Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Attorney-Client Privilege in Common Interest Scenarios- Walking the Waiver Tightrope with Michael Brophy, Garen Kirakosian
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to attorney -client privilege and common
- 0:05interest scenarios, walking the waiver tightrope.
- 0:08We are thrilled to have you join us today. My
- 0:11name is Courtney Patton, and I'm the co -chair
- 0:13of BHBA's Trust and Estate section. Before we
- 0:16begin, I'd like to take a moment to introduce
- 0:18Nancy Sanborn and Brian Joy of the Sanborn team.
- 0:22Nancy and Brian have been the official sponsor
- 0:24of this section since 2006. That's nearly 20
- 0:28years. Nancy and Brian, please say hello. Hi,
- 0:32everyone. Just a few moments. Everyone always
- 0:35kind of wants to know about the real estate market.
- 0:38So Brian and I thought we'd give you a tiny little
- 0:41update. Frankly, there has been a kind of a stall
- 0:45in the market since April. That seems to be the
- 0:47month that everything kind of took a little bit
- 0:50of a dive. So we're finding now that when we
- 0:55try to price properties or help buyers look at
- 0:59properties, we have to be very careful on how
- 1:02we analyze what things are selling for. Right.
- 1:05From the very beginning, if your price too high,
- 1:07the traffic drops, momentum fades, and the final
- 1:11price can slip. It's more important than ever
- 1:14to start at the right price and to get as many
- 1:17interested buyers as possible at the very beginning.
- 1:20So it's not always the easiest conversation to
- 1:23have with people, but we're here to do it. So
- 1:25have a great meeting. Enjoy. Take care. Bye -bye.
- 1:31Thanks, Nancy and Brian. In addition to the Sanborn
- 1:33team, the trust and estate section is also sponsored
- 1:36by Bond Services of California, Liberty Mutual
- 1:40Surety, California Title Company, and Pickford
- 1:43Escrow Company. Now, I'd like to turn things
- 1:46over to Rosita Yacoby to provide this month's
- 1:49legal updates. Thanks, Courtney. I will be presenting
- 1:54the case of the estate of Boyajian. case cited
- 1:57as G063155, 4th District, Division 3, filed on
- 2:05July 3, 2025. This case holds that the revocation
- 2:10of a will by cancellation must occur by physical
- 2:14alteration of the will. And a separate standalone
- 2:18document does not constitute a subsequent will
- 2:21unless it also transfers the property upon death.
- 2:26The decedent basically signed a two -page holographic
- 2:29will in 2006 that bequeathed her entire estate
- 2:32to her daughter Anoush. In 2018, the decedent
- 2:36signed the second document prepared by her son
- 2:39Robert, which purported to revoke all of the
- 2:42decedent's prior estate planning documents. After
- 2:46the decedent's death, Anoush petitioned to revoke
- 2:48the 2006 will, which Robert contested. The trial
- 2:53court ruled in favor of Robert and held that
- 2:55the decedent died in testing. Anoush appealed.
- 3:00The appellate court reversed and held that the
- 3:02cancellation of a will requires a physical alteration
- 3:06and the subsequent will must be testamentary
- 3:10in nature and dispose of property upon death.
- 3:13The 2018 document did not meet the probate code's
- 3:16definition of an instrument because it did not
- 3:19reflect the decedent's testamentary intent as
- 3:23it did not name a beneficiary and did not transfer
- 3:26or dispose of any property upon the decedent's
- 3:30death. Additionally, the document was notarized
- 3:33and not witnessed by two persons. which is required
- 3:37for wills, and such witness formalities are needed
- 3:40to turn a standalone lubrication into a will.
- 3:44A more detailed summary of the case will be posted
- 3:47on the Beverly Hills Bar Association website.
- 3:50And now to Aubrey. Thanks, Rosie. Now onto the
- 3:54program. Today's speakers are Michael Brophy
- 3:57and Garen Kirikosian. Michael Brophy is a partner
- 4:01in the trust estate and inheritance disputes
- 4:03team at Withers and is the regional divisional
- 4:06leader of their US private client and tax team.
- 4:09He is also the office managing director of the
- 4:12Los Angeles office. Michael has extensive experience
- 4:16representing individuals, families, charities,
- 4:19corporate trustees, private professional fiduciaries,
- 4:22and creditors in litigation involving complex
- 4:25trusts and estates. Michael's diverse practice
- 4:27includes will and trust contests, accounting
- 4:30disputes, breach of duty actions, elder abuse,
- 4:33and conservatorship disputes, document interpretation
- 4:38matters, and other contested probate and fiduciary
- 4:41related matters. Garen Kirikosian is a managing
- 4:44associate in Withers' private client and tax
- 4:46team. His practice focuses on litigating matters
- 4:49on behalf of individuals and families related
- 4:52to trusts, estates, and conservatorships, including
- 4:55trust and will contests, breach of fiduciary
- 4:58actions, accounting actions, and other related
- 5:01judicial proceedings and disputes. In addition
- 5:03to litigation, Guerin advises fiduciaries and
- 5:06beneficiaries through the administration of trusts,
- 5:09probate, and conservatorships. He also advises
- 5:12clients on all aspects of estate planning, succession
- 5:15planning, charitable giving, and special needs
- 5:17trusts. Please welcome Michael Brophy and Garen
- 5:21Kirikosian. Thank you Aubrey. We are thrilled
- 5:31to be here today and thank you all for attending.
- 5:34Today Garen and I will be walking the waiver
- 5:36tightrope. by looking at attorney -client privilege
- 5:39in common interest scenarios, specifically in
- 5:43the trust and estates world. Now, in our world
- 5:46of estate and business planning, confidentiality
- 5:49is vital. These are private family matters, and
- 5:52legal advisors are often given the most personal
- 5:55details about a family and its holdings. In litigation,
- 5:59such as will contests or contested trust administration,
- 6:03Private conversations with one's attorneys are
- 6:06instrumental to creating legal strategy, addressing
- 6:10potential case strengths and weaknesses, and
- 6:13to address difficult questions. So with separately
- 6:16represented co -trustees, they may want the ability
- 6:20to collectively discuss beneficiary disputes
- 6:22or alleged breach of duty with their counsel
- 6:25present. And while the contours of the attorney
- 6:29-client privilege often differ by jurisdiction,
- 6:32The basic concept is pretty straightforward.
- 6:35Subject to some exceptions, a client has a privilege
- 6:38to refuse to disclose and to prevent others from
- 6:42disclosing a confidential communication between
- 6:45the client and the attorney. Typically, the communication
- 6:49must be related to the purpose for which the
- 6:50attorney was consulted or retained. But absent
- 6:54waiver by your client, the right is generally
- 6:57retained and the right belongs to the client,
- 7:00not to the attorney. And a privilege may be waived
- 7:04if the holder of the privilege has voluntarily
- 7:06disclosed a significant part of that communication
- 7:10to a third party or consented to such disclosure.
- 7:14But in the world of representing beneficiaries
- 7:17and fiduciaries, some of these bright lines fray.
- 7:21For example, does your administration or litigation
- 7:24include a jurisdiction that follows the fiduciary
- 7:27exception to the attorney -client privilege,
- 7:29the so -called Riggs rule? where a beneficiary's
- 7:32right to information is often prioritized over
- 7:35the trustee's right to protect the attorney's
- 7:37client privilege? Does that jurisdiction impose
- 7:40duties on the attorney to disclose privileged
- 7:42information to the beneficiaries? Does it matter
- 7:45if the communications are made in a litigation
- 7:47context or a non -contentious administrative
- 7:50context? And while there are many topics of interest
- 7:53when thinking about the attorney -client privilege
- 7:56in the context of representing beneficiaries
- 7:58and fiduciaries, today's presentation focuses
- 8:01on the specific issue of purposeful, intentional
- 8:06disclosures of privileged communications and
- 8:09information to aligned third parties with common
- 8:13interests. Now, this doctrine is broadly called
- 8:17by many names is you hear the common interest
- 8:20privilege, the community of interest privilege,
- 8:23the joint defense privilege, the joint prosecution
- 8:26privilege. I've heard it called the pooled information
- 8:29privilege, lots of different names. Today, we're
- 8:31gonna most commonly refer to it as the common
- 8:34interest doctrine. But with the many ways that
- 8:37the disclosure of privileged information under
- 8:40such an agreement can subsequently be deemed
- 8:42to be a waiver, Sometimes they feel like you're
- 8:46walking a tightrope no matter what you call it.
