Latest / Bad Decisions Podcast / Higgsfield AI Banned on X, Seedance 2.0 Goes Viral, Epic vs Google $800M Deal
Transcript
- 0:00Higgs field AIX account gets banned and apparently they're
- 0:03being cancelled. C Dance 2 Point O just got
- 0:07released and there are a lot of creators talking about it.
- 0:10Epic Games and Google Secret $800 million deal gets revealed
- 0:16in federal court and that is exactly what we're going to be
- 0:19talking about today. Everybody, welcome to the Bad
- 0:22Decisions podcast, a new version of it where we bring you guys
- 0:27every week, 3 times Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays,
- 0:32Technology, AI and Business Unfiltered.
- 0:35Because we realized there's just so much happening in the world
- 0:38today. The progress and the speed of
- 0:41technology, AI and business is so fast that it's hard to keep
- 0:44up with the information. And how can you find a reliable
- 0:47source of information? Because you have your blind
- 0:50optimistic people and you're blind pessimistic people.
- 0:54The people that just hype everything that they see and the
- 0:56people who just hate it on everything that they see.
- 0:59We saw too much of that and we were annoyed by it, so we
- 1:03decided to create a show where we filter through the BS.
- 1:07And you'll tell me. To talk about what's real and
- 1:10what's not. So in the first episode, we're
- 1:13going to talk about first about Higgs field account.
- 1:15So if you've been around Twitter, you have realized that
- 1:18their account got suspended recently.
- 1:21That's right. So this is what you see when you
- 1:25go to Higgs field on X account suspended.
- 1:28And for anybody that does not know, Higgs field is an AI
- 1:32platform, it's a wrapper platform.
- 1:35And what that means is that it doesn't actually hold AI models
- 1:38itself inherently. It packages other AI models for
- 1:42the use of creative, so it holds the models of video generation
- 1:48and. Photo generation.
- 1:49So instead of going to Google Gemini to use Nana Banana Pro,
- 1:52you can go to Higgs field. Use Nana Banana Pro there
- 1:55because they have other models there that you can test it out.
- 1:58So Pratt, if you can quickly pull up Higgs field website for
- 2:02people to just see. So this is the website and the
- 2:06reason why this is such an important topic to discuss is
- 2:09because they are currently, in my opinion as a creative, the
- 2:13dominating website when it comes to creating images and videos.
- 2:18The reason for that is because their wrapper model is actually
- 2:21something that works incredibly well.
- 2:23Their UI and UX is so efficient and effective compared to the
- 2:28other competitors because they know exactly how to take the
- 2:32ugly UI of the models themselves and turn it into something
- 2:36beautiful that creatives can use.
- 2:38And I think that's super important for beginners and
- 2:41people who don't know actually how to prompt, because when they
- 2:43go to Higgs field, they are able to use different templates, they
- 2:47are able to use the different styles that has been pre created
- 2:50for them. That's right.
- 2:51So it's very easy to use for the beginners, so.
- 2:54Pratt, if you can pull up Cling's website on the side.
- 2:57So this is cling themselves. So be careful.
- 3:00Clink is not a wrapper. Clink is one of the image and
- 3:03video generation models. But if you look at the UI here
- 3:06itself and if you actually try to use this website, it's a lot
- 3:10more complex and has many features that most people don't
- 3:14know how to use. Or alternatively, they reduce
- 3:18the they don't reduce. They have a lack of features.
- 3:21If you go back to Higgs field really quickly and just go to
- 3:24the top, you'll have something called Cinema Studio.
- 3:26So let's take a look at that top right cinema studio.
- 3:29Yeah, you can go there. So for instance, this is one of
- 3:31the latest editions of Higgs Field.
- 3:34And if you go to image on the bottom left, you have the
- 3:38ability to choose from camera lenses.
- 3:40Bottom right. Yes.
- 3:41So for film makers, this was an insane addition.
- 3:45Now this is not their own model. This is an extra prompt that
- 3:49they've added behind the curtains to tell Cling or VO3
- 3:54and all these video and image generation models to use a
- 3:57specific camera type. And for a lot of film makers who
- 4:01do not know how to prompt it, Higgs Field has done the job for
- 4:05them. Which is why Higgs Field has
- 4:07gained so much popularity in the past few weeks.
- 4:11But is that the reason they are suspended?
- 4:13No, no, no, no. That was the reason why they
- 4:15became famous. But they have been suspended,
- 4:18They've been getting cancelled on X and we're going to talk
- 4:21about. Y so there is one article that I
- 4:24found, Pratt, can you pull it up?
- 4:26Yes. So shout out to Noah for writing
- 4:29this article. I think they really been through
- 4:31every single detail that what is happening with Higgs field
- 4:34nowadays. I actually agree with most of
- 4:36the point except one. But we can go through it
- 4:40together and see what are the biggest problem that are people
- 4:43facing OK using Higgs. Field, before we get to the
- 4:46problems, I just want to quickly read this.
- 4:48So for people who don't know, Higgs Field has actually managed
- 4:51to raise a shit ton of money. How much in total?
- 4:54So April 20248 million dollar seed round, September 2020, five
- 4:58$50 million Series A at a $1 billion valuation and January
- 5:042026 another $80 million extension, which actually
- 5:09explains how they became so popular because they've also
- 5:13been paying or at least promising to pay lots of
- 5:16creators to talk about the product.
- 5:18And I'm sure if you've been a creative, you have definitely
- 5:21seen your favorite other creators talk about Higgs Field
- 5:24on Instagram, on X and on. YouTube, I think their marketing
- 5:26tactics on X is really, really strong.
