Latest / Kentucky Tonight / School Choice and Education Issues
Transcript
- 0:07[♪♪]
- 0:10GOOD EVENING.
- 0:11WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:12I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:13THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:15TONIGHT, WE’RE DISCUSSING SCHOOL
- 0:17CHOICE AND EDUCATION ISSUES.
- 0:19ADVOCATES OF SCHOOL CHOICE SAY
- 0:21PARENTS SHOULD HAVE OPTIONS FOR
- 0:23THEIR CHILDREN’S EDUCATION.
- 0:24IN THE PAST, KENTUCKY’S
- 0:26REPUBLICAN-LED GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 0:27HAS PASSED A “SCHOOL CHOICE”
- 0:28LAW SETTING UP A TAX-CREDIT
- 0:30SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM FOR STUDENTS
- 0:32TO ATTEND PRIVATE SCHOOLS AND A
- 0:34MEASURE TO FUND CHARTER SCHOOLS
- 0:35WITH PUBLIC DOLLARS.
- 0:36THE COURTS HAVE REJECTED THOSE
- 0:39LAWS.
- 0:39SO, THIS YEAR, LAWMAKERS HAVE
- 0:40BEFORE THEM TWO PROPOSED
- 0:42CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS TO
- 0:44CONSIDER ADVANCING SO KENTUCKY
- 0:46VOTERS CAN DECIDE WHETHER
- 0:48TAX DOLLARS CAN BE USED TO
- 0:50SUPPORT NON-PUBLIC EDUCATION.
- 0:52TO DISCUSS SCHOOL CHOICE• AND
- 0:53OTHER EDUCATION-RELATED
- 0:54MATTERS•. WE ARE JOINED IN OUR
- 0:54LEXINGTON STUDIO BY:
- 0:59HEATHER LEMIRE, KENTUCKY STATE
- 1:00DIRECTOR OF AMERICANS FOR
- 1:01PROSPERITY;
- 1:02BRIGITTE BLOM, PRESIDENT & CEO
- 1:03OF THE PRICHARD COMMITTEE FOR
- 1:04ACADEMIC EXCELLENCE;
- 1:07JIM WATERS, PRESIDENT AND CEO OF
- 1:09THE BLUEGRASS INSTITUTE FOR
- 1:09PUBLIC POLICY SOLUTIONS;
- 1:11AND
- 1:11EDDIE CAMPBELL, PRESIDENT OF THE
- 1:12KENTUCKY EDUCATION ASSOCIATION.
- 1:17SEND US YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 1:19COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER
- 1:21-- AT K-Y TONIGHT K-E-T. SEND AN
- 1:23EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT K-E-T
- 1:26DOT O-R-G. OR
- 1:28USE THE WEB FORM AT K-E-T DOT
- 1:29O-R-G SLASH K-Y TONIGHT. OR YOU
- 1:30CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 1:30WELCOME TO OUR GUESTS.
- 1:38WELCOME TO ALL OF OUR GUESTS
- 1:40THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE THIS
- 1:41EVENING.
- 1:41I WANT TO BEGIN WITH THIS SIDE
- 1:43TO GIVE US THE PROS FOR WHY
- 1:46SCHOOL CHOICE AND WHY NOW AND DO
- 1:47YOU HAVE A PREFERENCE OVER WHICH
- 1:50ONE YOU WOULD LIKE TO SEE
- 1:52ADVANCED OF THE TWO PROPOSED
- 1:53CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS AND WE
- 1:55COULD SEE MORE BECAUSE THE
- 1:57FILING DEADLINE IS NOT UNTIL THE
- 1:59LAST WEEK IN FEBRUARY.
- 2:00>> WHEN IT COMES TO THE
- 2:01CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT WE WANT
- 2:04CLEAR UNDERSTANDABLE LANGUAGE
- 2:05THAT REMOVES THE OBSTACLES TO
- 2:07ANY KIND OF CHOICE.
- 2:08I THINK THAT IS THE POINT HERE.
- 2:10IS THAT NO ONE-SIZE-FITS-ALL.
- 2:13YOU KNOW SCHOOL CHOICE IS NOT
- 2:14FOR EVERY CHILD IN KENTUCKY BUT
- 2:16IT SHOULD BE AVAILABLE TO EVERY
- 2:18CHILD.
- 2:18WHETHER IT IS A PUBLIC CHARTER
- 2:20SCHOOL.
- 2:21WHETHER IT IS A MICRO SCHOOL.
- 2:23WHETHER IT'S HOME SCHOOLING.
- 2:25WHETHER IT'S PRIVATE EDUCATION,
- 2:28A PAROCHIAL EDUCATION THE POINT
- 2:29IS TO REMOVE OBSTACLES THAT WILL
- 2:32GIVE OUR KIDS THE OPPORTUNITY TO
- 2:34SUCCEED IN THE FUTURE.
- 2:35AND SO WE NEED A CONSTITUTIONAL
- 2:36AMENDMENT THAT DOES THAT.
- 2:37WE DON'T NEED TO PASS A
- 2:40CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT FOR ANY
- 2:42PARTICULAR TYPE OF SCHOOL CHOICE
- 2:45AT THIS POINT THAT IS THE WORK
- 2:46OF THE LEGISLATURE COULD COME
- 2:48BACK AND DO THAT.
- 2:49>> Renee: SAY THAT AGAIN THE
- 2:53BILLS HOUSE BILL 208 AND HOUSE
- 2:56BILL 2 PROPOSED CONSTITUTIONAL
- 2:58AMENDMENTS IS THERE A DIFFERENCE
- 2:59OR DO THEY EMPOWER THE GENERAL
- 3:02ASSEMBLY TO ALLOW FOR THIS TO GO
- 3:04FORWARD AND ENABLING LEGISLATION
- 3:05AT A LATER TIME?
- 3:06>> THERE'S WRITTENLES IN THE TWO
- 3:08BUT THEY ARE WORKING ON IT.
- 3:10AND IT'S TIME TO GET THAT WORKED
- 3:12OUT.
- 3:13AND THERE ARE DISCUSSIONS GOING
- 3:15ON AND RECOMMENDATIONS BEING
- 3:16MADE AND WE APPRECIATE ALL THE
- 3:17HELP WE'VE GOTTEN ON THAT.
- 3:19I WOULD LIKE TO SAY, I DON'T
- 3:21THINK THE FOUNDERS OF OUR
- 3:22COMMONWEALTH INTENDED TO DENY
- 3:25EDUCATION FREEDOM BACK WHEN THEY
- 3:26WROTE THE CONSTITUTION BACK IN
- 3:28THE LATE 1800'S.
- 3:29THIS AMENDMENT IS INTENDED TO
- 3:32CLARIFY THAT NOTHING IN THE
- 3:34CONSTITUTION PREVENTS
- 3:35LEGISLATORS FROM FUNDING A
- 3:37SCHOOL CHOICE PROGRAM.
- 3:39>> Renee: THANK YOU FOR BEING
- 3:40WITH US THIS IS YOUR FINAL TIME
- 3:42ON KEN "KENTUCKY TONIGHT".
- 3:46ANYTHING ADDITIONAL?
- 3:46>> I WOULD MIRROR WHAT HE SAID.
- 3:50AMERICANS FOR PROSPERITY
- 3:51BELIEVES THAT THERE ARE
- 3:55SOLUTIONS TO THE EDUCATION
- 3:57PROBLEMS THAT WE'RE FACING.
- 3:58AND THERE IS A LOT OF INNOVATIVE
- 4:01IDEAS THAT CAN COME FROM A
- 4:03VARIETY OF DIFFERENT SCHOOL
- 4:06INSTITUTIONS.
- 4:07MANY OF THOSE WOULD BE A PUBLIC
- 4:09SCHOOL CHOICE FOR FAMILIES.
- 4:11BUT THERE ARE OTHER CHOICES THAT
- 4:13WOULD BETTER MEET THE NEEDS OF A
- 4:15CHILD.
- 4:16AND SO WE WANT FAMILIES TO BE
- 4:18ABLE TO MAKE THAT DECISION.
- 4:20AND CHOOSE WHAT IS BEST FOR
- 4:22THEIR OWN CHILD.
- 4:23>> Renee: Mr. CAMPBELL YOU
- 4:25HAVE BEEN PART OF THIS
- 4:25DISCUSSION FOR A WHILE.
- 4:27WELCOME BACK.
- 4:27THE BIG QUESTION THAT WE HEAR IS
- 4:29WHY NOT LET KENTUCKY VOTERS
- 4:31DECIDE?
- 4:31WHAT IS WRONG WITH PUTTING IT
- 4:33BEFORE THEM?
- 4:33ARE YOU AGAINST THAT IN
- 4:35PRINCIPLE?
- 4:35>> SO I THINK THE CONSTITUTION
- 4:37ALLOWS FOR THAT.
- 4:38WHEN WE LOOK AT SECTION 184 OF
- 4:41THE CONSTITUTION IT ALLOWS FOR A
- 4:43REFERENDUM.
- 4:44THIS WE ALREADY HAVE SCHOOL
- 4:45CHOICE IN KENTUCKY A PARENT CAN
- 4:47DECIDE WHEREVER THEY WANT TO
- 4:49SEND THEIR STUDENT OR CHILD HOW
- 4:51THEY WANT THEIR CHILD EDUCATED.
- 4:53THIS ISN'T ABOUT SCHOOL CHOICE
- 4:56IT'S ABOUT INITIATING VOUCHER
- 4:58PROGRAMS THAT TAKE PUBLIC TAX
- 5:00DOLLARS AND SEND THEM TO
- 5:02UNACCOUNTABLE PRIVATE ENTITIES.
- 5:04AND WE HAVE SUCH APPRECIATE
- 5:06STATE HOUSE RESOURCES WITH OUR
- 5:08TAX DOLLARS.
- 5:08THEY ARE THERE FOR THE COMMON
- 5:10GOOD.
- 5:10THEY ARE THERE TO SUPPORT NOT
- 5:11ONLY OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS, BUT
- 5:13OTHER PUBLIC WORKS AND THEY ARE
- 5:15SUPPOSED TO BE SUPPORTING
- 5:17EVERYONE.
- 5:17SO ALLOWING FOR OUR PUBLIC
- 5:19SCHOOLS TO HAVE ACCESS TO THOSE
- 5:20DOLLARS IS VERY IMPORTANT.
- 5:25>> Renee: SO Dr. BLOM, WHAT IS
- 5:27WRONG WITH MONEY FOLLOWING
- 5:28STUDENTS AND NOT FOLLOWING
- 5:31SYSTEMS?
- 5:31>> YOU KNOW, IT'S BEEN MENTIONED
- 5:33TONIGHT THE ACHIEVEMENT ISSUES
- 5:35THAT WE HAVE IN KENTUCKY.
- 5:36AND THAT'S UNDENIABLE.
- 5:38WE HAVE ROOM TO IMPROVE WHEN IT
- 5:39COMES TO STUDENT OUTCOMES.
- 5:41AND WITH LIMITED TAX DOLLARS
- 5:43THOSE TAX DOLLARS COME FROM EACH
- 5:44OF US AS TAX-PAYING CITIZENS
- 5:48WITH LIMITED DOLLARS WE SHOULD
- 5:49BE INVESTING THE DOLLARS AS
- 5:51WISELY AS POSSIBLE AND WE SHOULD
- 5:54BE PAYING ATTENTION TO THE
- 5:55RESEARCH THAT SHOWS STRATEGY
- 5:57SUGGEST STRATEGIES THAT ARE
- 5:59GOING TO BE RETURN THE MOST
- 6:02INVESTMENT FROM AN
- 6:03ACCOUNTABILITY STAND PILOT.
- 6:04THERE IS NO RESEARCH TO DATE
- 6:06WHICH HE IT COMES TO PRIVATE
- 6:08SCHOOL CHOICE THAT SHOWS THAT
- 6:09THAT IS A BETTER STRATEGY WITH
- 6:11TAXPAYER DOLLARS THAN THE
- 6:12CURRENT STRATEGIES WE'RE
- 6:14UTILIZING AS A STATE.
- 6:15WHEN IT COMES TO CHARTER SCHOOLS
- 6:16IT IS A DIFFERENT CONVERSATION.
- 6:17AND I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT IF
- 6:20ANYBODY WALK AS WHAT ARE FROM
- 6:21THIS CONVERSATION THAT THEY
- 6:22UNDERSTAND THE DIFFERENCE IN
- 6:23PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS AND
- 6:25PRIVATE SCHOOL CHOICE AND
- 6:27TRADITIONAL PUBLIC EDUCATION.
- 6:29UNDERSTANDING THOSE THREE THINGS
- 6:30IS REALLY IMPORTANT FOR DECIDING
- 6:32THE STRATEGIES THAT A STATE
- 6:34SHOULD USE TO IMPROVE EDUCATION
- 6:36OUTCOMES THAT IS WHAT WE'RE
- 6:38PAYING INTO AS TAXPAYERS.
- 6:40>> Renee: SUPPORTERS OF SCHOOL
- 6:41CHOICE MEASURES SAID THAT THE
- 6:43MAJORITY OF KENTUCKY KIDS WILL
- 6:44GO THROUGH THE TRADITIONAL
- 6:46PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM.
- 6:4890% OR SO.
- 6:49DO YOU DISAGREE WITH THAT?
- 6:50>> ABSOLUTELY NOT.
- 6:52REGARDLESS OF WHAT STRATEGIES
- 6:53THE LEGISLATURE DECIDES TO
- 6:55INVEST IN, THE VAST MAJORITY OF
- 6:57KENTUCKY'S ROUGHLY 650,000
- 7:00STUDENTS WILL BE IN TRADITIONAL
- 7:03PUBLIC SCHOOLS AS WE KNOW THEM.
