Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 14)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserve listeners. This is chapter fourteen in our deep dive on the
- 0:05Dugger family and the what one could call it a Christian cult called IBLP,
- 0:12and all the other topics that are branching off from there, of which there
- 0:17are many. Let's get into it. What do you say, Berta,
- 0:19Let's do it. This is the psychology stat of podcasts. I am doctor
- 0:23Kirkanda. I'm a therapist and a professor. And this is my new shirt
- 0:26that some people call peach and others call salmon. Berto, who will you?
- 0:30My name is Umberto cas and I grow hydrophonic couch potatoes. So this
- 0:36follow up is to read comments on YouTube and also emails. I have curated
- 0:43a list of these emails and comments that are informative. It's not just a
- 0:48bunch of comments. It's not every comment or every email. I learned a
- 0:52lot, and I wanted to share what I learned from these people to you
- 0:57all. Okay, So the first comment from YouTube is from kay w D.
- 1:03They say this is a great deep dive. Just one little correction.
- 1:07Although the parents claimed it was Josh who came forward, remember that. Yeah,
- 1:11Although it was the parents that claimed that Josh came forward, without being
- 1:17caught. Presumably that was actually a pr strategy. Oh, in actuality,
- 1:23one of the daughters woke up to him doing it. She punched him in
- 1:26the face, then she told her parents. He referred to her later as
- 1:32a goodie two shoes and a tattle tale. After that, Bertie, what
- 1:36do you think? You know? It's weird. Why did we give the
- 1:38benefit of the doubt because they actually had mentioned I don't remember which one of
- 1:44the many things I watched they were talking about that incident where it's like,
- 1:48oh, you know, you didn't expect it from her because I guess maybe
- 1:51she was like quiet and mild manner, but she really socked them or something
- 1:53like that, Like they were talking about this, but I didn't connect the
- 1:57dots. I just yeah, I believe that. I was like, yeah,
- 2:00yes, it's good that he came forward. Yeah, and I believe
- 2:05I remember saying this is their story. Yeah, And we don't know,
- 2:08but and this is a comment on YouTube, so we can't even necessarily know
- 2:12if that's accurate, but it does it's more likely that that's what happened.
- 2:16It's not typical for someone to come forward unless there was some reason, right,
- 2:23And we never heard of that, like he had some something happened where
- 2:28he was like, oh crap, I'm going to get caught or you know,
- 2:30the pattern just doesn't really fit with that. If he had done it
- 2:34once then maybe, but he apparently had been doing it for months, if
- 2:38not years, So why then just randomly Well one of the victims, the
- 2:44sisters, maybe was old enough to actually stand up for herself. This next
- 2:50email is from Patron Patricia. I believe so they say regarding Josh's cheating.
- 2:59Remember in twenty fifteen, I believe he was caught, Yeah, Ashley Madison,
- 3:05and then he came forward saying he had a pornography addiction. Even though
- 3:07we don't know if it was a pornography addiction, he was cheating anyway.
- 3:12Regarding Josh's cheating, Anna, his wife was blamed by the Duggers and the
- 3:16church. She had gained she had gained quite a bit of weight after having
- 3:22your kids. When when she was moved in, when she was moved in
- 3:25with Jimbob, I think after the infidelity came out and he was away at
- 3:31some Christian camp of some sort when she moved in, when Jim with Jimbob,
- 3:37she started and and you know, God forbid a woman lived by herself,
- 3:39you know, you know, when she was moved in with Jimbob,
- 3:44she started exercising and dieting a lot to lose that weight, and she did
- 3:47lose the weight quickly. She's on camera saying that she got into shape for
- 3:53Josh so that she could welcome him home like a warrior who was battling sin
- 3:58while at the rehabilitation center, which by the way, was run by a
- 4:02fundamentalist church in Illinois, Berta, what do you think, you know,
- 4:06I feel like I mentioned not I didn't know that detail, but I feel
- 4:11like I said something or I was thinking how basically they would probably think it's
- 4:15her fault. I was actually going a different route with it though I didn't
- 4:18know about the weight. I thought they were simply going to say, well,
- 4:23if she were providing for him as a wife, then you know,
- 4:26he wouldn't have to do anything with this stuff. Well that's pretty close.
- 4:29Yeah, and it could have been that. Yeah, literally, and yeah,
- 4:32again this is a comment or an email. We don't really know,
- 4:36but it seems definitely possible. Right well, because it goes with the theme.
- 4:41The whole theme of the construct is guys are generally trying to do the
- 4:45right thing, but the devil's just so evil and tempts them so badly,
- 4:49and it's up to women. Women really are that last line of defense.
- 4:53And if they drop their guard, what are the guys going to do?
- 4:56Like, you know, yeah, And of course, to remind my myself
- 5:00and maybe everyone else that is listening that when you are born into this high
- 5:05control cult that is constantly telling you, regardless of gender, that you don't
- 5:11matter as children, your only job is to serve the organization or the church
- 5:17or the religion or and then when something bad happens, you don't have access
- 5:24to wait, is this my fault? You know, because there's already gonna
- 5:28be a lot of self blame anyway for people, even if you strip away
- 5:31culture in all likelihood. But when you have that upbringing, then of course
- 5:36it's like, yeah, this must be everything is related to sin, and
- 5:44there's there's you know, there's always consequences for things, so any bad thing
- 5:47that happens to you, you know, could be conceivative as like I must
- 5:51not have been a good enough Christian and part of my and I don't know
- 5:56if we heard this, but you can imagine part of women's duties, either
- 6:00implicitly or explicitly, is that because they're supposed to have a lot of kids.
- 6:04Yeah, so you have a quiver full. Right, Well, it's
- 6:08probably least implicit that they have to be attractive absolutely to their partners. Right.
