Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Block Inc. (XYZ) Square Business Intelligence:Financials, Valuation, Risks Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Today, we're pulling back the
- 0:04curtain on a company that's probably touched your life in
- 0:06more ways than you realize. Blocking.
- 0:10Formerly known as Square. You know, if you've ever paid a
- 0:13small business with one of those little white card readers, or
- 0:16maybe used a digital wallet to ZAP money to a friend, you've
- 0:20likely interacted with them. We're going deep today
- 0:23uncovering the layers of this major financial tech player.
- 0:26That's the plan. Our mission here is really to
- 0:29give you a comprehensive look at Block.
- 0:31We'll cover everything from, you know, the basic business model
- 0:34to their financials. And even what big names like
- 0:36Warren Buffett see in them. Exactly.
- 0:38We've waded through, well, a lot of source material, articles,
- 0:42data to pull out the really important stuff for you.
- 0:44Think of it as a shortcut to getting informed.
- 0:46We'll throw in some surprising facts.
- 0:48Maybe a little humor too. And just to be clear upfront,
- 0:51this deep dive, it's purely for your education and information.
- 0:55All the analysis, it's based on public sources.
- 0:57Things can change, interpretations differ,
- 0:59Definitely. So absolutely not investment
- 1:01advice. OK, so scope.
- 1:03Wise, we'll hit their two main ecosystems, Square and Cash App.
- 1:06We'll look at the challenges they're facing, their cost
- 1:09structure, the leadership. Jack Dorsey.
- 1:11Yeah, him. And finally, what the numbers
- 1:14and those big investors seem to be telling us.
- 1:16OK, let's unpack this. Block Inc.
- 1:20It isn't just one thing, is it? It feels like 2 huge ecosystems
- 1:24working together. That's a great way to put it.
- 1:26They really operate through 2 core distinct but also
- 1:30complementary ecosystems, right? So first you've got Square
- 1:33that's all about merchants, payment services, those card
- 1:36readers you mentioned, point of sale software tools for sellers.
- 1:40Basically empowering businesses. OK.
- 1:41The business side. Then you have Cash App.
- 1:43That's the consumer side, peer-to-peer payments, yeah, but
- 1:45it's grown into a much broader digital wallet, investing
- 1:48features, even Bitcoin trading. Wow, that's a lot already.
- 1:51But wait, they also own Afterpay, the buy now pay later
- 1:54service they do and title the music streaming thing.
- 1:57How do these how do all these pieces fit together and actually
- 2:00make money? Yeah, it gets interesting there.
- 2:02The revenue comes from a few places, mostly transaction fees.
- 2:06That's from Square seller payments and cash app payments.
- 2:09Makes sense. Then there are subscriptions,
- 2:11software, services selling the hardware like the readers, and
- 2:14yeah, a pretty big chunk from Bitcoin trading on Cash App.
- 2:17Okay, so give us the numbers. How big are we talking?
- 2:19Huge In 2024, Block pulled in $24.12 billion in total revenue.
- 2:2524 billion. Yep.
- 2:27And Cash App was the big driver there, bringing in about $16.25
- 2:31billion. That's like, what, 60 some
- 2:33percent? 2/3.
- 2:34Yeah, well, Square, the merchant side generated around $7.68
- 2:37billion, so about 32%. And crucially, Cash App drove
- 2:41something like $10.2 billion just in Bitcoin revenue in 2024.
- 2:45OK. So Cash App is clearly the
- 2:47bigger earner in terms of sheer dollars coming in, but I always
- 2:50hear, you know, high volume often means lower margins.
- 2:52Is that true here? That's exactly the dynamic.
- 2:55How does that shake out profit wise compared to Square?
- 2:58And who are we talking about customer wise?
- 2:59How many people use this stuff? You nailed it.
- 3:02Cash App brings in the revenue volume, but if you look at gross
- 3:05profit, the story shifts a bit. About 58% of gross profit comes
- 3:09from Cash App and 42% from Square.