- 7:05MAINTAINING ADEQUATE INVESTMENT
- 7:06IN PUBLIC EDUCATION IS A
- 7:09CRITICAL FIRST STEP TO ANYTHING
- 7:10ELSE WE MIGHT ADD TO THE SYSTEM.
- 7:13WE WOULD ARGUE ANYTHING ELSE
- 7:14THAT GETS ADDED TO THE SYSTEM
- 7:16SHOULD BE GROUNDED IN RESEARCH
- 7:17THAT SUGGESTS TO THE INVESTOR IN
- 7:19THIS CASE THE TAXPAYER, THERE IS
- 7:20GOING TO BE AN ADEQUATE RETURN
- 7:22ON THAT.
- 7:22>> Renee: YOU SAY THAT RESEARCH
- 7:24DOES NOT PROVE THAT'S WHAT
- 7:26HAPPENS?
- 7:27>> DO DATE THERE IS NO UNBIASED
- 7:30RESEARCH IN THE AREA OF PRIVATE
- 7:32SCHOOL CHOICE THAT SUGGESTS
- 7:33INVESTING IN PRIVATE SCHOOLS
- 7:35WITH TAXPAYER DOLLARS WILL
- 7:37RETURN A BETTER OUTCOME THAN
- 7:40TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS ARE.
- 7:41>> Renee: BUT CHARTER SCHOOLS IS
- 7:42A DIFFERENT STORY.
- 7:43>> IT IS A DIFFERENT STORY.
- 7:44THERE WE HAVE RESEARCH META
- 7:48ANALYSIS THAT DO POINT TO
- 7:50CHARTER SCHOOLS HAVING A
- 7:51POSITIVE IMPACT STATISTICALLY
- 7:54SIGNIFICANT ABOVE TRADITIONAL
- 7:56PUBLIC SCHOOLS FOR SOME SETS OF
- 7:58STUDENTS IN SOME CIRCUMSTANCES.
- 7:59AND THAT IS LARGELY IN URBAN
- 8:02AREAS FOR TRADITIONALLY
- 8:04MARGINALIZED STUDENTS WHERE
- 8:06CHARTERS CAN DELIVER A BETTER
- 8:07EDUCATION FOR THOSE STUDENTS
- 8:09THAN THE TRADITIONAL PUBLIC
- 8:11SCHOOL.
- 8:12>> Renee: RESPOND TO WHAT SHE
- 8:14SAID THAT THE END WITH CHARTER
- 8:18SCHOOLS YIELDING POSITIVE
- 8:20RESULTS FOR DISADVANTAGED
- 8:21STUDENTS.
- 8:21>> OUR PUBLIC STUDENTS OPEN
- 8:24THEIR DOOR TO ALL STUDENTS.
- 8:25IT DOESN'T MATTER WHERE THEY
- 8:27COME FROM AND WHAT THEIR
- 8:28BACKGROUND IS.
- 8:29MAKING SURE OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 8:30HAVE ALL THE OPPORTUNITIES TO
- 8:32GIVE TO STUDENTS IS IMPORTANT.
- 8:34SO WE NEED TO MAKE SURE WE'RE
- 8:36FUNDING.
- 8:37THE BETTER QUESTION WE NEEDING
- 8:38TO ASKING IS WE HAVE A SURPLUS
- 8:40IN THE BUDGET WHY ARE WE NOT
- 8:43INVESTING IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 8:44TO MAKE SURE THAT ALL OF OUR
- 8:46STUDENTS NO MATTER WHERE THEY
- 8:47ARE LOCATED WHETHER IT'S URBAN
- 8:49OR RURAL HAVE THE SAME
- 8:50OPPORTUNITIES.
- 8:51WE SAW WHEN CARA PASSED IN THE
- 8:54EARLY 90s THAT INVESTMENT IN
- 8:56OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS, EDUCATION
- 9:00ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE STATE ROSE
- 9:02KENTUCKY WENT FROM THE BOTTOM TO
- 9:03THE MIDDLE AND WAS GROWING AND
- 9:06KENTUCKY WAS A LIGHTHOUSE IN THE
- 9:08SNAKES ON WHAT TO DO RIGHT WHEN
- 9:10YOU INVEST IN YOUR PUBLIC
- 9:11SCHOOLS.
- 9:12RIGHT NOW WE HAVE RECORD REVENUE
- 9:16THAT IS COME INTO THE STATE AND
- 9:18WE SHOULD BE INVESTING IN THOSE
- 9:19SCHOOLS.
- 9:20RIGHT NOW THE SEEK FUNDING IS
- 9:2229% BEHIND WHERE IT SHOULD BE
- 9:23WHEN YOU ADJUST FOR INFLATION.
- 9:25OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS ARE NOT
- 9:28IMMUNE TO INFLATION.
- 9:29THINGS GO UP.
- 9:30WE NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE
- 9:32PUTTING THE MONEY AND THOSE
- 9:33DOLLARS IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS SO
- 9:35WE CAN OFFER ALL OF THOSE
- 9:37OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDENTS NO
- 9:39MATTER WHERE THEY COME FROM.
- 9:41>> Renee: PROPOSED BY HOUSE
- 9:42REPUBLICANS PUTS IT AT 4800.
- 9:44WHAT IS THE BETTER NUMBER PER
- 9:46STUDENT?
- 9:48WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT FUNDING
- 9:49WHICH IS SEEK.
- 9:50>> IF IT KEPT UP WITH INFLATION
- 9:52FROM 2008 IT SHOULD BE AROUND
- 9:545500 RIGHT NOW.
- 9:55AND THAT'S A MAJOR JUMP FROM
- 9:58WHAT IS BEING PROPOSED.
- 9:59CAN YOU IMAGINE WHAT OUR PUBLIC
- 10:02SCHOOLS COULD DO HOW THEY COULD
- 10:03PROVIDE OPPORTUNITIES WITH A
- 10:05THOUSAND DOLLARS EXTRA PER
- 10:06STUDENT AS REVENUE FOR THAT
- 10:09DISTRICT TO PROVIDE SMALLER
- 10:11CLASS SIZES TO PROVIDE TUTORING
- 10:14PROVIDE OTHER OPPORTUNITIES THAT
- 10:15STUDENTS DON'T HAVE RIGHT NOW.
- 10:18>> Renee: SO Mr. WATERS DOES
- 10:20MORE MONEY MEAN BETTER ACADEMIC
- 10:24OUTCOMES.
- 10:25>> I WANT TO SEE THE EVIDENCE
- 10:26WHERE SPENDING MORE
- 10:28AUTOMATICALLY MEANS A BETTER
- 10:29EDUCATION SYSTEM.
- 10:30WE HAVE INCREASED SPENDING SINCE
- 10:32CARA PASSED IN 1990 WAS
- 10:34IMPLEMENTED IN 1990 PER PUPIL
- 10:37FUNDING IN KENTUCKY HAS RISEN BY
- 10:39122%.
- 10:40Mr. CAMPBELL TALKS ABOUT THE
- 10:42SEEK FUNDING AND THAT IS ONE OF
- 10:44THE STREAMS.
- 10:45WE HAVE SEVERAL STREAMS OF
- 10:46REVENUE THAT COME IN FOR EACH
- 10:48STUDENT IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 10:50SYSTEM.
- 10:50FEDERAL DOLLARS, LOCAL PROPERTY
- 10:52TAX DOLLARS.
- 10:53OTHER DOLLARS THAT COME IN.
- 10:54REALLY AN HONEST DISCUSSION
- 10:56ABOUT THIS LOOKS AT THE OVERALL
- 10:58FUNDING THAT SCHOOLS HAVE
- 10:59GOTTEN.
- 11:00IF YOU LOOK AT THAT, EXCEPT FOR
- 11:01THE GREAT RECESSION PERIOD THERE
- 11:072008-2013 THAT PURCHASE PUPIL --
- 11:10PER PUPIL FUNDING INCREASED.
- 11:12IF YOU TAKE INFLATION IN 1990 WE
- 11:15WERE SPENDING 7800.
- 11:19TODAY IT'S 17,000 PER STUDENT.
- 11:22BUT I'D LIKE TO --
- 11:23THERE IS A LOT TO TALK ABOUT
- 11:25WHEN I AGREE WITH Mr. CAMPBELL
- 11:27ON SOMETHING HE SAID WE HAVE
- 11:28SCHOOL CHOICE IN KENTUCKY AND WE
- 11:30DO.
- 11:30WE DO IF YOU'RE WEALTHY AND ABLE
- 11:33TO WRITE A CHECK TO A PRIVATE
- 11:36SCHOOL, COVER THE TUITION.
- 11:38YOU HAVE CHOICE.
- 11:38IF YOU ARE ABLE TO UP AND MOVE
- 11:40TO A SCHOOL DISTRICT THAT IS
- 11:41BETTER FOR YOUR CHILD YOU HAVE
- 11:44CHOICE.
- 11:45BUT IF YOU ARE NOT ABLE TO DO
- 11:46THAT THE QUESTION I'D LIKE TO
- 11:48ASK HERE AND THIS QUESTION IS
- 11:50OFTEN DUCKED AND NOT ANSWERED
- 11:53AND AVOIDED, SHOULD A CHILD
- 11:55WHOSE FUTURE CAN ABSOLUTELY BE
- 11:57CHANGED FOR THE BETTER IF THEY
- 11:58WERE IN A SCHOOL THAT WORKS
- 12:00BETTER FOR THEM SHOULD THEY BE
- 12:02DENIED THAT OPPORTUNITY SIMPLY
- 12:04BECAUSE THEIR PARENTS CAN'T
- 12:06WRITE THAT CHECK OR CAN'T MOVE
- 12:08TO A BETTER SCHOOL DISTRICT?
- 12:09>> I THINK WE HAVE TO BE CAREFUL
- 12:12THERE THERE IS A BIT OF A
- 12:14MISNOMER.
- 12:15PARENTS ARE NOT DENIED AN
- 12:17OPPORTUNITY TO ATTEND PRIVATE
- 12:19SCHOOLS BECAUSE WE CURRENTLY
- 12:21HAVE MANY SCHOLARSHIP FUNDS IN
- 12:22THE STATE THAT DONORS DONATE TO.
- 12:26TO ALLOW STUDENTS TO BE
- 12:28SCHOLARSHIPPED INTO PRIVATE
- 12:29EDUCATION IF FAMILIES KNTS'
- 12:30AFFORD IT.
- 12:31>> LET'S ALLOW ONE MORE.
- 12:32>> AND ONE MORE, THE LEGISLATION
- 12:35THAT HAS BEEN PROPOSED IN THE
- 12:37PAST THAT THAT ONE MORE IS
- 12:39ACTUALLY A TAX CREDIT WHICH
- 12:42RETURNS THE MOST RECENT
- 12:44LEGISLATION UP TO 90 CHENS ON
- 12:45THE DOLLAR TO THE DONOR.
- 12:48SO THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS
- 12:51PARENTS CAN ACCESS ALTERNATIVES
- 12:54TO PUBLIC EDUCATION IF THEY
- 12:55CHOOSE TO.
- 12:57AND THERE ARE GENEROUS DONORS IN
- 12:58THE STATE WHO ALLOW FOR STUDENTS
- 13:01TO ATTEND CATHOLIC SCHOOLS,
- 13:04PAROCHIAL SCHOOLS OTHER PUBLIC
- 13:06INSTITUTIONS WITH THOSE
- 13:07SCHOLARSHIP DOLLARS.
- 13:08IT'S IMPORTANT FOR AS THIS GOES
- 13:09TO THE VOTERS LATER IN THE YEAR,
- 13:11AND THE VOTERS WILL DECIDE IF
- 13:13THERE IS PUBLIC WILL TO MOVE IN
- 13:15THIS DIRECTION.
- 13:16THEY NEED TO UNDERSTAND THE
- 13:17DIFFERENCES IN THESE THINGS LIKE
- 13:19TAX CREDITS AND DEDUCTIONS FOR
- 13:21DONATIONS AND SCHOLARSHIP FUNDS.
- 13:24>> AND GET RID OF THE MISNOMERS.
- 13:27>> THE MISNOMER WE NEED TO GET
- 13:30RID OF THAT WE NEED TO PUT THE
- 13:32NEEDS OF STUDENTS FIRST OVER THE
- 13:34SYSTEM.
- 13:34LET THE SYSTEM RESPOND TO THE
- 13:37STUDENTS.
- 13:38LET THEM.
- 13:39WE'VE GOT 35,45 STATES THAT HAVE
- 13:43CHARTER SCHOOLS NOW WHICH YOU
- 13:44ARE RIGHT THERE IS A DIFFERENCE
- 13:46PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL BECAUSE OF
- 13:47THE DATA WE CAN GET FROM PUBLIC
- 13:48EDUCATION WE KNOW HOW THEY ARE
- 13:51PERFORMING AND THEY ARE REALLY
- 13:52THE ONLY KIND OF EDUCATION IN
- 13:53SOME PLACES THAT HAS CLOSED THE
- 13:56GAP BETWEEN BLACK AND WHITE
- 13:59STUDENTS.
- 14:00WE DES FRATLY NEED THAT IN OUR
- 14:03URBAN AREAS.
- 14:04BUT THE MISNOMER THAT WE DON'T
- 14:06NEED TO SUPPORT FAMILIES THAT
- 14:08CAN'T AFFORD OR CAN'T MAKE THAT
- 14:09JUMP I THINK THAT IS A MISNOMER.
- 14:12MOST KENTUCKIANS WOULD AGREE IF
- 14:14SOMEBODY NEEDS HELP IN SENDING
- 14:16THEIR CHILD TO A SCHOOL THAT
- 14:17WORKS BETTER FOR THEM WE SHOULD
- 14:19DO THAT.
- 14:20>> JIM ON THE POINT ABOUT
- 14:22CHARTERS ARE THE ONLY SCHOOLS
- 14:23THAT CLOSED ACHIEVEMENT GAPS.