- 6:14But that's a great point because the whole idea is you got to cover
- 6:18up, cover up, cover up. But once you got your husband,
- 6:20you got to keep them interested because you know, you got to have those
- 6:24kids, and you know it's not up to the husband to be interested like
- 6:28you. Everything comes back to that, And you know the other thing is
- 6:31just even having been Catholic in Colombia, I was actually also familiar. I
- 6:36think everyone was familiar with this feeling of guilt. You always feel like if
- 6:41bad things happen, it's probably because you were sinning. We were little me,
- 6:45my cousin out of Diana, and my cousin Alejandro. We were all
- 6:48having fun at Dana's house. We're jumping. I'm probably like ten, maybe
- 6:51eight, and we're jumping around, having a great time, and we're actually
- 6:55jumping off of my older cousin's bunk bed. Phone call comes in and it
- 7:01turns out my our uncle our mutual uncle had been in a horrible car wreck
- 7:05because someone had drugged him at a bar and he nearly died, and us,
- 7:11well, we did. We started crying and then we blamed ourselves.
- 7:14We were like, it's because we were breaking the rules. We were jumping
- 7:17off the bed. Oh my gosh, and we were seriously like like,
- 7:20we've done this to our uncle, you know, but that mentelly was not
- 7:25uncommon. Something we did caused the bad thing to happen. And I would
- 7:30say that that's pretty normal without that, even with kids. Yeah, sure,
- 7:33yeah. And then you layer on the because we started praying. We
- 7:36literally got our knees. We started like, I'm so sorry, We're so
- 7:39sorry. Right because in for example, with divorce, I would work with
- 7:44kids who would blame themselves and hopefully there are people around, including the parents
- 7:49would say no, no, no, no, no, it is not
- 7:51your fault. But when you have this all encompassing bubble that is surrounding you
- 7:57telling you, yeah, going on here, Anna wrote in and said,
- 8:03your lovely rap Kirk about the Christian side. Hug Christian side, hug,
- 8:09give it Christians side, lmao. My high school teams were called the rough
- 8:16Riders, because our high school was Roosevelt, So the Roosevelt rough Riders.
- 8:22So do you know who the rough riders were, Teddy Roosevelt, Right,
- 8:26yeah, it was his army units or something. You know, back then
- 8:31they would have rich people or nobles or lords or whatever who would have their
- 8:37own crew of soldiers that were knights of the round tables. Right. There
- 8:43was still a remnant of that, apparently during the Spanish American War, which
- 8:48is what he fought in around the turn of this. This is like the
- 8:52movie Tombstone. You know, it's a you got you got your little posse,
- 8:56right, and then you just sign up as a as a group and
- 8:58you or given uniforms. And then I actually had looked up what rough rider
- 9:05could refer to urban dictionary sort of thing, and do you know what it
- 9:09said? Well, I imagine it was like, you know, they were
- 9:11riding their horses and they're rough. Can you imagine it relating to sex inside?
- 9:18Oh yeah, maybe yeah, like fairly aggressive butt sex or something.
- 9:28Well, it's more mundane than that. It is not wearing a condom apparently.
- 9:33Oh. I thought I was like, there's another term too. Oh,
- 9:35there's a lot of terms. Yeah, bare back rough Rider anyway,
- 9:43I looked up Rough Riders, but then I think someone else commented that their
- 9:48mascot is the Rough Riders patron Robin. She says, Hi Kirk. I
- 9:52was raised Warmon and I found that it may have made me incredibly anxious about
- 9:56seeing nudity on TV and and in movies, specifically when seeing it around other
- 10:03people. My self esteem isn't great, and when my partner goes to the
- 10:05movies, I find myself googling the movie he's seeing to screen it for nudity.
- 10:11I have this intense fear that if he sees another woman naked, he
- 10:15will realize he doesn't want to be with me anymore. And this causes me
- 10:18a ton of pain. I was wondering if you could dissect how Mormonism ties
- 10:24into this possibly, how can I handle this fear, both on my own
- 10:28and with my partner? Berto, What do you think? Yeah, this
- 10:31reminds me of the Flap. I mean, because a brief history goes the
- 10:37flap. Come on, we all, so, I'm in I'm a freshman
- 10:41year in college. My new girlfriend is going to a different college, your
- 10:46current wife, future wife, your current wife new girlfriend at the time,
- 10:48and we just really started dating. And I was visiting her floor. She
- 10:54lived in the dorms, and I was visiting her floor and the door right
- 10:56across from her they had a a picture from Playgirl cut out on the on
- 11:03the door, but they had a strategically placed little flap flap, a little
- 11:07car yeah paper that you could lift, and uh, you know, I
- 11:13was I thought it was hilarious until I realized, Wait a minute, did
- 11:18she lift the flap? Did you lift the flap? Well, and back
- 11:20then you were a lot more insecure and a lot more jealous. For some
- 11:26reason, this like Madonna thing kicked in. My mother kicked like a lot
- 11:31of weird psychology kicked in for me to like day if I dayifi holidify this
- 11:39girl into like, well, she needs to be pure, she needs to
- 11:41be you're currently yeah again, we're just starting to date. So there was
- 11:48not even a semblance of a thought that would be married. So it was
- 11:50just like my new, recently acquired girlfriend. And yet for some reason something
- 11:54triggered in me and I was like, no, no, I gotta this
- 11:56person needs to be super pure and pretty. Ask you well, I literally
- 12:01was like, did you lift the flap? It's like did you order the
- 12:03code flap? And it's like, goddamn right, I did. But it
- 12:09was you can't handle the people, you can't handle the flap. But it
- 12:13was very weird because it was that same thing that that's being described, which
- 12:16was a fear of like, if they see this other nudity, they'll be
- 12:24well. In my case, a lot of it wasn't just seeing the other,
- 12:28it was seeing anything sexual. It was like, basically, they need
- 12:31to be pure, they need to be unsullied. What does that mean exactly?
- 12:35That's what I don't. I mean, okay, I I know on
- 12:39the surface, there were a couple of things because I had just recently broke
- 12:41broken up with my previous girlfriend because in fact, I felt that I had
- 12:46sinned deeply and had betrayed my Catholic vowels and all these things. I didn't
- 12:52know that you were still thinking that, like, oh I was super Catholic.
