Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / 156: Brian Knight of NASCUS on the Wisdom of Crowds, AI,Training & More
Transcript
- 0:35Mark Treichel: Everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:36episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:39Today I am here with a special guest, Brian Knight, the president
- 0:43of NASCS, the National Association of State Credit Union Supervisors.
- 0:47That's a mouthful, but NASCS is easier.
- 0:49Brian, how you doing today?
- 0:51Brian Knight: I'm doing well, Mark.
- 0:51Thanks for having me on.
- 0:52It's good to see you again, old friend.
- 0:54Yeah,
- 0:54Mark Treichel: good to see you.
- 0:55It's been an interesting year and federal charters, state charters
- 0:59state regulators et cetera, et cetera.
- 1:01So I'm really looking forward to chatting.
- 1:04About what's happened at NASCS and credit unions in 2023 and what
- 1:08you see on the horizon for 2024.
- 1:11We're recording this December 28th and this episode will be live early January.
- 1:17So yeah, let's so 2023, what's your takeaway on 2023, Brian.
- 1:22Brian Knight: 2023 was a busy year for nasca, for the credit union system.
- 1:26Obviously lots of big news affecting the credit union system,
- 1:29multiple big mergers of national organizations and associations.
- 1:35Were getting reconfigured, N-C-U-A-N-C-U-A board, and there's a
- 1:39lot of work going on at the state level.
- 1:41As well, as I look back on 2023 for NASCS, obviously, we did
- 1:44the things that we always do.
- 1:46We filed dozens of rule summaries and comment letters.
- 1:50We provided reviews of multiple state credit union acts for regulators for
- 1:55some of our credit union stakeholder.
- 1:57Members to take a look at where their act compares to other states to NCOA where
- 2:02it's going in the future We launched new committees to really zero in on some
- 2:07growing issues We launched a committee focused on the special designations,
- 2:12you know The minority depository institutions the low income designated
- 2:15the cdfis We have a new committee that is looking at those Issues related to those
- 2:21designations also helping to raise in some cases state regulator awareness of
- 2:26the importance of those designations, but also helping focus on those designations.
- 2:30So that committee has met a couple of times.
- 2:32We're very excited about that.
- 2:34We have a new round table focused on anti financial crimes heavily in the BSA AML.
- 2:41Space, but, we have begun transitioning our view of BSA and AML from a, I think
- 2:46what's been historically in the credit union space, a compliance focused view
- 2:51of Bank Secrecy Act and anti money laundering and NASCS has begun to look
- 2:55at that really through the lens of anti financial crimes, and I think in our view,
- 2:59those folks who specialize In that area, either at NCOA, at the state regulatory
- 3:05agencies, at the credit unions, at the leagues, they're not necessarily BSA
- 3:09examiners or BSA compliance officers, although that's the title they often hold.
- 3:13What they really are anti financial crimes professionals.
- 3:15I mean, that whole area I think has grown beyond compliance.
- 3:18And so we've begun to, to pivot our view of that portfolio through
- 3:24the anti financial crimes lens.
- 3:26And we've stood up a new round table of those professionals.
- 3:30Credit unions around the country.
- 3:31They don't even have to be NASCS members to, to gather on a regular basis
- 3:34and talk about all of those issues.
- 3:36Plus, I also think as we talk about 2024, that obviously there's a renewed focus on
- 3:41those issues on the financing of terrorism on sanctions program, whether it's OFAC
- 3:46or FinCEN, you look at the war in Ukraine, you look at what's going on in Gaza.
- 3:50And obviously from a foreign policy perspective, there is a renewed emphasis.
- 3:54On sanctions and those issues, but we also see continued implementation of
- 4:00the 2020 anti money laundering act.
- 4:02So we'll talk about that again as we look ahead of 2024.
- 4:05So we've stood.
- 4:06We've stood that up.
- 4:07We're going to be launching a new legal roundtable.
- 4:10We're going to be pulling in the general counsels from agencies.
- 4:13Some of our regulators, we actually have a bumper crop of the regulators
- 4:16themselves who happen to be attorneys, even if they're not the
- 4:19general counsels for their agencies.
- 4:20And of course, we've always worked very closely with the general counsels from
- 4:24many of our credit union members and League and other stakeholder members.
- 4:27So we're going to be pulling together a round table.
- 4:29We actually used to have 15 years ago, and we just with workload
- 4:33and capacity it, it went by.
- 4:35That wasn't a priority for us, but we're relaunching it because we've
- 4:37had some conversations with folks who'd like to talk with each other.
- 4:40We've been running a series of free webinars going back now, 3 or 4
- 4:44years for all of our members on.
- 4:46Kind of litigation in the financial services sector, the class action
- 4:50litigation, general litigation, the CFPB and the SCOTUS and those kinds of issues.
- 4:54And there's been such a great response for it that we're going to stand up a
- 4:57group who will meet probably quarterly to just focus and talk about those issues.
- 5:02Also in 2023, Mark, you remember this when you were executive
- 5:04director, obviously, a lot of what we do is working with the national
- 5:08exam committees meeting quarterly.
- 5:10We have the, I call it new, but it dates back now to 2018 pre pandemic world, the
- 5:15joint supervisory working group, just series of state regulators who sit with
- 5:19senior staff and some on a quarterly basis and talk about all of the issues
- 5:24related to the shared supervisory mission that and state regulators have for
- 5:29the federally insured state charters.
