Latest / The Good The Bad & The Holy / Ep 1: A Few Good Men
Transcript
- 0:03[SPEAKER_01]: Welcome to the first episode of The Good, The Bad and The Holy, where we take on big questions in the movies we love through the lens of God, the Bible, and Judaism.
- 0:15[SPEAKER_01]: We break down our favorite scenes, the best lines, and the life lessons they teach us.
- 0:20[SPEAKER_01]: My name is Jeremy Ellis, I am a Hollywood writer, producer, and I am joined by my two very good friends and fellow movie lovers, Rabbi Jonathan Morgenstern, and Attorney David Rifkin.
- 0:30[SPEAKER_01]: Our first episode is the military courtroom drama classic, a few good men.
- 0:35[SPEAKER_01]: You want the truth?
- 0:36[SPEAKER_01]: You can't handle the truth.
- 0:38[SPEAKER_01]: But we're going to handle it here, on the good, the bad, and the holy.
- 0:42[SPEAKER_01]: Let's get into it.
- 0:52[SPEAKER_02]: be honest about when we came up with this concept.
- 0:55[SPEAKER_02]: We were at the bar at Kiddish.
- 0:58[SPEAKER_02]: It's like, I don't know if I'm going to get any...
- 1:01[SPEAKER_02]: It was great.
- 1:03[SPEAKER_02]: It was great.
- 1:04[SPEAKER_02]: We're just having a liem, as I say, a shot, you know, of Scotch the Kilo, whatever, and we're like,
- 1:11[SPEAKER_02]: This would be a great idea for a podcast or like, yeah.
- 1:14[SPEAKER_00]: You know, we should have a podcast.
- 1:16[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, Drake.
- 1:17[SPEAKER_01]: That's it.
- 1:18[SPEAKER_01]: I always get my best ideas after doing shots.
- 1:20[SPEAKER_01]: Salute.
- 1:21[SPEAKER_01]: Nice.
- 1:21[SPEAKER_01]: The Hacles of storytelling are very universal, even.
- 1:23[SPEAKER_01]: And that's why they, you know, show up in all of these movies that we love so much.
- 1:27[SPEAKER_01]: But, you know, so much of what we study in Torah is story with history and mixed with metaphor, mixed with, right?
- 1:35[SPEAKER_01]: law and and I think that you know one of the things we're going to seek to do in this besides sort of talk about our favorite good and bad movies over time is to look at the movies that really sort of touch on some of those things which by way of introduction brings us to tonight's discussion our first one.
- 1:51[SPEAKER_01]: 1992's, a few good men, directed by, say, the late Great Rob Reiner, as member of you, a blessing, written by Aaron Schorkin, which was based on his 1989 Broadway play, which actually only didn't want anyone to award.
- 2:05[SPEAKER_01]: I think one of the actors was nominated for Tony, but it was a huge hit, sort of cemented Schorkin's name on Broadway, and then part of the deal for Broadway was actually that was sold to the producer, David Brown, who did jaws, who agreed to basically produce the play in order to get the movie right.
- 2:21[SPEAKER_00]: And he's a Scarthil guy.
- 2:22[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, really, yeah, cool.
- 2:25[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, he's from around here.
- 2:26[SPEAKER_01]: And in fact, he was an actor on Broadway.
- 2:28[SPEAKER_01]: And the way that he actually wrote the play was he was standing bar.
- 2:31[SPEAKER_01]: So he was that guy who would like your drink and intermission and the Broadway show.
- 2:34[SPEAKER_01]: He was like, many actors, right?
- 2:35[SPEAKER_01]: Playing his best part as a waiter, as a writer.
- 2:38[SPEAKER_01]: And he would write, like, on Cox on Appkins.
- 2:40[SPEAKER_01]: And the way that he got the story, which we can get into in a second, was that his sister was studying to be a lawyer or, you know,
- 2:50[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that in fact in fact the Joined Galilee character was based on her well that Joined Galilee played by the great to me more And so before so yeah, so the story which we'll get into was inspired at least by some of the details were real case
- 3:07[SPEAKER_01]: The movie also stars of course Tom Cruise in the lead role as the tenant Daniel Kaffey the lawyer from the jackaw is Assigned the defense of the two Marines who are accused of murdering one of their fellow Marines It stars Jack Nicholson as Colonel Nathan Jessup and in his Academy award winning role Colonel not sorry right Colonel Colonel Colonel and Daniel Kaffey Colonel Nathan Jessup right stars on the rise who stars on the rise
- 3:35[SPEAKER_01]: uh... to me more as co-castle uh... joan galloway lieutenant commander joan galloway uh... the great kevin hollick as uh... lieutenant yberg lieutenant who you lieutenant wineberg no official
- 3:49[SPEAKER_01]: In your And actually the movie is notable for a few other people.
- 3:53[SPEAKER_01]: JT Walsh also may as memory be a blessing Please Colonel Markinson when my all-time favorite actress JT Walsh back in the day Kevin Bacon as the Prosecuting Attorney representing the United States government.
- 4:06[SPEAKER_00]: He was of course in every movie in the era Yeah, that was the law It's degrees of Kevin Bacon.
- 4:10[SPEAKER_02]: That's right right and who could forget keep for southern
- 4:14[SPEAKER_01]: right.
- 4:14[SPEAKER_01]: They were like, so keep from the lost boys.
- 4:16[SPEAKER_01]: So keep her saw the woman.
- 4:17[SPEAKER_01]: This was like part of his big play to like drop his heart-throbbing image.
- 4:22[SPEAKER_01]: He's, you know, he had done flat liners a year before that.
- 4:24[SPEAKER_01]: But he's business.
- 4:25[SPEAKER_02]: Dude, flat liners is such there's so many religious overtones.
- 4:30[SPEAKER_02]: It's so much all about Olamabad and next world and and and judgment and oh man.
- 4:45[SPEAKER_01]: And then there's some other great out, you know, no, while he's in this movie, he plays one of...
- 4:48[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 4:49[SPEAKER_01]: Reads task to find.
- 4:50[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, Cuba Gooding Jr.
- 4:52[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 4:52[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 4:53[SPEAKER_01]: Also.
- 4:53[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 4:54[SPEAKER_01]: And a little fun Hollywood trivia, I would star in another Tom Cruise movie, five years later, in which Cuba Gooding Jr. Oh, and a cat.
- 5:01[SPEAKER_01]: Of course.
- 5:02[SPEAKER_02]: Show me the money.
- 5:03[SPEAKER_01]: I mean the money.
- 5:03[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 5:04[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 5:05[SPEAKER_01]: He, uh, if you, uh, Jeremy McWatt.
- 5:07[SPEAKER_01]: Jeremy McWatt.
- 5:07[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 5:08[SPEAKER_01]: It's showin' the money.
- 5:09[SPEAKER_01]: And since then, things haven't been going so great for Cuba, but, uh,
- 5:12[SPEAKER_01]: Well, he was in that car.
- 5:14[SPEAKER_02]: He was in.
- 5:14[SPEAKER_02]: It was a really good movie that the, um, he was the diver, the Navy diver.
- 5:18[SPEAKER_00]: That was, that was great.
- 5:19[SPEAKER_00]: He was also fantastic in his good as it gets.
- 5:21[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, no, he's great.
- 5:22[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, he's oh, yes.
- 5:23[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, with Jack Nicholson.
- 5:25[SPEAKER_00]: With Jack Nicholson, yeah.
- 5:26[SPEAKER_01]: It'll be my other and he's with Jack Nicholson and so it's again, and they all connect back to Kevin Bacon.
- 5:30[SPEAKER_01]: All right, now we can go home.
- 5:31[SPEAKER_01]: Now we can go.
- 5:32[SPEAKER_01]: We're done.
- 5:32[SPEAKER_00]: We're done.
- 5:33[SPEAKER_01]: We're Yote as they say.
- 5:34[SPEAKER_01]: We are done.
- 5:35[SPEAKER_01]: So Joe put his Jews, we have to mention the box office in the money.
- 5:38[SPEAKER_01]: Um, it basically made $243 million on a budget of $40 million in 1992, which is a lot of money.
- 5:45[SPEAKER_01]: Winner winner, chicken dinner.
- 5:46[SPEAKER_01]: win a chicken dinner.
- 5:47[SPEAKER_01]: The film is nominated for four Academy Awards including best picture, which is a great return on investment.
- 5:54[SPEAKER_01]: The general rule of thumb is if you can get back three times your budget, your in-profit, and this movie I'm sure has gone.
- 6:00[SPEAKER_01]: What's the math on that?
- 6:01[SPEAKER_00]: Well, don't you just need to clear your budget?
- 6:03[SPEAKER_01]: No.
- 6:04[SPEAKER_01]: No.
- 6:04[SPEAKER_01]: And first of all, you split everything with the exhibit artist a quick little lesson here.
