Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Life Coach Ethical Complaint
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. So over the past ten or fifteen years, I've
- 0:04been increasingly concerned with the so called profession of coaching or life coaching. I've
- 0:12been concerned about this for many years, but I feel like it's been getting
- 0:17worse since the pandemic. And I have talked about this before on the podcast,
- 0:22but my malpractice insurance just sent me a case in which a therapist was
- 0:26successfully sued for operating as a coach. I've also seen some alarming things with
- 0:33religion oriented therapists as of late, like with the Ruby Frankie case. You
- 0:38know Jody Hildebrandt if you've been following that, she was a licensed counselor in
- 0:43Utah, advertised herself as an LDS or Mormon therapist and had been operating with
- 0:49a lot of high renown for decades, and according to the reporting the allegations
- 0:56this past year, she has been one of the most harmful things therapist that's
- 1:00ever lived on this planet. Honestly, I mean, I don't I'm not
- 1:03exaggerating. There's strong evidence that she has been harming and torturing children for decades,
- 1:08and probably harming a lot of different people. Her family members have been
- 1:14trying to get the Utah authorities to do something for years, because, according
- 1:19to them, Jody Hildebrant has been influencing parents to harm their children. She
- 1:23advertises herself as a parenting helper, therapist coach sort of person, and she
- 1:30has a licensed therapist, and she also claims to be a life coach.
- 1:34So anyway, her family members have been trying to get the Utah authorities to
- 1:38do something about this for years, but nothing happened until a child escaped her
- 1:42compound earlier this year twenty twenty three. And the child escaped and told the
- 1:49neighbor. You know, it's like, oh my God, help me,
- 1:51help me. Told the neighbor that he was being tortured for dazed and like
- 1:55I said, Jody Hildebrant was a life coach. Now, I want to
- 1:57be clear that coaches are not inherently unethical, and therapists who are also life
- 2:04coaches are not inherently violating an ethical code or a law. So I want
- 2:10to be clear that coaches can be helpful. In fact, for many years
- 2:15I worked alongside a life coach here in Seattle that had a lot of positive
- 2:23reviews, and this coach would actually refer a lot of his clients to me.
- 2:27He would refer clients to me who he detected as suffering from either a
- 2:32clinical issue or a significant marital problem. He would ethically determine that some of
- 2:39his clients needed someone in my field, not in the coaching field, and
- 2:45he would refer his clients to me, and then his clients would come to
- 2:47me. I would hear about the way that he operated through these clients,
- 2:53and everything seemed on the up and up. So you can have life coaches
- 2:58or coaches that know what they're doing, that operate quote unquote ethically or at
- 3:04least operate in a way that US therapists would not criticize. So there are
- 3:10those people that do that, but there are many others, many many others
- 3:15that do not operate in what we as a field in psychology and psychotherapy,
- 3:22and also the public at large would not characterize as operating within ethical or moral
- 3:28bounds, which I'll get into in this episode. You know, part of
- 3:31the problem with even discussing this topic of life coaching is that life coaching or
- 3:38coaching can mean anything from one or two sessions of career advice that last,
- 3:45you know, fifteen minutes each You know, two fifteen minute discussions of just
- 3:50what should I do with my next career? Or should I take this job?
- 3:53Or how do I get a promotion? It could be something as simple
- 3:57as that. Or life coach can refer to ten twenty years of coaching about
- 4:03dozens of issues, including marital conflicts, social anxiety, existential dread. You
- 4:09know, someone needing religious guidance, someone suffering from a lack of motivation i
- 4:15e. Depression or grief, this sort of thing. It could refer to
- 4:18that, right, Life coaching can refer to ten sessions about how to start
- 4:24a business. It can refer to five sessions about how to flirt. It
- 4:29could refer to a year of sessions about how to be a good parent,
- 4:33how to help your neurodivergent kid in school and at home. Life coaching can
- 4:40refer to long term coaching that mainly involves just venting about one's life, and
- 4:46that very much could look like therapy, or a life coach might help someone
- 4:50to find themselves whatever that means, and so on. So you know,
- 4:55when refer to life coaching, everyone has a different idea of what it is,
- 5:00and apparently is a lot of different things, which I think is part
- 5:03of the problem, you know, because if life coaching was just about career
- 5:10advice, or it was just about how to clean your house, or it
- 5:14was just about how to socialize it work a little better, or how to
- 5:19dress or how to decorate your home, then yeah, those are not clinical
- 5:25topics, right, But so often life coaching absolutely gets into what everyone would
- 5:31consider to be a clinical topic depression. Now, the coach might not call
- 5:38it depression. They might not even know what depression is because they might not
- 5:42have any education or training in that area. They might not even quote unquote
- 5:46believe in depression. So they might be talking to someone they might have a
- 5:51client who suffers from what would likely be evaluated as suffering from a mood disorder,
- 5:58but the coach either doesn't know or is choosing to ignore that so that
- 6:03the coach can retain a client and earn money. So, you know,
- 6:08there's just a lot of issues there. The other issue is that for many
- 6:12coaches, again, since they don't necessarily have training, they might not even
- 6:15know how to detect depression to begin with. Even if they knew of depression
- 6:19or believed quote unquote and depression, they might have no idea how to evaluate
- 6:25it because of of course, why would lay because the coaches are lay people
- 6:30in psychology. I think that's important to emphasize now again on a return to
- 6:34say that there are many coaches that are absolutely aware of that. There are
- 6:39professional organizations that are trying to develop an ethical standard to follow, but there's
- 6:45no mandate for a life coach to follow these ethical standards. They're just internet
- 6:50websites and organizations that provide trainings that have no authority over life coaches. Whereas
- 6:57for me, as as marriage of family therapist and someone that is trained as
- 7:02a psychologist. For me, I have the ethical codes of THEAAMFT Ethical Codes.
- 7:09I also have the codes of the American Psychological Association that I am expected
- 7:13to hold myself to, and I have a ton of training in it,
- 7:16and I have a ton of supervision that I have attended. You know,
- 7:21just hundreds of hours of supervision alone. I mean, you know, forget
- 7:26about all the hours in school that I because I have basically two masters and
- 7:30a doctorate. It's a shit ton of class time. And in addition to
- 7:34that all the supervision that I've been through, just hundreds of hours of me
- 7:40talking with supervisors so that they can teach me and guide me and mentor me.
- 7:45So it's a lot of training, right well, life coaches might not
- 7:48have any of that. In fact, typically I would say they don't.
- 7:51Now. I suspect, and I've said this many times before, that in
- 7:56the future there that coaching will be a regulated profession that you will either be
- 8:01certified or licensed by the government in the United States in your state to provide
- 8:07coaching. And so when that happens, there will be standards of training and
- 8:13ethical codes and continuing education, and there will be a license. And when
- 8:20licensed coaches violate those ethics or those laws, then their license can be stripped
- 8:28or sanctioned in some way, in the same way that for US mental health
- 8:33clinicians. That is true as well, the same with medical professionals. But
- 8:39when that happens, in all likelihood, there will be another name that will
- 8:43be developed, because there's always going to be a group of people that will
- 8:48want to practice outside of licensure, because once you have all those requirements of
- 8:54training and ethics, that will probably just get more robust as time moves on.
- 9:00That's been the case for all the other professions, like with marriage of
- 9:03family therapy, for example, the requirements of training and ethical codes were minimal
- 9:07thirty years ago as opposed to today, because things just get more intense and
- 9:13there's more expectations. There's more case law to alert us to things that need
- 9:18to be discussed, and so with coaches it will probably be that way.
- 9:22But that will just leave a whole group of people that don't want to be
- 9:28trained. They don't want to bother with that, they don't want to be
- 9:31held to that standard for whatever reason. They don't want to be limited in
- 9:35terms of their behavior. Because once the coaching profession is established, there will
- 9:41be very firm boundaries regarding what a coach can and cannot do. So there
- 9:46will always be a group of people I imagine that will not want that restriction.
- 9:52So there'll be another name, like maybe coaching will become a profession,
- 9:56but life coaches will remain not a profession, you know what I mean,
- 10:01Or guidance guide, guide, guiders, mentors or something. There'll be some
- 10:05other name that will be developed, you know. And I'm all for the
- 10:11free market to some extent, of course, as long as there's adequate protections
- 10:15for the public and the consumer. And I think it's totally fine that they're
- 10:20like, right now, I think it's absolutely trul I don't want to make
- 10:22coaches illegal, but I think that there needs to be a lot of education
- 10:30to the public as to what coaches and therapists are and what the differences are.
- 10:35And I think that this is becoming a problem because a lot of therapists
- 10:41are also becoming coaches and muddying the waters. And I think this is resulting
- 10:46in a lot of misinformation to the public about what therapy is and what coaching
- 10:52is, which I'll get into now. Another caveat is that in some forms
- 10:58of therapy they will refer them to themselves as coaches as opposed to therapists or
- 11:03counselor, like with Boinian therapy. If you've heard my deep dive on Murray
- 11:07Bowen, he and colleagues would train their therapists to refer to themselves as coaches.
- 11:13But that's very different. And this was forty fifty years ago, so
- 11:16they weren't saying to change your profession from therapist or counselor to coach. They
- 11:22were just saying, refer to yourself as coach because it demotes you on the
- 11:28power scale. Because you don't want to create a dynamic with the client where
- 11:31you're the expert in the client is the person who doesn't have power or knowledge.
- 11:35And also it I think was an effort to help the clients back then
- 11:41to understand that the therapists weren't there to like diagnose and to fix certain problems.
- 11:48The therapist was there to help the client to become differentiated, to coach
- 11:52the client to become differentiated. Anyway, you can listen to my deep dive
- 11:56on that. But that isn't to say that these professionals considered themselves to be
- 12:01outside of their ethical codes or outside their profession. They they just use a
- 12:05different words. I just want to throw that in there. Okay, So
- 12:07let's take a break, and when we get back, I'm going to go
- 12:11into the case that my malpractice insurance sent me regarding a counselor who was successfully
- 12:18sued because of this issue of the therapist also being a coach. All right,
- 12:24let's take a break. All right, So this is the case right
- 12:31up that my malpractice insurance sent me. So the case involves a counselor,
- 12:37a licensed professional counselor who has been a licensed professional counselor for twenty years.
- 12:43So the counselor who was sued has a lot of experience twenty years. You
- 12:46know, they're not directly out of grad school. The counselor is male,
- 12:52and he practices somewhere in the United States. He's in private practice. He
- 12:56was in private practice, and he specialized in treating clients who suffered from substance
- 13:01use disorders. But I'm guessing in all likelihood he treated all sorts of clients,
- 13:07but I don't know that. But he claimed and advertised himself to specialize
- 13:11in working with substance use disorders. He also offered life coaching services to some
- 13:18of his clients. The case righte Up was clear in stating that he has
- 13:24no formal training as a life coach and he is not certified by any sort
- 13:28of entity or any sort of professional organization of coaches. Now, he doesn't
- 13:33need training in coaching to claim and to be a life coach and to provide
- 13:37life coaching because there is no guideline, there's no regulation around that. But
- 13:43the right Up said, by the way, he also didn't have any training,
- 13:46which might have helped, but who knows, It's unclear. So getting
- 13:50into the treatment, he began treating a client who was male in his mid
- 13:56twenties, so a young man. He was homeless, and he was also
- 14:01unemployed, and he had a criminal history, and he also had a history
- 14:07of substance use. The client was referred to the counselor by the court.
- 14:11The counselor assessed the client with generalist anxiety, substance induced depression in any social
- 14:18precise or and the counselor proceeded to provide psychotherapy or talk therapy to the client.
- 14:22They didn't go into detail as to what the counselor was doing, and
- 14:26the counselor also provided life coaching, so both therapy and life coaching, and
- 14:33the clinician the counselor was clear about that. Okay, So let's take a
- 14:39little bit of a sidebar here and talk about the problems with coaching and also
- 14:46the problems with therapists providing coaching. Again, I want to provide a caveat
- 14:52that many coaches are very ethical and are providing a wonderful service to many many
- 14:58I've heard from many pe people along those lines, clients of my own who
- 15:01have been to coaches and benefited greatly. And there are many therapists that are
- 15:07also life coaches who use this form of service and this dual provision of service
- 15:16in a completely ethical, above board way, and they are also very helpful
- 15:20people. Okay, Having said that, I want to comment on why a
- 15:28therapist would even be a life coach to begin with, because it's to me
- 15:31a little bit of a strange decision. But I'll also say, as a
- 15:35caveat that there are situations in which that would be good. Like, I
- 15:41know someone who is a therapist, and she's very good as a therapist.
- 15:46She works with couples and individuals, and she provides coaching for people regarding dating
- 15:52and flirting. She's very good at helping people, teaching people how to meet
- 16:00on one, how to flirt, how to date effectively, and has helped
- 16:06many people on those lines. So the therapy profession and job that she does
- 16:12is you know, standard therapy with all the sort of things that you would
- 16:17expect, but she also advertises herself as someone that can help someone to date.
- 16:22Well, well, it's not traditionally a clinical problem. Now I will
- 16:26say, as a therapist, I have helped people with flirting and dating.
