Latest / Eye Spy: The Intelligence History Podcast / Spies in the Vatican: Part I
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Eye Spy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 0:08I'm your host, Krystel von Kumberg.
- 0:12Every few weeks, I'm going to be interviewing historians, practitioners and scholars in
- 0:16the field of intelligence to explore some aspects of the past and what it can tell us
- 0:21about the present and future of intelligence studies.
- 0:26David Alvarez is professor at St. Mary's College of California and has taught at universities
- 0:31in France and Italy.
- 0:33A student of the Diplomatic, Intelligence and Military History of the Modern Papacy,
- 0:37his first book with Robert Graham, Nothing Sacred, Nazi Espionage Against the Vatican,
- 0:42was translated and republished in French, Italian, Polish, Portuguese and Slovenian
- 0:47editions.
- 0:48A second book, Spies and the Vatican, Espionage and Intrigue from Napoleon to the Holocaust
- 0:53also appeared in French, Italian and Polish editions.
- 0:56His most recent book, On the Modern Papacy, is The Pope's Soldiers, Military History
- 1:01of the Modern Vatican.
- 1:03His articles on subjects ranging from papal cryptology to the papacy and the American
- 1:07Civil War appear in several edited volumes in such professional journals as Catholic
- 1:12Historical Review, Cryptologia, Diplomatic History, Intelligence and National Security
- 1:18and Nuova Antologia Militare.
- 1:21By invitation of the editors, he contributed the entry on the Military Papacy to the Cambridge
- 1:25History of the Papacy, which came out in 2025.
- 1:29He addressed, by invitation, the Intelligence Working Group of the Italian National Parliament
- 1:33on the topic of Vatican Intelligence capabilities and served as a consultant to the Vatican
- 1:38in the investigation into the pontificate of Pope Pius XII that is part of the inquiry,
- 1:44still in process, leading to Pacelli's possible canonisation by the Catholic Church.
- 1:50The author's secondary research interest is the history of espionage.
- 1:54He has authored two books on American intelligence in the Second World War and Early Cold War,
- 1:59edited a special issue on the journal Intelligence and National Security and published more than
- 2:04a dozen articles in professional journals on topics in American, German and Italian
- 2:09intelligence history.
- 2:11On the strength of these publications, he was invited to spend a year as scholar in
- 2:14residence at the National Security Agency.
- 2:18Welcome to iSpy, the intelligence history podcast.
- 2:22Today I'll be asking you some questions primarily about your second book, Spies and the Vatican,
- 2:28Espionage and Intrigue from Napoleon to the Holocaust.
- 2:32Thank you so much for joining us today.
- 2:34It's my pleasure.
- 2:37In your book, you describe the Eternal City as frequently depicted as a major capital
- 2:42of the secret world of espionage and that popes, no less than kings and prime ministers,
- 2:48priests and dictators inhabit a secret world of spies, assassins, saboteurs and clandestine
- 2:53operations.
- 2:54And yet in your book, Spies and the Vatican, Espionage and Intrigue from Napoleon to the
- 3:00Holocaust, you allude to the ways people have readily accepted a certain image without acknowledging
- 3:05the lack of evidence to substantiate some of the myths surrounding the Holy See's
- 3:09realm of intelligence.
- 3:12Could you elaborate on what place the Vatican has as the world's oldest yet smallest power
- 3:18and whether the pope ranks amongst the most informed world leaders or whether this is
- 3:22simply a myth?
- 3:25The place of the papacy in, I guess, the realm of intelligence in particular, but the realm
- 3:33of world affairs in general, has varied over time.
- 3:39It's not the case of a consistent engagement with world affairs or a consistent engagement
- 3:46with the world of intelligence.
- 3:49Its approach to world affairs and intelligence has differed with historical circumstance,
- 3:57has differed with historical personalities.
- 4:00So that at particular times in the history of the papacy, which is of course a history
- 4:04of over two millennia, the papacy has been heavily involved in world affairs and heavily
- 4:12involved in what we today would call the intelligence world.
- 4:17But then at other times it has kind of drifted into a passivity in both those areas where
- 4:23it's not much engaged with world affairs and not much engaged with intelligence or espionage.
- 4:30I'm sure we'll get into some details later on in today's discussion.
- 4:36But again, it's a matter of circumstance and a matter of personality.
- 4:41If you're wondering about, well, what is the position today, or at least in contemporary
- 4:48period, I think we're in an age and have been for some time where the papacy has had a reduced
- 4:58impact on world affairs and an extremely reduced engagement with the world of espionage and
- 5:07intelligence.
- 5:09The Vatican is not a major player in world affairs and it is certainly not even a modest
- 5:15player in the world of espionage and intelligence.
- 5:20And could you reflect on some of your research at the Vatican archives, including how you
- 5:26first uncovered such a rich collection of material?
- 5:31How did you navigate the sources dealing with surveillance, ciphers, diplomatic correspondence
- 5:37and warnings about foreign intelligence services attempting to intercept the Pope's confidential
- 5:42communications?
- 5:43Yes.
