Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #71🎙️ |Public Inquiry Narrative Building Week Beginning 2nd June 2026 Day 1 |
Transcript
- 0:00Unknown: Sitting in the public inquiry day after day,
- 0:03ostensibly taking notes, I observe a lot of stuff, and one
- 0:08of the things I've learned is that there's a noticeable gap
- 0:11between telling the truth and or landing an idea with the
- 0:15targeted listeners to give them the impression that they have a
- 0:20true understanding of events to say a good barrister doesn't
- 0:25need to tell a known truth, that their skill lies in selecting
- 0:29facts and then framing them, emphasising some, minimising
- 0:34others, until the listening quarry is guided towards a
- 0:38particular conclusion. Much of the debate since the beginning
- 0:43of the inquiry is more an argument about what the facts
- 0:47mean rather than arguing against the facts. If you see what I
- 0:50mean, I suppose it comes down to a battle over definitions.
- 0:54Really, they do this in a number of different ways, and I think
- 0:59it would be a good exercise for folk attending the public
- 1:02inquiry to see can this bot when the barristers are up to their
- 1:06tricks, which are many and can look like some of the following.
- 1:12What facts had my case here for Delridian? Are they legally
- 1:16relevant? And then what facts would create the strongest
- 1:19narrative to that to get that across to the commissioners. I
- 1:25imagine this is discussion going on in the barristers' heads.
- 1:33Here's a question: Can we third parties begin to notice when
- 1:38barristers frame some of the facts in different ways, classic
- 1:42examples come to mind. This one is about the release of water
- 1:48from the mind processing back into the own Kahlu, and we were
- 1:54told that the water will be even cleaner than it was before. So,
- 2:00what does clean mean in this context? Will it support life,
- 2:06or is it clean, as in an acid bath? You get my drift. What
- 2:13other techniques are they using? Let's see. The good is weaving
- 2:18lists of facts into a good story creating the most convincing
- 2:23legal argument that the facts could hardly be any other way.
- 2:30Notice, too, that the barristers often like to have the last
- 2:33word. The commissioners are left with the resounding echo of
- 2:36their final thoughts on the subject. Other times the
- 2:41barristers become strategically ambiguous, and this was in
- 2:45evidence today when I believe Beattie said, at one juncture,
- 2:50it's not clear how mining will adversely affect language
- 2:53heritage. Here he manages to shift the question from proving
- 2:58mining won't affect heritage to questioning the certainty of the
- 3:02adverse effect on heritage, as already more than adequately
- 3:06presented by third parties in their statement of case. Going
- 3:11back to the skill of reframing every argument will have its
- 3:15weak points or bad facts as they're known, and watching the
- 3:20applicant's barristers jumped through the hoops to give them a
- 3:23different interpretation, is sometimes amusing, other times
- 3:27downright worrying. Do they really believe this shit? Sorry,
- 3:31I didn't mean to say that. For example, Baroni, today another
- 3:35advocate for Dalradion, spent some time endeavouring to
- 3:38reframe the bad fact that there was no community consultation
- 3:42carried out whatsoever around cultural heritage. He used the
- 3:46following as examples as to how this was done: one public
- 3:50session at the mine, the publishing of company publicity
- 3:55on the website, and some marketing material. And then
- 3:59even had the temerity to say, because we're talking about it
- 4:02right now, that this was community engagement, like, how
- 4:06desperate do you have to get to use that as a reframing
- 4:09strategy, using different other facts to arrive at the same
- 4:13meaning, and just by the bye, he went on to make sweeping
- 4:17generalisations about how there would be no impact on language
- 4:21or community cohesion and folklore. Fortunately, in the
- 4:26room with us, we had Dr. Vincenzo Surface, who easily
- 4:29dismantled his argument, bad fact by bad fact. She
- 4:33specialises in community consultation, but getting back
- 4:38to the business of reframing, I think it'd be a good game to see
- 4:41how many times we can spot the barristers at this, like in that
- 4:45old form of ice, by could even put our hand up and shout
- 4:49reframe, so that commissioners really get it, laugh out loud.
