Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #29: Gerrymandering w/ Special Guest Mary Noone
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:02I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:04Today's a special episode because we have a guest.
- 0:06But before we get to that and today's topic, as always, a disclaimer, whether you're news to
- 0:11the show or not, As a nonpartisan analyst, I do not take a specific stance or for or against
- 0:16anybody's particular views or any particular groups they belong to.
- 0:19But nonetheless, I believe today's guest has a very worthwhile viewpoint to discuss on a topic
- 0:25that just about all of us can agree poses a serious problem for our political system,
- 0:31regardless of our political leanings.
- 0:32Today, we're gonna talk about gerrymandering and its negative impacts down the line,
- 0:37including how it affects voter turnout amongst Democrats, Republicans, and independents alike,
- 0:42how it affects political discourse, political competitiveness, and fair elections are queer
- 0:47pieces to the health of American governance, but all too often the specter of gerrymandering
- 0:52threatens it.
- 0:52But it's a complex and deep topic, one that today's special guest has a lot of experience
- 0:58dealing with, and that guest is Mary Noon.
- 1:01Mary Noon is a seasoned campaign strategist and advocate who has translated her business
- 1:06experience into the campaign world.
- 1:09She's particularly experienced in Indiana, her current state, and grown growing up in
- 1:14Massachusetts, she sees up close the stark difference of what governing looks like.
- 1:19Governing that she says benefits the collective.
- 1:21Experience personally the impact of a red or as Mary refers to as a rigged state, and a blue
- 1:26state can be an eye opening experience.
- 1:29Currently, she is the president of Mary Noon campaign strategy.
- 1:32And previously, she cofounded and served as the president of Hoosier victory Alliance.
- 1:37And she was also the chair of the Indiana women's action movement.
- 1:41So without further ado, let's get into the topic of gerrymandering and please welcome Mary
- 1:46Noon.
- 1:47Mary, how are you doing today?
- 1:49Good.
- 1:49How are you, Paul?
- 1:51I'm I am doing good.
- 1:52We got a special guest, you, right on here.
- 1:54So this is a good day.
- 1:55So let's just get right into it.
- 1:58What are a couple examples of gerrymandering that you have seen in your work in campaigns
- 2:03and advocacy?
- 2:04Yeah.
- 2:05You know, when we start talking about gerrymandering, I like to put it in three
- 2:09buckets because it's a very complex issue as you know.
- 2:12There's the technical aspect that we have to talk about.
- 2:15There's the downstream and impact, which incur I talk about voter apathy, and then there's the
- 2:22real world consequences of gerrymandering.
- 2:25So to step back to understand gerrymandering, we have to understand how we got here.
- 2:29Like, why is this a hot topic?
- 2:31Why do some states talk about gerrymandering and others do not?
- 2:35And gerrymandering came from the sheer fact that in, 02/2008 after Obama got elected, some
- 2:41people on the GOP side were like, woah.
- 2:43Wait a minute.
- 2:44How do we gain our power back?
- 2:45What tools in the toolbox do we have to gain more seats in our in our congressional and
- 2:52state houses?
- 2:53And what they did was they turned to Karl Rove, and they turned to another gentleman by the
- 2:58name of Thomas Haffeller.
- 2:59He was down in North Carolina.
- 3:00He has since passed away.
- 3:02And they gave him the challenge of looking at the golden question, how do we gain our power
- 3:08back?
- 3:09And they came up with this project called Redmap, and they threw in $60,000,000 behind
- 3:16this project.
- 3:17And what happened in this project, is very interesting if you'd like to follow the
- 3:21history, if you'd like to get in the weeds, some folks might.
- 3:25There was a great book written about this project.
- 3:27It's called Rat F U, and I won't finish the the say the statement, but by David Daley.
- 3:33And he really outlines the complexity of gerrymandering, but what really happened.
- 3:38And Thomas, who was the orchestrator strategist behind it, basically changed the concept of
- 3:44redistricting, and this is where we need to start.
- 3:46And I'm gonna read exactly because I don't like to misquote folks.
- 3:49He basically said, usually, the voters get to pick the politicians.
- 3:55In redistricting, the politicians now get to pick the voters.
- 3:59So when you say that, you're like, woah.
- 4:01Woah.
- 4:01Wait a minute.
- 4:01That's not democracy.
- 4:03How do we get here?
- 4:04And how we got here was this $60,000,000 red map project that took away your voice, created
- 4:12this system that we're now trying to operate in or get out of, that it really took the power
- 4:18away from the people.
- 4:20And like he said, put the power in the politicians, and we all know we don't want that
- 4:24power to be there.
- 4:25It's supposed to be democratic.
- 4:26So that's where I like to start is, like, how do we get here?
- 4:29This is the technical start.
- 4:30We have to kinda pull back the layers.
- 4:34Right.
- 4:34So actually getting a little bit more into that technical aspects.
- 4:38So we have two main types of gerrymandering.
- 4:40Right?
- 4:41And and regardless of political affiliation, they've both been used.
- 4:44So we have packing where you put as many voters of the opposite party into a district as
- 4:49possible.
- 4:49So it's much easier to win all these other districts.
- 4:52And then there's fracking where you try to dilute voters of the opposing party by
- 4:57diffusing them across as many districts as possible so they can't mount any challenge in
- 5:00those areas.
- 5:01Yep.
- 5:02Do you see one as more insidious and common than the other?
- 5:06Are they both pretty prevalent and on the same level of unfairness in your opinion?
- 5:11Good question.
- 5:12So the the packing and cracking, you know, cracking a district district, it doesn't matter
- 5:17which tool they use in the toolbox.
- 5:19It's all driven by data.
- 5:20So if you were to use Thomas's example, he was a a GOP strategist.
- 5:25It's all data driven.
- 5:26It's all census driven.
- 5:28It's all the best of the best looking at voter data, moving data.
- 5:34You know when branders go out there?
- 5:35My background is in marketing, and it you know, a brander will find out, people's likes and
- 5:40dislikes, and you can try to forecast and draw some conclusions.
- 5:44They layered and unlayered a lot of data and used algorithms to figure out what people's
- 5:49persuasions were hypothetically, and that's how you get to the district mapping.
- 5:53He did it so strategically that the reason we found out of Thomas's mastermind plan was this
- 6:02is a little interesting history for those who likes the history and how this all happens, is
- 6:06Thomas's daughter, and him were estranged.
- 6:10He passes away.
- 6:11She decides to go to the house, you know, as some, you know, children do.
- 6:15You go through your collectibles, your items, and she finds a box.
