Latest / Logic Library / 05 - Why I Write Such Excellent Books, Part 3 - Ecce Homo - Friedrich Nietzsche

Transcript

05 - Why I Write Such Excellent Books, Part 3 - Ecce Homo - Friedrich Nietzsche · Logic Library

0:01
Why I write such excellent books. Part three, Beyond Good and Evil,
0:13
the prelude to a philosophy of the future One. My work for the years
0:20
that followed was prescribed as distinctly as possible. Now that the yea saying part
0:29
of my life task was accomplished, there came the turn of the negative portion,
0:35
both in word and deed, the transvaluation of all values that had existed
0:41
hitherto the Great War, the conjuring up of the day when the fatal outcome
0:47
of the struggle would be decided. Meanwhile, I had slowly to look about
0:53
me for my peers, for those who, out of strength, would profer
0:59
me a health hand in my work of destruction. From that time onward,
1:04
all my writings are so much bait. Maybe I understand as much about fishing
1:11
as most people. If nothing was caught, it was not I who was
1:18
at fault. There were no fish to come and bite. Two. In
1:29
all its essential points, this book eighteen eighty six is a criticism of modernity,
1:37
embracing the modern sciences, arts, even politics, together with certain indications
1:45
as to a type which would be the reverse of modern man, or as
1:49
little like him as possible. A noble and yea saying type. In this
1:56
last respect, the book is a school for gentlemen, the term gentleman being
2:00
understood here in a much more spiritual and radical sense than it has implied hitherto
2:08
all those things of which the age is proud, as, for instance,
2:15
far famed objectivity, sympathy with all that suffers, the historical sense, with
2:22
its subjection to foreign tastes, with its lying in the dust before betti fe,
2:30
and the rage for science, are shown to be the contradiction of the
2:34
type recommended, and are regarded as almost ill bred. If you remember that
2:43
this book follows upon Zarathustra, you may possibly guess to what system of diet
2:50
it owes its life. The eye, which owing to a tremendous constraint,
2:57
has become accustomed to see at a great distance Zarathustra, is even more far
3:02
sighted than the Czar. Is here forced to focus sharply that which is close
3:08
at hand the present time, the things that lie about him. In all
3:15
the aphorisms, and more particularly in the form of this book, the reader
3:20
will find the same voluntary turning away from those instincts which made a Zarathustra a
3:27
possible feat refinement in form in aspiration and in the art of keeping silent are
3:35
more or less obvious qualities. Psychology is handled with deliberate hardness and cruelty.
3:43
The whole book does not contain one single good natured word. All this sort
3:49
of thing refreshes a man who can guess the kind of recreation that is necessary
3:54
after such an expenditure of goodness, as is to be found in Zarathustra.
4:00
From a theological standpoint, now pay ye heed, for it is but on
4:06
rare occasions that I speak as a theologian. It was God himself who,
4:13
at the end of his great work, coiled himself up in the form of
4:16
a serpent at the foot of the tree of Knowledge. It was thus that
4:21
he recovered from being a god he had made everything too beautiful. The devil
4:28
is simply God's moment of idleness on that seventh day. The Genealogy of Morals
4:38
a polemic. The three essays which constitute this genealogy are as regards expression,
4:46
aspiration, and the art of the unexpected, perhaps the most curious things that
4:53
have ever been written. Dionysus, as you know, is also the god
4:58
of darkness. In each case, the beginning is calculated to mystify. It
5:03
is cool, scientific, even ironical, intentionally thrust to the fore, intentionally
5:12
reticent, gradually less calmness prevails here and there a flash of lightning defines the
5:19
horizon. Exceedingly unpleasant truths break upon your ears from out remote distances with a
5:29
dull, rumbling sound, until very soon a fierce tempo is attained, in
5:34
which everything presses forwards at a terrible degree of tension. At the end,
5:41
in each case, amid fearful thunderclapse, a new truth shines out between thick
5:47
clouds. The truth of the first essay is the psychology of Christianity, the
5:55
birth of Christianity out of the spirit of resentment, not as is supposed,
6:00
out of the spirit in all its essentials, a counter movement, the great
6:08
insurrection against the dominion of noble values. The second essay contains the psychology of
6:15
conscience. This is, not, as you may believe, the voice of
6:19
God in man. It is the instinct of cruelty, which turns inwards once
6:26
it is unable to discharge itself outwardly. Cruelty is here exposed for the first
6:32
time as one of the oldest and most indispensable elements in a foundation of culture.