- 5:44You know, I'm often asked, how did I get started in this area, almost as if it's some kind
- 5:51of extremely eccentric avocation, much like collecting 18th century teacups or something
- 5:59like that.
- 6:00How does anybody get started in anything in our line of work?
- 6:05When I was just starting out a long time ago, I was in a field that was then referred to
- 6:14commonly as diplomatic history.
- 6:17And my early research and my first publications were actually on the subject of American relations
- 6:25with Turkey during the Second World War and during the early Cold War.
- 6:30And as I was researching such relations, I naturally kind of backed into a bigger issue
- 6:40of what were America's relations with the neutral powers during the Second World War.
- 6:46And I began to run across occasional references, sometimes only cryptic references to the United
- 6:54States and the Vatican during the war.
- 6:57And those references kind of piqued my interest, and especially after I started looking around
- 7:04and discovered that really that nobody seems to have paid much attention to United States
- 7:11relations with the Vatican during the war.
- 7:14And I thought, just for my own interest, I'd kind of like to know more about that.
- 7:21But that interest intersected with another interest of mine, and that was that I even
- 7:30back then was quite an italophile and completely enamored of all things Italian, cuisine, language,
- 7:38history, culture, broadly understood.
- 7:42And it occurred to me that I could combine these two interests.
- 7:48I could pursue my interest, a budding interest, an emerging interest in the Vatican with trips
- 7:57to Rome.
- 7:58That's as simple as that.
- 7:59I would go to Rome and I would look into archival sources and I would find out where our collections
- 8:06are, their collections.
- 8:08And that took me to the Vatican archives.
- 8:11And as I worked, I discovered more and more stuff and my interest began to shift from
- 8:18purely diplomatic relations into this world of espionage and intelligence operations in
- 8:25the modern papacy, 19th, 20th century.
- 8:30And in particular, I began to notice references to what we today would call communications
- 8:43intelligence.
- 8:44I would be looking at the dispatches of a papal representative in Vienna or Berlin or
- 8:52Washington and in their written dispatches sent back to the Vatican reporting on affairs
- 8:58in their host countries.
- 9:00I would frequently see references to or sentences saying something like, I'm not confident in
- 9:10the security of my cipher.
- 9:14We'll send details by hand of a personal courier or a warning back to the Vatican.
- 9:21I think my mail is being monitored.
- 9:24My phone calls are being monitored by the German police or by the American police.
- 9:30And I began to think, well, gee, that's kind of interesting.
- 9:33I never would have imagined such things happening.
- 9:38And then I actually purely by serendipity opened up a file and there was a Vatican codebook,
- 9:47the whole thing.
- 9:48And I thought, holy cow, this is interesting.
- 9:51And I'd already had a kind of a side interest in cryptology.
- 9:56And I thought, gee, I'm going to look into this.
- 10:01And as it happens among professional historians, one thing leads to another, doors that you
- 10:08never thought you'd even open, let alone walk through.
- 10:11You find yourself walking through and entering a room that's entirely new and fresh and
- 10:17exciting.
- 10:18And that's how I kind of began to back into the Vatican as a subject of intelligence history.
- 10:29And it's an interest that I've continued to this day.
- 10:35The sources are much richer than anybody might have expected.
- 10:39And they're relatively unexplored.
- 10:44I guess any kind of research project is at least at certain stages incredibly engaging
- 10:53and incredibly exciting.
- 10:54We all know that sometimes their research projects are neither engaging nor exciting.
- 11:01But working in the Vatican archive, I've worked in archives in the United States and the UK,
- 11:08France, Spain.
- 11:10I've worked in Italian archives.
- 11:14And the Vatican archive was an experience unlike any other.
- 11:18It was itself kind of an adventure.
- 11:21And I felt as if I was an adventurer in the Vatican archive.
- 11:27And it was easy to pursue this research project because the conditions under which I conducted
- 11:36this project were themselves, irrespective of the file in front of me or the papers I'm
- 11:42thumbing through, exciting and engaging.
- 11:46Yeah.
- 11:47So that sounds really, really awesome and a great experience.
- 11:53Yeah, it was.
- 11:55Working in the Vatican archive was a strange experience.
- 12:03This is now going back decades, right?
- 12:05And I know currently that research conditions have changed.
- 12:10But back in the day, I sound like I'm recalling the Spanish-American war or something.
- 12:15But it was quite an adventure to work in the Vatican archive.
- 12:19And if you want, I can talk about how it's an adventure and how it's not like the normal
- 12:26archives.
- 12:27Please do.
- 12:28That would be really interesting.
- 12:29Well, you know, this is at a time when it was called the Vatican secret archive.
- 12:35It's no longer called that.
- 12:37They've changed the name.
- 12:39And to gain access to it, access was...
- 12:44When I first started out, I was warned, oh, you'll never get in.
- 12:47It's closed and all kinds of discouraging advice and comments.
- 12:52But in fact, it's open.
- 12:57But then you had to jump through certain kinds of hoops to gain access.
- 13:03And some of the hoops are familiar to anybody who's worked in any European archive.
- 13:07You have to have a letter of introduction.
- 13:10You have to demonstrate that you have legitimate academic credentials.
