Latest / The Counter Momentum of Spin, with Dr. Franco Musio / The crucial turning point in the Russia-Ukraine war
Transcript
- 0:13On the America Out Loud News Talk Radio Network, the counter-momentum of spin.
- 0:19I'm your host, Dr.
- 0:20Franco Musio.
- 0:21To our friends listening in the U.S.
- 0:23and around the world, today's topic is front and sub center, really is in global news, almost daily twists and turn.
- 0:30Well, not almost.
- 0:31There are daily and even more frequent than that.
- 0:35The title is the crucial turning point in the Russia-Ukraine war, particularly in light of the most recent 28 uh point U.S.
- 0:44proposed peace plan.
- 0:45I'm thrilled to reintroduce a leading expert in this topic, Ambassador Kenneth Yellowitz.
- 0:51Ambassador Yalowitz was a career foreign service officer from 1966 to 2001 and served twice as U.S.
- 0:59ambassador to the Republic of Belarus from 1994 to 1997 and to the country of Georgia from 1998, 2001.
- 1:09Other overseas assignments include Moscow twice, and very importantly in 1991 at the time of the breakup of the Soviet Union.
- 1:17So he was actively on the ground, so to speak, uh there, not so to speak, he was on the ground, and he was, and there's no better expert on this topic than him.
- 1:27So since his retirement from the State Department in 2001, well, has he remained active?
- 1:34Absolutely.
- 1:35Uh very active academically teaching at the School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University, Dartmouth University, and currently at Virginia Tech and Washington and Lee Universities.
- 1:46He doesn't want me to talk about this, his accomplishments, honors, interviews, articles written, uh, all of that would fill up this program.
- 1:53So, Ambassador, thank you so much for joining us and willingness to share your experience, your insights on the war, which uh, oh my God, more and more complex.
- 2:07Well, thank you very much again for having me.
- 2:10Uh I thoroughly enjoy uh these conversations and uh look forward to the continuation today.
- 2:17Absolutely.
- 2:18Thank you myself, myself as well.
- 2:20So we spoke last time about uh we didn't include Zelensky, we did just for a moment, but uh seeing the war through his prism and the prism of um Ukraine.
- 2:32We'll speak about the 28-point peace plan shortly, in just a moment.
- 2:36But um just as kind of an introduction to that, and the circumstances culminating in this plan.
- 2:44Uh I hand it to you.
- 2:46You're the expert.
- 2:49Very good.
- 2:50Thank you.
- 2:51Um let's begin with a a brief uh bit of history.
- 2:55Um the instigator of this war, uh, the attacker uh, you know, is Russia.
- 3:03Uh it really began in twenty twenty thirteen, twenty fourteen, uh, when the Russians uh annexed Crimea and then fomented um, you know, an uprising, uh civil war, if you will, uh in eastern Ukraine.
- 3:20Uh that war, you know, I had a uh very uneasy ceasefire until 2022, uh, when uh Putin launched a full-scale invasion uh of Ukraine.
- 3:34We're coming up almost to four years.
- 3:37Yeah.
- 3:37And uh this is going to be a very good thing.
- 3:39He called it, I'm sorry, but he called it an inter he called it an invitation, didn't he, or special military operation.
- 3:45He called it a special military action.
- 3:48Actually, he did that because uh their expectations at the time uh were that this war would be over very quickly, that the Russian army would overwhelm uh the Ukrainians, and that the Russian soldiers, you know, would be welcomed as you know, as heroes uh on the main streets of of uh Ukraine.
- 4:09That of course did not happen because what that overlooks is a very uneasy relationship between uh Ukraine and Russia since they both became independent, uh, but even longer ago.
- 4:23And as I said, the Russians expected an easy victory.
- 4:27Um what they what what their aims are, and they have not changed at all over the years, you know, are to get rid of the Zelensky government, probably to assassinate him, uh, to make sure that uh uh Ukraine never becomes a member of NATO, that it has a very limited, you know, military force, uh, you know, that there are no foreign troops uh, you know, on Ukrainian soil.
- 4:53That means NATO troops, um and that uh uh Ukraine would basically be a puppet state of Russia.
- 5:01Uh the Russians have never uh accepted the fact that Ukraine is an independent country.
- 5:08Uh ever since 1991, there have been machinations, you know, to undermine its sovereignty and to weaken its control, say over uh Crimea, but the military action obviously is a far, far more serious threat.
- 5:25Yes.
- 5:25And as I said, what they expected was that their troops are going to march in and decimate, you know, the Ukrainians.
- 5:31Yes.
- 5:32That did not happen.
- 5:33The Ukrainians fought back very, very well.
- 5:36And for Ukraine, their aims are also very, very clear.
- 5:40They want their land back.
- 5:42They want Russia punished.
- 5:44Uh you know, they want uh uh Russia to have to pay compensation, you know, for all of the uh damage, you know, that they have done.
- 5:53Yes.
- 5:54Uh they have been uh wanting to see Mr.
- 5:56Putin uh condemned and tried as a war criminal.
- 6:00Uh and those are the things, you know, that are are very important to them.
- 6:04And the loss of territory, the loss of Crimea, those are unacceptable, you know, to the Ukrainians.
- 6:11Right.
- 6:12And they very bravely fought back after the initial Russian invasion.
- 6:17They went on the offensive and did well, then it bogged down.
- 6:22And what you have is this slog warfare, you know, right now that is really going on for about two years.
- 6:30Uh the Russians are still using uh mass techniques, you know, to try to gain small amounts of territory, yeah.
- 6:38And the Ukrainians are using, you know, drones, more sophisticated uh equipment to attack in the rear of Russia, and what they're doing is trying to knock out its energy infrastructure the same as the as the Russians uh are doing to Ukraine.
- 6:56Right.
- 6:56So um the the question is why, you know, this war has had a million casualties on the Russian part, and probably a quarter to a third of that on the Ukrainian side.
- 7:08Both economies are hurting.