- 14:25>> THE ONLY PROGRAMS.
- 14:27>> WE HAVE EXAMPLES RIGHT HERE
- 14:29IN KENTUCKY OF SCHOOLS THAT HAVE
- 14:31CLOSED ACHIEVEMENT GAPS AND
- 14:33NARROWED THEM SIGNIFICANTLY.
- 14:34ONE IS YEARS AGO WHEN WE
- 14:36REPORTED ON SOUTH HEIGHTS
- 14:37ELEMENTARY IN HENDERSON,
- 14:39KENTUCKY.
- 14:40WHERE THE MATH AND THE READING
- 14:44PERFORMANCE OF AFRICAN-AMERICAN
- 14:44STUDENTS IN THAT ELEMENTARY
- 14:46SCHOOL WAS TWICE THE NATIONAL
- 14:48AVERAGE.
- 14:49I'M SORRY TWICE THE STATE
- 14:51AVERAGE.
- 14:51AND WE LOOKED INTO --
- 14:53>> Renee: WHAT WERE THEY DOING
- 14:55DIFFERENTLY THAT CAUSED THAT
- 14:56SUCCESS?
- 14:56>> WHEN WE TALK ABOUT INVESTING
- 14:58DOLLARS WE HAVE TO BE REALLY
- 15:00INTENTIONAL WHAT WE'RE INVESTING
- 15:01IN.
- 15:02WHAT THE RESEARCH SHOWS WORKS IS
- 15:05ENSURING THAT ALL OF OUR YOUNG
- 15:07PEOPLE HAVE ACCESS TO THE HEALTH
- 15:08AND MENTAL HEALTH AND PHYSICAL
- 15:10HEALTH SERVICES THAT THEY NEED
- 15:12TO BE SUCCESSFUL IN THE
- 15:13CLASSROOM.
- 15:14THAT THEY HAVE EXTENDED LEARNING
- 15:15TIME.
- 15:16THAT IS BOTH AFTER SCHOOL AND IN
- 15:17THE SUMMER MONTHS.
- 15:19YOU THINK ABOUT HIGHER WEALTH
- 15:22FAMILIES THEY HAVE THOSE SORTS
- 15:24OF THINGS THEY ARE ABLE TO
- 15:26PROVIDE FOR THEIR YOUNG PEOPLE
- 15:27ON THEIR OWN N A STATE THAT IS
- 15:29SIXTH IN POVERTY, MANY KENTUCKY
- 15:31FAMILIES ARE NOT ABLE TO PROVIDE
- 15:33EXTENDED LEARNING SERVICES, ARE
- 15:35NOT ABLE TO PROVIDE ADEQUATE
- 15:37HEALTH SERVICES.
- 15:39>> Renee: THE SCHOOL IN
- 15:41HENDERSON DOING THOSE THINGS?
- 15:42>> INVESTING IN THAT IN THE
- 15:43NEIGHBORHOOD AROUND THE SCHOOL
- 15:45TO MAKE SURE ALL KIDS COMING TO
- 15:47SCHOOL READY THEY WERE IN AN
- 15:48ENVIRONMENT THAT HONORED THE
- 15:50BACKGROUND THEY WERE COMING FROM
- 15:51AND THOSE STUDENTS PERFORMED AT
- 15:53HIGHER LEVELS.
- 15:54>> Renee: HOW DID THEY AFFORD
- 15:55THAT?
- 15:56>> THEY INVESTED THE DOLLARS IN
- 15:59THAT DISTRICT AND IN THAT SCHOOL
- 16:00IN A WAY THAT HONORED THAT
- 16:02APPROACH.
- 16:02SO WE NEED TO START GETTING
- 16:04MODELS LIKE THIS OUT INTO THE
- 16:07STATE AND HAVE CONVERSATIONS
- 16:08ABOUT MODELS LIKE THIS.
- 16:10>> Renee: WHEN WAS THAT?
- 16:11THE SEEK MONEY WOULD HAVE BEEN
- 16:13LOWER AT THAT TIME.
- 16:15THAT DISTRICT MADE IT WORK WHAT
- 16:16WAS GIVEN FROM THE STATE.
- 16:18>> ANOTHER IMPORTANT WAY THAT
- 16:19IT'S IMPORTANT FOR FOLKS TO
- 16:21UNDERSTAND HOW THIS WORKS IS
- 16:22BRINGING COMMUNITY RESOURCES TO
- 16:24THE TABLE.
- 16:24SO THOSE THAT ARE ARGUING FOR
- 16:27SCHOOL CHOICE ARE ARGUING
- 16:28AGAINST SCHOOL CHOICE WHATEVER
- 16:30IT MIGHT BE ARE WE THINKING
- 16:31ABOUT THE SYSTEM REALLY IN A
- 16:33COMPREHENSIVE WAY?
- 16:34BECAUSE IT'S NOT JUST OUR
- 16:36TRADITIONAL SCHOOL AND THE
- 16:37SCHOOLHOUSE AND THE SCHOOL
- 16:39DISTRICT.
- 16:39OUR SCHOOL DISTRICTS NEED TO
- 16:40WELCOME THE COMMUNITY TO THE
- 16:41TABLE AND THE COMMUNITY NEEDS TO
- 16:43BE WILLING TO COME TO THE TABLE
- 16:45ROLL UP ITS SLEEVES AND SAY WHAT
- 16:47ARE ALL THE ASSETS WE HAVE IN
- 16:48THIS COMMUNITY IN OUR
- 16:50NEIGHBORHOOD IN OUR COMMUNITY AT
- 16:51LARGE AND HOW ARE WE GOING TO
- 16:53BRING ALL THAT TO BEAR FOR THE
- 16:54STUDENTS AND FAMILIES IN OUR
- 16:56COMMUNITY TO ENSURE THEY
- 16:59SUCCEED.
- 17:00>> Renee: THAT IS A LOFT GOAL.
- 17:01WHAT DOES IT LOOK LIKE
- 17:03OPERATIONALLY?
- 17:04WHAT DOES A COMMUNITY DO TO
- 17:07OPERATIONALIZE?
- 17:08>> THERE ARE THINGS LIKE WE
- 17:10COULD LOOK AT HOW DO WE
- 17:12COLLOCATE HEALTH SERVICES IN A
- 17:13SCHOOL THAT NEEDS IT.
- 17:14LET'S THINK ABOUT THE WEST END
- 17:15OF LOUISVILLE.
- 17:17DEEPLY URBAN AREA.
- 17:19HIGH POVERTY, MANY NEEDS.
- 17:20LET'S THINK ABOUT COLLOCATING
- 17:22THE HEALTH SERVICES THAT THOSE
- 17:24STUDENTS AND FAMILIES NEED RIGHT
- 17:26THERE IN THE MAYBE EVEN IN THE
- 17:27SCHOOL PROPERTY ITSELF AND ALLOW
- 17:29THE COMMUNITY, ALLOW THE MEDICAL
- 17:33COMMUNITY, THE ON TOMORROWRY
- 17:34COMMUNITY TO BRING THOSE
- 17:35SERVICES TO BEAR FOR THOSE
- 17:37STUDENTS.
- 17:38SO THAT THE COMMUNITY CAN TAKE
- 17:39CARE OF THE NEEDS OF STUDENTS
- 17:42THAT THEREFORE ALLOWING THE
- 17:43SPACE FOR HIGH QUALITY TEACHING
- 17:45AND LEARNING TO TAKE HOLD.
- 17:47AND HONORING THE PROFESSION THAT
- 17:48OUR TEACHERS ARE IN ALLOW THEM
- 17:51TO DO THE JOB THEY HAVE BEEN
- 17:53TRAINED TO DO WHILE THE
- 17:53COMMUNITY AND ASSETS ALL THE
- 17:55FOLKS WHO WANT THE DIFFERENT
- 17:58SCHEMES CAN SAY WE'RE GOING TO
- 17:59ROLL UP OUR SLEEVES AND HELP
- 18:01WITH THE THINGS THAT KEEP KIDS
- 18:02FROM LEARNING.
- 18:04>> Renee: THE WHOLE CHILD
- 18:05SUPPORTS.
- 18:05>> THE WHOLE CHILD SUPPORT AND
- 18:08IT'S COMMUNITY SCHOOLS.
- 18:09YOU KNOW, AND OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 18:12ARE POISED TO BE PARTNERS WITH
- 18:15THEIR COMMUNITIES THEY WANT TO
- 18:17BE PARTNERS.
- 18:17IF YOU DRIVE BY MY SCHOOL RIGHT
- 18:20NOW, ALL THE DISTRICT
- 18:21TOURNAMENTS ARE GOING ON.
- 18:22YOU WILL DRIVE BY A SCHOOL THE
- 18:24PARKING LOT WILL BE PACKED THE
- 18:25COMMUNITY IS IN THERE SUPPORTING
- 18:26THEIR STUDENTS, SUPPORTING THEIR
- 18:28TEAMS.
- 18:29IT IS A GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO
- 18:31REACH OUT TO THE COMMUNITY AND
- 18:32SAY, HEY WE WANT TO PARTNER WITH
- 18:34YOU TO MAKE SURE WE'RE MEETING
- 18:35ALL THE NEEDS THE WHOLE CHILD
- 18:38WHETHER IT BE MEDICAL SERVICE,
- 18:39DEPOSIT TALL, VISION, AND
- 18:42KENTUCKY HAS SET THAT UP THROUGH
- 18:44OUR FRISKY CENTERS AND THOSE
- 18:46LAID THE FOUNDATION TO MAKE
- 18:48THOSE COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIPS
- 18:49HAPPEN.
- 18:50SO, AGAIN, INVESTING IN OUR
- 18:52PUBLIC SCHOOLS TAKING THIS
- 18:54OPPORTUNITY WE HAVE RIGHT NOW TO
- 18:56LIFT UP EVERY SINGLE PUBLIC
- 18:58SCHOOL ACROSS THE COMMONWEALTH.
- 19:01GIVES EVERY STUDENT IN THE
- 19:02COMMONWEALTH THAT OPPORTUNITY TO
- 19:03HAVE A HIGH QUALITY EDUCATION.
- 19:05AND NOT ALL STUDENTS HAVE
- 19:08OPTIONS.
- 19:09I GREW UP IN LESLIE COUNTY THERE
- 19:10IS NO PRIVATE SCHOOL THERE.
- 19:12AND FUNDING THAT WOULD GO AWAY
- 19:14FROM IN THE STATE AS STUDENTS
- 19:17TAKE THE ADVANTAGE OF THESE
- 19:19VOUCHER SCHEMES, LOWERS THE
- 19:21AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT WILL BE
- 19:22SUPPORTING THOSE RURAL SCHOOLS.
- 19:24>> I JUST WANT TO BRING THE
- 19:29POINT THAT THIS IS
- 19:32OVERWHELMINGLY SUPPORTED BY
- 19:33FAMILIES IN KENTUCKY.
- 19:36WE ARE A GRASSROOTS
- 19:37ORGANIZATION.
- 19:37WE HAVE TALKED TO OVER 200,000
- 19:41PEOPLE AT DOORS SINCE MAY ABOUT
- 19:43THIS ISSUE.
- 19:44AND WE ARE FINDING THAT OVER 70%
- 19:47OF THE PEOPLE THAT WE HAVE
- 19:49TALKED TO AT DOORS AND HAVE LONG
- 19:51CONVERSATIONS WITH ABOUT THEIR
- 19:52THE BIGGEST ISSUES THAT ARE
- 19:55FACING THEM THIS WAS ONE OF THE
- 19:57TOP ISSUES FOR THEM.
- 20:00AND --
- 20:00>> Renee: DID YOU ASK THEM
- 20:02POINT-BLANK SHOULD STATE DOLLARS
- 20:04BE DIVERTED TO PRIVATE SCHOOLS
- 20:05AND THEY SAID YES.
- 20:0770%.
- 20:08>> YES.
- 20:08THEY WANT CHOICES FOR THEIR
- 20:11CHILDREN.
- 20:11AND I THINK WE SAW A MAJOR
- 20:15INCREASE IN SCHOOL CHOICE LAWS
- 20:16PASSED ACROSS THE COUNTRY AFTER
- 20:18COVID.
- 20:20BECAUSE PARENTS WERE JUST
- 20:23DISILLUSIONED WITH THEIR
- 20:24CHILDREN'S EDUCATION AND THEY
- 20:25WANTED OPPORTUNITIES TO PUT
- 20:27THEIR CHILD IN THE BEST
- 20:29EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT FOR
- 20:30THEIR CHILD.
- 20:30SO I THINK WE CAN'T IGNORE THIS
- 20:33IS SOMETHING THAT KENTUCKY
- 20:34FAMILIES WANT.
- 20:35AND THAT THEY ARE ASKING FOR.
- 20:38AND IT IS THE REASON IT'S PASSED
- 20:40IN 33 STATES ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
- 20:42IT'S WHAT PARENTS WANT.
- 20:44>> Renee: SO THIS COMMENT
- 20:47QUESTION QUOTE KENTUCKY
- 20:48STRUGGLES TO HAVE EQUITABLE AND
- 20:50WELL FUNDED EDUCATION WITHOUT
- 20:52FUNDS BEING DIVERTED TO PRIVATE
- 20:54INSTITUTIONS.
- 20:55HOW CAN KENTUCKIANS TRUST THE
- 20:57LEGISLATURE WITH OUR CHILDREN'S
- 20:58FUTURE.
- 20:59DO YOU CARE TO RESPOND TO THAT?
- 21:01>> SURE.
- 21:02ACTUALLY THESE DOLLARS ARE FOR
- 21:04WHAT PURPOSE?
- 21:05THEY ARE FOR THE PURPOSE OF
- 21:07EDUCATING STUDENTS.
