Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Dana Ginsburg of ComplianceTech Fair Lending Tips & More
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Today I'm here with Dana Ginsberg of Compliance Tech.
- 0:07Dana, how are you doing today?
- 0:09Dana Ginsburg: I'm doing great, Mark.
- 0:10Thanks for
- 0:10having
- 0:11Treichel: me.
- 0:11You got it.
- 0:12I'm excited to have you on.
- 0:14You know a lot about a lot of very hot topics that are going on in
- 0:20the credit union world right now.
- 0:22If you could, if you'd give us a little bit of your background
- 0:25as it relates to your work at Compliance Tech, that would be great.
- 0:29Sure,
- 0:30Dana Ginsburg: um, so I've been with Compliance Tech, um, on and off since
- 0:35about 1998, um, with a little bit of a break, um, for family life and things
- 0:41like that, but really I've been talking all things fare lending, HMDA data,
- 0:46CRA data for quite some time, and I'd say for the last decade I have been
- 0:52working as a point person for all of our Software users, um, as well as
- 0:58our consulting, um, in that space.
- 1:02So I'm a point of contact at the company for both, uh, lenders, um,
- 1:07regulatory agencies, as well as housing groups that use our software.
- 1:13So uniquely positioned because I'm talking to a lot of different industry
- 1:18folks about fair lending, um, every day.
- 1:21Treichel: Well, and it's a topic that.
- 1:23Is it's a hot topic, I guess, you know, for lack of a better word, but the
- 1:28landscape, the current landscape in fair lending and the credit union industry,
- 1:32uh, you know, could you kind of describe what's going on with that and why it's
- 1:36so important for credit unions to, to be aware of what's going on regulatory, the
- 1:42new emphasis, obviously it's always been important, but what, what's your take on
- 1:46the current landscape in fair lending?
- 1:50Um, so I think
- 1:50Dana Ginsburg: what we've seen over the last, you know, 4 or 5 years is
- 1:55probably an increase in the NCUA's Fair Lending Examination Program and
- 2:04the information that they've been putting out to the credit unions.
- 2:08Um, I myself have been working and spoken at quite a few, uh, CUNA, I
- 2:14think they're now the American Uh, America's Community Credit Union.
- 2:18They've changed their name, but the CUNA used to have a fair lending
- 2:21workshop and I've seen over the last couple years more information coming
- 2:27forth more awareness within the credit union landscape about fair lending.
- 2:33Um, I think most recently there was a big story, uh, that caught
- 2:37everybody's attention that was on.
- 2:39CNN with Navy Federal Credit Union, uh, talking about lending disparities,
- 2:45um, in terms of, uh, their applicants.
- 2:48So it's definitely even more on the radar than it has been, uh, but
- 2:53we've seen, you know, the, the NCUA also putting out more information,
- 2:59increasing their level of expectations from the credit unions themselves.
- 3:04Treichel: Yeah, that's for sure.
- 3:05And that, that Navy story in CNNI think it was, uh, has has got a
- 3:09lot of attention in the press.
- 3:11It got a lot of attention at the, uh, uh, with the banking committee.
- 3:15Uh, if I remember right, both the Democrats and the Republicans
- 3:18individually wrote letters saying, Hey, uh, the, the all members are
- 3:24important, but the people who defend our country are extremely important.
- 3:28And can you, uh, there, there's gonna be more coming relative to that
- 3:32because I think they wrote to the CFPB.
- 3:34And one of the other regulators saying, Hey, we'd like to, uh,
- 3:38have you take a close look at this.
- 3:40So, and of course, things trickle down.
- 3:42And you mentioned that there's a lot of, you know, a lot more
- 3:44discussion by NCOA about it.
- 3:46Chairman Todd Harper has, um, has been a very passionate about this from his
- 3:51days when he was on the hill and then when he was the PACA director at NCOA
- 3:56public and congressional affairs.
- 3:57And now he, Okay.
- 3:59Now he's in charge of NCOA as the chair so he can set the tone and he
- 4:03has set the tone by talking about it more, raising the bar relative to that.
- 4:07Uh, and the budget they, you know, every year, they keep increasing the
- 4:11amount of fair lending exams that credit unions, um, will be having.
