Latest / MBA Training Marketing / Balancing brand and performance budgets: the 60/40 rule explained
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Leaders Insights Podcast.
- 0:07Today's episode, Balancing Brand and Performance Budgets, the 6040th rule explained.
- 0:13Every marketer I know says they believe in brand building, and every one of them spends
- 0:1780% of their money on performance ads.
- 0:21Why the gap?
- 0:22Because performance is a slot machine that pays out visibly.
- 0:25You put a dollar into Google.
- 0:27You see the click, the sale, the number.
- 0:30Brand is a savings account that pays out in three years, and no CFO ever got promoted
- 0:34for patience.
- 0:36So the 6040th rule, 60% brand, 40% performance, is that just a comforting fiction for people
- 0:43who like TV ads?
- 0:44No, it's from actual work.
- 0:46Leibnay and Peter Field studied hundreds of campaigns entered into UK Effectiveness Awards,
- 0:52and the split that maximized long-term profit landed around 60% on brand, 40% on activation,
- 0:59activation being the stuff that makes someone buy this week.
- 1:03That's the durable principle.
- 1:05The exact number moves, the direction doesn't.
- 1:07Fine, but long-term profit is what everyone says right before they waste a fortune.
- 1:12What's the mechanism?
- 1:13Two jobs.
- 1:15Performance harvests demand that already exists.
- 1:18People ready to buy.
- 1:19It creates demand that doesn't exist yet, so that when someone's finally in the market,
- 1:24you're the name they already trust.
- 1:27Roughly 95% of your potential buyers aren't shopping today.
- 1:31If you only spend on the 5% who are, you're fighting everyone else in an auction and your
- 1:36costs climb every quarter.
- 1:38That 95% figure, where's it from?
- 1:42Sounds like a vendor slide.
- 1:43It's the 95-terrory five rule from the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, an academic marketing
- 1:49outfit not a software company selling you dashboards.
- 1:53And it holds for most business categories.
- 1:55Most of the market is out of the market at any given moment.
- 1:59Give me a company that actually lived this.
- 2:01Not a theory.
- 2:02Airbnb.
- 2:04Around 2019 they were pouring money into search and performance channels.
- 2:08Then their CFO, Dave Stevenson, did something rare.
- 2:12He pulled back performance spend and shifted heavily toward brand.
- 2:16Then travel collapsed in 2020 and they cut marketing dramatically.
- 2:20Their traffic mostly came back on its own because people typed Airbnb directly.
- 2:26By 2021, they said something like 90% of traffic was direct or unpaid.
- 2:31That's brand doing the work, performance can't.
- 2:34Convenient story though.
- 2:35Maybe they'd have recovered anyway because they're famous.
- 2:39They're famous because of exactly that spending.
- 2:41That's the point.
- 2:42The fame is the asset.
- 2:44But I'll give you the other side because 60 40ths as a commandment gets people killed.
- 2:49Go on, when is following at a mistake?
- 2:51When you're a startup with no revenue.
- 2:54If you've got 18 months of runway and no proof anyone wants the thing, spending 60%
- 2:59on brand is vanity.
- 3:01You need sales now to prove the model, so flip it.
- 3:04Go heavy on performance until you've got product market fit.
- 3:08The 60 40ths is for established businesses with a base to defend.
- 3:13So who else should ignore it?
- 3:15Anyone in a category people buy rarely and research heavily.
- 3:19Enterprise software, mortgages, and anyone whose whole business is one channel, say a brand
- 3:24living entirely on Amazon.
- 3:26There, brand and performance blur.
- 3:30Because winning the search result is the brand.
- 3:33Context beats the ratio every time.
- 3:35Here's the uncomfortable one.
- 3:37If brand pays off in three years, how does a CMO keep her job in year one when the
- 3:41numbers look flat?
- 3:43You measure the leading signals.
- 3:45Track branded search volume, see how many people type your name into Google.
- 3:50Because that rises before revenue does.
- 3:53Track share of voice, your slice of category advertising versus rivals.
- 3:57And track your direct traffic.
- 3:59If those climb while your paid costs hold steady, you're building the account even
- 4:03if the quarterly sales chart is boring.
- 4:06You give the CFO a scoreboard that isn't just this month's return on ad spend.
- 4:11Something people can do Monday morning?
- 4:13Pull your last 90 days of spend and calculate the real split.
- 4:17Brand versus direct response.
- 4:19Not what you think it is, the actual number.
- 4:22Almost everyone's at 80 20ths or worse toward performance and genuinely surprised.
- 4:28You can't fix a ratio you've never measured.
- 4:30Measure it before you defend it.
- 4:32Good place to stop.
- 4:33That's a wrap.
- 4:35Fresh CMO briefings drop daily at MBA-training.com.