- 5:32We have monthly calls with all of our state regulators.
- 5:36Every other one of those calls, we invite NCUA to participate and NCUA continues
- 5:40to find value in joining that call.
- 5:42So every other month, NCUA and all the state regulators are on
- 5:46the phone on a Thursday afternoon, just talking about all of the.
- 5:50Supervisory concerns issues trends that they see out there.
- 5:55Exciting news towards the back end of 2023 in November, the South Carolina
- 6:00board of financial institutions achieved its 1st and ask us accreditation.
- 6:04So, congratulations.
- 6:06to Commissioner of Banking Kathy Bickham.
- 6:08I'm actually headed down to Columbia in early February to present them
- 6:12their big certificate and congratulate them on achieving NASCS accreditation.
- 6:18And then lots of training and education.
- 6:20We probably put well over 2, 000 people through various NASCS events in
- 6:242023, whether they were our director's colleges, our executive forums, our
- 6:31big AFC training, our cyber security training, our cannabis banking, and
- 6:36that doesn't even include all the training we do specifically for the
- 6:39states, whether it is a state specific training for their agency, or whether
- 6:43it is sending state regulators to FFIC.
- 6:47Classes are providing them other scholarships so they can augment
- 6:51their state training budget.
- 6:52So busy, busy year in 2023.
- 6:54But looking back, pleased with NASCSIS performance, pleased with the
- 6:59state of the state system in 2023.
- 7:02I think a lot of challenges obviously lie ahead in 2024, but I think as
- 7:06we finish out the year and look at January and beginning the next year,
- 7:10I think we're in as good a shape as we can expect to be to face and meet the
- 7:14challenges that are that are coming.
- 7:16Well, I get
- 7:17Mark Treichel: tired just, just listening to all those achievements for the year.
- 7:19It's like, holy smokes.
- 7:21Did you add, did you double staff
- 7:22Brian Knight: too?
- 7:23No we still do this with a staff of
- 7:26nine.
- 7:26Mark Treichel: Wow.
- 7:27That's fantastic.
- 7:28So a couple of the, the fraud, anti financial crimes when I hear that in
- 7:34my mind, I also go a little bit beyond the anti money laundering and BSA side
- 7:38of things and, and just with like AI, there was a podcast I was listening
- 7:43to where they were giving an example of a, it was a New York Times reporter
- 7:49who had a friend who had an account at Bank of America and they tried to use,
- 7:54someone tried to use his voice to get his account and she was smart enough to
- 7:57figure out that it wasn't him, but it was an AI version of him and shut the
- 8:01account down and It blew up a business deal that he had because he was overseas
- 8:05and he had actually stopped in and said, Hey, I'm going out of the country.
- 8:09I want you to know I'm going to be doing some things.
- 8:11And then unbeknownst to him, someone else tried to steal his identity.
- 8:15And then in talking with different clients and, with that example and
- 8:18different things, and they're talking to me about all the different.
- 8:22Softwares are outside vendors.
- 8:24They have to try and mitigate the fraud side of things.
- 8:28You're kind of looking at specifically tied to the BSA
- 8:30and AML side on that committee.
- 8:32But this is, I don't want to say I'm scared where this is going, but when
- 8:36I hear what's actually happening out there it's a, it's a challenging
- 8:41arena in the, in, in fraud right now.
- 8:44Brian Knight: Yeah you're absolutely right.
- 8:45And while this roundtable itself to start up is looking through the financial
- 8:50crimes with respect to the sanctions programs, you're absolutely right.
- 8:54I mean, part of our pivot to look at this through the anti financial crimes lens
- 8:58is, I'll get to AI in a 2nd, but even.
- 9:00Going at the base level cyber security.
- 9:02Now, we began to recognize years ago that the nexus between your
- 9:06information security officer and your cyber security concerns and your
- 9:10traditional anti money laundering concerns that nexus was growing.
- 9:14And we began at our cyber security conference to be giving the information
- 9:17security examiners and officers a dose of the anti money laundering security.
- 9:22Curriculum and at our anti money laundering conference, we're giving
- 9:26them a dose of the cyber curriculum.
- 9:28So you're absolutely right.
- 9:28The anti financial crimes is bigger.
- 9:30And when you then mix in the AI, it is really challenging, whether it's
- 9:34traditional cyber security the ransomware and, clicking on a link versus the AI
- 9:40it's just a never ending challenge.
- 9:43It's interesting as we look at the capability of artificial intelligence.
- 9:47Intelligence.
- 9:48It actually reminds me of an early debate in the cyber security realm going
- 9:52back a couple years, and you probably remember this from executive director.
- 9:55We talk about either the multi factor authentication, but there was a time
- 9:58in there were biometric authentication was, that's the greatest thing.
- 10:02Nobody is going to be able to compromise, marks, retina scan or
- 10:06marks, fingerprint and everything else.
- 10:08But even back then, there were some experts who I remember
- 10:12were like, be careful.
- 10:14If your password is compromised, you can change your password.
- 10:18But if your fingerprint is compromised, or your retinal scan
- 10:22is compromised, or your voice is compromised, how do you change that?
- 10:27Or your face?
- 10:28And so they said, be a little careful because there is no
- 10:31changing your biometrics.
- 10:32Once it's compromised, you can get a new password, you
- 10:35know, every hour on the hour.
- 10:37And I feel as though, the story you told in that article that's on the New York
- 10:40Times is That's where we are, right?
