Latest / The So What? / Integrating Economics and Foreign Policy
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website, jplandman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28These first few recordings were done at our dining room table, but we will soon be moving
- 0:33into a studio. Hello and a very warm welcome, as always, to this recording, which accompanies
- 0:42JP's latest research note. It's dated 27 June 2023 and the title is Integrating Economics
- 0:51and Foreign Policy. JP, you quote a biographer who wrote a biography of Zbigniew Brzezinski,
- 0:59Jimmy Carter's national security advisor. He said, the ignorance of geopolitical minds
- 1:06about economics is matched only by the economics profession's ignorance about foreign policy.
- 1:14And then you say that's a very apt description of the current debate in South Africa. What
- 1:19do you mean? Well, what the biographer said was that Brzezinski and other foreign affairs
- 1:27luminaries like Henry Kissinger and Marlene Albrecht, the names he used, were all people
- 1:33that were not really very much interested in economics. They were interested in geopolitical
- 1:37maneuvers. But economics are extremely important in any country. And if you're the world's
- 1:46number one economy like America, you can probably afford not to worry too much about economics.
- 1:50When you're a smaller country like South Africa, you actually have to. And what struck me about
- 1:55that remark by the biographer is simply that in the debate that we currently have in South
- 2:01Africa about our foreign policy, the relationship with the US, the relationship with Russia
- 2:06and so on, there is almost a Chinese wall, dare I say, between economics and diplomacy
- 2:16or foreign policy. And it is as if the two are totally disconnected and not talking to
- 2:21each other and not the one reinforcing the other. And you believe they should be integrated?
- 2:27Absolutely. It should absolutely be integrated. And it is just noticeable that even the US
- 2:32now is moving to a much more integrated economic and foreign policy approach. So I think we
- 2:39also have to do that. And now the question then arises, well, how do you integrate them?
- 2:44What in economics is important in foreign relations and the other way around? Now, thankfully,
- 2:49the Minister of Finance, Inokwa Nungwana, answered this question in parliament. And
- 2:54he said there are four transmission channels, that's what he called them, determining the
- 2:59influence of foreign policy on our domestic economy. And those four transmission channels
- 3:05or four areas is basically the currency, trade and supply chains, investment and liquidity.
- 3:14And what I do in Inokwa is to take each of these four areas or each of these four transmission
- 3:18channels, and we look at to what extent foreign policy decisions affect the local economy
- 3:25via that transmission channel. Now, the first one, if I can just plunge into it, is the
- 3:30currency. And we saw it immediately when the Lady R fracas, based in the open and became
- 3:39a hot topic. What happened to the currency? What happened to the round? Well, it depreciated
- 3:44immediately. It is recovered, then recovered a little bit, but it is still very, very weak.
- 3:50What was the impact of that depreciating currency? Well, the Reserve Bank increased interest
- 3:55rates by 50 basis points, while everybody up till that point expected the bank to increase
- 4:01by 25 basis points. Now, you can say 25 basis points, a quarter of a percent is not a lot.
- 4:08But if you think that you levy that interest rate charge across the entire economy, individuals,
- 4:15households, businesses, government itself, and so on, it adds up to a huge amount of
- 4:21money. So, the transmission channel worked very immediately. The currency depreciated
- 4:27when there was a foreign policy dispute, and sub-Africans are paying the price through
- 4:32high interest rates. Simple. So, it was better, it would have been better for us to have a
- 4:39foreign policy stance that would not have precipitated that kind of currency depreciation.
- 4:45The second one is the trade and supply chain. This is where the whole AGOA thing, African
- 4:50Growth and Opportunity Act, where that debate comes in. But of course, it's about much more
- 4:55than just AGOA. As the minister pointed out in parliament, it's not just trade, which
- 5:00is AGOA, it's also supply chain. We cannot by any stretch of the imagination produce
- 5:08everything that we need in the country ourselves. It's not possible. We're using cell phones,
- 5:12which were imported, we're using software, which are imported, we're using oil, we run
- 5:17our motor cars, which are imported and so on. So, it's about much more than just AGOA,
- 5:23it's also trade. And what we did was to look at the trade, comparing the trade of two blocks.