- 8:52Before diving further into the common interest
- 8:54doctrine, let's briefly consider how waiver works
- 8:56when other parties are present or copied on what
- 8:59would otherwise be a privileged communication.
- 9:02When it comes to discussing strategy with clients,
- 9:04it's not unusual for them to want to involve
- 9:07other trusted friends, family, and advisors.
- 9:10But what happens when your client includes another
- 9:13party in privileged communications, like when
- 9:15you're co -defending a lawsuit or co -administering
- 9:17a trust? Or what if they just bring a friend
- 9:20to an estate planning meeting? Does this constitute
- 9:23a waiver? And if so, to what extent? There are
- 9:27lots of reasons why clients bring people with
- 9:29them to meetings. It includes family dynamics,
- 9:32cultural norms, language barriers, and different
- 9:35levels of sophistication. And knowing what relationships
- 9:38maintain the privilege or cause a waiver is an
- 9:42important consideration. And if you find yourself
- 9:44taking advantage of any of these agency type
- 9:47principles, like an authorized representative
- 9:49or a reasonably necessary person, how does that
- 9:52need to be formalized, if at all? And what risks
- 9:56need to be disclosed to the client before including
- 9:59those people on meetings and communications?
- 10:02There are many waiver possibilities in family
- 10:06situations and lawyers are well served to discuss
- 10:09basic privilege concepts with the client at the
- 10:11start of every new engagement. I think one of
- 10:14the most important privilege concepts for a client
- 10:16to understand is waiver. Today's focus is on
- 10:20a doctrine that actually works to shield against
- 10:22waiver. We're focusing on people who are separately
- 10:25represented but who want to collaborate on a
- 10:28legal strategy or defense. This is not a joint
- 10:32representation where an attorney is engaged by
- 10:35two or more parties. Joint representation generally
- 10:37eliminates the concern of privileged communications
- 10:40being waived by disclosure to a co -party. Our
- 10:46goal for today is to discuss common issues involved
- 10:48in the creation and scope of a common interest
- 10:51or joint defense relationship, which are instrumental
- 10:54in how a particular jurisdiction approaches claims
- 10:56of waiver. We'll also talk through how these
- 10:59issues are litigated, including the scope of
- 11:01a waiver, and focus on some special issues relating
- 11:04to privilege and aligned parties in the trust
- 11:06and estates context. There are certain unique
- 11:09issues that may arise regarding joint defense
- 11:12and waiver for parties like co -trustees, successor
- 11:14trustees, and in other cases where you have a
- 11:17change in allegiance. Finally, we'll conclude
- 11:20with looking at some best communication and privilege
- 11:23practices when addressing collaboration with
- 11:25aligned parties. Like the rocks in this photo,
- 11:28there's an art to balancing the benefits of sharing
- 11:31attorney information with the needs to maintain
- 11:34confidentiality. Careful control and instruction
- 11:37will allow you and your client to walk the tightrope
- 11:41of ensuring effective representation without
- 11:43compromising privilege. And while precedent laws
- 11:47governing common interest agreements vary somewhat
- 11:50from state to state and across federal circuits,
- 11:53We can start today's discussion by looking at
- 11:55a description of the doctrine in the third Restatement
- 11:58of the Law Governing Lawyers, Section 76. It
- 12:02says, if two or more clients with a common interest
- 12:05in a litigation or non -litigated matter are
- 12:08represented by separate lawyers and they agree
- 12:10to exchange information concerning the matter,
- 12:13a communication of any such client that otherwise
- 12:15qualifies as privileged that relates the matter
- 12:18is privileged as against third persons. Any such
- 12:22client may invoke the privilege unless it has
- 12:24been waived by the client who made the communication.
- 12:27Unless the clients have agreed otherwise, a communication
- 12:29described in subsection one is not privileged
- 12:32between the clients described in a subsequent
- 12:35adverse proceeding between them. So as an introduction
- 12:39to today's topics, let's break this down further
- 12:42by focusing on the bolded phrases in the restatement.
- 12:45Two or more clients. You're going to need to
- 12:48be clear at the outset who is the client and
- 12:50who is each client's lawyers. Clarity on this
- 12:53issue will be key in establishing and enforcing
- 12:56your agreement and maintaining your ethical obligations.
- 13:00Indeed, common interests among multiple parties
- 13:02leads to confusion relating to client and counsel
- 13:06identity and can lead to inadvertent waiver.
- 13:08with families with many beneficiaries, for example,
- 13:11it is not unusual for some of the interested
- 13:13parties to attempt to free ride on the legal
- 13:16advice obtained by a family member rather than
- 13:18retain their own attorney. So it's going to be
- 13:20very important to understand who the clients
- 13:23are and who represents them. The next bolded
- 13:27phrase is with a common interest. In evaluating
- 13:30claims of waiver, whether the clients have a
- 13:33sufficient common interest, whatever that means,
- 13:37may be a keystone issue. that may cause the entire
- 13:40waiver protection doctrine to fail? Is the communication
- 13:43sufficiently related to the common interest?
- 13:46What level of commonality? Identical? What about
- 13:49mixed business and legal discussions with counsel?
- 13:53The next phrase is in litigation or non -litigated
- 13:56matters. We'll talk about this more in a bit,
- 13:58but in some jurisdictions, like California, the
- 14:01common interest doctrine may apply to matters
- 14:02outside of the litigation context. which is one
- 14:05of the reasons why I prefer using the common
- 14:07interest doctrine verbiage instead of the joint
- 14:10defense agreement, which is more of a litigation
- 14:12context. But other jurisdictions, such as New
- 14:16York on the other hand, require anticipated or
- 14:19actual litigation. If active or anticipated litigation
- 14:23is a necessary element in your jurisdiction,
- 14:25then the proximity of litigation will become
- 14:28the focus. Next highlighted is the phrase separate
- 14:32lawyers. That detail distinguishes a common interest
- 14:35scenario from a joint representation scenario.
- 14:38If one attorney is representing all of the parties
- 14:40on a side, then it's not a common interest arrangement.
- 14:44Those writing on the history of common interest
- 14:47doctrine in a lot of the cases have noted that
- 14:50early on in its development, counsel and courts
- 14:52often failed to make this distinction in certain
- 14:55filings and rulings, combining the concepts of
- 14:58joint representation with common interest. The
- 15:02next bolded phrase is agree to exchange. Agree.
- 15:06That means there some sort of agreement is typically
- 15:09required. But what evidence of your agreement
- 15:12will be necessary is going to depend on jurisdiction.
- 15:15And if it's a formal written contract, will that
- 15:18contract itself be discoverable? That is often
- 15:20an evade litigation. And it's not unusual for
- 15:23the parties to start operating under the common
- 15:25interest protection based on an oral understanding
- 15:28later documented in a formal writing. particularly
- 15:31if the discussion involves handling your aligned
- 15:33party's confidential information. There may be
- 15:35negotiations on how that will be handled during
- 15:38and after the litigation. And so that won't be
- 15:41addressed in the agreement until those terms
- 15:44are met, or a meeting of the minds have been
- 15:47met. So this, of course, raises a lot of questions.