- 4:15So, uh, the, the likelihood of NCUA coming to do a fair lending exam at
- 4:20any individual credit union has more than doubled over the last couple
- 4:24of years since Todd has come on.
- 4:26Um, and.
- 4:26It's quite possible.
- 4:28It's quite possible that could continue to increase because now he has a second
- 4:31vote in his party who also Tanya Otsuka, who's demonstrated that she is very
- 4:37passionate about this and that I think she's her words were this is going
- 4:40to be a focus of mine while I'm here.
- 4:43So definitely a hot topic.
- 4:46Dana Ginsburg: And I think what's really important, um, is not to cause alarm.
- 4:51Um, I think that the N.
- 4:52C.
- 4:53U.
- 4:53A., um, in their recent supervisory highlights for what they're
- 4:57talking about for 2024, is they are extremely forthright and forthright.
- 5:03And open with their communication and their expectations and what
- 5:07their, their focus is going to be.
- 5:09So whenever there's questions, instead of, you know, having a huge alarm go off of,
- 5:15oh, my gosh, we have to look at everything and and we're, we're overwhelmed for
- 5:19those credit unions that are maybe building their fair lending program.
- 5:23They are directly telling folks exactly what their focus is going to be, and
- 5:29they outline it, um, in, in those recent, uh, supervisory highlights.
- 5:34Dana,
- 5:34Treichel: that's, that's a great point.
- 5:35You know, every year, they, in January, that letter comes out, and
- 5:38they highlight which regulations they are going to be looking at.
- 5:41And of course, fair lending is there this year, but it's, it's a great point that
- 5:45they kind of signal what They are going to be focusing on, uh, so that credit unions
- 5:52can maybe get a running head start, uh, to make sure that, uh, or review their areas.
- 5:56Maybe perhaps is the best way to say it before NCUA comes in.
- 6:00And so in that regard, um, if a credit union is looking at that letter and
- 6:05they say, okay, here's some things, uh, that I know NCUA is doing from where
- 6:10you sit and the things you've seen and the things that compliance tech
- 6:14does, what are some proactive Steps that credit union can take relative to
- 6:20fair lending monitoring, for example.
- 6:23Dana Ginsburg: So it's a really great question.
- 6:24So we know this year they've put out a focus of redlining pricing and marketing.
- 6:32And the biggest thing that I would say to the credit unions is that
- 6:37you've got to know your data.
- 6:39You need to know.
- 6:40The types of the types of loans that you are making and be able
- 6:45to have monitoring in place.
- 6:47So whether that's home mortgage Disclosure Act data, that's always if you are
- 6:51a Honda reporter, that's always the first place that I would go in terms of
- 6:57having an understanding of our lending.
- 7:00You don't want to not have something that gives you analytics.
- 7:05Um, and so that's always the starting point.
- 7:09But the additional point is to be able to review the different types
- 7:14of loan segments that you have and make sure that you have a sufficient
- 7:18monitoring in place, whether that's.
- 7:20For mortgage lending, consumer lending, auto lending, and auto lending has
- 7:27been called out by the NCOA as part of their supervisory highlights.
- 7:32So if you are doing auto lending, if you have relationship with, with dealers and
- 7:39you allow dealer markup, those are all things that you want to take into account.
- 7:45To be proactive in your monitoring.
- 7:49Treichel: That's a great point.
- 7:50And so you mentioned hum to data and you reminding me of a conversation I had
- 7:54with the credit union recently that had gone through a fair lending examination.
- 8:01And so N.
- 8:02C.
- 8:02U.
- 8:02A.
- 8:02As part of.
- 8:05I'm going to get this mostly correct as part of how they determine
- 8:10who they're going to look at.
- 8:11They'll do a random sample and pick some credit unions randomly, but they
- 8:15also look at the HMDA data and they, they, they, for outliers and you know,
- 8:20whether that's statistically, you know, your X number of standard deviations
- 8:24away for this particular category, or this data looks a little bit.
- 8:29Different than other credit unions or is alarming.
- 8:31They will look at the actual data.
- 8:33And in this instance, what triggered that credit union from getting a visit from N.
