Latest / Escape The Clock: How to Become Financially Free and Have the Option Not to Work / Don’t Retire… Graduate! Redefining Financial Freedom with Eric Brotman, CFP
Transcript
- 0:00Do you have a freedom number? Most people plan
- 0:03to retire at 65. Others obsess over the net worth
- 0:06that lets us walk away from a life of forced
- 0:09work. But nearly half of Americans are pushed
- 0:12out earlier than planned due to layoffs or health.
- 0:15On the flip side, 1 in 8 end up returning to
- 0:18work, not because they ran out of money, but
- 0:20because they prepared for the end of a job, but
- 0:22not the beginning of a life. Today, on Escape
- 0:25the Clock, we are flipping the script. We stop
- 0:27retiring, which implies retreating, and we start
- 0:30graduating. Stay tuned for the specific defense
- 0:33protocols you need to fortify your financial
- 0:35castle so that when you leave the workforce,
- 0:38it is finally on your terms. Welcome back to
- 1:03Escape the Clock, the show where we highlight
- 1:05strategies and approaches for achieving your
- 1:06financial freedom and having the option not to
- 1:09work. I'm your host, Daniel C. Rogers. There's
- 1:11this classic program manager's dilemma called
- 1:13the day two problem. No matter how well your
- 1:16project goes, things can easily fall apart after
- 1:19you secede. The accumulation phase goes great.
- 1:21We run, we build these great projects, we run
- 1:24them, we track KPIs, manage budgets, and eventually
- 1:27hit the launch date. But then the decumulation
- 1:29phase starts, the operation phase. where the
- 1:32plan ends and our success can easily fall apart.
- 1:35We build the castle, but we forget to build the
- 1:37lifestyle inside it and the moat around it to
- 1:40protect it. And in my experience, the thing that
- 1:43sends people back to work isn't usually a lack
- 1:45of savings. It's an unforeseen risk that wasn't
- 1:48on the risk log, the identity crisis. They have
- 1:51the financial capital to survive, but they lack
- 1:53the mental preparedness to thrive without the
- 1:55structure of a job. So how do we shift from playing
- 1:58offense to playing defense to secure our freedom?
- 2:01and our purpose forever. Today's guest is here
- 2:04to help us figure that out. He believes that
- 2:06retirement shouldn't be a cessation of life,
- 2:08but a promotion. Eric Brotman is the CEO of BFG
- 2:11Financial Advisors and a veteran certified financial
- 2:14planner who has dedicated his career to financial
- 2:16literacy. He served as an employee to the Board
- 2:19of Trustees for the Maryland State Retirement
- 2:21and Pension System, and he is the author of Don't
- 2:23Retire, Graduate, as well as the host of the
- 2:25Don't Retire, Graduate podcast. Eric, welcome
- 2:28to Escape the Clock. Daniel, I love the way you
- 2:30frame that. It's great to be here. Thank you.
- 2:32Thank you. Eric, you know, you said the word
- 2:35retirement is part of the problem. I love that.
- 2:38Can you take us back to the moment you realized
- 2:40that traditional definition was broken? Well,
- 2:43you know, I've been spending over the last three
- 2:45plus decades time working with folks who have
- 2:48reached that magical retirement age. And it's
- 2:50funny. It's like the unicorn. You know, you search
- 2:52for it your entire working life and then you
- 2:54get there and you're like, now what? There's
- 2:55an unbelievable disconnect. And I started with
- 2:59the simplest exercise. I looked up the word in
- 3:03the dictionary. I know that sounds old school,
- 3:06but I'm old enough that I can get away with that.
- 3:08And to retire, if you think about it, the English
- 3:11language started, of course, in the UK, not here
- 3:13or Great Britain. And to retire is to go to sleep.
- 3:16And that's what I feel like we're doing. I feel
- 3:18like we're having this wonderful, amazing life,
- 3:20building this vitae and this resume and this
- 3:24network of humans and becoming important in our
- 3:27own worlds and our own industries. And then we
- 3:31just say, I'm done. I quit. And it's daytime
- 3:33TV and shuffleboard and maybe occasional golf.
- 3:36That's brutal. No one should do it. Yeah. Retire
- 3:39is like to go out to pasture. I think that's
- 3:41one thing I saw. Yeah. I'm like, well, I don't
- 3:44feel like that's what I did. Yeah. I think retirement
- 3:47needs to be framed as the absence of needing
- 3:49to work, not the absence of work itself. If you
- 3:52reach financial independence, whether you're
- 3:5344 or 74, when you get there, if you reach financial
- 3:57independence, you can arguably do anything you
- 4:00want, but you need to have those things. And
- 4:02it has to be more than a bucket list, Daniel.
- 4:04It can't just be, I want to visit the Taj Mahal
- 4:06and Mount Rushmore. It's got to be more than
- 4:09that, or you'll check them off and then wonder
- 4:11what to do. So I do think there's a necessity
- 4:14to have passion and purpose in your life. And
- 4:17that's why I consider it a graduation because
- 4:19a graduation is in fact the end. of a program.
- 4:21It's the end of high school or the end of college
- 4:23or the end of some other program. But it's also
- 4:26celebratory in that it's a new beginning. It's
- 4:29a launchpad to the next great thing. So, you
- 4:33know, I would hate to see it be the last launchpad.
