Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 10 – The Death of Public School… It Sounds Serious! (Guest: Cara Fitzpatrick)
Transcript
- 0:00Andy: Cara Fitzpatrick, welcome to Wonky Folk.
- 0:03Cara: Thank you for having me.
- 0:04Andy: Yeah, it's great, and you're the last guest.
- 0:08Jed has been off, he is hiking in Spain, and he's been gone for a
- 0:12bit, and you're going to be the last guest before his triumphant return.
- 0:15I'm sure he'll be in a fantastic mood after that.
- 0:18I appreciate you taking the time.
- 0:20Hey, I always start like you're in New York, I know you live with
- 0:24your family, but just give us a little bit of the background.
- 0:27Where did you grow up?
- 0:29And how did you get into education?
- 0:32Cara: Oh, I grew up in Washington State, but in Eastern Washington,
- 0:36people always think Seattle.
- 0:39Eastern Washington is more like Idaho, not at all like Seattle, very conservative.
- 0:43Sort of rural farming a lot.
- 0:46And my mom is a public school teacher, retired now, and my
- 0:52sister is also a teacher in the same district where we grew up.
- 0:57And so I ended up writing about education, but had no interest in being a teacher.
- 1:02So I guess that's kind of how I got into it.
- 1:05Andy: Cool.
- 1:05What was school like for you?
- 1:08Like, mean...
- 1:08If your mom was a teacher, your sister was at a place you found
- 1:12gratification, validation, was school frustrating and hard?
- 1:14Like, what was your relationship with school?
- 1:17Cara: I don't think anyone has ever asked me that.
- 1:20I had a fine relationship with school.
- 1:23The area that we were in, like I said, was somewhat rural, so there
- 1:27were no sort of choices as we would think of them, you know, there is now
- 1:32more schools, but at that time there were maybe three elementary schools,
- 1:36a middle school, or as we called it, a junior high and then a high school.
- 1:40And so that, that was it.
- 1:42You know, that was sort of, those were your choices unless maybe you
- 1:46were going to drive a good distance.
- 1:48And so, you know, it was fine.
- 1:50There were things about it that were better and things that were
- 1:54worse, but it was overall fine.
- 1:57I mean, I didn't struggle in school, I guess.
- 2:00Andy: Good.
- 2:00So you say you basically, you enjoyed it.
- 2:02I have good feelings.
- 2:04Cara: Yeah.
- 2:04I mean, for the most part, you know, I think I was a smart kid.
- 2:09who was somewhat bored sometimes.
- 2:10And, for whatever reason, right around my junior and senior year of high school.
- 2:16They got rid of a lot of the AP classes, and so that did not help, but you know.
- 2:22Andy: Did they get rid of like budget cuts or for policy
- 2:26reasons what was behind that?
- 2:27Cara: I actually have no idea because I wasn't at all plugged into it.
- 2:31I just knew all of a sudden there were fewer honors classes to take.
- 2:35And that had been kind of the track I had been on.
- 2:37But, it never was raised as an issue of like, "oh, we
- 2:42could send her somewhere else.
- 2:44" There was nowhere else to go.
- 2:47So, you know, and my, my parents didn't have expectations of me
- 2:51leaving for college or doing any of those sorts of things.
- 2:54So it was just like, this is good.
- 2:55This is good enough.
- 2:57Andy: And did you leave for college?
- 2:58Were they shocked at that?
- 3:00Cara: I well, so I went to the University of Washington, which does
- 3:04not seem like a big, shocking move is it's in Seattle, but my parents
- 3:09were definitely opposed to that.
- 3:11Andy: Very different place makes me washington.
- 3:13Cara: Yeah, I actually had a couple of teachers tell me that I should not go to
- 3:17like the big city as they thought of it.
- 3:19And that I would die and no one would care because it was such a large school.
- 3:24And my parents and I had some disagreements about it my senior year.
- 3:29And ultimately the way I got around that was I applied to exactly one college,
- 3:32which was the University of Washington.
- 3:34And I said, if you want me to go, this is the school that I've gotten
- 3:37into because I applied nowhere else.
- 3:39So, that was my creative way of getting what I wanted.
- 3:44Andy: You're lucky to live in a state with a school like UW.
- 3:46It's a great school.
- 3:47Cara: It is a good school.
- 3:49Andy: Okay, that's interesting.
- 3:50I always ask people that because I find in the sector, and this is a bit of a gross
- 3:54overgeneralization, there's certainly exceptions, but in general, like, You
- 3:57find people who either they really love school and they found like a lot of
- 4:00validation there And that's why they work in education because it's an area They've
- 4:04always felt good or they really didn't like it for whatever reason they felt,
- 4:08you know excluded or marginalized or they really struggled they weren't good at it
- 4:12and so like they're in this career because they're trying to fix it, and they're
- 4:15like trying to change it so others don't have that experience and people often
- 4:19I find fall in those two broad buckets.
- 4:22You do get some people who are just like yeah, they're more rare.
- 4:26Cara: I was going to say I might be in the rare bucket.
- 4:28Andy: That's good.
- 4:29You're rare.
- 4:30That's really heavier.
- 4:31So, we can look, we can talk about your biography all afternoon, but the
- 4:35reason we've got you here is because you have a new book out, The Death of
- 4:40Public School, which sounds ominous.
- 4:43And so I figured we'd better have you on because that sounds very serious.
- 4:47Cara: I have a friend who lives in Mexico actually.
- 4:50And she had a hard time, you know, getting the book to Mexico.
- 4:53And then she showed it to her daughter.
- 4:55Who's in elementary school.
- 4:56And she said, is it a scary book?
- 4:59Andy: So.
- 5:00You tell me.
- 5:02Is it a scary?
- 5:04Cara: I mean, it's kind of on point, right?
- 5:06Halloween is tomorrow.
- 5:07No, I mean, I think it has a provocative title, it's not actually what the
- 5:14original title was, but I, I, you know...
- 5:18Andy: I have to pause you there.
- 5:18So this is always it.
- 5:19What did you want to call it?
- 5:22Cara: So, the original title that I sort of, you know, sold the book proposal
- 5:28with was The Unholy Alliance or Unholy Alliance, which is a Paul Williams quote.
- 5:33It ends up being a chapter, a couple of titles.
- 5:37And I just really liked.
- 5:39That Paul Williams quote, because I thought it spoke to so many
- 5:41different sort of political weird alliances in school choice, but for
- 5:47selling a book to audiences that aren't familiar with the subject.
- 5:52It could be anything, you know, so the conversation we had was it could be a
- 5:57history of like the Catholic Church It could be some kind of Roman Empire thing.
- 6:01It didn't say education.
- 6:04Andy: Apparently we all do you think about the Roman Empire a lot.
- 6:06Cara: Yes, that's a thing right now.
- 6:08So yeah, it didn't necessarily make a ton of sense as jumping out about education
- 6:14And then a lot of people don't also know what school choice is, and so that was
- 6:18in the subtitle, so we kind of had this conversation where we went around in
- 6:24circles, but we're ultimately what is this about, you know, and it's sort of this
- 6:28question about whether or not the school choice movement erases or, you know,
- 6:34gets rid of public schools or if it just sort of changes what public education is.
