capital ROIC or return on total capital ROTC?
- 52:06Looking for at least 12% on average over 10 years.
- 52:09This measures how efficiently they're deploying all capital,
- 52:12both debt and equity. It's also a fail.
- 52:15Return on invested capital has been pretty modest.
- 52:17It was roughly 8.5% in FY20 25, and often lower historically.
- 52:22A low 12%, yeah. This is a common characteristic
- 52:24for growth companies that have made significant acquisitions,
- 52:27resulting in large amounts of goodwill on the balance sheet.
- 52:30Goodwill intrinsically drags down ROIC figures calculated in
- 52:34the standard way, so it hasn't consistently met Buffett's
- 52:37standard for efficient capital utilization across all its
- 52:41deployed capital. OK.
- 52:42Return on assets ROA of at least 6%.
- 52:45This one is borderline. Return on assets just hit 6.0%
- 52:49in FY20. 25 S it barely met the criterion for that specific
- 52:53year. Just squeaked by.
- 52:54Just squeaked by. However, the 10 year average ROA
- 52:57is far below this level because again, net income was tiny for
- 53:00many years, while total assets grew very rapidly through
- 53:02acquisitions. So historically, it hasn't
- 53:05consistently met this 6% standard across the decade.
- 53:08OK. And finally, a low depreciation
- 53:10relative to gross profit, suggesting it's not an asset
- 53:12heavy business. Buffett might look for 10% or
- 53:14less. Here we have a strong pass.
- 53:17Sales forces, depreciation and amortization typically run at a
- 53:21lean five, 8% of its gross profit, well under the 10% mark.
- 53:26OK. This indicates it's not an
- 53:28overly asset intensive business in the traditional sense.
- 53:31It aligns perfectly with Buffett's preference for low
- 53:34CapEx models, where a large portion of the value and expense
- 53:38is tied up in human capital and intellectual property rather
- 53:41than heavy machinery or physical infrastructure that depreciates
- 53:44quickly. OK.
- 53:45So after putting Salesforce through this rigorous
- 53:48comprehensive checklist, what does this all mean?
- 53:51How did Salesforce ultimately perform on our Buffett style
- 53:54assessment? And maybe more importantly, what
- 53:56does it tell us about the company's evolution?
- 53:58Right, The big picture, take away what this all means is that
- 54:01Salesforce, particularly in its earlier iteration as a pure
- 54:04growth stock, failed many of Buffett's classic test for being
- 54:08a great company at a great price.
- 54:10Right, the price is often the sticking point.
- 54:12Exactly. It's valuation has generally
- 54:14been too high for a traditional value investors comfort and it's
- 54:18gap earnings record was quite erratic until very recently,
- 54:21lacking that consistent monotonic growth that Buffett
- 54:24famously prefers. But the picture is much more
- 54:28nuanced now and it has changed significantly.
- 54:31Salesforce scores exceptionally well on crucial underlying
- 54:34quality metrics that Buffett does value highly, things like
- 54:38it's consistently high gross margins, it's powerful and
- 54:41consistent free cash flow generation and it's very strong
- 54:44low leverage balance sheet. Strong fundamentals underneath.
- 54:47Absolutely. These are undeniable signs of a
- 54:49fundamentally powerful and resilient business model.
- 54:52Its undeniable Moat, its market dominance in CRM was built in
- 54:57part at the cost of heavy spending in its earlier growth
- 55:00phase, which suppressed reported GAAP profitability for years.
- 55:03But the key take away, I think, is this.
- 55:06While maybe not a classic Buffett stock of the past, the
- 55:09kind he might have bought cheap in its early days and held for
- 55:13decades, Salesforce is certainly moving strongly in the direction
- 55:16value investors appreciate. It's showing clear signs of
- 55:20maturity. It's focusing on improving
- 55:22margins, disciplined expansion, and, crucially, beginning to
- 55:25return significant capital to shareholders.
- 55:28Right, the capital return is huge.
- 55:29It is, and it's worth remembering that even Berkshire
- 55:32Hathaway itself briefly invested in Salesforce back in 2020.
- 55:36That suggests an appreciation even then for its underlying
- 55:39business quality, despite some of these traditional valuation
- 55:42concerns we just walked through. It's truly a company in
- 55:44transition, and that this checklist really helps us see
- 55:47the magnitude and direction of that shift.