- 16:30It's not a common topic, but you know, you practice long enough with
- 16:33the sort of clients I work with and I have helped clients with that,
- 16:37And during those conversations, I didn't say, by the way, we're not
- 16:41providing I'm not providing therapy right now, I'm providing a coaching service. No,
- 16:45it's all therapy. You know. That wasn't the reason why they came
- 16:48to me. It was just among them. You know, you work with
- 16:51clients for years and years, there's going to be a lot of things that
- 16:53come up. So and I felt that at least with that topic, that
- 17:00I know enough both personally and clinically to help people with it anyway. So
- 17:08whereas like if a client were to ask me about like how to buy a
- 17:11car, or how to do their taxes, or how to renovate their kitchen,
- 17:17I wouldn't you know, provide that sort of coaching or that sort of
- 17:22help. You know what I mean. I'm saying that I would only help
- 17:23a client with something that I had reason to believe that I knew what I
- 17:29was talking about enough to help them and not harm them anyway. So with
- 17:33this therapist that I know, she you know, she does both of those
- 17:36things, and they're very separate. She works also with these coaching clients around
- 17:42how to meet someone and how to flirt well and to you know, how
- 17:47to dress, how to smile, how to make conversation, and there's nothing
- 17:52clinical. So if the client were to bring up something clinical, then this
- 17:57therapist that is also a coach that I know, she would, you know,
- 18:00stop the coaching session and say, I need to refer you to a
- 18:06therapist. In fact, she wouldn't even necessarily work with that client in her
- 18:11practice because she would worry about the dual roles. So she would refer that
- 18:17student in her flirting class to another therapist while retaining that student as a student,
- 18:23right, so you know, keeping those boundaries very, very firm.
- 18:27So again, there are people that can do this, but I have seen
- 18:33so many other cases which I want to get into. So there's a lot
- 18:38of people, and increasingly so over the past, like I said, fifteen
- 18:44years, but more so in the last five years, I really didn't hear
- 18:47very many, particularly in my circle. I didn't hear a lot of therapists
- 18:51talking about being coaches because there's enough to do within the profession of counseling and
- 18:56therapy that why do you need to become a coach. So increasingly, more
- 19:00recently I start hearing. Even in the circle that I'm in, people starting
- 19:07to say like, well, I think I'm going to start a coaching side
- 19:10business because of X Y and Z. So let me talk about x Y
- 19:12and why would someone do this. Well, one of the things that they
- 19:15will say, and I see this online as well, is that they will
- 19:19say, well, coaching is action oriented. It's goal oriented. Coaching is
- 19:26for people that want to take action, whereas therapy addresses mental health. Okay,
- 19:33so what do they mean when they're saying this, Well, I think
- 19:36what they're trying to say, which I don't agree with, by the way,
- 19:40is that therapists don't help someone with discrete, short term goals like I
- 19:48want to get a better job, or I want to clean my house or
- 19:52I want to quit smoking next week something like that. And the idea is
- 19:59that therapy is about like trauma and talking about your feelings and about providing evidence
- 20:06based treatments, and you know, none of that is involved with trying to
- 20:12find a job, you know, that sort of thing. But there's actually
- 20:17a lot of training and a lot of precedent in our field for decades around
- 20:22career counseling. I mean, it's a whole wing of the counseling profession,
- 20:27and there are you know, there's research and measurements, you know, assessment
- 20:32measurements to determine aptitude and preference of the client, and there's whole protocols or
- 20:38how to help, so therapy can be very action oriented. You know.
- 20:42I had a client once that came to me for quitting smoking. That's all
- 20:47he came to be for. And since I know enough about addiction and treatment
- 20:51and recovery and smoking in particular, because I used to have a problem with
- 20:56it myself for many years and successfully kick the habit, which was not easy,
- 21:03perhaps the hardest thing I've ever done, and learned a lot through that
- 21:07several year process of failing and failing until I succeeded twenty three years ago.
- 21:15Uh yeah, twenty three and a half years ago. I still have dreams
- 21:19that I'm smoking. It's weird. I'll have a a dream I'll just be
- 21:26like casually smoking a cigarette, and then all of a sudden, I go,
- 21:29oh shit, I'm smoking. Why shouldn't be smoking? And then I
- 21:33remember all these other times that I've relapsed, but I'm remembering other dreams.
- 21:40It's the weirdest thing in my dream. I'm always convinced that I've been relapsing
- 21:45off and on for the past twenty three years. But I'm I'm literally remembering
- 21:49other dreams in which I relapsed and realized I was relapsing, and it's such
- 21:53a relief that when I wake up, I'm just like, oh my god,
- 21:56not only did I not relapse in that moment, but I haven't been
- 22:00smoking for twenty three years at all, not even slightly, you know.
- 22:04And so anyway, those are weird dreams and all. Another kind of weird
- 22:10part of the dream is I often it feels bad. It feels really bad.
- 22:15It's not like, yeah, I get a smile. I just feel
- 22:17so demoralized because it was very demoralizing when I would relapse back in the day.
- 22:22It took me about three years to quit. But so anyway, you
- 22:26know, a client would come to me just for that, and I provided
- 22:29therapy for that. I think the session count was three to five. It
- 22:33was very short, and I don't know if he sustained his abstinence, but
- 22:37you know, he did achieve absence, and I did provide a lot of
- 22:42education and other kinds of tips about that. So that's extremely action oriented it's
- 22:48also fucking therapy and considered mental health. I mean, it's it's a diagnosis
- 22:56in the DSM about a use disorder, and there's a whole protocol about how
- 23:03to do that. Now, I'm not saying every therapist has the competence to
- 23:07provide that kind of treatment, but it's certainly under the umbrella of that.
- 23:11It's under another umbrella of substance abuse treatment, right, there's a certification is
- 23:17there a licenser for that in Washington State anyway, there's a process of becoming
- 23:22a legit government you identified individual in substance abuse treatment. So it's also for
- 23:30those folks anyway. So also, there are many forms of therapy theoretical orientations
- 23:37that are absolutely action oriented. So this idea that coaching is action oriented and
- 23:44therapy is not is false because there are forms of therapy, like we literally
- 23:49have a whole wing of therapy called brief therapies. There's a set of theories
- 23:56and modalities that are under this umbrella called brief therapy. In fact, whenever
- 24:03I will state the theories that I hold to as a therapist, I will
- 24:08rattle off the umbrellas the larger categories of theories. Because I'm such a theory
- 24:15nerd and have been for so long that I know in session I am calling
- 24:22upon all of these umbrellas and specific theories underneath each umbrella. You know,
- 24:27sometimes they call people like me eclectic. It's more fashionable today to call ourselves
- 24:33integrated. But whatever word you put to it, I fall within the camp
- 24:37like John Norcross and other folks, other psychologists and researchers that will find,
- 24:42according to research, that it's best if us therapists actually have a wide range
- 24:48of theories that we are competent and knowledgeable in, because then we can tailor
- 24:53the treatment to the client and the situation rather than the other way around.
- 24:57And so you know, just a of those. It's been a while,
- 25:00so I've done this, so let's see if I can do it. So
- 25:03there's the whole psychodynamic umbrella. Attachment theory could be argue that it's underneath the
- 25:07dynamic umbrella, but I would say it's so in separate. So all of
- 25:11attachment theory and all the research and the types of therapy like EFT and other
- 25:17kinds of things that use attachment theory. Then we have systems theories, family
- 25:21systems theories, and just general system theory. I also use feminist and cultural
- 25:27awareness is maybe a term that I would context awareness power and privilege and socialization
- 25:36and bias and prejudice and cultural harm, gender harm. So that's another umbrella.
- 25:41Another umbrella is brief therapy such as soution focus and narrative and Milton Ericks
- 25:48and social oriented and you could argue CBT is kind of Another umbrella is cognitive
- 25:53therapy. I don't say CBT isn't the same, because it's really two different
- 25:57whole wings of therapy. You have cognitive theory and therapy, and then you
- 26:02have behavioral theory and therapy. Uh, there's also what am I leaving out,
- 26:10there's also neurological ideas. There's not really a neurological theory, but there
- 26:15are a lot of there's a lot of brain science and neurology and biology,
- 26:19physiology. You know, of course medications are in this, but also you
- 26:23could argue that like sleep and other kinds of knowledge about the brain executive function,
- 26:30that kind of thing amygdala. That's another umbrella that of course I adhere
- 26:33to you because why would you not humanistic therapy I use, you know,
- 26:38there's a lot of schools underneath the umbrella of humanistic therapy positive regard, empathy,
- 26:45self disclosure, authenticity, you know, being real with your clients,
- 26:49helping clients to be real with themselves, helping clients with their emotions, expressive
- 26:55therapies, experiential therapy, you know. So why things so anyway, brief
- 27:00therapy is a whole field, and it's argued that you could argue that within
- 27:04brief therapies they are very action oriented, like solution focus, like motivational interviewing,
- 27:10like cognitive therapy, like behavioral therapy, like RIBT rational motive behavioral therapy.
- 27:15You have, you could argue act is under this category. I'm not
- 27:18sure everyone would agree with that. And also humanistic therapies can be this way
- 27:22as well. There's many accounts of some of the main figures within humanistic therapy
- 27:30that will give cases in which they treated a client for five minutes and helped
- 27:36them you know, so those can be very action oriented. You know,
- 27:41if I just think off the top of my head, the sort of action
- 27:44oriented goals that I've helped clients with or at least attempted to help, like
- 27:48quitting smoking, well, quitting any substance, helping them just with their sleep,
- 27:56just help them get better sleep at night and evaluating that whole sleep system
- 28:00right by biological their environment, sleep hygiene, of course their cognitive reality.
- 28:07You know, what do they think about when they're trying to fall asleep?
- 28:10The worries, you know, because a lot of people will have trouble falling
- 28:12asleep because they're worried about not being able to fall asleep, you know,
- 28:15or they're worried about something the next day, or they don't know how to
- 28:18control their thoughts, so their mind is racing when their head it's the pillar.
- 28:22There's just a lot of different things that therapists can and do help clients
- 28:27with regarding sleep. And that's a very action oriented thing. Right now.
- 28:33Could a coach help someone with sleep, Yeah, as long as it didn't
- 28:38get into clinical areas like depression or medications or other kinds of things. You
- 28:45know, cognitive notions are not necessarily a clinical idea, right You know,
- 28:52if you had a friend that said, hey, you know it helps when
- 28:56I do this at night and maybe that i'll help you, your friend isn't
- 29:00providing a clinical service in that in that moment, so you know, but
- 29:06again, a lot of the literature trying to sell coaching to the masses and
- 29:11also trying to get therapists to become coaches, and the justifications. A lot
- 29:17of therapists will say, I'm a coach is they will say, I want
- 29:21to also provide this other service that is action oriented, and it's like,
- 29:25no therapy can be their action oriented. Now, like I said earlier,
- 29:29there are many things within the action oriented camp that therapists would not provide.
- 29:34You know, services that therapists would not provide, like how to get organized
- 29:38in your house. Well, but even that, you know, I've I've
- 29:41helped clients with organization. I don't go to their hout. Well, I
- 29:45have done that. So when I did in person or in home therapy for
- 29:51about ten fifteen years, you know, the first ten fifteen years of my
- 29:53career, I did that. And you know, occasionally clients families, like
- 30:00a common scenario would be I would have a fifteen year old kid with ADHD
- 30:04who was having a hard time with with their ADHD, only having a hard
- 30:11time with organization, and I would be in the home and I would be
- 30:15contracted by the government to go into the house and there's usually some bigger problem
- 30:18like the kid ran away or got in a fight at school or something,
- 30:22and at some point I'm treating the family and I would say, okay,
- 30:25well, here are the options. Let's, you know, let's look at
- 30:27an assessment, let's look at medication. Let's also look at specific therapies or
- 30:33techniques to help someone with ADHD. And one of the things that you can
- 30:38do is you can help the person with ADHD have a system that works within
- 30:44their ADHD and accounts for it. Like you know, for a kid that
- 30:48doesn't have ADHD, you don't have to remind them to turn in their homework
- 30:52when they get to school because the way that their brain works, more often
- 30:56than not, their working memory and their executive function, their neuronal reality is
- 31:02such that they will just naturally remember. It will just occur to them,
- 31:06Oh, I better turn into my homework. You don't have to remind them,
- 31:10or not necessarily, but they're much more likely, whereas someone with ADHD,
- 31:12it'll be very difficult for them to remember that because their brain is different
- 31:18and their working memory is not as good. It works to some extent,
- 31:22but it doesn't work as well or in the same way, and so when
- 31:26they get to school, they don't have that kind of working this category of
- 31:33working memory, and there's a whole there's all this science and theory and language
- 31:37around this, and I'm using my own just for the sake of brevity,
- 31:40but working this type of working memory is kind of weird, like if you
- 31:44don't have ADHD and you wake up in the morning, like my wife is
- 31:48kind of like this. She doesn't really have a system of reminding herself to
- 31:53do things. She doesn't really have a calendar, and I'm always my mind
- 31:59is always just blown away that because for me, I have everything in my
- 32:04calendar, I mean down to like and I think I developed this because as
- 32:07a therapist, you know, when you have thirty forty appointments a week,
- 32:13you know, including clients and supervision and other kinds of appointments, there's no
- 32:17way that you're going to just remember that, right. You have to have
- 32:22this very clear list. And I became very oriented from the time I was
- 32:28in my mid twenties till today to my calendar where I just compulsively and reflexively
- 32:34look to my calendar throughout the day because I just never know what I'm doing,
- 32:39you know, even today. And so my wife is like this where
- 32:45she wakes up in the morning, and she's very responsible, like she is
- 32:51the opposite of flake. I can't imagine anyone having ever described her as big
- 32:54a flake or irresponsible or late. She's where perfect for each other because we're
- 33:00both extreme on time people, pathologically on time people. And so even though
- 33:08she doesn't really have a system, she still remembers, you know, it'll
- 33:13just occur to her. Oh, today's Wednesday. This is the day of
- 33:16my dead disappointment. It's at two o'clock or something like that. You know,
- 33:19I mean, that's a little extreme. She probably writes that down,
- 33:21but even so, you know what I mean. Whereas people with ADHD,
- 33:24they're not. So my point is is that i'd be working with a fifteen
- 33:28year old about how to account for the fact that they in all likelihood have
- 33:34a deficit in that and will never just develop it out of thin air.
