Latest / Bloomberg Law / Trump Trial Day 1 & SCOTUS Homelessness Case
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 1: It's a historic day, the first criminal trial of a
- 0:13Speaker 1: former president of the United States. Donald Trump is accused
- 0:17Speaker 1: of trying to corrupt the twenty sixteen presidential election by
- 0:22Speaker 1: falsifying business records to cover up a hush money payment.
- 0:26Speaker 1: In opening statements, prosecutor Michael Colangelo called it election fraud,
- 0:31Speaker 1: pure and simple. Quote. This was a planned, long running
- 0:35Speaker 1: conspiracy to influence the twenty sixteen election, to help Donald
- 0:39Speaker 1: Trump get elected through illegal expenditures to silence people who
- 0:44Speaker 1: had something bad to say about his behavior. But outside
- 0:48Speaker 1: the courthouse, Trump said it was a case about a
- 0:50Speaker 1: payment to a lawyer that was listed as a legal expense.
- 0:55Speaker 2: What else would you call it?
- 0:56Speaker 3: Actually, nobody's been able to say. What are you supposed
- 0:59Speaker 3: to call it?
- 1:00Speaker 4: Lawyer puts it a bill or an invoice, and you
- 1:04Speaker 4: pay the bill.
- 1:05Speaker 1: And in the book it's a little line.
- 1:07Speaker 3: That's a very.
- 1:08Speaker 4: Small little line.
- 1:09Speaker 1: I don't know if you didn't even write more than
- 1:10Speaker 1: two words. It sounds like you could tell a life story.
- 1:14Speaker 1: They marked it down to a legal expense. This is
- 1:16Speaker 1: what I got in Dintedough in the defense opening statements.
- 1:20Speaker 1: Trump's lawyer Todd Blanche said the former president did not
- 1:23Speaker 1: commit any crimes and is a victim of overreaching by
- 1:27Speaker 1: prosecutors who put their faith in poorn Star Stormy Daniels
- 1:32Speaker 1: and attorney Michael Cohen. He said Cohen was disbarred, a
- 1:36Speaker 1: convicted felon and a convicted perjurer who could not be believed.
- 1:41Speaker 1: Joining me from the courthouse in Lower Manhattan is Patricia Hurt.
- 1:44Speaker 1: Todd Oblomberg legal reporter Patty. Alvin Bragg has been the
- 1:49Speaker 1: subject of many a complaint from Trump. He didn't give
- 1:52Speaker 1: the opening statement, but was he in the courtroom?
- 1:55Speaker 3: Alvin Bragg, the Manhattanda is sitting in the front row
- 1:58Speaker 3: right behind his trial key, and he listened intently as
- 2:02Speaker 3: it was a prosecutor named Matthew Colangelo. They used to
- 2:05Speaker 3: work at the Justice Department and also worked for the
- 2:08Speaker 3: New York Attorney General when they brought civil suits against
- 2:12Speaker 3: the Trump Corporation back in the Trump University days. He
- 2:16Speaker 3: was part of that case and he's now the prosecutor
- 2:20Speaker 3: that gave the opening statement.
- 2:22Speaker 1: Give us the highlights of Colangelo's opening statement and whether
- 2:27Speaker 1: it was dramatic or subdued or somewhere in between.
- 2:31Speaker 3: Well, it was pretty dramatic because the jurors are hearing
- 2:34Speaker 3: for the first time and we've heard about this toush
- 2:37Speaker 3: money case. But what he was saying was that there
- 2:39Speaker 3: was an agreement, a secret agreement between Donald Trump a
- 2:43Speaker 3: David Pecker, who was a publisher and CEO and chairman
- 2:47Speaker 3: of the National Inquirer's owner company called the American Media Incorporated,
- 2:53Speaker 3: so that the two of them met with Michael Cohen
- 2:57Speaker 3: in a secret agreement to make sure that they would
- 3:00Speaker 3: kill and catch very any solationous news against Donald Trump
- 3:04Speaker 3: to help his campaign chances, and also attack and published
- 3:09Speaker 3: negative stories about his adversaries of his opponents for election,
- 3:12Speaker 3: including Ben Carson and Ted Cruz. And they were promoting
- 3:16Speaker 3: negative stories about Ted Cruiz, for example, claiming that his
- 3:20Speaker 3: father was involved in the assassinations of JFA. So there
- 3:23Speaker 3: was a story about a Trump dorman who claimed that
- 3:26Speaker 3: Trump had had a love child, and they bought his
- 3:29Speaker 3: silence off so that he would never tell his story.
- 3:32Speaker 3: And then in twenty sixteen, in October twenty sixteen, and
- 3:35Speaker 3: months before the election, the Access Hollywood tape comes out
- 3:39Speaker 3: in which Trump is caught on a hot mic discussing
- 3:42Speaker 3: his conquest of women, and that tape had a quote
- 3:46Speaker 3: unquote immediate and explosive impact on the campaign. They knew
- 3:50Speaker 3: it was damaging, not only because Trump bragged about sexual assault,
- 3:54Speaker 3: but it was in his own words and in his
- 3:56Speaker 3: own voice. Colangelo said, So, then what happened is they
- 4:00Speaker 3: decided to buy off any other salacious news and National
- 4:04Speaker 3: Enquirer knew about this other woman named Stormy Daniels, an
- 4:08Speaker 3: adult film actress who said she'd had a sexual encounter
- 4:12Speaker 3: with Trump in two thousand and six, so they reacted
- 4:15Speaker 3: very quickly to pay her off. The DA says they
- 4:18Speaker 3: have emails and text messages as well as a recording
- 4:23Speaker 3: of Trump discussing this payoff to Stormy Daniels with Michael Cohen,
- 4:29Speaker 3: and that Michael Cohen decided to record it. So they
- 4:32Speaker 3: have Trump in his own words on this recording, which
- 4:34Speaker 3: can support and corroborate Michael Cohen's account.
