Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #6 - What Could be the 28th US Constitutional Amendment?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to another episode of the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Reeder.
- 0:06Today, we're gonna talk about amendments to the US constitution.
- 0:11We've had 27 of them over the course of our more than 230 years under the US constitution.
- 0:18An extraordinarily difficult document to amend, but at some point, we'll probably see a 28th
- 0:24amendment to it.
- 0:25So what could it be, and when could we see it?
- 0:29Well, that's what we're gonna talk about today.
- 0:32So, obviously,
- 0:33we should first start with the process of amending the US constitution.
- 0:37So for an amendment to be become
- 0:41part of the constitution, First, it has to be proposed to Congress.
- 0:45Congress has to approve it, and then it has to be passed on to the states and be fully
- 0:51ratified after enough states
- 0:54pass it there.
- 0:55So two methods of proposal.
- 0:581 is 2 thirds of the US House and US Senate prove the amendment to become ratified at
- 1:06the next step, or a national convention is called by congress at the request of 2 thirds
- 1:12of the state legislatures.
- 1:14And then if it passes that point, the two methods of ratification are 3 quarters of the
- 1:21state legislatures, which is 38 out of 50 states, or special conventions called in 3
- 1:28quarters of
- 1:28the states approve the amendment for ratification.
- 1:33So a few quick ratification stats for you.
- 1:37The average number of years per amendment that actually gets ratified, there's been about
- 1:4212,000 amendments that have been posed at some point in congress.
- 1:50Very, very few of them even sniffed the ratification procedure.
- 1:55In fact, we've only had 33 that have been passed by congress, but only 27 of them have
- 2:01been fully ratified.
- 2:02So there's 6 that have at least gotten to the ratification stage but have not actually
- 2:07completed it.
- 2:08Average number of years per amendment, so 1789 was the year of full ratification of the US
- 2:14constitution.
- 2:14Prior to that, we had the articles of confederation, so 235 years divided by 27
- 2:21amendments.
- 2:22We average about one amendment being ratified every 8.7 years.
- 2:26But the first 10 amendments, which are the bill of rights, those were all ratified a little
- 2:33over 2 years after the constitution was ratified.
- 2:36So that was in 1791.
- 2:38So if we consider that statistic, we've seen 17 amendments over the course of about 233 years.
- 2:46So 233 divided by 17, average one amendment being ratified every 13.7 years.
- 2:55Now it's sometimes come in spurts where we've had bunch of amendments in a small, period of
- 3:04time, and then later on, more get
- 3:08ratified much further down the line.
- 3:11Not always, but in some cases, we've had them, bunched up.
- 3:16So how long does a state's passage of an amendment generally last or rather the time
- 3:21between a or an amendment getting passed by congress and then getting ratified by
- 3:29the states well, when congress passes it and ratification happens, those are two different
- 3:34things.
- 3:35So the shortest time frame has been about a little over 3 months for the 26th amendment
- 3:42from passage to ratification, which lowered the voting age to 18 years old.
- 3:48We'll mention that specific amendment a couple times, shortly, but the longest time frame on
- 3:54the other hand was 43 months, give or take a few days, which was the 16th amendment, which
- 4:00allowed for an income tax, another one that will be mentioned shortly.
- 4:06But some amendments that have been proposed but don't really go anywhere, there's been some
- 4:10rather curious ones.
- 4:13We have a point 003% rate of ratification for these amendments, and ones that have not even
- 4:18gotten close to that include polishing the US senate, which was proposed in 18/76, so that
- 4:24would have made congress unicameral.
- 4:26We have a US house and a US senate, so then we would have just had the US house if that
- 4:32actually got ratified.
- 4:35We had another one that would have renamed the US the United States of the Earth in 18/93.
- 4:41Interesting one.
- 4:42And, abolishing the US Army and Navy in the same year, 18/93.
- 4:46That was one that was proposed, and then there was one that would have made divorce illegal in
- 4:521914.