- 7:10The Russians have been sanctioned.
- 7:12Why is it you know that they have not yet been able, you know, to come to agreement on a ceasefire?
- 7:18Well, I'm I'm not I'm not in your shoes.
- 7:20I'm gonna interrupt.
- 7:21I apologize for interrupting you, Ambassador.
- 7:24You're gonna say it probably is the the pendulum has swung to their side, uh, at least militarily.
- 7:31We'll we'll talk about that a little bit later.
- 7:33This moment as we speak.
- 7:35I I I think, yeah, this is what Putin believes.
- 7:39Um, you know, he does not worry about casualties, he does not worry about losing men and meat grinders.
- 7:45No.
- 7:46Um, his aims have not changed whatsoever.
- 7:50And the various ideas that have been put forward for a ceasefire, he refuses to accept.
- 7:56He wants uh uh uh acceptance of Russian conquest of territory to come before a ceasefire, and that is unacceptable, you know, to Ukraine and and everybody else.
- 8:09Of course.
- 8:10So as I said, he uh he does believe that time is on his side.
- 8:15Russia is a bigger country, more people, uh, more probably more armaments, and he is willing to accept these casualties again because he does not accept Ukraine as an independent state.
- 8:29He has stated this over and over again that Ukraine is part of Russia, and that's where it belongs.
- 8:36So you you when you when you get diametrically opposing war aims like this, you're not going to have uh a peace solution, particularly when the military balances you said, it's slightly in favor of the Russians, but it is not decisive.
- 8:52Ukrainians have not been defeated.
- 8:55And that's a situation, you know, where basically the war has just dragged on, and Putin believes, you know, by bombing Ukraine, by you know, uh killing civilians, doing all the terrible war crimes that they are doing, that eventually Ukraine will submit, or Western countries, you know, will you know stop supporting and they're there they are looking at the crucial role of the United States in Europe.
- 9:23Europe, of course, you know, has been very supportive of Ukraine.
- 9:27The United States, you know, has been ambiguous uh to put it mildly.
- 9:32Oh and uh they they have now come up with the United States, you know, with this peace program.
- 9:39But that's the background, why this has been so difficult to negotiate is because you've got a war going on and neither side in a decisive situation.
- 9:48I don't know what your thoughts uh I think I do know your thoughts of uh the phrase peace through strength coming from uh from Reagan, but clearly, clearly uh that's what Russia.
- 10:00And so many other the Mideast and so forth understands.
- 10:04And as long as he is able to have this relationship with China, North Korea, I guess Syria sending mercenaries, Cuba, North North Korea sending mercenaries.
- 10:17He's not going to give up until he feels like his back is to the wall, and it's clearly not to the wall.
- 10:25But Ambassador, I I have here in front of me.
- 10:28It was leaked.
- 10:30It was leaked right to me.
- 10:32No, it was leaked to the media.
- 10:35This 28 point I have my contacts.
- 10:43Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 10:43I don't think Marco Rubio is very happy about this.
- 10:46But but anyway, so so how was it constructed?
- 10:50And there's all kinds of you know, I my my sense is that the Ukrainians had almost nothing to do with the drafting, most likely based on the core provisions, uh, whereas it was mainly uh Witkoff and uh and his Russian counterparts.
- 11:07But let me go through some of these, which are no-brainers, I think, and no starters.
- 11:13But so number one, territorial concession.
- 11:16So Ukraine would recognize Crimea as Russian and accept the freezing of the line of contact in Kherson and the the Nabot Dumbas area.
- 11:26So most of that area would be controlled by Russia.
- 11:29Okay.
- 11:30All right, yeah.
- 11:30Give me a break.
- 11:32Again, through the eyes of the Ukrainians, no.
- 11:34So military limits.
- 11:35And this appears to me as mainly anti-Ukrainian, mainly.
- 11:41So Ukraine would agree to a limit on its armed forces, 600,000.
- 11:45NATO, they would agree not joining NATO, would agree to to not station troops in Ukraine.
- 11:52Oh, and NATO not stationed troops, uh stationing troops in Ukraine.
- 11:56Russia would not invade its neighboring countries.
- 11:59Well, yeah, okay.
- 12:01Uh uh all parties would receive full amnesty, full amnesty for the for the actions during the war, uh, a comprehensive prisoner and body exchange.
- 12:11A hundred billion in frozen Russian assets would be invested in Ukraine's instance uh reconstruction, but while I don't know.
- 12:19I uh this is not funny, but almost is with the U.S.
- 12:22receiving 50% of the profits from this venture.
- 12:25So I wonder where that came from.
- 12:28Or who put that who put that in there?
- 12:30Uh Europe would contribute an additional 100 billion for reconstruction.
- 12:34Uh Russia would be re reintegrated into the global economy, lifting of sanctions.
- 12:40They would be invited back to the uh to the GA.
- 12:43So let me just start with that.
- 12:44The those are core provisions, and then there's a there's a lot of other key points, too.
- 12:51Well, it's it is obviously extremely one-sided.
- 12:56Um, and I want to go back to one other point, so just to clarify.
- 13:00Sure.
- 13:00Um, Ukraine would not only have to give up Russian territory that the Russians now hold, you know, in Crimea and Donetsk uh, you know, and and Zaporizhia, they would also have to give up all of the Donbass, all of Donetsk, some of which is still controlled by Ukraine.
- 13:20So there would be additional territorial demands put on Ukraine, and the Russians basically go off scot-free.
- 13:28They would have to return, you know, a few territories of Ukraine that they hold.
- 13:33But again, this is a very, very one-sided thing.
- 13:36And let me just say a couple of things about this proposal.
- 13:40Sure.
- 13:41One, as I don't think anybody is really certain, you know, who did it.
- 13:46Um, uh Rubio supposedly told senators that it was a Russian draft, which was probably sounds like it.
- 13:55Uh but the uh the the U.S.
- 13:58has come back and said no, you know, that it was our drafting, you know, Whitkoff and company, uh, and that it really is ours.
