Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 10/08/26 EPISODE 031: WE PICKED A BARREL of BUFFALO TRACE
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Well, folks. We appreciate you being here. We are gonna be doing our very first barrel pick on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. Shout out to El Paisano Liquors, Yusuf, Amido. They said, Hey, we got a couple barrels coming up. Would you do the picks for us? And this is the first one we're gonna be picking. And it is a Buffalo Trace barrel pick. We got three samples. We're gonna dive in, nose them up, give our thoughts, talk about them, and ultimately we're gonna pick which barrel that you will see in the coming months. Stay tuned for that notification on whenever that barrel comes out. ⁓ but we'll have a 323 Bourbon Library podcast barrel pick of Buffalo Trace at El Paisano Liquor. So let's dive into this thing. We got them labeled up A, B, and C, blind poured. Let's see what we got. I'm gonna start diving in here on A. I might I might hit the nose on each first instead of nose palette. Gotcha. Just my dance between these noses. Ooh. There is a lot. Neat Yeah, wow. ⁓ B's nose jumped out to me initially. A's came up came first to me. C C came out to me a little bit. As far as you've preferred? So far. A on the nose. Just that first sniff. See, B to me is a little soft. On the nose? In what sense? What do you get on light. Okay, light light. Light scent to me. Not much. Not very strong. Do you want a strong nose or do you want a sweet nose? Be able smell the vanillas, the caramels, the so B B for me, that vanilla cherry pops out more on B on the nose. Where C has a little bit of that cherry. I don't get a lot of cherry on A. So I get I get that cherry on A. You get more cherry on A than B. Getting more cherry on. Okay. Okay. I agree with James B's just softer, more simple. They're all very similar, yeah. They're very I mean, they're like picking straws, right? Right. ⁓ I might have to start tasting these. Now all these are in the one twenties, low one twenties on the proof. James diving in on A. Let me try A as well. Same here. Okay. ⁓ Little bit of sweetness, little bit of fruit, proof points up there on the backside. It's singing on the proof. Yeah, she's I'm curious. She's in the back of the throat right now. She's just yikes. ⁓ So we can once we pick we'll tell like what floor, what barrel house, all that stuff. Okay. Yeah. Class A, I'm gonna try B. I don't know. B's less subtle. Less subtle? Yeah, than A. A little more spice to it. I felt like I got a little bit more spice on A. So what do you mean by less subtle? I d I I think it was more like just like the nose. It was not as I thought you were s guys were saying the like B was subtle. Like it was like for me it was. Like you didn't get as much ⁓ Correct, and I'm getting the same with B. ⁓ you're getting the like okay, less flavor. Yeah, it's lighter. It's nice. It's lighter though. It's lighter, but I do like the flavor of B. Yeah. Yeah. All right. And try C on the on the flavor. And also might just need to open up a little bit. Yeah. We're just letting these things breathe. Talk about ⁓ A B C. So for those that are like watching or listening, ⁓ the the proof points on these range from anywhere from sixty one point five one ABV. Sixty one point five one. Sixty one point five one hundred and twenty three So 123 point zero two ⁓ up to sixty one point six three. 123 point six. So we're talking like two tenths of a percent difference in the proof point. Obviously, these are both all three, whichever one we pick is gonna get watered down to ninety proof, right? Buffalo trace. ⁓ I'm gonna try see. Even though they're so close, like A and B so far. Different. It tastes the proof tastes different. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Wow. Earl C. Maybe it's just because I was talking for a few minutes, but I love this like cherry note that I'm getting on glass C on the palette. C is pretty good. And she's legs are Extra going on on C. Yeah, super viscous. Get a little bit of apple cider on C. Apple cider? You know what's wild is like initially I really liked the nose on B. But now that these are opening up, A and C are t are smelling more similar to each other, and then B is kind of an outlier to me. B's giving me more like dark caramel notes where C is a little more like bright cherry versus dark cherry. And then A it's somewhere between ⁓ almost like a Cherry Caramel. Well I figure out what labor profiles A giving me. I'm not get s spice like a lot of baking spice out of I mean we we can go as minimal as thumbs up, thumbs down, thumbs sideways like ⁓ and actually how I like to do these is rule out one. Is there a bottom one that we're gonna say it is not in competition anymore? So I would say let's focus on let's pick our least favorite of the three. And then kinda go from there. What do you think, James? Where are you