Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Dunbar's Research
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.metigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.n ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I Love you. Keep going.
- 0:20It is July 13th. It is 2023.
- 0:24It's 7:36 PM Pacific Daylight Time.
- 0:34Join our discussion and we've been talking the last couple of
- 0:40weeks about relationships and building social networks, and I
- 0:45thought that we would finish up that topic by talking about
- 0:51Dunbar's research on relationships and patterns of
- 0:55relationships that make you happy.
- 0:57But I also wanted to say that we're going to change the format
- 1:01of this evening by making the first Thursday of the month a
- 1:12level one for the meditation and attachment curriculum.
- 1:19And so on the 1st Thursday of the month, we'll begin to talk
- 1:22about the. Meditation and attachment system
- 1:28and we'll do that every month going forward starting on
- 1:32August, the 1st Thursday at August and then the other three
- 1:36Thursdays will continue to be I love you keep going but we're
- 1:42I'm finding more and more that there needs to be a regular
- 1:46introduction to that curriculum and so work we've been working
- 1:50it out what to do and and that's where we landed.
- 1:53So we'll give it a try and see how it goes.
- 1:59Robert Dunbar is a British researcher and he originally
- 2:03asked the question is there a limit to the capacity of the
- 2:07human mind to recognize faces? And so he began to research that
- 2:12and what he discovered was that there is a active buffer of
- 2:17memory of an active buffer where the.
- 2:23Capacity to recognize 3D representations of faces is not
- 2:30saying this very well, that there is an active buffer of
- 2:33memory that stores about 150 faces that can be recognized
- 2:39pretty quickly and that those are 3D faces and that that
- 2:48number is about 1:50. Should I make to not say that in
- 2:52a way that makes sense so the human mind can recognize about
- 2:57150 faces in 3D pretty readily and that that's the the size
- 3:04limit of it? In the later research he did
- 3:08discover that the the body mind recognizes 2D representations of
- 3:13faces differently than 3D representations and that the 2D.
- 3:18Representation of faces is quite a bit bigger than that 150
- 3:22number. You know, we were all saying,
- 3:27well, I have 5000 friends on Facebook, How can the capacity
- 3:30to recognize faces possibly be limited to 150?
- 3:35So it turns out that there's a big difference between
- 3:37recognizing 3D faces and recognizing 2D faces.
- 3:45Once he discovered that number, he decided he would look to see
- 3:49whether there were structures in human society that were around
- 3:55those numbers. And So what he discovered was
- 3:59that historical institutions like, say, the Roman legion,
- 4:04were divided into divisions of 150, and that many policing
- 4:09organizations around the world use that number to determine.
- 4:14How many police are necessary to keep order And because in social
- 4:22groups, large social groups where you can recognize
- 4:26everybody in the social group and you know who they are, the
- 4:30groups themselves are self policing.
- 4:33But as soon as the numbers exceed that where you don't
- 4:36really know or recognize everybody, the self policing
- 4:39systems break down and some kind of.
- 4:43Order is necessary then. What he wanted to look at is how
- 4:49many people do you actually have to know to be happy to have a
- 4:53sense of being connected in the world.
- 4:55And that was quite different than the the larger group of
- 4:59150. What he noticed was that there
- 5:05was a the sharp division between.
- 5:09Closeness in in the way that we've organized things, that
- 5:14there's an above the line where you tell people everything, and
- 5:19there's a below the line where you tell people some things.
- 5:23The above the line, what we mean by tell them everything is that
- 5:26you give them a complete and accurate representation of the
- 5:30your experience of the present moment.
- 5:33Does it mean you haul out the scroll?
- 5:36Of every terrible thing that you've ever done and get them to
- 5:38initial by each one so that you feel a sense that they won't
- 5:44abandon you as soon as they find that out, that this is just your
- 5:50willingness to tell somebody your authentic experience of the
- 5:54present moment. Now in secure attachment
- 5:59systems, that's. Basically, the way that
- 6:02relationships are modeled, you have people that are close to
- 6:05you, and that the way that you gauge the closeness is your
- 6:08willingness to tell them your experience of what's happening
- 6:11without the fear of being abandoned if you do, And then an
- 6:16insecure and disorganized detachment, the capacity to be
- 6:20authentic is greatly limited because of the fearfulness of
- 6:25being abandoned. If you actually represent
- 6:27yourself, we can look at that. In that the way in which these
- 6:35attachment relationships form and understand that we don't
- 6:42actually see ourselves without the reflection of ourselves from
- 6:50someone else, it's too easy to get lost and and distorted in
- 6:57mind representations. We don't know each other in
- 7:06another way than that you present yourself authentically
- 7:10to somebody. They understand what you fixes
- 7:14or they react to what you've experienced, and they reflect
- 7:17back to their experience of you in that moment.
- 7:20And that's how we begin to understand who we are and how.
- 7:27What we're thinking and feeling registers in infancy.
- 7:32Of course the the main caregivers, the one that we're
- 7:35focused on and our capacity, our whole world is really that face
- 7:41that's reflecting back to us, their experience of us.
- 7:45And we begin to construct a working model of who we are
- 7:48based on those reflections. So we might think that we're
- 7:52completely delightful in any situation because.
- 7:55The reflection of who we were in each of those moments of
- 7:59expression was one of delight in being with us, where we could
- 8:04have had a caregiver that was overwhelmed by the experience of
- 8:08us. And what was reflected back to
- 8:10us was their sense of fearfulness, their sense of
- 8:13overwhelm. And maybe they were annoyed and
- 8:15angry by the way that we presented ourselves.
