Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Supreme Court Health Care and Public Health Rulings 2025-2026: Critical Takeaways for Legal Practitioners
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. My name is Nancy Lam. I'm the
- 0:06vice chair of BHBA's health care law section.
- 0:09I am delighted to introduce our speaker, James
- 0:12Hodge. Professor Hodge is the Peter Cuit Foundation
- 0:16Professor of Law at ASU's Sandra Day O 'Connor
- 0:19College of Law and Director of the Center for
- 0:21Public Health Law and Policy, where his scholarship,
- 0:25teaching, and applied work expand health law,
- 0:28public health law, global health law, ethics,
- 0:31and human rights. A prolific scholar with more
- 0:34than 300 published articles and among the top
- 0:371 % of downloaded authors on SSRN, he has helped
- 0:41draft major model public health laws, including
- 0:44the Model State Emergency Health Powers Act and
- 0:47the Uniform Emergency Volunteer Health Practitioners
- 0:51Act, and a nationally recognized expert in many,
- 0:55many public health areas. And now let's get started.
- 1:00All right, Nancy, thank you so much for that
- 1:02very kind introduction. Good morning, everyone.
- 1:05It's a delight to be able to join you for this
- 1:07critical seminar today. And I'm really looking
- 1:09forward to the discussion we can have in regards
- 1:11to SCOTUS or some U .S. Supreme Court related
- 1:14impacts in health law and policy from this prior
- 1:17year. So let me take the opportunity now to go
- 1:19ahead and share screens, show you a little bit
- 1:21of what we've got in store for our program here.
- 1:23And with that said, I'll give you a little sense
- 1:25of exactly what the sort of game plan is before
- 1:28we just launch right in. to our core discussion.
- 1:31And as per typical arrangements through Beverly
- 1:34Hills CLE programming, we'll take any questions,
- 1:37any comments a little bit later after some of
- 1:40the material has been discussed so you have the
- 1:41opportunity there fully to basically assess and
- 1:45digest what's been going on in regards to US
- 1:47Supreme Court impacts in the health law arena.
- 1:50So without further ado, this is a little bit
- 1:52of what I hope we can accomplish with our discussion
- 1:54today. Slides will be made available to you afterwards,
- 1:58which you may find very helpful for some of the
- 2:00facts and issues raised here, but to be sure,
- 2:02I'm looking forward to editorializing as much
- 2:04as I can in regards to this specific assessment.
- 2:07It's been another Dynamics US Supreme Court term
- 2:10this past year. I mean, as we start into this
- 2:13next year's term already, controversial cases
- 2:16before us. But what the U .S. Supreme Court did
- 2:18again this past year has proven to be yet another
- 2:21seminal series of health law related cases on
- 2:24major health law related topics, which I'll introduce
- 2:27here momentarily. For each one of the cases that
- 2:29I'll highlight today, of which there will be
- 2:31about eight or so, with a few honorable mentions
- 2:33along the way, I'll briefly take you into the
- 2:36sort of brief facts and issues that the U .S.
- 2:38Supreme Court absorbed in that specific decision.
- 2:40Let's talk a little bit about what's actually
- 2:42at stake. Why was the case So important. Why
- 2:46was it selected, at least in relation to my overview
- 2:49of a really critical health law case that we
- 2:51need to be aware of and conscientious of? And
- 2:54then let's talk about what the actual decision
- 2:56was, what its impacts might be. And I'll even
- 2:59offer a few practice tips that I kind of see
- 3:02coming out of these decisions so that you have
- 3:04at least a reasonable idea of how my impact practice
- 3:07in the health law or other arenas right now in
- 3:10the United States. And again, note questions
- 3:12and comments. for a little bit later. So let's
- 3:15jump into it. Looking forward to this great discussion
- 3:18and as we do so, let's make sure you know as
- 3:20a backdrop everything I'll be discussing on all
- 3:24these different cases. is already neatly laid
- 3:27out in a real, nice, concise manuscript that
- 3:30we've got with the Journal of Law Medicine Ethics
- 3:32available to you online currently and through
- 3:35our COE provider. That specific document will
- 3:38lay out more detail some of what I'll be discussing
- 3:40here. But let's go past what we think and how
- 3:44we think of these specific cases in this specific
- 3:46scholarly arena and get right to the heart of
- 3:49what and how these cases impact what we do in
- 3:51health law. So to that end, let me first start,
- 3:54if I may, with some very brief mentions of cases
- 3:57of which the U .S. Supreme Court did issue decisions,
- 4:01or will soon in the very near future, I dare
- 4:03say, that didn't quite make our cut for top cases
- 4:07of focus, but yet might be ones you should be
- 4:09aware of. And that includes the Haines Celestial
- 4:11Group case versus Ponquist. Now, in this specific
- 4:14case, this was entirely the U .S. Supreme Court
- 4:17taking on a procedural issue, but the facts of
- 4:19it are definitely worth noting. They reviewed
- 4:22whether or not Whole Foods was actually improperly
- 4:24dismissed from a case that involved claims of
- 4:27child autism arising suggestively from heavy
- 4:29metal poisoning through some of EarthBest's organic
- 4:32products, which of course sold at Whole Foods.
- 4:35Ultimately, what the U .S. Supreme Court did
- 4:36in this specific case is literally vacate the
- 4:39defendant's judgment in this regard. That was
- 4:41of interest. But to be sure, although the facts
- 4:44are sensational, this was a highly procedural
- 4:47decision not related to the facts at hand. Burke
- 4:50V. Choi. Delaware's affidavit requirement for
- 4:52medical malpractice suits, whether that's replicated
- 4:55in California or not is not, I'm not sure of,
- 4:58but when you see it in regards to affidavit requirements,
- 5:01similar to what you see in Delaware, this report
- 5:04made very clear it does not apply in federal
- 5:06court under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure
- 5:08Rule 8, which only requires a short and plain
- 5:10statement of the claim. Whether that shows up
- 5:12in your practice or not, representing med malpatients
- 5:15or clients, I won't know for sure, but to be
- 5:18To be honest, Burke v. Choi gives us at least
- 5:20clarity on that issue. The next case is on here
- 5:25for a very important reason, because we're not
- 5:27done with this litigation, I can assure you.
- 5:29Danko Labs versus Louisiana was the US Supreme
- 5:33Court's opportunity to step in and issue an emergency
- 5:37stay. of the Fifth Circuit's order that would
- 5:40have suspended national distribution of Mifopristone
- 5:43based on FDA's 2023 REMS note or order, relaxing
- 5:47that in -person dispensing requirement for the
- 5:49drug itself. Now, the Fifth Circuit would have
- 5:52suspended distribution of Mifopristone, as you
- 5:54all remember this from late last spring. U .S.
- 5:57Supreme Court did step in. They put an emergency
- 5:59stay on that. It held that Fifth Circuit order
- 6:02in place. Currently, right now, as we speak,
- 6:04Fifth Circuit is actually reexamining these issues
- 6:07all over again, as is FDA. So while this case
- 6:12doesn't have significant proportions from SCOTUS
- 6:16yet, you wait and watch for this next turn and
- 6:19see how this case may come right back up before
- 6:21us. And then finally, one decision that gets
- 6:24a lot of our attention today on the 25th anniversary
- 6:27of 9 -11 in relation to all of the different
- 6:30presidential emergency powers, one of which often
- 6:33slips under the radar is President Trump's emergency
- 6:36power to impose tariffs pursuant to the International
- 6:39Emergency Economic Powers Act. You know, that's
- 6:41what he tried to do in relation to tariffs imposed
- 6:44against Mexico, China, and others on the premise
- 6:47that there was a public health crisis related
- 6:50to drug trafficking that warranted that type
- 6:53of tariff authority as an emergency declaration
- 6:57pursuant to the Emergency Powers Act issued by
- 6:59Congress. US Supreme Court does clarify on learning
- 7:02resources versus Trump. That's not a legitimate
- 7:06exercise of tariff authority because it was not
- 7:08sufficiently given to President Trump to impose
- 7:11those tariffs under that specific sort of arena.