- 5:30The one is four main Western countries, and those countries are the US, Germany, Japan,
- 5:35and the United Kingdom. They are our main trading partners.
- 5:39Japan is an interesting case, because it's not physically in the West, or geographically
- 5:45in the West, but it's part of the G7 and part of that whole economic block.
- 5:50Absolutely. Yeah, you're quite right. It's located in the East, but it's part of the
- 5:53West. One of the things one must remember. And it is very clear that we export much more
- 6:02to the four Western countries than what we export to the BRICS. So, in terms of bringing
- 6:08money into the country by selling our goods, our main clients are sitting in the West,
- 6:14not in BRICS. In fact, the relationship is about two times. We export twice as much to
- 6:21the four Western countries than what we export to the four BRICS countries.
- 6:27If you move to the import side or the supply side, you find much the same thing. We import
- 6:32much more from the BRICS countries than what we import from the four Western countries.
- 6:39And 70% of the BRICS imports really come from China. I must just put that as a sub note.
- 6:44So it's not so much Russia, Brazil, even India. China is the main provider of imports into
- 6:50South Africa. But here is the point. We run a trade surplus with the four Western countries.
- 6:56We run a huge trade deficit with the BRICS countries, which basically means a deficit
- 7:01with China. Now, if you're a capital scarce country like South Africa, it is better to
- 7:06have a surplus than a deficit. Deficit has to be paid for. So we run a deficit with BRICS
- 7:11and we run a surplus with the West. You can clearly see that the surplus of the West is
- 7:16helping to pay for the deficit with the BRICS countries. And again, if that is where your
- 7:22clients are, if that is where the people are who buy your goods, it is appropriate, I think,
- 7:28to treat them with respect and maintain good relationships.
- 7:33I just want to point out to the listeners that those of you who are interested in the
- 7:38hard data do go to the written note. There are very clear figures which illustrate everything
- 7:45that you have just said.
- 7:47Yes, indeed. And that may be very useful. We're just talking conceptually. And while
- 7:52we're on it, can I recognize the contribution that was made by Peter Roo in the research
- 7:57for this note? He's the one who worked on the numbers and compiled the numbers. So there
- 8:03are four transmission channels, so four areas of impact. There's the currency. We talked
- 8:07about that. There is trade and supply chain. We talked about that.
- 8:11Just before we move off trade and supply chain, it is quite clear if you look at the fact
- 8:16that we export about twice as much to Europe or to those four countries rather than what
- 8:21we export to BRICS. It is quite clear that it is much easier for sub-African exporters
- 8:27to get their products into those countries than to get their products into the BRICS
- 8:30countries. So there's clearly a whole area of work that needs to be done.
- 8:36And one who would like to see the Department of Foreign Affairs, instead of embarrassing
- 8:41us internationally, rather help our exporters to get their exports into countries like China
- 8:46and the other BRICS countries.
- 8:49The third transmission channel is investment. And here we're talking about foreign direct
- 8:53investment. And again, the numbers, which are in the written piece, are simply overwhelming.
- 8:59We get three times as much investment from the four Western countries that we refer to
- 9:05than what we get from BRICS. And that would make sense. The BRICS countries, even China,
- 9:12are developing countries and they would have less capital available. China may be the outlier,
- 9:18while the developed countries, the four countries that we're looking at, are mature economies
- 9:23and they have more capital that they can disperse.
- 9:26So we get three...
- 9:27They look for investment opportunities outside of their own borders.