- 33:37They have to have workarounds, they have to have a system, and so
- 33:42I would go through physically with them. Let's look at what your bag looks
- 33:46like. You know, your backpack that you bring to school. Where do
- 33:51you put your homework? Where is your homework? Now? What sort of
- 33:55reminders can you put to yourself? To have a routine is the more routine
- 34:00it is, the more likely you're to remember it. Right, So if
- 34:05they have a routine where every single time they enter a classroom they just have
- 34:08to remember one thing, which is to open up their bag, pull out
- 34:13their calendar and look at their calendar, and on that calendar it'll tell them
- 34:19turn in your homework. And they might have even written that themselves the previous
- 34:22night after they did their homework, they wrote down in their calendar, turn
- 34:27in your homework. And so when they enter class, they open it up,
- 34:30they oh, yeah, that's right. They wouldn't necessarily remember that,
- 34:32so it reminds them. So anyway, that's very action oriented, is my
- 34:37point. Hope you get my point. I'm rambling again. But so that
- 34:43distinction is a little funny now as I gave that example earlier where my friend
- 34:47and colleague she provides regular therapy and life coaching for flirting and how to meet
- 34:52someone. That's a class format with one to ten students at a time.
- 34:59It's a that number of classes, like you know, five to ten classes,
- 35:04and they're you know, it's it's a particular kind of vibe right when
- 35:07she's in that vibe she's not the same as when she's a therapist. She's
- 35:13like, hello, everyone, let's talk about this, and clients aren't encouraged
- 35:17to go into their traumas or anything like that. If they bring up a
- 35:21trauma, she would have you know, she would have ground rules about that
- 35:24sort of thing and or pull them aside and say, hey, I'm going
- 35:29to recommend that you talk to a colleague of mine. You know. So
- 35:31that is very action oriented and can work in that way. But like I
- 35:36said, there's a lot of action oriented things in therapy that would also anyway.
- 35:43Okay, So that's one reason why therapists will say I'm going to become
- 35:47a coach as well, is because they're trying to say I want to be
- 35:51action oriented, which is weird to me because unless it's very specific, like
- 35:55a class on how to help people flirt, there's no reason to do because
- 35:59you know, what a lot of therapists are doing is they're just taking clients
- 36:02in the exact same way with the exact same issues like marital conflict or trauma
- 36:09symptoms. They wouldn't be identified as such, but you know, like just
- 36:14a lot of distress. Someone has a lot of distress about their life.
- 36:16They don't really know why, but they just know that their life isn't going
- 36:20well. And these therapists will take on these individuals in their life coaching wing
- 36:25of their job. And it's not discreet, right, It's not like how
- 36:30to flirt. It's like general problems that probably are clinical anyway. So another
- 36:37reason why a lot of therapists will say this is why I'm becoming a coach
- 36:42is what they will say is because of marketing. They will say that,
- 36:45well, I want to appeal to people that have stigma about therapy, you
- 36:51know, because a lot of people have a stigma about going to see a
- 36:54therapist, and so I want to help those people. And what I'm to
- 37:00do is I'm going to call myself a coach. And I've had a lot
- 37:01of clients come to me saying that they would never see a therapist, but
- 37:06they absolutely don't mind seeing a coach. Well, unless it's a legit coaching
- 37:12practice that is highly limited in terms of its scope, in terms of what
- 37:17sort of things you're doing. You're just providing therapy to people and calling it
- 37:22coaching. Right. Another problem with this is that, well, yeah,
- 37:27stigma is a problem, and helping people to get to therapy is something we
- 37:31need to be doing. But we shouldn't destroy our profession or our practice to
- 37:37accommodate the stigma. We should try to reduce the stigma right, so that
- 37:42people go to therapy when they need, when they need to write, or
- 37:45at least when they suspect they need therapy, they get assessed by someone.
- 37:50So that justification doesn't make sense to me. Another justification that I'm hearing more
- 37:55recently is that people will say, well, I wasn't making enough money as
- 38:01a therapist. I couldn't pay my bills, I couldn't pay my student loans.
- 38:06But as a coach, I can actually pay my bills. Okay,
- 38:09So that can be a legitimate reason that could result in a legitimate dual practice
- 38:16of being a counselor and a coach. Having said that, what I hear
- 38:21from people is that they're not very thoughtful, you know, like with my
- 38:24colleague, I don't know, I doubt this was her motivation, but it
- 38:29could have been, but I doubt it was that She's like, I'm not
- 38:31making enough money in my regular clinical practice. I am really good at teaching
- 38:37classes about flirting and how to meet people, and if I appeal to a
- 38:40certain richer or wealthier audience, and I package my marketing well enough, I
- 38:49might be able to charge a lot, you know, especially if there's a
- 38:52lot of students. Say if every student paid fifty dollars an hour, and
- 38:57I have five students or ten students five hundred dollars an hour, and I
- 39:01don't have the paperwork or the clinical responsibility, I could just teach that class.
- 39:05So can that be a legitimate reason? Say, you know, I'm
- 39:07not making enough money in my practice, I need to do this other thing,
- 39:09and you know, I can sort of use bits and pieces of my
- 39:15clinical expertise in my coaching practice while not actually providing a clinical service and being
- 39:21very clear about that. Yeah, you could do that. But what I
- 39:22hear from a lot of people anecdotally is I mean, I guess it would
- 39:28have to be anecdotally if I'm hearing from people is that they're just accepting clients
- 39:35as coaching clients. And because coaching can be a variety of different formats,
- 39:43Like it's not uncommon for coaching meetings sessions to be shorter than an hour.
- 39:50So you can have a coaching session that's like fifteen minutes right, And if
- 39:54you provide a very sought after service, then you could charge a hund dollars
- 40:00for that fifteen minutes, and if you have four people in that hour,
- 40:02then you have four hundred dollars an hour, which is, you know,
- 40:06typically a lot higher than the price that or the fee that therapists will offer,
- 40:12you know, typical I think average American fee would be I don't know,
- 40:15I'm just going to take a guess, let's say one hundred to one
- 40:16hundred, fifty hundred and seventy I don't know, somewhere in that zone.
- 40:20And so you know, they're making more money. Now, if it's a
- 40:23legit, actual coaching practice and the therapist has a lot of boundaries around this
- 40:29whole thing, then that can be a way to do it. But that's
- 40:31not what I'm hearing. What I'm hearing is therapists that are marketing themselves as
- 40:37coaches, appealing to people who might have stigma about going to therapy, packaging
- 40:42it in this sort of executive marketing language, providing at times an absolute clinical
- 40:50service, and advertising themselves as a therapist who's also a coach. In fact,
- 40:55a lot of the recommendations around this dual profession or this dual career for
- 41:02some therapist is that if you are ever at talking to someone about your coaching
- 41:08practice, you do not mention that you're a therapist. You don't mention that
- 41:13you have qualifications as a therapist, you don't mention that you have a master's
- 41:16degree in counseling. You just talk about your coaching credential and your coaching experience
- 41:23and what coaching can do. Because even if coaches did say, you know,
- 41:29therapist coaches, even if they did say to a client, hey,
- 41:32you know, I also have a therapy practice, even if they did say
- 41:37that to their coaching clients, it's possible that the client would confuse that and
- 41:43would use coaching for clinical You know, you could absolutely see that, and
- 41:47I wouldn't faul to the consumer for that, right, you know, the
- 41:51consumer the client comes in and you know, additionally talking about coaching concerns and
- 41:57then at some point is like, oh, oh yeah, well, I
- 42:00guess I have to kind of talk about my mom and the way she treated
- 42:02me, And the client is like, well, you're a therapist, so
- 42:06you can help me with that. I mean, people do that to me
- 42:07in my personal life. I'll have people in my personal life that I'll say
- 42:10like, well, you're a therapist, so you know you can help me
- 42:15with this, or you're a therapist, you can react to this differently,
- 42:20even though I'm not paying you, and you know, and I would say,
- 42:22no, no, no, I'm not your I'm not your therapist.
- 42:23I am a therapist, but I'm not your therapist. I'm just a regular
- 42:27human. It does, you know, I can help people, but it
- 42:32doesn't mean necessarily anyway. The point is is that some people will say,
- 42:37well, I needed to start a coaching practice because I wasn't making enough money
- 42:39as a therapist. Okay, so let's look at that one. What that
- 42:44tells me is that the person is early career. Which is another thing that
- 42:47I've seen anecdotally is that early career therapists will want to you know, they
- 42:53have a visionist as to how much money they're going to make, and early
- 42:58career as a therapist. Often it takes a while to get to that place.
- 43:02It did for me. You know, I was earning thirteen dollars an
- 43:07hour, which I think is about twenty six dollars in today's dollars something like
- 43:13that, and yeah, it was hard. I was earning two thousand dollars
- 43:20gross income or after taxes something like that. Yeah, probably after taxes two
- 43:23thousand dollars a month. And due to my student loans and credit cards,
- 43:29I had interest, just interest, of eleven hundred dollars a month, so
- 43:34I really only was making nine hundred dollars a month to pay for a very
- 43:38cheap apartment and a very shitty car with three hundred thousand miles on it.
- 43:43All my clothes were from secondhand stores, you know. And I didn't have
- 43:46cable TV. I mean I barely had a TV. My TV was like
- 43:50this really crappy, thirteen inch piece of crap. Anyway, So yeah,
- 43:57it sucks in the beginning, and let's talk about that and let's change that,
- 44:00or let's work on that, and may I help you with building your
- 44:06career and earning money so you can pay your bills. But that isn't,
- 44:09in my view, a justification to say I'm going to throw out my ethical
- 44:14codes in my training and become a coach and treat clients very similarly and advertise
- 44:21myself very similarly because I want to make more money. You know, I
- 44:24just don't understand that. Plus, this is what I'll hear they'll say being
- 44:29a therapist doesn't pay enough full stop, and I think, well, maybe
- 44:35where you're at in your career, or maybe your community is another thing.
- 44:38You know, maybe in your town the expectation about fee is lower, or
- 44:44there's not enough clients to go around or something. And yeah, I get
- 44:47that, but that's not a reason to break from your profession. That's motivation
- 44:54or that would be a prompt. You know, if someone came to me
- 44:58and said, I'm in a small town and I just graduated, and I'm
- 45:01trying to build a private practice, and it's been a few years and I've
- 45:05worked really hard, and I've marketed myself well, and I have a mentor,
- 45:09and yet I'm still not able to pay my bills because i only have
- 45:13like five clients. Then I would say, well, I wouldn't say start
- 45:16a coaching practice. I would say, well, maybe you should look at
- 45:22other communities that are nearby. Now, in today's world, post pandemic,
- 45:25most therapists are online these days as far as I can tell, so that
- 45:30wouldn't be a problem. But I hope you get my point, because according
- 45:34to statistics, therapists make a fair salary and that's just and that's including therapists
- 45:40that work for agencies, which typically just not pay that much. Again,
- 45:45anecdotally, in Seattle, the cost of living is very high compared to other
- 45:52cities in the United States and the world, So just take that in consideration.
- 45:54But you know, anecdotally, I would say that after a few years,
- 45:59and I trained and mentored hundreds of therapists postgrad because they would hire me
- 46:05as their supervisor postgrad, And I would say anecdotally that in today's dollars,
- 46:12and I know current recent grads that are in the situation after a few years,
- 46:16they're earning at least one hundred and fifty thousand dollars a year, if
- 46:20not two hundred thousand dollars a year, you know, maybe one hundred thousand
- 46:22if things, because because the other thing is marketing. What I've learned about
- 46:28the difference between a therapist that makes a lot of money and a therapist that
- 46:30doesn't. A therapist that has a lot of clients versus a therapist that doesn't
- 46:35has little to do with their ability. I mean, has something to do
- 46:38with their ability as a therapist, but I would say ninety percent of it
- 46:42has to do with how good they are at marketing. And you don't even
- 46:45have to be very good at marketing. You just have to be motivated.
- 46:51You just have to put in the effort. It's not even that hard.
- 46:53There are little things like just being a part of certain Facebook groups where frequently
- 47:00there are people saying, I'm looking for a therapist for this. You know,
- 47:04there are therapist Facebook groups where other therapists will be looking for a referral.
- 47:09And if you stay on top of that and respond quickly and have a
- 47:15good elevator speech, even mildly good, then in my experience, that's one
- 47:22of a few factors that can result in making the difference between an early career
- 47:27private practice therapist that makes two hundred thousand dollars versus someone that makes less than
- 47:32forty thousand dollars a year. And I've seen that. I've been ground level,
- 47:36you know, because I would work with these folks for an hour every
- 47:39week, and you know, for the folks that were not earning very much
- 47:44money and didn't have a lot of clients, a lot of our discussions were
- 47:46around marketing. I mean, because you know, I had a supervisor once
- 47:52that had basically one or two clients in the span of like three years.
