Latest / Migraine Relief Code with Dr. Amelia Scott Barrett, MD / Is Italian Wheat Safer for People with Gluten Intolerance?
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, everybody.
- 0:00I just had to share a little bit of this beautiful Ligurian coastline with you.
- 0:07I am here in Northern Italy, and a lot of people have had the experience of being able to
- 0:13tolerate gluten better when they come to Italy.
- 0:15So I wanted to talk to a little bit about the top three myths about why that may or may not
- 0:20be true.
- 0:20So first myth for people with migraine is this.
- 0:25I don't get a migraine when I eat gluten, so I don't have to worry about it.
- 0:31Okay, folks.
- 0:32So the reason that that is not true is because gluten isn't so much a trigger, meaning the
- 0:39last thing that happens before you got your migraine.
- 0:42Gluten contributes to chronic inflammation in your body.
- 0:47Okay.
- 0:47So there's a lot of uncertainty, I think, about what inflammation actually is.
- 0:51So have you ever had a cut and it got a little bit red around the edges?
- 0:56That's inflammation.
- 0:57Those are chemicals in your body that cause that redness, the tenderness, the heat around
- 1:06that wound.
- 1:07That's your immune system reacting to something.
- 1:11In that case, it's doing you a favor.
- 1:12Right?
- 1:13It's helping you clean up that wound, make new tissue, and recover.
- 1:16That's your immune system doing its job.
- 1:19Well, what happens with gluten is your body is reacting to the gluten that you eat in the same
- 1:25way.
- 1:27You just don't see it because it's happening on the inside.
- 1:29Right?
- 1:30So you can certainly get some symptoms from that, but a lot of times people don't.
- 1:36And it's really just like those tipping buckets at a kid's water park.
- 1:40They're sort of slowly filling up, filling up, filling up, filling up, and then something
- 1:44happens and the bucket tips over and you get a migraine.
- 1:47The problem isn't the last thing that made the bucket tip over.
- 1:51That's just the trigger.
- 1:53The problem is that the bucket filled up.
- 1:55Do you see what I'm saying?
- 1:57So I think that this issue is actually massively underrecognized.
- 2:00It's a much bigger problem for people with migraine than we think.
- 2:03So if you can't feel this process happening in your body and you don't necessarily get a
- 2:08migraine after you eat gluten, how do you know if it's even happening to you?
- 2:12Well, the best way to figure that out is through a new type of genetic testing called
- 2:16functional genomics.
- 2:17I just like to think of that as being a very practical, hands on type of genetic testing
- 2:23that gives you actionable results so that you can actually do something about.
- 2:27You know, it's not about finding out if you have a risk for some rare condition.
- 2:32It's about, hey.
- 2:33What can I do in my daily life to improve my health and reduce the symptoms that I am
- 2:39getting from these underlying issues?
- 2:41So with the type of testing that I do for the students in my courses, you can learn which
- 2:47type of genes you have that may increase your chance of celiac disease or gluten intolerance.
- 2:53Now for celiac disease, of course, you can't eat gluten, period, ever.
- 2:57All kinds of wheat, Italian wheat, American wheat, ancient wheat, all the wheats have
- 3:03gliadin, which is the part of the protein that your immune system reacts to.
- 3:09So for people with celiac disease, gluten is is always a known.
- 3:12But for people who are gluten intolerant, it can be a much more difficult thing to figure
- 3:17out, especially if you don't get an immediate reaction to it.
- 3:20So there are actually specific genes, they're called HLA genes, that determine your risk of
- 3:27being sensitive to gluten, of being gluten intolerant.
- 3:31And once you know that information about your body, then I think you can make a wise choice.
- 3:36Alright.
- 3:36Myth number two that I hear out there a lot.
- 3:39American wheat was hybridized after World War two, and it's because of these newer hybrid
- 3:47types of wheat that we have more difficulty tolerating the wheat that's grown in America.
- 3:53Well, it actually turns out that this is not entirely true.
- 3:57Let me show you this study.
- 3:58So this study, comparative study on gluten protein composition of ancient and modern wheat
- 4:04species tells us that, actually, it's the ancient species of wheat that are higher in
- 4:11gliadin, which is the part that we react to in the wheat.
- 4:16Now these modern wheat species are actually the same in Italy and The United States.
- 4:21We tend to make pasta from durum wheat.
- 4:24It's called semolina flour, and common wheat is used more for making things like breads, and
- 4:30it's a softer kind of wheat.
- 4:33And in Italy, it's ground very, very, very fine.
- 4:35So they have a special name for that particular type of flour, but it's more related to how
- 4:39it's milled.
- 4:40It's not related to the properties of the wheat itself, which is what our body reacts to.
- 4:46So as you can see here, we can look at the gliadin content of different kinds of wheat.
- 4:51Einkorn and emmer, which are typically thought of being ancient grains, are over here on the
- 4:56right.
- 4:57They're actually quite high in gliadin, which is the stuff that our body reacts to.
- 5:01And you'll see the common wheat over on the left is actually pretty low.