- 10:41I mean, it's the, it's the AI now compromising the one thing that, we
- 10:45think, we believe our eyes and we believe our ears and now you're not sure.
- 10:50Mark Treichel: Right.
- 10:50Yeah, exactly.
- 10:51Yeah.
- 10:51It's a, it's a lot, it's the wild, wild West when you throw
- 10:54that AI into the fraud side.
- 10:55Brian Knight: And NASCS has been doing a lot of talking about AI.
- 10:59We've had speakers of various aspects of AI, not just the cybersecurity.
- 11:02There's the, what I'll call the ethical compliance components of,
- 11:06AI underwriting, just understanding.
- 11:09What is AI today versus what we think it is?
- 11:13As I know you're aware, look, there's a entire academic school that even
- 11:17says it's a misnomer because it's not actually intelligent, right?
- 11:21I mean, you can, you can ask a language model AI to write you an essay about,
- 11:27the flying colors podcast, and it will write a fabulous essay talking about how
- 11:30wonderful this podcast is, which it is.
- 11:33But let's be clear, it has no idea what Flying Colors podcast is.
- 11:37It doesn't know what those words mean.
- 11:39It doesn't know who you are or what a podcast is.
- 11:42It just knows that when it looks, through language learning, these
- 11:46are all the things that people say about it, complementary.
- 11:49And so it's not actually intelligent.
- 11:52And so I think understanding that and appreciating that comes with, to your
- 11:56point, a healthy dose of caution.
- 11:59Now, it is still only regurgitating and computing what
- 12:04it is learning from society.
- 12:06So for good or bad, it will also incorporate those
- 12:10things in its algorithms.
- 12:13Mark Treichel: Well said, very well said.
- 12:15Yeah, it's going to add, and we're just seeing the beginning of
- 12:18what that means and doesn't mean.
- 12:20Yeah, that's, I see.
- 12:22I see 2024 2025 and every year beyond really kind of pushing the
- 12:27envelope relative to that, but also creating opportunities, but also
- 12:32creating risks on the other side.
- 12:34So, and the lead.
- 12:35So the legal roundtable, more and more credit unions.
- 12:40The, there, there was the time when there was CEOs and there were the vice
- 12:44presidents of lending and the CFO, the CEO, the CFO, the VPs and maybe they hired
- 12:50out to get general counsels, but it's far more common now, especially in the large
- 12:55credit unions that they actually have.
- 12:56A general counsel and where the world is that they might not be in every
- 13:03meeting that the CEOs in, but nearly all.
- 13:05And then there are, when I was at N.
- 13:07C.
- 13:07U.
- 13:07A.
- 13:07As executive director, there were a lot of meetings where it's I need
- 13:11to have the general counsel here.
- 13:13So I don't need to repeat it.
- 13:15And and they look at lens and not that they're, they end up being like a co CEO,
- 13:20but they the stature of that position over the last 20, 15, 10, five years, and now.
- 13:26It is making it what as critical a position as there is in credit union.
- 13:33So I think that's great that you've got that.
- 13:35You've got that committee back up and running.
- 13:37And I'm sure it's like the wisdom of crowds and N.
- 13:40C.
- 13:40U.
- 13:40A.
- 13:40seeking seeking the advice of NASCS, right?
- 13:44When you have a panel of CEOs, they're going to focus on One
- 13:49aspect and the attorneys look at life through a different lens.
- 13:52So they're going to point out some things.
- 13:53Again, both opportunities and risks.
- 13:55Have you seen that already in, in that
- 13:57Brian Knight: committee?
- 13:59Yeah, so we haven't stood the legal committee back up, but in our
- 14:02conversations and in the webinars we've done on some of the legal
- 14:06issues, you're absolutely right.
- 14:07Look, the credit union system exists within the broader fabric of the
- 14:12financial services sector and increasingly the financial services sector.
- 14:17When we look at these issues from AI to even now courts reconsidering
- 14:22Chevron and what discretion agencies have and these kinds of issues.
- 14:26There is a larger drop of legal issues that are, if not shaping the
- 14:34financial services sector, certainly exerting quite a bit of influence.
- 14:38On it, and I think increasingly from our regulatory agencies from N.
- 14:41C.
- 14:41U.
- 14:41A.
- 14:42out to the system stakeholders themselves understanding how those
- 14:47legal challenges are playing out, whether what rules from the C.
- 14:50F.
- 14:50P.
- 14:50B.
- 14:51actually take effect as I noted to Chevron and what that means for discretion
- 14:56to interpretations of what is U.
- 14:58D.
- 14:58A.
- 14:59To the various, class action litigations and what constitutes,
- 15:03notice, into the realm of cyber security, what is negligence?
- 15:07What constitutes a breach?
- 15:08What constitutes a substantial incident under NCOA versus a material incident
- 15:14for the federal banking agencies?
- 15:16All of these issues are playing out.
- 15:19And certainly we saw during COVID an entire whole legal HR
- 15:22world come front and center.
- 15:24That again is probably beyond for those who have spent their
- 15:27careers in financial services.
- 15:29They understand compliance.
- 15:30They understand the rules.
- 15:31They understand a balance sheet.
- 15:32And now all of a sudden we're in a world of.
- 15:34Can I require employees to be vaccinated?
- 15:36Can I even ask them if they are vaccinated?
