Latest / Newcomer Pod / Look on my Monthly Uniques, ye Mighty, and despair! (w/ Ben Smith)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone. This is Katie letting you know
- 0:02that we're showing this week's dead cat episode a few days.
- 0:04Earlier than usual it's an interview that Tom and I did on
- 0:08Friday with Ben Smith of the New York Times about three hours
- 0:11after we finished recording Ozzy media.
- 0:14The company that we discussed at length announced that it was
- 0:17shutting down following a series of stories kicked off by Ben's
- 0:20great reporting. So, when we talk about things,
- 0:24like the future of Ozzy that future was about to be
- 0:27announced, not long after we ended the interview.
- 0:30Without further Ado, here's the show.
- 0:47We are here with Ben Smith. My esteemed New York Times
- 0:50colleague, he used to run the BuzzFeed news room.
- 0:53He's compared to be a media columnist.
- 0:55He has broken news as a columnist, and over the past
- 0:59couple of years, but probably no story that's been bigger in the
- 1:03world of people who care about media are extremely tiny Niche
- 1:07than the story that he wrote earlier this week on Ozzy media
- 1:11company. That most people have probably
- 1:13not heard of that's run by an extraordinarily charismatic, man
- 1:16named Love's Watson and he had an extremely, I would say
- 1:21dramatic tale of how Ozzy in the midst of raising its money.
- 1:25Had one of us Executives pretend to be an executive at YouTube in
- 1:29order to fool bankers at Goldman Sachs into giving the company 40
- 1:33million dollars, it does sound a lot like Securities fraud to me.
- 1:36I'm just sitting over here. Somebody, who covers the justice
- 1:38department? It does, it does have that ring,
- 1:40which is probably why the federal government is now
- 1:43investigating Ozzy. And Ben is here with us today.
- 1:46Today to talk about this story to talk about what it means for
- 1:50start-up media startups, which used to be incredibly hot and
- 1:53now are looking less. So and sort of anything else
- 1:56that's on his mind, been thank you for being with us.
- 1:58Well, thank you all for a thanks for having me and yeah, actually
- 2:02it's funny. I really thought the Aussie
- 2:03store would be something that only people in our tiny corner
- 2:06of the universe had any interest in which did not not turn out to
- 2:09be the case. What's been so interesting about
- 2:13Ozzy, is I covered that space. I probably wrote, you know, as
- 2:16much About that whole industry as anyone like kind of the
- 2:19digital media companies that all took off around the same time,
- 2:23Ozzy was always a bit of an outlier to me, I would hardly
- 2:26think about them in that group, you know, to me it was always
- 2:29the company that was largely in my mind, that's probably not
- 2:34true, but largely funded by Laurene.
- 2:35Powell jobs is, you know, investment vehicle, Emerson
- 2:39Collective, but I mean, been you were at BuzzFeed for a long time
- 2:44and kind of came up with that class of companies like What,
- 2:47what was Ozzy to you like? How did it kind of live in your
- 2:49mind as one of the members of the cohort?
- 2:54I mean I think it was always mostly kind of puzzling like a
- 2:58you just knew that no one was reading it.
- 3:00Obviously. And in 2017 we did a story about
- 3:04how they had or how to the agency was not totally clear who
- 3:09had done it, but a lot of fake traffic was being delivered to
- 3:13Ozzy advertisers and Kind of made sense because they had no
- 3:18real traffic but they had a lot of advertisers and they just had
- 3:20no, I couldn't, they didn't have an audience.
- 3:22And I'm you said, it seems like you have an audience, they be
- 3:24like, well, our audience are Outsiders, not assholes like
- 3:26you. It's like you know fair and then
- 3:29Carlos has this incredibly sort of always on dealmaker kind of
- 3:36charming garrulous guy who knows everybody?
- 3:38And sometimes you know you're fun to talk to you about what
- 3:41was going on in the industry. Yeah.
- 3:43How would you describe Carlos? I went with, this is something
- 3:45it's only now. Urging in the subsequent stories
- 3:48that have come out, since you wrote your First Column, what is
- 3:51he like as a person when you speak, when you would speak with
- 3:53him what was he like I mean a very you know I mean I you know
- 3:56I think like I'm not sure I want to speak for myself to different
- 3:59people have different impressions of him but I think a
- 4:01lot some people thought he was this incredibly charismatic.
- 4:04Brilliant figure of some people thought he was a great sales
- 4:07guy. Some people felt like he was a
- 4:08sales guy who liked was trying a little too hard and say, those
- 4:11were the three Impressions. It seemed like the business with
- 4:15Ozzy, because, right? No one would ever.
- 4:16Send Ozzy articles. I don't think in my entire time
- 4:19covering that space, I wrote one about them or ever read an
- 4:23article about them, but it seemed like their kind of
- 4:26Flagship business was this conference that they did the
- 4:29Ozzy Fest, right? And they would get really big
- 4:31names, people like Hillary Clinton or, you know, high
- 4:36level. I don't know Executives or
- 4:39people politicians would show up at this thing.
