Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Trial Tutorials: Opening Statements
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to this installment of trial tutorials.
- 0:06Today we are covering opening statements. I'm
- 0:09Rudy Lehrer, a member of the Board of Governors
- 0:11of the Beverly Hills Bar Association. I'm delighted
- 0:14to introduce our speaker today, Morgan Chu. Mr.
- 0:18Chu is a partner at IRL and Manila LLP. He is
- 0:23chair of the firm's litigation practice group.
- 0:26Chambers USA described Mr. Chu as quote, beyond
- 0:29doubt, the most gifted trial lawyer in the USA.
- 0:33In Peter versus Nanquest, Mr. Chu argued and
- 0:37won a decision, believe it or not, by nine to
- 0:41zero at the US Supreme Court, in which it overturned
- 0:44a federal circuit panel decision on appeals by
- 0:47patent applicants. To date, Mr. Chu's results
- 0:52at trial and in settlement have resulted in over
- 0:55$9 billion in actual payments to his clients.
- 0:59That's separate and apart from key defense verdicts,
- 1:02which he has also obtained over his career. Mr.
- 1:05Chu, we are honored to have you here today. Now,
- 1:08a note for our audience. If time permits, Mr.
- 1:11Chu will consider questions at the close of the
- 1:13presentation. Please be sure to list those questions
- 1:16in the Q &A chat. So with that, let's get started
- 1:20and I'll turn the mic over to you, Mr. Chu. Thank
- 1:22you. Thank you very much. Good afternoon, everyone.
- 1:29Sally was very excited to be going to school
- 1:33on a bright and sunny day until she got to the
- 1:37crosswalk to her elementary school. And her legs
- 1:44will never be the same. If you're a really gutsy
- 1:50plaintiff's lawyer in this personal injury case,
- 1:54sit down. I want to talk about that sample opening
- 2:02and pick it apart. Notice that it is likely that
- 2:12everyone in the courtroom is looking at Sally's
- 2:18legs. Notice what was not said. There is no mention
- 2:27that Sally will never be able to walk down the
- 2:31aisle when she gets married years later. Notice
- 2:36there is nothing said about the two years of
- 2:41reconstructive surgery for her legs. Notice also
- 2:46that there's nothing said about the Ford F -150
- 2:51that was going 60 miles an hour. in a 25 mile
- 2:56an hour school zone. It didn't need to be said.
- 3:01Those things did not need to be said to tell
- 3:05a story. So rule number one for opening statements
- 3:09is tell a story. Tell a story in a way that people
- 3:14are going to remember it. A good story doesn't
- 3:20have 23 points or 17 or 11. or nine points. A
- 3:26good story usually has one good point. A story
- 3:35is something that jurors can describe to their
- 3:39friends or family after they're done with their
- 3:42jury duty. What was the case about, their friends
- 3:45would say. From the opening you've just heard,
- 3:50I think it would be relatively easy for every
- 3:55juror to say, oh, it was about Sally who got
- 4:00hit in the school crosswalk and her legs were
- 4:05mangled. Notice also what's going to happen next
- 4:13in the trial. The skid marks, the speed of the
- 4:18Ford F -150, the school crossing zone. All of
- 4:26that can be explained by the accident reconstruction
- 4:29expert. None of it needed to be said in the opening
- 4:33statement. Notice also, it was short. How short
- 4:40was it? I'm guessing 30 seconds. How short was
- 4:44it? I counted two sentences. And in two sentences,
- 4:52there was a story. Now not every opening statement
- 4:56can be reduced to two sentences or 30 seconds,
- 5:01but every good or decent or even fair opening
- 5:09statement ought to be short. So if there's one
- 5:16takeaway from this, Make your opening statement
- 5:21short. I didn't always realize that. I used to
- 5:25think, gosh, I was involved in these very complex
- 5:28cases, and that I needed a lot of time for opening
- 5:31statement. And then I noticed judges started
- 5:37to say, well, Mr. Chu, how much time do you need
- 5:39for opening statement? An hour. An hour, I can
- 5:44read what wrinkled brows look like. over time
- 5:50I learned without being required to shorten my
- 5:54opening statement. And some judges now, particularly
- 5:57federal judges, in many different states throughout
- 6:00the country limit opening statements. That's
- 6:03less common in California state courts, less
- 6:06common in state courts throughout the United
- 6:09States. But shorten it yourself. Remember, each
- 6:15minute that ticks by, you run the risk of boring
- 6:20one of the jurors. You don't run that risk in
- 6:23the first five minutes, 10 minutes, 15 minutes.
