Latest / Toronto Talks / Powering Ontario Without Pricing Industry Out with Brad Duguid
Transcript
- 0:00Brad Duguid: It's not an exaggeration to say this is an existential moment for industry,
- 0:06Brad Duguid: and the direction is either we're headed toward deindustrialization,
- 0:10Brad Duguid: or this is our opportunity to ensure that we can navigate through these very challenging times,
- 0:16Brad Duguid: but industry can't do it alone.
- 0:18Giles Gherson: Hello,
- 0:18Giles Gherson: I'm Giles Gherson,
- 0:19Giles Gherson: and this is Toronto Talks,
- 0:22Giles Gherson: the voice of Toronto's business community.
- 0:24Giles Gherson: What are we talking about?
- 0:26Giles Gherson: Each episode is a conversation with top business leaders about how they're shaping growth,
- 0:31Giles Gherson: driving competitiveness,
- 0:32Giles Gherson: and building up our economy.
- 0:34Giles Gherson: It's about what they believe it will take to make sure the Toronto region remains one of
- 0:38Giles Gherson: the world's great global cities.
- 0:41Giles Gherson: Here's today's conversation.
- 0:43Giles Gherson: Brad, welcome to Toronto Talks, our podcast,
- 0:45Giles Gherson: Toronto Region Board of Trade podcast.
- 0:47Giles Gherson: Really great to have you on.
- 0:49Giles Gherson: I think where I want to start is, because we're going to get into a very complex subject of energy prices.
- 0:54Giles Gherson: So before we scare people off,
- 0:57Giles Gherson: you know,
- 0:57Giles Gherson: It's really, I think, in many ways, I would say you're the right guy at the right time in this place.
- 1:03Giles Gherson: Right. So and,
- 1:04Giles Gherson: you know, you've had this,
- 1:06Giles Gherson: I would say,
- 1:06Giles Gherson: again, a storied public service career as a Scarborough City Councillor in Toronto.
- 1:12Giles Gherson: and then moving to provincial politics,
- 1:15Giles Gherson: a whole array of ministerial portfolios,
- 1:18Giles Gherson: one of which I was glad to work with you on, which was economic development.
- 1:22Giles Gherson: But you had infrastructure.
- 1:23Giles Gherson: You had energy for a long time, which is what we want to talk a little bit about.
- 1:29Giles Gherson: The list goes on,
- 1:31Giles Gherson: training colleges,
- 1:31Giles Gherson: universities,
- 1:32Giles Gherson: and so on.
- 1:32Giles Gherson: So you saw government from a very broad perspective.
- 1:35Giles Gherson: Now you find yourself as president of AMPCO,
- 1:39Giles Gherson: which is the Association of Major Energy Users.
- 1:43Brad Duguid: Power Consumers.
- 1:44Brad Duguid: Power Consumers of Ontario.
- 1:46Giles Gherson: But just to get it right,
- 1:48Giles Gherson: the very large consumers of power in Ontario, which is the large corporation,
- 1:52Giles Gherson: big industrial users,
- 1:53Giles Gherson: cement,
- 1:55Giles Gherson: auto manufacturing,
- 1:56Giles Gherson: the list goes on,
- 1:57Giles Gherson: petrochemical complexes and so on.
- 2:00Giles Gherson: These are the big users of power and energy in Ontario.
- 2:04Giles Gherson: And you're the kind of the association that speaks for them.
- 2:08Giles Gherson: And they're in a pickle right now.
- 2:11Giles Gherson: And so really what we want to talk a bit about is the pickle they're in and some of the ideas you've been putting forward to try to break the logjam and try to move forward.
- 2:22Giles Gherson: So let's talk a little bit about that.
- 2:24Giles Gherson: But before we do,
- 2:25Giles Gherson: maybe just tell us a bit about how you got into AMPCO.
- 2:28Giles Gherson: What brought you there?
- 2:29Giles Gherson: You had this, as I said, storied political career.
- 2:32Giles Gherson: Then you left with the change of government.
- 2:36Giles Gherson: You went into consulting for a bit and then AMPCO.
- 2:40Giles Gherson: So what took you to AMPCO?
- 2:41Brad Duguid: Well,
- 2:41Brad Duguid: storied is a good word because it doesn't mean good or bad.
- 2:43Brad Duguid: It just means storied.
- 2:44Giles Gherson: I mean it good.
- 2:45Brad Duguid: Yeah, I'm glad.
- 2:47Brad Duguid: And you are very much part of that.
- 2:49Brad Duguid: And this is a bit of a mutual admiration society in a way.
- 2:52Brad Duguid: You and I have been friends a long time,
- 2:55Brad Duguid: but some of my best times in government were working with you.
- 2:58Brad Duguid: And I'm not just saying that.
- 3:00Brad Duguid: I think you know it.
- 3:01Brad Duguid: We were known as the dynamic duo very much at Queen's Park,
- 3:05Brad Duguid: both in good ways and bad ways.
- 3:06Giles Gherson: Yeah, probably.
- 3:07Brad Duguid: But we're always doing good work.
- 3:08Giles Gherson: We thought so.
- 3:09Brad Duguid: But, you know, when I look back in those days,
- 3:11Brad Duguid: Giles,
- 3:11Brad Duguid: and I know this has nothing to do with what we're talking about now,
- 3:16Brad Duguid: the one thing we can look back on,
- 3:18Brad Duguid: And I hope you do with pride as well,
- 3:20Brad Duguid: is between you and I and our teams,
- 3:23Brad Duguid: we transformed Ontario's entire economic development strategy from the old school strategy
- 3:29Brad Duguid: to how to take on the new world global economy.
- 3:32Brad Duguid: And if ever there was a time when that kind of approach is needed,
- 3:36Brad Duguid: it's probably now.
- 3:37Brad Duguid: So I look at those times with a lot of pleasure.
- 3:42Brad Duguid: It was an honor working with you.
- 3:43Giles Gherson: Likewise,
- 3:44Brad Duguid: very much.
- 3:45Brad Duguid: And I think those experiences have really played a significant role in my capacity
- 3:52Brad Duguid: to help bring AMPCO along,
- 3:54Brad Duguid: the Association of Major Power Consumers in Ontario.
- 3:57Brad Duguid: And you stumbled a little over the acronym.
- 4:00Brad Duguid: Doesn't everybody?
- 4:00Brad Duguid: But don't feel bad because when I was Minister of Energy,
- 4:03Brad Duguid: and I say this to my AMPCO folks,
- 4:05Brad Duguid: I used to try to figure out who's APPrO and who's AMPCO.
- 4:08Brad Duguid: And before they'd come into my office,
- 4:09Brad Duguid: I'd have to ask my staff, who are these guys again?
- 4:11Brad Duguid: So I'm hoping now that we're in government circles
- 4:15Brad Duguid: so much more than maybe we used to be
- 4:17Brad Duguid: that they actually know who we are.
- 4:19Giles Gherson: You know who we are.