- 8:37C.
- 8:37way was that they had, um, recorded, uh, incomplete applications were recorded
- 8:45as withdrawals of the application, which was technically not correct.
- 8:50But the number.
- 8:51Um, looked weird when it was categorized as that and that led to NCUA coming for
- 8:57a visit at which, which led to in the end, a visit is not a bad thing because
- 9:04it can lead to you serving your members better, but it led through an intense
- 9:08period, um, where that one action.
- 9:12Uh, had led to a review that then, you know, when they show
- 9:15up, they don't just look at that.
- 9:16They look at everything, uh, as part of the fair landing.
- 9:19So, um, any thoughts relative to that comment before I ask you a couple
- 9:23of follow ups on the auto landing?
- 9:25Well,
- 9:25Dana Ginsburg: that specific topic in terms of the HMDA data being the entry
- 9:31point and sort of the most important thing to have a handle on, um, we
- 9:36have seen that be the focus, right?
- 9:39High withdrawn rates, high.
- 9:41Just, uh, just, you know, denial rates.
- 9:45Um, also when there is missing government monitoring information.
- 9:50Uh, so, you know, the race, the gender, um, things like that, that are missing.
- 9:55So anything that is going to throw your institution into focus, and
- 10:01there are tools out there that can help you see if you are an outlier.
- 10:07And I think NCUA was probably that one of the first agencies in the past 20 some
- 10:13odd years with that focus of outliers.
- 10:16And I remember I wrote about it a long time ago.
- 10:18I think you could probably still find it online, you know, Dana
- 10:21Ginsburg, credit Union Outliers.
- 10:23Um, but that's really sort of sorting through the thou, you know,
- 10:28the couple thousand credit unions who are reporting the HAMDA data.
- 10:33And they sort it in different ways, excuse me, to be able to see are you an outlier
- 10:38and you can know that ahead of time.
- 10:41Um, with HMDA being reporting, you know, HMDA's due in less than a, about a week,
- 10:47a week from Friday is the filing deadline.
- 10:50You want to know what your 2023 HMDA data looks like.
- 10:54You don't want to wait till it's publicly available.
- 10:56So in case you do have coding issues or you have things that are going
- 11:00to call attention, you want to have, you want to know ahead of time so
- 11:04that you're prepared for potential questions that might come forward.
- 11:09Treichel: Makes sense.
- 11:10Makes sense.
- 11:11Now.
- 11:11Pivoting to from, from Hamda to the auto lending, uh, and you
- 11:16mentioned relationships with dealers.
- 11:18Um, that's where things I, when a credit union makes a loans and, and they, they've
- 11:24trained their own people and it's someone down the hall, or it's someone at their
- 11:28own branch, you know, that creates.
- 11:30Um, a different set of challenges as opposed to having a relationship
- 11:36with, you know, name it, 20 dealers who are out there, um, making loans
- 11:42and offering, you know, your credit union, your someone ability to join
- 11:47your credit union as an indirect loan.
- 11:50Uh, any, any thoughts relative to what you're seeing relative
- 11:54to that or how a credit union.
- 11:56Can be proactive in either of those scenarios, the in house
- 12:00or the, the indirect type
- 12:02Dana Ginsburg: of, um, so when it comes to your auto lending and that portfolio
- 12:08or that portfolio of business, you want to make sure you're looking at all of the
- 12:13policies and procedures wrapped around.
- 12:16The auto lending that you're doing, and the biggest risk is going to come from
- 12:21the question, and it's a yes, no question.
- 12:24Do you allow dealer markup?
- 12:26And you immediately eliminate or reduce your fair lending risk significantly.
- 12:33If the answer to that question is We don't, we don't
- 12:37allow discretionary markup.
- 12:39Um, if you have discretionary markup and it is permitted, that's where
- 12:44the analysis needs to happen where you need to look and make sure that
- 12:49there aren't differences in who.
- 12:53And how large those markups are across the prohibited bases.
- 12:58So that's where the monitoring and if you, if you do allow those dealer
- 13:03markups, that's where you need to have a.
- 13:06A program and a plan in place to monitor to make sure that there isn't
- 13:12anything popping to the surface in terms of those dealer relationships.