6:41
The third essay replies to the question as to the origin of the formidable
6:45
power of the ascetic ideal of the priest ideal despite the fact that this ideal
6:53
is essentially detrimental, that it is a will to nonentity and to decadence.
7:00
Es reply. It flourished not because God was active behind the priests, as
7:08
is generally believed, but because it was a fote de me from the fact
7:15
that hitherto it has been the only ideal and has had no competitors. For
7:23
man prefers to aspire to non entity than not to aspire at all. But
7:29
above all, until the time of Zarathustra, there was no such thing as
7:34
a counter ideal. You have understood my meaning. Three decisive overtures on the
7:42
part of a psychologist to a transvaluation of all values. This book contains the
7:48
first psychology of the priest, the Twilight of the Idols, how to Colossifies
8:00
with the Hammer one. This work, which covers scarcely one hundred and fifty
8:07
pages, with its cheerful and fateful tone like a laughing demon, and the
8:13
production of which occupied so few days that I hesitated to give their number,
8:20
is altogether an exception among books. There is no work more rich in substance,
8:26
more independent, more upsetting, more wicked. If anyone should desire to
8:33
obtain a rapid sketch of our everything before my time was standing on its head,
8:37
he should begin reading me. In this book. That which is called
8:43
idols on the title page is simply the old truth that has been believed in
8:48
hitherto. In plain English, the twilight of the idols means that the old
8:54
truth is on its last legs. Two. There is no reality, no
9:03
ideality which has not been touched in this book. Touched. What a cautious
9:09
euphemism, not only the eternal idols, but also the youngest, that is
9:15
to say, the most senile modern ideas. For instance, a strong wind
9:20
blows between the trees and in all directions for the fruit the truths. There
9:28
is a waste of an all too rich autumn in this book. You trip
9:31
over truths, you even crush some to death. There are too many of
9:35
them. Those things that you can grasp, however, are quite unquestionable.
9:43
There are irrevocable decrees. I alone have the criterion of truths in my possession.
9:52
I alone can decide it would seem as if a second consciousness had grown
10:00
up in me, as if the life will in me have thrown a light
10:05
upon the downward path along which it has been running throughout the ages. The
10:11
downward path hitherto this has been called the road to truth. All obscure,
10:18
impulse, darkness, and dismay is at an end. The good man was
10:24
precisely he who was least aware of the proper way. Translator's footnote a witty
10:31
reference to Gerta's well known passage in the Prolog to Faust. A good man,
10:37
though in darkness and dismay, may still be conscious of the proper way.
10:43
The words are spoken by the Lord and a translator's note, and speaking
10:50
in all earnestness. No one before me knew the proper way, the way
10:54
upwards. Only after my time could men once more find hope life, tasks
11:03
and roads mapped out that lead to culture. I am the joyful harboringer of
11:09
this culture. On this account alone, I am also a fatality. Three
11:20
immediately after the completion of the above named work, and without letting even one
11:26
day go by, I tackled the formidable task of the transvaluation with the supreme
11:31
feeling of pride which nothing could equal and certain at each moment of my immortality,
11:39
I cut sign after sign upon tablets of brass with the sureness of fate.
11:45
The preface came into being on the third of September eighteen eighty eight,
11:50
when, after having written it down, I went out into the open.