- 47:57So you run out of stuff to talk about because and supervision you're supposed to
- 48:00you know, mainly you're talking about clients. Well, there's not a lot
- 48:04to talk about if the therapist only has a couple of clients in the span
- 48:07of a few years. And so we spend a lot of time talking about
- 48:09marketing. And I you know, figured out a lot through supervisors like this
- 48:15that there's just some people that put in the effort and some people who don't.
- 48:21And it's kind of weird, and I don't really understand that difference.
- 48:24There's a little bit of savviness involved, you know, there's but the things
- 48:29that I anyway, so to make more money to me is not a viable
- 48:35reason to become a coach if you're a therapist, unless you have a particular
- 48:40topic like flirting and how to meet people, how to date, or some
- 48:46other narrow thing that you're really more interested in teaching to people rather than providing
- 48:53a clinical service, you know what I mean. Maybe that's one way to
- 48:57look at coaching is that I don't know if this holds water, but if
- 49:02the concern for the coach e could be considered something that you could take a
- 49:09class about then it's a legit coaching focus. You know. You can have
- 49:16a class on how to flirt. You can have a class on how to
- 49:20organize your bedroom. You can have a class on how to best plan your
- 49:25career. You can't have a class on how to recover from trauma. You
- 49:29can't have a class. I mean you can't see there's no I mean you
- 49:32could have a class I suppose, but it wouldn't work, you know,
- 49:36because it has to be tailored. There's so many clinical issues that have to
- 49:40be closely monitored by an expert, not just a therapist, but an expert
- 49:45in trauma. Can you teach people how to not have merital conflict? I
- 49:51would say no. You could have a class that could maybe help, but
- 49:55it's so nuanced, and especially clients with personality disorders, when they take a
- 50:00class, they're going to misinterpret the information. You know, like if you
- 50:06talk to and I would see this happen. And this happens a lot,
- 50:08like with TikTok, like because people turn to TikTok as an educational tool,
- 50:14which is fucking ridiculous. I mean, there are some good, you know,
- 50:17educators and clinicians on TikTok, but they get buried underneath all the bullshit
- 50:22because of the algorithm. So, you know, I would have clients that
- 50:25would come to me a couples that would have taken a class and say the
- 50:30husband has let's just go with borderline personality disorder again, and he would,
- 50:37you know, have learned a good tip, like when you are upset,
- 50:43it's good to talk about your feelings like I statements instead of being accusatory.
- 50:49Well, this fictional client will come to me and say, yeah, I
- 50:52totally do that all the time. I say, you know, I feel
- 50:55like I feel like you don't care about my feelings and I feel like you
- 51:00are a distant withholding jerkface. Okay, so that's not a true application of
- 51:07what they are being taught. But that's not a mystery to us clinicians because
- 51:13people have traumas and schemas and you know, emotional issues and histories and resentments
- 51:22and so those things are not accounted for when you're just taking a class or
- 51:27watching a TikTok video anyway. But you know, I don't know if that
- 51:30holds water in terms of like you could take a class of meditation, you
- 51:34could take a class on mindfulness and coaches can help someone with mindfulness and with
- 51:38meditation. You know, that to me makes sense. Okay. Another reason
- 51:43why I will hear therapists who want to become coaches also is they will say
- 51:49that, hey, you can practice across state lines. So if you don't
- 51:52know, therapists in the United States are only licensed in the state that they're
- 51:58licensed in. Now, a therapist can hold a license in multiple states.
- 52:01I have friends and colleagues that do that. You know. They they have
- 52:07a house in California and a condo in Seattle, and they travel between both
- 52:14places and they have a license in both states and they can provide therapy to
- 52:19people in both states. But that's not the typical situation. And even if
- 52:22you did have two state licenses, that excludes the other forty eight. So
- 52:27now I get this problem and it upsets me and bothers me. I know
- 52:31that there's at least a little bit of a movement to try to federalize the
- 52:37laws and the licensure, because if we had a federal law, or at
- 52:43least a law that said, look, if you're if your license and once
- 52:47it's sort of like with a driver's license, it's the same actual thing.
- 52:51When I cross state lines and I drive into Oregon or Idaho, I don't
- 52:54need to get another driver's license because they have passed law that say, I
- 53:00don't know the exact laws, but it must be along these lines that says,
- 53:05look, if someone, you know, if a state licenses someone to
- 53:10drive, then by law, they are now licensed to drive in all of
- 53:15the states. Well, you could have that for a therapists, but for
- 53:17whatever reason, that doesn't happen. But it could happen, and if we
- 53:23put our minds to it, it's a no brainer. Because especially with online
- 53:28therapy, what's the difference these days? The point is is that this is
- 53:31in the same category of a therapist saying I'm not making enough money and so
- 53:37I'm going to become a coach. This is underneath that umbrella. I guess
- 53:39they're saying, I'm not making enough money, so I need to get clients
- 53:43from outside of my licensing area, and so in order to do that,
- 53:46I'll just be a coach. Again, if it's a legit coaching practice that
- 53:51is very limited to a set of coaching specific topics, then okay. But
- 53:57I see a lot of people that well, like a common scenario that I'll
- 54:01hear is it'll be a therapist that will provide coaching, and they get a
- 54:07coaching client. I don't even want to call them clients, coaching consumer,
- 54:12a coaching from another state, and they start out with a limited goal like
- 54:20I want to I guess this is big career, even though that's not typical,
- 54:23but I want to work on my career. Okay, So the client
- 54:28and coach talk about career for a couple sessions, but very quickly the client
- 54:34starts talking about their husband and how their marriage is falling apart, and how
- 54:39their parents treated them badly, and how they have some odd thoughts sometimes and
- 54:45they are worried greatly, and how their sleep isn't going well and they're on
- 54:52antidepressants but they don't know if it's helping. And you know, typical kinds
- 54:55of clinical assessment and exploration and you know things that are talked about in therapy,
- 55:00And what the coach will do is justify to themselves and say, well,
- 55:06I'm not saying the word depression, and I'm not saying the word you
- 55:09know, OCD or something. I'm just listening. So the coach proceeds to
- 55:15listen and the client absolutely knows that the coach is also a therapist and wants
- 55:22to blur that boundary, which is fine because as a consumer they can want
- 55:24whatever they want and what do they know. And so the you know,
- 55:29the client starts to vent and look forward to sessions so that the client can
- 55:35complain about her husband and the which I'm not denigrating. Complaining about when's spouse
- 55:42is one of the foundations of therapy. Not that as a therapist, I
- 55:49or other therapists are supposed to play into that and say, yeah, your
- 55:51spouse is such a drink face, but it can be a pretty robust or
- 55:55rich, fertile ground upon which therapy can take place in a variety of different
- 56:00helpful ways. But anyway, so the therapist slash coach starts to listen,
- 56:07the client starts to cry. The therapist is, you know, using reflective
- 56:13listening, which is a therapy technique, right, not always, of course,
- 56:16lay people can use reflective listening techniques. There's a lot of empathy,
- 56:21and the therapist starts saying little things like, well, you know, it
- 56:25sounds like there's some issue with some projective identification and it kind of works as
- 56:31this, or wow, it sounds like there's some anxiety going on there,
- 56:36you know, there's like some mild therapy talk, but the therapist continues to
- 56:40justify to themselves. Look, I'm not providing therapy because I haven't provided an
- 56:45assessment and I'm not doing my normal DBT or my EMDR or whatever, and
- 56:51so therefore this is coaching. It's not therapy. And maybe it is coaching
- 56:54and not therapy, but it doesn't look like that to me very much.
- 56:58If I saw these sessions and I would say, oh, obviously this is
- 57:01a therapy session. I'm not hearing like overt language. But rarely do therapists
- 57:07use overt therapy language with their clients because it'd be weird. It's jargon and
- 57:10terms, and clients don't know what you're talking about. So anyway, another
- 57:15reason why therapists will say that they're becoming a coach is because they want to
- 57:21skirt ethical and legal responsibilities. Now you're not going to hear this in public,
- 57:24but I will hear people say stuff like this. They will say stuff
- 57:29like, well, like I want to treat someone outside of my jurisdiction,
- 57:34or I want to be able to do this avant garde type of therapy that
- 57:38is a little questionable, a certain touch based body based therapy, and I
- 57:44don't want to have to answer to the ethical codes or to the authorities because
- 57:49I know that this therapy works. Blah blah blah. And along those lines,
- 57:53there are ways, like with touch and somatic therapy, Yeah, it
- 57:58is a bit risky, but there there's a whole field of that within our
- 58:04profession. There's a lot of research. There are ethical codes that are provided
- 58:08by organizations that use somatic and touch therapy. There's a whole protocol about what
- 58:15you do with informed consent, and with consent each time with clients. You
- 58:20know you can as a therapist do some pretty wacky shit in therapy and do
- 58:24it ethically and responsibly, minimizing risk to clients. So this idea that one
- 58:31would need to skirt the ethical requirements or responsibilities is problematic and a dozen different
- 58:38ways. Also, I will hear therapists say stuff like, well, I
- 58:44just hate the paperwork, and if I were a coach, I wouldn't need
- 58:47to have any paperwork. I'll hear stuff like that, or I'll hear someone
- 58:52say something like I want to be able to provide a service to people that
- 58:58I work with, because you know, people I work with, they often
- 59:01will ask me for help, and ethically it would be considered a multiple relationship,
- 59:07a dual relationship, probably a problematic relationship if I was to provide a
- 59:10service to my coworkers that I work with every day, forty hours a week.
- 59:15So I'm going to have this coaching side gig and make all this money
- 59:20and provide that service, Again, pretty problematic. And there's a whole lot
- 59:25of things that I've heard in this or another thing that I heard and saw
- 59:31was someone was a student, and not my student, but a student that
- 59:37I had heard about who was not licensed yet as a clinician, but she
- 59:42had learned a lot about how to be a helper, how to be a
- 59:45therapist a clinician, but she wasn't authorized to I think I think what happened
- 59:50was, for whatever reason, people were reaching out to her online to get
- 59:55clinical help from her, and at first she would have to say, well,
- 1:00:00well, I'm not licensed yet, so you'll have to wait a few
- 1:00:02years until I am, or I'm an intern or whatever you know. And
- 1:00:08but over time she started thinking, well, there's all these people that want
- 1:00:14my help, and I could start making money, and I could start paying
- 1:00:16off my student loans early if I took on these clients, but I'm not
- 1:00:20authorized to. What's another answer? And then somehow she heard about coaching and
- 1:00:24she's like, oh, okay, I'll just be a coach. You know,
- 1:00:28anyone could be a life coach. So I'll just tell these people,
- 1:00:30look and I'll be very clear to them, this is not therapy. I'm
- 1:00:34a life coach. Again, if it was legitimate life coaching and was within
- 1:00:39the limitations of life coaching, then fine, But it didn't sound like that.
- 1:00:44It sounded like she was providing therapy light, which is not not therapy.
- 1:00:49Therapy light is still therapy. Right. This is a problem. And
- 1:00:52really all of this points in one direction, which is that there are I
- 1:00:59don't know the percent Maybe there's some research on this. I couldn't find any,
- 1:01:02but I don't always find all the different studies. But I wouldn't be
- 1:01:07surprised if there was a really robust, well funded study that had a really
- 1:01:15good method of gathering information that looked into the question as to what percentage of
- 1:01:22coaches are providing a therapeutic what would be considered a clinical service to their clients.
- 1:01:29I would suspect that we would be looking at, you know, eighty
- 1:01:34percent of coaches or higher. I don't know. That's just anecdotal. Again,
- 1:01:37that's just me making sit up. It could be less than one percent,
- 1:01:40it could be ninety nine plus percent. I just don't know. But
- 1:01:46given my anecdotal experience, given what I've heard from the public, I think
- 1:01:51that there's a lot of life coaches that are absolutely perfid, especially when you
- 1:01:58think about having twenty to thirty clients in a week or more. Right,
- 1:02:02because if you're doing fifteen minute sessions, you know, you might have like
- 1:02:06fifty clients in a week. What's the chance that they're not stepping out of
- 1:02:10the boundary with none of their clients. Now, some life coaches, I'm
- 1:02:14sure are doing that, but I know that many are not, and that
- 1:02:20they are dipping into clinical work, sometimes fully into clinical work, just full
- 1:02:24on discussing ADHD and medication and depression and trauma. There's many accounts of that,
- 1:02:32And so the profession, so to speak, of life coaching is a
- 1:02:37problem in general, and if the public knew better, you know, if
- 1:02:42the public, I mean, the problem is is that even if we did
- 1:02:45tell everybody in the public by the way, life coaches have no credentials,
- 1:02:50no training, and here are things that you go to a life coach for,
- 1:02:53whereas therapists do have training, and here's all the things that you can
- 1:02:57go to a therapist for. Even if you told the public that and they
- 1:03:00fully comprehended it and understood it, they still wouldn't necessarily know why they as
- 1:03:06an individual want therapy. So many people will come to therapy with a complaint.
- 1:03:13They'll verbalize a complaint, but then later therapists such as myself, will
- 1:03:17determine that the real problem was something else. Now, I wouldn't just arbitrarily
- 1:03:23come up with that. It's a collaboration. And so even if we did
- 1:03:27educate the public about this line between therapy and maybe it's even diagram of therapy
- 1:03:34and coaching, there'd be a lot of people that would end up in coaches
- 1:03:37offices, but they don't know that they absolutely should be in a therapy office,
- 1:03:43and unless that coach is highly ethical, because the problem is is that
- 1:03:49the coach would have to give up money by referring the client to a clinician.