- 15:50When do courts recognize the existence of common
- 15:53interest agreements? How does one establish agreement?
- 15:56Can it happen on the telephone or Zoom? Or does
- 15:58it have to be writing an email? It could differ
- 16:01from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. But most courts,
- 16:05like those in California, require an express
- 16:08agreement, whether oral or in writing, to keep
- 16:10the common interest materials confidential. And
- 16:13what evidence does one use? That's another issue
- 16:16we'll talk about a little bit later. But can
- 16:18you establish a common interest agreement, an
- 16:21oral one, without revealing privileged communications?
- 16:23It can be a tough and thorny issue. And the final.
- 16:28bolded clauses otherwise qualifies as privileged.
- 16:32Now, a common interest or joint defense agreement
- 16:34does not itself in California create a privileged
- 16:37situation. This is why I refer to it as a doctrine
- 16:40rather than a privilege. It's a non -waver doctrine
- 16:43in California. Calling it a privilege can confuse
- 16:45some clients who think the existence of the agreement
- 16:48makes all communications with the aligned parties
- 16:50privileged. Instead, it provides a means to protect
- 16:54otherwise privileged communications from discovery.
- 16:59The public policy behind it is really for the
- 17:01purpose of further collaborating legal strategy
- 17:04and promoting efficiency. Now, some courts have,
- 17:09in fact, considered it an extension of the attorney
- 17:12-client privilege, but many others recognize
- 17:15it as an exception to the traditional waiver
- 17:17consequence of disclosure. Though today's presentation
- 17:21throughout will expand on these issues. One of
- 17:27the challenges of the common interest doctrine
- 17:28is that it is recognized and applied differently
- 17:30across jurisdictions. Some states reference it
- 17:33in their evidence statutes, while California
- 17:35and some federal courts only recognize the doctrine
- 17:38in judicial opinions. The Supreme Court stated
- 17:41in its 1981 Upjohn decision that an uncertain
- 17:44privilege or one which purports to be certain
- 17:46but results in widely varying applications by
- 17:48the courts is little better than no privilege
- 17:51at all. And that makes sense, but that's exactly
- 17:54what we have is an inconsistent usage of the
- 17:57common interest doctrine across jurisdictions.
- 18:00However, despite that patchwork of rules across
- 18:04jurisdictions, there are still some common elements
- 18:06we find regardless of the jurisdiction. First,
- 18:09you have that the information shared with the
- 18:11co -party would otherwise be protected from disclosure.
- 18:15Second, the participants in the exchange had
- 18:18a reasonable expectation that the information
- 18:20disclosed would remain confidential. And third,
- 18:24the disclosure was made to advance their shared
- 18:27interest in securing legal advice on a common
- 18:29matter. It's not too different than what Mike
- 18:33explained was set forth in the restatement. The
- 18:36purpose of the doctrine is twofold, to encourage
- 18:38the free flow of information and to enhance the
- 18:41quality of legal advice. Courts have reasoned
- 18:44that doctrine's positive effect on the quality
- 18:46of legal advice benefits society by promoting
- 18:50justice and offers benefits to the interested
- 18:52parties and the system as a whole. The idea being
- 18:56that when counsel is more informed, they can
- 18:57provide better legal advice, and when counsel
- 19:00can cooperate, it is likely to save the court
- 19:02time. This, however, would be unlikely if the
- 19:05collaboration waived the attorney -client privilege.
- 19:08Now, let's... Pause for a quick second to acknowledge
- 19:11our favorite topic, ethical duties as lawyers.
- 19:15When considering the common interest doctrine,
- 19:17we must remember our ethical obligations as attorneys.
- 19:21Entering into a common interest agreement implicates
- 19:24the duty of confidentiality, the duty of competence
- 19:28and diligence, the duty of communication, and
- 19:31the expectation of zealous advocacy. I'll note
- 19:34that the ABA issued a formal opinion regarding
- 19:37the specific relationship between an attorney
- 19:40and allied parties in situations like common
- 19:43interest agreements, and stated that attorneys
- 19:47may owe the non -clients in the group certain
- 19:50fiduciary duties that are part of the agreement,
- 19:52but they do not become clients. For example,
- 19:55an attorney can be obligated to maintain confidences
- 19:58of the other parties, but this does not extend
- 20:01an ethical duty to the non -client members of
- 20:04the common interest agreement. And I think that
- 20:06distinction is important for sometimes the inevitable
- 20:10when a problem occurs because the harm party
- 20:12will need to know what the rules, duties, and
- 20:14obligations are. Great. So a lot of states, when
- 20:23it comes to evidentiary issues, follow the Uniform
- 20:25Evidence Code. California does not. But because
- 20:29a lot of trust administrations touch on states
- 20:32that do, have some version of the uniform evidence
- 20:36code. We've included two examples of those types
- 20:40of statutes in the materials in the slide. And
- 20:44taking the South Dakota and Kentucky examples,
- 20:48looking at South Dakota, it says a client has
- 20:50a privilege to refuse to disclose and to prevent
- 20:52any other person from disclosing a confidential
- 20:55communication made for the purpose of facilitating
- 20:58the rendition of professional legal services
- 21:01to the client. by the client or representative
- 21:04of the client, or the client's lawyer or representative
- 21:06of the lawyer, to a lawyer or representative
- 21:09of the lawyer, representing another party in
- 21:11a pending action and concerning a matter of common
- 21:13interest therein. That's a mouthful, and it's
- 21:17similar to what we've been talking about, but
- 21:18I include these examples because what's interesting
- 21:24to note is that the Uniform Evidence Code and
- 21:26both of these examples focus on disclosure to
- 21:29counsel and not the aligned party. And what that
- 21:32means is a uniform evidence code jurisdiction
- 21:35may not recognize a common interest protection
- 21:40to communications made from client to client
- 21:43if the attorneys weren't present. And so again,
- 21:48thinking about. that how that impacts a multi
- 21:51-jurisdictional administration or a contentious
- 21:55case with a will contest in one state and a trust
- 21:58contest in another state can make these kinds
- 22:00of issues really glaring. But let's focus a little
- 22:05bit closer to home. Yeah. So in California, the
- 22:10common interest Privilege is not an independent
- 22:13privilege as we discussed earlier. It's a non
- 22:16waiver doctrine derived from evidence code sections
- 22:19912 and 952. The common interest doctrines specify
- 22:24circumstances under which disclosure to a third
- 22:27party would not be considered a waiver of the
- 22:30privilege. The attorney -client privilege is
- 22:32extended to parties who share communications
- 22:34with counsel where the parties hold a common
- 22:37legal interest. I'm a litigator, and clients
- 22:43usually do not come to me unless litigation is
- 22:45somewhere in the picture. And the most classic
- 22:48common interest scenario is the defense arrangement,
- 22:51where both parties are aligned in their efforts
- 22:53to defeat claims being made against them. These
- 22:55are often referred to as JDAs. But in these jurisdictions
- 23:00that require some proximity to litigation, even
- 23:04that line is fuzzy. And courts draw a number
- 23:07of lines, and walking these lines can become
- 23:09quite precarious. Some courts, example, may refuse
- 23:12to apply the doctrine unless there is some adequately
- 23:16anticipated litigation, either active litigation
- 23:20or adequately anticipated. In New York State,
- 23:23for example, there must be pending or reasonably
- 23:25anticipated litigation. And they had a pretty
- 23:29high profile opinion back in 2016 involving the
- 23:33Countrywide Bank of America merger. where there
- 23:36were pre -merger discussions prior to the post
- 23:39-merger litigation, where the parties of the
- 23:43transactions were sharing confidential information.