11:54
That morning I was greeted by the most beautiful day I had ever seen in
12:01
the upper Egudine, clear, glowing with colour and presenting all the contrasts and
12:09
all the intermediary gradations between ice and the south. I left sils Maria only
12:16
on the twentieth of September. I had been forced to delay my departure owing
12:22
to floods, and I was very soon and for some days the only visitor
12:28
in this wonderful spot on which by gratitude bestows the gift of an immortal name.
12:37
After a journey that was full of incidents and not without danger to life,
12:43
as for instance at Como, which was flooded when I reached it in
12:46
the dead of night, I got to Turin on the afternoon of the twenty
12:52
first. Turin is the only suitable place for me, and it shall be
12:58
my home. Henceforward I took the same lodgings as I had occupied in the
13:03
spring six one one one via Carlo Alberto, opposite the mighty Palazzo Carignano in
13:13
which Vittorio Emmanuel was born, and I had a view of the Piazzo Carlo
13:20
Alberto and above it across to the hills. Without hesitating or allowing myself to
13:26
be disturbed for a single moment, I returned to my work, only the
13:31
last quarter of which had still to be written. On the thirtieth of September,
13:37
tremendous triumph the seventh day, the Leisure of a God on the banks
13:43
of the Poe translator's footnote, there is a wonderful promenade along the banks of
13:50
the Poe, for which Turin is famous, and of which Nietzsche was particularly
13:54
fond, and translator's note. On the same day I wrote the preface to
14:03
The Twilight of the Idols, the correction of the proofs of which provided me
14:07
with recreation during the month of September. Never in my life have I experienced
14:15
such an autumn, nor had I ever imagined that such things were possible on
14:20
earth. A Claude Laurins extended to infinity each day equal to the last in
14:30
its wild perfection. The Case of Wagner a musician's problem one. In order
14:41
to do justice to this essay, a man ought to suffer from the fate
14:46
of music as from an open wound. From what do I suffer when I
14:52
suffer from the fate of music? From the fact that music has lost its
14:58
world, transfiguring yea saying character that it is decadent music and no longer the
15:05
flute of Dionysus. Supposing, however, that the fate of music be as
15:11
dear to man as his own life, because joy and suffering are alike bound
15:16
up with it, then he will find this pamphlet comparatively mild and full of
15:22
consideration, to be cheerful in such circumstances, and laugh good naturedly with the
15:31
others at oneself credendo de caire severroon translator's note, the motto of the Case
15:41
of Wagner. End of translator's note. When the verum deceree would justify every
15:48
sort of hardness is humanity itself? Who doubts that I, old artillery man
15:56
that I am, would be able if I liked to point my heavy guns
16:02
at Wagner? Everything decisive in this question I kept to myself. I have
16:07
loved Wagner. After all, an attack upon a more than usually subtle unknown
16:15
person whom another would not have divined so easily, lies in the meaning and
16:22
path of my life. Task. Oh, I have still quite a number
16:26
of other unknown persons to unmask, besides a cagliostro of music. Above all,
16:36
I have to direct an attack against the German people, who, in
16:40
matters of the spirit, grow every day more indolent, poorer in instincts,
16:45
and more honest, who, with an appetite for which they are to be
16:52
envied, continue to diet themselves on contradictions and gulp down faith in company with
17:00
science. Christian love together with antisemitism and the will to power to the empire,
17:08
dished up with the Gospel of the humble, without showing the slightest signs
17:15
of indigestion. Fancy this absence of party feeling in the presence of opposites.