- 3:12OK, so closer. Right.
- 3:14It confirms that Cash App is higher volume, but Square while
- 3:18smaller revenue wise contributes more significantly margin wise
- 3:21per dollar. It's that classic volume versus
- 3:24margin trade off. Interesting customer numbers.
- 3:26As of 2024, they reported around 57 million monthly active users
- 3:31on Cash App, 57 million and on the Square side, about 4 million
- 3:36active sellers using the platform.
- 3:37Plus, you know millions and millions of those Square
- 3:40hardware units sold over the years.
- 3:42And Cash App keeps adding users like crazy.
- 3:44I think they added something like 27,000,000 new users back
- 3:46in 2020 alone. That growth is just phenomenal.
- 3:50But you know, no company, especially one growing this
- 3:52fast, has a perfectly smooth ride.
- 3:54They must be facing some headwinds, right?
- 3:55Oh. Absolutely.
- 3:56What are the bumps in the row they're hitting right now?
- 3:58The short term stuff? And what about the bigger, maybe
- 4:01more structural risks they need to keep an eye on long term?
- 4:04Yeah. So short term block is actually
- 4:06quite sensitive to the wider economy macroeconomic
- 4:09conditions. Like consumer spending?
- 4:11Exactly. They've even mentioned
- 4:13macroeconomic headwinds, specifically when they cut
- 4:16guidance recently. Look at Q12025.
- 4:19Their revenue actually dipped about 3% year over year, came in
- 4:22at $5.77 billion, missing forecasts.
- 4:27Ouch. And it ties directly back to
- 4:28people maybe spending a bit less.
- 4:30You know you skip buying that coffee using a Square reader or
- 4:33you send less money on Cash App. It adds up and hits their
- 4:36volumes. Right, it connects directly.
- 4:38Plus there's always intense competition and just general
- 4:41cyclical slowdowns in retail that affect the square side.
- 4:44And the crypto market? You mentioned the big Bitcoin
- 4:46revenue, but that seems like a massive headache sometimes,
- 4:48doesn't it? So couldn't you argue their
- 4:50early Bitcoin bed positions them well if crypto does go
- 4:53mainstream? It's definitely a double edged
- 4:54sword. You're right.
- 4:55A crypto volatility, it causes huge swings in their financials
- 4:58short term. How so?
- 4:59Well, in Q12025 they had $2.43 billion in Bitcoin revenue.
- 5:04Sounds great, right? But the gross profit from that,
- 5:06only $68 million, Wow, tiny margin.
- 5:09Tiny. It shows how price swings really
- 5:12hammer the profitability of that segment.
- 5:14A lot of that Bitcoin revenue is just pass through high volume,
- 5:18very low margin. Plus those things like rising
- 5:20interest rates can slow down the buy now pay later activity with
- 5:23after pay. OK, but to your point, yes, if
- 5:27Bitcoin stabilizes, if it finds wider adoption blocks, early
- 5:30infrastructure and integration could absolutely be a long term
- 5:33strategic advantage. They're already there.
- 5:35OK. So that's the short term
- 5:36turbulence. What about the bigger picture,
- 5:38those longer term risks that could really change the game for
- 5:40them? Right, the structural stuff.
- 5:42A big one is regulatory scrutiny compliance.
- 5:46The regulators always watching fintech.
- 5:48Always Block has faced investigations SEC state
- 5:52regulators like New York's DFS, particularly around cash App and
- 5:55banking rules. Why is that so critical?
- 5:57Because stricter rules think anti money laundering, know your
- 6:00customer may be new. Limits on buy now, pay later
- 6:02could force changes in how cash app works.
- 6:04It could increase their costs significantly or even limit how
- 6:07fast they can grow. OK.
- 6:09What else? Then there's just the whole
- 6:11payments landscape potentially shifting.
