Latest / Newcomer Pod / Musk & Zuck Go Head to Head, Vying to Rule Global Online Discussion (with Katie Notopoulos & Tom Dotan)
Transcript
- 0:01Hey, it's Eric Newcomer. Welcome to the Newcomer podcast.
- 0:05Or maybe it's dead Cat. This week we've got Tom Doton,
- 0:08our old cohost, back on the show, a little bit like old
- 0:12times. We also invited Katie Metopolis,
- 0:15the former BuzzFeed reporter who's been posting up in a storm
- 0:19on threads. And we got into the war between
- 0:23Elon Musk's Twitter and Mark Zuckerberg's.
- 0:27New Threads app, which has been taking off and we dig into the
- 0:31future of the Real Time Battle Royale forum for worldwide
- 0:36discussion and where Threads fits into it.
- 0:39It was a fun, lighthearted episode about the state of a key
- 0:44consumer company. And then at the tail end, we
- 0:47talked a little bit about Tom's reporting at the Journal and the
- 0:50downturn in tech. Give it a listen.
- 0:53Hey everybody, welcome to. I think we're This is a dead cat
- 0:57episode, right? We have the newcomer podcast, as
- 1:00we've been calling it more recently.
- 1:01Lots of brand confusion going on.
- 1:03Tom Dotan, who abandoned the podcast to go work at the Wall
- 1:08Street Journal, is back. Apparently his editors think
- 1:11it's now safe for him to make an appearance.
- 1:13Tom. It took a couple of months, but
- 1:15I had to get clearance from high level masthead people to appear.
- 1:18But I'm here. I've been given strict
- 1:21instructions, yeah. Well, a good Benioff story under
- 1:24your belt. They're like, all right, he's in
- 1:25the cult enough. I'm indoctrinated enough that
- 1:28I'm coming here as a representative of the Journal
- 1:29and not as a defective member of Dead Cat.
- 1:32Yeah, that's right. And then we've got Katie
- 1:34Natopolis X BuzzFeed right. Also recently I think announced
- 1:40she stepped down as Editor in chief of Threads.
- 1:42She's been long running for the history of this short lived
- 1:46social media site bit. Pretending to be the editor in
- 1:49chief of threads. Katie, welcome to the show.
- 1:52Thank you, Thank you so much. But Erica, unfortunately I was
- 1:56personally fired by Mark Zuckerberg.
- 1:59I didn't resign. Was that like via DM, like Fred
- 2:01DM or does he call you? Where does he go about firing
- 2:05people? He's been good at it this year.
- 2:07There's been lots of firings at Meta, but.
- 2:09I don't think I addressed this in my bit.
- 2:10I said I was going to a meeting with him.
- 2:12I don't think I specified in person or over Zoom, but you
- 2:16know, I guess because you know, I'm on the East Coast, he's in,
- 2:18you know, San Francisco. I guess it must have been a Zoom
- 2:20firing, probably. Hawaii, but yeah, yeah.
- 2:23We had a huddle before the podcast started about whether we
- 2:26would do this bit as a sincere bit and decided us left for the
- 2:30threads. Obviously, like the news story
- 2:33here is, you know, Facebook, meta, whatever we're calling
- 2:35them, has come on the scene super strong with this Twitter
- 2:39competitor. Tom, have you, have you spent
- 2:41any? I'm not threads.
- 2:43Yeah, I've done 2 threads so far.
- 2:45If Katie was trying to be the editor in chief of threads, I
- 2:48was trying to be the cat turd two of threads.
- 2:51And I and I posted that they have been shadow banning me and
- 2:54ghost banning me. And I'm not getting the
- 2:56engagements that I previously had seen on my threads.
- 2:59And everybody took it seriously and said like, if there's
- 3:02something wrong here. And then Alex Heath suggested
- 3:04that I had a profile photo. That's why I'm not getting the
- 3:06engagement I expected. So yeah, I I've not done well on
- 3:11threads so far, but I am. I am on it.
- 3:12Yeah, you. Were never large on Twitter in
- 3:14the 1st place, so if anything, this is your chance to like.
- 3:18Yeah, I didn't. I mean, I was not my medium.
- 3:20I'm no Katie, the top of this, or or newcomer for that matter.
- 3:23I never succeeded really on on Twitter.
- 3:25But I don't think Threads is going all that much better for
- 3:28me. It's not like this is a fresh
- 3:30page, although I do have my name because I was stuck with my
- 3:33stupid, you know, 2010 or whatever Twitter name, city of
- 3:37the town. And then because it chooses your
- 3:40Instagram handle. The city of the town is an LA
- 3:42reference, and you're a San Francisco.
- 3:44You have a house in San Francisco, so I don't even want.
- 3:46To explain, I don't even want to explain what the reference is,
- 3:48but but anyway. It is LA, right?
- 3:49No. It's not it's it's from, it's
- 3:51from, it's from the Bay Area. It's it's the reference.
- 3:54It's fine, OK, well either way but but it it pulls your
- 3:57Instagram name right for your threads handle.
- 4:00I believe right that everyone and a lot of people have kind of
- 4:02bullshit Instagram handles too. So there are people that I think
- 4:05were unexpectedly. Stuck with that as their threads
- 4:09name. Like I What is yours?
- 4:10This is Cadence I I have the The one upside to having like a
- 4:13really hard to spell unusual last name is that I never have
- 4:16competition on any platform for getting my real name.
- 4:20I don't have to be captured too. I can be just captured.
- 4:24Yeah, I I'd be thrown to the other Eric Newcomer.
- 4:27He lives in Manhattan. He's sort of tech adjacent.
- 4:29I've I've been over to his house for a beer tasting.
- 4:31So so. You've met.
- 4:33Oh yeah, we at least socialize. I've been like.
- 4:36I think twice now. Now we're just, yeah.
- 4:38So it's hysterical dinner party where I have to explain to
- 4:40people. My name is also Eric Newcomer.
- 4:43Anyway, I want to sort of get like the vibe of Threads.
- 4:45And later on in the episode we can talk about the real, like, I
- 4:48don't know, Twitter threads War you you had a funny tweet about
- 4:53or. Sorry, they're not tweets.
- 4:54What are they? They're posts.
- 4:55They're posts. So what?
- 4:57Yeah, they the official Instagram account.
- 5:01Gave a dictionary that I think you would call a conversation a
- 5:06thread like I was reading some interesting threads that Eric
- 5:11was talking about, but an individual post is called a post
- 5:14and then instead of a retweet, it's a repost.
- 5:17What did you think was going on there?
- 5:18I found this super strange that they were dictating like what
- 5:22language they want people to do. I I couldn't tell if they were
- 5:25worried people are going to start using.
- 5:28Like, tweet. And they didn't want to
- 5:29encourage people to just like embrace.
- 5:31I sort of took it as that that was literally people were asking
- 5:36that, that people were like, what do we call them to be
- 5:38called? Because they're not tweets.
- 5:39Do we call them retweets? You know what we call it?
- 5:41We call. And I think that the worst case
- 5:43scenario was, I feel like a lot of people were joking what you
- 5:45would call them threats, right, Which is probably not what they
- 5:49want. Right.
- 5:50So I think it was this kind of a like.
- 5:54People are having too much fun with word play, which I'm
- 5:57generally against. But there's a lot of like, you
- 6:00know, your followers or your thread count type tweets, you
- 6:04know, Yeah. So there's a lot of like, you
- 6:06know, people keep comparing it to like, you know, a new summer
- 6:09camp where you know, everybody sort of jokey and like trying to
- 6:12come up with like the lingo that will rule the platform.
- 6:16Yeah, and I also think it's really worth remembering that,
- 6:19like. I mean obviously it's it's been
- 6:21a lot more people than they even anticipated signing up.
- 6:24Like I think it's in 70 million or something.
- 6:26Like most of these people are not on Twitter.
- 6:28Most of them don't know anything about that.
- 6:30Most of them are not comparing it to Twitter.
- 6:33So it's like complete normies. It's like 16 year olds in
- 6:37Brazil, right? Like they're not thinking about
- 6:40like do we call it a retweet? Like they're kind of like oh new
- 6:44platform. What is this as part of
- 6:45Instagram, like tell me what to do here.