- 4:42I mean, in one sense, I imagine his Charisma and his You know,
- 4:47ability to build an image of what Ozzie is probably help get
- 4:52those people to come, right? Like, that's, that's a fairly
- 4:54fair trade of, you know, for Prestige and image for
- 4:58appearance, right? Yeah, I mean, I do think that
- 5:01his relationship with Laurene Powell jobs was this incredibly
- 5:04validating thing and that he you know, it's not that he sort of
- 5:08egregiously traded on it any more than anybody else that
- 5:11industry trades on things. But but the fact that she was
- 5:15his investors she and Ron Unwittingly recency, negro
- 5:18three. If you're interested, the 2013
- 5:19in Silicon Valley, those are like the three investors you
- 5:22would most want. We're his three sort of startup
- 5:24investors was incredibly validating and I think also that
- 5:27people wanted to get any you know, she has she represents
- 5:30just this massive pile of money to people and so I think there
- 5:33was like a well if he's close to to Lorraine, no harm doing them
- 5:38a favor and you know I do think there's an element of in which
- 5:40like right now, everything is sort of the politics of Royal
- 5:43courts of billionaires and like half the sort of talented
- 5:46people. Of my generation.
- 5:47I know one way or the other just sort of work for billionaires
- 5:49and are constantly worried about their position, relative to
- 5:52other, courtiers in their courts.
- 5:54And like, I think that's sort of, also part of this, you here
- 5:58up. He was sort of one part of this
- 6:00extended Royal jobs court and so people were who were looking to
- 6:04get to her. So I was potentially a way for
- 6:06that, although and I think he didn't, he benefited from that
- 6:09all. I don't think he, at least in
- 6:11the early days overly represented himself as that.
- 6:14I think they are real friends. So were you Rise at all by her
- 6:17response to the story, the statement she gave I I read it
- 6:21as her distancing herself from him.
- 6:23Maybe I've misread that but it did not, it certainly wasn't a
- 6:27statement of support. I mean it was certainly Andrew
- 6:30Cuomo, distant. I mean, of sorry.
- 6:33Certainly Emerson distancing itself, I don't know if it was,
- 6:39I don't think. I mean, I the way I read it, it
- 6:41was Emerson discussing self, but I think almost very much not
- 6:46Lorraine distancing herself. I love this idea of media
- 6:51becoming especially startup media becoming a game of which
- 6:54billionaire which benefactor, which wealthy benefactor can you
- 6:58find ya some sort of Medici era type game of, you know, which
- 7:03random rich person will give you money and legitimacy?
- 7:08Yeah, well I think you definitely see that impulse
- 7:10coming from the billionaire. As I mean something like a Marc
- 7:13benioff buying Time Magazine there.
- 7:16Has no business value for him. I mean, I don't even know what
- 7:18Time Magazine is at any point. But I think you know post Jeff
- 7:22Bezos, you know buying the Washington Post and doing a
- 7:25pretty good job with that and then you know, Laurene Powell
- 7:29jobs, buying the Atlantic. Yeah, I guess like the flip side
- 7:32of that would be what's-his-name the Facebook, billionaire, who
- 7:35bought the new Republic and like, did horribly owning that
- 7:39like, yeah, I don't know. I just imagine that week with
- 7:41the great accrual of wealth and billionaires status in this
- 7:45country. They feel some Obligation to
- 7:47help these kind of, especially Legacy Media companies.
- 7:50I mean, the Ozzy thing feels a little different because it's
- 7:52like they're tapping into the next thing, right?
- 7:55It was part of this whole class of companies like Mike and and
- 7:58fusion well you know I think the thing is there were I think that
- 8:02there were, you know, there were a handful of companies that had
- 8:07built real audiences and we're making sort of real connections
- 8:10with people. And I would say that Vox was
- 8:13BuzzFeed was and just worried, you know, Then a bunch of like,
- 8:17you know, Upworthy had a big real audience for a while.
- 8:20Could have bottom of the internet places, like, 9gag
- 8:22really did. And then there are other
- 8:26companies that raise money saying, we're going to be like
- 8:28those companies, but but they didn't actually, you know, ever
- 8:36build the audience but there were telling us, you know, but
- 8:38they thought they were. I don't think I don't think.
- 8:39I don't think Ozzy launch imagining that it wasn't gonna,
- 8:43you know, the launched is a scam or anything like that.
- 8:46Right, right, well, it's interesting, the like fake it
- 8:49till you, make it Tech mentality, you know when it goes
- 8:52wrong because like at the same time we've got the Elizabeth
- 8:55Holmes trial happening at the moment and a lot of people are
- 8:59making the same comparison between, you know what you wrote
- 9:02about with Ozzy and Elizabeth Holmes.
- 9:04Which I mean I don't know, I mean if we are talking about
- 9:06Federal investigations it's not that crazy of a comparison but I
- 9:10think the hope is like if you can string people along with
- 9:13your hope of what this could be, then eventually the Complicated
- 9:16shit will work itself out and to a degree.
- 9:19I mean, like with their announced that seems insane like
- 9:22much more insane. You're talking about, actually
- 9:24think, like, you think this is more?
- 9:27Because I think you can do with media, you know like what's the
- 9:29what is traffic right? It's just whatever comes for
- 9:32says, I mean they're all made up numbers you know I guess I don't
- 9:35know. Maybe maybe that's true too true
- 9:36where you worked but that's that has not been my experience.
- 9:38Like I think you know, you were it business instead of right now
- 9:41is like trying to convert people real people to pay for the stuff
- 9:44and And yeah, I don't know. I mean, I guess maybe I'm a
- 9:48little prickly about this because we were best.
