Latest / First Trust ROI Podcast / Ep 81 | Bob Stein | Will Populist Politics Upend the 2026 Midterms…and the Economy? | ROI Podcast
Transcript
- 0:08Ryan: As we head into the midterm elections, populist rhetoric surrounding data centers is rising.
- 0:14Ryan: The Trump administration is offering $5,000 checks if the Republicans can maintain both houses of Congress.
- 0:21Ryan: And what will happen with the Social Security Trust Fund in the next few years?
- 0:25Ryan: Joining me to answer these questions and more is Bob Stein, Deputy Chief Economist at First Trust.
- 0:31Ryan: Thanks for joining us on this episode of the First Trust ROI Podcast.
- 0:35Ryan: So I'm not sure how many times you've been on the podcast now, but uh I know we we counted up last time, and uh I think we're getting we're running out of digits on our hands.
- 0:47Bob: Yeah, anytime you are willing to put me on, I want to be on Ryan.
- 0:53Ryan: Okay, so we do have a lot to talk about.
- 0:55Ryan: We've got an upcoming election, we've got um sort of the rise of populism and populist rhetoric heading into that election.
- 1:02Ryan: We've got uh a lot happening with the economy, and I want to dissect some of these things, but let's start off with election day.
- 1:11Ryan: We're heading into it.
- 1:12Ryan: Um when I when I say populist rhetoric, one of the things that comes to mind for me is that I've noticed over the last couple months there's been a lot more people that have come out against data centers in particular.
- 1:26Ryan: And my theory on that is because you know it's one of these issues that no one really knows what a data center is in the in the you know the normal public.
- 1:36Bob: And the hostility really has been bipartisan.
- 1:38Ryan: It's been very bipartisan.
- 1:41Ryan: Everyone just knows that they hate them because they're afraid that their water bills or uh or their water supply is gonna get fouled and their electricity bills are gonna go up.
- 1:50Ryan: And it seems like both sides have have said, you know, we're gonna put moratoriums like Governor Abbott in in Texas has put a pause on.
- 2:00Ryan: Um Governor Hokel in New York has said moratorium.
- 2:04Ryan: Shapiro, I think, did something similar in Pennsylvania.
- 2:07Ryan: And so um I I guess my question for you is is my take that this is at least somewhat political heading into the midterms.
- 2:17Ryan: Is that do you agree with that?
- 2:19Bob: I think it's very political, Ryan.
- 2:21Bob: I completely agree with that.
- 2:24Bob: Hopefully, what I'm certainly hoping for is that cooler and more rational heads prevail after the midterm cycle is done and get on with uh licensing and permitting and allowing for more data center construction.
- 2:42Bob: Data centers, AI, the intellectual property related to those items have been a leading source of economic growth over the past couple of years.
- 2:54Bob: They will continue to contribute heavily.
- 2:56Bob: They have knock-on effects in terms of uh water facilities being constructed.
- 3:02Bob: They create an incentive for more construction of power plants of various kinds.
- 3:08Bob: We need that.
- 3:09Bob: Some people are claiming it's gonna drive up energy costs and water costs.
- 3:13Bob: Well, that that's a market signal that we need more reservoirs, we need more uh perhaps uh uh closed loop systems at data centers to conserve on water, and we need more energy production in the United States.
- 3:29Bob: Ultimately, however, this is not just about our economy, it's about national security because every time we slow the construction of data centers, and slow because of that, perhaps the rollout of more intensive use of AI over time, um, we're doing it while China is not.
- 3:48Bob: And 10 or 20 or more years from now, we may be in a geopolitical conflict with rivals or enemies who have not limited themselves, where that nature of part of the conflict will be the release of AI bots designed to undermine the infrastructure of the opposition country.
- 4:11Bob: And so I uh or to defend against the AI bots that the other country has released.
- 4:17Bob: I want to be at the cutting edge of that.
- 4:19Bob: And yeah, I know that that many people have to pay more in temporarily at least in until the economy adapts to it, in water bills or energy costs.
- 4:29Bob: Um, but that's the price we pay for maintaining our civilization and our national security over the next generation.
- 4:37Bob: It will also contribute to economic growth.
- 4:39Bob: There are a heck of a lot of jobs are being created.
- 4:41Bob: Remember how a year ago a lot of people were talking about how AI is gonna replace all these jobs?
- 4:47Bob: Well, if anything, we've had more intensive use over of AI over the past 12 months, and job growth has picked back up.
- 4:54Bob: Um, I think in the end, AI is not a substitute for some jobs, but it's also a complement for many others, as I think we've discussed in the past.
- 5:03Bob: And it's gonna be a net job creator, not a net job destroyer.
- 5:08Ryan: Yeah.
- 5:08Ryan: What's your so that's the physical layer of AI, right?
- 5:12Ryan: What do you what's your take on some of the advanced frontier model companies that are also coming out with sort of a doomer take where um I'm not gonna ask you to maybe opine on the technical aspects of it, but there's there's fears that um you know somehow it it's gonna end civilization.