- 6:08[SPEAKER_01]: 50% goes to the exhibitor up until a certain point, and then after a certain
- 6:16[SPEAKER_00]: is in the movie see wait I thought I thought we did just make nothing they just make everything on concession is that false well that's where they make all their money yeah we theater the business now direct you get you into the theater with the movies right and then they saw you pop right so that but they also got to happen after the box office because they're also putting up the costs to the taste
- 6:33[SPEAKER_01]: Without them, there's no way to showcase the movie.
- 6:36[SPEAKER_01]: I will say, for all of the technological changes that have happened in Hollywood and a lot of the democratization and one of the things that the movie companies also have is the distribution to get a movie into the movie.
- 6:48[SPEAKER_01]: Then we'll get into it is the movie opens up in Guantanamo Base in Cuba, which was also interesting to see Cuba in 1997.
- 6:55[SPEAKER_01]: That was
- 6:57[SPEAKER_01]: Blooming, it's so large, especially right now, Cuba feels like it's about to fall, so there's kind of a historical time capsule to all of this, but this is Cuba, and the movie opens up, and we're in a marine barracks at Windward Company, and there's a marine sleeping in bed, and all of a sudden these two other guys burst into the room, Marines, they've got the duct tape out, they're sticking ragged in his mouth, and off of his look of the absolute terror, the marine being taped to the bed, and
- 7:24[SPEAKER_01]: you know, we fed to black and we opened up on lieutenant, well, we actually opened up on the marine, what is that called?
- 7:30[SPEAKER_01]: What are the guys called?
- 7:31[SPEAKER_01]: Do you do all the right full?
- 7:32[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, that's cool.
- 7:33[SPEAKER_00]: That was really cool.
- 7:34[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that was that was a great one.
- 7:35[SPEAKER_00]: We're doing the right, yeah, the right full read.
- 7:37[SPEAKER_00]: It was, it was, it was a drill team, right?
- 7:39[SPEAKER_02]: It was, yeah, before that, by the way.
- 7:40[SPEAKER_02]: What movie did that that take you to when you started with with you know before anything What movie did take you that the Marines come in and they start beating him and they they Talk well, I mean full metal jacket of course I was watching it last time like oh my god, this is full metal jacket They is full metal jacket where there was before there was coming right there anything
- 8:00[SPEAKER_01]: But you were going to catch a beat down, but yeah, same thing.
- 8:02[SPEAKER_01]: So anyways, they come in and they appear to murder this guy as we come to find out to me more, is walking across the quads.
- 8:10[SPEAKER_01]: She's walking into the jaguar and she's going into a meeting and she's talking about this case, the tap, and that basically we learn this private Santiago, the Marine who has tied down to the bed, has been murdered or dead and the issue is whether or not he's been murdered, and two Marines have been arrested and charged with the crime.
- 8:26[SPEAKER_01]: And so now the question is, what to do about it?
- 8:29[SPEAKER_01]: And she goes in and she explained to the case.
- 8:32[SPEAKER_01]: It's very funny.
- 8:33[SPEAKER_01]: Classic sort of Aaron Sworkin scene.
- 8:35[SPEAKER_01]: Her contention is that this is not just two Marines getting out of hand.
- 8:39[SPEAKER_01]: That basically, this is an issue.
- 8:41[SPEAKER_01]: A code read.
- 8:42[SPEAKER_01]: And as the rabbi was just saying, Well, I'm going to go code read.
- 8:45[SPEAKER_01]: Much like the scene in full metal jacket, where private pile gets a beat down with some soap and a towel.
- 8:50[SPEAKER_01]: A code read is a disciplinary action that is taken by
- 8:54[SPEAKER_01]: the men of the company themselves in the room company in order to discipline and unruly soldier.
- 9:00[SPEAKER_01]: There's an example that's given in the middle of the movie by Noah Lyle that if there was a soldier who refused to bathe, they might give you a barracks bath or something like that, which is where they tie you down and get rubbed down with steel wool and brushes and very painful.
- 9:14[SPEAKER_01]: But you don't ever screw up again, you don't make the mistake again.
- 9:19[SPEAKER_01]: This is, to me, more, join Gala's contention that this is what's happened, which of course is now a big problem because code reds are effectively illegal and they've been disallowed.
- 9:31[SPEAKER_01]: And so things is that the Gitmo,
- 9:34[SPEAKER_01]: Wantanamo Bay is run by Nathan Jessup, which is the character played by Jack Nicholson, highs, and this is the kind of thing that basically threatens to become a major political sort of media mess, and so what to do about it, to me more is not assigned the case, and instead the case is assigned to Tom Cruise.
- 9:54[SPEAKER_01]: goes up as Lieutenant Daniel Kaffey.
- 9:56[SPEAKER_01]: We beat him in classic Tom Cruise Aaron's work in fashion.
- 9:59[SPEAKER_01]: He's on the baseball diamond.
- 10:01[SPEAKER_01]: He's playing softball, and he is quintessential Tom Cruise.
- 10:05[SPEAKER_01]: And it's funny to look back now because he doesn't really play these roles anymore.
- 10:08[SPEAKER_01]: Now he's like Ethan Hunt, Tom Cruise.
- 10:09[SPEAKER_01]: But here he is.
- 10:11[SPEAKER_01]: It's like charming, good-looking, super smart, cocky.
- 10:15[SPEAKER_01]: He right, can carry on a conversation while he's like, you know, running baseball drills with his team.
- 10:23[SPEAKER_01]: To me, more as a opinion, the absolute wrong person for this case, because he doesn't seem to be taking it seriously.
- 10:28[SPEAKER_01]: But the setup is basically that these Marines who are charged, she believes it's a code read, and the question is whether or not they were ordered to do this.
- 10:36[SPEAKER_01]: Old's, the investigation takes place in to this, and pretty clear that, in fact, it was a code read, and that, and it sets up this great moral,
- 10:46[SPEAKER_01]: sort of quantity, this great sort of question of the gality and justice, which is was private time to go murder by Lieutenant Dawson and Downey, or were they following orders and in fallen orders, were they absolved to that, were they considered innocent, are they considered innocent?
- 11:03[SPEAKER_01]: Leave a leave a leave, we can get into all of this.
- 11:04[SPEAKER_01]: And if in fact, they were following orders, we gave the orders, which, and who's culpable for that, which sets up, of course, the great courtroom trauma.
- 11:12[SPEAKER_01]: But so yeah, that is the setup of the movie.
- 11:14[SPEAKER_01]: And in nutshell,
- 11:15[SPEAKER_01]: Rabbi or your impressions of this movie when you saw it.
- 11:17[SPEAKER_01]: Were you rabbi yet when you saw this movie in 90s?
- 11:19[SPEAKER_01]: No, yeah.
- 11:21[UNKNOWN]: No.
- 11:22[SPEAKER_02]: Um, my impressions.
- 11:24[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, you know, just as you were speaking, there are certain things that are like, that just like really jump at it.
- 11:30[SPEAKER_02]: First of all, in Judaism, we have this concept, Tarshabal Pen.
- 11:36[SPEAKER_02]: Specifically, as it relates, it's like one of the whole marks of Orthodox.
- 11:40[SPEAKER_02]: You know, we believe that there's like my monodies talks about this.
- 11:44[SPEAKER_02]: There are two tores.
- 11:44[SPEAKER_02]: There were literally two tores that were given at Sinai.
- 11:49[SPEAKER_02]: One is scripture as we know it, right?
- 11:51[SPEAKER_02]: They're written, they're written code.
- 11:53[SPEAKER_02]: And the other is the oral tradition.
- 11:55[SPEAKER_02]: And the oral tradition has been passed down.
- 11:58[SPEAKER_02]: Generation generation.
- 11:59[SPEAKER_02]: Ultimately, it was initially oral and then it was written down in the Talmud and the Mishna.
- 12:04[SPEAKER_02]: But even then, they're still
- 12:05[SPEAKER_02]: unwritten rules ideas, whatever, and it's a, you know, this code read thing, there's a great scene with no, it would know a while when Kevin, they can bring, we just have to use their name.
- 12:18[SPEAKER_02]: Kevin, they can know a while, and Kevin, they can bring some of the, you know, the rule book for, you know, company, one word, blah, blah, blah, and Guantana, we'll make you, blah,
- 12:27[SPEAKER_02]: Here, can you find me the section that talks about code read?
- 12:31[SPEAKER_01]: He's like, it's not here, it's not what he means, it's not here, it doesn't talk.
- 12:36[SPEAKER_02]: What do you mean, I thought it's part of your, you know, part of your laws, part of, you know, the things your protocol, your code, and they're like, yeah, no, it doesn't work.
- 12:45[SPEAKER_02]: I torch about that.
- 12:46[SPEAKER_02]: It's literally, they're literally things to show up and then Kathy, right Tom Cruise brings the book back and goes, you should wear the mess hall as like meaning there are things that are just intrinsic to who we are, to what we believe.
- 13:01[SPEAKER_02]: And the beauty actually of this, the whole Marine concept and there's a whole another kind of perspective that's laid out in the movie is
- 13:10[SPEAKER_02]: is is living by a code is having certain ideals and ideas and values that you that you like value and that you live and and even die by.
