Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 57: Talks Denied — But Iran Is Already in the Room
Transcript
- 0:16Iran's foreign minister is in Islamabad not to meet the
- 0:20Americans, his government spokesperson made that explicit.
- 0:25There are no plans for a meeting between Iranian and United
- 0:28States negotiators in Pakistan. And yet Arachi is there, on the
- 0:32ground in the building, meeting Pakistani officials while that
- 0:36same government insists no talks with the Americans are planned.
- 0:39Two things are true simultaneously.
- 0:42The meeting is happening. The meeting is not happening.
- 0:47That contradiction is not confusion.
- 0:50It is strategy. And it is the most important
- 0:53thing to understand about where this war stands on Day 57.
- 0:57Because the gap between those two sentences is exactly where
- 1:00the question of war or peace is being decided right now.
- 1:04It is Saturday, April 25th, 2026, day 57 of Operation Epic
- 1:10Fury. The ceasefire holds.
- 1:13The naval blockade continues. Arachi is in Islamabad.
- 1:17The Americans are not in the room.
- 1:20What passes between Pakistan and Iran this weekend will shape
- 1:23whether a second round of negotiations happens at all, and
- 1:26whether this conflict moves toward resolution or stalls into
- 1:29a prolonged, weaponized standoff.
- 1:32This is episode 57 of Epic Fury, the US Iran war podcast.
- 1:37Follow on Spotify, an Apple podcast to stay with this story
- 1:41as it develops. Start with Arachi's Islamabad
- 1:44visit because it is the most operationally significant
- 1:47diplomatic development since the ceasefire extension on Tuesday,
- 1:50and because the way Iran is publicly framing it tells you
- 1:53almost as much as the visit itself.
- 1:56Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Arachi flew to Islamabad on
- 1:59Friday and met with Pakistani officials, including Foreign
- 2:03Minister IS Shakhtar. CNN confirmed the meeting from
- 2:07footage of Arachi's arrival at the Pakistani foreign ministry.
- 2:10Iran's Foreign Ministry spokesperson Ismail Beguai then
- 2:13issued a statement calibrated with precision.
- 2:16There are no plans for a meeting between Iranian and United
- 2:19States negotiators in Pakistan. Iran's observations would be
- 2:23conveyed to Pakistan. The foreign minister is meeting
- 2:27with Pakistani officials in support of their ongoing
- 2:29mediation and good offices for ending what he called the
- 2:32American imposed war of aggression.
- 2:35That statement does three things at once.
- 2:37It confirms Arachi is an Islamabad, a fact cameras have
- 2:41already recorded. Impossible to deny.
- 2:44It explicitly rules out any direct encounter with the
- 2:47Americans, cutting off any impression that Iran is
- 2:50responding to Trump's ceasefire extension by going to the table.
- 2:53And it frames the entire visit as support for Pakistan's
- 2:57mediation role, not as a diplomatic concession to the
- 3:00American position. Iran is telling its own public
- 3:03and its hardline military establishment one thing.
- 3:06We are not sitting across from the Americans.
- 3:09We are talking to Pakistan. Pakistan will carry our
- 3:13observations wherever they need to go.
- 3:15That distinction matters enormously inside Iran.
- 3:18Going to Islamabad to support Pakistan's mediation is not the
- 3:22same as going to Islamabad to negotiate with the United
- 3:25States. The difference is real.
- 3:28Its preservation is precisely what makes the civilian
- 3:31diplomatic channel domestically defensible.
- 3:34Whether the Americans ultimately receive what Iran conveys
- 3:37through Pakistan is a question of mechanics.
- 3:40The principle that Iran has not gone to the table under American
- 3:44pressure remains intact, and that principle is what keeps the
- 3:48IRGC from moving to block the civilian track entirely.
- 3:52Consider what preceded this 4-5 days after the ceasefire
- 3:56extension. On Tuesday, Iran maintained what
- 3:58CNN described as virtual silence.
- 4:01No formal response to the extension.
- 4:04No communication with American officials.
- 4:07No indication that a delegation had been authorized to board a
- 4:10plane. The three to five day private
- 4:13window that United States officials communicated to
- 4:15reporters on Wednesday came and went without public rupture.
- 4:19The administration did not restart bombing.
- 4:22On Friday, the ceasefire held. And then also on Friday, Arachi
- 4:27flew to Islamabad. Not to the table, to the city,
- 4:32not to the Americans, to the Pakistanis.
