Latest / Chatter that Matters / Janet Sherlund - Abandoned at Birth
Transcript
- 0:02If our life is a symphony and notes, then each of
- 0:06us is born into a unique melody.
- 0:09This composition shaped by our heritage, the DNA of our
- 0:13parents, the arms that first held us.
- 0:17But what happens when the first notes of our song are a mystery, when the
- 0:21melody of our beginning is shrouded in silence,
- 0:25when there's an absence of one crucial chord, the identity of your
- 0:29birth parents. What reverberates is a childhood where
- 0:33bedtime stories don't carry the whisper of ancestral tales, or
- 0:37the family tree begins with your branch? And it's a
- 0:40reality for millions around the world, a sonnet of
- 0:44questions woven in the very fabric of their existence. Even if
- 0:48that child is adopted into a home of love, a sanctuary where, on the
- 0:51surface, they're much better off, they have safety, security, and possibilities,
- 0:56What lies underneath is something that could eat away at their self esteem
- 1:00and identity. Who am I?
- 1:04And this yearning and ache to unravel the enigma of their origins
- 1:08never goes away. A desire to know who their birth mother
- 1:12was, and how she carried you. Was it shame, or did it bring shame, was
- 1:16it desperation, horrific circumstances,
- 1:20Was it even a hint of a dream of one day reuniting? It's
- 1:23almost like this physical drive to reconnect with the birth mother, to
- 1:27reconnect with the center of your world, the the your whole world at the beginning
- 1:30of your life. And it's almost this physical compulsion, like,
- 1:34I need to find her. I need to find her. I need to feel that
- 1:37connection in order to to finally feel
- 1:40peace. Joining me today is Janet Sherlund,
- 1:44who wrote a powerful book titled The Bandit at Birth: Searching for the Arms
- 1:48That Once Held Me. I'm recording this remote, but during my
- 1:51interview, many times I wish I could held her in my arms, if only
- 1:55for a moment to take away some of her
- 1:58pain.
- 2:04This is chatter that matters with Tony Chapman
- 2:08presented by RBC.
- 2:13Janet, Sherlyn, thanks for joining me on Chatter That Matters. Oh, thank you so
- 2:16much for having me, Toni, and, and for that beautiful introduction.
- 2:20I'm at a beautiful position in with the podcast that I often get
- 2:24pitched by publicists. And, and one of my favorite is Simon
- 2:27Shuster, who's publishing your book. And I
- 2:31opened yours and I read the prologue, and I
- 2:35had to keep reading. I absolutely felt like I was in the car
- 2:38with you that day on that warm
- 2:42November day, as you say with this bright sun and blue skies.
- 2:46And I was wondering if you could just read the prologue for my
- 2:50audience so they can get swept away the way I did.
- 2:55I drove to the adoption agency on unusually warm November
- 2:59day, 65 degrees with bright sun and
- 3:03pure blue skies. Most trees still held their leaves,
- 3:07the consequence of a warm, wet autumn and the roadside
- 3:10glowed green and gold with only the occasional streak of orange.
- 3:14The radio blasted Springsteen, and I drummed to the steering
- 3:18wheel, my mind wandering with the ease of familiar roads.
- 3:22The route took me through the town where my husband, Rick, and I had lived
- 3:25for 30 years and along roads I remembered from my childhood.
- 3:30Given my destination, the drive through my past was poetic.
- 3:35Snugged into my seat, sunlight curling around my shoulders,
- 3:38I was grateful for the opportunity that lay ahead to
- 3:42read excerpts of my adoption file from 1954.
- 3:4711 years earlier, I took the same drive to the agency while searching for my
- 3:51birth parents. Such information hadn't been offered to me then.
- 3:55But now, many years into a difficult journey, the
- 3:59compassionate social worker thought it might be helpful. Well,
- 4:03I had since discovered many facts about my adoption. I was looking
- 4:06for nuanced details. Did my mother ever hold
- 4:10me? Have I ever seen her face?
- 4:14Where was I between my birth and adoption? I
- 4:18hoped reading specifics would bring an moment of understanding
- 4:22and prayed for much needed closure. Fortified by all I had
- 4:26learned over the past decade, I walked into the agency with a
- 4:29big smile, confident the pages I read today would be the
- 4:33holy grail, the final piece of the puzzle.
- 4:38Jennifer, what did you learn that day? Because you're walking
- 4:42in with just the skip to your step. First
- 4:46of all, things were real visceral. I mean, holding papers
- 4:50from 1954, you know, the actual typed pages
- 4:53and the actual handwritten notes of the social worker in her in
- 4:57her longhand script, the pages that were
- 5:01limp or brittle. And and it was like I was transported back
- 5:04in time to this point of my life that I had
- 5:08no idea about. You know, I was adopted. I was never told birth stories
- 5:12or 1st day stories or 1st weeks or month stories. And
- 5:16and it was like this secret that had been in this in this
- 5:19file all these years that all these other eyes had seen but mine had
- 5:23never seen. And, reading
- 5:27reading the information, especially the descriptions
- 5:30of me as a baby that were written by other people like
- 5:34the psychologist doing the developmental tests and
- 5:38and things was was so shocking first because I had
- 5:42a different name. I, you know, I think when I was growing up, I thought,
- 5:45oh, I was adopted. I must have been, you know, baby girl blank
- 5:49or, you know, and then my parents named me and that was my first identity.