17:22
Fancy this gastric neutrality and disinterestedness. Behold this sense of justice in the German
17:30
palate, which can grant equal rights to all, which finds everything tasteful without
17:38
a shadow of doubt. The Germans are idealists. When I was last in
17:44
Germany. I found German tastes striving to Grant Wagner and the trumpeter of sackingen
17:52
equal rights translator's footnote, an opera by Nessler which was all the rage in
17:59
Germany to twenty years ago and translator's note. While I witnessed the attempts of
18:04
the people of Leipzig to do honor to one of the most genuine and most
18:10
German of musicians. Using German here in the old sense of the word,
18:15
a man who is no mere German of the Empire, the master Heinrich Schultz,
18:22
by founding a List's Society, the object of which was to cultivate and
18:27
spread artful listige church music translator's footnote. Unfortunately, it is impossible to render
18:37
this play on the words in English and translator's note without a shadow of doubt.
18:45
The Germans are idealists. Two. But here nothing shall stop me from
18:59
being rue and from telling the Germans one or two unpleasant home truths. Who
19:06
else would do it if I did not? I refer to their laxity in
19:11
matters historical. Not only have the Germans entirely lost the breath of vision which
19:18
enables one to grasp the course of culture and the values of culture. Not
19:23
only are they one and all political or church puppets, but they have also
19:30
actually put a ban upon this very breath of vision. A man must first
19:37
and foremost be German, he must belong to the race. Then only can
19:45
he pass judgment upon all values and lack of values in history. Then only
19:52
can he establish them to be German is in itself an argument Germany, Germany
19:59
above all all is a principle. Translator's note the German national song Deutschland Deutschland
20:07
Uberalus and translators note the Germans stand for the moral order of the universe.
20:15
In history. Compared with the Roman Empire, they are the upholders of freedom.
20:22
Compared with the eighteenth century, they are the restorers of morality, of
20:26
the categorical imperative. There is such a thing as the writing of history.
20:32
According to the lights of Imperial Germany. There is i fear, anti Semitic
20:37
history. There is also history written with an eye to the court. And
20:44
her von Tretsk is not ashamed of himself. Quite recently an idiotic opinion in
20:52
Historicus an observation of Fisher the Swabian athete, since happily deceased made the round
21:00
of the German newspapers as a truth to which every German must assent. The
21:08
observation was this, the Renaissance and the Reformation only together constitute a whole,
21:17
the esthetic rebirth and the moral rebirth. When I listen to such things,
21:23
I lose all patients, and I feel inclined. I even feel it's my
21:29
duty to tell the Germans, for once in a way, all that they
21:33
have on their conscience, every great crime against culture for the last four centuries,
21:41
lies on their conscience, and always for the same reason, always owing
21:48
to their bottomless cowardice in the face of reality, which is also cowardice in
21:53
the face of truth, always owing to the love of falsehood, which has
22:00
become almost instinctive in them. In short, idealism, it was the Germans
22:07
who caused Europe to lose the fruits the whole meaning of her last period of
22:11
greatness, the period of the Renaissance, at a moment when a higher order
22:17
of values, values that were noble, that said yea to life and that
22:22
guaranteed of future, had succeeded in triumphing over the opposite values, the values
22:29
of degeneration. In the very seed of Christianity itself and even in the hearts
22:34
of those sitting there. Luther, that cursed monk, not only restored the
22:41
Church, but what was a thousand times worse, restored Christianity, and at
22:48
a time too, when it lay defeated Christianity, the denial of the will
22:53
to live exalted to a religion. Luther was an an impossible monk who,
23:02
thanks to his own impossibility, attacked the Church and in doing so restored it.