- 1:03:54Right the coach would have to say, oh, this client that is
- 1:04:00paying me a lot of money. I actually am detecting the possibility of a
- 1:04:03problem that I cannot treat, both because I'm not competent and I have no
- 1:04:09education, but two because it's unethical and harmful to clain. So I need
- 1:04:14to refer this person to another profession, and I'm going to lose this person
- 1:04:18as a client. Not always so, of course, you can have coaching
- 1:04:20in therapy, but you know a lot of times you would just lose that
- 1:04:24client, and thus you would lose that income. And it's not just that
- 1:04:27one session, right, you could be losing years of an income stream.
- 1:04:30So coaches have an incentive to either sweep their concern for the public under the
- 1:04:38rug or go into denial of it. Because when you have monetary or beneficial
- 1:04:44benefits, beneficial benefits to taking an action, your brain can play tricks on
- 1:04:51itself, right, you could. You could just end up tricking yourself into
- 1:04:54believing this This isn't a clinical issue. You know, there's no even though
- 1:04:58if you really sat down at the about it, you would know that it
- 1:05:00is a clinical issue. Anyway. Now, another thing I just want to
- 1:05:03point out is that in my experience, many of the therapists who also become
- 1:05:10coaches are not just problematic in their coaching practice, but they're problematic in a
- 1:05:16variety of ways. Again, I want to emphasize there are many therapists that
- 1:05:20are also coaches that are completely above board and are doing a wonderful dual service
- 1:05:27to society. Having said that, in my experience, like if I heard
- 1:05:31of a therapist who was also a coach, it's a red flag for me.
- 1:05:34It doesn't It doesn't necessarily mean there's something nefarious or problematic or an ethical
- 1:05:40going on. Absolutely I would have no idea. But like if I had
- 1:05:45a friend that came to me and said, oh, I found three therapists
- 1:05:48online and I don't know which one to go to, and I heard and
- 1:05:54the only thing that I had to go off of, and the only thing
- 1:05:58that my friend had to go off of, was that two of the therapists
- 1:06:01were just therapists and the third therapist was also a coach, and I don't
- 1:06:05have any other information and there's no way to get any other information, then
- 1:06:09I would say, you know, you're better off not taking that risk of
- 1:06:14the therapist slash coach and just stick to the therapists who are just therapists.
- 1:06:18I know that some of you out there are probably therapists and coaches and that
- 1:06:23is a dick move. But I'm just telling you what I would tell a
- 1:06:26friend, because I've seen so many therapists slash coaches that are problematic in a
- 1:06:31variety of ways. Among the therapists that I know who became coaches, they
- 1:06:36almost always had a number of other ethical issues, like they're just in it
- 1:06:41for the money instead of trying to make a world a better place. They
- 1:06:45have terrible record keeping. Obviously, in their coaching practice, they don't need
- 1:06:50to have record keeping because there's no regulation around that, so they might not
- 1:06:54have any record keeping, but even in their therapy practice, they also have
- 1:06:58terrible record keeping because that's that's one of the reasons why they wanted to become
- 1:07:01an also coach, is because they hate having to follow rules and they hate
- 1:07:06having to follow regulations and be ethical. So there's that also. Anecdotally,
- 1:07:15I would find that therapist slash coaches often had a fairly chaotic personal life that
- 1:07:18affected their practice, like showing up late to their sessions or not even showing
- 1:07:23up to their sessions, you know, particularly early career therapists. It's a
- 1:07:28good idea that when you have a client that is a little confounding, that
- 1:07:31you do a little homework, you know, you read up on things,
- 1:07:33or you consult. And I would find that these therapists coaches would not do
- 1:07:39that. They would just figure they've learned all there is to learn. Now
- 1:07:45again, are all therapists coaches like this. Absolutely not. I have colleagues
- 1:07:49and friends that are doing great work. But it's just a sign of a
- 1:07:55problem. Now. Does that condemn therapist slazed coaches? No, absolutely not.
- 1:08:00But I think that we just I don't know. I'm trying to figure
- 1:08:02out what the solution is really because it's an unregulated profession. Again, it
- 1:08:08will be regulated at some point in the future. I would predict within twenty
- 1:08:12years it'll become maybe even fewer, maybe like within ten years it'll become,
- 1:08:15at least in some states, a regulated profession. And maybe even by the
- 1:08:19time you're listening to this, you know, maybe it's a rerun in the
- 1:08:23future or something that already is. I don't know, But I don't know
- 1:08:26if that necessarily solves the problem, because you know, you will have people
- 1:08:31that will be minimally trained, right, because the idea would be is that
- 1:08:35there would be like a training regimen that you would need to demonstrate to the
- 1:08:42state to be licensed. But obviously that training would be less far less than
- 1:08:46being an actual clinician because you're just a coach. You don't need ninety nine
- 1:08:53percent of the training that a therapist does. You don't need any training on
- 1:08:56diagnosis. Maybe a little bit just to detect if there is an issue to
- 1:09:00for them out. I don't know, but it would be pretty minimal,
- 1:09:02you know. Plus like the types of topics that coaches are typically to be
- 1:09:09seeing, it's not super complicated at least for the minimal requires. Anyway,
- 1:09:15I'm just trying to figure out the solution, and I guess if I had
- 1:09:19it my way, a lot of things would be different. There would be
- 1:09:24no stigma about going to therapy at the very least that if your license in
- 1:09:27one state, your licensed in all states. I would change it so that
- 1:09:31early career therapists have cheap access to mentorship. I wrote in my Supervision book
- 1:09:40that a big part of my own trajectory and a lot of the people that
- 1:09:45I've worked with in terms of professional satisfaction and competence and success in one's career,
- 1:09:51has to do with competent mentoring. And I'm not talking about just like
- 1:09:57someone you talk to once every six months, you know, I'm talking about
- 1:10:00like, you know, really highly attentive mentors. In my life, I
- 1:10:05had those sorts of people, Paul David being one of them for me,
- 1:10:10the main one for me in my early career. But also I mentored many
- 1:10:15many therapists along those lines where I would you know, I wasn't just there
- 1:10:19to talk about their cases. I was there to talk about everything, including
- 1:10:24their personal life, you know, and as it pertained to the being a
- 1:10:28therapist, and as it pertained to their career. You know, I'd spend
- 1:10:30a lot of time looking at their marketing. I would learn from other superviss,
- 1:10:35you know. I'd look at those superviss that were very successful, and
- 1:10:39I would take note of how they marketed their practice, and I would teach
- 1:10:43it to my other mentees. And I would find that some supervises, even
- 1:10:49though I taught them how to market, they still wouldn't do it for some
- 1:10:51reason. And I would work on the barriers, you know, like what's
- 1:10:56the barrier that's preventing you from actually doing what I'm telling you to do,
- 1:11:00and of course you don't have to because it's marketing. It's just you know,
- 1:11:03but what's what's getting in the way, and is there a resistance?
- 1:11:06Is there some kind of trauma or schema or you know, some people that
- 1:11:12I worked with grew up in poverty and just felt like they were completely out
- 1:11:15of their depth when it came to anything business or money related. They felt
- 1:11:19like they didn't deserve it, or it had a really bad feeling to them.
- 1:11:25You know, that's just one example. But as a mentor and a
- 1:11:29supervisor, I didn't just say, well, you know, figure it out
- 1:11:31with yourself or go to therapy. And you know, I would say,
- 1:11:34you know, talk with your therapists. But I would also get you know,
- 1:11:36really close with these folks and get my hands dirty, so to speak,
- 1:11:40and really try and put myself into it. You know, I would
- 1:11:45think about the supervisor later. So I think that that's a big I would
- 1:11:49really solve a lot of problems. It would solve the problem of these early
- 1:11:55career therapists not being very successful and not knowing where to turn. Because the
- 1:12:00other thing is that a lot of early career therapists will believe that they should
- 1:12:03be earning two hundred thousand dollars a year right after graduation. So they've been
- 1:12:09misled. In fact, Paul David, my mentor, he at interviewing me
- 1:12:15to get into the program. I wasn't even in school yet. I was
- 1:12:19just interviewing to get in and half the time because I was coming from business
- 1:12:26and he and he knew. I told him that I was, you know,
- 1:12:29in market research and at an office. I wasn't earning that much money,
- 1:12:32but I in all likelihood, if I kept to that career, I
- 1:12:38would make a lot more money, you know, not like a lot,
- 1:12:41a lot, but you know tech world because the market research it was in
- 1:12:45Bellevue, which is near Redmond and Kirkland, where you know Microsoft, and
- 1:12:49it was in the nineties, so it was when all those companies were exploding
- 1:12:55and there's a lot of money in activity, and I was. I worked
- 1:12:58for a market research firm and it was and it was sort of my beat,
- 1:13:01the tech side of the contracts, and so I worked with Microsoft a
- 1:13:06lot. I've talked about this before, but I was heavily involved in the
- 1:13:11marketing for Windows ninety five. If you remember, this is the version of
- 1:13:16Windows in which was made famous by these events, these live events that Bill
- 1:13:24Gates and I can't remember his name, the CEO of Microsoft at the time,
- 1:13:27and they would do these live events and there'd be you know, loud
- 1:13:30music and lasers and smoke machines, and they were really trying to hype up
- 1:13:35Windows ninety five. And it's kind of a weird thing to think about that
- 1:13:40an operating system version would have like a tour, like a band would have
- 1:13:44a tour, like We're going to tour the unveiling of Windows ninety five.
- 1:13:47I mean, what the hell. But operating systems were a big deal back
- 1:13:53then. I remember that anyway. And they were doing this on stage and
- 1:13:58if you just google it, there's all these really good see these like and
- 1:14:00god bless them. You know, they're probably nice people, but you have
- 1:14:02these seven pasty white, you know, frumpy looking nerds dad types that are
- 1:14:10trying to dance to this music and trying to hype the room for Widness ninety
- 1:14:14five. And I think it's the CEO. He's like spinning his arms.
- 1:14:18Anyway, I was heavily involved in that. One of the tasks that I
- 1:14:21was involved with was I was surveying all the participants about their experience and if
- 1:14:27it increased their likelihood of buying windows twenty five or blah blah blah. And
- 1:14:32anyway, So I'm being interviewed at Antioch by Paul David's first time or second
- 1:14:39time i'd met him, because the first time I met him was at a
- 1:14:41open house and he gave a speech that convinced me to become mayors of Family
- 1:14:45Therapist. I didn't even know about the profession. The second time I met
- 1:14:47him was this interview, and half the time he's just telling me like,
- 1:14:51look, you're not going to make very much money when you got out of
- 1:14:54graduate school. You might actually never make as much money in this profess as
- 1:15:00you have, you know, as you likely would have made in the business
- 1:15:03and the trajectory you were on. And he didn't just stop there. He
- 1:15:06kept doubling down. He just kept telling me over and over again so that
- 1:15:12I made a firm choice. So, you know, that's what mentorship can
- 1:15:15do. It can put into perspective these folks, these early career therapists that
- 1:15:20are just like I'm not making enough money. I'd say like, well,
- 1:15:25who the hell is mentoring you? Who the hell is uh working with you?
- 1:15:29And why did they not tell you that. I think there also should
- 1:15:32be some case law, and I think it's increasing regarding just life coaching in
- 1:15:39general, because I think that there's a lot of harm happening and just because
- 1:15:43it's unregulated doesn't mean that there isn't a problem occurring, you know. Like
- 1:15:45and I know I'm not an expert in this area, but I know this
- 1:15:49is already established, but I feel like it needs to be bore established and
- 1:15:51I feel it needs to be moore advertised to clients and to therapists and coaches
- 1:15:59that if a coach or to cross a line with a client and dip into
- 1:16:02clinical material that could be demonstrated as clinical material, then you're liable even though
- 1:16:09you're as a life coach. You know, say you have a life coach
- 1:16:11that isn't even a therapist or just a life coach, that there would be
- 1:16:15a precedent and that there it would be well known not only to the consumer
- 1:16:19but to the life coach that you know, if you cross that line,
- 1:16:23there could be major consequences. And I feel like that because it's kind of
- 1:16:26the wild West that hasn't really been established yet, because there hasn't been enough
- 1:16:29case law, enough people suing people. And also I don't think clients are
- 1:16:34being informed because of course there's no obligation from the life coach to inform the
- 1:16:40consumer about their rights. For us as therapists, it is somewhat illegal,
- 1:16:45but more of an ethical responsibility that we actually inform our clients about their rights
- 1:16:49about what to expect. We can't advertise, we can't false advertise, we
- 1:16:55can't make false claims without incurring consequences. And we also have to tell the
- 1:17:00client who they can complain to. We have to give them the address and
- 1:17:05email address or contact information of our state licensing board. Say, if you
- 1:17:10have a complaint, here is who you talk to. I mean, there's
- 1:17:14not a lot of businesses that in the very beginning of providing a service tell
- 1:17:17you who to complain to, right whereas a life coach, you know there's
- 1:17:21who they're going to call. There's nobody. And also a lot of life
- 1:17:26coaches, anecdotally a percentage anyway, claim some bullshit about how perfect their help
- 1:17:31is and the sort of things that they can do to help people, and
- 1:17:35they can also force people to or influence people to write positive reviews about them.
- 1:17:41Therapists are not supposed to do that. We've been trained not to.
- 1:17:45You can complain to the licensing board if you ever do have a therapist that
- 1:17:47does this, and that therapist should be reprimanded and sanctioned in some way.
- 1:17:51And so I guess that would be another thing, other solution to this.
- 1:17:56It's just making into law or case law a very clear line between coaching and
- 1:18:03therapy that I just do not think exists today. Now some of you might
- 1:18:09be thinking, well, Kirk, why do you even care about this?