- 4:20Brad Duguid: you're right.
- 4:22Brad Duguid: You're right. The big industries in Ontario:
- 4:24Brad Duguid: steel,
- 4:25Brad Duguid: mining,
- 4:26Brad Duguid: auto,
- 4:27Brad Duguid: advanced manufacturing,
- 4:29Brad Duguid: cement,
- 4:31Brad Duguid: petrochemicals, forestry,
- 4:32Brad Duguid: all of the big users.
- 4:34Brad Duguid: It's the heart of our economy.
- 4:35Brad Duguid: It is in many ways
- 4:37Brad Duguid: over a million people employed by that sector directly and indirectly.
- 4:42Brad Duguid: It's a big part of our
- 4:43Brad Duguid: economy.
- 4:44Brad Duguid: But for a kid from Scarborough who had a political life and went into, as you said,
- 4:48Brad Duguid: the private sector for a bit for a while.
- 4:51Brad Duguid: What happened is I was doing good work. I was doing
- 4:55Brad Duguid: consulting work and I felt like I was missing something.
- 4:58Brad Duguid: I wasn't building anything anymore.
- 5:00Giles Gherson: Yeah.
- 5:00Brad Duguid: And when AMPCO came calling,
- 5:03Brad Duguid: I looked at that as a great opportunity to apply
- 5:06Brad Duguid: some of the knowledge, the skills and the context that people like you and I get during our time in
- 5:12Brad Duguid: government to try to help industry during very difficult times.
- 5:17Brad Duguid: And boy, have things changed
- 5:18Giles Gherson: I was going to say when
- 5:19Brad Duguid: Difficult
- 5:19Giles Gherson: times went to crisis times. Difficult
- 5:21Brad Duguid: times.
- 5:22Giles Gherson: Well, I
- 5:22Giles Gherson: was going to say, because when you took it over,
- 5:24Giles Gherson: when you took over AMPCO,
- 5:25Giles Gherson: we've
- 5:27Giles Gherson: always had a
- 5:27Giles Gherson: long, I mean, not always, but for a long period of time in Ontario, even when you were
- 5:31Giles Gherson: energy minister,
- 5:32Giles Gherson: the issue of energy cost has been a factor in,
- 5:36Giles Gherson: can we attract
- 5:37Giles Gherson: manufacturing investment here?
- 5:38Giles Gherson: Can we retain companies
- 5:39Giles Gherson: here?
- 5:40Giles Gherson: Can they grow here?
- 5:41Giles Gherson: And there's always been
- 5:42Giles Gherson: some tension,
- 5:43Giles Gherson: I think,
- 5:43Giles Gherson: between government of Ontario,
- 5:45Giles Gherson: irrespective
- 5:45Giles Gherson: of the political stripe and large power users,
- 5:49Giles Gherson: consumers,
- 5:49Giles Gherson: with energy cost.
- 5:52Giles Gherson: And so you knew that going in.
- 5:55Brad Duguid: Boy,
- 5:55Brad Duguid: did I.
- 5:56Giles Gherson: Yeah,
- 5:56Giles Gherson: you knew that going in.
- 5:57Giles Gherson: But now you find yourself in a much different situation.
- 6:01Giles Gherson: Just give listeners a sense of what your members are saying about energy costs right now.
- 6:09Brad Duguid: Well, you summed it up really well.
- 6:11Brad Duguid: I mean, we're getting the crap kicked out of us on tariffs.
- 6:16Brad Duguid: and that's just not words.
- 6:18Brad Duguid: I mean, we have members that have had to reduce production.
- 6:22Brad Duguid: Their production is down.
- 6:24Brad Duguid: They've reduced workforces.
- 6:26Brad Duguid: You look at the auto sector
- 6:27Brad Duguid: and you look at the challenges in the auto sector.
- 6:30Brad Duguid: We've got plants like Brampton that are very uncertain.
- 6:34Brad Duguid: You've got the Ford investment that is now paused.
- 6:37Brad Duguid: Who knows what's going to happen?
- 6:39Brad Duguid: You've got the big battery plant that Honda was going to build
- 6:42Brad Duguid: that is paused at least for a couple of years.
- 6:46Brad Duguid: Steel industry is getting hit very,
- 6:48Brad Duguid: very hard.
- 6:49Brad Duguid: And then when you think of it, okay, those are the direct hits and there are others.
- 6:53Brad Duguid: But every industry is being hit hard in the supply chain as costs have gone up for them.
- 6:59Brad Duguid: So this is,
- 7:01Brad Duguid: I don't like to use this existential word.
- 7:04Brad Duguid: It's not a word that guys from Scarborough even grew up knowing what it meant.
- 7:08Brad Duguid: But it's not an exaggeration to say this is an existential moment for industry.
- 7:14Brad Duguid: And the direction is either we're headed toward deindustrialization in Ontario,
- 7:18Brad Duguid: and God forbid,
- 7:19Brad Duguid: because that impact is huge,
- 7:21Brad Duguid: or this is our opportunity to ensure that we can navigate through these very challenging times.
- 7:28Brad Duguid: But industry can't do it alone.
- 7:30Giles Gherson: Well,
- 7:30Giles Gherson: no, and in fact, you use the word deindustrialization,
- 7:33Giles Gherson: which is,
- 7:34Giles Gherson: I think, an apt word, an appropriate word.
- 7:37Giles Gherson: but it's a passive word.
- 7:39Giles Gherson: I look at it as we are being de-industrialized,
- 7:43Giles Gherson: right?
- 7:44Giles Gherson: President Trump
- 7:45Giles Gherson: made it very clear,
- 7:46Giles Gherson: you know, I'm going to put severe economic pressure on Canada,
- 7:50Giles Gherson: folks in Ontario,
- 7:51Giles Gherson: to move industrial production to the U.S. Now, we've tried to do it with other
- 7:56Giles Gherson: countries as well, but we're next door.
- 7:57Giles Gherson: We have an integrated economy.
- 8:00Giles Gherson: And so the threat to us
- 8:02Giles Gherson: was more severe than with any other country in the world. And they might say, we offered you the
- 8:07Giles Gherson: best deal.
- 8:08Giles Gherson: It was by far the worst deal in terms of impact,
- 8:10Giles Gherson: right?
- 8:11Giles Gherson: And so it's being done to us.
- 8:13Giles Gherson: And then the question is, I think your position would be,
- 8:15Giles Gherson: how are we protecting ourselves? I mean,
- 8:17Giles Gherson: if you're Ukraine, you're attacked by Putin,
- 8:19Giles Gherson: you defend yourself,
- 8:21Giles Gherson: right?
- 8:22Giles Gherson: We're kind of being
- 8:22Giles Gherson: attacked by the U.S.
- 8:23Giles Gherson: I think it sounds like, it feels like we are.
- 8:27Giles Gherson: We can all know that we are
- 8:30Giles Gherson: economically,
- 8:31Giles Gherson: right?