- 8:18And so we understood ourselves to be somebody who was annoying,
- 8:23somebody who was difficult. And we began to construct a
- 8:28working model of ourselves that's based on those
- 8:31reflections that making sense. So the capacity to be authentic
- 8:39is really dependent on our expectation of what will happen
- 8:43if we express ourselves authentically.
- 8:45And this really comes from the early childhood period when
- 8:49there's no capacity to express in another way.
- 8:54Than what's authentically happening.
- 8:57As you grow older and have a greater capacity to understand
- 9:03the reactions of other people to you, you can begin to navigate
- 9:08and present in ways that are different than completely
- 9:12authentic. If the authentic expression is
- 9:14not received. I think that those of us who
- 9:19learned inauthenticity. We did so because there was no
- 9:23other choice, and it was a bitter lesson, a painful lesson
- 9:29to begin to present ourselves in a way that the other person
- 9:33needed us to present, rather than as a celebration of who we
- 9:38are, what our understanding was in that moment, so that above
- 9:46the line. Grouping of people are people
- 9:49that you can express your experience of the present moment
- 9:53without so much fear of abandonment that you begin to
- 9:58deflect or change that authentic expression into an inauthentic
- 10:03one, an insecure and disorganized relationship.
- 10:07Authentic expression is not valued so much.
- 10:13Below the line are people that you tell some things to, not
- 10:17everything. Lucy's off to express her
- 10:33authentic opinion of the world. So we also can talk about
- 10:43collaborative relationship systems and transactional
- 10:46relationship systems and trauma bonding as as main of ways of
- 10:51forming relationships. In intimate collaborative
- 10:55relationships, authenticity is highly valued and you really pay
- 10:59attention to who receives you and understands you and who
- 11:03appreciates you, who delights in you and you value those
- 11:06relationships and direct your energy towards them.
- 11:09In transactional relationships, it's more role based.
- 11:13They perform a series of tasks for you and you reward them.
- 11:18You perform a series of tax tasks for them and they reward
- 11:22you. And then in trauma bonding, of
- 11:24course you're not actually in relationship to the person you
- 11:28are with, you're in relationship to the idea of the of the person
- 11:33they're in relationship to you, not as who you are, but the idea
- 11:38of. Who maps on to their trauma
- 11:41pander patterning? When we talk about intimate,
- 11:51collaborative relationships, we're also talking about this
- 11:55capacity for authenticity. In relationships where you are,
- 11:59you feel safe and free to express yourself authentically.
- 12:06And Dunbar was looking at this and saying how many of those
- 12:09relationships you actually need to feel connected and happy.
- 12:13And the number I thought was surprisingly low.
- 12:18Some people like to have central organizing relationships of what
- 12:24we would call an A relationship, somebody that you take care of
- 12:27on a daily or every other day basis, somebody that you tell
- 12:30everything to. Most people like to have a
- 12:35sexual component to that relationship because it's so
- 12:37resource intensive. But then this also points to
- 12:43aspects of sexual orientation. Are you on the monogamous end of
- 12:48the scale? Are you on the polygamous end of
- 12:50the scale? Hardcore monogamy really is not
- 12:54flexible so much that you can adapt to a more open
- 12:58relationship structure, whereas. Truly Poly people can adapt to a
- 13:05monogamous situation more easily, but this is a
- 13:09characteristic of your sexual orientation is usually pretty
- 13:12fixed. And then we have the the, you
- 13:15know, gay, straight, and in between.
- 13:19I think the most maligned group in our culture are bisexuals.
- 13:26Gay people think that they should just come out finally.
- 13:29And straight people think they should just come out finally,
- 13:32and they're stuck in the middle with the experience of arousal
- 13:37that goes in more than One Direction.
- 13:43We have also that gender. The early research that came out
- 13:51of John Hopkins that John Money did on gender, I think, if I
- 13:56remember it correctly, had eight.
- 13:58Points of gender, five of which were prenatal and three of which
- 14:03were postnatal. Partly about the
- 14:06hormonalization, the masculinization and the
- 14:11demasculinization or the fem and this one say this, but we're all
- 14:17born. We all start as a female.
- 14:21That's the default. And then depending on the sperm
- 14:25and the fertilization, we either go.
- 14:28And an XX pattern, which is female, or an XY pattern, which
- 14:32is male. The the brain structure then in
- 14:37male zygotes is defeminized and then mascotized.
- 14:41But that doesn't always happen for everybody.
- 14:44In the same way, it's conceivable that you could have
- 14:49a brain as a male that wasn't the mask, wasn't defeminized but
- 14:54mascotized that you could have a.
- 14:57Brain that was feminine and not masconized that have a you could
- 15:02be a female, start off as a female zygote, then have a brain
- 15:07that was defeminized and mascodized.
- 15:10So there's a large range of things that can happen in the
- 15:14process of gestation. And then you're born, of course,
- 15:19and you have secretary genitalia, which is triggering
- 15:26of. Identification of sex and then
- 15:29the kind of socializing that that tends to produce.
- 15:35And so you have the sex assignment, the the cultural
- 15:39conditioning of that. And then of course you have, as
- 15:42adolescence begins, the capacity to choose your own identity.
- 15:53Sorry. So right at the beginning of
- 15:55this. Art.
- 15:56You said that Dunbar A classifications tended to be
- 16:02sexual because of something about resources or why?
- 16:08Why was it that they tend to be sexual?