- 6:13You hear talk about central bank digital currencies, right?
- 6:15Yeah, CBDC's. Or even just more pressure
- 6:18squeezing fees down across the industry.
- 6:20Yeah. That could really eat into their
- 6:21main revenue source, those transaction fees.
- 6:24Right. The core model.
- 6:25And that Bitcoin risk doesn't go away long term either a major
- 6:27crash or a real turn in consumer or regulatory sentiment against
- 6:32crypto that could permanently slash profitability from that
- 6:35segment makes sense. And finally, you know, just
- 6:37competition. New payments tech popping up,
- 6:40maybe big tech giants making bigger plays in finance, plus
- 6:44the risk that some of their own new ventures after pay title
- 6:47proto just don't pan out as hoped.
- 6:49OK. So behind all this revenue, all
- 6:50these risks, there's obviously a cost to doing business.
- 6:53Yeah. How does Block actually spend
- 6:54its money? Is it mostly fixed costs or does
- 6:57it scale up and down with volume?
- 6:59It's a mix really. Some costs are definitely
- 7:02variable, directly tied to volume.
- 7:04Think transaction fees they have to payout.
- 7:05Card networks, digital currency costs for Cash App, those go up
- 7:09as they process more money. The cost to manufacture the
- 7:11hardware, the readers, that's variable per unit.
- 7:14And parts of marketing like customer acquisition costs have
- 7:17variable components too. But it sounds like they're
- 7:19really pouring a ton of cash into building things into
- 7:22innovation and scaling up. What are the big fixed costs?
- 7:25They really are investing heavily.
- 7:26That's where the bulk of the costs lie in fixed or semi fixed
- 7:30areas, especially product development, their R&D and SG
- 7:34and a sales and marketing general and admin.
- 7:36How much are we talking? R&D alone was almost $3 billion
- 7:39in 2020, four $2.914 billion to be precise.
- 7:44That nearly doubled in just four years.
- 7:46Sales and marketing was close to $2 billion G and a around $2.15
- 7:51billion. These costs, they don't just
- 7:53track short term volume swings. It's like building the
- 7:55infrastructure. First, exactly.
- 7:57Think of it like building a giant factory.
- 7:59Huge upfront cost, but once it's running the cost per item made
- 8:02can drop significantly. Block needs serious scale to
- 8:05make these big investments pay off long term, right leverage.
- 8:07Yeah. If they get that scale, the
- 8:10profit potential per transaction could be huge.
- 8:13Now they can cut some discretionary spending if things
- 8:15slow down, but that core R&D that tends to stay high for
- 8:19future growth and honestly they're fixed costs, did outpace
- 8:23revenue growth in the 20/22/2024 period.
- 8:26OK, so who's steering this ambitious ship?
- 8:29Let's talk management, especially with a founder like
- 8:31Jack Dorsey still right there at the top.
- 8:33Yeah, the leadership is definitely notable.
- 8:34Jack Dorsey, Co founder of Twitter to Remember.
- 8:36He's Blockhead chairman, Co CEO and importantly, he owns about
- 8:4010% of the Class A shares. So he's got skin in the game a
- 8:43lot of. It a lot.
- 8:44It aligns him directly with long term shareholder value.
- 8:48You also have key long time execs like Amrita Ahuja.
- 8:50She wears multiple hats. President CFOCOO and Christy
- 8:54Esperanza as chief legal officer.
- 8:56How transparent are they? You mentioned they cut guidance.
- 8:58Generally, they seem pretty upfront about challenges.
- 9:00Cutting guidance in May 2025. Citing those macro headwinds is
- 9:03an example. They also face that activist
- 9:05short seller report from Hindenburg Research back in
- 9:082023. Right.
- 9:09I remember that allegations about inflating metrics.
- 9:12Yeah, but block management pushed back, publicly refuted
- 9:15the claims and said they were cooperating with regulators.