- 6:47I think that like. It's such a big sprawling user
- 6:52base that you know, That's why it's so like basic, you know?
- 6:57Explain to me, though, the case for why people that have never
- 7:01liked Twitter would suddenly join a Twitter copycat and find
- 7:05use in it? Because Twitter's been around
- 7:06for a while. Like clearly the mechanics and
- 7:08design of that social media app are not broadly appealing to
- 7:12more than whatever, 200, three, 100 million users.
- 7:15So why now? Are they expecting people in
- 7:17Brazil that have shunned Twitter for, you know, the first decade
- 7:21of its existence? More are suddenly going to be
- 7:23like, oh, thread, because I can use my Instagram handle and like
- 7:27auto sign up easily is suddenly a compelling experience.
- 7:30So I don't know exactly this, but I have a large suspicion.
- 7:34So I had like as an eager person to test out this new app.
- 7:38Like I had done the thing where you could like preorder it on
- 7:41iTunes so that would like load immediately I like.
- 7:44At exactly 7:00 PM when it like was ready to be downloaded or
- 7:47whatever Because I was excited to do that because I was
- 7:50following technology news and knew there was a new app coming
- 7:54out. But I am assuming that for most
- 7:57people like I don't think most people like heard about the app
- 7:59and then went to the App Store to go looking for it.
- 8:01I assume that most people opened Instagram and got a prompt
- 8:05saying Click to the new threads experience that they basically
- 8:10it signed people up right from inside the Instagram app.
- 8:13So. You know, so it's all just like
- 8:15anyone who opened Instagram yesterday was sort of pushed
- 8:19into a funnel to join the app. And so they might have been
- 8:22like, I don't know, what's this? Sure, I don't know.
- 8:24I like Instagram. Well, I'll do the thing.
- 8:26Yeah, and like Facebook, Instagram, Meta, whatever.
- 8:29They can always do that. They could launch any app they
- 8:31wanted, put a prompt in one of their, you know, billion plus
- 8:34user apps and push a not insignificant percentage of them
- 8:37to just sign up. Doesn't matter what it is.
- 8:40And they have, but those have always kind of like flopped,
- 8:43right? Like this is unique in that
- 8:45like. It is day three, though.
- 8:48Yeah I mean it still could flop. We're.
- 8:49Going to get into our predictions about what will
- 8:51happen. So think about that.
- 8:52But yeah, they have tried. You know what I mean?
- 8:56That reals is like successful, but TikTok is certainly like way
- 9:00ahead. There have been other standalone
- 9:04apps. What was it like?
- 9:06It was like slingshot or something.
- 9:07Yeah, Lasso. Paper wasn't that.
- 9:10Like rip offs of Snapchat and stuff.
- 9:13And then they eventually made stories which were successful.
- 9:17But those were products within an existing app.
- 9:20But I feel like it's been rare that they actually put their
- 9:23whole Medussy into forcing people onto another, actually
- 9:27downloading a full separate app and.
- 9:30It feels like there are like a couple things it does feel like.
- 9:33The contempt for Elon Musk, especially among like reporters
- 9:37and sort of the left and sort of the blue checks, the old blue
- 9:42checks, you know, I feel like that revolt in the sort of
- 9:46hunger for that crowd, myself included, to like, find a new,
- 9:51not like I'm some huge account, but to find a new home, help
- 9:55motivate this. And then.
- 9:56Which is of course hysterical because those same blue checks.
- 10:00Over the last five years, hate suck, hate, hate.
- 10:02It was like a theme. Of dead cat like I feel like a
- 10:04lot of early dead cat was all about like the anti Facebook and
- 10:09was sort of like the corrective. It's a core.
- 10:11Belief of the blue checks. I mean, that's what animal.
- 10:13They just are totally forgotten. It's all mood.
- 10:16I don't, I don't. Know.
- 10:18Yeah, I think it's a lot of like the enemy of my enemy is my
- 10:21friends, right? A. 100, clearly, clearly that is
- 10:23the diagnosis. I mean, so it's that.
- 10:27It's obviously sort of Instagram's power to get
- 10:30Instagram people there. And then it's also the people
- 10:33who are like you got to get on a platform early and try and build
- 10:36followers. So I feel like it's like those 3
- 10:38crowds like trying to coexist. Like the social media managers
- 10:43who need to build up their accounts in case this is the
- 10:47next big thing. The rebellion from Twitter and
- 10:49then these sort of beautiful Instagram people who are getting
- 10:53sort of like told that this is a piece of.
- 10:57Yeah, I have another theory there too, because it is when
- 10:59you sign up for the app, the the fee is all for now is purely
- 11:03like algorithmic and it sucks in a lot of like people you don't
- 11:07follow. So it's just it's a ton of
- 11:09celebrities, Like the people who are like the most famous people
- 11:14on Instagram, like literally just who has the most, you know,
- 11:18it's like Jlo and Shakira and like Gordon Ramsay, like
- 11:21celebrities that aren't even necessarily the ones that you're
- 11:23like most interested in. I don't know.
- 11:25I'm interested in those celebrities, I guess, But it's
- 11:27just like huge followers. And I do think there's a thing
- 11:30to where a lot of those celebrities are excited to be on
- 11:33there and posting. And for now they are like Paris
- 11:36Hilton is posting and you know, all these sort of celebrities,
- 11:40it's a little bit cringy to watch because they're not quote,
- 11:43UN quote good at it. But I do think that there's a
- 11:45segment of these, like traditional celebrities who had
- 11:48a lot of success on Instagram that never really figured out
- 11:51how to, like, transfer that over to TikTok, which is slightly
- 11:54more allergic to like a movie star post.
- 11:58You know, it's like the Kardashians aren't big on
- 12:00TikTok, you know, but they work really well on Instagram, not on
- 12:04TikTok. And I think that there's
- 12:06probably a lot of enthusiasm from those big celebrities who
- 12:09have not found TikTok success. And are sort of clinging on to
- 12:14Instagram relevancy because they know it's important for their
- 12:17careers to have a big social media following.
- 12:20And so they're probably excited to get on to this.
- 12:23And then, you know, fans and regular people are excited
- 12:27because they see all of a sudden celebrities, which haven't
- 12:30posted to Twitter in years, Like celebrities have left Twitter a
- 12:34long time ago. I mean Adam Mosari or Mark
- 12:36Zuckerberg. I forget which one said that
- 12:38they would have. Sort of a chronological feed and
- 12:42sort of a follower feed, which would be key to sort of creating
- 12:48some of the stuff that media likes, which is like news stuff,
- 12:51and also just being able to follow like niche interests
- 12:55without being just in this warmy sort of fray.
- 12:58I don't know what are people's views on like, I don't know the
- 13:01algorithmic feed. Like I think the average person
- 13:03does want an algorithmic feed, right?
- 13:05Or I think so too. I think there's a reason that
- 13:08they've continued to have an algorithmic feed on Instagram
- 13:11for years is because like, test after test after test always
- 13:15shows that that's what people actually want.
- 13:18I think what he was saying is like that, you know?
- 13:20I mean, there's like a ton of really seeming basic features
- 13:22that aren't on there. There's no DM ING, There's no
- 13:24like. Yeah, I don't think so.
- 13:28You think you can only search for people you can't search for
- 13:30like turn like words. And so it sounds like they will
- 13:33add more stuff including probably I'm guessing it would
- 13:36be kind of like how you could toggle between you know even on
- 13:40Twitter like for you versus following is probably what it
- 13:43would be like. That would be my guess.
- 13:46I mean that seems to be like a logical thing.
- 13:49I will say that like having used it for.
- 13:52Over a day and following some more people that are people I
- 13:56actually want to follow my feet has the celebrities have sort of
- 13:59calmed down it's like adjusted a little bit like the algorithm is
- 14:02sort. Of Part of the reason you're on
- 14:03this podcast is for a second. Like you know.