- 16:10Well, you need to in an A relationship, you're taking care
- 16:14of somebody on a daily or every other day basis.
- 16:18And the other quality of that is that the needs of the
- 16:21relationship are put in primary position and you're.
- 16:25Solo exploration needs are put in secondary position so that
- 16:29the relationship needs take precedent over your solo
- 16:33exploration needs. That's a huge commitment of
- 16:36time, energy and resources. And because of that people who
- 16:40like to have sexual experiences tend to sexualize those
- 16:45relationships. So obviously not necessary.
- 16:48You look at the statistics of. 60% of marriages being sexless
- 16:53after five years. It really does depend on, I'd
- 16:58like to say how well your sexuality emerged from the the
- 17:04institutes of your upbringing. Like to say, we're all born with
- 17:13a slick, smooth, sexy sports car of the sexual orientation.
- 17:19By the time we're old enough to drive, it's a banged up old
- 17:22jalopy that also then points to the family system.
- 17:38You grow a bit off in a class system that you grew up in.
- 17:40Did you come from a reasonably resourced family or a very well
- 17:45resourced family and. And were the things that made
- 17:51understanding life in the way that we live it easy for you
- 17:56were you born without resources and so there was a constant
- 18:00challenge and struggle and that because of that your parents
- 18:05were or parent were in such difficult shape that they
- 18:13weren't able to provide for you. That the the security of an
- 18:17environment that would help you develop a sense of security, a
- 18:23sense of safety in the world. When we talk about attachment,
- 18:26of course we're really talking about this sense of safety, this
- 18:30sense of security which allows the attachment system to shut
- 18:34down and the exploration system to turn on that.
- 18:37You could then be engaged most of the time in exploring things
- 18:41that have real meaning to you. And not in in a place of
- 18:48fearfulness, so that the exploration system never really
- 18:52engages and you're constantly seeking reinsurance and safety
- 18:56from the people around you. There's another relationship
- 19:03above the line, which I called and I think also Dunbar called B
- 19:08relationships. B relationships are people that
- 19:13you see weekly or every other week that you also tell
- 19:16everything to that you take care of.
- 19:19But the the main difference between A and B relationships is
- 19:23that in B relationships your personal exploration is still in
- 19:28primary position in the needs of the relationship aren't
- 19:32secondary position. Then below the line the the
- 19:35closest group is the C group. That's 30 to 40 people for most
- 19:40adults. And then the D group is rounding
- 19:47out the remaining 150. That was the original research.
- 19:55He's modified it a little bit in multiples of three really.
- 19:59He talks about it A relationships and B
- 20:03relationships, three to five people maybe, And then.
- 20:12In sea relationships, there's a band of close C's, maybe 15
- 20:15people that are like bees in a lot of respects, but you don't
- 20:21have the bandwidth to maintain the relationships that are more
- 20:25intimate in a constant level. But that's the place you go to
- 20:30fill up your intimate relationships.
- 20:33If one of the relationship should fail, that leaves about
- 20:3730 people in the rest of the band.
- 20:39And then. 150 or so. Then there's a larger group of
- 20:461500 people and 1500 people are people are faces that you can
- 20:52recognize and that you can make some association to.
- 20:56So you know, in our media driven culture, it's likely that you
- 21:01can recognize dozens or more faces of.
- 21:07People that are prominent and appear often in media without
- 21:11ever, ever having any real contact with them.
- 21:14People that you know certain things about but you don't know
- 21:19or have never met. And then there's a wider group
- 21:23that tops out at about 5000, which are there's a statistical
- 21:32significance about. Whether you've seen that face or
- 21:36not, seen that face, that makes sense.
- 21:39And then so that's the the whole picture of the mind and its
- 21:43capacity to recognize faces. But in Dunbar's research at
- 21:49looking for who's happier, what he found was that he calls it 1
- 21:591/2 in terms of the the A's. That the happiest people in
- 22:05committed couples are people that have a designated person
- 22:09that can hear everything about the relationship and be used as
- 22:15a sounding board by one part, one person in the partnership.
- 22:19And that sometimes if each person has that designated
- 22:22person that is, that it's agreeable to the other person in
- 22:26the a relationship to hear everything about the
- 22:29relationship that those people tend to be.
- 22:34The happiest in their a relationship.
- 22:36So then, because the needs of the relationship are primary and
- 22:42the secondary exploration is secondary and those
- 22:45relationships, you really do need to have the other person
- 22:48agree that you can express openly what's going on in the
- 22:53relationship to someone else. And if that isn't agreeable to
- 22:58the partner you really shouldn't violate.
- 23:01Violate that confidence by discussing it somewhere else
- 23:06that making sense. But the happiest people have
- 23:18designated people that you can use as a sounding board to make
- 23:22sense. Remember, we really understand
- 23:24ourselves as it's reflected back from someone else.
- 23:28When you're in a primary relationship with someone else
- 23:31and they're so central to your life, if there's a conflict in
- 23:35the relationship that. The sense of who you are I can
- 23:39be quite distorted and so it's useful to have that possibility
- 23:44of another reflection. It's also useful to have B.
- 23:52So what he also found in the happiest group is that each of
- 23:56the partners in the A relationship have a number of
- 24:02secondary relationships that are intimate, that are emotionally
- 24:06regulating. The reason that this makes
- 24:08people happy is because you have alternatives to only one person
- 24:12being emotionally regulating. That also allows them to and you
- 24:16also to have your solo exploration.
- 24:20If you really center your life on one person and only have one
- 24:25regulating relationship, you're dependent on them to regulate
- 24:30you if you get disregulated and so.