- 13:22[SPEAKER_02]: And there's something very beautiful about that.
- 13:24[SPEAKER_02]: And Kathy and Lieutenant Weinberg really have trouble with that.
- 13:29[SPEAKER_02]: They represent kind of like society.
- 13:31[SPEAKER_02]: I'm like, come on, this is a little mumbo jumbo.
- 13:34[SPEAKER_02]: This is silly.
- 13:35[SPEAKER_02]: We don't believe that.
- 13:36[SPEAKER_02]: Like it's almost like Starward, like Jen, you know, the Jedi's versus the, you know, they're not rooted in anything.
- 13:42[SPEAKER_01]: Correct.
- 13:43[SPEAKER_01]: Correct.
- 13:43[SPEAKER_01]: Tim Holley's correct.
- 13:44[SPEAKER_01]: No, they said, I give orders all day long.
- 13:48[SPEAKER_01]: Nobody follows anything I say.
- 13:50[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 13:51[SPEAKER_01]: And he says, well, they're in a different world.
- 13:52[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 13:53[SPEAKER_01]: Different code of rules.
- 13:55[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 13:56[SPEAKER_02]: We follow orders or people die.
- 13:58[SPEAKER_02]: But I was like, oh, that's so good.
- 14:00[SPEAKER_02]: That's cute.
- 14:00[SPEAKER_02]: It's something.
- 14:01[SPEAKER_02]: No, it's actually beautiful.
- 14:02[SPEAKER_02]: It's beautiful that that exists, not to discipline people, in an extra judicial manner.
- 14:12[SPEAKER_02]: way, way too far, but there's something just so beautiful about that, you know, and that's the world that we're living in, and I'd say, you know, the world we live in right now is like, and that was the 90s, the 90s, it was, I guess it was, it was just starting to unravel, like that post-modern post-denomination, all post-religious kind of work, like, oh, we're just going to do our thing, and I mean, look where we are now.
- 14:34[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, it's like, you know, a million times worse, but it was rather, very prescient, you know,
- 14:42[SPEAKER_02]: is something in also in Jewish law.
- 14:45[SPEAKER_02]: It's called Makas Marduce, which is in Jewish law.
- 14:49[SPEAKER_02]: There's this concept of, yes, there's really, we believe it's reward and punishment.
- 14:52[SPEAKER_02]: Now we don't have a Jewish court to administer these things anymore and whatever, but essentially it's like, if there's someone, like my monodies as a famous like description of, someone who is withholding a get from a woman, right?
- 15:06[SPEAKER_02]: You know, two people get married and then you know,
- 15:11[SPEAKER_02]: the marriage.
- 15:12[SPEAKER_00]: Get as a Jewish divorce for those for the uninitiated.
- 15:15[SPEAKER_02]: Correct, right?
- 15:16[SPEAKER_02]: So, you know, a man has to give his wife a get, and just like, you know, a man gives his wife a ring in general, right, and then, you know, that's what this ring ID wed, right?
- 15:26[SPEAKER_02]: Same thing.
- 15:26[SPEAKER_02]: He gives his wife this Jewish writ of divorce, and so let's say someone's, oh, I'm not doing it.
- 15:31[SPEAKER_02]: I'm holding it overhead.
- 15:32[SPEAKER_02]: It's a terrible, terrible sin.
- 15:34[SPEAKER_02]: It's one of the worst thing to this day.
- 15:36[SPEAKER_02]: It's one of the worst things that anyone can do, and we have various things that
- 15:40[SPEAKER_02]: You know, kind of, in the world of halachad that, you know, we've, we've employed, so that never happens again.
- 15:45[SPEAKER_02]: But the rhombum says very clearly, he says, Coltono, so Adchi Omirotsani, we beat the living life until he says, OK, I'll do it!
- 15:55[SPEAKER_02]: It's like, we can't live like this.
- 15:56[SPEAKER_02]: This is at hand.
- 15:57[SPEAKER_02]: Like we can't get trustful.
- 15:59[SPEAKER_00]: I'm just kind of curious.
- 16:00[SPEAKER_00]: I can, can someone who administers this beat down for the get, can that person be held liable in a Jewish court?
- 16:11[SPEAKER_02]: I think technically not, nowadays yes, because it's against the law, and Jewish court is a Jewish law unless it relates to something ritual is subservient to.
- 16:24[SPEAKER_00]: Right, so it would violate New York State law, for example, and therefore, you know, that would violate Jewish law because you can't violate New York State.
- 16:32[SPEAKER_00]: Correct.
- 16:33[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 16:33[SPEAKER_00]: So that's understandable, but it would be on that basis, not in a whole life.
- 16:36[SPEAKER_01]: Correct.
- 16:36[SPEAKER_01]: One of the things that the movie does is,
- 16:40[SPEAKER_01]: When you remember it, it's easy to think right.
- 16:41[SPEAKER_01]: He was, you know, Jess was wrong, right?
- 16:44[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, right, this is like, right, invention was, he was wrong.
- 16:47[SPEAKER_01]: He ordered the code right on Santiago, go to despite all the evidence that he was not sort of failing as a Marine because of anything I was on and caffeine all of the rest sort of uncovered the truth.
- 16:56[SPEAKER_01]: But, you know, when you watch it again, there's a lot of debate, like Kevin Pollock really feels like these were just two Marines who beat up on a weaker kid, right, and more than that.
- 17:05[SPEAKER_02]: What does he say?
- 17:05[SPEAKER_02]: He compares that he goes very night goes very chewy.
- 17:08[SPEAKER_02]: We could say that because we're Jews and he goes very he goes not to it like the Nazis with Nurburg right right we have we were following orders right and then And he says that's it and work for the Nazis, which is actually one of the things that's both at
- 17:20[SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, Kathy says, well, they're not, they're not following, right?
- 17:23[SPEAKER_01]: They were Nazis, right?
- 17:24[SPEAKER_01]: It's he, he drives the right, that's part of his argument.
- 17:27[SPEAKER_01]: But the question of whether or not follow an orders, assuming that they're not coming from the Nazis in this case, in particular, if you're coming from the Reins and it's a question of fence or if it's a question of safety, they have their own, you know, right?
- 17:37[SPEAKER_01]: What does Kendrick say?
- 17:38[SPEAKER_01]: God, you know, God, chlorocone, no, no.
- 17:41[SPEAKER_01]: You and it, you and it, you and it, you and it, chlorocone, chlorocone, chlorocone,
- 17:44[SPEAKER_01]: It's essentially we got to turn on the list, but it's still higher than almost most.
- 17:48[SPEAKER_01]: And so the tomotic law that I looked up was, if somebody comes and says to you, you have to commit a crime.
- 17:58[SPEAKER_01]: Even if they have authority invested in them, that the higher authority that you're supposed to listen to is the divine one, which in this case would say.
- 18:05[SPEAKER_01]: either beat down perhaps or murder obviously or you know killing is definitely a crime in this context and so Not to get to the movie, but that does seem to be like with the lesson that Dawson and Downey learn, right, that's correct.
- 18:15[SPEAKER_01]: Big If you would say what you thought that the justice principle I suppose that that it was unjust what they did if it wasn't necessarily illegal
- 18:24[SPEAKER_02]: Judaism doesn't believe in blind, you know, following.
- 18:27[SPEAKER_02]: There's a reason why we, you know, we're like the most, you know, Talmudic, and we debate everything, and we question everything.
- 18:35[SPEAKER_02]: And we answer question with the question, the point is it's, it's who we are, right?
- 18:40[SPEAKER_02]: Even even Abraham Abraham, right?
- 18:42[SPEAKER_02]: God says, kill the Sodomites.
- 18:45[SPEAKER_02]: Abraham's like, yeah, no, what do you mean?
- 18:49[SPEAKER_02]: And Abraham says, God, that would be wicked.
- 18:53[SPEAKER_02]: I can't, you can't do that.
- 18:54[SPEAKER_02]: There are righteous people there, we can't do that.
- 18:57[SPEAKER_02]: He goes and he questions God, right?
- 19:00[SPEAKER_02]: And ultimately, you know, kind of he loses the battle but he pushes back, Moses same thing, right?
- 19:05[SPEAKER_01]: I wanted to destroy this.
- 19:07[SPEAKER_01]: It's because in my talk, he says, he changes God's instructions,
- 19:13[SPEAKER_01]: you know take vengeance on the media that's for the children of Israel.
- 19:16[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, both when most of says that he says inflict shams vengeance in other words he and I read one of the commentaries because I thought it was interesting.
- 19:24[SPEAKER_01]: Uh-huh, dear was that you're teaching me some I didn't hear that he's appealing to
- 19:29[SPEAKER_00]: that he's what he's he's appealing to them on on a divine level i mean really that's really what it is right that it in other words it's not something they could deny because they could deny it being from a man or anything up but i'm gonna push back on that little bit rabbi because you know there's if for example uh... the situation was that just upset like through candoric or other what said i want you to right
- 19:53[SPEAKER_00]: that's that's a black and white issue right and you can just like in your example was when when when God told Abraham to smite the Sodom that's a that's a black and whiteish and here at worst what he told him was to administer a code read right there was no
- 20:13[SPEAKER_00]: he didn't say murder the guy.