- 14:06So that's question number one is whose draft, you know, was it?
- 14:11And secondly, uh again, I'm going back to my experience as an ambassador.
- 14:16Yes.
- 14:17You cannot negotiate a peace agreement over the head, you know, of one of the warring parties as they were trying to do here.
- 14:25No.
- 14:26Uh Ukraine was cut out and Europe was cut out.
- 14:30These are two major participants.
- 14:33This is a war of Europe.
- 14:35You know, this is their destiny.
- 14:37And the Europeans have become very, very concerned about the threat that Russia poses today.
- 14:44This agreement, you know, well, if this agreement went forward as written, uh, it basically uh gives Russia a clear diplomatic victory that they have not won on the battlefield, and it leaves the Russian military almost intact, you know, to do a repeat sometime down the future.
- 15:04Well, what would Henry Kissinger have done?
- 15:06Henry Kissinger uh would not have accepted this.
- 15:10Uh in other words, if he were to draft no.
- 15:14Um you worked with him.
- 15:16Did you not?
- 15:17Uh I did I I worked for him.
- 15:20I didn't really know him.
- 15:21Uh-huh.
- 15:21Uh-huh.
- 15:22Okay.
- 15:22Okay.
- 15:23But but I don't think he would um, yeah, he he would come out with this, you know, as an initial draft.
- 15:29I I just can't see that.
- 15:32Um there's more.
- 15:33No, I I agree.
- 15:35There's more.
- 15:36So the United States would provide uh security guarantees in in um Ukraine.
- 15:41There would be a dialogue, quote unquote, dialogue between Russia and NATO, mediated by the U.S.
- 15:47Uh Ukraine would be eligible for EU membership, um, and would face uh a period of time of preferential market access, elections in Ukraine within 100 days.
- 15:59I I suspect that Zelensky would win that.
- 16:03Uh, but I don't know.
- 16:04Um share electricity, uh sharing of electricity between the uh nuclear power plant between Russia and Ukraine, uh Zeparisia, uh that they would uh abolish all discriminatory measures, guarantee the rights of Ukrainian and Russian media and education.
- 16:22Um here's another one.
- 16:24Um a non-aggression agreement, as we mentioned before that, would be concluded between Russia, Ukraine, and European countries.
- 16:32Do I would I trust Russia with that?
- 16:35I don't think so.
- 16:37Uh and legally binding um these agreements would be legally binding, monitored by peace council, uh Trump would would um oversee that.
- 16:48So these other key points, um, yeah, they're they're gonna have to be reconstructed is my guess.
- 16:54There's a couple things there that make sense, but not not the overwhelming.
- 16:59Well, you you you are you are absolutely right.
- 17:03And the reaction to that uh draft uh has been very negative in the U.S.
- 17:09Senate.
- 17:09Uh it's been very negative, you know, in Europe, it's been very negative, you know, with allies like Japan and South Korea, you know, which obviously see, you know, what it is.
- 17:20And the uh the news from yesterday was that yesterday uh Rubio met with the Ukrainians and that you know they they were you know making some progress.
- 17:31My guess again, because and I I I've referred to the diplomacy here as a mess, um, mainly because you know, this idea of negotiating over the head of the Ukrainians, and then giving the poor president of Ukraine, you know, five days to make an agreement on whether or not to sign you know a new Munich pact.
- 17:52Right is just just unconsciential given the fact, you know, how they have fought for four years uh and what they have accomplished.
- 18:01Yes.
- 18:01The way that this should have been done is there should have been consultations between Europe, the United States, and the Ukrainians, you know, on a position, and then present it to the Russians, and then you have the negotiations uh uh uh you know on the final text.
- 18:18Uh, you don't give the Ukrainians a diktat, you know, which is impossible, you know, for Zelensky.
- 18:24Yes.
- 18:25And the poor guy, you know, uh is now again being insulted in the way he was insulted, you know, in whatever it was January or February in the White House, you know, given ultimatums, and this guy is a hero.
- 18:39I mean, this is a real leader, Mr.
- 18:42Zelensky.
- 18:43He is.
- 18:43And he's trying to wiggle, he's trying to find wiggle room.
- 18:46And I I feel for the guy because he said, you know, uh, we have to choose we may have to choose, you know, between our you know, our alliance and our our conscience, you know, and it's a very, very chuck choice, you know, that he's faced with.
- 19:02Ambassador, hold that thought.
- 19:03Hold that thought.
- 19:04We're gonna go to station break, and when I come back, okay, more of uh this because there's there's so much to talk about.
- 19:11Uh thank you, Ambassador.
- 19:13We'll be right back.
- 19:13In just two minutes per day, you can reclaim your health and cut your grocery bill in half with one simple convenient product.
- 19:20Our doctor formulated Green 85 juice formula, powerful dose of ultra-concentrated essential nutrients, stops hunger in its tracks, and supplies your cells with what's missing in the grocery store food.
- 19:32Go to Chemicalfree Body.com forward slash out loud today, get nature's super multivitamin Green 85, empower your immune system, cut down on your grocery bill, and save 20% on your first order.
- 19:46Well, I challenge you to find a broad array of great voices, a deeper bench of experience or a more dedicated collection of passionate patriots than here on America out loud.
- 20:03Now is our time, my fellow America.
- 20:07America outlaw.
- 20:08News.
- 20:09Liberty and justice.
- 20:16All right, we are back.
- 20:19Welcome back.
- 20:20So, Ambassador, just touching on what we were speaking about on the first segment, during the first segment.
- 20:26So what would it take for Russia to a seed and agree to ending this war because my again, my sense, I was mentioning before Russia needs to have, or or any of the two parties somehow their back to the wall and a sense of insecurity to agree to provisions.
- 20:54Because I I think we're you're the expert, but a diplomatic complete stalemate.
- 21:01I hand it to you.