- 13:14You have to explain your research topic ahead of time.
- 13:18That's kind of common.
- 13:19But I remember when I showed up for my very first visit to the Vatican archive, I was
- 13:26directed to a reception desk.
- 13:29And the young man behind the reception desk explained to me that I was required to write
- 13:40a letter to the pope asking for permission to use his archive.
- 13:49And I had to write that letter in Italian on the spot right there in front of the receptionist.
- 13:58I was stymied by thinking, how do I even address this letter?
- 14:03I mean, what is the proper form of address if you're writing a letter to the pope?
- 14:08And my Italian was certainly sufficient for research purposes.
- 14:14I read Italian quite well, but I'm not in then and even now not in the practice of writing
- 14:20a lot of Italian.
- 14:22So I wasn't exactly confident about my ability to compose a letter without using a dictionary
- 14:29or looking something up.
- 14:31Nope, I had to do it right there right now.
- 14:33And there are people in line behind me, so get to it.
- 14:37And so he gave me the stationery, gave me a pen.
- 14:41I wrote out, dear Holy Father, and I wrote a little paragraph and signed it.
- 14:48And I gave it to the receptionist who read it over.
- 14:51And under his breath, as he was reading it, he kept saying to himself, impossibile, impossibile,
- 14:59you know, it's impossible.
- 15:00This is impossible.
- 15:02So he said, no, I will write it.
- 15:05You sign it.
- 15:06So he ripped up my letter, took out another piece of stationery, wrote his own in my name,
- 15:13wrote a request for permission to use the archive and turned it around, gave it to me,
- 15:18said, sign it.
- 15:19I signed it.
- 15:20And he gave me my entry ticket.
- 15:23Well, starting off totally humiliated and embarrassed was not the way to start off in any archive,
- 15:31let alone the Vatican Archive, which was then governed by very strict rules of protocol.
- 15:37Women had to wear skirts or dresses.
- 15:39They couldn't show their shoulders.
- 15:41Men had to wear coats and ties.
- 15:43You couldn't take the coat off while you're in the reading room either, as I discovered
- 15:47on my first day ever.
- 15:49And I sat at my assigned table and took my coat off because it was warm.
- 15:56It was, you know, it's July in Rome.
- 15:58It's not just warm, it's hot.
- 16:00And there's no air conditioning.
- 16:03And so I took my coat off and within five seconds, one of the attendants came up and
- 16:08chastised me, no, always, you have to always wear your coat.
- 16:13So I had to put my coat back on.
- 16:17Well, only one person in the archive spoke English.
- 16:23And because he was the only one who could speak English, he was in high demand because
- 16:30there were many British and Canadian and American, Australian, Indian researchers who required
- 16:40his assistance in navigating through what was then very arcane system of finding aids,
- 16:48indexes.
- 16:50This was nothing was electronic.
- 16:52Everything was pen and paper.
- 16:54Big indexes would be in thick volumes that look like they could have been props in a
- 17:00story about in a movie about the Renaissance.
- 17:05So you had to learn the ropes.
- 17:09And they were not very helpful.
- 17:13They wouldn't volunteer any information.
- 17:15They would answer all your questions, but they wouldn't volunteer any information at
- 17:21all.
- 17:22And oftentimes they would just tell you that the files you want are not available.
- 17:28There was no appeal, no explanation.
- 17:31You just accepted that judgment.
- 17:33These files are not available.
- 17:37And you would only be able to receive three files a day, no matter how thick the file
- 17:44was.
- 17:45I remember once I ordered files and three files came to my table and one of the files
- 17:53was empty, literally.
- 17:54There wasn't anything in it.
- 17:56Nothing.
- 17:57I opened it up and nothing was there.
- 17:59Well, okay.
- 18:01So I went to the archivist and I said, I'm returning this file.
- 18:06I'd like to order in its place.
- 18:08I'd like to order this other file.
- 18:10And he said, no, I'm sorry, you can't.
- 18:12You've already ordered your three files.
- 18:14I said, but this isn't a file.
- 18:16There's nothing in here.
- 18:17Look.
- 18:18And he says, it doesn't make any difference.
- 18:20Three files went to your table this morning.
- 18:22Okay.
- 18:23And that's it.
- 18:24We don't guarantee that there's anything in the file.
- 18:27You just get three files, right?
- 18:30And you don't know what's going to be in there until you open them up.
- 18:35And sometimes you open them up and there are 500 pages of material.
- 18:40Other times you open the file up and there's one or in this case, none.
- 18:46But the counterbalance to that is they have at the Vatican Archive the nicest cafe I have
- 18:55ever been to in an archive.
- 18:58It's in an old tower and it's shared by the Vatican Archive and the Vatican Library, which
- 19:03are two separate institutions with their own rules and regulations.
- 19:09And they're separated by a courtyard and this cafe.
- 19:12And the cafe is in an old tower and it's just as charming as you would expect.
- 19:20And it's packed with researchers who I think much prefer sitting in the cafe and having
- 19:27cappuccino and sputini and things like that than sitting at the tables and dealing with
- 19:33the archivist, right?