- 20:15[SPEAKER_00]: He said whatever it was, perform this, perform this, this part of the training that is sort of formal and formal.
- 20:25[SPEAKER_00]: There was, right, but there was no, there was no intent to murder the guy now.
- 20:30[SPEAKER_00]: You know, whether ultimately you might be culpable when something goes bad.
- 20:33[SPEAKER_00]: That's a, that's a, that's a different issue, but it's not, it's not one of these.
- 20:37[SPEAKER_00]: snap decisions where a soldier, which is, you know, in your example with Jews were always questioning everything were always, you know, when a soldier questions an order, people die so they're taught not to question those orders when they're given directly and especially when it's, when it's not something that is
- 20:57[SPEAKER_00]: One of my problems with kind of like the theme of the movie was, you know, they, I think in Sorkin's writing, it makes it the idea of giving a code read was almost conflated with the idea of he was told to murder them.
- 21:16[SPEAKER_00]: And so it was a disciplinary action that went bad, and it went bad, and it's not clear why it went bad.
- 21:24[SPEAKER_00]: I'll get into that as far as illegal issues concerned.
- 21:26[SPEAKER_00]: But I, you know, it wasn't the idea that it was a code read in the first place was
- 21:36[SPEAKER_00]: To me, didn't cross the law of having to question morally, whether or not it was right and wrong.
- 21:44[SPEAKER_00]: Now, you can say, well, yes, there was this directive.
- 21:48[SPEAKER_00]: It's unlawful.
- 21:49[SPEAKER_00]: OK, but that goes into kind of a legality.
- 21:52[SPEAKER_00]: Doesn't go into a morality.
- 21:53[SPEAKER_00]: From a morality standpoint, you had a very all-shocks.
- 22:00[SPEAKER_00]: What's his name from the kid from?
- 22:05[SPEAKER_02]: No, no, I don't know.
- 22:06[SPEAKER_00]: No, I don't know.
- 22:07[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, very, you know, very awesucks kind of guy.
- 22:09[SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, yeah.
- 22:10[SPEAKER_00]: I would have administered a code red.
- 22:12[SPEAKER_00]: We do code reds all the time.
- 22:13[SPEAKER_00]: What's the big deal?
- 22:14[SPEAKER_00]: You know, I had a code red.
- 22:15[SPEAKER_00]: I had a code red, but you know, I never dropped my gun again.
- 22:20[SPEAKER_00]: I had the code red.
- 22:22[SPEAKER_00]: So it seems like then the idea of the code red itself was kind of like ordinary course, right?
- 22:30[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, and I'm just just push back.
- 22:33[SPEAKER_02]: I agree with you.
- 22:34[SPEAKER_02]: I agree with you, and if that's like that's like part of it And it's like it's hazing.
- 22:37[SPEAKER_02]: Let's be honest.
- 22:38[SPEAKER_02]: It's hazing, right?
- 22:39[SPEAKER_02]: And what but hazing with a purpose was a hazing for the sake of hazing But by the way, even though it was guy, I went to why you but I said I didn't.
- 22:46[SPEAKER_02]: I wasn't in a prep But like gone even the guys were hazing.
- 22:49[SPEAKER_02]: They're saying oh, we're driving guys.
- 22:50[SPEAKER_00]: You need and I was one of them haze for the sake of hazing That's different than the Marines Anyways
- 23:00[SPEAKER_02]: There's a line that gets crossed between hazing and bullying.
- 23:05[SPEAKER_02]: Right, hazing can become bullying, right?
- 23:09[SPEAKER_02]: And really just kick in someone there down, so to speak.
- 23:13[SPEAKER_02]: I think that's the idea.
- 23:14[SPEAKER_02]: We found it through the movie that was at Dawson, right?
- 23:19[SPEAKER_02]: How Dawson, he would protect Santiago, because he knew he knew he was off.
- 23:25[SPEAKER_02]: Like he knew this guy is fainting, he can't make any of the runs, he blacks out, he has no friends.
- 23:33[SPEAKER_02]: What did he do that was when he was protecting all, you know, everyone said stay away from him.
- 23:37[SPEAKER_01]: While he testifies, he says, you know, do you think about giving Santiago a code right or something like that?
- 23:42[SPEAKER_01]: When?
- 23:42[SPEAKER_01]: It was what did he do?
- 23:43[SPEAKER_01]: I don't remember what he did.
- 23:44[SPEAKER_01]: She went and he says, because he's Dawson would have kicked our butt, you know, Dawson was like, right, don't touch him.
- 23:49[SPEAKER_01]: And so you think, okay, well that doesn't seem like a guy who,
- 23:53[SPEAKER_02]: That's kind of the lesson, so like there is, the line is like, can the guy take it, can you handle it?
- 24:02[SPEAKER_02]: There's this idea in Judaism as much Jewish stuff here.
- 24:08[SPEAKER_02]: But there's an idea of rebuke.
- 24:11[SPEAKER_02]: There's a verse that says,
- 24:16[SPEAKER_02]: And then it says Bilotisa al-Lotisa al-Avkhayt, don't bear a sin on his behalf.
- 24:22[SPEAKER_02]: So the basic understanding of that is like, oh, you should review and don't bear a sin, because we're all Jews are connected to each other, right?
- 24:29[SPEAKER_02]: We're like New York telephone, remember that?
- 24:31[SPEAKER_02]: Okay, and we're responsible for each other, and if this guy is sinning, then that sin sort of goes on.
- 24:37[SPEAKER_02]: You also, you have a responsibility to say something to him.
- 24:40[SPEAKER_02]: But there's another idea, and the other rendering of that is, alternative rendering is, don't bear a sin in his behalf.
- 24:47[SPEAKER_02]: In what sense, why would you bear a sin?
- 24:49[SPEAKER_02]: If you rebuke someone who's not willing to, who can't take that rebuke, either just his constitution or you know he won't receive it well or you know he'll sort of laugh it off and then it'll make it like a worse sin kind of thing.
- 25:04[SPEAKER_02]: you're you're you're going to be sending oh my god the person didn't know and now you're telling him they have so the tour the gama says that sometimes it's better not to say and it's better to not to say anything if you know won't be heard right then to say something uh... that won't be heard right so it's like point is like there's some there's some instances where
- 25:26[SPEAKER_02]: you shouldn't review the guys not worthy of that he can handle that review like you can handle the truth Santiago couldn't handle the he to the poor kid just wanted to leave the base he was clear he was sick he'd probably had a hard condition in the end that turns out like this is the more and he should have taken he should have he yet markets and help from that this is point and right and and Dawson the point is like I think the concept of the end was
- 25:50[SPEAKER_02]: Like, you know, with Moses or the Moshep, right?
- 25:52[SPEAKER_02]: The Jewish people sin, right?
- 25:53[SPEAKER_02]: The golden calf, right?
- 25:55[SPEAKER_02]: This was 40 days after we received the divine revelation at Sinai, the Jewish people sin, and then God's 40 days later, and God says, don't do idols.
- 26:06[SPEAKER_02]: They're bowing down to an idol.
- 26:08[SPEAKER_02]: And God says to Moses, you know what?
- 26:11[SPEAKER_02]: Let's destroy them.
- 26:12[SPEAKER_02]: I'm going to start again from you.
- 26:13[SPEAKER_02]: You know, Moses says to God, not only does he say not on my watch.
- 26:17[SPEAKER_02]: Just as we're okay.
- 26:18[SPEAKER_02]: What?
- 26:19[SPEAKER_02]: He says, if you do it, wipe me from a book, you know why God?
- 26:22[SPEAKER_02]: Instead of the beginning of the book of Deuteronomy, I'm saved from it, because it's your fault.
- 26:28[SPEAKER_02]: It's your fault.
- 26:29[SPEAKER_02]: You gave them all this gold.
- 26:30[SPEAKER_02]: They're this slave nation.
- 26:31[SPEAKER_02]: They're coming from nowhere.
- 26:32[SPEAKER_02]: They had nothing all of a sudden.
- 26:34[SPEAKER_02]: They have all the spoils of Egypt and
- 26:37[SPEAKER_02]: What would they have done, as the Talmud says, Mayasa, Otoa, Bencialo, Yachta, how could he not have sinned?
- 26:44[SPEAKER_02]: Of course he would sinned.
- 26:46[SPEAKER_02]: You gave them all the gold, and you left them up.
- 26:48[SPEAKER_02]: I was up there that when the cats away, the mice will play.
- 26:50[SPEAKER_02]: And then he said, if you destroy them, destroy me.
- 26:53[SPEAKER_02]: It goes through me.
- 26:54[SPEAKER_02]: And imagine, had Dawson said to, whatever, Kendrick, Kendrick, right, Kendrick.
- 26:59[SPEAKER_02]: The keeper said to him,
- 27:01[SPEAKER_02]: Code Red goes for me beat me up.