- 15:38All of these things coming front and front and center, I think has just elevated
- 15:43the importance of the legal realm.
- 15:45Yeah.
- 15:46Mark Treichel: Great point.
- 15:47The couple other things you mentioned is mergers, a big organization.
- 15:52So we've got NAFCU and CUNA going away and it's going to be America's credit unions.
- 15:56That's I've had a couple of different podcasts on that with John McKechnie
- 16:00and Jeff Bassino, but and then there was a PSCU is merging with
- 16:05the name escapes me of who they're merging with, but what was it?
- 16:09Co op.
- 16:10Co op.
- 16:11That's right.
- 16:11Thank you.
- 16:12And.
- 16:13And so any general thoughts relative to either one of those
- 16:16that you want to chat about?
- 16:18Brian Knight: It'll be interesting to see the end results.
- 16:20I think there are efficiencies and benefits that the credit union
- 16:23system is going to recognize.
- 16:25All four of those entities involved in the mergers, had top notch boards of directors
- 16:31who, looked at these issues and considered the benefits to be achieved by the system.
- 16:37And I think from NASCS's perspective, look, these are two major mergers.
- 16:41And I think no matter what corner of the credit union
- 16:44space you happen to reside in.
- 16:46There are going to be ripples out from it.
- 16:48And so I think from Naska's perspective, we're just waiting to see as
- 16:52these things ripple out from this.
- 16:53That is just such a major movement of, four kind of mass centers
- 16:58in the credit union space coming together and just seeing what
- 17:01the ripple outs are going to be.
- 17:03And I think there's always going to be unforeseen results.
- 17:05Good.
- 17:06Potentially good, potentially, maybe not, not to just not anticipate and so waiting
- 17:10to see what that is, but excited for the future of the credit union system.
- 17:13I think on the 1 hand, it's exciting to note.
- 17:15The credit system is still alive and vibrant and still
- 17:19will be willing to rethink.
- 17:21How it's traditionally, done things and willing to experiment and to make
- 17:26changes and to adopt to the future, which is, what NASCS has always stood for.
- 17:30So on the one hand, exciting to see doesn't directly impact us.
- 17:33But again, it's going to affect everybody in the credit union space because
- 17:37those are just such four power centers.
- 17:39Yeah,
- 17:40Mark Treichel: it's going to be interesting at GAC
- 17:42and the big reveal there.
- 17:43And I know they just announced a bunch of the positions that they filled
- 17:46and it looks like they've done well.
- 17:47Positioning that, to start off here real soon in 2024.
- 17:51And so the change at the NCAA board.
- 17:53So now we've got time Tanya Otsuka, who, I don't know if she's been sworn in I
- 17:58hadn't, I've taken a little bit of time off here between Christmas and new years,
- 18:02but I'm sure if if it hasn't happened, it'll happen any day now and any thoughts
- 18:07relative to that with now we'll have a.
- 18:11Chairman Harper, the Democrat Chairman Todd Harper has been in place, but he
- 18:18hasn't had a second Democratic vote.
- 18:19And I've had podcasts where I've talked about what I think that means.
- 18:23I think climate change.
- 18:25I think consumer compliance.
- 18:27I think he's going to dust off the proposed rule on succession
- 18:32planning, which may or may not apply to state charters.
- 18:35I think I have to go back and see how that rule was proposed.
- 18:40But any thoughts relative, as soon as I said it, I thought I wrote
- 18:46a blog post that it was just fed.
- 18:48And I wrote a blog post that said the top 10 reasons why they
- 18:51shouldn't make it a regulation.
- 18:52So I don't think it should become a reg.
- 18:54I think it might though.
- 18:55So any thoughts on where you, how you see this impacting credit unions and or N.
- 19:00C.
- 19:01U.
- 19:01A.
- 19:01and or state charters.
- 19:03Brian Knight: I Mean, of course, you're gonna have the fundamental dynamics of
- 19:06the NCA board changing whenever you have a party shift in, for all intents and
- 19:11purposes, the power center of the board from two Republicans to now two Democrats.
- 19:16So it's going to change that.
- 19:18Clearly, I'd be remiss if I didn't start off by acknowledging,
- 19:22board member hoods service.
- 19:24He was fantastic to work with for NASCS for the state system.
- 19:27Always very accessible.
- 19:28I thought his 2nd.
- 19:30Time on the board in particular, I think was a.
- 19:34Success and so thank him for his service and excited to see the new board.
- 19:39Certainly.
- 19:41Yes, no, it's coming with.
- 19:44Experience and an understanding, I have a fondness for the attorneys coming
- 19:49with a with an in depth understanding of the broader financial services
- 19:53sector and in depth understanding of the legal intricacies of financial services
- 19:58and financial service regulation.
- 20:00I think that's always a good thing.
- 20:03I don't know what it means.
- 20:04I think it's interesting that now all three NCAA board
- 20:06members are former Hill staff.
- 20:08Maybe that means nothing other than all three NCAA board
- 20:11members are former Hill staff.
- 20:13It's a definite trend.
- 20:15Yeah, it's a definite definite trend.
- 20:17But I do I think this nominee, like all nominees obviously has the
- 20:20experience to do it, but brings a unique set of skills from her position
- 20:24on the banking committee that I think portends a great value for the credit
- 20:29union, for the credit union system.
- 20:32I would still like to see a former state regulator on the NCRA board.
- 20:37I know you're very familiar with that, rant from NASCS.