- 5:53But first to realize and see on official paperwork
- 5:57that I was someone else. I was, you know,
- 6:00Linda Lee Jones. It's like, who the hell was Linda Lee
- 6:04Jones? And but I was really and I was referred to that over and
- 6:08over and over in the paperwork. And I was referred to as, you know, Shirley
- 6:11Ann Jones' daughter, Linda Lee. And I'm like, what? Like, what? And it
- 6:15was it was very profound and really shook me even
- 6:19though I had some of that information already. But somehow seeing it, holding
- 6:22it, seeing those external descriptions of
- 6:26me and seeing this description of this newborn
- 6:29baby lying there who had mannerisms that I still
- 6:33have and that people still note that I have was
- 6:37really shook me to my core. You read a note from your
- 6:41birth mother, Shirley, that made you feel quite unglued? She
- 6:45had an unusual level of denial. The the agency kept noting
- 6:49that. Most of their birth mothers and their normal practices,
- 6:53included more involvement of the birth mother in the those early in the early
- 6:57weeks. And she just refused to meet me, to look at me, to
- 7:00acknowledge me in in any sense. And, you know, when the when
- 7:04the baffled social worker asked her if I was even real to her, she just
- 7:08said, frankly, no. And she refused to the whole time
- 7:12and and she just kept asking in every meeting, when can I send the papers?
- 7:14When can I send the papers? And and then was relieved to sign them,
- 7:19you know, after, I was a month in in foster care.
- 7:23And it was just seeing those names and seeing my connection to
- 7:26to her to this other identity and sort of understanding that my heritage,
- 7:31my DNA was real and came from a real person
- 7:34and that that I was made up of that
- 7:38person's DNA and not my adopted parents yet, which I knew.
- 7:42But there was just something so profound about it and and her
- 7:46denial from the get go was was so painful.
- 7:50It was it was just like trying to be dismissed and erased. It was
- 7:53truly abandoned at birth. So I wanna because we have so much ground to
- 7:57cover in such a short time. So there's gonna be times when I move this
- 8:01story forward, but now I wanna go back to your childhood because you're adopted
- 8:04by Audrey and Bob, who have struggled to
- 8:08conceive their own children. So they built a family of
- 8:11adopted children, you and 3 siblings. This part I
- 8:15really felt, the first hug I wanted to give you is you sitting at the
- 8:19dinner table with your 2 brothers, your sister,
- 8:23and your parents feeling that you didn't even belong here. This is
- 8:26almost virtual reality versus the family. Yeah. It was. You know, it's
- 8:30funny. And back in the day when, no one talked
- 8:34about those kinds of things, we didn't have concepts of other realities
- 8:37or, we certainly didn't talk about identity
- 8:41or even understand DNA and and heritage like we
- 8:45do now. But even as a child, when I had
- 8:49no knowledge of of bigger concepts, I'd sit around the
- 8:52dinner table and you could just feel the separation
- 8:56between everyone. You know, I was in my own little I call it
- 9:00genetic dust, but it was just I sat there and mess and each person around
- 9:04the table was so disconnected. We were all
- 9:07there participating together, but there's
- 9:11no connection between any of us, and you just felt it. It was you would
- 9:15have come to learn is how much blood and cells
- 9:19are are connecting in ways that we don't even acknowledge in in our
- 9:23even nowadays and in our culture. There's some kind
- 9:26of cellular recognition and understanding between family
- 9:30that goes it's beyond words. It's almost like it like an
- 9:34animal recognizes its own. I don't know if it's
- 9:38smell or pheromones. I don't know what it is, but
- 9:42I was very aware of it even as a child that we each were
- 9:45just in these, like, separate spaces, separate
- 9:49pods, and we're just made up of different I didn't know the word for it,
- 9:53but we were just made up of different DNA. And and you could just feel
- 9:56that. And it's interesting, you know, when you're, you know, I think every
- 10:00kid has an imaginary friend. My name was Jacob O'Malley. I've never
- 10:03told anybody that. I don't even know I don't even know how his name just
- 10:05came to me. Tell me the story of the the Chinese
- 10:09princess. Well, I I was a a little girl with a, you know, a
- 10:12round I had no idea I was of Irish descent. I I just had this
- 10:15round face and little eyes that smiled into slits when I
- 10:19smiled, and I had the typical 1950 something, you know,
- 10:23hairstyle, a little short bob and the bangs cut off in in my
- 10:27my brown hair by that time. And, I never saw anyone else
- 10:30I I looked like. And I had this big golden book
- 10:34of children around the world. And I loved that book and the
- 10:38illustrations in it. And the illustrations of the the
- 10:41old Chinese girls were, looked like me. They had
- 10:45the same hair cut and and the eyes that were as small as mine get
- 10:48when I smile. And and, you know, I liked their little silk pajama
- 10:52things they wore and stuff. But those those images
- 10:56were the more than any I'd seen in real life within my
- 10:59family or even with other people that we knew, those were the images I thought
- 11:03I looked most like. So I decided I was a
- 11:06kidnapped Chinese princess, and I've been brought to America.
- 11:10But I was sure people were looking for me. The guards of the palace were
- 11:14gonna come look for me. And the funny thing is for someone who is as
- 11:17anxious as I was as a child, I didn't feel threatened
- 11:21by the idea of being found and taken back to China. I
- 11:24thought that, that would make me feel whole. That, you
- 11:28know, as long as I was with my and I don't even know how no
- 11:32one talked about this stuff. This was just so internal and so instinctive. And I
- 11:36just thought, once I'm with the the the people that brought my my real
- 11:39biological family, my family of origin, I'm going to feel whole and
- 11:43safe even if it's, like, in China. So I had no
- 11:47idea who I was. I was a little Irish girl. I wasn't Chinese, but but
- 11:50that was my only point of reference.
- 11:55You know, it's interesting as I read your book and I read every page
- 11:58how important the father and your, the father that
- 12:02adopted you were in your life and how
- 12:05horrible your birth mother and the mother that
- 12:09adopted. I wanna talk about her first, Audrey, because I I
- 12:13came to really dislike Audrey. Yeah. 1st, I I I sorta said
- 12:16she's just a a character in a sitcom. You know? She's misperfectionist,
- 12:20and everything has to be right, and, you know, she has to steal every scene.