- 9:31They do. And increasingly, Indian and Chinese companies are also doing it, but there are
- 9:36many more European countries or companies from those four countries investing in South
- 9:42Africa than they are from the BRICS countries. But the bottom line of this paragraph, for
- 9:48purposes of the audio, is three times more. We get three times more investment from those
- 9:53four Western countries than what we get from the four BRICS countries.
- 9:57And the last one is liquidity. And liquidity is an interesting one, because liquidity is
- 10:03a little bit like your bank account. Sometimes you are overdrawn because you have to pay
- 10:08medical expenses or you buy furniture or you buy a car or whatever, and you need credit.
- 10:16You need a bank overdraft. Now, the same goes for the country. When the country runs a current
- 10:21account deficit, it needs to finance that deficit in one way or another. You need a
- 10:28positive inflow on your capital account to pay for a deficit on the trade account.
- 10:33Now, South Africa, generally speaking, is a current account deficit country. We're not
- 10:40there every year, and there are now in COVID and so on times where we were not a deficit
- 10:46country. But generally speaking, we are. We're a capital scarce country. And when you need
- 10:53that overdraft, when you don't have capital to finance your needs, that's when you need
- 10:57liquidity. Now, where does the liquidity come from? It comes from essentially international
- 11:04private sector companies like pension funds, like insurance companies, like banks, who
- 11:12advance money to two countries. They make what is called portfolio investments, or they
- 11:19can also make direct loans in the case of a bank. Into South Africa, that is how money
- 11:24comes in, and you use that money to finance your deficit. Now, these are not governments
- 11:30providing the money. I think that's very important to say. It's private companies that provide
- 11:34the money. And funds, pension funds. And pension funds.
- 11:37Yeah, that's what I mean by private. Pension funds, insurance companies, banks, and so
- 11:41on. Rich individuals, family offices, that sort of thing. Now, these people operate much
- 11:48more on optics. They obviously do their fundamental research, but optics affect them. And if you
- 11:55do silly things that make them risk averse, that is the term, and they become risk averse,
- 12:01then they don't supply you with the money. And you don't have liquidity. Now, what happens
- 12:05if you don't have liquidity? Well, you absolutely slow down the functioning of the economy.
- 12:11That is what happened in South Africa after 1985, or in 1985, when P.W. Borda made his
- 12:17famous or infamous Rubicon speech. Just before they made the speech, Citibank said they're
- 12:24no longer going to supply South Africa with liquidity. They stopped our credit lines,
- 12:29and we were forced into a dead standstill. Other banks, of course, other institutions
- 12:34followed Citibank. And from 1985 to 1993, basically a period of eight years, we struggled
- 12:41with liquidity, and you see it in our economic growth numbers. Growth simply slumped, because
- 12:47what normally happens when you don't have the capital available to finance a deficit,
- 12:53it's like a household as well, you're forced to go into a surplus. You're forced to lower
- 12:58your expenditure so that you generate a surplus. Now, in economic terms, the way you do it
- 13:04is you force down GDP growth, you make the economy smaller, literally, so that it needs
- 13:11less capital, and then you are in a position where you're not dependent on foreign capital.
- 13:16We were there for eight years, 1985 to 1993. It's not a comfortable place to be. And what
- 13:22we must understand is not just about foreign direct investment, which is the third transmission
- 13:26channel. It is also about this fourth transmission channel, which is liquidity, or think of it
- 13:32as a bank overdraft. So these are the four areas where the Minister of Finance said there
- 13:38are clear avenues, or as he called it, channels through which the economy gets affected. And
- 13:44I find it a very useful frame through which to look at our foreign policy.
- 13:49But if one listens to that, it just really sounds as if our Department of Foreign Affairs
- 13:56is, it is almost not understandable what they do. But then you put the other side on the
- 14:04piece of paper, and that is geopolitics, and you say, no, we have to also look at South
- 14:10Africa's position in the world. And there is a rationality to their actions.