sitting? You you're you got a lot of mental brain power going right now and I can I can see you think it churning on this thing. Tough decision. ⁓ man, this Fuji apple on what is this glass C now? On the nose? This is the first one barrel pick I'm doing. It's hard. It's very hard. Same for me. I've never done one in So yeah, yeah. These are these they're fun, right? Because I mean scary. But scary. It is a little bit nerve wracking because you're like, I don't want to pick a fucking shitty bottle because we're gonna get, you know, I well, for this bottle, it's probably two hundred and twenty to two hundred and fifty bottles. You know, because this is you know somewhere between six and eight year, probably Buffalo Trace. So you're gonna get a high yield from this bear, almost likely. ⁓ which one do you hate the most? Or like the least? Let me put it that way. Cause they all actually smell and taste really good. th there's not to me, it's gonna be hard to eliminate. These are all very, very similar. There's not like on the proof point you're talking two tenths of the proof, so you're not gonna differentiate from that. I'm also thinking these have to be proofed down to to ninety. To ninety. So what's gonna s what's gonna stand out once it gets proofed down? True. So you're not just drinking a water down bourbon. I had I thought I was I thought I was there on being able to eliminate one and now I th I'm re I can't either. I thought I was g I thought I was gonna eliminate B but now I go back to B and it's like it's not it's actually got some good I thought I was gonna eliminate A and go with C and I tried them back to back and I think I like A better than C. I think I like C so far the most. Really? I think. I'm about to eliminate C. Really? Yeah. I don't know. Let me try B. It's been a minute since I've come in. Let me try the nose. So I'm all over the place. That's all right too. Like Thought I like B and then I went to C. Okay. You gonna eliminate C? Yeah. All right. Fair. I'm gonna eliminate C. There is a There's a missing depth to see. ⁓ it's more astringent, it's more ethanol forward, it's not as deep and caramelly on the palate. I've tried it now against A and then I did C and then I did B and then I did C. And every time and I've gone and I've done C and then B and then C and then A. And every time C C just ⁓ is not doing it for me. Cleanse my palate one more time. Why isn't I'm curious to why isn't C it's just the astringency and the ethanol. I don't feel like there's the sweetness that I want. Okay. There's not the fruit that I want. And I'm getting a lot more alcohol on C. Try it one more time. We're gonna go C. I'm gonna go C A. I'm gonna go You're gonna go C A? Did you go C B? Not yet. Okay. I'm nosing C B C It's nice, but B is nicer with a like a caramel sweetness on the nose of B. Now I'm gonna taste C and then taste B. He's nice. I think I like B the best. I think I went back to B. C's nice, but B is w superior to C. But I and I think like A like I don't know, I'm I'm going I'm been going back and forth. ⁓ B to me is I don't know. Is B is B where you like it now? Well, that's the problem. Yes. But I That's what I've got in my head is like I like B now, but would I like B? Well, you're not t you're you won't know. Yeah. So you gotta taste it now and hope that well, theoretically, these are all two one hundredths of a proof point difference. It's not like there's one that's eight point. Well I know, but there's still the there's a big d I mean, B to me and I think to you is more just kinda Settle and it's kind of like an easy sipper. Yeah, like C I can just drink now just the way it is, and just C sorry, B. B. B. B. Just drink I enjoy B now. I can keep drinking B. Well how he's afraid. So what he's saying is is we just don't really know much about like the whole process. Yeah. Our first pick. So he's saying when it gets watered down. Watered down, yeah. He's afraid that's gonna be too watered down. Well, hey, let's find let's let's firm into our top two. And then we can water them down. ⁓ that's true. I've got Kentucky limestone water. You guys can proof it down to I we I mean we don't have an agrometer. Hydrometer. Hydrometer to tell hydrometer? What did I say? Hydrometer. To get down to you know actually, but we can water it down and see if it op one opens up differently than another one. ⁓ C for me is on the outs. Now I'm gonna go back and do A B and see if I Like those better than C. I'm gonna go go back and try a ⁓ Coming from a cooking background, I understand how much Something can be watered down. How different that's gonna taste. I need a little bit more in my cup. Bolgers? Yeah. If we're gonna start hitting waters on these, I need a couple more drops of liquid in my blast here. Yeah, I think we should hit I'll take more of A. More A? Are you? And I think we should each do maybe start with one and just one one drop. One water drop. Yeah. Per on A and