- 12:54I mean, I knew that, but I didn't know you were,
- 12:56oh yeah, interesting. So I felt, dude, I felt like I
- 13:01had I was going to hell. I felt horrible, horrible. So it's
- 13:05possible that with your current wife then girlfriend, you're thinking, in order for
- 13:11me to retain this attachment, and you know, this shadow of the abandonment
- 13:18of my mother is hanging over me, and I need to not sin like
- 13:24that. I need to do the right thing, and I need I need
- 13:28us to not say I need someone like that. And if this person's going
- 13:31to be impure, then that must have been it. But of course I
- 13:35wasn't going through all these things, you know, in my head. Literally
- 13:39it was just a feeling. And then I think there was another layer to
- 13:43it, which was probably like having seen my father's behavior when I was a
- 13:48little kid, and there was a lot of controlling behaviors there. So I
- 13:52think I was modeling that as well. But why on her because she reminded
- 13:56me of my mom? Probably I don't know. Again, I never used
- 14:01to be like that. Then I was like that with her, And ironically
- 14:03she was like the least the person I would have had to worry the least
- 14:07about in the world in that regard, like about cheating on me or something.
- 14:11But I keep forgetting wrought it out, Like there's one question. I'm
- 14:16guessing I must have asked this before. Did she lift the flap? Well
- 14:22she might have, but her I didn't. She barely remembers this. Yeah,
- 14:30but she probably didn't because she also that's the other irony. She was
- 14:35in fact a pure little Catholic girl too, so she probably was like too
- 14:37scared to lift the damn flap. I wish she had looked the flap,
- 14:43but yeah, it was. It was weird. So it could be both
- 14:48a purity thing of God will smite us if we're not pure, or an
- 14:54insecurity thing in security, jealous purity everything a her not wanting to be with
- 15:01me, controlling and also controlling like I need to control the situation. Yeah,
- 15:07well we only you know, people say controlling, but it's really an
- 15:11offshoot of the previous two things. People don't. People don't control just because
- 15:15they want to. No. No, In my case, it's I want
- 15:16need to control because I don't want this mother to leave, right right,
- 15:20So I'm going to impose boundaries so this mother doesn't leave. Yeah, yeah,
- 15:24and you do call her mother like Mike pans. But again, what's
- 15:28so bizarre is we're talking about like, oh, this is right, but
- 15:31the context back then it's like, imagine you just start dating someone. What
- 15:35what Isn't it fascinated that sometimes people's personalities and some imperceptible nuances trigger these super
- 15:43deep reactions and emotions in us before we're ever even half conscious about why.
- 15:52Yeah, wouldn't it be nice if a different set of ideas had been presented
- 15:56to you growing up? Yeah? Yeah, Well my response to you is
- 16:03the following Robin. Number one is that in these groups, it is essentially
- 16:11told to you over and over and over and over again that all men are
- 16:15essentially compulsive rapists. If they see skin, they have no control over their
- 16:21behavior, and it's not their responsibility to fix that. It's women's responsibility to
- 16:26solve that problem by not showing skin or by saying Nike, Nike, Nike,
- 16:30Nike, that kind of thing. So that is that's brainwashing, and
- 16:36that's cult and doctrination. And for you to have a husband who you love
- 16:40to go to a movie theater that might involve, you know, that sort
- 16:45of thing, then of course you believe that that'll unleash some sort of that
- 16:51that compulsive rapist inside of him, because that's what you've been told. You
- 16:55know, when I was taking notes on this burdo it, you know,
- 16:56I wrote that down and I was like, well, that's probably going to
- 17:00but that's essentially what they were teaching, right, they were teaching that boys
- 17:03are compulsive rapists because even if even it's not just that they're attracted to you,
- 17:10yeah, but they won't be able to control themselves. Well, and
- 17:12then if you say no, right, and it's even worse in a way
- 17:15because you're calling it rape and they might have, but actually what they would
- 17:21say, like, well, no, they're compulsive because they can't help it.
- 17:23They wouldn't even think of it as rape, even though it's literally rape,
- 17:26right, and because it's still the woman's fault at that point, right,
- 17:30they're just acting on the thing that you made him act on. Because
- 17:33there's no talk about well, if you dress like that, you might incur
- 17:38men's attraction to you. And then a girl twelve year old razor, Well,
- 17:42but what if I don't want to do anything with him? And I
- 17:45say no? They don't talk about that, no, because if they answer
- 17:49that question without this premise, they would say, well, yeah, I
- 17:52mean, especially because they're not talking about random people. They're talking about their
- 17:56own you know, congregants, right, They're talking about Bobby down the street,
- 18:00or Bobby's sitting right there, and so don't put Bobby in that situation,
- 18:04he's not going to be able to control HM. So that is,
- 18:07you know, that's brainwashing. So and then of course the boys are brainwashed
- 18:12to believe that that's the case for them. The other thing that I don't
- 18:17know if you experienced this, Robin, but there's a notion in a lot
- 18:21of these organizations that there's a very slippery slope to evil, and if you
- 18:27look at something that is impure or law, it's just a matter of time
- 18:33before you're just sliding down that slope and you become addicted to porn and everything
- 18:37falls apart. So that would of course raise a lot of anxiety if he
- 18:42is going to a movie theater and he might see what could be considered you
- 18:45know, it's it's not called pornography, but it's pornographic a naked person in
- 18:52an R rated movie or something. Number three is you're taught, of course
- 18:56that sexuality outside of marriage or procreation and is totally against God, and a
- 19:00lot of bad things happen if you step outside of that. And so to
- 19:04have your husband experience some sort of sexual experience while he's away from you is
- 19:11of course, with that brainwashing terrorized. You know, it's very scary.