- 21:08AND THE SUPREME COURT RULED THAT
- 21:09IN THESE TYPES OF PROGRAMS, THAT
- 21:13THEY ARE CONSTITUTIONAL BECAUSE
- 21:14IT'S PARENTS DECIDING WHERE THE
- 21:16DOLLARS GO AND I THINK THAT IS A
- 21:17KEY IMPORTANT THING.
- 21:18THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE IN
- 21:20VOUCHERS DIRECT VOUCHERS VERSUS
- 21:22A SCHOLARSHIP TAX CREDIT IS ON A
- 21:25SCHOLARSHIP IT'S PARENTS,
- 21:26FAMILIES THAT DECIDE WHERE THE
- 21:27DOLLARS GO.
- 21:29AND.
- 21:30>> Renee: THE SAME TYPE OF
- 21:31SCHEME.
- 21:32WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
- 21:34AN EDUCATION OPPORTUNITY AND A
- 21:35VOUCHER?
- 21:36>> A VOUCHER IS MONEY DIRECTLY
- 21:37GIVEN TO A SCHOOL FOR A STUDENT.
- 21:40WHEREAS A SCHOLARSHIP TAX CREDIT
- 21:43IS A DONATION LIKE Dr. BLOM
- 21:45SAID TO A THIRD PARTY NONPROFIT.
- 21:48>> Renee: A TAX DEDUCTIBLE.
- 21:51>> TAX DEDUCTIBLE DONATION THE
- 21:54NONPROFIT THEN HANDS THE DOLLARS
- 21:55OUT ACCORDING TO QUALIFIED
- 21:57STUDENTS.
- 21:57AND WHERE THEY WANT TO GO TO
- 21:59SCHOOL.
- 22:00MY QUESTION THOUGH I HAVE A
- 22:01QUESTION IS, WHY DOES THIS HAVE
- 22:03TO BE EITHER OR?
- 22:05I'M FOR BOTH AND.
- 22:07>> Renee: BOTH AND WHAT?
- 22:08>> I WANT A GREAT PUBLIC
- 22:11EDUCATION SYSTEM REALLY THIS IS
- 22:14WE HAVE GREAT SCHOOLS WE HAVE
- 22:16GREAT TEACHERS.
- 22:18WE HAVE AND ABOUT A THIRD OF OUR
- 22:19KIDS IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS ARE
- 22:22GETTING A GREAT EDUCATION IN
- 22:23TERMS OF RESULTS.
- 22:25ABOUT A THIRD ARE THERE BUT THEY
- 22:27ARE NOT GETTING THE RESULTS THAT
- 22:30WE NEED TO SEE AND ANOTHER THIRD
- 22:32ARE FALLING THROUGH THE CRACKS.
- 22:33SO WHY DOES IT HAVE TO BE EITHER
- 22:35OR?
- 22:36IT CAN BE A WIN-WIN.
- 22:37WE SEE IN FLORIDA FOR EXAMPLE,
- 22:39THE MORE CHOICES FLORIDA HAS HAD
- 22:41THEY HAVE THE MOST EDUCATIONAL
- 22:43OPTIONS IN THE COUNTRY.
- 22:44AND GUESS WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO
- 22:46THE PUBLIC SCHOOL PERFORMANCE?
- 22:48ESPECIALLY WE SEE WITH CHARTER
- 22:50SCHOOLS OUTPERFORMING MANY
- 22:51TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 22:54SO THIS --
- 22:54>> Renee: HAS IT IMPROVED THE
- 22:56TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 22:57BECAUSE OF THE COMPETITION?
- 22:58>> AND THEY ARE SPENDING LESS
- 23:00DOING IT.
- 23:01SO TO YOUR POINT, I AGREE
- 23:03RESOURCES ARE PRECIOUS AND THEY
- 23:05NEED TO BE USED WISELY.
- 23:07BUT FROM WHAT WE'RE SEEING IN
- 23:09OTHER STATES THIS IS NOT ABOUT
- 23:11DESTROYING PUBLIC EDUCATION THIS
- 23:12IS ABOUT IMPROVING IT.
- 23:13AND I THINK WITH THAT MOTIVATION
- 23:16OF CHOICE AND COMPETITION, I
- 23:18THINK IT WILL CAUSE IMPROVEMENT
- 23:20IN OUR PUBLIC EDUCATION SYSTEM.
- 23:23AND, LOOK, WE'VE GOT AREAS IN
- 23:25OUR STATE LIKE APPALACHIA THEY
- 23:27HAVE MADE PROGRESS IN SCHOOLS
- 23:28WITH READING PERFORMANCE.
- 23:30POVERTY CAN'T BE --
- 23:32POVERTY IS A REASON EVEN MORE OF
- 23:34A REASON TO GET THIS RIGHT.
- 23:36BECAUSE WE HAVE A LOT OF KIDS
- 23:37WHO NEED US TO GET THIS RIGHT.
- 23:39AND IN LOUISVILLE, WE'VE GOT A
- 23:4230-50S OF OUR KIDS THAT THE
- 23:46CANNOT READ PROFICIENTLY IN OUR
- 23:47STATE.
- 23:48LET'S NOT SUGAR COAT WHAT IS
- 23:50HAPPENING.
- 23:50>> I WOULD ARGUE THERE THAT
- 23:53ABSOLUTELY, POVERTY SHOULD BE AN
- 23:55ARGUMENT FOR US TO MAKE WISE
- 23:57DECISIONS WITH PUBLIC DOLLARS.
- 24:00IF WE ARE ALLOWING, RIGHT, LESS
- 24:04THAN IMPACTFUL POSITIVELY
- 24:07IMPACTFUL STRATEGIES TO BE PAID
- 24:07FOR WITH TAX DOLLARS, WE'RE
- 24:10ACTUALLY HURTING THE FAMILIES
- 24:12AND THE YOUNG PEOPLE IN OUR
- 24:13STATE AND HURTING OUR OUTLOOK
- 24:15FROM AN ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS
- 24:17STANDPOINT.
- 24:18SO IF POVERTY IS THE ARGUMENT,
- 24:21IT BEHOOVES US TO MAKE
- 24:23EXCEPTIONALLY WISE DECISIONS
- 24:24WITH PUBLIC DOLLARS BECAUSE WE
- 24:25DON'T HAVE THE DOLLARS TO WASTE.
- 24:27>> AND WE'RE CAUSING OUR
- 24:29CHILDREN TO SUFFER IF WE DON'T
- 24:31TEACH THEM HOW TO READ AND IF WE
- 24:33DON'T TEACH THEM HOW TO DO MATH
- 24:35IF THEY ARE NOT PREPARED FOR THE
- 24:37JOBS WE ARE FAILING THEM IN THAT
- 24:39WAY.
- 24:39>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 24:40>> I'M ALL FOR THE MENTAL HEALTH
- 24:43PROGRAMS AND THE DENTAL AND
- 24:44ANYTHING WE CAN DO.
- 24:45BUT IF WE DO ALL OF THAT AND WE
- 24:47DON'T EDUCATE OUR CHILDREN, I
- 24:49THINK THAT IS A REAL PROBLEM.
- 24:50>> YOU WILL NEVER HEAR ME SAY WE
- 24:53DO ALL OF THAT AND WE DON'T
- 24:55EDUCATE.
- 24:55>> THE EMPHASIS NEEDS TO BE ON
- 24:58THAT.
- 24:58>> MAKING SURE AS THIS GOES TO
- 25:01AS WILL LIKELY BE A VOTE FOR A
- 25:03CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT THIS
- 25:04YEAR IT IS SO IMPORTANT THAT
- 25:05VOTERS ARE INFORMED ON THESE
- 25:08ISSUES.
- 25:08SO REALLY OWNING THE FACT THAT
- 25:09WE HAVE DROPPED FROM 8TH IN THE
- 25:12NATION IN FOURTH GRADE READING
- 25:14IN 2015 TO 29TH.
- 25:15WE ARE GOING IN THE WRONG
- 25:17DIRECTION AS A STATE AND THAT IS
- 25:19UNDENIABLE.
- 25:20WE'VE NEVER RANKED HIGHER THAN
- 25:2233 IN THE NATION IN MATH AND
- 25:24WE'VE DROPPED TO 41.
- 25:26DO WE HAVE PROBLEMS THAT NEED TO
- 25:27BE SOLVED?
- 25:28ABSOLUTELY WE DO.
- 25:29AND WE MUST SPEND THOSE DOLLARS
- 25:33WISELY.
- 25:33>> Renee: SO DOES THAT ALSO MEAN
- 25:34IN INVESTING THE READ TO SUCCEED
- 25:37PROGRAM AND ADDRESS LITERACY AND
- 25:39NOW BILL WILL BE CONSIDERED
- 25:42ADDRESSING NUMERACY AND
- 25:43MATHEMATICS.
- 25:44>> AND WHAT WE KNOW WORKS.
- 25:45LET'S GO BACK TO THE RESEARCH
- 25:47AGAIN.
- 25:47WE CAN TALK ABOUT PARENT CHOICE
- 25:49AND WE HAVE POLLING THAT TELLS
- 25:50US WHAT PARENTS WANT, TOO.
- 25:52AND THE OVERWHELMING MAJORITY
- 25:5493% OF BOTH PARENTS AND VOTERS
- 25:57WANT KIDS TO BE ABLE TO READ,
- 26:00WRITE AND TO DO AATHYMIA
- 26:02PARTICULAR.
- 26:03THEY WANT THEM TO THINK
- 26:05CRITICALLY AND SKILLS TO BE
- 26:06SUCCESSFUL.
- 26:07WHAT WE KNOW WORKS IS INVESTING
- 26:09IN TEACHING AND ENSURING OUR
- 26:11TEACHERS HAVE THE TOOLS THEY
- 26:13NEED WHETHER THEY ARE IN PRIVATE
- 26:14SCHOOLS AND SUPPORTED BY TUITION
- 26:16OR THEY ARE IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 26:17AND THEY ARE SUPPORTED BY TAX
- 26:19DOLLARS.
- 26:20THOSE ARE THE THINGS THE
- 26:22STRATEGIES THAT WE NEED TO HE
- 26:23FOCUS ON.
- 26:24>> Renee: THIS QUESTION FROM
- 26:25MARTIN RIVERS OF LEXINGTON IS IT
- 26:27TRUE THAT PUBLIC SCHOOLS RE8 A
- 26:29PLACE TO BRING TOGETHER CHILDREN
- 26:31OF ALL KINDS OF BACKGROUNDS,
- 26:33RELIGION, RACE, INCOME WOULD
- 26:36CHARTER SCHOOLS NOT EFFECTIVELY
- 26:38SEGREGATE ALONG MUTUAL TELL
- 26:41AXIS.
- 26:41ISN'T HAVING CHILDREN INTERACT
- 26:43WITH DIFFERENT PEOPLE GOOD AND
- 26:44IMPORTANT FOR CIVIL SOCIETY?
- 26:46YOU MENTIONED THIS EARLIER,
- 26:47Mr. CAMPBELL ABOUT HOW PUBLIC
- 26:50SCHOOLS TAKE IN ALL CHILDREN NO
- 26:52CHERRY PICKING.
- 26:53IS IT YOUR CHILDREN THAT OTHER
- 26:54SCHOOLS WHO ARE ALLOWED A LITTLE
- 26:56BIT MORE LIBERTY IN THE TYPE AND
- 26:57QUALITY OF STUDENT THAT THEY CAN
- 26:59ACCEPT WOULD IT LEAD TO THE
- 27:01SEGREGATION THAT Mr. RIVERS
- 27:03ELUDES TO HERE?
- 27:03>> I THINK HE IS RIGHT.
- 27:05WHEN YOU HAVE THE --
- 27:07THERE'S NO REQUIREMENTS PLACED
- 27:10ON PRIVATE SCHOOLS THAT THEY
- 27:12PROVIDE ANY KIND OF SERVICES.
- 27:14THAT THEY PROVIDE SERVICES FOR
- 27:16STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES.
- 27:17THEY CAN PICK AND CHOOSE WHO
- 27:19THEY ALLOW TO COME INTO THEIR
- 27:21SCHOOL OR BE ACCEPTED.
- 27:22>> Renee: SO THEY DON'T HAVE TO
- 27:24FOLLOW FEDERAL LAWS THAT PUBLIC
- 27:25SCHOOLS HAVE TO FOLLOW?
- 27:27>> EXACTLY.
- 27:28OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS ARE VERY
- 27:30ACCOUNTABLE.
- 27:31FOR THE PUBLIC DOLLARS THAT THEY
- 27:32ARE USING FOR THE DOLLARS THAT
- 27:34THEY ARE PUTTING TO EDUCATE OUR
- 27:36STUDENTS.
- 27:37AND IF IT WASN'T, IF IT WASN'T
- 27:39AN ISSUE YOU WOULDN'T HAVE SEEN
- 27:42IN THE BUDGET BILL LANGUAGE YOU
- 27:44HAVE TO POST READING AND MATH
- 27:45RATES ON YOUR WEBSITE WHEN WE
- 27:47HAVE A SCHOOL REPORT CARD THAT
- 27:49HAS ALL THAT INFORMATION IN IT
- 27:50RIGHT NOW.
- 27:52I THINK WE HAVE TO REALLY THINK
- 27:54ABOUT THE ACCOUNTABILITY PART.
- 27:59IN THE OTHER SCHOOLS DON'T
- 28:01ALWAYS HAVE THOSE BOUNDARIES
- 28:04THAT OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS OPEN THE
- 28:06DOOR THEY WELCOME EVERYBODY IN.
- 28:07AND I WANT TO GO BACK TO THE
- 28:11POINT ABOUT DOING THE RIGHT
- 28:14THINGS AND BASED ON RESEARCH.
- 28:16WE HAVE EDUCATORS IN THE STATE
- 28:17THAT ARE DOING PHENOMENAL
- 28:19INNOVATIVE WORK IN THEIR
- 28:20CLASSROOMS.
