Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Quick Take on NCUA's Exam Plans for 2026
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker: Hey everyone, this is Mark TriCal with another
- 0:04episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:06Thinking back to when I started this podcast and how I actually
- 0:10discovered podcasts, it.
- 0:13Was 2020 during the pandemic when I started listening to podcasts after
- 0:20having retired, and I followed a Vikings, Minnesota Vikings podcast, a Minnesota
- 0:25Timberwolves podcast, which led me to a.
- 0:29Doing a search for consulting podcast.
- 0:31'cause I was dip, gonna plan on dipping my toe into the consulting world.
- 0:35And I stumbled across a podcast called Consulting Success.
- 0:39And then I used a lot of self-education via other podcasts for starting
- 0:44the business and other things.
- 0:45So anyway one of the podcasts that I discovered early on was one of
- 0:50the original podcasts out there, one of the OGs, if you will.
- 0:54Stuff you should know and stuff you should know occasionally does live
- 0:59podcast recordings across the country and tongue in cheek hat tip to those guys.
- 1:05I, we will be doing our first live podcast type event as I'm about to get on a
- 1:11cruise, the Florida QS cruise for 2026 with two of my team members, Steve Farr.
- 1:18And Todd Miller, and we're gonna be talking about a lot of things
- 1:21NCA, everything you wanted to ask NCA, but we're afraid to ask and
- 1:26what we've seen in credit union relationships over the last years.
- 1:30And just before we took off, I'm recording this, friday, January 16th.
- 1:35A couple days ago, NCOA came out with their supervisory priority letter, and
- 1:39that's always one of our most downloaded episodes when we get back to shore and
- 1:44when we get back to, to where he reside.
- 1:48Steve and Todd in that instance are in Montana.
- 1:50We're gonna record a podcast the normal way by looking at our laptops
- 1:54and bringing our own notes into it and having some discussions relative to that.
- 1:58But as a primer for that, I am recording this on, as I said, Friday, January 16th.
- 2:04We don't get back from our crews until next week, and I'm going
- 2:09to use this episode as a primer for NCA supervisory priority.
- 2:13Podcasts and we'll issue this early next week.
- 2:17And then after everybody gets settled we're gonna take what we talked
- 2:21through at, on the cruise and perhaps maybe have some recordings from the
- 2:25cruise if the situation warrants.
- 2:27But we're gonna talk through that.
- 2:28And and you'll hear both my thoughts, Steve's thoughts, Todd's thoughts
- 2:33on the priorities after digesting it and discussing it with credit
- 2:37union folks directly on the crews.
- 2:39So with that N NCAA's letter on letter to, and I'm getting texts saying I
- 2:45need to check in and tell 'em that I'm healthy, which I already did.
- 2:48So anyway yeah, the cruise is upon us, but I am.
- 2:53Looking at N NCAA's letter to credit unions.
- 2:55Of course, they come out with this every January.
- 2:58They come out with it.
- 3:00And as a reminder, as I've discussed on other podcasts the
- 3:04NCA chairman has the pen for this.
- 3:06So when there are three board members, the chair decide what
- 3:09goes in this, sometimes they're collaborative, other times they're not.
- 3:13In this instance, there's no one to collaborate with because there
- 3:16is one board member Kyle Halman, so he can put into this letter.
- 3:19What he wants, which will explain why he made a reference to the
- 3:23agency's supervisory priorities being consistent with the agency's
- 3:28no regulation by enforcement policy.
- 3:30This letter is meant to assist credit unions as they plan for this year.
- 3:35Now that no regulation policy to me taking what it says, which.
- 3:41In my opinion is a little convoluted is to imply that you can, NCA
- 3:46will only enforce regulations.
- 3:48They won't import, enforce noten, enforceable things like an examiner's
- 3:53opinion like a letter to credit union, and they have to link
- 3:56everything back to a regulation.
- 3:58However, of course, their loophole that I've discussed in the past is that
- 4:01safety and soundness is a ginormous.
- 4:03Loophole that they can link anything to.
- 4:05So it sounds really good.
- 4:07And I'm glad to see the letter talks about they're not gonna do that,
- 4:11although we see it happen quite a bit.
- 4:13And then it comes down to the credit union deciding do I push back?
- 4:16Or do I not push back now?