- 4:37Speaker 1: Did we know that before?
- 4:39Speaker 3: We knew that there was a recording, but we didn't
- 4:42Speaker 3: know this level of detail of all these emails and
- 4:45Speaker 3: text messages going back and forth between the parties. And
- 4:48Speaker 3: Colangelo said that Trump was basically was reluctant to reimburse Pecker,
- 4:54Speaker 3: and Pecker was concerned about not getting his money back,
- 4:57Speaker 3: and he paid Stormy off. So Michael Cohen took it
- 5:00Speaker 3: upon himself to take a home equity line of credit
- 5:03Speaker 3: and walked over the money and wrote his own personal
- 5:07Speaker 3: check paying off Sturmy Daniels hundred thirty thousand. That's in
- 5:10Speaker 3: twenty sixteen, right before Trump gets elected. And then Trump
- 5:14Speaker 3: went to the election and then has caught on tape
- 5:16Speaker 3: discussion again does he have to really pay now that
- 5:18Speaker 3: he's won. So then Michael Cohen later gets reimbursed by Trump.
- 5:23Speaker 3: Then false records are created to paper over these hush
- 5:28Speaker 3: money payments, calling them legal fuel.
- 5:30Speaker 1: Prosecutors often, very often have to present witnesses that are
- 5:36Speaker 1: tarnished in different ways. How did the prosecution handle the
- 5:40Speaker 1: fact that their star witness, Michael Cohen, is a convicted felon.
- 5:45Speaker 3: Well, that's what they were saying. They were pointing out that, yeah,
- 5:48Speaker 3: we have this guy, Michael Cohen. Yes he's a convicted
- 5:51Speaker 3: perger er. Yes he pled guilty to felonies federal felonies
- 5:55Speaker 3: of campaign finance, but he did it at Trump's behalf,
- 5:59Speaker 3: and he was saying that you know, none of these
- 6:02Speaker 3: these witnesses are pure, but he also said that they
- 6:06Speaker 3: have a trove of evidence supporting papers and texts, documentation,
- 6:12Speaker 3: bank records, you name it that support what Michael Cohen says.
- 6:17Speaker 3: Where the parties who are part of this discussion and
- 6:19Speaker 3: part of this It's not a scheme because of course
- 6:22Speaker 3: Donald Trump's not charged with any conspiracy, but this agreement
- 6:26Speaker 3: that there was evidence, a trove of evidence that would
- 6:28Speaker 3: support what Michael Cohen and what Stormy Daniels say, did it.
- 6:32Speaker 1: Come across that this was more than just you know
- 6:35Speaker 1: what the defense is going to say, accounting that this
- 6:38Speaker 1: was a conspiracy, an election interference.
- 6:42Speaker 3: The prosecution calls it election interference, but the princi layter
- 6:45Speaker 3: Todd Blanche says there's no crime here. Entering into non
- 6:48Speaker 3: disclosure agreement is not against the law, and he says
- 6:53Speaker 3: that Stormy Daniel's testimony will be quote unquote salacious, It
- 6:56Speaker 3: does not matter. He's tony jury. You can't base your
- 6:59Speaker 3: verse on a man who's so unreliable, claiming that Michael Cohen,
- 7:04Speaker 3: who has quote unquote obsessed with Donald Trump and has
- 7:06Speaker 3: made it his vendetta and his career, and he's pinned
- 7:10Speaker 3: his financial future on making sure Donald Trump gets convicted
- 7:14Speaker 3: and also going after and harassing Donald Trump. So he's saying,
- 7:19Speaker 3: you can't trust a guy like that.
- 7:21Speaker 1: Was Michael Cohen the focus of the defense, that he's
- 7:24Speaker 1: just unbelievable.
- 7:26Speaker 3: Well, the same thing with Stormy, She's not credible that
- 7:29Speaker 3: neither of these two people. Basically, Stormy was depicted as
- 7:33Speaker 3: that she tried to quote unquote extort money from Donald Trump,
- 7:38Speaker 3: and that she was trying to embarrass him and hurt
- 7:40Speaker 3: his brand, and that there's nothing wrong with what Trump did,
- 7:44Speaker 3: and that he claimed that is organizations and publications by
- 7:49Speaker 3: stories all the time, and then folded into that. David Pecker,
- 7:53Speaker 3: the man who is part of this Trump Tower meeting
- 7:56Speaker 3: in twenty fifteen and they'd launched this ketch and kill scheme,
- 8:00Speaker 3: gets on the stand and he said that part of
- 8:02Speaker 3: their business model was what he called quote unquote checkbook journalism.