- 24:34That means they have to be available to you, which can be
- 24:38inhibiting either to your exploration because you can't
- 24:41separate from them, or their exploration because they can't
- 24:48separate from you. If you have that that B level of
- 24:53relationships, then they can go off and you're not bereft of
- 24:58somebody to regulate you because your B group can regulate you.
- 25:02And you can go off and they won't be left without a
- 25:05regulator. Is that making sense?
- 25:09And then the C group 30 to 40, the D group rounding up to 150.
- 25:17Dunbar also discovered that that was not the most common
- 25:20formulation in the West. The most common formulation was
- 25:24to have one A relationship, no B relationships.
- 25:28No close C relationships and just general C's and that that
- 25:34made people much less happy and much more dependent on their A
- 25:38relationship. I should also say that not
- 25:41everybody wants to have an A relationship.
- 25:44There's no obligation to do that.
- 25:48Many people have B relationships, multiple B
- 25:53relationships, some with or more than one with sexual.
- 25:58Components to it And then that's a totally valid model for being
- 26:02in relationship. We don't we get very
- 26:07heteronormative in terms of how we think relationship should be.
- 26:13And this is again part of this structure of your sexual
- 26:18orientation which is pretty fixed.
- 26:20And so part of this of course is to really look deeply at what's
- 26:25arousing for you And then. Also understand that just
- 26:30because it's arousing for you, you don't have license to that
- 26:33engage in that activity in the world without consent of other
- 26:38people. And that that means you have to
- 26:41have people who are who are capable of consent.
- 26:46So again, this is pointing toward authenticity and you
- 26:51express what your desires and interests are to somebody in an
- 26:56authentic way. And can you hear their response
- 27:00to that and then adapt to their permission?
- 27:07And can they adapt to your permission in the radio, your
- 27:11great relationship, your consent?
- 27:17We we tend to notice and develop our understanding of consent in
- 27:22relationships by modeling what happens in our family system.
- 27:26Did you grow up in a family system where consent was
- 27:30routinely negotiated and people and the caregivers in your
- 27:35family system came up with a winwin scenario so that both
- 27:39people were satisfied with that? Or did you grow up in a family
- 27:43system where the power dynamic was not like that?
- 27:48I grew up in a in a in a family system where my father's choice
- 27:53was was the choice. And it was never even
- 27:56negotiated. It was never negotiated.
- 27:58It was just what it was. There wasn't the possibility for
- 28:05that. And so that's the modeling I
- 28:08really understand at that original family system level.
- 28:17So I tend to be hypersensitive about consent and relationships
- 28:21because it was absent. Is that all making sense so far?
- 28:32So you can begin and I think one of the things that's important
- 28:36about considering this is that you can begin to map what your
- 28:42pattern and relationship is. And you can then begin to
- 28:47recognize where you have assets and where you have deficits and
- 28:50you can begin to develop the the deficits so that you have a more
- 28:55robust relationship network that supports you.
- 29:02The main advantage of this is that with a lot of social
- 29:06support. You're much freer to explore and
- 29:10explored a much deeper level, a much more meaningful level,
- 29:14because you have the support you need if you get knocked sideways
- 29:18and can't emotionally regulate yourself as you're exploring.
- 29:23But you do have to tend to the garden of these relationships,
- 29:27which takes a lot of time, energy, and resources, One of
- 29:31the biggest difficulties that insecure and disorganized people
- 29:35have around. Putting these social networks in
- 29:37place is they don't see the value of the relationships.
- 29:42They don't see the value of the attachment enough to be willing
- 29:46to put the amount of time, energy and resources into the
- 29:49relationships that secure functioning relationships
- 29:53require. Their experience of
- 29:56relationships has not been that productive and so they don't see
- 30:00the value of it and so in withholding the energy.
- 30:05The time, energy and resources from relationships which are
- 30:08necessary to support secure functioning relationships, you
- 30:13self select out of having them and it's also self reinforcing.
- 30:18You don't put the energy in so you don't have them and so you
- 30:22you begin to believe the representation that these
- 30:25relationships aren't available. Do understand that we're all in
- 30:30the same boat we all need these social networks to.
- 30:35Support our solo exploration. And if we're not doing enough
- 30:40solo exploration, we we are often in a state of despair and
- 30:45being alive and even in privileged societies.
- 30:51I noticed in the meditation communities, at least the ones
- 30:54that I'm involved in, there's a fairly high level of privilege
- 30:58that most people have. Even in privileged communities,
- 31:02this human life is difficult and hard to do.
- 31:06And as you get older and the amount of energy that you have
- 31:10diminishes, it gets harder and harder to do it.
- 31:14When you have insecure, disorganized relationships, it
- 31:20it takes a ton of energy just to stabilize the relationship, so
- 31:25the energy that you might use to explore is consumed by
- 31:29stabilizing. Unstable relationships, but
- 31:33secure, functioning relationships don't really
- 31:35operate it that way. You open a topic that needs to
- 31:39be negotiated, you negotiate a way to be in relationship to
- 31:44each other with that subject matter, and you come to an
- 31:50agreement that is a win win. In secure, functioning
- 31:54relationships, you don't accept win lose.
- 31:57Relationships, because you understand that they don't
- 32:00settle. You can't expect somebody to
- 32:03persist in a win, lose relationship without demanding A
- 32:09renegotiation. But in a winwin situation, you
- 32:15can settle conflicts in relationships and then you don't
- 32:19have to attend to them because they're there's an agreement
- 32:23that people keep and that settles it.