- 4:19They also talked through and put a positive spin on them being
- 4:23wiser in using their resources.
- 4:26Which is really just another way of saying, Hey, we attacked our budget.
- 4:29We got rid of 27% of our staff, we got rid of a lot of talented
- 4:33staff, and because of that we're going to tailor our exam program.
- 4:37Because we were required to by the presidential executive order.
- 4:40So he's being consistent with carrying the water of the Trump administration.
- 4:44And of course, it a letter coming out on this.
- 4:47Not a shocker.
- 4:48When you see Todd Harper, former NCH Chairman have the pen, you
- 4:52see a lot of stuff on consumer compliance, and I'll get into that.
- 4:56But when you see Chairman Halman talk about it, you always know he's gonna bring
- 5:00something up about Bitcoin or stable coin.
- 5:05Et cetera.
- 5:05And they make a reference here too, including the guide, the Guiding
- 5:09and establishing National Innovation for US Stable Coins Genius Act.
- 5:13And it has a link to the Genius Act.
- 5:15Stablecoin I'm curious to see what kind of dialogue I have on the cruise
- 5:19relative to stable coin and how that might impact credit unions, whether
- 5:23credit unions are getting into that, whether they're fearful of what it's
- 5:26gonna do to their ability to tap into member shares, whether it's gonna.
- 5:32Their ability to tap into, what shall we say, the youth movement who are more
- 5:37into stable coins than 80-year-old.
- 5:3970-year-old, 60 year olds.
- 5:40Pick a number.
- 5:41But halman, that's his baby.
- 5:42So of course, that baby got woven into the supervisory priorities.
- 5:45Why?
- 5:46Because of Trump, because the chair drives the agenda.
- 5:50The chair dries this letter.
- 5:52It also says, Hey, gives them the, not the cop out, but the subtle nuance
- 5:56that yeah, they just, because this is what we say we're gonna do based on
- 5:59your personal risk at your institution, we may pivot and do other things.
- 6:04Balance sheet management is one broad category.
- 6:07They talk about the fact that they can look at and plan to look at Cecil.
- 6:11They talk about how the delinquency and charge offs are at.
- 6:1810 year, what is it?
- 6:2010 year the overall delinquency rate within federal credit unions is at
- 6:23its highest point in over a decade.
- 6:25So clearly they're thinking that.
- 6:28Something they need to watch.
- 6:29That means that's something that you need to watch.
- 6:31And then of course when they issue these letters, they're 4, 5, 6 pages long.
- 6:35And then they have links to all sorts of guidance, adding pages and pages.
- 6:39And so under lending they make reference to the commercial
- 6:42real estate loan accommodations.
- 6:43We've seen a lot of things on that.
- 6:44We'll be talking about that on the cruise.
- 6:46Update to interagency policy statement on allowance for credit losses.
- 6:50They're saying, Hey, don't forget to do this.
- 6:52And we're seeing that in some of our contacts as well.
- 6:55Home equity line of credits nearing their end of drop period.
- 6:58A letter to credit unions from oh eight and that, so that goes back to
- 7:01the great recession when NCAA had some insurance fund losses and did some IG
- 7:06audits on some West coast disasters, if you will, that cost the insurance fund
- 7:11money because of home equity loans that weren't properly managed, which led to
- 7:14that letter to credit unions coming up.
- 7:17As always, evaluating third party relationships.
- 7:19That's their hat tip to to indirect lending.
- 7:22And they're linking that that letter to credit unions, which, which is from 2013.
- 7:27And then they go all back, all the way back to 2001 loan charge off guidance.
- 7:32And.
- 7:332003, supervisory letter on concentration risk.
- 7:36And concentration risk is something that we've talked a
- 7:39lot about on the podcast here.
- 7:40We're gonna probably hit that pretty hard on the cruise, and when we circle back
- 7:44with Todd and Steve to talk through their take on this letter after this week we'll
- 7:48have a lot more details relative to that.
- 7:50So again, this is a 10,000 foot level.
- 7:52This is a mark.
- 7:53Just read the letter, just printed it off and is getting ready to put his
- 7:56notes together for our first live ever.
- 8:00Podcast on the cruise.
- 8:01Sensitivity and market risk and liquidity were all boiled
- 8:05up into one major category.
- 8:07And I've mentioned in the past that at some junctures, NCA has listed
- 8:1213 priorities in this letter.