- 8:07Speaker 1: And I suspect we're going to hear a lot more
- 8:09Speaker 1: of that when he retakes the witness stand tomorrow. As
- 8:13Speaker 1: far as the defense opening, how convincing was it on
- 8:17Speaker 1: the subject of this is much ado about nothing? At
- 8:21Speaker 1: one point Bland said it's just thirty four pieces of paper.
- 8:25Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean it was effective at some point, you know,
- 8:28Speaker 3: like I said, he called kid that Jeremy Daniels was
- 8:31Speaker 3: trying to quote unquote almost extort end quote money from Trump,
- 8:37Speaker 3: and the prosecutor wept up and said objection, and the
- 8:40Speaker 3: judge struck it from the record. He was trying to
- 8:43Speaker 3: basically hint to the jury and telegraph to them, look,
- 8:46Speaker 3: these people are not credible, and why would you believe
- 8:49Speaker 3: their word? And he actually also said, spoiler alert, spoiler alert,
- 8:55Speaker 3: there's nothing wrong with trying to influence an election. And
- 8:59Speaker 3: I don't know how the jury's going to feel about that.
- 9:01Speaker 3: I mean, we'll have to see if a Manhattan jury
- 9:03Speaker 3: is going to agree with the defense lawyer that there's
- 9:06Speaker 3: nothing wrong with trying to do what Donald Trump did
- 9:08Speaker 3: that all fear and love and war, including death.
- 9:11Speaker 1: That may be a bridge too far.
- 9:13Speaker 3: I know that's a very bold statement to make, you know,
- 9:17Speaker 3: it depends on how the jury is going to react
- 9:19Speaker 3: to that and how they'll feel.
- 9:20Speaker 1: Did the prosecution object to.
- 9:22Speaker 3: That, Yes they did. There were lots of times they
- 9:25Speaker 3: leapt up and objected. I actually lost track after.
- 9:28Speaker 1: Three the first witness, David Pecker, took the stand for
- 9:33Speaker 1: a brief time. What can you tell us about him?
- 9:36Speaker 3: He actually walked into the curtain with a big smile
- 9:39Speaker 3: on a space and at first Trump was nadally scribbling
- 9:43Speaker 3: something on a piece of paper, and then later on
- 9:46Speaker 3: Trump basically twisted his entire body to turn and look
- 9:50Speaker 3: at Pecker and watch him intently as he testified. He
- 9:53Speaker 3: was on a very very brief time. I was saying
- 9:56Speaker 3: maximum twenty two minutes. Most of it was talking about
- 10:00Speaker 3: his biographical his background, and it was interesting to me
- 10:04Speaker 3: to hear. He said that where did their offices? Where
- 10:06Speaker 3: were their offices in New York? And he said down
- 10:09Speaker 3: by Pech Street, which is down like a few blocks
- 10:12Speaker 3: from here. So if you think about it, we're in
- 10:14Speaker 3: a courtroom in a courthouse in Lower Manhattan, and then
- 10:18Speaker 3: maybe just about a half mile away on Tech Street,
- 10:21Speaker 3: the National Inquirer and American Media and have their offices too.
- 10:27Speaker 1: And he's gotten immunity from prosecution, right, and he's the
- 10:31Speaker 1: first witness because he's going to set up the whole scheme.
- 10:34Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, he seems like he's a good, composite witness.
- 10:37Speaker 3: And he testified before the grand jury. When you do that,
- 10:40Speaker 3: you get immunity. So he's testifying with a grant of immunity,
- 10:45Speaker 3: and he can lay out the scheme in a way
- 10:47Speaker 3: that maybe somebody that was allegedly tainted the way Satan
- 10:51Speaker 3: may view Michael Cohen as being painted and conflicted because
- 10:54Speaker 3: of his background and his convictions might be see. So
- 10:58Speaker 3: Pecker doesn't have that kind of a pat.
- 11:01Speaker 1: This morning, Judge Murshawn ruled on what evidence prosecutors will
- 11:06Speaker 1: be able to use in their cross examination of Donald
- 11:10Speaker 1: Trump should he take the witness stand.
- 11:13Speaker 3: Also an interesting ruling that the judge Mersehawan said that
- 11:17Speaker 3: the prosecutors that if Trump takes the stand, He made
- 11:21Speaker 3: a series of rulings that said there were certain things
- 11:24Speaker 3: that possecutors could question or cross examined Trump about, including
- 11:29Speaker 3: the two Egen Carrol verdicts of finding that he defamed
- 11:34Speaker 3: her as well as and she's the New York writer
- 11:37Speaker 3: that said he sexually assaulted her and then defamed her
- 11:41Speaker 3: when he called her a liar, and then also can
- 11:45Speaker 3: talk about the prosecutors are free to question Trump about
- 11:48Speaker 3: how he was found to a violate a judge in
- 11:52Speaker 3: Goron gag order in the New York Attorney General trial,
- 11:56Speaker 3: and the judge also ruled that Trump could be questioned
- 11:59Speaker 3: about the verdicts the New York Attorney Generals of you know,
- 12:03Speaker 3: winning verdict of whether it four hundred and eighty five
- 12:06Speaker 3: million dollars he has to disgorge for unlawfully or illegally
- 12:11Speaker 3: inflating his assets in a civil faud sit.
- 12:14Speaker 1: That I was surprised that the that the order was
- 12:17Speaker 1: so broad, that the judge was allowing the prosecution so
- 12:21Speaker 1: much leeway.