- 9:50People would often say things like, well, are you just buying
- 9:52all this traffic from Facebook and it's like, wait, are you
- 9:54crazy? Of course, for not like it's
- 9:56really hard. We're trying to reach people,
- 9:58right? And but here's my point and I
- 10:02think we say and the other things I think with their
- 10:03enough. So you know, I did some point
- 10:05like somebody will invent something where you can have
- 10:07somewhat less blood in the vial and and still be able to get a
- 10:12diagnosis of, you know, various conditions from that blood It
- 10:15wasn't a crazy idea that you did bit like going to a Quest labs
- 10:19and having the like extract a gallon of blood from your arm
- 10:21after you wait for 45 minutes wasn't necessarily going to the
- 10:24Future. And I think they probably went
- 10:26in thinking that they were going to solve it and you can actually
- 10:28imagine a scenario, right? We're like six months before
- 10:32Kari recalls they're like acquired by Walmart and Walmart,
- 10:36takes that team and then somebody in that team actually
- 10:38figures that out, right? Like I don't think I think that
- 10:40most of these con, when I'm not want to call any of these people
- 10:43kind of met, it's all kind of alleged, but I think Usually,
- 10:46they're also deceiving themselves.
- 10:49Hmm. So do you think that?
- 10:52Do you think that what happened with Ozzy based on your
- 10:55reporting? Do you think what happened with
- 10:57Ozzy? Is something that has that feels
- 10:58applicable to to the larger sort of startup media space where,
- 11:02but for the grace of God, we could have all been there or do
- 11:06you think that there is something particular about
- 11:07Carlos and particular about this company?
- 11:09Clearly impersonating, YouTube executive is far more extreme
- 11:14than I think what most people be willing to do.
- 11:15And I think what they were doing with their traffic was also like
- 11:18the car Watson show didn't have an organic audience.
- 11:21It was all Arbitrage where they were selling at premium rate ads
- 11:25and then taking a lot of that. Money and buying you are buying
- 11:27YouTube pre-roll for the show. I mean, it was just all paid.
- 11:31There was no very little organic.
- 11:33So I mean, some of it was sort of well, maybe it's all the
- 11:36stuff is on a spectrum. And this is way down the
- 11:38Spectrum, but it's like way down the Spectrum.
- 11:40It's an order of magnitude, more deceptive.
- 11:43I think, than what most media companies were doing.
- 11:46I'm going to do think if you look at how Vice talk to these
- 11:48to talk about it, It's traffic. There's an example of a website
- 11:53that did not have very much traffic.
- 11:54The pretended to have a lot of traffic, that's not really just
- 11:57similar. That's the only analogy I can
- 11:58really think of. And the thing is right, like so
- 12:01much of kind of the real money in this business is in
- 12:03television and the notion that you build a brand real or fake
- 12:07on the internet and then flip it into TV, makes certain amount of
- 12:10sense. And maybe actually it's easier
- 12:11if it's fake because it's not so messy.
- 12:14You don't feel like interact with reality, right?
- 12:17But that's that's the fake it till you make it meant.
- 12:18Leti, right? It's like if you can convince
- 12:20enough people that you have a brand that you have an audience,
- 12:23eventually someone with real money and someone who can put it
- 12:26in front of an actual audience, will, you know, will bite, and
- 12:29then you sort of done it right? Then you flip that.
- 12:32I mean, like Vice is such a great example because they are
- 12:35trying to be more of a television company, and they
- 12:38have a cable network, which is insane for a, you know, a brand
- 12:41that's aimed at Millennials that most don't pay for cable, but
- 12:45they're making a, you know, money from that like that,
- 12:47there's a billion exaggerator. I mean, if you compare
- 12:49breastfeed and vice one, looks like it's going to exit and
- 12:52deliver for investors in one looks like it's not going to and
- 12:55so you know to defense point is that you can take to make it
- 12:59until ultimately you have to deliver and what Aziz been doing
- 13:01and trying to raise money. It looks like is simply trying
- 13:05to find a way to have some sort of logical exit and buying time
- 13:09until that moment. And so I don't know, like Ben
- 13:12aren't Tom. You guys, I never covered media,
- 13:15you know, do you feel like it's the exit?
- 13:18The hard stop where you can no longer pretend.
- 13:21I mean this case it wasn't that it was the college Securities
- 13:24for us that is also a time to stop.
- 13:28Yeah. Right.
- 13:30Yeah. I don't know.
- 13:32I mean I do think yeah and I don't know I think he's like I
- 13:35think there are lots of great businesses that did really good
- 13:38stuff and didn't get the quote unquote, exit and lots of
- 13:40garbage companies that sold for a lot.
- 13:42I realize like Silicon Valley. The founders are all focused on
- 13:45their exits like particularly the bad ones.
- 13:46Actually, I think Ink. But yeah, I know, actually I
- 13:51think if you look back like at all the media companies that big
- 13:55media companies acquired most of them no longer exist in any
- 13:58form. And so I don't think I don't
- 14:00think that the sort of notion that they sold is a validation
- 14:03that they were real or fake or than anything else.
- 14:07I mean, depends how you're looking at it and from whose
- 14:09perspective, you know, if you were able to exit your, you
- 14:12know, and get some payback on your shares.
- 14:14But but I mean back to Asia, specifically what I would like
- 14:17so much about your story was that you have this incredible
- 14:21anecdote about the, you know, impersonation of a YouTube
- 14:25executive that obviously you know was what got it so much
- 14:28attention, but the large portion of your story is just pointing
- 14:31out things that anyone who would follow this company and was
- 14:35aware of how the media industry Works would.
- 14:37I thought it would have suggested which is like when
- 14:40they're claiming they have 25 million uniques.
- 14:42That's more than most companies that have way more brand
- 14:45recognition have when they're claiming they have tens of
- 14:48millions of emails, on their list, compare that to morning
- 14:52Brew which is one of the most popular daily newsletters.
- 14:55They have three million and you know, there's no you don't need
- 14:59to get, you know, deep internal files to determine that.