- 55:50This framework provides such a clear, almost X-ray vision for
- 55:54analyzing a company, doesn't it? It helps us see beyond just the
- 55:57headlines and truly understand the the DNA of the business and
- 56:01how it's changing. OK, Understanding the past and
- 56:03present, the business model, the risks, the checklist.
- 56:06That's all crucial context. But for investors, the real game
- 56:10is always about the future, isn't it?
- 56:11How does this deep dive with all its insights into performance
- 56:14risks and these structural changes translate into a
- 56:17potential intrinsic value for Salesforce?
- 56:20This is where we attempt to, well, quantify that future
- 56:23potential. Exactly this is where a
- 56:25discounted cash flow or DCF analysis becomes absolutely
- 56:29invaluable to powerful and widely respected valuation
- 56:32method, but certainly not without its own limitations.
- 56:35Essentially what it does is IT projects sales forces, future
- 56:38free cash flow, FCF, that actual cash the business generates
- 56:42after all expenses and reinvestments and then it
- 56:45discounts that future stream of cash back to today's value to
- 56:48estimate an intrinsic value, usually under a few different
- 56:51scenarios. OK.
- 56:51Discounting future cash back to the present.
- 56:53Precisely this helps us understand what the company
- 56:56could be worth if certain growth assumptions hold true over the
- 56:59long term. So where do we begin with this
- 57:02projection? What's our starting point for
- 57:03Salesforce? We begin with Salesforce's
- 57:06strong recent free cash flow performance.
- 57:08We'll use the $12.434 billion in FCF generated in fiscal year
- 57:132025 as our baseline, our starting point.
- 57:16OK. That $12.4 billion number.
- 57:19Yeah. And for our analysis, we'll use
- 57:20a 10% discount rate. It's a pretty standard
- 57:23reasonable hurdle rate often used for equity investments.
- 57:27It reflects both the time value of money a dollar today is worth
- 57:30more than a dollar tomorrow, and the inherent risk involved in
- 57:33forecasting future business performance years out.
- 57:37It represents the minimum annual return an investor might
- 57:39typically demand from an investment like this. 10%
- 57:42discount rate, Got it. And then we look at different
- 57:44growth possibilities for that free cash flow, correct, Because
- 57:47forecasting the future is never a single certain path.
- 57:50There's always a range of outcomes.
- 57:52Exactly right. Uncertainty is inherent, so
- 57:55we'll explore 3 distinct scenarios for FCF growth over
- 57:59the next decade to cover a sensible range of potential
- 58:01outcomes for Salesforce. OK.
- 58:03What's the first scenario? Maybe the cautious 1.
- 58:06First, let's consider a conservative case.
- 58:09This assumes very mild 5% FCF growth per year for the next 10
- 58:13years, followed by a modest 2% terminal growth rate thereafter,
- 58:17basically forever into perpetuity.
- 58:19Only 5% growth, that seems low for Salesforce.
- 58:22It is intentionally low. This scenario essentially
- 58:25assumes Salesforce is cash flow barely grows from here, maybe
- 58:28due to significant market saturation finally hitting or
- 58:31intensified competition really taking a bite, or perhaps
- 58:34prolonged economic stagnation globally.
- 58:36It's a cautious. OK.
- 58:37So under that conservative 5% growth, what's the value?
- 58:41Under these rather cautious assumptions, the estimated
- 58:43intrinsic value for Salesforce comes out to approximately $205
- 58:46per share. This gives us a sort of baseline
- 58:49of what the company might be worth if its growth
- 58:51significantly decelerates from historical norms.
- 58:53OK, 205 dollars conservative value.
- 58:56That sets a floor, so to speak. What's the more realistic or
- 58:59maybe nominal outlook, given what we've learned about its
- 59:02strategy in those big AI bats? Right, our nominal or base case.
- 59:06This assumes a more moderate, yet hopefully sustainable 15%
- 59:10FCF growth per year for the next 10 years, also followed by that
- 59:132% terminal growth rate. 15% growth?
- 59:16That feels more plausible, maybe.
- 59:18It represents a path where Salesforce leverages its
- 59:21potential for continued expansion through its new AI
- 59:24initiatives, the introduction of more industry specific clouds
- 59:27and ongoing international growth.
- 59:29It suggests Salesforce can maintain a healthy growth
- 59:31trajectory, albeit not the, you know, 2030% hyper growth of its
- 59:35earlier years. OK.
- 59:36And the value in that nominal 15% case.