- 6:27You might begin to run that risk as the minutes
- 6:32tick by after that. And to a certainty, you are
- 6:37not only running that risk, but perhaps incurring
- 6:41the wrath of some one or more jurors as you drone
- 6:47on. And as you drone on, people won't remember
- 6:51what's the main point of the story. So the first
- 6:57point is, tell a story and make it short. And
- 7:03as you're preparing, think about what you're
- 7:06going to say. A little bit later, we'll talk
- 7:10about how to prepare an opening statement. But
- 7:13however you prepare, Make it short and then make
- 7:19it shorter and make it shorter still How important
- 7:25is opening statement Some people who write about
- 7:31and teach Trial practice say it is the most important
- 7:36aspect of a trial. There's no doubt. It does
- 7:40have a central importance There are three times
- 7:44during the course of a trial that you might get
- 7:47to talk directly to the jurors. One is opening
- 7:52statement, one is closing argument, and usually
- 7:57in state court, you can actively participate
- 8:00in voir dire. In federal court, many judges won't
- 8:03let you ask a single question. Some federal judges
- 8:06will let you ask a few limited questions, but
- 8:11they'll watch you with an eagle eye. making sure
- 8:15you're not conditioning jurors in a way that
- 8:17is considered improper. So think of it as two
- 8:22or two and a half opportunities to speak directly
- 8:24to the jurors. And most of the trial time is
- 8:28going to be consumed by direct examinations,
- 8:33cross examinations, and maybe examinations in
- 8:37a rebuttal case. This is a precious opportunity.
- 8:43who write and teach trial practice say it's the
- 8:46most important opportunity because it's the first
- 8:49time that jurors hear directly what is the case
- 8:54about and they're hearing from both sides. Psychologists
- 9:01and people who study how we communicate say there
- 9:06is the rule of primacy, what you hear first,
- 9:10and that holds true. for the trial at large,
- 9:13and it holds true for opening statements. Before
- 9:19I go on to some other do's and don'ts, let me
- 9:23go to our hypothetical. I hope everyone's had
- 9:27an opportunity to review the hypothetical, but
- 9:30even if you haven't, here's the opening for the
- 9:35plaintiff. Nathan and Jessica are 36 and 33 years
- 9:40old. Two years ago, they were very happy. They
- 9:44got aboard the vacations to go cruise ship They
- 9:50were celebrating Jessica's birthday And they
- 9:54were asked by the cruise director to everyone
- 9:57on board. Do you want to participate in a belly
- 10:01flop contest? It was a fun thing to do and Well,
- 10:09Nathan said OK. And they were all invited to
- 10:15the side of a pool. Hundreds of passengers showed
- 10:19up. And Nathan raised his hand. He signed up.
- 10:24He was going to be 11th out of 14. And there
- 10:28were 10 people belly flopping before him, some
- 10:32making a big splash, some not making a splash,
- 10:35some barely doing a belly flop. Who practices
- 10:38how to belly flop? Nathan didn't know how to
- 10:44do a belly flop. He wasn't told what to do or
- 10:49what not to do. He was not told what not to do
- 10:57in a pool that at its deepest part was four feet
- 11:06deep. He was not told don't dive into the pool
- 11:14and not knowing how to do a belly flop, not receiving
- 11:21any instructions on what a belly flop is. He
- 11:25did what many people do naturally when they are
- 11:30diving into a pool. He dove in and he hit his
- 11:36head and he suffered. serious acute spinal injuries.
- 11:49Now I'll be defense counsel. Well, what Mr. Chu
- 11:56didn't tell you was that there were signs, five
- 12:03of them in total, that warned passengers about
- 12:08the rules. for each of the swimming pools on
- 12:11the cruise ship, and it included a rule, no diving.
- 12:21Mr. Chu also didn't tell you that along the side
- 12:24of the pool there were markers every three feet
- 12:30that said what the depth of the pool was. Four
- 12:34feet, four feet, four feet, and circling the
- 12:37pool And Mr. Chu didn't tell you that in addition,
- 12:44there was a warning that had the icon of someone
- 12:49diving into the pool with a red circle and slash
- 12:53against it. There was a warning, number one,
- 12:57from the five signs. There was a warning about
- 13:00the depth of the pool, and there was a warning
- 13:04not to dive. That's what he didn't tell you.
- 13:10Now I'm going to stop. Being plaintiff's lawyer
- 13:15for Nathan and Jessica, I did not do one of the
- 13:22cardinal rules for anyone, whether you're representing
- 13:27the plaintiff and speaking first, or representing
- 13:30the defendant and speaking second. And that is
- 13:34to anticipate your weaknesses. and bring them
- 13:39out. And therefore I handed my adversary, he's
- 13:46a pretty good lawyer. He kind of looks like me,
- 13:51but he's on the defense side. I handed him a
- 13:56gift because he could begin his opening with
- 14:01a drumbeat of what Mr. Chu did not tell you.