- 1:18:12Like what's the problem here? And you know, is it really all that
- 1:18:18bad? I mean, who really cares? Well? I worry about clients
- 1:18:23being harmed, and it's happening. It's happening in this case that I'm about
- 1:18:27to elucidate it. It happens. It's happening all the time. Now.
- 1:18:31Therapists can harm their clients too, even though therapists have been trained and they've
- 1:18:35been regulated, and they are regulated. So it's not like therapists can't harm
- 1:18:40people. But when you have an unregulated and does some extent, unmonitored,
- 1:18:44unresearched profession like coaching, then it's hard to know how much harm is happening.
- 1:18:49But of course we have to imagine that, you know, there's a
- 1:18:53lot of people being harmed. I'll give the caveat there's plenty of coaches that
- 1:18:59are absolutely not harming their clients. But you know, it's not hard to
- 1:19:03imagine that there's a lot of clients of coaches that are being harmed because you
- 1:19:08can literally be anything, and just you could be an eighteen year old high
- 1:19:14school dropout that says you're a life coach and if you market yourself well enough,
- 1:19:17you're going to get clients. Or you could be someone who is involved
- 1:19:23in a lot of crime. I don't know, I'm just trying to think
- 1:19:26of others, and that's not typical to the situation. But you know,
- 1:19:29all right, so I worry about clients being harmed. Let's talk about that
- 1:19:33for a bit, so non therapist life coaches, So just you know,
- 1:19:36just regular coaches can harm clients because they might may or may not have any
- 1:19:42training. The training that they got might not be sufficient. There's no oversight
- 1:19:46necessarily, right. In fact, I would take a guess and say that
- 1:19:50the vast, vast majority of life coaches have no supervision and no oversight.
- 1:19:55And I'm here to tell you that therapists helpers in this arena if we call
- 1:20:00life coaches kind of in this arena early career. For the first number of
- 1:20:02years, they need a lot of oversight. In fact, you know,
- 1:20:05clinicians know this. But if you if you don't know this, let me
- 1:20:10tell you that for most of the professions your early career, by law,
- 1:20:15you have to be supervised greatly. You know, like in my profession,
- 1:20:19marriage of family therapy. You for the first two years at least you have
- 1:20:26to have weekly supervision. Actually I think it's twice a week, right,
- 1:20:30so, or no, I think it's weekly. Yeah, weekly. Anyway,
- 1:20:32point is is that you need a lot of supervision. And this is
- 1:20:35you know, supervision is intense. When I have a supervisor, I meet
- 1:20:40with them once a week for an hour. You you get to know each
- 1:20:45other pretty well and you talk about a lot of things. There's you know,
- 1:20:46it's an hour a week. It's a lot you can get into.
- 1:20:50So you have these life coaches that have have zero training and zero oversight,
- 1:20:57zero supervision. No one is take a look at their competence, their practice,
- 1:21:04what they're doing, the assumptions they're operating from. They're just you know,
- 1:21:08these life coaches can be completely just on their own. They just woke
- 1:21:14up one day and said they were a life coach, So to expect that
- 1:21:18these individuals would have any sort of Again, if we educated the public sufficiently,
- 1:21:25then that's not a problem. I'm not saying that you can't be a
- 1:21:28life coach, but I don't think that the public is educated properly. And
- 1:21:31like I said earlier, even if they were educated properly, you know,
- 1:21:34people still don't necessarily know what they don't know. Also, disclosures. US
- 1:21:40therapists have to disclose a number of things to our clients up front that life
- 1:21:45coaches have. They have no responsibility for that. Also advertising, I've been
- 1:21:53over that. You know that we have ethical codes about like you're It's not
- 1:21:56common that you would find a therapist that would make a ridiculous claim online about
- 1:22:00their abilities and what they can do. There are some, but it's not
- 1:22:03very frequent, Whereas when I look at life coaches in general, they're advertising
- 1:22:09materials. It's ridiculous the kind of I mean, it's stuff like people.
- 1:22:14You know, if you've been watching the Twin Flames documentary with me on YouTube,
- 1:22:19you know that any charismatic person who has some sort of narcissistic problem or
- 1:22:28psychopathic problem can claim to be a life coach and convince people of their magical
- 1:22:34powers to cure anything, you know what I mean. So there's a greater
- 1:22:40likelihood of a life coach having that problem, and that's not I mean.
- 1:22:45Well anyway, Okay, So just to kind of provide one more point here
- 1:22:48and then I'll get back to the case, is that I from the beginning
- 1:22:53I've been I haven't really really been able to put into the words until I
- 1:22:57was prepping for this episode that I worry about our profession becoming deluded. And
- 1:23:01let me explain that when we have this blurring of lines between therapy and coaching,
- 1:23:08which isn't on paper supposed to be happening, but absolutely is happening,
- 1:23:12particularly when you have therapists that are also coaches, legitimizing the coaching profession.
- 1:23:18And again, coaching is a legitimate profession if it's kept within a certain boundary.
- 1:23:23But I can you know, I cannot say that coaching is a legitimate
- 1:23:27safe product. You know, if someone came to me and said I'm gonna
- 1:23:30I have a problem, I'm going to seek a coach, do you think
- 1:23:32that's a good idea, I would say, whoa like you, You would
- 1:23:35have to do so much homework to figure out if you if it's right for
- 1:23:43you, and if this professional is not likely to harm you, like There's
- 1:23:47a lot that has to go into that. So in that way, I
- 1:23:51would not call life coaching as you know, the people that adhere to that
- 1:23:56label, because we include everyone, not just the legitimate people, but we
- 1:24:00everyone that has that label. I would not say that it's a legitimate profession.
- 1:24:03And so when we as therapists who are a legitimate profession and have worked
- 1:24:10very hard, you know, talk therapists in general, psychotherapists in general,
- 1:24:15psychology professionals, ben health professionals in general. We've been I mean since Freud.
- 1:24:19Freud spent most of his career trying to legitimize basically what we all do,
- 1:24:26and he succeeded, and then subsequently all sorts of people, including us
- 1:24:30today and me included, have been trying to spread the word about the legitimacy
- 1:24:35of our profession and how we can help people. And we've worked really hard
- 1:24:41for that. And so for us to just associate ourselves to some extent with
- 1:24:46life coaches and allow that association to happen willy nilly, then I think it
- 1:24:51invites this association that I don't think is good for our field. Like I
- 1:24:58said, I in the future, I'm pretty sure life coaches will become a
- 1:25:02legitimate profession in my eyes, and that they will become regulated and formalized regarding
- 1:25:08training and boundaries. But as of today that is just not the case.
- 1:25:13That worries me that there are people on TikTok that are following coaches and early
- 1:25:18career therapists that don't know what they're talking about yet, but are more interested
- 1:25:23in being an influencer than they are and helping people. You know, there's
- 1:25:26being inundated to all this information, and there's a lot of people out there
- 1:25:30that are just like, well, you know, life coaches, therapy,
- 1:25:32what's the difference. In fact, there's a lot of people that will say,
- 1:25:36I'll hear this that coaches are better than therapists regarding clinical matters. You
- 1:25:42know, there'll be people that will say, oh, I was going through
- 1:25:44a really rough time and my mom died and I lost my job, and
- 1:25:46I found this coach and you know, they completely turn my life around.
- 1:25:51Whereas I'd been to a therapist before and that therapist was worthless. Now that
- 1:25:56individual, I don't doubt their story and there's nothing wrong with that. There
- 1:26:00could be something wrong if we looked into the life coaching scope, you know
- 1:26:03what the life coaching was getting into. But in terms of that consumer,
- 1:26:08I don't fault them at all for that. When someone says they had a
- 1:26:11bad experience in therapy, then I tend to agree that because it does happen.
- 1:26:14And when someone says they had a great experience, a life changing experience
- 1:26:17in coaching, I tend to believe that too. That does happen. And
- 1:26:23those are cases that are good, and I'm happy that happens. But there
- 1:26:27are so many other situations where it's not that way, and for us to
- 1:26:33be associated with that, I just think it's a problem. And so I
- 1:26:38think for us as mental health clinicians, we should be educated on how to
- 1:26:45talk about this problem because you know, one of the things that I see
- 1:26:47a lot of clinicians doing when because there are a lot of people that think
- 1:26:50like me. If you're a clinician listening, there's a good likelihood you already
- 1:26:55thought like the way I do, and either you've had a fair amount of
- 1:27:00education or discussions around this, but in all likelihood, you probably haven't,
- 1:27:03and so you probably just have a general discomfort with life coaching, but you
- 1:27:11don't really know how to articulate why you feel uncomfortable. And so I think
- 1:27:15we have to be better about that and be very clear to people and effective
- 1:27:23at communicating to people online in person, to our students and supervisors. You
- 1:27:30know, there's a lot of novice therapists that are listening to us, and
- 1:27:34we influence them, and so I think we have to have an ability to
- 1:27:38articulate to them what's going on. And so I think that I worry because
- 1:27:45the other the other thing is that I'm old enough to remember when my profession
- 1:27:50and other professions and mental health we're not really legitimate professions in fact, for
- 1:27:58a long time. And I don't know the exact history on this, so
- 1:28:01take what I'm saying with a grain of salt. But when I started as
- 1:28:05a therapist, they only had this thing called registered counselors. And where do
- 1:28:12I begin with this? Okay, So this is a very brief discussion of
- 1:28:17the history of mental health in my field. You had psychiatry, you had
- 1:28:20medical doctors like Freud and others. Who also provided mental health services or solely
- 1:28:27provided mental services, but they were medical, medically trained like any other doctor,
- 1:28:32any other physician. Then you had this other group of people that emerged
- 1:28:38called psychologists, and these were doctoral level individuals who also provided mental health services.
- 1:28:44At some point there was this movement to increase the number of mental health
- 1:28:49in people and also make the career a little bit more accessible by not requiring
- 1:28:55a doctorate, by saying, well, we can teach you enough things in
- 1:28:59a master's degree. I'm only ninety five percent sure that this is all accurate
- 1:29:02in general, So to take away saying with the green of salt, and
- 1:29:06so for a good amount of time you had this unregulated bunch of so called
- 1:29:13clinicians who were master's level educated, and they called themselves counselors or therapists.
- 1:29:18I think marriage of family therapy was this way as well, but there was
- 1:29:24no education requirement. It was the same as coaching. Anyone could call themselves
- 1:29:29a therapist. They could have no education, or they could have a lot
- 1:29:32of education. So you had people providing therapy or counseling and hanging a shingle
- 1:29:39and charging money who had zero education and training and oversight and you had others
- 1:29:44that had a lot they had a master's degree and all the things. Then
- 1:29:49us master's level people, because I was a master's level person before I got
- 1:29:53my doctorate, but before I got my master's there was a lot of advocacy
- 1:29:57to actually professionalize our fiel and to tell the government, hey, we need
- 1:30:01you to start regulating us, and as a collaborative effort to create the profession
- 1:30:06and the licensure and the requirements and blah blah blah accreditation. So I remember
- 1:30:12a time when we were like coaches, and we were legitimately attacked by psychiatry
- 1:30:19and psychology as being a bunk field, as being a bunch of idiots that
- 1:30:26don't necessarily know what they're doing. Or at least there's a percentage of these
- 1:30:30registered counselors, because that was the designation, was that you just had to
- 1:30:34register as a counselor. So eventually the state of Washington anyway added this registered
- 1:30:42counseling designation for master's level people. And all you had to do was take
- 1:30:47I think you had to watch like an hour video about HIV and AIDS and
- 1:30:53then you and you paid forty dollars. I did this actually when I was
- 1:30:58first entering the field, and then you're a registered counselor. That was it.
- 1:31:02And the reason why they had that was because then there could be a
- 1:31:05recourse by the public to take away your registration so that you could no longer
- 1:31:09be a counselor. But it was, you know, you didn't have to
- 1:31:12have any education or anything. I mean, so I remember a time when
- 1:31:15we were basically an illegitimate field, illegitimate profession, and I worry that we
- 1:31:24could return, at least partially back. You know, there's a lot of
- 1:31:27benefits when we and the public are very in the public knows that we're very
- 1:31:33firm about our boundaries, and we're very professional, and we're very buttoned up,
- 1:31:39and we have a lot of self policing and a lot of self policing
- 1:31:44regarding ethical codes and training and care. You know, like when I was
- 1:31:48providing mentorship and spending a lot of my blood, sweat and tears to help
- 1:31:54my mentees, I wasn't being paid for that extra work. I did it
- 1:31:58because I wanted to, because because it meant something to me. And that's
- 1:32:03a special thing. You know. We're not in it just for the money.