- 8:32Giles Gherson: How are we defending ourselves?
- 8:34Brad Duguid: Well, let me move it to the double whammy because,
- 8:37Brad Duguid: yes,
- 8:38Brad Duguid: tariffs are a crisis situation.
- 8:40Brad Duguid: They're really challenging,
- 8:41Brad Duguid: and we're working through that.
- 8:43Brad Duguid: And we can't control a lot of that.
- 8:44Brad Duguid: I mean, government's trying to provide supports and things like that,
- 8:47Brad Duguid: but you can't control that.
- 8:49Brad Duguid: What you can control is your energy and electricity policy.
- 8:53Brad Duguid: And the challenge there is we're seeing electricity rates going up by 165 per cent.
- 8:59Giles Gherson: From when to when?
- 9:00Brad Duguid: Over the next three years.
- 9:01Giles Gherson: Okay.
- 9:01Brad Duguid: That's not my numbers.
- 9:02Giles Gherson: Has it started yet?
- 9:03Giles Gherson: Are you already seeing it?
- 9:04Brad Duguid: We're kind of into year one of that now.
- 9:05Giles Gherson: Okay.
- 9:06Brad Duguid: So last winter we saw the spikes in electricity going up double,
- 9:10Brad Duguid: triple,
- 9:11Brad Duguid: quadruple in some hours.
- 9:13Brad Duguid: Our electricity goes hour to hour.
- 9:14Giles Gherson: Yeah, so hour to hour.
- 9:15Giles Gherson: So you don't really see it over the long haul.
- 9:17Brad Duguid: No, but the average is definitely a steeper curve than we've ever seen.
- 9:21Brad Duguid: That's untenable.
- 9:23Brad Duguid: So you're asking these industries that are fighting for their economic survival,
- 9:29Brad Duguid: fighting to try to be competitive in that geopolitical environment,
- 9:33Brad Duguid: to also have to endure untenable electricity cost increases.
- 9:39Brad Duguid: It's just not viable or possible.
- 9:43Brad Duguid: The key there is that's something we do have control over.
- 9:46Brad Duguid: But,
- 9:46Giles Gherson: Brad, so we know we've got a government in Ontario that has said,
- 9:51Giles Gherson: and I think I believe them, has wanted to bring electricity prices down.
- 9:55Giles Gherson: They understand the problem,
- 9:56Giles Gherson: right?
- 9:57Giles Gherson: And yet what we're seeing is energy prices rise, as you say, in some ways looking to surge.
- 10:03Giles Gherson: Why? Why? What's happening at the same time as tariffs?
- 10:09Brad Duguid: Well, this is not a finger-pointing exercise. No, the price increases aren't about incompetence anywhere. It's about the reality
- 10:15Brad Duguid: of our electricity system. And as I used to say when I was Energy Minister, power costs money.
- 10:23Brad Duguid: Reliable power costs money. You can't deny that. Right now, we've got both a short-term
- 10:29Brad Duguid: term and a long term problem.
- 10:31Brad Duguid: The short term problem,
- 10:32Brad Duguid: a little complicated,
- 10:34Brad Duguid: but right now,
- 10:35Brad Duguid: over the next five to seven years, we're refurbishing a lot of our nuclear units.
- 10:38Brad Duguid: Pickering B is kind of going off as we speak. Just now. Just the last few days.
- 10:43Brad Duguid: And that takes a big
- 10:45Brad Duguid: chunk of lower-cost power because it's been there so long.
- 10:51Brad Duguid: The prices are fixed.
- 10:53Brad Duguid: The day-to-day
- 10:54Brad Duguid: prices of running nuclear are not as high.
- 10:56Brad Duguid: It's the capital costs that are higher,
- 10:58Brad Duguid: but that's
- 10:59Brad Duguid: through global adjustment and other things.
- 11:01Brad Duguid: So that's what we've got to replace.
- 11:03Brad Duguid: I think it creates a huge gap.
- 11:05Brad Duguid: The only thing,
- 11:06Brad Duguid: not the only thing,
- 11:07Brad Duguid: but the primary thing we have to replace that with is natural gas.
- 11:11Brad Duguid: That comes in at the highest margin level.
- 11:14Brad Duguid: And that's what's jacking market rates up
- 11:18Brad Duguid: over the next five to seven years.
- 11:21Giles Gherson: And isn't it we used to use natural gas,
- 11:22Giles Gherson: I mean,
- 11:23Giles Gherson: typically because nuclear is such a big part of our base load.
- 11:25Giles Gherson: We got hydro as well.
- 11:27Giles Gherson: But natural gas was kind of peaking fuel, right?
- 11:29Brad Duguid: Yes, ideal for peaking.
- 11:30Giles Gherson: Ideal for peaking.
- 11:30Brad Duguid: You can turn it up and down easy.
- 11:32Giles Gherson: But now it's going to be base load.
- 11:33Giles Gherson: Is that not right?
- 11:34Brad Duguid: Now it is in base load and will be for a very long time.
- 11:37Brad Duguid: And there's no alternative to that.
- 11:39Brad Duguid: So that's why we're concerned about the short term.
- 11:42Brad Duguid: And we'll talk a little bit maybe later about some of the things AMPCO's working with government on to try to mitigate that.
- 11:49Brad Duguid: But the other issue,
- 11:50Brad Duguid: when we get into long term,
- 11:52Brad Duguid: we can talk about that as well,
- 11:54Brad Duguid: is we've got electrification coming our way.
- 11:57Brad Duguid: And yeah, people say, 'Oh, Trump paused it and it's slowing down.'
- 12:01Brad Duguid: Electrification's coming fast and it's coming our way.
- 12:03Brad Duguid: And it's gradual, gradual,
- 12:05Brad Duguid: and then boom,
- 12:06Brad Duguid: it's going to hit.
- 12:07Brad Duguid: And that's transportation,
- 12:08Brad Duguid: that's buildings,
- 12:09Brad Duguid: that's industrial,
- 12:11Brad Duguid: among other things.
- 12:12Brad Duguid: Electric vehicles will probably, at some point, become a much larger part of transportation.
- 12:16Brad Duguid: There's no question.
- 12:18Brad Duguid: It's all coming our way.
- 12:19Brad Duguid: And then you've got data centres coming into the mix.
- 12:22Brad Duguid: We're going to need,
- 12:23Brad Duguid: I think it's very conservative to say 65% more power by 2050.
- 12:29Brad Duguid: I think it's probably double or more.
- 12:31Giles Gherson: Well, I mean, I think the Independent Electricity System Operator and I think the government,
- 12:33Giles Gherson: you know, Minister Lecce, who I think is really seized of this, right?
- 12:37Giles Gherson: He's doing everything he can to go, we've got to start building.
- 12:40Giles Gherson: I think that's been one of the real strong points of this government is they really grabbed onto the need to grow the energy grid, almost double it by 2050.
- 12:48Giles Gherson: But to your point,
- 12:49Giles Gherson: that's not a cheap exercise.