- 14:07And immediately, he is undermined the plaintiff's
- 14:13lawyer's credibility at the very beginning of
- 14:17the trial. If I could rewind being plaintiff's
- 14:22lawyer, I would have pointed out that with the
- 14:27hundreds of people there, who could see those
- 14:32four foot markers? Because the crowd was right
- 14:35next to the pool. Who could see those signs on
- 14:41the pavement that said no diving because it was
- 14:44crowded with hundreds of people? Who could read
- 14:47to stop the signs by the entrances to the pool
- 14:56where at line 17 it said no diving and before
- 15:01no diving it said No ice cream, no food, no alcohol,
- 15:08no this, no that. But it would have been one
- 15:14minute to anticipate one of the key weaknesses.
- 15:20Note also, I didn't go through all of the facts
- 15:26that dealt with what the defendant might point
- 15:30to in the case. Perhaps Nathan did not follow
- 15:37what would be recommended in terms of medical
- 15:41procedures. That could be left to another point
- 15:46in time. And that defense point that the injuries
- 15:51might not have been as severe if Nathan had gone
- 15:58through a different course of treatment. sounds
- 16:02not so good as a defense. And therefore, I did
- 16:08not need to anticipate it. My opening for the
- 16:15plaintiff in the hypothetical, it was relatively
- 16:18short, more than two sentences, but not too long,
- 16:23I don't think. And the defense could add to what
- 16:31defense counsel said, but on the defense side,
- 16:37I wouldn't go on too long because defense counsel
- 16:42in my hypothetical had undermined what was taking
- 16:47place. So let me go to some do's and don'ts about
- 16:54opening statement. The first is tell a story.
- 17:01No matter what kind of case it is, tell a story.
- 17:05Tell a story that anyone from the street could
- 17:09understand. Tell a story that you can torture
- 17:13if you have a 10 year old at home. Torture your
- 17:1610 year old or 12 year old. Torture your spouse.
- 17:22Torture staff at your law firm. Torture some
- 17:26of your fellow lawyers. and see if you can tell
- 17:29the story in three minutes or so, and just ask
- 17:32the simple question, what's this case about?
- 17:36See if people can not just tell you they understood
- 17:39the story, but tell you what the themes are for
- 17:44your side of the case. Although I've already
- 17:49said it, make the opening short, edit it, and
- 17:53make it shorter. Let me go to some don'ts. Don't
- 18:04start with excuses. Don't start with overly long
- 18:09introductions. What's an excuse? I'm not as good
- 18:15as the other lawyer. Her case is very easy to
- 18:20explain. I'm sorry I'll have to take three hours
- 18:24of your time to describe the case. Another excuse
- 18:31that you should avoid is stating a rule of law
- 18:36such as, opening statement is not evidence. Think
- 18:43about what that says to jurors. It says, well,
- 18:48don't listen to me. Every juror, whether they
- 18:52have been called to jury duty or not in the past,
- 18:55knows that they're supposed to decide the case
- 18:58on the evidence. There have probably been preliminary
- 19:01instructions that have said exactly that. And
- 19:04if at any point in opening statement, a lawyer
- 19:07says, opening statement is not evidence, that's
- 19:11another way of saying, Mr. or Ms. Juror, feel
- 19:15free to tune me out right now. The next don't
- 19:22is probably going to be hard for some more junior
- 19:27lawyers or lawyers who have done ten opening
- 19:31statements or more. Don't read your opening statement.
- 19:41Notice I didn't say for preparation, don't write
- 19:46out your opening statement. Some people find
- 19:50it easier to write out their opening statement
- 19:55in full. Nothing wrong with that. But if you
- 19:59do that, try to shorten it to something you can
- 20:04fit on an index card. Or at least one sheet of
- 20:098 .5 x 11 paper. And if you can fit it on one
- 20:13piece of 8 .5 x 11 paper, see if you can reduce
- 20:17it. to a series of bullet points that will remind
- 20:22you of the key points. And even if you need to
- 20:26have that sheet of paper in front of you or the
- 20:28index card, you will be prevented from reading
- 20:33it. There's a judge who was on the Southern District
- 20:39of New York, he's now on the Second Circuit,
- 20:42and he tells this wonderful story. He spent a
- 20:45number of years as an assistant US attorney in
- 20:50the southern district of New York. And there's
- 20:52a very well -known lawyer who was working as
- 20:59an assistant US attorney. And a younger lawyer
- 21:04was doing his first opening statement. He'd prepared
- 21:08for it. And the senior lawyer looks at him and
- 21:12says, hey, you look prepared. This is the morning
- 21:16of opening statement. You got a dark suit on.
- 21:20You've got a nice bow tie. You look like you're
- 21:26ready. Are you ready? Yep, I'm ready. And you've
- 21:31got your opening statement figured out. Yep,
- 21:34I've got it right here. And the senior lawyer
- 21:38sees, oh, he's showing me many pages. of what
- 21:45he has written out for his opening statement.