- 14:15No, absolutely. That is what Brzezinski's biographer said. He said the ignorance of
- 14:21the geopolitical minds about economics is matched only by the economics profession's
- 14:27ignorance of foreign policy. And I think it's a beautiful summary, because if you now look
- 14:32at South Africa's foreign policy stance, what is it? Well, the first point to factor in
- 14:36is that South Africa accepts that the world is busy breaking up into three blocks. There
- 14:43is the Western Bloc, which is led by the US, and one can basically say the G7 countries,
- 14:50plus some smaller players like Australia and New Zealand and so on. And it's not the West,
- 14:56because it includes, as you've pointed out, Japan. It includes Australia, which sits in
- 15:01the East. That's the G7 Bloc. The second Bloc that's forming in the world is China, and
- 15:08the country is very dependent on China, very much in the influence sphere of China. Now,
- 15:14the China Bloc is not as cohesive and as strong at this stage as the G7, but it's forming.
- 15:20There's no question about it. And the third block is what is loosely referred to as the
- 15:24Global South. Now, who is the Global South? Well, it includes South America, the continent
- 15:29of South America. It includes Africa. It includes the Middle East. It includes India and even
- 15:36China. So you can see that that is by far the biggest block in the world. It's also
- 15:41the least cohesive. Now, South Africa is part of the Global South. We are there by way of
- 15:48tradition. We follow the principles of the Bandung Conference of 1955, the non-alignment
- 15:56conference that was held there. And we basically say the world cannot be unipolar. South Africa
- 16:05is very much against the unipolar world. And we would like to see a multipolar world where
- 16:10everybody is treated with respect and dignity. And this Global South position that South
- 16:17Africa have will not be abandoned and it will not move over into the G7 Bloc simply because
- 16:23the G7 Bloc is South Africa's most important economic partners, more important than the
- 16:28BRICS partners. So economically, we belong with the G7. Politically, we belong with the
- 16:33Global South. We want to stay clear of China. I think that is very clear. South Africa is
- 16:39one of the few countries in Africa where there are no Belt and Road Initiative projects. The
- 16:44same logic. If you're against a unipolar American world, you're also against the unipolar Chinese
- 16:50world. So we very much see ourselves as part of the Global South and that position South
- 16:55Africa will not give up. So now the trick is to integrate these two things. Economically,
- 17:01you belong with the G7. Politically, you are part of the Global South. And then you want
- 17:07to maintain good relations with China because they're a huge export market, but they're
- 17:11also a US supplier of goods in your supply chain. So we want to be friends with everybody,
- 17:18which is a perfectly legitimate and laudable stance. But then your foreign policy must
- 17:22reflect the fact that you want to be more or less friends with everybody. And you say
- 17:26it is possible because Brazil and India have given us examples. Yes, that's the important
- 17:32learning point. What I've done in the note is to compare South Africa's behavior with
- 17:38Brazil and India. Why Brazil and India? They're both part of the Global South, like us. They're
- 17:44both democracies, just like we are. They're both against the unipolar world, just like
- 17:50we are. But they behaved very differently in the UN Security Council in votes and resolutions
- 17:58on the Ukraine war. They took a very different stance from what we did. We did not display
- 18:02the nuance of Brazil and India. India, by the way, played the game very cleverly and
- 18:10they have a very clear idea of what is their national interest. Why do I say that? Well,
- 18:17they refused to impose sanctions against Russia and in fact they went and they bought oil
- 18:21from Russia, but they bought it at a huge discount. When the market price was running
- 18:27at about $80 a barrel, they were buying for 45. Now that's a lovely discount to get for
- 18:33your country. More than that, they paid for it in rupees. To such an extent that Lavrov,
- 18:39the Russian Foreign Minister, had to travel to Delhi and he admitted, you can see the
- 18:43video on YouTube, he admitted that the rupees that the Russians now own, which sit in the
- 18:49Indian banking system, are of no use to the Russians. You know, what do you do with a
- 18:53rupee? Well, you can buy some Indian goods and then the surplus. So the Indians have
- 18:58got a very clear idea of what is in their own interest and they pursued it. They didn't
- 19:03impose sanctions, bought the oil, paid for it in rupees in terms of their own national
- 19:08interest. Now I don't detect that strong push for South Africa's national interest in our
- 19:14foreign policy. If you compare our position to Brazil, Lula from Brazil is very clear.