- 12:22Speaker 3: Ah. Yes, but you know they aren't actually wanted more
- 12:26Speaker 3: including you know, there's apparently a case involving Hillary Clinton
- 12:30Speaker 3: from Florida where the judge ripped into Donald Trump for
- 12:34Speaker 3: calling it like a serial litigant, and the judge said
- 12:37Speaker 3: he just thought it was too far afield.
- 12:39Speaker 1: That might effect whether Trump testifies or not, because you
- 12:43Speaker 1: can just imagine the.
- 12:44Speaker 3: Cross you know, the key things like, you know, credibility, reliability,
- 12:50Speaker 3: how do you do your conductor business? Oh wait, a
- 12:54Speaker 3: state Supreme Court justice determined that you committed civil frauds.
- 12:58Speaker 3: It's a two juries found that use the same Ejing Carroll.
- 13:02Speaker 3: Oh wait, the state judge found it you violated his
- 13:05Speaker 3: gag order. And then when you claim that you weren't
- 13:07Speaker 3: talking about his law clerk, he found you, quote unquote
- 13:10Speaker 3: not credible. So those are the kinds of things that
- 13:12Speaker 3: have a lot to say about Donald Trump's credibility.
- 13:16Speaker 1: All right, Now, tomorrow morning, the judge is going to
- 13:19Speaker 1: hear the prosecution's motion that it made before opening statements
- 13:24Speaker 1: during jury selection.
- 13:26Speaker 3: When the trial started on Monday, with jury selection last
- 13:29Speaker 3: Monday on the fifteenth. The days leading up to jury
- 13:32Speaker 3: selection on the fifteen, Trump had gone and tweeted and
- 13:36Speaker 3: posted on social media and truth social a lot of
- 13:39Speaker 3: comments slamming Michael Cohen and slamming Stronmy Daniel and saying
- 13:45Speaker 3: all kinds of critical things. And the prosecutors said that
- 13:48Speaker 3: those statements were a violation of the gag order, including
- 13:52Speaker 3: a third statement that they said had been made that
- 13:55Speaker 3: warning the jury selection started, and they were surmising that
- 13:59Speaker 3: they the Trump may have sent it when he was
- 14:01Speaker 3: in the courthouse already. After he does that, he issues
- 14:05Speaker 3: more statements. So now they have I think a compendium
- 14:07Speaker 3: of at least ten statements they say are a violation
- 14:11Speaker 3: of the judges prior gag order, And the most recent
- 14:14Speaker 3: one was an extended gag order on April first, not
- 14:18Speaker 3: to make critical comments of the witnesses because it could
- 14:22Speaker 3: be viewed as intimidation, because Trump's followers could be you know,
- 14:25Speaker 3: it could be sticking them on to attack them or
- 14:30Speaker 3: make comments or make their lives miserable. So if the
- 14:33Speaker 3: judge is going to have a hearing to determine if
- 14:35Speaker 3: Trump has contemptuously violated the gag and they're asking that
- 14:40Speaker 3: he get one thousand dollars fine for each of the
- 14:43Speaker 3: three violations and a warning that he doesn't obey, he
- 14:47Speaker 3: could face jail.
- 14:48Speaker 1: I can't imagine how high the threshold would be to
- 14:51Speaker 1: put him in jail, though, Thanks so much, Pat, We'll
- 14:53Speaker 1: check back with you after court tomorrow. That's Bloomberg Legal
- 14:57Speaker 1: reporter Patricia Hurtado. Blessness has reached record levels in this country,
- 15:03Speaker 1: with more than six hundred thousand people experiencing homelessness on
- 15:07Speaker 1: any given night, and today, for the first time in
- 15:10Speaker 1: forty years, the Supreme Court took up the topic, considering
- 15:14Speaker 1: what measures cities can take to deal with the rising homelessness.
- 15:18Speaker 1: Here's Liberal Justice Sonya, So to mayor.
- 15:21Speaker 4: Where do we put them? If every city, every village,
- 15:25Speaker 4: every town, lacks compassion, and he passes a law identical
- 15:31Speaker 4: to this. Where are they supposed to sleep? Are they
- 15:35Speaker 4: supposed to kill themselves?
- 15:36Speaker 5: Not?
- 15:36Speaker 1: Sleeping grants pass. A rural Oregon community of forty thousand
- 15:41Speaker 1: has an ordinance finding people for sleeping in public places
- 15:45Speaker 1: using blankets or other bedding, and the Ninth Circuit rule
- 15:49Speaker 1: that law violates the Eighth Amendments prohibition against cruel and
- 15:53Speaker 1: unjust punishment. But during the oral arguments today, many of
- 15:57Speaker 1: the conservative justices suggest that judges should not be the
- 16:02Speaker 1: ones to design policy. Here are Chief Justice John Roberts
- 16:07Speaker 1: and Justice Neil Gorsuch.
- 16:09Speaker 5: And it's a policy problem because the solution, of course
- 16:12Speaker 5: is to build shelter, to provide shelter for those who
- 16:16Speaker 5: are otherwise harmless. But municipalities have competing priorities. I mean,
- 16:21Speaker 5: what if there are lead pipes in the water, do
- 16:24Speaker 5: you build the homeless shelter or do you take care
- 16:26Speaker 5: of the lead pipes? What is there aren't isn't enough
- 16:28Speaker 5: fire protection? Which one do you prioritize? Why would you
- 16:32Speaker 5: think that these nine people are the best people to
- 16:35Speaker 5: judge and way those policy judgments? And six judges across
- 16:40Speaker 5: the country are now going to superintend this under the
- 16:42Speaker 5: Eighth Amendment.