- 14:06Four out of like 7 of the things in my feed were you at one
- 14:10moment. You know, it's just like, I mean
- 14:12I I posted this, but it, you know, it, it does feel like it
- 14:16swings from like brands to people you just followed to like
- 14:20models like one second to the next where it's like, it almost
- 14:24feels like there's somebody like sitting there with a dial trying
- 14:27to figure out what's on it. Oh yeah, they probably.
- 14:30They have no idea what they're doing right now in terms of
- 14:32what's going to work. So I'm sure they've got a bunch
- 14:34of engineers just crazily moving sliders around trying to see
- 14:38like, oh, the topless, the topless is big.
- 14:40Give more to topless. They're like, no, no, they don't
- 14:42like it. They hate it.
- 14:43Back off. It's what we're losing people
- 14:46that Paris Hilton. I mean, I what I did like in
- 14:49that first day, especially like in the morning when it was like.
- 14:53You know, really no one knew what was going on and people
- 14:55were just logging on for the first time.
- 14:57I sort of realized that there was this rare opportunity where
- 14:59like you could post incessantly and like because essentially
- 15:07people's feeds were quasi blank and also largely filled with
- 15:11like celebrities or you know. The Bitches account like things
- 15:15like that, that like it would be really annoying if I did that on
- 15:18like Twitter, like that is not an acceptable behavior.
- 15:21It would be viewed as annoying. But somehow in this like rare
- 15:24moment, I feel like I was able to kind of do that and like get
- 15:27away with it a little bit. But I was also like I was doing
- 15:30a bit like I was like pretending that I.
- 15:32Was that's the best. It's like, oh, I'm posting too
- 15:34much because that's the character I'm right, who's
- 15:37shameless. Yeah, I was pretending to be the
- 15:40editor in chief of threads, so I would be like.
- 15:43You know, retweeting or reposting Gary Vee, you know,
- 15:47who's kind of like I roll, right?
- 15:49Like they. They took down one of your posts
- 15:51already, right? Yes, yeah.
- 15:53What did you say? Without looking at it in front
- 15:56of me, someone asked me, you know, as editor in chief.
- 15:59And it was like a little bit of a mixed bag where like, I think
- 16:01most of my friends knew I was kidding, right?
- 16:04But like, clearly, like, also some people who didn't know me
- 16:07from Twitter at first was like most of the people you know that
- 16:11I knew or whatever. Some people didn't.
- 16:12And they were like, they believed it.
- 16:13And that was like a little bit funny because I was also, in my
- 16:16opinion, posting things that were kind of obvious to us,
- 16:18right. Well, that's.
- 16:19Like a huge feature that was always the thing on Twitter, you
- 16:22know? And I've got in fights with
- 16:23people about this where it's like, you know.
- 16:27The in Group 40% gets us the joke, but 60% of people maybe
- 16:30don't and it gets traffic in part because of the confusion.
- 16:34But then the sort of in Group gets to laugh at the rubes who
- 16:37should obviously get it and like it just it's like a recurring
- 16:40joke at this point on this type of.
- 16:42Yeah, social. Network anyway.
- 16:44So that was, that was kind of what was happening.
- 16:45So some people were taking it seriously and someone said are
- 16:48you going to ban the Nazis and like.
- 16:51It's a legitimate question, right?
- 16:53Because like this has been an ongoing issue with social
- 16:56platforms that you know how they are addressing moderation
- 16:59issues. And I wrote back something like
- 17:02Threads is, you know, we want respectful and inclusive
- 17:06conversation here at Threads. And so we respect People's
- 17:10Choice to lead a Nazi lifestyle. So we are inclusive and like
- 17:15heart emoji. Well, there's your answer.
- 17:21I mean what's so great about a post like that is that, you know
- 17:24Katie, that not lowlevel people had to have a discussion about
- 17:27whether or not to delete this and how this reflecting poorly
- 17:31on the brand. I would even venture to guess it
- 17:33went all the way up to Zuck at this point at this point, not
- 17:37that there was an emergency meeting held, but like you know
- 17:39these decisions at the early stages are very sensitive and
- 17:43there were policy people that had to come down.
- 17:46And have discussions about your shit posting and that's not
- 17:49something you will probably get to have happen again for a
- 17:52while. I know I'm did.
- 17:53They tell you. Do you have visibility into
- 17:55this? A high level executive messaged
- 17:59me and was like, do you have any idea how many questions I've had
- 18:02to answer about whether or not you actually work here?
- 18:04Yeah. Yeah, I did ask Instagram of
- 18:07Adam Miserri wanted to come on the podcast with you, but he
- 18:10declined. It's probably for the whys
- 18:12though. Yeah, the issue was Katie, not
- 18:15newcomer. Yeah, I'm blaming her, you know.
- 18:18Yeah, sure. We, yeah, we would have bumped
- 18:21Tom. No, I mean there's so much to
- 18:22get into on the moderation and I want to talk about Twitter,
- 18:25Verzian Musk, but this sort of like will it succeed.
- 18:28I think will help. I'm curious where we're all on
- 18:30the spectrum of success because obviously you know Sub Stack had
- 18:35notes there was blue sky, there are all these Mastodon things
- 18:38like we you know and. We all lived during the pandemic
- 18:42where like Clubhouse, which is a different type of app, but
- 18:44people were very convinced that that would be the next thing.
- 18:47And we've lived through these periods where there's sort of
- 18:50desperation, especially among the social media or the Twitter
- 18:54addicted for like a new one and just to keep it going.
- 18:58So there's obviously this sort of startup energy that exists
- 19:01that has to play out to see, but where are you both on?
- 19:07You know, is this going to be bigger than Twitter?
- 19:10Is this going to be the Uber to Twitter's lift in a year?
- 19:15I predict yes. Tom.
- 19:17Twitter in its current state like not Max Twitter.
- 19:20Like not Twitter when it was at its peak in terms of users.
- 19:23Like Twitter is the company today, Yeah.
- 19:25Oh yeah, that's such a low bar. Yeah, that's such a low bar.
- 19:29I mean, I haven't read the latest leaks on how many users,
- 19:31but I'm assuming it's really plummeted.
- 19:33Throughout the so we. Already I agree.
- 19:35I mean, so we all agree that Threads is like Coke to Pepsi or
- 19:39like at least. If not, does anyone think like
- 19:42Twitter is like going to be more like a true social level where
- 19:46it's not even seen as a sort of pure mainstream social platform
- 19:52or? I don't know.
- 19:54I mean, I I do think that if Threads continues to succeed and
- 19:58have lots of users and lots of celebrities or whatever, like I
- 20:02do think that. I mean, like, there's going to
- 20:04be people who cling to Twitter because there's lots of things
- 20:07that Twitter can offer that threats can't.
- 20:08Like you can't really be, like Anonymous.
- 20:12It's, I mean, I don't know. There's also like, people who
- 20:15really care about their large followings that existed on
- 20:18Twitter that they like, can't bring over.
- 20:21There was just Adam Masari had just like Threaded posted about
- 20:27how like that they're not really going to imagine this as a place
- 20:32for news. And that they sort of see it.
- 20:34That's why, right. And and so I think that like, I
- 20:39mean, I know why they don't want to do that right.
- 20:41Like news and politics like sucks for the platform to deal
- 20:45with. Like it's a bad business to be
- 20:48in. So like Twitter may still have
- 20:49an edge there. One thing they've come out of
- 20:51the gate with is that, you know, they were very like we're going
- 20:54to be nice. Like I think part of the
- 20:56complaint about Elon among many is just that he's been sort of
- 21:00like mean spirited and sort of encouraged.
- 21:02A mean crowd. So you know, Medic can just say,
- 21:05oh, this is going to be the Nice platform.
- 21:07And you know, to them I think Nice also includes like not that
- 21:11sort of mean news media sort of sensibility, you know what I
- 21:16mean? So I'm curious what you guys
- 21:17think about that. And also there's this like
- 21:19broader question I think in my mind, which is just like do you
- 21:22think fundamentally like sort of the personality, like these
- 21:26narrative questions like the actual behavior of Elon Musk,
- 21:29the positioning of like Facebook in terms of.
- 21:32Being nice and what they're going to include.