- 4:36Like, to what? You define it as moving towards
- 4:39something. Can you go a little bit deeper into
- 4:42why treating financial independence as a graduation
- 4:45changes how someone would prepare for it? Well,
- 4:48I think you need to figure out not only what
- 4:50you're going to be doing, but sort of who you
- 4:52want to be when you grow up. And some of the
- 4:54things you're going to be doing will require
- 4:56capital. Some of them won't. And so if there
- 4:59are things that you want to do, if you're passionate
- 5:00about philanthropy, if you're passionate about
- 5:02travel, if you're passionate about about all
- 5:05kinds of different projects, if you want to do
- 5:07consulting, whatever it is. You've got to be
- 5:10moving towards that and you have to make sure
- 5:12that you're not just unplugging. So having a
- 5:16plan is more than just the math. The math is
- 5:19arguably middle school math. It's algebra at
- 5:22best. This isn't a math problem. It's a human
- 5:24behavioral and psychology problem. And that's
- 5:27a much deeper conversation. Completely agree.
- 5:30You know, I was I was going through I've read
- 5:32a lot of books at this point, financial books
- 5:34and and yours. Your framework is so similar,
- 5:37maybe the most similar to how at least I thought
- 5:39about it. I was a project manager, though. And
- 5:42so I probably don't think like maybe normal people
- 5:45that are thinking about things like financial
- 5:47freedom. You talk about important milestones
- 5:49as a way to get to your goals and things like
- 5:51that. I was really curious, like, do you see
- 5:54it like a program? Do you have a background in
- 5:56program management? Where did that inspiration
- 5:58come from? I have no background in project management,
- 6:02but I'm a lifetime learner. So I have been through
- 6:0512 or so graduate programs, certificate programs.
- 6:09I'm still reinventing myself academically, intellectually,
- 6:13in all the ways that I know how. You know, this
- 6:15year I did a program on financial behavior keynotes.
- 6:19Next year I'm doing one on public speaking. I'm
- 6:22also doing one on sort of whole person meditation
- 6:24and finding different level as a financial advisor
- 6:28specifically. So, you know, I'm trying to continue
- 6:31to grow. Arthur Brooks wrote an amazing book.
- 6:34If you've read from strength to strength, if
- 6:36you've not read it, put it on your short list.
- 6:38It is it is an amazing way to frame what we're
- 6:41doing as we. change from our intelligence curve
- 6:44to our wisdom curve. And it's a really interesting
- 6:47piece because when you're 25 or 30, it's all
- 6:51about what you just learned. It's all about the
- 6:53textbook. It's all about having the right answer,
- 6:55which more and more computers have done for us.
- 6:58But nonetheless, that was the thing. It was about
- 7:00knowing the rules, knowing the way it works,
- 7:02having the right answer and having it at the
- 7:03tip of your tongue. People, as they get into
- 7:05their 40s, 50s, 60s and beyond, are less likely
- 7:08to know that stuff. And arguably, it's because
- 7:11it becomes less important to us. Now we're trading
- 7:13on wisdom, the experience to say that might be
- 7:15what the math problem says. But here's what really
- 7:17happens when someone loses a loved one, a spouse,
- 7:20a parent, a job. I mean, when life changes on
- 7:25you, it's not academic. It's personal. Well,
- 7:28as someone who's graduated so many times, you
- 7:31probably have a strong sense of what graduation
- 7:33means. So many times, though, graduation is kind
- 7:37of this little bit of a celebration, but then
- 7:40we end up kind of moving to another chapter,
- 7:43leaving, well, taking knowledge with us, but
- 7:45leaving the rest behind in a way, right? We kind
- 7:47of trying to look at that next chapter. In a
- 7:49traditional retirement, you know, people feel
- 7:52like they're leaving their identity behind so
- 7:53much of the time. Yes. How do people deal with
- 7:57that identity crisis that they have? Well, it
- 7:59starts by answering a really important question.
- 8:03which is, oh, tell me about yourself. Who are
- 8:04you? If the first thing you say is I'm an engineer,
- 8:07I'm an architect, I'm a project manager, then
- 8:10you're identifying almost entirely who you are
- 8:13with what you do. That's your day job. But I
- 8:15would argue you have a lot more roles. Maybe
- 8:17you're a husband, maybe you're a father, maybe
- 8:19you're a hockey fan, maybe you're a gardener
- 8:21or a cyclist. Do you have lots of other things?
- 8:23And so when I see folks on LinkedIn and they
- 8:25change their profile from project manager, vice
- 8:28president of yada yada to retired. If it said
- 8:31deceased, I would not be any less interested
- 8:34in connecting with that human at that point.
- 8:36You've really just given up. And, you know, you
- 8:38mentioned something about the fact that each
- 8:40graduation is an end, but it's also this step
- 8:43into the unknown. The happiest high schoolers
- 8:46I know are the people who finish their senior
- 8:48year having already gotten into college or some
- 8:50program they're going to. The happiest college
- 8:52students I know or apprenticeship programs I
- 8:55know are the people who finish, but they've already
- 8:56got a job lined up. The ones who finish and then
- 9:00say, oh, my gosh, now what? You know, they're
- 9:01the deer in the headlights. And it's a difficult
- 9:04thing. I know some people are planners and some
- 9:06people aren't. And I'm a planner. I want to know
- 9:08what's next. You know, I want to know what my
- 9:10next adventure is, not because I'm trying to
- 9:12rush through this one. You know, it's not about
- 9:14saying, oh, I can't wait until then or I can't
- 9:16wait until then. I think it's OK to enjoy the
- 9:18now and enjoy everything about it, but also know
- 9:21that there's a now plus one coming, whatever
- 9:23it is. Yeah, if you're excited about that next
- 9:25chapter, you're going to really celebrate that
- 9:27milestone in a bigger way. I love that anxiety
- 9:30and that uncertainty and ambiguity. It's gone.
- 9:33In your work, you talk about financial triage.