- 12:24Yeah. But the more we get unpack her first of all, she's one of
- 12:28the mathematician, a brain, first one of the first women, if not
- 12:32the first woman, to get her her master's in mathematics or PhD. So I get
- 12:35her full credit, but as you said, she every you know, if there's water skiing,
- 12:38she had to win. If it was a family movie, she had to be the
- 12:41one that was the star. I mean, it was almost like so I said, okay.
- 12:45I can I can accept the fact that she she needs it? But what really
- 12:48angered me is a couple things. Your younger brother, Mark,
- 12:52adopted needs leg braces, and instead of showing empathy,
- 12:57she was almost embarrassed and just considered vulnerable and weak. Yeah. Yeah. It
- 13:00was it was funny. My my sister-in-law, I was talking about she had just read
- 13:04the book, and called to talk about it. And we
- 13:08were talking about Mark, and and he was the child she had the softest spot
- 13:12for. But it wasn't a spot of respect.
- 13:17I think it was love to the extent that she could, but it was more
- 13:21this. She saw him as as weak. I think his
- 13:25whole life, you know, she she didn't like my older brother, probably a
- 13:28younger sister. She was ashamed of them. They they weren't living up to her
- 13:32standards. And and as I said, I was the one who and I was so
- 13:36desperate for love. I just made myself be whatever she wanted
- 13:40me to be. Well, let's talk about your other brother for a sec, Eric. I
- 13:43mean, he's a rebel. He's a he's a troublemaker. And you
- 13:46overhear your mom saying to her friend, thank heavens he
- 13:50isn't from me. Yeah. Now that and that is that sums up my
- 13:53mother. I mean, it was really sad and and poor Eric had been,
- 13:57you know, he had had so much loss by the time they adopted him. He'd
- 14:00been through 2 different foster homes. His birth mother and
- 14:04grandmother visited with him repeatedly through the 9 months
- 14:08before he was adopted, hoping to to keep him and ultimately
- 14:12couldn't. But he had had 2 different foster placements.
- 14:15And, you know, by the time he came to my parents, he he must have
- 14:19been so confused and so distrustful of attachment
- 14:22and certainly hadn't had that, you know, what he needed as
- 14:26an infant. And so I think I think that formed him for the rest of
- 14:30his life. I think, you know, he would do anything for anybody. He he
- 14:33grew up to be a guy that would just help anybody and always wanted to
- 14:36be the friend of everyone and do everything. But, you know, his reaction
- 14:40to adoption, which is typical of half the adoptees, is that he
- 14:43would act out and I think test the limits. Like, is this gonna be another
- 14:46family that leaves me? And because he
- 14:50acted out and he didn't like school and he he was
- 14:54a rebel. I mean, he embarrassed my my mother. I mean, she was such
- 14:58a tightly wound, you know, had
- 15:02to be perfection, had to be the a plus student in every way that
- 15:05that really upset her. And, my younger sister had that same kind of
- 15:09personality and Why did you think she had children? Because she wasn't
- 15:13was it just because it completed the picture that she wanted everybody
- 15:17to think that they were the perfect nuclear family because it Yeah. It just
- 15:21strikes me and and, you know, we're gonna move the story on. But she
- 15:24through the entire book, every time she comes back, there doesn't seem to be
- 15:28even any softening. Even when she's writing
- 15:32her obituary near dad's, it's all about her
- 15:35and how she's gonna be perceived. It was striking, but I wanna now move to
- 15:39your dad because you love this guy. Yeah. Share a
- 15:43story that you just felt that when he was around,
- 15:47he was as happy to have you as you were to have him. He was.
- 15:51And I I think the thing that most speaks to my father
- 15:55is what he told me when I was a young girl and I I asked
- 15:59him if he believed in in heaven. And he went to church in every
- 16:03Sunday and sang in the choir and all that. I I, you know, he certainly
- 16:05was a religious man and I I I asked him about, do you believe in
- 16:09heaven? Thinking he'd give me some, you know, religious answer.
- 16:13But instead, he just looked at me and he smiled and he said, I
- 16:16believe heaven is the feeling you leave in other people while
- 16:20you're while you're still here on this earth. That's the
- 16:24way he lived his life. And when he died at age 96
- 16:27and every note or letter we received spoke
- 16:31to that, how dad made everyone that he spoke
- 16:35with feel respected and appreciated and elevated.
- 16:39And they all spoke about his sense of humor. He had a very dry,
- 16:42witty Minnesota, Scandinavian sense of humor. But
- 16:46it is that that's how he lived his life and that's what I
- 16:50patterned myself after. That's what I chose to pattern myself after
- 16:53because I I just loved that answer. And I was so happy that
- 16:57he shared that with me. I thought that was a very grown up thing to
- 17:00tell a little child, and it wasn't, you know, a storybook thing. It
- 17:04was how he really felt and lived. So I guess gonna just touch
- 17:08on 3 boys in your life before you end up meeting the love
- 17:11of your life, but match your first love. And I feel so sorry for
- 17:15you because this you know, even though I I don't think he really made your
- 17:19heart beat, he was a convenient relationship, and then he turns violent
- 17:22on you one day. And thankfully, you got out of that situation because
- 17:26Yeah. A lot of people don't. They start blaming themselves. And so I
- 17:30I give you that, and then Greg comes along who's who should be in in
- 17:34jail, but one night date assault, gets you drunk.
- 17:37Yeah. You know? And then Lonnie, when you're at Colgate University, is this
- 17:41you know, was somebody you really started getting great at connecting Schnau, but he was
- 17:44more of a bohemian free spirit versus somebody who wanted to commit. How did
- 17:48you deal with those three relationships? Because you're already you've got a lot
- 17:51of anxiety as a child. You you've experienced panic attacks. There's a lot
- 17:55of things happening. And, you know, almost like you said about your older
- 17:59brother, what did you just feel like the rug was always being pulled underneath you
- 18:03that that that you're never gonna be able to plant roots? A lot of
- 18:06adoptees have trouble with trust, with intimacy,
- 18:10and it's and I I could see how that played out in my life too.