- 27:04[SPEAKER_01]: He's a model.
- 27:05[SPEAKER_01]: He's a model soldier.
- 27:06[SPEAKER_01]: I think he should have, because I, you guys were touching a thing that I think is interesting, but you, so you think Rabbi that Dawson, and this is simply what he, uh, uh, comes to learn at the end of the film, that he should have said to Kendrick.
- 27:16[SPEAKER_01]: No.
- 27:17[SPEAKER_01]: You want to take it out and hit.
- 27:18[SPEAKER_01]: Take it out on me.
- 27:19[SPEAKER_00]: So I love this idea.
- 27:21[SPEAKER_00]: I actually never thought of this.
- 27:23[SPEAKER_00]: And I just love it.
- 27:25[SPEAKER_00]: It wasn't the code red necessarily.
- 27:29[SPEAKER_00]: It was the code red on this particular guy.
- 27:33[SPEAKER_00]: Correct.
- 27:33[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 27:34[SPEAKER_00]: That was the issue.
- 27:34[SPEAKER_00]: That was them.
- 27:35[SPEAKER_00]: That was the rub.
- 27:36[SPEAKER_00]: And that was what?
- 27:38[SPEAKER_00]: Dawson ultimately recognized was the problem not that you know, oh, I did a code read because I was told to do it right and then so it's interesting I go back to Kendrick for a second right who told Dawson and Downey to do it now It's interesting how he selected those two guys
- 27:57[SPEAKER_00]: And this comes out a little bit in the film where he had previously disciplined Dawson for not following orders, because he snuck food to a guy who was being deprived of food.
- 28:12[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 28:12[SPEAKER_00]: So he already knew that this was a guy, so he was like a model Marine, and he wanted to follow orders, but he knew that because he already had him once, that he was
- 28:22[SPEAKER_00]: that he was, he was the guy who was actually going to follow through because he'd already even disciplined.
- 28:27[SPEAKER_00]: He's got his own moral code.
- 28:28[SPEAKER_00]: He also had needs to follow one.
- 28:30[SPEAKER_02]: And he also needed to teach him.
- 28:31[SPEAKER_02]: And it was training him.
- 28:33[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 28:33[SPEAKER_02]: He knows the dust has a conscience.
- 28:35[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
- 28:36[SPEAKER_02]: And he's like, you know, I don't like that.
- 28:37[SPEAKER_00]: And from you.
- 28:38[SPEAKER_00]: And Downey and Downey just follows orders.
- 28:40[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 28:40[SPEAKER_00]: So he's a guy who'll never do anything.
- 28:42[SPEAKER_00]: Especially when Dawson tells him to do it.
- 28:44[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 28:45[SPEAKER_00]: So it's interesting that all the people,
- 28:48[SPEAKER_00]: in that platoon he chose Dawson and Downey to go to he he he he he went to them to administer the code red right because he maybe he viewed them as the people who are least likely to resist with respect to Santiago right um... and maybe others you know would have would have would have had more of a problem with with the minister so he's it can trick is the guy who obviously
- 29:15[SPEAKER_01]: That's interesting, I'm listening to the, like I said, I think on the one hand, what might be considered sort of the obvious moral lesson, right, is there and sort of in kind of has this cake and eat it too, because we can talk about the legalities, but it's certainly implied at the end of the movie that, you know, when Nicholson makes his mistake,
- 29:38[SPEAKER_01]: and gives up to the goat about the fact that he had lied and the flight orders and I think that's part of it.
- 29:43[SPEAKER_01]: You know, there's parts of me that when I watched the movie and when I think about the movie now, I think I'm not sure that he was wrong and I think David, maybe you were starting to get it that a little bit right like it's almost... and it even...
- 29:54[SPEAKER_01]: before the rabbi said you were sort of like look the code read isn't really like it wasn't really saying and as Nicholson says when he answers them when they ask them about it lunch he's like listen he's like because the directive came from the admirable the admiral of the Navy like I gave it attention that it would still that's what I'll say on the record but like off the record I think they're invaluable part of like the teaching here that's the tour show
- 30:17[SPEAKER_01]: But the point that you're making Rabbi is the one they think Dawson kind of gets at the end which is the Dawson realizes well Well, we should have done was we should have stood up for Willie for you know He gets a name really San Diego like he was the week one.
- 30:27[SPEAKER_01]: He was the one who he couldn't then yes on he should have done what you said You know, it's it's
- 30:32[SPEAKER_01]: It's fine, I'm not sure why I come out.
- 30:33[SPEAKER_01]: To me, that's a very Hollywood pack thing.
- 30:36[SPEAKER_01]: Interestingly, the real case that some people say that was based on, I think the one that maybe his sister was involved in, so our consistent, the Marine who was accused does not get dishonorably discharged.
- 30:45[SPEAKER_01]: He actually is honorably discharged.
- 30:46[SPEAKER_01]: And in fact, that Marine was not particularly thrilled when he saw a few good men to come out.
- 30:50[SPEAKER_01]: Which, okay, wow.
- 30:51[SPEAKER_01]: I only mentioned that because,
- 30:53[SPEAKER_01]: You know, it's a very Hollywood pat ending, but that, you know, that Dawson, who seems very much where you are, David, and very much, I mean, I'd say a believer in the code right.
- 31:01[SPEAKER_01]: In fact, the fact that he doesn't mention it to Kathy that it never comes up, like he doesn't say, yeah, we were given an order.
- 31:05[SPEAKER_01]: Like, Kathy, like, you know, has to get that atom.
- 31:07[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 31:08[SPEAKER_01]: You know, they're, they're all these different shades of the morality that come out.
- 31:11[SPEAKER_01]: But it sounds to me like,
- 31:15[SPEAKER_01]: you do agree rabbi that you think that Dawson should have done that you think at the end like that should have done the right thing that you should have stood knowing that he couldn't have known the future I mean you can see that in hindsight but like if you know if you weren't his situation.
- 31:28[SPEAKER_02]: I'd like to think you know that if I were in his situation I would have I would have you know went back at my commanding what you got.
- 31:39[SPEAKER_02]: to go through me to go through me.
- 31:40[SPEAKER_02]: Well, that's why they don't put rabbi's and gitmo.
- 31:42[SPEAKER_02]: Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
- 32:05[SPEAKER_02]: You know, like, in Judaism, I, you know, I like to say that, like, I believe in Allah, very strongly.
- 32:11[SPEAKER_02]: You know, you mentioned the word Allah, which means Jewish law, a lot of laws that govern everything in life.
- 32:16[SPEAKER_02]: But I believe in Allah, with the heart.
- 32:19[SPEAKER_02]: You have to have Allah, with the heart.
- 32:21[SPEAKER_02]: Sometimes it could be, because it could feel, if someone just sort of practice it, it could be heartless sometimes.
- 32:27[SPEAKER_02]: even if Allah says, I need to do this, you have to have a heart about it and you have to feel what, you know, how this is going to impact the other person and figuring it out who won't deal with them the other side.
- 32:41[SPEAKER_02]: And sometimes the answer is like, yeah, you know, is this wrong way back?
- 32:46[SPEAKER_02]: Can I do it?
- 32:50[SPEAKER_02]: Maybe you don't want to ask me that question, you know, it's sort of leave it, you know, you leave it there you have to know who you're talking to and and clearly do us a new That that Santiago didn't belong and get mo and he was begging to leave and even I mean he knew he had him he had him you know with the fire right line is the fence the fence line, you know firing like right
- 33:12[SPEAKER_02]: He knew he knew and that's that's the problem and when you say the the code What was it not code red but what was the what's their code?
- 33:20[SPEAKER_00]: What did start was the code starts with core or who's no no it's such a company company?
- 33:25[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, right unit unit unit Yeah, yeah, yeah unit right in his unit and he's the leader and he should you look out for you.
- 33:32[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, I always tell my kids like the end of the day
- 33:35[SPEAKER_02]: God is going to judge us by how we looked out for the most vulnerable, the people who are on the periphery in our community.
- 33:45[SPEAKER_02]: We take care of them.
- 33:46[SPEAKER_02]: We're there for them, right?
- 33:48[SPEAKER_02]: That's who we have to be.
- 33:49[SPEAKER_02]: And as much it makes things more difficult, but that's why we're here.
- 33:55[SPEAKER_02]: That's why God put us on this earth.
- 33:57[SPEAKER_01]: But you feel a little differently, David, or I don't want to put words in your mouth,
- 34:02[SPEAKER_01]: The Dawson and Danny should have been, you know, dishonally discharged, do you think?
- 34:05[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, well, well, you know, if you get into legalities of it, you know, the, the, the, the, the first of all, there's no such thing as kind of becoming a Marine.
- 34:14[SPEAKER_00]: There's kind of them becoming an officer and either one of these guys are officers.
- 34:17[SPEAKER_00]: So that's, that's the whole, that whole thing.
- 34:20[SPEAKER_00]: is not is not realistic like a lot of other things that you know are not realistic frankly I've always had a problem with the fact that the term code read which I've since learned is not actually a term that they use and I know that it's you know it's just I thought it was bad
- 34:38[SPEAKER_00]: It was a bad choice.