- 28:21THEY ARE THE EXPERTS WHEN IT
- 28:22COMES TO TEACHING AND LEARNING.
- 28:24AND WE'RE NOT HAVING DIRECT
- 28:27CONVERSATIONS WITH THEM ABOUT
- 28:28PROGRAMS THAT THEY CAN INITIATE,
- 28:31RESEARCH BASED PROGRAMS,
- 28:33EVIDENCE-BASED PROGRAMS THAT
- 28:34COME RIGHT OUT OF THE CLASSROOM
- 28:36FROM THE PRACTITIONERS WHO ARE
- 28:38DOING THE WORK.
- 28:39WE NEED TO BE HAVING THOSE
- 28:41CONVERSATIONS.
- 28:41>> Renee: WASN'T THAT THE
- 28:42PURPOSE OF SCHOOLS OF
- 28:43INNOVATION?
- 28:44>> IT WAS.
- 28:44AND WE DON'T HAVE A LOT OF THAT
- 28:46GOING ON.
- 28:47BUT WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
- 28:50OUR TEACHERS AND OUR OTHER
- 28:53EDUCATION SUPPORT PROFESSIONALS
- 28:54WORKING WITH STUDENTS EVERYDAY,
- 28:55HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO PUT IN
- 28:59PLACE AN EVIDENCE-BASED STUDY
- 29:02THAT SHOWS AND CAN PROVE THAT
- 29:04THEY ARE GROWING THEIR STUDENTS.
- 29:05BUT THEN BE ABLE TO SHARE THAT
- 29:08INFORMATION ACROSS THE BROAD
- 29:10SPECTRUM OF PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 29:11AND IF WE'RE NOT CAREFUL, IF
- 29:13WE'RE NOT INVESTING IN OUR
- 29:14PUBLIC SCHOOLS, WE'RE NOT GOING
- 29:15TO HAVE THE HIGHLY QUALIFIED,
- 29:18HIGHLY SKILLED EDUCATORS THAT
- 29:20ARE TRAINED IN WHAT TEACHING AND
- 29:21LEARNING IS SUPPOSED TO LOOK
- 29:23LIKE.
- 29:23>> Renee: THIS COMMENT REAL
- 29:26QUICKLY.
- 29:27CHARTER SCHOOLS GET TO PICK
- 29:29THEIR STUDENTS FROM A VIEWER WHO
- 29:30IS ECHOING WHAT THE PREVIOUS
- 29:32CALLER HAD SAID AND WHAT Mr.
- 29:34CAMPBELL SAID IS IT POSSIBLE
- 29:35THAT THEORY SUCCESS IS BASED ON
- 29:37THE CHOICES IN OPPOSITION TO
- 29:38PUBLIC SCHOOLS WHO HAVE TO
- 29:40PROVIDE EDUCATION TO TO THE
- 29:42STUDENTS THAT CHARTER SCHOOLS
- 29:44WOULD NEVER ACCEPT?
- 29:45>> I THINK WE KEEP MENTIONING
- 29:47PRIVATE SCHOOLS IS THE ONLY
- 29:49OTHER OPTION TO FAMILIES MAKING
- 29:51A DECISION FOR THEIR CHILDREN TO
- 29:53ATTEND A DIFFERENT TYPE OF
- 29:56EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM.
- 29:57AND I THINK THERE IS A VARIETY
- 29:59OF DIFFERENT THINGS THAT THEY
- 30:01CAN USE THIS FUNDING FOR.
- 30:02IT CAN BE HOME SCHOOLING.
- 30:04IT COULD BE A MICRO SCHOOL.
- 30:06THERE IS A VARIETY OF DIFFERENT
- 30:08WAYS THEY CAN USE THE FUNDING.
- 30:09I DON'T WANT US TO JUST FOCUS ON
- 30:12PRIVATE SCHOOLS BECAUSE THERE IS
- 30:13A NUMBER OF OPTIONS AND
- 30:16INNOVATIVE IDEAS AND HOW A CHILD
- 30:18CAN BE EDUCATED.
- 30:21AND SO I JUST WOULD LIKE US
- 30:24FOR --
- 30:25YEAH.
- 30:25>> Renee: HAS THE CONCEPT OF
- 30:27MICRO SCHOOLS COME UP IN
- 30:29KENTUCKY?
- 30:29>> DURING COVID.
- 30:33>> Renee: DEFINE WHAT MICRO
- 30:34SCHOOLS ARE.
- 30:34>> IT CAN BE SMALL COUPLE OF
- 30:37FAMILIES DECIDE THEY WANT TO AND
- 30:39DURING COVID WHEN SCHOOLS WERE
- 30:40SHUT DOWN SOME FAMILIES
- 30:42ASSOCIATED TOGETHER WHICH IS
- 30:44TRULY AN AMERICAN THING.
- 30:45AND DECIDED WE DON'T WANT OUR
- 30:47KIDS TO MISS OUT BECAUSE THESE
- 30:50BUREAUCRATS IN JEFFERSON COUNTY
- 30:51DID NOT WANT TO REOPEN THE
- 30:53SCHOOLS THEY GOT TOGETHER AND
- 30:54SAID WE'RE GOING TO EDUCATE OUR
- 30:56CHILDREN AND THEY FOUND AND
- 30:58HIRED A TEACHER TO DO THAT AND
- 30:59THE KIDS DID NOT MISS OUT.
- 31:01I HAVE TO CLEAR UP SOMETHING IN
- 31:03CHARTER SCHOOLS ALL 45 CHARTER
- 31:05SCHOOLS LAWS STIPULATE THAT
- 31:07CHARTER SCHOOLS CANNOT PICK AND
- 31:08CHOOSE THEY MUST TAKE
- 31:11FIRST-COME-FIRST-SERVE AND THAT
- 31:12IS EVERY LAW INCLUDING THE LAW
- 31:14THAT PASSED HERE IN KENTUCKY
- 31:15THAT HAS BEEN STRUCK DOWN BY THE
- 31:17COURT STILL TO BE HEARD PROBABLY
- 31:19BOOT THE SUPREME COURT.
- 31:21THESE ARE PUBLIC SCHOOLS IT'S
- 31:22IMPORTANT TO NOTE BEFORE THIS
- 31:23VOTE IN NOVEMBER, WHAT REALLY IS
- 31:26WHAT.
- 31:27CHARTER SCHOOLS ARE PUBLIC
- 31:28SCHOOLS.
- 31:28THEY ARE PUBLICLY FUNDED THEY
- 31:29HAVE TO ABIDE BY THE SAME
- 31:31TESTING REQUIREMENTS AND MANY OF
- 31:33THE OTHER REQUIREMENTS.
- 31:34THE DIFFERENCE IS THEY CAN BE
- 31:36MORE INNOVATIVE IN THEIR
- 31:37APPROACH IN THEIR DAY-TO-DAY
- 31:39APPROACH.
- 31:40AND THEY HAVE A CHARTER AND THEY
- 31:41HAVE A PRINCIPAL FOR THAT SCHOOL
- 31:44THAT IS IN CHARGE OF THAT SCHOOL
- 31:45AND THEY HAVE TO BE ACCOUNTABLE
- 31:47FOR WHATEVER THEY SAY THEY ARE
- 31:48GOING TO DO IN THE CHARTER.
- 31:50FOR EXAMPLE, IN THE LAW, IF
- 31:53THERE ARE MORE STUDENTS WANTING
- 31:54IT TO GET INTO A CHARTER SCHOOL
- 31:57THAN THERE ARE SEATS THEY TO
- 31:59HAVE A RANDOM LOTTERY.
- 32:00THAT IS AS UN--
- 32:02THAT IS NOT CHERRY PICKING AND
- 32:03THAT IS NOW MAGNET SCHOOLS CAN
- 32:07THEY HAVE AN ADMISSION PROCESS
- 32:09WHERE THEY CAN DENY STUDENTS
- 32:10THAT DON'T FIT THAT REQUIREMENT.
- 32:13EVEN SOME OF THE TRADITIONAL
- 32:14SCHOOLS DO THAT.
- 32:16CHARTER SCHOOLS BY LAW CANNOT DO
- 32:18THAT.
- 32:18AND WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT LEARNING
- 32:20DISABLED CHILDREN THAT IS
- 32:21ANOTHER AREA WE NEED CHOICES IN.
- 32:23WE NEED SCHOLARSHIPS FOR THOSE
- 32:25FAMILIES TO BE ABLE TO GET THE
- 32:26SERVICES AND THE TUTORING OR
- 32:28WHATEVER IT IS THEY NEED.
- 32:29LET'S BE CLEAR THAT CHARTER
- 32:31SCHOOLS ARE PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 32:33>> THIS IS A REALLY IMPORTANT
- 32:34POINT THAT JIM IS MAKING THAT
- 32:36PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS ARE HELD
- 32:40ACCOUNTABLE UNDER THE CURRENT
- 32:41ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM AND TO THE
- 32:43LOCAL DISTRICT.
- 32:43BECAUSE IN KENTUCKY THEY WOULD
- 32:45BE AUTHORIZED BY THE LOCAL
- 32:46DISTRICT OR IN THE CASE OF
- 32:48NORTHERN KENTUCKY BY NORTHERN
- 32:50KENTUCKY UNIVERSITY.
- 32:51BUT THAT ACCOUNTABILITY PIECE IS
- 32:52IMPORTANT.
- 32:53WHEN WE TALK ABOUT PRIVATE
- 32:55SCHOOLS HOME SCHOOLS MICRO
- 32:56SCHOOLS ALL THE THINGS BEING
- 32:58THROWN INTO THAT CONVERSATION
- 32:59NOW, THERE'S NO ACCOUNTABILITY.
- 33:01>> THAT IS NOT TRUE.
- 33:02THAT IS NOT TRUE.
- 33:03>> THE ONLY ACCOUNTABILITY IS
- 33:05THE PARENT'S CHOICE.
- 33:06>> THAT IS A HUGE ACCOUNTABILITY
- 33:08FACTOR BECAUSE IF A PARENT ISN'T
- 33:10SATISFIED THAT A SCHOOL IS
- 33:12EDUCATING THEIR CHILD, THEN THAT
- 33:13SCHOOL DOESN'T EXIST.
- 33:15WHEREAS IF WE HAVE A FAILING
- 33:17PUBLIC SCHOOL AND EVEN
- 33:18UNFORTUNATELY SOMETIMES CHARTER
- 33:20SCHOOLS, BUT THEY WILL REMAIN
- 33:22OPEN AND THEY WILL CONTINUE TO
- 33:25FAIL STUDENTS OR TO
- 33:26UNDERPERFORM.
- 33:27THE GREATEST ACCOUNTABILITY
- 33:28FACTOR YOU HAVE IS A PARENT
- 33:30DECIDING THIS SCHOOL WILL DO THE
- 33:32JOB FOR MY CHILD.
- 33:33I DON'T WANT TO GET IN THE
- 33:35MIDDLE OF THAT.
- 33:36I THINK THAT IS A HIGH
- 33:38ACCOUNTABILITY FACTOR.
- 33:38>> WE NEED TO BE CAREFUL ABOUT
- 33:40CALLING SCHOOLS ESPECIALLY OUR
- 33:41SCHOOLS FAILING.
- 33:42THERE IS NO FAILING SCHOOL.
- 33:44THERE ARE SCHOOLS UNDER
- 33:46RESOURCED, SCHOOLS NEED SYSTEMS
- 33:47THAT NEED TO BE PUT INTO PLACE
- 33:49BUT WE HAVE EDUCATORS IN THOSE
- 33:51SCHOOLS SERVING THOSE KIDS,
- 33:53WORKING WITH THEM EVERY SINGLE
- 33:55DAY.
- 33:56BUT TO SAY THE SCHOOL IS FAILING
- 33:58IS JUST NOT TRUE.
- 33:59>> WELL, I DISAGREE.
- 34:00>> WE ARE BASING THAT ON AN
- 34:02ARBITRARY PICTURE IN TIME ON
- 34:04ACCOUNTABILITY.
- 34:05>> NOT ARBITRARY, OBJECTIVE.
- 34:06>> IT IS A PICTURE IN TIME.
- 34:09THIS IS A SNAPSHOT IN TIME.
- 34:10>> THEN IT WAS FAILING DURING
- 34:12THAT TIME.
- 34:13>> NOTHING MEASURES HOW FAR THAT
- 34:14STUDENT HAS COME SINCE THEY
- 34:16WALKED IN THE DOOR THE FIRST
- 34:17DAY.
- 34:17AND WE HAVE TO BE ABLE TO REALLY
- 34:19LOOK AT AN ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM
- 34:21THAT MEASURES THE WHOLE CHILD
- 34:24AND THEIR SUCCESS THROUGHOUT A
- 34:25YEAR AND NOT JUST FROM A
- 34:27SNAPSHOT POINT OF VIEW.
- 34:29THE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM THE
- 34:30TEST THAT IS PUT IN PLACE IS
- 34:31ACTUALLY TO LOOK AT THE SYSTEMS
- 34:33THAT THE SCHOOL SYSTEM IS
- 34:34PROVIDING TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY
- 34:37ARE PROPER SYSTEMS.
- 34:38>> I FIND IT IRONIC THE UNIONS
- 34:40ARE ALWAYS OPPOSED TO ANY
- 34:42OBJECTIVE RELEASE OF HOW SCHOOLS
- 34:44ARE PERFORMING.
- 34:46IN EVERY OTHER SECTOR OF OUR
- 34:49SOCIETY WE HAVE JUDGMENTS THAT
- 34:50WE MAKE ABOUT THAT.
- 34:52I THINK THAT THERE IS A LOT OF
- 34:54GREAT TEACHERS EVEN IN SCHOOLS
- 34:55THAT AREN'T DOING WELL FOR THEIR
- 34:58STUDENTS.