- 59:39Here the intrinsic value jumps significantly up to around $425
- 59:43per share. So you see the sensitivity to
- 59:45that growth rate already. This is a scenario where
- 59:47Salesforce maintains good solid growth, but maybe not explosive
- 59:50growth, $425 nominal value, big jump from 205 dollars, OK.
- 59:56And for those who are truly bullish on Salesforce's ability
- 59:59to execute its AI strategy and maybe even reaccelerate growth
- 1:00:02significantly, what does the optimistic case suggest?
- 1:00:06Right, the optimistic case. This is designed to be a highly
- 1:00:09aggressive best case scenario. It assumes a robust 25% FCF
- 1:00:14growth per year for 10 years, followed by a slightly higher 3%
- 1:00:18terminal growth rate, reflecting maybe higher long term inflation
- 1:00:21or growth potential. 25% growth for a decade.
- 1:00:24That's ambitious. Highly ambitious.
- 1:00:27This implies Salesforce significantly reignites hyper
- 1:00:30growth, perhaps driven by extraordinary AI monetization,
- 1:00:33maybe successful market share gains against competitors, and
- 1:00:36broad global expansion hitting on all cylinders.
- 1:00:38OK, the blue sky scenario, what's the value?
- 1:00:40Though under these ambitious conditions, the intrinsic value
- 1:00:42could be as high as $967 per share, almost $1000, this would
- 1:00:47place it firmly in trillion dollar market cap territory.
- 1:00:50This represents really the absolute upper bound of what
- 1:00:53seems conceivable if pretty much everything goes perfectly for
- 1:00:55them. Wow 205 $5 conservative $425
- 1:00:59nominal 967 other optimistic. These numbers are vastly
- 1:01:03different, spanning a huge range depending entirely on our
- 1:01:06assumptions about future growth. So how does that compare to
- 1:01:09where the stock is trading today, around $165?
- 1:01:12And what does it tell us about a potential buy price for an
- 1:01:15interested investor? That's the crucial question that
- 1:01:17ties all our analysis together, isn't it?
- 1:01:19Where does the current price fit in?
- 1:01:21The current stock price for Salesforce is hovering around
- 1:01:23$165 per share now, if we apply Buffett's preferred 25% margin
- 1:01:29of safety to our most conservative intrinsic value
- 1:01:32estimate of approximately $205 per share.
- 1:01:34OK. 25% off 205. Dollars, The target by price
- 1:01:37would be around $155 or lower. 20 Four, $5.75.
- 1:01:40Dollars $554.00 so the current $165 is slightly above that
- 1:01:45conservative by point. Slightly above, yes.
- 1:01:47And it's notable, as we mentioned, that Salesforce did
- 1:01:49briefly trade down in that zone, specifically around 130 a
- 1:01:52$150.00 during the Bradder market downturn in late 2020.
- 1:01:56Two that offered a more compelling entry point based on
- 1:01:58this conservative valuation. So at its current price of $165,
- 1:02:03it's slightly above this conservative margin of safety
- 1:02:05threshold. It implies perhaps modest
- 1:02:08undervaluation relative to a cautious outlook, but maybe not
- 1:02:12a deep bargain by very strict value investing standards.
- 1:02:14OK, but what if you believe more in the nominal case?
- 1:02:19Well, if an investor believes in a growth trajectory closer to
- 1:02:21our nominal case with that intrinsic value of $425 per
- 1:02:25share, then the stock at $165 would appear significantly
- 1:02:29undervalued. Yeah, $165 looks cheap compared
- 1:02:32to 425 dollars. Exactly.
- 1:02:35And that more optimistic 15% growth scenario, the curb price
- 1:02:38would already offer a substantial margin of safety,
- 1:02:41making it potentially a very attractive opportunity for those
- 1:02:44confident in sales forces, future execution and AI strategy
- 1:02:47paying off. This really highlights how
- 1:02:49incredibly sensitive intrinsic value calculations are to our
- 1:02:52assumptions about future growth and profitability, doesn't it?
- 1:02:55It shows why truly understanding those underlying assumptions and
- 1:02:58having a well reasoned basis for them is absolutely crucial for
- 1:03:01any investor making a decision. It's not just about the number,
- 1:03:04but the story behind the number. Absolutely, you've put it
- 1:03:07perfectly. It's vital to remember that
- 1:03:09these valuations are based on specific assumptions about
- 1:03:12future growth, future margins, discount rates, and they are
- 1:03:16inherently forward-looking and absolutely not guaranteed.