23:07
Catholics would be perfectly justified in celebrating feasts in honour of Luther and in
23:14
producing festival plays in his honour. Translator's note. Ever since the year sixteen
23:21
seventeen such plays have been produced by the Protestants of Germany, and Translator's note,
23:29
Luther and the Rebirth of morality. May all psychology go to the devil
23:37
without a shadow of a doubt. The Germans are idealists. On two occasions,
23:42
when at the cost of enormous courage and self control and upright unequivocal and
23:49
perfectly scientific attitude of mind had been attained, the Germans were able to discover
23:56
backstairs leading down to the old ideal again, compromises between truth and the ideal
24:03
and in short, formulae for the right to reject science and to perpetrate falsehoods
24:11
Leibnitz and Kan't. These two great breaks upon the intellectual honesty of Europe finally
24:19
at a moment when there appeared, on the bridge that spanned two centuries of
24:25
decadence, a superior force of genius and will, which was strong enough to
24:30
consolidate Europe and to convert it into a political and economic unit with the object
24:37
of ruling the world. The Germans, with their wars of independence, robbed
24:44
Europe of the significance, the marvelous significance of Napoleon's life, and in doing
24:51
so they laid on their conscience everything that followed, everything that exists today,
24:56
this sickliness and one of reason, which is most opposed to culture, and
25:03
which is called nationalism, This nevosa naciur now from which Europe is suffering acutely,
25:11
this eternal subdivision of Europe into petty states with politics on a municipal scale.
25:18
They have robbed Europe itself of its significance, of its reason, and
25:23
have stuffed it into a cul de sac. Is there any one except me
25:30
who knows the way out of this cul de sac. Does any one except
25:33
me know of an aspiration which would be great enough to bind the peoples of
25:40
Europe once more together? Three? And after all, why should I not
25:48
express my suspicions in my case too? The Germans will attempt to make a
25:56
great fate give birth merely to a mouse. Up to the present they have
26:02
compromised themselves with me. I doubt whether the future will improve them alas how
26:10
happy I should be to prove a false prophet in this matter. My natural
26:15
readers and listeners are already Russians, Scandinavians and Frenchmen. Will they always be
26:23
the same? In the history of knowledge, Germans are represented only by doubtful
26:30
names. They have been able to produce only unconscious swindlers. This word applies
26:37
to Fichte, Schelling, Schopenhauer, Hegel, and Schleilemacher, just as well
26:47
as to cant or Leadnitz. They are all merely Schleilemacher's translator's footnote. Schleiermacher
26:56
literally means a weaver or maker of vain and translator's note, the Germans must
27:03
not have the honor of seeing the first upright intellect in the history of intellects.
27:11
That intellect in which truth ultimately got the better of the fraud of four
27:17
thousand years, reckoned as one with the German intellect. German intellect is my
27:23
foul air. I breathe with difficulty in the neighborhood of this psychological uncleanliness that
27:32
has now become instinctive, an uncleanliness which in every word an expression betrays a
27:40
German. They have never undergone a seventeenth century of hard self examination, as
27:47
the French have a laroche fulcl a decar are a thousand times more upright than
27:55
the very first among Germans. The latter have not yet had any psychologists.
28:02
But psychology is almost the standard of measurement for the cleanliness or uncleanliness of a
28:07
race. For if a man is not even clean, how can he be
28:12
deep? The Germans are like women. You can scarcely ever fathom their depths.
28:21
They haven't any, and that's the end of it. Thus they cannot
28:26
even be called shallow. That which is called deep in Germany is precisely this
28:32
instinctive uncleanliness towards one's self of which I have just spoken. People refuse to
28:38
be clear in regards to their own natures. Might I be allowed, perhaps
28:45
to suggest the word German as an international epithet denoting this psychological depravity. At
28:53
the moment of writing, for instance, the German emperor is declaring it to
28:59
be his crit ristian duty to liberate the slaves in Africa. Among US Europeans,
29:04
then this will recalled simply German. Have the Germans ever produced even a
29:11
book that had depth? They are lacking in the mere idea of what constitutes
29:18
a book. I have known scholars who thought that Kant was deep at the
29:25
Court of Prussia. I fear that her von Tresk is regarded as deep.