- 12:51Brad Duguid: It's costly.
- 12:52Brad Duguid: And you're not going to see AMPCO say that we shouldn't be making these investments.
- 12:56Giles Gherson: No, absolutely not.
- 12:57Brad Duguid: Because reliable power is just as important to our members as cost.
- 13:02Brad Duguid: But we're talking about $30 billion over the next five years in just nuclear.
- 13:09Brad Duguid: And that only includes one of the four small modular reactors.
- 13:13Brad Duguid: That doesn't include the new nuclear that they're talking about.
- 13:16Brad Duguid: That doesn't include transmission,
- 13:18Brad Duguid: the hundreds of billions of dollars that are going to have to be invested in transmission.
- 13:23Brad Duguid: So I would estimate between now and, say, the next 25 years, you're probably looking at half a trillion dollars,
- 13:30Brad Duguid: maybe more,
- 13:31Brad Duguid: in infrastructure that's going to have to be built.
- 13:33Brad Duguid: And it doesn't include smart grid and modernization.
- 13:37Brad Duguid: So all of that,
- 13:38Brad Duguid: nor does it include local distribution,
- 13:41Brad Duguid: which all has to be upgraded.
- 13:42Giles Gherson: Which is a big, big issue here in Toronto in particular.
- 13:44Brad Duguid: So those investments have to be made.
- 13:46Brad Duguid: The question is,
- 13:47Brad Duguid: How in God's name are we going to pay for them, Giles?
- 13:50Brad Duguid: And you can't,
- 13:51Brad Duguid: ratepayers,
- 13:52Brad Duguid: whether it's residential or industrial,
- 13:55Brad Duguid: won't be able to shoulder that full burden.
- 13:57Giles Gherson: Well, there's no point building it.
- 13:58Giles Gherson: I mean, basically,
- 13:59Giles Gherson: right, if you can't build competitively priced power,
- 14:01Giles Gherson: there's no point having it because no one's going to use it or want to use it.
- 14:04Giles Gherson: So the trick is, as you said, reliable power,
- 14:08Giles Gherson: as much as you need, right?
- 14:10Giles Gherson: Available power.
- 14:11Giles Gherson: And at a price that's competitive with other jurisdictions around us,
- 14:15Giles Gherson: or we won't have any need for it because people won't be able to build here.
- 14:19Brad Duguid: Well,
- 14:20Brad Duguid: and if deindustrialization does, not to be negative,
- 14:23Brad Duguid: but it's very risky.
- 14:24Brad Duguid: It'll take a big load off of it.
- 14:26Brad Duguid: If deindustrialization,
- 14:26Brad Duguid: even reduced industry in Ontario occurs,
- 14:30Brad Duguid: a lot of the building we're doing could end up being stranded assets.
- 14:34Brad Duguid: And guess what happens when those big industries leave?
- 14:37Brad Duguid: The cost is still there.
- 14:39Giles Gherson: Yeah, yeah, you're still using it.
- 14:39Brad Duguid: So now you spread that cost out among less people,
- 14:42Brad Duguid: more residential costs and more costs to the businesses that are still here.
- 14:46Brad Duguid: No, that's a perfect storm.
- 14:48Giles Gherson: It is a perfect storm.
- 14:50Giles Gherson: So we need to avoid the perfect storm.
- 14:52Giles Gherson: Let's do that.
- 14:52Giles Gherson: So what we're saying is we've got this big energy,
- 14:55Giles Gherson: we've got this big nuclear bill coming,
- 14:57Giles Gherson: and I have to say at the Board of Trade we are avidly supporting
- 15:01Giles Gherson: that the government's move towards the nuclear build,
- 15:04Giles Gherson: in part,
- 15:05Giles Gherson: because we know we need the
- 15:06Giles Gherson: electricity by 2050.
- 15:08Giles Gherson: We need to grow our industry,
- 15:09Giles Gherson: getting through the mess we're in currently.
- 15:11Giles Gherson: But we also believe that electrification clearly is happening,
- 15:16Giles Gherson: and we can't afford to
- 15:17Giles Gherson: stand aside from that. We need to be fully part of that as an economy.
- 15:21Giles Gherson: But then you've also got
- 15:22Giles Gherson: the issue of making sure that, as we say, that it's going to be priced at the right price.
- 15:29Giles Gherson: And so back to what we were saying about what you are thinking and your members,
- 15:35Giles Gherson: how can you help the government thread the needle here?
- 15:40Brad Duguid: Well, there's two things we should touch on,
- 15:42Brad Duguid: and I'll respond to the short term first.
- 15:46Brad Duguid: Because if we don't make it through the short term,
- 15:47Brad Duguid: the long term is not going to matter for the industry.
- 15:50Brad Duguid: John Maynard Keynes
- 15:51Brad Duguid: said, 'In the long run, we're all dead.'
- 15:52Giles Gherson: That's right.
- 15:55Brad Duguid: The next five to seven years,
- 15:56Brad Duguid: as I said, are going to be very, very challenging.
- 15:59Brad Duguid: The rates are jacking up to a point where they're untenable.
- 16:03Brad Duguid: So we need some kind of rate mitigation.
- 16:06Brad Duguid: And I was in government long enough to know that when you go to government with solutions,
- 16:11Brad Duguid: you've got to make sure that they're doable,
- 16:13Brad Duguid: that they're implementable,
- 16:15Brad Duguid: and that they're affordable if you really want to get them through.
- 16:18Brad Duguid: So AMPCO worked very,
- 16:20Brad Duguid: very hard.
- 16:20Brad Duguid: And I get the government credit and I get the ministry credit.
- 16:25Brad Duguid: It took us a while to convince them that the problem was as bad as it was.
- 16:28Giles Gherson: And that's part of government relations.
- 16:29Brad Duguid: Well,
- 16:30Brad Duguid: when you're on the outside,
- 16:31Brad Duguid: that's how you'd feel at first.
- 16:31Brad Duguid: And they've got lots of other things going on.
- 16:33Brad Duguid: But,
- 16:34Brad Duguid: you know, it took us a while.
- 16:34Brad Duguid: But they really, they understand it.
- 16:37Brad Duguid: The minister gets it,
- 16:38Brad Duguid: which is really important.
- 16:40Brad Duguid: The ministry gets it,
- 16:42Brad Duguid: which is really important.
- 16:43Brad Duguid: And they've set up a working group to work with AMPCO on solutions.
- 16:46Giles Gherson: Oh, good.
- 16:46Brad Duguid: And we've come forward with some, what I think are very viable ideas.
- 16:51Brad Duguid: It's all about mitigation.
- 16:53Brad Duguid: There's no other way around it.
- 16:55Brad Duguid: You have to mitigate these increases so that businesses and industry will survive that period.
- 17:01Giles Gherson: Does mitigation mean just spreading it out, or does it mean absolutely moving the cost to some other place?