- 19:15Yeah. Number four is that women are made to feel dirty for having curves,
- 19:21for having a body. Right, It's this notion of your body is
- 19:26evil and men are so you have to cover it up. It's disgusting and
- 19:30men are going to want it, which is also evil, and you're evil
- 19:33by extension, you know what I mean. It's there's a lot of just
- 19:37shaming of just being being a woman, especially like as you're developing as a
- 19:42teenager. But it also, Robin sounds possibly like it's just good old preoccupied
- 19:47attachment, you know, and you are worried about losing your attachment figure,
- 19:52and so you have a preoccupation with the anxiety about that. So you know,
- 19:56I don't know, all right, but let's take a break. We
- 19:59get back more or emails and comments. What do you say, Let's do
- 20:02it all right? Back from the break. So this next comment on YouTube
- 20:11is from Quti Yoli. They say, cuti jolie. My parents also had
- 20:15the belief they couldn't be alone with the opposite sex after they became religious.
- 20:21I remember one time a female family friend called my father frantically needing help,
- 20:26but my mom wasn't home, so he took ten year old me to chaperone.
- 20:33I was upset because I had a lot of homework, so I complained.
- 20:37He said, especially when a woman is as this distraught, we have
- 20:42to be extra careful. She might do anything in this state for comfort.
- 20:48She might do anything in the state for comfort. You're here to protect against
- 20:52that. Oh. Oh, you know it's weird because before that statement,
- 20:57I was about to slight defend this because I was thinking, you know,
- 21:02actually it's not a bad idea to to not put yourself in compromising situations like
- 21:08and you know, I speak from firsthand experience, having put myself in too
- 21:12many dumb situations in my life. But I mean, like, if you're
- 21:18if you're like, if you think something might be awkward or sexually charged or
- 21:22something, and you want to just like, you know, bring your kid
- 21:25along so nothing happens. Like I actually think that that's maybe wise. But
- 21:29then the statement is like, well, you know, if women are in
- 21:33these hysterical moments, you don't know what could happen. It's like, oh,
- 21:36okay, okay, yeah, never mind, what is it Bathsheba or
- 21:38something? Yeah, isn't it David or something? Right, And it's like
- 21:42this assumption that basically and this is almost kind of the it's just the same
- 21:48theme. First of all, like women are just gonna tempt you. They're
- 21:51going to they're the ones offering you the apple, right, Like, let's
- 21:55just remember that that's the case. And plus they're not rational actors, right,
- 21:59they're especially in these moments, they're gonna they just throw at yourself like
- 22:03you don't know, and what are you gonna do? You gotta yeah,
- 22:06Anonymous Patroon. She wrote in and said, I grew up with Jimbob and
- 22:10the others. I was there when I was there when a small group of
- 22:14us went to IBLP as young teens. And I think, oh, this
- 22:19is my own notes, And basically I think what she's saying is Jimbob was
- 22:23was one of them. So a group of teens that went to IBLP when
- 22:29it was just a fledgling clice. So so this person's older, like they're
- 22:33Jimbob's age, right, right, I have I have since left the belief
- 22:38system and on Bardo, You're right, Oh, it takes many years.
- 22:44It takes many years to figure out what is reality. And every once in
- 22:48a while I still get triggered that everything that I think is true is actually
- 22:55sorry, and every once in a while I still get triggered that everything that
- 22:57I think is true is a actually not true. It gave me heart palpitations
- 23:03when I first saw that you were going to be covering the Dugger saga chiming
- 23:07in here. I got a lot of that sort of thing. Yeah.
- 23:12I even talked in person with a few people that were telling me that once
- 23:18they saw that we were covering it, they were like, oh, close
- 23:21for comfort, and they had to talk with their therapists for a while and
- 23:26maybe not even listen to it because that's incredible. Yeah, just because of
- 23:30how hard it was. One person even said, you know, she was
- 23:34like, intellectually, I know that you and Berto would have a good take
- 23:40on the whole matter, but I couldn't risk if it wasn't because I love
- 23:45your podcast so much that I would I would be devastated if you said something
- 23:52like, well, you know, it's pretty healthy in the end. I
- 23:53mean women are like that, let's be honest. Yeah. Also, because
- 23:57of her history and trauma of being betrayed in this way, she had an
- 24:03emotion or a trauma echo of well, you know, you can't depend on
- 24:10other people. They're going to betray you in this way, They're they're going
- 24:12to side with the cult over your feelings intellectually. She's like, really sure
- 24:19that that's not even And she even talked to the therapist about this, Oh
- 24:22wow. And whenever I hear this, I'm always like, well, of
- 24:27course the therapist is going to say, don't listen to that stupid podcast,
- 24:30like what are you doing? Like, I don't know why. I always
- 24:33think, really, yeah, what, yeah, well that's fascinating. Well,
- 24:37because we're not super buttoned up and serious all the time, and I
- 24:41have, But it's not the kind of would you say that to one of
- 24:45your You wouldn't say that to one of your clients. You might say,
- 24:48like you might say something like, well, be aware of maybe what things
- 24:51you're listening to, what kind of inputs you're doing, Maybe I'm channeling my
- 24:53therapist. But it would have been it wouldn't have been like you can't listen
- 24:56to Rush Limbaugh. You know, well, at the very lea, I
- 25:00wouldn't expect a therapist just compared us to Russia them up. Yeah, I
- 25:03wouldn't expect a therapist to say what this person told me, which was that
- 25:08the therapist said you could you know, you can trust him or something like
- 25:12that, like actually seemingly from her description, encouraging her the client to actually,
- 25:18yeah, that's a little surprising too. I would have expect that more
- 25:21neutral nuance. Take Yeah, and maybe it was more neutral, but it
- 25:25was definitely in the encouraging side of things. But I could see it too,
- 25:27like, well, listen normally, but Bardo is on the podcast,
- 25:30so yeah. So reading this sense again, it gave me heart palpitations.
- 25:37When I first saw that you were going to be covering the Dugger saga,
- 25:41and my therapist had already been gently pressing me that maybe I should unpack the
- 25:45influence of this stage of my life. It was hard for me to see
- 25:49the remaining holdover issues. But after listening to your thirteen hour deep Dive,
- 25:55just chiming in, it's more than thirteen hours, it was thirteen chapters.