- 34:39[SPEAKER_00]: It's a little cheesy of a term, right?
- 34:42[SPEAKER_00]: And I say that only because the military is very creative with its no-lanclature.
- 34:48[SPEAKER_00]: Let's stop the thing.
- 34:48[SPEAKER_02]: You know what it's called?
- 34:49[SPEAKER_00]: There is a thing, right?
- 34:52[SPEAKER_00]: Or if there is, it certainly wouldn't be called a code ready.
- 34:56[SPEAKER_00]: Right?
- 34:57[SPEAKER_00]: That's just sounds it's it's it's cheesy.
- 35:00[SPEAKER_00]: I mean the Marines came up with the the US military came up with things like Fubar and snap food rights like these these are these are never who are these are people who are all very creative Stay away from the poor little work
- 35:13[SPEAKER_00]: There's cash, but the whole idea of coming up with something as kind of pedestrian is cold red, whatever that means.
- 35:25[SPEAKER_00]: It's not the most important thing in their life.
- 35:27[SPEAKER_00]: It's not, there's not a nuclear missile going off.
- 35:30[SPEAKER_00]: There's not an invasion.
- 35:31[SPEAKER_00]: Why would this be a cold red?
- 35:32[SPEAKER_00]: Silly, just so then a mixture of the got me started with that.
- 35:37[SPEAKER_00]: I didn't care for that as a
- 35:45[SPEAKER_00]: But there are other, you know, kind of aspects of this movie that, and we're watching it recently, kind of didn't.
- 35:57[SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't really, it doesn't hold up after many years.
- 36:01[SPEAKER_00]: But there are, there are other parts of the movie that I think didn't.
- 36:06[SPEAKER_00]: age, didn't age, for a particular like, well, all right, what does an age where those are my questions actually let's get to the writing first of all like I'm a I'm an Aaron Sorkin to me is a is a guilty pleasure, right, he is he's that this rapid fire walk with me kind of Everybody's style and no one speaks the way his characters do, but that's okay because it's entertaining and then his later work
- 36:32[SPEAKER_00]: you know, for sure was was, you know, obviously we all know about West Wing and things like money ball and American president and social network.
- 36:45[SPEAKER_00]: He's done written all these really great interesting movies since then, but this is really his first work and I thought that
- 36:55[SPEAKER_00]: A lot of the dialogue in it, especially from Kathy, especially from Weinberg, the speeches, and also from Galaway, the speech about what they stand on a wall, or Weinberg is because because they're bullies, it was so kind of sanctimonious, it wasn't clever, right?
- 37:15[SPEAKER_00]: And that really maybe compared to his later work,
- 37:20[SPEAKER_00]: I found it to be very, very pedestrian in the way that he crafted those particular aspects of it.
- 37:31[SPEAKER_00]: That leaving aside entirely kind of the,
- 37:37[SPEAKER_00]: whether or not legally speaking, any of these things would have ever occurred, right?
- 37:43[SPEAKER_00]: So, for example, the court scenes are preposterous, right?
- 37:48[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know much about the rules of civil procedure in a jagged court, but I would imagine it's not too dissimilar from what goes on in a regular trial.
- 37:59[SPEAKER_00]: The idea that you can make these speeches
- 38:02[SPEAKER_00]: the fact that you're going to trial in three weeks with no motion practice right the fact that the fact that there's a there's a prosecution expert witness that says that he's a hundred percent certain that that that there was he must have been poison and they have no expert.
- 38:22[SPEAKER_00]: that of their own to put on on this subject.
- 38:24[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, that is just the hide it goes into the conscious.
- 38:28[SPEAKER_00]: Just for them.
- 38:29[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, just just just absolute.
- 38:32[SPEAKER_00]: So I guess, you know, from being big a litigator in particular, I'm like, oh, this is it just there's there's there's
- 38:38[SPEAKER_01]: So unrealistic in the way that this, you're like my father watches medical shows turn he's always exactly not what happened.
- 38:44[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and you know interestingly enough obviously this movie came out when I was twenty two years old It's before I was a lawyer probably sought for the for I didn't actually see this movie in the theater I saw this movie probably on HBO or something something a year or two later So it was obviously just before law school for me.
- 39:02[SPEAKER_00]: It was certainly before it's practice
- 39:03[SPEAKER_00]: Also, oh my god, maybe he, this guy, Kathy, was a year out of law school, and nine months into his Jack career.
- 39:14[SPEAKER_02]: No, I mean, that's my son's.
- 39:15[SPEAKER_02]: I haven't seen him.
- 39:17[SPEAKER_02]: Wow.
- 39:17[SPEAKER_00]: Like literally nine months, associated to have nine months practice, don't even get to carry my bag.
- 39:23[SPEAKER_00]: 31 cases.
- 39:24[SPEAKER_01]: 41 cases in blah, blah, blah.
- 39:26[SPEAKER_01]: That's what the, I'm so good to say that.
- 39:27[SPEAKER_01]: All right, so there's a few things I want to bring up.
- 39:29[SPEAKER_01]: But let's, I thought it was really, I thought it was interesting because
- 39:33[SPEAKER_01]: What we remember of this movie, and it's because they are short of writing and it's because Tom Cruise is Tom Cruise is He's everything we said in the beginning.
- 39:40[SPEAKER_01]: He's the cocky good looking smart Can settle out any case, right?
- 39:44[SPEAKER_01]: He's he's the hero who you figure has to overcome his arrogance or as you know He's overconfidence or as Joanne Galois says this daddy issues
- 39:56[SPEAKER_01]: Here's the thing about upon rewatching and something, this is, and this is why I love movies because I didn't remember this.
- 40:02[SPEAKER_01]: So,
- 40:04[SPEAKER_01]: the scene that is so he so she says that to him she right he yeah still settle out the case get him home in six months right he's plea bargaining everything like he does all the time and she gives him the whole you know daddy's shoes were too big to fill right and then he goes to a bar and it's like this very Aaron's working thing and he sit there and he sees some guy who's like a lawyer or him yes as the exact same lot yes exactly that's some little case then he goes at him from like the where went to memorial is something like that
- 40:32[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, searching thing.
- 40:33[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, searching thing and then you walk in and he pleads not guilty on every half He makes the argument.
- 40:38[SPEAKER_01]: He lets them stand on their own.
- 40:39[SPEAKER_01]: He's not a coward, right?
- 40:40[SPEAKER_01]: He does hold the things that Dawson wants him to do because that's the whole thing.
- 40:43[SPEAKER_01]: Dawson doesn't want to take the six month play He doesn't appreciate Kathy for all he does and and the scene ends with Kathy having that sort of great line Like oh, so this is what the inside of a court room looks like that's not what I want to talk about What I want to talk about is this and this is the thing I thought was great
- 40:57[SPEAKER_01]: Before that happens, as the courtroom is being cleared when the judge dismisses it and everybody's going out, Kathy says this, he says, why does a Jaguar with nine months experience and a repen, and for settling out cases fast, get assigned a case from division like this?
- 41:11[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, could it be so that it never sees the inside of a courtroom?
- 41:16[SPEAKER_01]: And see, this is where I will actually push back a little on the circuit of it all.
- 41:19[SPEAKER_01]: And I have to say, this is where people forget about Tom Cruise, because Tom Cruise did this also on a color of money.
- 41:23[SPEAKER_01]: And it's one of my, these are these are my favorite movies.
- 41:26[SPEAKER_01]: It's in it's really it's a pretty bold choice like you watch those movies You think that they are what they are on the surface, but in fact like when that line came through to me I realized a couple of things that first of all all that scene in the jack war when the guys like you know Lieutenant you know, he's managing the situation and he tells you know to join Gale.
- 41:43[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 41:44[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, no thanks
- 41:45[SPEAKER_01]: you know they say she's a great investigator but not a dog and a lawyer and you think that they're assigning a lawyer who's a dog and a good lawyer right and that's whenever you keep saying about him but then you realize with that line that probably not they were probably just like how do we how do we sweep this onto the road right and
- 42:00[SPEAKER_01]: And what I love idea that what happens in that moment is the realization for him not that it's daddy issues or not being inside of a courthouse.
- 42:07[SPEAKER_01]: But that what he realizes is that every attribute that makes him confident and cocky and allows him to tell, like, yeah, go right up to the White House and talk to my boss, the president, if you want to have me replaced and he drinks with everybody, that the thing that he thinks makes him so special is the thing that actually made him almost like the perfect choice to be the path to be a stooge.
- 42:25[SPEAKER_01]: Dude, just sweeping on the rug, right?
- 42:27[SPEAKER_01]: You know, Ben Franklin talked about his thing in his biography.
- 42:29[SPEAKER_01]: He just got a biography that really struck with me, which is that he talked about how when he was a younger man and he would go to all the people in town, the patrons of the city and fill it.