29:30
And when I happen to praise Sandhaul as a deep psychologist, I have often
29:37
been compelled in the company of German university professors to spell his name aloud four
29:47
and why should I not proceed to the end? I am fond of clearing
29:52
the air. It is even part of my ambition to be considered as essentially
29:57
a despiser of Germans. I expressed my suspicions of the German character even at
30:03
the age of six and twenty see Thoughts out of Season Volume two, pages
30:11
one six four to one six five. To my mind, the Germans are
30:17
impossible when I try to think of the kind of man who is opposed to
30:22
me, in all my instincts, my mental image takes the form of a
30:26
German. The first thing I ask myself when I begin analyzing a man is
30:33
whether he has a feeling for distance in him, whether he sees rank,
30:40
gradation and order everywhere between man and man, whether he makes distinctions. For
30:48
this is what constitutes a gentleman. Otherwise he belongs hopelessly to that open hearted,
30:56
open minded alas and all very good natured species lacanaye. But the Germans
31:04
are knaye. Alas they are so good natured. A man lowers himself by
31:11
frequenting the society of Germans. The German places everyone on an equal footing.
31:19
With the exception of my intercourse with one or two artists, and above all
31:25
with Richard Wagner, I cannot say that I have spent one pleasant hour with
31:30
Germans. Suppose for one moment that the profoundest spirit of all ages were to
31:37
appear among Germans, then one of the saviors of the capital would be sure
31:42
to arise and declare that his own ugly soul was just as great. I
31:49
can no longer abide this race with which a man is always in bad company
31:56
which has no idea of nuances, woe to me, I am a nuance,
32:01
and which has not a spree in its feet, and cannot even walk
32:07
withal. In short, the Germans have no feed at all. They simply
32:13
have legs. The Germans have not the faintest idea of how vulgar they are.
32:20
But this in itself is the acme of vulgarity. They are not even
32:25
ashamed of being merely Germans. They will have their say in everything. They
32:31
regard themselves as fit to decide all questions. I even fear that they have
32:37
decided about me. My whole life is essentially a proof of this remark.
32:45
In vain have I sought among them for a sign of tact and delicacy towards
32:51
myself? Among Jews, I did indeed find it, but not among Germans.
32:58
I am so constituted as to be gentle and kindly to everyone. I
33:04
have the right not to draw distinctions, but this does not prevent my eyes
33:08
from being open. I accept no one, and least of all my friends.
33:15
I only trust that this has not prejudiced my reputation for humanity. Among
33:22
them, there are five or six things which I have always made points of
33:29
honor. Albeit the truth remains that for many years I have considered almost every
33:36
letter that has reached me as a piece of cynicism. There is more cynicism
33:42
in an attitude of good will towards me than any sort of hatred. I
33:47
tell every friend to his face that he has never thought it worth his while
33:53
to study any one of my writings. From the slightest hints I gather that
34:00
they do not even know what lies hidden in my books. And with regard
34:06
even to my Zarathustra, which of my friends would have seen more in it
34:12
than a piece of unwarrantable, though fortunately harmless arrogance. Ten years have elapsed,
34:22
and no one has yet felt it a duty to his conscience to defend
34:25
my name against the absurd silence beneath which it has been entombed. It was
34:32
a foreigner, a Dane, who first showed sufficient keenness of instinct and courage
34:38
to do this, and who protested indignantly against my so called friends at what
34:46
German university to day would such lectures on my philosophy be possible? As those
34:53
which doctor Brandes delivered last spring in Copenhagen, thus proving once more his right
35:00
to the title psychologist. For my part, these things have never caused me
35:07
any pain. That which is necessary does not offend me. Our morphatty is
35:14
the core of my nature. This, however, does not alter the fact
35:19
that I love irony, an even world historic irony. And thus, about
35:27
two years before hurling the destructive thunderbolt of the transvaluation, which will send the
35:31
whole of civilization into convulsions, I sent my case of Wagner out into the
35:37
world. The Germans were given the chance of blundering and immortalizing their stupidity once
35:45
more on my account, and they still have just enough time to do it
35:50
in and have they fallen in with my plans admirably, My dear Germans,
35:55
allow me to congratulate you, and of why I write such excellent books. Part three