- 6:40And so that's where we came down.
- 6:43Andy: Look.
- 6:44It's definitely a catchy title.
- 6:45It's going to make people buy it because it's alarming.
- 6:47I do think Unholy Alliance because it's a good title because
- 6:50you get into a lot of history.
- 6:51That's not so told.
- 6:53I mean, I think the sort of history on the right and school vouchers is like
- 6:59a tool of segregation and so forth.
- 7:00We hear a lot about that, particularly lately.
- 7:03You hear a lot less about sort of the new left and you get into Chris
- 7:06Jenks and Jack Coons and Ted Coldery.
- 7:09And, I just had dinner with Ted about a week and a half ago or so.
- 7:13Cara: Oh, did you?
- 7:14Andy: Yeah, there's, I mean, like, these are people who, like, came
- 7:17at this from a totally different Perspective and that often is minimized
- 7:22and sort of how people tell the story.
- 7:23So Unholly Alliance seems good because I think you did a nice job getting
- 7:27into the more complicated history.
- 7:29Cara: Yeah.
- 7:29I mean, that's what was attractive to me about it was sort of this idea of
- 7:33all of these different people from very different backgrounds sort of being
- 7:37interested in the same sort of tool or mechanism, but with very different
- 7:41intentions and the idea they overlap.
- 7:44You know that some of these people that you would have Christopher Jenks
- 7:47at the same time that you would have segregationists, you know, I thought
- 7:50that was so interesting and you never hear that, you know, you rarely hear
- 7:54about that, that aspect of things.
- 7:55So, but yeah, as a title, it just, it had to go to a chapter title.
- 8:00Andy: And you get into one of the things I thought was interesting to get
- 8:02into is saying, I'll still hear about a lot is the alum rock demonstration
- 8:05project and sort of that, you know, they actually tried to put some of
- 8:08these ideas, some of Jenks's ideas into practice during the Nixon administration.
- 8:13And they tried to do it.
- 8:17As you were writing the book, were you surprised?
- 8:19Were you like learning about this stuff or was this like a story you were familiar
- 8:25with and you felt like should be told?
- 8:27Cause I just think like, it's a part of the book I really liked.
- 8:30It's a history that if you watched everybody's trying to rip each
- 8:33other's face off on Twitter around this, like seemingly very ignorant
- 8:36of this complicated history.
- 8:38And so I liked that you got into it.
- 8:40So like, I guess my question is, what was that like for you?
- 8:44Cara: Well, so I knew pieces of it.
- 8:46I knew pieces of the story from being an education reporter.
- 8:50I didn't know a lot of things.
- 8:52I had heard of alum rock.
- 8:54I knew, you know, Little, little bits about things, but I didn't know all the
- 8:59ins and outs, and I think, you know, I also, I knew pieces from either a for or
- 9:07against choice sort of standpoint, you know, so if you're, if you're for choice,
- 9:12maybe you talk about Milton Friedman, and you talk about Jack Coons, and you know,
- 9:16you talk about some of these different pieces, and if you're opposed to it,
- 9:20then maybe you talk about segregation.
- 9:22And I just was interested in how those things actually fit together.
- 9:25Like, how are those both true at the same time, and how do they overlap?
- 9:30And I didn't know some of those pieces, I feel like when you're an education
- 9:35reporter, you sort of know the stuff that affects what you're writing about.
- 9:38So I knew Florida's story pretty well, cause I worked in Florida for a long time.
- 9:42I grew up in Washington state, so I knew that we really didn't have.
- 9:46I mean, hardly any school choice to speak of a few charter schools now, and
- 9:50that's been contested in the courts.
- 9:52So I just, you know, I was kind of interested in how do these things fit
- 9:56together and sort of bounce off each other and how do you actually pass
- 10:00some of these things politically?
- 10:02You know, because they are so contested and people are so, I mean,
- 10:06just there's no like middle ground.
- 10:08I kind of felt like I was searching for a middle ground and, you
- 10:11know, you don't see much of one.
- 10:13So how do you even pass these things then?
- 10:15And so then I looked for places of sort of connection.
- 10:20Andy: Well, that's sort of from the beginning.
- 10:21You talk in the book about Minnesota, you know, and Ember and, you know, the effort
- 10:29to get the charter law passed there and like you talk about how everybody ended
- 10:33up kind of everybody was disappointed in it for a compromise for different reasons.
- 10:38Talk about that.
- 10:39Is that sort of like, you know, is that sort of a theme that comes through this
- 10:43or is one side actually over time winning?
- 10:46Cara: Well, I mean, what I conclude is that over time conservatives win, right?
- 10:50That, one of the questions I had at some point in the research, this was
- 10:55five years, but at some point, one of the questions I had was, you know, who
- 11:00wins between sort of these different visions for choice because you have
- 11:03sort of the Milton Friedman universal, it's good for everybody, argument.
- 11:09And then you have this very sort of narrow, progressive argument of
- 11:15this is good for low income kids.
- 11:17And I wondered, you know, Who's vision for choice sort of wins, so
- 11:22that was a question I had and you know in this current moment It feels
- 11:26very much like Milton Friedman's vision for choice has won over this
- 11:30sort of more progressive model that different people have championed.
- 11:34Minnesota I was kind of interested in because you know one of the things
- 11:37you do here as an education reporter is that Al Shanker supported Charter
- 11:42schools, you know, and I thought, well, that's interesting why is this very
- 11:46well known, you know, teachers union president, a supporter of charters.
- 11:51And the Minnesota story was interesting too, because, you know, those were sort
- 11:56of democratic voices saying that we need some choice, but not school vouchers.
- 12:00And I liked the idea of how to charters and school vouchers sort
- 12:04of hit up against each other.
- 12:06You know, how do those things play off each other politically?
- 12:09And because charter schools is kind of a weird idea, I mean, it's normal
- 12:13to us now, but it's kind of a strange idea when you think about it, we'll
- 12:16have a different kind of public school, like all this major features of public
- 12:22school, but broken off from the district.
- 12:25That's a really interesting kind of odd idea.
- 12:28And I liked, sort of this, I like this idea of if we could go back
- 12:33to when these things were new and erase what we know about them now.
- 12:37What was appealing at the time?
- 12:39Why did something sort of take off?
- 12:42And Ember wrote in her book, um, which is a really useful history of charter
- 12:48school legislation in Minnesota.
- 12:49She wrote about how she was actually, opposed to school vouchers.
- 12:54And so she was looking for something that would create sort of choice and
- 12:58innovation, but wasn't taking away sort of from the public system,, and so I
- 13:04thought that was really interesting.
- 13:06Andy: Let's stay on charters for a second.
- 13:08You said like, if you could go back, you would change, what would you change?
- 13:13Cara: Well, no, not change something.
- 13:14I'm saying when you're trying to write a history book, you know, when I'm
- 13:20researching these things, you have to sort of think about what you don't know, like
- 13:25try to pretend you don't know how this ends up and think about it in the moment.
- 13:30And I just thought it was interesting that in that moment, if you're a
- 13:34Democrat looking for something that is sort of an answer to school vouchers.