- 5:32Ryan: And if you don't have um heightened regulation, and I I think Anthropic recently put out uh a piece where they said we have to uh and maybe Gemini uh did as well, where they want kind of like a self-regulatory organization, like a FINRA um for the technology sector.
- 5:49Ryan: Um is this uh maybe um maybe this isn't a fair question because you're not a technology uh, you know, can I give you a lot of is this just regulatory capture?
- 5:58Ryan: I guess is my my question.
- 5:59Bob: Um to some extent, yes, Ryan.
- 6:01Bob: Yeah, I I don't think it's any I don't think it's odd or bizarre given what we know about how um uh of human nature that some of the leading companies in AI and the development of AI uh are now calling for regulation, which uh whether it's uh uh within industry or imposed by the government, which would slow the process of developing uh competitors to their market position.
- 6:30Bob: Um I think a lot of this doom and gloom um has to do with those companies scaring the public into supporting regulations to entrench their current lead in an industry that they may not lead in five years from now or even two years from now if it is not regulated.
- 6:50Ryan: Yeah.
- 6:51Ryan: And that's that's not without precedent in in history.
- 6:55Ryan: In fact, that's usually what happens.
- 6:57Ryan: It doesn't matter if it's even even like the energy sector, if you look back historically, energy sector tends to be regulated by people that know energy.
- 7:04Bob: And they do it in various ways.
- 7:05Bob: I mean, you had manufacturers in the United States in the late 19th century who loved high tariff walls, in part because it it warded off competition from abroad, from put some potentially lower cost producers.
- 7:18Bob: So it takes many different forms.
- 7:20Bob: It's like labor unions that used to be much more aggressively anti-immigration.
- 7:26Bob: If you went back a hundred years, why?
- 7:28Bob: Because they didn't want cheap labor undermining their market position.
- 7:31Bob: Every organization wants to entrench itself uh to the detriment of those that might compete against them in the future.
- 7:38Bob: Just human nature.
- 7:40Ryan: Okay, so uh there was a recent Supreme Court decision that um uh as I understand it, um basically will disallow what the Trump administration had sought to put in place regarding uh mail-in uh ballots for the midterm elections.
- 7:58Ryan: And it seems like that is not going to be allowed.
- 8:00Ryan: So I I want to shift and talk a little bit about your expectations for the midterms.
- 8:05Ryan: Um so my first question regarded related to that is will that impact the outcome of the election?
- 8:12Bob: It will impact it, but not enough to change any the results in any significant way, as far as I can see.
- 8:19Bob: Okay.
- 8:19Bob: So the the Republicans' biggest problem in this cycle, at least in terms of the House of Representatives, is that as of this morning, they were behind in the real clear politics polling average by 8.2 percentage points.
- 8:31Bob: Okay, they won the national house vote in 2024 by 2.7 percentage points.
- 8:38Bob: So they're doing um, let's say 8.2, 2.7, they're doing 10.9 percentage points worse.
- 8:44Bob: Let's round it to 11.
- 8:46Bob: My rule of thumb is every percentage point costs you about three seats.
- 8:50Bob: Um if not for redistricting, they would probably be in the vicinity of like 190 seats as the outcome of this cycle if the polls stay where they are.
- 9:01Bob: Now they have gotten some benefit on net from redistricting.
- 9:04Bob: They'll get more benefit between net between 2026 this year and 2028, and so much benefit that they may actually take back the House, even if they don't win the presidency in 2028.
- 9:15Bob: That's not a lock, but um that's a distinct possibility.
- 9:19Bob: But in this particular cycle, you know, I think they're gonna end up somewhere in the vicinity of 200 seats in the House of Representatives.
- 9:26Bob: Their biggest problem by far um is not the Supreme Court striking down this mail-in ballot measure, um, which would have helped them a little bit at the margin, maybe a few seats, um, unnet, but it's really um that they're doing so poorly in the polls on a national level, uh mail-in, not mail-in, regardless.
- 9:46Bob: Um uh so that's uh so will it affect it?
- 9:50Bob: Yes, it's not gonna be enough to make a difference in terms of the House of Representatives.
- 9:54Ryan: So one of the issues I think that um has probably doesn't have much support with the public um has been the outbreak of the the war in Iran.
- 10:04Ryan: And I think the Trump administration seemed to think that that was gonna be over relatively quickly.
- 10:09Ryan: Um, and now it seems like it's it's probably not going to be over by election day.
- 10:14Ryan: But if it were to be over by election day, is it already too late or could that actually give them a lot of people?
- 10:18Bob: No, if it were over by election day in a favorable way, I think that would be a big feather on the cap of the Trump administration or Republicans generally.
- 10:25Bob: I don't anticipate that.
- 10:27Bob: I don't think there's going to be a popular uprising in Iran to overthrow uh the Islamic Republic.
- 10:33Bob: I think that's incredibly unlikely, not just this year, um, but next year or the year after.
- 10:38Bob: What I do think is possible, but it's going to take a uh um uh a consistent effort over the next few years, is some sort of internal coup.