- 19:36Very nice cafe and I haven't personally been in the archive recently, but I just had the
- 19:42occasion a couple days ago last week to talk to somebody who had and I asked specifically,
- 19:49how's the cafe?
- 19:50And he said, it hasn't changed.
- 19:52It's exactly the same, which is good news for any researcher.
- 19:56It's worth a trip to the archive just to visit the cafe.
- 20:00Definitely sounds like it.
- 20:04So that was a long-winded response to your question about what it's like in the archive.
- 20:08It's easier to use the archive now.
- 20:12They have improved their finding aids.
- 20:15They have gone electronic on a lot of finding aids.
- 20:19You can order things online from a distance.
- 20:23You still can only get three files a day though.
- 20:26That hasn't changed.
- 20:28But the working conditions are changed, I think, for the better.
- 20:34Women don't have to wear dresses.
- 20:37Men don't have to wear coats.
- 20:40But there's still no air conditioning.
- 20:44You still only get three files a day.
- 20:47Three files isn't a lot.
- 20:49That's annoying.
- 20:51Yeah, it's a little frustrating because it's only open.
- 20:55The archive is only open five hours a day.
- 20:59It's open from eight to one.
- 21:04And if you get three slim files, you could work through them in the first half hour easily.
- 21:11It's 8.30 and now you've got a whole day ahead of you that oftentimes is an expensive day
- 21:17because you've traveled from Canada or you've traveled from the United States or from wherever.
- 21:23And you're staying in Italian hotels and you're paying for Italian meals.
- 21:27And now you've got a day in which no more work can be done because you've already got
- 21:33your three slim files.
- 21:38The upside is you go out and enjoy Rome, I guess, right?
- 21:42Exactly.
- 21:43Yeah.
- 21:44Right.
- 21:45What's so bad about that, I guess?
- 21:48But again, because of those rules, it's kind of hard to schedule your time.
- 21:56You don't know whether you're going to have a full day or a half day or just a small portion
- 22:02of a day working in the archive.
- 22:06And then when you're really busy, when you've got a lot to do, one o'clock rolls around
- 22:12and everybody's out and there are no afternoon or evening hours.
- 22:16There are no hours on the weekends.
- 22:20And the archive closes for long periods of time.
- 22:23It's closed for three weeks over the Christmas, New Year's period.
- 22:28It's closed July and August and half of September every year.
- 22:34So you've got to plan.
- 22:36You've got to plan your time ahead.
- 22:40They made one reform.
- 22:42Well they thought it was a reform.
- 22:44I don't know if the researchers thought it was, but they decided that you would have
- 22:48to reserve ahead of time a table and you could do it online.
- 22:54So you could say, well, I'm going to plan a trip in April or I'm going to go after the
- 22:59close of the school year in June.
- 23:02So I'll reserve a table for June.
- 23:07And you could reserve up to what I think it was six months ahead of time.
- 23:13And you could reserve for any number of days.
- 23:16But you had to specify which days.
- 23:18You can't just say I want a table for 20 days.
- 23:21You had to actually give them dates.
- 23:26And that didn't work out very well because as the Vatican archive becomes better known
- 23:33beyond the world of medieval and Renaissance historians, as people working in what the
- 23:40modern period or the more contemporary period have come to discover that there's a lot of
- 23:45stuff and relevant materials in the Vatican archive, the demand for tables is constantly
- 23:52increasing.
- 23:54And I remember last year I wanted to reserve place and I was told that they were now taking
- 24:04reservations for five months down the road.
- 24:08Five months.
- 24:11They were booked up for the next five months.
- 24:16This is again not exactly, this is so Vatican, but it's not exactly conducive to efficient
- 24:22research.
- 24:23But the good news is that just last month or two months ago, they abolished that rule
- 24:30and now it's back to first come first serve.
- 24:33You just show up and hope that you're going to get a table.
- 24:37Okay, that's that area.
- 24:39That's I guess except you know you got to get there at seven o'clock in the morning
- 24:43to stand in line because just because you have a pass doesn't mean there's no guarantee
- 24:50that you'll get in tomorrow, right?
- 24:53It's not as if once you get the pass, you're assured of entry indefinitely.
- 24:58Every day you have to get into that line.
- 25:05You can't reserve a place anymore.
- 25:09How did the role of the Papacy evolve between 1815 and 1945, a period when intelligence
- 25:17and covert operations became increasingly central to statecraft?
- 25:22How did these changes unfold over time?
- 25:24And perhaps we can start by examining the 19th century, a particularly dangerous period
- 25:29for the Papacy during which intelligence efforts were essential to counter threats to its
- 25:34authority.
- 25:35What role did intelligence play during this turbulent era following the Napoleonic Wars
- 25:39marked by political subversion and revolutionary activity within the Papal States?
- 25:47Well if we want to talk about how the role of the Papacy evolved over time, and I think
- 25:57you mentioned 1815 to 1945, and mentioned that that period witnessed intelligence and
- 26:08covert operations becoming increasingly central to the activities of many major and minor
- 26:17powers.
- 26:18As far as the Papacy was concerned, that period witnessed intelligence and covert operations
- 26:24becoming increasingly peripheral, not central, to Vatican policies and Vatican affairs.