- 13:41I think just politically, you can't just say, well, we're just
- 13:43for traditional public schools.
- 13:45Cause in that moment in time, it was all about Ed reform and it was, you
- 13:49know, this fallout still from a nation at risk and all that kind of thing.
- 13:53And so it's trying to back up and think about what it looked like at
- 13:58that time, which is kind of hard to do actually, to go back and
- 14:01say, well, what did this look like?
- 14:03Before we had all of these things before, you know, the ending sort of.
- 14:07Andy: So I want to go deeper on the book with like that begs like an obvious
- 14:11political question like the debate.
- 14:13The Democrats basic position right now is they are against
- 14:16most kinds of school choice.
- 14:18Pretty much everything except fairly limited public school choice.
- 14:21For the most part, there's obviously exceptions, there's Democrats who support
- 14:24school vouchers, there's Democrats who support charter schools and so forth.
- 14:27But like, in general, the party is fairly hostile to choice.
- 14:32I'm sorry.
- 14:32Cara: Yeah.
- 14:33I said, Yeah, there's been a backlash.
- 14:34Andy: Yeah, it's certainly more hostile.
- 14:35I think that it was during either the Clinton administration,
- 14:37the Obama administration.
- 14:40So against that backdrop, the argument is basically nothing.
- 14:47And you've got Republicans championing a bunch of choice.
- 14:50So it's sort of lots of choice against essentially nothing on the I'm not saying
- 14:53the Democrats agenda on everything on education, nothing on the choice issue,
- 14:57it's fairly narrow, against this Republican real, this real pressure
- 15:02and demand for choice at a time when it's pretty broadly supported as well.
- 15:06So, like, what does that mean for the Democrats?
- 15:09And what does that mean for school choice?
- 15:12Cara: Well, I mean, I'm not a advocate or a political operative at all, but.
- 15:17Andy: No, but you're an analyst.
- 15:19A reporter with history.
- 15:21Cara: I mean, as a journalist and as somebody who spent all this time
- 15:25sort of trying to understand the politics of this and see how people
- 15:28actually got these programs passed.
- 15:31I mean, to me, it seems like Republicans have often been better at this.
- 15:36You know, they've been really good on messaging, like they, they're
- 15:40actually fairly masterful at messaging around school choice.
- 15:43And I think also that the Republican supporters of choice have been good
- 15:48at presenting something and packaging something, you know, they have something
- 15:53to sell that's different than what exists.
- 15:56And I think if you're in politics, trying to sell sort of the status
- 16:00quo is not really a selling message like we like what we have, you
- 16:05know That doesn't do a lot for you.
- 16:08Andy: Especially when a lot of people clearly don't like what they have.
- 16:11Cara: Exactly right, exactly.
- 16:14It's like no it has problems and it's inequitable But ultimately
- 16:18we think we should stick with it.
- 16:19Like that's not a really just politically speaking, that's not the strongest
- 16:22message I think and I feel like sometimes, , especially in this moment,
- 16:28it just feels like Democrats don't necessarily know how to answer some of
- 16:33these things, the parental freedom stuff and this huge explosion of school choice.
- 16:38It doesn't, it still feels like they don't have a very good answer to it.
- 16:43And so, I mean, that's kind of a problem for them, but it's interesting
- 16:47to watch because it does feel like even after all this time, there's
- 16:51still not a very good answer to it.
- 16:54. Andy: So one of the things that's saying on this, one of the parts of the book
- 16:57that I was somewhat skeptical of, you talk about sort of lots of grass, you talk
- 17:02about grassroots opposition later in the book to some of this stuff, but a lot of
- 17:06those groups are not grassroots groups.
- 17:08This is like organized political warfare and it's just between,
- 17:12you know, two different camps.
- 17:15Right.
- 17:16Occasionally there's like organic stuff springs up, but most of the people
- 17:19who are generally associated sort of prominent advocates, they have.
- 17:22You know, they have money behind them from the teachers unions or
- 17:25from left learning foundations.
- 17:28And conversely, on the right, certainly a lot of the advocates there have money
- 17:31behind them from foundations on the right.
- 17:33So I'm not, I'm certainly not trying to claim that like one side of the
- 17:36others is pure, impure, but it's just this is like a special interest fight.
- 17:40And in some ways we get all wrapped around the axel on its education it's really
- 17:45in some ways no different than fights.
- 17:46Are we going to like deregulate?
- 17:49In the past, like we deregulate the airlines or you can deregulate telecom.
- 17:53Who's going to get to make all these regulatory decisions?
- 17:56It's sort of the same thing.
- 17:58And so where I'm going with that is, you know, you talked about some of
- 18:02these groups, but like, if you look at like ample public polling, like a
- 18:07majority of Hispanic Americans, Black Americans, they want school choice, right?
- 18:12Like the main group standing astride saying no is sort of this alliance,
- 18:17which I guess you could call an unholy alliance of sort of white progressives
- 18:21and the producer interest in education, primarily the teachers unions, but also
- 18:25like the school districts and so forth.
- 18:27Like, how does that fit with sort of the story you tell in terms of the politics
- 18:33as they evolve and where they are now?
- 18:36Cara: Well, I don't think there's any sort of pure side.
- 18:38I mean, the teachers unions have been opposed to pretty much all
- 18:42forms of school choice overall.
- 18:45You know, since the start, I mean, they were even opposed to dual enrollment
- 18:51or junior and seniors go to get some classes at college, I mean, I think
- 18:55they have generally been opposed to anything that was outside of school
- 18:59districts, that's a lot of things.
- 19:02Andy: Except we have to, pause for the give credit to Shanker.
- 19:04Right.
- 19:05Cause he's one of those, I'm not on everything and I think he arguably,
- 19:09he failed to reform the union the way he wanted to, but like, He's one of
- 19:12those people, you can read stuff he wrote and you read it to people and
- 19:16they just immediately assume it's like some conservative Republican saying
- 19:19it and you can like, you know, take off, you're like, that was Al Shanker.
- 19:23He was, I think he was trying to move in a different direction on some
- 19:27of this stuff as long as it didn't like really screw over his members.
- 19:30Cara: Yeah, I mean, Shanker is an interesting figure in all of it, because
- 19:34I think there was a willingness on his part to entertain different ideas.
- 19:39I think in part because he didn't want what he viewed as
- 19:42bad policies imposed on them.
- 19:46And so I think he had an idea that, you know, if you sort of play ball on
- 19:51some things and show a willingness to consider some ideas, then, you know,
- 19:55that just comes across better than just straight opposition to all things.
- 20:00And I think he also was fairly honest about there being
- 20:03some challenges in education.
- 20:06But the, but with the charter school thing, you know, he was in favor of
- 20:09that for a few years and then very quickly lumped it in with school
- 20:14vouchers and called it a gimmick, you know, so I think sometimes his
- 20:17support for that gets overstated.
- 20:20A bit but on the.
- 20:22Andy: You're right I mean the unions tell us sort of like it sounds like a biblical
- 20:24story there was like this eden like state with charters and then this like now
- 20:29we're in this like fallen state, which is convenient for their political narrative,
- 20:33but it's not really what happened , you know, and the other side tells the
- 20:38story of like Shanker was for this shanker's for that you should be for this
- 20:41and that's not the whole story either.
