Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Navigating Chinese Social Media For Research" with Chu Yang
Transcript
- 0:05You're listening to a stage talk titled Navigating
- 0:08Chinese Platforms for Research. This week, we
- 0:11were joined by researcher Qiu Yang. Qiu is an
- 0:15expert in Chinese audience research and came
- 0:18in to provide us with an overview of the most
- 0:20popular Chinese social media platforms. Her investigative
- 0:24tips and tricks were focused on accessing the
- 0:27platforms from foreign devices. and she mentioned
- 0:30some useful resources for analyzing country -wide
- 0:33and diaspora -wide trends. You can find links
- 0:36to all of the resources mentioned in the talk
- 0:38in the podcast description. This talk was hosted
- 0:41by me, Charlotte Marr, on Thursday the 30th of
- 0:44April, 2026, in the BellyCat Discord server.
- 0:55Welcome all to our Stage Talk series. Thanks
- 0:59for joining us today, especially if it's sunny
- 1:02where you are. I hope you're enjoying the sunshine
- 1:04when and where you can. Chinese social media
- 1:09is one of the world's most dynamic digital ecosystems.
- 1:12But for researchers and journalists working from
- 1:14outside China, it can be difficult to access,
- 1:17navigate and interpret in some cases. In this
- 1:21stage talk, we're joined by Qu Yang, an analyst
- 1:24and researcher with experience studying Chinese
- 1:26and Iranian media environments. Qu contributes
- 1:30to the China Media Project, and recently wrote
- 1:33a guide on researching on the app Xiaozhuangshu,
- 1:36red note, for Bellingcat. Today, together, we'll
- 1:39explore how these platforms work in practice,
- 1:42what makes them distinct, and how to approach
- 1:44them effectively from a foreign device. Whether
- 1:47you're tracking stories, analyzing trends or
- 1:49just trying to get a clearer view into these
- 1:51spaces, this session will offer practical insights
- 1:54and grounded advice. Before we start, a short
- 1:57reminder that you can place your questions in
- 1:59the chat accessible on the right hand corner
- 2:01of your screen. But please remember that this
- 2:04is being audio recorded for the podcast. So if
- 2:07you don't want me to mention your username for
- 2:10security reasons or whatever, please add that
- 2:13as a note in your question. Okay, Chu, I'll cross
- 2:16over to you and I will mute my mic. Hi. Hi, everyone.
- 2:22I'm going to share my screen first. Hi, everyone.
- 2:26I'm glad to be here and to have the chance to
- 2:29connect with the Valentine community. My name
- 2:32is Chu Yang. I'm a journalist and media researcher
- 2:35focusing on China's digital spaces and information
- 2:39ecosystem. I write for the China Media Project
- 2:42and I recently published a guide on Balinkite
- 2:46about using xiao hong shu, also known as Red
- 2:49Note or Little Red Book for open source investigation.
- 2:54Today, I want to talk about something quite practical,
- 2:57how you can actually use Chinese social media
- 2:59as a journalist or researcher even if you don't
- 3:02have a Chinese phone number, don't read Chinese
- 3:05and have never opened any of these apps before.
- 3:09So I will cover the three things, how to get
- 3:16the access, why this platform is worth your time,
- 3:19and which tools and resources to use. So the
- 3:23first one, let's start with the most basic question.
- 3:26What can you actually do without a Chinese phone
- 3:29number? It's actually more than you might think.
- 3:32First, you don't even need an account. Weibo,
- 3:35you can actually see trendy topics without any
- 3:38account. The hot search list, meaning like trendy
- 3:42topics, is publicly accessible. Douyin and xiaohongshu
- 3:47are more limited. You can scroll through whatever
- 3:52the algorithm serves you. By the moment you want
- 3:55to search, open a specific post, or read the
- 3:58comments, you will need to register. But you
- 4:03can register with the overseas number. All these
- 4:07three platform accepts international phone numbers,
- 4:11and unlike Chinese users who are subject to real
- 4:14-name registration requirements, international
- 4:17users aren't, so the setup process is actually
- 4:20quite relaxed. You can use your regular phone
- 4:23number, or if you prefer to keep the things separate,
- 4:28a cheap prepaid SIM card that can receive a verification
- 4:33code works just fine, but Here I want to flag
- 4:37something important, especially for xiaohongshu.
- 4:41When you register with an overseas number, the
- 4:45platform automatically tags you as an international
- 4:48user. And that changed everything about what
- 4:53you see. The algorithm will start pushing you
- 4:56English language content, posts from expat influencers
- 5:00or content created for international audiences,
- 5:04which Sounds convenient, but for investigation
- 5:07purpose, it's actually quite a problem. Because
- 5:11what you are seeing is no longer what the Chinese
- 5:15users see. So my first practical tip, if you
- 5:19are using Xiaohongshu for research, disabled
- 5:22automatic translation. Let the app show you content
- 5:26as it natively appears. It will help you distinguish
- 5:31between posts made for domestic audiences. and
- 5:34posts made for people like you. And more broadly,
- 5:38be aware that your feed is being shaped constantly.
- 5:42Every search you do, every post you do on, every
- 5:45account you follow, all of all of that trains
- 5:48your algorithm. Your location also plays a role.