- 20:40But again, look our state regulators.
- 20:43In a lot of cases have a very wide, broad perspective in a lot of ways,
- 20:48kind of akin to what she's bringing from the banking committee, because
- 20:51for most of our state regulators, they don't just do credit unions, they do
- 20:54credit unions, they do banks, they do securities, they do, mortgage originators,
- 20:58non depositories, money transmitters, they bring that entire universe of the
- 21:02broader financial services sector, as well as an understanding of the innovation
- 21:07that takes place at the state level.
- 21:09So I would like To see that in the future on the NCUA board, but excited
- 21:13to see where the NCUA board is going.
- 21:15With respect to the initiatives that you checked, yes, I think
- 21:19we'll see work on those in addition to the succession planning, which
- 21:24was federal credit unions only.
- 21:26I would not be surprised to see perhaps NCUA revisiting share
- 21:32insurance reform, the statutory structure of the share insurance Fund.
- 21:37Certainly there is interest.
- 21:38Obviously NCOA interest in third party supervisory authority.
- 21:43And hopefully this brings renewed efforts to get what I think is probably most
- 21:48critical for the credit union space.
- 21:49And that is the CLF reform to get re implemented.
- 21:53The Covid era expansions of the CLF.
- 21:57I think I would hope that would be, among the top priorities.
- 22:00I know NCA has been working on that on Capitol Hill.
- 22:04So not to say that they haven't been, but perhaps with the connections
- 22:08and the renewed vigorous that she is bringing with her recent.
- 22:11I think that's essential for the future of the credit union system,
- 22:18particularly the majority of the system that are modestly sized and the role
- 22:22that the corporates I know are prepared to play, but can't because of the
- 22:26kind of current limiting structure.
- 22:29Mark Treichel: Great points.
- 22:30Yeah.
- 22:30And as far as the CLF and the 3rd party, I've always been
- 22:34supportive of the CLF side of it.
- 22:37I've gone, I want to say I've gone back and forth on the 3rd party
- 22:41But I was, one of the strategies.
- 22:45That I was aware of when I was at it and two ways you need to ask for it because
- 22:48if something blows up, you need to say I didn't have it and you don't want them
- 22:52to be able to say you didn't even ask us.
- 22:54You didn't tell us.
- 22:55So there's that side of it.
- 22:57And then there's the side of it.
- 22:58Okay.
- 22:58Once you get it, is it.
- 23:00What do you do with it?
- 23:01Is it like that?
- 23:02You got to be careful.
- 23:03Not if they get it not to be the dog chasing the ice cream truck.
- 23:10Okay, now I got the iconic.
- 23:11Now, what am I going to do?
- 23:12And my concern always was if we got it when I was there,
- 23:16or if they get it now is.
- 23:20How do you utilize resources?
- 23:21How do you expand staff?
- 23:23Do you expand staff?
- 23:24When do you go in?
- 23:25When don't you go in?
- 23:26Who do you go in with?
- 23:28And that's I don't want, Pandora's box might not be the right word,
- 23:32but that's what pops into my head.
- 23:34And, there's always this battle for resources.
- 23:37The examiners don't feel they have enough.
- 23:39The regions oftentimes don't feel they have enough.
- 23:42Now they're putting more resources into consumer compliance.
- 23:45And I have a disagreement with Chairman Harper on the fact
- 23:49that I don't think consumer compliance is safety and soundness.
- 23:52And I think they are, I think those two things are mostly binary.
- 23:55And so there's just, there's not enough hours in the day, just like
- 23:58you had a busy 2023, if they get it, how are they going to handle it?
- 24:03And I'm sure they will handle it because they always rise to the occasion.
- 24:05So I would.
- 24:06And with this recent malware situation where a lot of credit unions were
- 24:10knocked down I've revisited my thoughts and I think I'd rather catch
- 24:14the ice cream truck than not at this
- 24:16Brian Knight: juncture.
- 24:17Yeah, and I understand all of those concerns, and I know as
- 24:20you're aware, NASCS is a little bit unique in the credit union space.
- 24:24We are not opposed to NCOA having third party authority.
- 24:28We've never been opposed to NCOA having third party authority going
- 24:30back to, I think, 2005, when then chair Joanne Johnson actively
- 24:34sought it before, before Congress.
- 24:37Look, we've got 29 or so state agencies that have some
- 24:41form of 3rd party authority.
- 24:44They use it sparingly.
- 24:45They use it when needed.
- 24:47They don't generally conduct.
- 24:49Regular examinations, but when you need that authority as a regulator,
- 24:53as you need that authority.
- 24:55And when something goes wrong and you can't get the answers that you need to
- 24:59protect the operations, the reputation of the overall system, the deposits
- 25:04of individual credit union members, it's an invaluable authority to have.
- 25:08And so while I understand.
- 25:10There are concerns as to how NCOA would wield that authority, and I won't
- 25:14suggest that we don't have, some similar concerns as to how to be wielded,
- 25:17particularly ensuring that we don't have redundant use of the authority in
- 25:21those states where it is already there.
- 25:23I think for a regulator, it is a valuable authority.
- 25:26If I were looking at a state credit union act on behalf of an agency,
- 25:29and they were asking NASCS for suggestions, and I saw that they did
- 25:32not have that authority, it would be 1 of the things that I would suggest.
- 25:36And then.