- 4:52So some
- 4:53of the more curious instances.
- 4:56But, again, those really didn't actually go anywhere.
- 4:59Now before we get to what could be the 28th amendment to the constitution, we should talk
- 5:05about the amendments that have come before.
- 5:07And you can think of them in several major groupings.
- 5:10Not they're not necessarily,
- 5:13for lack of a
- 5:13better term, objective where there are groups that are recognized by a wide swath of people.
- 5:20The bill of rights is is one that everybody recognizes, but there are some other ones that
- 5:25I've sort of made up on my own.
- 5:27Some people may consider them a similar grouping, but just just to make it easier for
- 5:33thinking about what kinds of amendments have come up in the past.
- 5:38Couple of them are commonly categorized groups, others not necessarily agreed upon, and a
- 5:44couple of these un, amendments that I've according to this system that I've just made
- 5:50up, they're ungrouped, which was the 11th amendment, which dealt with lawsuits between
- 5:55states, and then the 27th amendment, which dealt with
- 6:00congressional compensation.
- 6:01So the groupings that I've
- 6:05some partially just devised on my own and some that are recognized by others, the bill of
- 6:11rights, first 10 amendments, so those are things like the the freedom of speech, freedom
- 6:17of religion, press, assembly petition, the 5 freedoms that are in the first amendment,
- 6:24second amendment, right to bear arms, 4th, protections against legal searches and
- 6:29seizures, all those sorts of things, cruel and unusual punishment, protection against that in
- 6:34the 8th amendment.
- 6:37So a bunch of those kinds of things that we kind of just assume, we take kinda take for
- 6:43granted were in the bill of rights.
- 6:45And the fact that that bill of rights was not originally part of
- 6:48the constitution was one of the big points of opposition for the anti federalists, the people
- 6:56who posed
- 6:59scrapping the articles of confederation and replacing it with the US constitution.
- 7:02But a couple years after the constitution, federalists or people who supported the
- 7:07constitution promised that these bill that this bill of rights would get added later on, and it
- 7:13did in 17 /91.
- 7:14And but that was a big point of contention, in the debate over the ratification of the US
- 7:16constitution.
- 7:16And then the other group that's generally recognized as
- 7:27a group, by most other people is you have the Reconstruction era amendments, and
- 7:32Reconstruction era refers to the post civil war, specifically, years, so late 18 sixties,
- 7:3918 seventies.
- 7:40The re Reconstruction era amendments were the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments.
- 7:45Those mostly addressed racial inequality, so 13th amendment.
- 7:49Slavery, obviously, a long time coming, should have been done well beforehand, but it wasn't
- 7:55until right around the very end of the civil war that slavery was abolished outright.
- 8:0215th amendment granted the right to vote for all males regardless of race.
- 8:08Women's right to vote wasn't until several amendments later, but the 14th amendment, while
- 8:14it's mostly known for the equal protection clause, It's got kind of a wide scope.
- 8:19It it also deals with civil war debts and and preventing people who have been, convicted of
- 8:28insurrection and rebellion against the government from being from being able to
- 8:35hold office as president, vice president, US senate, US house, or even
- 8:42other offices at the state and local level unless congress, 2 thirds of each chamber of
- 8:49congress, decide to override that its ability, but mostly known for the equal protection
- 8:55clause.
- 8:56And then you
- 8:56have the progressive error amendments, 16th, 17th, 18th, and 19th amendments.
- 9:01That's some people would probably recognize that as a group of amendments too.
- 9:06So 16th amendment instituted an income tax.
- 9:0917th amendment changed the changing of US senators so that instead of being appointed by
- 9:14state legislatures, which is how it originally was done, they are now directly elected like US
- 9:20house or president it is by voters.
- 9:25Now it's a direct election as opposed to the state legislatures using their states' US
- 9:30senators.