- 19:21He condemned the Russian invasion, but he also condemned the Western NATO specifically
- 19:26for stoking the war and by implication for supporting Ukraine. This was a while ago already.
- 19:34His foreign affairs advisor recently said, a lovely description, he said, you cannot
- 19:40judge the Ukraine war by the last one and a half years. It is a product of the Cold
- 19:45War. Ukraine is a victim of the Cold War. Now I haven't heard the South African government
- 19:52or Durko saying Ukraine is a victim here. We've bought into the binary position. It's
- 19:58either NATO and the US or Russia. My view from the beginning is what about the 43 million
- 20:04people who live in Ukraine? What about the 43 million Ukrainians? Do they not count?
- 20:10Are they of no relevance? It's not a binary story. It is much more complicated than just
- 20:15binary. Now the Brazilians clearly understand that and say it in public. We haven't said
- 20:22it in public. So if you compare our behavior to the behavior of India and to the behavior
- 20:27of Brazil, our diplomatic behavior that is, then clearly we're not as non-aligned as they
- 20:34are and not as firm in our own independent thinking and in our own independent search
- 20:43for what is in our national interest, like the Indians have done. It looks like people
- 20:48are thinking in terms of us and them. Yes. And that's not good enough in a tri-polar
- 20:54world where you want to have relationships with anybody. You cannot afford the luxury
- 20:58of us and them. That's lazy thinking as it is in normal life. Have we seen knock-on effects,
- 21:07for example, in the relationship with the G7? Yes, we have seen knock-on effects. This
- 21:11year for the first time since the time Thabo Mbeki was president, we're talking over 20
- 21:17years here in total, South Africa was not invited to the G7, annual G7 summit. Even
- 21:25President Zuma went to all the G7 summits. President Ramaphosa went. This year the invitation
- 21:32did not arrive. Now you can say that is just coincidence. You can say Japan, who was the
- 21:39host this year, preferred to have the chairman of the African Union there. And I'm not persuaded
- 21:46at all because the African Union has been around for a long time and other host countries
- 21:52do not invite the chairman only. But while we're on the point, inviting the chairman
- 21:57of the African Union is actually, I think, not in Africa's best interest. What happens
- 22:02when you go to these summits regularly? Well, you develop a relationship with the other
- 22:06leaders. You can build trust. They can understand where you come from. You can continuously
- 22:11clarify misunderstandings. You become part of a network. If you have a rotating chairman,
- 22:19every year there's a new EU chairman, and if you have a rotating chairman now coming
- 22:24in and disappearing and coming in and disappearing, how do you build a network from which Africa
- 22:29as a continent can benefit? So I will never know. We will never know whether there's a
- 22:35link between our foreign policy missteps and the non-invitation to the G7, but I think
- 22:42it is something to take note of, and I think it is we bluff ourselves if we say, oh, it's
- 22:47only because Japan wanted to invite the whole African Union and not just a particular African
- 22:52country. But on the other hand, you do say that the United States may be overplaying
- 22:59its hand. Absolutely. Look, this whole note is about balance. It's about integrating
- 23:05ostensibly opposing things. It's about doing what is right, but in a way which takes you
- 23:11forward. Now, what we've seen in the US in the way that they handled the Lady R story,
- 23:19in the way that they sanctioned a private flight school in Oudtsweren, I mean, Oudtsweren
- 23:24of all places, you know, I come from that part of the world. It is really deep rural.