B? On all all three of them. Well what w whatever you're not eliminating. I've I don't think James and I have eliminated any yet. That's don't I mean I if I I feel like you have to eliminate at least one without watering it down. Because that's cast strength. It's uncut. It's unfiltered. ⁓ you so you've gotta understand that like these are all like they're at the same proof. So whatever you taste in now, you're gonna taste a 90 proof just at a lesser proof. It's not like one's gonna get watered down more than the other, frankly. I'm ready. That was quick. I'm sh I mean I'm ready. ⁓ I'm eliminating A. You're eliminating A. And why? What's the reason behind it? It's just I I feel that B and C to me are just better sippers and I just don't enjoy ⁓ better. There's more ethanol on A to me. You think? On the tet And we're gonna probably pick A from the thing. ⁓ On the palate on the palate or nose? I don't know. I mean B to me right now is a winner. I enjoy B the most. Which is funny because on the first like go around, y'all bro y'all both weren't on B. ⁓ that's true. I don't like C I I I I I'm gonna be honest with you, I can't put my name on C. Yeah. I don't care if it gets proofed down or not. It's too astringent. Yeah. There's not enough sweetness in it. Completely out on C. C gets eliminated. Yeah. It's just for when you drink when you drink a buffalo trash, what do you think? Like what are you expecting? Like the sweetness is fantastic. Yeah. I don't get any of that on sweet on C. I get like this alcohol forward, like not I don't get the the fruit or the sweet ver vanilla, caramel, whatever. For me, this is between A and B. ⁓ so let's do this. A and B, cast strength. Let's try ⁓ Just push whichever one you like better forward. And then we'll water down and we'll try them again. And if it we'll see where it changes for each of us. You've already tasted it. B's forward for you? Yeah. Nose or palette or both? Palette. Nose I think I like A better on the nose, but The bees coming around on the nose too. I need to wash my palate up. B B B came out spicy that time for me. Let me try it first again. to refill my glass again. God damn. B, I'm watching this little like bourbon drop slide down the glass. This bitch is taking its time. Yeah. Touch more. Anybody any more B and A. Pass me the A there? Just a ton a teensy bit more A. What? Listen, at the end of the day, ⁓ here's where I'm at, man. Our Weller 107 store pick went bananas. Sold out 220 bottles in less than 30 hours with El Pisano. They're like, That's the best thing we've ever done. So now we're back with a buffalo trace. Let's get this nose one more time before we add some water to it. Do you guys push forward or back or B forward? You're A forward. At the moment. I don't know. I've been on B the whole night and then like I don't know. All right. How many drops of Kentucky limestone water should we add? Let's start with one each. You you can order in Kentucky limestone water, ⁓ about a couple liters of it. ⁓ did you? Yeah. I save it just for tasting whiskies. this thing up. Go back to the nose. The A nose cherry. Big time. All day long, that big cherry note on A. I mean B's got it, but I think A's a little more fruit forward. I would say that's true. But the B just has that sweeter note to me than A does. On the nose or the palate? On the nose. I'm gonna go three total drops, two more on each. Did you taste him? I did taste them. ⁓ one more? Yeah, we'll still I'll do two more. Two more drops each. Alright, we got some Kentucky limestone water going in the glasses. We wanna make listen, we're we're doing our best here. This is for science, folks. Just doing the Lord's work for science. We want to make sure that we absolutely pick the best barrel possible for El Pisano liquor in downtown Tempe. We we we stopped by there, some Madhouse. All the a all the all the kids were coming back to school for college. Sorority fraternity folks just mobbing the streets. I actually it's kind of hard to park. It was very hard to park. Chunk Carlo watched me as I did a ninety-seven point two. He awesome powered and I awesome powered my fucking truck into like a mini Cooper car spot. all right. Back at it, two glasses, A and B. I think I like the nose on B is this good this this like Fuji Apple crismin crispness to glass B on the nose. I do like that. I like no the nose on B. It's much sweeter, cleaner. But A's nose, it has the it has the apple or the cherry fruit, but it's got this like ice cream caramel sweetness on the back of the nose. crisp a apple. I I I to me B B's taken it for me so far. You too? Yeah. On the nose or the palate? Palette. I mean that you know me with nose, but I mean the palette to me, I just think B's for me. Okay. What do you like about it? Over A? think it's less I mean, just a very easy sipper. Crisp apple. Got some vanilla in there. I just like I don't know, something about B to me is like ever since the very