- 25:36The other big issue, I think, for the credit union system is, look,
- 25:40there is also a disadvantage to the overall credit union system
- 25:43for NCOA not having that authority.
- 25:46And that is that NCOA doesn't have access.
- 25:50To those reviews of third party vendors done by their sister banking
- 25:53agencies and what you know, and what I know is that when a federal banking
- 25:59agency reviews a critical third party vendor, it will send a report of that
- 26:04review to that vendors bank clients.
- 26:07And so you could have a credit union and a bank using the same non QSO vendor.
- 26:12On a Thursday afternoon, and the CEO of the community bank is sitting at her
- 26:16desk, and she gets a report from the FDIC or the OCC if it's a national bank.
- 26:22About the status of that vendor, the credit union CEO sitting at her
- 26:26desk across the street, nothing.
- 26:28It's Thursday and that's it.
- 26:31That's a blind side for some in the system.
- 26:34And quite frankly, we've seen that play out at the state level where we've had
- 26:37states who have gone in because of.
- 26:40Concerns that were raised during their examination of a state charter credit
- 26:43union could not get the answers they needed and went through the, beyond the
- 26:48credit union to the vendor, because they had direct authority to do that, and
- 26:52they would notify if there were federal credit unions who use this vendor, they
- 26:55would notify some of the other states.
- 26:57But at the end of the day, that state exam in many cases could not be
- 27:00shared with the federal credit unions.
- 27:02And she was given a heads up as to what the state found.
- 27:05Okay.
- 27:05But the state would send out its exam report out to its state charted credit
- 27:09unions being like, are you aware?
- 27:10And Brian, vendor, this is what we found.
- 27:13You need to fix this or have it fixed or be on alert or find a new vendor.
- 27:18And the Federals were generally clueless.
- 27:20And so I do think there is an information gap that is concerning
- 27:24for the credit union space.
- 27:25But again, that's not to discount those concerns that you rattled off.
- 27:29I'm aware of those share some of them, but I just think that.
- 27:32Yeah.
- 27:32The supervisory value of this authority when wielded appropriately
- 27:38to me for NASCS outweighs those
- 27:40Mark Treichel: concerns.
- 27:41Said.
- 27:41Very well said.
- 27:42And I think, yeah, you're right.
- 27:43It's time.
- 27:43It's time for insulating.
- 27:44Have that authority back at sunset back with Y two K.
- 27:48And I think it'll be they've been beating the drum for forever.
- 27:51But I think Chairman Harper, And maybe having, a board member that another
- 27:56board member, tied to the Hill.
- 27:57Maybe that's something that they can get done together.
- 27:59So I'm hopeful that they can, I think it's time.
- 28:02And yeah.
- 28:03So very well stated.
- 28:04All right.
- 28:04So 2024, Brian what what's happening starting next week what's on the agenda
- 28:10for NASCS and state chartered credit.
- 28:14Brian Knight: A ton.
- 28:14You and I have already talked on some of the big issues that'll be coming, the
- 28:17NCAA board, those initiatives, looking at artificial intelligence, looking at anti
- 28:21financial crimes, whether that's the money laundering space, the cyber space, oh,
- 28:28and the big one kind of related to all of that, particularly when we look at cyber
- 28:31security, which then quickly takes you into the realm of privacy, open banking.
- 28:36What is open banking going to look like when it gets
- 28:39implemented in the United States?
- 28:40And I believe it is a when not an if, but, open banking can mean
- 28:45a couple of different things.
- 28:45It can mean the right to port your data at a very basic level to a right to have any
- 28:52API of your choosing be able to interact.
- 28:55With your financial institution at your demand to manipulate your
- 28:58data and everything in between.
- 29:00And what does that mean?
- 29:02Where does the cybersecurity responsibility lie?
- 29:05Where does the implementation costs lie?
- 29:09Who decides what the standard of data?
- 29:12Data is I know the CFPB has an initial proposal out there, but
- 29:16we've NASCS has been looking at open banking as it first arose in the EU.
- 29:20We've talked to some countries.
- 29:22We're talking with the credit unit system in Australia that has gone
- 29:24through it to try to put our arms around.
- 29:27What are the things we need to be thinking about as open banking
- 29:30comes to the US when it comes?
- 29:33I don't think it's something that's going to be implemented, obviously,
- 29:35by the regulators, state or federal.
- 29:37This is going to come from a different policy center.
- 29:40Yeah.
- 29:40Which is concerning because the impact is going to fall on our depository
- 29:44institutions where, or the states or the prudential regulators, but at a minimum,
- 29:47we need to be prepared for this debate.
- 29:49Understand the nuances for this debate.
- 29:51Prepare the system to be able to weigh in as it gets shaped
- 29:56because I am not convinced.
- 29:58The final form of open banking as it will be implemented in the U.
- 30:03S.
- 30:04has been decided upon.
- 30:05And so I think there's an opportunity to try to get in there and try to get answers
- 30:09or at least a robust policy discussion around all of these intricate issues.
- 30:14So I see that as tied to the artificial intelligence and the A.
- 30:18F.
- 30:19C.
- 30:19debate because I think privacy security all of that is wrapped into that.
- 30:23So I think that'll be Yeah.
- 30:25A big, big issue.
- 30:27Another issue is, Naska says, I noted that we've been reviewing some state acts
- 30:32upon request of some of our members is just understanding what will and should
- 30:38the credit union system of the future look like, you and I talked last year
- 30:42and we, you and I both talked about how.