- 4:35That precision is deliberate. The IRGC hardliners who spent
- 4:40this week dismissing the ceasefire extension as a ploy
- 4:43and preparing what they describe as new military cards cannot
- 4:46credibly object to the foreign minister meeting a trusted third
- 4:49party mediator. The civilian track advances.
- 4:53The internal veto does not trigger.
- 4:56The channel stays open without anyone in Tehran having to
- 4:59publicly admit it is open. There is something else the
- 5:03Iraqi DAR meeting delivers, something the United States has
- 5:06not had since the ceasefire extension on Tuesday.
- 5:09A current, direct, in person Iranian communication about
- 5:13where Tehran actually stands. Not the public posture of
- 5:16contempt and silence that has defined Iran's visible conduct
- 5:20all week. Not Galabaf's advisor calling
- 5:23the extension a ploy. Not the Foreign Ministry
- 5:26spokesperson announcing no meeting is planned.
- 5:29Not the IRGC seizing vessels in international waters.
- 5:33What Iran conveys privately to Pakistan, and what Pakistan then
- 5:37conveys to Washington, is the actual Iranian position,
- 5:40stripped of the domestic performance that every public
- 5:43statement requires. That position will determine
- 5:46whether there is a second round of negotiations and when.
- 5:50To understand what Arachi is signaling in that private room,
- 5:53it is necessary to map the five issues that remain unresolved,
- 5:57because these are not abstract diplomatic topics.
- 6:00Each one is a barrier, and each barrier, if it cannot be moved,
- 6:05is a reason the war continues. The first barrier is Iran's
- 6:09nuclear program. Whether Iran will end all
- 6:12enrichment activity, as the United States demands, or retain
- 6:15A civilian enrichment capacity under international inspection,
- 6:19as Iran insists, is its sovereign right.
- 6:21This is the issue that launched the war.
- 6:24It remains the hardest gap to close.
- 6:27The second barrier is Iran's ballistic missile program. the
- 6:30United States wants significant constraints on range and
- 6:34payload. Iran has offered nothing on this
- 6:36front, and its negotiating history suggests it will resist
- 6:40any agreement that leaves it unable to threaten Israel or
- 6:43United States regional bases. The third barrier is the Strait
- 6:47of Hormuz, reopening it, fully clearing the mines, establishing
- 6:51A governance framework for unimpeded commercial transit,
- 6:54and ending the IRGCS pattern of vessel harassment and seizure.
- 6:58The 4th barrier is Iran's support for armed proxy groups,
- 7:02the network financing and arming Hezbollah, the Houthis, Hamas,
- 7:05and multiple Iraqi militias. Proxy dismantlement is the issue
- 7:09Iran's hardline military establishment is least likely to
- 7:13accept. It strikes at the Irgc's entire
- 7:16regional doctrine. And the 5th barrier is sanctions
- 7:19relief and reconstruction, the sequencing of when economic
- 7:22pressure is eased relative to Iran's compliance steps and the
- 7:26unresolved question of who bears the cost of rebuilding the
- 7:28Iranian infrastructure destroyed in the strikes.
- 7:31Iran's civilian population is living with that destruction
- 7:35every day. The sequencing of relief will be
- 7:37a central test of whether any agreement is politically
- 7:40survivable inside Iran once it is signed. 5 barriers.
- 7:45All five were on the table across the 21 hours of the first
- 7:48Islamabad round. None were resolved.
- 7:51The Iraqi DAR meeting is Iran's opportunity to signal which of
- 7:55the five it is prepared to move on and to test whether the
- 7:58American position has shifted in any of them since Vance flew
- 8:01home. The answer will determine
- 8:03whether there is a second round and when.
- 8:06Trump said on Thursday that he could make a deal with Iran
- 8:09right now, but is willing to wait for what he called an
- 8:12everlasting agreement. He also pledged that the United
- 8:15States military would destroy any vessel found laying mines in
- 8:18the Strait of Hormuz, a direct warning about a specific Iranian
- 8:21capability that has been one of the central constraints on
- 8:24global shipping since the war began.
- 8:26The mines laid at the start of the conflict remain a physical
- 8:29hazard in the Strait. Trump's pledge defines what
- 8:32comes next. Any future mine laying attempt
- 8:35will be treated as an active act of war requiring an immediate
- 8:39military response. The everlasting framing deserves
- 8:42attention on its own terms. It is the latest in a series of
- 8:46formulations Trump has used across 57 days to describe what
- 8:50a final agreement must look like.
- 8:52Unconditional surrender in March.
- 8:55No enrichment at the April 8th press conference.
- 8:59Far better than the JCPOA in mid-april.