- 9:36And I thought I love the way you do this. This
- 9:38is very cool. So you talk about you have to triage
- 9:41this and really get in there almost surgically.
- 9:43And as a program manager, I really rely on like
- 9:45systems and things to manage complexity because
- 9:48the whole idea of being a really great. Project
- 9:51manager is you're really taking something very
- 9:53ambiguous and difficult and you're breaking it
- 9:56down and you're disambiguating it and you're
- 9:58getting rid of the complexity and you have to
- 10:00use systems and protocols and stuff to do that.
- 10:02If someone's listening right now and they feel
- 10:05that their financial life is a bit chaotic, how
- 10:07would you help them? What's that specific pre
- 10:10-retirement curriculum or order of operations
- 10:12that would help them stop the bleeding and start
- 10:15making real progress towards building the wealth
- 10:17they need to be able to celebrate? that big milestone
- 10:19that they should be working towards? The first
- 10:22step of any journey is figuring out where you
- 10:24are. It's the you are here sticker on the kiosk
- 10:27before you figure out where to take that turn
- 10:29or what have you. So I think the first step for
- 10:31anyone at any stage of their financial lives
- 10:34is inventory. Take inventory of where you are
- 10:36and be really honest with yourself. If you're
- 10:39married or have a significant other, really honest
- 10:41with him or her. Be transparent because if you
- 10:44lie to yourselves or your spouse or even a financial
- 10:47pro, you're wasting your time and your money
- 10:48in there. So be really thoughtful about saying
- 10:51this is where we are or where I am with open
- 10:55honesty. And then say, now, what are the steps
- 10:58that I need to take? And who are maybe the co
- 11:01-pilots I need to help me navigate? So what we
- 11:03do as CFPs is we are the primary care physician.
- 11:08We talk triage. You talk medicine. We are not
- 11:11necessarily the surgeons. We're the ones who
- 11:13are going to take a look at the body and say,
- 11:15all right, you need this doctor, this doctor,
- 11:18and this doctor. Let's get them. And so I can't
- 11:21say for sure that there's one thing to do first
- 11:23or another thing to do first because every family,
- 11:25every situation is different. But I will say
- 11:27in the simplest of terms, as a project manager,
- 11:29if you were to have a matrix with four boxes
- 11:31in it. And one access was urgency and one access
- 11:35was importance. Some things that are urgent and
- 11:38important come first. Then there are things that
- 11:40are urgent but maybe not important that need
- 11:42to come quickly or be delegated quickly so that
- 11:45you can focus on the important things. And anything
- 11:48in that box that's not urgent and not important
- 11:50truly should be last on the list. It's a rainy
- 11:53day project. It's not something we have to get
- 11:55to. And so you start to look at all the different
- 11:58components. of a financial plan. You look at
- 12:01risk management and cash management and debt,
- 12:03and you look at insurances and you look at investment
- 12:06portfolios and you look at timelines and you
- 12:08look at employee benefits and government benefits
- 12:10and all the various pieces, your taxes, your
- 12:13legal documents, your mortgages, your bank statements,
- 12:17all of the things. We've had folks show up at
- 12:19our office with like two suitcases, like two
- 12:21roller bags and dump it on the conference table
- 12:23like it's an audit. Here you go. Boom. But they
- 12:28have no idea what they've got. And the financial
- 12:30world is very complicated. The tax world is very
- 12:33complicated. I believe it's partially complicated
- 12:36due to acts of legislation that make it so. But
- 12:39there's also a complexity generated by the financial
- 12:42professionals who want to stay relevant. If the
- 12:44tax code was really simple and you could file
- 12:46with a postcard, you might not have a CPA. CPAs
- 12:49don't want that. I'm not picking on them. It's
- 12:52just a fact. So it's complicated. You need to
- 12:55speak the language. You know, imagine opening
- 12:57a game box of Monopoly, having never played it
- 13:00before, never seen it before, and just starting
- 13:02and hoping for the best. If you don't know what
- 13:04the rules are, or if you're playing with somebody
- 13:06who likes to make up new rules or change them
- 13:08or house rules are, you do this. It's not going
- 13:11to be as much fun as if you understand the game.
- 13:13And money, to a great extent, is partly a game.
- 13:18The financial world, it's not always fun to play.
- 13:20It can be real hard. But if you know the rules,
- 13:23it helps. It'd be very frustrating to play Monopoly
- 13:25without knowing the rules. Imagine that. Imagine
- 13:28if you didn't know Boardwalk from Baltic, you'd
- 13:31be in deep trouble. Absolutely. You would not
- 13:32understand why you're getting behind and why
- 13:34you're struggling. You know, advising so often
- 13:38is the soft skills of trying to redirect people.
- 13:42towards where they need to start based on that
- 13:44triage a lot of the time and i do notice that
- 13:47there's a lot of people especially younger people
- 13:50now who want to jump straight into investing
- 13:52oh yeah right the offense how do you help someone
- 13:56in that situation understand that some of the
- 13:58more foundational elements like debt management
- 14:01or cash flow should be the area of operation
- 14:04they start with before they get to the stuff
- 14:06that they're excited to work on I try to paint
- 14:08it in terms people can readily grasp. Like, for
- 14:10example, you rarely pick out the window treatments
- 14:13before you pour the foundation for the new house,
- 14:16right? There are certain things that have to
- 14:18happen first. You have to have blocking and tackling
- 14:20before you can talk about the play you're going
- 14:22to run. Investing, while important, is arguably
- 14:25last. It is the last piece of that puzzle. It's
- 14:28the cherry on top. You know, there are so many
- 14:31things that have to come first because no matter
- 14:33what you're investing in or how you're doing
- 14:35it or how nice your portfolio looks, if you have
- 14:37wild personal debt or if you don't have your
- 14:40other ducks in a row, you're undermining yourself.