- 4:53Seriously, though, one of the things we, as third parties,
- 4:57need to be alert, alert to throughout this. Inquiry is not
- 5:02necessarily what has been said, but what has not been said.
- 5:06We need to notice when important context is omitted, when
- 5:11speculation begins to be treated as established fact, and when a
- 5:15particular impression has been created without anyone ever
- 5:20having to utter a literal untruth, for example, if we
- 5:25spend hours talking mitigation measures for dust and noise and
- 5:29traffic, but little time discussing whether communities
- 5:33should have to live with those impacts in the first place, or
- 5:38when human rights is placed as a catch-up question at the very
- 5:43end of a three day session. These omissions shape this
- 5:47narrative of the whole inquiry, and when predictions about
- 5:53future environmental performance are presented with great
- 5:56confidence, it's worth remembering that they are still
- 6:00forecasts and assumptions, not established facts. The future
- 6:05has not happened yet, and if people are repeatedly referred
- 6:10to as receptors, impacts are described as manageable, and
- 6:15risks are characterised as acceptable. Listeners can be
- 6:19left with impressions that everything is under control,
- 6:22even though other folk might reach a very different
- 6:25conclusion when looking at exactly the same evidence. I'll
- 6:32be the first to say I'm not used to listening to barristers. An
- 6:36early on inquiry, I used to come away thinking I've heard the
- 6:38whole story, when in reality I was coming away with a carefully
- 6:43constructed interpretation of the facts as laid down by the
- 6:47particular barrister on the day. Take today, for instance, with
- 6:51the open question for the applicant that the third parties
- 6:56have pointed out that the cultural heritage assessment
- 6:59methodology is fundamentally flawed and is not consistent
- 7:03with professional principles, is outdated to narrow in focus, and
- 7:08has the applicant anything to add to that, and mr. Long, yet
- 7:15another barrister went on for a long time, really just reading
- 7:20over what methodology they had used in their submission, which
- 7:24everyone in the room was already aware of. Commissioner Donhee
- 7:28had to ask him three times, was there anything else he wanted to
- 7:32add to this. Finally, right at the end, he remarked that the
- 7:36work on the extraction site and exploration site can't have an
- 7:40impact, as it was all subsurface. This made Donohue
- 7:45sit up and pay attention, questioning him again.
- 7:50Everything in this area is subsurface. Then Beatty sees his
- 7:55chance to focus on the facts, which could help his case, and
- 7:58speaking like he was an expert mine manager, I believe, said
- 8:03that there is no surface drilling in the exploration area
- 8:06and underground, and it would not, and it will not come within
- 8:10100 metres of the surface. At this point, I would like to
- 8:15remind the listeners that we're talking about cultural heritage,
- 8:18not the intricacies of mining. Gordon, another barrister gets
- 8:23in on the action, muttering something about an update in
- 8:26some document somewhere, and that the drilling will not come
- 8:28above 100 metres. Commissioner Donnie was quick enough to ask,
- 8:33was it on the document, or did you infer it, reminding him to
- 8:37focus on the question, and it was I've gone on a bit long with
- 8:41this, so I'm going to wrap it up. I only meant to give it a
- 8:44couple lines as an opener for the day, just as a by-the-by
- 8:49most of the day was spent talking about cultural heritage,
- 8:52but as Emma McAleer remarked that you would never have
- 8:56guessed that heritage was anything other than built
- 8:59heritage with little or no attention given to intangible
- 9:03heritage. Again, here we can see how the narrative is being
- 9:07altered. I suppose one point worth noting is that for the
- 9:13very first time a government department, historical
- 9:17environmental division HED, actively backed the third party
- 9:21concerns along with Mid Ulster District Council and Fermanagh
- 9:26and Omar District Council. That's it for today. Thanks a
- 9:31million for listening, and we'll see you all again soon. And
- 9:37don't forget, if you're listening regularly, follow the
- 9:41podcast on Spotify, or leave a review on Apple Podcasts, and it
- 9:46really helps more people find the show and keep these
- 9:49conversations moving further out into the world.