- 21:49And the senior lawyer says, well, let me see
- 21:52that. And he takes the 15 pages and goes. Rips
- 22:01it all up and throws it in the trash can. Now,
- 22:05I'm not wishing that on anyone. The junior lawyer
- 22:09did just fine because he knew the case well enough.
- 22:13He didn't need the crotch of the pages and he
- 22:18didn't need to read the opening statement. The
- 22:22main point is, do not read an opening statement.
- 22:31Another point, do not be too detailed. Not every
- 22:37little twig of evidence needs to be highlighted.
- 22:42You can tell that from my opening about Sally.
- 22:47There'll be many important pieces. They're not
- 22:49just twigs, they're branches on a tree, but there's
- 22:54no need to highlight them during the course of
- 22:59opening statement. Being too detailed also has
- 23:03the disability of making your opening statement
- 23:07more complicated, harder to follow, and longer.
- 23:14Now I'm going to go to another don't, because
- 23:18this is the basic rule of opening statement in
- 23:22every court, state, and federal in the United
- 23:24States. Do not argue. The rule is you're supposed
- 23:31to state the facts. You're not supposed to argue.
- 23:39An argument might be you can't believe anything
- 23:44that 10 -year -old Sally could say. She doesn't
- 23:48have much of a memory of the accident. Well,
- 23:51it's a bad argument, but it's argument nevertheless.
- 23:58The strike zone here is very difficult to define.
- 24:02You think baseball umpires sometimes have a tough
- 24:04time with strike zones, particularly in the era
- 24:07before we have video replays and can see exactly
- 24:11what a strike zone is. But judges have very different
- 24:17strike zones. For some, it's very small. And
- 24:20any tinge of an argument, they may chastise counsel.
- 24:26If you happen to be in a situation where opposing
- 24:29counsel may object or the judge on her own says,
- 24:32counsel, you're arguing, you step back and say,
- 24:37yes, Your Honor, with a smile, and say, the evidence
- 24:40will show Because that little phrase is a way
- 24:46to say I'm just talking about the facts So keep
- 24:50that in your tool chest to help you out Now let's
- 24:57go to some of the maybes One big maybe is if
- 25:04your case has some technology of some kind that's
- 25:09out of the realm that an ordinary person off
- 25:12the street would know, you might want to teach
- 25:15a little bit about it. But try to do it in a
- 25:22simple way that will make people understand what
- 25:27the case will be focused upon. I have a lot of
- 25:32cases that are very heavy in terms of technology.
- 25:36They involve designs as an example for semiconductor
- 25:41chips. The designs can be very complicated or
- 25:47difficult to understand to get better performance
- 25:51by executing instructions from the firmware that's
- 25:56on the chip out of order. You can tell that jumble
- 26:00of words doesn't sound like it's going to be
- 26:03easy for anyone. to understand. But people do
- 26:10understand the following. That engineers, scientists,
- 26:20and ordinary consumers prefer faster chips. That
- 26:27ordinary consumers prefer chips that save power,
- 26:33meaning they give the consumer longer battery
- 26:38life. So if you are going to explain some technology,
- 26:47find a framework that everyone on the jury can
- 26:52understand. You don't necessarily have to discuss
- 26:57and educate the jurors about the technology.
- 27:02It's a maybe. But if you do, keep it simple.
- 27:08Second, maybe use visual aids. What I see more
- 27:16and more in just about every kind of presentation
- 27:21including opening statements is that the presenter
- 27:25uses this big crutch. It's easy to use. and it's
- 27:32called PowerPoint. It slides or it's boards with
- 27:37a bunch of words on it. An effective opening
- 27:42can use zero visual aids. You notice I didn't
- 27:46use any visual aids in doing an opening for Sally
- 27:52or for Nathan and Jessica. That crutch of using
- 28:02visual aids can be very, very effective, but
- 28:08it can also be counterproductive. First of all,
- 28:14once you start showing jurors slide one, two,
- 28:1818, 23, and so on, they are no longer looking
- 28:25at you. They are looking at the board. So it's
- 28:31hard for you to establish visual contact, eye
- 28:35contact with the jurors. Second, if your jury
- 28:43has seen 23 slides or 64 slides, it's more difficult
- 28:51for them to remember what was the important point
- 28:54or what were the three most important points.
- 29:00Consider using zero slots. If you want to use
- 29:04slides, recognizing that you might be using them
- 29:08as a crutch for yourself to remember the points
- 29:14you want to make. Well, your little three by
- 29:19five index card is much better for those purposes.
- 29:26Another point about visual aids. Most of the
- 29:31time, they're not very good. Most of the time,
- 29:35they're really bad. They're too complicated.
- 29:40They have too many words. I have, for all the
- 29:45lawyers in my firm, what they will say. And you
- 29:49can ask anyone at IRL Manila who's been involved
- 29:53in our trial practice currently or in the past
- 29:56many years. What's Morgan's rule about visual
- 30:02aids and PowerPoints for trial? I have a rule.