- 10:50Bob: Um I think uh the uh IRGC um in uh Iran, which is essentially running the shows in replacement of the molos right now.
- 11:00Bob: Um the IRGC has people who are true believers.
- 11:04Bob: The IRGC also, remember, this is 48 years after the Islamic Revolution.
- 11:09Bob: Okay.
- 11:10Bob: They also have a lot of people who have been pretending to be true believers.
- 11:14Bob: Think about where the Soviet Union was 48 years after the Bolshevik Revolution, it's 1965.
- 11:20Bob: There are not a lot of true believers left in 1964, real true communists who wanted to create heaven on earth or whatever.
- 11:28Bob: Okay, um, those guys had all died off, um, even to the extent they believe it in the first place, or killed each other off, okay?
- 11:36Bob: So um I think you have a lot of people who are pretending to be true believers in the IRGC.
- 11:42Bob: They've been doing it because it's beneficial for their careers.
- 11:45Bob: They're smart people, they understand the benefit of the prevailing orthodoxy in Iran, they understand um uh uh how to uh how to uh uh what that prevailing orthodoxy is, again, the benefit of it, and they understand also how to rationalize it to themselves.
- 12:05Bob: The smarter you are, the easier it is to rationalize your own belief in a kakamami idea.
- 12:13Bob: Okay?
- 12:13Bob: And so and so there are, I think, in in like in every dictatorship um or authoritarian regime, um, non-true believers who claim to be true believers.
- 12:25Bob: Um, if we squeeze our economy enough over time, I think they can gain the upper hand internally and take out the real true believers, the non-pretenders.
- 12:35Bob: And I don't know how many of them are or their balance of power, but sometime over the next few years that could happen.
- 12:40Bob: If it happens, if you can turn Iran into a version of Egypt, if you will, authoritarian, but not unfriendly to the West, that would be a major accomplishment by the Trump administration.
- 12:54Bob: Um gotta remember, a lot of people don't know this.
- 12:57Bob: Um we lost about 50,000 people, Americans, in Vietnam.
- 13:04Bob: Okay, sometimes you mention that to somebody just in passing, they're like, what are you talking about?
- 13:08Bob: 50,000.
- 13:09Bob: No way, we didn't lose 50,000.
- 13:10Bob: Then they look it up.
- 13:11Bob: Yeah, 50,000.
- 13:12Bob: Okay, that's like a dozen people a day for 10 years.
- 13:18Bob: A dozen people a day for 10 years.
- 13:21Bob: Okay.
- 13:21Bob: Um if you look back at uh how many we lost in Iraq and Afghanistan combined after 9-11, I think that's a few thousand plus.
- 13:31Bob: Okay.
- 13:32Bob: Um in Desert Storm and Desert Shield.
- 13:37Bob: Desert Shield was leading up to Desert Storm, okay, back in 1990-91.
- 13:45Bob: We lost about 350 to 400 people.
- 13:47Bob: Okay, and that was considered a great success.
- 13:50Bob: We didn't even dislodge Saddam Hussein in 1991.
- 13:53Bob: We we kind of let him stay in power.
- 13:56Bob: All we did was get Iraq out of Kuwait.
- 13:58Bob: That's what that's what our accomplishment was.
- 14:01Bob: We lost 350 to 400 people.
- 14:03Bob: So far, this conflict with Iran where we have taken out the Mullah leadership in Iran almost completely.
- 14:09Bob: We've lost 18 people.
- 14:11Bob: And we have starved their economy and put them in a position where it's going to be touch and go for them for the next couple of years.
- 14:20Bob: 18 people.
- 14:20Bob: Now, every every death is a tragedy.
- 14:23Bob: Every single one, including these 18.
- 14:26Bob: But when you put it in perspective compared to Vietnam, compared to the supposedly very successful Desert Shield and Desert Storm with 350 to 400, with Iraq and Afghanistan under Bush, Obama, and Biden, 18 people without active shooting day after day and casualties day after day, we've accomplished a lot considering the loss to the United States so far relative to these other conflicts.
- 14:53Bob: So I I don't see um Iran as unsuccessful so far.
- 14:59Bob: I see it as a big question mark.
- 15:01Bob: If two years from now, with a total of 50 American deaths, again, the additional 32 would be a tragedy, okay?
- 15:09Bob: Every single one.
- 15:11Bob: But if we can permanently shift Iran to being um no longer anti-West, that would be a major geopolitical accomplishment.
- 15:22Bob: And I don't think at this point we can say that's not going to happen.
- 15:26Ryan: I wonder what that would mean if if that's if that timeline is correct, what would that mean for energy prices and inflation over the next couple of years?
- 15:36Bob: Uh it if it happens, and I'm not saying there's no guarantee it will.
- 15:40Bob: Sure.
- 15:40Ryan: We're we're hypothesizing, right?
- 15:43Bob: If it does, I mean oil I think goes back down to $60 to $65 a barrel.
- 15:48Ryan: Yeah.
- 15:48Ryan: Um and at the end.