- 15:03It's just basic common sense and I think that's what people
- 15:05forget, so often. In the media world is that you
- 15:08can make these claims. But anyone with a modicum of
- 15:10understanding with know what smells bad.
- 15:13Yeah. Yeah.
- 15:14I think that's right. And, and, you know, anyone with
- 15:16a modicum of understanding, much less, all the richest.
- 15:19Brilliant most brilliant people in the world which perhaps
- 15:22suggest that they are not the Geniuses that they purport to be
- 15:25your money. Doesn't confer intelligent
- 15:27attention good. So you mean by the way I don't
- 15:33know how much you got into it in your story but do you think if
- 15:36this Euler, you know Scooby-Doo moment with Alex Piper at
- 15:41YouTube, hadn't happened, I hadn't you know been you know
- 15:44spoiled by the rotten kids that golden would have invested.
- 15:47I mean is there a world in which they're able to get through that
- 15:50moment and the 40 million dollars?
- 15:51They were expecting it from Goldman actually goes through
- 15:53and they could kind of continue this escapade.
- 15:57Well, you know, they did what they did raise around it, just
- 15:59didn't come from Goldman. Do you think that's imperiled
- 16:03now? I mean you applied your in your
- 16:05story that it was going to happen but like everyone is Rats
- 16:07from a ship, it happened because they did raise the money.
- 16:10Yeah I mean I think that if you were an investor Who bought in
- 16:18and if and again I'm not, I'm sort of reporting on all this
- 16:21and I'm not sure exactly what's the case and if the company did
- 16:25not inform you that they were being investigated by the FBI
- 16:28for alleged Securities fraud, that might be a kind of material
- 16:32issue that would trigger you to potentially fire a lot file, a
- 16:36lawsuit, or something like that. Like you were specifically
- 16:38sketching really background? Yeah.
- 16:40You certainly want your money back and you probably could get
- 16:43companies. Blows up over something that
- 16:45you'd be totally, new event should have told you, I don't
- 16:48know. Katie, what do you think?
- 16:48Will they get it back? I think that oftentimes, there's
- 16:51a like a SharePoint, some sort of material change in the
- 16:54company being under investigation.
- 16:56Knowing it not disclosing, it could fall under that and
- 16:59depending on how the money is distributed.
- 17:02Some people, you know they say they're going to invest but they
- 17:04haven't wired the money over yet.
- 17:06They could put a stop to it. They could kill try to claw
- 17:08money back. What's so interesting to is, I
- 17:10think this calls into question how much money is really left
- 17:13inside. The company and if the company
- 17:16were to collapse, who would get money back and how much I mean I
- 17:20would, it's not clear from the stories but I'm not sure if do
- 17:23you have any reporting to the suggest you?
- 17:26How money is being used? I thought that your follow-up
- 17:28story on Brad bus, he was really interesting because it was such
- 17:30a high expense production. They were putting on supposedly
- 17:34for any is so that's like so so so expensive, like the money,
- 17:38they were burning was so intense.
- 17:40All again toward something that wasn't true right?
- 17:43Carlos Watson. To tell people it was for a any
- 17:46it was never for a any. And then you have an executive
- 17:48actually telling people. This is not only building your
- 17:51company on likes and it's incredibly bad and all these
- 17:55other ways. So, you know, viewed to
- 17:57questions, you have reporting on, you know, how much money
- 18:01remains at the company, giving given High burn rate and then to
- 18:05the Brad Bessie incident is fascinating, did you get a sense
- 18:09from Bessie? After he confronts the founders?
- 18:12It seems maybe he was confounded.
- 18:14Their response that it was no big deal.
- 18:15And, you know, do you have more insight on that because they
- 18:19kept moving forward and we're going to make it work and he,
- 18:23you know, quit and did other employees contact him.
- 18:27I mean, he was so open about it that they were all being lied to
- 18:30did. He was there an exodus that
- 18:32followed him? The thing is to do television
- 18:35production. It's just so much work, and they
- 18:36were like 100 Ozzy is in kind of crazy.
- 18:39Is that even while they were misleading people, they were
- 18:42also producing really expensive to produce.
- 18:44Reduce technically high quality content.
- 18:46So if you're like the post production supervisor, you're
- 18:49just you're right. You are in fact, putting out a
- 18:51show all the time and it's covid and you're employed and the
- 18:55checks are clearing. And so I think all those people
- 18:57were like, I, this is insane, but I'm getting paid basically,
- 19:00and do you think the checks are going to continue to clear?
- 19:06You know, I don't know. I mean, I think the question of,
- 19:08you know, it's not even clear that the companies really has a
- 19:11board the end. It was a solution version Market
- 19:14which is Marc lasry, and Steen company.
- 19:19They were still representing as a board member and they say,
- 19:22Loretta is a board member. There Lorraine is no longer a
- 19:25board member, she's listed as one hand, interesting.
- 19:28And, and so, I think the only remaining board members as of
- 19:34this recording our Arliss and Michael Mo mgsv but Mo isn't
- 19:39returning my calls but it's just not clear.
- 19:43I don't know what happens. Now, it seems like it'll involve
- 19:46a lot of lawyers. I thought Marc lasry statement
- 19:49was so interesting that he didn't have a lot of experience
- 19:52with investigations and controversy.
- 19:54So he wasn't really the right person, but he was on the board
- 19:56of the Weinstein Company during the very months, when Jody
- 20:02Cantor and, you know, all these other Reporters were calling him
- 20:07and all the other he's familiar with crisis.
- 20:09Yeah, absolutely already with Craig has steel that and tweet
- 20:13it because that's in said, you know, would you first reached
- 20:16out to the board and said I'm writing this story?