- 30:09It's a simple rule. I call it the billboard rule.
- 30:15What's the billboard rule? You're driving down
- 30:18the street, anywhere in Los Angeles, and you're
- 30:22gonna see a billboard. And you've got about three
- 30:25seconds. To drive safely and understand what
- 30:31the billboard means Some very effective billboards
- 30:37you might remember Apple had a billboard that
- 30:40had one word on it think Every billboard is designed
- 30:48For the viewer who's going to look at it for
- 30:53three seconds you can't have more than 25 words,
- 30:59better to have four words, three words, one word,
- 31:01maybe zero words, but a limited number of words,
- 31:05better to have a graphic, and better that the
- 31:10billboard make one point, not three points. That's
- 31:17the billboard rule. Now, when you get in your
- 31:21car later today or tomorrow, driving down the
- 31:24street, you'll look at billboards a little differently
- 31:29for the next day or two, and ask yourself for
- 31:33each billboard, do you get the point? If you
- 31:37do, it's at least an okay billboard. Is the billboard
- 31:42memorable in terms of the point? Well, it gets
- 31:45a higher grade. If you see too many words on
- 31:50the billboard, it should get a failing grade.
- 31:57Visual aids are fine. Don't use too many. And
- 32:01if you use them, use the billboard rule. The
- 32:08visual aids, although they can be extremely effective,
- 32:13are not very effective at some things. Let me
- 32:17give you an example. I had a case where we wanted
- 32:23to demonstrate how much $30 billion is. And if
- 32:32you think about it, I didn't know. And as I asked
- 32:39other people in my firm, nobody really knew what
- 32:44a billion dollars is. That sounds odd. We can
- 32:48all figure out there should be, if it's one,
- 32:52one comma and a series of zeros. Yes, we can
- 32:56figure that out. But what does a billion dollars,
- 33:00much less 30 billion dollars mean? And we had
- 33:07some graphics consultants. We had a lot of people
- 33:10in the trial team. Everyone had their ideas.
- 33:14And most of the ideas revolved around taking
- 33:18currency $20 bills, $100 bills, whatever it is,
- 33:24and having them wrap around the globe. Well,
- 33:28how many times around the globe do you have to
- 33:31go to get to $1 billion? Or having those dollars
- 33:37laid end to end to go to the moon, or maybe it's
- 33:41to the moon and back. But as I thought about
- 33:44it, I said, this doesn't get people thinking.
- 33:47how much a billion or 30 billion dollars is.
- 33:51It just shows an interesting graphic. Another
- 33:56alternative is to show dollar bills stacked up
- 34:00high. So instead, I decided for opening to use
- 34:09words with no graphics. And here's what I said.
- 34:21How much is $30 billion? It's very difficult
- 34:28for me or most people in this courtroom to understand
- 34:33what $30 billion is. But let's suppose you're
- 34:39lucky in life and you're earning $30 ,000 a year
- 34:47and You don't have to spend a penny of it on
- 34:52rent, on gas, on groceries. You don't even have
- 34:57to pay taxes. And every year you can take the
- 35:01$30 ,000 and put it in a savings account. How
- 35:10many years will it take you to get to $30 billion?
- 35:23My pause is intentional. I want people to think
- 35:28about it. They're not looking at a visual. They're
- 35:33asking themselves, how many years? I asked our
- 35:37damages expert that. He took out his fancy calculator.
- 35:43It can do lots of tricks and gymnastics. and
- 35:48all kinds of other things. And he punched a bunch
- 35:51of keys and he came up with the wrong answer.
- 35:56And he was off by a lot. Because one of the difficulties
- 36:00of using any kind of calculator is knowing how
- 36:03many places should be before or after the decimal
- 36:07point. What's the answer? How many years to get
- 36:13to 30 billion? One million years. And that's
- 36:26a way to think about how to describe something
- 36:30where I think it's more effective to describe
- 36:36it orally and not to use any graphics because
- 36:42you could say, well, How many years is a million
- 36:46years? You go back to the year Christ was born,
- 36:49it's a little more than 2 ,000 years ago, to
- 36:53when the great pyramids in Egypt were first constructed.
- 36:56It's roughly 4 ,500, 5 ,000 years ago. It's a
- 37:02tiny, tiny fraction of a million years ago. is
- 37:13describing expert testimony. Some cases may boil
- 37:20down to a battle of experts. Not all, but some
- 37:24cases may be just that. So if that is the case,
- 37:32if you can think forward to jury deliberations,
- 37:36And what will the jurors, assuming half are favorable
- 37:40for the plaintiff and half are favorable to the
- 37:42defendant, what will they be debating? They may
- 37:45be debating the expert witnesses for each side.
- 37:49And if you think that's a real possibility, you
- 37:52may decide that you should describe expert testimony.