- 13:17Treichel: Got it.
- 13:18Um, you know, as as you're kind of explaining that I'm thinking about,
- 13:23you know, the risk ultimately, uh, potentially is a class action
- 13:28lawsuit or lawsuits where members are are saying, Hey, I was wronged.
- 13:33Um, are are you seeing, um, in that arena?
- 13:37I'm not sure if this is anything you can speak to.
- 13:39Are you seeing me?
- 13:41More news stories relative to that or more decisions relative to that, where,
- 13:46uh, which could be a highlight of, you know, it's the right thing to do.
- 13:51But oh, by the way, you, it can cost you money if you don't do it right.
- 13:57I think
- 13:58Dana Ginsburg: years ago, there were there were some things that 1st landed
- 14:01this on the radar, like, in the late 90s and things like that early 2000s.
- 14:07Um, recently, we haven't seen too many cases.
- 14:12However, the, the.
- 14:15Scrutiny is there, and we know that all of the agencies are
- 14:20reviewing auto lending data.
- 14:24Um, so it definitely, it just takes, you know, 1 sort of complaint, um, 1 sort of.
- 14:32Decision or, or something like that to cause issues.
- 14:37So it's not again, not to cause alarm.
- 14:39I think that where I'm sitting is I attend all these conferences all of the time.
- 14:44I am not a lawyer by background.
- 14:47I feel like it's very important to make sure that credit unions have the
- 14:51information and we sort of simplify down.
- 14:54Well, what are we being asked to look at?
- 14:57How can we.
- 14:59You know, help with telling you what data points you need to look at and sort of let
- 15:04folks know that this is, you know, this is something that you can take on and it
- 15:10doesn't need to be a huge analytics team.
- 15:13You don't have to have statisticians on staff that it's a very doable.
- 15:18Um, you know, as long as you have a resource, you can find the tools out
- 15:23there to make sure that you are just.
- 15:25Not going to be surprised down the road when somebody else looks at your data.
- 15:31Treichel: Sure.
- 15:31No, that makes sense.
- 15:32Yeah.
- 15:32You want to understand it before someone asks you to see it.
- 15:34That's a.
- 15:36, that's for sure.
- 15:37Mm-Hmm.
- 15:38. So, so pivoting to, you know, another, another topic that I see
- 15:43in the news a a lot recently is, uh, relative to appraisal bias.
- 15:48And there was, I believe there was an F-F-I-E-C guidance that came out
- 15:51recently relative to, uh, appraisal bias.
- 15:54Uh, and then also of course, um, redlining.
- 15:57Sure.
- 15:58Uh, are, you know, what are the key considerations for credit unions
- 16:02relative to appraisal bias and redlining?
- 16:04And then, uh, what.
- 16:07Kind of tools.
- 16:08Does can you at compliance tech provide to credit unions or other institutions?
- 16:14My listeners are credit unions, obviously.
- 16:16But what what kind of tools out there?
- 16:18Do you have that can help the credit unions achieve that?
- 16:23Sure, that's
- 16:24Dana Ginsburg: a big question.
- 16:25A lot of pieces.
- 16:26So let's talk redlining 1st.
- 16:30And I think what's really important from the credit union perspective as that N.
- 16:37C.
- 16:37U.
- 16:37A.
- 16:37made it very clear in there.
- 16:39I think that a webinar February 8th, you can go down, load the slides.
- 16:43They talked about redlining being a focus for joining us today.
- 16:47Community charter credit unions, as well as credit unions that
- 16:51have a multiple common bond.
- 16:53So, if you are a community charter credit union, or you have a multiple common bond,
- 17:00you will need to focus on the red lining.
- 17:03And make sure that you're looking to see, you know, where you are
- 17:09lending in your communities.
- 17:11Who are you lending to and have certain.
- 17:15Analytics in place to be reviewing potential redlining issues.
- 17:20Um, so from that redlining perspective, and I can talk about some of the,
- 17:24the tools, but I think it's really important so that that we kind of
- 17:29narrow down, you know, who, who is being held accountable to serve.
- 17:34their community.
- 17:35So that's kind of one of those, uh, caveats there.