- 20:18And it was clear that they knew what had happened in February.
- 20:22In the year of Our Lord 2021 was it weird to you that there had
- 20:26not been an internal investigation.
- 20:28They seemed so sanguine about this last three spoke for the
- 20:32board and I thought it was totally bizarre.
- 20:35And I think the The yeah, I mean I really seem strange to me than
- 20:39anybody. I talk to about it that you
- 20:40wouldn't. I mean, really just to cover
- 20:42yourself as a board. And that's I mean ultimately a
- 20:45lot of the way that these corporate actors Act is to
- 20:48protect themselves and actually kind of shocking.
- 20:52They wouldn't investigate and to protect themselves from other
- 20:55investors. Among other things.
- 20:56Like I just Yeah, it seems really strange rolling back a
- 21:01little bit on this. I mean, as someone who worked
- 21:03in, you know, in the digital media sphere, you know like I
- 21:07mentioned like the cohort in which, you know, Ozzy came from,
- 21:12what was it that Drew you to wanting to write about them?
- 21:14Me, I'm imagining you'd heard about the Alex Piper incident
- 21:17and that's just such a juicy story.
- 21:18You've got to confirm it, but was it one thing about like can
- 21:22I track this one? Anecdote down?
- 21:24Or is it like yeah. What is the deal with Ozzy?
- 21:26Because it's so that's amazing. I'm a very tip driven reporter
- 21:29to be totally honest. Like I, yeah, you know, I like I
- 21:32sort of know what as he is and sort of always was like and but
- 21:35you're not going to write a story that's like this company
- 21:37you've never really heard of isn't exactly what it seems
- 21:40like, who cares? Well, especially if you don't
- 21:43care about the company that they nobody hears about it, right?
- 21:45Because it doesn't have any real audience.
- 21:47So like who am I writing for? So I that's why I wouldn't
- 21:50really have thought of everything but as a but that I
- 21:53mean, that Goldman thing is one of the craziest things I've ever
- 21:56heard. So it needs and wants Able to
- 21:58track that down. I sort of was like what's a
- 21:59What's Happening Here impersonating.
- 22:02Another person in order to get 40 million dollars.
- 22:04If it happened is definitely, it's just, it's just such a
- 22:09literal secure. I mean, it's just like, yeah,
- 22:11it's such literal fraud but also like so ham-fisted and so sane,
- 22:17you know, I suppose somebody just like in a dupe Goldman and
- 22:21I'm, it's incredible. I mean, I'm sure you've had
- 22:22these conversations to I spoke with somebody who, I mean, I
- 22:25used to cover Wall Street so you know who was like Oh yes.
- 22:28Spoken to one of the people on the call and they knew from the
- 22:32minute, they got the Gmail address.
- 22:34That something was weird. And then the therefore, the
- 22:37flood lights are like, what the heck.
- 22:40So like who, who, who in their right Minds things?
- 22:45I can I can do this. I can get away with this.
- 22:47That's the other you said with right mind yes they had been
- 22:51telling all these stories at particularly about their
- 22:54relationship with YouTube. And then Goldman says, we want
- 22:58On to talk to you, too. And so I think I don't think
- 23:01it's I think they were in a bit of a corner, you feel like it
- 23:04was the first time somebody to actually set like check to their
- 23:07work. I've no idea if it was the first
- 23:08time they that they did something like this or not, they
- 23:10say it was, but I do think the reality is they had talked up
- 23:14this relationship, they didn't really have and so suddenly,
- 23:18they're very flat, very close, I think.
- 23:20Or they think they're very close on this investment.
- 23:22There's some last questions from Goldman Goldman, emails and
- 23:25says, hey, we'd like to talk to YouTube and maybe another of
- 23:28your partner is one of these other guys.
- 23:29Guys and suddenly it's like, frightened Toby.
- 23:33Didn't think dammit. Think what do we do?
- 23:34I don't know. And I think like You know, these
- 23:38things you can sort of, I guess, I sort of think that it's pretty
- 23:40relatable that you for people that you tell some little lie
- 23:44and get the gets deeper and deeper and deeper.
- 23:45And I think that's kind of what happened here.
- 23:48Sure. But there's also the story that
- 23:50people want to believe that got Ozzy to hold and to be clear, I
- 23:52have never done anything like, you know.
- 23:55Yeah. Well, typically, you know, if it
- 23:58crosses your mind, you you, you know, you cross it out, you
- 24:01know, like the first you're like, well, we could pretend to
- 24:03be Alex Piper and then you move on.
- 24:06But Like back to like you know the nature of the scam, I think
- 24:10the reason you know an Asia itself.
- 24:12The reason that it had so much purchase with investors is
- 24:15because I think a lot of them wanted to believe it.
- 24:18You know, if you look at Elizabeth Holmes and the mark
- 24:20that she had, when she was able to raise money, she would get
- 24:23this money from older men who wanted to feel like they were
- 24:29backing a female entrepreneur. And, and maybe they felt like
- 24:32they were a father figure to her.
- 24:35Maybe I'm being very generous with this, but But it was a way
- 24:38to like, generous, and like they were rooting for a woman and
- 24:44start up because there aren't a lot of this.
- 24:47Right now, I know. I sorry.
- 24:48I, when I say generous, I mean they're actual feeling, and I
- 24:51know, but I'm saying like there's yeah, I mean, I think
- 24:54good these things always sort of hold up a mirror to society, in
- 24:58a certain way rice. It was fascinating that you had
- 25:01two people talk about wanting to work with Ozzy because they felt
- 25:04this sort of social Awakening after the death of George Floyd.