- 5:52The xiaohongshu you see after a week of use will
- 5:54be quite different from the one a user in Shanghai
- 5:57sees. That's not a reason not to use it, but
- 6:01it's something to keep in mind when you are accessing
- 6:04how representative your sample is. So this is
- 6:09the basic access issues. The next question is
- 6:15like, why do you need to use Chinese social media?
- 6:21So I would like to frame it around three directions.
- 6:28Direction 1 is searching for topics and resources.
- 6:32Chinese social media are quite simply enormous.
- 6:36Xiaohongshu alone has around 300 million monthly
- 6:40active users and processes over 600 million searches
- 6:44a day. Weibo has been the de facto public square
- 6:48for Chinese internet users for over a decade.
- 6:52For journalists, that means there is a huge amount
- 6:55of primary source material, eyewitness accounts,
- 6:59personal testimonials, grassroots reactions to
- 7:03events that simply don't service in English language
- 7:08media. I will give you an example from my guide.
- 7:12When the 2025 Miss Finland was accused of making
- 7:17anti -Asian gestures, A search for 芬蘭小姐, Mr.
- 7:22Land, combined with 投訴, which means complaint,
- 7:27on 小紅書, revealed an entire ecosystem of collective
- 7:31action. Users were sharing complaint templates,
- 7:35posting different pathways for filing reports,
- 7:38documenting outcomes. That's not something you'll
- 7:42find in your Reuter wild story, but It's exactly
- 7:46the kind of grassroots coordination that's valuable
- 7:49to report on. And with the Chinese diaspora now
- 7:52spread across the world, there are millions of
- 7:55Chinese nationals living outside of China. Social
- 7:58media activity by the diaspora community can
- 8:02turn into global stories. Xiaohongshu in particular
- 8:06has become a kind of lifestyle and community
- 8:10hub for young Chinese living abroad, which makes
- 8:13it especially useful for stories involving that
- 8:17demographic. And on direct two is understanding
- 8:23real public opinion and nuance. This is where
- 8:27it gets really interesting and this is actually
- 8:29something that happened last week. So it's very
- 8:33timely. On Tuesday, China's Ministry of State
- 8:42Security published a post to its Chinese account,
- 8:46claiming that hostile foreign forces are funding
- 8:50lying flat influencers to systematically brainwash
- 8:54Chinese youth. Lying flat, Tangping, in Chinese,
- 8:59is a cultural phenomenon where young people opt
- 9:03out of the relentless pressure to work harder
- 9:06and more compete for status. It's essentially
- 9:10China's version of quiet quitting, but more philosophically
- 9:15deliberate. The state's security is announcing
- 9:18that this isn't an organic social response. It's
- 9:24more like a foreign plot. Now, if you only read
- 9:28the official statement, you get one picture.
- 9:32But if you go to Xiaohongshu and search Tangping
- 9:35right now, you get something completely different.
- 9:39The comments section are full of mockery. I pulled
- 9:43a few quotes at random from the comment section
- 9:47on a Xiaohongshu post by a state media account
- 9:50sharing the video. So not sure if you can read
- 9:54it, but it says, one user from Beijing wrote,
- 9:59no need to incite us. We chose this ourselves.
- 10:03And another one from Jiangsu said, where do we
- 10:06collect the foreign money? Let's go together.
- 10:09And then there are... is my personal favorite,
- 10:12a user who wrote completely deadpan. I'm 38 years
- 10:17old and I want to answer to the nation's call.
- 10:20I'm planning to join the tobacco company, the
- 10:23power company, patrol China, listing every state
- 10:26-owned, essentially unattainable employer he
- 10:31can think of. And the reason why he wrote 38
- 10:35is It's a phenomenon in China that now, like
- 10:40after you are 35, basically it's really hard
- 10:43to find a job. So he would kind of like put,
- 10:47have order warning or like the art target. That
- 10:54comment is doing a lot of work in not so rejecting
- 10:56the official framing. It's pointing directly
- 10:59at the structure inequality that drives line
- 11:04flight. in the first place. The irony is that
- 11:10that exists precisely because the competition
- 11:13for the state sex drop is so brutal and so unfair
- 11:16that many young people have simply just given
- 11:21up trying. This gap between the official narrative
- 11:25and what people are actually seeing is itself
- 11:27a story and you can only find it if you are looking
- 11:31at the platforms. And the third direction I want
- 11:35to point out is studying Chinese social media
- 11:38as a subject. It's slightly different. Instead
- 11:43of using these platforms as a resource for other
- 11:46stories, you are studying the platforms themselves
- 11:49from a media or technology perspective. How does
- 11:54censorship work? what gets deleted and when.
- 11:58How do viral information ecosystems function
- 12:01under authoritarian control? This is a longer
- 12:05term, more systematic work. But it's some of
- 12:09the most important jumbling being done on China
- 12:13right now. I will put you to some resources for
- 12:18this. So let me give you some practical tools
- 12:21organized in three levels. The level one is the
- 12:26platform specific tracking. For Weibo, the simply
- 12:30entry point is the hot search list, weibo .com
- 12:35slash hot. It's a real time ranking. of trendy
- 12:39topics updated constantly. Even without reading
- 12:42Chinese, you can track what topics are moving
- 12:44and use translation tool to understand them.