- 9:3218th amendment prohibited alcohol, consumption of alcohol, sale of alcohol, distribution of
- 9:38alcohol, and the 19th amendment instituted the women's right to vote.
- 9:42So the progressive era was marked by widespread social and political activism in the early
- 9:471900, particularly against big business.
- 9:51Progressives of then and progressives of today, they do have some similarities.
- 9:56Their ethos is somewhat similar, but some of the issues are a
- 10:00little bit different, for example, back then until 1920
- 10:05with the ratification of the 19th amendment where women were granted the right to vote.
- 10:11Some states did allow women to vote, but not all of them.
- 10:14So that was an issue back in that day.
- 10:16Obviously, now women can't vote, and they actually tend to vote at much higher well, not
- 10:22necessarily much higher rates, but they tend to vote at higher rates than men do now.
- 10:27And then you've got the 2 alcohol related amendments, 18th being both part of this group
- 10:33and the progressive error group.
- 10:34A few of these amendments are could be considered part of a couple of groups.
- 10:39And then the 21st amendment repealed prohibition, and it's the only time we've
- 10:44actually had a one amendment repeal another amendment.
- 10:47And you've got the presidential related ones.
- 10:49These are more nonconsecutive, so they weren't in rapid succession.
- 10:52The 20th, 22nd, and 25th amendments.
- 10:55The 20th is most known for changing what they call the lame duck period.
- 10:59Federal government, which is that time frame between when the next batch of federal elected
- 11:07officials is elected and when the previous ones actually end their term.
- 11:13So now that's shortened and terms for federal officials end in January.
- 11:1722nd amendment then changes it or or modifies it so that presidents can only be elected
- 11:24twice, or they could actually serve up to 10 years if they take over past the halfway point
- 11:30of the previous president's term.
- 11:33So 4 years is a full presidential term.
- 11:36Halfway would be 2, and then they can still get elected twice.
- 11:39So it can be up to 10 years that a president can actually serve.
- 11:44And then the 25th amendment, which clarified procedures for succession to the presidency if
- 11:49the president is incapacitated in some way.
- 11:51They resign.
- 11:52They impeach.
- 11:54They pass away in some way.
- 11:57The 25th amendment clarified these procedures, and part of what really was the impetus for
- 12:04that was the assassination of, JFK.
- 12:08Then finally, we have the voting related group of them.
- 12:12So we have, again, the 15th amendment, voting rights regardless of race, 19th, regardless of
- 12:19gender you are.
- 12:2126th amendment lowered the voting age to 18 years old, but we also had the 23rd amendment,
- 12:27which was which granted electoral votes to the DC area as if they were a state, and then the
- 12:3424th amendment, which abolished poll taxes.
- 12:36And poll taxes were a method of, particularly southern states, to try to suppress the black
- 12:45vote.
- 12:46So what they did was you tried to vote.
- 12:48You had to pay tax in order to vote, and you might think that, well, doesn't this also apply
- 12:56to poor white voters?
- 12:57Well, a way that southern states got around that was, for example, grandfather clauses and
- 13:03where if their grandfather was allowed to vote, then they didn't have to pay these poll taxes.
- 13:09So very insidious ways that black voters were deprived of the right to vote, but,
- 13:16technically, they still had it.
- 13:19In name, they had the right to vote.
- 13:21They had suffrage, but in reality, they couldn't actually do it.
- 13:26And if they weren't, even if they weren't poor voters, there are still all sorts of voter
- 13:31intimidation tactics that were used against them as well.
- 13:34So before we actually get into the potential 28th amendment that we may see in the future,
- 13:41Let's talk about how we can evaluate the likelihood next amendment to the US
- 13:46constitution.
- 13:46There's no clear cut way of this is how you need to hit these particular points, but these
- 13:53are things to consider if you're if, for example, if you're supporting one of these
- 13:59amendments and you're actually trying to get it passed.