- 38:00But don't toss out the other rules. Be short,
- 38:05make A point, hopefully one point, not seven
- 38:09points. And then ask yourself, if I fairly describe
- 38:15in opening what each expert will say, why should
- 38:19the jurors be favorable to my side of the case?
- 38:25And if it's not a clear answer, maybe you need
- 38:28to rethink some of the themes of your case. A
- 38:35fourth point about a maybe is damages. Some people,
- 38:42plaintiff or defendants, they don't discuss the
- 38:45amount of damages. And I used to think that way,
- 38:51particularly if I was on the plaintiff's side
- 38:54asking for a very large amount of damages. And
- 38:59then defense counsel would say, What Mr. Chu
- 39:05didn't tell you is he is asking, he's going to
- 39:10be asking at the end of this case for a billion
- 39:12dollars or in some cases more than that for the
- 39:21people he represents. So here's a happy medium
- 39:27to consider. It may not apply to every case.
- 39:35Let jurors know or consider letting jurors know
- 39:41if you're representing the plaintiff the magnitude
- 39:46of the case in terms of damages. And by that,
- 39:52I do not mean that you have to put a dollar sign
- 39:56in their mind. and say, well, this case is worth
- 40:00billions of dollars. Because that will come as
- 40:04a shock. Most people say, well, how can that
- 40:06be? Or maybe even with a personal injury case,
- 40:11someone of minus means, whose injuries were not
- 40:15catastrophic, may be asking for three million.
- 40:21And to some people, that will seem like a lot
- 40:24of money because they've already heard about
- 40:27or heard something about what the physical injuries
- 40:31are. Let me give you an example of a way to describe
- 40:38basic facts about damages. This is a patent infringement
- 40:47case. The defendant infringed. It didn't infringe
- 40:54once or a thousand times. It infringed 15 million
- 41:03times by making 15 million infringing chips and
- 41:09selling for several hundred dollars each 15 million
- 41:15chips So I didn't put a number on it But I put
- 41:20some brackets some people may do some simple
- 41:24calculations in their mind Everyone will come
- 41:27away thinking, oh, this is a case that by order
- 41:34of magnitude involves a lot in the way of damages.
- 41:43Here's another maybe, and it depends upon the
- 41:48case. Leave some surprisingly good evidence to
- 41:53be presented. first through witnesses. Make it
- 42:03a surprise. Make it a surprise for people. Make
- 42:09it a pleasant surprise. Make it a kind of surprise
- 42:13that will enhance your credibility. I'll come
- 42:21to another maybe. in a little bit. I do see that
- 42:27there are some questions. I can go to some questions,
- 42:31and I encourage people to go online to ask questions.
- 42:38One question. What are your thoughts about opening
- 42:40statements for a bench trial? Oh, I think that's
- 42:44easy. I came to the remarkable conclusion that
- 42:50the purse sitting on the bench is a human being.
- 42:55And they're like the jurors. Well, they are the
- 42:59juror. It might be a single juror for the facts,
- 43:02but you want to whet their appetite. And all
- 43:05the rules for a jury trial apply to a bench trial.
- 43:14If you've had a trial brief, I still would apply
- 43:19all the rules. The rules include tell a story,
- 43:23make it a compelling story, make it a set of
- 43:27facts that will compel the finder effect to rule
- 43:33in your favor. Let me use this as an opportunity
- 43:37to mention, because you might want to read about
- 43:40this, going back many, many, many years ago,
- 43:44there are a couple of social scientists who did
- 43:48what are called the Chicago jury studies. And
- 43:53they publish numerous articles about those Chicago
- 43:56jury studies. Some people interpret those studies
- 44:01to mean that the opening statement is the most
- 44:05important part of the trial because a huge percentage,
- 44:1085 % of jurors, make up their mind because of
- 44:15what they hear at opening statement. In actuality,
- 44:20pundits who wrote about the Chicago studies were
- 44:26creating something that was not directly said
- 44:28by those who conducted the studies. But what
- 44:32is true is the following. If both sides follow
- 44:40the basic rules, that is, describe the facts
- 44:44of the case, and both sides do a decent job of
- 44:50describing the best facts for their side. It
- 44:56is unremarkable that most people hearing the
- 45:01best of the facts from both sides will conclude
- 45:07who ought to win or at least tentatively come
- 45:11to that conclusion. Another question. How often
- 45:18do you make your opening longer versus shorter
- 45:22as a result of mock jury trial results? It is
- 45:31almost always shorter for Just about every case
- 45:36we have We do one or more mock jury trials And
- 45:45it's not to predict the outcome. It's to test
- 45:49certain themes for both sides. Mark jurors don't
- 45:52know who's doing the presentations, don't know
- 45:55who's paying them to show up for the mock jury.