- 42:37[SPEAKER_01]: He would, you know, joke and try to be the funny guy and him use them and I was totally his guy in Hollywood until he realized like,
- 42:44[SPEAKER_01]: they don't like me for like that there's no respect that i'm getting from this that being the guy who drinks with everybody has parties and hits the baseball and you know will settle out a case like kaffee will like that is not respect and it's not just these can end up as the lawyer that he sees in the bar right because that's the obvious like to it's actually that what he realizes and this is why i don't think it's about his father is that he is he's he's he's the dude right like
- 43:08[SPEAKER_01]: I found that to be so interesting and I thought that it framed the whole idea that he makes this argument and everything he does and I actually found it very crusading because I thought like the fact that he asks Nicholson for you know the transfer order is it just that he kind of like it's just
- 43:23[SPEAKER_01]: that may be Nicholson's line, which is what you sort of remember, right?
- 43:26[SPEAKER_01]: At the time, Chris was really sharp, and he doesn't like the way he's talking to Joan Gallo, and he makes the BJ comment, and so he asks him for it.
- 43:32[SPEAKER_01]: He pushes a little bit, or that he's going to now Kendrick when he's got to keep her shovel, and that he's like going to now Kendrick.
- 43:37[SPEAKER_01]: And you think it's all because he's righteous, and he's got the crusade.
- 43:40[SPEAKER_01]: The part of me thought, no, it's actually that he's a little pissed.
- 43:44[SPEAKER_00]: he's pissed he's like he realizes these guys are manipulative on a level that is much deeper and i just thought that was yeah but it wasn't because he had a gestalt moment i mean he bit it that they admit that may have by the way that may have been true but remember he was literally going to withdraw from the case because the guy didn't take the plea because Dawson didn't take the plea a literally until he walked into the courtroom on the day of trial and entered where i guess
- 44:14[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 44:14[SPEAKER_01]: It's very movie-ish.
- 44:15[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 44:16[SPEAKER_01]: Just to clear it.
- 44:18[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 44:18[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 44:19[SPEAKER_00]: All of this, all of a sudden that comes up, but he was, he was sort of almost, I don't think it was a revelation to him.
- 44:28[SPEAKER_00]: He obviously knew about this.
- 44:30[SPEAKER_00]: You know, I don't see it like this.
- 44:33[SPEAKER_00]: This is fiction.
- 44:34[SPEAKER_00]: So we don't know.
- 44:35[SPEAKER_00]: But it doesn't, it doesn't see.
- 44:37[SPEAKER_00]: It seems like he was in a situation where,
- 44:41[SPEAKER_00]: he had to either, it would have been bad for him from a career standpoint to what basis would he even have to withdraw his, it was Dawson who was the guy who said I'm not playing to anything that kind of forced his hand.
- 44:56[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, right, but right, legality of, because again, some of it is, it's Hollywood, so it's, the legality is not gonna hold up any more than the medicine on Nip Talk I'll talk about when I worked on that show.
- 45:04[SPEAKER_01]: But what I mean is is that from the moral play
- 45:11[SPEAKER_01]: I thought the like the sort of simplistic version of what I might tell my five or eight year old, if I would tell him about this movie was like, you know, it's why you always at the stand up for the right person, you know, the weak person, and I would tell you a lot of what you said, Rabbi, and I would say that that's what it's about.
- 45:27[SPEAKER_01]: It's not that I think he has his Gestalt moment, but I do think that he's going to
- 45:30[SPEAKER_01]: Suddenly you begin to realize like when you start to see the machinations of things that are not necessarily evil intended or maliciously intended but that are at its core sort of kind of corrupt in some way right and you begin to understand your role in that and you begin to understand yeah that's really I totally saw that also
- 45:51[SPEAKER_01]: And I thought that was interesting because the thing that is most culpable to me about Nicholson and this is where Mark and the guy who gets it morally in the first place, right?
- 46:01[SPEAKER_01]: And it's conflicted, but it's that he tries to lie about it.
- 46:03[SPEAKER_01]: So my father was told me, it's like the thing you did that was wrong was bad, that's bad.
- 46:06[SPEAKER_01]: Who we all understand, we all do it, but that you lied about it.
- 46:09[SPEAKER_01]: That was the thing, right, that he covered it up.
- 46:12[SPEAKER_00]: Well, and on that point, just switching gears a little bit.
- 46:17[SPEAKER_00]: That might be the biggest plot hole in this entire movie, which is the cover-up, which ultimately was the, was Jess-ups on doing, right?
- 46:30[SPEAKER_00]: At least, you know, that, because the, the, the, the, fudging the flight logs for all, you know, all, all, all, all of that stuff, but, so here, which is interesting, but the reality
- 46:47[SPEAKER_00]: There is no need for that at all, right?
- 46:50[SPEAKER_00]: Plausible deniability is this.
- 46:52[SPEAKER_00]: This letter comes to this letter comes to Jessup.
- 46:56[SPEAKER_00]: Jessup says, I'm denying the request to transfer, and I'm leaving the investigation to my subordinates to deal with it.
- 47:06[SPEAKER_00]: I don't need to deal with the investigation.
- 47:09[SPEAKER_00]: And effectively, that's really what he did, right?
- 47:13[SPEAKER_00]: So what did he do?
- 47:17[SPEAKER_00]: He told Kendrick, hey, this guy better score, but he better have perfect scores next time around or I'm gonna hold you personally responsible for it and tell him to do a code read.
- 47:26[SPEAKER_00]: It was implied, that's fair.
- 47:28[SPEAKER_00]: It was implied, all of that is fine.
- 47:30[SPEAKER_00]: And he needed to leave with it that the idea of then going beyond that to say, oh, yeah, I transferred him he didn't need to do that he didn't need to do that the thing you only did that when he said he only did it when they asked about it well and oh, meaning it didn't he didn't really he didn't do a transfer order
- 47:49[SPEAKER_02]: He didn't have a transfer order at that moment to get mo.
- 47:52[SPEAKER_00]: No, but he didn't have the only reason they asked him for the transfer order in the first place.
- 47:56[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, because he said I approved his transfer.
- 47:59[SPEAKER_00]: He never needed to say I approved his trip.
- 48:03[SPEAKER_01]: They're coming down there.
- 48:04[SPEAKER_01]: Everybody knows they're coming, Kathy and the rest of them.
- 48:05[SPEAKER_01]: And the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the
- 48:13[SPEAKER_01]: They were covering it up.
- 48:14[SPEAKER_01]: Now to your point, like, what were they covering up?
- 48:16[SPEAKER_01]: He didn't need to cover it?
- 48:17[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 48:18[SPEAKER_01]: That may be legit.
- 48:18[SPEAKER_01]: I think is key on a character level about Nicholson, and this is where I think the Kathy thing is interesting.
- 48:26[SPEAKER_01]: When they're at that lunch, the thing about Nicholson, and this is the famous one, you know, later Tom Cruiser's pasties, he's like, you know, he's large.
- 48:32[SPEAKER_01]: From 300, you know, David, you'd say, to come, Nicholson is so arrogant.
- 48:36[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.
- 48:37[SPEAKER_02]: That's the thing.
- 48:38[SPEAKER_02]: He has to be involved in everything.
- 48:39[SPEAKER_02]: That's who he is.
- 48:41[SPEAKER_02]: He's the head.
- 48:42[SPEAKER_02]: He's he close all the shots by definition.
- 48:46[SPEAKER_02]: You don't know that.
- 48:47[SPEAKER_02]: You do not have the case.
- 48:48[SPEAKER_02]: He doesn't someone like Nicholson is not a political operator.
- 48:51[SPEAKER_02]: Of course he is.
- 48:52[SPEAKER_00]: He's literally about to be named a director of opera.
- 48:55[SPEAKER_00]: He's literally about to be named the director of operations for an essay.
- 48:59[SPEAKER_02]: because he believes he calls all the shot and pulls all the strings and that is his colloc like that's who he is that's the idea but you don't you don't get to where he is a guy like him without having self preservation skills and and the self preservation skills would have been plausible deniability but then once you start by them power corrupts take take someone I'll give you let me give you a toll right here I'm on
- 49:26[SPEAKER_02]: Take home on home on ride to hayman store in the, you know, in the school of western McGill's sister.
- 49:32[SPEAKER_02]: Haman is, he's copies the biceroy to, to, to, to, to, ah, shv, rose, right?
- 49:38[SPEAKER_02]: He, he's a political operator.
- 49:40[SPEAKER_02]: There's no question.
- 49:42[SPEAKER_02]: And then he throws it all away.
- 49:44[SPEAKER_02]: He ruins the whole, why?
- 49:46[SPEAKER_02]: Because one guy wouldn't give him the power that he wanted.
- 49:51[SPEAKER_02]: And it might more or less allow you to grab a little bit of that.
- 49:54[SPEAKER_02]: Everyone needs to bow to me.
- 49:56[SPEAKER_02]: And he throws it all the way all the way.
- 49:58[SPEAKER_02]: That's the point.
- 49:59[SPEAKER_02]: It's the story about someone who has power was Eubris, who has arrogance, needs to be involved in everything.