- 25:59Yeah, I see after listening to all of the Deep Dive, I see
- 26:03much more clearly where I have some sorting still to do. So thank you
- 26:08both for that. Berto, What do you think that's great? I mean
- 26:11again, I think full disclosure if I were, because I was in therapy
- 26:18for many years, I think listening to people talk about the things that I
- 26:22was trying to process. Would have been very helpful to me. Now,
- 26:26I know we don't cover every topic at all times, but since we have
- 26:30covered a lot of topics, I think for me, I would have found
- 26:33it valuable. So I think in this case, even if we were getting
- 26:37the wrong takes, because we often do right well you do, But even
- 26:41if we're getting the wrong takes, the discussion is still as long as you
- 26:45can you know, you know, make sure you're not being overly triggered in
- 26:48things. The discussion can help you think out loud yourself. At least that's
- 26:52how I experience when I listen to things on that I care about, that
- 26:57that might be related to my I traumas or my issues. Is it still
- 27:03continues that conversation for me. So I see a value there. Yeah,
- 27:06I hadn't thought about that when you put it that way, And of course
- 27:07that would make a lot of sense that overall, for people that are in
- 27:12the midst of a very important chapter of their therapy, that it would be
- 27:17something, you know, like watching just a regular TV show might feel irrelevant
- 27:22given what you're going through, and to listen to a podcast that really goes
- 27:26into these things could validate, right, because you know, when you're in
- 27:30therapy, your therapist says you're not alone, you're normal, but you don't
- 27:33really know until you actually hear from other people. As an example, if
- 27:37I had been you know, because I mentioned how when I started going,
- 27:41the main theme it wasn't my mom, it wasn't this. The main theme
- 27:45was me not being present aware of my present, my body, my issues
- 27:51right now, and that was a big theme and that never like magically went
- 27:56away. It just kind of like, you know, I worked on it,
- 27:59right, But I do imagine that if I had never even heard of
- 28:03that, I guess I had in the sense of like, oh, you
- 28:07know, meditation or things like that, but it's not something that has talked
- 28:10about very much. And it's interesting that you had randomly a therapist that was
- 28:14like did right, because most therapists are not that focused on the here and
- 28:18now like that therapist was. And I don't end as good at being able
- 28:22to hold that space of frustration for you because she had to frustrate you by
- 28:27bringing you back to the present and you were like, but why are you
- 28:32you know it was you were like, well, I don't understand what's happening,
- 28:33and and but to have that warmth or that differentiation, that calmness,
- 28:40to just be like, yeah, just asking because I still had in my
- 28:44head it wasn't you know, it wasn't like I was like trying to out
- 28:47smarter or anything, but I definitely in my head had the thing about like,
- 28:49well, I know what we're doing here, Like I get it,
- 28:52I get what we're doing here, but I don't understand why we're talking about
- 28:56this, Like why does it matter what I was feeling five minutes ago?
- 29:00And it's interesting to think about if you hadn't gone through that about of therapy,
- 29:04what would have happened with your thyroid a couple of years ago, that
- 29:08you might not have paid attention or valued yourself, and that there's a lot
- 29:15of things in the last ten years that yeah, man, that's a good
- 29:18point. But I what I was getting at was that if I had listened
- 29:23somehow miraculously to something at the time that would validate that, Like if I
- 29:29had listened to two dudes or gals talking and then someone says, yeah,
- 29:33you know, I often I'm rooted in the past and I'm recounting these things.
- 29:38But then I missed these big things that were happening to me in the
- 29:41moment, Like that would be really interesting, right, I'd be like,
- 29:45Oh, that's what I'm going through, and then it helps me process and
- 29:48maybe again maybe they have the wrong take about it. But then I told
- 29:52the therapist to shove it. But that still helps me think out loud,
- 29:56right, And I should say that a lot of people, which I did
- 29:59not really expect, we're saying that they came out of a cult like this
- 30:03and they were brainwashed and now they're recovering. And even though that might have
- 30:08been a long time ago, it was very validating to hear us react in
- 30:15the way that we did because we went thing by thing. They didn't just
- 30:19blanketly say it's a cult's all stupid. We we went point by point and
- 30:26really explored it and and it really expanded on them and said and then and
- 30:32looked at it. You know, let's let's look at this under a microscope
- 30:33and really evaluate it. You know it, even though a lot of these
- 30:37folks would characterize themselves as no longer being brainwashed or in the cult, you
- 30:41know, it lingers with you. Oh, there's always that nagging voice of
- 30:45just like you know that you're impure, you're gone to hell, or you're
- 30:49wrong or whatever. Anyway, going out with the email here, So this
- 30:53person was with Jimbob in early amazing early in the middle Yeah, IVLP.
- 31:00Yeah. According to the culture we were raised in, everything, and I
- 31:04mean everything is spiritual, quote unquote. Nothing is just a present day thing.
- 31:11Nothing is actually exactly what it nothing is actually exactly what it seems to
- 31:17be. It's all a big parable. It's all related somehow to the principles
- 31:22in the Bible. You just need to study to figure it out. And
- 31:25when you create such a wacky perspective, you are primed for a guru who
- 31:30can bring some kind of order to the chaos. Can you see that?
- 31:34Yeah, that is a that's very insightful. Number one. I can totally
- 31:38relate to this that feeling. Like, you know, growing up, we
- 31:42studied the Bible in school because it was a Catholic school. Most schools in
- 31:48Columbia were Catholic, and you would study it and it wasn't presented. Of
- 31:53course, it wasn't presented like well and here's you know, here's another book
- 31:56that was written and here's some No, no, it was isn't that as
- 32:00this meta reality, right, like, yeah, you can learn your math,
- 32:04you're spelling, but this is the real thing. This is what's happening,
- 32:08and it is true that then you were using that lens to like color
- 32:13everything in the world, every interaction. Now you could look at that as
- 32:17a positive from some angles, right, you could say, well, okay,
- 32:21if the angle you're coloring everything through is like, how can I be
- 32:22a better person today? How can I do what Jesus did or whatever,
- 32:25like how can I help this lady cross the street? Well, that seems
- 32:29very positive, but then there's lenses and angles that start making everything. Oh,
- 32:34there's demons after me everywhere, They're all trying to make me sin.