- 14:43You're filling a bucket that's got holes in the
- 14:44bottom. And so I think it's really important
- 14:47to have a solid foundation, to have a solid structure.
- 14:49And when you get to the investments, and yes,
- 14:52I freely admit the investments are more fun to
- 14:54talk about. They're more fun to talk about at
- 14:56cocktail parties, at the water cooler, whatever.
- 14:58Everybody likes to say, oh, you guess what my
- 15:00401k did? Nobody says, have you heard about this
- 15:03life insurance policy? It's awesome. No one's
- 15:05ever said that at a water cooler unless they'd
- 15:07had one too many. So I do think that it's what
- 15:10people want to talk about, especially young people.
- 15:13And it's been made worse by some of these online
- 15:16vendors that have gamified investing. Where if,
- 15:20oh, if you bought a stock, cha -ching, you get
- 15:22a gold star and a badge and all this stuff. They've
- 15:25gamified it. And it's not a game. As much as
- 15:29I just said, it's a game with rules. Investing
- 15:32is something you have to really understand or
- 15:34you have to hire somebody who really understands
- 15:35it. And if anybody tells you that they're smarter
- 15:38than the market, they can time it, they can do
- 15:40all these things, run. Because no one can. It's
- 15:43not possible. Absolutely. Robinhood just added
- 15:46the ability to do shorts and they came up by
- 15:49so much. It actually makes me very nervous. Things
- 15:51like that. Yeah, of course. What could go wrong
- 15:54by going into endless debt? Bottomless? Yeah.
- 15:56Not understanding how leverage works and then
- 15:58jumping into, you know, yeah, that scares me.
- 16:01Yeah. Let me ask you then, because, you know,
- 16:03you did mention there's a not a very difficult
- 16:06math problem here. You know, someone's following
- 16:09the advice they're going through and they're
- 16:10doing the triage properly. Do you see kind of
- 16:13like a specific green light metric that you're
- 16:14looking at? Like, how do you help someone know,
- 16:16okay, you're actually pretty stable. Now you
- 16:19could start doing that thing you want to do now,
- 16:21which would be think about transition or maybe
- 16:24aggressively investing. Like, is there certain
- 16:26metrics that you like to look at? I would say
- 16:28the first thing is your balance sheet has to
- 16:30be free of really adverse debt. And by adverse
- 16:34debt, I don't mean all debt. If you have a mortgage
- 16:36or you have leverage against a business or something
- 16:38that's an asset that's designed to grow. Not
- 16:41so terrible generally, but if you have consumer
- 16:43debt, car notes, student loans in most cases
- 16:46I consider to be an abomination. You know, the
- 16:48exception might be for professional schools where
- 16:51it really will buy you a better outcome. Undergraduate
- 16:54school is not worth borrowing six figures for.
- 16:57It's just not. And unfortunately, we've lost
- 17:00our way from that standpoint. But if you have
- 17:02really adverse debt, you've got to first fill
- 17:04that in. You can't build a mountain chart when
- 17:06you're starting in a hole. The next thing is
- 17:08you have to have positive cash flow. It doesn't
- 17:10matter how much money you make. You know, income
- 17:13and wealth are not the same thing. Income is
- 17:15what's coming in. But if your expenses are higher
- 17:18than your income, your wealth is going backwards.
- 17:20So thinking about having positive cash flows,
- 17:23just like a business. If you were running a business,
- 17:25you would want a P &L. You want your revenues
- 17:27to be greater than your expenses. So you had
- 17:29a profit. Same thing's true at the household
- 17:31level. And then it's about building a savings
- 17:34rate or investing rate that marries your objective
- 17:38for financial independence. So you're out of
- 17:41debt or adverse debt. At least you've got positive
- 17:43cashflow. You've got more coming in than what's
- 17:45going out. Now, how much should you be saving
- 17:48or investing for the true longterm? And how much
- 17:50should you be using to enjoy your life? Because
- 17:53I've seen too many people who save every penny
- 17:55and never live too. And there's like anything
- 17:57else, there's a spectrum to squirrel away. Every
- 17:59penny and never live is sad. To save nothing
- 18:02and live great and then one day wake up and you're
- 18:05living under a bridge is also not a great outcome.
- 18:07So there's something in between there, Daniel,
- 18:08right? Absolutely. And so I think figuring out
- 18:11do you need to put away 10 % or 15 % or 30 %
- 18:15of what you make into something. And when I say
- 18:18it's a simple math problem, one of the chapters
- 18:19in the book starts with the formula. And the
- 18:22formula actually looks very daunting. But the
- 18:24simple nature of this is if you put X dollars
- 18:27away. Every month for Y years and you get Z percent
- 18:31will become this figure. But then thinking about
- 18:34what that figure means, there are people right
- 18:37now who think if 20 years from now I can build
- 18:39a portfolio that's a million dollars, I can retire
- 18:42comfortably. And the reality is a million dollars,
- 18:44while a nice figure, probably only provides you
- 18:48with about $40 ,000 a year to live on. And I
- 18:50don't know too many people trying to save to
- 18:52a million dollars who are comfortable living
- 18:54on $40 ,000 a year now. Imagine $40 ,000 a year
- 18:5720 years from now when that's equivalent to $15
- 19:00,000 today because of inflation. The number's
- 19:03going to be massive. And if you look at just
- 19:05the number, if you're 26 years old and you're
- 19:07listening to this and you're going, how much
- 19:09do I need? If I were to tell you $10 million,
- 19:11you'd panic. But that might be the answer. And
- 19:14it's not impossible over 40 years given the right
- 19:17behaviors. In terms of for young people. beginning
- 19:19with a 401k at your first employer that's got
- 19:21a match and understanding how that works is a
- 19:23win and understanding why the Roth might be a
- 19:26better option for you is a win. And, you know,
- 19:28choosing the right health insurance plan at your
- 19:30company is all those things are little wins.