- 16:43Speaker 1: Joining me is an expert in constitutional law. Harold Krant,
- 16:46Speaker 1: a professor at the Chicago Kent College of Law, tell
- 16:50Speaker 1: us about the facts here.
- 16:51Speaker 2: How so the grants passed word unlike other towns try
- 16:58Speaker 2: to combat the home business problem in various ways, and
- 17:01Speaker 2: homeless necessaris we know is unhealthy and breed crime. So
- 17:05Speaker 2: it's not good for people who are homeless. It's not
- 17:07Speaker 2: good for the city either. But the way they've done
- 17:09Speaker 2: it is to potentially criminalize the act of sleeping with
- 17:14Speaker 2: a blanket in a public space. And homeless advocates sued
- 17:19Speaker 2: challenging the ordinance as inconsistent with the Eighth Amendment ban
- 17:23Speaker 2: on cruel and unusual punishment, and they look to a
- 17:27Speaker 2: decision of over sixty years ago called Robinson, in which
- 17:31Speaker 2: the Supreme Court held that the Eighth Amendment is indeed
- 17:34Speaker 2: violated or punishing what is known as a particular status.
- 17:39Speaker 2: So in that case it was the status of somebody
- 17:42Speaker 2: who was a drug addict. And the court reasons that
- 17:45Speaker 2: you can punish someone for taking drugs even if they
- 17:50Speaker 2: have a compulsion, even if they're addicted, but you can't
- 17:53Speaker 2: punish someone merely for having the status of being a
- 17:56Speaker 2: drug addict. And as applied to this case, mosteople think,
- 18:00Speaker 2: including the court below, that a criminal penalty for the
- 18:05Speaker 2: status of being homeless is clear violation of that Supreme
- 18:09Speaker 2: Court principle from years ago. And listening to the court
- 18:15Speaker 2: there was a variety of opinions that were expressed, But
- 18:20Speaker 2: I think that the Court is going to try to
- 18:23Speaker 2: dissolve the injunction on any number of theories, but not
- 18:28Speaker 2: say that it's okay to punish someone on basis being
- 18:31Speaker 2: homeless itself. There was some sympathy amongst the conservative justices
- 18:35Speaker 2: and clearly amongst the liberal justices for the plight of
- 18:39Speaker 2: the homeless, and that criminalizing the status is no way
- 18:43Speaker 2: to solve a problem. But that leaves a number of options.
- 18:47Speaker 1: So start with the question of the necessity defense. At
- 18:50Speaker 1: one point, just as the LANDA. Kaigan just said outright,
- 18:53Speaker 1: tell me about the necessity defense.
- 18:56Speaker 2: For one thing, it was interesting the focus in the argument,
- 18:59Speaker 2: which was to an end of hours on the necessity defense.
- 19:03Speaker 2: The necessity defense is a sort of a built into
- 19:06Speaker 2: most state codes of criminal law, including that Oregon, which
- 19:11Speaker 2: says that if you have a if it's a necessity
- 19:14Speaker 2: to do something like tying up a ship to some
- 19:17Speaker 2: private property in a storm, that one can do that
- 19:21Speaker 2: and not be convicted of a criminal offense. Why because
- 19:24Speaker 2: your preservation outweighs the importance of the property value. And
- 19:29Speaker 2: so the court was experimenting with the idea. One way
- 19:34Speaker 2: out is saying that organs a necessity defense would be
- 19:38Speaker 2: an individual ticket to escape any kind of criminal sanctions
- 19:43Speaker 2: if someone could prove that they had nowhere to sleep
- 19:45Speaker 2: and there wasn't a bed available in a nearby shelter,
- 19:50Speaker 2: So that was one way out. The Justice Department gave
- 19:54Speaker 2: another way out and stead that the class action and
- 19:57Speaker 2: the injunction was inappropriate because individual situation of all of
- 20:02Speaker 2: the plaintiffs had yet to be fleshed out. In other words,
- 20:06Speaker 2: according to the Justice Department, individuals would have to show
- 20:10Speaker 2: that they had nowhere to go before they could get relief,
- 20:14Speaker 2: and the court below didn't do that. They just granted
- 20:18Speaker 2: an injunction based upon the pleadings at the pleting stage
- 20:22Speaker 2: in a class action. To complicate the matter, one of
- 20:26Speaker 2: the three plaintiffs who had a criminal charge against her
- 20:28Speaker 2: had died tragically before this case went to the Supreme Court,
- 20:33Speaker 2: and so there may not be enough, according to the
- 20:35Speaker 2: Justice Department, enough of a live injury about the criminal
- 20:39Speaker 2: sanction to go before the court. So that was a
- 20:42Speaker 2: second way out. A third way out that the court
- 20:45Speaker 2: discussed was there's a new orgone law that has yet
- 20:49Speaker 2: to be administered or put into practice, which seems to
- 20:54Speaker 2: ban any kind of interdiction on what seems to prevent
- 21:01Speaker 2: criminalizing homelessness. And so if this law and effect is
- 21:05Speaker 2: an effect, why should the court bother to decide this
- 21:09Speaker 2: case or to allow the injunction blow to stand. So
- 21:13Speaker 2: it's difficult to know exactly where the Court's going, but
- 21:17Speaker 2: they seem to think, the conservative justices, that there's something
- 21:21Speaker 2: wrong with having courts administer these very complicated line drawing
- 21:26Speaker 2: policy of when sleeping outside is permitted and when it's
- 21:32Speaker 2: not permitted under the Constitution. And so I think they
- 21:35Speaker 2: leaned towards a way to getting.