- 15:50Ryan: But in the intern, it will be in the intern, it will remain higher.
- 15:53Ryan: Yeah.
- 15:53Bob: But I think our economy has to a gr to a significant extent adapted.
- 15:59Bob: There's still more adaptation that needs to occur because consumers have run down their saving rate to pay for the higher energy costs over the last uh six to nine months.
- 16:09Bob: Sure.
- 16:10Bob: Okay.
- 16:10Bob: And eventually they're going to have to reassert a higher level of savings, and that potentially could slow the economy over the next couple of years.
- 16:16Bob: Not necessarily lead to a recession by itself, but be one of several things that if they occur, if they occurred in combination, could lead to a recession.
- 16:26Bob: So we haven't fully adapted.
- 16:28Bob: But if we can get $60 to $65 a barrel of oil, and frankly, the economy, the overall real pace of real GDP growth since we attacked Iran has been okay.
- 16:41Bob: Not gangbusters.
- 16:43Bob: Okay.
- 16:43Bob: We're growing at a rate, my estimate, is around 3.5% annual rate for the third quarter.
- 16:49Bob: We grew 1.5% for the second quarter.
- 16:51Bob: We grew about 2% for the first quarter.
- 16:53Bob: That's not really different from what was happening before we attacked Iran.
- 16:57Bob: So if you want to show, like, you know, uh a pain for top-line growth in the US, it's it simply isn't there yet.
- 17:06Ryan: Um okay, so I have all sorts of follow-up questions swirling about in my mind, but since we're we we talked a little bit about in inflation, um, one of the byproducts of inflation, I think, has been um you know people struggling with affordability.
- 17:24Ryan: And that's definitely been a narrative that's been uh talked about quite a bit.
- 17:28Ryan: And as a result of that, you've seen some of the more um not only populist, but even some of the democratic socialist candidates uh ending up getting elected, um, like you know, the the mayor of New York City, um government or governor, mayor uh Zoran Mamdani.
- 17:45Ryan: Um and you've got you know the popularity of AOC getting better and better.
- 17:52Ryan: Um so as we head into the midterms and as we look forward to the elections in 2028, what are the implications of that?
- 18:00Ryan: Is this is this gonna continue to see the surge of uh even like socialist candidates?
- 18:06Bob: Um I think we are.
- 18:07Bob: Um the DSA, the Democratic Socialist of America, um they are very careful with not running multiple candidates, generally speaking, in each of these races.
- 18:19Bob: So you'll have multiple normal Democrats, but then one DSA person.
- 18:23Bob: Um and primaries generally have lower turnout.
- 18:27Bob: And so they're not um so when you have a situation where not a lot of the opposite party votes in your primaries, or it's not completely open, like California does a joint primary essentially, where both parties do the primary together and it's the top two candidates.
- 18:41Bob: Okay.
- 18:42Bob: So when you don't have that situation, um they can, as a significant minority of the Democratic Party in each state, if they all turn out or almost all turn out, they can nominate that candidate.
- 18:56Bob: And then because of within party loyalty, get other Democrats to vote for that candidate and have a shot of wedding.
- 19:04Bob: So here's the basic problem.
- 19:06Bob: Okay, three generations ago, two generations ago, one generation ago, even, um uh you had parties like the Communist Party USA, Communist Workers' Party, Revolutionary Communist Party, Workers of the World Party, Socialist Workers' Party.
- 19:23Bob: I give you there's a whole laundry list of these parties.
- 19:26Bob: Some of the people who are in the DASA are really legitimate democratic socialists.
- 19:32Bob: I'm not saying that's good or bad.
- 19:33Bob: That's just what they are.
- 19:34Bob: They truly believe in um in American democracy and just prefer to use that democracy, prefer that the candidates who win are those who want the government to play a much bigger role than it already does in the U.S.
- 19:50Bob: economy, including the ownership of some means of production.
- 19:54Ryan: Okay, so uh taking this back to the upcoming election, you you uh said uh more or less, I don't think you put any specific numbers on it, but you think that in the House the Democrats are like likely to take a majority.
- 20:09Ryan: Uh I don't think you said uh your outlook for the Senate, but um I I guess two-part question: what is your outlook for the Senate?
- 20:17Ryan: But then what are the implications of maybe a further left-leaning Democratic majority in the House?
- 20:26Ryan: Uh what are the implications for the economy as we think about the next few years?
- 20:30Bob: Okay, so what I think is gonna happen in the U.S.
- 20:32Bob: Senate is that the Republicans narrowly retain control.
- 20:35Bob: Okay.
- 20:35Bob: Now I have to tell you, um, if you look at my House forecast, I am more pessimistic for the Republicans than the market consensus.
- 20:47Bob: And by market I mean polymarket and culchia, at least last time I checked.
- 20:51Bob: Um oddly, I am a little more optimistic for the Republicans than the prediction market suggest for the U.S.
- 20:58Bob: Senate.
- 20:59Bob: I think the Republicans probably end up with 51 seats in the U.S.
- 21:02Bob: Senate.