- 26:41We have to remember that in 1870, the old Papal States, that is the territory, the broad
- 26:52swath of territory in central Italy that popes had governed as sovereigns since the late
- 27:00first millennia.
- 27:03In 1870, they disappeared as the Papal territories were subsumed within what was now called the
- 27:14Kingdom of Italy.
- 27:17As Italy is unified under the House of Savoy, the Papal States become the last of the old
- 27:27principalities that once were scattered across the Italian peninsula, the last of those principalities
- 27:33to survive.
- 27:34And in 1870, as a result of a war, House of Savoy takes over the Papal States, unifies
- 27:44Italy under the dynasty of Savoy, and the Pope has lost his temporal, his secular territories.
- 27:53He's no longer a sovereign.
- 27:56He has no territory.
- 27:58He has no army anymore.
- 28:00He has no navy anymore.
- 28:04And so the decline, the disappearance of the secular power of the Papacy, in a sense, removed
- 28:15the need for intelligence and covert operations.
- 28:20Covert operations against whom?
- 28:23Intelligence on what?
- 28:26Up until 1870, there had still been a residual effort to gather information, to collect intelligence
- 28:42on the part of various elements within the Papal government.
- 28:48Pope was still a sovereign ruler up until 1870, and not only was he a sovereign ruler,
- 28:53but that early 19th century was a time in which the Papacy faced diplomatic and military
- 29:05threats.
- 29:09And so intelligence was a useful tool for, at least in theory, a useful tool for Popes
- 29:19up until 1870.
- 29:21And they did have, maintain a modest intelligence capability affected through this institution
- 29:30called the Pontifical Gendarmerie, a police force, a national police force within the
- 29:37Papal States that was responsible for law enforcement, maintaining internal order, but
- 29:45was also charged with gathering information.
- 29:50Most of the information that it attempted to collect concerned internal threats to the
- 29:58Papacy, subversive groups within the Papal States, anti-Papal groups who were working
- 30:08to overthrow the Pope as a secular ruler, either because they wanted to unify with the
- 30:19growing Kingdom of Italy that was expanding across the peninsula in the early 19th century,
- 30:24mid 19th century, or because they wanted to substitute a different kind of regime in place
- 30:30of the Papal regime, a republic or whatever, that depended upon the group basically.
- 30:40And so the Papal police, the Gendarmerie were active in trying to collect intelligence on
- 30:47these subversive groups within the Papal States.
- 30:51They didn't do very much intelligence work outward directed.
- 30:55They didn't run foreign operation or much in the way of foreign operations.
- 31:00It was mainly internal security, which they conducted with some success actually.
- 31:07But after 1870, there wasn't a need for any of this, right?
- 31:12And so the intelligence capabilities of the Papacy, already modest in the 19th century,
- 31:22effectively disappear entirely after 1870.
- 31:26At a time when other powers are beginning to recognize the utility of intelligence agencies
- 31:35of intelligence operations, the Papacy is losing interest.
- 31:40Its experience is exactly the opposite of the experience of major powers as we come
- 31:47to the close of the 19th century and enter the 20th century.
- 31:53And as you mentioned, the emphasis is more on this domestic surveillance security rather
- 31:59than foreign intelligence.
- 32:02So could you highlight how perhaps these two intersect at times?
- 32:13And the Vatican in your account largely depended on ambassadors and consuls.
- 32:20Were these networks stable?
- 32:22Did they have clear directives or was the structure of collecting information rather
- 32:27vertical?
- 32:28If we're talking about the period before 1870, where the emphasis was on internal security,
- 32:40the Papal police, the gendarmerie, used almost all the methods of intelligence collection
- 32:51that we're familiar with today.
- 32:55I mean, before 1870, the gendarmerie conducted mail surveillance.
- 33:04They intercepted communications.
- 33:06They tried to break the codes of some of these underground subversive groups.
- 33:12They engaged in active foreign liaison with other national police forces, in particular
- 33:19the Austrian police and intelligence services, in order to share information, share techniques
- 33:29and practices.
- 33:31The Papal police used penetration agents.
- 33:34They infiltrated agents into these various subversive groups.
- 33:38They used double agents.
- 33:39They used all the things that security services use today without, of course, the level of
- 33:46technology that we benefit from today.
- 33:49But again, all that is inter-directed with regard to learning about the outside world,
- 33:57the world beyond the borders of the Papal States.
- 34:01The Papacy depended almost exclusively upon its network of diplomatic representatives,
- 34:11its ambassadors.
- 34:13The Vatican doesn't use the word ambassador.
- 34:15It uses a word nuncio.
- 34:20But a nuncio, a papal nuncio is under international law, the Vatican ambassador, with all the
- 34:27rights, prerogatives and responsibilities of an ambassador.
- 34:31They had a network of nuncios in the capitals of countries with diplomatic relations with
- 34:39the papacy.
- 34:41And they depended upon those nuncios for any information they needed or required about
- 34:50political affairs beyond the borders of the Papal States.