- 14:02So one is the subject being addressed a particularly controversial one in some way,
- 14:09especially if it's got a
- 14:11partisan or ideological charge to it, if it has a discernible bench, not even necessarily in
- 14:17terms of support.
- 14:17Maybe some support is across the aisle, but
- 14:19there's still one party that's still particularly opposed to that amendment, you're
- 14:27unlikely to get enough states to back it, especially in today's polarize climate.
- 14:32So one thing to consider there.
- 14:36Number 2 is a little bit little bit obvious, but what are the exact details?
- 14:41So get more specific with that.
- 14:43How specific or general does the amendment get?
- 14:47So broadness of the topic must be accounted for.
- 14:5014th amendment is much broader in scope.
- 14:52I guess, it's got a wider scope than, say, the second amendment, which deals specifically with
- 14:58firearms.
- 14:5914th amendment deals with the equal protection clause, but also civil war debts and ins
- 15:04insurrection and a couple of other things.
- 15:05I can't remember all the time of
- 15:06my head.
- 15:08Also the length
- 15:08of the amendment, 11 amendments amendments have at least 2 sections.
- 15:12So they go section 1, blah, blah, blah, section 2, blah, blah, blah.
- 15:16Some amendments are incredibly short.
- 15:18None of them are particularly long, but some of them are very short, and others are
- 15:22a little bit wordier.
- 15:24So
- 15:25length of the amendment must be considered and, similarly, wording of the amendments.
- 15:30So the phrasing matters, especially when it comes to legalese, lawyers find all sorts of
- 15:34ways to try to interpret the meaning of law to suit their whims.
- 15:41That's what lawyers do.
- 15:43So you need to account for exactly how you phrase these amendments because that could make
- 15:49or break whether they, a, get passed by congress, but, b, certainly, whether they get
- 15:54ratified by the states.
- 15:57And then the usage of numbers, some, not all, but some of these amendments deal with specific
- 16:04numbers that refer to things such as the proportion of congress that needs to support
- 16:08something, the number of officials that are affected, age, dates that these amendments take
- 16:15effect, 3, what are the previous policies and precedents regarding the amendment, whether
- 16:21it's federal or state level?
- 16:23Is it something the US constitution or other federal law has specifically addressed before?
- 16:27Does it say anything regarding this particular subject area that the amendment would be
- 16:34addressing?
- 16:35Is a constitutional amendment been tried for it in the past?
- 16:37There's about 12,000 of them that have been tried at some point.
- 16:42Has have any of them referred to what exactly the subject area your amendment is about?
- 16:51Had has have any of those amendments address that subject area?
- 16:55Number 4, is there a particularly strong movement at the state or local level regarding
- 16:59what that amendment would address?
- 17:01So the timing of these amendments is also very critical as the what we call the zeitgeist
- 17:07zeitgeist can make it easier or even just possible at all to ratify these amendments.
- 17:14And by zeitgeist, that's basically the spirit of the times.
- 17:18As times change, zeitgeist changes a lot.
- 17:21You gotta account for those kinds of things when you have future amendments that you're
- 17:25considering as well, like, expanding suffrage to black voters or voters of any race, to
- 17:33women, to 18 year old, that sort of thing.
- 17:37And one of these time frames that you can really look at as a as a perfect example is the
- 17:43progressive era, like the income tax and the direct election of US senators.
- 17:49The progressive era made those was perfect timing for those kinds of amendments to be not
- 17:56only passed by congress, but then ratified by the states.
- 17:59And then lastly, would it be a, for lack of a better term, quote, unquote, better approach
- 18:05for each individual state to amend their respective state and constitutions in this
- 18:10manner?
- 18:11And we'll obviously talk a a little bit about that with more specific examples.
- 18:15But is it even something that's in the purview of the states that the states could even
- 18:19address?
- 18:20Because there might be some things where the states can address it, but in other times, they
- 18:25can't.
- 18:25So now, finally, we'll go into some of the potential candidates for the 28th amendment.