- 5:29That's where they put a lot of their effort and I think they
- 5:33pay a lot of creators to create videos, create images, and then
- 5:36once the feature is released immediately on X, you will see
- 5:39people trying out that feature basically.
- 5:42That's right. So I do want to talk about this.
- 5:44This is why this show exists. You see, we're not trying to
- 5:47take any sides. I'm just going to tell you guys
- 5:49exactly how I feel about this. I use Higgs field intensively.
- 5:53I love their platform. I think the platform does a
- 5:56great job of capturing and packaging all of the models
- 6:00together. And when we read this article,
- 6:02as Farad said, there's a couple of points that we agree with and
- 6:05disagree with. So First off, Farad, do you want
- 6:07to talk about the wrapper? So there's been a hate on the
- 6:10fact that it's a wrapper. Yeah, and I think there is.
- 6:12So the issue here that they raised is that Higgs Field is a
- 6:16wrapper. They are using VO3, they are
- 6:18using Cling. They don't have a model
- 6:20themselves, which I think is totally fine for beginners and
- 6:24for average users. Higgs Field made it really easy
- 6:28for people to create videos, create images, create
- 6:31commercials. I think if you have a tool that
- 6:33helps you or enables you to create whatever you have in your
- 6:37mind, that's a plus. Of course, you might pay a
- 6:39premium, but if that helps you, that saves your time, I think
- 6:42that's totally cool. That's absolutely.
- 6:43Absolutely right. For us who are tech savvy, we
- 6:45don't go to VO3 to generate the video.
- 6:47Right, we use. Different wrappers because they
- 6:50have their own global prompt, they do prompt injection and
- 6:53they make the generation better, basically.
- 6:55That's right. Although they do charge you more
- 6:58money for that. So you can imagine what happens
- 7:00is if, for instance, Cling is going to charge you a cent for
- 7:04one video, Higgsfield is going to add their own premium on top
- 7:07and charge you 4 instead of 1. And that's because you're using
- 7:11their platform and because you get all of the models in one
- 7:13platform, platform, whereas you had to naturally go to Nano,
- 7:16Bananas, Google and then go to Cling.
- 7:18So two different websites, now you get it in one.
- 7:21So being a wrapper for me is not actually the problem here.
- 7:25There are other wrappers, so many other wrappers today.
- 7:28And I think they're actually doing a service to most of the
- 7:31users. Freepik is also a wrapper.
- 7:33Wievie is also a wrapper. So there's no problem with the
- 7:36fact that it's a wrapper. I think the problems actually
- 7:38come after that. So the first thing which I
- 7:42actually kind of absolutely hate was when they released the
- 7:46motion design generation. And I think the title of the
- 7:50video was, yeah, this is the one Hicksfield AI just ended. 20
- 7:54more creative jobs, 20 more creative jobs with the first AI
- 7:58motion design tool. First of all, this was posted on
- 8:00Hicksfield's own account and how I position myself.
- 8:05If I was Hicksville, I would say that this would enable 20 more
- 8:09creative jobs because honestly, at this stage, at this point, it
- 8:12won't replace anybody in the motion design section.
- 8:15But it's not even far. It's not even about the
- 8:17replacing thing. It's about the fact that this is
- 8:19clearly a tactic to just get clicks and get controversy
- 8:24around your brand so that you can get more views.
- 8:26And the reason why I hate this distasteful tactic is because
- 8:31you're using the creative's work to train your models, and you're
- 8:36being happy about the fact that you're now replacing them.
- 8:39I think if anything, since the work has been trained on real
- 8:43artists, you should respect them.
- 8:45You should respect them. It's creatives at the end of the
- 8:48day who are using your product. I'm just thinking what you guys
- 8:52are doing is great. You're servicing more creatives.
- 8:55Why do you have to go and hate on them?
- 8:57Why do you have to go and create a comment that I'm replacing
- 9:00now? I'm replacing you now after I've
- 9:03used your work. So that's the part that I I wish
- 9:06they didn't actually do. And I think this is a trend.
- 9:09I've seen it like other people also posting 3D artists are
- 9:13cooked, artists are cooked or DJs are cooked or yeah, we
- 9:17replaced 20 creative jobs. I would say that the position
- 9:21that you take when you're using this sentences is mostly to get
- 9:24clicks and there is very little reality to actually what is
- 9:28happening behind these tools, I think.
- 9:30They've gone a little bit too far with those comments to be
- 9:32honest. The next thing that was written
- 9:34in this article, which I have personally experienced myself.
- 9:37Well, actually, before we move on, there's actually another
- 9:39video we have to talk about here.
- 9:41So this is when they talked about replacing.
- 9:45They made this video of themselves bowing down to
- 9:48creatives and saying that the guys who work at Basfield are
- 9:51giving up a month's pay so that people can get free credits or
- 9:55something like that. Which again, very cool tactic.
- 9:58But for me, it felt like a planned thing again.
- 10:02And I just don't find it honest. And if I don't find you honest,
- 10:05I don't want to work with you. And that's a problem I have with
- 10:08this. Let's move on to the next one.
- 10:10This one is the one that hurts me the most to be honest.
- 10:13So unlimited. We've been using AI almost every
- 10:17day now, whether it's for coding or image generation or video
- 10:22generation, and Higgs field is one of the platforms that we
- 10:25use. We use all the platforms at the
- 10:26same time because of bad decisions.
- 10:28We experiment with things and then we make tutorials about
- 10:30them and breakdowns and we have subscriptions with every single
- 10:35wrapper that you can think about.