- 21:02Well you're uh this is something I and many, many, many of my colleagues have puzzled about for the last you know three or four years.
- 21:12I think the concl the the answer is that Putin will only negotiate in what what we would call a realistic sense.
- 21:22Um if uh there are two factors.
- 21:26One is their economy.
- 21:27Uh we haven't talked much about that.
- 21:30But uh their economy has been really lashed, you know, by the sanctions.
- 21:35Uh so far they have managed, you know, so to support the war, but it's an increasingly difficult issue to get around our sanctions, our export controls, uh, to export oil uh to find customers now that we are you know sanctioning two of their major oil and gas companies.
- 21:55Um they are they they are still a rich country, don't get me wrong, but this is costing them in ways that is gonna uh retard the growth of their economy for another decade easily.
- 22:08So that I I'm a student of the fall of the Soviet Union.
- 22:13There are many reasons for it, but one was a failing economy.
- 22:17It was you know not going to produce what it needed.
- 22:20That is one very important factor.
- 22:23Another factor, you know, is labor shortages.
- 22:26Uh they have tremendous shortages of labor.
- 22:29Because of that, the price of labor has gone way up, so they have very high inflation.
- 22:35They have incurred um huge uh amount of uh of debt or obligations, paying bonuses to the young men, you know, who they get to uh you know to enter the military, and then death you know, benefits, you know, to the families.
- 22:52Right.
- 22:52They are going to, and this this gets to something I know you are very interested in.
- 22:57They also are going to have a tremendous problem with PTSD, um, you know, for war wounded, you know, for all the various things, you know, hospitalizations, uh, you know, mental.
- 23:11Oh, well, they're ongoing.
- 23:12They're ongoing.
- 23:13We'll we'll address that.
- 23:14We'll address that later in this in this broadcast.
- 23:17But Ambassador, I I remember years ago.
- 23:20Go ahead.
- 23:21Sorry.
- 23:22Yeah, let's finish though.
- 23:24Though those are one set of factors.
- 23:26The other is the military situation.
- 23:29Um we have basically put limits uh on the types of weapons, you know, that we have sent to them and where in Russia they could be used.
- 23:40If we provided them, you know, with uh uh, you know, stronger type weaponry, and if we allowed them to use those weaponry weapons, you know, in uh in the rear, you know, way back in the rear, which the Ukrainians are doing, but I think they're using mainly their own things right now.
- 23:58But if we could shift the military balance so that you know the Russians see, you know, that their energy infrastructure is getting smashed to smithereens, uh, and that the Ukrainians are getting continued, you know, U.S.
- 24:12and European support.
- 24:13Right, those are the things that would lead, you know, sort of keep um develop the conditions where he might you know sit down.
- 24:21But you know, we're not doing that, or at least the impression was we we were, and then now there's just really uh a decline in that and proportional to that decline, the uh the Ukrainian response or or you know, victories or success uh appear to be declining as well because you're having this war of attrition, you're having the these still slowly, slowly, slowly the Russians are still advancing in terms of land.
- 24:49But one thing I wanted to bring up, I remember in the 70s, let's say, and 80s.
- 24:55The communist party.
- 24:57Well, they those who belong to the communist party belong to and and and are officials and such, they have a completely different uh lifestyle.
- 25:06So I I don't I uh they have special this and special that special stores, special country clubs, special.
- 25:13So how many of uh Putin and his leaders and is his entourage are really feeling personally the sanctions?
- 25:22I I don't or do you know again they don't care about soldiers being killed, they don't care, you know, uh ultimate victory is the most important thing.
- 25:33But again, going back to the sanctions and hurting the infrastructure the well, yes, yes, the infrastructure uh uh or the economy of the Russians.
- 25:42Does he care?
- 25:44As long as he and his family and everyone else are doing great.
- 25:49I I think they do care.
- 25:52Uh and you are correct.
- 25:54Um, you know, what what he has tried to do is basically uh shield the cities, the major cities.
- 26:02And if there's going to be a revolt, you know, in Russia, it's usually going to be led by you know intellectuals and usually by the middle class, and yeah, that means the cities, you know, Moscow and St.
- 26:14Petersburg.
- 26:15He has gone out of his way to shield those cities from the war.
- 26:20Uh most of the boys that are getting slaughtered are coming from the Muslim areas of the North Caucuses of Russia, uh, where you know the signing bonuses and the death benefits are heavenly, literally, you know, compared to their to the poverty there.
- 26:37And yeah, he has managed so far, but as you said correctly, they're using uh North Koreans, they're using, you know, uh uh uh people that you know that they they they have this advertisements, you know, like in India and other countries, misleading advertisements, you know, to young men, you know, come and make money in Russia.
- 26:57Well, if they come, then they're throwing right into uh you know the uh you know the cauldron.
- 27:02Um so yeah, so I mean that but as the war drags on, it's getting harder, you know, and harder uh to do that.
- 27:12The difference between now and the Soviet times, you're right.
- 27:16The Soviet elite, you know, live comparatively well.
- 27:19This elite has billions of dollars, you know, from oil and gas and chemicals and all the other uh you know resources that Russia had that have been taken over uh by these klepto capitalists, you know, Russian billionaires, and their money is stashed away, you know, in in Switzerland.
- 27:39They bought huge amounts of you know uh glamorous homes on the Riviera, you know, in England.
- 27:45That's the source of their money, you know, right now.
- 27:48And I think they feel that they're pretty much you know impervious.
- 27:53Those people have sold their souls.
- 27:55I don't know how else to put it.
- 27:56My wife and I know Oh, go ahead.
- 27:59Go ahead.
- 28:00My wife and I were went to Monaco last year to visit uh vacation, and what do you see?
- 28:06These huge beautiful yachts, yachts and and like mega yachts, super yachts.
- 28:13And I was told, no, these are all these are all Russian.
- 28:16Russians, Russian.
- 28:18This doesn't this doesn't vibe with what my uh you know, my perception and what's going on in the the Russian economy and this, that and the other, but but there is a very wealthy segment.