- 46:01And some potential themes for the side we're
- 46:05on just don't resonate. And if we were thinking
- 46:08of playing to some of those themes in opening,
- 46:13We're no longer going to do it. So often it makes
- 46:18opening shorter. Sometimes it does not have an
- 46:23impact, but it makes sense that it would often
- 46:27be shorter. Here's another question. How does
- 46:32your strategy change for a bench trial such as
- 46:35family law? I've not done family law. I have
- 46:41found that recently judges have preferred waving
- 46:44them all together. I have heard that. I have
- 46:49had the colleagues who've gone on the bench in
- 46:52LA Superior Court and they often have had family
- 46:57law matters and at least one still has family
- 47:00law matters as their assignment. And the judges
- 47:07are processing a lot of cases. which is why the
- 47:12judge may say, well, I don't need to hear opening
- 47:14and why many lawyers say, okay, if I was practicing
- 47:22family law, I think I could think of something
- 47:28important to say in three minutes or less. Do
- 47:39you do a detailed post -mortem on the case you
- 47:42have lost? If so, what have you discovered from
- 47:45a general principle point of view? Well, we try
- 47:51and do, and I try and do, a post -mortem on every
- 47:55case, win or lose, and sometimes cases aren't
- 48:00so clear. Now, the recent World Series was in
- 48:07doubt. It was in doubt after the fifth game,
- 48:12after the sixth game, after the first nine innings
- 48:20or eight and a half innings of the last game.
- 48:28But it's always worth doing a postmortem. And
- 48:31there are many cases where there are claims and
- 48:34there are counterclaims or cross claims. And
- 48:37so it's not a clear -cut winner, as was the case
- 48:41with the Dodgers. So that's something to keep
- 48:45in mind. But I don't wait to the end of a case.
- 48:51I am always doing a re -examination, such as
- 48:57at the end of opening statement. Oh, by hindsight,
- 49:03what should I have done? How should we adjust
- 49:07our trial presentation going forward? And as
- 49:12the testimony of witnesses unfold, those of you
- 49:17who've had one trial or 30 trials know, stuff
- 49:23happens. And particularly when stuff happens,
- 49:28it's always a good time to reassess. So that
- 49:32can be after opening the first witness, sec witness,
- 49:36and so forth. Another good question here is how
- 49:45often should you address the law and maybe its
- 49:48elements in the opening statement? Remember the
- 49:53basic rule, you can't discuss the law, but you
- 49:58can discuss the underlying facts. Let's assume
- 50:02it was a personal injury case and comparative
- 50:06negligence applies. In my Sally hypothetical
- 50:11going to school, I don't think anyone is going
- 50:16to suggest that Sally was at all at fault. Even
- 50:27if she jumped into the crosswalk, If the Ford
- 50:31F -150 was going slow enough, it could have break
- 50:34to a halt. So there was no need to discuss anything
- 50:39about comparative negligence. Maybe a simple
- 50:43statement, but not in the Sally case saying Sally
- 50:46was not at fault. That went without saying. Or
- 50:51it might be a contract case. We all know there
- 50:56needs to be offer acceptance. There needs to
- 50:59be consideration and other elements need to be
- 51:01met. And stating in a clear cut fashion, Jake
- 51:08made an offer to buy a bushel of apples. Elizabeth
- 51:15said, sold at X price. They had a contract. Now
- 51:24I'm just mentioned two basic elements for a breach
- 51:28of contract claim. Boy, all of these questions
- 51:33are terrific. Here's another one. Do the same
- 51:35general rules apply to closing statements, being
- 51:41short, lack of slides, or other visual aids?
- 51:46Will the same basic rules apply? Not being overly
- 51:52long, but closing can be longer. And I wouldn't
- 51:57describe it as lack of slides. I would describe
- 52:02it as being judicious, not having slide after
- 52:07slide after slide and only slides. In fact, visual
- 52:13aids can be somewhat more powerful for closing.
- 52:19You can take what a witness actually said and
- 52:25you can say Remember when Jim Buchanan was on
- 52:30the stand he said Humpty Dumpty fell and was
- 52:39crushed and You can put the words up on the slide.
- 52:45Maybe it's better to use a graphic Maybe it's
- 52:49better just to use, if you have daily transcripts
- 52:52from the trial, part of the trial transcript.
- 52:56I think it would be rare not to use any visual
- 53:00aids during closing. Let's take my Sally example.
- 53:07I didn't use any, but showing the crosswalk to
- 53:13her school. Maybe the skid marks. that were testified
- 53:18to by the accident reconstruction expert and
- 53:22a few other things would really would be quite
- 53:26memorable. Well, could I give an example of the
- 53:35shortest opening statement you gave and how long
- 53:38or short it was it? Let me broaden it to not
- 53:43only opening statement, but in complicated motions.
- 53:49And one example was a case. This was in the Southern
- 53:54District of New York. There was a lot at issue.