- 7:14Interesting decision, one for which President
- 7:16Trump and other future presidents may bypass
- 7:18by seeking other tariff authority, but at least
- 7:21on that route for public health emergency purposes,
- 7:24the legitimate use of power. All right, those
- 7:27are our cases worthy of note. Let's look now
- 7:30at the four major topics of cases that really
- 7:32got our attention. during the Supreme Court term.
- 7:35We're talking about issues regarding standard
- 7:36of care and First Amendment. I'll get into those
- 7:38three cases in just a moment, including one right
- 7:41out of California. There's the issues around
- 7:43LGBTQ plus rights and discrimination and a hot
- 7:47topic for the U .S. Supreme Court in prior sessions
- 7:50with cases like Skrimetti out of Tennessee. And
- 7:53this past term, you'll see a further more important
- 7:55how the Supreme Court takes this topic on again.
- 7:58Government controls and Second Amendment just
- 8:00cannot get through a term. in the US Supreme
- 8:02Court for the last several years without really
- 8:05substantial gun control and second amendment
- 8:06related repercussions. And then public health
- 8:09liability issues, always a concern, always an
- 8:11issue. This term no different as we'll see in
- 8:14the Monsanto case involving obviously the specific
- 8:19cancer related allegations against Roundup, some
- 8:22of which have come out of tens of thousands of
- 8:25lawsuits, many of which fall in California, I
- 8:27expect as well. All right, with that said, those
- 8:29are our major topics. Here are the major cases
- 8:32that we'll be taking on very briefly as we kind
- 8:35of think through all of these topics in the order
- 8:38of which I just illustrated them. What's neat
- 8:40about this specific graphic is just showing you
- 8:42where the cases originate from, like the Mirabelli
- 8:44versus Bonta case on free exercise out of California.
- 8:47But what's also interesting, the case out of
- 8:50Hawaii you see, is the spread here. Now, a lot
- 8:52of times with Supreme Court cases in the health
- 8:54law arena, what I'll often find is there's considerable
- 8:57jurisdiction shopping for those cases, often
- 8:59in the Southeast, looking for favorable courts,
- 9:02potentially on some of the more controversial
- 9:03concerns. Not so much this year. These cases
- 9:07really came out of multiple different jurisdictions.
- 9:09Even one case, the West Virginia case, was actually
- 9:12coupled with one out of Idaho as well. So we'll
- 9:15see the spread of what influence and what factors
- 9:18relate to these cases across the United States,
- 9:21of which these eight decisions will really get
- 9:23a lot of our attention. All right, let's jump
- 9:25into the first major area of importance here
- 9:28for our purposes, and that's standards of care
- 9:30matched up with First Amendment related issues
- 9:33that the U .S. Supreme Court has been honing
- 9:35on. extensively. Our first case, there's a big
- 9:40one, and it's dynamic, and I can't emphasize
- 9:44enough just exactly what was at stake here. Let's
- 9:48be clear, in Childs v. Salazar out of Colorado,
- 9:51you have the case of Childs, a licensed child
- 9:53counselor who's offering consulting services,
- 9:56and the whole basis for her consulting services
- 9:58to often minors patients, generally with the
- 10:01permission of their parents of course, is what
- 10:03and how we can go about extending or working
- 10:06to assist those patients with conversion. Conversion
- 10:10from being, you know, potentially gay back to
- 10:14heterosexual. Conversion therapy provisions are
- 10:17literally prohibited, or interventions are prohibited,
- 10:21by Colorado's mental therapy conversion law.
- 10:24It bans this type of counseling, and yet, Charles,
- 10:26as a licensed child counselor in the state of
- 10:29Colorado, wants to do it and claims a first amendment
- 10:32free speech interest to actually do that for
- 10:34consenting patients. Now the lower courts in
- 10:37this one just literally denied everything that
- 10:39she was after and relate to it. They said Colorado's
- 10:41law is neutral, it's generally applicable, it
- 10:43regulates professional conduct, the exact sort
- 10:45of answers you might anticipate when a state
- 10:48determines that a particular intervention like
- 10:50conversion therapy could be problematic. Tenth
- 10:52Circuit largely agreed. SCOTUS got a hold of
- 10:56the quake case and granted cert back in March
- 10:59of 2025 on this question, whether Colorado's
- 11:02laws centering certain conversations between
- 11:05licensed counselors and patients based on express
- 11:07viewpoints regulates conduct or speech and violation
- 11:10of the First Amendment. Because if it does, Colorado
- 11:14cannot prohibit this counselor from issuing these,
- 11:17providing this type of guidance. Now, what's
- 11:20at stake really is quite critical because conversion
- 11:23therapies under Virtually every major medical
- 11:27association has been largely condemned. This
- 11:30is that psychological practice, as we all know,
- 11:32I think, from attempting to change a person's
- 11:34sexuality or gender through counseling sessions.
- 11:37It's associated with higher rates of suicide,
- 11:39depression, anxiety, PTSD among patients undergoing
- 11:42conversion therapies. The American Medical Association
- 11:46manifold other U .S. medical associations. condemn
- 11:50the practice. And in Colorado alone there's 73
- 11:53,000 LGBTQ plus youth that might be under the
- 11:57protection of not having to undergo conversion
- 11:59therapies. 20 other states, I bet California,
- 12:03has similar laws. Now here's the deal. This case
- 12:07is not just about conversion therapy. It literally
- 12:10is about, in so many ways, what's the court's
- 12:13willingness? to insert its views into what constitutes
- 12:17standard of care. This is a case not just about
- 12:19whether Colorado can stop something in its tracks
- 12:22like conversion therapy among licensed health
- 12:25practitioners. This is a case about who's gonna
- 12:27make the decisions about what constitutes appropriate
- 12:32medical standard of care. In Colorado, the state
- 12:35legislature and health department made the decision
- 12:38along with medical boards. We don't want it done.
- 12:40Will the U .S. Supreme Court interfere with that
- 12:43specific decision? Well, the answer is, yeah,
- 12:46you bet it will. In a very surprising eight to
- 12:49one decision, Justice Gorsuch notes Colorado
- 12:53cannot invoke its licensure authority to mandate
- 12:56what a licensed counselor can discuss with his
- 12:58or her patients, notwithstanding the standard
- 13:00of care. It doesn't matter that Colorado's legislature
- 13:03and others found that conversion therapy just
- 13:06breaches. appropriate standards of care for treatment
- 13:09of persons within these licensed counsel settings,
- 13:13that counselor has sufficient First Amendment
- 13:16protections to avoid viewpoint discrimination,
- 13:19as the court notes. absent cases of fraud, defamation,
- 13:23and finding words. You know, you get a feel for
- 13:25this type of decision coming out of the courtroom
- 13:27at eight to one sort of majority here and you
- 13:30realize the chilling effect of it. Usually use
- 13:32the word chilling in regards to my analysis here
- 13:34in relation to how we chill First Amendment free
- 13:37speech. Not the case here though. This is chilling
- 13:39because what it allows Colorado or what it allows
- 13:43counselors to do and say in these specific settings
- 13:46against the backdrop of state health authorities
- 13:49and even state legislatures and a governor prohibiting
- 13:53such practices. That's the chilling effect here.