- 23:45And in the discovery and the subsequent litigation,
- 23:48claimed that there was a common interest protection
- 23:50for the sharing of information between clients
- 23:53and separately represented clients prior to this
- 23:57litigation. And the New York court looked at
- 24:01the history of it and decided that, put simply,
- 24:04When businesses share a common interest in closing
- 24:07a complex transaction, their shared interest
- 24:09in the transaction's completion is already an
- 24:11adequate incentive for exchanging information
- 24:14necessary to achieve that end. Therefore, you
- 24:17do not need the common interest protection in
- 24:19order to encourage that kind of sharing. The
- 24:22court concluded that these policy reasons for
- 24:24keeping a litigation limitation on the common
- 24:26interest doctrine outweighed any purported justification
- 24:29for doing away with it. And so in that particular
- 24:33instance, discovery was permitted. And if you're
- 24:37interested in sort of diving into the scholarship
- 24:39of this, Judge Garcia in the AMBAC decision gives
- 24:42a pretty powerful dissent and why that shouldn't
- 24:44be the case and that the common interest doctrine
- 24:46should have protected that information. But even
- 24:50if actual or anticipated litigation is part of
- 24:53the required analysis, we see courts in various
- 24:56jurisdictions using a number of approaches. Joint
- 25:01litigant scenario. That's the most easiest one.
- 25:03That's the JDA. That's when the litigation is
- 25:08actually pending. So that's a pretty easy one
- 25:09to apply. But what about the jurisdictions like
- 25:13the Fourth Circuit federal courts that look for
- 25:16contemplating litigation? Well, what does that
- 25:19mean? And so if you don't have a very clear idea
- 25:23of what contemplating means, you may have a line
- 25:26drawn on what is protected by the common interest
- 25:29doctrine and what is not, that won't really be
- 25:31known until it's litigated. A federal court in
- 25:36Colorado, another test was a strong possibility
- 25:38of litigation. All right. So it's not just contemplating
- 25:41litigation. Now the scale's tipping towards litigation.
- 25:44Strong possibility. Again, seems like a pretty
- 25:47problematic standard when you're trying to decide
- 25:49where the line is. And this deciding where the
- 25:53line is usually comes up in discovery when they're
- 25:55trying to seek the information that the members
- 25:58of the common interest agreement are trying to
- 26:01protect. We saw on the Fifth Circuit a palpable
- 26:06threat of litigation. Not sure how palpable threat
- 26:08is different than contemplating or strong possibility,
- 26:11but it sounds just as problematic in its application.
- 26:15Now, Garen outlined how in California, the common
- 26:19interest privilege is a non -waiver doctrine,
- 26:22and it's derived from evidence code sections
- 26:24912 and 952. Like California, Some states and
- 26:31federal courts also recognize a broad common
- 26:33interest approach, recognizing the doctrine in
- 26:35non -litigation contexts where legal interests
- 26:38are aligned. Even in certain federal courts and
- 26:42states that don't recognize pre -litigation common
- 26:48interests have found it in certain transactional
- 26:50settings, taxpayer settings, patent settings.
- 26:55But in California, you're going to see the focus
- 26:57is going to be on whether the communications
- 27:01related to the legal advice for which the communications
- 27:04were intended, that sort of analysis. So it doesn't
- 27:08become really about the proximity to litigation,
- 27:10but whether the common interests are focused
- 27:13on shared legal interests relating to the purposes
- 27:16of the advice. And so. even in that kind of broad
- 27:21application, there's a broad variation of what
- 27:24might constitute the proper circumstances to
- 27:26merit a common interest agreement. And you see
- 27:28this pop up a lot in disputes where parties on
- 27:33opposite sides of a lawsuit are aligned against
- 27:36a cross complaint. Courts that have various rules
- 27:42regarding pre -litigation, post -litigation,
- 27:45if these folks were talking with one another
- 27:49before the cross -complaint was filed or trying
- 27:51to prevent the cross -complaint from being filed.
- 27:54Is this a situation where it's sufficiently close
- 27:57to litigation? You can have a very complex analysis
- 28:00when you have cross -complaints in various allegiances.
- 28:06Looking at our common scenarios, what would happen
- 28:09if you had a trust governed by California law
- 28:11with one beneficiary in Illinois, one beneficiary
- 28:15in Texas, one beneficiary in Pennsylvania, all
- 28:18aligned in litigation, all separately represented
- 28:21against, let's say, a corporate trustee in Florida.
- 28:24And there's a Florida trust action and a lawsuit
- 28:27against the trustee in the federal courts in
- 28:30Texas, as well as at a state matter in California.
- 28:34Well, to feel comfortable proceeding with a common
- 28:36interest agreement under those circumstances,
- 28:40in order to collaborate and not waive privilege,
- 28:42we would need to make sure that we considered
- 28:44choice of law. and how each potential jurisdiction
- 28:47might consider the waiver doctrine? And have
- 28:50we sufficiently warned our clients before engaging
- 28:54in this common interest discussion that the answer
- 28:57may not be 100 % clear? Yeah, and in a lot of
- 29:03these cases across jurisdictions, the issue of
- 29:05the commonality of interest becomes the focus
- 29:07of the court's analysis. Therefore, I think it's
- 29:10always important to be mindful of what jurisdiction
- 29:12or jurisdictions you're potentially operating
- 29:14in and be mindful of the rules and precedent
- 29:17ensuring there is a commonality of interest under
- 29:20their doctrine or privilege or whatever it is
- 29:23that you're operating under. For example, some
- 29:26courts require that the legal interests be identical
- 29:29rather than merely similar or overlapping or
- 29:33aligned. In California, in order for it to apply,
- 29:36the parties don't need to have an identical interest
- 29:38for the doctrine to apply, but it must be a legal
- 29:42interest. For example, in the Raytheon case,
- 29:46the defendants were being sued for toxic contamination,
- 29:50but were found to still have a common legal interest
- 29:53necessary even though the liability shifting
- 29:56could have changed the outcome for each party.
- 29:59So even though the defendants basically could
- 30:01have shifted the burden from one to the other
- 30:03depending on how it came out, they were still
- 30:05found to have a common legal interest. And having
- 30:10a legal interest needs to be distinguished from
- 30:12having just simply a commercial or business interest.
- 30:16California courts have rejected applying the
- 30:18common interest doctrine, where disclosure was
- 30:21made to a third party that has simply a commercial
- 30:24benefit in the outcome of a case, but isn't litigating
- 30:27the same or similar legal rights and claims.
- 30:31Other courts may also draw a line between legal
- 30:33interests and things like financial, business,
- 30:36or personal interests. Some jurisdictions permit
- 30:40parties on opposite sides to share common interest
- 30:42against a third party. I think Mike covered that
- 30:45a little bit when you've got cross -complaint
- 30:46issues. But some others will not allow that.
- 30:50Being aware of what the government and jurisdiction
- 30:51says on these types of matters is critical in
- 30:54determining if there is sufficient commonality
- 30:56of interest to prevent the waiver. this could
- 31:02potentially create an issue, communications regarding
- 31:05trust or estate challenge and what communications
- 31:08regarding, whether you have litigation or administration
- 31:12communications, you know, that it blurs the lines.