- 32:27And so in secure functioning relationships for more and more
- 32:30of these agreements are made, less and less energy is
- 32:33necessary to stabilize the relationship.
- 32:36They tend to run pretty smoothly and then that frees up that
- 32:40energy that you can so that you can use it to focus on your
- 32:48exploration that making sense, but you have to change your mind
- 32:55and see the value of. Secure functioning relationship
- 32:59so that you'll put the time, energy, resources into them.
- 33:03And then you need to really reflect on what it is that you
- 33:06need to get out of a relationship that supports your
- 33:11exploration so that you can be engaged in the world and find
- 33:15meaning in the world. And then part of that process of
- 33:20intimacy is sharing authentically what you've
- 33:24discovered in your exploration. With the expectation that the
- 33:29person that you're sharing it to, that you're intimately
- 33:32involved with, built to light in you and your discoveries, and
- 33:38that you then, as they go out into the world and discover
- 33:41things and come back and express them to you, will be interested
- 33:46and delighted in what they found.
- 33:49And that's one of the main energies of secure functioning
- 33:52relationships, this expression of.
- 33:57Each other's exploration and the the meaningfulness of that, is
- 34:04that making sense. So the happiest people have an
- 34:11A. If they wanted, they have two to
- 34:13five B's. They have 15 close C's.
- 34:16They have 30 to 40 people in the C group, 150 people all
- 34:24together. Including the D group and you're
- 34:30hearing me about how much time, energy and resources that's
- 34:33going to take to put that social network in place and that if
- 34:40you're securely functioning, most of that's probably already
- 34:44there. And if you're insecurely
- 34:45functioning or disorganized, you'll notice that that
- 34:49structure is not really there, so.
- 34:56I do want to emphasize again that everybody's in the same
- 35:00boat on this. Everybody's looking for these
- 35:04kinds of supportive, intimate relationships.
- 35:08It's the nature of the human condition.
- 35:10It's even the physical structure of the brain, which has these
- 35:14bundles of neurons that are only found in mammals and other
- 35:21species that have. Complex social networks.
- 35:25They're not found in lizards. Not to disparage lizards, I was
- 35:37reading with some amusement, conspiracy theory about lizard
- 35:41people, which I won't get into. Is that all making sense?
- 35:56Going back a minute, if someone is in a insecure relationship
- 36:01and one partner is doing this attachment work, is there any
- 36:12other in any other option other than both partners need to do it
- 36:17or the outcome of 1 the the partner that does it is that
- 36:22they choose? They leave and they choose more
- 36:24wisely. Or is there any other option
- 36:28there? If one person does it and the
- 36:36other person doesn't do it, they the person who doesn't do it
- 36:40would have to be open to renegotiating a lot of the
- 36:44agreements. Mostly deal Breakers don't
- 36:51change that much. When you talk about deal
- 36:53Breakers, things that you have to have in the relationship and
- 36:57things that you can't have in the relationship aren't that
- 37:00many usually. And relationships, whether
- 37:05they're secure or not, if they have deal Breakers, those those
- 37:09relationships don't survive much anyway.
- 37:13But if you have a relationship that where that there are no
- 37:16deal Breakers in it. And you've made different kinds
- 37:20of negotiations with your partner.
- 37:25The typically the person who does the attachment work is not
- 37:29going to be able to keep the agreements.
- 37:32So it isn't. And the the partner who doesn't
- 37:36do the work is right in saying, I'm not the one who needs to
- 37:40change these agreements. You're the one who needs to
- 37:42change the agreements. And so there needs to be an
- 37:45acknowledgement that. As you do the attachment work
- 37:48and you can no longer tolerate the agreements that you've made
- 37:52that you are the one who's reneging out them and then
- 37:55inviting a process of renegotiation and seeing if you
- 38:00can come into a more balance where it's a kind of win, win
- 38:06situation that makes sense. Oftentimes that can happen and
- 38:13oftentimes it can happen. Within the partnership where
- 38:16you're you're successful in negotiating the relationship
- 38:20with your partner, sometimes you need to go into some kind of
- 38:24couples work where there's a referee and then there is some
- 38:29relationships that don't, aren't renegotiable.
- 38:37I would say that, you know, if you're in a relationship with
- 38:40somebody and there's some degree of intimacy.
- 38:42You're in the relationship because you value the person,
- 38:46and so it makes sense to the other person to renegotiate.
- 38:55The other thing that can happen, which is very typical, is that
- 38:58the relationship has already failed and you come into the
- 39:02attachment work with the idea that you might be able to save
- 39:07the relationship, but in the relationships that have already
- 39:10failed, that typically doesn't happen.
- 39:14They come apart quicker, but enough.
- 39:27Yes, thank you. I think one of the things that
- 39:33also is something that needs to happen is this.
- 39:43Capacity to hold the experience of the other person with
- 39:46delight. The capacities so the capacity
- 39:50to hold them in a positive light.
- 39:54So we also recommend that you do the the divine abodes as a
- 40:00constant practice that you can really create these working
- 40:04models of other people that are positive and delighting so that
- 40:09you have the capacity. For compassion in relationships
- 40:16with other people, the you know, the far enemy of compassion is
- 40:21cruelty. And you'll notice that in
- 40:24sometimes in relationships where there's a failure of compassion
- 40:28that one person responds instead with cruelty.
- 40:32They're disconnecting from the suffering of the other person
- 40:35because they can't bear it, but they do it with cruelty.