- 12:48For xiaohongshu, the built -in search is more
- 12:53powerful than it looks. A few things worth you
- 12:59can already check most of how it works from the
- 13:03guides Charlie just shared. A few things worth
- 13:09knowing is like you can combine keywords to narrow
- 13:13results. Instead of just searching a topic, combine
- 13:18it with a verb or action, like I mentioned with
- 13:21miss Finland and complaint. And you can also
- 13:24filter by different kinds of content types. So
- 13:27I won't get it too much into the building search.
- 13:32I think I have put most of this content inside
- 13:37the note. For tracking content trends across
- 13:41platforms, which articles are going viral on
- 13:45WeChat, which posts on Xiaohongshu I get in traction.
- 13:50New rank, which I also mentioned in the guide,
- 13:54is useful analytics. tool. It's not just for
- 13:58Xiaohu Shu, it covers all platforms. So it tracks
- 14:04content heat, account ranks, and article virality
- 14:09peaks. It's in Chinese but navigable with a translation
- 14:14layer. And the tier two is understanding Chinese
- 14:20digital culture. For anyone who doesn't read
- 14:23Chinese and wants to follow what's happening
- 14:25on Chinese platforms, my strongest recommendation
- 14:29is What's on Weibo. The site has recently rebranded
- 14:37to cover a broad scope under the name Eye on
- 14:41Digital China, which reflects the reality that
- 14:45the Chinese internet has expanded well beyond
- 14:48Weibo. It published English language explainers
- 14:55on viral moments, trendy topics, and platform
- 14:59developments, updated very regularly. It's genuinely
- 15:03one of the best entry points into Chinese digital
- 15:06culture for non -Chinese readers. And the level
- 15:103... in censorship and platform mechanism. For
- 15:15more systematic long -term research, China Digital
- 15:21Times does two important things. It tracks significant
- 15:29Internet events and viral incidents. And it also
- 15:34archives censored content from Chinese platforms.
- 15:38It also reports on Chinese censorship. So if
- 15:42a post gets deleted, there is a reasonable chance
- 15:46CDT has a record of it. And for academic level
- 15:50research into censorship, censorship mechanism,
- 15:54specifically, citizen lab at the University of
- 15:57Toronto has done extensive rigorous work on how
- 16:03Chinese platforms censor content, what a keyword
- 16:06list looks like, and how the system adapts over
- 16:10time. Their reports are publicly available. So
- 16:17to sum up, Chinese social media is accessible.
- 16:22probably more accessible than most people assume.
- 16:26You don't need a Chinese phone number to browse
- 16:28and you don't need to read Chinese to get a start.
- 16:32But the real value isn't just the access, it's
- 16:36the ability to see what visual narratives are
- 16:40up against. The irony, the mockery, the quiet
- 16:44resistance, the structured critique hidden inside
- 16:47a joke about applying to Patrol China. So that's
- 16:52where the story is and these platforms are where
- 16:55you'll find it. My guide on Xiaohongshu is on
- 17:00the Bellingcat website. So you can just check
- 17:04it out and I'm happy to answer questions now.
- 17:11Thank you so much too. Thank you for going through
- 17:14those really systematic tips and also for spotlighting
- 17:19why. Oh, I didn't even realize I didn't turn
- 17:22on my video. No worries. I was just saying, it
- 17:26was great to also hear why this research is important
- 17:29and how it impacts not only knowledge of what's
- 17:33going on within the country, but also with the
- 17:36Diaspora as well, as you mentioned. Please do
- 17:40take a moment to read Chu's guide. As I said,
- 17:43it's in the chat and it's a fantastic run -through
- 17:47of how to dive into that particular platform.
- 17:52I wanted to ask Chu to kick the questions off.
- 17:55How do Chinese platforms in general differ in
- 17:58terms of content visibility and moderation? compared
- 18:03to platforms that maybe have a more global view.
- 18:07Is moderation a little bit stronger on Chinese
- 18:10apps or is it a little bit freer? Can you talk
- 18:14through a little bit what the moderation controls
- 18:17are like on those platforms? I think it depends.
- 18:21So for the Chinese social media platforms, how
- 18:26can I put this way? So for the platforms, If
- 18:30they are a huge platform, so when people, when
- 18:34they are doing like a sensor content, that means
- 18:37like they will affect the user experience. So
- 18:40this is a, so they operate in two layers. First
- 18:45layers is actually, they operate like a normal
- 18:48business or like a company, like any big platform,
- 18:53like any big... any global platform. So they
- 18:57have to care about the user experience or like
- 19:00not censor too much. And this is the one thing.
- 19:05But on the other hand, they also have to align
- 19:11with the state censorship, like all the rules
- 19:15or regulations. That means like they have to
- 19:18find a balance between like there are the absolute
- 19:23red line that you can't cross. I think you can
- 19:27find all these red lines from any research on
- 19:34Chinese censorship. What are the absolute taboos
- 19:38that you are not allowed to discuss on social
- 19:41media? Beyond this red line, there you can actually
- 19:47have sort of autonomy to decide how you are going
- 19:52to do your moderation. That means if you're a
- 19:58big platform, you will have more leverage to
- 20:03kind of negotiate with the state or to not regulate
- 20:08too much so that you won't push your users away.
- 20:20Was the moderation in Chinese social media different
- 20:24from their global platform? I think that's one
- 20:30big difference is that how relaxed your regulation
- 20:36or moderation is depends on the size of your
- 20:40platform. So it can actually become your leverage.