- 18:14But, you know, for the first relationship and and by the way, for the the
- 18:17first two guys, Matt and Greg, those those names were changed
- 18:21to protect their real identity, obviously. But,
- 18:25I I think, Matt, I I was using as a crutch to try and change
- 18:29my independence from my dependence, from my adopted family
- 18:32to try and get some semblance of of separation and my own sense
- 18:36of self. It it was kind of a sad
- 18:40grasp on my part that it did ultimately help me
- 18:43transition, but it was, you know, looking back in the context of
- 18:47an adoptee, I I can I can understand that?
- 18:51And then, you know, the next relation to the next relationship, the next
- 18:55assault, that and then he and, again, in his family, there was a
- 18:59history of trauma and violence that I didn't know about. And,
- 19:03so I was totally shocked about it. And and, you know, back in those days,
- 19:06people didn't talk about this stuff. It was very hidden and very
- 19:10very private. And then and then the guy at when I got
- 19:14first got to Colgate, I don't know. He was he was just awful.
- 19:17Clearly someone who had a habit of that from the reactions of of his
- 19:21roommates and things. And and, and that
- 19:25again, I don't think in the moment I I dealt with that
- 19:28well. It we didn't people didn't talk about it. You didn't hear about it when
- 19:32you did have a story like that to tell. No one told you to get
- 19:35help or seek help. And I think part of why I went into such a
- 19:39depression and withdrawal when I first got to Colgate was not only a
- 19:43point in my life where I was trying to really form myself, but but
- 19:47this assault, you know, looking back, you you don't go through something like that
- 19:51and not deal with it. It comes out. You're just not understanding
- 19:55what happened and why you're struggling. And I did a show with Dina Patel, and
- 19:58she talked about thinking that she had buried it and locked it away. And then
- 20:02Yeah. You know, 10 or 15 years later, it surfaced and
- 20:06just roared to her body and almost completely took her down. One thing that
- 20:10happened at Colgate that I was really happy for is you take
- 20:13this childhood development course. And to
- 20:17me, instead of maybe looking for boyfriends to help you
- 20:21escape your dependence on your parents or I thought this was
- 20:24really a turning point for you in the sense of trying
- 20:28to understand that some of the answers for your anxiety,
- 20:33the questions you had about your your own identity, It was gonna be
- 20:36a matter of your choice, and I thought that course, to me, and I maybe
- 20:40I read it wrong, was really the first step that you took
- 20:44to kinda claiming your life as your own. You're right. It
- 20:48was. And it was just so, it was so shocking to me and so surprising
- 20:52and so wonderful to know that there were these, that I wasn't alone
- 20:56in my thoughts and that there are a lot of people that have really studied
- 20:58this and thought about it, looked into it. It wasn't just opinions or, you know,
- 21:02feelings. It was it was really quantified. And I think I think one of the
- 21:06the points I keep making about biology and identity and and and
- 21:09belonging and all that, When I when I talk about this strength,
- 21:13this unknown strength, let let okay. So my adopted parents, I don't
- 21:17think either of them in a situation where someone
- 21:21attacked them, you know, physically or sexually. I I I don't know how
- 21:25they either would have reacted, but but I don't think it was the way I
- 21:27reacted. And so I I totally did not recognize
- 21:31the response I had in both situations where I got myself out of those
- 21:34situations and I took care of myself and I and I was strong and I
- 21:38moved forward. I I didn't recognize that in me at all. I thought it was
- 21:40such a weak person. Many, many years later, when I discovered
- 21:44my biological roots and heritage and met my birth parents,
- 21:47separately, they would have. I I could see there is,
- 21:51like, oh my god. That's how they would've responded. I mean, I had
- 21:55these traits, these strengths actually that
- 21:59came through my DNA and that were part of me that
- 22:02I never knew. I never saw. I never sat saw that behavior
- 22:07displayed by or mirrored in other people in my family.
- 22:11And it was only after that and looking back, I went,
- 22:15that's what that's where that came from. You know? In the in the moment, I
- 22:19was like, where is this coming from? I I don't understand. But it was there.
- 22:22I just had never seen it, never witnessed it. And I there were
- 22:26so many strengths and and characteristics of
- 22:30myself that I had no idea about and
- 22:33that I do believe had I seen had I
- 22:37seen other people around me acting in a certain way, responding to things
- 22:41in a certain way, it would have felt more natural to me to
- 22:45respond in those ways myself.
- 22:49It's just fascinating to me how much of us is
- 22:53our biology. It's it's it's nature. It's not nurture. It's so
- 22:56interesting that, you know, 2 very horrific circumstances
- 23:01led you to finding your superpower. And as they say,
- 23:05sometimes there's a silver lining in every cloud. You know, but part of
- 23:08this course, you reached out to this national database
- 23:12trying to match people who were adopted with their birth
- 23:15parents. And what you got back was a really a door
- 23:19slammed in your face. Your mom was had no interest in searching for you. I
- 23:22mean, the database was, we both put our hat in the ring, and they connect
- 23:26us. Yeah. You know, just so many things spinning through as you're going
- 23:30through. And then you meet the love of your life, Rick. And Yeah.
- 23:33He helps you get your anxiety out of control, your panic attacks.
- 23:37You become the parents of 2 boys, Will and Ben. As all of
- 23:41this is happening, does your desire diminish in terms
- 23:45of trying to find your roots because now you're actually building a
- 23:48new family tree? Or does it actually become more
- 23:52pronounced because you realize what it's like to be part of a family? Yeah.