- 30:44The broader financial services sector is undergoing transformational change, right?
- 30:48Old traditions of the roles of a depository institution versus a
- 30:52non depository institution versus who can access the payment rails,
- 30:56who can hold people's money, all of these things are being challenged
- 31:00and debated and shifting around.
- 31:03And the credit union system is going to have to find its place.
- 31:06In the reshaped financial services sector, which isn't just a U.
- 31:10S.
- 31:10financial services sector.
- 31:11It's a global financial services sector.
- 31:13And so we're going to have to find our place and think about what do we need
- 31:18to do to ensure that our role, but more importantly, our ability to remain
- 31:23relevant to credit union members from a regulatory agency perspective to ensure
- 31:28that we understand what's The trends and innovation that is needed versus
- 31:33the safety and soundness risk and make sure that we maintain robust supervision
- 31:38while not stifling the innovation needed for credit unions to remain relevant.
- 31:42And so I think all of that in 2024 will continue to percolate just underneath
- 31:46the surface, which is going to require a lot of kind of dedication to training to
- 31:51thought leadership to issue spotting on some of the things that we talked about.
- 31:55And of course, for our state agencies.
- 31:57Chris.
- 31:58This all takes place against the backdrop of day in and day
- 32:01out conducting examinations.
- 32:03One of the, one of the comments John Koloff and our staff who testified at
- 32:06the NCOA budget hearing, noted is the just tremendous amount of work done
- 32:12by state regulatory agencies and state sharded credit unions and the amount of
- 32:15money that state sharded credit unions pay to To support that work, the state
- 32:20charter credit unions reported paying over 94 million dollars to the state
- 32:24agencies to be state charter credit unions compared with 109 million that
- 32:28the federal credit unions pay to NCOA and the state charters are only 39
- 32:33percent of the number of credit unions.
- 32:35But you know, our state agencies conducted.
- 32:37Over 440, 000 examination hours generated over 1, 500 reports, and
- 32:46that's 46 agencies covering 2, 000 credit unions and, 68 million members
- 32:51and over half the assets in the system.
- 32:53While all of that day in and day out work that you are well aware of that folks
- 32:57don't kind of see when they think about NCA or they think about the state agency,
- 33:01they tend to think about the regulatory burden level and not the day in and day
- 33:05out work that's being done to safeguard.
- 33:07Deposits and the members of the system and by the way, safeguard
- 33:11credit unions from their sisters and brother credit unions who might not
- 33:15be as diligent as they are right in a cooperative in a cooperative system.
- 33:20And while conducting all of that, also staying abreast of all of
- 33:23the changes and trends is just going to be a busy year in 2024.
- 33:28I would be remiss if I didn't note.
- 33:30We're also gearing up.
- 33:32I talked about our busy 2023 schedule and then we'll have the same.
- 33:36Full robust schedule events in 2024.
- 33:39We're bringing all the state regulators together and I think.
- 33:42I presume NCOA will join us as they do every year for a regulator only meeting.
- 33:45That'll be in late March in Chicago.
- 33:48Our annual meeting of NASCAS, we call it the State Systems Summit, but our
- 33:51big annual meeting will take place in October, October 20th through 23rd in
- 33:56Colorado Springs, Colorado, a little bit later in the year, but that's
- 33:59the perfect time to head up into the foothills of the Rockies at the Broadmoor.
- 34:02So we're very excited about that.
- 34:04Again, that'll bring state and federal credit unions, all the leagues,
- 34:07NCOA, the state regulators together.
- 34:10Take care.
- 34:10And then on top of that, we'll continue our member webinars will continue
- 34:14our directors colleges are training.
- 34:15We have a whole slate of classes.
- 34:18We're putting out to the state regulators to attend and ask us is expense.
- 34:23So, just continuing the work that we always do mark to ensure that
- 34:26the state system and the overall credit unit system is ready to
- 34:29meet the challenges of tomorrow.
- 34:30Mark Treichel: It's good.
- 34:31The dual chartering system is important.
- 34:33It allows for the incubator of ideas and Nazca's and state charter credit
- 34:37unions are fortunate to have you at the helm of their trade association
- 34:42to help move that ball forward.
- 34:45And again, back to the wisdom of crowds that Nazca Springs to
- 34:48light many issues that help N.
- 34:51C.
- 34:51U.
- 34:52A.
- 34:52And help Credit unions help state charters help federal charters.
- 34:55By the way, if someone wants to I want to if someone wants to join ask us a state
- 35:01charter can join, you have that separate, we didn't get into that, but you have
- 35:04the state, you have two boards, right?
- 35:06You have the board.
- 35:08Of the state regulators and you have a board of credit unions.
- 35:11If someone wants to help support your organization by joining,
- 35:16how do they go about do that?
- 35:18And what does that mean for them?
- 35:20Brian Knight: Great.
- 35:20Thank you for that opportunity.
- 35:21And I was actually going to circle back to that because you've mentioned
- 35:23a couple of times the wisdom of crowds, which is what NASCS stands for.
- 35:26But, with respect to joining NASCS, look, any credit union system stakeholder.
- 35:31Is welcome to become a part of NASCS.
- 35:34We have state chartered credit unions that are members, predominantly our
- 35:37membership of state charter credit unions.
- 35:38I've got about half a dozen federal credit unions.
- 35:40Some of the larger federal credit unions and modestly sized federal
- 35:43credit unions are members of NASCS.