- 21:34Do you think that is really that determinant here or do you take
- 21:38more of the view that like product rules, everything, it's
- 21:42sort of the Instagram connection and that it's really sort of the
- 21:46tech hookups that matter more than these like big like
- 21:48personality type narratives? I think that it's like a little
- 21:53bit of both. I think that the reason that
- 21:55threads will be successful is because it's the product and
- 21:58it's Instagram. And most people don't know that
- 22:01Facebook owns Instagram still. So I don't think that people are
- 22:04really the average person who's going to sign up for threads in
- 22:08this, you know, probably by the weekend will be 100 million
- 22:12people or whatever is like he's really thinking hard about like
- 22:15Zuck versus Elon. On the other hand, the reason
- 22:18that people are fleeing Twitter is because of Elon.
- 22:21And on Twitter everyone's aware of who he is.
- 22:24And I mean he's. Such a huge.
- 22:26I would love to see data on the percentage of.
- 22:29The conversation that is about Elon, because it does feel like
- 22:31if you're on Twitter, it's just like there's a ton of Elon stuff
- 22:35like it'd be hard to imagine. What he saw to it that that's
- 22:38the case, right? I mean, there are other stories.
- 22:40Yeah. Yeah.
- 22:41He was worried when his post didn't get he was his own cat
- 22:43turd. I mean, what's funny here is
- 22:47like, if you look at the history of Facebook copycat features,
- 22:51they're usually in response to like existential threats or
- 22:54perceived existential threats, right?
- 22:56I mean, stories is the most obvious example.
- 22:58And if you talk to like the Snapchat people, they'll say
- 23:00that like what stories really did to Instagram wasn't so much
- 23:03like kill Snapchat is that it stopped people from fleeing
- 23:07Instagram or or Facebook to Snapchat like it.
- 23:09It stemmed the tide of people leaving it and that's all it
- 23:11needed to do. And 2nd order effects like it
- 23:13probably slowed down its growth, but with twit slowed down
- 23:17Snapchat's growth. But but with this like Twitter
- 23:19is obviously not a threat. This was not done for any reason
- 23:23other than. Like Zach was like.
- 23:25It's sort of sad we don't have like a billion person like
- 23:28global like Forum and like Twitter's had its chance for
- 23:32like a long time and now we're going to try.
- 23:35Yeah, but it's also there's it's just clearly, I actually think
- 23:37Katie you've talked about this before there's just certain
- 23:39limitations to the text based medium that is just not going to
- 23:44get. I mean pictures are more fun.
- 23:45They're more globally appealing. Anyone can court absorb.
- 23:49The, you know, enjoyment through a picture more so than like the
- 23:52language and the miscommunications and all this
- 23:54shit that comes with text. And I just don't think at this
- 23:57point, however many years since the the dawn of Twitter, this
- 24:01format is suddenly going to reach a billion people or appeal
- 24:03to a billion people. It's just not.
- 24:05There's no product fix for it is what it is.
- 24:08It is what it is. And we're also probably past the
- 24:10era of billion person social media networks anyway.
- 24:13Like TikTok. I mean, like, I'm not, I'm no,
- 24:15like, social media reporter. I'm not even a great thinker
- 24:17about this topic. But like, it's clear that we're
- 24:19in an era of like diffusion and social.
- 24:23Like like more niche social media experiences that are going
- 24:26to appeal to certain subgroups that want to experience things
- 24:29through this way. And so the idea that like this
- 24:31many years after the dawning of Twitter, Facebook or Instagram
- 24:35leading into the product is suddenly going to create.
- 24:38All of the fixes that these companies weren't able to do
- 24:40before and now there's a billion people that want to use it, It's
- 24:42just like it's it's not going to happen.
- 24:43And that's an unfair bar. Like I think for this is just
- 24:46opportunistic, you know, like they just kind of flicked this
- 24:48thing off over a couple of weeks and it's already got 70 million
- 24:50users, like that's already success for them.
- 24:53Don't you think? I think 1 narrative that has
- 24:56been underplayed so far is just that, that this sort of TikTok
- 25:02algorithmic sorting. Could work well in like a
- 25:06Twitter case, right? Because they're so bite sized
- 25:10that if you're really learning smartly what people want using
- 25:14sort of machine learning and a I you know, you could, without
- 25:18necessarily relying on their followers, deliver to them what
- 25:22they want. Not necessarily with real time
- 25:24news, but at least like over time like what what types of
- 25:27jokes they find funny. And so I do think starting with
- 25:31this algorithmic feed. Gives them a lot more
- 25:35opportunity and just sort of the sophistication of a Facebook to
- 25:40actually play in sort of the smart sorting in a way that
- 25:43Twitter's never really been capable of it.
- 25:46And then I I'm more Billish that you know there's the market here
- 25:50especially with Facebook's like global reach that that it could
- 25:54get to sort of you know, 500 million plus.
- 25:58Certainly I don't know, Katie, what do you think?
- 26:01It's the difference between like words and pictures, right?
- 26:03Like, I do think there is a limit on how many people want to
- 26:07write text posts. I don't know about you guys, but
- 26:10like my like real friends like ignore me friends like none of
- 26:14them were on Twitter and like, they never were like.
- 26:16And. They described this happiness
- 26:19and contentment they feel. Right.
- 26:21I've been like and oh, some of them may have like a lot of
- 26:23them, like at various, you know. Signed up sometime between like,
- 26:27you know 2009 and 2012 or something and then like read a
- 26:31couple posts but like didn't find that much value in it.
- 26:34Never had to desire to write tweets, but they're all on
- 26:38Instagram and some of them post, some of them don't really post.
- 26:41But I think for a lot of people they're like I don't have like
- 26:43an opinion about a thing that I'm going to write, but like I'm
- 26:46want to share a picture of my dog, you know, like that just
- 26:49like feels more normal. So I do think there is like a
- 26:52limit to like how much a text based thing can like.
- 26:55Explode. But I also think that I can see
- 26:57how it sort of lives nicely as like it exists alongside
- 27:01Instagram. Because Instagram is sort of
- 27:02like lacking in like text stuff. Which is why for a long time, a
- 27:08lot of the biggest meme accounts on Instagram, which were hugely
- 27:12followed like the fuck cherry kind of stuff, we're just
- 27:15screenshots of tweets because people do want like, funny.
- 27:19I'm using jokes and so. Those are all on Twitter, so
- 27:22they would consume them on Instagram.
- 27:24So, like, it makes sense that there's some connection and
- 27:28marriage between the two. I mean, the irony of course, is
- 27:30like, what if there was like a platform where you could like
- 27:32write text posts and post pictures and like, that's just
- 27:35Facebook, but like, no one wants anymore.
- 27:39Right. I mean there is always this
- 27:40undercurrent of like people just want to move to the new thing
- 27:43and like is there just sort of appetite to sort of?
- 27:47Start a new and have something new that's cool.
- 27:49And if Facebook wants to stay on top, it just needs to keep sort
- 27:53of shifting, You know, offering new places, new new ways to sort
- 27:57of build the norms early. Another key factor that
- 28:00shouldn't be overlooked is that it's always most successful to
- 28:04launch this kind of app in the summertime because that's when
- 28:06kids are out of school and it's like all teenage.
- 28:08Be real of 23. Right, exactly like this would
- 28:12not have worked if they launched it in March, like during final
- 28:15season. Like, if this works because it's
- 28:18like the teenagers are allowed to use their phones at 11:00 AM
- 28:22when they're normally not. And that's like a huge amount of
- 28:26who's on these apps is like young people who normally would
- 28:29be in school. And so like it's right now, it's
- 28:31like a perfect the timing of this couldn't have been better.
- 28:35Whether or not like that will totally sustain, you know,
- 28:38through the fall is, you know. I imagine obviously it'll slow
- 28:42down, but I don't see it going away like a clubhouse
- 28:44necessarily. Yeah.
- 28:46And also Facebook can keep this thing up and running with not a
- 28:48lot of work, right? Like if this thing tops out,
- 28:51like it'll probably get to and then it'll and then it'll, you
- 28:54know, lose users and it'll maybe get down to like 50-60.
- 28:57Seventy, I think it's already at 70.