- 23:56I think it became more pronounced. It never diminished. I mean, I I I had
- 23:59to put it aside for many years because I was so busy
- 24:03or so consumed with taking care of other people. My my children, my
- 24:07increasingly, you know, elderly adopted parents and other
- 24:11siblings who needed support and help. But, I
- 24:14literally thought about, you know, those questions. Who am I? Where do they
- 24:18come from? Every day in my life. I don't think a day went by when
- 24:21I didn't ask myself those questions and wished and
- 24:25wanted to somehow find a way to learn this. And there weren't. All those
- 24:28years, you could there were no DNA websites and there was no no social media.
- 24:32I mean, there was just there was sort of no way to do that. I
- 24:35had no information whatsoever to go on, not a name, not a place.
- 24:39But certainly having my own children, it only made me more curious because now
- 24:43it it affected them too on those, you know, all the pediatrician
- 24:47forms, family history. I did I don't know. You know, what what if there's
- 24:50something in our family they need to know about and, and who do they
- 24:54look like? And it turned out my oldest
- 24:58son, we kinda didn't know who Will looked like for most of our lives. Like,
- 25:01gee, he didn't really look like Rick. He'd looked me. I mean, at different night,
- 25:04when he was young, he looked like Rick when he was older, he looked like
- 25:06me. But and then when I ultimately met my birth father,
- 25:10I mean, they were clones. Just clones. And and so what
- 25:14would it have been like for Will to be able to see himself in
- 25:18someone else? And then my my half brother on my father's
- 25:21side and Will are just 2 peas in a pod, and and he could have
- 25:25been such a role, a great role model for Will. And and what if he
- 25:28had been able to know know Sean all his life? And and the the mystery
- 25:31deepened when I had my own children. And I also
- 25:36understood biology and connection more and and felt that
- 25:39missing link in in me probably even more. And it's interesting. You know, you put
- 25:43in the book in the primal wound, Nancy Newton Vary writes, sometimes
- 25:47the adoptee experiences a second rejection upon making contact
- 25:51with their birth mother. Being rejected again is devastating. It's
- 25:55all the excruciating feelings of abandonment loss resurface. And
- 25:59I wanna talk about let's move it to 2,006. You and Rick are
- 26:02now empty nesters, so we've really moved the story forward.
- 26:06And Rick wants you to meet. He says, look it. We gotta figure out a
- 26:09way, whether it's private investigation and stuff. And once again, you know, you continue to
- 26:13be rejected. As you say, 96% of birth mothers wanna
- 26:17meet their child. My mother doesn't. So what
- 26:20happens, which is I find first of all, this is where I I
- 26:24move my dislike from your the mother who adopted you to the
- 26:28mother who gives birth, But you end up meeting your
- 26:31father first. And I think it's one of the Even though you only had 2
- 26:35years with him because of his age and his health, I have to
- 26:39believe those are moan some of those moments are among the best of your life.
- 26:42Meeting him, so profound, transformed
- 26:46my life, filled up the big black hole that I had lived
- 26:50with every day of my life, that all adoptees, I think, talk about. We
- 26:54all recognize that term, the big black hole. And I
- 26:57was so surprised that even not knowing
- 27:01anything about him, simply meeting him and looking in his eyes
- 27:05and and having him say my name, that big black hole
- 27:08just filled up, filled up. It was just
- 27:12amazing. And it just I made sense for the
- 27:15first time in my life. And he went all in. I mean, he it wasn't
- 27:18just, hey. Thanks. It's great to see you. You know, make sure we'll send Christmas
- 27:22cards to each other. I mean Right. He wanted you to meet his kids. He
- 27:25want I mean, you it just you just inherited a new
- 27:29family that embraced you as they should as one
- 27:33of their own. And as he said to the, social worker when she
- 27:37reached out to him, I mean, he had no idea I existed. He did not
- 27:39know he had bothered a child at age 18 and, had
- 27:43never knew anything about me. And so this was quite a shock to get a
- 27:47call one night while you're watching Jeopardy that you have a grown daughter and she'd
- 27:50like to meet you. But when he confirmed the agency's
- 27:53legitimacy and and all that, he he said, if she has my blood, she's
- 27:57my daughter. Of course, I wanna meet her. So Larry is your birth dad, and
- 28:00you have to take him to the hospital. He's injured his hand. And the nurse
- 28:04looks at you and says, are you family? And what did you say?
- 28:08Well, it was funny because I hesitated. It was the first time we you know,
- 28:11he we'd really been together. And and I and I don't know. I don't know
- 28:15if he wants me to go back with him or not. I'm sitting there and
- 28:17but I do. I I'm like when she said, are you family? I'm thinking, yeah.
- 28:20I am. And I just say, yes. I'm his daughter. And we both I
- 28:24smile, and he looks a little shocked too. And and yet, you know, he
- 28:27then he just smiles and he winks at me, and he goes, she sure is.
- 28:31I mean, it was just, just one of the that first time was sort
- 28:34of said out loud by by someone else. That was my hug of happiness. And
- 28:38I have to say, I'm gonna encourage people to buy this book because
- 28:42we're we're just touching on so many of the powerful emotional cords.