- 1:03:19The actual market price will respond to countless
- 1:03:21unforeseeable factors, competitive shifts, broader
- 1:03:25economic conditions, changes in investor sentiment, execution
- 1:03:29successes or failures. This DCF analysis is a powerful
- 1:03:34tool to gauge what a stock might be worth under different
- 1:03:37conditions, helping you to understand the potential upside
- 1:03:40or downside based on your own reasoned beliefs about the
- 1:03:43future. It's a foundational piece of the
- 1:03:45puzzle, but it should never be the only piece you look at.
- 1:03:48OK, before we wrap up, just a quick reminder for everyone
- 1:03:50listening. Disclaimer All financial
- 1:03:53analysis presented here is for informational and educational
- 1:03:55purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 1:03:59It's based on publicly available sources and our own
- 1:04:01interpretations, which may differ from others.
- 1:04:04Please conduct your own thorough due diligence before making any
- 1:04:07investment decisions. Your financial situation and
- 1:04:09risk tolerance are unique. And if you enjoyed this deep
- 1:04:12dive and want to hear more, you can subscribe to us on Apple
- 1:04:15Podcasts or Spotify. Just search for deep value
- 1:04:18investing. We also often include a list of
- 1:04:21relevant books or resources in the episode description if you
- 1:04:24want to dig even deeper yourself.
- 1:04:26Hashtag #outro. Well, what a deep dive this has
- 1:04:29been into Salesforce CRM. We've unpacked their robust
- 1:04:34recent earnings, dissected that powerful software as a service
- 1:04:37model, explored both the temporary macroeconomic
- 1:04:40headwinds and those significant longer term structural risks
- 1:04:44they face, and we delved into their evolving cost structure
- 1:04:47and leadership's pretty clear strategic pivot for efficiency
- 1:04:50and profitability. We saw first hand how fierce
- 1:04:53shareholder activism fundamentally reshaped their
- 1:04:56capital allocation strategy, leading to those unprecedented
- 1:04:59share buybacks and the initiation of their first ever
- 1:05:01cash dividend. And we subjected Salesforce to
- 1:05:04that rigorous Buffett style checklist.
- 1:05:06While it didn't pass every single traditional value
- 1:05:09investing test, especially looking back at its historical
- 1:05:11valuation and sometimes erratic per share earnings growth in its
- 1:05:15earlier phases, it's undeniable business fundamentals stood out.
- 1:05:19Those consistently high gross margins, the powerful free cash
- 1:05:22flow generation year after year and that rock solid balance
- 1:05:25sheet, these are truly compelling quality factors.
- 1:05:30Salesforce is genuinely maturing, transitioning from
- 1:05:33that relentless growth at all cost company to 1.
- 1:05:36Seemingly focused on disciplined, profitable
- 1:05:39expansion and increasingly returning capital directly to
- 1:05:42its shareholders. The company is now making a
- 1:05:45profound, audacious bet on AI to drive its next growth cycle,
- 1:05:49really positioning itself for the future of enterprise
- 1:05:52software. So as Salesforce continues to
- 1:05:54navigate this intense competition and ever evolving
- 1:05:57tech landscape, making that bold wager on AI to fuel its next
- 1:06:01phase of growth, and as it seems committed now to consistently
- 1:06:04returning capital to shareholders.
- 1:06:06The real question for you, our informed listener isn't just
- 1:06:08what Salesforce is doing. It's whether it can truly
- 1:06:11maintain this new, maybe delicate balance of innovation
- 1:06:14and profitability to become a consistent long term compounder
- 1:06:17of value. And perhaps more importantly,
- 1:06:19for your own portfolio, at what price you're willing to acquire
- 1:06:23that potential future value today, factoring in your own
- 1:06:26reasonable expectations for their growth and execution?
- 1:06:29Absolutely. This deep dive, using a
- 1:06:32framework that helps us assess not just the company, but maybe
- 1:06:35the broader market temperature and the company's intrinsic
- 1:06:38value, is precisely how you can get better at spotting those
- 1:06:42potential opportunities and understanding a company's true
- 1:06:44worth beyond the daily noise. We hope this is giving you
- 1:06:48plenty to Mull over and maybe a fresh critical perspective on
- 1:06:51this tech giant. Until next time, keep digging
- 1:06:53deeper and always stay curious.