- 10:37The biggest problem that I have with Higgs Field is that they
- 10:40actually started selling a lot of the marketing and by
- 10:43positioning themselves as the only platform to have unlimited
- 10:47generations for Nano Banana Pro when it was released, Unlimited
- 10:50generations for Cling 3 point O. But the truth is no one actually
- 10:55gets to have unlimited generations.
- 10:57When you pay for the plan that you pay for, let's say it's
- 11:00$24.00 or $80. That's happening actually when
- 11:03you go and press. So when you go and press, first
- 11:05of all, it says OK, if you want to create your Nana Banana
- 11:07image, you can choose unlimited or not unlimited.
- 11:11So when you turn on unlimited to use it, if you can in your
- 11:13account, it will just go into the queue and it will load
- 11:16forever, eternally, never generating.
- 11:19The moment you switch it off, then your video or your image
- 11:23actually gets generated. So as a creative or an artist
- 11:26who doesn't have much time, you're just sitting down.
- 11:28You want to create something quickly.
- 11:29And you have a deadline, right? And.
- 11:30You have a deadline. You can.
- 11:32I actually never use your unlimited credits.
- 11:34I have barely used any of my unlimited credits, which is why
- 11:38it's painful, again, because I love the platform, but you're
- 11:41lying to me even though I'm paying you money.
- 11:44And the only reason they're doing that, of course, is
- 11:45because they have to win over Free Pick and Wevy, and they
- 11:48have to get as many users as possible.
- 11:50Again, it's a distasteful tactic.
- 11:53I wish I didn't have to do this because otherwise I would have
- 11:55just loved to continue. You don't.
- 11:57Have to say unlimited. You just say like how many
- 11:59credits you have, how many you can generate.
- 12:01You can give some free or extra credit.
- 12:03They say they give you free credits too.
- 12:05Does that work? It's like 10 credits a day,
- 12:07which is nothing. It's like one or two images.
- 12:09And for an artist, I can imagine if you're working actually on a
- 12:12commercial or on a pitch or on a pre production workflow, you
- 12:16need variation. You don't generate one time and
- 12:18you don't you use it. You create one time you on five
- 12:21or six variation. If every single time I have to
- 12:23stay in the queue for my unlimited credit.
- 12:26No one does, No one does. So everyone's just using their
- 12:29credits. They run out of the credits,
- 12:30they have to buy more. Next problem that I wasn't aware
- 12:34of myself. What is this mass banning of the
- 12:36account? Yes, so a lot of people
- 12:38apparently after opening accounts and paying for a plan
- 12:41had their accounts banned, which means I assume you lose access
- 12:45to your credit so you can't generate anything although
- 12:48you've paid for the account. This I wasn't aware of.
- 12:51I didn't actually get this problem myself so I don't know,
- 12:54but if it did happen it's kind of messed up.
- 12:56Oh, the next one is funny. Stolen templates.
- 12:58I mean, I when they put it side by side, it's obvious that
- 13:02somebody copied from someone else.
- 13:05So if for example, if Jitter or Ambato created that workflow
- 13:09definitely earlier, then Hicks will definitely copy that
- 13:12because they look exactly the same.
- 13:14Yeah, we're going to talk about that when we talk about C dance
- 13:16as. Well.
- 13:18The next thing is the OK, we can skip this one, the Higgs field
- 13:22moderator, we can go straight to the next one after that.
- 13:26So the marketing itself, the. Master campaign.
- 13:28This is the crazy. 1 S We can go to the next one.
- 13:31Pratt. This has been something
- 13:34actually, this is how I believe. Yeah, they got suspended.
- 13:37No, no, this is the reason I think they reported to X and the
- 13:40account got suspended because I've seen screenshot that the
- 13:43post had hundred impressions, but 70 comments and 70 retweets.
- 13:48And sometimes it's a video. Yeah.
- 13:49So it's obvious that people haven't even watched it or did
- 13:52they don't know what is it, they just got the link and.
- 13:55They got paid to retweet. Yes, exactly.
- 13:57So they're farming for more likes, farming for more comments
- 14:00and all that. So that is a problem.
- 14:02Of course, X has a problem with that.
- 14:04But for me, it's actually how they did the whole campaign.
- 14:08And what I've heard is, is something that is honestly
- 14:12alarming because if you look at actually some of the tweets
- 14:16people have posted, some creators have done the job,
- 14:20which means they have created videos based on Higgs Field's
- 14:23comments, but they've never gotten paid.
- 14:25So the promise was we're going to mass DMV creator that we know
- 14:29whether they're small, medium or big and we'll try to offer them
- 14:32some amount of money. And I'm sure they paid out a lot
- 14:35of money because I believe the CEO, it says $20 to $1000.
- 14:38No, I mean, overall hundreds of thousands of dollars have
- 14:41apparently been paid, but I assume hundreds of thousands of
- 14:44dollars have also not been paid out because a lot of creators
- 14:47came out saying we made the content, never got paid for it.
- 14:50So I believe what has happened is they just went crazy with the
- 14:54marketing DMS and they only got to pay so many of them in time.
- 14:58And that has pissed so many people off.
- 15:00Coupled that with the marketing tactic of taking away jobs of
- 15:04creatives and coupled that with the Envato elements, copy of
- 15:09motion graphics, all those things, of course people will
- 15:12become mad. So I guess the thing I'd have to
- 15:17say about all of this is that Higgs field as a platform is
- 15:21still my favorite. It's the easiest one to use and
- 15:24so many people love it because of the presets and how it allows
- 15:29you to create more freely compared to other platforms.
- 15:32And I just wish that they we're more.
- 15:35I think it's about the company culture.
- 15:37You know, probably they expanded too fast.
- 15:39They got all these raised. They hired.
- 15:41People. No, but expanding too fast is
- 15:42not a problem. You can.