- 20:48And I'm not talking about a sock puppet account
- 20:51here where you probably wouldn't engage too much.
- 20:54But if, for example, you wanted to get your story
- 20:59out to Chinese audiences and you decided to publish
- 21:02on a Chinese platform, how would you know if
- 21:05your account is being restricted or shadow limited?
- 21:09Are there signs? And how do you maintain a normal
- 21:15looking account from outside China? Okay, so
- 21:20it depends. The platform that does the shadow
- 21:28ban, the most sneaky is Xiaohongshu. And they
- 21:35will shadow ban a lot of content for political
- 21:39content, or you simply can't publish any political
- 21:44content. without any permit or like state authorized
- 21:48permit. So they are really strict on political
- 21:52content. And you will know if you can see like
- 21:57the traffic. You can kind of sense based on the
- 22:01interaction or the traffic that shows on your
- 22:05phone. Oh no, like shows on your, on your post.
- 22:11So if you post something and then you realize,
- 22:14okay, it has zero views or very few views, that
- 22:18means like your shadow band or the traffic is
- 22:21restricted. So it's the same with Weibo, but
- 22:27in general, Weibo is more relaxed than Xiaohongshu.
- 22:31You can post many things, way more things on
- 22:37Weibo than Xiaohongshu. Also what I talk about,
- 22:41what I meant by leverage. So another thing I
- 22:46think is like, we chat, we chat, they have official
- 22:52accounts. So in general, I think like they are
- 22:56actually probably like the most, how can I say?
- 23:01They are probably like the most relaxed one.
- 23:03You can actually post more, more things there.
- 23:08But before you publish, for that one is, before
- 23:13you publish, they will give you a warning if
- 23:17something sensitive or censored words is included.
- 23:21And then you have to check yourself and revise
- 23:24to make it published. Once it's published, normally
- 23:28it should be fine. That means like it went through
- 23:34the test. it went through the test. Of course,
- 23:39it can be deleted later, but in general, you
- 23:44can post more things there than Xiaohongshu and
- 23:51probably even more than Weibo. That's really
- 23:55interesting. I'd love to revisit the conversation
- 23:59on verification on those platforms in a second.
- 24:01But I'm also conscious that we've got quite a
- 24:04few questions coming through. So I wanted to
- 24:06make sure that we answer those. Nick has mentioned,
- 24:10thank you for the great resources. You mentioned
- 24:13that Chinese authorities now view lying flat
- 24:18or Tangping as a foreign information operation.
- 24:21Are there reports verifying that these are targeted
- 24:23campaigns? Is there a way to kind of outline
- 24:27what are targeted campaigns on these social media
- 24:32sites. So we're talking about like the lying
- 24:35flat? No, no, they are definitely not targeted
- 24:40campaign. It's just they are trying to claim
- 24:43that way. This kind of links in with my question
- 24:48on verification, so perhaps I'll ask it now.
- 24:51For example, on Twitter, we used to have the
- 24:53blue tick. opportunity where you knew if someone
- 24:56was kind of verified on Twitter because of the
- 24:59blue tick, that's since kind of gone away. Now
- 25:02everyone can buy access to a blue tick. You mentioned
- 25:05that WeChat has official accounts. Do any of
- 25:09the popular Chinese social media platforms have
- 25:12this kind of verification feature in them so
- 25:15that you know whether you're talking to an official
- 25:18or whether you're viewing an official page? For
- 25:22example, do they have kind of verification features
- 25:25like that? For the WeChat official account, it's
- 25:32actually quite different from what we mean like
- 25:34a verified account. It's just a call that way.
- 25:38But it's just basically like a publishing platform
- 25:42that everyone can use. So even an individual
- 25:48can run an official account. But when you start,
- 25:54it's tied to your real name. It's your Chinese
- 25:57ID. And every ID can apply for open... find most
- 26:06accounts. At most. Yeah. So it's quite different
- 26:11from, it has nothing to do with like, it's not
- 26:21like a recognized reputation or anything like
- 26:24that. It just has its name. It's interesting
- 26:28that you can't separate the ID from the account
- 26:31though. Um, so you have businesses, I'm guessing
- 26:34on these platforms represented via someone's
- 26:38ID and employee's ID and et cetera like that
- 26:41on these platforms. Yeah, but yeah, yeah, that's
- 26:44true. But, but that also mean like if that account
- 26:47publish something like illegal or like a problematic
- 26:52and that people is like legally have to take
- 26:57the legal responsibility. Right. Interesting.
- 27:01Okay. Yeah, you'd have to be pretty confident
- 27:08in your workplace to kind of take on that kind
- 27:11of responsibility, hey? Carvin asks, any experiences
- 27:19of using different tools for scraping and analysing
- 27:23for Charonchou? Any recommended software, GitHub,
- 27:27for example? Um, have you had an experience scraping
- 27:30these social media sites? But I feel like there's
- 27:35any scraping tools for xiao hong shu is there.