- 20:44Cara: No, no.
- 20:44And he, you know, he just was, I think, a complicated figure.
- 20:47So trying to boil it down into a talking point is probably where people go wrong.
- 20:52But, but, you know, on the grassroots thing, I think there are definitely
- 20:57organizations out there that are supporting traditional public schools
- 21:01and are opposed to school choice that are not necessarily just union funded.
- 21:06I think where it gets a little complicated is I think the idea of choice, just
- 21:12the basic idea is extremely appealing and it has pulled better over time.
- 21:18You know, I mean, school vouchers, it used to be that if you put sort
- 21:22of vouchers into a polling question, that it pulled worse, right?
- 21:27If you put some other way of phrasing it into the question, then it would
- 21:30pull better because vouchers just had a negative connotation to a lot of people,
- 21:35but I think also there's an aspect of familiarity to it, you know, we've now
- 21:40had different school choice options for a long time, and so there's a certain
- 21:46sense of, I know what that is, you know, and also again, I think the messaging
- 21:51around it is very good because what really sounds negative about choice?
- 21:59Andy: Yeah, well, I mean, I've said before, like essentially being against
- 22:03choice in America is like being against gravity and you only, you only have
- 22:07to like walk through like a grocery store or sort of any part of our sort
- 22:12of our various commercial sectors to see how much Americans like choice
- 22:15to the point even when those choices might not actually be optimal choices.
- 22:19People just, it's a very deeply ingrained function of how we live.
- 22:25And so not having an answer for that politically seems like a real, it
- 22:29seems like a box canyon strategy.
- 22:30There's just no, there's, you have to have some kind of answer, which
- 22:34obviously that's why Bill Clinton championed charter schools, he thought
- 22:38that would be a way out and sort of a third way kind of compromise on that.
- 22:44You couldn't, you can't just say no on this stuff, like,
- 22:48you have to have something.
- 22:49Cara: Yeah.
- 22:50And I think that we saw that then with charter schools for a long time,
- 22:54charter schools and, you know, merit pay for teachers, different sort of
- 22:57reform ideas that you could kind of package together, but the democrat
- 23:01answer to you know to school vouchers for a long time was charter schools.
- 23:05That really has only changed I think with you know, the Trump years and then
- 23:09the sort of divisiveness of Betsy Devos
- 23:12Andy: Yeah, you talk about Devos.
- 23:15So talk about that because that's certainly you were mentioning like
- 23:17earlier the word voucher had weird polling connotations something we were
- 23:20seeing during the Trump years was if you just attached an idea to Betsy
- 23:25Devos's name, it would pull lower, so if you described it to people and then
- 23:31you described it like in an A, B kind of sample, then you said like, this is
- 23:33something that Betsy Devos wants to do.
- 23:35It would pull lower, which isn't usual for a secretary of education to
- 23:39sort of cast that kind of a shadow.
- 23:41So you get into her a lot in the book.
- 23:43So talk about that.
- 23:44Cara: Well, it's funny.
- 23:45I get into her a little bit in the book.
- 23:47If I had a, I had someone tell me the other day that they wanted a chapter on
- 23:50Betsy Devos and they got like two pages.
- 23:53Andy: I got it.
- 23:56Cara: I was like, I'm sorry, but I didn't actually think that, you know, for as
- 24:01much media attention as she commanded and for as polarizing a figure as she
- 24:06sort of was, she didn't, most of her accomplishments were not actually in
- 24:11the realm of K to 12 or school choice.
- 24:15You know, a lot of the things that, that the Trump administration talked
- 24:18about, you know, or they talked about coming into office, didn't actually
- 24:23come to pass, you know, and there's not necessarily strong conservative
- 24:30support for, say, like a federal voucher pro, you know, because it gets into
- 24:34other other areas of, of disagreement.
- 24:37And so what I liked was, was this.
- 24:42Um, and she visited Milwaukee and she sort of called back to the history
- 24:45and she called back to Polly Williams.
- 24:48Andy: Yeah, exactly.
- 24:49Cara: Yeah, I liked that moment because one, she kind of gave this
- 24:53speech where she talked about what the future of public education was with
- 24:58through the lens of school choice.
- 24:59And I thought if you, I mean, speaking to the polarization of the issue,
- 25:03you either are going to read that and think, oh my gosh, this is awful.
- 25:07Or you're going to read that and think, actually, that sounds pretty good, and so
- 25:11I like that and the fact that she called back to this history with Polly Williams
- 25:17in Milwaukee, but ultimately I didn't think that she necessarily needed a whole
- 25:22chapter, you know, I didn't feel like she had, she was a very effective sort
- 25:28of voice for choice in her career, but as education secretary, I mean, people
- 25:35really, really reacted strongly to her in such a way that I think it caused a
- 25:39lot of the backlash with like anything that you could, I mean, as you said,
- 25:43anything that you could sort of attach or two for a certain group of people
- 25:46that was okay, then we don't want that.
- 25:49Andy: Interesting because she did it and to her credit, like, I mean, she
- 25:52didn't want a lot of multiple choices.
- 25:54To her credit, she took some tough stands at times that went against some of these
- 25:58ideas around like universal vouchers and so forth, like earlier in her career.
- 26:02And she wanted to make sure these things were targeted.
- 26:04We're going to help, uh, underprivileged kids and that's all been sort of,
- 26:08you know, all that sort of erased.
- 26:11Cara: Yeah, I mean, I think that for, it's interesting because how many education
- 26:16secretaries in the past do you think very many people could even name, you know?
- 26:22And it's just, it's interesting that she commanded that sort of attention, just
- 26:28that it would have any kind of effect really is sort of in itself interesting,
- 26:32but that I think was also just sort of the Trump effect, not even just DeVos.
- 26:36I think that was the Trump effect.
- 26:39So...
- 26:40Andy: So something you say early in the book that kind of relates to this,
- 26:44you talk about, it's a quote from Jeb Bush, the former Florida governor and
- 26:50very high profile education advocate.
- 26:52And Jeb says something like, I forget the exact quote, but it's basically
- 26:57this is like, this was the vision for vouchers and school choice all along.
- 27:01Start small and expand.
- 27:03Cara: Yeah he was asked in an interview at the Tampa Bay Times, basically it was,
- 27:09I don't remember the exact question, but it was something along the lines of sort
- 27:12of how did this, You know, I'll come to be and he basically said that you start
- 27:16small and expand which is actually how Pretty much all school choice programs
- 27:22have been passed, you know, and it's sort of interesting because the critics
- 27:28of them said from the start that you're going to start with low income kids or
- 27:33you're going to start with this cap on enrollment and then you're going to go
- 27:39You know, it's just going to be the start of this, it's going to go somewhere else.
- 27:41And so I thought, and when I listened to that interview, I just, I thought,
- 27:46well, that, that actually is kind of the whole sort of political strategy
- 27:50that's been extremely effective.
- 27:53Andy: My question for you on that, the reason why that jumped
- 27:56out at me is like, that's true.