- 31:14So it's important to be mindful of what counts
- 31:17as a common interest. And just as you're looking
- 31:20at the commonality of interests, you need to
- 31:23consider the role counsel's participation plays
- 31:27into the analysis. As mentioned earlier, a uniform
- 31:30evidence code jurisdiction may require counsel
- 31:33to be involved. In those jurisdictions that don't
- 31:35have that requirement, what level of connection
- 31:40to the legal advice is necessary for it to be
- 31:43covered by the common interest protection against
- 31:46waiver? So if you have a client -to -client discussion
- 31:49talking specifically about the legal advice from
- 31:52a prior communication, You may have a fight over
- 31:56whether or not that is sufficiently within the
- 31:59common interest protection because the attorneys
- 32:02themselves were not there. It's also important
- 32:06to ensure that your clients and the other parties
- 32:09are aware of exactly what information is protected
- 32:11by the common interest agreements so they do
- 32:14not accidentally communicate what they believe
- 32:16to be privileged information in a non -protected
- 32:18way. And so you may think it's completely fine
- 32:22sending all of the privileged information to
- 32:24your children, but the children aren't part of
- 32:26the common interest agreement. Their interests
- 32:28aren't entirely aligned. You may have completely
- 32:31blown to the non -waiver protection by a disclosure
- 32:34to a third party who doesn't fit under the protection
- 32:37umbrella. I will note that in the Second Circuit
- 32:42where counsel needs to be present, there is a
- 32:47case that came out in 2017 about two joint defense
- 32:51litigants who were in the hallway of the court
- 32:54discussing the advice and the strategy of the
- 32:57case, very clearly discussing things that would
- 33:00have been privileged if the attorney was standing
- 33:03next to them and giving them advice on it. But
- 33:06because they had We're talking outside the presence
- 33:10of counsel, and we're not seeking legal advice.
- 33:14The communications were not for the purpose of
- 33:16obtaining legal advice. In the United States
- 33:19versus Krug case, discovery into the testimony
- 33:23regarding those discussions was permitted. And
- 33:28so even when attorneys are involved in the relevant
- 33:31communications, the substance of the communications
- 33:34at issue also matter. You know, you heard earlier,
- 33:37Garen, talk about the mix of business and legal
- 33:42issues happens frequently in trust administration
- 33:45issues and in trust litigation, talking about
- 33:48business issues relating to the administration
- 33:50of the trust often happen in the same communications
- 33:52where you're talking about joint legal strategy
- 33:55in a common interest call. And so it's not nearly
- 33:59sufficient for counsel to be on the email. for
- 34:03the information on that email to be protected
- 34:05under this agreement. The substance of the email
- 34:08itself. must be analyzed to see if it furthers
- 34:10the common interest. Some guidelines I like to
- 34:14keep in mind is ensuring a connection to the
- 34:16purpose of the agreement, being mindful of not
- 34:20straying away from legal topics, making sure
- 34:22you've educated your clients on what that means,
- 34:25and ensuring that the conversation does not stray
- 34:27into topics where interests may directly diverge.
- 34:30So you may have a situation where, yeah, it is
- 34:32absolutely related to the legal issues, but it's
- 34:35you've spread yourself, your scope, into areas
- 34:38where the aligned parties on issue A are adverse
- 34:43to one another on issue B. And so you may end
- 34:46up waiving the privilege on discussions relating
- 34:48to that where they don't have a common interest
- 34:51under the relevant law. It's also important to
- 34:56keep in mind that the substance requirements
- 34:59for what is protected by the attorney -client
- 35:02privilege in the first instance. There are lots
- 35:06of presentations on what is necessary in order
- 35:10to have the attorney -client privilege protection.
- 35:13But a lot of them talk about, sort of like the
- 35:16California Evidence Code 952, that it includes
- 35:19a legal opinion formed and the advice given by
- 35:22the lawyer in the course of that relationship.
- 35:24And so, you have a two -step analysis often in
- 35:28these common interest scenarios. First, is the
- 35:31initial communication actually protected by the
- 35:34attorney -client privilege? And then, is it waived
- 35:37by sharing it with another party who's separately
- 35:40represented in their counsel? So, you have that
- 35:42two -step analysis. And you can see where the
- 35:46problems will pop up all the time, like in a
- 35:48co -trustee situation. They are separately represented,
- 35:51but want to discuss with council the potential
- 35:54litigation raised by a beneficiary. But in the
- 35:58context of that first discussion, you say, yes,
- 36:01we're going to have a common interest. But then
- 36:03you start talking about their own beneficial
- 36:04interests, which may be adverse to one another.
- 36:07They start talking about trust opportunities,
- 36:10business opportunities, so suddenly now we're
- 36:11into administrative discussions, and what if
- 36:14in the context of the discussion in the beginning
- 36:17you were aligned but halfway through your interests
- 36:20or thoughts on how to mitigate certain damages
- 36:22diverge? At what point does the discussions done
- 36:27with one another lose the attorney -client privilege
- 36:30and lose the non -waiver protection of the common
- 36:33interest doctrine? The substance matters and
- 36:37you want to stay on the correct side of the line
- 36:41to rely upon the common interest doctrine to
- 36:43avoid that waiver. So now that we've gone over
- 36:49the background and the rules, let's kind of do
- 36:51a real -world application. You find yourself,
- 36:55you've shared privilege information with an aligned
- 36:56party under a common interest understanding.
- 36:59When does the trouble begin? typically in the
- 37:02discovery process or in response to a subpoena.
- 37:06Going back to our presentation analogy, someone
- 37:08begins shaking your tightrope. Usually starts
- 37:12with discovery requests or subpoenas that seek
- 37:14privileged communications protected by the common
- 37:18interest doctrine. The party opposing disclosure
- 37:20will serve objections preserving the privilege
- 37:23and should provide a privilege log. The law should
- 37:26identify sufficient information to establish
- 37:28the privilege and that it falls within the common
- 37:31interest doctrine. If that's not sufficient,
- 37:34the propounding party will file a motion to compel,
- 37:37then the court will analyze if the withholding
- 37:39party has made a prima facie case that the matter
- 37:41is privileged. Generally speaking, the burden
- 37:44of establishing the common interest doctrine
- 37:46falls on the party who asserts that a certain
- 37:49disclosure is not a waiver under the doctrine.
- 37:53Assuming the privilege log is adequate, the court
- 37:55may be able to rule on the objection just based
- 37:57on the contents of the log. Another thing you
- 38:00can do, a party can also request an in -camera
- 38:02review to avoid any further disclosure until
- 38:05the court rules on the objections. But I think
- 38:08it's important to note that an in -camera inspection
- 38:10is likely unnecessary where the party claiming
- 38:13the privilege has failed to make a prima facie
- 38:17case that the documents in question are privileged.
- 38:22More often than not, waiver issues occur due
- 38:25to some of the following issues. A lack of clarity
- 38:28of what is necessary to create a common interest
- 38:30agreement, questions regarding the commonality
- 38:34of the party's interests, a lack of understanding
- 38:38regarding the scope and protection of the agreement
- 38:42and what role lawyers play in the agreement and
- 38:46preserving the privilege. And oftentimes there's
- 38:50a failure to provide sufficient evidence to meet
- 38:55the level of proof to show that it was information
- 38:58exchanged under a common interest agreement.
- 39:01This can happen on a number of fronts. Failure
- 39:04to establish the privilege status of the communication,
- 39:08failure to meet the proximity to litigation requirement.
- 39:13the nature of the shared information between
- 39:15the parties, if it's not related to the litigation,
- 39:18is it going to be free from disclosure? Or generally
- 39:26the substance of the communication, is it related
- 39:28to legal issues and is it related to legal issues
- 39:32that are relevant to the common interest agreement?
- 39:34I mean, just because it's a legal issue doesn't
- 39:36necessarily mean that it would be free from disclosure
- 39:38under the common interest doctrine. Another thing
- 39:41to consider is the inclusion of outside professionals,
- 39:45like an accountant who is assisting in providing
- 39:47legal advice. When deciding if the common interest
- 39:50doctrine applies, the court will scrutinize the
- 39:54inclusion of an outside professional and whether
- 39:56proper measures were taken under Cobell principles
- 39:59to shield disclosure. And on the issue of disclosure,
- 40:04it's worth touching on a few related concepts.