- 6:18And in the box is all his notes because he never emailed people.
- 6:22He never did anything and put anything in a digital record.
- 6:25It was all on floppies.
- 6:26She's like, what's these?
- 6:28Well, she starts looking at these floppies, and I know you.
- 6:30I know myself.
- 6:31If I I don't know about you, but if I had a floppy, I was like, I had to go find a computer
- 6:34to put it
- 6:35in.
- 6:35Yeah.
- 6:35She
- 6:36does that, and she's like, holy cow.
- 6:39And she runs to common cause down in North Carolina where she lived, and she hands it over
- 6:44to them.
- 6:45So that's when this gets starting, the layers start getting pulled back.
- 6:48So it's data driven.
- 6:50So whether you're cracking or or packing, it really doesn't matter.
- 6:54It's the end goal you're after.
- 6:56So it's just the tools they're using to either break up communities or put them all in one
- 7:01district.
- 7:02Now you're probably like, okay.
- 7:03Why does that matter?
- 7:04Well, that matters because look at some districts that I used to live in Massachusetts
- 7:09or some here in Indiana.
- 7:11When you have a district that encompasses a a section of a rural area, a big swath of it, and
- 7:18then a section that goes all the way into up into the into the, urban area because it's
- 7:25based on population and in our in our in our area that encompasses our population are are
- 7:29vaster.
- 7:30They're much larger.
- 7:31So if you've got different interests as you as the representative, you're creating a lot of
- 7:37animosity and tension within your district because you've got a big water issue you're
- 7:41dealing with.
- 7:41You've got a data center coming in the rural areas and the farmers like, well, wait a
- 7:46minute.
- 7:46You just took our water source for irrigation for our farmers.
- 7:49And the urban areas are like, well, this big data center's coming over here.
- 7:53We want the water.
- 7:54So now you're not getting into a a constructive dialogue.
- 7:57You're you're you're favoring who paid for you to get an office because that's where the going
- 8:03down the the money trail impacts because however you got in office is that's why AOC
- 8:09will say, I don't take lobby's dollars.
- 8:12I don't take special interest groups because she wants to be able to have a conversation
- 8:16with her voters.
- 8:17And when you start looking at, the real life issues and consequences, that's where it comes
- 8:22into play.
- 8:24Gotcha.
- 8:24The the the the whole floppy disk part of that just is kinda funny.
- 8:27I have a fascination with older computers.
- 8:30So just hearing that stuff.
- 8:31And obviously I don't have a comp.
- 8:32I don't think I have a computer that can use those now, but just goes to show you just how,
- 8:37you know, how long the gerrymandering has been an issue.
- 8:39Although obviously how it looks is, is a bit different now, but, before we get a
- 8:44Actually, really recent.
- 8:45This wasn't Thomas just recently passed away.
- 8:47This wasn't something
- 8:48Okay.
- 8:49He just chose to use that type of tool because he didn't wanna leave a digital footprint that
- 8:53you and I all know that when we share emails, gonna send somebody else.
- 8:58He was involved when Trump was in office when we were doing the censoring because he was
- 9:03trying to forecast what that means.
- 9:05So he's been involved in this for quite a long time.
- 9:09He just chose to use that tool because he you know, you can obviously draw conclusions here
- 9:14as why he's using floppies is because he doesn't want anybody to get ahold of his work.
- 9:19Right.
- 9:20Yeah.
- 9:20It it's it is scary just how how good these algorithms are getting.
- 9:25You feel like you say something not even into the computer and all of a sudden, oh, did this
- 9:29computer hear me?
- 9:30It feels like that sometimes.
- 9:32So before we get more into the effects that you see from, gerrymandering, because it's easy to
- 9:38just say, oh, gerrymandering is bad.
- 9:39But Right.
- 9:41Before we get to that, just a little bit more about how gerrymandering exactly looks.
- 9:46So how do we point to districts to be able to say, okay.
- 9:49That's clearly drawn in a deliberately and then is there a way to benefit one party?
- 9:54Because you can look at some districts and say, okay.
- 9:57That is not a that's not a legitimate shape.
- 9:59That's clearly meant to benefit somebody.
- 10:02But what about the less obvious cases?
- 10:05How do we sniff out those cases of gerrymandering?
- 10:08Yeah.
- 10:09That's a good question because I think you have to, you know, I think you have to go back.
- 10:14So you're the question you're asking is, how do we know my district is gerrymandering?
- 10:18Right?
- 10:19And it's it's what's happening in your district.
- 10:22It's it's okay.
- 10:24For example, you open up you open up a bill that you get from the doctor, and all of a
- 10:28sudden your bill is, you know, the same procedure that an annual screening that you had
- 10:34was normally a co payment or an extra dollar payment of a hundred dollars.
- 10:38And then the next year, you're like, Why do I have to pay $500 for this?
- 10:42So people don't start peeling back the layers until they're triggered.
- 10:46And when they're triggered, then they re then they start, you know, hey.
- 10:50Why is this?
- 10:51And then they call off they call the doctor or they call the office, and they said, well,
- 10:55that's what your health insurance is now paying for.
- 10:57Like, well, why is that?
- 10:59You go online, then you do a little research, and you realize, oh, wait a minute.
- 11:04The the bill that was passed is hospitals can now charge an additional surcharge for all
- 11:11these 10 procedures.
- 11:12And then you're like, oh, here's my representative.
- 11:15He voted for that.
- 11:16So it's not a a a thing that we are used to doing.
- 11:20It's not a normal cause and effect.
- 11:23But what happens is people are getting more and more triggered of wondering why things are
- 11:27happening.
- 11:28I'll give you another example.
- 11:29Here in Indiana, we had this big data center.
- 11:33We have three of them coming to Indiana.
- 11:36And a lot of folks are, you know, the first, for lack of a better word, it's enticing.
- 11:42You're like a big business is coming here.
- 11:44One of them is Microsoft, Another one is Amazon, and I'm gonna blank out on the third
- 11:49one.
- 11:50But when the center was coming, it was a big sale of somebody who was aging out of farming,
- 11:55a family farm, and they wanted to sell their property.
- 11:58Okay.
- 11:58Understandable.
- 11:59You wanna sell your property.
- 12:00You've been in the farming business for seventy years.
- 12:02Nobody in your family is taking over.
- 12:04Great.
- 12:05But in that process of selling the farm, the community wanted to know, okay.
- 12:10What kind of impact is it gonna have on us?
- 12:11Because the status center is coming.
- 12:13That's electricity.