- 28:46You only have 2 years with Larry and it's but, you know, I think you
- 28:49spent in those 2 years, you live more with
- 28:53your dad than some people sadly live with their dad for their entire
- 28:57life. I mean, you guys didn't squander. He spent time with you in
- 29:00Nantucket and such. Yeah. Your other dad, though, his
- 29:04health is failing. And Yeah. Your mom comes to live with you
- 29:08for a month. As you said, I could take her in the smallest of
- 29:11times, but it just continues. She just continues to come back
- 29:15into your life. To me, I if I was to name her as write a
- 29:18screenplay, I'd say she's the carpet or the rug puller. Every time you're standing
- 29:22on a rug and feeling good and curling your toes into the fabric, she
- 29:26seems to wanna yank it. But I just the the interesting thing that I I
- 29:29was fascinated about is you still the black hole might have been filled, but there
- 29:33was still a part where you wanted to know your birth
- 29:36mother. Share how it came about because I thought it was quite
- 29:40interesting that her refusal, you could have
- 29:44easily just backed away, but you went to her
- 29:47children, and that became And I wouldn't say it was
- 29:51a great bridge to your birth mom, Shirley, but at least it was the
- 29:55beginning of finally having a lunch together. Yeah. It was,
- 29:58it was something that the social worker from my agency had
- 30:02encouraged me to do all along, and I had refused
- 30:05because I thought, oh, you know, they're
- 30:09gonna be protective of it. She doesn't wanna meet me. I mean, I had I
- 30:12had reached out to Shirley every year for 5
- 30:16years and and she just kept just wouldn't even
- 30:19respond. She just, you know, just completely
- 30:23shut me out. Wouldn't even respond at a certain point. I was going through the
- 30:26agency at first and then directly. And each time she denied anything to
- 30:30do with me and and even speaking to me, which was very very
- 30:34painful. But you have a drive. I I think most
- 30:38adoptees have this and if you're in touch with it, it's almost like this
- 30:41physical drive to reconnect with the birth mother, to reconnect with the center
- 30:45of your world, the the your whole world at the beginning of your life. And
- 30:48it's almost this physical compulsion. Like, I need to find
- 30:52her. I need to find her. I need to feel that connection in order to
- 30:56to finally feel peace. And it it's just like this
- 31:01this missing limb or something that you just gotta find and you wanna, like, reattach
- 31:04from it. It's just this it's it's for me, it was this physical drive. Some
- 31:08some people have said, oh, you're very brave to do this. I'm like, I wasn't
- 31:11brave. I was compelled. Like, I couldn't not do this. So
- 31:14when she kept refusing me, the the social worker kept saying, you need to contact
- 31:18your your siblings on her side. They're 5. You're all adults.
- 31:22She doesn't get to make the decision for them whether they have a relationship with
- 31:25you. And I kept saying, no. No. No. They'll they'll be protective of her.
- 31:29She raised them and or or they'll have her same personality, and they'll not be
- 31:33interested in meeting me. And I just kept
- 31:36refusing until I finally really
- 31:40got mad when I was reading Joan Didion's Blue Nights
- 31:44and she was she had adopted a a child, her only
- 31:48child, and she said some things in there that just really annoyed me and
- 31:52and just, you know, push finally pushed me over the edge. And I
- 31:55went, I am gonna reach out to them. So I I did. I wrote a
- 31:59letter to all 5 of them and overnighted it so they'd all receive it the
- 32:02same time. And it was that, you know, I just I I just had
- 32:06a drive to connect with that side of me. But you got
- 32:09another rural love back. I'm not saying across the board
- 32:13initially, but certainly the there was so many reaching
- 32:17out and they were embarrassed for their mother and your mother,
- 32:21ashamed, basically let you know it's not just you. That's the way she raised
- 32:25us. I mean, there was a lot of feeling, but as you
- 32:28said, brave is not the word. You're compelled to saying, Yes, but
- 32:32I still wanna meet her. So take us to the time where you've you've
- 32:36you know, she gives you, I think, 18 hours notice that, yes, she
- 32:39can find a way to fit you in the schedule for lunch, lunch, but she's
- 32:43a very, very busy woman. And you spend a couple 2 or 3 hours
- 32:46talking, but, I mean, again, I was reading words in the paper. I
- 32:50wasn't there. I would say she, her, and your the mother
- 32:54that adopted you both lacked a soul. Yeah. It's so
- 32:58interesting that either mother and I very much
- 33:01acknowledge that I was better off having been adopted
- 33:05and raised by Audrey even with all her shortcomings than I would have been
- 33:08raised by my birth mother, Shirley. But I also point out to
- 33:12people 2 things can be true. It it it can be true that I was
- 33:16better off not being mothered by Shirley, and I
- 33:19still had a traumatic childhood that I
- 33:23didn't know all those years what my birth mother was like. And so, of
- 33:27course, I imagined that she was the
- 33:31love and the connection I was yearning for.
- 33:35But even when I met her and it turned out so funny that both my
- 33:37mothers were sort of cold and distant and very narcissistic, and both my fathers were
- 33:41loving and kind. Yeah. But 2 things can be true at
- 33:45once. You know, just because I was lucky not to be raised by her
- 33:48doesn't mean I was lucky to be raised in my adopted house, which
- 33:52was by all measures a perfectly fine, you know,
- 33:56lovely middle class upbringing with, you know, I wasn't
- 34:00abused in any way. It's it's I think it's sometimes hard for
- 34:03people to understand. And what people most want from adoptees is
- 34:07gratitude. And one of the things I'm trying to say with this
- 34:10book is don't ask us to be grateful for trauma.
- 34:14Like, as much as you'd like to think adoption is a happy thing for
- 34:17everybody, the one person it it's not happy for anybody truly,
- 34:21but but the real trauma happens to the the adoptee
- 34:25who is robbed of all their heritage and their connection to their past, robbed of
- 34:29their identity, forced to live a very false life, feel it, live with
- 34:32a different name, live with a different identity, feel that disconnect.