- 27:37Um, like for, from my experience, like xiao hong
- 27:40shu, like they don't really have like that API
- 27:43open for like scraping. So any tools is actually
- 27:48not that, it can't like the scrape. Xiaohongshu
- 27:55can't be scraped like any other like Twitter
- 27:57what people do with Twitter like before people
- 28:01can do with Twitter before like basically you
- 28:05you scrape 10 or some posts and then it will
- 28:11cut off and you have to like kind of redo it
- 28:15basically like every 10 every 10 or 20 posts,
- 28:20you have to do it again. So it can never do anything
- 28:24like what people can do with Twitter. So it's
- 28:31a little bit more limited. Somebody said no way
- 28:34back machine for it. No, I don't think so. Unfortunately.
- 28:40Somebody else put in the chat, social media manager
- 28:42in China sounds like a risky job. Absolutely.
- 28:50Arcadia End has asked, thank you for the interesting
- 28:53talk. Is using China Digital Times the best way
- 28:56to track when articles have been deleted from
- 28:59WeChat accounts, et cetera, or is there a way
- 29:01to do it yourself? My interest area is quite
- 29:04niche and I feel China Digital Times is more
- 29:08focused on political economic topics. So is there
- 29:11a way to find out if articles have been deleted
- 29:15from WeChat accounts yourself? track when articles
- 29:22have been deleted through. But I think like that
- 29:27thing, the most thing, the main issue is like
- 29:31your judgment. You have to know which article
- 29:34might be deleted and then you can track. I think
- 29:38that's more like the political judgment. It's
- 29:41more important than actually the technical part.
- 29:46So for China Digital Times, I think China Digital
- 29:59Times, they do something like rescuing archiving.
- 30:05That means they would archive content that they
- 30:11think it might be deleted. but it might not,
- 30:17but there is a way, I think it has to be like
- 30:23what are you going to, because there are tons
- 30:27of articles, what articles are you going to,
- 30:29do you want to follow, or is there a specific
- 30:36content or topic that you actually want to follow?
- 30:41So I think that's the judgment to set your tracker,
- 30:47like what kind of things you want to track. Thanks
- 30:54for that. There's been quite a conversation in
- 30:58the chat about Chinese names and English names
- 31:02and then not translating. back -to -back. I wondered
- 31:05if we could dig a little bit deeper into, you
- 31:08mentioned that you'd recommend people searching
- 31:11in Chinese rather than searching in English or
- 31:15another language on these platforms. Do you have
- 31:19any tips for figuring out keyword searching given
- 31:25language nuances and censorship sensitivities?
- 31:29Are there tools, translation services or workflows?
- 31:31that you recommend for non -Chinese speakers
- 31:34when looking for these kind of keywords perhaps
- 31:38along trends or niche topics? I think actually
- 31:45China Digital Times, it's a great resource. Let
- 31:54me see if I can find it. I think they are a great...
- 31:58The resource, they have like everything. They
- 32:01also have a database, kind of like a kind of
- 32:03database with the least censored words list and
- 32:07also with explanation for why certain words is
- 32:12censored. Yeah, I think that's the best go -to
- 32:18resource to use. So don't rely on Google Translate.
- 32:24No, I think the good thing with China Digital
- 32:27Time is like they have an English version. Really
- 32:35useful. Someone's just put in the chat, there's
- 32:40a tracker for WeChat on greatfire .org for anybody
- 32:45who's looking for that. We've had a few other
- 32:49questions coming in. Someone asked earlier, would
- 32:53using a Chinese phone make tracking Chinese social
- 32:56media easier in some ways? Am I right in thinking
- 33:00that if you had a Chinese phone, you'd still
- 33:02need a Chinese ID, is that correct? Or would
- 33:05a mobile device be sufficient enough? Yeah, but
- 33:10the thing with Chinese phone is like you need
- 33:13a Chinese ID to get a Chinese phone number. So
- 33:20yes, of course, having a Chinese phone will make
- 33:23that easy, but then you will need someone or
- 33:28someone who has a Chinese ID to buy that phone
- 33:32number for you. That means that person will be
- 33:36responsible for everything. And as a follow -up,
- 33:40someone's asked, and I think you touched on this
- 33:42in the talk, but maybe we could just recap. For
- 33:46platforms that require a phone, is there a method
- 33:48for non -mainland people to access? So is there
- 33:53a method to access those platforms without making
- 33:57an account? There are ways, but I don't think
- 34:02we should probably discuss it. Not open source
- 34:10ways. Not open source ways. Yes. Take that to
- 34:18direct message. Yes, exactly. Thanks guys for
- 34:22the comments there. We've had a few other questions
- 34:26about, would your previous content on other platforms
- 34:30be an issue? For example, Not Going to Look said,
- 34:34would your ex content be an issue? I speak amongst
- 34:37some interesting people. I also witnessed as
- 34:39Romani means I may or may not have spoken of
- 34:43political arcs, though I only have ever mentioned
- 34:45Chinese state once. Would your behaviour on other
- 34:52platforms impact your ability to register on
- 34:56these? No, no. As long as you don't public talk
- 35:01too much about China, it's fine. And then someone
- 35:04else has asked on the censorship issue, how much
- 35:07censorship is done by the platforms versus how
- 35:09much is done by the CAC? Does the CAC have staff
- 35:12that work in the platform? So do they just provide
- 35:14guidance to platforms on what to censor? Where
- 35:17are the censorship lines? So for the censorship
- 35:21line, I like during my, I think like in a previous
- 35:25answers, I have mentioned that CAC, they set
- 35:31up their red line. And that red line is evolving
- 35:35over time. That means there are the absolute
- 35:40taboo that you are now allowed to discuss on
- 35:44social media. For example, Xi Jinping or all
- 35:48kinds of his nicknames. are becoming the expanding
- 35:56database of the red line. So they are the one
- 36:00who set up those red lines. And beyond that red
- 36:09lines, the platform, they have their own autonomy
- 36:13to decide how much or how relaxed or how tight
- 36:16they want the censorship. In general, Weibo based
- 36:25on beyond the guidance provided by CAC, they
- 36:29have more autonomy to decide what to keep. So
- 36:38you can actually see quite a lot of resistance
- 36:41or like rebel statements on Weibo. But there
- 36:48is another platform, it's called Douban. So it's
- 36:53like Chinese version of good rate. Usually people
- 36:58use that for reviewing books and movies. And
- 37:04people also use that as a social platform to
- 37:08share opinions. So for that one, they probably
- 37:12have the tightest control or even more than the
- 37:24CAC guidance. Because it's a small platform and
- 37:33their users are more smarter in... in expressing
- 37:39their political view or their resistance. So
- 37:45they have more rules there, so it's tighter.