- 17:06Brad Duguid: You could do it in a lot of ways,
- 17:08Brad Duguid: but one of the ways we've traditionally solved energy issues for industry has been to squeeze the balloon to other ratepayers.
- 17:16Brad Duguid: We're trying not to do that because that's not politically viable,
- 17:20Brad Duguid: especially today.
- 17:20Brad Duguid: But when you have a cost-of-living
- 17:22Brad Duguid: sort of crisis going on,
- 17:24Brad Duguid: There's no government.
- 17:25Brad Duguid: It could be the right economic thing to do, but no government's going to do that.
- 17:28Brad Duguid: I wouldn't do it if I was in government.
- 17:30Giles Gherson: I get it.
- 17:31Brad Duguid: It's about taking some of the costs currently in the system where there's going to be some savings.
- 17:37Brad Duguid: And we've identified about half a billion to a billion and a half dollars of savings the government's going to see.
- 17:44Brad Duguid: As the energy system restructures,
- 17:46Brad Duguid: this gets too technical,
- 17:48Brad Duguid: but global adjustment is down.
- 17:50Brad Duguid: There's a program called the Comprehensive Electricity Plan that helps offset costs to some of those renewable costs to business.
- 18:00Brad Duguid: The government's going to save about half a billion to a billion and a half dollars per year over the next number of years while global adjustment's down.
- 18:08Giles Gherson: Okay.
- 18:08Brad Duguid: Because they won't have to, that program offsets global adjustment.
- 18:13Brad Duguid: So all we're saying is repurpose that into a program that works for finance,
- 18:18Brad Duguid: works for the government,
- 18:19Brad Duguid: that helps bring those costs down.
- 18:22Brad Duguid: And, you know, make sure that financing is not open-ended.
- 18:26Brad Duguid: Make sure that businesses that don't need it don't have to get it, that it's based on the fluctuating market rate.
- 18:32Brad Duguid: We've designed a mechanism that we think could successfully do that.
- 18:37Giles Gherson: And for a period of time then,
- 18:39Giles Gherson: we're confident the global adjustment will remain lower for a period of time.
- 18:45Giles Gherson: It'll presumably come back up at a certain point.
- 18:46Brad Duguid: Oh, it's going to come back up.
- 18:47Brad Duguid: When all those nuclear costs you talked about kick in,
- 18:50Brad Duguid: probably from 2030 out, it'll start coming back up.
- 18:54Giles Gherson: So you've got a four-year period now here?
- 18:55Brad Duguid: It's about a four-year period where industry is really hurting.
- 19:00Brad Duguid: Now is not the time to take that half a billion or a billion and a half dollars out of industry
- 19:05Brad Duguid: and spend it somewhere else or put it to the deficit,
- 19:07Brad Duguid: now's the time to try to keep these guys alive,
- 19:10Brad Duguid: keep them here creating jobs.
- 19:12Giles Gherson: So this will undercut the power costs,
- 19:15Giles Gherson: right?
- 19:16Giles Gherson: But what about your natural gas, this problem with natural gas,
- 19:18Giles Gherson: which we all know we need, you know,
- 19:20Giles Gherson: and the natural gas suppliers here are working very hard,
- 19:24Giles Gherson: we know,
- 19:25Giles Gherson: and they've done a pretty good job.
- 19:26Giles Gherson: But how do you kind of address that issue?
- 19:31Giles Gherson: The one thing that comes to my mind is,
- 19:34Giles Gherson: We've got a carbon tax here, an industrial carbon tax.
- 19:36Giles Gherson: The U.S. does not have.
- 19:37Giles Gherson: So your companies,
- 19:39Giles Gherson: their competitors in the U.S.,
- 19:42Giles Gherson: not only with tariffs now,
- 19:44Giles Gherson: but also we've got an industrial carbon tax,
- 19:47Giles Gherson: which,
- 19:47Giles Gherson: of course, is designed to help us move towards a greener grid.
- 19:52Giles Gherson: But we are moving to a greener grid.
- 19:53Giles Gherson: That's the whole point of the nuclear bill.
- 19:55Giles Gherson: That's the whole point of the Pickering refurbishment.
- 19:59Giles Gherson: So why are we paying double,
- 20:00Giles Gherson: in a sense?
- 20:01Brad Duguid: Well, there's an irony to this.
- 20:02Giles Gherson: Yeah.
- 20:03Brad Duguid: And that's that the way it's currently being applied to gas generators in Ontario has a detrimental impact on the business case for investment in electrification technology for industry.
- 20:16Brad Duguid: So let me explain that a little bit.
- 20:19Brad Duguid: The carbon price that natural gas generators in Ontario have to pay gets pushed into the market rate.
- 20:27Brad Duguid: So the market price.
- 20:29Brad Duguid: So industry is paying this extra cost.
- 20:32Brad Duguid: When Ontario has other options other than natural gas,
- 20:35Brad Duguid: okay,
- 20:36Brad Duguid: it's an incentive for Ontario to invest in those other options.
- 20:39Brad Duguid: So you could argue that even though it's a competitive disadvantage,
- 20:43Brad Duguid: it does get you making the right decisions on the environmental side.
- 20:47Brad Duguid: Today, as we speak over the next five to seven years,
- 20:50Brad Duguid: if Ontario is not running its natural gas plants full out,
- 20:54Brad Duguid: we're not going to have enough power to meet demand,
- 20:56Brad Duguid: plain and simple.
- 20:57Brad Duguid: So they have no choice.
- 20:59Brad Duguid: There's no incentive in this carbon tax right now.
- 21:02Brad Duguid: There's no environmental benefit to it whatsoever.
- 21:05Brad Duguid: It is a straight cost pass-through to industry.
- 21:09Brad Duguid: The ironic piece of this is...
- 21:10Giles Gherson: And they can't avoid it.
- 21:11Brad Duguid: No, they can't avoid it.
- 21:13Brad Duguid: There's nothing they can do to avoid it.
- 21:15Brad Duguid: And industry in this province are investing significantly in electrification.
- 21:19Giles Gherson: Well, that's my point, yeah.
- 21:20Brad Duguid: So now you're making the business case more difficult for them
- 21:23Brad Duguid: because you're putting up the operating costs for them
- 21:26Brad Duguid: to operate their new technology.
- 21:30Brad Duguid: which dissuades them from making these investments.
- 21:33Brad Duguid: So that's the case we're taking to Ottawa
- 21:37Brad Duguid: to get Ottawa to understand
- 21:39Brad Duguid: this is not an anti-carbon tax rant.
- 21:41Brad Duguid: This is just a policy that right now,
- 21:44Brad Duguid: because of the conditions,
- 21:46Brad Duguid: because of the way Ontario's electricity system
- 21:48Brad Duguid: is structured,
- 21:49Brad Duguid: isn't working.
- 21:50Brad Duguid: So let's fix it.
- 21:51Giles Gherson: And your fundamental point is that
- 21:54Giles Gherson: if the whole point of the industrial carbon tax
- 21:56Giles Gherson: when it was put in place
- 21:57Giles Gherson: was to incentivize the shift to green energy.