- 34:36And and we're supposed to be grateful. Well, we are grateful for a
- 34:40for a home and and for love, but we aren't grateful for
- 34:44the the stealing, the robbing us of who we are and
- 34:47and our true lives and making us feel bad if
- 34:51we if we note that and if we feel that and and we're not
- 34:55grateful. All four of your the your the
- 34:58parents that adopted you and and your birth mother and father are no
- 35:02longer with you. As you reflect, the dads were
- 35:06superhuman beings. Even though you only had 2 years with Larry, he he
- 35:10loved you as much as any dad could love, and I would argue Bob did
- 35:14as well. But did the mothers ever open their heart in
- 35:17any way, or did they continue to just fill the moat with
- 35:21denial or despair or frustration
- 35:25that you just couldn't understand how important their role was and
- 35:29how insignificant yours was in their life. They
- 35:32ever change their thing at all? I had I had a moment with my adopted
- 35:36mother about a week before she died that wasn't
- 35:40fully that but in which it was the most
- 35:44emotional that we'd we'd ever been when when she was you know
- 35:48she knew she was dying and and when we had sort of when I read
- 35:51about that the book we had a moment where we had a a
- 35:54closeness. I never had that with Shirley during the the
- 35:58few years that I knew her that that she was alive. We also went through
- 36:01COVID during that time. So there, you know, you cut a couple of years out
- 36:03of that short period where we couldn't see each other either. That and that just
- 36:07made things worse. She even she even retreated further and really, you
- 36:11know, wanted me out of her life. And, you know, when I sent her flowers
- 36:14on her birthday, told me to recall the flowers. I mean, she just didn't want
- 36:17any reminder of me. Then we, I did meet her a few times and we'd
- 36:20get together with my sisters often and, again,
- 36:24she could be pleasant to me but she could not accept me
- 36:28as hers.
- 36:32When we return more insights on what it feels to be abandoned by
- 36:36Janet Schirlin, Of course, my 3 takeaways, and I
- 36:40get her to read the 3rd because I think it's one of the greatest lessons
- 36:44in life I've heard yet on Chatter That Matters.
- 36:52Hi. It's Tony Chapman from Chatter that matters. The world's upside
- 36:55down and having peace of mind seems to be the exception versus the rule.
- 36:59RBC Wealth Management is hoping to change that. They don't have a
- 37:03crystal ball, but they do have a team of experts dedicated to working with
- 37:07you to preserve and grow your wealth and help you manage risk so that you
- 37:10can enjoy the rewards of your labor. Your peace of mind and
- 37:14financial health matters to RBC.
- 37:21Meeting him, so profound, transformed
- 37:25my life, filled up the big black hole that I had lived
- 37:29with every day of my life, that all adoptees, I think, talk about. We
- 37:32all recognize that term, the big black hole. You're listening to Chatter That Matters
- 37:36with Tony Chapman, presented by RBC. Today my
- 37:40guest is Janet Cherlin. Being adopted, well it made
- 37:44her feel like she was living a bored life. So she
- 37:48decided to write about it. And her memoir, Abandoned at Birth, Searching
- 37:51for the Arms That Once Held Me, not only fulfilled a dream of hers to
- 37:55become a published author, but in doing so, it raises awareness
- 37:59about loss and grief and adoption, and why it takes more than
- 38:02love to survive that trauma. Today,
- 38:06are you at peace now that you've you understand
- 38:10where you come from, at peace with the fact that you've got such a beautiful
- 38:14extended family? Have you found that, or is it is that the reality of when
- 38:18you've lived with something like this your whole life, that black hole always
- 38:21feels like it could just open it up and swallow you again? I'm I'm more
- 38:24at peace than I ever have been, and I think I have a a
- 38:28appreciation of myself, forgiveness forgiveness for myself and an
- 38:31appreciation of myself and my my strength. I I think one
- 38:35of the things writing this book did, even though through my whole life I thought
- 38:39about adoption, studied adoption, I've been in therapy most of my life for
- 38:42things. Thought I had it all figured out. But what writing
- 38:46this book did, which I'm bringing it all together, there was in another
- 38:50a deeper level of emotional processing. It wasn't
- 38:53the facts. It was the emotional processing. And I kinda
- 38:57could look back and realize how alone and how
- 39:00sad and how painful and how traumatized my life had been
- 39:04and a greater appreciation for having come through that. And I
- 39:08realized and and sort of accept in the way you accept grief into your life,
- 39:11I think. But I realize that when you're adopted, you really
- 39:15don't belong to anything. You are really alone. We are all alone, ultimate
- 39:19life, but you are alone. You're really not part of your adoptive family. You're not
- 39:22part of your biological family. And I, as I say, I'm lucky enough
- 39:25to have a wonderful husband and children but there's something, you know, again, that
- 39:29wasn't in my life early on and you really you're really
- 39:32alone. But now I think through going through this,
- 39:36you learn to accept the things that your adoption brought you. You
- 39:40learn to understand the things that are in you that you never understood. You see
- 39:43a connection to the past. You see a connection to your heritage and
- 39:47your history, and you form a strength. You form a core that all human beings
- 39:51need to form, that most people form in adolescence. And
- 39:55and those of us that that don't know it struggle to form that.
- 39:59I feel strong now, and I feel proud to have done
- 40:03the hard work because it's hard. But I also
- 40:06had a lot of pain in writing the book. It it really
- 40:10brought me in even deeper touch with the grief
- 40:14and the loss and the sorrow. And it it coincided with a time in my
- 40:17life where I was losing all these parents and my brother. There's so much loss.
- 40:20And it was agonizingly painful
- 40:24to to relive that and to,
- 40:28really to relive my life, which is why I hesitate. I didn't wanna write a
- 40:31memoir, but but I ultimately had to to get this story out.
- 40:35And but I take pride in having gone there and
- 40:39worked hard at that. And I'm appreciate the
- 40:42place I've come to in life be because of that. And and I've done it
- 40:46with help. But, you know, I I again, I had great therapists along the way
- 40:49and and family and and that kind of work does take support.
- 40:53But if you do it, you're not burying it. And I think Rick,
- 40:57even from the day he pulled out the watermelon when you're having the panic attack,
- 41:02was so in love with you even though you might have felt you could get
- 41:06abandoned by him the way other people had, I think
- 41:09over time, you realize that, you were his rock and he was your rock. And
- 41:13I and I think that's that's part of the love story in the book
- 41:16because he never felt threatened that you needed to know
- 41:20these answers. He never felt threatened that I why why am I not enough? Why
- 41:23aren't our sons not enough? I give testament to him as
- 41:27well because weaker people might feel that
- 41:31they're being insecure because you're not secure in your
- 41:34relationship. I'm a believer that we are also
- 41:38not just connected by cells, but our spirits
- 41:42carry on. And if you had a chance to
- 41:46send a message today to Larry, your birth
- 41:49father, based on all you've come through, the pain, the
- 41:53writing, where you are today, what would you say to him? Thank you for
- 41:57the openness and and the love. I mean, he just
- 42:01immediately opened and as does his whole family.