- 17:40Um, so that's important when we're talking credit unions.
- 17:44Um, and when it comes to the appraisal bias issue, there are
- 17:49some things that you can do to make sure you're doing a second review.
- 17:54Now you can't conclusively know from your HMDA data.
- 17:59Exactly, if you have appraisal bias, right?
- 18:03But there are certain, certain little, um, insights that you can gleam, uh,
- 18:10best practices and what we've found.
- 18:12And we, again, we write about it on our blog, um, which is on the
- 18:17compliance tech website, uh, but we give some hints on how you can use it.
- 18:22Look at loans, right?
- 18:261 way is to back into looking at loans that were tagged, denied for collateral
- 18:33and look at those loans that are in majority minority census tracts.
- 18:40So, when you have a loan denied the hundred denial reason for collateral.
- 18:46And you have them in majority minority census tracts.
- 18:50I'm not saying at all that conclusively, there's an appraisal issue going
- 18:54on, but that's 1 way to say to your.
- 18:59And examiner, part of our review is looking at loans denied for collateral
- 19:04and majority minority census tracts and just taking a 2nd, look to make sure that
- 19:10there wasn't something going on there.
- 19:12Now, I learned something learn something, um.
- 19:15Actually, quite interesting that in some companies, and this was a
- 19:20mortgage company that I was talking to that sometimes the loans don't
- 19:25even make it to that close denied status at this particular institution.
- 19:31They were sharing with me that sometimes they are finding that the
- 19:36appraisers may be doing something to maybe dissuade a full appraisal.
- 19:42So sometimes the.
- 19:45Loans are being withdrawn or tagged incomplete in and so 1 way to back into
- 19:53it is in the data and to be able to just say, let's take a sample of loans.
- 19:59You know, if we know straight up denied for collateral in the majority
- 20:03minority census tracks, and maybe we also add to that a sample of.
- 20:10Withdrawn and incomplete.
- 20:12In the majority minority census tracks, perhaps married with the
- 20:17appraisal appraiser name again, I'm not suggesting at all that, you know,
- 20:21conclusively by looking at the data, but it's an extra layer of review
- 20:26because I think lenders are struggling.
- 20:28Wait, there's this huge issue of appraisal bias.
- 20:31We know it's happening.
- 20:33There is a lot of documentation.
- 20:35There are all of these subcommittee hearings on in Washington
- 20:39DC where I'm very close to.
- 20:41So it's one, one kind of tip that I can give to credit unions to add that layer.
- 20:47Just like you want to add a layer of reviewing your complaints and
- 20:51make sure that your complaints are not fair lending related.
- 20:56And that's another layer just to build into your fair lending
- 21:01program and your review.
- 21:04Treichel: Interesting, you know, and as you're walking through that, I, so I
- 21:07moved around, my family and I with NCUA moved around the country a lot and, and
- 21:13when that happened, we'd have to sell the old, you know, you'd buy the new house,
- 21:16it'd get appraised and, and you'd sell the old house and it would get appraised.
- 21:21And, um, you know, once I hit a certain level at NCUA.
- 21:25Uh, NCOA had this program where they might have to buy the house if I couldn't
- 21:30sell it, uh, quick enough, right?
- 21:33And so, in those scenarios, I would, you'd have to get two appraisals and they
- 21:37would be, sometimes they'd be real close and sometimes they would be different.
- 21:41And you'd wonder, I'd look at them, I knew it wasn't redlining, but I would say, hey,
- 21:46why is this one higher and this one lower?
- 21:48And they had a policy that if they didn't If they weren't within
- 21:5210%, the two that you got, you had to go out and get a third one.
- 21:55And it was just always, uh, sometimes it was frustrating.
- 22:00Sometimes it was fascinating just to look at that data and what
- 22:02were the comparables they used.
- 22:05And a lot of judgment, I guess my point is a lot of judgment can go into those.
- 22:11And if you have that layer of reviewing it, different people.
- 22:16Use different, there's the rules and then there's the judgment that they can apply.