- 37:51And also because it's a smaller platform, so
- 37:54they don't really have that many leverage. So
- 37:58they want to, for their own survival reason,
- 38:03they want to keep the censorship tighter. In
- 38:10regards to finding ways that people are speaking
- 38:15about potentially taboo subjects on these platforms,
- 38:22somebody's put, I've seen in the past that Chinese
- 38:24users will use homonyms of censored words. Is
- 38:27this still a tactic being used to evade the censors?
- 38:30And somebody else earlier asked if there was
- 38:33any resources for finding ways that people were
- 38:38like terms that people were using to discuss
- 38:42more taboo subjects. Is there resources like
- 38:46that available? Yeah, that's still a tactic.
- 38:50And you can also find those kind of like the
- 38:53database of the this kind of word list on China
- 38:56digital times. They have like a system, they
- 38:59systematically like document all of this, all
- 39:04of this words. and also for not just censor wars
- 39:10but like a new phenomenon it's probably I'm not
- 39:13sure how many of you have followed China's politics
- 39:16but like the nickname of Xi Jinping because every
- 39:21people can't talk about his name and most people
- 39:24probably the thing most people know probably
- 39:27like Winnie the Pooh but after that Because all
- 39:32the things related to him is so heavily censored.
- 39:37So people just keep coming up with new ways to
- 39:40name him. So that itself is an expanding database.
- 39:50That's great. Thank you. Questions keep coming
- 39:53in. We've got about 15 minutes. So please do
- 39:58pop your final... Final questions in for the
- 40:02last 15 minutes. I wanted to ask how much impact
- 40:07has AI had on how Chinese audiences converse
- 40:11online? Obviously we're seeing a huge impact
- 40:14of how it's impacting more Western facing. social
- 40:20media platforms with Trump, for example, consistently
- 40:24publishing AI imagery and also being part of
- 40:30daily use. I mean, X has its own and Meta both
- 40:34have their own AI generation chatbots now. How
- 40:39much impact has AI had on how Chinese audiences
- 40:42converse online and the platforms themselves?
- 40:45Do they have any AI chatbots embedded or anything
- 40:48like that? Yeah, I think like every, even Xiaohongshu
- 40:52had the embedded AI search engine. And I think
- 40:59like one of the interesting thing with AI is
- 41:03actually how, because Cloudy, it's not accessible
- 41:10in mainland China. So that's a I think like that's
- 41:16an interesting phenomenon that you can see people
- 41:18how people discuss like how you can invade that
- 41:21kind of a geoblock How to get a Gmail like how
- 41:26to actually use the real AI a lot of people I'm
- 41:32sure I can see a lot of the discussions how people
- 41:34want to Because like for them, this is also some
- 41:38the reverse censorship in a way for them So I
- 41:43can see a lot of discussion about how they can
- 41:46actually got access, how to avoid being disabled,
- 41:53disbanded by Claudia. So that's the discussion
- 41:58I've seen. For the domestic AI models, I think
- 42:06like most people use it for fun. People won't
- 42:16use it for research, but mainly use it for silly
- 42:21reactions about ordering their delivery food,
- 42:26how to best order delivery food, and how to dress,
- 42:32how to decide their dress code or outfit. daily
- 42:36outfit. I think that's what I have seen most.
- 42:40For research purposes, people want to use a Cloudy
- 42:43or Gemini, but the geoblock is an issue for them.
- 42:50Are you also seeing AI being used for misinformation
- 42:55on the platform as well? Do you often see misinformation
- 43:00and disinformation being shared on Chinese platforms
- 43:03as commonly as we see on more globalized social
- 43:08media platforms. Obviously it's a huge issue
- 43:12over here. I'm wondering if there's similar issues
- 43:16on being able to assess credibility on these
- 43:20platforms as we talked about earlier with the
- 43:24difficulty with verification as well. Yeah, but
- 43:29I think the thing with AI usage within China,
- 43:34the thing is like a lot of people, I think they
- 43:37still even don't realize how sensitive the content
- 43:42in Chinese are. So a lot of them won't actually
- 43:48realize the content they see on the AI. It's
- 43:54actually biased or like it can even be like disinformation.