- 40:08First, the consideration of the timing of the
- 40:10disclosure. If your client is considering a common
- 40:13interest agreement in the future, disclosures
- 40:16of privileged material they make prior to the
- 40:18determination of that common interest may be
- 40:21deemed a waiver of the privilege. If you disclose
- 40:23information after the interests diverge, it can
- 40:25also be a waiver. Timing matters. Secondly, there
- 40:30is a consideration of who the disclosure is made
- 40:32to. Was it made to decline alone or decline of
- 40:35the attorney, as we talked about under a model
- 40:37evidence code jurisdiction that could be material?
- 40:40But even if the inclusion of counsel isn't necessary
- 40:44in your jurisdiction, have you considered the
- 40:46third parties and their relationship to the engagement?
- 40:49And have a solid footing that the third party's
- 40:54presence is necessary to the representation and
- 40:56does not constitute a waiver? Third is the question
- 41:00of who holds the privilege and has the power
- 41:02to control disclosure, including waiver. And
- 41:05as mentioned at the beginning of this presentation,
- 41:07privilege belongs to a client, not to an attorney.
- 41:10And it is not uncommon for disputes to arise
- 41:13between and amongst participants to a common
- 41:15interest agreement later on their relationship.
- 41:19Therefore, it is important to understand as a
- 41:22general rule how these communications function
- 41:24and where the privilege may be asserted and waived.
- 41:27Now participants generally may not assert privilege
- 41:30over communications previously shared with now
- 41:33adversaries while operating under a common interest
- 41:35agreement. But you may still have the ability
- 41:38to protect those disclosures from third parties.
- 41:41But they may also assert privilege over information
- 41:44they did not previously share under the common
- 41:46interest. So the privileged communications that
- 41:48occurred but weren't shared do not need the common
- 41:51interest doctrine protection because they weren't
- 41:53disclosed. You know, I think this leads into
- 41:59the fourth point, and that is the recipient's
- 42:03conduct matters. Is a participant in a common
- 42:06interest arrangement acting inconsistently with
- 42:09the confidentiality requirements? You know, for
- 42:11an example, that the other party that's aligned
- 42:14with your client is a blabbermouth. And you hear
- 42:17rumors that he's talking about common interest
- 42:19things all the time, and you don't do anything
- 42:21about it. You could be in a situation where knowledge
- 42:25of this person's lack of maintaining the confidentiality
- 42:28is going to evisciate the protection that this
- 42:31agreement might provide. The conduct of the participants
- 42:35must be consistent with the desire to maintain
- 42:38the confidentiality of the privileged materials.
- 42:40So, for example, starting a communication in
- 42:43a common interest scenario that says, please
- 42:44share this with the court. Well, that might be
- 42:47an indication that you did not intend the communication
- 42:49that followed to remain confidential. It's something
- 42:52that would have to be analyzed. A fifth point
- 42:56would be this concept of implied waiver. So this
- 43:00happens all the time where a party claiming privilege
- 43:03has placed the privileged communication directly
- 43:06at issue in the matter, haven't disclosed it,
- 43:09but made it an issue in the matter. And the disclosure
- 43:12of that matter is essential or fair adjudication
- 43:15of the action. And under those circumstances,
- 43:18waiver may be found. We could do an entire hour
- 43:21on implied waiver, so we won't spend a lot of
- 43:23time there. But you can see how that would apply
- 43:25in situations where there's an advice of counsel
- 43:28defense, good faith defense, the use of exculpatory
- 43:34clauses that allow you to rely upon advice of
- 43:37counsel. And so when you have the situation where
- 43:41there's an implied waiver and you have already
- 43:45taken confidential information from a co -party,
- 43:49how does your agreement with that co -party impact
- 43:52your ability to even make the defense? Because
- 43:55you can't waive their privileged rights under
- 43:58the agreement. So you'll have a contractual obligation
- 44:01that may interfere with your ability to raise
- 44:04these defenses because of the implied waiver.
- 44:06It's definitely an issue to consider on how you
- 44:09can raise the necessary defenses and anticipate
- 44:15how the court's going to handle the waiver issue,
- 44:18particularly when there's an aligned party who's
- 44:20not raising that defense. Finally, just a word
- 44:24on inadvertent disclosure. It isn't true under
- 44:28most state's laws that if you... reveal a privileged
- 44:32piece of information accidentally that it's automatically
- 44:35a waiver. In most instances, it is not as long
- 44:38as steps were taken to immediately alert the
- 44:41recipient of the error and the request for its
- 44:45return. And so it really comes down to what is
- 44:48the evidence of a party's intent to waive. And
- 44:50so if it was clearly done in an accidental form,
- 44:53then you may be able to establish that you did
- 44:55not intend to waive and that the disclosure was
- 44:58inadvertent. That can be a battle when it is
- 45:03clear that someone meant to disclose a bunch
- 45:05of information. They just accidentally included
- 45:07something they didn't. How do you show that you
- 45:09didn't mean to include that one thing? That could
- 45:11be a very difficult thing to establish. And once
- 45:13the disclosure is out there, you're going to
- 45:15have to show that the waiver is not such that
- 45:19it should be disclosed or used at trial. And
- 45:24so I think One of the reasons why we're all here
- 45:28today is to think about how common interest agreements
- 45:31impact the trust in the state's world. And that
- 45:35sort of leads us to discuss some sort of potential
- 45:38special issues in this field. Yeah, and some
- 45:42of the issues with common interest agreements
- 45:44or rather relying on common interest agreements
- 45:47is the choice of law is always a problem. It's
- 45:51always something that needs to be considered
- 45:53because it could impact the effectiveness of
- 45:55your common interest agreement, and what is disclosed
- 45:59under the common interest agreement can remain
- 46:02confidential. We were recently involved in a
- 46:04matter with an institutional trustee who was
- 46:07in litigation with beneficiaries, and the matter
- 46:09was initially in state court. It was settled,
- 46:12and then the settlement fell apart. A new lawsuit
- 46:14was filed, and then that lawsuit was removed
- 46:17to federal court. Each of those steps the first
- 46:21jurisdiction, the settlement, the breakdown of
- 46:23the settlement, and then the removal to federal
- 46:24court potentially impacts the common interest
- 46:29agreement and what elements need to be met in
- 46:31order to preserve the waiver. Another hot topic
- 46:37is litigation funding, the use of outside funds
- 46:40to help pay for litigation costs in exchange
- 46:42for some interest in the outcome. You see this
- 46:46more and more in the trust in the state's world.
- 46:49And while there's a lot been written on sort
- 46:52of the ethical duties to prevent outside funders
- 46:55from directing the engagement, we're seeing a
- 46:58divergent of thinking on whether the common interest
- 47:00doctrine would protect the disclosure of privilege
- 47:03information to these funders, because they often
- 47:07want to know what your claims are going to be
- 47:10and your basis for your claims. And that frequently
- 47:12can involve things that involve the attorney
- 47:15-client privilege. And so if you're in a state
- 47:17like Delaware or Illinois, courts there have
- 47:21found that voluntarily sharing privilege information
- 47:24with a non -party funder is a waiver. But if
- 47:27you're in states like Pennsylvania and Florida,
- 47:30there are cases that say, no, this information
- 47:33when disclosed to a funder in a confidential
- 47:37manner maintains the privilege. In one state,
- 47:42Nebraska actually codified that the confidentiality
- 47:46of attorney communications shared with litigation
- 47:47funders is protected under their statute. And
- 47:51while the litigation funder question is still
- 47:53in flux in California, there was a state bar
- 47:57opinion in 2020, it's 2020 -204, that discusses
- 48:02the issues of litigation funders. And that opinion
- 48:06stated that the lawyer should take appropriate
- 48:08steps to limit the risks to the client, that
- 48:11the disclosure of privilege information to a
- 48:14litigation funder will affect a waiver of the
- 48:17attorney -client privilege or work product protection.