- 40:43Or indifference. And you know you really are in a
- 40:50secure, functioning relationship.
- 40:52You really are taking on the care of the other person and
- 40:56you're interested in doing a good job and taking care of them
- 41:00so that they feel well taken. Care of.
- 41:03Which means you're taking care of them in a way that's
- 41:05meaningful to them, not in a way that's meaningful to you.
- 41:10One of the things I noticed in the couple's work I do often is
- 41:14that one person takes care of the other person in the way that
- 41:17they would like to be taken care of, and are angry about the fact
- 41:24that their partner confronts them over and over again,
- 41:27feeling uncared for, and they don't really understand it.
- 41:30So mentalizing, he's there. Can you mentalize well enough to
- 41:35know what your partner needs, recognize the signals, and then
- 41:39just provide that care to them so that they feel seen, they
- 41:43feel understood, they feel known, they feel accepted.
- 41:47And they also feel safe because you know what to do to help them
- 41:51when they need help. And then they do that for you so
- 41:55that you feel seen, you feel understood, you feel known, you
- 41:59feel accepted, and you feel safe that.
- 42:03They they know how to handle you.
- 42:05They know what to do for you. You get into trouble and you
- 42:08can't do it for yourself. That making sense.
- 42:13And so you're it's this active engagement of care that doesn't
- 42:18depend on them telling you what to do.
- 42:23They do have to tell you in the beginning, and maybe they tell
- 42:26you three or four, eight times, but at some point you're
- 42:29supposed to be able to recognize what's going on with him and
- 42:32just do it because that's the agreement of that A level
- 42:37relationship. And even to some extent in the B
- 42:40relationships, one of the things that is so meaningful on the
- 42:45receiving end of care is if somebody sees what you need and
- 42:49they just do it because they know you, right?
- 42:53They want to be good at taking care of you, and then you do
- 42:58that for them. They feel seen and known,
- 43:02understood, and you feel seen and known and understood and
- 43:05protected. That's the thing that creates
- 43:07that sense of security in the relationship.
- 43:12Whereas if you know the 87th, the time or the 295th time, you
- 43:17have to ask them to do the same thing.
- 43:20Then it begins to be that you, they don't see you, they don't
- 43:23know you, they're not willing to take care of you, which is what
- 43:27creates a lot of friction. Anything else about that, I
- 43:35think it's a nice way to think about relationships and think
- 43:38about where you are in terms of putting your social group
- 43:41together so that you have the network available to you that
- 43:44will support you so that you can explore.
- 43:50To the point that you see this life, this world is a a place of
- 43:57beauty and interest and satisfaction.
- 44:03And then understand that if you're in despair, which happens
- 44:06quite a bit, if you don't see the world is that way, that
- 44:10really there's something needs to be some attention to your
- 44:14primary exploration, the pursuit of meaning.
- 44:17That you can come into that understanding.
- 44:23So why don't we do some meditation practice about some
- 44:30hard practice? We'll do some practice for an
- 44:33easy person and then for self. You really want to do the hard
- 44:43practices for self. Until the sense of self, the
- 44:48experience of self is delightful that you enjoy the experience of
- 44:58yourself as it manifests. I'm going to abandon using the
- 45:08bell. And I'll just tell you when
- 45:10we're beginning and when we're ending vocally.
- 45:13So go ahead and. Take your meditation.
- 45:16Posture will begin closing the eye, settling in the body,
- 45:22scanning through the body, looking for any tension you
- 45:24might be holding, seeing if you can release it All right.
- 45:28Come out of the meditation. Do.
- 45:37Any comments or questions? Okay.
- 45:48I have one. Okay.
- 45:52So when I am doing the initial part and you're guiding us to
- 45:59choose an easy person and that's an easy person to send or feel
- 46:06loving kindness with and for, right?
- 46:12And so the person I chose, the same one I chose last weekend,
- 46:16it's a person who already has the qualities of peace.
- 46:25And so when I'm saying may you be peaceful, it's like that
- 46:28person embodies peacefulness and seems to live it.
- 46:34So why would I be saying may you be peaceful?
- 46:37Because they're just already there.
- 46:40And so that's a confusing part for me with just that little
- 46:45segment And then I try to, but I will say that I during that time
- 46:52even though I was having this extra examination of the, you
- 46:55know, why am I sending maybe peaceful when this person is
- 46:59already embodying peace. So then I just started to feel
- 47:04the energy of. I could actually physically have
- 47:08a feeling tone with it. So that part felt like okay.
- 47:14Well, at least I'm on the right track.
- 47:16And then I I experiment a lot when you're guiding because I I
- 47:21have this habit of getting distracted and analytical and so
- 47:25I was like, well, maybe I should try.
- 47:29May you live a long and healthy life because you always say, you
- 47:34know you don't have to use maybe.
- 47:37Peaceful. But that felt cumbersome and it
- 47:40got me all off track. And then I'm like, I'm confusing
- 47:43myself and and then when it turned to me, I'd be peaceful.
- 47:49I was still trying to piggyback on the other person, yeah.
- 47:56Has anybody ever said to you that you might be overthinking
- 47:59this? Yeah, that's why I bring it up.
- 48:04That's why I bring it up, because how do I break that
- 48:06habit of overthinking? So when you notice that the mind
- 48:10is thinking focus, push more of your attention onto the object.
- 48:14And the object being the person. Who the mind state that peaceful
- 48:21quality? Put more of your attention on
- 48:23that peaceful quality. So drop the language of.