- 1:32:05I mean, it is a career. We do get into it because
- 1:32:09we want to pay our bills, but we're in it because we want to
- 1:32:13make the world a better place. And we benefit by being that way and
- 1:32:17by attracting people along those lines, and by advertising ourselves as such, and
- 1:32:21for the public to see us this way and for us to actually back up
- 1:32:27what we're saying, whereas I'm telling you, in the past, that's not
- 1:32:31how the public necessarily saw us. They would talk to a psychiatrist about going
- 1:32:36to see a master's level clinician, and that psychiatrists would say all the same
- 1:32:42things that I'm telling you about the coaching field, and they would be right
- 1:32:45to say so. So it's important that we hold the line. It doesn't
- 1:32:51mean that we just completely reject coaching, but we have to be very fucking
- 1:32:57careful when we just start flirting with that line and we start flirting with this
- 1:33:01other profession, because they could bring us down. We could retain licensure and
- 1:33:06all that other stuff, but we could, to the public's eyes, we
- 1:33:11could become associated with that and considered that. And there's enough people that already
- 1:33:15think that we're a bunch of idiots or were a scam or something and it's
- 1:33:20not it wouldn't be good. I just don't I worry about that. Okay,
- 1:33:28So this is turning out to be one of the longest episodes I've ever
- 1:33:30recorded or in a while anyway. Okay, so let's get back to the
- 1:33:36case the client. So I'll just probably forgot everything. So you have this
- 1:33:44licensed professional counselor private practice. He starts treating a mail in his mid twenties,
- 1:33:50homeless, unemployed, criminal history, history of substituses, court ordered,
- 1:33:55and the therapy. The counselor says, Okay, I'm gonna do counseling,
- 1:33:59I'm gonna do life coaching. So he's one of those people that does this,
- 1:34:02not that that's necessarily a bad thing, but let's continue reading. So
- 1:34:06the client apparently relied on his parents financially because he didn't have a job,
- 1:34:14and so the parents were paying for the therapy and the life coaching and for
- 1:34:20the client's rents and everything like that. And so when the counselor figured that
- 1:34:26out, the councilor recommended that the counselor would control all of the client's money,
- 1:34:31including all the money that the parents were giving to their kid, their
- 1:34:36adult child. So all the money for rents and food and car payment or
- 1:34:42whatever. The counselor says, I want you parents to give me all that
- 1:34:46money, and then I will pay my client's bills. And this was all
- 1:34:53presumably under underneath his life coaching umbrella. So again the counselor is saying,
- 1:35:00I'm providing therapy to this client and life coaching, and so when he says
- 1:35:03life coaching, he's like, well, then all bets are off. I
- 1:35:06can do anything. I can even take over the finances of this person.
- 1:35:11Now it's possible that the counselor was not trying to commit fraud and that the
- 1:35:16counselor there was no evidence of that. I'll just you know, spoiler alertn
- 1:35:19that. But that doesn't matter because if you're providing therapy to somebody and you're
- 1:35:27also let me go out this all right, So the counselor says, you
- 1:35:30know, I want to control all the clients' money, and also there will
- 1:35:35be no contact between the client and the parents. I don't know why the
- 1:35:41counselor was doing this, but that's what the counselor decided. And the counselor
- 1:35:45had the parents sign a contract stating that the counselor would be paid upfront for
- 1:35:51counseling services and life coaching services, so it'd be like this lump sum upfront,
- 1:35:57and the counselor would be reimbursed for the aliens living expenses including food,
- 1:36:00clothing, cell phone bill, and rent. And so the counselor would be
- 1:36:04paying all those bills and then reimbursed And the parents did sign that contract.
- 1:36:10So this gets back to what I was talking about earlier in terms of it's
- 1:36:14often the tip of the iceberg when I hear about a therapist slash counselor.
- 1:36:17It often will be found not all the time, of course, but at
- 1:36:21least anecdotally will be found by me that there's a lot of bullshittery that's occurring
- 1:36:29that you wouldn't know about because you weren't close enough to the situation. So
- 1:36:33this is a shit ton of bullshittery that's happening. Sometimes I say a sentence
- 1:36:40that I'm like, I wonder if that's the very first time that sentence has
- 1:36:42ever been said. You know, there's a shit ton of bullshittery happening.
- 1:36:46So therapy and coaching began. The parents, of course, gave a shit
- 1:36:54ton of money to the counselor because it was upfront, right, The counselor
- 1:36:59paid the bill and treatment continued for months. I don't know how treatment went,
- 1:37:02but they didn't go into that. The counselor hired the okay, so
- 1:37:09here's another here's another detail. The counselor hired the client to perform landscaping work
- 1:37:15at the councilor's home. So remember the tip of the iceberg thing. Now,
- 1:37:21Eventually, the client's parole officer, because remember court ordered the client.
- 1:37:28His parole officer eventually became aware after months of what was going on between this
- 1:37:34therapist and client, and the officer knew enough to say, there's something wrong
- 1:37:40there, and so the parole officer filed a complaint against the councilor with the
- 1:37:44Department of Licensing, and the Licensing Board opened in an investigation. The board
- 1:37:51hired an expert to look into the situation, and the expert looked into the
- 1:37:57situation and concluded that the counselor was negligent in treating this client. That's a
- 1:38:03legal or a licensing term, negligent in that at least I believe what this
- 1:38:11means is that the counselor didn't necessarily harm the client, but the counselor risked
- 1:38:17great harm by neglecting ethical standards. So the expert pointed out that contrary to
- 1:38:25what this counselor did, that life coaching should only be used with clients who
- 1:38:30are free from acute psychological distress. And apparently that was not done, meaning
- 1:38:35that regardless of whether or not the life coach is a therapist or not,
- 1:38:40a client who was going through significant psychological distress should not be just in coaching
- 1:38:46or coaching at all. And the psychological distress that this client was under was
- 1:38:51you know, depression, sounds like substance use, antisocial person and ice order.
- 1:38:57I mean, I wonder how that played a role. Another thing that
- 1:39:00the expert said was the counselor failed to demonstrate an understanding of the difference between
- 1:39:04counseling and life coaching, which is clear. Also, the counselor violated ethical
- 1:39:09codes by bartering services with the client. Now, the counselor tried to explain
- 1:39:16and said, hey, look, when I was engaging in the bartering agreements
- 1:39:21with this client and other clients that this counselor was doing it with, he
- 1:39:28did so with the client's best interests in mind, you know, like I'm
- 1:39:31guessing what the counselor said was. Look, I could have hired anyone to
- 1:39:35do my landscaping. I didn't need my client to do it, you know,
- 1:39:39I could have hired someone else. But my client really really needed a
- 1:39:44job and was struggling with finding one, and because of his criminal record,
- 1:39:48was having a hard time qualifying for one. And also he was kind of
- 1:39:53scared of working at other jobs because he was in early sobriety and there's you
- 1:39:59know, there's a lot of drugs in the world and a lot of people
- 1:40:00using various substances, and he worried that if you just got a random job
- 1:40:03that he might run into other people using and you know, that's a huge
- 1:40:08risk. And so it was a win win for him to be not a
- 1:40:12win win. It was a win for the client and not for me.
- 1:40:15For me to hire my client as a landscaper, because he wouldn't have any
- 1:40:20employees that would tempt him. I could help him. I could reassure him
- 1:40:25that he's doing a good job, you know, so we could talk about
- 1:40:30how it was when he was working in session. You know, there's a
- 1:40:31lot of benefits. I'm guessing that's what the councilor said. And okay,
- 1:40:35yeah, I understand the justification, but to hire your client as your landscaper,
- 1:40:45and I won't say that can never be done. Maybe there are situations
- 1:40:48where that can be done as a therapist for the client's benefit. But the
- 1:40:54proof that you did what you needed to do in terms of assuring that the
- 1:40:59client wouldn't be harm would be enormous. So you'd have to consult, you'd
- 1:41:02have to document, there would be all sorts of informed consent forms and discussions
- 1:41:08with the client regarding their rights. And but it'd be hard to imagine.
- 1:41:13Honestly, as I say it out loud, it'd be hard to imagine any
- 1:41:16situation that would convince me that it was worth the risk to hire a client
- 1:41:23to be your landscaper. I mean, maybe if a client just had years
- 1:41:28of a track record of being unable to secure employment and being unable to work
- 1:41:34with other people, and they just needed one experience, one controlled experience.
- 1:41:40But you know, you wouldn't have to hire the client to be a landscaper.
- 1:41:43You could just do like a mock work, you know, where everyone
- 1:41:45knows that it's fake. But there was none of that right. It was
- 1:41:49even though the counselor is saying, look, I was doing this for the
- 1:41:53client's benefit, okay, but you were also paying all of his bills and
- 1:42:00I didn't include this. But he's also driving him around in places. You
- 1:42:03know, he's basically like his big brother or something. I don't know.
- 1:42:10So, yeah, it's kind of ridiculous. So, as always with these
- 1:42:14ethical cases, or at least most of the time, the issue at hand,
- 1:42:19like how someone a counselor didn't know the difference between life coaching and therapy.
- 1:42:27That's just a tip of the iceberg. You got the bartering thing,
- 1:42:30you got the money thing, you have the driving the client around thing.
- 1:42:33You have the counselor believing. Because the counselor is doing this in the open,
- 1:42:40there's no attempt to hide what's happening. The counselor is is not secretly
- 1:42:45doing this. The counselor thinks this is okay, And that is just astounding.
- 1:42:51If you're a if you're a therapist or a student that's going to be
- 1:42:56a therapist, you totally understand that anything even close to this realm of behavior,
- 1:43:02your alarm bells would be going off. So loud. I mean,
- 1:43:05yeah, I always use this example, but I always have students or early
- 1:43:11career therapists that will say like, oh my god, I had a client
- 1:43:15that offered me a gift and I didn't know what to do, so I
- 1:43:18felt bad, so I accepted the gift. Am I going to go to
- 1:43:20therapy jail? And I'll say like, no, you know, let's look
- 1:43:26at it, let's talk about it. You know, there are considerations,
- 1:43:28and yes, you don't want to create a culture of expecting your clients to
- 1:43:32give you gifts or a culture that encourages clients to believe that you're supposed to
- 1:43:36get gifts as a therapist, especially expensive gifts. You know, there's there's
- 1:43:42ways around it, and sometimes in a pinch, you accept the gift and
- 1:43:45and you improvise and it's there's no, You're not going to go to therapy
- 1:43:49jail for that, And there's always sort of something you can do later,
- 1:43:53like next session. You could say, hey, you know, I talk
- 1:43:56with my supervisor and they said, I can't really accept this gift from you,
- 1:43:59but I just want to thank you so much for giving it to me.
- 1:44:00It's so thoughtful and I really appreciate that but according to the policy at
- 1:44:05this agency, I can't accept. You know, there's there's things you can
- 1:44:08do later on. It's not like doing it in the moment would be this
- 1:44:13huge problem. But anyway, that's just accepting gifts. You know. Farther
- 1:44:18way, farther down the road is having the client, having the parents sign
- 1:44:23a contract where they can't have contact with their twenty five year old son,
- 1:44:29and then telling the parents to give you all the money, and then you
- 1:44:32paying all the bills, and you providing life coaching, and you hiring that
- 1:44:40client as your landscaper. Like the typical therapist, in my view, draws
- 1:44:45they're too paranoid about ethics. The average therapist that I know anyway, they're
- 1:44:50way paranoid about even getting close to the threshold, and so they limit themselves.
- 1:44:56You know. Like another thing that I'll hear from people, not any
- 1:44:59of my students, because I abusum of this idea very quickly, is that
- 1:45:01self disclosure is unethical. I'll hear that sometimes, you know, even people
- 1:45:06in my university will come from other class and will be like, yeah,
- 1:45:10self disclosure is unethical. Be like what the fuck? Like that is not
- 1:45:13what the research says. It's not the consensus. There's literally there's it's It's
- 1:45:16not in a single ethics book or therapy book. I would challenge anyone to
- 1:45:21find any legitimate clinical book that would say self disclosure is unethical. It's just
- 1:45:26it's not even a debated topic in our field. And yet there's a lot
- 1:45:30of people that believe that, and so so typically novice therapists are too restrictive
- 1:45:38and too paranoid. Now, can self disclosure be unethical or be a problem,
- 1:45:42Yeah, but it's not inherently a problem, you know, in the
- 1:45:46same way that talking to your client could be a problem. Right, you
- 1:45:50might say stupid shit to your client, but the umbrella behavior of talking to
- 1:45:57your client is not a problem, you know what I'm saying. So for
- 1:46:00someone like this counselor to go so far, but it's like tip of the
- 1:46:06iceberg, and this is I see this a lot. I've and often I'm
- 1:46:12only seeing a little bit of the iceberg. You know. I'll see someone
- 1:46:15who's a therapist and a life coach and I'll only see like a little bit
- 1:46:19below the surface because I'm not an investigator and I'm not close enough the situation.
- 1:46:24I'm only like, oh God, I see that that's a red flag.
- 1:46:27I don't know if it's a problem. Then I learned a couple other
- 1:46:30things, or I hear a sort of way that they talk, and I'm
- 1:46:32like, oh, oh, that sounds like a bad thing. And I
- 1:46:38highly suspect that below the surface of the water there's all sorts of stuff just
- 1:46:42like what we're seeing here. All right, So what did the licensing board
- 1:46:46do? Because the expert found these things, and the counselor didn't have any
- 1:46:53sort of defense against it because it was all right there and factual evidence that
- 1:46:58that's what was happening. So what did the licensing board do? Many of
- 1:47:03you might figure that, oh, well, obviously they took the license away,
- 1:47:08right, or at the very least some pretty heavy sanctions. Well,
- 1:47:14deserving listeners, let me tell you the consequence that they bestowed. It is
- 1:47:19probation for ninety days and a five hundred dollars fine and eight hours of continuing
- 1:47:28education on ethics and professional boundaries. That's it. So probation for ninety days,
- 1:47:34which I believe just means that the counselors. If the counselor committed another
- 1:47:43violation within those ninety days, then the counselor would be in extra trouble or
- 1:47:46something, because probation doesn't mean you can't practice typically. I mean, maybe
- 1:47:51it did, but even if that were true, ninety days ninety days,
- 1:47:55that's it. But I'm ninety percent sure that probation for ninety days just mean
- 1:48:00that, you know, they're like, we're watching you for ninety days.