- 15:43Have you can. Expand fast.
- 15:45But you don't have to say we're replacing artists, the same
- 15:47artists who helped build your products.
- 15:49You don't have to say we're replacing you.
- 15:51Even if that is true, you don't have to.
- 15:54Say it again, Why does? Why?
- 15:56You have to be, you cannot be a good kind person.
- 16:00If you're going to start by saying we're replacing your job.
- 16:03How? If, OK, we're brothers, right?
- 16:06Will I ever go and say to Farrad's face, hey, I'm
- 16:08replacing you if I love him, I will never say that.
- 16:11So it's just for me it becomes a big question mark.
- 16:14Do they care about the same audience that is using their
- 16:18product? Right?
- 16:19It's creatives ultimately who are using your product.
- 16:22If you don't care about them, then eventually they're going to
- 16:25move on to a better wrapper, and there's only enough time that we
- 16:29need to give until another wrapper comes around.
- 16:31That could be better easily. Easy.
- 16:32With Vibe coding available to everyone.
- 16:34Not even vibe coding. With the amount of money that
- 16:37VCs are pouring into AI startups, I think somebody can
- 16:41come easily and get their templates, make it better, make
- 16:43the UI better. People are here not because of
- 16:45the model, they are here because of the UX, because of the user
- 16:48experience. Yeah.
- 16:49So if someone can come in and make a better user experience, I
- 16:53that's why I think they're pushing a lot for their annual
- 16:55package, because if you pay for the annual membership, you are
- 16:58locked in for a year. So if somebody comes in, which
- 17:02they will come eventually, probably in the next few months,
- 17:05you you will say that, hey, I've paid for Higgs field for a year.
- 17:08I'm not gonna switch. But I gotta give hats off to
- 17:11their content creation team. I think it's Adele who's the
- 17:14host and whoever's the editor and the producer.
- 17:16They turn out content like crazy easy and their tutorials are as
- 17:22good as a solo creator. Even though they're a company
- 17:26traditionally companies like this, they will not have a good
- 17:29social media account or they don't know how to make content,
- 17:31but they rival our content and we're not a company had that has
- 17:35AI models or a wrapper. They they are very good at
- 17:38content creation, which is what has gotten them to this place.
- 17:41I guess how I want to end this topic is personally, I would
- 17:45love to hear more from the team themselves.
- 17:48I believe the CEO has made a tweet.
- 17:50Yeah, he posted something today, but I don't think the tweet
- 17:53explains a lot of these problems.
- 17:55It's an overall tweet. About you're sorry the same, you
- 17:58know, statements that comes out the.
- 18:00Thing is, I don't think this is over.
- 18:01I think their account being suspended is not an eternal
- 18:05suspension. They're going to make a
- 18:06comeback. Artists are still going to use
- 18:09them. So the reason why this show
- 18:11exists is we also will bring guests in the future and would
- 18:14love to be able to speak to the members of the team or the CEO
- 18:17and the founder to figure out exactly what's happened and how
- 18:21they're going to be moving forward.
- 18:22Because a lot of the artists will lose faith in the product
- 18:26if they can't connect with the brand.
- 18:28And that's what's happening on X at least.
- 18:30I don't know about Instagram or YouTube.
- 18:32I haven't seen the comments there, but X is very much, you
- 18:34know, riled up about this whole situation.
- 18:37And I think that wraps it up for Higgs Field.
- 18:40If you guys have any comments specifically about this, let us
- 18:43know in the comments. We're gonna move on to the next
- 18:45topic. We have Seed Dance 2 point O.
- 18:49It got released and everybody's going crazy.
- 18:51We get the typical captions of Hollywood is cooked, film makers
- 18:55are cooked, movie makers are cooked.
- 18:57But if you look at the videos, they look pretty damn good.
- 19:01OK, so this is the Tom Cruise Brad Pitt fight.
- 19:03Here's a good man. He knew too much.
- 19:07About Can you make it big? He had to.
- 19:09Die, and now you die. Too.
- 19:13OK, let's watch that again. He was a good man.
- 19:21He knew too much about our Russia operations.
- 19:24He had to die, and now you die too.
- 19:27OK, pause, pause, pause model, right?
- 19:30No copyrights, so this is out. This is C Dance 2.0.
- 19:35It's not a new model. C Dance has been around.
- 19:37This is their newest version, not even publicly released yet,
- 19:41so only certain people exclusive creators have access to them.
- 19:45Or if you're in China, if you can use DOI yen to get an
- 19:48account, some people are getting that.
- 19:49If you look on X, you'll find a way to actually open an account
- 19:52and use it. We haven't tested it ourselves,
- 19:55but this, for anybody that doesn't know, is the model
- 19:59created by Bytedance, who are the creators of Tiktok.
- 20:04So Bytedance is the owner of Tiktok.
- 20:06They now have C Dance 2 point O that they're going to release in
- 20:09February. It is February or down, isn't
- 20:12it? It is February.
- 20:13So sometime in February I believe they're going to release
- 20:15it. And what is insane?
- 20:17Let's go back to the Tom Cruise one for a moment.
- 20:20We have both sides of the story. Half of the people are saying
- 20:25this is incredibly good and they're worried.
- 20:27And the other half are like, we're still not worried.
- 20:30So let's take a look at this. Rhett Reese, who says, I hate to
- 20:33say it, it's likely over for us. Rhett Reese is one of the
- 20:36writers of Deadpool. No way.
- 20:38Yeah, he is one of the writers of Deadpool and Zombieland.
- 20:42So this is not just a random somebody, right?
- 20:45And I wanted to just pay attention to this.
- 20:48I mean, just hold it right and pause the video.