- 28:58But you know, these people will attrite.
- 29:00So like, it'll get to that number and Facebook can keep
- 29:02this up and running. It's probably a low cost thing
- 29:05to, you know, keep operating with your cloud computing costs
- 29:08and. Maybe it has some like side
- 29:10order effects is like an ad platform but for Facebook it can
- 29:13just be like a hobby of a hobby and it won't be that hard for
- 29:16them to keep it up and running and that's perfectly successful.
- 29:19And if it hurts Elon and like whatever, you know Silicon
- 29:22Valley Dick measuring contest that's going on right now, like
- 29:25great. All the more for it.
- 29:26Facebook stock, you know, the stock market does not think
- 29:29there's a huge product. It's up like 3.1% basically over
- 29:34the last five days. So.
- 29:36There's definitely a shrug from investors.
- 29:39I I don't know, I I, I'm. Because it's not a great
- 29:42business. Twitter was never a good
- 29:43business. So if you build a smaller
- 29:45version of Twitter, what you know, they're they're interested
- 29:49in like the longterm effects of you know, Instagram's growth and
- 29:53and they're doing well right now, right, Like Facebook or
- 29:55Meta has been like in an upward swing this year because you
- 29:59basically the they've sucked up as like the ads have moved away
- 30:03from the bigger media companies like BuzzFeed.
- 30:06And you know, float almost entirely into digital media.
- 30:09You know, you know the big social media platforms, they've
- 30:12seen huge, you know, tailwind effects from that.
- 30:15And so that's interesting to investors, whether or not they
- 30:18build a semi successful competitor to a dying social
- 30:21media platform like Twitter, like who gives a shit?
- 30:23It's totally irrelevant to investors.
- 30:25I mean, it's the same story Twitter's been trying to sell.
- 30:28It's like home of elite culture. It's tastemakers, you know, it
- 30:31decides. Yeah, it's where apparently
- 30:33that's not a good business. Succession of the world.
- 30:35So yeah, I know. I guess Twitter couldn't make it
- 30:37work. These things fit together.
- 30:39We can do them one by one or or separate.
- 30:42I feel like there's the like the free speech fight and sort of
- 30:45like what we actually think will happen in terms of the
- 30:48importance of these like global platforms.
- 30:51You know, like Katie you've already been censored like
- 30:54Instagram did famously have like a pretty heavy hand right with
- 30:58it. You know, like they're very
- 31:00particular on. The level of nudity and pretty
- 31:03harsh in terms of how they censor people.
- 31:06And it's not, you know, Instagram never really saw
- 31:09itself as like this sort of free speech like Mecca, you know what
- 31:13I mean? And then after that, let's talk
- 31:15about the sort of Zuck versus Elon, the whole thing.
- 31:17But it it fits into their personas and sort of this, I
- 31:21don't know, I guess to put a point on it.
- 31:23Are you worried that there's a lot of especially media
- 31:27enthusiasm for threads right now?
- 31:31And then we're going to wake up one day and it's going to be
- 31:34super censorious like anti news and like suddenly the press is
- 31:41going to find themselves back on this side of like free speech
- 31:44and say like hey, like Katie's making like a very obvious joke
- 31:49about like Nazis and we should allow some like level of
- 31:52sophistication. What's your view on how we're
- 31:55going to view threads politically like 3 months from
- 32:00now? I do think that, like for the
- 32:03average user, they want a nice clean environment.
- 32:08They don't want the assholes and the baddies and the paid blue
- 32:12check types on there. They don't like those people.
- 32:15Those people are mean. They're nasty.
- 32:17You know the riff, raff, whatever.
- 32:18So like the sanitized Instagram experience is.
- 32:23Good for most people. Exactly.
- 32:25I mean, that's I've been beating my head on the Twitter thing,
- 32:27right? Elon has said when he was
- 32:29acquiring Twitter that he wanted to represent like the middle
- 32:3190%. But the Normie middle loves
- 32:36censorship, right? That was the whole sort of like
- 32:39video game reviews. You know, there were Democrats,
- 32:41there were Republicans, Everybody was for, like, rating
- 32:43things. And it's the far fringes that
- 32:46are like, let's have a Wild West, you know, and and so
- 32:50Twitter. Elon clearly preferred the sort
- 32:53of Wild West. But like, yeah, I agree the vast
- 32:55middle is sort of like happy to not really think about speech
- 33:00policies. Right.
- 33:01Because I think that most people aren't, in a general sense, that
- 33:05interested in the kind of things that are getting censored
- 33:08anyways. And what they really want is
- 33:11they don't want to deal with assholes.
- 33:12They don't want harassment. They don't want, like random
- 33:15people showing up and saying mean things to them they don't
- 33:18want to, you know? And I think that the Elon Musk
- 33:22version of Twitter was certainly an interesting experiment in
- 33:26expanding the definition of what free speech on a platform should
- 33:31look like. You know, I think two different
- 33:33opinions of how successful. Yeah, I don't know.
- 33:37I mean, like, I do think they're like ultimately, like, yeah, Oh
- 33:40no, Are we all just going to be back on like a meta platform?
- 33:42Like, we we forgot we hate meta. Like, it's evil.
- 33:46But I think that, like, you know.
- 33:50Compared to how bad this other thing, you know that we all are
- 33:52sort of like flocking back to like, well, there's this nice
- 33:55safe experience where no one is like mean and nasty and I'm not
- 33:58going to see like, you know, some Mogga hat types.
- 34:02I mean Meta are professionals at this, you know, they do know how
- 34:05to run a social media company. They do sort of think about it,
- 34:09they they certainly have done, they've messed up and prioritize
- 34:13growth sometimes above sort of caution.
- 34:17But yeah, Tom, what's your view? I never have much to say on like
- 34:21the censorship aspect of these platforms.
- 34:23I think it won't really matter until it reaches some level of
- 34:25significant scale and influence in the broader media where we're
- 34:29like, Oh my God, look at all the Nazis that are, you know, coming
- 34:33together on threads right now to disseminate harmful information
- 34:38and and. You're not worried about over
- 34:41censorship or you're not worried about under censorship?
- 34:44I'm just not worried about either.
- 34:45No one really knows how to use these platforms yet and what the
- 34:49specific audience that will come to Threads ultimately will look
- 34:53like. So yes, Facebook clearly knows
- 34:55how to turn the dial more towards censorship and pull
- 34:58things down, and they're obviously more worried about
- 35:01their broader brand as a company than they are about the success.
- 35:04And the direction of free speech on threads.
- 35:06So if they start to see that this becomes the, like, Proud
- 35:10Boys watering hole, then yeah, they'll fucking tank all of
- 35:13those things without a second thought about it.
- 35:15So no, this is not going to be the the Elon Musk hour version
- 35:19of things. I'm kind of interested.
- 35:21But Katie, have you spent much time on spaces in the in the
- 35:24last couple of months? I've heard that that is like a
- 35:26pretty horrifying place of racist conversations and we do
- 35:31underground conversations. It's sort of.
- 35:34It's funny because, like, you can go on there and see what,
- 35:38like, you know, most people like the top space of what the moment
- 35:42is or whatever, and it's usually like weird people you've never
- 35:46heard of and often about like crypto or like hustle or that
- 35:49kind of stuff. I, you know, I mean, I was just
- 35:52thinking that. I think, I think, I think with
- 35:53censorship and like, I kind of agree.
- 35:54Like the like, you know, fighting over the, you know, one
- 35:58inch of lying about, can I say this word or not is like sort of
- 36:01irrelevant almost in the US because like all the really like
- 36:06horrible stuff that has happened as a result of like Facebook or
- 36:11whatever is, is in other countries where there's much
- 36:14lower moderation because maybe they don't have that many like.
- 36:18Contractors that speak the local language and so you know there's
- 36:22all this crazy stuff that happens that you know there's a
- 36:25genocide because they forgot to moderate in this small country
- 36:29somewhere else. As far as I know, threats is
- 36:30not, it's US only for now and that's partly they can't be in
- 36:34Europe because of the the EUGDPR stuff.
- 36:38But I mean I wonder too if it's that they are going to be very
- 36:41cautious with rolling out globally because.