- 27:58But that's also, that's how, like, all policy, I mean, like, Social Security
- 28:03started with pensions for widows.
- 28:06and orphans, right?
- 28:07And then expand into a broader social insurance program.
- 28:09We started, you know, Medicare and Medicaid started in more targeted
- 28:12ways and subsequently expanded like almost any policy domain.
- 28:18That's how you start, you know, with various kinds of like, you
- 28:22know, tax credits for different, like you start small and you try
- 28:25to, and then advocates get a toehold and you try to get it bigger.
- 28:27So I was surprised that like you were this was somehow like, that strikes
- 28:32me as that's just like, basically that's like what you do if you're
- 28:36an advocate for a particular policy, whether you're left, right or center.
- 28:40Cara: Yeah, no, I mean, I think that that's because why would that, you
- 28:44know, that makes sense in a lot of ways.
- 28:46Like you're not going to oppose something that's small and experimental and this
- 28:49is a pilot and we're going to try this out and then, but I don't know that's
- 28:54necessarily been as true in education.
- 28:57You know, there are things that people have said, we're going to try this and
- 29:01then it kind of has gone away, you know, I mean, you just think about all of the
- 29:04big Ed reform things that were just like dominant in the coverage earlier when I
- 29:12earlier in my career, but Merit pay and, you know, the VAM stuff that for a little
- 29:19while as a reporter, I was just consumed with this stuff in Florida, and it's not
- 29:26really what we're talking about anymore.
- 29:28It's sort of interesting.
- 29:30Andy: And in some ways that's like that kind of makes the point because those
- 29:33things they didn't start and iterate, they jumped really went from like,
- 29:37basically evaluating no teachers to deciding we're going to evaluate all
- 29:41of them, including in the majority of subjects and grades aren't even assessed
- 29:45and so well under its own pressure.
- 29:49And then, even before you got to all the although it was technically
- 29:52incredibly difficult for you and got to all the political stuff.
- 29:55So but I feel like things that generally succeed and become embedded is features
- 30:00of American life, and I think you can argue school choice is probably a feature
- 30:03of American life now, it's so broad, like they tend to start small and then
- 30:07they just sort of, grow and expand.
- 30:11Cara: Yeah, I mean, I think that that is a good way to start something, but I
- 30:15don't know if that's necessarily like a really obvious thing with choice, because
- 30:20one of the things I think is interesting about it is that American schools tend
- 30:25to be, our system is pretty decentralized and so it's interesting at all that you
- 30:31would have a movement where you might start something in Milwaukee and then
- 30:36have similar forces supporting it in Cleveland and supporting it in Florida.
- 30:41You know, I mean, I think that's one of the ways that the opposition to
- 30:44it has been sort of outmaneuvered in a certain sense, because it comes
- 30:49across as a local thing and it's treated as sort of a local thing.
- 30:54And so to have kind of these driving forces behind it, just the fact that you
- 30:57had the same Lawyers on so many of the cases I thought was really interesting,
- 31:03because so often things in education are well This is the thing we're doing in
- 31:07Florida, to see something spread is kind of I mean, like the, the Florida model
- 31:14that Jeb Bush was pioneering for quite a while to watch that go from one state to
- 31:20multiple states, that actually is kind of interesting in education, I think, and
- 31:24different maybe than some other areas.
- 31:28Andy: So one thing that's happened that sort of has fueled some of that expansion
- 31:32is you sort of, and you get into the book, there's sort of two tracks here.
- 31:35Yeah, the political tracks, the different kinds of school choice laws being passed,
- 31:39and then you have this constitutional track where you essentially have like
- 31:43a concerted legal strategy just to basically completely up end First
- 31:49Amendment jurisprudence first around, you know, ultimately around both the
- 31:55free exercise and establishment clauses.
- 31:57And we've sort of seen that still been playing out even in
- 31:59the last few years at the court.
- 32:00And it's sort of created this incredible space and opportunity and ultimately
- 32:05now the way the laws are or the way the Supreme Court, you know, precedents
- 32:09are almost like a propulsion for if you're going to have school choice,
- 32:12you're going to have to have fairly broad based school choice, and you're
- 32:16seeing that now there's like religious schools trying to come into the charter
- 32:18sector and that's very contentious.
- 32:20So talk about that in that part of the book.
- 32:23Cause that legal history isn't told that much.
- 32:28And it's I mean, by the time you have this sort of Louisiana case on like technology
- 32:32was you could sort of see that they were gonna succeed ultimately on on vouchers.
- 32:37You could sort of see the argument already gone over those previous 30 years.
- 32:41And so talk about that and sort of How that relates to this sort of
- 32:45really steady expansion of choice.
- 32:47Cara: Yeah.
- 32:48So this is an area that I didn't know very much about, when I started doing the
- 32:52research, but one of the first books that I've read was Voucher Wars, which was
- 32:58written by one of the lawyers that I ended up writing a great deal about in the book.
- 33:03And that was told from a, you know, pro school choice, sort of explaining
- 33:07the litigation from that perspective.
- 33:11And I thought, that was interesting because it hadn't occurred to me
- 33:14necessarily how important it was to win.
- 33:18In the courts, you know, I was thinking legislatively, how do you
- 33:21pass this and that kind of thing.
- 33:24But I thought, oh, well, yeah, of course, that seems obvious that these
- 33:28programs are instantly going to be challenged and that where you really
- 33:31have to win is in the court system.
- 33:34But I also, I didn't know that much about church state law, you know, I thought
- 33:39that was a somewhat clear cut thing.
- 33:43And so I thought it was interesting, actually, how murky it was.
- 33:46And so I ended up getting really interested in that.
- 33:51And then, you know, probably to the point where I was like, well, this is
- 33:53not anything that people are going to read because to understand it, it gets
- 33:58it such a, you know, it's like so in the weeds to understand and parse out these
- 34:02different cases and why one is building on the other and why they're important.
- 34:06And so I was kind of presented with this challenge of feeling like this is
- 34:11extremely important and should be part of the history and also how do you get
- 34:15people to sort of read through this?
- 34:18Cause I think if you do understand that, all of these precedents, then
- 34:23when something like Carson versus Macon happens, then you understand.
- 34:27Andy: What Carson making is the main case.
- 34:30What it was about.
- 34:31Cara: Yeah.
- 34:31I mean, it's the most recent case where the courts basically have said that not
- 34:39only are our school vouchers, okay, which is what Zelman was in 2002, but that,
- 34:46you know, if you're going to provide Sort of public benefits to secular
- 34:50private schools that you have to also provide it to religious private schools.
- 34:55Otherwise it's this issue of religious discrimination.
- 34:58Andy: That's based in more rural places where you sometimes have these
- 35:02tuition assistance programs to give people a broader range of choices
- 35:06because there's just a low density of public schools and schools overall.
- 35:11Cara: Yeah.
- 35:11Yeah.
- 35:12Sort of like where I grew up really.
- 35:14Andy: Right.
- 35:14And it was a challenge because , they didn't include sectarian schools maybe.
- 35:20Cara: Yeah.
- 35:21And you have families who are saying, why can't I enroll my kid in a
- 35:25religious school when I can enroll them in this other private school?