- 18:31Now there's probably think of a whole slew of candidates that might make for that that have a
- 18:39decent chance of becoming the next amendment, but I've I've just chosen 4 in particular that
- 18:45I think might make sense as a next amendment.
- 18:47Now I'm not saying that there's something I I support or I don't support.
- 18:52It's just based on the various factors that I I've included about evaluating the likelihood
- 18:58of these amendments.
- 18:59These seem to be more likely than most other ones to become, the next amendment, whether
- 19:06that be the 28th one or another one down
- 19:08the line.
- 19:09So the first one
- 19:10to talk about is the equal rights amendment, and this is a very unique situation because of
- 19:15the uncertainty surrounding whether ratification by some states previously still
- 19:21counts for this amendment.
- 19:22This is one of those 6 amendments I mentioned that were passed by congress but did not quite
- 19:28get the number of states it needed.
- 19:30So a brief history of the ERA is in 1972, congress approves the ERA.
- 19:37The original deadline to be ratified was for 7 years.
- 19:40It got extended until 1982, by which point only 35 states had ratified it by that deadline.
- 19:4838 were needed.
- 19:50Those 3 states may have now ratified it.
- 19:54The state of Nevada in 2017, Illinois in 2018, and Virginia in 2020 just ratified it in in
- 20:02those in those years and argued in court that the archivist of the US could publish and
- 20:08certify those amendments or the their equal rights amendment as part of the constitution.
- 20:14So they took court.
- 20:16US district court for DC dismissed the case saying the states lacked standing to invoke the
- 20:23court's jurisdiction, and then that was upheld by the US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit.
- 20:29So there's still a lot of debates as to whether congress can remove that original ratification
- 20:35deadline and whether the 35 ratifications before the deadline still stand.
- 20:40So these were ratifications made in the mid to late seventies, even early eighties.
- 20:48That in a lot of cases, vastly different governments than what they are now in terms of
- 20:54partisan and ideological leaning and just the kinds
- 20:58of people that that represented them.
- 21:01So do those ratifications still stand?
- 21:05That's the subject of a lot of debate, but,
- 21:09you know, we'll we'll we'll see we'll see where those go.
- 21:11So let's go back to the considerations, those five considerations I brought up for the ERA.
- 21:17So is it controversial, number 1, and it's the fact that it that there are legal arguments
- 21:24regarding it has kinda clues you in as to whether or not it's controversial.
- 21:30The the biggest point of contention is whether the ERA allows for abortion, not only for
- 21:39abortion, but basically abortion up until fetal viability or even up until birth.
- 21:47So we'll talk about the details of the ERA.
- 21:50It's a it's a very short it's got 3 sections, but they're all very short.
- 21:54So section 1 says equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the
- 21:59United States or by any state on account of sex.
- 22:02Section 2, the congress shall have the power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the
- 22:07provisions of this article.
- 22:09Section 3, this amendment shall take effect 2 years after the date of ratification.
- 22:13Now you'll notice that abortion was not specifically mentioned in the amendment, but
- 22:19going back to how specific or general an amendment is, there's some debate as to whether
- 22:26or not abortion is in the purview of the ERA, and possibility of abortion was a prominent
- 22:34part of the campaign against the ERA, particularly by Phyllis Schlafly, who was the
- 22:41public face of the campaign against the ERA.
- 22:44And now with transgender policies also becoming, more and more salient, now those
- 22:51might also be considered part of the ERA's purview.
- 22:53So, again, it's not about whether or not it's it's a good or bad amendment.
- 22:59That's for you to decide.
- 23:01But those kinds of controversies have been very effective at stopping it from becoming wholly
- 23:09ratified.
- 23:10So regarding previous policies, obviously, the states have all had their various, they've
- 23:16addressed the these kinds of gender issues in various ways, particularly with abortion, and
- 23:23and whether those previous ratifications still stand is debated.
- 23:27And if whether they still stand has huge ramifications for the possibilities for the ERA
- 23:35to be passed.