- 20:51This is a fight between Tom Cruise and Brad Pitt.
- 20:53As you can see, not only do we have so many different angles
- 20:57and shots, we have character consistency in all the frames.
- 21:02We have the voice that actually sounds similar to Tom Cruise and
- 21:06Brad Pitt. Their hair is simulated
- 21:09perfectly, like when when they're punching each other, the
- 21:12sound of the punch, it has weight.
- 21:14The background itself is in LA by the way.
- 21:18So it's a post apocalyptic version or a bomb has exploded
- 21:22in LA. And I actually looked this up.
- 21:25I'm going to try to find this, but I looked up where it is and
- 21:29if you can see where it's from because clearly we all know how
- 21:33AI works. AI is trained on data, and the
- 21:37data is usually created by humans, right?
- 21:39So the reason why we have Brad Pitt's face is because it's been
- 21:42trained on Brad Pitt's face. Now, a lot of people have
- 21:45problems with that because of copyright and the fact that
- 21:48you're using somebody else's likeness.
- 21:51The fact that you have the skyline of LA with that sunset,
- 21:55that comes from images that are available publicly, that comes
- 21:59from movies and TV series that have been around for years.
- 22:03And the fact that we have the LA bridge, that's one of the
- 22:05bridges in LA that has also been filmed multiple times in
- 22:09different films. So as long as Byte Dance went
- 22:12ahead and trained on all of those films.
- 22:15All of those on top of that. Including TikTok, they can
- 22:18easily go ahead and recreate a shot like this and.
- 22:22But what is scary that this the guy who posted it said this was
- 22:25a two line prompt. How do you explain everything in
- 22:29a two line prompt? I for an image I write a
- 22:33paragraph, Yeah, two paragraphs sometimes and I really want to
- 22:38try it, but I want to see how does control work in model like
- 22:41this. If you can get this kind of
- 22:43videos 15 second videos with A2 line prompt.
- 22:45So from what I heard, I looked it up and you can input images,
- 22:49you can input videos, you can input sound as references and
- 22:53you can mention them in your prompt.
- 22:54So you can even include a sound that you want to have inside and
- 22:58it will incorporate that into the video.
- 23:00Just this is the best video model I've seen today.
- 23:04But be careful, you have to try it for yourself.
- 23:07Yeah, how many times we've seen demos and by the time you go and
- 23:10try it yourself, it's not what they show in the demo, but
- 23:14because every single video. That I've seen, yes.
- 23:17Look at the next one. Can you pull up the ice one?
- 23:20No, no, no. The ice one.
- 23:22The ice one. This is Will Smith.
- 23:26And this one, play with sound. Play with sound.
- 23:28Yeah, we got sound. It's like a fucking movie.
- 23:46It's real. Go, go.
- 23:47OK, OK. I want you to pause here.
- 23:51OK. So I still feel like a lot of
- 23:54the AI models, they mess up when they get to humans.
- 23:56The humans are easily distinguishable from real ones,
- 24:00but this shot. This is like a VFX shot.
- 24:04You got the entire destruction of the ice with an organic
- 24:08creature that moves like the dune worm I mean.
- 24:13In the winter. For anybody who's tuning into
- 24:15bad decisions for the first time, just go and look at the
- 24:17library of content that we have on our YouTube channel.
- 24:20We we are 3D artists as well, so we know how hard it is to create
- 24:24a shot like this. So if this does come from a two
- 24:27line prompt, this model is the most advanced model I have seen
- 24:31today. But.
- 24:32Wait, can you go to the comments?
- 24:33Have they put their prompt? No.
- 24:36I don't think so. Again, I'm skeptical, but let's
- 24:39try. We have to.
- 24:40Try it ourselves. We have to try it ourselves, but
- 24:42this looks really really. Good.
- 24:43Let's go look at the Will Smith first one.
- 24:45So if you guys have been first one, not this one, you know.
- 24:48Smith and Spaghetti is the benchmark for AI video
- 24:51generation. Yeah, it's like a touring test.
- 24:53It is video. So this is 2023, this is AI,
- 24:57this is the first. The first one was it runway I
- 25:00think. No, no, no, that's this is not
- 25:02runway. No, no, no, and that's where we
- 25:06were last year. And then we're going to get to
- 25:12now actually don't play this, don't play this.
- 25:17Let's go to the the spaghetti 1. So this is this is from Sea
- 25:21Dance Spaghetti Monster. Wow, it's eating itself.
- 25:37You know what I really hope, I really want to see because OK,
- 25:41now we have these capabilities. Hopefully it is what as it is
- 25:45promised, we should see films, we should see short films with
- 25:51great stories. So, so far what we have seen, of
- 25:54course, they don't have a story, they are just 15 seconds.
- 25:56But if we really have this capability, there are no
- 26:00excuses. If you are someone who might
- 26:02want to make films or short films or even commercials with
- 26:06this story, this is great. This is amazing.
- 26:09It's just that I really hope it it is what they promised it to
- 26:13be. But just because everyone has an
- 26:16oven doesn't mean everyone bakes bread.
- 26:19So I I saw this on Instagram today and it's.
- 26:21Oven and the baking thing. Yeah, so imagine this, right?
- 26:25Just because ovens came around and people started having them
- 26:29in their homes doesn't mean everyone stopped buying bread
- 26:32and started making their own, you know what I mean?
- 26:34So that's why it's, it's interesting to see how advanced
- 26:38these models have become. But I don't think that means
- 26:41everyone's going to to make their own films.
- 26:43That's the thing. Not everyone, but I.
- 26:44Would say that the creative. They know the geographical
- 26:48limitation, the financial limitation.