- 25:08Or they saw this social Awakening around race in
- 25:10America. They want to be part of it, and
- 25:11they felt that Carlos presented them this way.
- 25:14And, and, and that is He represented that to them, he was
- 25:18like an easy answer to them, it's like they felt guilt over.
- 25:20The fact, there aren't that many minority LED media companies out
- 25:24there. And here was someone willing to
- 25:26fill that particular Niche for them in a way that it's just a
- 25:29very effective pitch to a certain type of person and
- 25:33allows them to probably look the other way when any other
- 25:35situation would have been like yeah I don't think these numbers
- 25:38really add up and it's does that make sense to you at all or
- 25:41totally into the Ford Foundation?
- 25:44Said it to me directly but they were so excited to invest in a I
- 25:47mean, I found it sort of depressing.
- 25:49Honestly, the way he put it, which is that this company
- 25:51showed that black LED companies like like will certainly be
- 25:56great and it's like, well actually a lot are like there
- 25:58are a lot of great black media printers but you sort of didn't
- 26:02bother checking, whether this was one of them.
- 26:04I mean it's and I do think it's also you know, Carlos is
- 26:09politics were very unthreatening.
- 26:11He's sort of, you know, his sort of basic point of view on the
- 26:13world. Is that like if only Republicans
- 26:16Democrats Talk more and have more nuanced conversations that
- 26:19everything would be better. And that's like a and you know,
- 26:22like it's a very Silicon Valley investor friendly point of view
- 26:26on the world. It's not, we need to shut down
- 26:29Facebook and take all your money, right?
- 26:32So well, that would be quite a media company.
- 26:37So I guess my last question is, here would be like, I mean, the
- 26:41Aussie story because it is so crazy, and involves such, you
- 26:45know, outlandish. Feats an axe, is there anything
- 26:48really? We can learn from it.
- 26:50You know, I mean, sometimes I think is so exciting.
- 26:52Honestly, like, I was in the column.
- 26:54I gotta write so I don't know. Stay tuned if you have any idea.
- 26:57Okay, thank you. Yeah, Donna exacts.
- 27:01I put that right over the top. Yeah, we do a better job at it.
- 27:04I mean, I don't know. I guess you'd have to start
- 27:07drawing conclusions on that whole class of, you know,
- 27:11digital media companies that came from that era and like
- 27:13BuzzFeed is clearly proved itself at least to a point that
- 27:16people keep saying that to me, and as somebody who really grew
- 27:18up in that, I really don't think that's true at all.
- 27:21Which look, I think is not true. Like I think a lot, most of it,
- 27:24I think I'll, you know, most of those companies were real, some
- 27:28succeeded on the merits, some crashed and burned on the
- 27:30merits. This was a really unusual
- 27:33situation. I also think that people who
- 27:36sort of blame digital media of forget half scammy, the media
- 27:39business has always been like, when I was the perfect Sam's on
- 27:42a great print newspaper. I believe one of our Marketing
- 27:45Executives was charged for telling advertisers that we were
- 27:50printing a gazillion paper is and we were In fact, not and
- 27:53they were dumping the extras and empty.
- 27:55Lots. So you know, the a deterministic
- 27:57magazines, juicers, Elation, always.
- 28:00Yeah. Yeah, circulation.
- 28:01Fraud is a very old. It's real deep when I worked at
- 28:05times a week. But it's the perfect fraud
- 28:10because usually unless your fleece and Goldman Sachs and
- 28:13investors the victims are advertisers, how much do they
- 28:16really care? You know, like they're willing
- 28:18to believe a lot of things when it comes to Roi or traffic or
- 28:22the effectiveness of ads. So like there's sort of like a
- 28:24tacit agreement on the part of some media companies.
- 28:27Advertisers to say like hey the numbers say what they say maybe
- 28:30it helped increase sales, maybe it didn't but you got to spend
- 28:32the money somewhere and that well it also there's a bit of a
- 28:36conspiracy to cover. Stuff up because the agency is
- 28:39don't. Who often are the ones who are
- 28:41supposed to have their eyes on the, on the wheel didn't.
- 28:45And they don't want to tell the advertisers they screwed up so
- 28:48often. If they, if an agency discovers
- 28:51that they've been scammed, they will maybe they'll make it right
- 28:54or they'll move the money somewhere else.
- 28:55But they're not going to go to the CMO and say, hey, by the
- 28:58way, you hired us to spend your money effectively and we're
- 29:00morons. Yeah, so maybe this is just a
- 29:02case where it's just, you know, the ending of Burn.
- 29:04After Reading like, it's just JK Simmons saying like, Well, I
- 29:07guess what we learned is to never do it all again.
- 29:09What do we learn Palmer? I don't know.
- 29:11Sir. I don't fucking know either.
- 29:16I guess we learned not to do it again because I don't know, I
- 29:19don't know. Well, we will be looking for
- 29:21your next column. Thank you for coming on.
- 29:23We know you're busy, you're drowning.
- 29:25So we appreciate. Thanks for uh, thanks for having
- 29:27me. It's nice to see you guys.
- 29:29Yeah, thanks Ben. Bye.
- 29:40I think that then definitely. I mean clearly he has a view on
- 29:44Ozzy, he wasn't He wasn't withholding of it but I did
- 29:53think it was interesting how you know, he he wants to separate
- 29:58Ozzy from the rest of kind of this like online news startup
- 30:03world and I'm wondering if he's right to do that.
- 30:06Like I don't actually like having not covered the media
- 30:08myself. I don't have like info an
- 30:10informed opinion, but what do you think of that?