- 23:36Otherwise, this or to be completely ratified by the states.
- 23:40If those don't stand, then it's there's a long road for the ERA to have to go back and get,
- 23:46passed by all those or not passed by congress again and then to become ratified by all those
- 23:51states again.
- 23:53So grassroots movements, again, for number the 4th consideration, there's strong grassroots
- 23:59movements both for and against it.
- 24:01There were back in the seventies eighties, and there's if the ERA picks up steam again, you
- 24:08can you can guarantee that those grassroots movements on both sides of the aisle are gonna
- 24:14pick back up for it again.
- 24:16And should it be state level for the last consideration?
- 24:20That's it's pretty hard to say.
- 24:23It's because of all those reasons we talked about before where, you know, how much do those
- 24:29ratifications from previous states still stand, and is it
- 24:37what exactly is in the purview
- 24:39of the ERA that's still debated?
- 24:41So it's really hard to say for sure whether the better,
- 24:47quote, unquote, approach would be to have the states do add their own ERAs to their state
- 24:54constitutions.
- 24:56So second of 4 potential amendments we'll talk about is term and or maximum age limits for
- 25:02congress.
- 25:03So the first numbered episode of this podcast, technically episode 2 due to my intro episode
- 25:08that described the podcast, centered on these age limits for congress specifically.
- 25:14So considerations, is it controversial?
- 25:17Doesn't seem to be the case, but that doesn't mean it can't be in the future.
- 25:22Age limits probably be more controversial than term limits, and as always, I'm not saying that
- 25:28they that we should or shouldn't have them.
- 25:30That's for you to decide.
- 25:32So the details of such an amendment, should it address both term and maximum age limits, or
- 25:38should it just focus on term limits, or should it just focus on age limits?
- 25:42If we focused on term limits, how many terms would term limits allow for?
- 25:48Would they be consecutive or cumulative?
- 25:50So consecutive meaning, let's say we have 4 terms be the term limit.
- 25:56So you
- 25:56can serve 4 back to back to back to back terms.
- 26:00You can then you'd have to sit out for a term, and then you can run for it again.
- 26:05Cumulative, on the other hand, if it was those 4 terms, you'd serve those 4 terms in the US
- 26:11house, and then that's it.
- 26:12You can't serve in the US house ever again.
- 26:16So would it be a consecutive or a cumulative
- 26:20term limit?
- 26:22Is it a different term limit for the US House and the US Senate yet to account for the stark
- 26:27differences in the term lengths of these offices?
- 26:31US House, 2 year terms.
- 26:34US Senate, 6 year terms.
- 26:37Previous policies, federal and state level, both have some examples of this, so it has some
- 26:44support from federal officials, but not
- 26:47a whole lot of actual movements, save for nonprofits like US term limits.
- 26:52And at least for state legislatures, 16 states have term limits for their state legislators.
- 26:58North Dakota, I believe, was the one that just became the most recent one.
- 27:02And then you have the grassroots movements, or are there grassroots movements?
- 27:08So, again, US term limits is probably the most visible nonprofit.
- 27:11There's probably some other groups that are involved in it as well.
- 27:14And then is this something that should should it be addressed by states in their state
- 27:19constitutions?
- 27:21So North Dakota in 2022 just passed a state constitutional amendment that limits members of
- 27:26congress to being 81 years old.
- 27:30Probably start to see some more states at least try to pass a constitutional amendment similar
- 27:34to that, whether it's 81 years old or maybe something like 75.
- 27:39We'll have to see.
- 27:41But right now, North Dakota is the only one that's taken that far of a step to actually
- 27:45address the age of their members of congress.
- 27:49So 3rd potential amendment, sort
- 27:52of similar to congress, is term limits for the US Supreme Court or SCOTUS for short.
- 27:58So currently, SCOTUS justices have lifetime terms, though they can be impeached or retire.