- 36:44The moderation outside of the US is like so much harder, and
- 36:49that's where the real problems are.
- 36:51Seems like people are gonna be able to get access.
- 36:53I feel like people are definitely tweeting.
- 36:55It's like I'm in Europe right now.
- 36:56I have it. I wonder if it'll be like the
- 36:58age gating where it's like you're not supposed to, you
- 37:01know? Suck is like a very key part of
- 37:03the early threads experience, and he's not an interesting
- 37:06poster. He never really has been.
- 37:08I mean, I know that. You know, hardcore posters like
- 37:10Katie and and people who really know how to do this stuff have
- 37:13been critical of Elon for being pretty cringe.
- 37:15And if you look at someone like, say Donald Trump who's like so
- 37:19good, you know, Elon really isn't very funny.
- 37:21And and you know, there's a lot of, you know, crying emojis that
- 37:26to speak a deeper insecurity over there.
- 37:29But Zuck is much worse. Like if your early experience
- 37:32with Threads is seeing Zuck kind of in and out of stuff, they've
- 37:35got to turn that dial down a lot.
- 37:37Because he's not. This is not his medium at all.
- 37:40I wonder what's gonna happen with that.
- 37:42I mean there there is something weird going on with suck in
- 37:45general. Like, I mean, I think you did
- 37:48want to talk about the whole, like the martial arts thing.
- 37:52Like there's a little bit of a like midlife crisis element
- 37:56going on that he's. Always.
- 37:58I mean, there was that, you know, the BBQ meme, like he's
- 38:01wanted to sort of be sort of character.
- 38:06But he's roundly rejected by the broader public.
- 38:08That happening is good for the platform.
- 38:10They want it to be friendly to normies like.
- 38:12In some ways I feel like his replies mostly serve the
- 38:14function of pay attention to the thing I'm replying to.
- 38:18And even if he's sort of like pretty meh, it like draws
- 38:22attention to that thing because it's the CEO of the platform and
- 38:26I just don't think we want another world where like.
- 38:29It's the CEO, the company that we're thinking about constantly
- 38:32when we're on the platform. You know, I yeah, that would be
- 38:35a nightmare. I mean, that's part of what's
- 38:37made Twitter so terrible recently.
- 38:39Right. Is that Elon loved Twitter so
- 38:41much that he needed to buy it, whereas that's clearly not the
- 38:44case with Zuck here. But I'm interested in the
- 38:46midlife crisis conversation if that's where this is headed with
- 38:50Zuck right now. I don't read it that I don't
- 38:53know you guys. You don't think of it?
- 38:54I mean, I I think that it's like.
- 38:56I guess not. Maybe not midlife crisis, but
- 38:59you know, I mean, like, there's been some weird new things,
- 39:01right? Like all of a sudden, I mean
- 39:03he's he's done these things of, like, he's had odd fascinations
- 39:06with new hobbies every year or whatever.
- 39:09But now, like being really into martial arts is like feels kind
- 39:13of like final form of like, I don't know, it's weird.
- 39:18Well, the 1st. One I've seen from him that you
- 39:21know is very much driven by. It like there's no broader
- 39:26marketing push that clearly it's a part of because if you look at
- 39:29like the previous ones there was like I'm going to kill my own
- 39:32meat which was I don't maybe there's some environmentalism
- 39:36behind that or or connection to you know, people who don't have
- 39:40insane like you know he was doing that at the time that he
- 39:42was becoming a hyper billionaire and so maybe he felt trying to
- 39:45connect to with the layman and then.
- 39:47His learning Chinese for a year. I mean, that one's pretty
- 39:50pretty, you know, not a lot of subtext.
- 39:52I'm gonna visit every state and that was kind of like.
- 39:56Yes, and it was around. An election cycle.
- 39:59That's what everybody was saying.
- 40:00He was gonna run for president, which was, like, absurd.
- 40:02In hindsight, yeah, yeah. I don't remember actually.
- 40:05There was like a book club at some point, so he clearly didn't
- 40:08have a lot of good ideas that year.
- 40:09But no, but this one is is the first one that seems, first of
- 40:12all, that I could see it happening for a good number of
- 40:15years. And you know, he's really
- 40:17putting himself out there on this one, right?
- 40:19I mean, he's. You know, fundamentally I I
- 40:22think especially as reporters we should be cheering for these
- 40:25people to be out there. I mean it's good like I mean
- 40:28it's it's insane how much they can gobble up sort of people's
- 40:32attentions. But I want more like, you know
- 40:35public figures to sort of live semi transparent lives.
- 40:40I don't know you you disagree or or or do you think the lives are
- 40:43so fake that it's like. There's no public service here
- 40:46because we're not getting sort of a real glimpse of.
- 40:50Them. No, I don't think it's fake.
- 40:52I mean, like, insofar as that, like, I think we can all agree
- 40:55like, it sucks like a weird guy, right?
- 40:57Like, and they say. This of the social network.
- 40:59Right. Like, not only that, but like,
- 41:01he's been so rich for so long. Being like, I have a human hobby
- 41:07now is like, you know, like. I think the funniest thing is
- 41:11like, there was that video of him doing.
- 41:12I like, I can't remember what martial art is.
- 41:14Is it jiu jitsu that he does but like he's doing in like in like
- 41:18a high school gym or whatever Like it's like clearly like the
- 41:21weird like rinky dink like. Well, my favorite thing is the
- 41:23New York Times had this subplot in one of their stories where
- 41:26it's like Zuck got like. Choked out.
- 41:29And then like they, like, vociferously denied that they're
- 41:33like, absolutely not. Like, yeah, Mark, like wrote an
- 41:36e-mail, you know, they're like, no, I never got choked out, you
- 41:40know? Well, their initial source on
- 41:42the choked out was the ref from that match and I didn't realize
- 41:45this, but his determination that suck had been choked out was
- 41:48that he was in some sort of like triangle arm bar or some sort of
- 41:51jiu jitsu hold and he began snoring.
- 41:54And I guess that's an indication that you've been choked out,
- 41:56which I look, I'm not like a martial arts watcher, but if
- 41:59that's a real thing that like if you're down, you just start
- 42:02snoring. Yeah, that's.
- 42:04Fascinating. Because, like, their denial had
- 42:07to be. He wasn't snoring.
- 42:08He was, it was effortful, grunting.
- 42:10Yeah. I think they had like a really
- 42:11specific phrase, but it was, I think it was like one of the
- 42:14first times that like. Suck had like commented directly
- 42:17on a story about him to the Times in like years or
- 42:20something. Yeah, what one person snore is
- 42:22another person's effortful grunting.
- 42:24Who knows? But so, you know, hey.
- 42:26There wasn't video. He has this whole thing now.
- 42:28We're like, he and Elon are sort of playing at this idea that
- 42:33they're going to have some sort of wrestling match, which is
- 42:36like. Never gonna happen.
- 42:37No, it's never gonna happen. And I can't tell if the like, I
- 42:42can't tell how I feel about it. My, my gut says cringe.
- 42:47Like, is it just the like the play acting of like I'm gonna
- 42:51fight? Well, I love the like.
- 42:53They both have to act like the other is the one who would pull
- 42:57out, right? I mean, ultimately it was Elon's
- 42:59mother that he used as a pretext not to do it.
- 43:03What? Any.
- 43:03OK, we have a couple other things I want to cover before we
- 43:07wrap. But make a prediction or like,
- 43:09let's offer some sort of prediction about how this plays
- 43:12off. Zuck versus Elon the Cage.
- 43:15Zuck. Versus Elon Threads versus
- 43:17Twitter. Like, I mean, now Twitter's
- 43:20threatening to sue. I don't know any creative.
- 43:23Well, that's I can make a strong prediction on that one.
- 43:25I mean, they have a history of making.
- 43:28There's a lot of Saber rattling that goes on from Elon's lawyers
- 43:31when it comes to lawsuits. I've gotten to see that a little
- 43:34bit when they threatened to sue Microsoft over.
- 43:37You know, over over usage of their API and stuff like that.
- 43:40And Yvonne is not exactly a huge winner at the courts these days
- 43:43too, so I'm not expecting anything on there.