- 43:58So I think that's the one thing to work on is
- 44:01the media literacy, which is really bad in so
- 44:06many ways in China. So I think the problem is
- 44:11a lot of people don't realize or haven't realized.
- 44:16But people have this sense, you can't trust the
- 44:19AI on everything. Well, I'm glad to hear that.
- 44:24We've got one question on Chinese corporate aggregators.
- 44:27It seems like the last of the Chinese corporate
- 44:29aggregators have been blocked outside of mainland
- 44:32China in the past month or so. Are any other
- 44:35recommendations or workarounds for those? Do
- 44:38you have any familiarity with the corporate aggregators?
- 44:42Yes. So the recommendation for that one, you
- 44:48actually have to use the VPN to the tour to China
- 44:54to the Chinese IP and then you can have the access
- 44:58from there. But then the problem is like you
- 45:02also you need a phone number, a Chinese phone
- 45:05number to actually access those aggregators.
- 45:12That's the main issue than just the VPN. Yeah,
- 45:17but I want just say the name of the VPN, but
- 45:22you need a VPN to, to a Chinese Ikey. And then
- 45:27you can, it can work. Thanks for that tip. VPNs
- 45:31are needed more and more. Even in the UK, I can't
- 45:36read blue sky DMs without a VPN on at the moment.
- 45:42So, yes, it's a thing. Going back to the censorship
- 45:46question, we've just had one come in. How does
- 45:48the CAC and platform moderation affect Hong Kong
- 45:51users? Are the platforms the same in Hong Kong
- 45:53as mainland China now? So the thing is like,
- 45:58it's not about like the location of the user,
- 46:02more the platform of the user. The problem is
- 46:07not location of the users, but the platform itself.
- 46:10So even the Hong Kong users, if they are subject
- 46:16to the CAC regulation, if they're on Weibo or
- 46:19like Douyin, or maybe if they use TikTok, it
- 46:23can be better. But if they use all the others,
- 46:27Weibo, Xiaohongshu, which a lot of people are
- 46:30using. So they will definitely subject to the
- 46:36CAC moderation. So it has nothing to do with
- 46:40the location. We're all like mainland or Hong
- 46:42Kong. It's more about the platform itself, where
- 46:45the platform is located. And is that the same
- 46:49for if you never use Chinese language on the
- 46:54account? So if you've, for example, as you were
- 46:56saying on Red Note, if you've kind of logged
- 47:00in with an English language setting, you're still
- 47:06being censored in the same way. So for example,
- 47:09if you try to post on a word that's censored,
- 47:13you'd still be censored despite it being in English,
- 47:16correct? Yeah. I'm really sorry if I pronounce
- 47:23this incorrectly, but for Wisin and WeChat, there
- 47:28is a difference between user agreements, right?
- 47:30Is that similar for any of the other platforms?
- 47:35So for the Wisin and WeChat, it's like one is
- 47:40for the user within China, the other is like
- 47:42users outside of China. The user agreements,
- 47:46whatever they say in the agreements, it's...
- 47:50The main difference is where the data is stored,
- 47:55like where they store their data. So that's the
- 48:00main difference. And WeChat is the same and Xiaohongshu
- 48:09is still the same. Even they have the international
- 48:12split so far, it's still like having the same
- 48:16data. have the data saved at the same place.
- 48:22For the different ways, Douyin and TikTok, it's
- 48:29different. So they store their user data at different
- 48:39places. So I think there are two approaches.
- 48:43So one is to store data at separate places or
- 48:48still use the same one. So far, we still can't
- 48:52see because it's still early stage to say where
- 48:57they're heading to. But so far, it's still the
- 49:00same. We don't encourage quick turnaround stories
- 49:09at Bellingcat. We're very much a long -form kind
- 49:12of platform. But let's just say, for example,
- 49:16you're working at a more breaking news newsroom
- 49:19and you need to find out quickly. what the Chinese
- 49:25audiences are saying on a particular political
- 49:27issue. What would be your advice to someone who's
- 49:31coming in really fresh and needs a quick answer
- 49:37to how Chinese audiences are reacting to a particular
- 49:39political issue quickly? What would be your step
- 49:42-by -step guidance on that if you're looking
- 49:45for breaking responses on Chinese social media?
- 49:52Breaking responses. I think the first place I
- 50:01would choose would be Weibo. That's where, like
- 50:06I mentioned during the presentation, that's the
- 50:10de facto public square. So you can see a lot
- 50:13of other breaking responses or breaking news
- 50:16are discussed there. That's all the discussion
- 50:19is happening. So just go there and see what people
- 50:24are discussing or especially look at the comment
- 50:28section. I think comment section is a goldmine
- 50:32where you can actually see what the normal people
- 50:35might respond or what they actually think. This
- 50:39is actually one takeaway. I have done like China
- 50:45studies for many years. Um, so I think like this
- 50:48is, uh, uh, this is the thing. It's like when
- 50:51people see the breaking news or breaking response,
- 50:55they first think like, Oh, China said blah, blah,
- 50:58blah. Or like China invading Taiwan or something.
- 51:03Um, or like, uh, all, all the Chinese people
- 51:07are supporting the government, either supporting
- 51:09the government or, um, um, being there. dissident,
- 51:15but it's actually quite a nuance, way more nuanced
- 51:19than that. And a lot of it like in between. So
- 51:23even people, maybe they don't dislike the government,
- 51:27but they also have their own dissatisfaction.