- 19:32Yeah. I mean, cashflow is so important too. I
- 19:34think so many people miss that. And I really
- 19:36would like to ask you about the magic number
- 19:39that I see floating around all the time, because
- 19:43let me start with a little context. So a lot
- 19:46of times when people get to a standard retirement,
- 19:49they start to worry mostly about like medical
- 19:51expenses so that's a very common concern right
- 19:53and a couple retiring today is estimated to need
- 19:56330 000 in medical expenses this was a fidelity
- 19:59retiree health care cost estimate report from
- 20:02last year and so they see these numbers they
- 20:04get really nervous about it but you know health
- 20:06care is just like any other expense right you
- 20:08can figure it out and you can figure out what
- 20:10you'll need there and you should have that but
- 20:12so many people especially in fire the financial
- 20:14independence retire early movement I have this
- 20:16obsession with the number being the 4 % rule.
- 20:19And as a program manager, I really don't love
- 20:21that because it oversimplifies and it can break
- 20:24under stress very easily because life is not
- 20:26as simple as a constant, you know, no constant
- 20:29will work. And I'm not saying you can't make
- 20:314 % work, right? You can be your average, you
- 20:34know, it's supposed to be inflation adjusted,
- 20:35but you talk about moving from offense to defense.
- 20:39And I really love that because a good program
- 20:42manager is a risk manager. You're thinking about
- 20:44the long game. You're thinking about how do I
- 20:47protect this thing? So what are the specific
- 20:49defense holes, liability, insurance, estate planning?
- 20:53What are the things someone really needs to be
- 20:56thinking about, which is more than how much money
- 20:59do I need to get into this account so I can withdraw
- 21:02at this percentage to really know that I played
- 21:06a good defense game? An ideal financial plan,
- 21:09and I put ideal in quotes because I'm not sure
- 21:11it fully exists, but an ideal financial plan
- 21:13is one that works no matter what. And it can
- 21:15handle the curves along the road because life
- 21:18isn't linear. It can handle a period of unemployment
- 21:21or an illness or an accident. It can handle if
- 21:23someone in the family dies tomorrow or if somebody
- 21:26lives to be 106. That's a really tough math problem.
- 21:30And so I think before we even try and start figuring
- 21:32out what are the defensive holes, we have to
- 21:35know that this is not a set it and forget it.
- 21:37it's a monitor it it's every six months or a
- 21:40year have that physical exam again you don't
- 21:42get a physical exam when you're 31 and then not
- 21:45again until you're 70 you get one every year
- 21:47ideally and that helps you see trends it helps
- 21:49you take care of yourself so where are the holes
- 21:52well one of them is is typically in risk management
- 21:54and some of the things in risk management are
- 21:57incredibly easy to fix some of them are related
- 22:00to how assets are titled or how beneficiaries
- 22:02are named, or how documents have been set up,
- 22:05or how your cash emergency fund is set and where
- 22:09it is and how much is it. Some families need
- 22:11six months of expenses sitting in cash. Some
- 22:14need 12. Retirees, some of them want five years'
- 22:17worth. And that's not ridiculous. You talk about
- 22:20the 4 % rule, and I agree with you. The 4 % rule
- 22:22doesn't work because your inputs are not always
- 22:25the same. If you had an investment that for the
- 22:28rest of time could do seven and a half percent
- 22:31every year forever, seven and a half, seven and
- 22:32a half, seven and a half, seven and a half, and
- 22:34you were pulling out four, four, four, four,
- 22:35you'd be adjusting for inflation at three and
- 22:37a half every year. It's brilliant. But we don't
- 22:40get seven and a half every year. There are years
- 22:42where we get 20 and years where we get minus
- 22:4420, you know, and so not that simple. So there
- 22:47are three different strategies for the withdrawal
- 22:50rate. And it really does depend on what your
- 22:53net worth is and what your spending needs to
- 22:55be. And you'll notice I avoid the B word. I like
- 22:58to keep things clean. And on my show, the B word
- 23:00is budget. I said it. I don't like it. Nobody
- 23:03should say that because a budget's like diet.
- 23:06Like you can talk about nutrition, but don't
- 23:08talk about diet. Nobody likes that. So if you
- 23:11know, for example, that based on your nest egg,
- 23:13based on your net worth, that you need a withdrawal
- 23:16rate of, say, 2 % to make ends meet. then you
- 23:19have a really good shot at continuing to grow
- 23:22that nest egg, keeping up with inflation and
- 23:24preparing for whether it's a healthcare emergency
- 23:26or some other emergency or opportunity that comes
- 23:28along. If your withdrawal rate is 4 % or so,
- 23:31four, four and a half, it's time to start talking
- 23:34about asset segregation. You can't use that total
- 23:37return, one big bucket, plenty of excess. Now
- 23:40you have to set some accounts for certain time
- 23:42periods. People call it the bucket strategy.
- 23:45There are lots of different names for it. But
- 23:46the reality is you need money that's available
- 23:49for the short term that's not subject to fluctuation.