- 32:37Everything's same, and then it becomes really toxic. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 32:43I thought that this section of the email was also really brilliant because it
- 32:47really encapsulates that experience and it's not a dimension that I usually consider, which
- 32:53is for a lot of religious people, they don't consider everything to be,
- 33:00you know, just through this single lens. They might think of God as
- 33:02being everywhere, or God as being not knowledgeable about everything, or God you
- 33:08know, like one example is that for people at one end of the spectrum
- 33:13they would claim that the Earth is six thousand years old and that God in
- 33:20the Bible literally just made each animal and made human. You know, it
- 33:24was just just as it's written, that's exactly what happened. Yeah, and
- 33:30that all that is literal and everything is under God and everything happens for a
- 33:34reason. Whereas another Christian might say, and these are the sort of Christians
- 33:37I grew up, which is that, well, yeah, God created the
- 33:43universe, but he also created science, physics, and yeah he created physics,
- 33:49he created the back round physical reality, and why couldn't it have created
- 33:54it? Right? And he's not He's not tinkering with every single atom of
- 34:00every single star in the universe. He just he made everything. And he
- 34:06also created the basis for evolution, maybe even knowing that humans would emerge or
- 34:10some sort of you know, intelligent life would emerge. And then he also
- 34:16gave us free will, and he also gives us society and government and responsibility
- 34:22to take care of the environment. You know, God isn't dictating every little
- 34:28thing that happens, right, You could say he knows that everything that's going
- 34:30to happen, and yeah, he basically is in control of everything. But
- 34:35it's up to us to figure out what we're going to do with this world
- 34:37and with the society and what we have. Whereas if you can go at
- 34:39the other end of the spectrum, then it's like, well, why make
- 34:44a choice at all? Why work on climate change? If God wants the
- 34:47earth to get warmer, then that's just what's happened, you know what I
- 34:51mean that way of thinking anyway, right, Oh, and by the way,
- 34:53you know, I know that recently you did some things about Jordan Peterson,
- 34:58but this is one of the things that really broke me off from him
- 35:02a few years ago, several years ago, was that he looks at religion
- 35:07through this lens. It's almost the oppit he looks at it, you know
- 35:10those Uh I remember. I have this memory of going to my dad's hospital
- 35:15where he was getting his PhD or whatever, and they had those two way
- 35:19mirrors that it has one of my favorite memories of seeing. But it's basically
- 35:22like this two way mirror where he Jordan Peterson can see the other side,
- 35:29but the other side only sees a mirror. And what he's trying to do
- 35:30is like, I'm afraid that by losing religion, they're going to realize this
- 35:35is a two way mirror and then there's stuff on this side. But that's
- 35:37going to be the dissolution of society because in his mind, the world works
- 35:43better when everyone does have these lenses to look through everything like this metamagic and
- 35:49that when you don't, When you don't, that's the dissolution of society because
- 35:52then people say, well, then nothing matters, I could just kill whoever.
- 35:57There's moralities irrelevant, blah blah blah, and it's a big, you
- 36:00know, cause of tension. But but then you know, when you go
- 36:05to a lot of research on this, all you gotta do is just look
- 36:08at groups of people who are atheists or societies that become more atheist and compare
- 36:15and you don't see anything like that. You know, it's the same curves,
- 36:17right, the same distributions. But but that's and then take into the
- 36:22extreme ast what you're saying, like everything becomes a thing every moment I had
- 36:29those those acquaintances or I want to call them friends, but their acquaintances when
- 36:32I was growing up in Tacoma that were that were like that, they were
- 36:37everything. There's always these angels and demons battling constantly. Everything is a thing,
- 36:42and it's such man anxiety and fear and oh yeah, stressful, yeah,
- 36:49very stressful everything. You know, God's right there watching everything that you
- 36:53do and judging you. You know, it'd be one thing if God was
- 36:58right there and going like, hey, I created sex, Yeah, I
- 37:01think safely enjoy sex. I created emotion, have have emotions. I created
- 37:08free will and agency. And you know, I'm also not so fond of
- 37:13oppression and sexism and racism as stated, you know, but I will well,
- 37:20not as stated, as well as implicitly stated. I mean, it's
- 37:24it's pretty clear that Jesus was all about anti oppression. I looked at in
- 37:30a certain New Testament that looked through a certain well, even the Old Testament,
- 37:34you know, the oppression of Moses and his people, you know what
- 37:37I mean. So yeah, but I'm just saying, like, through one
- 37:43lens, you could see the Bible as being just one long story of people
- 37:45being oppressed and then being able to persevere and God rewarding them, you know,
- 37:51for their pain and sufferings and punishing the oppressors. Yeah, certainly the
- 37:55metaphor is getting out of complete barbarism into some sort of a civil society yes,
- 38:01and then yet what you're referring to is not only is God there not
- 38:06doing what you're saying, but the devil is there too, and they're both
- 38:08yelling at maximum voice into your ears. Going on, I do want to
- 38:13point out that our parents' generation did not raise us with the full IBLP immersion.
- 38:19Jim Bob's parents were not that way with him as well, meaning that
- 38:23for Jimbob and an honest Patron's parents, they were, you know, they
- 38:30as adults, they were not in IBLP as they were growing up, and
- 38:32that seemed to be the case both him and the wife. They were not
- 38:37raised like that. They entered maybe as teenagers. Yeah, and so just
- 38:40going on, we were raised very strictly, no dancing, no public displays
- 38:45of affection, et cetera. But jim Bob and Deanna, his sister,
- 38:51were not raised in the way Jimbob and Michelle raised their own kids. It
- 38:54was like our parents leaned fundamental fundamental fund use, if you will, and
- 39:00followed Gothard, but it hadn't yet learned all the ins and outs of all
- 39:02the rule system. So it's kind of interesting you think about that, Like
- 39:07the generations that you have Jimbob's parents that were, you know, trying,
- 39:12but they hadn't been fully indoctrinated. And there's a lot of rules. When
- 39:15you teach the kids the rules from literally day one, think about all the
- 39:21rules that they know of and all the ins and outs, and then anyway,
- 39:25so the parents are learning this as like you know, thirty year olds.