- 26:51I think it's significantly. The barrier to entry is far
- 26:54lower, which is what's interesting to a lot of people
- 26:56who couldn't create before. Yes, one person was saying that
- 27:01on X today that the reason why I say Hollywood is cooked is
- 27:06because till today Hollywood was the only one who could make
- 27:10stuff like this. But now we can too.
- 27:13Bollywood. Bollywood could forget about
- 27:17Bollywood. Brad, what do you have to say
- 27:18about that? You haven't seen their action
- 27:22film? They're good.
- 27:23One of the best. They are good.
- 27:24They are good. One of the best.
- 27:26Actually, we should try to make an AI Bollywood one we don't
- 27:29have. AI video generation that makes
- 27:31Bollywood movies we haven't they are already exaggerated anyway
- 27:34yeah they. Already look like they were made
- 27:36with AI because of the exaggeration levels.
- 27:39Man, they're insane. So the biggest problem with C
- 27:44Dance that people are having is, of course, the likeness and the
- 27:48copyright issue. So let's go back to the Tom
- 27:51Cruise one. But wait, the copyright issue.
- 27:54I mean, of course I have problem with the copyright issue, but
- 27:57aren't the other ones also scraping the whole Internet?
- 28:00So that's what I wanted to talk about.
- 28:02If you just pay attention to what I'm about to say here, I
- 28:06don't know. How many of you guys have seen
- 28:08the film Ex Machina Pratt. Have you watched it?
- 28:11Yeah, I watched. It OK, so for anybody that
- 28:14doesn't know, check out the film.
- 28:15It's beautiful, especially in 2026.
- 28:17Very relatable. Came out too early though.
- 28:20For it's time, yeah, 2015 or something.
- 28:22So Ex Machina is about a young programmer invited to test a
- 28:26humanoid AI created by his CEO, who's the founder of Blue Book,
- 28:32the world's dominant search engine.
- 28:34As he interacts with the AI, the young programmer, he begins to
- 28:38question whether she is truly conscious or maybe he's the one
- 28:42that is being tested. So this is the film that we're
- 28:44talking about. Definitely worth a watch.
- 28:47I want to read you guys a part of the script from the film
- 28:51because it's very relatable right now.
- 28:52So this is the conversation between Nathan and Caleb.
- 28:55Nathan is the CEO. Caleb is the young programmer
- 28:59being tested. So Nathan, says the CEO, if you
- 29:03know the trouble I had getting an AI to read and duplicate
- 29:06facial expressions, know how I cracked it?
- 29:09So he's trying to show how realistic the AI humanoid robot
- 29:13is, and the young programmer doesn't know how he managed to
- 29:15get it looking so real. So the young programmer says, I
- 29:18don't know how you did any of this.
- 29:20The CEO responds. Almost every cell phone has a
- 29:23microphone, a camera and a means to transmit data.
- 29:27So I switched on all the microphones and cameras across
- 29:30the entire fucking planet and redirected the data through Blue
- 29:34Book, which is his search engine.
- 29:36Boom, a limitless resource of facial and vocal interaction,
- 29:41The young programmer responds. You hacked the world's cell
- 29:44phones? Nathan laughs.
- 29:47And he says, and all the manufacturers knew I was doing
- 29:50it, but they couldn't accuse me without admitting they were also
- 29:54doing it themselves. This is exactly what's happening
- 30:00today, right? The reason why the only people
- 30:03ringing the alarm for the copyright issues and the ethical
- 30:07issues is the fact that they're humans that are just talking on
- 30:11X and not the companies is because every single company has
- 30:15to scrape data to train their AI model.
- 30:18Whether it's text based, whether it's photo based, whether it's a
- 30:21video base. They cannot make a model if it's
- 30:24not being trained on data. And the data comes from all the
- 30:27people in the world. And the reason why the big
- 30:29companies are not really talking about it is because they're all
- 30:32doing it. I'm not saying it's right, I'm
- 30:34not saying it's wrong. But I can guarantee one thing.
- 30:37Every single person I have met over the past two years is using
- 30:41ChatGPT without any complaints. And ChatGPT was trained on
- 30:46everyone's data, so even though we could have problems with it,
- 30:51we are all using it. I think we are past that stage
- 30:54now that you we know that all these big AI companies are using
- 30:58this data. They script YouTube, they script
- 31:00all the social media platforms. Yeah, and that's why the models
- 31:04are so good and they are getting better and better every single
- 31:06day. And I think for everyone who's
- 31:10watching and who's using all these tools, I think the best
- 31:13way is to find out what is the best use case that they can get
- 31:16out of this tool. Whether it's in their work or
- 31:18their passion project, they should use it, and they should
- 31:21learn how to use them best. So that is it for C dance 2
- 31:27point O. What do we have next?
- 31:28We have the Epic Games, the parent company of Unreal Engine
- 31:32and Fortnite, and Google court case.
- 31:35So apparently there was a secret $800 million deal between Team
- 31:41Sweeney, the CEO of Epic Games, and the Google team.
- 31:45And I want to give a back story to everybody who doesn't know
- 31:48about the lawsuit. Epic Games with Google, with
- 31:50Apple, been in fight for many years, since 2020.
- 31:54It's been 6 years now. Fortnite was removed from Google
- 31:57Play Store, Apple App Store and Epic was suing both of these
- 32:01company in courts all around the world.
- 32:03It was so big that I think Tim Sweeney missed one of the Unreal
- 32:07Fest. He usually goes there and give
- 32:09the keynote. He didn't attend because he was
- 32:11attending the court. What happened was in 2023 Epic
- 32:15Games won the case against Google.