- 1:48:04And also a five hundred dollars fine he was probably charging. You know,
- 1:48:12God knows how much he was charging to this family because of how much time
- 1:48:15he was spending anyway, and then eight hours of continuing ahead on ethics eight
- 1:48:23hours, eight hours, that's nothing. It's probably a day, one day
- 1:48:30class, maybe a day and a half of an ethics class that's going to
- 1:48:34fix this problem, because this is not only you know, not only are
- 1:48:41we seeing below the water in terms of the iceberg, but God knows what
- 1:48:44he's doing with us other clients that was not investigated because that wasn't the scope
- 1:48:48of the investigation, right, They're not going to troll through his records and
- 1:48:51find other clients and ask them and current and past clients has he done anything
- 1:48:58like this before or what else has he done? What's the chance that this
- 1:49:00counselor all the entirety of his ethical violations occurred with one client. What is
- 1:49:08the chance of that, and yet eight hours of continuing it. It's so
- 1:49:13disappointing. This happens all the time. To me, I think people like
- 1:49:17this should have their license tripped away and never be able to practice. This
- 1:49:20happens in the medical field too. I don't know what it is about licensing
- 1:49:25boards and state governments that are so afraid to provide consequences, because to me,
- 1:49:31people like this are rare. They are exceedingly rare. We're talking,
- 1:49:36you know, the people that are capable of all of these violations. We're
- 1:49:41probably talking one or two percent of the professionals in our field that are committing
- 1:49:47half of the harm to the public, you know, as a whole.
- 1:49:51You know, if you think all the harm that our profession causes, this
- 1:49:55one or two percent is probably causing half or not more of the general harm.
- 1:50:00So we you know, what's the worry. I don't understand what is
- 1:50:05the licensing board worried about if because I'm sure they had this on the table,
- 1:50:11it's like, well, we could strip the license and never allow this
- 1:50:13person to pray. The other problem is is that because we have different licensing,
- 1:50:17different different licenses in different states, is that you can lose a license
- 1:50:21in one state and just get another license in another state. You know,
- 1:50:25this happened with that shrink next door guy. What was his name, Hirshcoff.
- 1:50:30I believe, doctor Hirshkoff. He was incredibly unethical with his client.
- 1:50:35You know, they made a TV show with Will Ferrell and Paul Rudd,
- 1:50:39great TV show series, Apple, I think, And this this therapist was
- 1:50:46basically like he basically moved, not basically he did. Long story short,
- 1:50:53if you don't know the case, this therapist found a client that had a
- 1:50:57lot of money and was socially insecure, and this therapist proceeded to essentially essentially
- 1:51:05take over all of his money and even his business. He wormed his way
- 1:51:12into his client's business and basically took that over too. He moved into this
- 1:51:18beautiful summer home of his clients and then made his client basically become his groundskeeper
- 1:51:26for him. And this went on for decades. This guy did lose his
- 1:51:30license in New York State, I believe, thank goodness, but he's just
- 1:51:34moved to another state and he's practicing there. Currently, so to put someone
- 1:51:40in prison for the rest of their life, that is a major alteration of
- 1:51:43freedom for an individual. To take away the ability for someone to practice medicine
- 1:51:47or psychotherapy in the United States anyway, it's not a huge deal. There
- 1:51:54are other professions. There are other jobs like coaching, for example. You
- 1:51:58know, there's a lot of their life isn't over, you know. But
- 1:52:01and the people that would qualify for what I would consider the threshold of taking
- 1:52:08away their license, they're pretty rare. It would be a and those individuals
- 1:52:14would have been given so many opportunities to do something different. I mean all
- 1:52:18the education and all the opportunities for consultation and supervision, I mean just googling
- 1:52:24it. Let's put it this way. I don't think I know a single
- 1:52:27therapist that has ever had anything close to this kind of relationship with one of
- 1:52:31their clients hiring them for anything like babysitting or landscaping or doing their taxes.
- 1:52:38I don't know a single person personally. I have only heard these stories through
- 1:52:44these ethical cases. So it's usually not necessary. There's usually another way,
- 1:52:48even if, like I was saying earlier, even if it is a social
- 1:52:53justice issue, like you can just not charge a client, right. The
- 1:52:56point is is, I just don't understand why licensee boards. You know,
- 1:53:00I don't know the full scope, of course, but I have heard so
- 1:53:04many accounts. There's so many, it's so weird. Okay, So plenty
- 1:53:10of legitimate complaints are submitted to the government in the United States, and only
- 1:53:15a percentage of them are even investigated. I hear a lot of people will
- 1:53:20make a complaint and nothing will happen, you know, including that hirstkof case,
- 1:53:25the streaking next door. There were several complaints over several years that were
- 1:53:29submitted to New York State and for several years I remember're talking like ten,
- 1:53:34fifteen, twenty years or something, the state did nothing. I mean,
- 1:53:40I think they investigated kind of, but it essentially did nothing. And it
- 1:53:45was so obvious that, I mean, he was living in his client's nice
- 1:53:50house. He and his client were the executors of a charity fund that was
- 1:54:01solely funded by the client, and you know, and the list just goes
- 1:54:04on and on again for decades. It was. It was extensive. So
- 1:54:08if ever there was a case that was worth investigating, it was out and
- 1:54:12yet it didn't. So that happens. So, but even of the ones
- 1:54:15that get investigated, many of these cases end up being dismissed that shouldn't be.
- 1:54:20And even among the ones that end up being found by the licensing board
- 1:54:27that the counselor has acted in an unethical or unstandard way, in a problematic
- 1:54:31way, the punishments are often far below the mark. I was a listener
- 1:54:40actually to this podcast years and years ago, contacted me and sent me a
- 1:54:46lot of emails and documentation and whatnot about a case that she was involved in
- 1:54:51which her therapist had committed an ethical violation, a series of them, and
- 1:54:57you can listen to those episodes. I think I call them like a rapist
- 1:55:00kisses his client or something. And he was increasing his physical and sensual touching
- 1:55:05of his client increasingly over a number of sessions, to the point where the
- 1:55:13entirety of the session he was he was laying down on the couch with her
- 1:55:17and caressing her in a sexual way and kissing her body and telling her how
- 1:55:24beautiful she is and saying how attracted. I mean, it doesn't get any
- 1:55:30worse than that. Right, He's laying on the couch in full double embrace,
- 1:55:39and you know, silently telling her how beautiful she is and how perfect
- 1:55:44she is, and how much he likes her, and you know, da
- 1:55:46da da da, And she would say that, you know, she was
- 1:55:51being indoctrinated. She actually enjoyed it, because you know, when you're getting
- 1:55:58that kind of attention, it feels good. But that's the thing about you
- 1:56:02know, it's similar to cult indoctrination. Cult members don't say to themselves that
- 1:56:09they're not enjoying being a cult, you know. They they they think they're
- 1:56:13at the promised Land because the manipulative leader is manipulating and making you feel like
- 1:56:19you're special and you're safe and this is good for you. Meanwhile, it's
- 1:56:24not right. The trauma starts to be felt later. And that's what happened
- 1:56:29to her anyway. So and there's all documented, and the therapist, the
- 1:56:35counselor did not refute any of the details that the client provided, or at
- 1:56:41the very least didn't have any evidence to refute it. And so it was
- 1:56:45basically just taking as fact that whatever the you know, all the client's allegations,
- 1:56:50and so there wasn't like a he said, she said thing, And
- 1:56:56the documentation, of course was terrible. There was no consultation, there was
- 1:57:00no justification, there was no training, you know, because you can have
- 1:57:04training in using touch and therapy, obviously this would not count. But at
- 1:57:09the very least there is some training. He had never had any of that.
- 1:57:13I think he didn't even know the field existed. And he'd been he
- 1:57:16was an experienced therapist, he'd been a therapist for decades. And it goes
- 1:57:20to the licensing party just think, well, this is slam dunk case.
- 1:57:24His license will be gone. I mean, he's a disgusting pervert that is
- 1:57:28a problem to society in general, let alone being a therapist. And they
- 1:57:32only I think they took his licensees away for a time and then he got
- 1:57:36it back. Now, his sanctions were, you know, pretty severe,
- 1:57:41he had to be supervised, but still he gets his license back. And
- 1:57:45I'm thinking, do we need this person to have his license? Is is
- 1:57:50that a necessity? Are there no other therapists in the area? What are
- 1:57:58we doing? Because even if someone could say, look, the risk is
- 1:58:02low that they've learned their lesson, I'm like, well, I don't care,
- 1:58:06you know, like there's other jobs and become a car salesman or work
- 1:58:12at the Starbucks, like We're not preventing you from working. You can work,
- 1:58:15but you've proven that you are not worthy of the mantle of this profession.
- 1:58:23And I also think that because a lot of times these licensee boards are
- 1:58:27made up of actual clinicians like us, and I think if in a way,
- 1:58:30it's kind of self policing, right, and so if we self police
- 1:58:34in a very harsh way, I think that sends a message not only to
- 1:58:38other therapists to watch their shit, but also to the public to say,
- 1:58:42you know, we take your care very, very seriously, and when one
- 1:58:45of us focks up, we oust them in no uncertain terms. They are
- 1:58:50gone. We don't have any tolerance for that kind of shit because, you
- 1:58:54know, accepting a gift, no big deal. One of these ethical violations
- 1:58:59with one client, okay, But the amount of problems that we see with
- 1:59:03these people, I just think, you know, you had your chance,
- 1:59:06and you fucked it up, and you're done. Get another job. There's
- 1:59:10a lot of other jobs out there, a lot of other careers. You
- 1:59:12know, you could be a cabaret singer or a Christmas tree cutter downer.
- 1:59:19There's a lot of fucking jobs, and those other jobs do not carry with
- 1:59:25them the risk of harm to human life and psychology that this job does.
- 1:59:30So you know, hit the bricks, But this person gets ninety days probation,
- 1:59:35five and dollars fine and eight hours of continuing at It's like we are
- 1:59:45required baseline to have about eight hours of continuing at on ethics every so often,
- 1:59:51like that's normal, that's just par for the course. So this guy
- 1:59:57was just required to do like a little bit more than typical of continuing it.
- 2:00:02It's just it's so bizarre. And if I were this client, the
- 2:00:06family that was harmed, I'd be so pissed off about it, be like
- 2:00:10what now. It's also possible that the family actually doesn't consider themselves to be
- 2:00:15harmed because they didn't mention that it was the probation officer that reported him.
- 2:00:19So I guess I don't know what's going on there. But anyway, well
- 2:00:26that was a long ass episode. Full disclosure. It is Christmas Eve Eve
- 2:00:30right now, or as I like to call it, Rebecca's Birthday eve Eve,
- 2:00:36and I don't know. I guess I'm just in the mood to ym
- 2:00:42or. It's also been a while since I did just a random individual solo
- 2:00:48episode, and maybe I had a lot of pent up energy around talking,
- 2:00:55and I used to do this a lot more, but now with all my
- 2:00:57co hosts, I feel like it's just not very I don't have any timeslots
- 2:01:00for me to just do my own episodes, you know, so that must
- 2:01:03be what it is. Also, I'm pretty passionate about this, and I've
- 2:01:09you know, I've talked about this over the years, but I feel like
- 2:01:11I've never really fully got it, gotten into it, and I think I
- 2:01:17had a lot of pent up energy around this. I'm positive that some of
- 2:01:23you are pissed off at me about this whole thing, or not positive,
- 2:01:26but I suspect and I'm willing to have my mind changed. You don't have
- 2:01:30to be a dick. If you're contacting me or commenting below, you could
- 2:01:34say, hey, Kirk, I agree with this, I disagree with this.
- 2:01:39You don't even have to be particularly. In fact, I'm much more
- 2:01:41likely to be convinced if you're not a dick, you know, if you're
- 2:01:44just like, hey, you know in my experience or something like that.
- 2:01:47But if you're a dick, then I'm at the point now where I don't
- 2:01:51even read the rest of the email. If I see dickishness. I'm just
- 2:01:55like, yep, I'm done. So I guess if you're a dick,
- 2:01:58be a dick at the end of the email, that I'm more likely to
- 2:02:01at least entertain the thing. But I am curious, you know, because
- 2:02:10this is not only you know, coaching as an is. Not only is
- 2:02:15it an unregulated field, but the discussion around this is also not super buttoned
- 2:02:19up in graduate school and in professional circles. I don't hear a lot of
- 2:02:26sophisticated talk among therapists about coaches. There's not a lot of a consensus or
- 2:02:35discourse to have us therapists have a sophisticated take and to understand other than you
- 2:02:43know, maybe just like I don't know about this, but I don't really
- 2:02:45know much more. I suspect in the future it will be a lot different.
- 2:02:48But and maybe some of you live in these circles, you know,
- 2:02:51Like I imagine some grad schools go into this quite extensively, at least I
- 2:02:57hope they do, And so I'd be curious as to your experience. But
- 2:03:00from my experience, it's almost never talked about, and the only things that
- 2:03:05I hear are either just like I don't know, seems a little shady to
- 2:03:09be a therapist and a life coach, but that's as far as it goes.
- 2:03:12Or people are just life coaches and therapists and they're just like, yeah,
- 2:03:15I became a life coach as well because you know, some of my
- 2:03:18clients they just want that kind of thing and there's not really any more discussion
- 2:03:25around it. So yeah, all right, Well take care of yourself,
- 2:03:30truly, stay ethical because you deserve it, you really really do.