- 34:58BUT FOR THE SAKE OF THE STUDENT,
- 35:00IF THE STUDENTS ARE THE MAIN
- 35:02CONCERN, WE HAVE TO BE HONEST
- 35:03ABOUT THE FACT THAT NOT EVERY
- 35:05SCHOOL IS HIGH PERFORMING IN OUR
- 35:07STATE LIKE WE WANT IT TO BE.
- 35:08AND WHATEVER WILL CAUSE THAT TO
- 35:11HAPPEN I'M FOR.
- 35:12>> Renee: IN HOUSE BILL 208, AND
- 35:15I WILL PIVOT TO HOUSE BILL 2, IN
- 35:18HOUSE BILL 208 IT DOES SAY IN
- 35:20SECTION ONE TO GIVE FAMILIES OF
- 35:22LIMITED FINANCIAL MEANS MORE
- 35:23EDUCATIONAL CHOICES.
- 35:25ARE YOU IN FAVOR OF THE GENERAL
- 35:27ASSEMBLY PROVIDING A PORTION OF
- 35:28EDUCATIONAL COSTS FOR STUDENTS
- 35:31OUTSIDE OF THE COMMON SYSTEM OF
- 35:33COMMON SCHOOLS LIMITED FINANCIAL
- 35:35MEANS.
- 35:35SOME PEOPLE ARE CONCERNED THAT
- 35:36THIS WOULD OPEN THE DOOR FOR
- 35:38RICH PEOPLE TO GET TAXPAYER
- 35:40FUNDED ASSISTANCE TO SEND THEIR
- 35:43RICH KIDS TO PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 35:44IS THAT THE ULTIMATE END GOAL?
- 35:46>> I WOULD SAY AMERICANS FOR
- 35:49PROSPERITY SUPPORTS UNIVERSAL
- 35:51SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 35:54WE BELIEVE --
- 35:54>> Renee: WHICH MEANS WHAT?
- 35:56EVERYONE.
- 35:57>> EVERYONE.
- 35:58REPRESENTATIVE CALLAWAY IS
- 36:00ACTUALLY AMENDING HIS BILL TO
- 36:04INCLUDE EVERYONE.
- 36:06NOT JUST LIMITED INCOME.
- 36:09SO THAT WILL BE CHANGED.
- 36:10AND PROBABLY HOUSE BILL 2 IS
- 36:13PROBABLY THE ONE THAT WILL BE
- 36:15MOVING.
- 36:16AND SO OUR COALITION OF SCHOOL
- 36:19CHOICE SUPPORTIVE ORGANIZATIONS
- 36:22ARE WORKING WITH THE LEGISLATURE
- 36:24ON JUST RECOMMENDED LANGUAGE
- 36:27CHANGES TO MAKE SURE THAT
- 36:29THERE'S NOT ANY CHALLENGES UNDER
- 36:31THE SUPREME COURT.
- 36:34BUT OBVIOUSLY HOUSE BILL 2 IS
- 36:35PROBABLY THE ONE THAT WILL MOVE.
- 36:37>> Renee: AND IT DOESN'T REFER
- 36:38TO FINANCIAL MEANS AT ALL.
- 36:40Mr. WATERS THAT BRINGS UP A
- 36:42POINT BECAUSE THE ARGUMENT THAT
- 36:44SCHOOL CHOICE ADVOCATES MADE
- 36:45IT'S SUPPOSED TO HELP THOSE
- 36:47DISADVANTAGED OF LOW MEANS
- 36:49FINANCIALLY DOWN TRODDEN GET THE
- 36:51ACCESS TO THE TYPES OF EDUCATION
- 36:53RESOURCES THAT MORE WEALTHY
- 36:55FAMILIES HAVE.
- 36:56THIS SEEMS TO POKE HOLES IN ALL
- 36:57OF THAT?
- 36:58>> I WOULD SAY, TOO, I MEAN JUST
- 37:00BECAUSE YOU LIVE IN A CERTAIN
- 37:01ZIP CODE DOESN'T MEAN THAT --
- 37:03A LOT OF THESE PEOPLE WILL
- 37:05CHOOSE TO GO TO A PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 37:07IN A DIFFERENT ZIP CODE BECAUSE
- 37:09THEY WANT THE EDUCATION THAT
- 37:10THAT PUBLIC SCHOOL PROVIDES.
- 37:12THIS ISN'T JUST, AGAIN, IT'S NOT
- 37:15JUST RELEGATED TO PRIVATE
- 37:17SCHOOLS OR --
- 37:19>> .
- 37:19>> Renee: THEY ARE NOT GOING TO
- 37:20GO TO A FREE OR REDUCED SCHOOL.
- 37:23>> WE HAD 10 STATES LAST YEAR
- 37:25THAT WENT WITH THE UNIVERSAL
- 37:28SCHOOL CHOICE PROGRAM INCLUDING
- 37:29INDIANA, WEST WEST VIRGINIA.
- 37:33MANY STATES WE COMPETE WITH HAVE
- 37:35GONE THIS ROUTE ARE ARE MOVING
- 37:41THAT DIRECTION.
- 37:43UNIVERSAL OPTIONS BECAUSE ONE
- 37:43SIZE DOES NOT FIT ALL AND THAT
- 37:46MEANS ONE SIZE DOES NOT FIT ALL.
- 37:47THAT MEANS A PUBLIC CHARTER
- 37:50SCHOOL ISN'T FOR EVERY STUDENT.
- 37:51BUT JUST LIKE A TRADITIONAL
- 37:53PUBLIC SCHOOL IS NOT FOR EVERY
- 37:55STUDENT.
- 37:56SO I THINK THAT WHAT WE WANT
- 37:57HERE ARE OPTIONS.
- 37:59WE WANT ALTERNATIVES.
- 38:01AND LOOK ARE OUR KIDS NO MATTER
- 38:04WHAT THE ZIP CODE IS THEY
- 38:06DESERVE A CHANCE TO HAVE THE
- 38:07SCHOOL THAT WORKS BEST FOR THEM.
- 38:09LET'S REMOVE THOSE BARRIERS AND
- 38:11IF THEY CHOOSE NOT TO USE THAT,
- 38:13THEN FINE.
- 38:14BUT WE'VE SEEN POSITIVE RESULTS
- 38:16THAT HAVE IMPACTED OUR PUBLIC
- 38:18EDUCATION SYSTEMS BECAUSE WE HAD
- 38:21THAT DYNAMIC.
- 38:24>> Renee: THIS COMMENT SAYS
- 38:25QUOTE STATES SURROUNDING US HAVE
- 38:28MASSIVE BUDGET DEFICITS DUE TO
- 38:29THE FUNDING OF PRIVATE SCHOOLS
- 38:31WITH PUBLIC DOLLARS DO WE KNOW
- 38:33THAT TO BE TRUE?
- 38:33>> I CAN'T COMMENT WHAT IS
- 38:36DRIVING OUR BORDER STATES BUDGET
- 38:39DEFICITS.
- 38:40BUT I DO THINK IT'S INTERESTING
- 38:42TO LISTEN TO A CONVERSATION
- 38:44ABOUT ADDITIONAL OPTIONS WHEN
- 38:46WHAT WE'RE SAYING IS WE WANT TO
- 38:48INCREASE THE NUMBER OF OPTIONS
- 38:50EVEN THOUGH WE KNOW THAT THOSE
- 38:53OPTIONS MAY NOT ALLOW THAT
- 38:55STUDENT TO PERFORM BETTER.
- 38:57AND WE KNOW THAT AS THE ADULTS
- 38:59IN THIS SPACE.
- 39:00>> WHAT ABOUT THE PARENTS?
- 39:01>> WE KNOW THAT GOING IN BASED
- 39:03ON WHAT THE RESEARCH SHOWS.
- 39:04>> THE PARENTS KNOW WHAT IS
- 39:07BEST.
- 39:07>> THERE IS RESEARCH IN FLORIDA
- 39:08RIGHT NOW THAT SHOWS THAT AS THE
- 39:11CHOICE PROGRAM HAS PERSISTED
- 39:13THEY ARE ACTUALLY SEEING MORE
- 39:15NEGATIVE RETURNS.
- 39:16>> ARE YOU SAYING FAMILIES DON'T
- 39:18KNOW WHAT IS BEST FOR THEIR
- 39:20CHILDREN.
- 39:21>> LOW-INCOME FAMILY ACCESSING
- 39:23THOSE PROGRAMS.
- 39:24FROM A FISCALLY CONSERVATIVE
- 39:28STANDPOINT --
- 39:29>> FLORIDA IS NOT ACCURATE.
- 39:31WE'VE SEEN WHEN CARA BEGAN IN
- 39:34THE EARLY 90s, AND FLORIDA
- 39:36THEN TRAILED KENTUCKY IN EVERY
- 39:39AREA ALMOST EVERY OTHER STATE
- 39:40THEY WERE ONLY OUTPERFORMING A
- 39:42COUPLE OF STATES AND WASHINGTON
- 39:46D.C.
- 39:46TODAY, ONLY ONE STATE IS
- 39:48OUTPERFORMING FLORIDA'S PUBLIC
- 39:49EDUCATION SYSTEM AND THEIR KEY
- 39:52ACADEMIC AREAS AND THEY'VE
- 39:54PASSED UP KENTUCKY AND THEY ARE
- 39:55SPENDING LESS TO DO IT.
- 39:56THEY HAVE INCREASED SPENDING
- 39:58LESS MUCH LESS THAN WE HAVE OVER
- 40:00THAT SAME AMOUNT OF TIME.
- 40:02AND IN FLORIDA, THERE'S BEEN A
- 40:05BIG DEMOGRAPHIC SHIFT BACK WHEN
- 40:08THAT STARTED, OF COURSE, 60% OF
- 40:10THE KIDS IN FLORIDA'S PUBLIC
- 40:11SCHOOLS WERE WHITE STUDENTS WE
- 40:13KNOW THEY DO BETTER ON TESTING.
- 40:15NOW IT'S ONLY 40% THEY ARE A
- 40:18MAJORITY MINORITY STATE WHEREAS
- 40:20KENTUCKY 75% OF OUR STUDENTS ARE
- 40:22WHITE.
- 40:23FLORIDA'S OUTPERFORMING US AND
- 40:25WE'RE SPENDING MORE WE'VE
- 40:27INCREASED MORE THAN THEY HAVE.
- 40:28WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE?
- 40:29THE MORE CHOICES THEY'VE GIVEN
- 40:32PARENTS THE PUBLIC THEIR PUBLIC
- 40:33EDUCATION HAS PERFORMED.
- 40:34>> LET'S LOOK AT ARIZONA FOR A
- 40:37MOMENT.
- 40:37>> WHAT ABOUT FLORIDA?
- 40:39>> I COVERED --
- 40:41YOU JUST COVERED FLORIDA.
- 40:42>> THAT IS GOOD WE HAVE
- 40:44AGREEMENT.
- 40:44>> LET'S GO TO ARIZONA FOR A
- 40:46MINUTE WHERE IN ARIZONA THEY
- 40:48EARMARKED $33 MILLION FOR SCHOOL
- 40:50CHOICE VOUCHER PROGRAM.
- 40:51THEY ENDED UP SPENDING $550
- 40:56MILLION.
- 40:56AND THERE ARE 10 TIMES MORE
- 40:58SCHOOL CHOICE VOUCHERS GOING TO
- 41:00STUDENTS IN THE 25 HIGHEST
- 41:04INCOME ZIP CODES THAN THERE ARE
- 41:05GOING TO THE LOWEST 25% OF
- 41:08ARIZONA FAMILIES.
- 41:09>> Renee: AND THAT POINT, PIGGY
- 41:12BACKS OFF WHAT THIS CALLER SAYS,
- 41:15I HEAR ARIZONA IMPLEMENTED A
- 41:17VOUCHER SYSTEM AND THERE HAVE
- 41:19BEEN INSTANCES OF WASTE, FRAUD
- 41:20AND ABUSE WITH NO ACCOUNTABILITY
- 41:22FOR THE PRIVATE SCHOOLS AND HOME
- 41:24SCHOOLING PARENTS.
- 41:24WHAT IS TO PREVENT THAT FROM
- 41:26HAPPENING IN KENTUCKY?
- 41:27>> I MEAN, I WOULD SAY THAT WE
- 41:31SEE THAT SOME IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 41:33AS WELL.
- 41:33THAT CAN HAPPEN, I THINK IN ANY
- 41:37EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT.
- 41:37THERE NEEDS TO BE ACCOUNTABILITY
- 41:40AND I MEAN THAT IS, I THINK, A
- 41:43FURTHER DISCUSSION THAT WE CAN
- 41:45HAVE ONCE THIS AMENDMENT PASSES
- 41:46AND WE LOOK AT THE SPECIFIC TYPE
- 41:48OF SCHOOL CHOICE PROGRAM THERE'S
- 41:51ESA'S, SCHOLARSHIP.
- 41:53>> .
- 41:54>> Renee: EDUCATION SAVINGS
- 41:56ACCOUNTS.
- 41:56>> Renee: AND THAT IS DIFFERENT
- 41:57FROM THE OPPORTUNITY ACCOUNTS
- 41:58THAT THE COURT STRUCK DOWN.
- 42:00>> THEY HAD A LOT OF
- 42:02SIMILARITIES.
- 42:02THEY ALLOW STUDENTS AND PUBLIC
- 42:04SCHOOL STUDENTS TO USE THE
- 42:06DOLLARS FOR WHATEVER THEIR NEEDS
- 42:07ARE.
- 42:07THIS IS ABOUT THE STUDENTS.
- 42:09THIS SHOULD BE ABOUT THE
- 42:10STUDENTS.
- 42:11AND YOU KNOW, I THINK THAT IS A
- 42:13GOOD POINT.
