Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Insights and Challenges: ACEC Research Institute's 2024 Q4 Engineering Business Sentiment Survey
Transcript
- 0:00Music.
- 0:18Welcome to Engineering Influence, a podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:23We are here today to talk about the newly released ACEC Research Institute 2024
- 0:30Quarter 4 Engineering Business Sentiment Survey.
- 0:35It's a quarterly survey, as the name would imply,
- 0:38that kind of takes a look at current business conditions within the engineering
- 0:41industry and also takes a look at what might be around the bend by interviewing
- 0:47and surveying CEOs within our industry.
- 0:51Very pleased to be joined by Joe Bates, our researcher who has been toiling
- 0:56away at this survey for, God, how many quarters have you done this for now, Joe?
- 1:02This is our 13th quarter, so we're just at the three-year mark now.
- 1:06Yeah, three-year mark. So, I mean, this is a ton of data.
- 1:10Go to the ACEC Research Institute website, the www.acecresearchinstitute.org,
- 1:16and take a look at past surveys and get a historical view and read the quarter
- 1:23four review for seeing what's ahead of us.
- 1:26So, Joe, as we've done in the past, really the survey is a great piece of information
- 1:32for engineering firm executives to.
- 1:37Really, you take a look at current business conditions. You look at what's around
- 1:41the corner for future business conditions and some hot topics.
- 1:44So let's take a look at where we are right now.
- 1:47What does quarter four look like for the industry?
- 1:51Yeah, quarter four, Jeff, looks really good. You know, we've been on a pretty
- 1:55solid run this year in terms of our current sentiment.
- 2:00So we ask three questions regarding current sentiment. One is about the overall U.S. economy.
- 2:07One is regarding the industry itself.
- 2:10And the third is regarding firm finances.
- 2:13And on all of these metrics, we're positive as we have been.
- 2:17The overall U.S. economy, that metric has shown the most change over the last three years.
- 2:23And we're seeing a little bit of moderation. We kind of hit a high point back
- 2:28in the second quarter of this year. And we've dropped a few points since then.
- 2:35We use a net rating. And for those of you not familiar with it,
- 2:38we take the percent of positive responses, subtract the percent of negative responses.
- 2:43Those who are neutral, they're not included in the calculation because they're
- 2:47neutral. So we're trying to find on balance what percentage of the respondents
- 2:53are positive or negative.
- 2:55So in this case, we have net rating of plus 36 for the U.S. economy.
- 2:59That's a very, very solid number. It's very good.
- 3:03As I said, it's down just a few points from earlier this year,
- 3:06but nothing to be concerned about.
- 3:07And then when we look at the industry and firm finances, we've been in the plus
- 3:1180s for the last three years. There's just been a tremendous amount of positivity
- 3:17around the industry and firms.
- 3:21You know, IIJA has certainly helped to buoy that. Coming back out of the COVID
- 3:26recession has also just been, you know, phenomenally strong for our industry.
- 3:31Yeah, it's been, it's really historically, since COVID and even during COVID,
- 3:36there was still a good amount of optimism.
- 3:38It just seems as though that, you know, our industry is optimistic with the
- 3:44legislation that's in place, the fact that money is still being spent through
- 3:48the bipartisan infrastructure law,
- 3:51the fact that there are a lot of projects that are now hitting the point of,
- 3:55you know, going into construction phase.
- 3:59There are a lot of projects out there and of opportunity within the industry.
- 4:03But at the same time, it seems as though, and one of the hot topics really kind
- 4:08of goes towards hiring again, it really comes down to workforce.
- 4:12And what I noticed is that there has been an uptick in firms that are actually
- 4:16turning down profitable work.
- 4:19Is that largely tied to the inability to fully staff those projects?
- 4:25Yes, that's exactly right. We ask this question every so often,
- 4:30and we've been asking it for the last two years now, whether your firm has turned
- 4:35down any work due to the lack of employees.
- 4:38We use the term turned down, but it could also be that you're not pursuing certain projects as well.
- 4:45And we do see that half of firms tell us they have turned down or are not actively
- 4:51pursuing projects they could be.
- 4:53And that among those half, over a quarter are turning down good profitable projects.
- 5:00And that is a huge issue.
- 5:03We could be growing even more as an industry if we actually had enough people to do the work.
- 5:11Nine out of 10 firms are hiring. That has not changed in the last three years.
- 5:17The median number of openings is five.
- 5:20That has not changed. And of course, it varies by firm size.
- 5:24So when you look at the percent, the number of open positions as a percentage
- 5:30of FTEs, we see that at 8% in the industry overall.
- 5:35Now that's one percentage point lower than we've seen in the past.
- 5:39It had been 9%. So just a slight, slight easing, perhaps, of maybe the demand side.