- 53:58There was some great complications. It had to
- 54:02do with the position of West Publishing that
- 54:09the pagination in its reporters was subject to
- 54:13copyright protection. and it had brought a dozen
- 54:17or more suits successfully in trial courts and
- 54:22had singular success or a string of successes
- 54:28in the appellate courts. And we were representing
- 54:33a New York based publisher, Matthew Bender. And
- 54:36we wanted to attack that where across the board
- 54:40West Publishing had been successful. The court
- 54:47had reserved all morning for the argument. The
- 54:52other side went on for an hour and three quarters
- 54:58and then finally sat down. I got up and said
- 55:09the following. West Publishing is claiming a
- 55:16copyright, copyright protection in one, two,
- 55:28three, and other page numbers. The claim is staggering.
- 55:41And I sat down. I haven't done a two sentence
- 55:46opening or closing, but I have done some openings
- 55:52with few minutes, few words, and a limited number
- 56:01of sentences. Let's see another example. Oh,
- 56:08how do you stay sharp? That can mean a lot of
- 56:13different things. And do you see yourself as
- 56:17getting sharper and sharper with age? Oh, that
- 56:20suggests that I'm aging. Well, people ask those
- 56:31questions or similar questions. And I would say
- 56:36for everyone who's participating, in this program,
- 56:41everyone in the audience. We all recognize that
- 56:45past a certain age, some would say past age 18,
- 56:49someone else might say past age 23 or 29. They
- 56:55can't quite do the same things they did before.
- 57:00Maybe if they run, they run a tad slower or they
- 57:05lift weights. It's a tad more difficult to lift
- 57:08a certain amount of weights. So there is an interesting
- 57:14thing, and I'll say it in a very positive way,
- 57:17that I truly believe. One of the great things
- 57:21about being a lawyer is that unlike just about
- 57:26everything else in life, whatever other profession
- 57:30or avocation you chose, most lawyers in fact,
- 57:37get better with age. Now, I wouldn't say that's
- 57:42the case with terrific brain surgeons because
- 57:46their physical skills may decay. And you certainly
- 57:51wouldn't say that for pro football players and
- 57:55many other people. But we get smarter. and wiser.
- 58:01We learn how to avoid mistakes. We learn how
- 58:05to anticipate. We don't throw away what we learn
- 58:08every day. We add it to our stores of knowledge.
- 58:13And I would liken it to the following. I'll use
- 58:20an example. I think it was Peyton Manning, and
- 58:23he was at the top of the game as he grew older
- 58:29and older. chronologically. And he was a championship
- 58:33quarterback. And people would ask him, well,
- 58:37how do you do it? You're obviously not as fast.
- 58:42You're not as quick physically. He said, yeah,
- 58:48I know that. Of course I know that. What I see
- 58:53every play unfold in slow motion. And over the
- 59:01years, I began to know that I could spot where
- 59:08my first receiver, my second receiver, my third
- 59:12receiver was, and at the same time, I could determine
- 59:16who's rushing, who's not rushing, whether they're
- 59:22doing something else in terms of their defense,
- 59:25whether they made a shift in their defense. Everything
- 59:28is unfolding. more slowly. So lawyers, we're
- 59:35like decent bottles of wine and unlike the best
- 59:40of wines, we get better and better over time.
- 59:46We'd love to know if there's a story behind the
- 59:48Span Camp pen holder. Well, yeah, there is something
- 59:53that's case related, but I hadn't had Spam in
- 59:57many years. COVID came around. There was a feared
- 1:00:02meat shortage because some meat packing plants
- 1:00:05had to be closed. So my wife, Helena and I, when
- 1:00:08we were at Costco and we could go to Costco during
- 1:00:12COVID, I said, well, let's buy some canned meat
- 1:00:14of some kind. So of course, at Costco, you can't
- 1:00:18buy one can of Spam. So I bought whatever the
- 1:00:21size of the packaging was. I said, yeah, I hadn't
- 1:00:25had Spam in a long time. This tastes... pretty
- 1:00:28darn good. And spam and cheese on an English
- 1:00:36muffin is terrific. Slices of spam on a salad.
- 1:00:40It has limitless possibilities, including when
- 1:00:45I was in Japan very recently. I went into a convenience
- 1:00:49store and one of the items they had in the refrigerator
- 1:00:53was spam sushi. which tasted great. It tasted
- 1:00:58great. Now, in addition, the can comes, I'd say,
- 1:01:02free of charge and is great for holding all kinds
- 1:01:06of things, not just pens and pencils, but I found
- 1:01:09it very useful as a pen and pencil holder as
- 1:01:14well. I want to thank all of you for joining
- 1:01:19this program. And one last thought for everyone.
- 1:01:25Have fun. Have fun practicing law for the rest
- 1:01:29of your lives. Thank you.