- 23:51You need money that's for the next period of
- 23:54years, usually the next five, where volatility
- 23:56will be low. But then you need the discipline
- 23:59to keep any money that you're unlikely to touch
- 24:01for at least 10 years fully engaged in growth,
- 24:04where you will eventually lose your standard
- 24:07of living. Now, for folks who have a withdrawal
- 24:09rate at six and seven and eight percent in order
- 24:12to live because they haven't saved enough or
- 24:13because their world's too expensive, in addition
- 24:16to trying to cut costs where you can or going
- 24:18back to work, which some people are forced to
- 24:20do, you also have solutions like annuities and
- 24:23other types of things that people don't want
- 24:25and don't like and they're expensive, but they
- 24:28can solve a problem when you're in that spot
- 24:29sometimes. And, you know, it is a recipe to run
- 24:33out of money. But if you showed up on my doorstep
- 24:35and you said, I've got an eight percent withdrawal
- 24:36rate, I don't think this is. going to work. And
- 24:38I said, sir, you're 87 years old. If you got
- 24:400%, you're good for 15 years and you're not going
- 24:45to get 0%. So you might be okay. You know, withdrawal
- 24:47rate is by itself, just a number at 88 years
- 24:50old, it might be fine at 68. It's a disaster
- 24:52because you might have all that time in front
- 24:55of you. Yeah. I mean, you really need to look
- 24:56at every tool that's available to you to customize
- 24:59your solution to the problem. And you have this.
- 25:02area where you talk about questions to determine
- 25:04if you should break up with your financial advisor.
- 25:07And I love that so much for so many reasons,
- 25:09but I actually want to ask you the inverse because
- 25:12many of my listeners are using complex problems
- 25:15themselves, you know, a little bit of a DIY kind
- 25:18of thing, right? Because of the nuances here
- 25:22that we just covered, when should you know that
- 25:26it's time for a co -pilot? that maybe you might
- 25:29have a blind spot or you might be missing a tool
- 25:32that you should be considering. When would you
- 25:34want someone to think about maybe it's time to
- 25:37go figure out not only if you have a financial
- 25:40advisor, how to break up with them, but like
- 25:41maybe you should start talking to one if you
- 25:43haven't spoken to one before. Or talking to two
- 25:45or three and figuring out where you're comfortable,
- 25:47all those kinds of things. First of all, your
- 25:49financial advisor has to be the right fit for
- 25:51you in the same way you're. your primary care
- 25:53physician has to be the right fit. And if you're
- 25:55somebody who takes great care of yourself, you're
- 25:57on the treadmill every day and you're eating
- 25:59right and you're keeping your stress right and
- 26:01you're sleeping great and you assume you're in
- 26:03perfect health and you never go to the doctor,
- 26:05there can be things that you miss. This is very
- 26:07similar. I do think anyone with the means to
- 26:10do it should have a financial advisor on some
- 26:12basis. That does not mean you have to hand over
- 26:15all of your financial affairs and have them manage
- 26:18them. Like anything else, it can be extremely
- 26:21high touch. can be sort of a supplement to do
- 26:24it yourself. Some people want a concierge physician.
- 26:27They want somebody who's going to take care of
- 26:28everything. As a financial advisor for a client
- 26:31to say, look, we just just just handle it. Tell
- 26:33us what to do and we'll do it. Take everything.
- 26:35We're happy to do it that way. But we have other
- 26:37folks who say, you know, I just sort of want
- 26:39to make sure I'm on track every year or two.
- 26:41And I'm going to keep managing certain things
- 26:43on my own. And let's just get some eyes on it.
- 26:45And if the day ever comes where they don't feel
- 26:49like they can handle it anymore, it's gotten
- 26:50too big or too complex or they're working two
- 26:53jobs and don't have time or whatever happens.
- 26:55They'll already have that relationship they can
- 26:57rely on and they don't have to. then shop, particularly
- 26:59under duress, to find somebody to help them.
- 27:02So I think it's okay to get that financial physical,
- 27:05even if it's not every year. Say, where are we
- 27:08really? Are we in good shape? You know, and I've
- 27:10told enough people over my 30 plus years, my
- 27:13gosh, you're doing everything right. You don't
- 27:14need a financial advisor. You might want one,
- 27:17but you don't need one. It's kind of like saying
- 27:19you might want this type of insurance or this
- 27:21type of solution, but you don't need it. It might
- 27:24make you feel better. It might be less responsibility
- 27:26on your end. You know, for your listeners who
- 27:28don't have a financial advisor and who've never
- 27:30used one, I would tell you that a decent financial
- 27:33advisor, and there's a whole list of interview
- 27:35questions in the book. There's a whole chapter
- 27:37dedicated. Here are the questions to ask. And
- 27:39not because one answer is better than the other,
- 27:41but because you have to understand what the answers
- 27:43mean. Financial advisors are tougher to hire
- 27:46than some other professionals because there is
- 27:49no standard. and no career path for people to
- 27:53become financial advisors. If you're hiring a
- 27:55doctor, you fully expect they went to med school
- 27:58and they're an MD. If you hire a lawyer, you
- 28:00expect that they've passed the bar and are in
- 28:03fact JDs. Your CPA is either a CPA or he or she's
- 28:06not. But your financial advisor could be somebody
- 28:09who showed up for their first day at work at
- 28:11XYZ Mutual Life Insurance Company and they've
- 28:15got financial representative on their card and
- 28:17they're no more adept at it than the guy next
- 28:19door doing anything. So I do think the certified
- 28:22financial planner practitioner is a gold standard,
- 28:25but it's not the only gold standard. There's
- 28:27some other ways. And so understanding what credentials
- 28:30an advisor has, what services they provide, how
- 28:33they're paid, how they work with you, what you
- 28:35can expect from them is very reasonable. And,
- 28:38you know, unfortunately, it's not simple. Most
- 28:40people rely on a friend or a neighbor or another
- 28:43advisor for a referral or a recommendation. And
- 28:46while that's a lovely thing and we consider it
- 28:48an honor to have somebody say, hey, we'd like
- 28:51you to talk to our folks. The truth is you don't
- 28:53know if that recommendation is from somebody
- 28:54who's being really well taken care of or who's
- 28:57in the dark. So I do think it's incumbent upon
- 29:00everybody to really objectively look at their
- 29:03finances and potentially to have somebody else
- 29:05look at them. You know, I have a financial advisor,
- 29:08not because I don't know how to do it, but because
- 29:10emotionally you're connected to your money in
- 29:12a different way. And I wanted somebody else to
- 29:15say, Come on, you know, just go do that. And,
- 29:18you know, there are some really good athletes
- 29:21who have coaches and trainers and all those things.