- 5:48Firms may be slowing down just a tad, but there's such a lack of workers and
- 5:54firms are just dying to hire more people that I doubt many people really feel it.
- 6:00Yeah, that has been a constant. The workforce shortage is something real.
- 6:04It's something that needs to be addressed. It's something that we're working
- 6:07on at ACEC with the Engineering Workforce Consortium.
- 6:11And for anyone out there listening in the new administration coming in,
- 6:15engineering workforce shortage is something that needs to be paid attention
- 6:19to because we are at the crux of everything to, you know, if you want to try
- 6:25to make America great again,
- 6:27again, you need to build. And to build, you need engineers.
- 6:31So we definitely need to have those individuals out there in the marketplace.
- 6:35How is the workforce shortage and really other economic indicators affecting
- 6:42the future outlook for the industry?
- 6:45I think it has a significant drag on the future.
- 6:49You know, what we're seeing, actually, this was a bit surprising to me when
- 6:54we ask about future sentiment. we actually saw pretty significant declines in
- 6:59the fourth quarter compared to the third quarter.
- 7:02Now, I've had to caution people because it could partially be a timing issue.
- 7:09This survey was conducted in early September.
- 7:12We had had a few not-so-great jobs reports over the summer.
- 7:17We had not yet started cutting interest rates from the Federal Reserve.
- 7:23Inflation was sort of It's still a little bit stuck, but then later September
- 7:27and into October, the news got a lot better and the Federal Reserve started
- 7:32cutting interest rates, et cetera.
- 7:33So this decline that we've seen in future.
- 7:37Sentiment in the fourth quarter. We really have to wait and see what happens
- 7:43with the first quarter of next year.
- 7:46And of course, a lot can happen between now and then, as you mentioned,
- 7:50we have a new administration coming in.
- 7:52So there's a lot of moving parts here right now.
- 7:57How baked in do you think the political uncertainty, like you said,
- 8:00the survey was conducted in September, that was really when things started to
- 8:05change in the presidential race.
- 8:07How baked in do you think the political uncertainty is with how firm executives
- 8:13are looking at 2025 coming up? Yeah, it's a huge part, Jeff.
- 8:18We ask those individuals who are not optimistic about the future why that is the case.
- 8:25And they tell us the number one reason is economic uncertainty.
- 8:31But no, the number two reason is political uncertainty. And that political uncertainty
- 8:37in the first and second quarter of this year was actually the first,
- 8:41the number one biggest concern. So now it's number two.
- 8:45I imagine it's still going to stay at the top in the next quarter simply because
- 8:50there's a lot of unknowns about what will happen.
- 8:53So that is something that's fully baked into these numbers. The workforce shortage
- 8:57is baked in. The concern about inflation is definitely moderating.
- 9:03People are much, much less concerned about inflation at the moment,
- 9:06but they're not yet totally unconcerned about interest rates because there's
- 9:13still uncertainty there as to how far the Federal Reserve will go,
- 9:17how long they'll cut rates.
- 9:18And if we have renewed inflationary pressures because of certain policies that
- 9:24are made by the new administration, that could change everything next year.
- 9:28So there really is a lot of uncertainty. And I think that's reflected in some of these numbers.
- 9:33That's an interesting point. You know, the concern over inflation,
- 9:37I think, you know, that is – the economy was, of course, the major driver,
- 9:41I think, in the election as we're finding out more and more.
- 9:45But it's more of a question of interest rates and exactly where are they going
- 9:48to fall and exactly what's going to happen with the constitution of the Fed moving forward.
- 9:53And how is that going to drive rates and what's the disposition of the Federal
- 10:00Reserve, you know, in the new Trump administration?
- 10:02Yeah. A lot of uncertainty still out there. Yeah. And the Powell Fed has shown
- 10:07us over the last few years that they are hesitant to raise rates and they are they're easy,
- 10:14easily persuaded to cut them a little bit before we might be fully out of the woods.
- 10:19So I think that has a dynamic that we're looking at as well.
- 10:23I think the GDP numbers are going to be pretty strong next year.
- 10:27I'm not too concerned about that at the moment unless we have some kind of a major external shock.
- 10:33But I think the real concern is if we have such strong growth numbers or we
- 10:38have inflationary measures that are put in place, such as tariffs,
- 10:42that could be a big concern next year.
- 10:46Yeah, absolutely. And we'll see the effect of that in probably the next survey done in Q1.
- 10:53Looking at market sectors, have you seen any big shifts in market sectors of
- 10:59interest by the industry?
- 11:01What are the hot topics or hot industries and which are the ones that are showing some softening?
- 11:07Yeah, we definitely have what we call winners and losers.
- 11:10You know, that's kind of our shorthand for talking about sectors.