- 13:56My practice tip here is really quite clear. You
- 13:59want to anticipate more challenges on First Amendment
- 14:01grounds of specific guidance provided by health
- 14:03practitioners. You can bet on that going forward
- 14:05nationally. Things that states flat out don't
- 14:09agree with might be prohibited. Things that those
- 14:11counselors or others acting pursuant to First
- 14:13Amendment interests want to be able to do for
- 14:16the benefit of their patients as they see it,
- 14:18that will be challenged. And you've got to be
- 14:20able to counter with specific public health requirements
- 14:21for licensed practitioners. There's absolutely
- 14:24an argument here that works. It just didn't survive
- 14:26in this specific case of just how profound and
- 14:28compelling the interests are to avoid these specific
- 14:31types of interferences with standard of care.
- 14:35Our next case is First Choice Women's Resource
- 14:37Center versus Platkin. out of New Jersey. Now
- 14:40what's at work here is kind of interesting. A
- 14:41little bit of a procedural thing here, but to
- 14:43be sure, a very interesting outcome. What you
- 14:46have here is New Jersey's Attorney General issuing
- 14:48this opinion that demand donor information from
- 14:50a faith -based pregnancy center. First choice.
- 14:53They claimed that first choice, that is, claimed
- 14:55a First Amendment violation on a Section 1983
- 14:58action. Okay, it's all interesting, and that's
- 15:00all before us here in that regard. But what's
- 15:02really curious here is why New Jersey's issuing
- 15:04this opinion at all. They have a Reproductive
- 15:07Rights Protection Act. They believe First Choice
- 15:10was violating that in the type of guidance and
- 15:13information it was getting from donors in relation
- 15:15to that that was being distributed to persons
- 15:18coming to First Choice for specific care. So
- 15:20they're investigating First Choice. This opinion
- 15:22was the natural route to go. The state court
- 15:26upheld this opinion. Never even undertook the
- 15:30Constitutional claims. Wasn't worried about Constitutional
- 15:32issues at work here. Federal District Court,
- 15:34when First Choice switched this case over on
- 15:37a Section 1983 action, to Federal District Court,
- 15:40dismissed the claim as unright and Third Circuit
- 15:42Court of Appeals, affirmed. When the Supreme
- 15:45Court took the case up in mid -June of this past
- 15:48year, it did so on whether a Federal Court in
- 15:51a first filed action can hear the subject of
- 15:54a subpoena investigation as potentially violative
- 15:56of First Amendment freedoms under Section 1983,
- 15:59or do we have to wait for state court action
- 16:02and the enforcement of that subpoena? Now, what's
- 16:05at stake here, honestly, is privacy related concerns.
- 16:08In this case, maybe public health and reproductive
- 16:12rights interests, you know, underlie the nature
- 16:15of what and why. New Jersey Attorney General
- 16:17was after these specific records. Then maybe
- 16:21some would say well of course we got to get access
- 16:23to those records to know better what the sort
- 16:25of premier purposes were and who was supporting
- 16:27first choice on these specific messages. It could
- 16:30be damaging to patients under reproductive rights
- 16:32norms. But you know on the other side of it the
- 16:35next time this is going to be a public health
- 16:38entity or some other enterprise clearly trying
- 16:41to advance the health of individual patients
- 16:43and that to that degree could be the next up
- 16:46on this specific list. The privacy replications
- 16:49here are fairly profound. How much information
- 16:53can government get about donors to associations
- 16:57like this in a non -governmental sort of way?
- 17:00Well, the decision was very clear and it was
- 17:03very certain on a nono majority again, Justice
- 17:06Gorsuch writing that opinion that first choice
- 17:08absolutely can raise those constitutional violations
- 17:11under Section 1983. They do not have to comply
- 17:14with that subpoena to have standing. They have
- 17:16the ability to do it well before that the type
- 17:19of chilling effect Justice Gorsuch talks about
- 17:22in relation to having to even hear about or deal
- 17:24with these specific subpoenas impacts the association
- 17:28rights under First Amendment that donors would
- 17:30never necessarily respond to and want to see
- 17:32their data kept confidential. This is a partly
- 17:34client decision, again, realizing for this certain
- 17:37point. This does not work well in regards to
- 17:40protecting reproductive interests in New Jersey
- 17:41for the moment, but the fact is, again, this
- 17:44specific case is a two -way street. The next
- 17:47time that subpoena authority comes up, it's going
- 17:49to be against an entity that is attempting to
- 17:52maybe advance a public health objective. Let's
- 17:55say a pro -vaccine entity or otherwise. when
- 17:58and how government in another arena could actually
- 18:00access those data that's been shut down by this
- 18:02court because Section 1983 actions very much
- 18:05could come into play, as per my tip in relation
- 18:08to this specific decision. All right, and then
- 18:10our final one in this sort of standard of care
- 18:13arena is very interesting because we've never
- 18:18seen the Supreme Court make a statement on this
- 18:20specific front before. In Miller versus McDonald
- 18:23out of New York State, you've got Amish private
- 18:26school attendees challenging New York's, like
- 18:28California's, school vaccine mandate that absolutely
- 18:32does not allow religious exemptions. I mean,
- 18:34that's not happening in California right now
- 18:36and it's not happening in New York State. Now,
- 18:39these Amish parents allege that allowing medical
- 18:42exemptions, even though that's constitutionally
- 18:45required, way back to cases like Jacobson versus
- 18:48Massachusetts, but not religious ones, violates
- 18:50the First Amendment free exercise rights. That's
- 18:52their claim, that we have a free exercise interest
- 18:56in a religious exemption to vaccines affecting
- 18:59our kids going to schools pursuant to New York
- 19:02state law. Lower courts dismissed it. We've never
- 19:07seen that before. We haven't had any reason to
- 19:09actually issue a decision in that realm, nor
- 19:11has the U .S. Supreme Court ever issued a decision
- 19:14saying, that you have a First Amendment free
- 19:17exercise guarantee of religious exemption from
- 19:19vaccine requirements. But that question was what
- 19:23was presented before the court when it granted
- 19:26cert briefly in this case whether a law that
- 19:28categorically disallows religious exemptions
- 19:30but permits secular ones violates free exercise
- 19:34rights in the First Amendment. Now, let's remember,
- 19:37vaccination of kids for related conditions like
- 19:40measles and other fronts, so controversial as
- 19:43we speak now, represents standard of care. Any
- 19:46pediatrician who is within their right mind in
- 19:49relation to the interests of public health protection
- 19:51will suggest and demonstrate that that's within
- 19:55the standard of care. So the question is whether
- 19:57or not, again, we're going to allow religious
- 19:59exemption to that when it is not constitution
- 20:01required presently. What's interesting about
- 20:04the case is what happened. Everybody knew it
- 20:06was at stake. And you're seeing it nationally.
- 20:10States like Arizona, for example, right next
- 20:12door to California and states like South Carolina
- 20:15and Florida and Texas all have outstanding measles
- 20:18cases as we speak, some of which are becoming
- 20:20highly problematic. We're about to lose our long
- 20:23standing measles status as far as measles free
- 20:26as the United States for since the 1990s. We're
- 20:29about to lose that on an international scale,
- 20:31which is horrendous, all because of the uptake
- 20:34of exemptions. to vaccine -related mandates for
- 20:37school children and daycare, kids in daycare.