- 28:30Yeah, and it's very small, and it's very much dependent on uh Putin.
- 28:36Uh they have to be totally loyal to him.
- 28:38There have been a couple of oligarchs uh who fallen out of you know, fifth story locked windows, you know, there are all kinds of funny things that happen, you know, to some of the rich people who cross him.
- 28:50They end up in prison or they flee for their lives.
- 28:53Yeah, and they know very, very well that they cannot, you know, directly contradict him.
- 28:59What goes on, you know, in his circles, the closest to him, those are, you know, rather than these guys are oligarchs, but they are mostly from the security operat, you know, who he's given, you know, very nice prows prizes to.
- 29:14These are the people he trusts.
- 29:16These are his buddies from the KGB, you know, and and you know, and some of the intelligence services, and these are the people who are really formed the backbone, you know, of his regime.
- 29:27These are the people he consults.
- 29:29He does not talk to, you know, uh experts anymore the way that you know he might have done in the past.
- 29:36And he it's sort of like a a uh a closed circle around him.
- 29:40They tell him what he wants to hear, and he keeps doing what you know what they tell him.
- 29:46And that is the problem.
- 29:47He's just divorced from reality.
- 29:49They have their special place in hell as well.
- 29:52A lot of people.
- 29:54I'm I'm gonna go to a different uh subject.
- 29:57My cousin, uh Mr.
- 29:59Peter Lupo.
- 30:00He he's uh very astute in political science.
- 30:02He asked me a couple weeks ago, and and and it's it it's a wonderful question.
- 30:07He says, you know, during the Civil War, the American Civil War, he said there were which I had no idea, there were individuals from Japan and Asian Germany and Europe, kind of observing on the side the battles, just kind of watching it's it's surreal, actually, but they they were watching as to the military techniques in our civil war and trying to learn from them.
- 30:31Well, is that occurring in Ukraine as a laboratory?
- 30:35And yes, it is from what I'm learning here for modern warfare.
- 30:39So under the umbrella of hybrid warfare, I'm gonna mention to you some things that have blown my mind, completely blown my mind.
- 30:47But but so what's going on there again as a laboratory, uh in terms of unmanned, unmanned aerial vehicles, these are drones, UAVs, unmanned surface vessels right above, right above the level of the water.
- 31:01Uh then there's unmanned ground vehicles, UGVs, but there's something else too that I'm learning.
- 31:08Uh autonomous vehicles.
- 31:10So I gather we'll get into the AI in a moment, but but there are vehicles both in air and right above the water or below the water as submarines that are not directed by human beings sitting in in a room somewhere with a computer.
- 31:27They have the programs themselves to attack and destroy.
- 31:31So we have an incredible, almost Star Wars type scenario going on.
- 31:38We do, and um it's very you've described it uh very, very accurately.
- 31:42And one point I wanted to make before you know going into uh broader discussion is the Ukrainians have managed, they do not have a navy, yet they have destroyed about one-third of the Russian Black Sea fleet, and they have forced the Russians, you know, to uh you know, sort of diminish their operations in the Black Sea and to use ports in the Russian Black Sea.
- 32:08And it's it's these unmanned vehicles, you know, these submarines, uh, the drones.
- 32:13They have taken out it has been a huge embarrassment, you know, to the Russians, because a lot of their floating fortresses have just been sunk, you know, or disabled.
- 32:24And that has allowed, you know, the Ukrainians basically to continue to export wheat, you know, through the Black Sea.
- 32:31And the Russians were trying to stop that at the beginning of the war, and they have failed.
- 32:36But the naval warfare uh scenario, if you will, uh, is one of the real remarkable success stories, you know, you know, for the Ukrainians.
- 32:46Let me just uh back up for one second.
- 32:49The first war that I'm aware of uh where drones were decisive uh was in the wars between Azerbaijan and Armenia.
- 32:59Azerbaijan uh got drones from Turkey and basically use them, you know, the Armenian troops were defenseless.
- 33:07The Armenian troops have been armed uh by Russia, but they were not uh you know, up they were not able to deal with these Turkish drones.
- 33:15The Ukrainians initially have had a very significant advantage using drones.
- 33:22They are very inventive.
- 33:24The Russians getting drones from uh Iran and I don't know if North Korea produces them as well.
- 33:31But the Ukrainians had the advantage.
- 33:34And one way that that has changed, you know, the nature of the warfare is that the Russians are no longer using mass attack, you know.
- 33:44Uh what they are doing is smaller groups of men, you know, 10, 15, 20, mounted on motorcycles or bicycles, uh, you know, to attack.
- 33:55And and those are much tougher to deal with, I gather, you know, than with uh with drones.
- 34:00That is why what is one of the reasons the Russians you know have been able you know to push forward.
- 34:06Whether they could hold these territories is another question.
- 34:10Right.
- 34:10But uh the Russians, there's there's some wonderful analysts of the uh Russian military um that I I studied, you know, their writings.
- 34:20And the best article that I've seen recently, I'm just gonna mention it here because it is so good.
- 34:25It's called How Russia Recovered by Dera Masakot in the magazine Foreign Affairs.
- 34:34And simply what she points out is that the Russians, you know, initially, you know, by force of arms and all the armor that they threw in, you know, had the Ukrainians on the defense of the Ukrainians, you know, using the drones and lots and lots smarter tactics, then went on the defense uh the offense.
- 34:53That did not work.
- 34:54And what you have now is sort of this not quite stalemate, but where the Russians, you know, have improved.
- 35:00What she points out in this article is is that the Russians have learned, uh, they have learned from this war, they've learned how to use AI, they've learned how to, you know, develop, you know, supersonic missiles, uh, their drone technology, their training has improved, their command and control has improved.
- 35:20There's still very serious faults, you know, with the Russians.
- 35:24But her point is that they are are much further along now than it was before.