- 12:14That's a huge amount of water.
- 12:16That's traffic flow.
- 12:18That's neighborhoods.
- 12:19And on that side of the district, it is much more rural.
- 12:23That's where the baseball fields are.
- 12:25That's where all the community spaces.
- 12:27And there was also a creek, an environmental creek that that services a lot of recreational
- 12:32activities, and it has been being protected in the wetlands.
- 12:36And the community said, well, woah, woah, woah, wait a minute.
- 12:38This big center's coming here.
- 12:39Well, what about all these issues we need to discuss?
- 12:42Right?
- 12:43Because they were triggered.
- 12:45So there's a community meeting that happens, and 300 people show up to ask a lot of these
- 12:50questions of their representatives, a lot of these environmental questions.
- 12:55So rewind in our legislative session in 2023, they reclassified that legislator, their
- 13:03representatives, who they're now trying to ask questions to.
- 13:06Now keep in mind, the representatives in that district, the state legislator, senator, and
- 13:11the state representative did not show up for the meeting.
- 13:15They don't have to.
- 13:16They don't have to answer these questions.
- 13:18The questions they were asking was a lot of environmental, water, electricity bills.
- 13:24When you go back in the twenty twenty four three session, because this was last year in
- 13:282024, they already reclassified lands, large swaths of lands across Indiana.
- 13:34So no longer do corporations when they come into the area have to put in some environmental
- 13:40protections, rewrite the water, make sure that the the common spaces, the common lands are
- 13:46protected.
- 13:47People are scratching their head.
- 13:48They're like, well, why not?
- 13:49Well, your representatives voted for it last year.
- 13:52So what's happening is representatives are not showing up when people have a concern because
- 13:58people are busy.
- 13:59Their heads are down.
- 14:00They're raising their families.
- 14:02They're going to work.
- 14:03And when they raise their hand because they're triggered, remember, people don't take action
- 14:07because it's still a trigger, and they're trying to get answered, and it's too late.
- 14:11The project is already down the pike.
- 14:13People are making decisions on your behalf.
- 14:15So that's how gerrymandering is affecting people.
- 14:18And now that the problems are getting worse, people are starting to wake up and wanna say,
- 14:23and they're frustrated because their voices aren't being heard because, like I said,
- 14:27project's already down the pipe.
- 14:28That's already been decided.
- 14:30Sorry, but representatives don't even show up.
- 14:34So, actually, this made me think of, another question.
- 14:38And this isn't really quite a consensus.
- 14:40It seems to be the popular opinion, but it's I don't think it's quite a consensus as some data
- 14:45suggests that more and more people are finding neighborhoods to move to where they find people
- 14:52that are more like them politically.
- 14:54So the idea is that more Republicans are moving to Republican areas and more Democrats are
- 14:59moving to Democratic areas.
- 15:00Again, not necessarily consensus, but do you think or do a, do you, do you agree with that?
- 15:05And B, do you think that that is also a potential contributor to gerrymandering where,
- 15:10okay, maybe at some point this district wasn't so unfairly leaning one way, but maybe further
- 15:17down the road when more and more people move there, maybe then it technically becomes
- 15:22unfair.
- 15:22Do you, see it that way?
- 15:24That's the social fallout.
- 15:26That is really and that creates so I think that's the after effect.
- 15:30The going back to the tools that the representatives use to gerrymander, and it
- 15:34imposes this feeling of, like, I don't you know, before you I grew up in Massachusetts, an
- 15:40Irish Boston area.
- 15:41I grew out in the Central Mass, but then I moved to Boston.
- 15:44Everybody talks about politics.
- 15:45You know, you got Tip O'Neill.
- 15:46You've got the Kennedys.
- 15:47You got Fitzy, you know, Rose Kennedy's father.
- 15:51And, we've stopped talking about politics.
- 15:54So as a result, the question going back to your question is people wanna know who their
- 15:58neighbors are now because they're nervous because we've become so polarized.
- 16:02That's the fall of gerrymandering is we've become so polarized rather than just moving
- 16:07into a neighborhood and going to your neighbor with a bundt cake and saying, hey.
- 16:11I just moved in.
- 16:12You wanna come over from coffee?
- 16:13People wanna know who they're living next to now because of the impact.
- 16:18And that's not how we should be living.
- 16:21Right.
- 16:22No.
- 16:22Absolutely.
- 16:22And that's that's I it's something that I've been working a lot on, writing and and a,
- 16:30public speaking, topic on polar polarization in gen in general, but a couple of those things,
- 16:39gonna or or definitely gonna be a part of it.
- 16:41So you know what?
- 16:41Let's let's keep this, track.
- 16:44I'll get to another question that I I was gonna ask, but let's let's keep on this whole,
- 16:50effects of, gerrymandering because besides hindering electoral competitiveness, and you
- 16:56already talked about a couple of potential effects, what are some of the other problems
- 16:59that you see that have arisen from gerrymandering?
- 17:02For example, do you see any particular effects on voter participation?
- 17:06Oh, absolutely.
- 17:08Absolutely.
- 17:09Indiana is now fiftieth in voter turnout.
- 17:12It creates like, as I mentioned, it has three impacts.
- 17:14You've got the technical thing that's going on.
- 17:17You've got and then the other one is voter apathy.
- 17:19Because you people feel like they don't have agency.
- 17:22They don't have they don't feel like they can make an impact.
- 17:26For example, you know, I've been involved in campaigns, and there are times when I'm out
- 17:30there with the candidate knocking on doors.
- 17:32And you hear he I was with a candidate, and one of this candidate is really crafty in in terms
- 17:38of very skilled at connecting with voters.
- 17:40And this young woman was on her porch, and she was doing some studying in in college age.
- 17:46And she and this was during the the Dobbs decision, you know, taking her agency away.
- 17:51And she said, I don't do politics.
- 17:54And and the candidate goes, oh, no.
- 17:56No.
- 17:56No.
- 17:56No.
- 17:57Politics does you.
- 17:58Let me sit down and tell you.
- 17:59Yeah.
- 18:00This impacts you.
- 18:01So people have stepped out of the process, and they feel like they don't have any control
- 18:05because it's so gerrymandered.
- 18:07And then those who are in control get louder and louder.
- 18:10And so when you people feel like they don't have a means to change things, they step out of
- 18:16the process.
- 18:17Because as we know, gerrymandering, as we talked about, was is data driven.
- 18:21They look at how to keep control regardless of what side of party you are.
- 18:25You know?