- 28:04The idea back when the framers of the constitution were making it especially are
- 28:10argued especially vociferously by Alexander Hamilton.
- 28:14Yes.
- 28:14That Alexander Hamilton in I forget which federalist paper it is, but the idea is it
- 28:19would shield justices from political pressures if they had lifetime terms.
- 28:23But that view has been called into question in your sense, especially in more recent decades
- 28:28as supreme court confirmations have become much more bitter partisan and ideological battles.
- 28:37So now should they actually have terms or not not just term limits, but actual term lengths.
- 28:47So controversy, probably gonna be gonna be more so than for congress given that SCOTUS was
- 28:52explicitly designed to be a lifetime appointment, and then you also got all into
- 28:59question about the separation of powers and checks and balances being how power is divided
- 29:04between the executive branch, which is president and cabinet, legislative branch being
- 29:09congress, and the judicial branch being the courts.
- 29:13Does it upset that balance in some way?
- 29:16Does it tip the scales of checks and balances towards the
- 29:19executive or legislative or both branches in comparison to to to the judicial branch?
- 29:27That's up for debate.
- 29:29Details be how long do we make these terms, and should they be staggered for each of the 9
- 29:33justices, or would it be we have 3 justices that are appointed again at the same
- 29:39or at the same time, or is it just one every 2 years or every 1 year?
- 29:45So previous policies, mostly, you see them at
- 29:48the state level where state level governments have term lengths for their justices.
- 29:55They have also mandatory age limits, but don't have earned limits, term lengths, but not term
- 30:01limits.
- 30:02So their term is for a certain period of time for a
- 30:06lot of these states.
- 30:07And then there's a bunch of
- 30:09them that also have mandatory age limits, so they can serve up until they're 70, 75, however
- 30:16many years old a state has it set for.
- 30:19But at the federal level, Democrat Ro Khanna of California introduced a bill back a few years
- 30:25ago for 18 year terms for SCOTUS justices, and one would be appointed every 2 years, but the
- 30:32bill didn't really go anywhere.
- 30:34It's it sat in
- 30:35one of the judicial subcommittees.
- 30:38So that didn't really go anywhere.
- 30:40Would a bill like that pick up more steam again, or would it have
- 30:44to be a constitutional amendment?
- 30:46Grassroots movements, the most visible group is probably the non profit fix the court, which
- 30:51seeks those 18 year terms with, or those 18 year terms and each justice being appointed or
- 30:58one justice being appointed every 2 years.
- 31:02And lastly, should it be a state level thing?
- 31:05This wouldn't be even in the purview of the states because the state governments don't
- 31:10actually have any jurisdiction
- 31:12over SCOTUS, so this is probably gonna have to be a
- 31:17constitutional amendment, if not
- 31:20a congressional bill.
- 31:22But, again, with that congressional bill, there may be those that issue of the separation of
- 31:27powers and checks and balances, so it may have to become a US constitutional amendment for
- 31:33that to actually become a reality.
- 31:34And then lastly, we'll talk about campaign finance reform, specifically independent
- 31:39expenditures.
- 31:40So these independent expenditures, also called super packs, they can raise and spend unlimited
- 31:45amounts of money in support of or in opposition to a candidate or a
- 31:50ballot measure as long as they do not coordinate with those campaigns.
- 31:58One of my former adjunct professors calls it orange jumpsuit rule.
- 32:02If you break it, you will be going to jail, and you will
- 32:04be doing some hard time
- 32:06or at least for a long time.
- 32:08So it's a big no no for these campaigns.
- 32:11These independent expenditures coordinate with the main campaign.
- 32:14So a super PAC for Donald Trump can't coordinate with Donald Trump's campaign.
- 32:19A super PAC for Kamala Harris can't coordinate with Kamala Harris's campaign.
- 32:24If they do, there will be some serious legal repercussions for them.
- 32:28So controversy, probably hard to say with complete accuracy, but public opinion seems to
- 32:34be pretty decidedly against independent expenditures.