- 43:47It's hard to not see Twitter. It's funny, I was told before
- 43:50going on this podcast I shouldn't veer too much off of,
- 43:53you know, reported material. But it's hard not to see Twitter
- 43:56as like continuing its precipitous decline and not just
- 44:00because, you know, threads could or could not be a huge hit.
- 44:03It's just the product decisions aren't getting any better.
- 44:07It seems like, you know, business wise.
- 44:09Literally died. I mean, it feels like they
- 44:11rushed it. I mean, I think that I've seen
- 44:13reporting that Facebook rushed this out in part because, you
- 44:16know, they were doing the rate limiting with Twitter.
- 44:19And so people were so mad at Twitter that it was like, Oh my
- 44:22God, we need to seize on this. So definitely my my point of
- 44:26view would just be like whatever happens.
- 44:29I feel like even if, you know, Threads wasn't super successful,
- 44:33the decline of Twitter is just. Going to continue.
- 44:37It's inexorable and they're playing not very smart games
- 44:40with their cloud computing bills and you know that's just
- 44:43ultimately going to result in more downtime.
- 44:46And the people that were on the fence about this thing, like the
- 44:49one thing you can't overcome is a non usable product, but you
- 44:52can have as many, you know, policy decisions and algorithm
- 44:55decisions you want. But if the thing doesn't load
- 44:58and you can't post, there's not a lot going for it.
- 45:02Twitter had become a pay to play app, like basically you.
- 45:05You paid money to them and you get to annoy everybody else.
- 45:09Katie, any you have any predictions for?
- 45:12I yeah, I think that like Twitter.
- 45:16I think it's going to get weirder in the next six months.
- 45:20Like a lot of people are going to leave.
- 45:22A lot of people are going to see Threads as like a perfectly
- 45:26serviceable exit, you know, that will scratch the itch for
- 45:30something to open on your phone. When you want to read a few
- 45:32jokes, they'll, you know. Leave the Celebrities will
- 45:38probably start posting less because ultimately, like,
- 45:42celebrities will find it not that rewarding to do text
- 45:45posting. And I think, yeah, like I think
- 45:48that Twitter will just get like weirder and weirder and more
- 45:51insular because you're going to be left with like, only the
- 45:54real, like the true freaks. The real posters.
- 45:57Does that include you, Katie? I'm genuinely curious because
- 46:00you're so like you built your career.
- 46:02In many ways. I think I'm being so good on
- 46:03Twitter. And and kind of defining a
- 46:05certain voice there. And I sort of see Someone Like
- 46:07You being like I'm out as a real death knell for any version of
- 46:13Twitter that I ever found interesting.
- 46:15Well, there certainly are people like myself who, you know,
- 46:18especially like journalists who spent a decade building up a
- 46:21large following on Twitter so that when they tweet out their
- 46:25stories or whatever, people click on them, they get sources
- 46:27that way. You know, losing that is going
- 46:30to, like, suck, you know? Like this was a great tool for
- 46:34me professionally. Hopefully I will still be able
- 46:38to to do work without it, but. But do you think you're gonna
- 46:43dual app or what's your? Do you have a plan?
- 46:45Yeah, I mean, like, I guess. I mean, it's it's weird.
- 46:48It's like, there's been so many moments where I've been like,
- 46:50this is the moment everyone's gonna leave Twitter.
- 46:52I mean, like, I don't. I think so many people are like,
- 46:55I don't want to leave Twitter. But eventually it's gonna.
- 46:58The thing that will make me leave is not that one day I'm
- 47:01going to say that's it. I quit.
- 47:02I can't take it anymore. It's just gonna as.
- 47:05Other people. As other people that I care
- 47:07about leave, it's going to be less interesting to open and
- 47:10literally within. The last day you see a friend
- 47:12that you fall. It's like a lot.
- 47:14You're not like breaking up, just like one day.
- 47:16It's a slow with them, right? It's just it's like.
- 47:18Oh, I guess that was the last one, you know, I didn't realize.
- 47:21Yeah, I mean, yeah, like, even in the last day since.
- 47:26Threads launched I like and part I mean I think the rate limiting
- 47:30that happened last weekend 2 weeks ago when people hear this
- 47:34like was that really like I think was a big like it was it
- 47:40became like, I like, I'm just not going to bother with this
- 47:43app And so I just even on Twitter now you can get real
- 47:46ghost town vibes. They're like have been being
- 47:49ghost town vibes for the last six months but really really now
- 47:53like. I'm just not seeing that many
- 47:55people that I know or like posting.
- 47:59I can see that there's lower engagement on my own posts, like
- 48:03it's just it's less and less fun.
- 48:06Eventually we'll get to the point where I don't feel like
- 48:08opening it as much all. Right.
- 48:11I want to talk briefly about each of your reporting or Katie
- 48:14really. I mean you you were such you
- 48:16were a diehard buzzfeeder. I mean you really stuck with
- 48:19them as things got rough. And, you know, represented some
- 48:23of the best of their reporting. Always such a creative and
- 48:26wonderful writer. I'm curious, what's your plan
- 48:29right now? Are you, are you definitely
- 48:31staying in the reporting biz? I mean, you sort of made a joke
- 48:34about Ben Smith, you know, giving you the, what was the
- 48:37wisdom Ben Smith had? He was like, oh, if you have a
- 48:40bunch of rebels, do you like, you know, you give them station
- 48:43posts basically in the new regime so they're occupied and
- 48:46then they don't cause you trouble.
- 48:48And you were saying, like, oh, now I.
- 48:50I can have the real heart of a poster.
- 48:51I'm not a journalist. I'm only like, yeah, I don't
- 48:54know, is there a world where you're like, oh, this influencer
- 48:57world or something? I'm interested in that.
- 48:58Or what do you think about sort of the reporter influencer
- 49:01divide and what's what's your ambition at?
- 49:04The moment I think that I will probably continue to be in
- 49:07reporting, but right now I mean I.
- 49:09The people who have been laid off of BuzzFeed News, which is
- 49:11like, it sucks and it's very sad.
- 49:13The only upside is that because it was the entire division of
- 49:17BuzzFeed that shut down, it triggered.
- 49:19This is like so boring now. It triggered the New York Warren
- 49:21Act, which means that they have to keep you on payroll for an
- 49:25extra 3 months before your severance.
- 49:28Paid to tweet on threads like that's really the editor.
- 49:31Yeah, I'm still a BuzzFeed employee for another month.
- 49:34And then I get six months of severance.
- 49:36So like, I'm sort of like relaxing for right now.
- 49:40It's beautiful. It's like a nice, personally,
- 49:43I'm finding it a very nice time, like, to be able to like take a
- 49:46break. But yeah, I was sort of having
- 49:48this moment where I was like, oh, this is such a weird thing.
- 49:50Like this new app is launching and it's very squarely in what I
- 49:55would normally be covering. Like normally I would have.
- 49:59Been reporting and writing about this and like having to come up
- 50:02with a story, but I don't have to do that.
- 50:05So instead I like did this whole shtick about pretending to be
- 50:09the editorinchief. And also like I probably
- 50:10couldn't have done that if I was like actively being a reporter,
- 50:13but. I have this whole hobby horse
- 50:15that, you know, the reporter class especially, you know,
- 50:18which I'm a part of, which came up either through newspapers or
- 50:21journalism school or whatever, who believes in sort of the
- 50:24priesthood of, you know, journalism is very defensive
- 50:27about. Distinguishing, like, the
- 50:29creator influencer world from journalists, whereas I'm I've
- 50:33become much more of an advocate of like we should collapse them
- 50:36all and hold everybody to the same standards.
- 50:38You know, if you're Lex Friedman doing an interview with Mark
- 50:41Zuckerberg or something, you should be held to your
- 50:43reputation and people should pressure you to ask tougher
- 50:46questions and all that. And like drawing some huge
- 50:49distinction between, I don't know, the journalist class.
- 50:52And everybody else is like not serving anybody.
- 50:55I don't know. Do you agree with that?