- 18:25A lot of people will say New York really, you know, plays with the boundaries, and it does
- 18:29isn't a true representative of the voters.
- 18:33But then they go to step number two.
- 18:35They change how who can vote, when you can vote, who should be on the roll.
- 18:39So they start to take away more and more of your agency.
- 18:42So when people don't feel like they have power, they give up because, you know, we are all
- 18:48working, raising kids, the daily life struggles and challenges.
- 18:53When you don't feel like you have agency, you start participating, and that's the larger
- 18:58effect.
- 18:58That's what they want.
- 18:59We don't want people to participate.
- 19:02For example, here in Indiana, one of the good things is our early voting time is thirty days.
- 19:10You can vote early for thirty days.
- 19:12Now within those thirty days, there's different counties do different hours, etcetera.
- 19:17But when you're out there and you're asking people why didn't you vote, here's what they
- 19:23say.
- 19:24Oh, I was at work, and my boss asked me to do x, y, and z, and I had to stay longer, and I
- 19:29didn't get to vote.
- 19:30Because here in Indiana, they close the voting places at 06:00 at night.
- 19:34Okay.
- 19:34That's a challenge.
- 19:35You get out of work at 05:30.
- 19:37You get home.
- 19:38You make sure the kids are there.
- 19:39There's not enough time to turn around to go to vote.
- 19:42So they constantly chip away at your agency.
- 19:45And when you've lost the power to participate until something bad happens, we are creatures
- 19:51of habits.
- 19:53That's when people start waking up.
- 19:54When the people start taking their power back, that's when things are gonna change.
- 19:59Yeah.
- 19:59That's interesting.
- 20:0006:00 is down here in Florida.
- 20:01It's actually or at least at least for my county, it's it's 07:00.
- 20:07And you you you touched a little bit on it with the the whole, political efficacy.
- 20:11Didn't quite say that word, but that's what you were referring to.
- 20:13As just kind of funny because I just did a, my last episode of the podcast was just me talking
- 20:18about political efficacy, and I didn't even get onto the, gerrymandering aspect.
- 20:23But let's shift gears a little bit here and talk a little bit more about, why, I guess,
- 20:31sort of why gerrymandering is still able to happen.
- 20:35So talk about Supreme court cases and the Supreme court us Supreme court states, Supreme
- 20:39courts.
- 20:39They've they've dealt with, gerrymandering before, and some people would probably say
- 20:45insufficiently.
- 20:47So do you think that the in your opinion, do you think the US Supreme Court or even state
- 20:51Supreme Courts have been effective in tackling the issue of gerrymandering?
- 20:55More specifically on partisan lines versus, say, racial gerrymandering, which has been,
- 21:00strongly addressed previously.
- 21:02Right.
- 21:02I think before we even get there, we gotta step back.
- 21:04So how do states actually decide their boundaries?
- 21:07There there's congressional in their in their state house boundaries, there's three avenues
- 21:12they can use or or or tools that they use.
- 21:14One is some states are now gone to independent commissions where with an outside source,
- 21:20again, data driven to decide the the regulations.
- 21:25And there's different representatives on equal sides on these independent commissions.
- 21:29It's how they've decided to have their districts drawn.
- 21:32The other one is legislators' control.
- 21:34When the legislators decide, they hire somebody.
- 21:38And if it they're in control, you gotta wonder who they're gonna hire.
- 21:41Okay?
- 21:42And they make all the decisions.
- 21:44And then the other one is political commissions where they have equal representation on each
- 21:48sides, and they hash out the differences and they go back and forth.
- 21:52And it does have to go to a vote to their to into their state house if they're a super
- 21:56majority or or that's where it plays out a little bit more intensely.
- 22:02So you have those step one.
- 22:04You had those commissions that decide what the districts are.
- 22:08Now within that work, if they did some cracking and packing, then you can take it up to the sup
- 22:15your your courts, your state courts, and then your supreme court.
- 22:18Now keep in mind, if you're in a very gerrymandered one control state, over the
- 22:23years, you've also packed your court.
- 22:25You also packed your state house.
- 22:26Excuse me.
- 22:27Your state house has packed your supreme court.
- 22:30Now if your supreme court is very much in lines lockstep with your state house, they're gonna
- 22:35pause it right there.
- 22:36They're gonna find, you know, legal reasoning for why they feel this is not, disenfranchising
- 22:41voters, and then it doesn't get up to the Supreme Court.
- 22:44That's why everybody's really watching North Carolina and the recounting of that Supreme
- 22:51Court race because that's your step one.
- 22:53You can't get it out of the state level court system.
- 22:56You Can't get it up to the Supreme Court for them to really imply the Voting Rights Act and
- 23:01the litmus test that they the tools that they have.
- 23:03And then you've got states like down south in Mississippi.
- 23:07Was it Mississippi, Louisiana?
- 23:09That they deemed it.
- 23:13I forgot which district.
- 23:14It was one of the districts in the in the it's in Louisiana.
- 23:17It was one of the the the city districts around New Orleans, and they deemed it, they packed
- 23:22everybody in, and they deemed it unconstitutional.
- 23:25Now it needs to go back to the state house, and they need to redraw it.
- 23:28They said, no.
- 23:29We're not gonna do it.
- 23:30So now you're in the court battle.
- 23:32The election time ticks on, and you have to hold an election.
- 23:34So they're pausing and using the legal system to their advantage.
- 23:38So there are tools in our toolbox.
- 23:41Are the courts working?
- 23:42Yes.
- 23:43If you wanna follow more of this, I highly recommend following democracy docket with Mark
- 23:47Elias.
- 23:48He really follows these cases, and he has his teams on the ground because the end of the day
- 23:53I'll share a story with you.
- 23:55Health care.
- 23:56Health care, we all need health care.
- 23:57Right?
- 23:58It's universal regardless of your political affiliation.
- 24:03Here in Indiana, we have the highest health care costs, and most of it's associated with
- 24:08the hospitals.
- 24:09Now keep in mind, when you're in Indiana, you have the small nonprofit hospitals closing up
- 24:15all being gobbled up by the bigger hospitals.
- 24:19We even have the leading economists here in Indiana have claimed that our hospital system
- 24:24is a perfect example of a monopoly.
- 24:26Now peel back the layers.
- 24:27You look at all our representatives.
- 24:29They're all on the take, I like to say, because they're all getting their dollars, their
- 24:33campaign dollars from the hospital associations, etcetera.
- 24:36But how does it impact you?
- 24:38It impacts employees and employers because they have to dole out the highest health care costs
- 24:43to cover their employers.