- 35:29And her point, which I think is a very, very good one, is Russia, because of what it has learned and done, you know, producing new equipment and technologies, is now much better placed, you know, than many countries in fighting the next war, if you know an example.
- 35:47I do all the all the things that you know that you mentioned.
- 35:52And uh that is a very, you know, serious concern.
- 35:56Let me to your point about the naval warfare.
- 35:58So the the in the first in the world, the Ukrainian had a Magura 7 sea drones.
- 36:03They were armed with air-to-air uh sidewinder missiles, and they they downed two Russian fighter jets over the Black Sea last uh this past May.
- 36:12And so this is this is of course unmanned systems.
- 36:15I'm just gonna name, and and we have a whole other range.
- 36:18We have the integration of AI and big big data.
- 36:22Oh my God, we have hypersonic weapons, as you mentioned, that they were they're using counter drone developments.
- 36:28Um, but I'm gonna name to you some companies.
- 36:31These are U.S.
- 36:32tech companies that are directly involved.
- 36:35We have plantar technology, so they have AI-based software, and it helps the forces uh with advanced targeting and data analysis.
- 36:42We have Microsoft, Amazon, Google, Starlink, SpaceX.
- 36:47We have Aero Vironman, we have ClearView AI, we have Planet Labs, Maxar, Max Art Technologies.
- 36:53I learned about that through in the um uh what do you call when you go watch movies in terms of Maxart?
- 36:59Exactly, you know, uh Shield AI.
- 37:01And then, but uh to your point about the Russian military equipment, they have found they have found products from our companies, Texas instruments, yes, Intel, analog devices, uh, advanced micro devices, uh all with Russian and Russian equipment.
- 37:18You know, I I'm thinking right now, did they did they take some of our hardware in um Afghanistan and uh take that and use it for you know it just comes to mind right now?
- 37:30I I don't know, maybe they did, maybe they have.
- 37:33Uh all that's I don't think that yeah, I I don't think that's the primary culprit.
- 37:39The primary culprit is the way that they've been able to break sanctions and get around them, and they're doing that in a variety of ways.
- 37:46They've set up dummy companies, you know, that can import and export.
- 37:50Uh they're importing and exporting to friendly countries.
- 37:54Turkey has done a lot.
- 37:55Um was it United, uh, one of the UAE, one of those countries has done a lot.
- 38:02Uh North Korea, Iran, you know, they're using they're using yeah, Qatar, they're you they're using cutouts, you know.
- 38:09That's another thing that that's this like laundering the laundering that the mafia does, kind of, but it's pretty much pretty much, but uh the Russians are very clever people.
- 38:20They're technologically, you know, very capable.
- 38:23And there's a lot of of dual use equipment.
- 38:26Yes, uh, you know, that has uh uh you know chips in it, and they just mine those chips.
- 38:32Uh so I mean they they have a whole army of people, and as you know, you know, they have a whole army of of scammers and you know, uh uh you know, computer uh people who are you know intercepting sea coats, doing all kinds of things.
- 38:46Of course.
- 38:47This has been a an all-out you know, war, you know, ambassador, ambassador, hold that thought.
- 38:52We're gonna come right back.
- 38:54Uh we're gonna have our second station break and much more to come.
- 38:59Tired of harsh chemical toothpaste that do more harm than good.
- 39:02Upgrade your oral health with SMILE.
- 39:04The doctor formulated toothpaste for the wellness company.
- 39:06SMILE uses powerful peptides, remineralizers, and probiotics to rebuild gum tissue, strengthen enamel, and keep harmful bacteria away.
- 39:14And also leaves your mouth feeling fresh with a clean mint flavor.
- 39:17No fluoride, no toxins, just real science-backed results.
- 39:21Go to TWC dot health forward slash outloud and use code outload for 20% off your first order.
- 39:28You wouldn't go a day without brushing your teeth or washing your hands.
- 39:31What about washing your nose?
- 39:33I mean, your nose does filter the air you breathe, air loaded with bacteria, viruses, and irritants.
- 39:39Make nasal hygiene part of your routine with clear.
- 39:42No messy bottles to fill, no drowning sensation.
- 39:45Clear is a natural drug-free saline with the added benefit of xylitol, which blocks bacterial and viral adhesion available in stores and online at clear.com.
- 39:55That is XLEAR.com.
- 40:01And we are back with Ambassador Yalowitz.
- 40:04The last segment we were talking about the technological advances.
- 40:08And I just want to talk a little bit about this to counter drone developments.
- 40:13And there is, you know, it's it's way above my level in terms of physics and mathematics.
- 40:20But last year, the Ukrainians uh started a new branch, a military branch, the unmanned systems forces.
- 40:27And I wonder if we're we're learning from that as well that we should do that ourselves.
- 40:33But but they're doing they're using, I I guess our stuff, our, and we're we're watching what's happening.
- 40:42I mean, it's it's surreal that we're at you know, uh 60,000 feet looking down, or maybe or more from satellites, actually.
- 40:50Uh so my sense is the longevity, which is not we want, the intensity is not we want of the conflict.
- 40:57It allows for rapid iterations and fine-tuning of these systems.
- 41:02And so you you can't do that in controlled environments.
- 41:06Uh so this is uncontrolled.
- 41:08But we're learning so much.
- 41:09And I remember too, we were talking about the the AI.
- 41:12Oh my goodness gracious, it's it's flourishing to a degree that's just astronomical.
- 41:19The cyber the the issues with cybersecurity and big data.
- 41:23But the Russians had malware, like uh Fox Blade, a virus that uh we were able to to, or they through us to detect and neutralize.
- 41:33Uh so much, so much going on.
- 41:36Again, I called it Star Wars.
- 41:38But it looks like it is, actually.
- 41:41It is.
- 41:42It is.
- 41:43I think you're you're characterizing it uh correctly.
- 41:46And uh this is an area, you know, technology, you know, where the Russians are very, very good, where they've traditionally had trouble is getting the fruits of their research, you know, into production.
- 41:58Yeah.