- 21:02Bob: Right now they have 53, so that's a net loss of two.
- 21:05Bob: So how how's it going to play out?
- 21:07Bob: Well, the vast majority of seats that the Republicans have to defend in this in this particular cycle are in red Republican states.
- 21:16Bob: Now, there are still probably three, maybe four, where they are vulnerable.
- 21:21Bob: So those would be Alaska, Texas, Ohio, just maybe Iowa.
- 21:27Bob: But my best guess, looking at the pattern from previous cycles, including wave elections, is that the Democrats will probably only pick up one seat, just one out of those four.
- 21:41Bob: Um, possibly more.
- 21:42Bob: I wouldn't be utterly shocked if it's two instead of one, but I think it'll just be one.
- 21:46Bob: I can't tell you which in advance.
- 21:48Bob: There's you know, there's seven weeks to go, Ryan.
- 21:50Bob: So um, but my best guess is the Republicans will only lose one seat.
- 21:54Bob: I also think they're almost certainly going to lose North Carolina.
- 21:57Bob: Tom Tillis, the incumbent Republican.
- 21:59Bob: Saw the writing on the wall, didn't even stand for re-election.
- 22:03Bob: Democrats were able to nominate Roy Cooper, the former governor, two-term, generally pretty popular, for that Senate seat.
- 22:13Bob: And so Roy Cooper is almost certainly going to win that race.
- 22:16Bob: The big question marks to me are Maine and Michigan.
- 22:19Bob: In the state of Maine, Susan Collins, if you look at the prediction markets, if you look at the polling averages, they say that Susan Collins is going to finally get beat.
- 22:30Bob: However, she has a proven track record of winning that state even in really bad years for the Republican Party, like 2008 and 2020, as well as widely outperforming the polls in each of her last three races.
- 22:45Bob: Now, why does she outperform the polls and why is why do I think that's going to happen again?
- 22:49Bob: There are a lot of MAGA-style voters, and this goes back to even before MAGA existed, okay?
- 22:57Bob: There are a lot of MAGA-style voters in rural Maine who hate Susan Collins' guts.
- 23:03Bob: They hate her because she isn't MAGA or conservative enough.
- 23:08Bob: But in the end, when they look at who the Democrats nominate and Susan Collins, they decide to vote for her regardless.
- 23:15Bob: Okay, and that has happened cycle after cycle.
- 23:17Bob: My best guess is that the pattern holds and she narrowly escapes a loss that she does win that state.
- 23:23Bob: Net of all this, I think the Republicans probably end up losing two seats.
- 23:28Bob: Okay, there's a wide range of possible outcomes.
- 23:30Bob: The best guess that they lose two seats.
- 23:32Bob: Prediction markets say it's gonna be even worse for the Republicans, okay?
- 23:35Bob: More like 50-50.
- 23:37Bob: Uh Nate Silver is talking about the Democrats winning 51 seats outright.
- 23:42Bob: Okay.
- 23:42Bob: Um but I I actually think it's gonna go a little more favorable to the Republicans than the consensus.
- 23:50Bob: Whereas with the House, I have a more gloomy outlook for the Republicans.
- 23:54Bob: Vice versa for the Democrats in both cases.
- 23:56Ryan: Before you get to the some of the economic implications, there was uh an idea that was recently floated by the president and and actually I think the Treasury Secretary also um, at least somewhat tacitly endorsed it, or maybe even outright, that um if the Republicans can maintain control of both houses, they're gonna send five thousand dollars to everyone.
- 24:21Ryan: So I have so many questions about that.
- 24:24Ryan: But is that something that they can do?
- 24:26Ryan: Can they take, you know, five thousand dollars of the people's money and just send it back to them and spend a trillion dollars to do that?
- 24:32Bob: No, that's not gonna happen, Ryan.
- 24:33Bob: So here's the deal.
- 24:34Bob: First of all, it's highly unlikely that the Republicans are gonna keep control of the House of Representatives.
- 24:40Bob: I I only at best 15% chance of the government.
- 24:42Ryan: But why do they think they can say it?
- 24:44Ryan: Because they're like, well, what's actually gonna happen to 10,000?
- 24:49Bob: If I never have to pay, I might as well be generous.
- 24:51Bob: Okay.
- 24:52Bob: You know, it's like so um I think in the end, it's not they're not gonna be in a situation where it's even plausible because the Democrats are gonna control at least one of uh the chambers of Congress.
- 25:04Bob: And so it's a promise they can make and that they'll never have to pay for.
- 25:07Bob: Um so uh the other thing is that even if they retain control, there are probably enough Republicans are Capitol Hill.
- 25:18Bob: Like, remember, if they retain control of the Senate, then it's very likely that in that scenario, Susan Collins is still sitting in the Senate.
- 25:27Bob: Lisa Murkowski will still be a U.S.
- 25:30Bob: Senator, okay, she's not up for re-election.
- 25:32Bob: So you're gonna have a number of moderate Republican senators who are like, no, the budget deficit is in the vicinity of $2 trillion last year, okay, pointing to the year that fiscal year that's gonna end September 30th.