- 9:18It suggests you know an open response rather than trying to
- 9:21sweep things under the rug. And the alignment besides
- 9:24Dorsey's stake. It seems strong other executives
- 9:27also hold significant equity, and Dorsey himself has famously
- 9:31pledged to give away a lot of his wealth.
- 9:33But he continues to hold his block stock through thick and
- 9:36thin, which is telling. They even took pay cuts during
- 9:39the early COVID uncertainty. OK, let's get to the bottom
- 9:42line, the financials, what do the numbers really tell us about
- 9:45Blocks journey so far and its current health, especially with
- 9:48all this growth and investment? Well, the revenue growth story
- 9:50is undeniable. Super rapid, averaging maybe
- 9:533040% a year before 2022. Then it slowed.
- 9:56It still rebounded. 25% growth in 2020, three 10% in 2024.
- 10:00Still strong growth. Yeah, the profitability, that's
- 10:02been much more volatile. They were mostly losing money
- 10:06operationally speaking, in the early years.
- 10:08They only just turned an operating profit in 2024.
- 10:11That feels like a pretty big milestone.
- 10:13It really is. It's like that shift from just
- 10:14burning cash to actually making money on the core business.
- 10:17Super important for long term sustainability.
- 10:20Their Net margin hit around 12% in 2024, which was a huge jump
- 10:24from basically 0 the year before.
- 10:25And the balance sheet, how does that look debt cash?
- 10:29Surprisingly strong, almost conservative.
- 10:31You could say. Assets are way higher than
- 10:33liabilities, $36.8 billion in assets.
- 10:37They've got around $9 billion in cash. 9 billion in cash.
- 10:40Roughly, yeah. And debt is only around 4 or $5
- 10:44billion. So their debt to equity ratio is
- 10:46quite low like .24 tons of financial flexibility there.
- 10:49And they don't pay dividends, right?
- 10:50Reinvesting everything correct? All cash goes back into growth.
- 10:53So with these financials, rapid growth, finally hitting
- 10:55profitability, strong balance sheet, it begs the question,
- 10:59what do the really savvy investors think?
- 11:01You mentioned Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway actually
- 11:04bought block stock. That seems kind of surprising
- 11:07for Buffett. What's the story?
- 11:08It is interesting, isn't it? It shows different investment
- 11:10approaches. Berkshire, the quintessential
- 11:12value investor, started buying block while it was still square
- 11:15then back in mid 2021, OK, by late 2023, reports showed them
- 11:20holding around 8.3 million Class A shares.
- 11:24Now the interesting part is his cost basis was apparently around
- 11:27$197.00 per share. 197 dollars? Wow, the stocks been way below
- 11:31that for a while. Exactly.
- 11:32So he definitely incurred some significant paper losses.
- 11:36But as far as public filings show heading into mid 2025, it
- 11:40looks like Berkshire is still holding.
- 11:41They haven't sold which it suggests a very long term
- 11:44conviction looking past the short term price swings.
- 11:47Other value guys like Seth Klarman, Bill Miller have also
- 11:50held positions at times. But not everyone agrees.
- 11:53Right. Contrast that with someone like
- 11:54Kathy Wood, more of a tech growth investor.
- 11:57Her funds bought heavily in 20/20/21 but then sold out by
- 12:002022 after the stock tanked. So you see a real divergent in
- 12:03how different investors value block.
- 12:05This leads right into the big valuation question.
- 12:08What does all this mean for blocks intrinsic value,
- 12:11especially with all these moving parts, Cash app growth, Bitcoin
- 12:14square margins, and that intrinsic value estimate you
- 12:17hinted at earlier. It sounded quite different from
- 12:19where the stock is trading. Some might argue you know that a
- 12:22simple DCF doesn't capture the full picture for a disruptor
- 12:25like block. How do you account for?
- 12:27That that's the multi billion dollar question, isn't it?
- 12:30And you're right to bring up the limitations of DCF.