- 41:59Uh that's a problem that goes back to the Soviet Union.
- 42:02But I wanted to uh we'll talk about this one, but I wanted to make a point too.
- 42:06And that is you began uh at the outset talking about you know observers coming and watching, you know, the civil war.
- 42:13Um that was from Peter, my cousin, yes.
- 42:17No, no, no, but this is a very important point.
- 42:22We have provided military equipment and intelligence, you know, to the Ukrainians.
- 42:27That is now under threat.
- 42:29You know, as President Trump has basically said if you know, if uh Putin, if uh uh Zelensky doesn't agree to this peace proposal that we're gonna cut, you know, cut off everything.
- 42:40I don't think that's gonna happen.
- 42:41No.
- 42:42But that would that would be a real blow.
- 42:45Now let me tell you what we are gaining from this war.
- 42:48We have no troops on the ground, you know, we have no direct you know threats to Americans, uh, but what we are gaining, and it's not just you know, from 60,000 feet up, you know, we it's not that we have people on the ground, but we have very close cooperation, you know, with the Ukrainian military and Ukrainian intelligence.
- 43:08And I'm sure we have picked up a wealth of information about Soviet military tactics, the way that they're being able to incorporate AI, uh, their use of you know, cyber you know, warfare, uh, all the various things, you know, that you talked about, uh, we are learning about how the Russians are employing, and that is priceless.
- 43:30Well, the Ukrainians are employing this.
- 43:32The Ukrainians, I my understanding is you know, this 3D printers, they're so they're actually even rudimentary, they're able to come up with parts from 3D printers.
- 43:44But but that's besides the point.
- 43:46I I think is it not the Ukrainians who have gained mainly from our systems, as opposed to what the Russians have stolen from our systems or or or from our our uh AI and big uh uh big data and uh the cybersecurity, but the the actual kinetic uh knowledge in terms of all the other uh technological companies involved.
- 44:09Um because you mentioned Russia, yes, but uh if it were not for us and uh all the technology, Ukraine would have quote unquote lost this war right at the beginning, I think.
- 44:22I I would agree, uh, but also there's another factor here.
- 44:28Uh before when there was a Soviet Union, Ukraine, uh the Donbass and also Ukrainian, you know, the big cities were critical in terms of you know that Russia and the Soviet Union's uh military capabilities.
- 44:43Some of their most important you know, institutes and research centers and you know, weapons production was in Ukraine.
- 44:51The Ukrainians, you know, are not some backward country, you know, that's just getting out.
- 44:57The Ukrainians are very clever, very well educated people, and they are dealing now with uh uh uh you know a sworn enemy.
- 45:06You know, uh the Russians say, you know, that the Ukrainians are little are our our little brothers, little brothers that we love them, we're all one.
- 45:13The irony is incredible.
- 45:15Hypocrisy.
- 45:16Those little brothers are now hitting them over the head with you know iron clubs.
- 45:21And you know, that that is just a joke.
- 45:23And and this is going to be there for a long, long time to come.
- 45:27That's uh also one of the problems with you know uh getting a ceasefire is how to get the systems, the uh uh the military observers, you know, that both sides will trust, you know, to you know, to observe this thing.
- 45:42But you know, my point simply is that the Ukrainians were not a tabula arrasa, you know, they are very capable people, and they are able to, you know, I talked about the Russian inability to get stuff from the research labs, you know, into production.
- 45:57Yes, Ukrainians don't have that.
- 45:59Um Ukrainians, you know, we live close to Appalachi here, and I see all the time, you know, you go out in the places, you see guys, you know, repairing old trucks, you know, they look like they're finished.
- 46:10Well, they're out there repairing them and making them run again.
- 46:13That's what the Ukrainians, you know, were able to do.
- 46:16They're now getting you know much better equipment, but you cannot undersell uh or diminish the capability of the Ukrainian, the ingenuity and the perseverance.
- 46:28Yeah, exactly.
- 46:29The ingenuity uh ambassador, you mentioned we we don't have boots on the ground there, thank God.
- 46:35But uh did we learn?
- 46:37I gather we did from Vietnam and Afghanistan and Iraq uh and so many other conflicts, the United States, because by this point, in order to have Russia succumb, oh my goodness, we would have to have uh uh a much bigger presence, I would think.
- 46:57And and uh now there's a lot of opposition in Congress and and all over to the United States funding this this humongous proxy war uh with you know military hardware and such.
- 47:11And and it's it's kind of blown out of uh uh blown out, but but again, I don't see an end to the war.
- 47:18I personally don't the way it is now, unless Putin is assassinated, which who knows what's gonna come after that.
- 47:25It could be worse.
- 47:27Um I I you know I'm a pessimist, I guess, but I yourself and your job as a diplomat, by definition you can't be a pessim pessimist in that particular job.
- 47:40But my goodness gracious, it's almost like being a psychiatrist.
- 47:43Well, you have to be a psychiatrist in a way.
- 47:47Do you not in dealing with this this situation?
- 47:51I mean, uh you've had to be a psychiatrist when you were with Lushenko when you were in in Georgia.
- 47:57You you were a psychiatrist yourself.
- 48:01Were you not?
- 48:02Well, let me let you know let me say a couple of things.
- 48:05Um I I give President Trump, you know, some credit, you know, for at least trying to get you know this process off dead center.
- 48:16Uh that is, you know, I have no problem whatsoever.
- 48:20The problem I have is the you know, the way in which this has been done.
- 48:25Um he his negotiating team has no Russian expertise.
- 48:29Uh the top three negotiators, Witkoff, Rubio, and and the son-in-law Kushner, uh, who are apparently you know the driving force, you know, behind this thing.
- 48:40None of them have any Russian experience whatsoever.
- 48:44The one the one person who had some experience, General Kellogg, has now been fired.
- 48:50Um, he was the Russian expert, and he has been completely cut out of the negotiations all along, and he just quit or was fired.