- 21:37Speaker 1: Rid of the case, and several justices seem to suggest
- 21:41Speaker 1: that it was very difficult to draw those kinds of lines.
- 21:45Speaker 1: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Lawshell, I'll continue this
- 21:48Speaker 1: conversation with Professor Harold Krant to the Chicago Kent College
- 21:51Speaker 1: of law. Was there one thing that all the justices
- 21:55Speaker 1: seem to agree on. I'm June Grosso and you're listening
- 21:59Speaker 1: to Bloomberg. Today the Supreme Court wrestled with major questions
- 22:04Speaker 1: about the growing issue of homelessness as it considered whether
- 22:08Speaker 1: cities can punish people for sleeping outside when there's a
- 22:12Speaker 1: lack of shelter space in the community. It's the most
- 22:14Speaker 1: significant case before the High Court in decades on the issue.
- 22:19Speaker 1: I've been talking to Professor Harold Krant of the Chicago
- 22:21Speaker 1: Kent College of Law. It seemed like the questions of
- 22:25Speaker 1: most of the conservative justices indicated that they thought this
- 22:30Speaker 1: was not a problem for the courts to decide. And
- 22:33Speaker 1: the Chief said at one point, why do you think
- 22:36Speaker 1: these nine people are the best to judge this? So,
- 22:39Speaker 1: I mean that seemed very clear that they didn't think
- 22:41Speaker 1: that the court should be deciding policy.
- 22:44Speaker 3: No.
- 22:44Speaker 2: I agree that that concern was very expressedly clearly by
- 22:49Speaker 2: some members of the court. And the other related issue
- 22:52Speaker 2: to that is the injunction below creates a kind of
- 22:55Speaker 2: nightmare for the police because the police don't know whether
- 22:59Speaker 2: some a one is in an encampment. Who have they
- 23:03Speaker 2: checked to see whether there is an opening in a shelter.
- 23:06Speaker 2: Have they not checked is there an opening in the shelter?
- 23:08Speaker 2: Are they not going to the shelter because of mental illness?
- 23:11Speaker 2: Are they not going to the shelter because they fear
- 23:13Speaker 2: for their safety? And these kind of line drawing issues
- 23:17Speaker 2: that law enforcement officers face are very troubling and very difficult,
- 23:22Speaker 2: and so there is certainly, you know, empathy for that
- 23:25Speaker 2: difficulty which was triggered by the injunction. Nonetheless, I think
- 23:31Speaker 2: the Court will not disturb the precedent from sixty years
- 23:35Speaker 2: ago that says that their Eighth Amendment is violated by
- 23:39Speaker 2: he punishes status. So I think the Court will released
- 23:43Speaker 2: at least my prediction is in dicta suggests that punishing
- 23:48Speaker 2: homelessness is wrong, but it's also wrong to have this
- 23:51Speaker 2: injunction based upon the Eighth Amendment.
- 23:54Speaker 1: So, as you mentioned, there was a lot of because
- 23:56Speaker 1: of that Supreme Court decision, there was a lot of
- 23:59Speaker 1: talk about the difference between status and conduct, and there
- 24:03Speaker 1: was all kinds of things about the difference between being
- 24:07Speaker 1: a drug addict and being homeless. The Chief Justice said,
- 24:11Speaker 1: a number of US, I think are having difficulty with
- 24:13Speaker 1: the distinction between status and conduct. Where do you think
- 24:18Speaker 1: most of them came down on that.
- 24:21Speaker 2: I think most of the court recognized that the distinction
- 24:25Speaker 2: between status and conduct gets tricky. So give an easy
- 24:29Speaker 2: example from the oral argument. Yes, you may if you
- 24:31Speaker 2: have a right to sleep outside because you're homeless, that's
- 24:34Speaker 2: one thing. But then do you have a right to
- 24:36Speaker 2: have cooking gear? Do you have the right to have
- 24:39Speaker 2: a blanket or a tarp? Do you had then had
- 24:42Speaker 2: the right to urinate in public? And so on it
- 24:45Speaker 2: and the conduct, in other words, is so closely linked
- 24:49Speaker 2: to status that it's difficult to parse the two, and
- 24:53Speaker 2: it can be done. But I think the court's position
- 24:55Speaker 2: was they didn't want to be in the situation of
- 24:57Speaker 2: trying to say you could have a five foot by
- 25:01Speaker 2: six foot blanket but not an eight foot by ten
- 25:04Speaker 2: foot tarp. That these kinds of decision shouldn't be left
- 25:08Speaker 2: to the court based upon the Eighth Amendment, these sort
- 25:12Speaker 2: of differences of when conduct is so closely linked to
- 25:15Speaker 2: the stats of homelessness that it must be permitted. You know,
- 25:18Speaker 2: one other example, people said that you know, if you
- 25:22Speaker 2: if it's too far, you don't have to go to
- 25:24Speaker 2: an available homeless shelter. If it's thirty miles away, but
- 25:29Speaker 2: if there's one that's close by and they won't take
- 25:31Speaker 2: your dog, you don't have the right to do that.