- 12:32So let's try a Buffett style discounted cash flow analysis.
- 12:36We're basically trying to estimate future owner earnings.
- 12:39Owner earnings remind me what that is exactly.
- 12:41It's essentially the real cash profit leftover for the owners
- 12:44after the company has made all the necessary investments to
- 12:47maintain its competitive position and operations.
- 12:49It's often seen as a more realistic measure of earning
- 12:52power than just reported net income.
- 12:55Got it. So what is the DCF model spit
- 12:57out? OK, let's run a conservative
- 12:59scenario. We use the estimated 2024 owner
- 13:02earnings, about $1.8 billion. Assume a pretty modest 5% annual
- 13:07growth and free cash flow going forward.
- 13:10Use a 10% discount rate standard practice and a 2% terminal
- 13:13growth rate, OK. That calculation gives us an
- 13:16intrinsic equity value for Block somewhere in the range of 24 to
- 13:19$28 million. Billion, OK per share.
- 13:21That translates to roughly 38 to $44 per share.
- 13:24Now, if you want a margin of safety, say 30%, like Graham and
- 13:27Buffett often advocate for, your theoretical buy price Based on
- 13:30this conservative DCF would be down around $26 per share. $26
- 13:34Wow. OK.
- 13:35But back to my earlier point, does that conservative DCF miss
- 13:39the, you know, the disruptive potential, the optionality?
- 13:41Absolutely. That's the key critique and it's
- 13:43valid. A standard DCF is inherently
- 13:46conservative. It values what you can
- 13:48reasonably forecast based on current operations and modest
- 13:51growth. For a company like Block, a lot
- 13:53of the excitement and frankly, the current stock price is based
- 13:56on potential. Potential for Cash App to become
- 13:59even bigger, Potential for Afterpay to dominate BMPL,
- 14:02Potential wins from new ventures, Potential crypto
- 14:04upside. Things that are really hard to
- 14:06plug into a spreadsheet with high confidence.
- 14:08So the market is clearly pricing in a lot more optimism than that
- 14:11$2644.00 range. Oh, definitely.
- 14:14So the current price around $75 a share, yeah.
- 14:17How does that compare to the DCF value?
- 14:19What does it imply? Well, $75 is about 3.2 times
- 14:22that conservative fair value range we calculated.
- 14:24So from a strict conservative DCF perspective, it suggests a
- 14:28pretty low margin of safety at current prices.
- 14:31Flipping it around, if you assume today's $75 price is the
- 14:34fair intrinsic value, you'd need to plug in much more aggressive
- 14:38growth assumptions into the model to justify it.
- 14:40We're talking maybe implied returns of 1517%, but that
- 14:44requires Block to grow its cash flows very substantially and
- 14:47consistently for a long time. So it really hinges on your
- 14:50assumptions about future growth, especially for Cash App Bitcoin
- 14:54margins after. Pay precisely your view on the
- 14:56intrinsic value heavily depends on how optimistic you are about
- 14:59those key growth drivers and margin improvement.
- 15:02OK. Let's bring it back to the
- 15:03present. How did their latest earnings,
- 15:05Q12025 reflect these trends we've been talking about?
- 15:09Did they show the growth needed to justify the price?
- 15:12Q12025 actually showed some of that continued pressure.
- 15:15We discussed. Revenue came in at $5.77
- 15:17billion. That was down 3% from the year
- 15:19before and it missed analysts estimates.
- 15:21Down 3%. Not great, not ideal.
- 15:24Profitability looked OK on the surface.
- 15:25Net income was about point nine, $6 billion, but that included a
- 15:28$93 million loss on Bitcoin remeasurement.
- 15:31The accounting hit from bitcoin's price dropping.
- 15:33Exactly. It's not a cash loss from
- 15:35operations, but it reflects the paper value decrease of their
- 15:39Bitcoin holdings during that quarter.