- 48:59This is a recipe for the disaster.
- 49:01The guy Dmitriev that these are Americans were negotiating with the Russians, these are all people who've dealt with these issues for years and years and years.
- 49:11They're fluent in English, they're bilingual.
- 49:14We cannot, our people don't understand Russian.
- 49:16They they only know what an interpreter, you know, is telling them.
- 49:20Uh, and the Russians have, as I've said, have very strong ideological motivations, you know, in this war, ideological, territorial, and also existential, you know, for Mr.
- 49:33Putin.
- 49:34We do we do not have those stakes uh, you know, uh on the part of our negotiators.
- 49:38That's why I mentioned psychiatrists, because yeah, psychiatrists need to know this.
- 49:43The trouble with yeah, the trouble with our team, I believe, is that you know the president wants a peace agreement, you know, here and in Gaza, so that he can focus on you know China and also what he regards the internal threats, God knows what that means.
- 49:59Um
- 50:00you know in in this country he wants a deal you know with Putin he has made no bones about that and the the problem with that is our European friends are telling us is if you give Putin a victory in Ukraine watch out for the future well yeah right exactly how can you trust uh the man or whoever would succe be the successor can we ever trust the Russians or Soviets or whatever in yeah in 19 I'm sorry uh uh 1994 the Russians gave a solemn commitment to us the Ukrainians the British not to invade Ukraine you know not to fiddle around with their borders that was when Ukraine gave back their Soviet era era nuclear weapons to Russia that has just been ripped to shreds uh you you cannot believe anything the man says that's the problem no no and all that you know he was smiling and everything when when you looked at and and Trump knows that I mean he's not that uh he knows that they were playing they were playing us I think in Anchorage uh oh they were so good no question no question and the question that I have is why why he was so angry with Putin and why you know two months later you know he's drafting a plan to give Putin what he wants this this is not this is not the way you do diplomacy well Ukrainians are not going to accept it anyway I mean they're meeting right now in Geneva uh what's is the third day or so um no the uh if I were Zelensky well he's already stated no hell no I'm not gonna accept this well no no what what what what no what he what he has stated you know is that he appreciates you know what Trump is trying to do uh you know but that you know he needs to you know to fine-tune it that's the best response you know that he could give is you can't say directly no to Trump but what you can do is what what uh he's learning from Putin what Putin has done all along is oh yes I want to see sorry but there are a few points that we have to take care of before just a few right yeah yeah and that's that's what kills us so ambassador before I I speak about uh the humanitarian crisis which is just overwhelming from both sides actually but but mainly Ukrainian um maybe I should uh have somehow have you there uh because uh you you would know more than than any of them uh in terms of the history and in terms of uh I never asked you do you do you speak Russian I never asked you that yes yes yes yes yes I never asked you yes I serve I I I I served there twice yes yes yeah in Moscow yes yes okay so so if uh it were up to you and your shoulders and you were there what would you do to end this war diplomatically well the first thing that I would do is lock down the relationship with the allies and with the Ukrainians um uh because if if Putin knows that there is a united front uh that he is not going to be able to break uh that is critically important the second thing I would do is stop threatening you know to you know uh cease sending weapons and intelligence you know to Ukraine make sure you would you would you would stop doing that no no I'm saying you I would make sure uh you know that we that we are not doing it you know yeah is uh interesting is we are threatening yeah I would do just the opposite I would I would tell Putin that we are going to continue arming and sending uh intelligence to Ukraine that that's crucial and the third thing is I would probably not put the limits on Ukraine in terms of where you know they can use uh these weapons the fourth thing I would do is there's something like 200 billion dollars of Russian assets you know that are frozen frozen yes yeah yeah instead of using those to for us to make money off of you know they're being used uh give that money to Ukraine let the world thank you know uh uh you know uh uh uh supervise that so that the reconstruction can be done and the fifth thing that I would do is to remind the world that Putin is a a wanted war criminal by the International Court of Justice and that until this war stops uh you know that and and that was another very bad part of the of our draft you know that all the you know the slate would be wiped clean how do you wipe clean who's killed of course of course but how how effective would that be for example Netanyahu in Israel is the same thing he's he's wanted by the court is he not and I mean it's completely different dynamics but yeah no but that's that's important very important Dr.
- 55:06Lucio because we put our foot down on Netanyahu we told him that he had to negotiate a ceasefire because he had been doing the same tactics as Putin you know oh I want to cease fire but then this is not right that is not right and then just killing it he was playing uh Biden and he was playing Trump but Trump in the case of Gaza you know has done what I consider to be the right thing you know to put pressure on Netanyahu you know to negotiate Trump has not put pressure on Putin he is you know when you welcome him on the red carpet you know in in uh in Anchorage Alaska that is not the way to deal with Putin right right we're learning that so Ambassador the the few minutes we have left I'm gonna just touch on the uh humanitarian crisis it's overwhelming.
- 55:53Yes please so I wrote an article a couple of years ago it's changed it's devolved it's worsened internally displaced persons around Ukrainians 3.7 million um international refugees uh approximately 7 million so so 10 point 10 point seven million total and uh of those killed civilians uh over 14 almost 15 thousand at least as of now killed and total wounded and such uh my goodness so much more than that uh ukrainian soldiers close to 75 1000 uh killed so there are refugee stories to beat the band there are uh civilian life under attack you have food issues you have destruction of the infrastructure but we're gonna have to end it here ambassador as I mentioned to you we we could go on and on um thank you so so much uh and thank you all for listening but thank you ambassador um you're welcome thank you i i look forward because i i i want to speak with you again once things are ironed out in the next few weeks if you would allow me to because things are gonna happen obviously in terms of this and and this war has to end it has um I agree so thank you all uh I look forward to being with you weekly on the countermomentum of spin please note that this show and all the shows on America out loud radio go to your favorite podcast networks within 24 hours Apple Apple Podcast Spotify Pandora tune in Amazon iHeart Radio among many others have a great day God bless you