- 32:17But now there are one article on Verge that you could see that
- 32:22that has been an 800 secret deal between these two companies.
- 32:26How does this court case work? Why it's there?
- 32:29Let us explain that to you. So the biggest problem Epic
- 32:33Games had with both the App Store and the Google Play Store
- 32:35was monopoly, the antitrust law. So when a monopoly happens, it's
- 32:41horrible for any market. And if you don't know why that
- 32:45is, it's because when you have fair competition, you will have
- 32:49small, medium and large sized businesses competing against
- 32:52each other, releasing features in an open market that
- 32:55ultimately benefits the users. But what tends to happen when
- 33:00companies become too large? They start eating up smaller
- 33:03companies. They start working together to
- 33:06squeeze every other company so that they're the only ones
- 33:09standing. So you'll only have a Google and
- 33:11an Apple. So as a user, you might think
- 33:14that's good, but ultimately, Google and Apple, being the only
- 33:16ones, can work together to decide on the prices of
- 33:19everything. So they can rake up prices.
- 33:21And you can't do a damn thing about it because there's no
- 33:23competition that you can choose over them.
- 33:26You either have to go to the Apple Store or the Google Play
- 33:29Store and that's it. So the US and other courts
- 33:31around the world came up with the antitrust laws to help with
- 33:34this. So any act that kills fair and
- 33:36open competition in a free market will have to go against
- 33:39it. That's what the law says.
- 33:41And there's two reasons why this happened.
- 33:43So I'm not 2 reasons, 2 examples.
- 33:45And I think for context, I'm going to tell you guys because
- 33:47it's really interesting. One of the first times this
- 33:49happened was with John D Rockefeller's company who
- 33:52controlled almost all of USS oil refining.
- 33:55They use secret deals with railroads to get cheaper
- 33:58shipping, hurting the competitors, buying up
- 34:02everything and squeezing all of the rival companies.
- 34:05That's one. Another one was with Microsoft
- 34:07that had a near monopoly on computer operating system
- 34:10Windows. So the government said Microsoft
- 34:13broke antitrust rules by forcing computer makers to bundle
- 34:17Internet Explorer, its Web browser that I'm sure everyone
- 34:20had to use before, and using dirty tricks to block
- 34:23competitors like Netscape. And so when this happens,
- 34:27imagine Netscape may not have been as good.
- 34:29But if Microsoft just goes against them and buys all the
- 34:32other companies to make sure everyone uses Internet Explorer,
- 34:35no one has a choice to use that but anything else.
- 34:40So the customer technically don't have a choice.
- 34:43Yeah, they will just end up with one single product to use and
- 34:47there is no chance for a new competitor comes to the market
- 34:50because they either get acquired by the big company or they will
- 34:53go out of the business in one year or two.
- 34:55That's right. So as a consumer, you cannot
- 34:57even trust the small companies because they won't last long in
- 35:00the market. Anyway, that's right, and what
- 35:02tends to happen at the end of the day is that the monopolies
- 35:05just decide on everything and they just charge the people, the
- 35:09users, a lot of money and no one can do a thing about it.
- 35:12In this case, Epic Games was everyone's sweetheart just a
- 35:17couple of years ago. Why?
- 35:18Because Tim Sweeney publicly announced that App Store and
- 35:22Google Play Store are becoming monopolies and they're charging
- 35:25developers like us, Epic Games and like all the other Indies, a
- 35:30lot of money for all the sales that comes through the App
- 35:33Store. And I understand that's a normal
- 35:35thing. Even Steve Jobs was one of the
- 35:36first ones who wanted to have a lot of percentage on the App
- 35:39Store. And that makes sense because,
- 35:41well, it took a long time for Apple to come and build the App
- 35:45Store and make sure it's reliable, it's trustable that
- 35:47developers can come there and users can come there and they
- 35:50can purchase things that can, you know, have services and
- 35:53people can easily give their credit cards and debit cards and
- 35:56feel safe. The biggest problem was the in
- 35:58game purchases. So there is a one time
- 36:00subscription but in games like Fortnite you buy coins and
- 36:03imagine every single time you buy coins through apps App Store
- 36:06you have to pay 30% to the Google.
- 36:08So not us, not the users, but Epic Games have to pay 30% to
- 36:12Apple, and that's a huge chunk that goes through every single
- 36:15purchase. So what Team Sweeney wanted to
- 36:18do was just demonstrate to the courts that this is unfair
- 36:22because maybe even Epic Games can't eventually handle this,
- 36:25but indie developers can't. They're going to die out so fast
- 36:28because most of the money needs to be spent on the game and then
- 36:31be paid out to Apple Store or Play Store.
- 36:34And that's when people started supporting Tim Sweeney.
- 36:37People started supporting Epic Games in this mission and they
- 36:41ended up winning I believe some. Of the cases.
- 36:44Some of the cases and the biggest problem appeared just
- 36:48when this news went live that throughout all of this time that
- 36:53they've been going against each other, Epic Games and Google,
- 36:56they actually had a secret $800 million deal together for, I
- 37:01don't know, six or seven years to for eight for Epic Games to
- 37:05pay $800 million to Google. So they can do joint product
- 37:09development, joint marketing commitments, joint partnership
- 37:13and then Google help market Fortnite.
- 37:16Epic also help market Android and also use epics products
- 37:20technology like Unreal Engine and Fortnite.
- 37:23So you may be asking yourself why that is a problem, and I
- 37:28understand at first it might not be a parent.
- 37:30I also had to question it myself.
- 37:32So I started asking Grok and Chachi BT why this could be an
- 37:35issue and why the judge revealed this as a problem.