- 15:41Adjusted earnings per share dollar and 56 cents was also
- 15:44below what analysts expected, and gross profit dipped overall
- 15:47as transaction volumes weakened. What about the specific
- 15:50segments? Cash App Square.
- 15:52Cash App users held steady 57 million monthly actives and
- 15:56importantly, the gross profit per user actually went up 9% to
- 16:00$81.00. So there's still monetizing that
- 16:02base effectively. OK.
- 16:03That's positive. Afterpay also looks strong,
- 16:05gross merchandise volume of 19%, gross profit up 23%, but again,
- 16:10that Bitcoin revenue line $2.43 billion in revenue, only
- 16:14$68,000,000 in gross profit. Because of the price volatility
- 16:17and the square side, the seller business saw volume and revenue
- 16:20decline compared to the previous quarter.
- 16:22And the outlook, what did management say?
- 16:23They cut their full year 2025 gross profit guidance again,
- 16:27pointing directly at weaker consumer spending, but they are
- 16:30projecting some modest growth returning in the second-half of
- 16:32the year. They're betting on, you know,
- 16:34expanding after pay and rolling out some new AI initiatives to
- 16:37help kick start growth again. OK, So pulling all these threads
- 16:40together, the two ecosystems, the risks, the costs, the
- 16:44leadership, the volatile financials, the valuation
- 16:46debate, what's the ultimate take away for someone trying to
- 16:50understand Block? Well, Block is clearly a fast
- 16:54growing, innovative fintech company.
- 16:56They've built significant scale in both consumer and merchant
- 16:59spaces and they have a remarkably strong balance sheet
- 17:02which gives them options. But historically profitability
- 17:05has been very inconsistent. It seems to be improving now,
- 17:08turning profitable operationally, which is key, but
- 17:11it's been a bumpy ride. That unique market position, the
- 17:14founder LED aspect, it might justify a premium valuation in
- 17:17some investors eyes. Get the numbers.
- 17:19Yet the numbers, especially profitability and cash flow have
- 17:22fluctuated a lot. And as our conservative DCF
- 17:24showed, the current market price seems to bake in a lot of future
- 17:27success already potentially offering a lower margin of
- 17:30safety today compared to a few years ago.
- 17:32It really depends on continued strong execution.
- 17:34Right, our goal here at The Deep Dive, as always, is to help you
- 17:38connect those dots, gain that knowledge quickly and
- 17:40thoroughly, and hopefully give you some aha moments without
- 17:44drowning you in data. Absolutely.
- 17:45And let me just reiterate, this content is purely for
- 17:48educational and informational purposes.
- 17:51All the financial data, the analysis, it's based on publicly
- 17:54available sources. Things change, interpretations
- 17:56differ. It is absolutely not investment
- 17:59advice. Please conduct your own due
- 18:01diligence. Talk to a licensed financial
- 18:03advisor before making any investment decisions.
- 18:06Nothing here is an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy any
- 18:10securities. And hey, if you find this
- 18:11valuable, please like and subscribe.
- 18:13We're on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, on our YouTube channel,
- 18:16Deep Value investing. Check the episode description
- 18:18too. We've got a great value
- 18:19investing book list there. You can also support the channel
- 18:21and help us develop a cool Buffett indicator app.
- 18:24There's a GoFundMe link in the description. gofundme.com/after
- 18:28turning Buffett's wisdom into a daily tool for investors, we'd
- 18:31really appreciate any support. OK.
- 18:33And now as we wrap up, a final thought for you to chew on.
- 18:36Given blocks really aggressive spending on R&D in these new
- 18:39ventures like after pay and potentially others, and
- 18:42considering that historical volatility in his profits, how
- 18:45much growth does this company truly need to deliver year after
- 18:48year to actually justify its current valuation?
- 18:51Then maybe more importantly, how long can they realistically
- 18:53sustain that kind of high growth in such a fast changing
- 18:56competitive market? Something to think about.