- 25:33Speaker 2: I mean, still, all these kinds of application questions of
- 25:38Speaker 2: when conduct is linked to a status, it is problematic.
- 25:42Speaker 2: But I do think at the bottom mic I think
- 25:45Speaker 2: even a majority of the court will not disturb a
- 25:48Speaker 2: notion and may even support the notion that punishing someone
- 25:52Speaker 2: based upon the mere status of being homeless is does
- 25:56Speaker 2: violate the Constitution. But the question is what's the remant.
- 26:00Speaker 1: There was a lot of questioning from the conservatives, again,
- 26:04Speaker 1: especially the Chief. I remember one exchange he had about
- 26:08Speaker 1: if there's a shelter to go to over the county
- 26:11Speaker 1: line or whatever, do they have to go to that
- 26:13Speaker 1: shelter or not.
- 26:14Speaker 2: But the question really is twofold because in that issue,
- 26:19Speaker 2: many of the justices think that this town cannot shift
- 26:22Speaker 2: responsibility to a different town, that there's something wrong with
- 26:27Speaker 2: a city saying well, that's another city's problem, And obviously
- 26:32Speaker 2: Justice sort of mol said well, if all cities take
- 26:34Speaker 2: that position, we're never going to have any kind of
- 26:38Speaker 2: relief for the homeless. But based upon further questioning, I
- 26:44Speaker 2: think the attorneys, even for the almost coalition, seemed to
- 26:49Speaker 2: say if there was a close by shelter across a
- 26:53Speaker 2: town's lines, not a state lines, but across the town's lines,
- 26:57Speaker 2: that it would be sufficient to offer them the homeless
- 27:01Speaker 2: a position in a nearby shelter, even across some kind
- 27:05Speaker 2: of municipal boundaries. But again, the kind of line drawing
- 27:09Speaker 2: that this case raises, I think has given the court
- 27:14Speaker 2: a great deal of pause, and they want to try
- 27:16Speaker 2: to give a solution that's not heartless but nonetheless does
- 27:20Speaker 2: not mesh the court in these very messy details of
- 27:25Speaker 2: how best to effectuate a ban on some kind of
- 27:30Speaker 2: homelessness that is plaguing many of our towns across the country.
- 27:35Speaker 1: Does this statute criminalize being homeless?
- 27:40Speaker 2: It does, somewhat indirectly after several civil citations. Than under
- 27:46Speaker 2: this ordinance someone is subject to a criminal violation, and
- 27:51Speaker 2: indeed the civil penalties or something like three hundred dollars
- 27:55Speaker 2: for the first violation, so it's very steep. So there
- 27:59Speaker 2: was questions about even whether this would violate the excessive
- 28:02Speaker 2: fines part of the Eighth Amendment, but the court below
- 28:05Speaker 2: did not answer that, and so the parties did not
- 28:07Speaker 2: urge the court to reach that issue at this particular time,
- 28:12Speaker 2: but they, I think even our lawyer for the grants
- 28:16Speaker 2: past the town agreed that under the ordinances applied, criminal
- 28:21Speaker 2: penalties were available.
- 28:23Speaker 1: There was talk about the danger of having people sleep outside.
- 28:28Speaker 1: And when the Supreme Court addressed homelessness the last time
- 28:32Speaker 1: it upheld a National Park Service rule that prohibited sleeping
- 28:36Speaker 1: in parks around Washington. Correct, So might they say, well,
- 28:41Speaker 1: laws like this are to protect the health and safety
- 28:44Speaker 1: of the community.
- 28:46Speaker 2: It's true that the best solution is not to allow
- 28:49Speaker 2: homelessness to give and create work, enough, free food, enough options.
- 28:55Speaker 2: So there is homelessness, and I think everybody in the
- 28:59Speaker 2: court would want to to see that too, for that
- 29:02Speaker 2: to happen, you know. But you know, in this case,
- 29:06Speaker 2: I don't think the former the National Park Service president
- 29:10Speaker 2: really covers this instance because as the court all everybody
- 29:14Speaker 2: agreed there could be like a time placed manner restrictions
- 29:16Speaker 2: on public camping, when when you can go, when you
- 29:19Speaker 2: can public camp, and where you can public camp, and
- 29:24Speaker 2: whether whether you can leave items or even cooking gear
- 29:27Speaker 2: at your camp. Everybody seemed to think that that would
- 29:29Speaker 2: be you know, appropriate at a minimum, that would be appropriate.
- 29:33Speaker 2: But the real question is at the at the end
- 29:36Speaker 2: of the day, is can you criminalize people don't have
- 29:41Speaker 2: a home for living in the public when, as the
- 29:46Speaker 2: Justice is said, you know, you have to breathe, you
- 29:49Speaker 2: have to leave somewhere. That's part of being alive, and
- 29:52Speaker 2: if you don't, you're not alive. And so with that
- 29:55Speaker 2: kind of status or that kind of incredible importance, I
- 29:58Speaker 2: think the Court must recognize that, even if it tries
- 30:02Speaker 2: to get out of the difficult position, it has found
- 30:07Speaker 2: itself in trying to make these very tough lines that
- 30:10Speaker 2: it doesn't feel qualified to make.