- 30:12I think it. I think it is an interesting
- 30:15comparison. Because he's right.
- 30:17BuzzFeed is a real business they have made hundreds of millions
- 30:21of dollars. They have a diversified Revenue
- 30:23stream, their financials are all out there.
- 30:25Like they have a very plausible SPAC that they're putting
- 30:29together. But I also think that to say
- 30:33that there is a world of difference between, you know,
- 30:37it's like Ozzy could have been in the BuzzFeed mold if it had
- 30:41gone a slightly different direction, you know, you can
- 30:44convince enough advertisers you Convinced enough decent
- 30:47reporters to work for you. You can convince enough
- 30:50celebrities to do appearances at your conferences that you build
- 30:53a real business. I mean like that's the make it
- 30:55part of the fake it till you make it, you know, you don't
- 30:57have to just keep faking it until everybody, you know, just
- 31:00agrees to make you too big to fail, like, you can at some
- 31:03point turn it into a legitimate business.
- 31:06And so, you know, maybe there is something rotten at the core of
- 31:11Ozzy that made it. So, it was inevitable, that it
- 31:13was end up this way. Or, at some point, you kind of
- 31:16like, Wake up and say, all right, we have these connections
- 31:19with, you know, Hillary Clinton and Steven Pinker.
- 31:22I don't know who I, you know, shows up at their conferences
- 31:24and we have advertisers coming to us saying we can reach an
- 31:30audience, that's hard to reach in a cool and formed, you know,
- 31:35politically active way. And let's hire and they did
- 31:39hire, you know, legitimate reporters from BBC, and, and
- 31:42other outlets to do things. And at some point, you kind of
- 31:45make the turn, you know, You, you turn straight and you build
- 31:49a real business and my guess is that maybe is what Ozzy was
- 31:53expecting. It's like we just get this
- 31:54Goldman money. Yeah, we will have pretended to
- 31:57be all exclaiming reminds me so much of Bernie Madoff and so
- 32:00many ways. Obviously did spiral out of
- 32:02control like that and result in like the loss of Fortunes for
- 32:06countless people. But just that idea, you know,
- 32:09that that, that made off at first just it wasn't his intent
- 32:15to run upon, right? You really did think he put the
- 32:17money back in until it just kind of spiraled out of control.
- 32:20Yeah, and it's you know, it's funny been making the comparison
- 32:23of like I really thought Elizabeth Holmes, she may have
- 32:25just sold this whole thing to Walmart and then no one would
- 32:29have thought that and it's like, well, you still, you still built
- 32:32a fraudulent company, you still have the technology.
- 32:34This is a little different but remember Jed.com, hmm.
- 32:38How that was going to crash and burn.
- 32:39But there were so many predictive articles about how
- 32:41Jet.com made no sense and it was their ridiculous.
- 32:44And like this thing that economics didn't work.
- 32:46We're going to be Amazon, what a waste of time, what a waste of
- 32:48investor money, and then they sold to Walmart, right?
- 32:54And and, and mark Laurie had a, you know, very important role at
- 32:58Walmart. Still it still does still
- 32:59doesn't even though jet essentially has been dismantled,
- 33:02you know, you could argue our Walmart would argue to
- 33:05shareholders that the acquisition.
- 33:07Help them in some way and that, even though this, I think it
- 33:10did, crazy dream. It won't unquote, worked out in
- 33:15the end for everyone. Yeah, but what's interesting
- 33:18with the media company is that the Acquisitions are almost
- 33:21always terrible in my present company because I bought them
- 33:25all my present company, excluded, brilliant.
- 33:28Brilliant move. But you know, you look at
- 33:30something like ulti spying cheddar.
- 33:34See you just said two hours. I'm like, what are these words?
- 33:36Altice has a giant cable company and cheddar is John cheddar is
- 33:42like, kind of a millennial CNBC, which still exists but and it
- 33:45was deleted. A person who came from BuzzFeed
- 33:49Ron Steinberg, one of the pret, the president at BuzzFeed very,
- 33:53very charismatic boy that that solutions that were we can never
- 33:57use charismatic assassin. John Steinbeck is a great
- 33:59salesman and I know or that built.
- 34:02Oh boy, John Steinberg is a talented man.
- 34:06And very energetic. And he's a force to be reckoned
- 34:09with you've ever had a conversation with him, but he,
- 34:13you know, he sold his company. He's now an executive at altice
- 34:16and I I think they thought kind of bringing him on was a way
- 34:18that they could make their brand, something that Katie
- 34:20better was aware of. And, you know, it's interesting
- 34:26with media because a lot of these Acquisitions just they
- 34:28just don't go very well. But if you're an investor, you
- 34:31get an Roi. And I got a think at a certain
- 34:34point that was probably the thought process.
- 34:36But you know, is it going to go public is gonna be the next
- 34:39Disney now, but will someone want to buy it at some point
- 34:43worth a shot. I actually met Carlos Watson and
- 34:47Ben Smith in the same week approximately it was while I was
- 34:53still at fortune. And I was looking for a new job
- 34:55because I felt like time Inc was really struggling.
- 34:58This would have been, I think in 2013 or so that's your not a
- 35:02media report. I am a genius and I thought
- 35:05timing was struggling in 2013. I don't remember, it's 2013 and
- 35:092014, but it was one BuzzFeed was building out its new, its
- 35:12business news desk and I think that Peter Lauria I'll have to
- 35:17check that name. Very nice - yeah, it was really
- 35:20nice, guy. Covered media.
- 35:22Yeah, covered media at BuzzFeed. Did a really nice job.