- 8:14And when everything's a priority, nothing's a priority.
- 8:17They've gotten better at scaling it back, but one of the ways they
- 8:20scale it back is instead of having.
- 8:22A category of li liquidity and a category on sensitivity.
- 8:25They roll it into one, so they make it a little bit more user friendly,
- 8:28but they are basically pointing out anything and everything that could
- 8:32be a risk that they might look at.
- 8:33So sensitivity and market risk and liquidity, of course, a lot of credit
- 8:37unions with with the influx of COVID money and then going longer term on investments.
- 8:43They make a hat tip to the fact that the underwater situation, because
- 8:46of interest rates has improved in that arena, but they're still seeing
- 8:48some liquidity issues, and we're still seeing it in our conversations
- 8:52with credit unions where NCUA is.
- 8:55Pushing strategies to reduce NEV pushing strategies to become more member
- 9:01focused and less less borrowing focused, or less non-member deposit focused.
- 9:07Even though all of those sources are legitimate tools, sometimes NCOA
- 9:12will beat you up if you don't have good corporate governance over that.
- 9:16Earnings and ca capital adequacy is always in the letter to credit unions.
- 9:21And they highlight it here and they indicate when evaluating a credit
- 9:24union's earnings, NCA Examiners will assess whether the current and
- 9:27prospective sources of earnings are sufficient to support capital targets
- 9:31under a range of interest rates, credit and liquidity stress scenario.
- 9:35NSU examiners may focus on policies, procedures, risk limits, and capital
- 9:39planning practices, including how credit unions incorporate interest
- 9:43rate, risk funding constraints and concentration risks into their
- 9:46capital adequacy assessments.
- 9:48We're seeing a lot of how much capital is enough in our discussions with
- 9:52credit unions and credit unions, having a plan to show their board,
- 9:57their members and their regulator why the level that they have is adequate.
- 10:01Sometimes NCA.
- 10:03We'll say yes, you are well capitalized, but we think you
- 10:05have other risks in certain areas.
- 10:07Sometimes in my opinion, they go on rabbit holes that, that aren't justified.
- 10:11I've seen that a lot this year in some instances where their support in the
- 10:16exam and their approach in the exam was a little bit more, examiner opinion then
- 10:21what Halman said at the top end that they're only gonna regulate regulations.
- 10:25So again stay tuned for more details on our thoughts on that post cruise.
- 10:31Interestingly, payment systems has been highlighted as a standalone area, and
- 10:36I've got a chart that I've put together.
- 10:39That shows what topics have been covered over certain years,
- 10:43and there are perpetual topics like loan quality, occasional.
- 10:48Topics like like payment systems and new topics which
- 10:52come up every once in a while.
- 10:54Payment systems was a priority for NCUA in 2019.
- 10:58In no, in 2022, and not before that for the last four years,
- 11:02and then not for 23, 24, 25.
- 11:04And they're raising it again.
- 11:06And the language here.
- 11:07That they say is the payments environment continues to evolve rapidly as consumer
- 11:12expectations shift toward more efficient methods that provide for immediate
- 11:16access to funds and fund transfers.
- 11:19Payment systems relying on increasingly complex integrations of applications,
- 11:24information systems interfaces, security features, and internal controls.
- 11:28This complexity introduces the potential for added operational
- 11:31and security risk exposures.
- 11:35The risks of fraudulently induced payments, elicit use of consumer data
- 11:40and cybersecurity breaches targeting payment systems continue to grow.
- 11:44And CA examiners will continue to assess whether credit unions
- 11:47have effective governance.
- 11:49Risk assessments, vendor management and security frameworks in place to
- 11:53support payment system operations.
- 11:55Protect member data and ensure resilience against fraud and cyber
- 11:59threats inherent in payment ecosystems for more payment systems Information,
- 12:04refer to the retail payment systems and the wholesale payment systems.
- 12:08Topics in the F-F-I-E-C council's IT exam handbook info base.
- 12:13So there's another a hundred pages that they link.
- 12:15To this letter, and again, that the fact that they're highlighting this
- 12:18is that they're probably seeing some situations where they're having to deal
- 12:23with this and downgrade credit unions.
- 12:25They're probably having discussions in their skiffs, their their
- 12:29secured secured compartmentalized information facility where they talk
- 12:33about top secret things that might be happening by foreign players.