- 51:30So I think like the common section is where you
- 51:33can actually find this kind of nuances where
- 51:35what actually the actual people. are thinking
- 51:38or what the actual people are saying. So I think
- 51:43that's the thing often absent from reporting.
- 51:51Thanks for that guidance. It's really good to
- 51:54know. Someone's put in the chat, comment section
- 51:56is a goldmine is so, so true. So definitely check
- 52:01those out. We had a comment earlier that was
- 52:04asking for a follow -up on the corporate aggregators,
- 52:06whether having a Taiwanese phone number helps
- 52:08access them. And somebody in the chat has suggested
- 52:14they're all Chinese only, I'm afraid, or VPN.
- 52:21So that's your solution there. Yeah, thanks so
- 52:26much guys for your comments. We have five more
- 52:30minutes, so if you have a final question, please
- 52:32do put it in the chat. You mentioned loads of
- 52:37resources in regards to training the algorithm
- 52:44towards your research interests. For example,
- 52:47if you make a sockpuppet account, an account
- 52:50where you are trying to focus on one specific
- 52:55topic. What's the best way to kind of train that
- 52:58on the different social media accounts that you've
- 53:02mentioned? Xiaohongshu I'm guessing is more of
- 53:06a continuously searching the keywords and liking
- 53:09content like that. Do you need to comment on
- 53:13items for it to be fed to you on some of these?
- 53:16How do the algorithms work in regards to trying
- 53:19to tailor your feed into the topic area that
- 53:22you're trying to research? So I think for Weibo,
- 53:29that's two of the platforms people use the most.
- 53:34And I think Weibo is quite simple. You just follow
- 53:38other opinion leaders or influencers. You follow
- 53:43them and they will repost some... they will repost
- 53:48when some viral event happens. And then you will
- 53:54see that's a way, you can use that one as a starting
- 53:59point, entry point. And then you can find more.
- 54:04So basically you want to... let the algorithm
- 54:07know what kind of people you want to follow and
- 54:10it will give you a recommendation. I recently
- 54:13tried. It's actually quite accurate. So if you
- 54:19follow some liberal bloggers with liberal views,
- 54:27and if you follow one, it will recommend you
- 54:29several more. It's actually quite accurate. And
- 54:34then if you want to follow the nationalist side
- 54:39of their block, how they respond to official
- 54:45framing, or how they amplify the state voices,
- 54:49you can actually follow, I think like in... previous
- 54:53reports, people have already identified the networks
- 54:56of those kind of national list of bloggers. So
- 55:00it's actually very easy to find one and then
- 55:04you can very easily to identify the network.
- 55:09I can try to find that one, the article, but
- 55:13it was back then it's basically a network of
- 55:16amplified state points. So basically I think
- 55:22the the whole point is what kind of you want
- 55:26to write or like if you work as a researcher
- 55:28or like a journalist what's your beat or what's
- 55:32your focus or like what's your topic and I think
- 55:34after that you will figure out who or what to
- 55:38follow and for xiao hong shu I think it's quite
- 55:40easy you just search and search the topic then
- 55:48you have to be creative What are the things in
- 56:03between the whole workflow? How you can cut the
- 56:08workflow into different pieces that you can actually
- 56:11try to match your keywords, search word or keywords.
- 56:16with the process. It's the same with doing an
- 56:20open source investigation or it's like you have
- 56:23to be creative. You have to understand like how
- 56:25things work and where you can actually find the
- 56:30thing to cut in. It's going to put your problem
- 56:33solving skills to the test. Well, unfortunately
- 56:37we're coming to time, but if people want to feed
- 56:39back or if they just have follow -up questions,
- 56:43where can they get in contact with you? They
- 56:48can contact me. I have a LinkedIn. I think that's
- 56:51probably the best way to reach you. Oh, no, sorry.
- 57:03It's okay. I can probably add it in. And again,
- 57:08please do take some time to have a look at her
- 57:12fabulous guide into red notes. really worth looking
- 57:17at and learning from. There's some really useful
- 57:21tips in there that everybody hopefully can learn
- 57:26from. And if you're interested in talking about
- 57:29this subject further, by all means, we have spaces
- 57:33within the stage talk. Ah, you found your LinkedIn.
- 57:36I was just posting it here. Thanks for that.
- 57:38We have a space to talk about the tools and sites
- 57:42where you can post useful things. You can also
- 57:46use InfoSec to talk about digital security. Central
- 57:52Asia, a space where we talk a lot about Chinese
- 57:56news as well. So please do use those spaces in
- 57:59the Discord as well to dig further into this.
- 58:01But for now, thank you everybody for listening
- 58:03and thank you two for coming in to talk to us.
- 58:07We'll be back in two weeks time with another
- 58:08stage talk. But for now guys, happy reading the
- 58:11guide and good luck with your little puzzle.
- 58:15All right, thank you so much all. Thank you for
- 58:19listening to the stage talk. If you'd like to
- 58:21catch a stage tour live where you can ask the
- 58:24guest questions, join the Bellingcat Discord
- 58:27server by visiting www .discord .gg slash Bellingcat.
- 58:34The music you've heard is titled Dawn by Newer
- 58:37Self and is courtesy of Artlist.