- 50:06[SPEAKER_02]: I need to hang this guy.
- 50:09[SPEAKER_02]: This guy is going down.
- 50:11[SPEAKER_02]: That's exactly what, what, what, what, just upset?
- 50:15[SPEAKER_02]: Jet lab deal.
- 50:16[SPEAKER_02]: Just upset?
- 50:16[SPEAKER_02]: No, no.
- 50:18[SPEAKER_02]: We're gonna train him.
- 50:19[SPEAKER_02]: And I'm gonna personally see it to it that he's trained.
- 50:22[SPEAKER_02]: Right.
- 50:22[SPEAKER_02]: He starts this close with the name building.
- 50:24[SPEAKER_02]: We need to tell them it.
- 50:25[SPEAKER_02]: Like, like, you're on the links to it.
- 50:26[SPEAKER_02]: No.
- 50:27[SPEAKER_01]: This is me, because I am, right.
- 50:29[SPEAKER_01]: He says, the minute that his right his orders are questioned, right, he has that great line that he turns to J.C. Walsh, where he, like he says, you know what Matthew, I think I, I, word with you, and he like,
- 50:40[SPEAKER_01]: He's like we did our commission.
- 50:42[SPEAKER_01]: We came up, but for whatever reason I've been promoted fast with a new and if that's a source of tension I don't give a shit.
- 50:46[SPEAKER_01]: What is he even before that he detect great line where he's like, yeah Yeah, you know, that's a good idea.
- 50:50[SPEAKER_01]: Transferment to be the expedient thing.
- 50:52[SPEAKER_01]: I'm sure that's the thing in fact Maybe we should transfer them all
- 50:56[SPEAKER_01]: So when they're in position, he is, it's in that moment and even again, I think the thing that great, but why couldn't he just say and leave well enough alone and say I'm not transferring him?
- 51:07[SPEAKER_00]: Why does that's my decision?
- 51:08[SPEAKER_00]: Screw all of you.
- 51:10[SPEAKER_00]: I'm not listening to anything you're saying.
- 51:12[SPEAKER_00]: I'm the boss and I'm saying don't, hey.
- 51:15[SPEAKER_02]: That's precisely.
- 51:16[SPEAKER_02]: No, initially.
- 51:16[SPEAKER_02]: He's saying, why, when Tom Cruise and that, like, when they were coming down, why, why make up a story?
- 51:23[SPEAKER_02]: He just said, said, I thought, it's very simple, David, because that means on his watch something happened that he didn't know about.
- 51:32[SPEAKER_02]: Someone in that position of power will never allow something like that.
- 51:36[SPEAKER_02]: that I owe it up no I knew that course I knew right well boy but then if you know that it then you're probably you can't be Colonel Jessup if you didn't if you didn't know about it that's the whole it's that's what makes it so it's that suspension of disbelief you know right yeah yeah so much fun like
- 51:52[SPEAKER_02]: Oh my god, he's going at it.
- 51:54[SPEAKER_02]: He's going to get him to blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 51:56[SPEAKER_02]: That would never happen to a courtroom ever at that moment.
- 51:59[SPEAKER_02]: But I just want to say this, the moral sort of that piece of like, you know, of going back to Kathy and and and like start at his realization of, you know, kind of
- 52:11[SPEAKER_02]: You know, that there's actually some, there's honor in this world, right?
- 52:13[SPEAKER_02]: And that's where they, you know, you salute him at the end.
- 52:16[SPEAKER_02]: It goes back to like, what is the, like, kind of enduring line of this, of this movie?
- 52:22[SPEAKER_02]: At least for me.
- 52:23[SPEAKER_02]: You can't handle the truth.
- 52:24[SPEAKER_02]: And it goes, that's like,
- 52:26[SPEAKER_02]: That's Kathy, right?
- 52:27[SPEAKER_02]: You can't handle the truth.
- 52:28[SPEAKER_02]: Kathy's got.
- 52:29[SPEAKER_02]: He's living.
- 52:30[SPEAKER_02]: He's trying to live this sort of fake life.
- 52:32[SPEAKER_02]: And it's got, you know, a daddy's state.
- 52:33[SPEAKER_02]: Does it have daddy's stop and, you know, living up to something and he thinks he's being a great lawyer by doing what?
- 52:39[SPEAKER_02]: I'm really doing nothing, right?
- 52:40[SPEAKER_02]: Because he's not standing up for people.
- 52:41[SPEAKER_02]: He's not really helping me.
- 52:43[SPEAKER_02]: He's doing, you know, for himself.
- 52:45[SPEAKER_02]: And then, you know, Jess, so he now takes on this case and he's sort of figuring it out.
- 52:49[SPEAKER_02]: Is it's right?
- 52:50[SPEAKER_02]: Can I do it?
- 52:50[SPEAKER_02]: He's drunk, and he still can't figure it out.
- 52:52[SPEAKER_02]: And then, you know, Jess obsessed him.
- 52:55[SPEAKER_02]: You can't you know he says you can't hear I want the truth you can handle the truth because here You know, and that's what he's dealing with this whole time.
- 53:03[SPEAKER_02]: It's obviously goes back to the cut square heavy Right, it's about buying obviously Obviously his name was Rabbi Monachim and the Morgan Stern, okay?
- 53:12[SPEAKER_02]: He is all about truth.
- 53:14[SPEAKER_02]: It's about finding that
- 53:16[SPEAKER_02]: inner point in yourself of like being honest with yourself and being truthful.
- 53:21[SPEAKER_02]: And that's the greatest like that's like the greatest religious epiphany or spiritual kind of attainment you could have is being honest.
- 53:31[SPEAKER_02]: And perhaps for once a small moment, you know, I don't know if Daniel can't be after the credits, you know, doesn't go back to being, you know, the hot shot, whatever,
- 53:39[SPEAKER_02]: There's some, he finds a point of truth, he finds something deeper in himself, in standing up for these feeling, you know, doing what he did in the right way, and he handled it, could handle it, and then he
- 53:56[SPEAKER_00]: yeah it is okay so so let's do this what was your score of the movie when you first saw it and what was the score of the movie when you re-saw it sure go all right i mean it's one of the time you use these tents you sense
- 54:10[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, like, honestly, we're talking out of a 10 and we're talking out of a 10.
- 54:14[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, yes.
- 54:14[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, mine would have been when I first saw it like a 9.5, 9.6.
- 54:18[SPEAKER_01]: And I'll just say very quickly one.
- 54:19[SPEAKER_01]: I recognized the down to a guy like Aaron Sorkin.
- 54:23[SPEAKER_01]: Tom Cruise was like 29, 30.
- 54:24[SPEAKER_01]: You know, so he was like the guy, it is prime.
- 54:27[SPEAKER_01]: But I mean, I don't even think it was in his pride.
- 54:28[SPEAKER_01]: I think he was like entering his own incredible run.
- 54:31[SPEAKER_01]: If I were going to tag it now, I'd say it's still pretty high, which I know is in a very good answer.
- 54:35[SPEAKER_01]: I definitely share a lot.
- 54:37[SPEAKER_01]: What is it now?
- 54:38[SPEAKER_01]: It was 9.5 less.
- 54:39[SPEAKER_01]: I'm 5.96 then.
- 54:41[SPEAKER_01]: It's probably like a 9.394.
- 54:42[SPEAKER_01]: And it's only because I do think some of it shows its age and sorkings like he's very young.
- 54:47[SPEAKER_01]: I think Rob Riner's very earnest to director, especially in this movie.
- 54:51[SPEAKER_01]: And I probably think anymore.
- 54:53[SPEAKER_01]: Now I'm sort of like, yeah, they didn't do anything wrong.
- 54:57[SPEAKER_01]: I still like, he's the case, but a little bit for Nick will sit in this version now.
- 55:09[SPEAKER_01]: I've lived long enough to kind of go, yeah, yeah, you know, right by?
- 55:13[SPEAKER_02]: I'm at like an 8.5 back then and like a seven.
- 55:18[SPEAKER_00]: It's so interesting.
- 55:19[SPEAKER_00]: I'm right around there.
- 55:22[SPEAKER_00]: I'm also 8.5 when I first saw it.
- 55:25[SPEAKER_00]: Seven is generous, but I'm gonna go with the seven also, that was it.
- 55:28[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I know why he became a lawyer.
- 55:30[SPEAKER_01]: He just lived the reality and went, oh, this is not what it's like.
- 55:33[SPEAKER_02]: There's something a little cheesy about it.
- 55:36[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that's the part that bothers me.
- 55:43[SPEAKER_01]: That's our show.
- 55:44[SPEAKER_01]: Thanks for listening to this episode of The Good, The Bad and the Holy.
- 55:48[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Jeremy Ellis with Rabbi Jonathan Morgan Stern and Attorney David Riftkin.
- 55:53[SPEAKER_01]: If you liked what you heard, follow the show, leave us a review and send it to the friend you always end up arguing about the movies with.
- 56:01[SPEAKER_01]: Until then, keep watching, keep arguing, and keep the faith.