- 12:37But obviously the fact that it's risen its head for the first time.
- 12:41Is that they're seeing some things.
- 12:42They're hearing some things and they're worried about this.
- 12:45And of course, when you've got, when you've got all these different systems
- 12:48of pulling money here, pulling mon money there the link back to the
- 12:51third party due diligence it's all intertwined and it all creates risk.
- 12:56And it all layers onto the stresses that you have in running your
- 12:59credit union to keep your membership safe and your members' funds safe.
- 13:02And your regulator at bay.
- 13:05It also has a section on fraud prevention and detection and just quickly fraud
- 13:10remains a pervasive and elevated risk in the US financial system.
- 13:13NCUA Examiners will continue to review credit union efforts to deter and
- 13:17detect fraud, including the adequacy of internal controls and separation of
- 13:21duties to guard against insider abuse.
- 13:25In 2026, the agency will review its examination procedures to ensure internal
- 13:29control and other reviews areas align with the ever-changing fraud landscape.
- 13:35And CUA will continue to work with key stakeholders in the credit
- 13:38union, regulatory and law enforcement communities to enhance fraud
- 13:42prevention and detection awareness.
- 13:44And capabilities where possible visit enc Sue's Fraud Prevention resources page,
- 13:49which again has hundreds and hundreds of pages on it that they've incorporated by
- 13:52reference into this letter to credit use.
- 13:55So fraud wasn't brought up in 25, 24.
- 13:59It wasn't 23, it wasn't 22, it wasn't in 21, 20 or 19.
- 14:04So it comes and it goes, when does it come?
- 14:06It comes when they have losses that show fraud or they hear things that.
- 14:10That show fraud.
- 14:11They have a specific reference to internal fraud management insider
- 14:16abuse, which means that something happened in some credit union that
- 14:19led somebody to say either staff.
- 14:22Or the board who might, they get frustrated, they see a loss, they see a
- 14:26review showing why something happened.
- 14:28Then they weave it in here with a subtle reference.
- 14:30So clearly somewhere somebody felt this needed to be raised or
- 14:34they just said, Hey, we haven't brought it up in three years.
- 14:36Let's highlight it again.
- 14:37I doubt that's the case.
- 14:38I think it's the former, not the latter.
- 14:41Compliance risk management.
- 14:42This is probably the biggest differentiation.
- 14:45BSA is always in some way, shape, or form highlighted as a separate item or
- 14:53woven into consumer financial protection.
- 14:55And over the Biden years, the consumer financial protection area
- 15:01was expanded on what was covered.
- 15:03They did more fair lending exams.
- 15:05They did sorts of all sorts of things that were happening.
- 15:09And by the way, the office that did that, from my understanding, although
- 15:11NCA has not been public about it, is going to be merged into the region.
- 15:15So they're getting, allegedly getting rid of wands, allegedly getting rid of
- 15:19cure, allegedly getting rid of consumer oCFP, office of Consumer Financial
- 15:25Protection and spinning that back up into the regions, and you can argue
- 15:27whether or not that makes sense or not.
- 15:29You can argue whether or not they're just doing it because they gutted
- 15:32themselves and got rid of so many people, but they're, I'm being
- 15:35told, they're doing it nonetheless.
- 15:36Eventually, hopefully they'll plan on telling the credit union industry that.
- 15:41But they've totally deemphasizing consumer compliance and focusing
- 15:46specifically on BSA and a ML type items.
- 15:50And then Kyle Halman has always been a champion since he showed up of
- 15:54weaving something in here about the appropriateness of recording your meetings
- 15:57with NCUA, giving a copy of those to NCUA.
- 16:00And of course, if you're a state charter, checking with your state regulator
- 16:04before recording because some states.
- 16:07Some state banking, credit union divisions don't allow that.
- 16:11So that's my quick take on this letter to credit unions.
- 16:16I'm looking forward to getting on stage and record not recording,
- 16:19but having a live podcast with interaction from the crowd.
- 16:25With my team members, Steve and Todd.
- 16:27And when we get back we'll have some other things that we'll discuss
- 16:31about how the crews went and the interactions that we had there.
- 16:34So again, as always, thanks for listening.
- 16:37Thanks for watching.
- 16:38This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.