- 25:45Bob: We are not sending $5,000 per person out the out the door.
- 25:50Bob: We're simply and they're gonna have to enact something.
- 25:52Bob: The Treasury can't decide to do it on their own.
- 25:54Bob: So the bill simply would not pass.
- 25:57Bob: And Trump will like, you know, gnash his teeth and make a lot of mean tweets and pull his hair.
- 26:03Bob: But I think privately he'll be happy he doesn't have to live up to the promise.
- 26:06Bob: Like even in the scenario where they won both houses, okay?
- 26:09Bob: Um uh uh because uh uh enough moderate Republicans decide to prevent him from living up to that.
- 26:18Ryan: Okay.
- 26:18Ryan: Economic implications of your likely um scenario where the Democrats take the House, the Republicans maintain the Senate.
- 26:29Ryan: Is this uh sort of just gridlock and nothing is this the best scenario?
- 26:33Bob: Yes and no.
- 26:34Bob: So here's what I expect, and this is actually gonna be pretty big, Ryan.
- 26:37Bob: Yep.
- 26:37Bob: So I would anticipate um eventually, maybe middle deep into 2027, some sort of a budget agreement between the Democrats that control the House, Republicans in the Senate, and the Trump administration.
- 26:52Bob: President Trump will then renege.
- 26:55Bob: Um before the early 1970s, it was legally ambiguous whether if Congress passed a bill to say spend $100 million on a project that the President has to actually spend $100 million.
- 27:09Bob: Can he just spend up to $100 million?
- 27:11Bob: Umywhere between zero and $100 million, but no more than that.
- 27:16Bob: Um, presidents would periodically impound funds, refuse to spend everything that was appropriated by Congress.
- 27:23Bob: Legally ambiguous.
- 27:25Bob: Well, in the second term for President Nixon, early 1970s, he's weakened by Watergate.
- 27:31Bob: Congress passes something called the, I think it was the Budget Control and Enforcement Act, and I think it was 1974.
- 27:37Bob: Um and uh um ever since then, presidents had have been prevented from impounding funds in that way, refusing to spend monies appropriated by Congress.
- 27:50Bob: This isn't entitlements, this isn't Social Security of Medicare, Medicaid, this is or the Affordable Care Act.
- 27:55Bob: This is discretionary spending that's annually appropriated, has to be approved by Congress.
- 28:01Bob: Okay.
- 28:02Bob: I think he'll renege and take it to court.
- 28:04Bob: I mean, Trump is obviously comfortable in the courtroom.
- 28:07Bob: And unlike the decisions with birthright citizenship, unlike the decision regarding tariffs, I think he's actually going to win this one.
- 28:16Bob: Probably a close call.
- 28:17Bob: Say a 5-4 decision in favor of the president having impoundment power.
- 28:21Bob: That means that for the remainder of his term, at that point it'll be like one year, and all future presidents will have this power of impoundment, refusing to spend money appropriated by Congress.
- 28:34Bob: Um and if that happens, that will give the president more leverage in the future to reduce discretionary spending.
- 28:41Bob: Um I think that will be a I wouldn't say revolutionary change, but a major change in budget politics in the US as an outgrowth of um uh uh of the situation with the Democrats controlling at least one chamber next year.
- 28:59Ryan: That's interesting.
- 29:00Ryan: Um Okay.
- 29:01Ryan: Linked to that is a question that I know you get all the time.
- 29:06Ryan: Uh you and I have spoken at uh the same set of meetings several times in the last uh several weeks.
- 29:13Ryan: And the question that I have observed comes up in every one of those meetings is about social security.
- 29:20Ryan: And uh I think there's more and more people that are growing increasingly concerned that the Social Security Trust Fund is going to run out of money and they want to know is that actually going to happen?
- 29:30Ryan: And is there uh a fix for it that the uh the Congress has that they're gonna enact at some point?
- 29:38Ryan: Uh and when does that happen?
- 29:39Ryan: Uh what sort of scenario do you expect with Social Security?
- 29:43Ryan: Are they gonna run out of money?
- 29:44Bob: I don't know whether it's gonna be one minute to spare or five years to spare.
- 29:49Bob: But at some point over the next several years, before the Social Security Trust Fund hits zero, in which case you'll still have ongoing revenue flow into Social Security, but not enough to meet full benefits, enough to meet roughly 80 percent of benefits.
- 30:04Bob: Um before that happens, the Democrats are gonna win.
- 30:09Bob: There's going to be a general revenue transfer to the Social Security Trust Fund.
- 30:14Bob: And when the Democrats propose it, the Republicans are gonna stomp their feet and pull their hair and gnash their teeth and say this does not fix the situation long term.
- 30:26Bob: We need structural reforms, um, uh we need to have a commission to make proposals.
- 30:32Bob: And the Democrats will say, you're absolutely right.
- 30:34Bob: However, legally, if we do a general revenue transfer, it will enable Social Security Administration to continue to send out the checks on time.
