Latest / Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick, powered by CBT News / How Consumer AI Is Reshaping the Car-Buying Experience
Transcript
- 0:06Announcer: Welcome to Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:12Jim Fitzpatrick: AI is changing the way dealerships communicate with customers, and it's also reshaping the conversation around pricing transparency, compliance, and digital retailing.
- 0:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Joining us now is Devin Daly, who's the co-founder and CEO of Impel, for a preview of his upcoming panel discussion at the CBT News Auto Leadership Summit on June 16th.
- 0:32Jim Fitzpatrick: His uh his part, his segment, I should say, is titled AI, Digital Retailing, and the Next Frontier of Pricing Transparency.
- 0:40Jim Fitzpatrick: So, Devin, thank you so much for joining us on the show today to discuss this event.
- 0:44Devin Daly: Jim, thank you so much for having me and can't couldn't be more excited about the upcoming event on June 16th.
- 0:49Devin Daly: Thanks for thanks for including us.
- 0:50Jim Fitzpatrick: Sure.
- 0:51Jim Fitzpatrick: So a lot of dealers thought that the FTC's big rule was dead.
- 0:54Jim Fitzpatrick: Is this pressure actually coming off or what's the deal?
- 0:59Devin Daly: Right, no, I think the industry uh exhaled a big sigh of relief in January 2025 when the FTC rule was vacated by the Fifth Circuit.
- 1:08Devin Daly: Um, but obviously, more recently in March 2026, the FTC sent warning letters, as we've all heard about, to the 97 dealer groups nationwide, telling them that advertised prices must include the total price.
- 1:20Devin Daly: So I think it's safe to say that uh no, this has you know not been exhausted or the pressure is not off.
- 1:26Devin Daly: And just recently, earlier this week, Cox Automotive even paused their pricing badges, right?
- 1:32Devin Daly: So um the good or great price badges that were on listings were paused in June of 2026.
- 1:38Devin Daly: Uh, a sign that even folks that focus on pricing or vehicle data are reevaluating how they present prices.
- 1:45Devin Daly: So I think punchline, uh, this is an industry-wide shift.
- 1:49Devin Daly: It is not over, and it's not just a dealership problem.
- 1:52Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, there's no question about it.
- 1:53Jim Fitzpatrick: And I think even other some other third-party lead providers have uh followed suit.
- 1:57Jim Fitzpatrick: So the panel title uh talks about engaging customers before they walk in the door.
- 2:03Jim Fitzpatrick: What's actually changed there?
- 2:05Devin Daly: Yeah, I mean, I think first of all, uh a lot of folks are negotiating price long before they enter the showroom, right?
- 2:11Devin Daly: I mean, we've even heard the stories about consumers that are using AI agents to even negotiate the deal and really try to fully negotiate that deal.
- 2:19Devin Daly: So look, I think the punchline is the first pricing interaction is rarely on the lot anymore.
- 2:26Devin Daly: It's a digital response to a lead, it's uh an online web chat.
- 2:30Devin Daly: The part that most dealers miss, everyone knows that you have to advertise an FTC compliant price.
- 2:36Devin Daly: What many may not realize is even in a sales conversation, that can constitute where a rep is communicating, that can constitute an advertising or pricing disclosure.
- 2:46Devin Daly: So the compliance conversation has moved out of just the marketing department and the website and the ad copy and into the CRM and the BDC.
- 2:56Devin Daly: And again, that's where AI obviously can really help ensure compliance uh with the FTC pricing guidelines.
- 3:02Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, absolutely.
- 3:03Jim Fitzpatrick: Does AI, from your perspective, make this uh the this compliance problem better or worse?
- 3:09Devin Daly: It's a great question.
- 3:10Devin Daly: You know, it's kind of a bowl of hand, right?
- 3:13Devin Daly: But I think AI, if used properly, the operative word there is if, um, you know, an enterprise-grade AI platform can absolutely help with compliance, right?
- 3:23Devin Daly: I think it is difficult to trust a rep to navigate the ever-changing world of your pricing strategy and FTC compliance.
- 3:32Devin Daly: AI, though, if configured properly, which is something you know we counsel dealers on, and dealers are able to, you know, sort of inform and structure the AI in the way that they would like, can absolutely help drive better compliance.
- 3:46Devin Daly: There's there's no doubt about that.
- 3:47Devin Daly: Yeah.
- 3:47Devin Daly: The other sorry, just one last comment on that, Jim.
- 3:49Devin Daly: I would just say the other benefit is AI is number one consistent, obviously, but also reviewable.
- 3:55Devin Daly: Every conversation with an AI platform creates a record.
- 3:59Devin Daly: And, you know, with AI in this FTC regulatory environment, that's a feature, not a risk.
- 4:04Devin Daly: And so if a regulator or auditor says, show me, you've got that AI record there to protect yourself.
- 4:10Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 4:10Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 4:10Jim Fitzpatrick: Isn't transparency just a cost that dealers are gonna have to eat at the end of the day?
- 4:16Devin Daly: Look, I mean, I think we were heading towards a world of complete and utter price transparency prior to Gen AI.
- 4:22Devin Daly: And I think, you know, the release of these generative AI models have unlocked a new era of transparency where, you know, trying to maintain information asymmetry is likely a fool's errand, right?