- 35:45Leagues are members of NASCS.
- 35:46The corporate credit unions are members of NASCS.
- 35:48About 18 other system stakeholders.
- 35:51If you're a credit union system stakeholder, generally speaking, you
- 35:54are welcome to be a part of NASCS.
- 35:56We do have two governing bodies.
- 35:58We have a regulator board of directors, but we have a credit
- 36:00union advisory council as well.
- 36:02That advisory council represents what we call our stakeholder side of
- 36:05our membership, the credit unions, the leagues, the other system
- 36:08stakeholders, but our board and our advisory council always meet together,
- 36:12talk about the issues together.
- 36:13And to your point, I think that's why.
- 36:15Okay.
- 36:16NASCS has been so successful in these, nearly 60 years that we've
- 36:21been doing this since 1960, 65 is it is the wisdom of crowds.
- 36:25It was a regulators only association until the late 1980s.
- 36:31In the late 1980s, early 1990s, the regulators invited the credit union system
- 36:35into the organization to your very point.
- 36:37They're like, look, for the past 30 years, give or take, we've been very
- 36:41successful in talking among ourselves.
- 36:43About the issues that we see and debating what should be the supervisory response.
- 36:47We have a blind spot.
- 36:49We ourselves don't run credit unions or banks for that matter.
- 36:53And sometimes what sounds good to us doesn't work the way we thought it
- 36:57would when it's being implemented.
- 36:59So they did for that kind of wisdom of the crowd, they opened NASCS to
- 37:03the system stakeholders to be like, let's talk about these issues together.
- 37:06We can tell you our perspectives as regulators, not just of credit
- 37:09unions, but in many cases of the broader financial services sector.
- 37:12Here are the things we have seen gone wrong in the past with this versus
- 37:17the, innovation and the operational expertise of the credit unions and the
- 37:22credit union supporters, the leagues who are serving the members as every day
- 37:26as they come in and meet their needs.
- 37:27So it is that wisdom of crowds.
- 37:29Anybody interested in joining NASCIS, you can go to our website,
- 37:31click on join the conversation.
- 37:33It'll show you the different categories.
- 37:35If you join NASCS, you become part of our conversation.
- 37:38You are welcome to serve on most of our committees.
- 37:40We do have part of our shop.
- 37:42We are still at our core that regulators professional association.
- 37:46We were formed as a 1965.
- 37:48so there is a part of our work that is closed off from the system stakeholders.
- 37:53A lot of that work with NCUA behind the scenes on those things.
- 37:55Obviously, that's confidential.
- 37:57That doesn't it.
- 37:58Get transferred over to our system side, but on our broader system side
- 38:02of our membership, whether it's our L and R committee, this legal committee,
- 38:05I was talking about the special designations committees, working
- 38:09groups, issue, spotting the education, the training, the discussion of.
- 38:13Of policy, probably 1 of the most popular committees in is our legislative
- 38:18and regulatory affairs committee.
- 38:19It meets the 1st, Wednesday of every month.
- 38:21It's got about 80 folks on there from agencies from credit unions
- 38:25from leagues from others and.
- 38:281st, Wednesday of every month in the afternoon, they get together
- 38:30and they begin hashing out, these various issues, whether it is somebody
- 38:34asking a state specific issue.
- 38:36Hey, we don't we're not allowed to do this in our state, or we don't allow this in
- 38:39our state who has a different view versus.
- 38:42Discussions of AI and NCUA proposed rules or CFPB proposed rules or FinCEN or OFAC
- 38:49issues, but it is that wisdom of crowds.
- 38:51Thanks for asking, but go to the NASCSIS website and you can click on join
- 38:56the conversation and see how to join.
- 38:58Mark Treichel: Fantastic.
- 38:59And Brian, as we wrap up here, is there any question I should have asked you today
- 39:03that I did not, that you want to highlight
- 39:05Brian Knight: here?
- 39:06No, I think, as, as always, I think you and I have spent a lot of time talking
- 39:09about these issues over the years.
- 39:10I think we've covered a lot of the big, big issues.
- 39:14I appreciate what you do both with this podcast and with, the
- 39:18consulting you do in the credit union.
- 39:20Space and, I'll tell your listeners.
- 39:22Sometimes I have NCOA questions.
- 39:24I need a different perspective.
- 39:25I think I called you up on just about a year ago.
- 39:28I called you up.
- 39:28I was like, okay, Mark, once again, let's go through this NCOA budget.
- 39:32Let's debate OTR.
- 39:33Explain it to me.
- 39:34What am I missing here from your perspective?
- 39:36So
- 39:37Mark Treichel: where are they hiding?
- 39:38Where are they hiding the bodies?
- 39:40Brian Knight: I appreciate you and what you do appreciate this conversation,
- 39:43this opportunity to talk to your listeners about NASCS and what they do.
- 39:48Mark Treichel: Fantastic.
- 39:48Brian has always enjoyed our chat and I want to thank you for your time today.
- 39:54Brian Knight: Thank you.
- 39:54Happy holidays to you, Mark.
- 39:56I hope you have a happy and successful 2024, and I'm sure I'll be seeing
- 40:00you down the line somewhere.
- 40:01Mark Treichel: Likewise.
- 40:02Sounds good.
- 40:02And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 40:04I hope you listen again soon.
- 40:05This is Mark Trenkle signing off with flying colors.