- 24:44They pull back in their coverage.
- 24:46But even to even go back even further, I'll give you a true example.
- 24:51So we have a great organization here in Indiana.
- 24:53The doctors have come together because they see this impacting us, them, and their patient
- 24:58care.
- 24:59It's called Good Health Coalition, Good Trouble Coalition.
- 25:02They they're doctors and health care providers that have come together and say, wait a minute.
- 25:06We need to follow the health legislation going through much closer with a medical expert in
- 25:12the room to help bisect what this what this impact is to our to our consumers, like cost
- 25:18and price.
- 25:19So you need your annual screenings.
- 25:21We all get to be age 45, 50, depending on where you live.
- 25:25Need a colonoscopy.
- 25:26Right?
- 25:27Your your general practitioner will say, okay.
- 25:31It's that year.
- 25:31You need to go have that screening because we all know that's screening preventative for
- 25:35cancer down the road.
- 25:37And you're you go out to the desk, and what do they do?
- 25:39They make the appointment for you.
- 25:40Right?
- 25:40Like, they say, oh, there's an opening over here at this clinic, or you're five minutes
- 25:46from the hospital because that's where you work and you wanna go to the hospital to have that
- 25:49outpatient taken care of.
- 25:51Right?
- 25:52So it's up to scheduling availability and location.
- 25:55Right?
- 25:57Little did you know, because we're back to monopolies in the hospitals, that if you happen
- 26:02to get that appointment scheduled at the hospital, it is 5.7 times cost dinged on if
- 26:09you're on Medicaid because that's where it's going right now.
- 26:12Medicaid, the hospital gets to charge Medicaid five five point seven times more than if you
- 26:19walk over to it in outpatient centers that we know we have a lot of them around to have the
- 26:24same procedure.
- 26:25Why is that?
- 26:28You wonder why our health care costs are so high is because we've got a system that is
- 26:35allowing people and the the excuse me, the folks in the state house not to have someone
- 26:41challenge them.
- 26:41It comes back to accountability.
- 26:43Because let me take this one step further.
- 26:45So you've got that real life impact happening.
- 26:48Nobody's calling out that state legislator because the hospital got to take in more money.
- 26:53Woo hoo.
- 26:53They got to make more money off of your health care.
- 26:57But who's holding that elected official accountable to change the system?
- 27:02In a very gerrymandered state, people stop running against these highly gerrymandered
- 27:08representatives.
- 27:10So nobody's challenged them.
- 27:11When you're not being challenged, there's no accountability.
- 27:14When there is no accountability, it comes back and impacts you.
- 27:18Right.
- 27:19And that that's I mean, you you really went down the rabbit hole, but, I mean, when it
- 27:23comes to politics, there's pretty much always a rabbit hole to go down to.
- 27:26I mean, everything's gotta be convoluted, sometimes more than it really needs to be.
- 27:31But, wanted to step back a little bit into earlier in your, answer to that question
- 27:37because actually, is a perfect segue.
- 27:40You know, talking a bit about the basic methods that you use in redistricting.
- 27:44So just to reiterate, states give redistricting authority to either their state legislatures, a
- 27:50commission outside the legislature, which might or might not have politicians on it depending
- 27:54on the state.
- 27:56They're actually both the state legislature and an outside commission.
- 27:58I wanna say it's Virginia and New York that use that.
- 28:01I can't remember exactly who Ballapedia
- 28:03that.
- 28:04Yeah.
- 28:04Yeah.
- 28:05But so according to Ballapedia and full disclosure, I am a former employer of
- 28:09Ballapedia.
- 28:09So but that's that's not why I'm highlighting them.
- 28:12They just do fantastic work.
- 28:1433 states legislatures redraw congressional district boundaries, not including the states
- 28:19that only have one US house district and 34 states legislatures redraw state legislative
- 28:25district boundaries.
- 28:26Now, of course, it's easy to see the incentive for a state legislator to redraw district lines
- 28:32to benefit themselves.
- 28:33But do you feel any particular state has a well thought out system for redistricting
- 28:38congressional and or state legislative district lines?
- 28:41And if so, which state?
- 28:43You know, that's a good question.
- 28:45Personally, I would love to see enacted in the John Lewis Voting Rights Act redistricting done
- 28:51by independent commissions.
- 28:52Let's just give the boast the voice back to the people.
- 28:56If we have independent commissions, data driven results using data, using the systems that are
- 29:03out there I'll give you example.
- 29:05In Indiana, during the redistricting in 2020, there was a coalition that came together with
- 29:11Common Cause, ACLU, a a 24 other nonprofits, nonpartisan, and they used data driven with
- 29:20professors from around the state and outside the state to really look at what would be the
- 29:25fairest ultimate.
- 29:27And they did it, not only did they have the commission and representatives from on this
- 29:32commission from all different communities across the state, they even did surveys and
- 29:38polls and asked the community members, you know, every the voting populace, what do you
- 29:43want?
- 29:43Do you want to have the redistricting done in a way that's fair?
- 29:48And you define fair.
- 29:49What is fair?
- 29:50And they wanted fair representation, and they wanted a independent commission.
- 29:55So this independent commission, they even had contests so people could really get a kind of
- 30:01civic excitement about it, like getting the power back to the people.
- 30:04Because when you give people back their power, they get engaged and they participate.
- 30:08And the challenge with that, these state legislative commissions that are completely
- 30:14controlled, when it goes to the state house, even though all that work was done, they only
- 30:18had, I believe it was a two hour hearing to present all this information.
- 30:23And they they they then they said, okay.
- 30:25Thank you very much.
- 30:26They went behind closed doors.
- 30:27Now here's the map we want done.
- 30:29They voted on it.
- 30:30It's done.
- 30:31So to answer your question, states that have got it right are states that are using
- 30:36independent commissions using the tools in the toolbox because we we know how to do this, and
- 30:42and letting the people then vote and having representatives, debates, discourse,
- 30:48accountability back in their districts to see who's gonna be the representative.
- 30:53Michigan got it right when they moved in 02/2018 to independent commission, and now
- 30:58they've got it pretty balanced.
- 31:00When you've got state houses that teeter back and forth to who is in control, Pennsylvania
- 31:06goes back and forth.
- 31:07Mhmm.
- 31:07Michigan's going back and forth.
- 31:09That's okay.
- 31:09That's healthy.
- 31:11When you've got leaders let me you might find this quite comical, because when you think
- 31:16about it, you're like, are you kidding me?