- 42:15THAT THE DOLLARS OUGHT TO BE
- 42:17ABOUT THAT.
- 42:17AND LOOK, WE CAN PASS THE
- 42:19CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.
- 42:20ONE OF THE GREAT THINGS ABOUT
- 42:22KENTUCKY BEING BEHIND THE REST
- 42:23OF THE NATION, IS WE HAVE ALL
- 42:25THE LABORATORIES OF DEMOCRACY
- 42:26LIKE JUSTICE BRANDEIS SO
- 42:29FAMOUSLY LABELED IT.
- 42:30WE CAN SEE AND TO YOUR POINT I
- 42:32AGREE I THINK WE SHOULD LEARN
- 42:34FROM THE MISTAKES OF OTHER
- 42:35STATES HAVE MADE ON THIS AND
- 42:37LET'S GET IT RIGHT.
- 42:38LET'S HAVE THE MOST ROBUST
- 42:40EDUCATION SYSTEM IN AMERICA.
- 42:41>> Renee: YOU MENTIONED FLORIDA.
- 42:45BUT THIS LEXINGTON CALLER SAYS
- 42:48WHAT WILL KEEP PRIVATE CHARTER
- 42:50SCHOOLS FROM RAISING TUITION
- 42:52LIKE IN FLORIDA.
- 42:53DID THEY RAISE IT?
- 42:54>> I'M SURE SOME SCHOOLS LOOK AT
- 42:57INFLATION LIKE Mr. CAMPBELL
- 42:58SAYS IT'S AFFECTED EVERYBODY.
- 43:00HERE IS THE THING WE FOUND CAN
- 43:03SCHOLARSHIPS THAT A LOT OF
- 43:05PRIVATE SCHOOLS AND THEY GET
- 43:06BEAT UP ON A LOT UNFORTUNATELY,
- 43:08A LOT OF THEM HAVE SAID, HEY IF
- 43:11WE GET A SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM
- 43:13PASSED WE WILL WORK WITH
- 43:16FAMILIES TO MAKE SURE THAT THEIR
- 43:17KIDS GET THE EDUCATION THEY
- 43:19NEED.
- 43:19IF THIS IS THE BEST FIT.
- 43:20AND SOME CASES THAT MIGHT MEAN
- 43:22THAT FAMILIES PAY SOMETHING
- 43:24TOWARD THAT IN ADDITION TO THE
- 43:25SCHOLARSHIP THAT WOULD BE BASED
- 43:27ON THEIR INCOME.
- 43:28WE'VE SEEN PROGRAMS LIKE THAT IN
- 43:30THE PRIVATELY DONE HERE BEFORE
- 43:32AND THEY WORKED TO EDUCATE KIDS
- 43:35AND REALLY HIGH POVERTY
- 43:37FAMILIES.
- 43:38>> Renee: SO YOU ARE NOT
- 43:39ADVOCATING OR ARE YOU ADVOCATING
- 43:40FOR TUITION FREE CHOICE?
- 43:42>> NO.
- 43:43THIS IS ABOUT PROVIDING FUNDING
- 43:49AT A CERTAIN LEVEL AND THEN IT'S
- 43:51ABOUT SCHOOLS AND PARENTS AND
- 43:53FAMILIES WORKING THAT OUT.
- 43:54THAT IS BY FAR THE BEST WAY TO
- 43:55DO THAT.
- 43:57>> Renee: Mr. CAMPBELL?
- 43:58>> WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE OTHER
- 44:00STATES WHERE VOUCHER PROGRAMS
- 44:0380% OF THE PEOPLE THAT ARE
- 44:05ACCESSING THOSE PROGRAMS ARE
- 44:07ALREADY STUDENTS ARE ALREADY
- 44:09ATTENDING PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 44:10PRIVATE SCHOOLS ARE TELLING THEM
- 44:11THEY HAVE TO FILL OUT.
- 44:12>> THAT IS A TRAGEDY, ISN'T IT.
- 44:15I MEAN THE KIDS ARE GETTING INTO
- 44:17THE SCHOOLS THAT FITS BEST FOR
- 44:19THEM WHATEVER THEIR INCOME.
- 44:20>> THEY ARE ALREADY IN THE
- 44:21PRIVATE SCHOOL THEY ARE NOT
- 44:22COMING FROM THE PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 44:23THEY ARE TAKING AWAY PUBLIC
- 44:26SCHOOL DOLLARS TO BE PUSHED INTO
- 44:27A PRIVATE SCHOOL AND WHEN WE
- 44:29TALK ABOUT ARIZONA, THEY STARTED
- 44:33WITH THEN THEY INSTITUTED THEIR
- 44:36VOUCHER PROGRAM, IT WAS A ABOUT
- 44:4125 MILLION WAS THAT THE
- 44:42STARTING.
- 44:43NOW IT'S ALMOST A BILLION
- 44:45DOLLARS PER YEAR IN THEIR BUDGET
- 44:47AND THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT WHAT
- 44:48PROGRAMS WILL HAVE TO BE CUT.
- 44:50SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT TAKING
- 44:52PUBLIC TAX DOLLARS FOR THE
- 44:53COMMON GOOD AND NOW WE'RE GOING
- 44:55TO FIND WAYS IN BUDGETS AND THIS
- 44:56IS NOT JUST ARIZONA THIS IS
- 44:58MULTIPLE STATES, WHERE THEY
- 45:00FOUND THEY HAVE TO CUT SERVICES.
- 45:03THEY HAVE TO CUT PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 45:05FUNDING AND CUT POLICE AND FIRE.
- 45:08THOSE OTHER PUBLIC SERVICES THAT
- 45:09ARE SUPPORTED BY TAX DOLLARS
- 45:11BECAUSE THIS IS DRAINING THOSE
- 45:13PRECIOUS TAX DOLLARS OUT OF THAT
- 45:14GENERAL FUND.
- 45:15>> THAT IS THE POINT HERE.
- 45:16WE CAN MAKE SURE WHEN THE LAW IS
- 45:19PASSED THAT IT'S DONE RIGHT,
- 45:21IT'S SETUP RIGHT, AND THAT THERE
- 45:22IS A ACCOUNTABILITY.
- 45:24I DO NOT WANT US TO CREATE MORE
- 45:27FAILING SCHOOLS.
- 45:27I WANT CHARTER SCHOOLS.
- 45:29I WANT THE PROGRAMS TO BE
- 45:30ACCOUNTABLE.
- 45:32THE.
- 45:32>> WHAT IS IT GOING TO LOOK
- 45:35LIKE?
- 45:36>> THE LAW HOUSE BILL 563 THAT
- 45:38PASSED A COUPLE YEARS AGO HAD
- 45:41VERY RIGOROUS STEPS THAT YOU HAD
- 45:42TO FOLLOW IN IN ORDER TO CREATE
- 45:46A ACCOUNT GRANTING ORGANIZATION.
- 45:48I THINK WE HOLD THEM ACCOUNTABLE
- 45:50FOR HOW THEY SPEND THOSE
- 45:52DOLLARS.
- 45:52AND THAT WAS A VERY SMALL
- 45:54PROGRAM IT WAS A $25 MILLION
- 45:56PROGRAM HERE WHICH WAS VERY
- 45:58SMALL COMPARED TO OUR OVERALL
- 45:59BUDGET.
- 46:00BUT WHAT AN OPPORTUNITY FOR EVEN
- 46:01A FEW KIDS YOU KNOW TO GET A
- 46:04BETTER EDUCATION.
- 46:04THAT IS WHEY WANT.
- 46:05I WANT OUR STUDENTS TO HAVE THAT
- 46:08OPPORTUNITY AND THEN LET THE
- 46:09SYSTEM ADJUST TO THAT.
- 46:10THAT OUGHT TO BE THE PRIORITY.
- 46:12WE'LL FIGURE IT OUT.
- 46:13BUT I THINK WE LOOK AT OTHER
- 46:15STATES LIKE YOU SAID, I AGREE
- 46:17LET'S GET IT ON THE TABLE HERE
- 46:18ARE THE MISTAKES MADE AND HERE
- 46:20IS WHAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN DONE
- 46:21AND WE HAVE THAT ADVANTAGE.
- 46:22>> THERE WAS ACCOUNTABILITY ON
- 46:25THE GRANT ORGANIZATIONS THE
- 46:30AUTHORIZING ORGANIZATION NOT ON
- 46:31WHERE THE DOLLARS WERE BEING
- 46:33SPENT.
- 46:33>> THE LAW WAS SETUP TO ADDRESS
- 46:36THAT.
- 46:37>> GRANT ORGANIZATION GOT TO
- 46:38KEEP 10% OF THOSE DOLLARS.
- 46:40>> THIS LAW HERE WOULD HAVE BEEN
- 46:44JUST --
- 46:44>> 563 ALLOWED FOR THE
- 46:46ORGANIZATION TO KEEP 10% OF THE
- 46:49SCHOLARSHIP DOLLARS FOR FEES AND
- 46:52RUNNING THE ORGANIZATION.
- 46:52>> AND WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE
- 46:56PUBLIC --
- 46:56>> PUBLIC SCHOOL 100% OF THOSE
- 46:58DOLLARS GO INTO THE PUBLIC
- 46:59SCHOOL.
- 46:59>> THE PUBLIC EDUCATION SYSTEM
- 47:00HOW MUCH ARE THEY SPENDING?
- 47:02THIS HUGE INCREASE IN
- 47:04NONTEACHING PERSONNEL THAT ARE
- 47:05BEING HIRED.
- 47:06WE NEED TO PAY OUR TEACHERS
- 47:07MORE.
- 47:08WE NEED TO DO BETTER FOR OUR
- 47:10TEACHERS LIKE YOU SAID.
- 47:11WHERE ARE THE DOLLARS GOING?
- 47:12WE NEED LOTS AFTER COUNTABILITY
- 47:14FOR THE 12 BILLION WE ARE GOING
- 47:17TO SP SPEND ON K-12 EDUCATION.
- 47:19>> Renee: THERE IS A QUESTION
- 47:20ABOUT CENTRAL OFFICE PERSONNEL
- 47:23HAVING SUBSTANTIAL SALARIES
- 47:24COMPARED TO THOSE IN THE
- 47:25CLASSROOM.
- 47:26>> THAT IS A CONCERN AND A
- 47:27QUESTION THAT SHOULD BE
- 47:28ADDRESSED AND LOOKED AT.
- 47:31EDUCATENERS THE CLASSROOM HAVE
- 47:33FALLEN FURTHER AND FURTHER
- 47:34BEHIND WHEN IT COMES TO PAY IN
- 47:35THE STATE OF KENTUCKY WE HAVE
- 47:37NOT FOCUSED ON THAT.
- 47:39THERETO'S NOT BEEN BUT 3% ADDED
- 47:41TO THE STATE MANDATED SALARY
- 47:44SCHEDULE SINCE 2008 SINCE 2008
- 47:46ONLY 3% HAVE BEEN ADDED TO THAT
- 47:49SCHEDULE.
- 47:49OUR FIRST YEAR TEACHERS MAKE AN
- 47:52AVERAGE OF $34,000 A YEAR.
- 47:54WE KEEP FALLING BEHIND.
- 47:56WE'RE 44TH IN THE NATION FOR
- 47:59FIRST YEAR TEACHER PAY.
- 48:0040TH FOR AVERAGE TEACHER PAY.
- 48:02AND WHAT IS REALLY SAD ALL OF
- 48:04THE INDIVIDUALS WHO MAKE THE
- 48:06SCHOOL WORK OUR TRANSPORTATION
- 48:07WORKER OUR FOOD SERVICE OUR
- 48:10CUSTODIANS AND SCHOOL NURSES ALL
- 48:12OF OUR SUPPORT STAFF WE RANK
- 48:1548TH.
- 48:15WE HAVE TO TAKE CARE OF THE
- 48:17INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE TAKING CARE
- 48:19OF OUR KIDS EVERY SINGLE DAY.
- 48:21AND THAT INVESTMENT HAS TO
- 48:22HAPPEN.
- 48:23WE HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY RIGHT
- 48:24NOW TO INVEST IN THOSE
- 48:26EDUCATORS.
- 48:28>> Renee: LET'S GET BACK TO A
- 48:30QUESTION ABOUT --
- 48:32THIS QUESTION FROM A VIEWER
- 48:33ABOUT IF WE GIVE OPTIONS HOW DO
- 48:37WE TRANSPORT THESE CHILDREN TO
- 48:38THEIR CHOICE?
- 48:40THE TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM?
- 48:41>> JEFFERSON COUNTY IS HAVING
- 48:43TROUBLE TRANSPORTING THEIR
- 48:45PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENTS THEY ARE
- 48:46NOT GOING TO TRANSPORT SOME OF
- 48:47THEM.
- 48:48I THINK THESE ARE THINGS THAT
- 48:49NEED TO BE FIGURED OUT.
- 48:50>> Renee: WHAT HAVE OTHER STATES
- 48:51DONE TO REMEDY THE
- 48:53TRANSPORTATION CONCERNS?
- 48:54>> MOST PLACES PUBLIC CHARTER
- 48:56SCHOOL STUDENTS ARE TREATED AS
- 48:58PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENTS THEY ARE
- 49:00TRANSPORTED BY THE DISTRICT.
- 49:01AND OTHER PLACES THEY MAKE
- 49:03ARRANGEMENTS WITH PARENTS WHO
- 49:04MIGHT HELP FUND THAT OR GET
- 49:06THEIR KIDS TO SCHOOL.
- 49:08THEY MIGHT NOT PROVIDE
- 49:09TRANSPORTATION.
- 49:10THAT IS SOMETHING THAT HAB TO BE
- 49:11UP FRONT AND PARENTS HAVE TO
- 49:13KNOW.