- 9:04And now everlasting. Each iteration has shifted from
- 9:08the last. Unconditional surrender is a
- 9:10maximalist war demand. No enrichment is a specific
- 9:14nuclear condition. Far better than the JCPOA is a
- 9:18relative benchmark. Everlasting is something
- 9:22different. It is an aspiration about
- 9:24duration rather than a statement of specific conditions.
- 9:28It describes how long the agreement must hold, not what it
- 9:31must contain. That shift matters.
- 9:34Everlasting is a formulation Iran civilian diplomatic track
- 9:38can potentially engage with in a way that unconditional surrender
- 9:41cannot. An everlasting agreement, one
- 9:44that resolves the nuclear question, establishes A
- 9:46governance framework for the Strait of Hormuz, addresses
- 9:49sanctions, and creates a regional security architecture,
- 9:52is not inherently incompatible with Iran retaining A civilian
- 9:56nuclear program under permanent international inspection.
- 9:59If what Trump means by everlasting is that the
- 10:01agreements constraints must be permanent rather than time
- 10:04bounded, no more 10 year JCPOA sunset clauses that expire and
- 10:08leave both sides renegotiating under worse conditions then the
- 10:11distance between Washington stated position and what Iran
- 10:14civilian track could accept. Maybe smaller than the public
- 10:17rhetoric has suggested all week, the JCPOA is fatal.
- 10:20Flaw, in the view of many analysts, was precisely its
- 10:24temporality. An agreement that removed limits
- 10:26on a timeline gave Tehran a pathway back to nuclear breakout
- 10:30capacity without violating its terms.
- 10:33If both sides have now internalized that lesson,
- 10:36everlasting may represent more common ground than it first
- 10:39appears. Whether Trump and Iran civilian
- 10:42diplomats are using the same word to describe the same thing
- 10:45is precisely what Arachi is in Islamabad to help Pakistan
- 10:48understand. Pakistan will then carry that
- 10:51understanding to Washington. That is the function of the
- 10:55channel. On Saturday morning, the five
- 10:58barriers remain. Arachi is in the city.
- 11:01Pakistan is in the room. Turn now to Netanyahu because
- 11:05the Israeli Prime Minister released information on Thursday
- 11:09that reframes the entire leadership picture of the past
- 11:12two months. Netanyahu revealed he was
- 11:14diagnosed with early stage prostate cancer during a routine
- 11:18checkup and has successfully undergone treatment.
- 11:21He said he kept the diagnosis secret for two months.
- 11:24Through the 1st wave of strikes on February 28th, through the
- 11:27escalation of March, through the ceasefire announcement on April
- 11:308th, through the 1st Islamabad round on April 11th, through the
- 11:34Lebanese ceasefire, the naval blockade and the ceasefire
- 11:37extension. Specifically because he did not
- 11:40want the news released at the height of the war with Iran.
- 11:42The 76 year old Prime Minister said the delay was intended to
- 11:46prevent what he called more false propaganda against Israel.
- 11:50The medical situation itself is not a governing incapacity.
- 11:54Early stage prostate cancer with successful treatment does not
- 11:57prevent Netanyahu from functioning as Prime Minister.
- 12:00He has been publicly active throughout, but the secrecy
- 12:04carries its own weight. It confirms that the Israeli
- 12:07government was managing 2 entirely separate information
- 12:10environments during the war's most intense phase, the military
- 12:14and diplomatic environment visible to the public, and a
- 12:16parallel environment known only to Netanyahu's innermost circle,
- 12:20which other Israeli officials were informed were allied
- 12:23governments told. Those questions will persist.
- 12:27The timing of the disclosure is not incidental.
- 12:30Netanyahu chose to reveal his diagnosis the day after the
- 12:34Lebanon ceasefire extension, a diplomatic development that
- 12:37reflected positively on his leadership announced at the
- 12:40White House with Rubio and Vance flanking him.
- 12:43He chose a moment of relative political strength when the
- 12:46international optic was favorable and the domestic
- 12:49pressure slightly reduced. Leaders do not choose random
- 12:52moments to release sensitive personal information.
- 12:56They choose moments that serve a purpose.
- 12:58Netanyahu chose this one on the humanitarian dimension.
- 13:02The World Food Program issued a warning on Friday that global
- 13:05acute food insecurity is at alarming and deeply entrenched
- 13:09levels across 10 countries, with the outlook for the remainder of
- 13:122026 described as bleak. Sudan is particularly exposed.