- 48:19This may include having the funder sign a non
- 48:21-disclosure agreement, appropriately labeling
- 48:24shared materials as confidential, and taking
- 48:26other steps to maintain the confidentiality of
- 48:29the shared materials. And while this state bar
- 48:32opinion wasn't on the issue of whether the common
- 48:34interest privilege applies, that language certainly
- 48:37suggests that protection could be appropriate
- 48:39if the materials were handled in a confidential
- 48:42manner. The role of a fiduciary also has its
- 48:47own issues with respect to the attorney -client
- 48:48privilege and the, you know, the knock on to
- 48:51that is the common interest doctrine. You know,
- 48:53for example, you may have a mix of either communications
- 48:58or calls and meetings that are administrative.
- 49:01Some are related to the administration of a trust,
- 49:03some are related to the litigation. You know,
- 49:05when you have an overlap of that, it creates
- 49:07for potential problems in figuring out what is
- 49:10subject to the waiver and what is not. Sometimes
- 49:15you also have different people assuming different
- 49:17but related roles, one as a trustee and a different
- 49:20person as an administrator. And how does that
- 49:24impact the other party's potential access to
- 49:28privileged communications related to the trust?
- 49:32You could also have a situation where you have
- 49:34a beneficiary serving as fiduciary and the dual
- 49:36role further complicates the analysis regarding
- 49:39what the commonality of interests are and who
- 49:42they have those common interests with. There's
- 49:45also the situation, Mike touched on it earlier,
- 49:48the fiduciary exception jurisdictions where a
- 49:51party to a common interest agreement will need
- 49:53to be concerned that an aligned trustee will
- 49:56be forced to share information with beneficiaries.
- 50:01Situations like this just heighten the tension
- 50:03between the duty to inform beneficiaries and
- 50:06the obligation to maintain the confidences with
- 50:10the other people in the common interest agreement.
- 50:13We also have potential issues with agents and
- 50:16employees. I know fiduciaries often use agents
- 50:19and employees through the administration of a
- 50:23trust and often through litigation as well. And
- 50:26while basic privilege rules often protect these
- 50:28communications, it's important to be mindful
- 50:32of the rules and those different roles and how
- 50:36they can create issues under the common interest
- 50:38doctrine. For example, there are circumstances,
- 50:42there are questions as to whether the communication
- 50:45and information would be waived or not if you
- 50:50have agents who are performing non -legal services
- 50:53or if the agents and employees are not properly
- 50:56educated on the terms and the scope of the common
- 51:00interest agreement, what do they need to do to
- 51:03comply and maintain the protection of the different
- 51:05communications? Then you also have the issue
- 51:08of the agents that that may be continuing to
- 51:11be involved past the term of their agency? And
- 51:14how does that open up those communications to
- 51:18waiver after the fact? And while the large focus
- 51:23of the common interest doctrine is what happens
- 51:27during discovery in active litigation, you need
- 51:31to give some consideration at the outset to post
- 51:34litigation concerns. Was there an agreement on
- 51:37how the confidential information will be used
- 51:40post litigation? What if the interests diverge
- 51:43on appeal or in subsequent litigation? One of
- 51:48the interesting questions that has popped up
- 51:50in cases is, will there be ethical issues? inhibiting
- 51:55your future engagement on behalf of your client
- 51:57because of the confidential information you received
- 52:00from a co -party that is later adverse. And so
- 52:04you may have an ethical problem with proceeding
- 52:08with an engagement in subsequent litigation with
- 52:12a party to the common interest agreement in the
- 52:14first litigation. Something to think about. And
- 52:17obviously in California, we have to think about
- 52:19the successor trustee issue. As Garen was talking
- 52:23about the unique issues with fiduciaries, when
- 52:25the litigation is over, often there's a settlement
- 52:27agreement or a fiduciary will resign, or there'll
- 52:30be an agreement that a neutral will come in and
- 52:35you'll have to give some thought on how to protect
- 52:37the privileged information that was protected
- 52:41by the common interest agreement in that transfer
- 52:43of power. I'll say just a few moment words about
- 52:49ADR, alternative dispute resolution. Mediation,
- 52:55for example, has its own privilege. And so there's
- 52:58a lot of discussion on the interplay between
- 53:00the mediation privilege and the common interest
- 53:02doctrine. You also see this come up in arbitrations.
- 53:07Have the parties explicitly discussed how privilege
- 53:10and common interest issues are gonna be handled
- 53:13under the arbitration rules? Are they gonna be
- 53:15following the specific state rules or is it more
- 53:19ambiguous? How will the arbitration rules impact
- 53:22issues regarding in -camera review, attorney
- 53:25-client communications versus attorney work product?
- 53:28There are a lot of things that can be spelled
- 53:31out in ADR and are often not. And so it may become
- 53:34an issue up to the arbitrator on how they're
- 53:36going to address some of these issues. We're
- 53:41at the point now where we've done a lot of talking
- 53:43about some of the issues that could come up and
- 53:46the things you need to be thinking about. But
- 53:48we want to sort of finish our time today by talking
- 53:50about some best practices to help think about
- 53:55these issues and protect yourself and your client.
- 53:59Yeah, one of my favorite things is to impress
- 54:02upon people is to educate your clients. Make
- 54:05sure they understand. which of their communications
- 54:08will be privileged, which of them are likely
- 54:11to not maintain that privilege, and how including
- 54:15other people on those communications and which
- 54:17people they include would likely violate that
- 54:20privilege. A lot of times you have, even in a
- 54:23common interest situation, the co -parties have
- 54:26some sort of relationship that's independent
- 54:29of the agreement. And so a lot of times you'll
- 54:31have communications that they have that are separate
- 54:35and apart from just what you're trying to do
- 54:38in the litigation setting or whatever the common
- 54:41interest is, and just to inform them that just
- 54:45because we have a common interest agreement with
- 54:47this party doesn't mean that everything you discuss
- 54:50with them will be privileged. Impressing upon
- 54:54them that only the communications related to
- 54:57the specific issues of the common interest agreement
- 55:00could maintain that privilege. Some other things
- 55:04to remind your clients of are, you know, despite
- 55:08that you have despite having that common interest
- 55:10and that we have maybe a free flow of information
- 55:12that the other parties council is not there to
- 55:15represent them and does not represent them. You
- 55:18know, reminding them that the common interest
- 55:20doctrine only works to keep. um existing privileges
- 55:24in place and doesn't apply just you know to everything
- 55:27that could be discussed with those other parties
- 55:29um and you know reminding them that information
- 55:32provided may ultimately at some point be used
- 55:34against them um if there are disputes that arise
- 55:37with the other you know the other parties that
- 55:39have a common interest um you know and you know
- 55:43i think that a lot of times you have people just
- 55:44adding uh adding co -parties or adding related
- 55:48parties to to uh meetings and phone calls and
- 55:51things like that, just because they're brainstorming
- 55:54sessions. Well, those can also come back to haunt
- 55:57your client if they're not careful of who they're
- 56:01including in those calls. And the other one that
- 56:05I always like to point out is if your client
- 56:07is a trustee, what happens if they resign or
- 56:12at some point are removed, worst case, or are
- 56:15joined by a co -party? Which of those, what communications
- 56:19now become opened up to disclosure to that new
- 56:23trustee? Yeah, I sort of jokingly refer to this
- 56:26as sort of the Miranda rights of common interest
- 56:28agreements, where you go in there and sort of
- 56:31impress upon them that this is serious. It is
- 56:34something that we need to understand at the beginning,
- 56:36because once something is disclosed, you can't
- 56:39put it back in the barn. And so taking off these
- 56:43things as sort of the Miranda rights of common
- 56:45interest agreements is one way of looking at
- 56:47it. I'll also note, we talked earlier about the
- 56:50problem of evidence, but you could also tackle
- 56:54the problem of evidence and the problem of reminding
- 56:57your clients in the same way by labeling things,
- 57:00labeling emails, identifying things as confidential,
- 57:05making sure that when you're sharing information
- 57:08that the transmittal email says this is confidential
- 57:11pursuant to common interest agreement. creating
- 57:15a written record of efforts to maintain confidentiality
- 57:18may help you and your client meet the evidentiary
- 57:21burdens. And so, and you know, this is where
- 57:24you have COVEL letters, you may have agency powers
- 57:28of attorney created, you may have other things
- 57:30to document the relationships. And so labeling
- 57:34and writing things down become very important.