- 4:34Devin Daly: As we all know, the big unlock of Gen AI is that it is trained, and and really that the fundamental or the foundation of it is the ability to crawl the entirety of the world wide web.
- 4:46Devin Daly: And so consumers now have at their fingertips all of the pricing available anywhere.
- 4:51Devin Daly: And so, yes, I mean it is our our firm belief that it is better now to embrace pricing transparency and information symmetry.
- 4:58Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, having said that, and having said that the internet's already made buyers smarter, um, what's what's actually left to change?
- 5:06Devin Daly: Yeah, look, I mean, I think again, the the business was historically built on information asymmetry, and you know, uh the dealer knew the real cost, the value of the trade, which fees were soft or not, and that gap was the original source of distrust in car buying.
- 5:21Devin Daly: And you know, again, now we believe two forces are closing it at once.
- 5:25Devin Daly: You've got regulation from the FTC, uh, which is essentially an asymmetry reduction project because all in pricing and advertise equals paid exist to put the consumer and the dealer on equal footing.
- 5:37Devin Daly: And then again, the consumer now has AI in their own pocket, in many cases, even informing how they negotiate and uh and engage with that dealership and negotiate with that store.
- 5:47Jim Fitzpatrick: Sure.
- 5:47Jim Fitzpatrick: One more thing that dealers have got to focus on.
- 5:49Jim Fitzpatrick: Where do dealers most often trip up?
- 5:53Devin Daly: You know, I think uh getting the disclosures right, especially on add-on products.
- 5:57Devin Daly: And so, you know, that's another, I think, benefit of AI, right, is being able to have that disclosure early on inside the AI system, not just on a paper form at signing, which is fraught with potential issues.
- 6:11Devin Daly: Um, we believe doing that ahead of time can help you get ahead.
- 6:14Devin Daly: And having you know built-in control layers, guardrails, repositories, which your management level set and control but are designed to help the AI deliver compliant disclosures consistently with every consumer in every conversation.
- 6:28Devin Daly: And I think about that not just as a compliance risk mitigation tactic, but if you use AI to disclose and discuss F and I or add-on products earlier, you can also warm consumers up before they get tossed in the F and I box, which we all know can help FI and PVR attachment rates.
- 6:43Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right, that's right.
- 6:44Jim Fitzpatrick: This is uh famously cyclical business for sure.
- 6:48Jim Fitzpatrick: How does AI fit uh a market that's always swinging?
- 6:53Devin Daly: Yeah, to your point, right?
- 6:54Devin Daly: Auto is notoriously cyclical, you know, new versus used versus fixed, but also things like terror, I mean COVID, inventory shortage, then tariffs, gas prices with Iran, interest rates, which today the markets are dropping because they think interest rates are gonna be high.
- 7:08Devin Daly: And more recently now, things with the FTC.
- 7:11Devin Daly: And so it seems like nearly every month we are pivoting tact or strategy.
- 7:16Devin Daly: And it is nearly, if not totally, impossible to train human staff in pivot direction every month, right?
- 7:23Devin Daly: If you think about tariffs and trying to train your team to articulately and easily explain to a consumer this is a pre-tariff vehicle versus a post-tariff vehicle, or our vehicles are mostly assembled in the U.S.
- 7:35Devin Daly: And so this is the impact of tariffs.
- 7:36Devin Daly: Again, with the changing tariff policy, you'd have to train and retrain and check in, and that can be a six-week process.
- 7:43Devin Daly: By the time we're done, it's like painting the Golden Gate Bridge.
- 7:46Devin Daly: The policies change or the strategies change.
- 7:48Devin Daly: AI allows you to scale up and down seamlessly, change your strategy from a primarily, you know, variable-driven strategy to fixed or you know, new versus used, and all throughout all of those changes, ensure that you're doing all of that in a compliant way.
- 8:10Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right, that's right.
- 8:11Jim Fitzpatrick: And through companies like yours, dealers will make it through.
- 8:14Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, this is just one of just one more thing that they, you know, today's dealers got to deal with, but we'll make it.
- 8:19Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, we are a resilient group out there, and uh you're helping dealers figure all of that out.
- 8:26Jim Fitzpatrick: So, folks, you're gonna see Devin Daly at uh the conference, uh, which we're so excited about.
- 8:30Jim Fitzpatrick: It's the CBT News uh auto leadership summit on June 16th uh at the Salamander Hotel.
- 8:38Jim Fitzpatrick: If you haven't registered, please do so.
- 8:40Jim Fitzpatrick: This is a conference you definitely want to attend.
- 8:43Jim Fitzpatrick: It's almost a must-attend, right, Devin?
- 8:44Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, with all that's going on, you don't want the FTC knocking on your door going, uh, can we talk to you for a minute?
- 8:49Jim Fitzpatrick: And that conversation could cost you millions in fines if you're not doing it right.
- 8:54Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh and Devin's got his hand on the pulse of what's going on there.
- 8:57Jim Fitzpatrick: So thank you so much, Devin, for joining us on the show.
- 8:59Jim Fitzpatrick: Look forward to seeing you in just a couple of weeks.
- 9:01Devin Daly: Absolutely.
- 9:02Devin Daly: Thanks for having me, and couldn't look forward to it more.
- 9:04Devin Daly: Thank you.
- 9:04Jim Fitzpatrick: Thanks.