- 20:40This is reality now, and the consequences of
- 20:43this could be profound. What the U .S. Supreme
- 20:46Court did in this decision in a pericureum, in
- 20:49a quick, like, two -page decision, is something
- 20:52you often will see it do when it's not quite
- 20:54ready to make that choice but really wants to
- 20:57get better guidance from the lower circuit. Here
- 21:00the Second Circuit in New York State was told,
- 21:02you need to look again at this case. And in looking
- 21:06at this case, will you take a close look at Mahmood
- 21:09v. Taylor, our 2025 Supreme Court decision? That
- 21:12decision enjoined Maryland school practices that
- 21:14disallow parents to opt out of LGBTQ curriculum
- 21:18on religious grounds, First Amendment free exercise
- 21:21grounds. Said the court, Mahmood v. Taylor, parents
- 21:23get to opt out of that, Maryland. That same principle,
- 21:27says the U .S. Supreme Court, should be considered
- 21:30here in Miller. And what's really curious about
- 21:33it is it punted that case right back to the Second
- 21:37Circuit and the Second Circuit issued a decision
- 21:41within the very end of the Supreme Court term
- 21:44on June 30th. It's a stormy related situation
- 21:48now because of what the Second Circuit basically
- 21:50did. It literally said we did look at Mahmood
- 21:53v. Taylor. And we don't change our reasoning
- 21:56in relation to this. New York does not have to
- 21:59provide a religious exemption to vaccine requirements
- 22:03affected school kids in daycare. This case currently,
- 22:08based on information that we're seeing right
- 22:10now, very well could get appealed right back
- 22:13up to the US Supreme Court. And if that court
- 22:17takes this case again, and we're watching it
- 22:19very closely through our ASU Center for Public
- 22:22Health Law and Policy, if it takes that case
- 22:25again, it will do so, I predict, very capably
- 22:28to reverse. what it's seeing in the Second Circuit,
- 22:31potentially for the first time issuing a statement
- 22:33that there is a national First Amendment free
- 22:36exercise protection for religious exemptions
- 22:39of vaccines. Now that could be trouble with a
- 22:41capital T if that occurs because states like
- 22:43New York and California that do not allow those
- 22:47religious exemptions will have to change their
- 22:50game should we see that decision from the court.
- 22:52Watch for it. Let's see what this next term entails,
- 22:55but this was very dicey. That takes us into LGBTQ
- 22:58plus rights and discrimination related issues.
- 23:01The most sensational or one of the more sensational
- 23:03cases was exactly from the basis of what we just
- 23:07heard following Mahmoud B. Taylor. That's right
- 23:09out of California in Mirabelli versus Bonta.
- 23:14Here what you've got are parents that discovered
- 23:16their biologically female child had socially
- 23:18transitioned, including use of male pronouns.
- 23:21And they learned this. It is happening within
- 23:24California public schools. only after their child
- 23:27literally attempted suicide and got to the bottom
- 23:29of what's really at work here. California public
- 23:32schools knew about the situation, and in fact,
- 23:35under state law in California, as you all know,
- 23:37school officials cannot inform parents of their
- 23:41child's transition unless the child actually
- 23:43consents. So public schools were aware of the
- 23:47specific child's transition and did not inform
- 23:50the parents. It got so bad in relation to some
- 23:53of the dynamics here that we literally saw an
- 23:55attempted suicide situation. It's dire circumstances,
- 23:59but the parents sue and the sue on the grounds
- 24:02that the specific California state law infringes
- 24:05their first amendment free exercise rights or
- 24:08contributes substantive due process. That's the
- 24:10gist of what you see out of this specific case.
- 24:13We already know what's at stake as UCLA has done
- 24:15such a good job of documenting the hundreds of
- 24:18thousands of persons. across the United States
- 24:21who are transgender, identifying as transgender
- 24:25in some mode of transitioning from genders, something
- 24:29for which this is not limited to very specific
- 24:32minor circumstances. Tens of thousands of Americans
- 24:35in any given point in time undergoing transitionary
- 24:38processes. California's state law designed to
- 24:41provide some level of privacy protection for
- 24:43that against the backdrop of what can be very
- 24:46damaging and harmful parental practices at times.
- 24:50But the Supreme Court's decision in a per curiam,
- 24:55relying a lot on Mahmoud v. Taylor, the case
- 24:58we just mentioned a few moments ago, couldn't
- 25:00have been clearer. Those parents do have a free
- 25:04exercise right that was very likely infringed
- 25:07under strict scrutiny. In other words, California
- 25:10state law very likely cannot survive strict scrutiny,
- 25:13compelling interest analysis. contrary to substantive
- 25:16due process principles that uphold those parent's
- 25:20interests in their child's upbringing. Now, Justice
- 25:23Kagan was all over this in relation to her dissent,
- 25:26finding high levels of significant problems in
- 25:28regards to child privacy and protecting kids
- 25:31within these school environments. This is a dreary
- 25:35decision, though, because of some of what and
- 25:37how far this court is expecting California to
- 25:40go in relation to its rebooting it back to the
- 25:42Ninth Circuit for additional observations and
- 25:45findings highly consistent with what you would
- 25:48see in the movie Taylor example. Right now, we're
- 25:51not aware of any developments out of the Ninth
- 25:53Circuit since the case was sent back. We're watching
- 25:55that very closely, but to be sure, it's been
- 25:58told what exactly to do, and that California
- 26:01state law is unlikely to survive that analysis
- 26:03for sure. West Virginia versus BPJ was also coupled
- 26:09with the case out of Idaho I mentioned a moment
- 26:11ago, Little v. Hecox. Now, what you've got here
- 26:15are multiple states. That's what we've seen so
- 26:18many times in relation to patent discrimination
- 26:21in this specific case against transgender athletes.
- 26:26It's been one case after another before the U
- 26:28.S. Supreme Court on transgender related issues,
- 26:30including the notorious Scrimetti decision out
- 26:32of Tennessee from this past term. But in these
- 26:35cases, you've got states like West Virginia and
- 26:37Idaho basically passing these legislative acts
- 26:40of foreign brother governors that literally restrict
- 26:44transgender athletes, particularly males transgendering
- 26:46to female, from participating on all girls teams
- 26:50or biological girls teams. What you got in West
- 26:54Virginia is this young individual since third
- 26:56grade had identified as living as a girl and
- 27:00was excluded from her high school's cross country
- 27:02and track teams. She raised a lawsuit as did
- 27:07a person in Idaho who was college or collegiate
- 27:10level and since actually kind of stepped away
- 27:11from the case, but the case in this West Virginia
- 27:14setting got the Supreme Court's attention on
- 27:17whether or not that type of disallowance of a
- 27:21state that refuses to let a transgender female
- 27:25participate on all female and biological female
- 27:28teams, whether that violates the Education Amendment
- 27:30Act, Title IX, as well as equal protection principles
- 27:33that would prevent a state from distinguishing
- 27:35or offering sports teams based on biological
- 27:37sex determined at birth. Does federal law stop?
- 27:42West Virginia, Idaho, and multiple other states
- 27:45from prohibiting these athletes without any further
- 27:49distinction about what their quality of athleticism
- 27:52is or whether they actually are roughly comparable
- 27:54to biological girls when they attempt to compete.
- 27:57No distinctions, just flat -out ban. Is that
- 28:01violative of equal protection or Education Amendments
- 28:06Act Title IX? What's at stake here is not just
- 28:10about sports. Let's be clear on that. Discrimination
- 28:13of transgender persons in sports sure is at front
- 28:16and center of this specific decision, but we're
- 28:18seeing it in education and in business and employment
- 28:22and in health -related contexts as well. The
- 28:26question for us is how far might the court go?