- 37:38He hasn't made a decision on it yet, but he just wanted to tell
- 37:41everyone this deal existed. And the reason why people are
- 37:45now creating a lot of noise on the Internet about this topic is
- 37:50because you see, if Epic Games was going against Google for the
- 37:54fact that Google was a monopoly, now that they have a deal
- 37:57together, that means behind the scenes, this could potentially
- 38:01happen. Epic Games and Google could talk
- 38:03together and Epic Games could be like, you know what?
- 38:06We're not going to push you as hard anymore in court and try to
- 38:09win cases for all the other developers to give you more pain
- 38:13if you just help us out. So I'll help you out.
- 38:15I'll scratch your back, you scratch my back.
- 38:17I'll work with you. We have services between each
- 38:20other and I'll pay you and you promote my game and I promote
- 38:23you. And at the end of the day, I
- 38:25will not try to fuck you over in court.
- 38:28So this actually is fine for Epic Games at Google.
- 38:31But you can imagine all the indie developers are like, we
- 38:34were supposed to support you so that we get something as well,
- 38:37right? We wanted to support this deal
- 38:39so that ultimately the indie developers can survive
- 38:42throughout this Monopoly game. This is why people are sort of
- 38:47raising the alarm. But there is another angle that
- 38:49I want to look at. In the article they mentioned
- 38:52that they are making a product together.
- 38:55As we know Epic Games had Unreal Engine, the most powerful game
- 38:58engine out there that they've built.
- 39:00Fortnite on Google has one of the most powerful AI engine
- 39:04Gemini which can create video image and also a world model
- 39:08Genie that is like a word model. You can play games generates 3D
- 39:11worlds, but you cannot use those 3D words.
- 39:15Read out a game engine if you want to make a game because it's
- 39:17not VR application. It's because it's not
- 39:19deterministic exactly. So when you're walking in an
- 39:21environment and you turn around, by the time you turn back the
- 39:25world that is generated is slightly different than before.
- 39:28And in games that's a problem because if you're playing a
- 39:30Fortnite like game and you turn around and the world is
- 39:32different, it just won't work. But imagine the scenario that we
- 39:36have these powerful tools within Unreal Engine and now you can
- 39:41make words, you can make scenes for the virtual production movie
- 39:45that you're making. You can make scenes for your
- 39:47game, You can make scenes for your commercial with Google
- 39:50Gemini or Genie suite. That would be that would be the
- 39:53most powerful tool. Imagine the video generation
- 39:56with the amount of control that you have it in Unreal.
- 39:58That would be next level. I think another reason that they
- 40:01are. Talking about this deal is that
- 40:03they realize in the future probably they need each other,
- 40:06yeah, rather than they spend this amount of money fighting,
- 40:09they could be collaborating on a product which probably take out.
- 40:12Competition. So if you can pull up this, the
- 40:15tweets by Tim Sweeney himself, he's actually not shying away
- 40:20from responding to people. And I want to make this very
- 40:22clear. We are one of the biggest users
- 40:25of Epic Games products. We have the leading platform for
- 40:30education of Unreal Engine. We use it every single day, and
- 40:34we love Epic Games. Because to be very honest, even
- 40:38though I've seen the news about this and I understand people's
- 40:40stance against monopolies, I'm also against having a monopoly
- 40:43because it's never good for anyone.
- 40:46I generally want to hear more about this deal and figure out
- 40:49what the details are because the judge actually hasn't revealed
- 40:53all the details. And Tim Sweeney is probably one
- 40:56of the most humble CEOs and founders that we've seen.
- 40:59We've watched podcast from him, talks from him, we use his
- 41:02products. He's always been on the side of
- 41:04the people and the side on the side of the developers and
- 41:07creators. So I'm sure whatever he's trying
- 41:09to work out here is not dodgy. I just wanna.
- 41:12Figure out spicy details from the Epic versus Google.
- 41:15He's sharing. It he's not, he's not hiding
- 41:17from it. No, he's not hiding it.
- 41:18He's not hiding it. I really hope that we get those
- 41:22AI models within Unreal Engine. I think that would be the best
- 41:25outcome for everybody. So that's it about the Epic
- 41:31Games and Google News. We've covered all three topics.
- 41:34That was the first episode. Yeah, All right, Pratt, can we
- 41:37go back to the our hands are just like, all right, there you
- 41:41go. So that was it for the first
- 41:44version or the first episode of this version of the Bad
- 41:48Decisions podcast. Ladies and gentlemen, as you
- 41:52know, this is gonna come back to you every Monday, every
- 41:55Wednesday, every Friday. And it will be available on
- 41:57YouTube X and Spotify. If you guys want us to cover a
- 42:01topic, just leave it in the comments.
- 42:03That's right. And we will be.
- 42:06Responding we will be covering we will be covering it one more
- 42:10thing if you guys are watching this right now, whether you're
- 42:13watching it on your phone on your laptop on your computer,
- 42:16whether you're on the couch or in your bedroom or in the car on
- 42:19the commute because that's the whole purpose you can be
- 42:21anywhere you can listen to this or watch this make sure you guys
- 42:24go ahead and record it tag us on Instagram or X.
- 42:27We'd love to see how you guys are watching or listening to
- 42:29this, and we'll share it as well.
- 42:31This is the first of a great series.
- 42:35I cannot wait to do more of this with Farhad and Pratt.
- 42:38And yeah, thank you so much for watching this video.
- 42:41Also if you have any friends that you think would benefit
- 42:43from knowing about. These send it over.
- 42:44Send it over to them. So that's it for today, ladies
- 42:47and gentlemen. We'll see you guys on the next
- 42:48one. Ciao.
- 42:49Ciao.