- 23:30To now say that that flight school is a potential threat to the security of the United States
- 23:35is simply just rubbish. I'm sorry, but it's just rubbish. Now, the problem with this kind
- 23:41of overplaying your hand, it looks very arrogant. It looks very bossy, and bossiness and arrogance
- 23:48can have a political side effect, and the political side effect is us and them, exactly
- 23:53what you referred to earlier. Plays into the hand of the people who want to mobilize. In
- 23:591977, a year after the Soweto riots, South Africa was also in dire straits. And what
- 24:07did John Foster do? The then Prime Minister, he led the National Party to its biggest election
- 24:13victory in nearly five decades that it ruled the country. How did he achieve that? Well,
- 24:18he just ran against Jimmy Carter. That's all. You know, the canvases went up the street
- 24:23and said, who do you vote for? John Foster or Jimmy Carter? And that's it. He wiped out
- 24:27the opposition. Same thing happened in Hungary more recently with the Prime Minister, Victor
- 24:34Orban. He ran against John Soros, who happened to be an Hungarian born citizen, but is now
- 24:39in the US. And he just ran against against George Soros. Mugabe ran against Tony Blair
- 24:47in several elections. So be careful for igniting us and them dynamic politics. It may really
- 24:54backfire against the things that you want to advance. In summary, so what? Well, I think
- 25:00the summary comes out very clearly. We are economically much more integrated with the
- 25:06West than what we are with BRICS. As the world shifts towards the BRICS, we will obviously
- 25:12also become more integrated with the BRICS. And we don't, we simply don't want to choose.
- 25:17We want to be part of both. But at the moment, we are much more part of the Western of BRICS.
- 25:22Economically, economically, economically, that's where we sit. Our foreign policy must reflect
- 25:27that. And if you take our foreign policy and you compare it with other countries from the
- 25:32global South, then you can see that we've made a couple of missteps that we we could
- 25:38have avoided. Just compare ourselves to India and compare ourselves to Brazil, those two
- 25:43other countries from the global South. As the world is breaking up into three blocks,
- 25:48it is our duty, it is our national interest, in my view, to maintain good relationships
- 25:54with all three blocks. We're not in favor of a unipolar world. We're in favor of a multipolar
- 25:59world. But then you must maintain relations with the multipolar world. You cannot say
- 26:04I will not deal with this one or deal with that one. I think we also, one of the so what's
- 26:09for me is that South Africa needs to have a much, much clearer idea of its own identity,
- 26:17what it stands, what it wants to say, and also its own national interest. And for me,
- 26:22the example remains India. You buy oil at a huge discount and you pay for it in your
- 26:26own currency. I mean, you know, it hardly can get better than that. But that's because
- 26:31the Indians pushed for it. They realized the Russians were in a weak position and they
- 26:36said, yes, we'll buy your oil, but at a discount, then you take our currency. And the Russians
- 26:41had to do that. So we can do, I really don't care what happens with Russia, but I do care
- 26:48about South Africa's national interest. And we must have a very clear idea what it is
- 26:54and then push for it aggressively in all the places where we interact. Essentially, it's
- 27:00about integrating own interest and international interest, own interest with our partners'
- 27:07interests, own identity of where you stand in the world. That is really what it comes
- 27:12down to. Thank you very much for a very clear and fresh look at the whole thing. And I think
- 27:19a more holistic view of the current international relations problem that we have.
- 27:27No, we must take our cue from the Brzezinski biographer. It is not just about geopolitics
- 27:33and it's not just about economics. It's about both. And it cannot be about either one. It
- 27:37must be about both. Yeah. Thank you very much. Thank you.
- 27:45Thank you for listening to the So What Podcast. If you enjoy this content, please don't forget
- 27:50to leave a review and a rating and please consider subscribing so you don't miss any
- 27:55future episodes. Also, tell your friends. Remember, you can find a written version of
- 28:01all JP's content at jplandman.co.za.