- 30:43Bob: And no Republican wants to be in a state.
- 30:45Bob: None.
- 30:46Bob: I don't care how conservative they are, even Rand Paul in Kentucky, where Social Security recipients are not getting their checks on time.
- 30:53Bob: So the Democrats are gonna win.
- 30:54Bob: There's gonna be a general revenue transfer, essentially income tax revenue used for Social Security purposes.
- 31:00Bob: We already have a case where that happened during COVID, and many Republicans voted for it.
- 31:06Bob: Okay, we cut the payroll tax and offset the revenue loss of the Social Security Trust Fund by doing a general revenue transfer.
- 31:14Bob: Okay.
- 31:15Bob: That's what's gonna happen again, and it might happen multiple times, and eventually they'll get around to that commission.
- 31:20Bob: And the commission will probably do something close to what happened in 1982 when they enacted a uh bipartisan agreement to raise taxes on future workers.
- 31:31Bob: I'm not saying it's good, I'm just saying this is what's gonna happen.
- 31:35Bob: They'll probably change the benefit formulas on Social Security to make it a little less generous to future upper income beneficiaries from that point forward.
- 31:46Bob: Um uh the grandfather and the old the folks who are already getting the benefits or close to getting their benefits.
- 31:52Bob: And they might do some um uh changing the retirement age a little bit, whatever.
- 31:58Bob: But you know, again, but but most of it's gonna be higher taxes on future workers.
- 32:03Bob: I personally find that unfortunate.
- 32:05Bob: But uh I'm realistic, and that's where I think the politics is leading us over the next several years.
- 32:12Ryan: So will it maybe this is too detailed, but will will it continue to be uh a payroll tax or will it just be so they'll just increase the payroll tax?
- 32:21Bob: They'll do some combination of either increasing the payroll tax or increasing the wage base that the payroll tax applies against.
- 32:28Bob: They'll probably do a little bit of both.
- 32:30Ryan: Okay, yeah.
- 32:31Ryan: So is there any other alternative that that would be um maybe wouldn't require uh something that's are you asking about like what we could do or what we will do?
- 32:43Ryan: I mean, there's been over the years, there's been all sorts of proposals.
- 32:48Ryan: Yeah.
- 32:49Bob: Whether it was uh privatizing 2005.
- 32:53Bob: Yeah, you saw what happened to that.
- 32:54Bob: You need 60 votes in the U.S.
- 32:56Bob: Senate, yeah.
- 32:56Bob: Unless you completely and permanently end the filibuster.
- 32:59Bob: That's not gonna happen.
- 33:00Ryan: Yeah, that was right after the dot-com bubble burst, though, wasn't it?
- 33:03Ryan: That that was proposed.
- 33:04Ryan: It would have been a great time.
- 33:05Ryan: It would have been a perfect time.
- 33:06Ryan: Yeah, yeah.
- 33:07Ryan: But investor sentiment was easy to turn against and say, no, this is a terrible idea.
- 33:12Ryan: Did you not notice what just happened to the market?
- 33:14Bob: Yeah, yeah.
- 33:14Bob: I mean, we can go into a lot of depth on the nitty-gritty of what it would take to do a market-based reform of Social Security.
- 33:23Ryan: Yeah.
- 33:24Bob: Um, my personal preference as a like more of a free market guy is to not dwell on um um turning it into personal accounts because I'd be concerned about government control, like managerial control of voting those shares in the future.
- 33:43Bob: Um and even if you try to prevent that, it could be undone just by any act of Congress, by any Congress in the future.
- 33:49Bob: Um, what I want to do is just cut future benefits and maybe do it gradually over time by changing the inflation indexation, unwinding what Jimmy Carter did in the late 1970s, which was um a way to count productivity growth for the benefit of workers.
- 34:10Bob: It it it I'm getting at the technical weeds here, but to me, the true libertarian solution long-term, is not a putting it in the stock market, although that'd be fine.
- 34:21Bob: No, I I get that.
- 34:22Bob: Like I would support that over the current system.
- 34:24Bob: But the even better libertarian solution is just shrinking the program, okay?
- 34:30Bob: Um, because every extra dollar that Social Security Administration would put into stocks or people would put into stocks in their own personal accounts if they were able to do so, would just shift the allocation of money that is not in Social Security a little bit away from stocks.
- 34:46Bob: So, net of all this, it wouldn't really it would it would basically force people who otherwise don't invest in stocks to do so.
- 34:54Bob: Okay?
- 34:55Bob: Um and it's not clear to me that very long term that would be a sustainable sustainable equilibrium, even if it would make those people who wouldn't otherwise have the predilection to put money in the stock market, even if they even if they were successful in terms of their investment.
- 35:16Bob: I don't know if that would be a stable equilibrium.
- 35:19Ryan: So the way that governments can very sneaky reduce future liabilities in real terms is inflation.
- 35:28Ryan: Is that not true?
- 35:29Bob: You can't do that with social security.
- 35:30Bob: Because it's indexed to inflation.
- 35:31Bob: Exactly.