- 28:30Previously, just a few years ago, Justice Gorsuch
- 28:32makes clear in Bostic versus Clayton County that
- 28:35you can't discriminate on the basis of LGBTQ
- 28:39status and employment settings. But will this
- 28:44court, literally with this decision, reassess
- 28:48the Bostic holding? Oh, that's what was on the
- 28:50table. How far will this go? Because oral arguments
- 28:54gave us pretty clear since US Supreme Court was
- 28:56not about to let these athletes compete in these
- 28:58specific arenas with the idea that they are protected
- 29:01under federal law for that purpose. That's exactly
- 29:04what we saw in Justice Kavanaugh in a more split
- 29:06decision here, 6 -3. Congress's clear prohibition,
- 29:09he says, of sex -based discrimination in federally
- 29:12funded athletics applies only to biological sexes,
- 29:16not transgender. transition persons, just biological
- 29:19sections. He notes that either Title IX or equal
- 29:22protection prevents states from limiting biological
- 29:24males from playing on female teams as a categorical
- 29:26prohibition. States can ban those athletes competing
- 29:30on female teams irrespective of whatever specific
- 29:32claims they make as to how much they are very
- 29:35much in line or akin to the persons in regards
- 29:38to the unique physical limitations. What he also
- 29:42makes clear, however, just as a note, is that
- 29:44states could also allow transgender athletes
- 29:46to compete. The Title IX or Equal Protection
- 29:49is not going to stop either one. This is a dark
- 29:52sort of outcome here though because of, just
- 29:54again, what we're talking about here, blanket
- 29:58patent discrimination against transgender persons
- 30:01based on simply who they are and what they're
- 30:05attempting to do. Now, how far this went was
- 30:08going to be the real question. Did it go so far
- 30:11as to overrule Bossick versus Clayton County,
- 30:13which provided Gosh, protections against this
- 30:16type of discrimination in employment settings?
- 30:19Why not in sports? Well, the court did make clear
- 30:21in Justice Sports that the Concurring Opinion
- 30:23clarifies too. We are not overruling Bostock
- 30:26here. That's not our purpose. This is solely
- 30:28limited to what Education Amendments Act and
- 30:30equal protection means in the sports -related
- 30:33arenas. State laws that allow transgender athletes
- 30:36remain lawful, but that could change. We'll see.
- 30:39and anticipate, I think, as a practice tip, a
- 30:41potential expansion of this discriminatory approach
- 30:43well beyond transgender persons in the near future.
- 30:46As often will remind us, if it can happen, this
- 30:49type of discrimination to persons who are transgender
- 30:51or transitioning, it can happen to other groups
- 30:54before this court. Wait and watch to see how
- 30:57far this court may go on these specific fronts.
- 31:01Gun control and Second Amendment has been before
- 31:03this court on so many different occasions. this
- 31:06year being no different. And to be sure, the
- 31:09case that you see out of Texas, United States
- 31:12District of Zimani, lays out for us yet another
- 31:15opportunity for the Supreme Court to stress just
- 31:17how critical and important the Second Amendment
- 31:19is, irrespective of the specific gain or attempt
- 31:23to actually provide meaningful public health
- 31:26and health -related protections, through here,
- 31:29in this case, the Federal Gun Control Act. passed
- 31:32years and years ago that prohibits unlawful uses
- 31:34of controlled substances from possessing firearms.
- 31:38So here you've got an individual, Humani. He
- 31:40was picked up as a felon, and he actually owns
- 31:43a firearm. He shouldn't. But most importantly,
- 31:46he was also picked up in regards to having marijuana
- 31:49on his possession, which is still a controlled
- 31:51substance on the CSA tables as we know. When
- 31:54that happened in Texas, they charged him under
- 31:56the Gun Control Act with a felony, and to be
- 31:59sure, he raises a Second Amendment claim that
- 32:01he can't be charged at all, because not what
- 32:04the Gun Control Act should allow is prohibiting
- 32:07unlawful uses of these substances for possessing
- 32:09firearms. That's in breach of Second Amendment
- 32:11interest. Cases dismissed in regards to the indictment,
- 32:16the circuit affirmed that. You have the U .S.
- 32:18literally appealing this to the Supreme Court
- 32:22of whether the GCA violates second amendment
- 32:24by allowing criminal charges for firearm possession
- 32:27against a person without evidence of any intoxication
- 32:30or unlawful use of a controlled substance. What's
- 32:33important in the facts here to understand in
- 32:35Omani is while the police found marijuana on
- 32:38his possession and plenty of it when they also
- 32:41found a firearm he wasn't under the influence
- 32:44at that point in time or at least wasn't proven
- 32:46to be and he's saying listen I present no risk
- 32:50to anybody when I simply possess something and
- 32:52then also own a firearm. The Gun Control Act
- 32:55is about preventing risks and that was not risky
- 32:57in that particular capacity. What's at stake
- 33:00here is, recognizing really the numbers, 20 %
- 33:03of gun owners in the United States, based on
- 33:05good reliable data, use drugs. And habitual drug
- 33:09users are more likely to commit crimes and misuse
- 33:12firearms. We also know that as well. Millions
- 33:15of Americans could actually legally own a firearm
- 33:17despite illegal drug use at the same time. That
- 33:21combination is deadly. From a public health perspective,
- 33:24the combination of illicit drug use and gun ownership
- 33:28has proven to be quite the deadly one, to say
- 33:30the least. But that's what we're going to have
- 33:33to live with, says Justice Gorsuch. And again,
- 33:36a surprising 9 -0 decision. The Second Amendment
- 33:40says the court here prohibits... and the GCA
- 33:43for mere possession of firearms and occasional
- 33:45use. Literally reading the statute more narrowly
- 33:48than maybe even Congress intended, but because
- 33:51of a legitimate Second Amendment interest to
- 33:54possess guns against the backdrop of no illicit
- 33:57specific harm caused to anybody under the court's
- 34:01Bruin and Rahimi tests, the Second Amendment
- 34:02rights here prevail. A very choppy approach.
- 34:06court still trying in Hamani to figure out what
- 34:09the appropriate tests are for how to apply second
- 34:12amendment protections against the backdrop of
- 34:15very real world public health related and health
- 34:17related concerns. A practice tip here is something
- 34:20to remember. If the federal gun control act does
- 34:24not allow for such prosecutions, state law does
- 34:27not either. So whatever and however California
- 34:29state law may have allowed for these prosecutions
- 34:31for illicit drug users owning guns, that's out.
- 34:35because the court makes clear her second amendment
- 34:37allows those persons under other circumstances
- 34:40unrelated to their use of those drugs to actually
- 34:43possess guns. And let's be clear on this. The
- 34:48US Supreme Court, they're not done on second
- 34:51amendment analysis. No. Right now, before the
- 34:54U .S. Supreme Court, we have several cases, in
- 34:56fact, two that have been approved for cert. We'll
- 34:58be hearing moral arguments on it. Vera Montes
- 35:01out of Illinois and Grant out of Connecticut,
- 35:03basically asking the question, can we even prohibit
- 35:06people, as Illinois and Connecticut do, and I
- 35:10dare say California, from possessing AR -15 machine
- 35:14gun type of weapons? Can we prohibit that? That's
- 35:18before the court as we speak. I think we know
- 35:21in the case like Hamani what the court's outcome
- 35:23of that's going to be, we shall see. Mulford
- 35:26v. Lopez out of Hawaii gives us a very different
- 35:29scenario and it's equally the outcome that we
- 35:32might have expected from this U .S. Supreme Court.
- 35:35What Hawaii does is bans carrying a firearm on
- 35:37private property that's open to the public, you
- 35:39know, like stores and theaters and stuff without
- 35:41express consent of property owners. In other
- 35:46words, you got to get the consent of the property
- 35:47owner owning private property to carry guns on
- 35:51board. That sounds logical, like if they came
- 35:54into a private residence, you would need to give
- 35:56consent for allowing that gun to appear. Gun
- 35:59advocates say, well, see, that violates the Second
- 36:01Amendment, presumably forbids us from carrying
- 36:03guns in public places without express permission.