- 29:23Why? They're already great athletes. Well, yes,
- 29:25they want to stay that way. You know, I have
- 29:27a trainer who comes to the house because if I
- 29:28didn't, I wouldn't work out. If I have an appointment,
- 29:30I show up and I lift. If I don't have an appointment,
- 29:33I got stuff to do. Financially, it's very similar.
- 29:35It's funny you said that because I was going
- 29:37to mention that I. kind of outgrown many financial
- 29:40advisors and throughout my time doing it, I actually
- 29:42left seven different advisors throughout my 20
- 29:45year program. Quite a few. Wow. Now, lots of
- 29:48different reasons, sometimes not the best financial
- 29:51advisor. Sometimes they were amazing, but I just,
- 29:52you know, my needs would change and I was constantly
- 29:55kind of evaluating that, but I'm actually close
- 29:58to getting my own degree and a wealth management
- 30:01degree and becoming an advisor. And people are
- 30:02surprised to hear that I still have one that
- 30:05I still go in because I do, I like to have. checkups
- 30:08two to three times a year on what I'm doing.
- 30:10Because to be honest, I don't think anyone can
- 30:13have zero blind spots. I don't think that's possible.
- 30:15I think you need to find somebody, like you said,
- 30:17that can stress test some of your stuff and do
- 30:21that for you. You're a writer, aren't you? You
- 30:24do a lot of writing. Yeah, I do. Yes. Who edits
- 30:27your work? That's a great question. So I actually
- 30:30self -edit and then I pay for a third party person
- 30:34to do a final edit pass for me. Same idea. you
- 30:37know, I, I can't edit my own work. I love to
- 30:40write, but I need somebody else to read it. Not
- 30:43because when I read my own writing, I'm reading
- 30:45what I think I wrote and I'm hearing it the way
- 30:48I intended it. I want somebody who's objective
- 30:51to look at that and say, this is the way I took
- 30:53that. And maybe there's some interpretation here,
- 30:56or maybe, maybe we got to change the framework
- 30:59a little bit. And not because I don't think I'm
- 31:01a fine writer, but because I can't. edit my own
- 31:05work. And I think financially it's very similar.
- 31:07I think it's really important to have somebody
- 31:09objective who has no skin in the game to be able
- 31:12to say, you really ought to consider this, this,
- 31:15and this. And I'm free to say no, like any client
- 31:17to say, I realize I should do that, but that's
- 31:19just not, I'm going to, I'm going to self -insure
- 31:21for that, or I'm going to do this differently.
- 31:23But if I go in there knowing that. It's not a
- 31:25financial advisor's job to force you to do anything.
- 31:28It's our job to educate you on and to share options
- 31:30with you and to have you make an educated decision
- 31:33that you're going to live with. Ultimately, it's
- 31:35your money, it's your portfolio, it's your plan.
- 31:37You have to live with the outcomes. We have to
- 31:39try and show you the possible outcomes and help
- 31:41you pick one that makes sense from a risk standpoint,
- 31:44but also from a life standpoint. Absolutely.
- 31:48I really want to ask you this one last question,
- 31:50and then I want to give you a chance to let the
- 31:51audience know how to connect with you as well,
- 31:53because we covered so much great stuff today.
- 31:54If you could give one piece of advice to someone
- 31:57who's five years away from their graduation date
- 31:59to help them best prepare for one, celebrating
- 32:02that huge accomplishment, but two, just knowing
- 32:06that they're going into their post -graduation
- 32:08to live the best possible life they can, what
- 32:10would you tell them? Two things. From a planning
- 32:13standpoint, I'd say take inventory and start
- 32:16immediately. Make sure you know exactly where
- 32:18you are and not just where you think you are.
- 32:20But on a more psychological standpoint, if you're
- 32:23five years from retirement or what retirement
- 32:25means to you and you have the bandwidth and the
- 32:28ability to do it, take a month or two off. Practice.
- 32:31See what it's like. See what it's like to wake
- 32:34up in the morning, make your coffee and not have
- 32:35to rush to email or to work or to whatever it
- 32:38is you do. And be thinking about how you might
- 32:41want to spend half of your adult life, which
- 32:45is what retirement can be. Certainly, if we look
- 32:48at the years between 20 and 80 as your most productive
- 32:51adult years, if you're 50, you're at the 50 -yard
- 32:54line, no pun intended. I'm on that back nine
- 32:57right now myself, so I get it. Think about how
- 32:59you would want to spend your day, your time,
- 33:02your money, and try it. I get bored after four
- 33:06days on vacation. Seriously, if I'm not going
- 33:09biking down a volcano, I'm going to be bored
- 33:12that day. I've got to find something to do. And
- 33:14some people can sit around, oh, I've got all
- 33:16these books I want to read. Maybe that's you.