- 34:55In 1870, with the demise of the Papal States, the Vatican continues to have diplomatic relations
- 35:06with other countries.
- 35:07It has no territory, but it is still a recognized entity under international law.
- 35:13And so it maintains diplomatic relations with a range of countries and has ambassadors reporting
- 35:23from the capitals of those countries.
- 35:26But this network is a very modest network in size.
- 35:32The papacy after 1870, well into the 20th century, maintains diplomatic relations with
- 35:38a relatively small number of countries.
- 35:43The diplomatic network of the Vatican is Eurocentric.
- 35:49Most of the countries with which it has relations are in Europe or South America.
- 35:55There is no diplomatic representative in Russia, for instance, or in the Middle East, or the
- 36:02Far East.
- 36:03For that matter, there's no diplomatic representative in the United States or in the UK.
- 36:11So it's a network modest in size, but even more modest in its capabilities.
- 36:18And the diplomatic network up into the early 20th century is weak as a potential source
- 36:26of intelligence because the Vatican's diplomatic representatives are very ill-prepared to collect
- 36:37any political information, in part because they wear two hats.
- 36:43And that's true even today, although today the diplomatic network is much larger and
- 36:49its personnel are much more professionally competent.
- 36:54The nuncios have always worn two hats.
- 36:58They are diplomatic representatives in the traditional sense, but nuncios are also responsible
- 37:07for monitoring the Catholic Church within the nation where they are located.
- 37:17So that the nuncio in France is responsible for monitoring the activities of the French
- 37:23Catholic Church as well as conducting relations with the French government.
- 37:28Two hats.
- 37:29By training, by culture, by appetite, nuncios had always been more interested in the ecclesiastical
- 37:40hat rather than the diplomatic hat.
- 37:44There was always a tendency to emphasize the role of supervising the National Catholic
- 37:50Church, less interest in what we would consider diplomatic reporting.
- 37:57They were not trained until the 20th century, at least.
- 38:00They were not trained to do this, and they limited their activity in such a way that
- 38:08the ecclesiastical responsibilities always had priority.
- 38:14And this was a weakness that the Vatican recognized.
- 38:19In fact, if you look through the dispatches of nuncios from the second half of the 19th
- 38:26century, often in the margins, notes made by officials in the Vatican Secretariat of
- 38:34State in Rome, the Vatican Department responsible for diplomatic affairs, there'll be notations
- 38:43by supervisory authorities in the Secretariat of State commenting to the effect that this
- 38:51nuncio has to be reminded that he needs to report political news.
- 38:58He needs to tell us more than just who are the preferred selections to be the bishop
- 39:05of Toulouse, for instance, or the Archbishop of Bogota, Colombia.
- 39:11We need political news.
- 39:14The nuncios had to constantly be prodded, had to be called to their responsibilities, so
- 39:20to speak, because they tended to neglect political reporting.
- 39:25And they totally neglected, totally, reporting on military affairs, economic affairs.
- 39:35You will thumb in through the files of nuncio dispatches well into the 20th century.
- 39:43There's no information on military affairs, no information on economic affairs, and little
- 39:50information about political affairs.
- 39:54So there was no, for the papacy after 1870, even if they wanted what we today would call
- 40:04political intelligence, they had no structure to provide that intelligence.
- 40:14The structures that were available, that were used for intelligence purposes by, say, other
- 40:19countries, were not appropriate for those functions in the Vatican context, which was
- 40:33a real problem for the Vatican, because when the Vatican needed political information,
- 40:39it had very little ways of accessing that information.
- 40:44And when would they need such information?
- 40:47During the First World War, during the Second World War, during the rise of the Bolsheviks
- 40:57in Russia, and then the subsequent centralization in Russia of authority.
- 41:04Many challenges in the 20th century faced the Vatican, and it was ill-prepared to confront
- 41:12those challenges because it lacked the information necessary to do so, and it lacked the means
- 41:18to collect that information.
- 41:24You make an important distinction here between also the quantity and quality of intelligence
- 41:29flowing into the Vatican, being quite restricted by these limitations, as you've outlined.
- 41:36This seems distinctly different to other state security apparatuses and somewhat counts as
- 41:41the very essence of the nature of espionage.
- 41:45So what makes the Vatican's approach, do you think, quite distinct?
- 41:51The interest in intelligence varies with time and personality.
- 41:57Some popes may, oftentimes by circumstance, but also merely for personal reasons, may
- 42:04be more interested in what we would generally characterize as international affairs than
- 42:10other popes.
- 42:12So I guess to answer your question is the engagement with intelligence is variable depending
- 42:19upon circumstance and personality.
- 42:22But the big difference is that the Vatican doesn't have any security organizations.
- 42:28The Vatican doesn't have an intelligence service and hasn't had one since the 1870.
- 42:37There is no institutional process for systematically collecting intelligence beyond the diplomatic
- 42:50network that the Vatican maintains up to the present day, and secondly, open sort, what
- 42:56we today would call open source intelligence.
- 43:00The Vatican has no clandestine collection capabilities at all, none, and hasn't had
- 43:09since 1870.