- 22:21And, um, you know, just kind of thinking out loud, if, if, if you, if
- 22:26you're reviewing it and you're seeing that loans in a particular area done
- 22:30with, done by a particular appraiser are coming in lower by then loans in
- 22:36that particular area done by another appraiser, there's the whole concept of
- 22:41independence of the appraisers, but, um.
- 22:44And that's their responsibility.
- 22:47Uh, and yours, I guess, but ultimately.
- 22:51You could look at, you know, having in one area using 5 or 6 different appraisers
- 22:57or ultimately the, the, the, the, the pre the pre approved list is something
- 23:05that I would think you're, you're kind of saying that's what you'd want to be
- 23:08looking at and looking at that data to make sure there aren't any anomalies that
- 23:12put you or the members in harm's way.
- 23:15Am I interpreting that right?
- 23:16I think
- 23:16Dana Ginsburg: so, I think it's a, it's within the, the data.
- 23:20So kind of making it something tangible.
- 23:23I'm all about practical.
- 23:25So, instead of having a general, we're going to do a review of appraisal bias.
- 23:31Well, what can you practically start with?
- 23:34And what we've found and my colleagues and I have found is that the data.
- 23:39You know, isolating those applications that are denied.
- 23:45Or collateral in majority minority census tracks is a beginning point because if you
- 23:51have a borrower who is equally or better qualified and a member of a prohibited
- 23:56basis group in a majority minority census track, and they were denied.
- 24:04And you matched up, right?
- 24:06You need to then be able to say, well, why and ask those questions.
- 24:11And so from the data is a good starting point to see if you
- 24:16can isolate that information.
- 24:19And there are tools out there.
- 24:21Compliance tech has tools that help with that type of analysis.
- 24:25So it's.
- 24:26Important to to kind of look from a data data component, because
- 24:33otherwise it becomes so overwhelming for credit unions to build out.
- 24:37What is this monitoring that we're doing?
- 24:39So we try to give practical guidance as to how you even begin to implement it.
- 24:47Um, and the same thing goes for complaints and complete monitoring, right?
- 24:52You can go to the CFPB.
- 24:54They have a complaint database for every single lender in the country,
- 24:59and you can type in the lender name and download the complaints do a quick
- 25:05pivot table and see what the subject of the complaints are and start to see.
- 25:11If you have fair lending related complaints, and again,
- 25:16I'm all about the basics.
- 25:18These things are available online.
- 25:20So if you don't have a sophisticated complaint monitoring system,
- 25:25you can start with something and examiners are always so receptive
- 25:31to folks that are being proactive.
- 25:34They want to partner with you.
- 25:36They want to help you.
- 25:37And so those are the types of things that I share, just because I'm
- 25:40dealing with lenders all of the time.
- 25:43Treichel: Sure, sure.
- 25:44Well, Dana, I think you also, you offer a free ebook at Compliance Tech.
- 25:48Is it on this topic or is it, uh, what does that free ebook, uh, Oh,
- 25:53Dana Ginsburg: so yeah, so we have an ebook for credit unions.
- 25:56It's on our website.
- 25:57Um, and if you type in the search on our website and you type in ebook,
- 26:02um, it's there and it gives fair lending tips across all different
- 26:06subjects, um, beyond the ebook, right?
- 26:09We have a guide on mitigating fair lending risk.
- 26:13Um, there's a lot of resources up there to help you.
- 26:17Begin the process, you know, we can help lenders that have a robust fair lending
- 26:21program and need software analytics.
- 26:23But if you're also just getting started.
- 26:25There's a lot of information on our website as well as well as, you know,
- 26:30ideas about how to get how to get started and those resources that you need
- 26:36Treichel: online.
- 26:38Excellent.
- 26:39That's that.
- 26:39I'm going to, I'm going to download that myself when we get done here.
- 26:44Sounds good.
- 26:45So, um, you know, the, a lot more, a lot more.
- 26:49Emphasis on all of these things in the banking world right now.
- 26:53Um, it's possibly that that, you know, there could be an even
- 26:57further increased emphasis along the lines of what I, um, said, I
- 27:02believe Chairman Harper's goals are.
- 27:03But, you know, moving even further, 1, 2, 3, pick a number of years,
- 27:08the future of fair lending.