- 35:29Which is an interesting question.
- 35:31But there's 30 some years of cases that sort of lead up to that point.
- 35:38And so, I was sort of trying to unravel that and understand
- 35:44the different ways that they.
- 35:46Sort of argued those cases because for a long time it was just establishment
- 35:51clause Arguments and now it's sort of more on this issue of religious
- 35:54discrimination and free exercise and and the tension between those two things.
- 35:59But one of the things I thought was really interesting was going way back.
- 36:03You know where I kind of where I started the book in the 50s.
- 36:07I thought it was really interesting that at that point in time and really
- 36:10up until you know 70s 80s there was this sense that the court was not at
- 36:17all going to allow any kind of really public support for private education.
- 36:22There was a big movement around Catholic schools, you know, because Catholic
- 36:25school enrollment was declining, schools were closing and there was some interest
- 36:30from lawmakers in different places to try to help those institutions.
- 36:34And really the courts were like, yeah, no, I think the Catholic
- 36:36schools, you know, provide this public service and they're good schools but
- 36:41ultimately it's advancing religion.
- 36:42We can't do it.
- 36:44And, you know, and so to see that evolve over time to now where it's like,
- 36:47no, you have to give support to those institutions or you're discriminated
- 36:52against, that's quite a journey, actually.
- 36:55And so I I was really interested in that.
- 36:57Andy: It really is.
- 36:58Cara: Yeah, I mean, it's really kind of stunning.
- 36:59Andy: It literally turned on its head.
- 37:03And I don't know that the rhetoric has caught up being something I noticed and
- 37:06maybe this is just more like social media debate but you hear a lot of people still
- 37:10talk about like the separation of church and state and education and this high
- 37:14wall and Like, you used to hear that even when you had Title I services being
- 37:19provided in parochial schools and all of that you still heard that and it was
- 37:23like, well, the wall's already been kind of penetrated to some, to some extent.
- 37:27And, but you still hear it now and it's like a fairly settled issue, it seems.
- 37:32Cara: Yeah.
- 37:33Well, and the thing I thought was interesting when Carson versus Bacon
- 37:36happened, you know, was that some of the, so I'm not even just the
- 37:40Twitter debates, but some of the news coverage even was like, Oh, this is
- 37:44this crazy thing that has occurred under, under sort of the Roberts court.
- 37:47And it was like, not, not really though, guys, that's actually,
- 37:52you know, that that's actually.
- 37:54Something that's been kind of a slow journey over several decades,
- 37:59really, I mean, Rehnquist's court started moving in that direction and
- 38:02sort of carving the path, but that's been years and years in the making.
- 38:10Andy: As a journalist, does that make it because I feel like what you're what
- 38:13you're putting your finger on, there's an awful lot of presentism in the debate.
- 38:17You had a bunch of stuff happening during the Trump years that people
- 38:22like, Oh, my God, this is unprecedented.
- 38:23But it was stuff that was actually, like, quite precedent.
- 38:27It was, you know, these that link back to previous policies.
- 38:30I mean, that's I'm certainly not defending I mean, Trump did some stuff that I think
- 38:34is, he certainly argues unprecedented.
- 38:38But just on education, people would get spun up about stuff and you're like, this
- 38:41actually is, none of this is really new.
- 38:43These are just like longstanding debates, but they were kind of caught up in the
- 38:46sense of presidentism, as you said, like about like, that this is something
- 38:49the Roberts court cooked up at a whole cloth rather than like a, you know.
- 38:53Fairly long running argument with a lot of cases and so forth behind it.
- 38:58Is that hard as a reporter if you're trying to operate in a
- 39:01climate where, like, everything's seeming, everything's new?
- 39:04Oh, you know, new in air quotes?
- 39:07Cara: Yeah, I mean, I think it's frustrating in some ways.
- 39:11Because I think, I mean, it gets into some of the stuff that's going on, I
- 39:14think, in newspapers and journalism and sort of the decline of just the
- 39:18number of journalists out there, so a lot of times what you have are fairly
- 39:23young reporters covering things, and so sometimes I think people are not
- 39:29as familiar with some of the history.
- 39:32But I also think, you could probably, unless you are a courthouse reporter with
- 39:37a lot of background, you could probably be forgiven for not knowing all of the
- 39:41ins and outs of like church state history.
- 39:45But yeah, sometimes I see things and it's like, no, it's not actually this bold new
- 39:51thing, it's kind of the same old thing.
- 39:54It's just a different person.
- 39:56Andy: I'll give people a pass.
- 39:57I'll certainly forgive you if you don't know all the history.
- 39:59I expect everybody to be steeped in constitutional law, and, you know, if
- 40:03you're a reporter, like you need to, you know, understand like there was once
- 40:06a lemon test and this stuff, but like.
- 40:09I do think if you're writing about a Supreme Court case, you should
- 40:12understand if it's like genuinely new or if it's a continuation and sort of
- 40:16stands on the back of some earlier.
- 40:19Cara: Yeah, and also just what it actually does, because I think some
- 40:24of the school choice cases have been more limited in sort of scope, then
- 40:31the coverage would maybe suggest him.
- 40:33But it's sort of the breathless coverage sometimes I think is almost overstating
- 40:38what something has really done.
- 40:39So there's sort of two issues there, like understand the history of it.
- 40:43And then it's not the first, you know, this didn't just come out of left field.
- 40:47And then and then also sort of this It's really over the top breathless.
- 40:50Oh, my gosh, what have they done?
- 40:52It's like, not quite that
- 40:55Andy: well, it can confuse issues, right?
- 40:56Like, so, like, the Janice's case, people were so this breathless
- 40:59coverage that, like, this was the end for the teachers unions.
- 41:02And, like, it is certainly affecting their membership.
- 41:05And you're seeing sort of a slow membership decline.
- 41:08The reporting and a lot of commentary on it was like, this is it, this is,
- 41:12Like, and so the fact that, like, you know, the case came down in the
- 41:16summer and the teachers unions were still around in December, like, was
- 41:19like surprising people when, like, you should have, it was not how its
- 41:23impact was not going to work like that.
- 41:25It was going to be a process over time of how it affected them.
- 41:29But it was this sense of, like, oh, and then people kind of moved on.
- 41:32Like, oh, that was a big nothing when, in fact, it's actually shaping
- 41:36a lot of the politics around the sector in some pretty profound ways.
- 41:40Cara: Well, it's interesting because, so with Carson versus Macon, I mean, I did
- 41:45think some of the coverage was a little over the top and a little breathless.
- 41:49But at the same time, now we're looking at this possibility of religious charter
- 41:53schools and different ways that states are interpreting what that case is.
- 42:01And so, that is actually a fairly large effect, but it's sort of, it's like,
- 42:09okay, well, how do we square this?
- 42:11On the one hand, I thought some of this was a little over the top.
- 42:13And on the other hand, we're talking about religious charter schools.
- 42:15Andy: Well, it's I think you square it, but they didn't matter, right?
- 42:19Like my definition of Supreme Court case matters.
- 42:21I think it's the context.
- 42:23Sort of how it matters and how it came into being.