- 49:14>> Renee: FAMILIES OF LESSER
- 49:15MEANS THAT WOULD BE A BIG
- 49:17BARRIER FOR THEM?
- 49:18>> BUT SEE HERE IS THE THING
- 49:20IT'S NOT A ZERO SOMETHING THIS
- 49:22WAY OR THAT WAY.
- 49:22WHEN A SCHOOL CAN BE INNOVATIVE
- 49:24IF THEY CAN BE INNOVATIVE IN THE
- 49:26TYPE OF PROGRAM THEY WILL BE
- 49:27INNOVATIVE IN TRANSPORTATION.
- 49:29WE HEARD OF ALL KINDS OF IDEAS.
- 49:31>> LIKE AN UBER?
- 49:33>> TAXIS, WHATEVER OR BUSES
- 49:36SMALL BUSES OR WHATEVER.
- 49:38SO LOOK, I DON'T A--
- 49:40I'M NOT CALLING FOR US TO SPEND
- 49:42OUR RAINY DAY FUND WE DON'T NEED
- 49:44TO SPEND OUR RAINY DAY FUND ON
- 49:46PAYING TEACHERS MORE.
- 49:47WHAT WE NEED TO DO IS REALIZE
- 49:48THAT THE LEGISLATURE HAS GREATLY
- 49:51INCREASED THE AMOUNT OF FUNDING
- 49:52GOING TO LOCAL DISTRICTS FOR
- 49:54THEM TO DECIDE WHAT TO DO WITH
- 49:55THOSE DOLLARS.
- 49:56THEY SHOULD BE THE ONES MAKING
- 49:58THOSE DECISIONS.
- 49:58I HAVE A QUESTION TONIGHT
- 50:00SOMEBODY HELP ME WITH PLEASE,
- 50:02BECAUSE I DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW
- 50:03THE LARGEST SCHOOL DISTRICT IN
- 50:05KENTUCKY CAN HAVE A $2 BILLION
- 50:08BUDGET AND YET WE HAVE TEACHERS
- 50:09IN THAT SYSTEM WHO ARE HAVING TO
- 50:11DIG INTO THEIR POCKETS TO
- 50:13PROVIDE SUPPLIES AND TEXTBOOKS
- 50:14AND THE THINGS THEIR STUDENTS
- 50:16NEED.
- 50:16$2 BILLION.
- 50:17THAT'S MORE THAN TWICE WHAT THE
- 50:19METRO COUNCIL BUDGET IS.
- 50:20WHERE IS THE MONEY GOING?
- 50:22>> Renee: YOU SHOULD ASK THE
- 50:25JEFFERSON COUNTY EDUCATION
- 50:26DISTRICT ABOUT THAT.
- 50:28SO THIS QUESTION FROM JEFFERSON
- 50:30COUNTY TO Mr. CAMPBELL SAYS
- 50:31HOW CAN YOU SAY WE DON'T HAVE
- 50:33FAILING SCHOOLS YOU MENTIONED
- 50:35THAT BEFORE WHEN 198,000
- 50:37STUDENTS ARE CHRONICALLY ABSENT
- 50:39AND OVER 30% OF OUR KIDS CAN'T
- 50:42READ, DO MATH OR MEET ANY
- 50:45OUTCOME AT GRADE LEVEL.
- 50:46>> I'M SAYING WE CAN'T LOOK AND
- 50:48MAKE A GENERALIZATION ABOUT A
- 50:50FAILING SCHOOL.
- 50:50YOU CANNOT CALL A SCHOOL
- 50:53FAILING.
- 50:53THERE ARE SCHOOLS UNDER
- 50:55RESOURCED.
- 50:55THEY DON'T HAVE THE FUNDING TO
- 50:57DO PUT IN PLACE ALL THE SYSTEMS
- 50:58AND MAKE SURE THAT EVERY
- 51:01STUDENTS' NEEDS AND
- 51:02OPPORTUNITIES ARE BEING MET.
- 51:03WE HAVE TO HAVE THE SYSTEMS IN
- 51:04PLACE.
- 51:05THOSE COST MONEY.
- 51:07WE HAVE SYSTEMS THAT ARE NEED
- 51:11LEADERSHIP.
- 51:11THERE'S FAILING IN THE
- 51:12LEADERSHIP AND MAKING SURE THAT
- 51:14EVERYTHING IS BEING DONE IN THAT
- 51:15SCHOOL.
- 51:15WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
- 51:17HAVE WHOLE CHILD SERVICES
- 51:20PROVIDING AND CREATING COMMUNITY
- 51:21SCHOOLS TO MEET THE NEEDS OF
- 51:23STUDENTS.
- 51:23IF A STUDENT IS HUNGRY OR SICK
- 51:27OR HAS SOME HEALTH ISSUE, WE
- 51:30NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT THE
- 51:31SCHOOL IS THERE TO SUPPORT THAT
- 51:33STUDENT 365 DAYS A YEAR.
- 51:36NOT JUST DURING THE SCHOOL DAY.
- 51:40>> Renee: THIS QUESTION OR
- 51:44RESPONSE COMMENT FROM VAN SMITH.
- 51:46I WILL POINT THIS TO YOU, YOUR
- 51:50GUEST STATED THAT AMERICANS FOR
- 51:52PROSPERITY IS A GRASSROOTS
- 51:54ORGANIZATION THAT IS FALSE THEY
- 51:57ARE A COKE BROTHERS FUNDED
- 51:58ORGANIZATION.
- 52:00TRUE OR FALSE?
- 52:01>> CHARLES COKE WAS ONE OF THE
- 52:02FOUNDER OF AMERICANS FOR
- 52:04PROSPERITY WE ARE DONOR FUNDED
- 52:06AND DONORS BELIEVE IN THE ISSUES
- 52:08THAT WE WORK ON WHICH THEY
- 52:10SUPPORT BOTTOM UP SOLUTIONS TO
- 52:12COMPLEX PROBLEMS.
- 52:14AND SO I WOULD SAY YES, CHARLES
- 52:20CAULK WITH HIS BROTHER.
- 52:21BUT DONORS ARE THE ONES WHO KEEP
- 52:24THE ORGANIZATION GOING.
- 52:26AND THEY SUPPORT INNOVATION IN
- 52:29EDUCATION.
- 52:30>> Renee: SO IN THE LAST FOUR
- 52:32MINUTES, A QUESTION BASIC IS
- 52:34THERE MIDDLE GROUND?
- 52:35CAN THIS SIDE AND THIS SIDE FIND
- 52:37A SOLUTION IN THE CENTER?
- 52:39>> LET'S HAVE BOTH AND.
- 52:42IF SCHOOLS OF CHOICE DON'T DO
- 52:44WELL AND THEY DON'T ATTRACT
- 52:46STUDENTS THEN WHAT IS THE HARM
- 52:47IN ALLOWING THAT WE'LL KNOW?
- 52:49WHAT IS THE HARM IN ALLOWING
- 52:51THAT POSSIBILITY I SAY WE HAVE
- 52:55BOTH AND RATHER THAN EITHER OR.
- 52:57>> Renee: IS THERE A BOTH AND
- 52:59POSSIBILITY?
- 52:59>> I THINK IF WE'RE GOING TO
- 53:01HAVE THIS DISCUSSION WE SHOULD
- 53:02FIRST FULLY FUND AND FOCUS ON
- 53:04THE PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM THAT
- 53:06WAS INTENDED BY THE FRAMERS OF
- 53:08OUR CONSTITUTION HERE IN THE
- 53:09STATE OF KENTUCKY.
- 53:10A SYSTEM OF COMMON SCHOOLS FOR
- 53:12ALL STUDENTS THAT PROVIDED A
- 53:15FREE PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATION.
- 53:16FOR ALL STUDENTS.
- 53:18WE DON'T NEED TO BE TRYING TO
- 53:19BUILD ANOTHER SYSTEM ON TOP OF A
- 53:22SYSTEM THAT WE ALREADY HAVE.
- 53:24LET'S LOOK AT THE SYSTEM WE
- 53:25HAVE.
- 53:26LET'S TALK ABOUT WHAT IS NEEDED
- 53:27HOW WE CAN CREATE INNOVATION
- 53:30WITHIN THOSE SCHOOLS.
- 53:31MAKE SURE WE'RE MEETING THE
- 53:33NEEDS OF ALL STUDENTS NO MATTER
- 53:35WHERE THEY COME FROM.
- 53:36WE MEET THEM WHERE THEY ARE WHEN
- 53:37THEY COME TO THE DOOR AND
- 53:39PROVIDE THEM OPPORTUNITIES
- 53:41THROUGHOUT THEIR CAREER.
- 53:42WHEN THEY ARE IN SCHOOL.
- 53:43THAT'S WHAT WE NEED TO BE
- 53:44LOOKING AT.
- 53:45NOT TRYING TO BUILD A NEW SYSTEM
- 53:47ON TOP OF ONE THAT WE HAVE.
- 53:49I THINK THE FRAMERS OF THE
- 53:52CONSTITUTION WERE VERY
- 53:53THOUGHTFUL WHEN THEY WROTE THIS
- 53:55AND WE HAVE PUBLIC DOLLARS FOR
- 53:58PUBLIC GOOD SO LET'S MAKE SURE
- 54:00THAT WE'RE USING THOSE DOLLARS
- 54:02TO ENHANCE EVERYBODY IN THE
- 54:04COMMONWEALTH.
- 54:05ALL AT THE SAME TIME SO THAT
- 54:07KIDS HAVE THE SAME OPPORTUNITIES
- 54:09AS KIDS IN PIKEVILLE AS THEY DO
- 54:11IN JEFFERSON COUNTY.
- 54:12>> THAT IS NOT HAPPENING THOUGH,
- 54:14WE NEED THE CHANGE.
- 54:15>> THAT IS THE POINT WE NEED TO
- 54:17FOCUS ON THAT RIGHT NOW.
- 54:18>> .
- 54:18>> YOU WILL SAY THIS IS --
- 54:23I WILL SAY THAT KENTUCKIANS WANT
- 54:25OPTIONS FOR THEIR CHILDREN.
- 54:27AND WE'RE HEARING IT LOUD AND
- 54:29CLEAR ACROSS THE STATE.
- 54:31YOU CAN EVEN LOOK AT THE TWEETS
- 54:34THAT THE GOVERNOR AND THE
- 54:36LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR HAVE MADE
- 54:37ABOUT THIS ISSUE AND PEOPLE'S
- 54:40OVERWHELMING RESPONSES TO SAYING
- 54:42THEY WANT SCHOOL CHOICE AND WANT
- 54:44THE OPTIONS FOR THEIR CHILDREN.
- 54:46>> KENTUCKY HAS LED THE NATION
- 54:50IN ECONOMIC EDUCATION
- 54:51IMPROVEMENT IN THE PAST.
- 54:52WE'VE LED THE ENTIRE NATION.
- 54:54WE CAN DO THAT AGAIN.
- 54:56IF WE GROUND OUR STRATEGIES AND
- 54:58OUR INVESTMENT IN WHAT RESEARCH
- 55:00SHOWS IS GOING TO WORK.
- 55:02IT'S CRITICALLY IMPORTANT THAT
- 55:04AS THIS SIXTH POOREST STATE IN
- 55:05THE NATION WE DO THAT WELL IF WE
- 55:07ARE GOING TO ACHIEVE ECONOMIC
- 55:10COMPETITIVENESS AND THE ECONOMIC
- 55:12PROSPERITY OF KENTUCKIANS.
- 55:14SO GROUNDING WHAT WE KNOW WORKS.
- 55:16AND INVESTING IN THOSE IS
- 55:19CRITICALLY IMPORTANT.
- 55:20TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS YES
- 55:22WE HAVE WORK TO DO BUT WE'VE LED
- 55:23THE NATION BEFORE.
- 55:24PUBLIC CHAFORTER SCHOOLS CAN BE
- 55:26A TOOL IN THE TOOLBOX IF DONE
- 55:28WELL AND APPROPRIATELY.
- 55:30SCHOOL CHOICE PRIVATE SCHOOL
- 55:32CHOICE THE RESEARCH IS NOT
- 55:35THERE.
- 55:35>> Renee: ALL RIGHT.
- 55:3620 SECONDS Mr. WATERS.
- 55:38>> 82% OF KENTUCKY'S WHITE HIGH
- 55:40SCHOOL GRADUATES AN ASTONISHING
- 55:4497% OF GRADUATING BLACK STUDENTS
- 55:46LACK COLLEGE READINESS ACROSS
- 55:48THE FOUR ACADEMIC AREAS TESTED
- 55:51BY THE ACT.
- 55:52I WANT TO SEE THAT CHANGED.
- 55:54>> Renee: GOOD DISCUSSION.
- 55:55GOOD RIGOROUS DISCUSSION THANK
- 55:57YOU ALL FOR REPRESENTING YOUR
- 56:00VIEWPOINTS AND INFORMING OUR
- 56:02VIEWERS TONIGHT.
- 56:02WE A GREAT SHOW FOR NEXT MONDAY
- 56:05WE'RE GOING TO TALK ABOUT
- 56:06ABORTION AND FAMILY SUPPORT
- 56:09LEGISLATION THAT WILL BE ALSO A
- 56:11RIGOROUS DISCUSSION I CAN
- 56:13PREDICT.
- 56:13MAKE SURE YOU TUNE BACK IN NEXT
- 56:16MONDAY AT 8:00 P.M. ON "KENTUCKY
- 56:18TONIGHT" FOR THAT.
- 56:19AND JOIN US EACH WEEKNIGHT AT
- 56:226:30 WHERE WE ARE AT THE STATE
- 56:24CAPITOL REPORTING ON THESE
- 56:26ISSUES THAT MATTER TO YOU.
- 56:27WE'LL SEE YOU TOMORROW NIGHT AT
- 56:306:30 EASTERN 530 CENTRAL.
- 56:33TAKE GOOD CARE.