- 39:30The teenagers are learning it too. But I could also imagine that the
- 39:32Bill Gothard system and the IBOP system wasn't really a slick right, and hadn't
- 39:37really It wasn't as all encompassing as it would become to families like Jim Bob's
- 39:45kids, where their entire school system, all of their friends, all of
- 39:50their family members, all of the parenting, everything that they do is within
- 39:54this fundamentalist system. Listening to your deep dive, they were a few moments
- 40:00when I felt a little defensive from a sense of you othering an example.
- 40:06Yes, many people who took the homeschool route and spiritualized all academic learning ended
- 40:10up very cognitively deficient. However, several of us went on to thrive at
- 40:16places like Harvard and Stanford Burda. What do you think, Uh, yeah,
- 40:21I'm sure we did other. I definitely other regularly. I other for
- 40:27breakfast. But is there a butt? Well, there is kind of a
- 40:30butt for me, But I don't I don't mean to other the kids that
- 40:37like, it is a it is a system that is unfortunate because like the
- 40:40kids are born, they don't have any say in the matter, and then
- 40:44they just grow up and they're they're in that bucket. So I guess I
- 40:47was othering the system. The system is the thing I want to other.
- 40:52Yeah, so did you see the John Oliver recent episode though, it's a
- 40:55whole thing on homeschooling. Oh, okay, and it's pretty good from my
- 41:00estimation. I don't I'm not an expert, but but but yeah, you
- 41:06know, to be homeschooled. You know, if someone told me that they
- 41:07were homeschooled, I would have no idea what that meant. It really runs
- 41:10the gamut. It could be something like IBOP. It could also be something
- 41:15where a parent is just neglecting their kid and saying their homeschooling. But it
- 41:20can absolutely be a rigorous academic program. So much so. One of the
- 41:24first episodes that I ever did, I mean comparatively, it probably was three
- 41:30or four years into the podcast while but to us now, it was a
- 41:35long time ago in the beginning, and I did an episode with a fan
- 41:38of the podcast. I think we had three at the time, and she
- 41:43was three. She was from a homeschool environment, and she came on the
- 41:51podcast talk about homeschooling, and she was one of the most well adjusted,
- 41:55smartest wise kids I'd ever met. She knew all this stuff about psychology and
- 42:02about nonviolent communication, and you know, she was listening to our podcast,
- 42:07which was getting into technical, clinical kind of stuff and it was interesting her.
- 42:13You know, when I look at all the stats of our listeners,
- 42:15we have very very few people that are younger than eighteen, you know,
- 42:19which makes sense and almost probably is a good thing to some extent because we
- 42:22get into some adult stuff. But anyway, so yeah, absolutely there are
- 42:27plenty. Can you have a parent or you know, set of parents who
- 42:30have a homeschool regimen that is sound, but they also tailor it. I
- 42:36mean, that was the thing about this kid. She was saying that she
- 42:38had this school system that was it was tailored to her, and she did
- 42:43what she wanted to do. That's what I remember her telling me was that
- 42:46she would wake up in the morning, and because she had so much freedom,
- 42:51she actually really enjoyed learning, and so she just would grab the material
- 42:55and then tailor it to herself. You know, if it was about biology,
- 43:00she's like, ooh, okay, what if we went to the zoo
- 43:01and I did this or what you know? And she was like really involved.
- 43:06And she said there wasn't really any subject that she didn't like, because
- 43:09you know, when you throw all the kids into one system that teaches it
- 43:14kind of in one way, then some of the kids are gonna it's not
- 43:17gonna be tailored to them. And plus even for kids that want to go
- 43:20faster, they're held back. Kids that want to go slower, they're you
- 43:22know, it's a it's a it makes sense. But if you're homeschooled well
- 43:27and in this style, you could you could see it being amazing. So
- 43:30yeah, when I hear homeschooling, so I hope we didn't just say all
- 43:32homeschool kids are idiots, like I hope so because I know homeschool people that
- 43:37are also fantastic. Yeah, my friends are homeschool Stacy. My wife was
- 43:43homeschooled for a bit. Oh jeez, that explains every But she did say,
- 43:49as I was telling her about what I was learning about Ati, and
- 43:52I was like, Stacy, you wouldn't And we watched the documentary together,
- 43:55but I was like, Stacy, you wouldn't believe what's in this book.
- 43:58And she's like, you know, I wonder if that's what I was homeschool?
- 44:01Oh, because she remembers here Maricella these super religious, ridiculous notions of
- 44:07being interwoven within her math homework. You know what I mean? Her parents
- 44:12aren't that way, Oh my gosh. I don't know the whole story there,
- 44:15but I could imagine a situation which her parents were just looking for a
- 44:19homeschool curriculum and they were just given a bad one and they didn't know any
- 44:22better, you know. I mean, don't get me wrong, Like I
- 44:24could go hours on my disdain for the educational system I grew up under and
- 44:30all the things I saw wrong with it, and all the great things I
- 44:34learned in my home learning by myself with slight help from my dad, not
- 44:38much, because he was not good at the subjects I cared about. But
- 44:42that doesn't mean that I want to throw babies out with bathwaters. Yeah,
- 44:45And if I remember right, the thesis of the John Oliver episode was that
- 44:51there's a lot of different experiences. There are people who actually benefit greatly,
- 44:55and we would absolutely get behind the homeschooling that they're doing because they being bullied
- 45:00at school and so the parents just like, oh, let's take you out,
- 45:02and the kid is now thriving, or a kid is able to tailor
- 45:07their learning environment, or they might live in a district where they teach abstinence
- 45:14only and that you know, what are the other ridiculous things that are happening
- 45:16in Florida? You know those kinds of yeah, where they ban books and
- 45:20prayer in school. Right, you can't talk about evolution or something. Right.