- 36:06That can't be right in relation to what the scope
- 36:09of the Second Amendment should allow. Well, the
- 36:12lower courts had their day with it before it
- 36:14got to the U .S. Supreme Court on the question
- 36:16of whether the Second Amendment states may presume
- 36:18that firearms are prohibited on private property
- 36:20open to the public unless property owners affirmably
- 36:23authorize their possession. The oral arguments
- 36:26in the case rendered a decision highly consistent
- 36:28with the concerns you might have imagined. But
- 36:31following Bruin, the affirmative decision which
- 36:34the Supreme Court laid out this sort of antiquated
- 36:36test for what and how far the U .S. Supreme Court
- 36:39Second Amendment interests would extend back
- 36:41to historical norms, clarified ever so briefly
- 36:44in additional cases. The question was going to
- 36:47be whether you can actually prohibit firearms
- 36:49in these sensitive places like beaches and parks
- 36:52and bars and restaurants. States like Hawaii
- 36:54and California seek to do so. If you invalidate
- 36:58those laws, you're talking about concealed carry
- 37:01in a lot of places that states would not seek
- 37:04to allow. That's exactly what Justice Alito and
- 37:08a 6 -3 majority of the U .S. Supreme Court, however,
- 37:11will allow. It abridges, says Hawaii's law, that
- 37:14is, in the case. That abridges licensed gun owners'
- 37:17Second Amendment rights to come and go and say,
- 37:19please, for a private property open to the public.
- 37:21If you're going to open up that property to the
- 37:23public, you're going to allow those persons to
- 37:27carry weapons absent express postings to the
- 37:30contrary, which can be, as we know, politically
- 37:32divisive and something, you know, very much that
- 37:35a property or a Commercial enterprise may not
- 37:39want to have to post directly. Too bad, says
- 37:41the U .S. Supreme Court, Second Amendment interests
- 37:43override those specific concerns from a state
- 37:46perspective. You know, it's really just incredible
- 37:50how many times the court clarifies guns are everywhere
- 37:53and guns are allowed almost everywhere. Except,
- 37:57let's be clear on the practice tip here, where
- 37:59public property in regards to state and local
- 38:03government's interventions Even under D .C. versus
- 38:06Heller, when you're regulating public property,
- 38:09you know, state parks and local arenas and such,
- 38:12you have your strongest argument to limit gun
- 38:14possession with those specific settings. But
- 38:16in other arenas now, private property over the
- 38:18public, like stores and other groceries and such,
- 38:21no, we have problems keeping guns out of those
- 38:24settings under Second Amendment parlance here.
- 38:27All right, let's move on to our last major topic.
- 38:30Let's do so on the backdrop of thinking about
- 38:32public health liability. And in this case, another
- 38:36blockbuster theme of cases nationally that got
- 38:40significant attention before the U .S. Supreme
- 38:42Court in the case of Monsanto versus Dornel out
- 38:45of Missouri. The Federal Insecticide, Fungicide,
- 38:50and Rodenticide Act, FIFRA, preempts states from
- 38:55imposing labeling or packaging requirements on
- 38:58various different products. The types of things
- 39:00like, for example, would include Roundup, the
- 39:03most popular I think market -leading wheat killer
- 39:07product out there. And EPA maintains that Roundup's
- 39:10active ingredient, glyphosate, is not a carcinogen.
- 39:13A lot of entities disagree with EPA on that.
- 39:17International entities, multiple other countries,
- 39:19say it actually is. a carcinogen. And actually,
- 39:22as a result of that, they would require Roundup
- 39:24and other products containing it to include a
- 39:26specific cancer warning. Well, Roundup's not
- 39:28done that. Monsanto, its maker and Bayer, of
- 39:30course, the owner of Monsanto, have not put a
- 39:33cancer warning on it because EPA doesn't require
- 39:36it and that they don't have to put it on there.
- 39:38In fact, putting it on there would go against
- 39:40EPA indications. What you've got in Monsanto
- 39:45is plaintiffs receiving judgments Against Monsanto,
- 39:52for hundreds of thousands of dollars, I think
- 39:53it's a million dollar judgment against Monsanto
- 39:55in this specific case where Darnell was able
- 39:57to recover four cancer related issues, attributing
- 40:01them to Roundup and suggesting you violated our
- 40:05state -based labeling requirements in Missouri.
- 40:09The question here becomes whether state failures
- 40:12to warn claims are preempted by FIFRA following
- 40:15the determination by EPA that a cancer warning
- 40:17is not required. That's the question that got
- 40:20before the Supreme Court, pursuant to oral arguments
- 40:22in April, and a decision forthcoming. What's
- 40:25at stake? Couldn't be clearer. This is the next,
- 40:27or at least was the next, big series of cases
- 40:32with over 100 ,000 claims percolating nationally
- 40:35against Monsanto, tied to alleged cancers from
- 40:37these infected persons, using Roundup and other
- 40:40products containing glyphosate. This is big.
- 40:43I mean, this is asbestos big. that really can
- 40:47bankrupt enterprises because of potential harms
- 40:50here. Those cases are in serious trouble because
- 40:56what the U .S. Supreme Court does in its 7 -2
- 40:58decision authored by Justice Kavanaugh has flat
- 41:00out confirmed that FIFRA absolutely preempts
- 41:05contrary state -based labeling claims in line
- 41:08with congressional and EPA regulations and findings.
- 41:11Plaintiff state -based product liability claims
- 41:12based on failures to warn are consequentially
- 41:15Foreclosed. We're talking sunsetted. No more
- 41:19claims based on state -related labeling requirements
- 41:22when FIFRA and the EPA pursuant to it would not
- 41:26require the specific product roundup to actually
- 41:29contain a cancer -related warning. It shuts down
- 41:33hundreds or dozens, thousands of cases, just
- 41:35to be sure, on at least that violation of state
- 41:40-based labeling requirements. The practice tip
- 41:42here is profound. state -based liability claims,
- 41:46you've got to pass this threshold. If you want
- 41:49to seek state themes for liability related to
- 41:52products like these that are sold nationally,
- 41:54you're going to have to meet that threshold of
- 41:56finding out whether or not any existing statute,
- 41:59whether it's the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act
- 42:01or FIFRA or other fronts, overrides those state
- 42:05-based claims based on preemption analysis the
- 42:07court set forth in cases like Monsanto. And this
- 42:10court seems quite intent and assured. of wanting
- 42:14to provide that level of preemption analysis.
- 42:17It is reading provisions as you see within FIFRA
- 42:21and other particular federal statutes quite broadly
- 42:24to make clear that if EPA in this case did not
- 42:27find it necessary to issue that specific labeling
- 42:30requirement, then EPA was in its right mind and
- 42:33EPA controls the outcome of these specific decisions.
- 42:38That is a sunsetted case for sure because again
- 42:41of the numbers of claims not just in relation
- 42:45to this specific setting involving one product
- 42:48roundup, but the types of claims that are preempted
- 42:51at the state level by federal law of which Congress
- 42:53and the president will control for knocking out
- 42:56specific claims entirely. We see it in the gun
- 42:59related arenas. We see it related to generic
- 43:02drugs before the U .S. Supreme Court and here
- 43:05now in relation to these types of claims is particularly
- 43:08affecting often farmers in California and other
- 43:10places that have had widespread applications
- 43:13of Roundup and other arenas damaging and devastating
- 43:16at times as well. I hope that information gives
- 43:19you a lot to think through as you kind of assess
- 43:21what the major health law impacts were from this
- 43:24U .S. Supreme Court. in the prior term. My special
- 43:26thanks to my great colleague, Taylor Brown, who
- 43:28works with me closely on multiple of these issues
- 43:30at our ASU Center for Public Health Law and Policy.
- 43:33Just so you know as well, we regularly track
- 43:36these things and are doing so already for the
- 43:39next Supreme Court term, which will start here,
- 43:41of course, in just a couple of weeks in October.
- 43:43But this Court's already busy with a whole slate
- 43:45of additional new cases. We're tracking those
- 43:47carefully. I'll have a new update on our Center
- 43:49website. this Tuesday on September 15th with
- 43:53what we're seeing already as potentially dispositive
- 43:56cases in the health arena for this next Supreme
- 43:59Court term. Additional cases are always available
- 44:02for the Supreme Court or SCOTUS blog and do not
- 44:04hesitate to reach me via email at my address
- 44:07there below with any additional questions or
- 44:09comments not just on these cases but various
- 44:12different ones to come. Now with that said, let
- 44:14me turn it back over to Susanna for any additional
- 44:17or any questions or comments that you may have
- 44:19in the time period we've got to work with. I'll
- 44:21be more than pleased to address those. Susanna,
- 44:23are we seeing anything in regards to questions,
- 44:25comments arising from those attending today?