- 11:13The sectors that are doing the best and have been performing the best in terms
- 11:18of sentiment, as well as in reality for the last few years, are those supported
- 11:23by the government programs such as the IJA, the CHIPS Act, etc.
- 11:28And so what we're seeing are roads and bridges, infrastructure.
- 11:33Transportation at airports, all of the transportation elements are doing very well.
- 11:39Water and wastewater is also doing very well. We're seeing manufacturing doing
- 11:44well also, and that's very much a part of onshoring the last few years.
- 11:49So we continue to see that as being a growth sector as well.
- 11:53So those are the positives. On the negative side, we're really seeing a drag
- 11:57in the commercial real estate industry.
- 11:59That just is not doing very well right now.
- 12:03It has not done well since the pandemic, but there's some indications it could
- 12:07do even worse in the next year.
- 12:09On the residential side, it's not done so well the last couple of years,
- 12:13but depending on what happens with
- 12:16interest rates, that could boost the production of single family homes.
- 12:23So, you know, there are definitely some positives, but some cautionary areas as well.
- 12:28Yeah, commercial real estate has really been, really been, it just has not recovered yet.
- 12:34Since the pandemic, it would be good to see housing starts grow on data centers
- 12:39and other critical infrastructure for the tech industry, for a lot of support
- 12:46function for industry. How's that looking?
- 12:49Data centers are going gangbusters. They have been doing very,
- 12:52very well since we started this survey, but even better the last year or two.
- 12:59And the future sentiment is extremely high for data centers as well.
- 13:03You know, if you live in an area such as the D.C.
- 13:08Metro area where I live, you can't drive down the interstate without seeing
- 13:13a brand new data center being put up every month.
- 13:17So it's pretty solid right there for sure.
- 13:22Fantastic. Yeah, it's hard. It's like a data center wonderland when you get
- 13:27outside of D.C., out west and past Reston. They keep on building. Yeah.
- 13:32It's truly amazing. When you're taking off an airplane from Dulles Airport,
- 13:35if you look down, you can really see it.
- 13:38It's pretty great. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely.
- 13:41So, again, I mean, this is kind of scratching the surface here of the report.
- 13:45I mean, I really do encourage everyone to go up online to download this and dig into the numbers.
- 13:50And look again at past reports because, you know, with 13 quarters,
- 13:55now you're in the area of trends, right?
- 13:58So that's another thing to kind of point out is the fact that now with so much
- 14:03data under your belt, you can now look at trend data and you can start doing
- 14:08some serious forecasting.
- 14:09And Jeff, there's one other thing that we're currently working on with this
- 14:14data, and I hope that we'll be able to publish this in the next month or two.
- 14:19What we've done is now that we have a good time series of data,
- 14:23we've gone back and looked at economic indicators. We did this about a year
- 14:27or so ago and found some very positive correlations.
- 14:30But now that we have even more data, we've expanded the number of economic indicators we're looking at.
- 14:36So we're seeing correlations of our data as a leading indicator by one or two,
- 14:42in some cases, three quarters of things such as GDP, employment, housing starts.
- 14:48So that is something that we're going to come out with, I hope, in the next month or two.
- 14:52And it's going to have a lot of really rich data that I think will be even more
- 14:56helpful because then you can say, ah,
- 14:58if we see an increase in this measure in the sentiment index,
- 15:02we can expect an improvement in various economic metrics in the next quarter or two.
- 15:08So I think that's going to be some really powerful data that we'll have to share soon.
- 15:12Yeah, without question. And I mean, there's so much else going on with the Institute.
- 15:16It's just not the economic reports. You're also working on the diversity roadmap with my group.
- 15:22You're working on the Firm of the Future project of what the engineering firm
- 15:26of 2035 is going to look like.
- 15:28You just released your achievement report for fiscal year 2324.
- 15:32There is a wealth of information here. Again, the Institute started out just
- 15:38kind of doing a couple of studies and establishing itself during COVID,
- 15:41and now it's just really exploded to become really a very strong source for hard data numbers,
- 15:49economic trend analysis for the engineering industry.
- 15:51And Joe, your research has been fantastic. So I appreciate you taking time today
- 15:57to go through the sentiment report and look forward to having you back on to
- 16:01talk about that trend data and also look forward to Q1. 25.
- 16:05Great. Thanks, Jeff. It's always a pleasure to be with you.
- 16:09Fantastic. And again, if you liked this episode, please click like and subscribe
- 16:13down at the bottom there. You know what to do.
- 16:16Good old YouTube. We got to beat the algorithm, get some eyes on the content.
- 16:21So please join us in liking and subscribing. And again, this has been Engineering
- 16:26Influence Podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies. We'll see you next time.
- 16:31Music.