- 43:11And that is contrary to the myth of Vatican intelligence, which would like us to believe
- 43:19that the pope sits at the center of a web of information with intelligence coming in
- 43:27from all parts of the world, provided by faithful Catholics who are reporting the smallest piece
- 43:38of military, political, economic, and cultural information back to the Vatican.
- 43:43That is complete myth.
- 43:45Popes are, since the 1870 and even before, the popes are among the most poorly informed
- 43:56world leaders, not the best informed of world leaders.
- 44:03And they're poorly informed because they have no institutional way of collecting intelligence.
- 44:10I'll give you an example of what that would look like.
- 44:16During the Second World War, the then British ambassador to the Vatican, Sir Darcy Osborne,
- 44:31discovered that through his conversations with his counterparts in the Vatican Secretariat
- 44:39of State and his conversations with Pope Pius XII, Sir Darcy Osborne discovered that, to
- 44:46his surprise, that nobody in the Vatican seemed very well informed about what's going on.
- 44:53Right?
- 44:54They had only the weakest grasp on events in the wartime events in any theater of the
- 45:02war.
- 45:03And so Sir Darcy Osborne started on his own initiative to every day make a digest of BBC
- 45:15news reports.
- 45:18And he would make a written digest of these BBC reports and then give them to the pope
- 45:28to have them delivered to the papal apartments every day.
- 45:34And this went on for several months until the burden of work on Sir Darcy Osborne's
- 45:41shoulders were just so heavy that he couldn't continue to do this.
- 45:45And so he stopped making a digest of these BBC news broadcasts and no more were being
- 45:53delivered to the papal palace.
- 45:57And then he got a telephone call from the pope, from the pope's secretaries saying,
- 46:07what happened to the digests?
- 46:09We're not getting any more.
- 46:11And it turns out that the pope had come to depend upon these BBC digests prepared every
- 46:19day for his principal source of information about what was going on in the world.
- 46:25That the Vatican itself had no such capability.
- 46:30That it never occurred to them.
- 46:32And this is what is so difficult for intelligence and historians to get their arms around because
- 46:39we're used to dealing with agencies and countries that are very self-consciously going out
- 46:46there trying to collect information.
- 46:50In the Vatican, we have to understand in the Vatican, they weren't that interested in stuff
- 46:56like that.
- 46:57That by ecclesiastical culture, ecclesiastical training, it never occurred to most people
- 47:05in the Vatican that you could even do something, let alone want to do something like this.
- 47:11You're actually monitoring these broadcasts.
- 47:15That's a good idea.
- 47:16How come we didn't think of that?
- 47:18Yeah, right.
- 47:19How come you didn't think of any of these things?
- 47:24The pope admitted, I have so few sources of information that these daily BBC broadcasts,
- 47:35as biased as they might be, as selective as they might be, and nobody in the Vatican fooled
- 47:41themselves into thinking this was completely disinterested information, of course.
- 47:47But this is a precious source of information because I have very few alternative sources
- 47:52of information.
- 47:53Now, to the Vatican's credit, they learned, and by the end of the war, by 1945, Vatican
- 48:00radio is monitoring broadcasts, foreign news broadcasts, and producing on its own now a
- 48:09digest of broadcasts.
- 48:11But for the first few years of the war, they'd had no such instrument of collecting intelligence.
- 48:18They still had to depend upon the nuncios reporting from abroad.
- 48:23And some of these nuncios were still in the traditional mode where they thought their
- 48:29main job was reporting ecclesiastical news.
- 48:33As late as the Second World War, nuncios are being called on the carpet by their bosses
- 48:40and the secretariat of state, the foreign ministry of the Vatican.
- 48:44They're being called on the carpet because they're not reporting political news.
- 48:50This is in the middle of a global war.
- 48:52They have to be reminded to report political news, right?
- 48:57And then even when they report it, communications channels were so poorly developed that oftentimes
- 49:04there was a long delay between writing a dispatch or composing a telegram and its ultimate delivery
- 49:14to the Vatican, by which time the news, such as it was, we would say the intelligence,
- 49:21such as it was, was completely outdated.
- 49:24The poor guy who's the papal diplomatic representative in Tokyo during the war, it took sometimes
- 49:30seven months for his dispatches to reach the Vatican.
- 49:33Seven months.
- 49:35Wow.
- 49:36This isn't conducive to producing timely, actionable intelligence.
- 49:43Definitely.
- 49:44And it's also a very insular community, I guess, right?
- 49:49Very focused on what's happening on the inside rather than external.
- 49:54Well, you know, it's the people who were in the Vatican foreign ministry, this so-called
- 50:01secretariat of state, were intelligent, competent and experienced diplomats.
- 50:07I mean, but you can see in their dispatches or in their memos, their internal memos where
- 50:16they're talking to each other in the Vatican, their frustration at the lack of information.
- 50:24They feel the need for information, but they have no instrument for collecting the information
- 50:33at the level required.
- 50:35Now people say, well, the Vatican must have found out about this and must have found out
- 50:40about that.
- 50:43Intelligence does come into the Vatican, but it's too much to say the Vatican is collecting
- 50:50intelligence because that implies more purpose and direction than was actually there.