- 44:31Let me go ahead and see. I don't see anything
- 44:33here. Sometimes our viewers can be shy and send
- 44:36it over to our actual help desk through email.
- 44:38So just one second while I verify that. Great.
- 44:42Go ahead. Please don't hesitate. Be happy to
- 44:45address any specific questions on anything of
- 44:48what you've heard about or seen in regards to
- 44:50these specific issues or other ones that arise
- 44:52as well in regards to what the Supreme Court
- 44:55is doing currently in its current next term ahead.
- 45:33In the meantime, while I'm consulting with this
- 45:37list, Professor Hodge, do you have any other
- 45:41remarks or closing remarks or points that you
- 45:48would like to remind our audience? Yeah, there's
- 45:51one thing I think is worth noting, and you all
- 45:54probably are seeing it already in California
- 45:56especially, but the Supreme Court has already
- 45:58accepted CERT in regards to a case involving
- 46:02surrogacy in regards to a pregnant mother and
- 46:05a surrogate mother involved or a surrogate mother
- 46:07who's involved in specific privacy related debate
- 46:10and dispute out of Los Angeles. So that court
- 46:12or that case has gotten the court's attention.
- 46:14It will be hearing oral arguments on that. It's
- 46:17already something we're watching very carefully
- 46:19for the health related repercussions of it. The
- 46:22case seems to have a little more of a procedural
- 46:23element to it about what sort of access to information
- 46:26that a surrogate mother would get in relation
- 46:29to a specific child here, but To be sure, that
- 46:32case again out of California, one for which we're
- 46:35going to be watching very carefully over the
- 46:36next several weeks ahead. Expect more information
- 46:39on that as we kind of see just exactly what the
- 46:41Supreme Court digests over the course of its
- 46:44literally duration for the next term ahead. We're
- 46:47not sure when oral arguments are scheduled for
- 46:49that, but we're watching it very carefully. Alrighty,
- 46:55and I do believe I found some questions here
- 46:58for one. For counselors licensed in multiple
- 47:02states, does this ruling create a de facto national
- 47:09floor that overrides the 20 states with conversion
- 47:11therapy plans or only in the litigated posture?
- 47:14Yeah, interesting point for sure. Salazar is
- 47:17really quite clear. I'm just scrolling back to
- 47:19it as you all can see here briefly just to make
- 47:21sure we're very clear on what was said in regards
- 47:24to the impacts here. The court really just is
- 47:27very clear that you cannot restrict under First
- 47:32Amendment parlance on viewpoint -related discriminatory
- 47:35bases what even licensed counselors want to say
- 47:39in relation to this specific practice. Let me
- 47:42be really clear on just exactly what we think
- 47:44that means from this US Supreme Court. And a
- 47:47lot of my colleagues out there nationally are
- 47:48kind of digesting exactly how far this may go
- 47:51when you may have states, for example, that disagree
- 47:53with providing, say, for example, information
- 47:55about proper vaccines. Maybe that's something
- 47:58that states would like to restrict, even though
- 48:00we know fully the efficacy of vaccines for children.
- 48:03The reality of a case like this is to literally
- 48:06strip medical boards and California's Department
- 48:10of Public Health and others and the legislature
- 48:13from literally the ability to determine what
- 48:16the standard of care would be in a specific jurisdiction
- 48:19based on really good knowledge of medical associations
- 48:23and others of what is and is not safe for patients
- 48:26because a particular counselor or licensed personnel
- 48:30wants to provide that information. What's different
- 48:34here and important to note about a case like
- 48:36Charles, which does have national impact, no
- 48:38question about that. If California was to introduce
- 48:41anything like this or has anything like this
- 48:42on the books right now, you can consider it,
- 48:44I think, null and void, is the premise that if
- 48:47you're going to regulate the licensure of your
- 48:50state health practitioners in a way where you're
- 48:53limiting what they can literally just say about
- 48:56medical procedures, that's going to trip this
- 48:58wire. What they do Like, can you actually undergo
- 49:02surgical interventions in regards to these specific
- 49:06types of patients or otherwise? That's what we
- 49:08saw in Skirmetti, the Supreme Court, more than
- 49:10willing to allow Tennessee to stop that in its
- 49:13tracks. There was no viewpoint discrimination
- 49:15in relation to claim there. But if you're literally
- 49:17just talking about the sort of talking therapy
- 49:21or things that licensed practitioners may want
- 49:23to discuss with patients. The court took a very
- 49:27wide look at that saying that's the type of viewpoint
- 49:29discrimination that we can't allow to be restricted.
- 49:33The First Amendment interests are strongest when
- 49:35we have, you know, patients and doctors discussing
- 49:38options and things between them for the purposes
- 49:41of making those determinations. What's really
- 49:44problematic about it is we know these SOAR therapies
- 49:47are very damaging. This is not guesswork here
- 49:50as per that prior slide. Everybody who's within
- 49:54the sort of medical arena that has absorbed these
- 49:56specific conversion therapies over time, well
- 49:59outside of the sort of Christian perspective
- 50:01or otherwise, has found they can be really damaging.
- 50:05And the nature of how you allow that licensed
- 50:08practitioners to engage in therapies that are
- 50:11known to be damaging, that's what's really at
- 50:14stake here. I think one of the most interesting
- 50:17things about it that will apply in California
- 50:19and every other state around it is the premise
- 50:21that the moment a state determines just specific
- 50:24vocal interventions are the things which they're
- 50:27attempting to shut down. You're going to face
- 50:29a child's type of of a challenge. You're going
- 50:32to face that child that challenge because Charles
- 50:34sets out. a very chilling effect on that type
- 50:37of intervention. Watch out for it. Anticipate
- 50:40where and how it may impact the standard of care
- 50:42in California and other states. I hope that gives
- 50:45you a good sense of what the major concerns are
- 50:47related to this type of decision. Thank you for
- 50:49that question. Excellent one to ask. Anyone or
- 50:52any further questions that you're seeing, Susanna?
- 50:54Be glad to address them in our limited time left.
- 50:57Yeah, so let's see. Should states with religious
- 51:01exemption bans start building a more robust quote
- 51:04-unquote, compelling interest and least restrictive
- 51:08means. Record now, anticipating this issue returns
- 51:12to SCOTUS on the merits within a term or two?
- 51:15Yes, and quickly. I don't think we're going to
- 51:21wait around long for Miller v. McDonald to get
- 51:24back before the Supreme Court. And when it does,
- 51:28if the court accepts this case, which it did
- 51:31already. It just expected that its guidance back
- 51:34to the Second Circuit was sufficient to actually
- 51:36render what you're seeing here in this decision.
- 51:39And when it does, it expected, I think, the Second
- 51:43Circuit to properly assess what Mamou V. Taylor
- 51:46really means, and to give the court kind of an
- 51:49opt -out here, basically thrusting onto the Second
- 51:51Circuit what it intends to say itself, which
- 51:55is that there is sufficient First Amendment free
- 51:59exercise rights to basically avoid religious
- 52:05exemptions of vaccines as a blanket prohibition.