- 35:32Bob: You also probably can't do that for Medicare.
- 35:35Ryan: Okay.
- 35:36Bob: Okay?
- 35:36Bob: Um because as overall inflation as overall as the overall price level rises, it's also going to rise relatively in tandem with healthcare products.
- 35:47Bob: Okay.
- 35:47Bob: So um so inflation is not a way for us to escape the unfunded liabilities in Social Security and Medicare.
- 35:55Bob: Yeah.
- 35:55Bob: We can only do that through um uh by cutting the program or economic growth.
- 36:05Bob: But if it's economic growth, remember, more economic growth means a larger share of our future income will be spent on health care, including health care and retirement.
- 36:16Bob: So you can't do it directly through more economic growth, you can do it indirectly because um um non-payroll tax revenue will grow more quickly.
- 36:26Bob: Income tax revenue, which is not supposed to be used for Social Security, will grow more quickly if you have faster economic growth, right?
- 36:34Bob: So even though you don't fix the unfunded liability, you have more of this other pot.
- 36:38Bob: So a smaller share of that other pot is needed if you're gonna solve Social Security through a transfer of general revenue.
- 36:47Bob: So indirectly, economic growth can help Social Security, even though directly, if you're only looking at the Social Security system, economic growth doesn't help because faster growth means more revenue and higher benefits.
- 36:59Bob: Yeah.
- 36:59Bob: But if if it increases income tax revenue, you need a smaller share of that income tax money to shift over.
- 37:06Bob: So indirectly.
- 37:07Bob: It gets very complicated.
- 37:08Bob: It gets very complicated when you look at it closely.
- 37:12Ryan: Which is why um it's difficult for politicians to make any any sort of bold decisions because it's difficult to communicate that.
- 37:20Bob: They don't even understand the ideas I just gave you, except for a few of them.
- 37:24Ryan: Yeah, they really don't.
- 37:25Ryan: So to circle back to the question, we're not going to run we're not gonna run out of social security because taxes are likely to move higher.
- 37:34Ryan: Unfortunately, yes.
- 37:36Ryan: All right.
- 37:37Ryan: Well, I don't want to end on that note because ending on that note, um, you know, that the taxes are gonna go up to solve Social Security.
- 37:44Ryan: Um, that that's not an ideal way to end.
- 37:46Ryan: The ideal way to end a podcast episode is for me to ask you for a book recommendation.
- 37:50Bob: Wow.
- 37:51Ryan: Um, and and um so let's uh let's finish up with uh a Bob Stein reading list recommendation.
- 37:57Ryan: What would you recommend that viewers and listeners of the ROI podcast, what should we check out?
- 38:03Bob: Elegy in Blue by Mark Halprin.
- 38:06Bob: Not Mark Halprin with an E, he's the political analyst.
- 38:10Bob: Okay, Mark Halprin with an A, he is the author who was the speechwriter for Bob Dole briefly in 1996.
- 38:19Bob: Um he's a wonderful author.
- 38:22Bob: Um I've recommended his books in the past.
- 38:24Bob: I just finished uh his latest book called Elegy and Blue, which is fantastic.
- 38:29Bob: I mean, you you don't just get concrete ideas from reading nonfiction.
- 38:34Bob: You can reach a better understanding of the world by reading good fiction sometimes.
- 38:41Bob: And that's what this is?
- 38:42Bob: That's what this is.
- 38:43Bob: I mean, I when I read nonfiction, Ryan, I'm a little strange.
- 38:47Bob: Okay?
- 38:48Bob: I'm still like I'm 40 years out of college at this point, and I still have a pen with me, and I underline stuff and check stuff and star stuff and mark things in a nonfiction book.
- 38:58Bob: When I'm reading fiction, part of the reason I do so is because I don't have to mark anything up, right?
- 39:02Bob: Well, in this book, I had to fold pages and mark it up because it it he writes so beautifully, um, but he also passes along ideas about how people relate to the world and the generations and family life that are not normally contained even in nonfiction books.
- 39:23Bob: Um and it's by the way, it's short, it's like 240 pages or 280 pages.
- 39:29Bob: Not if you want to read it as a book of the month, it goes quickly.
- 39:32Bob: It's a wonderful book.
- 39:33Bob: It's about a retired, uh, wealthy investment banker, and uh basically he's hit by what it can only be described or best described as like the trials of Job.
- 39:44Ryan: Oh okay.
- 39:45Ryan: Yeah, what goes wrong?
- 39:46Bob: Yeah, yeah.
- 39:47Bob: Life's uh yeah, life breaks bad in certain ways, but he makes good of it.
- 39:53Ryan: Okay.
- 39:53Bob: Yeah.
- 39:54Ryan: All right.
- 39:54Ryan: Well, I appreciate the uh recommendation, and uh once again, thanks for coming on the podcast.
- 39:59Ryan: It's been my pleasure.
- 40:00Ryan: Thanks to all of you as well for joining us on this episode of the First Trust ROI podcast.
- 40:05Ryan: We'll see you next time.