- 50:58The Vatican, it's better to say the Vatican receives intelligence almost out of serendipity
- 51:06or by chance or by accident.
- 51:09Here's an example again from the Second World War.
- 51:17The Vatican communicated with its representatives abroad in cipher.
- 51:24They had code books and cipher tables and in all important or at least sensitive documents,
- 51:32reports, instructions were encrypted.
- 51:37Well, several countries during the Second World War, specifically, well, for sure, the
- 51:45United States, the UK, Germany, Italy, and then some smaller powers, Finland, Hungary,
- 51:54were all intercepting Vatican communications and attempting with success to break the ciphers
- 52:03that protected those communications.
- 52:07So the Vatican's confidential communications were compromised as a result of what we would
- 52:16today call communications intelligence operations on the part of several wartime powers.
- 52:24Well, the Vatican found out about this and how did they find out?
- 52:31Did they find out through positive intelligence operations?
- 52:37No.
- 52:38They found out when a junior papal diplomat in the Vatican embassy to Italy, of all places,
- 52:46went to the Italian foreign ministry to work out some minor issue concerning ecclesiastical
- 52:53properties in the city of Rome, just a little thing that was completely routine and relatively
- 53:03unimportant.
- 53:04And in the course of conversing with his counterpart, a junior diplomat in the Italian foreign ministry,
- 53:11the Italian diplomat blurted out, did you know we're reading all your telegrams?
- 53:20The enciphered telegrams.
- 53:23He just blurted it out.
- 53:26Well, to say the least, his Vatican counterpart was flabbergasted, right?
- 53:32And this was news to everybody at the Vatican.
- 53:37He went back immediately to the Vatican to report this to superiors and the secretariat
- 53:42of state.
- 53:43And he said, you know what I just found out?
- 53:45So and so in the Italian foreign ministry told me that the Italians are reading our
- 53:51encrypted telegrams, which means our ciphers have been compromised or solved, broken.
- 53:59And his superiors and the secretariat of state refused to believe him.
- 54:02He said, no, it can't be happening.
- 54:05I don't think so.
- 54:06And so they proposed a test.
- 54:10They proposed to send a phony message, not a real message, but of completely imaginary
- 54:17content and made up a message, encrypted it and sent it to the Vatican ambassador in Lisbon.
- 54:25This is in 1940, asking him to respond immediately in an encrypted response.
- 54:34OK.
- 54:35And he, Nuncio, the ambassador in Lisbon did so.
- 54:41And then a week later, this junior Vatican diplomat who had received the original warning
- 54:50went back to his contact in the Italian foreign ministry and said, effectively, prove it.
- 54:59Show me.
- 55:01And this Italian was indiscreet enough to produce plain text of what had been a telegram
- 55:13encrypted in the Vatican's most secure cipher, proving that the Italians were reading it.
- 55:19OK.
- 55:20It's a huge deal, right?
- 55:21This is a very, very big deal.
- 55:22It forced the Vatican to change all of its ciphers.
- 55:27Everybody panics.
- 55:28It's like a huge deal.
- 55:29You go to the Vatican archive, all the documents from the Second World War are now available,
- 55:35at least theoretically available.
- 55:38And you can go and look this stuff up now.
- 55:42And it caused a huge commotion, as you can imagine, in the Vatican Secretariat of State.
- 55:50But did they find this out through positive intelligence operations?
- 55:54No, they just found it out accidentally through the indiscreet comment of a junior diplomat
- 56:01in the Italian foreign ministry who happened to just blurt it out.
- 56:05Right.
- 56:06Why did he blurt it out?
- 56:08We don't know.
- 56:09Was it because he was a faithful, loyal Catholic who is outraged that his own government is
- 56:17prying into the communications of the pope?
- 56:21Maybe.
- 56:22Was he just showing off?
- 56:23Maybe.
- 56:24But this man was not a controlled agent of the Vatican.
- 56:29He wasn't operating under instructions.
- 56:32Nobody told anybody to go and find out if our communication security has been violated.
- 56:39They just found that out accidentally.
- 56:43And so when people say, well, the Vatican must have had intelligence, well, I guess,
- 56:48depending upon what we call intelligence.
- 56:51But if you're talking about the kind of thing most people think of, a result of espionage
- 56:59or clandestine operations or at least positive efforts to go out and find something, right,
- 57:07the Vatican didn't do any of that stuff, even during moments of crisis like the Second World
- 57:12War, when such information would have been extremely useful to Vatican policymakers.
- 57:21And you know, the curious thing is that other countries bought into the myth of Vatican
- 57:29intelligence supremacy.
- 57:32You look at the approach of the United States or of Germany or pick any of the wartime powers
- 57:41that you want.
- 57:43And they all assume that the Vatican is a storehouse of information that is inaccessible
- 57:50to any other government.
- 57:52And so during the war, all the wartime, all the major wartime powers are working like
- 58:00crazy to penetrate the Vatican, the Vatican becomes an important intelligence target because
- 58:07other countries believe there's a goldmine of information that they're sitting on inside
- 58:12the Vatican.
- 58:14And we need to access that information.