- 52:09maybe there's room for a state to actually say,
- 52:12well, only this type of religious exemption is
- 52:15allowed, or ones which are devoutly held, of
- 52:18which the denomination of the religious interests,
- 52:20for example, are well held by the entirety of
- 52:23those within that specific faith or such. Okay,
- 52:25maybe that's down the road for us to determine,
- 52:27but blanket prohibitions, like you see in California
- 52:30and in New York and a few other states still,
- 52:35those are definitely in trouble, I think, if
- 52:37this court takes Miller back. We believe, based
- 52:40on good information so far, that the plaintiffs
- 52:44that again lost at the Second Circuit level on
- 52:47the second time are planning to appeal to the
- 52:51U .S. Supreme Court for certification. And if
- 52:53they get that social area there, we dare say
- 52:57we're going to see the Supreme Court take this
- 52:58one on thoroughly with the more the conservative
- 53:01sort of perspective sufficient for votes to actually
- 53:05disallow blanket bans of religious exemptions.
- 53:09To answer your question as succinctly as possible
- 53:11based on that analysis, yeah, you better be ready
- 53:13for this. You better be ready for what and how
- 53:16you're going to keep vaccination rates high in
- 53:19states where measles and other fronts are already
- 53:22running rampant in particular arenas when religious
- 53:25exemptions might be something that every American
- 53:28parent or otherwise is entitled to request and
- 53:31or get, notwithstanding potential litigation
- 53:33around that. The challenge there is that profound.
- 53:37That's why I'm calling it very stormy here. The
- 53:40potential here is very strong. Let me be really
- 53:43clear in making that point as obvious as we can.
- 53:46To date, the U .S. Supreme Court has never affirmatively
- 53:49said that any American has a absolute First Amendment
- 53:53free exercise interest in avoiding or in getting
- 53:56a religious exemption to vaccines. That's about
- 53:59to change, I dare say. And if it does, it's going
- 54:02to change practices in a lot of states. I hope
- 54:04that helps a little bit, and I would definitely
- 54:06get ready. All right, and it looks like we have
- 54:12another question. This is regarding Monsanto.
- 54:16But state failure to warn claims foreclosed,
- 54:18what costs of action, if any, remain viable for
- 54:21the 100 ,000 -plus pending roundup plaintiffs?
- 54:25Design defect, negligence in EPA emissions, fraud
- 54:28on the agency theories? You know, that's a good
- 54:32question, because what the court really did hone
- 54:34in on specifically is the failure to warn claims
- 54:37in relation to state of Missouri law that would
- 54:39allow those warnings to be put into place, but
- 54:42FIFRA does not. FIFRA absolutely says the court
- 54:45preempts states from actually imposing those
- 54:47labeling requirements. So are there other themes
- 54:50for which liability could potentially arise that
- 54:54would be sufficient for the purposes of these
- 54:57mountain of claims that we've got out there?
- 55:00many of which are tied to failure to warn or
- 55:02various different issues along those fronts.
- 55:05That's a reasonably good question. We don't have
- 55:07the answer to that at this point in time in relation
- 55:09to what the breakdown of these claims are. They
- 55:11were out there based on failure to warn. We knew
- 55:14pursuant to FIFRA that they weren't going to
- 55:15be successful under the Federal Act, but the
- 55:17state law claims were out there. largely negated
- 55:20through the decision in Monsanto. So I don't
- 55:23yet know, and I apologize for that, that I can't
- 55:26yet predict whether or not other claims based
- 55:28on other state -related interests would survive.
- 55:31But I stand by my practice tip here. If they're
- 55:34going to survive, it's because you found a way
- 55:37around federal preemption. This court has a pension
- 55:42for finding preemption in relation to liability
- 55:45-related claims arising from states on national
- 55:48interests in products and other arenas where
- 55:51there are big stakes, very substantial amounts
- 55:54of resources at work here, the potential to literally
- 55:58bankrupt companies like Monsanto around these
- 56:00specific claims should they be successful and
- 56:02take off. This court has a penchant for preserving.
- 56:05some of the federal interests involved with that,
- 56:08and I dare say getting past that threshold is
- 56:11going to be increasingly difficult, even if you
- 56:13find that route under state law. Now, Congress
- 56:16could shut it down, and this court would absolutely,
- 56:19I think, endorse that based on its reading of
- 56:22FIFRA and other fronts. So let's just be conscientious,
- 56:24even if you do find that claim. Congress, under
- 56:27this administration, and currently before we
- 56:30have midterm elections or so could shut some
- 56:33of those claims down and maybe looking at those
- 56:35forefronts as well. So I noticed we're close
- 56:43to time. Do we have one final question that we
- 56:45want to handle, Susanna? Yeah, um, let's see.
- 56:48I see one here, um, across, is it Childs or Chile's
- 56:52first choice in Mirabelli? Is there a discernible
- 56:54pattern of the court treating, uh, quote -unquote,
- 56:57professional or administrative regulation as
- 57:01presumptively suspect wherever a religious or
- 57:03viewpoint -based motive can be alleged? If so,
- 57:06how should public health agencies draft rules
- 57:09to survive that scrutiny going forward? Nice
- 57:12point and I won't even try to bring those both
- 57:14those cases back up because the point's well
- 57:16stated and I think I can affirm it. Yeah, it's
- 57:19really nice theme and trend that you're seeing
- 57:21among this US Supreme Court. It has been pro
- 57:24First Amendment free exercise for several years.
- 57:26We saw this even back to some of the earliest
- 57:28decisions during the COVID arena where we saw
- 57:31free exercise interest come down and shut down
- 57:33certain social distancing mechanisms in California
- 57:35and New York and other places. So this court's
- 57:37had a very strong interest in preserving and
- 57:40sort of maximizing free exercise interests under
- 57:42First Amendment. When it can detect that a particular
- 57:46free exercise interest is at stake and under
- 57:50constraints by state law, like it saw in Maryland,
- 57:53like it saw in California in the Mirabelli decision,
- 57:56when it can frame this specific sort of breach
- 58:00of individual rights within the free exercise
- 58:02arena, generally what we're finding with for
- 58:04this US Supreme Court is free exercise wins and
- 58:07state public health and other health related
- 58:09interests. could lose. Now there are circumstances,
- 58:14and we certainly may see this in Miller versus
- 58:16McDonald involving the vaccination front, where
- 58:19possibly the sort of compelling interest, as
- 58:22we were just discussing, can override all free
- 58:25exercise interests, but I just don't see it.
- 58:27This court's been quite insistent on just how
- 58:31extensive those free exercise interests are.
- 58:33So, frame your specific public health intervention
- 58:36to the fullest degree possible in outcomes that
- 58:40do not implicate religious beliefs or values
- 58:45or other specific fronts. It doesn't mean they
- 58:48won't be castigated under those realms. And it
- 58:50doesn't mean that you won't be observed or at
- 58:52least potentially challenged on First Amendment
- 58:55free exercise. But when you literally disallow
- 58:58something like a religious exemption, or you
- 59:01disallow a specific parent with particular religious
- 59:04backgrounds from these specific enterprises or
- 59:06such, you're definitely running into trouble
- 59:08with this court. And to that end, reframing or
- 59:10rephrasing what the actual sort of public health
- 59:13objective is, that is divorced from, separated
- 59:16from, and not based on religious outcomes, you're
- 59:19getting yourself much further in regards to the
- 59:21potential to survive that scrutiny. I hope that
- 59:23helps in that regard. I know we're at the top
- 59:26of the hour, and we made promises to all of our
- 59:28colleagues that, for those who could attend with
- 59:30us today, we keep things within time. I want
- 59:32to thank you for the opportunity to address you
- 59:34today, and I want to thank you, Susanna and Nancy,
- 59:36for your great introductions. I will look forward
- 59:39to any additional questions or comments you may
- 59:41have at my email address there. Don't hesitate
- 59:43to reach me, and I look forward to hearing from
- 59:45you. Thank you again. Susanna, back to you. This
- 59:48concludes today's presentation. We'd like to
- 59:51extend our thanks again to Professor James Hodge
- 59:53for an excellent presentation today, and we'd
- 59:55love to also thank our audience for joining us.
- 59:57Have a great day, everybody.