- 48:29May you be peaceful. May you be peaceful.
- 48:32Yeah, just why not just say peaceful?
- 48:36That would help. That's simplifying.
- 48:38That's a step. Yes, and each time you notice.
- 48:42So that's thought. The thoughts are coming out like
- 48:46the siren to grab you. Put wax in yours and lash
- 48:51yourself to the mast and don't listen to the thoughts that are
- 48:57coming for you. Just let them come and go in the
- 49:00background. Don't attend to them.
- 49:03Right. And it's always the thought of
- 49:04could I do it this way or why is it happening this way?
- 49:07You know, it's just over meta antula and meta and it's it's a
- 49:13habit. I know it's a habit that I have
- 49:16And so I'm trying to break that habit and you're saying during
- 49:22these guided meditations with you or whenever I'm doing it.
- 49:27To let that over analytical mind just be there.
- 49:30Just let it be in the background, Don't attend to it.
- 49:35Yeah. So don't question it and
- 49:36challenge it and say, oh, I I can't wait to ask George this
- 49:39question. I want an answer.
- 49:43And and then just let it go and just simplify.
- 49:48Peace. Feeling.
- 49:49Peace, peace. And then is it the feeling, tone
- 49:54I'm looking for or the view? Or.
- 49:57The view. And what's the difference
- 50:00between the feeling, tone of I'm starting to feel peaceful and
- 50:03calm and versus of you? Now, when I originally explored
- 50:09views, I had no concept of positive views really, so I
- 50:14worked with anger. Oh.
- 50:17How does the world appear when my mind is enraged?
- 50:20And how does it appear when it's not enraged?
- 50:24So then what is a common feeling state that you you get into?
- 50:30I guess it's is confusion or over analyzing a feeling state
- 50:35agitation. I don't.
- 50:37Know or agitation? How do you know that the mind is
- 50:40agitated? And how do you know when the
- 50:41mind is not agitated? I know when the mind is
- 50:46agitated, when it keeps grabbing for thoughts and trying to
- 50:50analyze them and make meaning out of them and make questions
- 50:54out of them. That's.
- 50:56That's a view of agitation. OK.
- 51:00So then, when the mind is not agitated, what does the self and
- 51:04world look like? Well, that's what I'm.
- 51:08Trying to looking, being a word for how do you experience self
- 51:11and world when the mind is not agitated?
- 51:15And how do you know that? Well, you mean through an
- 51:20experience felt since? I guess the closest I can come
- 51:25recently is I I got this new cat that likes to sleep on my belly
- 51:30and so I I take a little midday snooze for lunch and when it's
- 51:36sitting on my belly and purring. And I'm laying back on the
- 51:41couch, I can kind of calm my mind.
- 51:44It's it's a buddy system with the cat, I think.
- 51:49Yeah, I'm Co regulating. What would you call that that
- 51:53view? Calm and relaxed.
- 51:58OK, so you can tell the difference between calm and lat
- 52:03and relaxed and agitated. And can you then explore how the
- 52:08world appears to you when you're calm and relaxed, and how the
- 52:10world appears to you when you are agitated?
- 52:14And then what you'll begin to understand is the nature of
- 52:18view. The agitated view makes the
- 52:24world look a certain way. The common relaxed view makes
- 52:27the world look a certain way. And you recognize.
- 52:34You already recognize it. So the question is, can you
- 52:37mentalize what the recognition is?
- 52:40How do you know that you're common or relaxed?
- 52:42How do you know that you're agitated?
- 52:44That's what we're we're looking for.
- 52:46We're looking to exercise that. Yes.
- 52:50And then beginning to develop agency.
- 52:53This is the love and kindness view.
- 52:55Can I cause this to arise when I need it?
- 52:59Can I use that to displace the agitated view and just have
- 53:02that? Love and kindness view.
- 53:05Right have agency in the view, and with the view comes the
- 53:10underline, in this case, calm, relaxed.
- 53:14And then the whole world appears like that, and as long as you
- 53:16hold the view, it appears like. So I might want to substitute
- 53:22because I'm very, as you've probably figured out, I'm very
- 53:26like, whatever people are telling me in this guidance, I'm
- 53:30either supposed to do it or I'm going to fight it.
- 53:33And so when you're when you're leading, you know, maybe
- 53:36peacefully. I'm just like OKI got to do
- 53:38that, I got to do it. It's not working at all.
- 53:40So are you saying just ignore that, replace that with calm and
- 53:47and relax? Yeah, totally.
- 53:51OK, I'm going to train myself to not listen to you.
- 53:54OK, good, but you. Know, I mean, yeah, to an extent
- 53:59I can. Tell you that I was when I was
- 54:01in Miramar. I would do 11 walking pass
- 54:09around the there in the in the meditation center in in the the
- 54:18mounds of outside of Pin Lewin, which is near Mandalay.
- 54:26There was a track around the outside wall of the monastery.
- 54:30And you could walk it and it would take about 20 minutes to
- 54:32go, one time around. And so, you know, in the
- 54:38afternoon there'd be like a four hour period of doing walking
- 54:41meta. And I I as I was coming to the
- 54:44conclusion of the meditation period, I listened to my mind
- 54:48and I realized that I was saying.
- 54:51They all beans be pizza. They all beans be pizza.
- 54:56Yeah. He said that before and I.
- 54:58Remember it? So that isn't it.
- 55:02It is. You're not latching on to the
- 55:05words. We're latching out to the view,
- 55:10does it. The words don't matter.
- 55:12They fill up auditory thinking space so that it's less grabby.