- 42:27Cara: Yeah.
- 42:28And I think the idea that this just came out of nowhere from the
- 42:31Roberts court, that's just not true.
- 42:33Andy: And I think that just confused people, but it fit with this narrative,
- 42:36which was a weird narrative that, I mean, you say a lot of things about
- 42:40Donald Trump, but he's not a theocrat.
- 42:42Like, I don't think the guy, like, you know I doubt he's ever cracked the
- 42:48Bible, let alone like thought about it.
- 42:50So like the idea that he was trying to bring back a theocracy
- 42:53through this just didn't.
- 42:54It just seemed like just sort of like rhetoric, just like just rhetoric of
- 42:59the moment rather than like a deeply, any kind of deep political conviction.
- 43:05Cara: Yeah.
- 43:06Well, and I don't think it has anything to do with Trump really, but I did think
- 43:10it was interesting to see the court sort of shift on this free exercise, you
- 43:16know, that because that is something that in the book, I write about Virgil
- 43:21Bloom, who was a person advocating, you know, he was advocating for vouchers
- 43:25in the very first in the fifties.
- 43:27And he was talking about free exercise and that this was an issue
- 43:32of religious discrimination decades before the court really was giving
- 43:35that any kind of serious consideration.
- 43:38And I know even in the 90s and when some of the court cases were playing
- 43:45out in Milwaukee and Cleveland, some of the school choice supporters who
- 43:49were involved in those cases didn't think they would win on free exercise.
- 43:54So it is interesting to see that it's gone that direction, I just think, you
- 43:57know, it's gone that direction slowly.
- 43:59Andy: I want to come back to Bloom in a second and that whole piece and Friedman
- 44:03and all that, because I think that, yeah, the beginning of the book and the end of
- 44:05the book, like kind of fit around that.
- 44:07But before that, there's a quick question, like you didn't get into housing much
- 44:14and as I was reading parts of the book, it was like, well this is actually like
- 44:17a, in some ways a story of housing and housing segregation and historic housing,
- 44:23redlining policies, the way, you know, school districts look the way they look
- 44:26and so forth for a reason, the lack of choice, talk about how do you see, like,
- 44:32these issues of housing and segregated housing, redlining, both formal redlining
- 44:38and now sort of often, you know, informal education, redlining and formal in terms
- 44:43of like school district boundaries.
- 44:44How does that fit into this whole story of choice?
- 44:47Cara: Yeah, so I wrote about this a little bit in the introduction because
- 44:50I was saying that some of the arguments for school choice are compelling and have
- 44:56power because of the sort of built in inequities in the public school system.
- 45:01Because if you can essentially buy a better resource school by virtue of
- 45:06where you live, then there's something wrong with how the public school system
- 45:11Is organized and put together, you know, and some of that makes sense, because if
- 45:15you have kids living in a certain area, you need to have a school for them, you
- 45:19know, just structurally, that makes sense.
- 45:21But I think that, you know, when you have places where you can get in trouble
- 45:26and get arrested in some cases for sending your kid to a public school that
- 45:31they're not zoned for based on where they live, That's wild, you know, I
- 45:35mean, that's just wrong in a lot of ways.
- 45:38And I think it gives power to some of that argument for choice.
- 45:42You know, the other thing that's interesting about school choice
- 45:44to me is that if no one takes you up on any of these choices, Then
- 45:49there is no power to it at all.
- 45:50You know, if no one actually finds them worth choosing, if the
- 45:53charter school doesn't get anyone to come, then it has no power at all.
- 45:58And I think that's sort of interesting in itself.
- 46:01But this, this idea of housing, I think that's sort of a subtext because, you
- 46:08know, I'm, I say in the introduction that this is one of the things that
- 46:11sort of gives Power to the idea.
- 46:14But then you also see this in the segregation years, when people talk
- 46:18about segregationists use school vouchers, you know, try to get around
- 46:22Brown versus board to try to get around desegregating their public schools.
- 46:25They used a lot of things.
- 46:27It's not just school vouchers.
- 46:28They used attendance boundaries, they use admissions criteria.
- 46:32They used actually a lot of things that are still very much present
- 46:35in our public school system.
- 46:37And I tried to sort of point those things out because I think it makes the
- 46:42argument around that more complicated.
- 46:44Andy: I thought you did a good job with that, because the debate does
- 46:47seem to run one way vouchers were a segregationist tool, which is true.
- 46:52But so were lots of these other things that nobody says boo about.
- 46:56Cara: Yeah, lots of things.
- 46:59They tried everything.
- 47:01They weren't just doing the one thing.
- 47:02They tried everything.
- 47:05So I thought that was interesting too, because it
- 47:07complicates things a little bit.
- 47:08You know, if you can use attendance boundaries to segregate your schools,
- 47:12and if you can use admissions criteria.
- 47:14Well, in a lot of ways, we're still doing that.
- 47:17And other communities did that, too.
- 47:20And I thought that was part of the reason that Milwaukee ends up with vouchers,
- 47:24it's part of the reason that Cleveland does, because those school systems had
- 47:29segregation and under resourced schools and had cases involved, you know, like,
- 47:33so it's not just an issue in the South.
- 47:36And I felt like that also is still very much present in our current
- 47:42public school system, we just talk about it a little differently.
- 47:45And that's kind of an inescapable fact.
- 47:49And I think, again, on messaging school choice supporters are really
- 47:53good at playing those things up and pointing those things out.
- 47:56And the opposition is not, I think, as good at answering those charges.
- 48:02Andy: Well, I think they're not as good at answering them because
- 48:04they don't necessarily, there's not a coherent argument there.
- 48:06You sort of can't be for equity and against sort of structural racism or
- 48:13the present day contemporary effects of historic racism, and not have something
- 48:18pretty profound to say about the public schools and everything you just
- 48:22said, like, if you have means you can buy your way out of it and so forth.
- 48:25Intellectually, they're sort of stuck in that box canyon and sort
- 48:30of haven't figured out a way, and that's why I think school choice
- 48:33supporters have the upper hand.
- 48:36So, on that, two quick final questions, one probably won't be quick, because
- 48:42it gets to the core of the book, but at the beginning, you talk about
- 48:44Virgil Bloom, you talk about Milton Friedman and others, and I think
- 48:49what's really interesting about those people in particular, They were aware
- 48:54that some of the things they were advocating would have adverse effects,
- 48:57but they were like, it's worth it.
- 48:59Like it's that's the price.
- 49:03And they were sort of comfortable with those trade offs at
- 49:08a pretty profound level.
- 49:11Cara: Yeah.
- 49:12I mean, I think Milton Friedman's interesting because he was
- 49:15just very honest about it.
- 49:18He thought that there should be fewer public schools, you know, and he's a
- 49:23libertarian economist, so he thought that business was more efficient than
- 49:28government, you know, and that if you had a marketplace where parents could
- 49:33essentially, you know, buy education for their kids, that some schools would open,
- 49:39that would be bad, but other schools would open, that would be good, and that, You
- 49:43know, over time, this would drive some sort of improvement that there would be,
- 49:48he called it this flowering of schools that would open, and I think that's
- 49:53kind of interesting because he was just very clear that he thought having fewer
- 49:57public schools would actually be better.