- 50:56Or like, is there a world where you would learn more into being
- 50:59sort of a creator who with journalism instincts rather than
- 51:05sort of work at a media company as a sort of traditional
- 51:07journalist? I don't know.
- 51:09I mean, like, I think I'm inclined to agree with you in
- 51:12general. I think that this was a specific
- 51:13case where, like I think have I been?
- 51:16Actively reporting on threads, and also purposely
- 51:19misrepresenting myself on threads that like that probably
- 51:23wouldn't have been OK to do while I was my boss.
- 51:26Would have been like. That's a funny joke, but you
- 51:27need to stop. I could have got it, but it's
- 51:30probably. Like and it's like you're not
- 51:32hurting. I could have got away with it at
- 51:34BuzzFeed for six hours, I think at the Wall Street Journal, 0
- 51:38hours, you know, but. But I don't have a job, so I was
- 51:43allowed to get away for it for 24 hours.
- 51:44Exactly. All right.
- 51:45That's a good transition, Tom. All right, you left the show.
- 51:48You're at the Wall Street Journal now.
- 51:50You're in authority. You, you know, voice from God.
- 51:52What have you learned? Well, since I left the show,
- 51:54I've been flourishing at the Wall Street Journal.
- 51:57I cover Microsoft and enterprise tech since I joined.
- 52:00That has basically been the AI beat.
- 52:03Like every other reporter these days, I wrote a story about AI
- 52:07and the effect that it's had on the downturn.
- 52:10That we're in right now. This is really more of a
- 52:11newcomer story, honestly, but I I kind of took the ball and ran
- 52:14with it. I I'd had some conversations and
- 52:16I was actually out of New York with some startup founders who
- 52:19were you know, people have been around the tech space for a long
- 52:21time and they were telling me that this was like a weird
- 52:24downturn. Like they've been through
- 52:26different downturnslikethe.com bust or the 07, you know,
- 52:29financial collapse and people was talking about 2015 as being
- 52:32one of the downturns. I don't I was covering tech that
- 52:35I don't really remember what happened.
- 52:36Well, they were downturn like there was a blip.
- 52:38There is a blip where value of valuation down.
- 52:41Couple months maybe anyway, but so that was actually maybe the
- 52:43weirdest one of all. But the point here was like we
- 52:45were all expecting things to look really bleak in tech for an
- 52:49extended period because of, you know, whatever interest rates
- 52:53and the decline of all the stock prices and things like that.
- 52:55And then a I happened to come along and be this incredible
- 52:58buoyant force that propped up at least a lot of the optimism
- 53:03within the tech world and and look, I'm not here to say.
- 53:06That the downturn is over and we've reached a floor and
- 53:09everything is on its way up. But it's at least been like a
- 53:11surprising turn compared to other downturns.
- 53:14And so I was just talking to people, investors and other, you
- 53:18know, startup founders who ended up raising these.
- 53:21Newcomers story. Yeah, well, I didn't see it on
- 53:23Newcomer, so I like I said, I ran with it.
- 53:26But just had a chart that showed, I think like Series C
- 53:28rounds sort of rebounding a little bit.
- 53:30Yeah, there's starting to be some evidence of private market
- 53:34improvement. Yeah, the problem with all those
- 53:36data-driven stories to make this even more boring is that it's
- 53:39all very backwards looking. And so you don't get a good
- 53:41sense of what's going on right now.
- 53:43So I actually didn't get incredible data to back up the
- 53:45idea that like, things are up and up.
- 53:47But just in terms of optimism, it was funny to hear, you know,
- 53:51how many people are expecting huge things out of AI right now,
- 53:55which like let's be clear, hasn't produced a ton of money.
- 53:58So far for everyone, right. Like it's, it's obvious or what.
- 54:01Yeah, Yeah. Yeah.
- 54:02I mean like it's you know NVIDIA clearly it's it's going to start
- 54:05to the. Voters, I just wrote about this,
- 54:06bought a company, bought case tax, 650 million.
- 54:11I mean, that's a real exit and. Sure.
- 54:13And Mosaic exits. Or that was all in stock.
- 54:16Point. Three, yeah.
- 54:18But there, yeah, the exits are there.
- 54:19So that's that's one side of it. But then I mean if you look at
- 54:22the stock prices for. All of these companies, man.
- 54:24This is a real departure from like the cage match between
- 54:27you're really. Making this, you know we.
- 54:29Get No. But I'm not.
- 54:29I'm not getting myself. God forbid people you know like.
- 54:32This is a serious business podcast.
- 54:34Now we don't just talk about media things, but but yeah,
- 54:36anyway, I you know, there's a lot of optimism and expectation
- 54:39of what AI can do. And so the piece that I wrote
- 54:41was mostly about that and and where that fits into like
- 54:44previous downturns. But I want to be clear in case
- 54:47people start thinking that I think that we're past the worst
- 54:50of things. I have no idea.
- 54:52It's very likely that we're going to see like bankruptcies
- 54:54and like a huge calling of overvalued startups that came
- 54:58around in the last couple of years.
- 55:00But a I has been like a funny wrinkle in all of this.
- 55:03So that that was my story. I mean I I've basically said
- 55:06over the last like I don't know nine months now that like it's
- 55:10the story of dueling narratives with like a I rounds like super
- 55:13up and everything else super down.
- 55:15I I think the new turn is like some of those super down things,
- 55:19you know? What's happening with with the
- 55:21rest of the market and eventually some of the
- 55:24enthusiasm out of a I will cool down.
- 55:26But yeah, it's a weird it's a weird narrative time I think.
- 55:30I mean my last podcast was with the CEO of Tech Stars who was
- 55:34pretty bleak and you know her main point was just like venture
- 55:37capital funds take a long time to fail.
- 55:40And so I think to some degree people get impatient to see sort
- 55:44of the deaths and it's like there's a big lagging indicator
- 55:47when it comes to funds in terms of the actual.
- 55:50There's also I find like the opportunism of this era to be
- 55:53interesting. And and the the story I wrote
- 55:54before that actually I did it with a colleague of mine was
- 55:57about crypto and how a lot of the crypto miners have been
- 56:00trying to pivot to a I. Because they're stuck with these
- 56:03rigs now that are completely unprofitable because mining is
- 56:07basically dead at least for for Ethereum.
- 56:09And so they're hoping that they can like somehow turn these
- 56:12things into a I compute devices and it's an interesting kind of.
- 56:17Play because there's a lot of arguments about whether they're
- 56:19even powerful enough to do it. And it really flies in the face
- 56:22of like NVIDIA which tells everyone you need to buy their
- 56:25like multi 10s of thousands of dollars expensive chips in order
- 56:29to to train your A I models. And so again, it's just funny to
- 56:32see the crypto people reemerging again, you know, the ones who
- 56:37the survivors of the last tech hype cycle to, to see how they
- 56:40can somehow make some money during this current, you know,
- 56:43craze. That, again, isn't really making
- 56:45a lot of people, you know, revenue.
- 56:48All right, Tom, Great to have you back in the podcast.
- 56:51Katie, thanks for coming on. Excited to see what happens
- 56:54after this? This BuzzFeed paid to tweet on
- 56:58or paid to post on threads. Thank you for having me.
- 57:02And there is currently an opening right now to be the
- 57:04editor in chief of threats, right since you stepped down.
- 57:07I've been. I've been fired, yeah.
- 57:09Yeah. Yeah, OK.
- 57:10So if anyone wants that job, do they get in touch with you or
- 57:13how? How do you?
- 57:14Mark@meta.com. Sweet.
- 57:19Alright, thank you. Thanks so much for listening.
- 57:22I'm Eric Newcomer. Thank you to Katie the Topless
- 57:25and Tom Deton for coming on the show.
- 57:28Shout out to Tommy Herron, our audio editor, Riley Kinsella, my
- 57:31Chief of staff and young Chomsky.
- 57:34For the theme music. Like, comment, subscribe on
- 57:37YouTube, leave us a nice review on Apple podcast and of course,
- 57:42subscribe. To the sub stack newcomer.co See
- 57:47you next week. Goodbye.
- 57:48Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 57:49Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 57:51Goodbye. Goodbye, Goodbye, Goodbye.