- 33:18But try it. Get up every day and just read for
- 33:21two days or five days or eight days or play the
- 33:25video game or play golf twice a day or whatever
- 33:27it is. I think what you'll find is, number one,
- 33:30you'll be yearning for adult communication and
- 33:34meaningful dialogue with people. And you'll be
- 33:36finding ways to volunteer or places to go or
- 33:39things to do that will engage you because it
- 33:42can be incredibly lonely. Retirement in and of
- 33:44itself, if you're home all day, particularly
- 33:47if you live alone, but even if you're with a
- 33:48spouse who might still be going to work, you'll
- 33:51be bored out of your mind. That's powerful advice.
- 33:54And I will say from someone who did that myself,
- 33:57I definitely had a kind of a trial run before
- 34:00mine and I knew I was ready for it. But yeah,
- 34:03you're right. You never know what it's like until
- 34:05you've been there because that is a real transition,
- 34:08right? And you always want to be moving forward,
- 34:11never going backwards. Thank you so much, Eric.
- 34:14This was a fantastic conversation full of a lot
- 34:17of wisdom and insightful things. I really appreciate
- 34:19that. How can listeners connect with you, your
- 34:22podcast, your book? What's the best way? Well,
- 34:25to check out the podcast and the book and all
- 34:28of our materials, some of which are available
- 34:30for free online, go to bfguniversity .com and
- 34:34you can find all of our materials. And if you
- 34:37want to check us out from a financial planning
- 34:39standpoint and get to know our team and a little
- 34:41bit about us and maybe have that physical exam,
- 34:44bfgfa .com. Thank you again. Really appreciate
- 34:48it, Eric. It's been great, Daniel. Thank you.
- 34:58Today's conversation with Eric Brotman challenged
- 35:01the very vocabulary that we use when we describe
- 35:04our goals. Retirement is a word that commonly
- 35:07elicits an end. It suggests withdrawing from
- 35:11our busy, important lives and going out to pasture.
- 35:14But as we discussed, escaping the clock is not
- 35:17an end. It's a graduation. It is the commencement
- 35:20of the life you have been building toward all
- 35:23along. Reframing it, That way can actually help
- 35:26change everything. It can change the way we prepare,
- 35:29and it can move us away from retirement as a
- 35:32passive goal to one with a clearly marked finish
- 35:35line, one that rewards us with the new act of
- 35:38life that we designed. Eric spoke about the critical
- 35:41shift from offense to playing defense. During
- 35:44our accumulation years, we're focused on growth,
- 35:47taking risks, and maximizing our returns. But
- 35:50once we graduate, the game changes. It becomes
- 35:54about risk management. Deliberately planning
- 35:56for that shift can reduce the stress and it can
- 36:00allow us to continue the celebration of our big
- 36:02milestone. He also hit us with some real numbers.
- 36:05Hitting a million dollars might feel great, but
- 36:08as Eric points out, that would supply only $40
- 36:11,000 a year to live on. Living on $40 ,000 can
- 36:15really be hard, especially if you don't do that
- 36:18already. And in 20 years, that $40 ,000 is going
- 36:22to feel like a lot less, likely $15 ,000 or so
- 36:25thanks to inflation. So the real number might
- 36:28be as high as $10 million. And a number like
- 36:32that can be very scary. But like we covered,
- 36:34with some discipline and time, you can get to
- 36:37the FI number that actually works. And that will
- 36:40give you the peace of mind to really celebrate
- 36:42that graduation for real. If you feel like this
- 36:45is an impossible task, then I would like to circle
- 36:48back to the concept of a financial editor. We
- 36:51often think that we can DIY everything, but just
- 36:55as a writer cannot effectively edit their own
- 36:57work because we are too close to the story, we
- 37:00often cannot see the flaws in our own financial
- 37:03logic. Even financial advisors have financial
- 37:07advisors because the emotional side of money,
- 37:10it just creates blind spots that the spreadsheet
- 37:12can't fix alone. Finding the right fit of advisors
- 37:16can make a huge difference in building the confidence
- 37:19that we need to graduate. And when we graduate,
- 37:22it'll just be the once. And that brings me to
- 37:25the last big piece of advice that Eric had on,
- 37:28practicing that retirement. I personally took
- 37:31a trial run and I can tell you, it gave me the
- 37:34confidence that I had been missing. It's easy
- 37:37to dream about endless free time, but until you
- 37:39actually spend a month or two without the structure
- 37:41of a job, You don't know how you'll react to
- 37:44the silence. You have to ensure that you're running
- 37:47toward a new identity, not just running away
- 37:49from an old job. I would love to hear from you.
- 37:52Are you treating your exit like a resignation
- 37:55or as a graduation? Shoot me an email at contact
- 37:59at escapetheclock .com or leave a comment where
- 38:02you listen. Best of luck graduating into your
- 38:05financial freedom and escaping the clock. I'm
- 38:07Daniel C. Rogers. I'll see you next week. Thanks
- 38:11for tuning in to this episode. Remember, while
- 38:14I'm not yet a financial planner, I am getting
- 38:16my degree in wealth management. You should take
- 38:19anything you've heard here as tips and advice
- 38:21to making your plan. To learn more, visit www
- 38:24.escapetheclock .com. There you can find the
- 38:27book, resources, including the planner, and you
- 38:30can even schedule time with me. Please remember
- 38:32to like and subscribe so you don't miss an episode.
- 38:35Thanks for tuning in and I'll catch you next
- 38:36time.