beginning. I did so I did I think called out B as like my favorite when we first sipped. Yeah. Now I'm like these are the A and B are really hard. They're very super close. I think you get more of of those traditional flavors from B. Especially now that we've put it more water in there. Right. It's opened up more for me. It's tasting more like what I would expect. It's got a little more flavor than I like if you go pick up a Buffalo Trace bottle. Right? Yeah. I think these are so fucking close. My last sip here, B compared to A, had a little bit more sweetness to it. Yeah. Mm-hmm. For sure. which is which is crazy. Like the we we came into this, we smelled all three. We hadn't tasted anything. Immediately I loved B. I have been a a ping pong ball all night in this tasting. Initially I smelled B, I liked A and C. And then I tasted A and C and I'm like, ⁓ shit, they're not as good. I think I'm on B. You guys are on B? I'm locked in on B. I'm on I'm locked in on B. Locked in on B. So Make sure we're gonna pick the right one. We got B. We're gonna f we're gonna pour it up. B is let's see. Sixty one point five six proof. There's Is lot eighteen F eighteen. Do you know what's hilarious? What were we between? A and C or A and B? A and B. Okay. A and C A and B we we're in. I don't know what the fucking lots mean. They're both eighteen. One's H, one's F, one's twenty, one's eighteen. Who knows? We don't know. Gotta be located at the warehouse. Right. Let's all taste B, make sure we're we're all we are almost out of this sample. You got some more? Need any? No. Need doesn't need any. All right. Let's just sit back. Just shooting the shit. Should we try a ⁓ just someone else's buffalo trace to compare it to? Yeah. At ninety? Sure. All right, grab three more glasses over there. Can do that. And there's a buffalo trace. Bottom shelf. Right there, James. It's not open. It's open. We'll just ⁓ we'll just try this. Just a tat hinge. Yeah, just enough to just get a little comparison. This is ninety proof, obviously. A little more than that too. Just another buffalo trace. That way we can RB to someone else's. think I like our He smells better. Our caramel. We also don't know how much proof down we did to this. Well well, I'm re poured mine, so did you put more drips in it or no? Nope. I mean there was a little bit left in there, but it's back proofed up. Mm. B, like I think, wow. Now that we're not like trying to pick out the nuances and we've picked what what what is our favorite, B. It's got this balance between cherry fruit note and caramel sweetness. And a little touch of vanilla on the backside that's really good. Now I'm gonna try it against this other Buffalo Trace. No comparison. Did you try your other Buffalo Trace? Yeah, I liked it. It was good. It was good. Like our better. Obviously, B is at cast strength or foolproof, right? So it's gonna get proof down. which we gotta hope that that caramel, cherry, little bit of vanilla sweetness sticks. Sticks down, which I think it will. Yeah. ⁓ that Weller one ⁓ seven pick that I did with with El Paisano. barrel we picked was at 127 proof. Right. And it got proof down to 107. ⁓ and proof point. It stayed fucking fantastic. It was it was incredible. ⁓ let me know in the comments if you did you get a barrel ⁓ pick from El Paisano ⁓ Weller107. Also let us know in the comments how excited are you for a El Paisano 323 bourbon library. Pick of Buffalo Trace. If you love this, just wait. We got a Blanton's Gold pick coming in the near future. So they're coming out left and right and they're gonna be great. I can't wait to try that Blanton's one of seven. Yeah. Blanton's gold, excuse me. All right. So we are, are we all affirmatively saying hundred percent B. 100%? Yes. The B is what we're picking. So we are picking. Barrel select B lot 18 F eighteen, whatever that means. This we are we tasted it at 61.56 proof. ⁓ I think this is actually in the middle of the proof points of the three three picks, and the barrel number on this specifically is six twelve. Barrel six twelve. Nice. Love it. So We will post another podcast. I'll post it on my Instagram. I'm sure ten ten to AZ Whiskey. I gotta I gotta memorize your name. Is it Tenday Z whiskey? ⁓ okay. And a life well Life Well Made. A well life well made co. we'll we'll put it out there and stay tuned. This barrel pick's gonna come out probably where are we at? We're in August, Christmas. January, February, maybe? Yeah, you said three or four months. Yeah. Hopefully by the end of the year, twenty twenty six. But we'll let you know when this one's gonna be available. ⁓ I think we got a banger coming up. I like it. It's a good bottle. Super nice. So ⁓ Amido, Yusuf, thank you, gentlemen, so much for allowing us to pick a barrel for you. We can't wait to see it in the store. We can't wait to see the three two three Burban Library stickers on the bottle. We'll see you very soon. Enjoy. Cheers. Cheers.