- 22:02Giles Gherson: In fact, the reason we need to use more natural gas right now
- 22:07Giles Gherson: is because we are making the shift to green energy,
- 22:10Giles Gherson: to nuclear,
- 22:11Giles Gherson: but it's taking a fair bit of time.
- 22:13Giles Gherson: And in the meantime,
- 22:14Giles Gherson: we have to use more natural gas.
- 22:15Giles Gherson: And so it's kind of raising the cost of,
- 22:17Giles Gherson: you could say it's raising the cost of capital for business.
- 22:19Brad Duguid: A hundred per cent.
- 22:21Brad Duguid: And the benefit to industry would be about $2.6 billion over five years.
- 22:27Brad Duguid: Game changer?
- 22:29Brad Duguid: No.
- 22:29Giles Gherson: Maybe not.
- 22:29Brad Duguid: Yeah.
- 22:30Brad Duguid: Impactful?
- 22:31Giles Gherson: Yes.
- 22:32Brad Duguid: Damn right.
- 22:32Brad Duguid: I mean,
- 22:33Brad Duguid: especially during these hard economic times.
- 22:35Giles Gherson: So that would seem to be a slam dunk in the logic of what you're saying.
- 22:38Brad Duguid: Well,
- 22:38Brad Duguid: there's not a lot of disagreement at the provincial level on doing something like this.
- 22:43Giles Gherson: That's a federal piece, though.
- 22:44Brad Duguid: Well,
- 22:46Brad Duguid: the province has the ability to make the decision,
- 22:49Brad Duguid: but they need to work with the federal government, which has the guiding legislation over top of that.
- 22:54Brad Duguid: But the premier has taken a step further,
- 22:56Brad Duguid: and you're probably aware of this.
- 22:58Brad Duguid: He wrote a letter to the prime minister a week or two ago suggesting that maybe they should take the carbon tax temporarily,
- 23:08Brad Duguid: a hiatus of the carbon tax on tariff-impacted industries in Ontario while this economic situation is going on.
- 23:16Giles Gherson: That makes a lot of sense.
- 23:17Brad Duguid: Well,
- 23:18Brad Duguid: I think it's a practical suggestion.
- 23:21Brad Duguid: I understand that this is an important policy.
- 23:24Brad Duguid: Environmentally, for the federal government.
- 23:27Brad Duguid: And at this point,
- 23:29Brad Duguid: there's discussions going on
- 23:30Brad Duguid: between the two levels of government.
- 23:32Brad Duguid: I really hope they can work that out
- 23:34Brad Duguid: because that would be substantial,
- 23:35Brad Duguid: not to all of our members.
- 23:37Brad Duguid: We would still need the mitigation.
- 23:39Brad Duguid: We would still need to take the carbon price
- 23:41Brad Duguid: temporarily off of natural gas
- 23:44Brad Duguid: because there's a lot of industry
- 23:46Brad Duguid: that wouldn't benefit directly
- 23:47Brad Duguid: or might not qualify for that.
- 23:49Brad Duguid: But it would be very impactful
- 23:51Brad Duguid: to some of our steel industries for sure.
- 23:53Giles Gherson: Well, and they're right in the crosshairs,
- 23:55Giles Gherson: right?
- 23:56Brad Duguid: Yes.
- 23:56Brad Duguid: Both of those.
- 23:56Brad Duguid: Yeah.
- 23:57Brad Duguid: So we're hoping the government's going to work something out.
- 23:59Giles Gherson: So there's two things.
- 24:00Giles Gherson: Now,
- 24:00Giles Gherson: one thing that I know that some people have discussed is Ontario, as you said, is
- 24:05Giles Gherson: going to be,
- 24:05Giles Gherson: unfortunately,
- 24:06Giles Gherson: at the moment, facing increasingly uncompetitive energy costs.
- 24:10Giles Gherson: In the north,
- 24:11Giles Gherson: there's a special industrial rate, the northern industrial rate,
- 24:14Giles Gherson: which has
- 24:14Giles Gherson: been around for a long time.
- 24:16Giles Gherson: And it's a reduced rate,
- 24:18Giles Gherson: essentially,
- 24:19Giles Gherson: essentially, a discounted rate for energy in the north because
- 24:21Giles Gherson: it's recognized that the North is a harsher operating environment,
- 24:25Giles Gherson: longer distance to travel, products
- 24:27Giles Gherson: to move south,
- 24:28Giles Gherson: and so on.
- 24:29Giles Gherson: So it gets this discounted rate.
- 24:30Giles Gherson: And that rate, in my understanding,
- 24:32Giles Gherson: is a relatively competitive North American rate,
- 24:35Giles Gherson: right?
- 24:36Giles Gherson: I've heard some people say,
- 24:39Giles Gherson: why wouldn't we try at this moment in time,
- 24:41Giles Gherson: for a period of time,
- 24:42Giles Gherson: apply that northern industrial
- 24:44Giles Gherson: rate to heavy industry,
- 24:47Giles Gherson: large industry in general,
- 24:49Giles Gherson: your members,
- 24:50Giles Gherson: for a period of time to enable them
- 24:53Giles Gherson: to have a more competitive rate on their power. It doesn't mean you don't need to do what
- 24:58Giles Gherson: you've just said, but at least on the electricity rate.
- 25:01Giles Gherson: Now, that will cost the government some
- 25:03Giles Gherson: money, so maybe that's the problem with it. I assume it is.
- 25:05Giles Gherson: But is that still a possibility?
- 25:08Brad Duguid: Well,
- 25:08Brad Duguid: it would cost them money if they were trying to fund it out of general tax revenues.
- 25:14Brad Duguid: But if they fund it temporarily out of the savings from the comprehensive electricity plan,
- 25:20Brad Duguid: then it would not cost them additional money.
- 25:22Brad Duguid: So it would be a balance there.
- 25:23Brad Duguid: They would just repurpose that funding for a temporary period of time.
- 25:27Brad Duguid: And that Northern Energy Advantage Program,
- 25:32Brad Duguid: NEAP,
- 25:33Brad Duguid: which I brought in under NIER when I was minister, believe it or not, back in the day.
- 25:37Giles Gherson: So you know it well.
- 25:38Brad Duguid: So I know it well.
- 25:39Brad Duguid: And it's been effective.
- 25:40Brad Duguid: Government likes it.
- 25:42Brad Duguid: The ministry likes it.
- 25:43Brad Duguid: It's easy to administer.
- 25:45Brad Duguid: And to be frank,
- 25:46Brad Duguid: that was the model that we're proposing.
- 25:48Giles Gherson: Okay.
- 25:48Brad Duguid: With some differences to give the government a little less exposure.
- 25:53Brad Duguid: We're looking at, you know, you can gear it to, you know,
- 25:57Brad Duguid: provide the subsidy when the prices are above a competitive level
- 26:01Brad Duguid: and subsidize based on that.