- 27:10Uh, where do you see that heading?
- 27:14And based on where you see that heading, how can credit unions kind of stay ahead
- 27:20of of where the regulators may be going?
- 27:25Dana Ginsburg: Um, so I think as the regulators across all types of lenders.
- 27:31gain the tools, whether that's internal or external tools that they use, the
- 27:36technology is going to allow them to review so many more lenders than they ever
- 27:42were able to do, you know, where, when more than they had previously been able.
- 27:47So as the technology and the capabilities increase, right?
- 27:51So to the lenders need to be able to have access to the same types of tools.
- 27:57You can't be doing this Manually right by the time you are a reporter,
- 28:03you need to have tools in place to help you with the analytics.
- 28:08And so I, you know, in my opinion, I feel like the good news is, even
- 28:14though there's more regulatory scrutiny, there are so many.
- 28:17Tools and folks out there that are able to help you do this and that
- 28:24you're and the tools have gotten.
- 28:27So good that right again, you don't need a statistician.
- 28:30You don't need to necessarily have that.
- 28:32You know, you can be trained.
- 28:34There's wonderful fair lending training out there analytics training, um, so that
- 28:40the credit unions can have those tools.
- 28:42So I just think it's so important to be proactive.
- 28:46Don't be afraid.
- 28:47Of the data, there are people like me that help explain the data all of the time.
- 28:53Um, so I think that that's the biggest thing, uh, to make sure your
- 28:57board, your credit union board is on board with helping you get the
- 29:02resources dedicated to fair lending, whether that's, you know, software
- 29:06or consulting or a hybrid approach.
- 29:10Um, I think that that's really important.
- 29:12Um, and some of that just comes from.
- 29:14Also board training, making sure your board is trained on fair lending basics,
- 29:23not to mean that they are not going to be trained in fair lending advanced topics,
- 29:28but really just understanding why it's so important to do the monitoring and provide
- 29:34that training to them so that you get the resources in place for those compliance
- 29:40folks out there that are listening.
- 29:42That's
- 29:43Treichel: great advice.
- 29:44That's great advice.
- 29:44Well, Dana, this has been chock full of a lot of good information for me and
- 29:48hopefully for the listeners in the credit union community, uh, that that may be
- 29:52listening to this, uh, any, any questions that I did not ask you, uh, that I should
- 29:59have asked you or any last advice, uh, for credit unions on all of these topics.
- 30:05Dana Ginsburg: Um, so my parting advice again is to make sure you take use of
- 30:10all of the resources that are online.
- 30:12I do want to point folks to our our website.
- 30:16We have a link to the N.
- 30:18C.
- 30:18U.
- 30:18A.
- 30:18where they have a checklist for their, they have a fair lending manual,
- 30:25let's say, and it has I looked today.
- 30:2738 question.
- 30:30Checklist right of what their examiners are asking.
- 30:34So use that build your own internal risk assessment and use those
- 30:40questions as a, as a launch pad to see how you answer those questions.
- 30:47How the examiner may answer those questions.
- 30:49And that really gives you a road map to where you need.
- 30:53Um, and then if you have questions, uh, find me on LinkedIn, uh, Dana Ginsberg.
- 30:58It's you are G.
- 30:59I.
- 30:59N.
- 30:59S.
- 31:00B.
- 31:00U.
- 31:00R.
- 31:00G.
- 31:01Uh, find me on LinkedIn.
- 31:03I'm posting things all of the time.
- 31:04Fair lending related credit union related.
- 31:07So I try to put a lot of great resources out there.
- 31:10And you can also look, uh, visit the compliance tech dot com website.
- 31:14Treichel: Great, great advice on both those.
- 31:16I saw recently on LinkedIn, you just completed a, a, a marathon.
- 31:20So congratulations on that.
- 31:22And I do follow you on LinkedIn and you do have a lot of great
- 31:25information you put up there.
- 31:27Dana Ginsburg: I appreciate it very much, Mark.
- 31:29for having me and until next time.
- 31:31Treichel: Yes, indeed.
- 31:32Dana, thanks for being on and listeners.
- 31:34I want to thank you for listening.
- 31:36I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 31:37This is Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.