- 42:04And and there's something I I think
- 42:08extraordinary about meeting a parent when you're
- 42:12middle aged. There's no baggage. You know, if if a father
- 42:16raising a child or a child being raised, but in any family, you know,
- 42:20if you go through life, there's you have to have baggage. There are disappointments and
- 42:23there are expectations and all that. When you are an adult and you meet a
- 42:27parent as an adult, you can just be open to each
- 42:31other and love each other and wanna know all the stories of each other. It's
- 42:34a really beautiful, clean, unfettered
- 42:38kind of relationship. And, it was really neat to experience
- 42:42that. I wouldn't have guessed that, but we were just so open to
- 42:45each other and enthralled and wanted to know everything about each other, and it was
- 42:49really lovely. And you talked about Bob, the father who adopted
- 42:53you and raised you and you loved dearly, that he couldn't accept
- 42:56that level of emotion. But do you think he left us with him
- 43:00knowing just how much he loved him? Yes. I do.
- 43:04Oh, that's scary. There was that that nonverbal communication,
- 43:08you know. And and and certainly certainly, I wrote those things to him
- 43:12all the time. I never had I never could say it to his face just
- 43:15because he was that kind of private person but but I think we
- 43:18communicated nonverbally and spiritually, and I I think he
- 43:22knew. And if you had time with
- 43:25Audrey, the mother who adopted you, or you could send one
- 43:29message in a bottle to heaven or Mhmm. What would you say to her?
- 43:33I think I'd say I now understand.
- 43:38As I said, she was damaged when she was young. You know, she
- 43:41lost the sister. Her parents were grieving so deeply. And,
- 43:46I she just spent her life trying to get attention because she hadn't been
- 43:49given it as a as a child. And maybe I shouldn't say I forgive her.
- 43:53I I probably don't forgive her for all the things she did to us, the
- 43:56lack of love. But I but I I guess I would just say I understand.
- 43:59And let's not say the best for Alaska because this is far from the best,
- 44:03but, surely Yeah. You know, surely, if you did, know, if
- 44:07you caught her in that one moment, let her drawbridge down
- 44:10because I have to believe when that as much as she wanted to distance herself,
- 44:14she still carried you for 9 months. She still gave birth.
- 44:18There is still a cellular connection. What would you say to Shirley? That's a
- 44:22hard one. I think I'm still angry with
- 44:26her for, you know, we never connected. We never had that
- 44:29moment. I would just say, I
- 44:33guess, I still want to, you know, I I still want
- 44:37to know you. I still want to be connected with you, and and I
- 44:40wish that we had had that. Janet, I always end my my
- 44:44shows with my sort of three takeaways. And the first one
- 44:48is interesting what you just said. When you meet somebody, a
- 44:51parent at midlife, you know, there's no circumstances or
- 44:55baggage. You know, there's no condition, so you can love somebody
- 44:59unconditionally. And maybe the lesson for all of us there is
- 45:03to forgive those circumstances and
- 45:06the things that hold you back from unconditional love, to
- 45:10treat the times you are together with the people you
- 45:14share blood with as an opportunity to
- 45:17be unconditionally in love. And I think a lot of families would be
- 45:21better off because there's so many families that are just pulled apart,
- 45:25and not in your case because you were abandoned, but just pulled apart
- 45:29because they failed to ever reconcile. The second thing is what
- 45:33your housekeeper said when you were off to see your, Shirley,
- 45:37your birth mom for the first time, and she goes, the blood
- 45:40calls. Those three words to me compressed the entire
- 45:45book. Well, I wanted I it was originally named that. It was originally named The
- 45:49Blood Calls, and my publisher said, you know, that sounds too much like a
- 45:52vampire novel or or a mystery novel. It's so funny. It's so interesting that we
- 45:56both found because I I to me, that was what it was, and I love
- 45:59what you said that we are animals. There's a there's a
- 46:03connection, a cellular connection. I don't know whether it's scent or
- 46:06spirituality, but when you're adopted, you you
- 46:10can't feel that. You can't have that. And so there's no question
- 46:13why I could see why the word compelled came out. And then the
- 46:17final thing I wanna end with is to remind people what your
- 46:20dad said when you asked if there was heaven. And I
- 46:24want you to say that again because you say it was such love in your
- 46:28voice. He said, I believe heaven
- 46:31is the way it no. I believe heaven is the feeling you leave in
- 46:35people while you're still here on this earth. You know
- 46:39what? That is the most powerful
- 46:43words of wisdom I've had in my 220
- 46:46plus episodes that, if we stop
- 46:50thinking of heaven as a power grab by religious groups and
- 46:54thought thought of it really as a way to live our lives,
- 46:58I think humanity would be better off. Janet Charlene, I've
- 47:02just so enjoyed, first of all, I love reading your book. I still want to
- 47:06give you massive hugs, a lot now for
- 47:09happiness. There's a lot of tears through it, but I hope so many
- 47:13people read your book, not just the people who have been adopted,
- 47:16but just to create much better awareness on the planet,
- 47:20what it means to be compelled to find
- 47:24who you are and to help you identify why it matters. So thank you for
- 47:28joining me in Chatter That Matters. Oh, thank you so much. I really appreciate being
- 47:31here and loved speaking with you. Chatter that
- 47:35matters has been a presentation of RBC. It's Tony
- 47:39Chapman. Thanks for listening. Let's chat soon.