- 26:03Brad Duguid: But they're already above a competitive level,
- 26:04Giles Gherson: aren't they?
- 26:04Brad Duguid: They are right now.
- 26:06Giles Gherson: Okay.
- 26:06Brad Duguid: But,
- 26:08Brad Duguid: you know, some of the other things they do,
- 26:09Brad Duguid: if that brings it down,
- 26:11Brad Duguid: then...
- 26:12Brad Duguid: They won't be required.
- 26:13Brad Duguid: then yeah,
- 26:13Brad Duguid: use it if you need it.
- 26:16Brad Duguid: We're not looking for direct subsidy for industry
- 26:20Brad Duguid: for the sake of subsidy.
- 26:21Brad Duguid: We're looking just to help them keep their heads above the water.
- 26:23Giles Gherson: Well, you're trying to get through the night.
- 26:24Brad Duguid: Yeah,
- 26:24Brad Duguid: that's exactly it.
- 26:25Giles Gherson: And that's really what it is.
- 26:26Giles Gherson: And if we don't get through the night,
- 26:28Giles Gherson: then this economy will be very different.
- 26:29Giles Gherson: At the Board, we've been looking hard at,
- 26:33Giles Gherson: actually we did in economic development in the ministry,
- 26:36Giles Gherson: look at GDP per capita.
- 26:37Giles Gherson: And people say, arcane, but it's really income per capita,
- 26:40Giles Gherson: like income per person in the province.
- 26:43Giles Gherson: And we've been going down like this.
- 26:45Giles Gherson: And again, it's nobody's fault,
- 26:46Giles Gherson: but it's been one of these sort of slides compared to the U.S.
- 26:50Giles Gherson: But we looked at the Greater Toronto and Hamilton Area,
- 26:52Giles Gherson: so the Greater Toronto Area plus Hamilton.
- 26:54Giles Gherson: We brought in Boston Consulting Group, and we said, okay,
- 26:56Giles Gherson: look at the income per capita in the Greater Toronto and Hamilton Area.
- 26:59Giles Gherson: How does that compare to big U.S. cities,
- 27:02Giles Gherson: big metropolitan areas in the U.S.?
- 27:04Giles Gherson: They came back, and we all fell out of our chairs.
- 27:06Giles Gherson: I mean, they said literally as of last year,
- 27:10Giles Gherson: $100,000 per person gap.
- 27:14Giles Gherson: We're poorer,
- 27:15Giles Gherson: literally.
- 27:15Giles Gherson: Our output is $100,000 less per person than 11 major U.S. cities.
- 27:21Giles Gherson: And that's as far as you really want to go because when you actually looked at specific U.S. cities,
- 27:26Giles Gherson: my God,
- 27:27Giles Gherson: like the gap was even larger.
- 27:28Giles Gherson: You know,
- 27:29Giles Gherson: like San Francisco,
- 27:30Giles Gherson: you know, they were at about $500,000 to our $113,000.
- 27:33Giles Gherson: You know, like massive gap,
- 27:35Giles Gherson: much richer than we are.
- 27:36Giles Gherson: And so we became concerned about then our industrial base.
- 27:40Giles Gherson: You know, if we let that slide, these are high-value industries with high-value jobs.
- 27:44Giles Gherson: And you lose that at your peril because you start replacing those jobs with service jobs.
- 27:49Giles Gherson: That's how your GDP per capita goes down.
- 27:52Giles Gherson: And so for us, we kind of think it's a crisis that needs to be addressed.
- 27:56Brad Duguid: Well, I agree.
- 27:58Brad Duguid: And deindustrialization doesn't happen all at once.
- 28:01Giles Gherson: Oh, it's a long, slow.
- 28:02Brad Duguid: It's a trickle because these plants are what they call sticky assets.
- 28:06Brad Duguid: They put a lot into building the plants.
- 28:09Brad Duguid: Companies are generally hesitant to move them because they've got a lot of stranded assets there if they do decide to leave.
- 28:18Brad Duguid: But when you get to this point where deindustrialization starts to happen,
- 28:22Brad Duguid: it's one manufacturing mandate decision at a time.
- 28:26Brad Duguid: And we're seeing that we're losing those.
- 28:28Brad Duguid: It's one plant investment at a time, which is really important for competitiveness.
- 28:34Giles Gherson: Well,
- 28:34Giles Gherson: that's right. I mean, what we've been looking at is you've got the plant, as you say, been there for a long time,
- 28:38Giles Gherson: could be there for many more years.
- 28:40Giles Gherson: Then the question is, what technology are you using to manufacture the product you're making,
- 28:44Giles Gherson: right?
- 28:45Giles Gherson: And,
- 28:45Giles Gherson: you know, you look at the massive advancements in advanced robotics and, you know,
- 28:50Giles Gherson: the Internet of Things,
- 28:52Giles Gherson: you know, like the manufacturing process has really started to change with robotization and so on.
- 28:57Giles Gherson: All really good things in terms of actually helping people do things faster and better.
- 29:03Giles Gherson: But we've been really slow on this stuff.
- 29:05Giles Gherson: And again, if you're a business and you're under pressure,
- 29:08Giles Gherson: you're not going to make that investment.
- 29:10Giles Gherson: But then the problem is your workers have one hand tied behind their back compared to their American competitors.
- 29:16Giles Gherson: Forget tariffs.
- 29:17Giles Gherson: That's not even counting tariffs.
- 29:18Giles Gherson: Because you've got, you know, working away with like 20-year-old,
- 29:22Giles Gherson: 30-year-old equipment,
- 29:23Giles Gherson: and they're working with the latest equipment.
- 29:26Giles Gherson: And they can outrun you every time.
- 29:28Giles Gherson: And then how are you going to make your sales?
- 29:30Giles Gherson: How are you going to be profitable?
- 29:31Giles Gherson: All that stuff.
- 29:31Giles Gherson: So that's when they start to pull out,
- 29:33Giles Gherson: right?
- 29:33Brad Duguid: When the equipment gets really old.
- 29:34Brad Duguid: Boy, this discussion sounds familiar to me.
- 29:37Brad Duguid: It takes us back to our Queen's Park days when we fought really hard for the innovation economy
- 29:41Brad Duguid: and investing and leading in innovation and artificial intelligence.
- 29:44Brad Duguid: And look where it is now.
- 29:46Brad Duguid: It's stunning.
- 29:47Brad Duguid: It really is.
- 29:50Brad Duguid: But it's very challenging to those businesses if they're not getting those investment mandates.
- 29:56Brad Duguid: And the tragedy is these are really good businesses.
- 29:58Giles Gherson: I mean, I think we often forget.
- 30:00Giles Gherson: I mean, at the Board of Trade, but even at Economic Development, we would talk to manufacturers
- 30:04Giles Gherson: across the province all the time.
- 30:07Giles Gherson: And a lot of manufacturers have operations in the U.S. and other countries.