- 30:12Speaker 1: So you'd think that all the justices or nearly all
- 30:17Speaker 1: the justices would be against criminalizing homelessness, and then there
- 30:23Speaker 1: might be splits from that point.
- 30:25Speaker 2: That is my sense. It's obviously difficult, but I think
- 30:28Speaker 2: the Court was so interested in ways to try to
- 30:33Speaker 2: avoid deciding this case, and we talked about three or earlier,
- 30:39Speaker 2: that what's motivating them is the difficulty of trying to
- 30:44Speaker 2: say it's constitutional to ban homelessness, and I think that
- 30:49Speaker 2: they would be disingenuous if they held that without overturning
- 30:53Speaker 2: that sixty two year old Robinson decision. And all of
- 30:58Speaker 2: the lawyers said the court, we don't want to overturn Robinson.
- 31:02Speaker 2: And if all the lawyers saying don't overturn Robinson is
- 31:05Speaker 2: you know, that puts even more pressure on the court.
- 31:08Speaker 2: And I think Chief Justice Roberts tried to say Robinson
- 31:11Speaker 2: is different. I think that that's incredibly disingenuous. It's I
- 31:15Speaker 2: think this is a stronger case than Robinson because again
- 31:18Speaker 2: and Robinson, we're talking about the status of something being
- 31:21Speaker 2: addicted to drugs, and you know, obviously there was a
- 31:25Speaker 2: criminal offense that led up to that. In this case,
- 31:28Speaker 2: it's like, you know, a ban on having COVID or
- 31:30Speaker 2: a ban on breathing or and so the ban on
- 31:35Speaker 2: homelessness itself, I think is much is much more difficult
- 31:39Speaker 2: to accept even then the ban on being the status
- 31:41Speaker 2: of a drug addict in Robinson. So if Robinson stands,
- 31:45Speaker 2: I think the Court either is going to be disingenuous,
- 31:48Speaker 2: which of course has happened, or it's going to try
- 31:50Speaker 2: to find a way to get out of this case
- 31:54Speaker 2: without having to make a pronouncement.
- 31:56Speaker 1: Is the Ninth Circuit the only circuit that has taking
- 32:00Speaker 1: up this issue.
- 32:02Speaker 2: To my knowledge, the vin Silver has taken it up twice,
- 32:07Speaker 2: and I do think there's there's many cases that are
- 32:10Speaker 2: not percolating in other circuits that just haven't become filing yet,
- 32:13Speaker 2: because you know, the more recent case has signaled to
- 32:18Speaker 2: housing coalitions elsewhere that it's appropriate and indeed wise to
- 32:24Speaker 2: challenge any kind of criminalization of the homelessness. And these
- 32:28Speaker 2: cases at first started percolating I think since the early
- 32:31Speaker 2: two thousands in the Los Angeles case, and obviously California
- 32:35Speaker 2: head in the West Coast has seen some of the
- 32:37Speaker 2: worst of public camping. But obviously that's not only in California,
- 32:42Speaker 2: and there's a lot of people who camp on the
- 32:46Speaker 2: streets in public spaces, you know, all over the country.
- 32:49Speaker 2: So this case I think is important. It should take
- 32:52Speaker 2: a lot of eyeballs across the country. I think the
- 32:57Speaker 2: coach is going to wrestle with what to do again,
- 32:59Speaker 2: simply because at the end of the day, I don't
- 33:01Speaker 2: think they want to write an opinion that says it's
- 33:04Speaker 2: consistent with the Constitution to criminalize homelessness.
- 33:09Speaker 1: You know, speaking of eyeballs and importance, I mean this
- 33:12Speaker 1: week alone, you have this case, you have the case
- 33:16Speaker 1: on the Idaho abortion ban, you have the Trump presidential
- 33:21Speaker 1: immunity case. Does it seem like the Court is tackling
- 33:24Speaker 1: more controversial issues this term than before.
- 33:28Speaker 2: It's hard to catalog and making a comparison from term
- 33:31Speaker 2: to term. And indeed, I don't think anybody would have
- 33:34Speaker 2: known at the beginning of the term. You certainly would
- 33:36Speaker 2: have known about the presidential immunity issue the Court now
- 33:40Speaker 2: must wrestle with. And I think the Idaho care case similarly,
- 33:47Speaker 2: one wouldn't have predicted a year ago that that would
- 33:49Speaker 2: be before the Court. So some of this has come
- 33:52Speaker 2: because of late breaking developments doing no small part of
- 33:55Speaker 2: the Supreme Court's own actions, but nonetheless it has become
- 33:59Speaker 2: much more of a controversial haphly contested on docket.
- 34:02Speaker 1: It's going to be a very very interesting week. Thanks
- 34:06Speaker 1: so much. How that's Professor Harold Krant of the Chicago
- 34:08Speaker 1: kan College of Law. And that's it for this edition
- 34:11Speaker 1: of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you can always get
- 34:14Speaker 1: the latest legal news by subscribing and listening to the
- 34:17Speaker 1: show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at Bloomberg dot com
- 34:21Speaker 1: Slash podcast Slash Law. I'm June Grosso and this is
- 34:25Speaker 1: Bloomberg