- 31:18When you've got leaders who've been leading for so long and nobody's holding them accountable,
- 31:23Our house, majority leader, Todd Hudson Houston, rather, Todd Houston, just
- 31:32commissioned a committee in our state legislator to discuss annexing 14 counties in
- 31:40Illinois to bring them over into Indiana because we want more people over here in
- 31:44Indiana that think like us, these rural counties in Illinois.
- 31:47Seriously?
- 31:48Like, that's how you're spending your time where people meet to talk about the cost of
- 31:53electricity, putting food on the table.
- 31:55You know, Indiana is the most polluted state because we still burn coal.
- 31:59And you're talking about annexing counties from Chicago, you know, from Illinois.
- 32:04You know, actually, that makes me think of there was, I don't think I I don't think I
- 32:09ever, like, really, like, seriously reached anything, but I remember hearing, like, a year
- 32:12or two ago talking about either Idaho annexing Oregon counties or Oregon I think, yeah, I
- 32:19think I think it was Idaho annexing Oregon counties.
- 32:23And it's just you know?
- 32:24And it kinda makes me think of that whole whenever anybody in I've heard Democrats and
- 32:31Republicans both say it, you know, that we need to have, like, a national divorce of red states
- 32:35and blue states.
- 32:36First of all, that doesn't help anybody.
- 32:38That's just gonna make things worse.
- 32:39And second of all, it does not divide even evenly in terms of geography the way that a lot
- 32:46of people think it would.
- 32:48But act you know, but before I get to the next question, since you touched on a little bit,
- 32:54with these independent commissions, you talked about places like Michigan and Pennsylvania
- 32:58that have pretty even, state legislative chambers.
- 33:02Minnesota well, I guess Minnesota is maybe to a little bit of a lesser extent, but, I mean,
- 33:06they they their their house, just, flipped as well.
- 33:10But how do how do you ensure that a commission is independent?
- 33:16Because we did just a little bit ago, we talked about how some independent commissions can
- 33:21technically have politicians on it, or or they have to have people that won't run for office,
- 33:26but perhaps they might be lobbyist affiliate.
- 33:29It could potentially be lobbyist affiliated with a party or, you know, somebody from a
- 33:34party.
- 33:34How do we go about ensuring that these are independent commissions?
- 33:38You know, that's a good question.
- 33:40It just as you go down the slippery slope becoming super gerrymandered, when you take
- 33:45away that and you're starting to get a balance in your your state house, and when you're
- 33:53picking the commissioner, you if you pick the commissioner, the the the business, and you
- 33:58have equal representation on and you do it in a transparent way, not behind closed doors, and
- 34:05you have these open law meetings and everybody is welcome in the room, that's how you really
- 34:10do it.
- 34:10It's really not necessarily just about who's sitting around the table.
- 34:14It's about how the process has been conducted and allowing people to be in there, allowing
- 34:19the media to be in there, allowing the minutes to be read, you know, in a very transparent
- 34:24process.
- 34:25But when it's happening behind closed doors and there's two or three people involved, that's
- 34:30really where we run into a lot of problems.
- 34:33It's about transparency and accountability.
- 34:36Yeah.
- 34:36I've Meaning.
- 34:38Absolutely.
- 34:38You know, transparency, it always makes always makes government better when you have more
- 34:43transparency.
- 34:44So what are some other steps that we can take, big or small, to make gerrymandering less
- 34:50common?
- 34:50Are there any, reforms that that aren't necessarily directly related to, or to, excuse
- 34:56me, to redistricting that can be implemented that might alleviate gerrymandering?
- 35:00For example, do do you think term limits would have any sort of impact on that?
- 35:05You know, that's a really good question.
- 35:08So I go back and forth with term limits because, you know, there's different levels of
- 35:12of term limits.
- 35:13You know?
- 35:14Obviously, you know, you look at, you know you know, Mitch McConnell who's really aging.
- 35:20You know, like, okay.
- 35:21You know, we need to let the the gentleman served us well.
- 35:26Thank you very much.
- 35:27Time for somebody else.
- 35:28But when you talk about term notes, would people just say I want people in there for two
- 35:32terms, or I just want people in their office for one or three?
- 35:37There's the other equation that that really landed for me as you start getting into, as we
- 35:42say, the weeds of understanding the process behind the curtain.
- 35:45So you want somebody in your community to represent your community.
- 35:48And a lot of times, let's take somebody gets into office in the state level, and they're
- 35:52really well versed in education.
- 35:54And that's the the offering they're gonna add to the the the collective.
- 35:58And there's somebody else from the neighboring district who is a health care provider.
- 36:01So you want that voice in there.
- 36:03Right?
- 36:03But a person who is well versed in education also needs to sit on a couple other committees.
- 36:08Right?
- 36:10AKA, here comes the lobbyist.
- 36:12So then what happens is the lobbyist come in, and their job really is to be on the up and up
- 36:17and educate the representatives on other issues, let's say, environmental issues,
- 36:24electricity or the water sources or lead or whatever the the need is in the community.
- 36:31And if a well constructed lobby group is doing their work, they're going to educate the
- 36:36representatives on the facts.
- 36:40But at the same time, we know lobbyists like to butter up butter up, and they like to pay for
- 36:44lunch.
- 36:45They like to pay for a conference, and they're gonna just woo and wine and dine you.
- 36:49And but what happens is as a new representative, you're kinda like drinking from
- 36:53the fire hose because there's a lot of bills.
- 36:55When you think about it, a lot of these state sessions are only for four or five months, four
- 37:02months here in Indiana during a budget year, and you're talking about an absorbent amount of
- 37:06dollars you're responsible for allocating and spending, you're learning very quickly.
- 37:10You're technically supposed to file fifth up to 15 bills yourself.
- 37:15So if you think about it about it, there's a hundred people in there.
- 37:18You're all filing 15 bills.
- 37:19You gotta learn about the idiot the ins and outs of all those bills and the details and the
- 37:22larger impact and the legal ramifications.
- 37:25That's a lot to take in.
- 37:26So you do should rely on good lobbyists to say, okay.
- 37:30This is gonna affect this business.
- 37:32You know?
- 37:33Indiana is the RV capital of the world.
- 37:35How is that gonna impact that business if the steel is not, you know, taxed here and there
- 37:40from federal level, and what's the impact on the state level?
- 37:43So they need information.
- 37:46But what happens is when the lobbyists are wining and dining, you can kinda get lost in
- 37:50that.
- 37:51In other words, they end up having the power because they have the information.
- 37:56But when a when a when a state representative is in there longer and longer, they understand
- 38:00the the playing game.