- 45:24So of course, if you're a responsible parent, you have time,
- 45:29and you are into this sort of thing, you might consider doing homeschooling as
- 45:32a way to protect children from that influence and give them actual education. I
- 45:37mean, we were doing homeschooling during the pandemic, yeah, to some extent,
- 45:40to actually to a pretty good extent, Like I was, I was
- 45:45teaching stuff to my kids, I you know, several subjects and things like
- 45:49that. My wife took a year off from being a teacher to like teach
- 45:53our kid, you know, right, and it's like right, so absolutely,
- 45:58and then on the other side have things like IBOP and also a lot
- 46:02of allegations of abuse where the parents are wanting to generally abuse the child and
- 46:07control the child, and so if the child is at home, then they
- 46:12can really go after that kid. Other accounts of people where the curriculum is
- 46:15basically just doing a lot of chores, where the one person on the John
- 46:21Oliver Show was that they were showing the schedule and at the beginning it was
- 46:23like, here's math and here's pe, you know, physical education, which
- 46:29basically meant we just walked around the block a couple times and then look at
- 46:32the rest of this day. Paint the fence. Yeah, it was on
- 46:36the floor. It was like thirty different chores that they were doing. Maybe
- 46:39they were learning karate and so that is you know, it varies, but
- 46:45the John Oliver thesis was that it needs more regulation, There needs to be
- 46:51more oversight because there's so many kids that are being abused and harmed and uneducated
- 46:57or miseducated because of this notion that somehow parents have the full right to be
- 47:04able to do whatever they want. Because that's kind of the way it is,
- 47:07right now depending on the jurisdiction where it's it's like, well, we
- 47:09don't want to interfere with parents' rights. Well what if they're teaching this and
- 47:14the advocacy organizations are just like, hey, let them do what they want
- 47:17to do. It's not the government's role to get involved in that. I
- 47:22find it really odd that leading up to the moment of birth, there is
- 47:28this huge emphasis on the rights of the baby, of the fetus, of
- 47:31the baby, right like, it's important, it's alive, we got to
- 47:35you know, the mother is irrelevant. All that matters the baby. But
- 47:37as soon as the baby's born, the baby is now irrelevant. You don't
- 47:42need subsidies, you don't need food for stamps for the school, you definitely
- 47:45don't need any welfare. You don't need anything. And parents control the shots
- 47:50no matter what they're teaching or doing as the kid, Yeah, going out
- 47:52with email. A couple of things that I am continuing to turn over in
- 47:55my head after listening to your deep dive is that the attachment bonds in these
- 48:00families are not typical of today's culture. Let me explain, the parents focus
- 48:05on shoulds rather than love. If you, as a parent, do your
- 48:09job to shape your child's choices. Then the children will turn out quote unquote
- 48:15right. And this is another point by this person, this anonymous patron,
- 48:21that is said in a way where it's like, yeah, that is different.
- 48:25It's a different culture, it's a different way. It's so interesting that
- 48:29you could have parents that literally see the job of parenting to be so paradiymatically
- 48:38different than the way that we see parenting, because we see parenting as creating
- 48:44happy kids and kids that are thriving kids that has adults find meaning and purpose
- 48:50and whatever it is. And you know, of course even people in our
- 48:52camp will be controlling or have certain ideas about how that's going to look and
- 48:57maybe emphasize materialism or something as a whole other set of kind of things.
- 49:00But that for people in this in this high control group, they see parenting
- 49:06as it's your job as parents to make your kids follow the rules, that
- 49:10that's the only goal. You know, another irony because a lot of times
- 49:15I think of these kinds of groups that would advocate these things as you know,
- 49:21professing freedom and like I'm a free person. This is why I'm carrying
- 49:27my AK forty seven, my AAR fifteens, whatever because I'm free and you
- 49:31can't tread on me and all these things. But the irony is that but
- 49:37we must all conform and be a unit and not have individuality, and you
- 49:42must just follow these very strict rules. It's it is, It is incredible.
- 49:46So yeah, the goal of those systems is the system, not the
- 49:51child. It's the system. You need to have more kids in this system,
- 49:55in this triangle and go forward with the triangle getting bigger and bigger,
- 50:00because that's the goal, instead of, like, well, the other philosophy,
- 50:04which would be we think if we build up little, well functioning,
- 50:08autonomous, independent, empathetic beings, they can go and work as a network
- 50:16to make the world a better place. It's just two different, diametrically opposed
- 50:21philosophy, right, And just think about how it's so infused in every interaction
- 50:25that you're having with your kids, and how different you would feel about yourself
- 50:30as a human being being raised within that constant, all encompassing mindset from people
- 50:37that you're not here to be happy, you're not here to have a life.
- 50:42You're here to serve God and to follow the rules, and that's the
- 50:45only reason why you're here. And part of that is that once you're in
- 50:49my shoes, you will be making your kids follow the rules and the authority
- 50:52of this cult. And that you're an automaton. That's all you have.
- 50:57Freedom. You don't matter anyway. So let's take another break. But for
- 51:01the rest of this episode, this is going to be for patrons of the
- 51:04podcast. So if you want to listen to the rest of this, as
- 51:07with all the other chapters in full, you have to become a patron of
- 51:10the podcast by going to patreon dot com. Why should they become a patron
- 51:14of the podcast, Birtle, Because when you're a patron, we let you
- 51:17in on a few secrets. Things we've never divulged anywhere, nor will we
- 51:22ever even to patrons. Oh wait, and also we can't make all this
- 51:27content without our patrons. We make all this content because of our patrons.
- 51:30Patrons requested this, you know, like this is for our patrons, and
- 51:37we go long, man, we go along, we go like in depth
- 51:40and all these things, and so you know, you get to decide what
- 51:45you want to hear us blab about for a long time. And the more
- 51:49you're a patron, the more we blab. So right, that's right.
- 51:52The reason why we're doing this is because we took a pull a couple months
- 51:55back and asked all the patrons and they voted, and this was by far
- 52:00the number one. Pretty soon we're gonna have to take another poll. You
- 52:04pay trend we Blab and everyone out there, please take care of yourself because
- 52:07you deserve it. Why should they take care of themselves because they deserve it.