- 50:00And he also, you know, he exchanged letters with Virgil Bloom, as two
- 50:05people who supported school vouchers around the same time, but with different
- 50:09sort of intentions for him, and he was honest with Bloom, too, in saying,
- 50:14you know, this might actually not be good for Catholic schools because
- 50:17you'll have different competitors.
- 50:19And I thought that was sort of interesting that he wasn't necessarily like, Hey,
- 50:22let's get together as voucher supporters.
- 50:24He was like, I've got to tell you, this might not be good for your interests.
- 50:27I just thought that was sort of interesting that.
- 50:31Andy: He was, I interviewed him once about this.
- 50:33He was maddingly, sometimes open asset, maddingly consistent, like
- 50:38whether you agree with him or not on many things I didn't, but like,
- 50:43just like, just admirably consistent.
- 50:46Most people try to like fuzzy up the dark undersides of some
- 50:50of the policies they support.
- 50:52And that's, again, that's not a right left statement,that's everyone.
- 50:56Cara: That's politics.
- 50:57Andy: Yeah, exactly.
- 50:57But he just like very forthright and kind of leaned into them.
- 51:03Cara: Yeah.
- 51:03I thought he was a fascinating guy because he just was committed to what he believed
- 51:08and he wasn't necessarily trying to convince you, in a sort of slick political
- 51:14way, he just, he thought this is better.
- 51:17And my argument makes more sense than yours.
- 51:19And he just, he enjoyed debating, but ultimately he didn't change his mind.
- 51:24He didn't, you know, I mean, he didn't like some of the first
- 51:27school voucher programs because they were only for low income children.
- 51:31And he thought if it's good for one kid, it's good for all kids.
- 51:33You know, this isn't, I just thought it was, he was such an interesting
- 51:36guy that 50 years later, he still basically believed the same thing.
- 51:41Andy: But there are people like Jack Koons feels, he thinks Freeman sent
- 51:46school choice back decades because it got tied up in the free to choose
- 51:50frame and the TV show and became, and so like Jack feels like if you had the
- 51:56more progressive orientation on it, that it would've got a lot further,
- 52:01and you wouldn't have some of the left right politics that you have right now.
- 52:04Cara: I don't know, not to disagree with Jack Coons, who's a lovely person
- 52:10who talked to me after,, yes, he's a lovely guy who took my call after he had
- 52:15actually been seriously injured and I was like, why are you calling me back?
- 52:19Like, go and rest or something.
- 52:21Andy: He's a very caring person.
- 52:22Cara: Yeah, he cares that much.
- 52:24And he actually also seems to enjoy debate, though, because he
- 52:28was telling me with great delight about arguing with Milton Friedman.
- 52:33Andy: They were in Chicago together, and there was a wall there for a while.
- 52:36Cara: Yeah, I thought that was kind of fun, you know, some of the points of
- 52:41where people would, would agree about sort of the idea that we need this thing,
- 52:45but not how you would implement it.
- 52:47I thought, I'm a nerd, but I thought that was super fun.
- 52:50Some of those things, but I don't know if I agree with him anyhow, because it
- 52:55seems like the places where people tried this sort of progressive idea, you know,
- 53:04with not just with Kunz and Sugarman, but with Christopher Jenks, sometimes it
- 53:09fell down in the, it's complicated part.
- 53:12You know, like the, how are we actually going to implement this and all of
- 53:16these, like, oh, we could have a sliding scale and we can do this and that.
- 53:19I think sometimes that's where the messaging didn't.
- 53:22necessarily work out.
- 53:23Whereas the Friedman concept was pretty easy to understand.
- 53:27You might disagree with it, but it was pretty easy to understand.
- 53:30So I don't know if I agree with that.
- 53:33Andy: I think I agree a little more with Jack.
- 53:36I think the left right argument seems to be like, that's like the only thing that
- 53:41opponents of school choice really have is they make this partisan and this is what
- 53:44Republicans are for, it's a very sort of reactionary politics, there's not a
- 53:48positive alternative vision around choice.
- 53:51And I think if you could change those politics, it would look different.
- 53:55But let me ask you, so last question, I mean, I have to ask,
- 53:57like, because of the title, you said it wasn't your title, but...
- 54:02Cara: Oh, no, no.
- 54:02I mean, I didn't let them, like, put a title on the book that I didn't agree.
- 54:05Andy: But is this the death of, Kara, is this the death of public schools?
- 54:09Cara: Well, so, you know, I think it raises that question and I think some
- 54:14of it is in this area of sort of how Republicans and Democrats define public
- 54:20education, you know, because I think right now what Florida is doing, you
- 54:25know, I visited a micro school a week ago and what Florida is doing is, you
- 54:31could say it's public education, they're putting a lot of public dollars into
- 54:35paying for all of these different things, but it's not public school, right?
- 54:39That micro school I went to 80 percent of the kids had state dollars to go there.
- 54:45You could say that's a public education that they're getting.
- 54:48You know, the state is ready for that, but that's not a public school.
- 54:51And so I meant it kind of to be more profound than just enrollment numbers.
- 54:56And you know, that the public school system is in like a death spiral.
- 55:00But I, I think the fact that we are now in this place where you can talk about
- 55:04Florida, having such a different model of what could be called public education
- 55:10than, like, where I grew up in Washington, that, to me, is a profound change
- 55:15from, you know, when Milton Friedman first started talking about it in 1955.
- 55:22Andy: Yeah, I think that's a great, that's a great place to leave because
- 55:24I do think it is definitely public education is going to change and is
- 55:29changing and has profoundly change and how it's provided and so forth, like,
- 55:34whether that's good and actually ends up helping address some of these long
- 55:38standing problems of equity, whether that makes them worse or makes no difference.
- 55:41I think the jury is still out, but like, I think that's a like it is.
- 55:46It seems indisputable that things are changing how we think of public education
- 55:51and the relationship of families to public schools and so forth is changing
- 55:57is going to continue to change.
- 55:58Cara: Yeah, that's where I, you know, that's where I round up.
- 56:01That was my conclusion.
- 56:03Andy: Well, the book is The Death of Public School by
- 56:06Cara Fitzpatrick of Chalkbeat.
- 56:08It's a fantastic read, a lot of history that I suspect will be really interesting
- 56:14and engaging for a lot of readers.
- 56:16A lot of history about my state of Virginia that's not well known even now.
- 56:21And so, a terrific contribution of literature, The Death of Public Schools.
- 56:25Thank you, Kara, for taking some time with Wonky Folk.
- 56:29Cara: Thanks for having me.
- 56:30Andy: And you got me out of the doghouse.
- 56:31I did one last time with Morgan Polikoff.
- 56:34We didn't talk about choice at all.
- 56:35And so I think having a full on, you know, a full on episode on choice
- 56:40will get me back in Jed's good graces.
- 56:43Cara: We'll see.
- 56:45Andy: Thanks so much for your time.
- 56:45I really appreciate it.
- 56:47Happy Halloween.
- 56:47Cara: Thank you.
- 56:47Thanks.
- 56:48You too.