- 38:01They understand the chess pieces.
- 38:02They understand, like, well, that guy really or female really didn't tell me the true story.
- 38:07They didn't tell me the whole history.
- 38:09I found out more.
- 38:10I got to know the owner of this company.
- 38:12I got to know and they have a better understand the landscapes.
- 38:15They can better make a well grounded decision.
- 38:18That takes time.
- 38:19It takes time for a a really good representative to get grounded and build those
- 38:24relationships and understand the the larger impact of the decisions.
- 38:29But we also need them to be when they run every year to be running against somebody that holds
- 38:34them accountable to those decisions that they made.
- 38:37That's where we need to put the power is back with the voters.
- 38:42So if it's not gerrymandered and someone says, well, we didn't like those two decisions you
- 38:46made on x, y, and z.
- 38:47Let's challenge them and hold them accountable and let them answer to these questions.
- 38:50And if they get reelected, great.
- 38:51If they don't, they don't.
- 38:53But by having term limits, we're really throwing the balance of power into the
- 38:58lobbyists, into that wining and dining and wooing, and we'll pay for your campaign.
- 39:03We know they do that because in Indiana, there's very like, we call it loosey goosey
- 39:09fed, state campaign finance laws.
- 39:12They actually call Indiana the wild wild west with campaign donations.
- 39:17Yeah.
- 39:17When you when you bring up, lobbyists, it is kind of, you know, for for all the issues that
- 39:23that, you know, lobbyists bring, it is kind of that, you know, every so often you hear people
- 39:28say, we used to get rid of lobbyists.
- 39:30Like, well, there's a lot of unintended con consequences there if you do get rid of it.
- 39:34And then also if you phrase it as, well, do you think we should have advocates?
- 39:37Then all of a sudden, you know, you change change the language a little bit, then suddenly
- 39:41become people become more amenable.
- 39:43Right.
- 39:44So for the penultimate question on gerrymandering, at least, how do we
- 39:50disincentivize these politicians, from gerrymandering?
- 39:54Because politicians need incentives.
- 39:56Right?
- 39:57Argue arguably humanity in general has, you know, things that, incentivize them to do
- 40:02something.
- 40:03So is there any way we can convince politicians across the across the political aisle that if
- 40:10they redraw lines to unfairly benefit themselves or their party, that would actually
- 40:15hurt them electorally, legally, financially.
- 40:18How do we disincentivize politicians from trying to redraw lines unfairly?
- 40:24Yeah.
- 40:24I think the question is really we need to reframe and take our power back, and it comes
- 40:29from the people.
- 40:30The more we vote and hold them accountable and hold them accountable to their votes, that's
- 40:36how we're gonna change the system.
- 40:37It's really about getting the folks educated on the impact that the votes that that they're
- 40:43doing right now in their state legislators, either on the state level, the congressional
- 40:47level, how it's impacting them, and hold them accountable.
- 40:52Because a challenge state house seat or congressional seat is about accountability.
- 40:57It's answering to the people about the votes that you just made or the work that you're
- 41:02doing.
- 41:03So in order to chain get that accountability, we have to have someone road vote run against
- 41:08them.
- 41:09And if the district is so gerrymandered, people won't.
- 41:12So in very gerrymandered areas, we like to say, we need to redefine what winning looks like.
- 41:19So if you're in a very gerrymandered district, your job might be might be to run and to hold
- 41:28the other person accountable for their votes.
- 41:31While you might not win that time, but your job is accountability.
- 41:34And as people start realizing what's happening in your district, then more people will start
- 41:39showing up and start voting potentially to flip and start changing the power structure.
- 41:43And the other side the other in the other thing that's important in that is some of the very
- 41:47gerrymandering areas.
- 41:49When you look at Georgia, when they're bringing back the balance in Georgia, it happens at the
- 41:54top of the ticket first.
- 41:56What do I mean by that?
- 41:57So when you're in a very gerrymandered states, in order for you to flip back and or balance
- 42:03the power, you know, it's just about balancing power and having discourse again, is you have
- 42:08to run candidates in every seat of the bus regardless if it's very district y.
- 42:13It's back to holding them accountable, making the other side, spread their dollars and and
- 42:19and run-in all these districts and have those conversations, in front of the voting public
- 42:24about their votes, about their vision, about what they wanna see in this district.
- 42:28Because you have people running in very gerrymandered districts and winning winning.
- 42:35As we see right now in the state of Indiana, we don't have our congresspeople coming back and
- 42:39having town halls.
- 42:40They are not people have really concerning questions.
- 42:44Indiana is a farming, community.
- 42:48We have the number one tomato and corn.
- 42:51All these farm aid bills that were cut is impacting Indiana.
- 42:55The farmers want answers.
- 42:57Communities want answers, and they're not showing up because they don't have to.
- 43:01So how do you change that?
- 43:03You run against them, and you make them show up to these town halls.
- 43:07And if they continue not to show up, that's where you have the power and the people is to
- 43:11vote.
- 43:13It is a shame how how many, races across really federal, state, and local government,
- 43:20especially with the local level.
- 43:21You just see that just, there's just nobody to even challenge somebody.
- 43:28And, and, I mean, usually there's an incumbent, but sometimes it's just one person that's a
- 43:32newcomer and, they, they run and nobody else runs against them.
- 43:36And it's, it's definitely something that I I think regardless of, again, regardless of
- 43:41political opinions, it's it's it's a problem that needs to be addressed.
- 43:46Yeah.
- 43:46And I I obviously, I wish I wish we could say that we've we solved the issues of
- 43:50gerrymandering with with this, topic, but nonetheless, thank thank you again for this
- 43:55really in-depth insight that you have into gerrymandering.
- 43:59So before we wrap things up, gonna go, actually, first real quick, any final thoughts
- 44:06about, gerrymandering that we haven't really covered that's really pressing for you that you
- 44:12think really needs to get out there?
- 44:14Yeah.
- 44:15I think it goes back to giving the voice back to the people.
- 44:18We're seeing people feel a loss of agency, and gerrymandering is a big factor that contributes
- 44:24to it.
- 44:26And, you know, it's it's talk about it's about health care.
- 44:29It's about educating our children.
- 44:31It's about giving people access to choice, you know, whatever life path they wanna choose.
- 44:35And we have folks who are not thinking about the collective, but they're thinking about, you
- 44:41know, who got them into their seat, or they're voting for reasons that don't serve the area
- 44:48they're supposed to represent.
- 44:49And that's why we have voter apathy and people not paying attention.