- 13:16It imports more than half its fertilizers by sea from the
- 13:19Persian Gulf region, and the WFP confirmed that food shipments to
- 13:23the country are being diverted through a longer Red Sea route,
- 13:27adding time, cost and logistical uncertainty to supply chains
- 13:31that were already fragile before February 28th.
- 13:34Food prices in Gaza are 85% higher than before the Iran war
- 13:38began. The scale of what 57 days of
- 13:41Straight of Hormuz closure has done to global food systems is
- 13:45broader than the headlines suggest.
- 13:47Fertilizers transit the Gulf, grain shipments route through
- 13:51the region, fuel for irrigation, industrial inputs for food
- 13:55processing, all priced against oil.
- 13:58When the world's most important energy choke point closes, the
- 14:01cost of everything connected to it rises.
- 14:04Those costs fall hardest on populations with the least
- 14:07capacity to absorb them. They do not appear in the daily
- 14:11military briefings. They do not generate satellite
- 14:14imagery or casualty counts, but they are as real a consequence
- 14:18of this conflict as anything happening in the Strait itself.
- 14:22The 10 countries the WFP identified as facing the most
- 14:25alarming levels of acute food insecurity are Afghanistan,
- 14:29Bangladesh, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Myanmar,
- 14:32Nigeria, Pakistan, South Sudan, Sudan, Syria and Yemen.
- 14:37Several have no direct military connection to the Iran United
- 14:41States conflict, but they're connected to it through the
- 14:44global commodity and energy systems the Strait of Hormuz
- 14:47underpants. The humanitarian cost of this
- 14:50war is not measured only in the casualty figures from Iran,
- 14:53Lebanon and the Gulf states. It accumulates in food security
- 14:57indices and countries. The architects of this operation
- 15:00have probably never visited the UAE.
- 15:03IS presidential advisor Anwar Gargash said on Friday that
- 15:06rebuilding trust between Abu Dhabi and Tehran will take ages
- 15:09and ages after Iran targeted the United Arab Emirates during the
- 15:13conflict. That is a striking formulation
- 15:15from a senior official in one of the Gulf's most pragmatic
- 15:18governments, one that spent years carefully calibrating its
- 15:21relationships with both Washington and Tehran.
- 15:24Maintaining economic ties with Iran while sustaining its
- 15:26security partnership with the United States ages and ages is
- 15:30not diplomatic hyperbole. It is Abu Dhabi telling the
- 15:33region that the pre war normalization dynamic in which
- 15:37Gulf states were gradually rebuilding ties with Tehran, has
- 15:40been set back by years. That damage matters for any
- 15:44permanent settlement. A deal that ends the Iran United
- 15:47States military conflict but leaves the Gulf states exposed
- 15:50to Iranian proxy networks, missile threats and IRGC
- 15:54harassment in international waters is not a framework the
- 15:57regional architecture can sustain.
- 15:59Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Bahrain, Kuwait and Qatar all need to be
- 16:03embedded in whatever regional security structure a permanent
- 16:07agreement creates. The UAE statement is a measure
- 16:10of how much work on that regional dimension remains
- 16:12undone, work that no single Islamabad session between Vance
- 16:16and Gallabaf can produce by itself.
- 16:19Secretary of State Rubio said on Friday that Iran's footballers
- 16:22will be welcome at this year's World Cup, the tournament Co
- 16:25hosted by the United States, Canada and Mexico this summer,
- 16:29distancing the administration from a proposal that Italy could
- 16:32take Iran's place in the competition.
- 16:34The statement is a small but deliberate signal.
- 16:37Iran's National Football team competing in a World Cup on
- 16:40American soil while a diplomatic process is attempting to resolve
- 16:44a war between the two countries is a potent image of what
- 16:47normalized relations could look like.
- 16:50Rubio saying Iran's players are welcome is a message directed
- 16:53not at Tehran's government, but it ordinary Iranians following
- 16:56football, a signal that the United States draws A
- 16:59distinction between the regime and the people.
- 17:02On a day when Iran's foreign minister is in Islamabad, soft
- 17:05signals accumulate weight. Lebanon's ceasefire extension,
- 17:09announced with considerable ceremony just 24 hours earlier,
- 17:12is already fracturing. Israeli forces struck southern
- 17:16Lebanon on Friday, killing three people in strikes confirmed by
- 17:20the Lebanese Health Ministry. The Israel Defense Forces said
- 17:23it targeted Hezbollah rocket launchers in the towns of Yader
- 17:26and Kafra that posed a direct threat to Israeli soldiers and
- 17:30civilians. Hezbollah responded with a
- 17:32rocket salvo at the Stola settlement in northern Israel,
- 17:35citing Israeli violations of the ceasefire and the destruction of
- 17:39homes in southern Lebanon. Israel's United Nations
- 17:42Ambassador Danny Dannon had cautioned on Thursday that the
- 17:45extension was not 100% certain. Within a single day, both sides
- 17:50were formally accusing the other of violation.