- 32:38However, these committees that engage in independent expenditures are certainly going to
- 32:43be against it, and they're gonna spend exorbitant amounts of money to try to stop this
- 32:48amendment dead in its tracks, stop congress from even passing this amendment so it can't
- 32:53even have a chance at being ratified by the states.
- 32:57And then elected officials are often against these super pacs too because it's an easy way
- 33:03to get political brownie points until these super pacs start benefiting them.
- 33:08Then it's, you
- 33:08know, it's not it's not such a big deal anymore.
- 33:11So
- 33:13it you the public opinion is probably not gonna be too much of an issue.
- 33:17It's whether people elected officials are gonna actually take the step of banning these
- 33:24independent expenditures.
- 33:27So details, would super PACs be eliminated outright?
- 33:31Would the amount of contributions and spending simply be capped?
- 33:34What would that cap be?
- 33:36So several different moving parts to consider for that Previous policies.
- 33:41So here, you've got several court cases that you've gotta contend with, the rulings in these
- 33:46court cases.
- 33:47So all the way back in 18/86, we had the Santa Clara County versus Southern Pacific Railroad
- 33:52Company case, which ruled ruling recognized corporations as people with all the rights that
- 34:00entailed.
- 34:00And then particularly important and relevant for independent expenditures, Citizens United
- 34:08versus Federal Election Commission in 2010, the ruling there protected corporations from
- 34:14certain government regulations, and that's what really paved the way for these independent
- 34:19expenditures.
- 34:21So as for grassroots movements, I couldn't find a specific nonprofit that pushed for a
- 34:26constitutional amendment to ban independent expenditures, but I'm there there's undoubtedly
- 34:32groups that are gonna try to make that a reality given the public outcry against the
- 34:37Citizens United ruling.
- 34:40And then lastly, should it be a state level issue, or do they put it in the state
- 34:44constitutions?
- 34:46Given that the these federal courts have ruled that these independent expenditures are okay,
- 34:52it's probably gonna be considered unconstitutional for a state to try to ban
- 34:56independent expenditures.
- 34:57So it's going to have to be a US constitutional amendment, most likely.
- 35:03So that does it for these, the talk about amendments.
- 35:07So gonna end it off with the random question of the day.
- 35:12So
- 35:12the random question of the day is, what is the superior font type for electronic documents?
- 35:19I've I've become an aerial guy over the years.
- 35:23Calibri is also okay too.
- 35:25I used to
- 35:25be much more of a Times New Roman guy.
- 35:27Nothing against that, but I've I've taken to aerial and Calibri a lot more.
- 35:32Just just don't don't do Comic Sans because you cannot possibly be taken seriously if you use
- 35:38Comic Sans.
- 35:40And then, yeah, Wingdings are kinda funny, but nobody can read them.
- 35:43So, I mean, don't don't answer that either.
- 35:46But,
- 35:48I mean, I guess you can, but don't don't don't don't use Comic Sans.
- 35:52That's just you can't be taken seriously if you do that.
- 35:56But, anyways, that's gonna do it
- 35:58for this episode.
- 35:59Once again, as always, thank you so much for tuning in.
- 36:04Please like, comment, share, subscribe, share with all your friends and, so that they can
- 36:10hear me yammer on about all sorts of political topics because I like to I like to think I'm
- 36:17I'm really good at that
- 36:17at least.
- 36:18But may may maybe I'm not as good at
- 36:21that as I think I am.
- 36:22But any anyways, thank you so much again for listening.
- 36:25You can follow me on Facebook at Paul Raider, comma, author, and speaker.
- 36:31Also on LinkedIn, I write on medium.com about political science topics always from a
- 36:36nonpartisan lens, of course, and then my website, paulrader.org.
- 36:41And as always, catch my podcast every week.
- 36:46And, that's gonna do it for today.
- 36:49So until next time, take care.