- 55:17And choosing the person is that. Real critical in the beginning
- 55:22because I'm always like, well, this person makes me feel at
- 55:25ease and peaceful because they already have peace, yeah.
- 55:28Well. You know, we hold these working
- 55:31models of people and what we want is a simple relationship
- 55:36that has a lot of loving kindness associated with it.
- 55:39That when we think of them, that's generally the direction
- 55:42the mind inclines. The reason that the said I said
- 55:47that. The short list of easy people is
- 55:49so important because when you're out and about in the world and
- 55:54the mind gets caught up in anger, it's hard to then come
- 55:58into a meditative state and then pull the mind state up.
- 56:03But if you think of an easy person and that just displaces
- 56:06the anger mind state, then you just think of the easy person
- 56:11when you notice the mind is inclining toward anger.
- 56:16Or for me? Kind of what did I call it?
- 56:19Chaotic thinking or overthinking?
- 56:23Agitation. Agitation was the word.
- 56:26Yeah. Agitated mind.
- 56:28Yeah. OK, I I realize this is just one
- 56:31technique among many. And.
- 56:35But it is. It's a We really want to get you
- 56:41to understand what a view or a mind state is, because they.
- 56:46Change the perception of everything.
- 56:50And until you really see that they come and go and that you
- 56:53actually have agency to hold one or the other, it tends to cause
- 56:59you to believe your perception. And you slip out of active
- 57:02mentalizing into psychic equivalence.
- 57:06And in psychic equivalence, you think that you you're accurately
- 57:10experiencing what's happening, even though it's distorted.
- 57:15You just said choose one or the other aren't.
- 57:18Aren't there more than two to choose from?
- 57:23Mind states, Yeah, yeah, there's lots.
- 57:27Okay. So choose a different, better
- 57:29ones there are, right? The Buddha said the the five
- 57:34hindrances are all mind states, right?
- 57:37Lust, anger, restlessness and agitation, sloth and torpor,
- 57:42skeptical doubt, those are all mind states.
- 57:46All of the meta, all of the hard practices, loving kindness,
- 57:49compassion, sympathetic joy, equanimity.
- 57:52They're all mind states. And then I want you to also to
- 57:55be sensitive to the attachment mind states.
- 57:57This is a secure mindset, dismissing mindset, a
- 58:01preoccupied mindset, a disorganized mindset so that you
- 58:05have agency and you can recognize what's happening.
- 58:10Because if you can't recognize what's happening, you tend to
- 58:12believe that your perception of it is accurate, and that will
- 58:15lead to attention and action. Then you'll create these comic
- 58:19threads that are based on distorted perception.
- 58:24Right. Yeah.
- 58:27I think I'm getting it a little bit, little by little.
- 58:31But. Yeah, and you want to replace it
- 58:34with also secure attachment qualities like safety.
- 58:40Delight one of the other ones. You know all the secure attached
- 58:45ones like the. Emotional regulation and also
- 58:50the capacity to explore. And can those be ones that I
- 58:55hold as views during a practice like this?
- 59:00Like I am safe, I am emotionally regulated with the cat, OK?
- 59:07Or the ideal parent figures. Or with the ideal paradigm.
- 59:11OK, all right, that's helpful. I'm slowly, slowly getting a
- 59:16little glimpse of this complex model.
- 59:20It seems complex, but maybe I'm just making it complex.
- 59:24It's complex and there are a lot of parts, but if you explore
- 59:27each of the parts separately, which is the positive way,
- 59:29right? Pulling things apart and
- 59:31examining each part, then you can see how they work together
- 59:34and it becomes easier to. Understand and operate.
- 59:40Spokes of the wheel. Yeah.
- 59:44Yeah, it won't run without the spokes.
- 59:47Right. Okay.
- 59:49All right. Thank you.
- 59:50So thanks everybody. We just started a Level 2.
- 59:56If you want to join it, you can for another week and then it'll
- 1:00:00close up. We're going to start Level 0 as
- 1:00:04I said here the 1st. Thursday of the month is going
- 1:00:08to be our new Level 0 for meditation and attachment, and
- 1:00:11we'll talk about that. And then the other three or four
- 1:00:14Thursdays of the month will be I Love You Keep going.
- 1:00:19We have some level one starting, level 2 starting, and anyway, if
- 1:00:25you're interested in that stuff, it's on the calendar.
- 1:00:28Take a look at it. Ioffer this teaching freely and
- 1:00:31I do hope that if you can, you'll be able to make the
- 1:00:34donation. Edward.
- 1:00:43You're muted. Let's.
- 1:00:50Just regarding the Level 2, which I'm I'm in, you said
- 1:00:53something about someone taking phone numbers which I offered
- 1:00:58and emails which you supposedly offered about maybe us separate
- 1:01:04from the class. Enter you know, whatever.
- 1:01:07Enter I. Think is Allah is going to do
- 1:01:08that? And then you also said something
- 1:01:11about possibly at the time, which would be like tomorrow,
- 1:01:15but I haven't heard anything, so I don't know if it's happening
- 1:01:18yet, that's all. I don't either, but I can find
- 1:01:23out. You can find me and let you
- 1:01:27know. Yeah, fine.
- 1:01:31Thank you all. Right.
- 1:01:34There's a link on the website to make a donation if you if you
- 1:01:37can. I really appreciate any amount
- 1:01:39it helps support me and also the work meta group is doing.
- 1:01:43Happy to see you and happy to practice with you and see you
- 1:01:46soon. Bye.