- 17:54The extension is 3 weeks long. At this rate of deterioration,
- 17:58it may not survive 3 days. CNN satellite imagery published
- 18:02on Friday captured what that deterioration looks like from
- 18:05altitude. By April 23rd, the center of
- 18:09Bench Bale, one of the main towns of southern Lebanon, have
- 18:12been completely flattened. Buildings standing in April 14th
- 18:16imagery had been reduced to rubble.
- 18:18By the 23rd 9 days of operations, compressed into two
- 18:22satellite photographs, the human geography of southern Lebanon is
- 18:26being physically erased at a pace that imagery makes
- 18:29viscerally legible even from space.
- 18:32The pattern is already asserting itself.
- 18:35The previous 10 day Lebanon ceasefire reportedly recorded
- 18:38more than 10,000 violations in its first week alone.
- 18:42Every Israeli strike generates A Hezbollah response.
- 18:46Every Hezbollah response generates an Israeli strike.
- 18:49The framework permits Israel to respond to threats.
- 18:53Hezbollah asserts the right to resist.
- 18:56Neither condition is compatible with a sustained cessation of
- 18:59hostilities. Whether the three-week extension
- 19:02survives this cycle or collapses faster than the 10 day version
- 19:06ever placed is a question the next 72 hours will begin to
- 19:09answer. What the Lebanon track
- 19:11demonstrates, regardless of outcome, is the structural
- 19:14difficulty of managing multiple simultaneous ceasefire
- 19:17frameworks, each with its own dynamics, its own violations,
- 19:21and its own domestic political pressures, while attempting to
- 19:24construct a broader diplomatic resolution.
- 19:27The Lebanon front does not exist in isolation.
- 19:30It is entangled with the Iran negotiation, with Hezbollah's
- 19:34calculation about what Tehran instructs it to do, and with
- 19:37Israel's willingness to accept constraints on its military
- 19:40freedom of action in the South. A Lebanon ceasefire that
- 19:44collapses is not merely a Lebanon problem.
- 19:47It is pressure on every other part of this conflict
- 19:50simultaneously. Take the full picture of Day 57.
- 19:55Arachi is in Islamabad. Iran's observations are being
- 19:59conveyed to Pakistan. The Americans are waiting for
- 20:02Pakistan to carry those observations further.
- 20:05The blockade continues global active, costing Iran an
- 20:09estimated $500 million per day. Mines remain in the Strait of
- 20:13Hormuz. Netanyahu is recovering from
- 20:16cancer treatment he kept secret through two months of war.
- 20:19The World Food Program is warning of acute food crises in
- 20:23countries ten time zones from Tehran.
- 20:25The Lebanon ceasefire was extended by three weeks and
- 20:29violated within 24 hours. The UAE says the damage to Gulf
- 20:33Iran Trust will take ages and ages to repair.
- 20:37And an everlasting agreement between the United States and
- 20:39Iran remains the stated aspiration of the man who
- 20:42launched this conflict, who compare its potential duration
- 20:45to Vietnam and Iraq, and who this morning is waiting for Iran
- 20:48civilian diplomat to finish his meeting with Pakistan's
- 20:51mediators before finding out what Tehran has decided to say.
- 20:55The five barriers remain. The channel is open, but open
- 20:59channels do not resolve wars. What matters is what moves
- 21:03through this one. This weekend, before Washington
- 21:06decides whether the silence from Tehran has gone on long enough,
- 21:09that answer is not yet known. It will be known soon and when
- 21:14it arrives, it will determine whether this conflict enters a
- 21:16second round of talks or whether the blockade tightens, the
- 21:20pressure escalates, and the window that opened in Islamabad
- 21:23closes again. If this podcast is helping you
- 21:26make sense of what's happening, take 2 seconds to leave a five
- 21:29star rating on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 21:32It makes a huge difference to how many people find the show.
- 21:36This has been episode 57 of Epic Fury, the US Iran war podcast.
- 21:42Day 57. Arachi is in Islamabad.
- 21:46He is not meeting the Americans, he is meeting Pakistan.
- 21:51Those are two different sentences.
- 21:53The distance between them is where the diplomacy lives right
- 21:56now. The next episode will tell us
- 21:59whether that distance is closing or growing.
- 22:02We will be back very soon.