- 5:06Now the other thing is that Italy actually imports its wheat from kind of all over the
- 5:10world at this point, so it's not entirely fair to say that the varieties that are used in
- 5:14Italy and grown in Italy are different from what's used everywhere else.
- 5:19I mean, we're all part of a global economy these days.
- 5:21And now I think that the reason some people get upset over this idea of hybridization is
- 5:26because it's a little confusing to figure out what's the difference between that and
- 5:30genetically modified.
- 5:32They are very different.
- 5:34So hybridization is really just a farmer kinda taking two wheat stocks and mating them and
- 5:40making a new kind.
- 5:41Now I don't know how you mate wheat.
- 5:43If anybody watching this video knows how to do that, please drop it in the content.
- 5:47Genetic modification is a completely different thing.
- 5:50Now we don't have GMO wheat in The United States, so we don't have to worry about that.
- 5:57We do have genetically modified corn and soy.
- 6:01And the reason that those were made is that they farmers wanted them to be resistant to
- 6:06Roundup.
- 6:07Now the story about Roundup, which we'll get to a little bit more in a minute, but for the
- 6:12moment, basically, what they did is make corn and soy.
- 6:16They changed the genetic structure of it so that Roundup would not kill it so that they
- 6:22could spray that on the crops.
- 6:24The weeds would die.
- 6:25The crop would not, and that would therefore would increase yields, feed more people, feed
- 6:30more animals, and do good things.
- 6:32Alright.
- 6:33And that brings us to myth number three.
- 6:35It's the glyphosate.
- 6:37Now it is true that you cannot use Roundup in Italy as a desiccant.
- 6:43Okay.
- 6:44What does that mean?
- 6:45That just means they use it as a drying agent before harvest.
- 6:48So, basically, right as the wheat is ready to be harvested, you spray glyphosate on it
- 6:54because it dries it out, and it makes the harvest go better.
- 6:58I mean, maybe sounds like a bad idea to spray the poison on the food right before you eat it.
- 7:02I don't know.
- 7:02But, anyway, that's how is it is done in some parts of America, not all, but it is allowed
- 7:08here.
- 7:08It is not allowed in Italy.
- 7:10You can use glyphosate in other parts of farming here in Italy, just not right before
- 7:15you eat it, which does seem to make good sense.
- 7:18Now I do wanna point out that the intention with glyphosate was good.
- 7:24So glyphosate basically impacts a biochemical pathway that weeds have that we don't.
- 7:33So that's why people thought it was harmless for humans.
- 7:36Now the problem is we've learned over time, of course, that it actually does impact human
- 7:40health quite significantly.
- 7:42In fact, Monsanto has paid out over $11,000,000,000 in settlements for people who
- 7:47got a certain type of cancer called non Hodgkin's lymphoma from high levels of exposure
- 7:53to Roundup.
- 7:55And even if we don't have high levels of exposure, even low level exposure can still be
- 8:01harmful to the gut microbiome.
- 8:03Here is a study that confirmed the effect of glyphosate on the gut microbiome.
- 8:10I love this title.
- 8:11Separating the empirical wheat from the pseudoscientific chaff.
- 8:15Turns out it is harmful to the good bacteria that are in our guts.
- 8:22We have a combination of good bacteria and bad bacteria.
- 8:25If you wipe out the good bacteria, you get something called dysbiosis.
- 8:29Your gut doesn't work right.
- 8:31You get more symptoms at the time, but it also sets you up for this inflammation down the
- 8:37road, you know, that I was talking about with the the pain chemicals filling up the tipping
- 8:41bucket, and that sets you up for a variety of health problems in addition to migraine.
- 8:46So at this point, you're probably wondering why I'm saying that it's not the glyphosate when
- 8:51it's so clear that glyphosate actually does harmful things to our health.
- 8:56But here's the thing.
- 8:57You can buy organic products in The United States.
- 9:00Right?
- 9:01You can buy organic wheat bread.
- 9:03You can buy organic pasta.
- 9:06People still have reactions to those that they feel like they don't have here in Italy.
- 9:11Now why is that?
- 9:12I think number one, it's very confusing to figure out if wheat is a problem for you in the
- 9:17first place.
- 9:18Right?
- 9:18Unless you've had your genetic testing done, you're not gonna know what your baseline
- 9:25predisposition for having trouble tolerating gluten is.
- 9:29You're trying to figure it out totally based on trial and error, looking at your symptoms as
- 9:37evidence of whether or not this is a health problem for you.
- 9:40And that's just not always right because there could be dozens of things going on for you
- 9:45under the surface at any one time, and you don't know what those are.
- 9:48And I think the other important thing to keep in mind is just when you're on vacation, you're
- 9:51on vacation.
- 9:52Life is stressful.
- 9:53Right?
- 9:54Of course, that's gonna make your health better.
- 9:56We all know how bad stress is for us, and we know how little Americans vacation compared to
- 10:02the rest of the world.
- 10:03So during the times when we do, I think it's not surprising that our health gets better in
- 10:06so many different ways.