- 35:24I don't think he's a reporter anymore but he's he's great for
- 35:27great things. Yeah and I knew him from because
- 35:29we both covered ball straight. He wanted me to come in for an
- 35:32interview and then somebody to introduce me to Carlos Watson to
- 35:36see if I'd want to go work at a company.
- 35:37I'd never heard of called Ozzy. So I heard about this Ozzy
- 35:44thing. When I met with Carlos it was
- 35:46Strange interview because he, we spoke about me being a reporter,
- 35:49which would be the appropriate job for me.
- 35:52And then he shifted and said, you know, I actually see in you,
- 35:57the makings of an editor, perhaps a high level editor,
- 36:01perhaps, even managing editor, perhaps even managing editor of
- 36:05over half of this year ago sight, out of here.
- 36:10And I thought that, I mean, even even though, I'm even though I'm
- 36:13a dimwit, I knew that was a bad sign that I I just love just
- 36:17throwing human beings into roles who are unqualified.
- 36:19It's not totally great. So I decided that I probably
- 36:25wouldn't go to Ozzy and then Peter it set me up with an
- 36:28interview with Ben and that interview lasted, I think I
- 36:31clocked it at four minutes much shorter than the Aussie
- 36:35interview and Ben was pretty pretty straightforward.
- 36:38He said you know you're coming from the magazine world and
- 36:40magazine reporters are very, very slow ponderous.
- 36:43And they are usually pretty like not great.
- 36:46Beep reporter. So I also didn't get the job at
- 36:50BuzzFeed, so I was, I was I was I was basically knocked out of
- 36:54the world of startup, you know, Venture back media.
- 36:58Unfortunately, I had I had my shot and I wasn't able.
- 37:03I wasn't able to get in. I wasn't able to.
- 37:04Yeah, but yeah. It's just I'll just say, they
- 37:09were really extreme conversations and I think I came
- 37:13out in the think I came on the middle.
- 37:15I think it came out. middle, but I think it also speaks to kind
- 37:18of like how If based on those conversations, I would have
- 37:23predicted that both companies had ended up approximately in
- 37:27the places. They are now one struggling to,
- 37:31you know, establish legitimacy and or, you know, struggling
- 37:36with accusations of Fraud and then the other with very high
- 37:39standards doing much better. One of the few companies that's
- 37:43probably going to get out and have, you know, and hit the
- 37:47public markets. Yeah, no, definitely the best.
- 37:50The crop. And, you know, we could maybe
- 37:53revisit this topic, like a year from now or something.
- 37:55Because I think I think of all the places that wouldn't hire
- 37:57me. Yeah, yeah, I think we should
- 38:00check in that regularly. Oh, I can answer that too but
- 38:05we, you know, like the the full report card is yet to be fully
- 38:10submitted. I think on like that whole class
- 38:12of companies, we obviously have at the bottom, the Aziz I think.
- 38:16Cause he's like, did not complete but then you have, you
- 38:19know, your mics and your Fusion, And which kind of failed out and
- 38:23then we'll Mashable sure. They are still around to a
- 38:27degree, they got acquired, but for pennies on the dollar and
- 38:31then, you know, we have BuzzFeed, which is going to make
- 38:34a good go of it. Like we mentioned Vox, which I
- 38:37hear is a legitimate, you know, has a real business there.
- 38:40And then, and then Vice which who the hell knows as we talked
- 38:44about with Ben, but it certainly didn't turn out how it was
- 38:49cracked up to be. I think there was an expectation
- 38:51that they were creating the next Disney's and and the next New
- 38:54York Times and I don't know and pick your company and it just
- 38:57didn't turn out that way. And so we've gotten the full
- 39:00like banquet panoply of like outcomes from the frauds to the
- 39:06pretty good but no spectaculars. And also I think that the forces
- 39:09that I've applied, you know, I think the pressures on online
- 39:13media and on a lot of these startups, these are pressures
- 39:17that are being felt by You know, by more traditional media
- 39:22companies if not more. So like yes you can say some of
- 39:27these things have fallen by the wayside but look at what's going
- 39:29on in the magazine industry like Conde Nast is still standing but
- 39:33obviously struggling financially if not not in other ways time
- 39:40Inc, where I worked a company that I love does not really
- 39:43exist anymore. No, he's getting chopped up and
- 39:46resold, it's each publication. Is going to become a standalone
- 39:50asset, that get sold and traded again and again for The Branding
- 39:54and then you know, it like business make is part of
- 39:58Bloomberg. So you've already.
- 39:58So you saw traditional media also be torn apart by forces
- 40:04around digital advertising, digital media and and what and
- 40:10sort of like the D emphasis on the content for a really long
- 40:15period of time. So you know, we're all going to
- 40:17come out of this together. In a new place it's not just
- 40:21digital media will see. And now you're working for the
- 40:24New York Times. Very traditional media, I'm
- 40:26working for a company owned by the largest Media company in
- 40:29Germany and it really just all comes down to newcomer your
- 40:32heart. These are sold digitalexplorer.
- 40:35It's just Eric. And some stack just bravely
- 40:39charting A New Path. Yeah, with that said, Eric
- 40:43newcomer is returning next week from his vacation.
- 40:46I'm sure we'll have updates there.
- 40:47So, thanks for joining. Joining us again and we'll all
- 40:50be back in it. Goodbye.
- 40:55So work on Sally, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 41:04Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 41:07Goodbye. Joining us again and we'll all
- 40:50be back in it. Goodbye.
- 40:55So work on Sally, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 41:04Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 41:07Goodbye.