- 57:37Yeah, and while labeling is one thing, you can
- 57:40also separate those calls and correspondence.
- 57:44Separate business calls from legal strategy calls.
- 57:50Warn a client maybe when, if you're doing a joint
- 57:52call, when they start veering into some things
- 57:55that may or may not be protected by the common
- 57:57interest agreement, just so there's no inadvertent
- 58:00waiver. This may seem obvious after hearing all
- 58:05of this, but one of our best tips is be prepared,
- 58:08do your homework. If you have multiple jurisdictions,
- 58:11understand the privilege rules and how they vary,
- 58:14understand the common interest rules and how
- 58:16they vary, and also be aware of your jurisdiction's
- 58:18rules regarding the presence of people reasonably
- 58:20necessary for the accomplishment of the purpose
- 58:23for which the lawyer was consulted, language
- 58:25from our evidence code 912, and the use of agents
- 58:28and how that language and protection might vary
- 58:31if you're in multiple jurisdictions. Another
- 58:36thing that seems like it's basic, but it also
- 58:39feels important to repeat is that ensure your
- 58:42client knows who their attorney is. Unlike a
- 58:46joint representation scenario, the other parties
- 58:48in the common interest agreement and their counsel
- 58:51are not the counsel for your client. And I think
- 58:54that's just important to make sure that there
- 58:56isn't an inadvertent disclosure of otherwise
- 59:01privileged information, whether it's so easy
- 59:03to copy somebody on an email without even thinking
- 59:06twice or replying all to an email from your attorney
- 59:10without really thinking about who else is on
- 59:11that chain. And so just clarifying with your
- 59:15client who is actually on the immediate team
- 59:18as opposed to the common interest team. And I
- 59:22think this point is worth repeating both because
- 59:24you should be saying this at the beginning of
- 59:25the engagement, and you should be saying it at
- 59:27every instance where it sounds like the other
- 59:31party's attorney is giving legal advice, is you
- 59:34speaking up and saying, well, I agree with them.
- 59:37I'm your lawyer, but this is what I think, so
- 59:40that they don't begin to be reliant upon the
- 59:44advice of someone who isn't their attorney creating
- 59:45potential issues down the line. And if you're
- 59:50going to have a common interest agreement, having
- 59:53that oral or written understanding early in the
- 59:56process becomes key. You don't want to have several
- 1:00:00conversations with an aligned party and then
- 1:00:01remember, oh, we really should discuss a common
- 1:00:03interest agreement. You want to be able to say
- 1:00:05that you hit on it at the beginning. Another
- 1:00:09thing you can do is try to get a common interest
- 1:00:11agreement memorialized in either a case management
- 1:00:15order or some sort of stipulated protective order
- 1:00:17that would allay any questions and concerns about
- 1:00:21at least the expectation of confidentiality.
- 1:00:25There are different ways to do that, but that's
- 1:00:28one way to do it so that you can make sure that
- 1:00:31at least there's some sort of record that you
- 1:00:34had the expectation and that you memorialized
- 1:00:36it in some way that you can turn around and use
- 1:00:39that as your proof rather than having to actually
- 1:00:42disclose communications. So I'm going to close
- 1:00:46with two examples, one that should worry you
- 1:00:50and one that should make you feel positive about
- 1:00:53this. First is I had a case many years ago that
- 1:00:57involved two brothers versus their stepmother.
- 1:01:00Unfortunately, not an uncommon scenario in my
- 1:01:03practice. But hating their stepmother was really
- 1:01:07the only thing these two brothers had in common.
- 1:01:10They never really got along until this litigation.
- 1:01:12And so they entered into a common interest arrangement
- 1:01:15where they brainstormed and they were all separately
- 1:01:17represented. lo and behold halfway through the
- 1:01:22litigation these brothers who did not get along
- 1:01:24suddenly did not agree on how the litigation
- 1:01:28should be settled or proceed and became adverse
- 1:01:31and that was a situation where a ton of money
- 1:01:35was spent arguing over the common interest agreement
- 1:01:39and attorney -convict privilege in discovery
- 1:01:41battles which only got cut off when the case
- 1:01:44eventually settled but not before the trial started
- 1:01:48so I'm going to end with a final example with
- 1:01:52a happy ending. Let's say you have a trustee
- 1:01:55and a beneficiary who are aligned against a creditor.
- 1:01:58By entering into a common interest agreement
- 1:02:00and jointly preparing a defense, they end up
- 1:02:03saving the beneficiary money. They create a positive
- 1:02:06working environment between the trustee and the
- 1:02:08beneficiary. They're aligned together against
- 1:02:10the bad guy or bad girl. It creates a positive
- 1:02:14working environment that could spread to the
- 1:02:16rest of the administration. The trustee receives
- 1:02:19added protection by having the beneficiary sort
- 1:02:22of sign off on joint legal strategy. It would
- 1:02:26be hard pressed to say it's a breach of duty
- 1:02:28when you've signed off on it. And it can lead
- 1:02:33to judicial efficiency with sort of issue splitting.
- 1:02:35I'm going to file a motion on this issue. You're
- 1:02:36going to file a motion on this issue, instead
- 1:02:38of us both working independently, not knowing
- 1:02:40what we're doing and each filing their own motions.
- 1:02:43It benefits the court, benefits the party, can
- 1:02:45save money. Common interest agreements have real
- 1:02:48application in the trust and the state's field.
- 1:02:52Yeah, so I mean, I'll I'll end our presentation
- 1:02:55just by saying we've seen that common interest
- 1:02:59agreements can work really well when things work
- 1:03:01well and they can be disastrous when it's not
- 1:03:04applied correctly. So the bottom line when you're
- 1:03:07doing this is just to be prepared, like Mike
- 1:03:11said earlier, do your research and be deliberate.
- 1:03:13Don't share information with or other parties
- 1:03:16or enter into common interest agreements just
- 1:03:18because it's convenient. Make sure that you're
- 1:03:22doing it in a situation where it will actually
- 1:03:23assist you in preparing and advising your client
- 1:03:27or preparing some sort of legal strategy. And
- 1:03:31if it involves a fiduciary, multiple jurisdictions,
- 1:03:35or parties who are likely to possibly change
- 1:03:38allegiance or don't really have anything else
- 1:03:40in common, like the brother scenario Mike said.
- 1:03:43Just be mindful of those issues, disclose those
- 1:03:46to your client, and try to avoid any pitfalls
- 1:03:51like that. And with that, I think we'll close.
- 1:03:54Thank you all for your time. And if you have
- 1:03:56any, I don't know that we have time for Q &A,
- 1:03:59but if you have any questions, you can send them
- 1:04:02to our emails and try to respond to them after
- 1:04:04the presentation. Similarly, if you want a citation
- 1:04:07to any of the cases we discussed or the full
- 1:04:09names, you can reach out to us. Thank you so
- 1:04:11much for your attention. All right, this concludes
- 1:04:14today's program. We would like to thank our speakers
- 1:04:16today, Michael Brophy and Garen Kirikosian for
- 1:04:19an excellent presentation. Our next program will
- 1:04:22be Gifts with Purpose, Decoding the Types of
- 1:04:24Testamentary Gifts and their Consequences. This
- 1:04:27program will take place on September 10th with
- 1:04:29Julia Hay and Mark Stern. Thank you all for joining
- 1:04:32us this afternoon.