- 44:53And the unfortunate part is until bad things happen, that's when people wake up and
- 44:59participate, and we shouldn't have to get to that point.
- 45:02You I would hope that people who are elected officials value that oath a lot more and and
- 45:08value who they're representing it because we're all human.
- 45:11We gotta get back to humaning.
- 45:13I'm gonna that was a friend of
- 45:14Yeah.
- 45:15Word.
- 45:15We gotta get back to humaning, you know, that we're all in this together.
- 45:19So the depolarization is really not gonna help anybody.
- 45:23Yeah.
- 45:24Absolutely.
- 45:24I I you because it since you brought it up a couple of times, it made me think of the whole,
- 45:28you know, not doing something before it's too late.
- 45:30How I just remember back in in grad school, some of the studies that, you know, to really,
- 45:37this is just a very crude way to say, but for a lot of people, it really, you know, unless they
- 45:42have like a pretty particularly strong emotion, like fear, like a fear of, oh, do we need to do
- 45:47something?
- 45:48You know, a lot of times people will just go with the status quo unless they just do this,
- 45:52can't deal with it anymore.
- 45:54So it's obviously a lot of things to, consider.
- 45:59But and again, thank you so much for that that insight.
- 46:03Let's go ahead and go to one final question that is just meant to be fun, not nonpolitical
- 46:09because anytime I have a guest, and sometimes even on on my own, I like to pose a random
- 46:15question for both the guest and for the audience.
- 46:17So today's random question of the day is promise it's not any anything crazy.
- 46:23If you could have one superpower, what would it be?
- 46:25And don't and don't cheat and pick something like, oh, invincibility, because that's that's
- 46:29lame and boring or the ability to absorb other powers.
- 46:31So what's your superpower?
- 46:33Oh, what's my superpower?
- 46:34Oh, god.
- 46:35You know, it's I think it goes to, like, if I could travel in time.
- 46:39You know?
- 46:40If I could travel in time and I could go back to some of these eras I love history.
- 46:44I love reading histories and biography.
- 46:46If I could go back to, like, the roaring twenties and experience some of that, you know,
- 46:50or yeah.
- 46:51I think if I could go back in time, I think that if I could travel through time, but then
- 46:55again, I would be like, oh, let me change this.
- 46:57That's my better through my life.
- 47:00Life.
- 47:01Anyway
- 47:01They yeah.
- 47:02For me, that that that, that temptation would be too great.
- 47:06But to be able to see things up close, I'd go see, like, the cost the original constitutional
- 47:11convention Oh,
- 47:12man.
- 47:12Signing a declaration of independence.
- 47:14Just so so many different things.
- 47:15Or or do you even go back in time?
- 47:17Another question I asked, I I my previous guest is basically if they could pick any single
- 47:22person in history to have a conversation with, who would it be?
- 47:25And I picked Rod Serling from, the Twilight Zone, and I was just thinking, well, you know
- 47:29what?
- 47:29With your with your answer, I could just go back and back in time and have a conversation
- 47:34with him because that guy that guy was the definition of prescient.
- 47:38For me, though, I'm gonna pick something a little less, profound.
- 47:42And, for for me, it it's it's the ability to manipulate electricity.
- 47:47So when I was a kid, there was a cartoon I watched called static shock, and I thought that
- 47:51was, like he was, like, the coolest thing ever.
- 47:53It was, like, if I could just do things mundane things like, oh, I gotta charge my computer or
- 47:58charge my phone.
- 47:59My car is not starting.
- 48:01I'm gonna, you know, jump the battery or do crazier things like create a light show or
- 48:06manipulate magnetic fields.
- 48:07It's like that seems like the coolest thing ever.
- 48:10So for me, it's definitely manipulating electricity and also just having things shoot
- 48:14out of your fingertips just sounds I
- 48:16don't know.
- 48:17Rad for me.
- 48:18Not not I'm thinking Spider Man who but, like, who was the one who had the electricity
- 48:22electric?
- 48:22What was the what was the superhero that had the electric power?
- 48:27So there is static shock.
- 48:28As for another superhero, I'm sure there's somebody else that does it, but I think there's
- 48:32a Spider Man villain, Electro.
- 48:33I think he he
- 48:34Even though that there's one
- 48:35He's more of a villain.
- 48:36Yeah.
- 48:37Yeah.
- 48:38But, yeah, there's probably somebody else I can't really think of.
- 48:40But, anyways, that that's that's for me.
- 48:43So, Mary, thank you so much for coming out to the show and for for having such an in-depth
- 48:48conversation that's, you know, it it obviously, it it's something that that really needs to be
- 48:53talked about.
- 48:54And, yeah, it's it's it's talked about, but really to actually try to do something about
- 48:59it.
- 48:59Unfortunately, there's not been a whole lot, or not enough, I should say, that's that's that's
- 49:05been done for it.
- 49:06So, hopefully, we'll see that, in the future, and conversations like this will, you know,
- 49:11lead to those solutions.
- 49:12So and for you at home or wherever you're watching or listening to this, thank you again
- 49:17so much for listening.
- 49:19I've got my links in the show notes, my Facebook, LinkedIn, my my book, Why
- 49:24Independents Rarely Win Elections and How They Could Become More Competitive is available on
- 49:28Amazon and several other, links I can't think of off the top of my head.
- 49:33Mary, any links that you would like to share?
- 49:37Yeah.
- 49:37Absolutely.
- 49:37Thank you.
- 49:38You will find me on LinkedIn.
- 49:40You will also find me on Substack, and my Substack is called 92 county plan where I'm
- 49:45outlining how do we unrig a red state.
- 49:48And there's a lot of lessons that you could follow on the journey that you can use in other
- 49:51states, you know, in terms of, what's its impact and why we need to unravel this.
- 49:57And you can also find me on Blue Sky, and you can also find me on Facebook.
- 50:01And I don't go on Twitter anymore.
- 50:04It's just a rabbit hole that for me, it's just there's too much going on there.
- 50:08But that's where you'll find me.
- 50:09LinkedIn and Substack are the two top places you can find me.
- 50:13Like I said, 92 county plan, and the goal is to talk about how do we unrig some of these rig
- 50:19states so we can back get back to having conversations and solving the problems that
- 50:23really impact us all.
- 50:24Well, there you go.
- 50:25Go ahead and and check out all those links that Mary just talked about and and and mine as
- 50:30well.
- 50:30And please like, comment, share, subscribe, the podcast and for all of Mary's links as well,
- 50:36and that's gonna wrap things up for us.
- 50:38So until next time, take care.