- 30:14Giles Gherson: And they will tell you all the time their best facilities in terms of the quality of
- 30:18Giles Gherson: their workforce is in Ontario.
- 30:20Giles Gherson: I've had one big company.
- 30:22Giles Gherson: I won't mention it, but we all know it.
- 30:24Giles Gherson: They have plants all around the world,
- 30:25Giles Gherson: based in Ontario.
- 30:27Giles Gherson: And they said, not too long ago, they said, our best plants are in Canada,
- 30:33Giles Gherson: the most efficient plants.
- 30:34Giles Gherson: The ones that really perform,
- 30:36Giles Gherson: better than Germany.
- 30:37Brad Duguid: Yeah.
- 30:38Giles Gherson: Better than the U.S.
- 30:40Giles Gherson: Better than the U.S. South.
- 30:41Giles Gherson: You know, go through the list.
- 30:43Giles Gherson: But we don't have the conditions for them to thrive.
- 30:46Brad Duguid: Doesn't matter.
- 30:47Brad Duguid: Yeah.
- 30:48Brad Duguid: And that's where electricity prices do come in.
- 30:50Brad Duguid: And people will say,
- 30:52Brad Duguid: well, how big of a deal?
- 30:53Brad Duguid: It's one expense.
- 30:54Brad Duguid: of a gazillion variables.
- 30:57Brad Duguid: Well, if you're a steel plant,
- 30:59Brad Duguid: it's 30% or 40% of your cost profile.
- 31:03Brad Duguid: That's huge.
- 31:04Brad Duguid: Compared to labor, which might be only 10%.
- 31:05Brad Duguid: Now, if you're an auto plant,
- 31:07Brad Duguid: remember we went through this in our day.
- 31:09Brad Duguid: If you're an auto plant,
- 31:10Brad Duguid: well, maybe it's 5% or 10%,
- 31:12Brad Duguid: but it's one of the few variables
- 31:14Brad Duguid: in the decision-making process for costs.
- 31:17Brad Duguid: So if your electricity costs
- 31:19Brad Duguid: are higher than a competing jurisdiction,
- 31:21Brad Duguid: you could very well lose a mandate
- 31:23Brad Duguid: just because of that.
- 31:25Brad Duguid: We saw that.
- 31:26Giles Gherson: And we saw it.
- 31:27Brad Duguid: We experienced it.
- 31:28Giles Gherson: What we don't want is to have it happen again to us, right?
- 31:30Giles Gherson: I mean, I think we lost a lot of manufacturing jobs
- 31:32Giles Gherson: between 2008 and 2020,
- 31:36Giles Gherson: in part because of electricity prices,
- 31:38Giles Gherson: funnily enough,
- 31:39Giles Gherson: as we look back on those days.
- 31:41Giles Gherson: And now we can't afford to lose another,
- 31:44Giles Gherson: I don't think we can lose another 200,000 manufacturing jobs.
- 31:47Giles Gherson: We'll be,
- 31:47Giles Gherson: I think, in a bad shape.
- 31:48Giles Gherson: So this is really important.
- 31:50Giles Gherson: You're doing God's work.
- 31:52Giles Gherson: I think this is really important from our perspective at the Board of Trade.
- 31:55Giles Gherson: We want to support you every which way.
- 31:58Giles Gherson: I know that Minister Lecce and I know Minister Fedeli will be with you,
- 32:04Giles Gherson: you know.
- 32:04Giles Gherson: But they've got to figure out can they make the financing work.
- 32:07Giles Gherson: That's going to be the issue for them.
- 32:08Giles Gherson: But you're making it easier than it would be.
- 32:11Brad Duguid: We've got to get action.
- 32:13Brad Duguid: And to quote Jon Snow from Game of Thrones,
- 32:16Brad Duguid: winter is coming.
- 32:18Brad Duguid: And last winter the peaks were unbelievable.
- 32:21Brad Duguid: This winter,
- 32:21Brad Duguid: we're coming into it without Pickering B.
- 32:25Giles Gherson: Yeah,
- 32:25Brad Duguid: and the natural gas.
- 32:27Brad Duguid: And the natural gas is up.
- 32:28Brad Duguid: And tariffs.
- 32:29Brad Duguid: It's going to be a really challenging winter.
- 32:32Brad Duguid: So my goal now is to convince,
- 32:36Brad Duguid: yes, we've got good ears at Queen's Park,
- 32:38Brad Duguid: but we need to maybe get something in the fall economic statement
- 32:42Brad Duguid: that addresses some of this because my members are really desperate
- 32:47Brad Duguid: for support heading into this winter.
- 32:49Brad Duguid: I don't know if they can survive another winter like we did last winter.
- 32:52Giles Gherson: Well, I mean, that's important to hear.
- 32:54Giles Gherson: I mean, and the other thing people need to remember is we've got a lot of companies that are based in Canada.
- 32:58Giles Gherson: We have a lot of companies that aren't based in Canada.
- 33:01Giles Gherson: And they're sitting in some office somewhere in the U.S., somewhere in Europe or wherever it might be.
- 33:08Giles Gherson: They're making hard-nosed decisions about, do I keep this plant?
- 33:11Giles Gherson: I've got all these plants in the world.
- 33:13Giles Gherson: Which ones do I keep open,
- 33:15Giles Gherson: which are competitive, which aren't?
- 33:16Giles Gherson: And we cannot,
- 33:17Giles Gherson: once they close the plant in Ontario,
- 33:20Giles Gherson: it's done.
- 33:21Giles Gherson: So I think this is the moment.
- 33:23Giles Gherson: So yeah, we'll be following this really closely.
- 33:25Giles Gherson: Great conversation, Brad.
- 33:26Giles Gherson: Thank you for coming in and having this conversation.
- 33:29Giles Gherson: I think it's a critical issue.
- 33:31Brad Duguid: Well, I agree.
- 33:32Brad Duguid: Thank you for the Toronto Region Board of Trade's leadership on this stuff.
- 33:37Brad Duguid: It's so important.
- 33:39Brad Duguid: You're an important voice at Queen's Park and in Ottawa.
- 33:41Brad Duguid: And when we're working together,
- 33:43Brad Duguid: we're a lot stronger,
- 33:46Brad Duguid: more powerful,
- 33:46Giles Gherson: and I think we're heard a lot louder.
- 33:49Giles Gherson: I think for all our listeners who believe in the strength of this economy and the beauty of living in Ontario,
- 33:56Giles Gherson: which we all love,
- 33:57Giles Gherson: we want our kids to live here and thrive here.
- 34:01Giles Gherson: This is really, really important stuff.
- 34:03Giles Gherson: Great.
- 34:04Giles Gherson: Keep the economy going.
- 34:04Giles Gherson: Thank you, Brad.
- 34:05Giles Gherson: Appreciate it.
- 34:06Giles Gherson: Thanks for listening to Toronto Talks, conversations with the leaders shaping the region's economy.
- 34:12Giles Gherson: Follow us wherever you get your podcasts.